mani̇sa cities

Transcription

mani̇sa cities

İZMİR – MANİSA CITIES
Zertifikat: 01 100 032814
PROJECT OWNER
Project Owner’s Name
: TEİAŞ The Turkish Electricity Transmission Corporation
Adresss
: İnönü Bulvarı No:27 Bahçelievler 06100/ANKARA
Telephone
: 0 312 215 98 23
Fax
: 0 312 213 84 15
Name of the Project
: 154 kV Bornova – Morsan Cable
Energy Transmission Line Introductory File
Address of the Project Area
: City of İzmir
FIRM PREPARING THE ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
Name
: Selin İnşaat Turizm Müşavirlik Sanayi ve Ticaret Ltd. Şti.
Adress
: 4. Cad. 26. Sok. No: 8/10 Aşağıöveçler / ANKARA
Telephone
: 0 (312) 481 33 73 (Pbx)
Fax
: 0 (312) 481 45 85
Web / E-mail
: www.selinltd. com.tr / [email protected]
/ [email protected]
Report Date
: November -2005
INDEX
Page Number
INTRODUCTION OF THE PROJECT: .................................................................................................................... 5
A - MITIGATION PLAN........................................................................................................................................... 7
B- MONITORING PLAN ....................................................................................................................................... 11
C- WORK PROGRAM .......................................................................................................................................... 16
D- INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS............................................................................................................... 17
E- CONSULTATION WITH ORGANIZATIONS AND PUBLIC THAT WILL BE EFFECTED FROM
THE PROJECT................................................................................................................................................. 18
Table
Page Number
Table 1: Mitigating Plan ........................................................................................................................... 9
Table 2: Monitoring Plan........................................................................................................................ 13
Table 3 : Work Program ........................................................................................................................ 16
APPENDIX
:
APPENDIX-1: Layout Plan of the Route
APPENDIX-2 : Map Showing the Present Situation of the Route
APPENDIX-3 : Crossection of Underground Cable’s Canal
APPENDIX-4: Photographs of the Route
APPENDIX-5: Introductory Brochure of the Project
APPENDIX-6: Anouncements Made by Muhtars
APPENDIX-7: Anouncementon Local Newspaper
APPENDIX-8: List of People Participatingthe Meeting
APPENDIX-9: Reports of Meeting with Interested/Invited People and Organisations
APPENDIX-10: Questionare
APPENDIX-11: Photographs of Meeting
The General Directorate of TEİAŞ
154 kV Bornova-Morsan
Cable+ETL Environmental Management Plan
____________________________________________________________________________
The Firm Preparing Environment Management Plan :
Selin İnşaat Turizm Müşavirlik San. ve Tic. Ltd. Şti.
4. Cad 26.Sok. No: 8/10 A.Öveçler ANKARA
Tel: 0 312 481 33 73 Faks: 0 312 481 45 85
www.selinltd.com.tr E-Posta: selin@selinltd - [email protected]
Report Date
: November -2005
Responsibility
:
The contractor will appoint an Environment Manager. The Environment Manager (EM)
will be the contractor’s representative about environmental subjects.
The contractor will ensure that all staff, subcontractors, sellers and others are fully
conscious about environmental topics. The contractor will be in close contact with EM
and work at site in a sensitive way about environment. The contractor must supply a
copy of Environment Management Plan (EMP) at site and have full knowledge of its
content.
Aim Of The Environmental Management Plan:
The purpose of the Environmental Management Plan is to adopt suitable environment
management and control methods, to get environment fully protected and/or to keep
the environmental effects at the minimum level during the work and services and to
fullfil the requirements of the national laws and regulations.
4
____________________________________________________________________________
INTRODUCTION OF THE PROJECT:
The General Directorate of TEIAS planned to renew the present 154 kV Bornova-MorsanManisa Energy Transfer Line (ETL) . Bornova-Morsan-Manisa ETL is an aerial line of 154 kV,
starting from TEIAS’s 3rd Transmission Plant and Management Group Directorate’s shalt field,
passing through 58th pole till MORSAN (Manisa Organized Industrial Region) Transformation
Plant (TP) and ending with 10 electricity poles at Manisa TP. There is totaly 85 poles present
at the moment.
Through the concept of renovation ; 154 kV Bornova-Morsan-Manisa ETL’s part of 6,670 km
passing through Kazımdirik, Ergene and Evka3 districts of İzmir-Bornova will be done as
underground cable route and the present poles at the rest will be renewed. The Environmental
Management Plan is prepared for only underground cable route.
Topographic map and current map belonging to the route are given in Appendix-1 and
Apppendix-2 respectively. Current telephone line, substructure ( tap water line, sewer system )
are shown on this map. A typical cross-section of underground cable energy transmission line
and photographs of the route are given at Appendix-3 and Appendix-4 respectively.
In the content of this project , existing aerial lines in the city limits, about, 6,670 km. beginning
from BornovaTransformer Center, are planned to be underground cable lines. Underground
cables are designed as , 1000 mm2 cable + ( 2x1272 MCM conductivity) 154 kV underground
cable ETL. The length of the cable route planned for this project is 6,670 km.
For the 6,670 km underground cable line, a different route from the present aerial line was
chosen. The Underground Cable Line will be built till the 18th pole of the present line.
Any protected areas, cultural or historical values do not exist on and around the route of
underground cable energy transmisssion line.
The total length of the cable route planned for this project is 6,670 km. For the underground
cable line construction a bulding will be rented at a near place of project area or a temporary
work-site will be built at an empty region in Bornova. In addition, a generator and a container
will be placed at cable connection points and a guard will be on duty continuously. Domestic
waste arised from the site will be discharged to the current sewerage system since the worksite is inside the city limits. Work plan of the project is given in Figure-1.
Excavation of Canals
Installation of Conduits that
Cables will pass
Fill the Canals( except the
junction points)
Joining of cables and installation of cables inside
pipes
Fill the Junction Points
Şekil 1: Work plan of the underground cable construction
5
____________________________________________________________________________
Cable laying will be done by excavating canals at stages. Firstly, canals of 1.5 mt. depth and 1.1 mt.
wide and different lengths changing due to the condition of the route will be cut. The lengths of the
canals to be opened along the planned route will be 215 m. at the university housing sites, 120 mt. at
119th street(wide road), 375mt. near the current 18th pole and 440 mt. at other places.
HDPE type of pipes will be installed in these canals. Firstly, a special kind of bedding soil will be layed
as 20 cm. thick at the bottom of the canals and 3 HDPE pipes will be put on it side by side. After the
pipes are burried by 30 cm. thick special soil, PVC plated fences will be installed through the width of
the canal. Canal will be filled with 20 cm. of concrete after 50 cm thick stabilized filling material is layed
down on the wire. At last, the concrete will be covered with 10cm. thick asphalt by the Municipality
(Aasphalt price will be paid by TEİAŞ)
At the starting and ending points of the canals 10 mt. length will be resevedfor junctions and cable
laying without fillling. but rest of the canal will be filled. Surface of these junction points will be covered
with tent canvas, tape will be wrapped around for not to endanger the traffic, sandbags and warning
signs will be placed.
Excavation of 440 meters long canal, laying HDPE pipes and earth filling the canal and, installation of
cable inside the pipes and making the junctions and will take 10 days.
At the connection points which are unfilled, cable will be inserted from one end of the canal inside the
HDPE pipe placed before and by pulling from the other end with the help of guide, cable will be
passed inside HDPE pipe. During this operation, soft soap and oil will be rubbed continuously for the
cable to be easily pulled. After this step, the operation will finish by closing the top of the connection
points also. By this way, totally 6.405 km length of canals will be excavated along the planned route.
14 connection canals will be on this 6.405 km length route.
Since street will be passed at two points of the planned cable route, cables will be passed inside of
steel pipes at these places.
Underground cable line going out from Directorate of TEİAŞ’s 3rd Transformer Plant will enter into the
University Street for 2,25 km and then will pass through the Industry Street. It will exit from the
University area at 5,10 km by passing through the Ege University Campus at 3,15 km and will pass
the 119th street. It will go in to the 113th street and will connect to the current 18th pole at 6,670 km.
The underground cable energy transmission line route passes completely inside the city’s residential
areas. Therefore, the route passes through urban areas and there are no agricultural land.
Bornova, which is placed at north-east of İzmir, at the foot of Yamanlar mountain and on 380 degrees
latitude-270 degrees longitude is 8 km. to İzmir. Bornova has 400.000 permanent and 1.000.000
temporary population covers an area of 205 kilometersquare with its villages. Bornova is placed
inside the metropolis limits. It is surrounded by Manisa city fields at its North, Kemalpaşa at its east,
Karşıyaka and Konak at its west and Buca at its South. Its Municipality is established at the year 1882
and became town at 1957.
Bornova’s total population is 396.770 due to General Census done in the year 2000. 391.128 of this
population lives at centrum, 5.642 at the villages.. Population density is 1771 and population increase
rate is 35.46 %. Ege University which is the first university of Izmir has been built at Bornova and its
main campus is at Bornova.
6
____________________________________________________________________________
A–
MITIGATION PLAN
To prevent or minimize the environmental effects during the work that will be done at planning,
construction and operation stages of the project is separately explained below.
Planning Stage;
The part of the present line up to the 18th pole will be taken under the ground, but this part is
not on the route of the present aerial line. The areas that the underground cable line route pass
is given below.
Street Name
Bornova TM exit
Sanayi Caddesi
Sanayi Caddesi
Sanayi Caddesi
Sanayi Caddesi
Universite Caddesi
Universite Caddesi
At the Campus (University)
İzmir-Ankara Road Tunnel Pass
University’s Resident Area
University’s Resident Area
119th sokak (wide, two-way road)
113th sokak
113. sokak
113. sokak
Interface near 18th pole
Distance
0+00
0+450
0+900
1+350
1+800
2+250
2+700
3,150
3+600
4+050
4+275
4+500
4+950
5+100
5+400
5+850
6+300
6+670
For the underground cable line that will pass through Bornova’s street and crossroads,
necessary protocols will be signed with the Municipality of İzmir. The protocols will also be
signed with the Presidency of Ege University for the line that will pass from Ege University
Campus and Resident Area.
Most important subject at the stage of planning the underground cable line is determination of
the route. On the route determined by TEIAS, existence of present infrastructural foundations
and telephone line and the distance to them will be considered. In case where route passes
near present telephone line, probability of disturbing these telephone lines that will cause by the
electromagnetic field arising at operation stage must be taken into consideration.
In addition, the present situation must be well considered for not disturbing the infrastructural
foundations because of the excavations on the route of the underground cable line will pass.
Necessary information for that is taken from the City Directorate of Telekom and General
Directorate of İZSU.
For this reason, planning stage is important to minimize the environmental effects that may
occur during construction and operating stages.
The present map for the underground cable route is given in Appendix-2. The present
telephone line, infrastructure ( clean water, sewer systems ) and critical points for noise
measurement are shown on this map.
7
____________________________________________________________________________
Construction Stage
The precautions that will be taken for environmental effects during construction stage of the
Underground Cable Line and ENH are given below :
1. Dust Formation: At the construction stage of the underground cable line, operations of
canal excavation, loading the soil to trucks, discharging it to the filling places that
Municipality shows and pouring of filling material into the canals will be done. During these
operations, dust formation may occur. At this stage, loading and unloading will be done
paying attention not to cause dust and soil will be sprinkled with water to minimise dust
formation.
2. Solid Wastes: Solid wastes that will occur during construction stage will consist of domestic
waste arising from staff working and the waste caused by the construction operations(
paper, plastic, cement bag, wire, HPE pipe pieces etc.) Waste causing from the
construction operations and domestic waste will be collected separately and will be
transferred to firms licensed for collection or recycling of them.
3. Soil Waste; The soil excavated during the underground cable construction will never be put
back into the cable canal. Special stabilized materials will be used for the filling. Soil taken
out of canals must be sent separately to Excavated Soil Discharge Area, not being mixed
with concrete and asphalt waste. Recycling of asphaltic waste must be transferred to
Municipality’s asphalt production plant. Excavated soil will be loaded to trucks and brought
to the place Municipality permits.
4. Liquid Waste; During the construction stage, domestic waste water will arise from the staff
working. Since the construction will be done in the city, a suitable place whose
infrastructure is completed will be used for the work site/office or a depot area will be
rented. Domestic waste water arising from the work site will be given to the existng sewer
system.
5. Waste Oil; Oil changes of the construction equipment will be done at service stations.
Leakage controls of these equipment will always be done at site.
6. Noise ; At the construction stage, noise will occur due to the construction equipment. This
noise will shift with changing site. Since the work will be done step by step for
underground cable line, noise will only occur during excavation and cable montage stages.
For these reasons, noise will not be a continious problem and also work will be done
during daytime.
7. In order not to damage the existing infrasructral facilities, work will be done at the presence
of a supervisor from the related organisations. This will be determined at planning stage
and necessary informations will begiven beforehand.
8. Magnetic Field: During commissioning stage three points of measurement will be identified
and masured values will be compared with reference values. If measured values are above
the references countermeasured will be taken.

Operation Stage
Magnetic Field; system will be operated below ICNRP and TSI (TSE) referance values.
In case of copmlaints measurement will be repeated.
8
GENERAL DIRECTORATE OF TEIAS
154 kV Bornova-Morsan-Manisa Cable+ETL Environmental Management Plan
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1: Mitigation Plan
Phase
Planning/
Design
Construction
Construction
Issue
Area includes sites of significance
to human and natural environment
(historical/religious/cultural value or
ecologically
significant
or
protected) or high population
clusters..
Historical, Cultural and Archaeologic
Values
Removal of Mud
Construction
Dust
Construction
Solid Waste
Construction
Soil Waste
Construction
Liquid Waste
Construction
Noise
Mitigating Precaution
-Determination of present underground line, substructure and communication lines that
pass.
-During the excavations being done, whenever a subject having a historical, cultural or
archaeologic value is found the work will be stopped and Directorate of Cultural and
Natural BeingsCommittee will be informed
-The construction will be tried to be done in dry season, not in rainy weather as much as
possible.
– Watersystems wiil be protected from erosion of exposed soil surfaces created during
land clearing by the use of silt trapping systems ( e.g. bunds, sediment ponds etc. )
Responsibility
TEİAŞ
Employer
TEİAŞ
Employer
Contractor
- Sprinkle area with water particularly during hot, dry and windy conditions.
Contractor
- Waste causing from the construction operations and domestic waste will be collected
separately and will be transferreed to the licensed firm to be recycled..
- Domestic solid waste will be disposed to the closest container of Municipality.
Contractor
- The soil that will be excavated from the canals during the underground cable
construction must be deposited at the places determined by the Municipality.
- The excavated soil should never be poured into water sources.(streams, rivers, lakes,
ponds, etc.)
Contractor
- For the work-site choice, the places having infrastructure will be preferred and
discharge of the toilets will be connected to the sewer system of the city.
- Construction must be done during daytime hours. (07:00-19:00). Work will not be done
in the evening or at night due to ‘’Evaluation and Management of Environmental Noise’’
Regulation-item 26.c. Sliencers of excavation machines and trucks will be kept
working and be suitable to the standarts. Work machines and equipments used will be
suitable to the ‘’Regulation about Emission of Environmental Noise Occurred by
Equipments Working at Open Areas’’ (2000/14/AT) prepared by Ministry of Industry and
Trade, published at Official Newspaper of date 22/01/2003 and number 25001. Old
work machines must also supply the values given in this regulation.
Contractor
Contractor
9
GENERAL DIRECTORATE OF TEIAS
154 kV Bornova-Morsan-Manisa Cable+ETL Environmental Management Plan
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Construction
Soil, surface and groundwater
contamination from oil, lubricant or
fuel spills
Construction
Polychlorinated Biphenbyls
( PCB )
Construction
Occupacional Health And Safety
Construction
Safety of Public and Economical
Activities
Construction
Operation
Magnetic Field
Magnetic Field
Operation
Occupacional Health And Safety
Operation
Solid Waste
- Operational procedures must be established and implemented for spill protection and
control must be prepared, approved by the Environment Directorate of TEIAS and be
applied. (Oil changes of the construction equipment that will be done at service stations.
Continious leakage controls and prevention of these equipment will also be done
especially by using leakage boxes at site. ) İn addition, Leakage - Emergency Plans will
be prepared and Staff must be trained.
It is forbidden to purchase any electric equipment containing PCBs, or to purchase any
PCBs for use in any equipment.
- Health and Safety Plan must be prepared by the construction contractor and
submitted to TEIAS for approval prior to any work activity.
- Risk Analysis, Training Plan, Management Plan for Occupacional Health and Safety,
Measurement-Observation Plan, Fire, work accident, environmental accident and first
aid emergency plans must be prepared and controls must be done periodically. Control
check lists to be formed. Must be worked in accodance wit he of ‘’Work Law’’ and
Regulations abot Occupacional Health and Safety, PPE (Personal Protection
Equipment) should be used.
-Contractor can’t begin to work without TEİAŞ Environment Directorate’s approval of
procedures, plan, measurement programme and preodical control lists that will be
prepared as extention of Environmental Management Plan.
-Along the canals to be excavated, public’s entrance to the canal and other dangerous
places will be prevented by barriers, warning signs will be put at visible places and
warning will be supplied by reflector lights at nights. Walker passage must be given at
every 50 meters, passages must be at least 60 cm wide and have strong barriers at the
edges
-Special precaution must be taken for ambulance passage in front of Ege Nephrology
and Dialisis Center
During commissioning stage measurement will be done at identified points and if
measured values are above the references countermeasured will be taken.
System will be operated below ICNRP and TSI (TSE) referance values. In case of
copmlaints measurements will be repeated
Health and Safety Plan must be prepared and applied. The plan must include safety
training and practical purposed applications.
After 30 years of operation, used spare parts and/or similar materials will be kept in the
temporary depots of Group Directorate at suitable conditions and than will be
tarnsferred to licenced firms for recycling.
Contractor
Contractor
Contractor
(Plan Preparation)
TEİAŞ
(Plan Approval)
Contractor
Contractor
TEİAŞ
TEİAŞ
TEİAŞ
10
TEİAŞ GENEL MÜDÜRLÜĞÜ
154 kV Bornova-Morsan Kablo Enerji İletim Hattı
Çevre Yönetim Planı
__________________________________________________________________________________
B- MONITORING PLAN
Noise ; There are 3 critical points determined on the route. These points are shown on the
current map given in Appendix-2. The current noise level at these points must be measured at
day and night hours before the construction starts. Measurements must be repeated at
construction stage after the work has started. The noise measured must be compared with the
limits given in ‘’The Regulations for the Evaluation and Management of Environmental Noise’’.
Client must be informed if precaution must be taken due to the regulations. The complains that
may come from the local people other than the pre-deteremined critical points must also be
taken into consideration and the reason for complains must be removed by making additional
measurements. Studies done must be included in the Environmental Management Plan reports
that will be prepared every 3 months.
Dust : Dust will form during excavation, , filling , loading and unloading and storage
operations. Dust measurements will be done at 3 points shown on the map given in Appendix2 along the route where excavation will be done before the construction starts and will be
repeated at the construction stage. Measurements must be evaluated due to ‘’ The Regulation
for Industrial Based Air Pollution’s Control’’. Measurement results must not exceed the value of
1.5 /dust-hour due to the regulation. After the evaluation due to the regulation, the contractor
must take the necessary precautions. Among these precautions, sprikling the workplace with
water , paying attention not to blow around and covering the trucks with tents can be counted.
Results of the measurements must be included in every 3 months Environmental Management
Plan reports.
Magnetic Field: During commissioning stage measurement will be done at 3 pre- identified
points and if measured values are above the references countermeasures will be taken.
System will be operated below ICNRP and TSI (TSE) referance values. In case of copmlaints
measurements will be repeated.. In case of copmlaints measurement will be repeated
11
GENERAL DIRECTORATE OF TEİAŞ
154 kV Bornova – Morsan Cable+ETL Environmental Management Plan
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Table 2: Monitoring Plan
What
Where
How
Parameter is to be monitored is the parameter will be is the parameter will be monitored /
monitored
type of monitoring equipment
Historical, Cultural, and
At Field
Observation
Construction
Archaeologic Values
Erosion/Silt run off
At Work site
- It must be controlled that
Construction
mitigating precautions are
organized.
–Ground water must be controlled
by eye.
Dust
Dust measurements will - Dust measurement will be done
Construction
by the firms having certificate of
be done at work site
Sufficiency for Environmental
and affected area of
Analysis.
work sites’ critical
points.
3 Measurement points
are shown on the map
given in Appendix-2.
If there any complaints
measurements wiil be
repeted.
Construction
Domestic Water
At Work Site
Construction
Noise
Noise measurements
will be done at work site
and affected area of
work sites’ critical points
( hospitali school,
When
Is the parameter will be monitoredfrequency of measurement
Whenever a cultural value is met.
Responsibility
Contractor
- Once a day
- During or after a rainy or windy
weather
TEİAŞ
Environmental Unit
and Contractor
Dust measurements will be done at 3
points shown on the map given in
Appendix-2 along the route where
excavation will be done before the
construction starts and will be
repeated at the construction stage.
Measurements must be evaluated
due to ‘’ The Regulation for Industrial
Based Air Pollution’s Control’’. After
the evaluation due to the regulation,
the contractor must take the
necessary precautions. Among these
precautions, wetting the workplace,
paying attention not to blow around
and covering the trucks with awning
can be counted.
-Result of measurement must be
lower than 1.5 kg/dust hour due to
Industrial
Based
Air
Pollution
Regulation.
- It must be controlled that At the construction and closing
mitigating precautions are taken.
stages of the work site
TEİAŞ
Environmental Unit
and Contractor
- Will be done by laboratory
according to Consideration and
Management of Environmental
Noise Regulation’
-At the beginning of work, noise
measurement will be done for 10
minutes and will be repeated when
the type of work changes (when
additions done or a new equipment
Contractor
Contractor
13
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What
Where
How
monitored
house,etc).
.
There are 3 critical
points determined in the
project area.These
points are marked on
the present map given
in Appendix-2.
If there any complaints
measurements wiil be
repeted
Construction
Soil
At works-sites of camp
and line route
Construction
Waste Oil
Construction
PCB
Construction
Occupational Health and
Safety
Construction right-ofway
Construction
Public Safety
At works-site of line
route
When
Is the parameter will be monitoredfrequency of measurement
starts to work etc.).
-Measurements will be repeated at
night shifts and be done away at a
point from the affects and at east 1
m. of nearest house and 1.5 m above
the ground.
Measurement results of daytime
hours must be lower than 70 dBA.
The contractor must take precautions
if this limit is exceeded. Night time
value is not given since night work is
forbidden due to the regulation.
It must be examined that - Every day after the first canal is
mitigating precautions in the opened till the canals are closed.
contract are applied.
-Once at construction stage of worksite and once at the end of work.
At the work sites where Will be observed by eye.
leakage may occur and
for every machineequipment
At delivery site of
Certification showing no
equipment or materials content will be reviewed
Continuous inspection while machines
are working and during oil addition.
Responsibility
Contractor
Contractor
PCB When equipment or materials are
TEİAŞ
delivered.
Environmental Unit
and Contractor
- Must be controlled with
Daily/Weekly/Monthly
TEİAŞ
periodical control lists due to Work
Environmental Unit
Law and Regulations.
and Contractor
Observation must be done about
compliance specified in contract
(strength of passages-barriers,
existence of warning signs at the
right place, reflector lights’
condition must be controlled )
Daily
TEİAŞ
Environmental Unit
and Contractor
14
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What
Where
How
When
Is the parameter will be monitoredmonitored
frequency of measurement
Not to damage local and
On the route
Will be controlled by eye. Control
During
Construction
economical activities.
if tere areany complaints
construction stage.
Construction
Commissioning
Stage
Magnetic Field
Operation
Occupational Health and
Safety
Operation
Solid Waste
Operation
Magnetic Field
At 3 points determined
on the route (shown on
the map given in
Appendix-2)
At maintenance places
- Measurements will be done by
magnetic field measurement
equipment
At Commissioning Stage
- Control due to Risk Analysis and At every maintenance action
Occupational Health and Safety
Management Program.
At maintenance places - Will be determined by
At every maintenance action
observations.
At complaint points, if - Measurements will be done by
In case of complaints
there are any
magnetic field measurement
equipment.
Responsibility
TEİAŞ Contractor
Contructor
TEİAŞ Operation Unit
15
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
C- WORK PROGRAM
The activities stated in the Precaution and Observation Plans start and end dates are given in Table 3.
Tablo 3 : Programme
Date of Contract
Months
Activities
Excavation Work
Excavation Work Monitoring Programme
Erosion7mud leakage
Soil waste disposal
Solid waste
Occupational Health and Safety Issues
Public Safety
Dust
Noise
Historical and cultural values
Installation Operations (Underground Cable)
Installation Operations Monitoring Programme
Solid waste
Public Safety
Noise
Filling Work
Filling Work MonitoringProgramme
Public Safety
Dust
Noise
Operational Tests
Test Monitoring Programme
Public Safety
Commissioning
Maintenance woks
Line Maintenance Monitoring Programme
Solid Waste
Precautions
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
16
154 kV Bornova – Morsan
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
D- INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS
A monitoring program for possible environmental effects that may occur during planning, construction
and operation stages of 154 kV Bornova-Morsan Cable ETL project and precautions to minimize
these effects is prepared and given in Part 2 which also shows the responsible bodies.
In this part, the topics below are mentioned:

Responsibilities of Client for monitoring and precautions, their relation with the
environmental management
Reporting of environmental information and providing data flow,
Organizational structure of Environmental Management,
thr following topics are explained; how monitoring activities will go on, who will collect and analyze the
data, who will prepare the reports, how long will be reporting periods, what will be done according to
the activity for the report and who will be authorized to change or stop the applications.
Precautions and observation activities in the project begin at planning stage and continues at
construction and operating stages. Precautions given in Part 2 includes activities in Monitoring Plans
and responsibilities. Precautions and monitoring to be done by Contractor will be reported in definite
periods to TEİAŞ.
This project is evaluated in EIA Regulation Appendix-II, since it is prepared to renew of present
energy transmission line. For this reason, Project Introductory File which is prepared in accordance to
EIA Regulation Appendix-4 is presented to İzmir and Manisa Environmental and Forestery
Directorates. After the investigations, the decision was taken that ‘EIA was not necessary
After this stage, project works will be awarded to a Firm by TEİAŞ. When the project is prepared
construction works will be awarded to Contractor.
While construction work is done, Client( Group Directorate of TEİAŞ) will inspect if the requirements of
Environmental management Plan are fullfiled and EIA Report is followed.
Contractor is responsible for taking the precautions mentioned in the ‘Project Introductory Report’
which is approved by Environmentalo and Foresery Directorate.
Constructor will report regularly permissions taken according to the works done and beginning-end of
construction to TEİAŞ General Directorate when construction starts. Permissions taken from
beginning to the end of construction and situation of the work undertaken in Project Introductory
Report will be presented to the relevant Environment and Forest Directorates under coordination of
TEİAŞ.
If the constructor fails to fulfill the environmental requirements a written warning note is given. If the
warning is not taken into consideration payments of the constructor is stopped until the environmental
requirements are fulfilled
Environment Management Plan includes ; mitigating plan, monitoring plan and political, legal and
administrative frame of reports prepared according to EIA procedure.
17
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
E- CONSULTATION WITH ORGANIZATIONS AND PUBLIC THAT WILL BE EFFECTED FROM
THE PROJECT
Underground Cable Transmission Line Route passes through Kazımdirik, Erzene and Evka-3 regions
of İzmir-Bornova. A consultation meeting has been arranged to which people living there and related
organizations are invited. Meeting was held at Evka-3 where housing sites will be affected most.In
addition, inquiry study was done with the people living at this region and their opinions about the
project were asked. A brochure given in appendix involving introductory knowledge about the project
was prepared and distributed to the people living there, private sector owners and the people joining
the meeeting. Information about this meeting is given below.
Time of the meeting : 28.12.2005, 10:00 A.M.
Place of the meeting : Aras Kıraathanesi 119. Sokak No: 20/A Evka-3 Bornova/İZMİR
People Invited to the Meeting :
Name-Surname
Occupation or Profession
Telephone
Fax
Home Adress
Business Adress
: F. Gülay IŞIN
: Evka-3 District Muhtar
: 0232 375 88 85
: 0232 375 28 30
: Evka-3 mahallesi, 127/5 sokak No: 21 D: 2 Bornova/İZMİR
: Evka-3 mahallesi, 126/12 sokak No: 5/1 Pasaj 27 Bornova/İZMİR
Name-Surname
Telephone
Fax
Business Adress
: Dilek İduğ ÇELİK
: Kazımdirik District Director
: 0232 339 59 45
: 0232 388 09 52
: Kazımdirik mahallesi Zafer Caddesi No: 27 Bornova/İZMİR
Name-Surname
Telephone
Fax
Business Adress
: Ayşe Müjgan PAKYÜREK
: Erzene District Muhtar
: 0232 374 44 52
: 0232 373 57 56
: Erzene mahallesi 8. sokak No: 25/4-D Bornova/İZMİR
Name-Surname
: Musa ÇEÇEN
: President of the Management Board of
İzmir Electrical Engineers’ Society
: 0232 489 34 35
: 0232 445 68 68
: [email protected]
: 1337 sokak No: 16/8 Çankaya/İZMİR
Telephone
Fax
E.Posta
Business Adress
Name-Surname
Telephone
Fax
E.Posta
Business Adress
: Faruk İŞGENÇ
İzmir Environmental Engineers’ Society
: 0232 464 00 22
: 0232 422 09 59
: [email protected]
: 1479 sokak No: 11/9 Alsancak/İZMİR
In addition to these people, people living in the region are also invited to the meeting . Anouncements
were done at Muhtar’s offices. Reports of Muhtars’ about these anouncements were also given at the
appendix. Besides these, meetings were anounced in a locally published daily newspaper and the
interested people’s participation was requested. Announcement at the local newspaper was given at
Appendix.
18
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Those who have invited to join the meeting are :
Name-Surname
Telephone
Fax
Home Adress
Business Adress
: F. Gülay IŞIN
: Evka-3 District Muhtar
: 0232 375 88 85
: 0232 375 28 30
: Evka-3 mahallesi, 127/5 sokak No: 21 D: 2 Bornova/İZMİR
: Evka-3 mahallesi, 126/12 sokak No: 5/1 Pasaj 27 Bornova/İZMİR
Name-Surname
: Musa ÇEÇEN
İzmir Electrical Engineers’ Society
: 0232 489 34 35
: 0232 445 68 68
: [email protected]
: 1337 sokak No: 16/8 Çankaya/İZMİR
Telephone
Fax
E.Posta
Business Adress
Name-Surname
Telephone
Fax
E.Posta
Business Address
Home Address
: Ahmet Avni ATAYOL
: Member of the Management Board of
İzmir Environmental Engineers’ Society
: 0232 464 00 22
: 0232 422 09 59
: [email protected]
: 1479 sokak No: 11/9 Alsancak/İZMİR
: 119/8 sokak No: 4/2 Daire: 23 Evka-3 Bornova/İZMİR
The List of other local people participating the meeting are given below.
NAME
SURNAME
Yavuz
EFEOĞLU
Hüseyin BİLGİ
Yunus YILMAZ
ORGANİZATION
OR
OCCUPATION
Mechanical
Engineer
Group
Director
Deputy
Environmental
Engineer
Environmental
Director of
TEİAŞ
Electrical
Engineer
TELEPHONE/FAX
NO
BUSINESS AND HOME ADDRESS
0232 462 70 00
Business: TEİAŞ 3. İletim, Tesis ve
İşletme
Grup
Müdürlüğü
Bornova/İzmir
Tel: 0312 215 98 23
Faks: 0312 213 84 15
Business: TEİAŞ Genel Müdürlüğü
İnönü Bulvarı No:27
Bahçelievler/Ankara
0232 462 70 00
İşletme
Grup
Müdürlüğü
Bornova/İzmir
Home:
TEİAŞ
Lojmanları
Bornova/İzmir
İşletme
Grup
Müdürlüğü
Bornova/İzmir
Business: 4. cadde 26. sokak No:
8/10 Aşağıöveçler/Ankara
Home: Emlak Bankası Konutları B5 blok No: 17 Elvankent/Ankara
Home: 119. sokak No: 20/3 Evka-3
Bornova/İzmir
Business: Evka-3 Merkez Taksi
Durağı Bornova/İzmir
Home: 1203 sokak No: 8/7
Bornova/İZMİR
Kubilay UYLU
Map Engineer
0232 435 90 00
Orkun
GÜMÜŞTEKİN
Environmental
Engineer
Tel: 0312 481 33 73
Faks: 0312 481 45 85
Bünyamin
ŞAHİN
Mustafa
TÜRKAY
Retired
0232 375 03 74
RetiredTaxi driver
0232 375 12 30
19
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Hüsnü
BARDAKÇI
Retired
0232 375 78 54
Home: 125/7 sokak No:18 Daire:24
Bornova/İzmir
Refik TOP
Retired
0232 375 14 18
Kerim AKIN
Retired
0232 375 14 52
Home: 120. sokak Adil Demir Sitesi
5. blok 2/2 Evka-3 Bornova/İzmir
Home: 119. sokak No: 45/1 Evka-3
Bornova/İzmir
Programme of the meeting/Time Schedule:
Opening
: 10:00 A.M.
Opening speech and information about the project : 10:00 – 10:20
Yavuz EFEOĞLU
TEİAŞ 3rd Group Deputy Director
Information about environmental effects of the
project and the Environmental Management Plan
: 10:20 – 10:40
Hüseyin BİLGİ
General Directorate of TEİAŞ
Environment Director
Questions and answers
: 10:40 – 12:00
Closing
: 12:00
Summary of the Meeting (comments, questions asked and answers given )
Report involving the topics that has been discussed is given at Appendix-9
Meeting has been started with the speech of Yavuz EFEOĞLU who is TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Deputy
Director. Information about definition of the project, aim, the places route will pass, constructionoperation stages and secondary projects is given by Yavuz EFEOĞLU.
Afterwards, a brief description of the project is done by Hüseyin Bilgi who is the Environment Director
of General Directorate of TEİAŞ. Information is given about possible environmental effects of the
project and precautions that will be taken to reduce these effects in the concept of Environmental
Management Plan and period of Environmental Impact Assesment. TEİAŞ’s environmental point of
view and policy is explained.
Then, question-answer part began to take the opinions and suggestions of the participants. Questions,
opnions and suggestion that came from the participants and the answers given to them are given
below :
Bünyamin ŞAHİN (Retired): This service is comfortable for the people sitting at this region.
Appearance will be better when this project is finished.
Hüsnü BARDAKÇI (Emekli) : It is a good project for İzmir, it will have benefit. It will be very useful if
control is established about environmental noise protection. A permanent solution. İs it safe?
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Director Deputy): There is risk if you get as close as 2 mt. to
the current aerial energy transmission line. But you can walk on the pavement covering this cable. It is
much safer and serious controls will be held about this.
Musa ÇEÇEN (Management Committee’s President of İzmir Electrical Engineers’ Society): Even
though it is well introduced among the public that ‘underground line is good’, we know that there are
aerial lines in Europe and USA. Aerial lines in our country brings bad appearance because of route
choice and operation. In this route, an area of 30 meters will be nationalized by TEİAŞ. You can’t
even plant grass at this region.
20
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Hüsnü BARDAKÇI (Retired) : But it is a good project.
Musa ÇEÇEN (President of Management Board of the İzmir Electrical Engineers’ Society):
Illegal buildings are constructed at these regions. Electricity is also supplied after water by the
Municipality and aerial lines become unsafe. You should inform the public while doing this project.You
can’t expect participation without a prior information. A meaningful work is being done by this project.
Brochures and announcements are very good and as İzmir Electrical Engineers’ Society, we support
this project. Protection of only one person’s life is important to us. The region has high population
density and underground able will be better. There is a subject in the brochure you have prepared. A
154 kV project is not firstly applied by TEİAŞ here. We will have only one demand: we want ferro
magnetic coating at near of housing. There is no electromagnetic coating in the project.
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Director Deputy): There is red PVC coated 6*6 fence wire as
can be seen on the brochure .
Musa ÇEÇEN (Management President of Management Board of the İzmir Electrical Engineers’
Society): I’m not sure if this kind of wire will be enough for 154 kV at near housing sites. If
electromagnetic current density is calculated and screening will be done at places close to housing
sites, it will be a study that will not cause any trouble to you in the future. We can help if you want. This
subject has not been considered in Turkey yet.
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Deputy Director): Red PVC plated 6*6 fence wire will be
enough. This subject is searched in detail but we may require your opinions.
F. Gülay IŞIN (Evka-3 District Muhtar): Have you been informed public about the project via media?
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Director Deputy): We have given advertisement to a local
newspaper. TEİAŞ isn’t an establishment new at these things. We do all the necessary work.
F. Gülay IŞIN (Evka-3 District Director): As an example; there is a pole at the middle of the road
where this line will pass.
Society): A small house may be built in place of these poles.
F. Gülay IŞIN (Evka-3 District Muhtar): For example; BOTAŞ has been doing natural gas pipeline
work here. Can it be combined with the cable line?
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Deputy Director): These lines can not be passed from the
same place with another substructure line. You can’t bend this line. Natural gas, etc. Lines can be
bend. If you bend like natural gas and pass from the same place, it will explode at first time energy is
given. For this reason, natural gas and alike lines can not be passed under this line. Natural gas line
can not be passed under this line.
F. Gülay IŞIN (Evka-3 District Muhtar): People mostly says ‘’ since excavation is done at winter time,
we are having troubles like mud, etc.
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Deputy Director): But this is being done for the safety
of public, brings public interest.
Society): Buildings can not be constructed at the place where aerial line were removed. Let me
suggest this; can these areas be modified to a park ?
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Deputy Director): We are not owners of these areas. We only
own the pole places and have servitude under the wires. For this reason, we can’t do anything about
that.
Ahmet Avni ATAYOL (Member of Management Board of the Environmental Engineers’ Societyİzmir Branch): I am a citizen living in one of the buildings here at the same time. This meeting is
being done for only World Bank’s project ,beause it was requested be th Bank. Our opinion is not
21
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
being asked for the other projects. I was informed of this meeting from the invitation came to our
Society, not as a citizen.
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Deputy Director): But an advertisement is published at
newspaper, written announcements are given to the district muhtars and written invitation has been
sent to your Society. We have used every kind of communication methods for this meeting to be
heard.
Hüsnü BARDAKÇI (Retired) : Did any study be performed about the Earthquake Fault Line ?
Yavuz EFEOĞLU (TEİAŞ’s 3rd Group Deputy Director): We have been doing detailed studies about
fault lines in all of the studies we do. Therefore, we have also done the necessary studies for this
project.
Ahmet Avni ATAYOL (Member of Management Board of the Environmental Engineers’ Societyİzmir Branch): You have told that the EIA studies have been completed, but we don’t have
knowledge about that. Cable route doesn’t pass from a special area since it is in the city limits.
Intersection can occur with other substructure lines. Did you negotiate with the other instituitons? You
must have some plans for this. What will you do when another line will intersect with yours ? You must
inform the other institutions for such a situation. In addition, it will be better if information about soil
waste arising from excavation is mentioned in the Environmental Management Plan. EnvironmentalOccupational Health and Safety Regulations that will be obeyed are given in the brochure. There is a
need for more information about every regulation for assessment. In addition, we are pleased to hear
that TEİAŞ’s Environment Director is a member of Environment Engineers’ Society. I became very
happy about that. It will be good if staff who will work at field are experts about this subject.
Orkun GÜMÜŞTEKİN (Representative of the firm preparing the Environmental Management
Plan): During the EIA studies, we have taken the coordinates of lines passing near our route from the
related institutions to determine if there will be intersection and showed them on our current map. At
the survey stage of cable line route, studies will be performed considering this subject.
Hüseyin BİLGİ (Environmental Director of TEİAŞ): 46000 km. of energy transmission line has been
built since the establishment of EIA regulation. We are performing these kinds of meetings at various
places. In fact, this meeting is being done for World Bank’s request, but Turkish regulations don’t
recognize these. Also, people don’t show enough interest to these kinds of meetings. Sometimes, we
bring people to these meetings by taking them from their homes. For example, these meetings collect
more interest when arranged at villages. I am bothered from this situation. Citizens see us as
government and tell us us every trouble they have. We have been performing all kind of studies about
electromagnetic field since the year 2000. Please don’t tell us that it’s not being done. We have given
advertisement at newspaper, prepared and distributed brochures, made written announcements. I
wish we could reach everyone. Let me give you the files involving the studies we have done about
electromagnetic field for your examination.
Questionnaire Studies:
Quastionnaire is done with public living in the residence mostly affected from the project. Evaluation of
the questionaire by tables and graphics is given below.
Education Levels of People Participating the Questionnaire
Ratios
Education profile
(%)
Primary school
22,2
Middle school
22,2
High school
11,1
University
44,4
Total
100,0
Sex of People Joining the Questionnaire
Ratios (%)
Female
11,1
22
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Male
Total
88,9
100,0
Home Ownership Status of People Joining the Questionnaire
Ratios (%)
Own house
66,7
Rent
33,3
Toplam
100,0
Occupation of People Joining the Questionnaire
Ratios (%)
Salary ( Regular Work)
33,3
Little Tradesman
22,2
Big Tradesman
22,2
Retired
22,2
Total
100,0
Questionnaire:
housing sites?
YES
NO
Total
Are you worried about passing of the current aerial electricity line through your
Ratios (%)
55,6
44,4
100,0
Questionnaire: Did you get any other information about construction of underground ETL ?
Ratios (%)
YES
22,2
NO
77,8
Total
100,0
23
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
100
80
78
60
Percent
40
20
22
0
evet
YES
hayýr
NO
YIHDUYUM
Questionnaire: Did you get any other information about construction of underground ETL ?
Questionnaire: Where would you like to see the information about underground ETL ?
A) Television
Ratios (%)
YES
100,0
B) Radio
Ratios (%)
YES
33,3
C) Newspaper
Ratios (%)
YES
77,8
D) Billboard
Ratios (%)
YES
11,1
E) Internet
Ratios (%)
YES
11,1
24
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Questionnaire: Do you support the precence of an underground ETL in the neigbourhood of
your residential area?
Ratios (%)
YES
100,0
Questionnaire: What benefits will underground ETL bring to your region? Do you have any opinions?
Ratios (%)
No benefit
11,1
Indirect job oportunities (For example: material and service
supply to construction team)
Other
22,2
Total
100,0
66,7
70
67
60
50
40
Percent
30
20
22
10
11
0
hiç bir yarar
No benefit
Job opprtunities
dolaylý istihdam
diðer
Other
YARAR
Question: Do you think that construction of such an underground ETLmay cause any problem
here ?
Ratio (%)
YES
100,0
What kind of problems may be caused?
A)Noise Formation
Ratio (%)
YES
100,0
25
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
B)Damage of roads
Ratio (%)
YES
100,0
C) Dust Formation
Ratio (%)
YES
77,8
D)Traffic Jam
Ratio (%)
YES
22,2
E)Security
Ratio (%)
YES
33,3
Question: While underground ETL constructed in your region, would workers staying near your
housing sites be better or worse for your region?
Will be better
Doesn’t matter
Total
Ratio (%)
66,7
33,3
100,0
70
67
60
50
40
33
30
Percent
20
10
0
iyi
olur
Better
ne iyiDoesn’t
olurmatter
ne kötü
INPERZAR
26
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Question: What kind of benefits may bring the staff who will be there for construction work
to you ?
A)No benefit
Ratio (%)
YES
22,2
B)Bring Money
Ratio (%)
55,6
YES
C)Bring Employment
Ratio (%)
YES
55,6
Question: If underground electricity conduction line workers will stay in your region, what may be the
main problems arising from them ?
Ratio (%)
Will be no problems
44,4
Noise Pollution
11,1
Ethic botherings, theft, etc.
44,4
Total
100,0
50
44
44
40
30
Percent
20
10
11
0
No bothering olmaz
rahatsýzlýk
Noise
Pollution
gürültü artacak
Ethic
diðer
botherings,
theft etc
MAHRAH
27
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
COMPARATIVE TABLE
OF WORRIED PEOPLE’S RATIO TO THE EDUCATION LEVEL
WORRIED
EDUCATION
LEVEL
Total
YES
NO
Primary School
50,0%
50,0%
100,0%
Middle School
100,0%
-
100,0%
-
100,0%
100,0%
50,0%
50,0%
100,0%
High School
University
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
Primary
School
Middle
school
High School
University
YES
NO
COMPARATIVE TABLE
OF CABLE LINE SUPPORTERS AND FORSEEN BENEFITS
SUPPORT RATIO
BENEFIT
YES
Thinks no benefit will bring
11,1%
Thinks indirect employment will come
66,7%
Other
22,2%
Total
100,0%
100%
66,7%
80%
60%
40%
20%
22,2%
11,1%
Other
Indirect
Employment
No Benefit
0%
28
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
COMPARATIVE TABLE OF
CABLE LINE’S SUPPORTERS AND DISTURBING TOPICS
DisturbingTopics
Yüzdelik Oranları
Supports , but worries about Noise
100,0%
Supports, but worries about Road Damage
100,0%
Supports, but worries about Dust
77,8%
Supports, but worries about Traffic Jam
22,2%
Supports, but worries about Security
33,3%
100%
80%
100,0%
100,0%
77,8%
60%
33,3%
40%
22,2%
20%
0%
Supports, but Supports, but Supports, but Supports, but Supports, but
worries about worries about worries about worries about worries about
Security
Traffic Jam
Dust
Road
Noise
Damage
F- CONCLUSION
Results taken from the consultation meeting and questionnare done about the project :
1. All of local people and organizations support the project.
2. Most of the people living at the region were disturbed from the existing aerial line.
3. It is thought that the current aerial line may cause health problems, creates bad appearance, is
dangerous at rainy weather and give rise to corruption of electronic equipment lie TV, etc.
4. It will be efficient if information about the project is given by press (especially radio and TV)
5. Related professional Societies wants to be informed about the project in the beginning and wants
to be asked their opinions.
6. It was thought that Project’s construction stage would supply benefit by indirect employment ( e.g.
Material and Service Supply to the construction ) at the regions it passes through.
7.
During the construction stage, noise and dust formation, damaging of the roads are the possible
effects expected by most of the people.It is requested that the necesaary precautions to be taken
8. Traffic jam is not expected during the construction stage since the traffic is not dense near the
housing sites that route passes.
9. It is thought that in case a worksite is built and the workers stays at the region, economical
contribution will be supplied to th region.
29
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
10. People are generally worried of ethic botherings,e.g. theft, etc. if workers stay at the region.
However, most of the people mentioned that they believe the contractor firm will consider this
when choosing the workers to be employed.
11. A general opinion is dominant that there may be negative temporary environment effects during
the construction stage, but if the necessary precautions are taken, they will not be effected much
from the project.
30
APPENDICES
:
APPENDIX-1: Layout Plan of the Route
APPENDIX-2 : Map Showing the Present Situation of the Route
APPENDIX-3 : Crossection of Underground Cable’s Canal
APPENDIX-4: Photographs of the Route
APPENDIX-5: Introductory Brochure of the Project
APPENDIX-6: Anouncements Made by Muhtars
APPENDIX-7: Anouncementon Local Newspaper
APPENDIX-8: List of People Participatingthe Meeting
APPENDIX-9: Reports of Meeting with Interested/Invited People and Organisations
APPENDIX-10: Questionare
APPENDIX-11: Photographs of Meeting
APPENDIX-1
Layout Plan of the Route
APPENDIX-2
Map Showing Present Situation of the Route
APPENDIX-3
Crossection of Underground Cable’s Canal
APPENDIX-4
Photographs of the Route
Bornova Transformer Centre (TC)
18th Pole Where
Underground Cable Line
Ends
View From Underground
Energy Transmission Line
Route (Industry Street)
View From Underground
Energy
Transmission
Line Route (Evka-3)
Ankara Road Crosssection of the Underground Cable Route
APPENDIX-5
Introductory Brochure of the Project
APPENDIX-6
Anouncements Made by Muhtars
APPENDIX-7
Anouncementon Local Newspaper
APPENDIX-8
List of People Participatingthe Meeting
APPENDIX-9
Reports of Meeting with Interested/Invited People and Organisations
APPENDIX-10
Questionare
QUESTIOANRE PREPARED FOR TAKING OPINIONS OF PUBLIC TO BE AFFECTED FROM THE
PROJECT FOR THE UNDERGROUND CABLE ELECTRICITY CONDUCTION LINE PLANNED IN
SCOPE OF 154 kV BORNOVA – MORSAN – MANİSA CABLE+ECL PROJECT.
INTRODUCTION
General Directorate of TEİAŞ is planning to construct an underground electricity transmission line
passing through your housing sites. This meeting is a part of the study to collect data about residence
along the route and take your opinions about environmental and social topics. Information you give will
be very useful for decision.
Personal Knowledge and Social Status
1. Name of Region
:
2. Town/City
:
3. Name-Surname
:
4. Adress / Telephone number
:
5. Sex
: Male ( )
6. Age
:
Female ( )
7. What is your education level?
1( ) None
2( ) Primary school
4( ) High School
5( ) University
8. Your Profession
3( ) Middle school
:
9. Who is the owner of the house you’re living? (PLease check only one choice)
1( ) Our own house
2( ) Rental
3( ) Provided by Employer
4( ) Guest house
5( ) Rent without payment
6( ) Other (please mention)……………………………………………….
10. How many people live in your house? :……………………people
11. What is your occupational status?
1 (
2 (
3 (
4 (
5 (
6 (
7 (
8 (
9 (
10(
11(
) With Salary (regular work)
) Temporary worker
) Little Tradesman
) Big Tradesman ( alone )
) Boss
) Farmer
) Student
) Housewife
) Unemployed (Les than a year)
) Unemployed (More than a year)
) Retired, no working
Opinions about Current Aerial Electricity Line
12. Are you worried about passing of the current aerial electricity line through your housing sites?
1( ) Yes
2( ) No (Pass to 13th question)
13. What are your worries? ......................................................................................................................
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
Opinions about Underground Cable Electricity Conduction Line
14. Did you get any other information about construction of underground ETL?
1( ) Yes
2( ) No (Pass to 16th question)
15. What kind of things did you hear.?......................................................................................................
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
16. Where did you hear these from?……………………….. ………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
17. From which of the below can you hear and be informed more about underground cable electricity
conduction line?
1( ) TV
2( ) Radio
3( ) Newspapers
4( ) Bill
5( ) Hand bill
6( ) Meeting
7( ) Internet
8( ) Other (please mention)…………………………...
18. Do you support the precence of an underground ETL in the neigbourhood of your residential area?
1( ) Yes
2( ) No (Why?)…………………………………………………………………………………….
…………………………………………………………………………………………...………………...
…………………………………………………………………………………………...………………...
19. What benefits may construction of such an underground cable electricity conduction line bring to
your housing sites ? Do you have any opinions?
Give a number due to
priority.
Thinks no benefit will be supplied
1( )
No idea/don’t know
2( )
Direct employment (employment during construction)
3( )
İndirect emplyment (e.g.: supply of material and service to
4( )
construction staff)
Other (please mention)
5( )
……………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………
20. Now let’s think in opposite way. Do you think that construction of suhc an underground ETL may
cause any problem here ? What kind of problems may be caused?
Give a number due to priority.
No worries
1( )
No idea / don’t know
2( )
Noise
3( )
Damage of the roads
4( )
Dust
5( )
Traffic Jam
6( )
Security
7( )
Other (please mention)
8( )
……………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………
21. While underground ETL constructed in your region, would workers staying near your housing sites
be better or worse for your region?
1( ) Much better
4( ) Bad
2( ) Better
5( ) Very bad
3( ) Doesn’t matter
6( ) I don’t know
22. What kind of benefits may bring the staff who will be there for construction work to you ? Else?
(Please check all the related answers)
1( ) No benefits
3( ) Money
2( ) No idea / don’t know
4( ) Work oppurtinities
5( ) Other………………………………………………………………………......
23. If underground electricity conduction line workers will stay in your region, what will be the main
bothers arising from them ? (Please check all the related answers)
1(
2(
3(
4(
5(
6(
) Will be no bother
) No idea / don’t know
) Noise will increase
) Pressure on substructure will be formed
) Traffic jam will occur
) Other……………………………
THANKS…
Application Date
:……./……./2005
Pollster
:
APPENDIX-11
Photographs of Meeting
REGULATIONS TO BE OBEYED
DURING THE PROJECT
REPUBLIC OF TURKEY
MINISTRY OF
ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES
Regulation about Environment

Environment Law
Regulation for Excavation Soil and
Construction Wastes’ Control
Regulation for Solid Wastes’ Control
Regulation for Soil Pollution’s Control
Regulation for Water Pollution’s Control
Regulation for Excavations where Sewer
System can’t be Constructed
Regulation for Industrial Based Air
Pollution’s Control
Regulation for Oil Wastes’ Control
Regulation for Dangerous Wastes’
Control
Regulation for Evaluation and
Management of Environmental Noise
Evaluation for Environmental Effects’
Regulation
Regulation for Evaluation of Package
and Package Wastes’ Control
Protection of Cultural and Natural
Beings Regulation
TEİAŞ
2001
BORNOVA-MORSAN-MANİSA
ENERGY TRANSMISSION LINE
PROJECT
BORNOVA UNDERGROUND
CABLE ELECTRICITY
TRANSMISSION LINE
PROJECT
Regulation about Occupational Health
and Safety
Work Law
Regulation for Occupational Health and
Safety
Regulation for Personal Protection
Equipments
Regulation for Health and Safety about
Usage of Work Equipments
Regulation for Methods and Principles of
Workers’ Health and Safety Training
Regulation for Health and Safety
Warnings
SELİN
İnşaat Turizm Müşavirlik
Sanayi ve Ticaret Ltd. Şti.
PLANNED
UNDERGROUND CABLE
ROUTE
4. Cadde 26. Sokak No: 8/10
Aşağıöveçler / ANKARA
Tel: 0312 481 33 73 (Pbx) Faks: 0312 481 45 85
E.Posta: [email protected]
Web: www.selinltd.com.tr
6670 km. length of ETL passing through İzmirBornova limits of Bornova-Morsan-Manisa
Electricity Construction Line is planned to be
constructed as underground cable electricity
construction line by the Ministry of Energy and
Natural Sources.
Excavation of Canals
Installation of Conduits that
Cables will Pass
CROSS-SECTION OF
UNDERGROUND CABLE CANAL
Road level
Asphalt
10 cm
Concrete
20 cm
Warning Tapes
PVC+PE
20 cm
Stabilized Filling
Material
AIM OF THE PROJECT
Filling the Canals( except
the connection points)
150 cm
30 cm
120 cm
CONSTRUCTION STAGE
OF THE PROJECT
DEFINITION OF THE PROJECT
Red PVC coated
Wire (Φ2 mm)
30 cm
Aim of the project is to repalce 6670 km. aerial
lines passing through city with underground
ETL, starting from Bornova Transformer Center
of the Bornova-Morsan-Manisa Line by the
General Directorate of TEİAŞ.
Special Bedding
Soil
20 cm
Joining of cables and installation inside pipes
HDPE Pipe
(Φ 200 mm)
Fill the Junction Points
20 cm
Underground
Power Cable
33 cm
110 cm
REGIONS THAT LINE WILL PASS THROUGH
Kazımdirik – Erzene – Evka 3
POSSIBLE ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS
OF THE PROJECT
ADVANTAGES OF THE PROJECT
When the Underground Cable Electricity
Conduction Line Project has finished;
Bad appearance of aerial lines at
settelement areas will disappear,

A safer electricity conduction will be
supplied,
Construction problems at rural areas due
to the aerial lines will be removed.

Noise and Vibration

Temporary Dust Formation

Temporary visual
Image Pollution

Temporary Traffic Jam

Temporary damages on the roads

Domestic Solid Waste Formation

Domestic Waste Water Formation
33 cm
F/0 Cable
HDPE Pipe
(Φ32 mm)
SITES UNDERGROUND CABLE E.T.L. WILL PASS
Name of Site
Length of Line
Passing
(Meters)
Sanayi Street
2250
University Street
900
Campus (University)
1125
Ankara Road-Tunnel
Passage
225
University Resident
Houses
600
119th street
(the wide road)
300
113th street
1270
Total
6670