Model Comparisons - Erb Equipment Company

2013 Product Comparison
2013 Product Comparison
Articulated Dump Trucks
DEERE
250D-II
300D-II
370E
410E
460E
Rated Payload
23 222 kg (51,150 lb.)
27 326 kg (60,190 lb.)
33 630 kg (74,141 lb.)
37 266 kg (82,157 lb.)
41 820 kg (92,197 lb.)
Net Engine Power
198 kW (265 hp)
212 kW (285 hp)
315 kW (422 hp)
330 kW (443 hp)
359 kW (481 hp)
Heaped Capacity
13.8 m3 (18.0 cu. yd.)
16.6 m3 (21.7 cu. yd.)
20.5 m3 (26.8 cu. yd.)
22.7 m3 (29.7 cu. yd.)
25.5 m3 (33.4 cu. yd.)
CAT
725
730
735
740
VOLVO
A25E
A30E
A35E
A40E
TEREX
TA25
TA30
TA35
TA40
KOMATSU
—
HM300-2
HM350-2
HM400-2
Backhoes
Digging Depth
Standard
Extendable
4.34 m
4.39–5.46 m
(14 ft. 3 in.)
(14 ft. 5 in.–17 ft. 11 in.)
Loader Dump
Clearance
2.69 m
(8 ft. 10 in.)
Operating
Weight
6311 kg
(13,913 lb.)
310K
4.34 m
(14 ft. 3 in.)
4.39–5.46 m
(14 ft. 5 in.–17 ft. 11 in.)
2.69 m
(8 ft. 10 in.)
310SK
4.42 m
(14 ft. 6 in.)
4.55–5.61 m
(14 ft. 11 in.–18 ft. 5 in.)
310SK TC
N/A
410K
DEERE
310K EP
CASE
580N
CAT
416E
NEW HOLLAND
—
JCB
3CX
6364 kg
(14,030 lb.)
580N
416F
—
3C 14 ft.
2.69 m
(8 ft. 10 in.)
6671 kg
(14,708 lb.)
580SN,
580SN WT
420F/IT
B90B, B95C,
B95C LR, B95C TC
3CX 14 ft., 4CX 14 ft.
4.55–5.61 m
(14 ft. 11 in.–18 ft. 5 in.)
2.59 m
(8 ft. 6 in.)
9006 kg
(19,855 lb.)
—
—
—
—
4.83 m
(15 ft. 10 in.)
4.90–6.10 m
(16 ft. 1 in.–20 ft.)
2.69 m
(8 ft. 10 in.)
7435 kg
(16,391 lb.)
590SN
430F/IT
B110C, B115B
3C 15 ft., 3CX 15 ft.,
4CX 15 ft.
410K TC
N/A
4.90–6.10 m
(16 ft. 1 in.–20 ft.)
2.57 m
(8 ft. 5 in.)
9296 kg
(20,494 lb.)
—
—
—
—
710K
5.44 m
(17 ft. 10 in.)
5.44–6.81 m
(17 ft. 10 in.–22 ft. 4 in.)
2.92 m
(9 ft. 7 in.)
10 796 kg
(23,802 lb.)
—
450E
—
3CX 17 ft., 4CX 17 ft.
Tractor Loaders
DEERE
210K EP
210K
Operating Weight
4707 kg (10,379 lb.)
4959 kg (10,936 lb.)
Loader Dump Clearance
2.67 m (8 ft. 9 in.)
2.67 m (8 ft. 9 in.)
Loader Bucket Capacity
0.77–0.96 m3 (1.00–1.25 cu. yd.)
0.77–0.96 m3 (1.00–1.25 cu. yd.)
CASE
570N XT
570N XT
NEW HOLLAND
U80C
U80C
Crawler Dozers
DEERE
450J LT/LGP
550K XLT/LGP
650K XLT/LGP
700K XLT/LGP
750K std/XLT/LGP
Operating Weight
7386–7949 kg (16,283–17,525 lb.)
8750–9195 kg (19,290–20,272 lb.)
8890–9355 kg (19,599–20,624 lb.)
13 710–14 170 kg (30,225–31,240 lb.)
15 593–17 053 kg (34,377–37,595 lb.)
Blade Width
2464–3150 mm (97–124 in.)
2667–3150 mm (105–124 in.)
2667–3251 mm (105–128 in.)
3048–3353 mm (120–132 in.)
3251–3962 mm (128–156 in.)
Power
52 kW (70 hp)
63 kW (85 hp)
75 kW (101 hp)
93 kW (125 hp)
116–123 kW
(155–165 hp)
CASE
550H/650K-3
750L
850L
1150K
1650L
CAT
D3K2/LGP
D4K2/LGP
D5K2/LGP
D6K/LGP
D6N XL/LGP
KOMATSU
D31EX-22/D31PX-22
D37EX-22/D37PX-22
D39EX-22/D39PX-22
D51EX-22/D51PX-22
D61EX-15/D61PX-15
764 HSD
15 422 kg (34,000 lb.)
3353–3810 mm (132–150 in.)
149–157 kW
(200–210 hp)
—
—
—
850K std/WT/LGP/XLT/WLT
19 295–21 684 kg (42,538–47,805 lb.)
3251–4267 mm (128–168 in.)
139.5–152 kW
(187–205 hp)
1850K-3
D6T XL/LGP
D65EX-17/D65PX-17
950J std/LGP
1050J
25 565–26 877 kg (56,361–59,255 lb.)
35 309 kg (77,843 lb.)
3.7–4.5 m (145–177 in.)
4.04–4.3 m (159–170 in.)
184 kW (247 hp)
250 kW (335 hp)
—
—
D7E/LGP
D8T
D85EX-15/D85PX-15
D155AX-7
Crawler Loaders
DEERE
605K
655K
755K
Operating Weight
12 220 kg (26,940 lb.)
18 422 kg (40,614 lb.)
20 492 kg (45,178 lb.)
Loader Bucket Capacity
1.0–1.3 m3 (1.3–1.7 cu. yd.)
1.6–1.9 m3 (2.1–2.4 cu. yd.)
2.0–2.5 m3 (2.6–3.2 cu. yd.)
Loader Dump Clearance
2640 mm (8 ft. 8 in.)
2665 mm (8 ft. 9 in.)
2950 mm (9 ft. 8 in.)
CAT
939C
953D
963D
LIEBHERR
LR614
LR624
LR634
Excavators
DEERE
75D
85D
130G
135G
160G LC
180G LC
190D W (Wheeled)
Max. Digging Depth
4.11 m (13 ft. 6 in.)
3.97 m (13 ft.)
6.06 m (19 ft. 11 in.)
5.98 m (19 ft. 7 in.)
6.49 m (21 ft. 4 in.)
7.07 m (23 ft. 2 in.)
5.83–5.93 m
(19 ft. 2 in.–19 ft. 5 in.)
Operating Weight
8048 kg (17,743 lb.)
8537 kg (18,821 lb.)
13 388–14 481 kg (29,489–31,896 lb.)
13 900–14 900 kg (30,617–32,819 lb.)
18 017 kg (39,685 lb.)
20 120 kg (44,317 lb.)
19 600–20 700 kg (43,211–45,636 lb.)
Transport Width
2.47 m (8 ft. 1 in.)
2.47 m (8 ft. 1 in.)
2.69 m (8 ft. 10 in.)
2.69 m (8 ft. 10 in.)
2.69 m (8 ft. 10 in.)
3.00 m (9 ft. 10 in.)
2.53 m (8 ft. 4 in.)
CAT
—
308E CR SB
312E
314E CR
316E L
318E L
M318D
HITACHI
ZX75US-3
ZX85USB-3
ZX130-5
ZX135US-5
ZX160LC-5
—
ZX190W-3
VOLVO
—
ECR88
EC140DL
ECR145DL
EC160DL
—
EW180D
KOMATSU
PC78US-8
PC88MR-8
PC130-8
PC138USLC-8
PC160LC-8
—
—
210G/210G LC
220D W (Wheeled)
6.68 m (21 ft. 11 in.)
6.08–6.29 m
(19 ft. 11 in.–20 ft. 8 in.)
22 309–22 910 kg (49,139–50,463 lb.)
22 320–23 588 kg (49,207–52,003 lb.)
3.19 m (10 ft. 6 in.)
2.73 m (8 ft. 11 in.)
320E L
M322D
ZX210LC-5
ZX220W-3
EC220DL
EW210D
PC210LC-10
—
245G LC
250G LC
290G LC
350G LC
380G LC
470G LC
670G LC
870G LC
6.62 m (21 ft. 9 in.)
7.61 m (25 ft.)
7.88 m (25 ft. 10 in.)
8.18 m (26 ft. 10 in.)
8.18 m (26 ft. 10 in.)
8.28 m (27 ft. 2 in.)
9.15 m (30 ft.)
9.57–11.16 m
(31 ft. 5 in.–36 ft. 7 in.)
25 500 kg (56,167 lb.)
25 281 kg (55,736 lb.)
30 090 kg (66,338 lb.)
34 726 kg (76,557 lb.)
37 200 kg (82,012 lb.)
49 420 kg (108,952 lb.)
71 688 kg (158,045 lb.)
87 659 kg (193,255 lb.)
3.19 m (10 ft. 6 in.)
3.39 m (11 ft. 3 in.)
3.39 m (11 ft. 3 in.)
3.39 m (11 ft. 2 in.)
3.39 m (11 ft. 2 in.)
3.29 m (10 ft. 10 in.)
3.73 m (12 ft. 3 in.)
3.73 m (12 ft. 3 in.)
321D LCR
324E L
329E L
336E L
—
345E L
374D L
390D L
ZX245USLC-5
ZX250LC-5
ZX290LC-5
ZX350LC-5
—
ZX470LC-5
ZX670LC-5
ZX870LC-5
ERC235DL
EC250DL
EC300DL
EC340DL
EC380DL
EC480DL
EC700CL
—
PC228USLC-3
PC240LC-10
PC290LC-10
PC360LC-10
PC390LC-10
PC490LC-10
PC650LC-8
PC800LC-8
COMPACT EXCAVATORS
DEERE
Max. Digging Depth
17D
2.17 m (7 ft. 1 in.)
27D
2.59 m (8 ft. 6 in.)
35G
3.06 m (10 ft.)
50G
3.53 m (11 ft. 7 in.)
60G
3.77 m (12 ft. 4 in.)
Operating Weight
1893 kg (4,173 lb.)
2887 kg (6,358 lb.)
3520 kg (7,760 lb.)
4790 kg (10,560 lb.)
6145 kg (13,547 lb.)
Transport Width
1.28 m (4 ft. 2 in.)
1.55 m (5 ft. 1 in.)
1.55 m (5 ft. 1 in.)
2.00 m (6 ft. 7 in.)
2.00 m (6 ft. 7 in.)
BOBCAT
324
E26
E35
E50
E60
CAT
301.7D
302.7D
303.5E CR
305E CR
305.5E CR
KOMATSU
PC18MR-3
PC27MR-3
PC35MR-3
PC45MR-3
PC55MR-3
KUBOTA
U15
U25
U35
U45
KX-057
TAKEUCHI
TB016
TB228
TB235
TB250
TB153FR
Wheel Loaders
DEERE
Bucket Capacity
244J
0.8–1.1 m3 (1.0–1.4 cu. yd.)
324J
1.1 m3 (1.4 cu. yd.)
344J
1.3–1.5 m3 (1.75–2.0 cu. yd.)
444K
1.5–1.9 m3 (2.0–2.5 cu. yd.)
524K
1.9–2.1 m3 (2.5–2.75 cu. yd.)
544K
1.9–2.3 m3 (2.5–3.0 cu. yd.)
624K
2.7 m3 (3.5 cu. yd.)
644K/644K Hybrid
3.1–3.2 m3 (4.0–4.25 cu. yd.)
724K
3.1–3.6 m3 (4.0–4.75 cu. yd.)
744K
4.0–4.4 m3 (5.25–5.75 cu. yd.)
824K
4.6–5.2 m3 (6.0–6.75 cu. yd.)
844K-II
4.8–6.2 m3 (6.3–8.1 cu. yd.)
TOOL CARRIER/POWERLLELS
1.5–1.9 m3 (2.0–2.5 cu. yd.)
444K Powerllel™
544K Powerllel
1.9–2.3 m3 (2.5–3.0 cu. yd.)
624K Powerllel
2.7 m3 (3.5 cu. yd.)
624K Tool Carrier
2.7 m3 (3.5 cu. yd.)
644K Powerllel
3.1 m3 (4.0 cu. yd.)
Loader Dump Clearance
2.51–2.55 m (8 ft. 3 in.–8 ft. 4 in.)
2.67 m (8 ft. 9 in.)
2.77–2.85 m (9 ft. 1 in.–9 ft. 4 in.)
2.54–3.03 m (8 ft. 4 in.–9 ft. 11 in.)
2.61–3.12 m (8 ft. 7 in.–10 ft. 3 in.)
2.66–3.17 m (8 ft. 9 in.–10 ft. 5 in.)
2.69–3.23 m (8 ft. 10 in.–10 ft. 7 in.)
2.79–3.33 m (9 ft. 2 in.–10 ft. 11.1 in.)
2.84–3.33 m (9 ft. 4 in.–10 ft. 11 in.)
2.86–3.61 m (9 ft. 5 in.–11 ft. 10 in.)
3.12–3.63 m (10 ft. 3 in.–11 ft. 11 in.)
3.05–3.32 m (10 ft.–10 ft. 11 in.)
CASE
121E
221E
—
521E
521E
621F
721F
821F
921F
1021F
1121F
1221E
CAT
906H2, 907H2
908H2
914G
924K
924K
930K
938K
950K
962K
966K
972K
980K
VOLVO
L25F
L30B, L35B
L40B, L45G
L50G, L60G
L60G
L70G
L90G
L110G
L120G
L150G
L180G
L220G/L250G
KOMATSU
WA80-6
—
WA150-6
WA200-6
WA200-6
WA250-6
WA320-6
WA380-7
WA430-6
WA470-6
WA480-6
WA500-7
2.58–2.65 m (8 ft. 5 in.–8 ft. 8 in.)
2.68–2.74 m (8 ft. 9 in.–9 ft.)
2.70 m (8 ft. 10 in.)
2.81 m (9 ft. 3 in.)
2.79 m (9 ft. 2 in.)
521EXT
621F XT
721EXT
—
—
924K
930K
938K
938K
—
L50G, L60G
L70G
L90G
L90G
—
WA200PZ-6
WA250PZ-6
WA320PZ-6
WA320PZ-6
—
2013 Product Comparison
Motor Graders
DEERE
Tandem Drive:
670G/GP
770G/GP
870G/GP
6WD:
672G/GP
772G/GP
872G/GP
Power
Weight with Front Push Block, Rear
Ripper/ScariƟer, and Other Equipment
CAT
VOLVO
KOMATSU
164 kW (220 hp)
183 kW (245 hp)
198 kW (265 hp)
19 205 kg (42,340 lb.)
19 396 kg (42,760 lb.)
20 303 kg (44,760 lb.)
12M2 VHP Plus
140M2 VHP Plus
160M2 VHP Plus
G930B
G940B
G960B, G970
GD555-5
GD655-5, GD675-5
GD755-5R
175 kW (235 hp)
198 kW (265 hp)
211 kW (283 hp)
19 976 kg (44,040 lb.)
20 217 kg (44,570 lb.)
21 187 kg (46,710 lb.)
12M2 AWD
140M2 AWD
160M2 AWD
—
G946B
G976
—
—
—
Skid Steers
DEERE
313
315
318D
320D
326D
328E
332E
Class
1251–1350
1351–1600
1751 < 2200
1751 < 2200
2201 < 2700
2701 < 3150
3151 and over
Rated Operating Capacity
572 kg (1,260 lb.)
681 kg (1,500 lb.)
817 kg (1,800 lb.)
908 kg (2,000 lb.)
1180 kg (2,600 lb.)
1271 kg (2,800 lb.)
1453 kg (3,200 lb.)
Net/Gross Power
33.5/36.5 kW (45/49 hp)
33.5/36.5 kW (45/49 hp)
43.3/47 kW (58/63 hp)
47.1/50.8 kW (63/68 hp)
51.9/55.1 kW (70/74 hp)
62/64 kW (83/86 hp)
72/74.6 kW (97/100 hp)
BOBCAT
S130
S510
S530*, S570*
S590*, S630
S650*
S750*
S770*
CAT
216B Series 3
226B Series 3
236B Series 3
242B Series 3*
252B Series 3*
262C Series 2*
272D*
NEW HOLLAND
L213
L215
L218*
L220*
L225*
L230*
—
* = vertical lift path
Compact Track Loaders
DEERE
CT315
319D
323D
329E
333E
Class (35% of tip)
< 2000
< 2000
2001 < 2300
2601 and over
2601 and over
CASE
SR130
SR150
SV185*
SR200
SV250*
SV300*
—
Tipping Load
2003 kg (4,412 lb.)
2542 kg (5,600 lb.)
3257 kg (7,175 lb.)
3768 kg (8,300 lb.)
4279 kg (9,425 lb.)
Net/Gross Power
33.5/36.5 kW (45/49 hp)
47.1/50.8 kW (63/68 hp)
51.4/55 kW (69/74 hp)
62/64 kW (83/86 hp)
72/74.6 kW (97/100 hp)
BOBCAT
T180
T590*
T630
T750*
T770*
CAT
247B Series 3
259B Series 3*
279C Series 2*
289C Series 2*
299D*
NEW HOLLAND
—
C227
C232*
C238*
—
CASE
—
TR270
TR320
TV380*
—
* = vertical lift path
Scraper Systems
SCRAPER SPECIAL TRACTORS
CASE IH STEIGER SERIES
DEERE
Power Range
Wheeled and Tracked
AGCO CHALLENGER MT 800C SERIES
9460R/RT, 9510R/RT, 9560R/RT
338–412 kW (460–560 hp)*
385, 435, 485, 535
835, 845, 855, 865, 875
CARRY-ALL AND EJECTOR SCRAPERS
Heaped
DEERE
Capacity
Total Weight
REYNOLDS
MISKIN
7620 kg (16,800 lb.)
14CS10, 16CS10
SP-C17
1510C
11.5 m3 (15 cu. yd.)
10 024 kg (22,100 lb.)
14E10.5, 13E12
—
1512E
11.9 m3 (15.5 cu. yd.)
9307 kg (20,500 lb.)
16CS10, 18CMX12.5
D-19
1810C
13.8 m3 (18 cu. yd.)
10 215 kg (22,500 lb.)
17E10.5
E-20
1810E
14.0 m3 (18.3 cu. yd.)
8603 kg (18,950 lb.)
17CS12, 18CMX12.5
D-19
1812C
13.8 m3 (18 cu. yd.)
9534 kg (21,000 lb.)
18CS14
D-26
1814C
13.8 m3 (18 cu. yd.)
11 702 kg (25,800 lb.)
16E14
—
1814E
13.8 m3 (18 cu. yd.)
11 486 kg (25,300 lb.)
—
D-26
2112C
16.4 m3 (21.5 cu. yd.)
12 337 kg (27,200 lb.)
20E12.5
E-20
2112E
16.1 m3 (21 cu. yd.)
AGCO CHALLENGER MT 900C SERIES
945, 955, 965, 975
ASHLAND
—
I-155TS2
CS-18HD
I-180TS2
CS-18HD
—
—
—
—
CAT
—
—
—
TS180/TS185
—
—
—
—
TS220/TS225
* = 10% power boost
DKCD864 Litho in U.S.A. (13-02)
Not all products sold at all dealers. Wherever applicable, speciƟcations are in accordance with SAE standards. Models and speciƟcations
subject to change without notice. Competitive models may have changed since the publishing of this comparison.
www.JohnDeere.com