a. dean larsen book collecting conference

Transcription

a. dean larsen book collecting conference
A. Dean Larsen
Book Collecting Conference
March 13 –14, 2014
A. DEAN LARSEN
BOOK COLLECTING
CONFERENCE
March 21–22, 2013
L. Tom Perry Special Collections
Harold B. Lee Library
Brigham Young University
L. Tom Perry Special Collections
Harold B. Lee Library
Brigham Young University
Cover and postcard image:
Creation, Donald Jackson with contribution by Chris
Tomlin, Copyright 2003, The Saint John’s Bible, Order of
Saint Benedict, Collegeville, Minnesota, USA.
A. Dean Larsen
Book Collecting
Conference
March 13 –14, 2014
L. Tom Perry
Special Collections
Harold B. Lee Library
Brigham Young University
© 2014
Table of Contents
5
Welcome
7
Conference Schedule
Pre-Conference Workshops
11
Illuminated Capitals
15
Uncommon Uncial: A Beautiful Historical
Lettering Hand
19
Caring for Your Treasures: Family Papers,
Photographs, and Books
Conference Seminars
25
Zap! Pow! Bam!: Collecting Mormon
Comics and Pop Culture
31
Utah Art at the Keyboard
37
Beyond the Volumes of the Joseph Smith
Papers
41
Peepshows and Panoramas: The Victorian
3-D Experience!
45
Card’s Game: Collectible Orson Scott Card
51
A Proclamation from the Lord: Broadsides,
Posters, and Handbills in the Print Culture
of Mormonism
57
On Bended Knee: An Appreciation of
Devotional Literature
61
Breaking Though the Religion Taboo:
Contemporary Mormon Children’s Fiction
66
Luncheon Speaker
68
A. Dean Larsen Biography
70
Presenter Biographies
75
Seminar Times and Locations
Welcome
Dear Conference Attendees:
On behalf of the Harold B. Lee Library and the L. Tom Perry
Special Collections, I welcome you to the Eleventh Annual A.
Dean Larsen Book Collecting Conference. We are thrilled that you
chose to be with us. There are many choices for how to spend our
time each week and we express our appreciation to you for being
here. As the world moves more and more into a digital world, how
wonderful it is for us to celebrate the culture of the written and
printed word. That is not to say that we shun the new world view.
On the contrary, we embrace it as a means of disseminating our
primary sources and assisting in the research process. To us, the
digital expression of information is a wonderful tool that we add to
our arsenal of educational assets. But during this day together we
will focus on the tangible rather than the virtual.
With this conference, we honor the legacy of A. Dean Larsen,
Associate University Librarian for Collection Development in the
Lee Library for more than 30 years. He dedicated his life to building our collections. We also recognize Jean M. Larsen, Dean’s
wife, who has established an endowment specifically to support
this conference.
So, thank you for choosing to be with us. You have selected four
of eight different seminars offered this year. We know that some
of you have also elected to attend at least one pre-conference
workshop. We thank Kohleen Reeder, Joan Merrell, Judy Sommerfeldt, and Christina Thomas for their willingness to present
these workshops.
As you experience this year’s Book Collecting Conference,
please feel free to give us suggestions for next year’s conference. We are committed to not only offering new exciting seminars each year, but also to incorporating your suggestions and
improving our conference. We sincerely hope that you will enjoy
your time with us. At the end of the day we trust that you will feel
enlightened concerning the subject matter and uplifted with the
opportunity you had to make a tangible connection to the past.
Scott H. Duvall
Associate University Librarian
Harold B. Lee Library
5
Conference Schedule
Pre-Conference
Thursday, March 13
9:00 AM – 12:00 PM First Workshop Begins
12:00 PM – 1:30 PM Lunch (on your own)
1:30 PM – 4:30 PM Second Workshop Begins (or
continuation of all day workshop)
Conference
Friday, March 14
8:00 AM – 8:30 AM Registration, Breakfast Snack
8:30 AM – 8:50 AM Welcome
9:00 AM – 10:15 AM First Seminar
10:15 AM – 10:30 AM Break
10:30 AM – 11:45 AM Second Seminar
12:00 PM – 1:30 PM Lunch and Luncheon Speaker
1:45 PM – 3:00 PM Third Seminar
3:00 PM – 3:15 PM Break
3:15 PM – 4:30 PM Fourth Seminar
4:30 PM – 5:00 PM Evaluation Submission
7
Pre-Conference
Workshops
Illuminated Capitals
Joan Merrell
For hundreds of years, decorative or “illuminated” capitals have
been used to brighten pages, catch attention, and mark
beginnings. The Saint John’s Bible uses this tradition in both
classic and modern ways. Participants in this class will have
the opportunity to experience some hands-on techniques and
materials used in traditional illumination, such as vellum, pigments, quills, and gold leaf. As well you will sample more modern
methods such as using fine-tipped drafting pens and watercolor
pencils. Using basic skeleton, structures and under the guidance
of an experienced calligrapher, you will design and decorate
your own versions of illuminated letters. You will also have a rare
opportunity to look at some original illuminations in manuscripts
from the Library’s rare book collection. This is a wonderful opportunity to get a personal taste of an art that has been appreciated in books over much time and in many places.
Examples from the Saint John’s Bible
11
Notes:
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
12
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
13
Uncommon Uncial:
A Beautiful Historical Lettering Hand
Judy Sommerfeldt
The uncial lettering hand was in widespread use from the 3rd to the 9th
centuries A.D. and served as the primary book hand between the 4th
and 6th centuries. It continued to be used for versals – decorative initials
used to open paragraphs – during the Middle Ages.
This beautiful rounded majuscule script was an adaptation of the carved
Roman inscriptions. In fact, its name is derived from having been written
an “uncia” (a Roman inch) in height. In the 5th century uncial evolved
into a group of lettering styles known as half-uncial. These forms were
used in well-known manuscript books in England and Ireland including
the Book of Kells (circa 800 A.D.) and the Lindisfarne Gospels (698 A.D.).
Uncial is one of the most popular calligraphic styles of writing among
present-day scribes. Modern versions of this undemanding style are
based upon early historic forms and are ideal for beginners to learn.
Participants in this class DO NOT need to have previous calligraphic experience. We will begin by looking at some historic and modern examples
of uncial writing. Next we will learn the uncial alphabet strokes, first with a
pencil and then, with a broad edge metal nib and ink. After practicing
these beautiful letter forms for a while, participants will create a finished
piece combining uncial letters and watercolor.
Bibliography:
Bologna, Giulia, Illuminated Manuscripts, New York: Crescent Books, 1988.
Cicale, Annie, The Art & Craft of Hand Lettering, New York: Lark Books, 2004.
Fink, Joanne and Kastin, Judy, The Speedball Textbook: A Comprehensive
Guide to Pen and Brush Lettering, North Carolina: Speedball Art Products
Company, 1999.
Knight, Stan, Historical Scripts: A handbook for calligraphers, New York:
Taplinger Publishing Company, 1984.
Waters, Sheila, Foundations of Calligraphy, North Carolina: John Neal,
Bookseller, 2006.
15
Notes:
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
16
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
17
Caring for Your Treasures:
Family Papers, Photographs,
and Books
Kohleen Reeder and Christina Thomas
Family papers, photographs, and books are everyday objects
found throughout our home collections. Their prevalence often
allows us to forget that they are potentially fragile and can be
damaged by careless handling, improper storage, and exposure to environmental conditions. Through presentation and a
hands-on session, this workshop will offer instruction on the proper
handling and storage of these treasures, as well as how to respond when disaster strikes. Implementing these guidelines, tips,
and tricks in your home collections will help ensure that they are
available for future generations to enjoy!
In the morning session of this full day workshop, we will cover
common concerns that arise when individuals are handling,
storing, and displaying family photographs, papers, and books.
We will discuss the best ways to display and store photographs,
including tips about light sensitivity. Discussion of papers and letters will cover proper storage as well as dealing with unwanted
creases and folds, paperclips and staples, and handling extremely fragile paper. We will cover what factors to consider when deciding to repair or not repair a book and what simple preventative measures can be taken to minimize wear and tear on books.
For each of these topics we will also discuss what not to do as
well as when it is best to work with a conservation professional.
Disaster preparedness is another critical aspect of home preservation, as disasters can affect all of us at unexpected times.
We will briefly cover simple, yet effective measures to ensure
that your collections will remain better protected in the face of
a home disaster. This will include discussion of proper storage
19
places and containers, immediate response to water damage,
and when to call for professional assistance.
The afternoon portion of this workshop will give participants the
chance to try some of the methods and techniques for storage
and handling discussed in the morning portion. Each participant
will have the opportunity to sew an item into a pamphlet binder,
to flatten paper and to practice safe ways of removing staples
and paper clips. They will also make a protective polyester
jacket for a book.
Participants will also have the opportunity to consult with the
conservators about one personal item from home to determine
the best course of action for preserving and storing the item. For
future needs, they will also receive a comprehensive list of local
and online preservation resources and recommended conservators in the region.
20
Notes:
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
21
Conference Seminars
ZAP!POW!BAM! Collecting Mormon
:
Comics and Pop Culture
Trevor Alvord
“A physical marvel, a mental wonder, Superman is destined to
reshape the destiny of a world!” is the caption written to close
out Action Comics’ June 1938 debut issue of Superman. Today
that phrase seems almost prophetic. The influence of comic
books can be seen in almost all aspects of popular culture.
Internationally, three of the top ten highest grossing movies of all
time featured comic book characters. Comic books alone gross
about $800 million a year, not to mention the growth in conventions and merchandise.
Comic books began to grow during the era of pulp magazines,
but by the 1940s the golden age of the pulp was buckling. For the
previous three decades pulps were one of the most popular forms
of entertainment, but their pages tended to be filled with stories
written for teenagers and adults. In comes the 40s that not only
brought with it economic and geopolitical change, it also saw
significant demographic change as well. Children under the age
of 18, were record in number (an estimated 45 million), were a
blossoming demographic in need of entertainment on their level.
In stepped comic books to fill that need. During the 40s about 80
million comics sold every week and passed from person-to-person
an average of eight times, making comics the most popular
media among children of the era.
Today, some seventy-six years after comics started to leave their
mark on American society, Mormon themed comics have begun to enter their own golden age. Currently there are three
continuing comic book style incarnations of the Book of Mormon
iPlates, From the Dust, and the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day
Saints’ Book of Mormon Scripture Stories. For the first time in history
Mormons have their own comic super heroes, brought to life in
Salt City Strangers. Mormon artists are using their skill to explore
everything from futuristic galaxies, to the social interactions and
complexities of zombies, all through the comics they are creating.
In 2013, Salt Lake City held its first comic book convention to a
crowd of eighty thousand, making it the largest inaugural Comic
Con in North America.
25
Although comic books will be heavily featured in this session, participants will also have the opportunity to examine and interact
with the Mormon gaming world through exploring epic battles
of the Nephites and Lamanites in chess form, buying temples
and building the kingdom of God in LDSopoly, and navigating
Nephite territory in Helam: A Stripling Warrior Quest, the first Book
of Mormon video game. Comic Book Grading Scale:
Based on the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide
Keep in mind that comic book grading is a bit more complex
then most other grading systems.
MT 10.0: Absolutely perfect – has not one single flaw
MT 9.9: Only 1 very subtle bindery defect allowed
NM/MT 9.8: Only minor imperfections (such as an almost unnoticeable interior page tear (under 1/32 of an inch) or a small inconspicuous date stamp (must be very well hidden almost unnoticeable
NM+ 9.6: Same as 9.8 but with small almost imperceptible indentations allowed and/or slight staple discoloration
NM 9.4: Same as 9.6 but with an up to 1/16 inch bend without
any color break (no white showing through the color) also everso-slight blunting of the corners and a few very slight stress lines
NM- 9.2: Same as above but page color may be off-white to
cream in color and that 1 cover crease can be 1/16 to 1/8 inch
with no color break allowed
VF/NM 9.0: 1/8 inch bend with no color break, very minor foxing allowed, small amount of cover wear, several date stamps
and or small hidden initials allowed, slight staple tears allowed.
26
Minor accumulation of stress lines allowed and some very minor
interior tears allowed
VF+ 8.5: 1/4 inch cover crease with no color break allowed,
minor spine split with some minor color break allowed, some
slightly more noticeable stress lines allowed and paper can be
cream to tan but must remain supple
VF 8.0: Same as 8.5 but with some very minor spine roll—must lay
almost completely flat
VF- 7.5: Same as 8.0 but cover can have light cover soiling and
some interior pages can have corner slight tears—also cover can
have some corner wear
F/VF 7.0: Moderate reduction of cover reflectivity - minor creases
allowed, minor foxing, interior cover yellowing, date stamps, initials, and store stamps are allowed, slight rust migration allowed,
blunted corners, minor margin tears on interior pages allowed—
More and deeper stress lines allowed
FN+ 6.5: Up to 1/4 inch spine split or severe color break are allowed—Minor spine rolls allowed and cover can have minor
discoloration, staining and/or foxing as well as minor to moderate cover creases
FN 6.0: Same as 6.5 but with a loose but attached centerfold
FN- 5.5: Same as above but with some Marvel Chipping present
as well as some bundling ridges and minor abraded edges, also
light pencil marks possible
VG/FN 5.0: Low cover gloss possible minor to moderate dimples
and creases present, up to 1/2 inch spine split, moderate rolling
of the spine—may also have the beginning of an acid odor
VG+ 4.5: Cover wear is moderate to significant, cover may be
loose. Cover may be faded staples discolored, moderate staple
tears up to 1” spine split, moderate stress lines moderate interior
tears minor odor minor repairs and up to a 1/4 inch triangle or
27
1/8 square missing (must not effect story). Pages can be brown
but not brittle
VG 4.0: Same as above but with heavy spine wear and brown
staining on cover, also some pen and/or pencil writing is common but should not be excessive
VG- 3.5: Same as 4.0 but with frayed edges, oxidation shadows
on the cover and larger cover creases, with many dimples and
abraded corners
G/VG 3.0: Very low or no cover gloss, cover may be detached
on one staple, 1 1/2 inch spine split, Interior tears and larger up to
1/2 inch chunks missing (must not effect story), staples may have
been replaced and book length creases may be present
GD+ 2.5: Same as 3.0 but may have detached (but present)
centerfold or cover and rounded corners
GD 2.0: Up to 2 inch spine split, Significant cover wear heavily
rolled spine, rust migration on to the book, acid odor, but must
be fully readable
GD- 1.8: Major writing, heavy staining and light water damage possible
FR/GD 1.5: Cover creases tears and folds, may be detached
and with considerable wear and staining, up to 1/10 of the back
cover may be missing, one missing staple is acceptable and
massive rust migration
FR 1.0: Cut coupons (may effect story slightly), chunks of cover
missing centerfold may be missing, pages may be brittle, many
tears and folds and creases are very large and many, cover
may be crumpled
PR 0.5: Massive water damage, major damage effecting most
of the book (e.g. dog chewed it), running ink and coverless
books belong here.
28
Mormon comic and gaming related websites:
http://www.helamonline.com/
http://www.ldsboardgames.com/
http://www.spidercomics.com/
http://www.mormoncartoonist.com/
http://mormoniplates.blogspot.com/
http://www.schlockmercenary.com/
http://www.zombienation.com/
http://honestjoncomics.blogspot.com/
http://www.velluto.com/
http://www.tylerkirkham.com/
http://themormongamer.wordpress.com/
http://www.mormonbattalion.cc/
http://www.mormonzone.com/
http://timesandseasons.org/index.php/2012/10/book-of-mormon-comics/
http://www.motleyvision.org/author/theric/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7mSv0vt8ByA/
Notes:
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
29
Utah Art at the Keyboard
Janet B. Bradford and Lynn Richard Carson
Images of Utah and Mormons are depicted in movies. They are the
subjects of many books and articles. Sometimes they are the topic
of in-depth, multi-day conferences. Just how do others see us and
our state? And is that representation always the way we wish to
be characterized? Whether shown in a positive light or a narrow,
negative stereotype, a picture truly is worth a thousand words.
A study of music by and about Mormons provides new insights as
did an illustrated history of American popular sheet music by authors Harris and Riis (cited below). “American music evolved within
a cultural kaleidoscope,” they state, “and the composers, publishers, performers, and cover artists collectively known as Tin Pan Alley
powered the engine of American music for over fifty years, beginning around 1895 [and] through multi-page songs with ornate covers reflected America’s burgeoning cultural identity.”
This seminar will highlight our “cultural identity.” Artistic sheet
music covers of Utah from the 1860s to the 1940s will be shown
and discussed. All titles are from the Harold B. Lee Library and/or
from the Lynn R. Carson Mormon Music Collections. These covers
provide historical perspectives on a variety of subjects from early
Utah landscapes, political campaigns, and patriotic themes to
Mormon social customs and dancing. We will illustrate how Utah
and Mormons were portrayed in London in the late 1800s, on
Broadway in 1914, and compare these perceptions to the recent
Tony, Grammy and Billboard-winning Broadway hit, The Book of
Mormon the Musical.
Collecting strategies will be suggested.
Selected Chronological Listing of Titles:
The Mormons : Quadrille by Charles Coote (1860)
Brigham Young, or, Perhaps She’s on the Railway (1870)
Popsy Wopsy composed by Charles Merion (1870)
31
My Love He Is a Mormonite, comic song written and composed
by Harry Miller (1871)
Z.C.M.I March, composed by Joseph J. Daynes (1884)
On the Beautiful Salt Lake, waltzes composed by Anthon Pedersen
(1885)
The Holy Temple, sacred song by Joseph J. Daynes (1903)
The Mormon Coon, words by Raymond A. Browne; music by
Henry Clay Smith (1905)
The Girl From Utah: Some Sort of Girl, They Didn’t Believe Me,
music by Jerome Kern; words by Herbert Reynolds (1914)
Dearie Girl, words and music by Margaret Whitney (SLC, 1914)
(New York, 1915)
My Aviating Summer Girl, words and music by Clarice Manning
and Margaret Whitney (1915)
Heart Tones: A Reverie, piano solo by John M. Chamberlain (1915)
The Little Girl You Left Behind, words and music by Harry A. Montgomery (1915)
The Boys of the Salt Lake High, words by Boyd Merrihew and Norman Nathan; music by Norman N. Nathan (1917)
If You Saw What I Saw You’d Go to Utah, words and music by
Howard Patrick (1917)
Old Glory, composed and sung at the BYU Commencement
exercises June 1917
My Oriental Dream, by Leroy J. Robertson and J. Leonard Ivory (1922)
When It’s Springtime in the Rockies, words by Mary Hale Woolsey,
music by Robert Sauer & Milt Taggart (1929)
Alma Pater, pep song of BYU, music by Walt Daniels, words by
Glenn S. Potter (1931)
When Segos Bloom in Utah, words and music by Will Hanson (1932)
Lilac Time, by Herbert Auerbach and A.C. Lund (1935)
32
Along the Navajo Trail, piano solo by Seldon N. Heaps (1936)
Marching with the G.O.P., words and music by K.E. Fordham (1940)
Public Domain Sheet Music Collections Web Sources:
Music for the Nation, American Sheet Music (Music Division,
Library of Congress)
http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/mussmhtml/mussmhome.html
Lester S. Levy Sheet Music Collection (John Hopkins University)
http://levysheetmusic.mse.jhu.edu/
Sheet Music Consortium (UCLA)
http://digital2.library.ucla.edu/sheetmusic/
Recommended Readings
Dockter, Brent, Thomas Riis, Esther Terpenning. Yankee Doodle
Melodies: An Illustrated History of American Patriotic and Presidential Sheet Music from the American Music Research Center.
Boulder, CO: University of Colorado at Boulder, College of Music,
American Music Research Center, 2009.
Harris, David and Thomas Riis. In the Good Old Summer Time:
An Illustrated History of American Popular Sheet Music from the
American Music Research Center Boulder, CO: University of Colorado at Boulder, College of Music, American Music Research
Center, 2006.
Hicks, Michael. Mormonism and Music: A History. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1989.
McNiff, William J. The part played by the Mormon Church in the
cultural development of early Utah, 1847–1879. PhD thesis, Ohio
State University, 1929.
“Mormon Music: The Development of Leadership” in Howard
Swan’s Music in the Southwest, 1825–1950. San Marino, CA : The
Huntington Library, 1952.
“Mormons and Music: Maintaining and Mainstreaming Sectarian
Identity” in Stephan A. Marini’s Sacred Song in American: Religion,
Music, and Public Culture. Urbana : University of Illinois Press, 2003.
Scherrer-Gilbert, Donna Gena. “We’ll Sing and We’ll Shout;” The
Development of Early Mormon Identity Through the Poetry and
Songs of the Saints. Thesis, Arizona State Univeristy, 2000.
33
Notes:
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
34
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
35
Beyond the Volumes of the Joseph
Smith Papers
Robin Scott Jensen
When finished, the Joseph Smith Papers project will comprise a
collection of dozens of volumes and a dynamic website, both of
which will contain a wealth of information on Joseph Smith and
the history of the early Church. For novices and scholars alike,
the volumes of the Joseph Smith Papers can be, at times, daunting. I intend to solve that challenge with an in-depth discussion
of the project, ranging from its history, to how a typical volume is
produced today, to our future expectations and goals. The history will begin with Dean Jessee in the 1960s and 1970s through
his publications of The Papers of Joseph Smith and the reinvigoration of the project in 2001. I will explain briefly the volumes
we’ve published to date and explain a bit about the volumes in
the pipeline. I will focus on interesting discoveries made by the
project, including “new” documents (such as the Book of Commandments and Revelations), insight from a closer reading of
particular documents, and additional insight from a better sense
of the documents as a whole.
I will use a document from the Newel K. Whitney Collection (D&C
5) to explain the “life” of a document from inception to creation,
to storage, and to our publication of that document. Using this
approach, I will also walk the audience through one volume of the
Joseph Smith Papers, to better understand the volume and how it
can best be used, taking into consideration front and back matter,
annotation, source notes, and other design elements of the book.
Given the venue, I will end with a discussion of the role and history of book collectors with particular respect to the Joseph Smith
documents. Autograph collectors, rare book and manuscript
37
dealers, and other private individuals have done important work
in seeing that the past has been preserved. As some documents
are now held in archives, and other institutions have traced their
chain of custody through these collectors and dealers, a general
understanding of these individuals provides a better understanding of patterns of rare manuscripts. I will use real examples from
the past, including the printer’s manuscript of the Book of Mormon and documents purchased as recently as a few years ago.
Link: josephsmithpapers.org
Notes:
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
38
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
39
Peepshows and Panoramas:
the Victorian 3D Experience!
Maggie Gallup Kopp Christina Thomas
Panoramas
The word panorama was coined by British painter Robert Barker
in the 1780’s to describe his landscape paintings, which were
mounted in a cylindrical room. Viewers who stood in the center
of the room could take in a 360 o view as if they were actually at
the scene (military and naval battles were especially popular
subjects for early panoramas). Barker’s panoramas were major
attractions in Regency London. Around 1800, Sir Robert Ker Porter
improved the panorama by mounting a long canvas on rollers,
which allowed his painting to pass before the viewer–a motion
picture before the advent of photography or film. Other panoramas included prop landscaping in front of the painting to extend
the three-dimensional effect.
It wasn’t long before London’s printers were adapting the panorama format into a smaller scale, connecting printed sheets
of paper to form long scenes. The fad for panorama exhibits
waned before Queen Victoria ascended the throne in 1837, but
printed panoramas memorialized many major events and landscapes during her reign. L. Tom Perry Special Collections owns a
dozen English panoramas dating from the 1840s to 1890s, from
lavish productions by specialty printers to mass-produced panoramas issued by London newspapers.
41
Like peepshows, Victorian print panoramas are delightfully collectable, and while Barker and Ker’s panoramas have long since
been lost to the ages, fortunately for us, numerous copies of
printed panoramas have survived and can often be found on
the market today.
Peepshows and Tunnel Books
While the term peepshow wasn’t officially coined until 1801, it
typically refers to a sequence of pictures viewed through a lens
or hole set in a large box, or to a smaller paper diorama or paper
theater. Renaissance artists were some of the first to create the
larger box peepshows as a way to study and explore vanishing
point perspective and depth. Over the next several hundred
years, peepshows evolved and proliferated, spreading into the
realm of popular entertainment as they were carried from village
to village on the backs of traveling showmen. The peepshow
scenes ranged from religious, historical, and mythical scenes, to
portrayals of everyday life. Like panorama exhibits (though much
smaller), they placed a viewer in a three-dimensional scene.
It was eighteenth century German printers who began transforming peepshows into the more familiar handheld format,
just as London printers had done with panoramas. Martin Englebrecht was the most celebrated engraver of this period, and
many of his peepshows—or miniature theaters, as they are often
called—can still be found by collectors today. Predictably, other
European printers followed suit, and eventually the collectable
Victorian souvenir peepshows we recognize today were born.
Similar to panoramas, peepshows commonly commemorated
major events. The new term tunnel book came into vogue at
this time after one such commemorative book was produced
to celebrate the completion of the Thames pedestrian tunnel.
Given that the term peepshow was gaining an increasingly
disreputable connotation by this time, it is not surprising that the
more respectable echelons of Victorian London adopted this
new term. Tunnel book is in fact a term that remains in use today
by contemporary book artists who continue playing with and innovating with form.
L. Tom Perry Special Collections owns three Victorian tunnel
books, including two from the 1851 London Great Exhibition, and
one contemporary tunnel book included in Robert Sabuda’s
Alice in Wonderland.
42
Both panoramas and peepshows were communal forms of entertainment often used to explore three-dimensional effects and
celebrate major events. They might be considered the motion
pictures of their era—entertaining the masses through optical effects and transporting them to different places and times. It is fortunate for us that both panoramas and peepshows evolved into
the mass-produced paper objects that they did, so that many
copies remain available for the enjoyment and observation of
collectors today.
Resources for Collectors
British Panoramas:
J.R. Abbey, Life in England in aquatint and lithography, 17701860. London: privately printed at the Curwen Press, 1953.
J.R. Abbey, Scenery of Great Britain and Ireland in aquatint and
lithography, 1770-1860. London: privately printed at the Curwen
Press, 1952.
Peepshows and Tunnel Books:
Haining, Peter. Movable Books: An Illustrated History: Pages &
Pictures of folding, revolving, dissolving, mechanical, scenic,
panoramic, imensional, changing, pop-up and other novelty
books from the collection of David and Briar Phillips. London:
New English Library, 1979.
Hutchins, Edward H. “How-to-Project: A Tunnel Book”. Paper
Crafters. Sept./Oct 1994. http://www.philobiblon.com/gbwarticle/hutchins1.PDF
Montanaro, Ann. “A Concise History of Toy and Movable Books,”
http://www.libraries.rutgers.edu/rul/libs/scua/montanar/p-intro.htm
Notes:
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
43
Card’s Game:
Collectible Orson Scott Card
Robert L. Maxwell
The release of the movie Ender’s Game in November 2013 has
brought with it renewed interest in Orson Scott Card, particularly in
Utah. Orson Scott Card is a good example of a collectible contemporary author. This seminar will use Card as an example of how to
go about collecting the published output of such an author.
Orson Scott Card is one of the most successful LDS authors of our
time. Card came to the attention of the science fiction world,
where he is now best known, in August 1977 with the publication
in Analog of the short story “Ender’s Game.” This evolved into
the novel Ender’s Game, published in 1985 and winner of both
the Nebula and the Hugo Awards, a feat accomplished by only
one other book: Speaker for the Dead, the sequel to. Card has
published over fifty novels, nearly a hundred short stories, as well
as poetry, plays, graphic novels, and nonfiction works including
reviews, social criticism, and columns. His works have been translated into more than Twenty-five languages.
The Orson Scott Card Collection at BYU is a part of the L. Tom
Perry Special Collections’ Literature Collection. The collection
provides support to BYU literature programs, particularly English, as well as to researchers, faculty, and visiting scholars, and
includes the Orson Scott Card papers, housed in Archives. The
collection includes his literary papers, and the Library collects his
published work comprehensively.
Card began sending his papers to the Library’s Archives in 1978
and continues to send two or three shipments per year. Among
other things, the papers include correspondences, journals, and
manuscripts of all his published work. Special Collections collects
45
the published output of Orson Scott Card comprehensively. This
includes all published books, both in English and translated, and
all published short stories and articles. We collect in all formats,
including audiovisual formats and electronic and on-line formats.
This seminar will draw on this rich collection.
Selected Orson Scott Card Bibliography
Only the first edition of book-length works are given. Because of
space constraints, shorter works are not listed except as part of
anthologies. Also not included are materials edited by Card.
The Abyss, 1989
Ainge, 1982
Alvin Journeyman, 1996 (Tales of Alvin Maker 4)
Animated stories from the Book of Mormon, 1987 (Living Scriptures, screenplay by OSC)
Animated stories from the New Testament (Living Scriptures,
screenplay by OSC)
The Call of Earth, 1993 (Homecoming 2)
Capitol, 1979 (short stories)
Cardography, 1987 (short stories)
The Changed Man, 1992 (short stories)
Characters and Viewpoint, 1988 (nonfiction)
Children of the Mind, 1996 (sequel to Xenocide)
Cruel Miracles, 1992 (short stories)
The Crystal City, 2003 (Tales of Alvin Maker 6)
The Docudrama of the Restoration (Living Scriptures, screenplay
of several parts by OSC)
Doorways, 2002 (poetry and short stories)
Dramatized Church History, 1977 (Living Scriptures, script by OSC)
Dramatized New Testament, 1981 (Living Scriptures, script by OSC)
Dramatized Old Testament (Living Scriptures, script by OSC)
Earth Afire, 2013
46
Earth Unaware, 2012
Earthborn, 1995 (Homecoming 5)
Earthfall, 1995 (Homecoming 4)
Empire, 2006
Enchantment, 1998
Ender’s Game, 1985 (sequel: Speaker for the Dead)
Ender’s Shadow, 1999 (parallel novel to Ender’s Game; sequel:
Shadow of the Hegemon)
First Meetings: in the Enderverse (short stories). 2002
Flux: Tales of Human Futures, 1992 (short stories)
The Folk of the Fringe, 1989 (short stories)
The Gate Thief, 2013
Gold Bug, 2007 (comic book)
Great Mormon Women, 1983 (Living Scriptures, script by OSC)
Hamlet’s Father, 2011
Hart’s Hope, 1983
He is Risen, 1988 (screenplay by OSC)
Heartfire, 1998 (Tales of Alvin Maker 5)
Hidden Empire, 2009
Hill Cumorah Pageant: America’s Witness for Christ, 1988?
(script by OSC)
Homebody, 1998
Hot Sleep, 1979 (later published as The Worthing Chronicle)
How to Write Science Fiction and Fantasy, 1990 (nonfiction)
Invasive Procedures, 2007 (with Aaron Johnston)
Keeper of Dreams, 2008 (short story collection)
Laddertop, 2011 (with Emily Janice Card)
“Listen, Mom and Dad ...”: Young Adults Look Back on Their Upbringing, 1977 (nonfiction)
47
Living Principles of America, 1982 (Living Scriptures, script by
OSC)
Lost Boys, 1992
The Lost Gate, 2011
Lovelock, 1994
Magic Mirror, 1999
Magic Street, 2005
Maps in a Mirror, 1991 (short stories)
The Memory of Earth, 1992 (Homecoming 1)
The Miracles of Love, 1990 (screenplay by OSC)
Monkey Sonatas, 1993 (short stories)
The Mormons, 1978 (nonfiction)
An Open Book, 2003 (poetry)
Pastwatch: The Redemption of Christopher Columbus, 1996
Pathfinder, 2010 (Pathfinder series 1)
A Planet Called Treason, 1979 (later expanded as: Treason)
Prentice Alvin, 1989 (Tales of Alvin Maker 3)
The Princess and the Bear, 1977 (short story and poetry)
Rachel and Leah, 2004 (Women of Genesis)
Rebekah, 2001 (Women of Genesis)
Red Prophet, 1988 (Tales of Alvin Maker 2)
Red Prophet, 2006 (Comic book)
Robota, 2003 (with Doug Chiang)
Ruins, 2012 (Pathfinder series 2)
Saints, 1988 (previously published as A Woman of Destiny)
Saintspeak: The Mormon Dictionary, 1981 (nonfiction)
Sarah, 2000 (Women of Genesis)
Seventh Son, 1987 (Tales of Alvin Maker 1)
Shadow of the Giant, 2005 (sequel to: Shadow Puppets)
Shadow of the Hegemon, 2001 (sequel to: Ender’s Shadow;
sequel: Shadow Puppets)
Shadow Puppets, 2002 (sequel to: Shadow of the Hegemon;
sequel: Shadow of the Giant)
Shadows in Flight, 2012 (sequel to: Shadow of the Giant)
The Ships of Earth, 1994 (Homecoming 3)
Songmaster, 1980
Space Boy, 2007
Speaker for the Dead, 1986 (sequel to: Ender’s Game; sequel:
Xenocide)
Stone Tables, 1997
A Storyteller in Zion, 1993 (essays)
Treason, 1988 (expanded version of A Planet Called Treason)
48
Treasure Box, 1996
Ultimate Iron Man, 2005 (comic book)
Unaccompanied Sonata & Other Stories, 1981 (short stories)
Visitors, 2014 (Pathfinder 3)
A War of Gifts, 2007
A Woman of Destiny, 1984 (later published as Saints)
The Worthing Chronicle, 1983 (based in part on Capitol and Hot
Sleep)
The Worthing Saga, 1990 (expansion of The Worthing Chronicle)
Wyrms, 1987
Wyrms, 2006 (comic book)
Xenocide, 1991 (sequel to: Speaker for the Dead; sequel:
Children of the Mind)
Zanna’s Gift, 2004
Notes:
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
49
A Proclamation From the Lord:
Broadsides, Posters, and Handbills
in the Print Culture of Mormonism
Greg Seppi
Literally from the inception of movable type printing broadsides
have been an oft-used format for dissemination of the written word.
Indeed, even before the completion of Gutenberg’s 42-line Bible,
several broadside indulgences were produced for Pope Nicolaus
V no later than the year 1454. Other early broadsides were used for
the circulation of royal proclamations, official notices, and political
statements, sometimes to express opposition to authoritarian rule.
It should not, therefore, be surprising that Mormons would also use
this printing format to issue a variety of religious publications from
the earliest decades of Mormonism through the present day. This
seminar will examine all manner of Mormon broadsides from publications of scripture and early proclamations to recent pronouncements such as “The Living Christ: The Testimony of the Apostles” and
“The Family: A Proclamation to the World.”
51
Selected Bibliography of General Works on Broadsides, Street Literature,
and Ephemera
Collison, Robert. The story of street literature: forerunner of the
popular press. (London: J.M. Dent & Sons, Limited, [1973]).
James, Louis, ed.. Print and the people 1819–1951. (London: Penguin Books, Ltd., 1976)
Includes numerous examples of broadsides.
Rickards, Maurice. The encyclopedia of Ephemera: a guide to
the fragmentary documents of everyday life for the collector,
curator, and historian. (New York: Routledge, 2000).
A very good, general, all purpose volume which includes
examples of all varieties of broadsides and ephemeral
publications.
Shepard, Leslie. The history of street literature: the story of broadside ballads, chapbooks, proclamations, news-sheets, election
bills, tracts, pamphlets, cocks, catchpennies, and other ephemera.
(Newton Abbot [Eng.]: David & Charles, 1973).
Watt, Tessa. Cheap print and popular piety, 1550–1640. (Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press, 1991).
A study of the early period of popular ephemeral printing.
Web Sources
From the Library of Congress:
An American Time Capsule: Three Centuries of
Broadsides and other Printed Ephemera:
http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/rbpehtml/pehome.html
From the National Library of Scotland:
The Word on the Street:
http://www.nls.uk/broadsides/background.html
52
From the Library Company of Philadelphia:
Pennsylvania German Broadsides: Windows into an
American Culture
http://www.librarycompany.org/broadsides/
Mormon bibliographic works that include descriptions of broadsides, etc.
Allen, James B., Ronald W. Walker, and David J. Whittaker. Studies
in Mormon history, 1830–1997: an indexed bibliography. . . .(Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, c2000).
An enlarged edition of this work is available as a
searchable online database at:
http://mormonhistory.byu.edu/
Crawley, Peter. A descriptive bibliography of the Mormon
Church. Volume One 1830–1847. (Provo, UT: Religious Studies
Center, Brigham Young University, 1997).
–––––––––. A descriptive bibliography of the Mormon Church.
Volume Two 1848–1852. (Provo, UT: Religious Studies Center,
Brigham Young University, 2005).
–––––––––. A descriptive bibliography of the Mormon Church.
Volume Three 1853–1857. (Provo, UT: Religious Studies Center,
Brigham Young University, 2012).
Flake, Chad J. and Larry W. Draper. A Mormon bibliography,
1830–1930. Books pamphlets, periodicals and broadsides relating to the first century of Mormonism. Second edition, revised
and enlarged. (Provo, UT: Brigham Young University, Religious
Studies Center, 2004).
An enlarged edition of this work is available as a
searchable online database at:
http://atom.lib.byu.edu/mormonbib
Web source
From the BYU Library
Mormon Publications: 19th and 20th Centuries:
http://lib.byu.edu/digital/mpntc/
This web site is a full text searchable site that includes a
collection of early Mormon publications comprised of
books, missionary tracts, doctrinal treatises, broadsides,
hymnals and periodicals which helped define the
doctrinal development and historical movements of the
Mormon people in the nineteenth century. It includes a
few Mormon broadsides.
Notes:
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
53
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
54
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
__________________________________
55
On Bended Knee: An Appreciation of
Devotional Literature
Russ Taylor and Fr. Eric Hollas
“Devotional literature includes any religious book other than
strictly doctrinal or theological works, intended to be used
mainly for home devotion, that is, for meditation and prayer
and also for uplift (edification). Books of this kind might further be used to strengthen the spirit in times of temptation
and weakness, or to confirm one’s own stand in an adverse
situation, or to clarify one’s faith by outline—confessions and
catechisms. In short, all these books served the practice of an
inner rather than an external (ecclesiastical) devotion of an
earnest believer …1“
This session will explore various types of religious devotional texts
in the L. Tom Perry Special Collections, including medieval scriptural texts, books of hours, and other examples of private devotional works. We will examine the volumes of The Saint John’s
Bible and hear about how this beautiful work of art was created,
both from Father Eric and through videos featuring Donald Jackson, artistic director for the project.
While the books we will examine were made for “inner devotion,” we will, nonetheless, spend some time examining the external manifestations of these inner devotions as represented by the
beautiful illuminations on their pages. We hope our discussions
will leave all of us with a deeper understanding of the concept
of religious devotion.
Friedmann, Robert and John C. Wenger. “Devotional Literature.” Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. 1990. Web. 7 Dec 2013.
http://gameo.org/index.php?title+Devotional_Literature&oldid=103762.
1
57
The following works will provide some additional elaboration for
those interested in pursuing the topic further:
Bartlett, Anne Clark (ed.). Cultures of Piety: Medieval English Devotional Literature in Translation. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1999.
------- . Male Authors, Female Readers: Representation and
Subjectivity in Middle English Devotional Literature. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1995.
Bestul, Thomas H. Texts of the Passion: Latin Devotional Literature and
Medieval Society. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1996.
Christensen, James. Passage by Faith: Exploring the Inspirational
Art of James C. Christensen. Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 2012.
Hamerton, Philip Gilbert. Man in Art: Studies in Religious and Historical Art, Portrait and Genre. London: Macmillan, 1892.
Holmes, William. Religious Allegories: Being a Series of Emblematic Engravings, with Written Explanations, Miscellaneous Observations, and Religious Reflections Designed to Illustrate Divine
Truth, in Accordance with the Cardinal Principles of Christianity.
Philadelphia: J.W. Bradley, 1851.
Jameson, (Mrs.) Anna. Sacred and Legendary Art: Containing Legends of the Angels and Archangels, the Evangelists, the
Apostles, the Doctors of the Church, St. Mary Magdalene, the
Patron Saints, the Martyrs, the Early Bishops, the Hermits, and the
Warrior Saints of Christendom as Represented in the Fine Arts.
London: Longman, Brown, Green, and Longmans, 1850.
Kepler, Thomas S. The Fellowship of the Saints: An Anthology of
Christian Devotional Literature. New York: Abingdon-Cokesbury
Press, 1948.
Mahr, Adolf. Christian Art in Ancient Ireland: Selected Objects
Illustrated and Described. Dublin: Stationery Office of Saorstát
Éireann, 1932-41.
Ruskin, John. Mornings in Florence: Being Simple Studies of Christian
Art, for English Travellers. Orpington, Kent: George Allen, 1875-1877.
Weizsäcker, Heinrich. Die Kunstschätze des ehemaligen Dominikanerklosters in Frankfurt a. M. nach den archivalischen Quellen bearbeitet
und herausgeben. Munich: Verlag von F. Bruckmann, 1923.
58
White, Helen Constance. English Devotional Literature, 1600
-1640. Madison: University of Wisconsin, 1931.
Wilcox, Helen. Sacred and Profane: Secular and Devotional
Interplay in Early Modern British Literature. Amsterdam: VU University Press, 1996.
Winder, Lorie Joanne. Maria Regina Coeli: The Cult of the Virgin
Mary in Twelfth-Century Theology, Devotional Literature, and Art.
Master’s thesis, Brigham Young University, 1977.
Yoshikawa, Naoë Kukita. Margery Kempe’s Meditations: The Context of Medieval Devotional Literature, Liturgy, and Iconography.
Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 2007.
Notes:
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
59
Breaking Though
The Religion Taboo: Contemporary
Mormon Children’s Fiction
Rachel L. Wadham
The artistic form of literature is designed to comment on the
human condition and as such, works of fiction delve into the
themes and ideas that are important to humanity. This includes
religion. In fact, religious themes and allegories have long been
associated with great literature, where works such as Dante’s
Divine Comedy and Bunyan’s The Pilgrim’s Progress rise to the
top. The history of children’s literature also has some strong connections to religious themes evidenced by notable works such as
Lewis’ Narnia series. However in modern times, this connection
has proven to be weaker as traditional trade publishers have
shied away from religious topics. This is where independent publishers have stepped up to fill the void and the existence of many
of these publishers relies on the fact that they can embrace this
otherwise taboo topic. Publishers who focus on Christian novels
have long flooded the market, however after the success of
Lund’s The Work and The Glory series in the 1990s there has been
a burgeoning market for fiction aimed at the Mormon audience.
Engaging in these markets, publishers have produced books for
all audiences, including children. Today with more titles flooding the market than ever before, the trick is to hone in on those
of the highest quality. Without a doubt the quality of Mormon
children’s fiction varies greatly, so having criteria to apply to
these works is of significant importance. The major independent
publishers of children’s books have a lot to offer, and using refined judgment to assess the quality of their works brings to light a
growing body of works suitable for both personal enjoyment and
for building book collections.
61
Major Independent Publishers of Mormon Children’s Books
Cedar Fort Publishing: http://cedarfort.com/
Covenant Communications: http://www.covenant-lds.com/
Desert Book: http://deseretbook.com/
Horizon Publishers: http://ldshorizonpublishers.com/children.htm
Shadow Mountain Publishing: http://www.shadowmountain.com/
Walnut Springs Press: http://walnutspringspress.blogspot.com/
Assessing Quality In Children’s Books
The following resources, definition, characteristics and questions
provide a good set of criteria for assessing the quality of children’s books. While these criteria can be applied to any work,
they provide great insight when determining the quality of Mormon children’s fiction.
Resources:
Lukens, Rebecca J. (2007). A Critical Handbook of Children’s
Literature. Boston: Allyn and Bacon/Person Education
Tunnell, Michael O. & James, Jacobs. (2008) Children’s Literature
Briefly. (4. ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education.
Definition:
Michael O. Tunnell and James S. Jacobs tell us a good book “is
one created by a knowledgeable and skilled author in which the
elements of literature measure up under critical analysis. Quality is
recognized by evaluating different elements of the book, including
style and language, character, plot, illustrations, pacing, setting,
tension, design and layout, mood, accuracy, tone, point of view,
and theme. When a book reveals its story in powerful language,
contains memorable characters, and follows a compelling plot, the
fiction generally can be said to have quality” (p. 13).
Characteristics of Quality Children’s Books:
Encourage imagination, exploration, and play
Express authentic emotions in genuine contexts
62
Expand vocabulary
Extend a child’s understanding of themselves and others
Embolden discussion and thoughtful reflection
Exposes children to the world’s diversity
Essential Questions to Consider While Determining Quality:
The following list of questions are to reveal the important criteria
relative to judging the quality of children’s books. These questions are by no means comprehensive, but they are designed to
offer a basic standard that can be used to address the complex
nature of judging an individual text.
Format:
What is the physical size of the book?
How many pages does it have?
What kinds of font are used in the text?
Is the font represented in a nonstandard way (indented or margined differently, presented in different colors, etc.) and does
remain static or does it vary throughout the course of the text?
How is the text laid out and is this layout expected or unconventional?
Of how high a quality is the physical construction of the text?
How does the author organize, divide, or arrange the work?
Is this structure logical and consistent, or does it represent an
atypical organization?
What role do the illustrations play? Are they merely illustrative, or
are they integral to the story?
What visual literacy skills are necessary for the reader to interpret
both the text and the pictures?
Levels of Meaning:
Is there a central question that the author is trying to answer or give
perspective on? How dense are these concepts in the text?
How many interpretations does that central question allow for?
63
How many themes are present and how are they connected?
Does the theme represent a universal issue or need or is it blatant
or didactic?
How is the theme constructed and revealed? Does it emerge
authentically?
What conflict is evident in the story and from what source does it stem?
How many types of conflict are apparent in the text?
What connections can be made between this text and a reader’s broader world experiences?
What connections can be made between this and other texts
(both narrative and informational)?
Does the text make allusions to other texts? How much does the
meaning of the text rely on these allusions and knowledge of the
texts being alluded to?
Structure:
Is the setting familiar or unfamiliar? Are they represented realistically?
How is the plot constructed and how many plot lines does the
story follow?
Does the plot follow an accurate timeline or does it jump around
in time and/or space?
How identifiable is the climax? Are there numerous climaxes that
build to a central crisis?
Does the story resolve in a predictable way or are their twists
and surprises?
Does the end resolve satisfactorily or are there points left open
that will lead to a sequel?
How many characters are in the book? How many could be
considered a main protagonist?
Are the characters complex, multi-layered rather than
stereotyped or flat?
How much emotional or physical change do the characters
experience over the course of the text?
64
What style (omniscient, first person, third person, etc) is used to
express point of view?
Is the story told from more than one point of view?
How diverse are the characters and points of view of the text?
Do they represent cultures, races, colors, or ideas that are outside of the perceived norms of a particular population?
How credible and believable is the setting, plot, characters,
and theme?
How many details does the author use in describing the setting,
plot, or characters?
How dependent are interpretations of one element (such as setting, plot, or characters) on the other elements (like setting, plot,
character, or theme)?
What style and tone does the author use? For what effect is that
style or tone being used?
Does the book contain dialects or other specialized or archaic
language usage? To what extent is this language used?
What literary devices does the author use? How frequently are
these devices used?
How sophisticated or complex are these literary devices?
Knowledge Demands:
What background information or prior knowledge is necessary to
comprehend this text?
What does the author assume we already know?
Are there parts that could be confusing without the necessary
knowledge and why would they be confusing?
What level of preparation would need to be done with a reader
to prevent this text from being confusing?
Notes:
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
___________________________________
65
Luncheon Speaker
Fr. Eric Hollas
Fr. Eric Hollas, OSB, is a Benedictine monk and priest of Saint
John’s Abbey in Collegeville, MN. He was born in Oklahoma City,
and he received his BA in history at Princeton University in 1971.
Following seminary studies at Saint John’s, he received a PhD in
medieval studies at Yale University. His special interests include
the history of Spain in the Middle Ages, the history of monasticism
in medieval Europe, and the history of the book. He is a member
of the Medieval Academy of America, and he also serves as a
chaplain in the Western Association of the Order of Malta, as
well as in the Order of the Holy Sepulchre.
Since 1980 he has been a member of the theology faculty at
Saint John’s University, and from 1993–2002 he served as the
Executive Director of the Hill Museum & Manuscript Library. He
currently serves as Deputy to the President for Advancement, at
Saint John’s University.
The Saint John’s Bible
In 1998, Saint John’s Abbey and University commissioned renowned
calligrapher Donald Jackson to produce a hand written, handilluminated Bible. We invite you to explore this work of art that unites
an ancient Benedictine tradition with the technology and vision of
today, illuminating the Word of God for a new millennium.
More information on the Saint John’s Bible is available at http://
www.saintjohnsbible.org
66
Ecclesiastes, Donald Jackson, Copyright 2006, The Saint John’s
Bible, Order of Saint Benedict, Collegeville, Minnesota, USA.
Gospel of John Frontispiece and Incipit, Donald Jackson, Copyright 2002, The Saint John’s Bible and the Hill Museum & Manuscript
Library, Order of Saint Benedict, Collegeville, Minnesota, USA.
67
A. Dean Larsen
Memorial and Biography
The Harold B. Lee Library Book Collecting Conference is named in
memory of A. Dean Larsen, retired Associate University Librarian
at Brigham Young University, who
passed away on May 29, 2002 after
a long battle with cancer.
Dean Larsen worked at the BYU Library for 40 years and was principally
responsible for the acquisition of over
three million volumes during his career, adding not only to the general
collection, but building a world-class
Special Collections as well.
Under Dean’s direction, the Library
reached prominence as one of the nation’s finest research
libraries. Dean worked closely with Chad Flake to acquire unique
research materials that today form the core of Special Collections. Among the collections built by Dean and Chad are the
History of Printing, Renaissance and Reformation, History of Science, British and American Literature, Victorian and nineteenth
century Social History, and Western and Mormon Americana. His
personal interest in collecting rare books and manuscripts resulted in lifelong friendships with librarians, collectors, curators, and
book dealers around the world. Prior to his passing away, Larsen
and his wife, Jean, donated to the Lee Library their personal
collection of more than 1,800 books, pamphlets, maps, photographs, and postcards dealing with Yellowstone National Park
and established an endowment for its continued growth.
Both A. Dean Larsen’s life and career were centered on libraries,
book collecting, and BYU. For this reason the university is pleased
to recognize Dean’s many contributions by naming the Lee
Library’s Book Collecting Conference in his honor.
A. Dean Larsen was born August 23, 1930 in Vineyard, Utah,
a rural farming and dairy community adjacent to Orem and
Provo, Utah. He was the third of five children, two older brothers and two younger sisters, born to Vera Alice Austin and Ariel
Ellis Larsen. His early years growing up on a farm and in a house
without indoor plumbing required performing daily chores like
carrying water from the spring, providing kindling to start the fire
in the old kitchen coal stove and the heater in the front room, as
well as keeping the coal buckets full.
During the war years in the 1940s, a steel mill was constructed in
Vineyard thus prompting the relocation of several families living
in that area. When Dean was fourteen years of age the Larsen
family moved to Orem where they had purchased a small farm
and a newly remodeled modern home. Also on the property was
a large barn. With the move, Dean’s father started a hide and fur
business, thus the barn had a double function of providing shelter
for livestock and a spacious area for processing hides and furs.
68
Dean attended Lincoln High School in Orem where he was on
the debate team, associate editor of the yearbook, president of
FFA, and a student assistant for a very inadequate school library.
After graduating from high school, he entered Brigham Young
University, focusing his study on history and geography. Summers and evenings were spent buying and processing hides for
his father. He interrupted his university study after his sophomore
year to serve as a missionary for the Church of Jesus Christ of
Latter-day Saints. Upon completion of this two-year mission, he
returned to his studies at BYU and obtained student employment
in the Library. From that time on, books and the Library became
an integral part of his life.
When he graduated from the university with a major in history,
the Korean War was under way and he was drafted to serve in
the army. After basic and specialized training, he was assigned
to the Central Intelligence Corp in Stuttgart, Germany. This assignment and location provided extensive opportunities during
weekends and short leaves to experience travel throughout Europe. This opportunity imbued him with a lasting appreciation for
the arts, museums, libraries, bookshops, rare book dealers, etc.
Dean returned home from his tour of duty with the army in the
fall of 1956 and was hired full-time at the BYU Library with an
agreement that he would be given summers off to pursue a Master of Library Science at the University of Michigan. He completed his degree in August of 1960. The next year he was appointed
director for collection development. The fruits of his ability and
tireless efforts are now documented with the quality and quantity of books acquired during his tenure at the helm of acquisition
for Brigham Young University’s Harold B. Lee Library. Dean was
also an avid collector of material for his personal library. One
of his most extensive collections was his collection of Yellowstone materials. He also spent a great deal of time working on a
general bibliography for Yellowstone material. Before his death,
he was able to accrue information for more than tenthousand
annotated entries.
From the beginning of his career he demonstrated what some
have said is a gift or rare ability—a true “book sense.” It is something analogous to height in a basketball player—it can’t be
acquired through training—you either have it or you don’t. He was
able to recognize not only the value of the acquisition, but also to
envision how it would contribute to the collections of the Llibrary.
69
Presenter Biographies
Trevor Alvord
Trevor Alvord is the Curator of twenty-first-century
Mormonism and Western America at Brigham Young
University where he is responsible for building BYU’s
web archive and collecting twenty-firs-century
Mormon imprints. Before coming to BYU he served
as a Processing Archivist at Utah State University and
as Head of Special Collections at James Madison
University. Trevor received undergraduate degrees
from USU in History and Religious Studies in 2007 and
his MLIS from San Jose State University in 2009.
Janet B. Bradford
Janet B. Bradford has been a Music and Dance
Librarian at BYU since the mid-1980s. She has a BA
from BYU in Music Theory and Composition with
postgraduate studies in musicology. Her MLS degree
is from the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign.
Janet was raised in Geneva, Idaho, and currently
lives in Orem with her husband, Daron, daughter
Emily, and their cat, Max. She is also a stepmom
to four, grandmother of twelve, and sings in the
Mormon Tabernacle Choir.
Janet has eclectic musical tastes. Over the past few
years she has focused on collecting Mormon music for the BYU library.
Lynn Richard Carson
Lynn Richard Carson was born in Salt Lake City
in 1942. He collects music and recordings about
Utah and Mormonism. Lynn composed his first
hymn when he was fourteen and has been writing
sacred music as a form of private devotion and
worship ever since. He has composed more than
two hundred hymns, sacred songs, and keyboard
pieces, many of which are available for performance. His Hymn “Sabbath Day” is in the LDS
Hymnal. He is currently preparing for publication a
collection of keyboard music by nineteenth
century Utah and Mormon composers.
Lynn’s interests include musical practice in the LDS faith, 1830 –1900.
He and his wife Pamela are avid Sacred Harp singers and host a shape
note singing in Utah in their home on the fourth Tuesday of each month.
70
Robin Scott Jensen
Robin Scott Jensen is the associate managing
historian and project archivist for The Joseph Smith
Papers and coedited the first two volumes in the
Revelations and Translations series (published 2009
and 2011, respectively). He specializes in document and transcription analysis. In 2005 he earned
an MA in American history from Brigham Young
University, and in 2009 he earned a second MA in
library and information science with an archival
concentration from the University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee. He is now pursuing a PhD in history at the
University of Utah. His research interests include
book history, revelation manuscripts, early Mormon record keeping, and
the history of the Church Historian’s Office.
Maggie Gallup Kopp
Maggie Gallup Kopp is Curator of Rare Books at L.
Tom Perry Special Collections in the Harold B. Lee
Library, where she is responsible for the European
historical collections and rare British and American
literature. She is the curator of the Lee Library’s
current exhibit, Victorian Illustrators: from Sketch to
Print. She holds an MA from Fordham University and
an MLS from the University of Texas at Austin.
Robert L. Maxwell
Robert L. Maxwell is a regular presenter at the A.
Dean Larsen Book Collecting Conference. He is
one of the Library’s rare materials catalogers and
is curator of the Orson Scott Card Collection. He
holds a PhD in Classics from University of Toronto,
and a JD, an MA, and an MLS from Brigham Young
University. He also received his BA from BYU in
French and Latin.
71
Joan Merrell
Joan Merrell has been teaching calligraphy for
over twenty years around the country and at several international lettering arts conferences. She was
on the board of directors and is a past president of
the international Association for the Calligraphic
Arts. She graduated from BYU and studied further
at University of North Carolina at Charlotte as well
as having studied lettering with many top names
in the field in workshop settings and master classes.
She is a codirector of the 35th International Lettering Arts Conference to be held in Utah in 2017.
Her work has been carried by several galleries and
published in Letter Arts Review, Hand Lettering for Crafts, and others.
She received a purchase award from the 9th International Arts Competition of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Joan currently
lives in Jefferson City, MO and belongs to the St. Louis Calligraphy Guild.
www.LetterDesignStudio.com
Kohleen Reeder
Kohleen Reeder is the Head Conservator of Rare
Books and Manuscripts at the Harold B. Lee Library.
Her experience with conservation began as an
undergraduate student at Brigham Young University
where she worked at the Harold B. Lee Library
Conservation Lab. Kohleen holds a BA in Visual
Arts from BYU, and completed a MA in Conservation Studies at West Dean College in England. She
has completed conservation internships at the
Frick Art Reference Library, the LDS Church History
Library, University of Durham, and the National
Library of Scotland. From 2006 to 2008 she worked
as a Postgraduate Research Associate in Paper Conservation at the
Yale Center for British Art, where she completed a research project and
wrote a chapter published in the award-winning exhibition catalogue,
Mrs. Delany and Her Circle. Previous to her return to BYU in Spring 2013,
she worked for four and a half years as a Book and Paper Conservator
at the University of Utah J. Willard Marriott Library.
Gregory Seppi
Gregory Seppi is a rare book acquisitions specialist at the Church History Library. He earned an MA
in the History of Medicine from Oxford Brookes
University in 2011, and will begin studying for a
Master of Library Science degree in August 2014.
He also holds a BA in History from Brigham Young
University (2010). Following a successful internship at
the Church History Library in 2012, he was hired into
his current position in 2013. His research interests
include the history of LDS publishing and printing
(especially ephemera), contemporary LDS culture,
and the history of eugenics.
72
Russ Taylor
Russ Taylor has been Supervisor of Reference
Services at the L. Tom Perry Special Collections of
BYU’s Harold B. Lee Library since 1999. Prior professional work includes fifteen years as a corporate
speechwriter, three years as assistant curator of
Special Collections at BYU and temporary positions
as reference librarian at Mary Washington College
(Fredericksburg, Virginia) and Anoka-Ramsey Community College (Coon Rapids, Minnesota), and as
a contract library cataloger for Advanced Information Consultants (Minneapolis, Minnesota). To round
out his professional career, he has also worked as a
bullwhacker and an ox driver for the Minnesota State Historical Society
at the Oliver Kelly Historic Farm in Elk River, Minnesota, and at “This Is The
Place” Heritage Park in Salt Lake City.
Christina Thomas
Christina Thomas was first trained as a book repair
technician while a BYU student from 2000 – 2004.
She later completed the two-year bookbinding
program at the North Bennet Street School in Boston. After completing book conservation internships
at Haverford College, the Boston Public Library,
and the LDS Church History Library, she joined the
Harold B. Lee Library staff as assistant to James Fairbourn in 2009. In July 2013 the staff of the Harold B.
Lee Library Conservation Lab welcomed her as a
Conservator of Rare Books and Manuscripts.
Rachel L. Wadham
Rachel L. Wadham is the Education and Juvenile
Collections Librarian in the Harold B. Lee Library.
After completing a bachelor’s degree in sociology from BYU, Wadham obtained her master of
library science from the University of North Texas
in 1995. She also earned a masters of education
in curriculum and instruction with an emphasis
in adolescent literature from Pennsylvania State
University in 2007. She frequently teaches courses
on children’s and adolescent literature and has
authored two books and numerous articles in this
field. Wadham also serves as board member of
the Children’s Literature Association of Utah and is chair of its Young
Adult Book Award Selection Committee.
73
No Class
No Class
Class
10:30 – 11:45 am
1:45 – 3:00 pm
3:15 – 4:30 pm
No Class
Class
Class
Class
Class
Class
No Class
Class
No Class
Class
Class
9:00 – 10:15 am
No Class
Library
Instruction Room
2233 HBLL
Spec Coll
Classroom
1131 HBLL
LAO Conf Room
2070 HBLL
Friends Room
6525 HBLL
Location
Class
Rachel L.
Wadham
Russ Taylor &
Fr. Eric Hollas
Maggie Gallup
Kopp & Christina
Thomas
Robert L. Maxwell
Presenter
Breaking Through
the Religion Taboo
Devotional
Literature
Panoramas &
Peep Shows
Card’s Game
Seminar
No Class
No Class
Class
Class
Music
Seminar Room
4420 HBLL
Janet B. Bradford
& Lynn Richard
Carson
Utah Art at the
Keyboard
No Class
Class
Class
Class
LIIL Conf Room
2238 HBLL
Trevor Alvord
ZAP! POW! BAM!:
Mormon Comics &
Pop Culture
Class
Class
Class
No Class
3420 HBLL
A.L. Reynolds Room
Greg Seppi
A Proclamation
from the Lord
Class
Class
No Class
Class
4739 HBLL
Video
Conference Room
Robin Scott
Jenson
Beyond the
Volumes of the
Joseph Smith
A. Dean Larsen Book Collecting Conference. L. Tom Perry Special
Collections. HBLL 1130. Brigham Young University.
Provo, UT 84602. 2014 Conference. Phone: (801) 422-3514. E-mail:
[email protected]. Website: http://lib.byu.edu/adl
Project Coordinator: Tom Wells. Designer: SarahThulin.
L. Tom Perry Special Collections
Harold B. Lee Library
Brigham Young University