Hearing Record - Auckland Council

Transcription

Hearing Record
Hearing topic
Chairperson of
full panel
Full panel to
hear first five
days
Split panels for
remainder of
hearing
When
081 Rezoning and Precincts (Geographical Areas)
File ref:
Judge Kirkpatrick
Jan Crawford
Peter Fuller
David Hill
Greg Hill
Paula Hunter
John Kirikiri
Des Morrison
Stuart Shepherd
Les Simmons
Alan Watson
North Panel (Red)
Des Morrison (Chairperson)
Les Simmons
Alan Watson
Other panel members may
join throughout the hearing
Thursday, 3 March to
Friday 29 April 2016
IHP Staff
Time
Any of:
Phil Chung
Sarah El Karamany
Kylie Gemmell
Matthew Gouge
Alison Stilwell
Christopher Turbott
Rebecca Vertongen
Ann Marie Callaghan
Dana Danilova
Thomas Erikson
Philippa Geere-Watson
Julie McKee
South Panel (Blue)
John Kirikiri (Chairperson)
David Hill
Stuart Shepherd
Other panel members may join
throughout the hearing
9.30am each day unless otherwise
noted below
Each venue is outlined in the sessions below
Where
CBD
Hearing Room 1 and/or Hearing Room 2
Tower One, Level 16, 205 Queen Street, Auckland CBD
Orewa
Council Chamber, Level 1, Orewa Service Centre, 50 Centreway Rd,
Orewa
Council Chamber, Level 1, Henderson Service Centre, 6 Henderson
Henderson Valley Road, Henderson
Manukau
West Annex, Civic Building, Totara Room, Level 1, 31-33 Manukau
Station Road, Manukau
AUCKLAND COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVES WHO ATTENDED THE HEARING
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
5716, FS 3652
Auckland Council
Melinda Dickey, Legal
Diana Hartley, Legal
Alastair Cribbens, Auckland Transport
Jesse Colquhoun, Auckland Transport
Mathew Gribben, Legal
John Burns, Legal
081 HEARING RECORD
1
Robert Scott, Planning
Matthew Allan, Legal
Ryan Bradley, Planning
Joe Jeffries, Planning
Bain Cross, Planning
Erin Woolley, Legal
Austin Fox, Planning
Kimberley Edmonds, Planning
David Hookway, Planning
Sanjay Bangs, Planning
Anthony Traub, Planning
Melean Absolum, Landscape
Ewan Paul, Planning
Bridget Gilbert, Landscape
Shona Myers, Ecology
Jane Andrews, Ecology
Emily Buckingham, Planning
Marilyn Ford, Planning
Debra Yan, Planning
David Wren, Planning
Rebecca Sanders, Planning
Rebecca Freeman, Transport
Kate Morrissey, Planning
Larissa Clarke, Planning
Rachel Morgan, Planning
Matthew Riley, Urban Design
Andrew Gratton, Transport
Nicholas Vigar, Stormwater
Claudia Hellberg, Stormwater
Martin Peake, Transport
Martin Neale, Freshwater Ecology
Tim Fischer, Legal
Heather Ash, Legal
Andrew Beer, Open Space
Manu Bird, Ecology
Simon Cocker, Landscape
Nathan Te Pairi, Planning
Stephen Brown, Landscape
Jennifer Caldwell, Legal
Vanessa Evitt, Legal
Douglas Sadlier, Planning
Cara Francesco, Historic Heritage
Raj Maharjan, Planning
Robert Hillier, Geotechnical
Shelly Wharton, Stormwater
Nicholas Pollard, Planning
Megan Walker, Historic Heritage
Mark Tollemache, Planning
081 HEARING RECORD
2
NORTH PANEL
THURSDAY, 10 MARCH 2016 – CBD HEARING ROOM 2
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Les Simmons, Alan Watson
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany and Ann Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
Tim Fischer (Legal), Ryan Bradley (Planning), Matthew Riley (Urban Design), Ross
Cooper (Planning), Ms Smith (Legal)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
3602
5845
6540
1967
4742
7055
6549
7060
7066
3582, FS 1684
(from topic
016-017)
FS 3517 (from
topic 016-017)
Crotty Family Trust
Graham Collie
Brian and Val Davies
Greg Hines
Rodney W Harman
Sandra Stanley-Hunt
Dion and Melanie and Alan Mayes
Jeffrey Russell
Janemaree and Greg Hines
2528 (from
topic 016)
3323
(from topic
016)
5815a
Vision Wellsford
Lionel Foster
Alderwasley Trust
WF and SM Abraham
KingsWay Trust
5784
7161
Don and Jackie Stubbs
Chris Holt
6896, FS 3292
2692
2431 et al
(topic 016
only)
David Pinker (J Peters)
Rosal Trust
2972
2973
2974
2975
081 HEARING RECORD
Wilks Road South Landowners Group
Robert E and Linda D Uren
Glen and Wendy Nasmith
In Kyu Shin and Hyung Ryun Kim
David B and Gaynor Ronkowski
Represented by
Philip Crotty, Submitter
Adam Wild, Heritage
David Haines, Planning
David Wren, Planner
Lionel Foster
Russell Don
Wendy Crow-Jones
Douglas Allan, Legal
Kay Panther-Knight, Planning
Mark Hurt, Corporate
Graeme Salmon, Wastewater
Brian Putt, Planning
Malcolm Maclean, Legal
Burnette Macnicol, Planning
Mike Lee, Engineering
Steven Rankin, Engineering
Jamie Peters, Submitter
Diana Bell, Planning
Brian Sutton
John Scott, Submitter
3
2977
2978
2979
2980
2981
2982
2983
2984
2985
2986
2989
2994
2998
3003
3004
3007
3009
3032
3037
3040
3041
3044
3054
3058
3071
3073
3075
3078
3102
3105
3109
3113
3118
3128
3196
3198
3200
3201
3203
3205
3207
3208
3209
3211
3212
3213
3215
081 HEARING RECORD
John and Beo Smith
Xiu F Dong
Maree A J Coley
Zhi M Zhang and Xiao L Ge
Kwang Soo and Young Mi Han
Patrich (Trish) Hutt
Pai-ta and Shiao C H Chou
John and Pauline Scott
Wilkinson Family Trust
Ian T and Florence J Gatman
Keun K Lim and Soon H Kim
Peter A and Katherene J Small
Brian and Janet Smith
Kiong S Tan and Peng Jiang
Yong K Lee and Young H Ko
Bobae Family Trust
Christina T M K Pepers
William B and Joan A Earwaker
Kenneth J Lousley and Alison C
MacLeod
Hugo Hess and Andrea Baumann
Lance and Deidre Anderson
Sarah and Richard Nagle
Young Y Hahm and In Ja Kim
Earl L and Bernadette M Tipene
Pacman Family Trust and DMC
Family Trust
James and Clare Rouse
Zhenguang Zhong
Jennifer and David Lyndon
Postman Road Trust
Colin and Kathleen Humphrey
Brian Finn
John and Alena Lee
John Todd
Yu and De Investment Limited
Jun Young-Lim
Annie Chen and Andrew Shiu
Yang Yue Hong
Tianxing Zhou and Wanyi He and
Haiyan Zhu
Christopher P and Joanne C Wilkins
Richard Bright and Lusia Johnson
Sean and Kay Spargo
Jonathan and Deborah Bell
Kwang Joong Oh and Soon Ok Song
David and Cara Marks
Francis B and Karen S Halkyard
William and Caroline Fountain
Glen and Britt Doodes and Denise
4
3709
Ivatt
Su He and Lei An
Zhi Pei Li
Nejmian Family Trust
The Angelina Trust
Bryn Lockie et al
Donna M and Philip A Clark and Ed
Johnston and Co Trustees Limited
6770, FS 2175
Save our Saint Heliers Incorporated
and Saint Heliers/Glendowie
Residents' Association Incorporated
3216
3218
3219
3231
3237
081 HEARING RECORD
Rob Enright, Legal
Sally Peake, Urban Design
Graeme Burgess, Visual Tara Hotop,
Planning Margaret King, Submitter
5
MONDAY, 14 MARCH 2016 – CBD HEARING ROOM 2
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Les Simmons and Alan Watson
IHP Officers:
Dana Danilova, Philippa Geere-Watson and Ann Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
Tim Fischer(Legal), David Hookway (Planning), Evan Keating (Auckland
Transport), Robert Hillier (Geotechnical)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
Mark Hurt, Corporate
John Burgess, Traffic
Garth Falconer, Urban Design
Todd Fraser, Civil Engineer
Graeme Salmon, Wastewater
Richard Knowles, Geotech
2830
32 Church Street Family Trust
Sharon De Luca, Ecology
32 Church Street Family Trust (Douglas Allan) cross-examined Robert Hiller (Geotechnical) from
Auckland Council
Tony Catton, Corporate
Vaughan Smith, Planning
Mike Martin, Civil Engineer
John Burgess, Traffic,
Tim Heath, Economic,
The National Trading Company of
Matt Riley, Urban Design
2632, FS 2963 New Zealand
Treffery Barnett, Ecologist
081 HEARING RECORD
6
TUESDAY, 15 MARCH 2016 – OREWA
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Les Simmons, Alan Watson, Peter Fuller (from
2.00pm)
IHP Officers:
Matthew Gouge, Julie McKee
Council
officers:
Erin Woolley (Legal), Ewen Paul (Planning), Bridget Gilbert (Landscape), Shona
Myers (Ecology), Auckland Transport representative
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
Melean Absolum, Landscape
3286
Estate DA Aley
Michael Absolum, Trustee
Dr Mark Bellingham, Planning
265
Ashala Enterprises Limited
James Beaumont, Engineering
6517
Todd Sylvester
Dr Mark Bellingham
7068, FS 138
East Coast Farms Limited
Dr Mark Bellingham
2357, FS 142
Pauline Fudge
Dr Mark Bellingham
Alan Webb, Legal
Lance Hessell, Planning
7022, FS 611
Auckland Memorial Park Limited
Rob Pryor, Landscape
2556, FS 79
Silverdale Estates Limited
Barry MacDonell
2278, FS 149
Richard and Tracey-Lee Martin
Barry MacDonell
7067
Shieff Angland Lawyers
5736, FS 2034 Highgate Business Park Limited
Alistair White, Planner
Stride Holdings Ltd (Bianca Tree) cross-examined Alistair White from Highgate Business Park
Limited
21
Fiona G Flay
Pat Mulligan, Legal
Vijay Lala, Planning
FS 1125
BAA Land Holdings Limited
Nicholas Rae, Urban Design
LM Painton Estate, Silverdale Golf
Driving Range Limited and Runwild
5801
Trust
FS 3400
LM Painton Estate
FS 3388
Runwild Trust
Asher Davidson, Legal
FS 3399
Silverdale Golf Range Limited
2826
Snow Planet
Alistair White, Planning
Shane Hartley, Planning
Robert Speer, Retail Planning
Neil Barr, Landowner
1439, FS 413
Geoff McNaughton
Nigel Muir, Landowner
Ian McAlley
Ian Craig
2371
PLDL Limited
Mr Ian Clark, Traffic
081 HEARING RECORD
7
WEDNESDAY, 16 MARCH 2016 – OREWA
Panel
Members:
Les Simmons (Chairperson), Des Morrison, Alan Watson, Peter Fuller (from
2.25pm)
IHP Officers:
Christopher Turbott, Julie McKee
Council
officers:
Erin Woolley (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal), Mianette Broekman (Legal), Ewen Paul
(Planning), Carol Stewart (Principal Policy Analyst), Austin Fox (Planning), Nathan
Te Pairi (Planning), Stephen Brown (Landscape), Alastair Lovell (Auckland
Transport), Joe Jeffries (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
Bianca Tree, Legal
Jennifer Carvill, Planning
Stride Holdings Ltd (formerly DNZ
Robert Philpott, Economic
3863, FS 866
Property Fund Limited)
Steve Lewis, Corporate
Highgate Business Park (Douglas Allan) cross-examined Jennifer Carvill (Planning) and Robert
Philpott (Economic) from Stride Holdings Ltd
Stride Holdings Ltd (Bianca Tree) cross-examined Ewan Paul from Auckland Council
6505
Peter Snell Youth Village
Warwick Goldsmith, Legal
Don McKenzie, Traffic
Rob Greenaway, Recreation
Graham Ussher, Ecology
Jeff Brown, Planning
TABLED STATEMENTS
Paddy Baxter, Landscape
Stephen Skelton, Landscape
Duncan McNab, Farming Economic
Viability
Thomas Shand, Coastal Hazard
Brett Black/Steven James, Internal
Roading
Tony Bryce, Civil Engineering
Josh van Veen, Expenditure
Tom Bassett, Stormwater
6283, FS 3328 Chin Hill Farm
Andrew Linton, Geotechnical
Graham Ussher, Ecology
TABLED STATEMENTS
Tony Bryce, Civil Engineering
4826
James B Mackenzie
Steven Skelton, Landscape
6738
Alan Wiltshire
Mark Bellingham, Planning
Alan Webb, Legal
Kaaren Rosser, Planning
4931
North Shore Aero Club
Joe Smith, Aviation Expert
081 HEARING RECORD
8
THURSDAY, 17 MARCH 2016 – OREWA
Panel
Members:
Les Simmons (Chairperson), Alan Watson
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany, Julie McKee
Council
officers:
Diana Hartley (Legal), Ewen Paul (Planning), Ryan Bradley (Planning), Stephen
Brown (Landscape)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
2143
James R Davies
6862
Rod Clarke
FS 2720
John Greensmith
326, FS 99
2812
Karepiro Investments Limited
Karepiro Investments Limited, M
Sullivan and MA Nelson
865, FS 169
1337
DF Enterprises Limited
Waitoki Investments Limited
1824, FS 1226
306
2175
3131
4666
2600
Rahopara Farms Limited and Cabra
Rural Developments Limited
Robert H Maclennan
Huntington Trust
Ingolf Rockelrath
Carol Rockelrath
La Maison Trust
302, FS 105
SH 16 Limited
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Rod Clark, submitter
Allan Clarke, Horticulture
Michael Savage, Legal
Barry MacDonell, Planning
Dan McGregor, Winstone Aggregates
Ray Hollis, Agricultural Production
Dr Philip McDermott, Development
Planning
Neil Rasmussen
Graham Parfitt, Planning
Judith Eller
Carol Rockelrath
Ray Hollis, Agricultural Production
Planning
9
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Les Simmons, Alan Watson, Peter Fuller, Greg Hill
(session 1 only)
IHP Officers:
Thomas Erikson, Ann-Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
Tim Fischer (Legal), Ryan Bradley (Planning), Erin Woolley (Legal), Debra Yan
(Planning), Matthew Allan (Legal), Bain Cross (Planning), Mr Newman
(Watercare), Mr Brook, Manu Bird (Ecology), Larissa Clarke (Planning), Marilyn
Ford (Planning), Brian Waddell (Auckland Transport) Transportation Planning
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
6605
FS 2390
2970, FS 167
Sandee Investments Limited
Omaha Surf Club Incorporated
Omaha Beach Community
(Incorporated)
5472, FS 2918
The Gibbs Foundation
6928
Gulf Harbour Investments Limited
6922
Pine Harbour Holdings Limited
7307, FS 2877
Isbey and Collier Families
5763, FS 3502
Hounslow Holdings Limited
5612, FS 2702
3702
Atlas Concrete Limited (Mount Rex)
Atlas Concrete Limited (Woodhill)
5154
Valerie Close Residents Group
Penelope Shelbourne and Timothy
Smyth
6205
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Hamish Firth, Planning
Colin Leuschke, Owner
Hew Campbell
Richard Brabant, Legal
Karyn Kurzeja, Planning
Richard Brabant/Jeremy Brabant, Legal
Karl Cook, Planning
Gavin Lister, Landscape
Peter Boardman, Engineer
Leo Hills, Traffic
Curt Robinson, Acoustic
Grant Dumbell, Ecology
Alan Gibbs, Corporate
Kitt Littlejohn, Legal
Mr Bowden, Corporate
David Hay, Planning
David Hay, Planning
David Irwin, Urban Design
Mr. Herbert, Corporate
Jo Young, Planning
Peter Hall, Planning
Bart and Sue Isbey
Mark Arbuthnot, Planning
Richard Kidd – Husband of Ms Kidd there
to answer questions on Ms Kirks evidence
Keith Berman, Legal
Graham Collie, Corporate
Russell McVeagh, Legal
James Hook Planning
William Endean, Corporate
Christopher Short, Engineering
Penelope Shelbourne
10
TUESDAY, 22 MARCH 2016 – OWERA
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Diana Hartley (Legal) (from 9.40am), Ryan Bradley (Planning), Kimberley Edmonds
(Planning), Ewen Paul (Planning), David Hookway (Planning), Mr Newman
(Watercare), Alastair Cribbens (Auckland Transport), Claudia Hellberg
(Stormwater), Andrew Beer (Open Space), Alastair Lovell (Auckland Transport)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
1436
3257
6775, FS 2705
194
1317, FS 2841
132, FS 891
1809
FS 318
Kathrine Davis
Thompson Road Residents
Nikau Retreat Limited
Elizabeth Foster
Michael Twiss
Whangateau HarbourCare Group
(Incorporated)
K and E Planning Limited
D A and S J Sanders
3972, FS 3278
Manikum Investments
6592
Colin Chester
6595
5942, FS 3288
Poplar Trust
David and Barry G Pinker
7025
Goatley Holdings Limited and Stellan
Trust
7371
5520, FS 2271
Better Living Landscapes Limited
Wilks Road 2014 Limited
FS 2270
6608
Redvale Quarry Limited
Paul Wigglesworth
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Janet Woodhouse, Landscape
David Hay, Planning
Bob Demler, Planning
Elizabeth Foster
Nicholas Eagleson
Sherrill Sanders
Andrew Braggins, Legal
Colin Chester
Mr Ennis, Submitter
Planning
Steve Jones, Engineering
Alan Webb, Legal
Karen Pegrume, Planning
Sue Simons, Legal
Trevor Lee-Joe, Traffic
Graeme Salmon, Water and Wastewater
Todd Fraser, Stormwater
Graeme Causer, Corporate
Malcolm McLean, Legal
11
WEDNESDAY, 23 MARCH 2016 – OWERA
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Alan Watson, Jan Crawford (till 1.34pm), Les
Simmons (from 12.15pm)
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Diana Hartley (Legal), Erin Woolley (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal), Ryan Bradley
(Planning), David Hookway (Planning), Ewen Paul (Planning), Austin Fox
(Planning), Anthony Traub (Planning), Jane Andrews (Ecology), Mr Newman
(Watercare), Nathaniel Te Pairi (Planning), Shona Myers (Ecology), Stephen Brown
(Landscape)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
5988
2684, FS 1399
2148
1790
5805
Jenni McKeown
David Macpherson, Planning
Robert Brown
861
864, FS 3142
6440, FS 3136
866, FS 3728
Eruiti Limited
Dynamic Enterprise Limited
Robert and Linda Brown
Heather A Hernandez
Ngati Manuhiri Settlement Trust
Te Arai South Joint Venture/ Ngati
Manuhiri Settlement Trust
Te Arai Coastal Lands Limited
Tara Iti Holdings Limited
Te Uri o Hau Settlement Trust
4167
FS 3903
FS 3913
Te Arai Beach Preservation Society
Gregory Sarron Paraone McDonald
Roi McCabe
5237
1798
Jonathon F Amodeo
S G Noyer and K A Anderson
FS714 - Kawau Island Advisory
Committee
Lyn Hume
Godwit Trust
Zakara Investments Limited
Linda Pattullo
1298
5008, FS 3038
4593, FS 787
6534, FS 2607
261
6623
081 HEARING RECORD
Objective Holdings Ltd
Paul Majurey, Legal
Chris Casaloni, Corporate
Marie Alpe
Mike Harris
Julie Goodyer, Legal
Kerry Amodeo
Lyn Pardy
Lyn Hume
Alan Webb, Legal
Ian Vincent, Visual Landscape
Charles Shrimpton, Corporate
Daryl Hughes, Transport
Steven James, Engineering
Kate Madsen, Planning
12
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Alan Watson, Peter Fuller (Sessions 1 and 2) and Jan
Crawford (Session 3)
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany and Dana Danilova
Council
officers:
Erin Woolley (Legal), David Wren (Planning), Dave Paul (Planning), Diana Hartley
(Legal), David Sanders (Planning), Panjama Ampanthong (Planning), Kate
Stubbing (Legal) and Matt Spiro (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
6236, FS 3418
5927, FS 3503
5512
Orewa West Investments Limited
Kensington Park Holdings Limited
Pamber (Auckland) Limited
5390
Destination Orewa Beach Limited
3181, FS 3245
Changda International New Zealand
Limited
1764
2492
Ngati Whatua o Kaipara and Te
Kawerau a Maki
Body Corporate 111019
2641
Dawn Everiss and Douglas Mackay
4830, FS 2084
Orakei Bay Village Limited
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Craig Shearer, Planning
Greg Kernohan, Corporate
Michael Lee, Engineering
Craig McGarr, Planning
Sue Simons, Legal
Kate Mulcahy, Legal
James Lunday, Urban Design
John Lovett, Planning
Anne Buchanan, Legal
Roger McDonald, Planning
Kester Ko, Urban Design
Daniel Clay, Corporate
Edward Ashby, Corporate
Nick Roberts, Planning
Ritchie Sims, Submitter
John Mackay, Planning and Urban Design
Douglas Mackay, Submitter
John Duthie, Planning
Daryl Hughes, Traffic
13
TUESDAY, 29 MARCH 2016 – CBD HEARING ROOM 1
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Alan Watson, Les Simmons, Peter Fuller
IHP Officers:
Kylie Gemmell, Ann Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
Erin Woolley (Legal), Rachel Morgan (Planning), Tim Fischer (Legal), Steve Van
Kampen (Planning), Leo Jew (Landscape), Morgan Reeve (Urban Design)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
5833
Brian S & Pamela A Bolton et al
Waiwera Property Owners' and
Residents' Association
C Zambucka
3991
4844
1704, FS 926
2359
2736
1686, FS 929
FS 3497
2359
2736
081 HEARING RECORD
Waiwera Properties Limited and Retail
Holdings Limited (now known as
Waiwera Properties Limited and UP
Management Limited)
South Epsom Planning Group Inc
Three Kings United Group
Drive Holdings Limited and Retail
Holdings Limited (now known as Drive
Holdings Limited and UP
Management Limited)
Mission Bay Kohimarama Residents
Association
South Epsom Planning Group Inc
Three Kings United Group
Represented by
Raewyn Catlow, Planning
Peter Neeve, Planner
Garth Falconer, Landscape/visual
Evan Vertue, Corporate
Thomas Shand, Coastal Inundation
Rob Enright, Legal
Hugh Jarvis, Regional Planning issues
Don Stock
Rob Enright, Legal
Prof. Michael Pender, Geotech
Engineering
Dr Jan Lindsay, Vulcanology
Prof. Mike O’Sullivan, Groundwater
modelling
Garry Law, Wastewater Engineering
Infrastructure
Jan McCredie, Landscape/architecture
Richard Reid, Landscape/architecture
Prof. Dick Bellamy, SEPG Executive
Garry Bryan, TKUG Executive
Michael Wood, Witness/Citizen
Residents including:
Greg McKeown
Sarah Gilbertson
Karen Collins
Graeme Wrack
John Bridges
14
Bill Loutit, Legal
Steve Evans, Fletchers
Koos de Keijzer, Urban Design
Alistair Ray, Urban Design Peer Review
James Lord, Landscape
Rachel de Lambert, Landscape
Rau Hoskins, Cultural
Campbell McGregor,
Stormwater/Wastewater
Craig Richards, Traffic
John Duthie, Planning
John Tik, Engineering
Graeme Twose, Geotechnical
Tristan Bellingham, Contamination
2606, FS 2224
081 HEARING RECORD
Fletcher Construction Developments
(a division of the Fletcher
Construction Company Limited)
The Minister for the Environment
represented by:
Claire Kirman, Legal
Alex Devine, Legal
Amelia Linzey, Planning
Brendon Liggett, Planning
15
WEDNESDAY, 30 MARCH 2016 – CBD HEARING ROOM 1
Panel
Members:
Les Simmons (Chairperson), Des Morrison, Alan Watson
IHP Officers:
Dana Danilova, Philippa Geere-Watson
Council
officers:
Rob O’Connor (Legal), Mathew Allan (Legal), Melinda Dickey (Legal), Barbara
Anover-Water (Planning), Lindsay Wilson (Planning), Jeremy Wyatt (Planning),
Rebecca Greaves (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
6500
Odyssey House
Friends of Onehunga Community
House
1327
1889
5011
4409
4415
James Kirkpatrick Group Limited
Plutus Holdings Ltd
The Church of Jesus Christ of LatterDay Saints Trust Board
Federation of Islamic Societies of New
Zealand
Aitutaki Enua Society Incorporated
6993, FS 1210
Suzanne Weld
4554, FS 3083
Tamaki Redevelopment Company
Limited
7344
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Gerard Thomson, Planning
Philip Grady, Corporate
Tony Broad, Submitter
Bridget Graham, Submitter
Mike Yu, Planning
Lloyd Morris, Corporate
Michael Campbell, Planning
David Hay, Planning
David Hay, Planning
Suzanne Weld, Submitter
Paul Engles
Bill Loutitt, Legal
John Holyoake, Corporate
Carl Lucca, Urban Design
Tim Robinson, Urban Design
Campbell McGregor, Infrastructure
Scott McIntyre, Infrastructure
Todd Langwell, Transport
Mark Vinall, Planning
16
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Les Simmons, Alan Watson,
Greg Hill, Peter Fuller, Paula Hunter (attended morning session only)
IHP Officers:
Thomas Erikson, Philippa Geere-Watson
Council
officers:
Melinda Dickey (Legal), Matthew Gribben (Legal), Jennifer Caldwell (Legal),
Matthew Allan (Legal), Kate Stubbings (Legal), Rebecca Greaves (Planning), Matt
Spiro (Planning), Rebecca Sanders (Planning), Nicholas Pollard (Planning), Sally
Peake (Planning), Tania Richmond (Planning), Barbara Anover-Water (Planning),
Rober Scott (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
4962, FS 3255
Diana Drive Investments Ltd
5861
4336, FS 3754
Orakei Marina Management Trust
KiwiRail Holdings Ltd
FS 3129
Ports of Auckland
6414
Auckland Trotting Club
6218
The Avondale Jockey Club
2193
Advance Properties Group
3026, FS 978
Auckland Racing Club
FS 367
The Ellerslie Stables Precinct Limited
Carlaw Heritage Trust, Carlaw
Campus Ltd Partnership, P.F.I Ltd
Herne Bay Residents Association Inc
Dirk Hudig
Jason P Robertson
Kate I Robertson
Diane B Hudig
Hannah and Peter Sargisson
The Bird Trust
2364
3635
FS 1932
FS 1934
FS 1935
FS 1933
2536
3406
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Brooke Dales, Planning
Matthew Gibson Submitter
Kit Littlejohn, Legal
Max Dunn, Planning
Catherine Raeburn, Planning
Glen Munro, Urban Design
Daniel Sadlier, Legal
Philip Brown, Planning
Rebecca Skidmore, Urban Design
Philip Brown, Traffic
Daniel Minhinnick, Legal
Rachel de Lambert, Visual and Landscape
Kim Hardy, Planning
John Childs, Planning
Clinton Bird, Urban Design
17
MONDAY, 4 APRIL 2016 – CBD HEARING ROOM 2
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany, Philippa Geere-Watson
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Melinda Dickey (Legal), Robert Scott (Planner)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
Irene and Michael Rosser
Michael Rosser, Submitter
Bridget Hackshaw
5327, FS 2142
4219, FS 560
Pengelly Properties Limited
6848
8994
6329
3477
Bridget Hackshaw
John Compton
Carter Family Trust
Centro Investments Ltd
2500
73 Parnell Road Limited
FS 3914
FS 3146
Mayfair Body Corporate
Cowie Street Investments
7325, FS 3152
FS 3875
Domain Heritage Trust
Cleethorpes Fifty Five Ltd
Unification Church of NZ Trust Board
& Family Federation for World Peace
& Unification of NZ
Parnell Business Association (Parnell
Inc)
Parnell Community Committee Inc
1241
2016
5747, FS 3055
FS 2956
3749, FS 3098
3433
081 HEARING RECORD
Strand 25 Ltd
Alastair Kay, Peter Keys and Alan
Drake
Roncon Pacific Limited
Tim Carter, Submitter
Helen Atkins, Legal
Nicholas Stevens, Corporate
Jeremy Salmond, Corporate
Neil Rasmussen, Corporate
Mr Knight, Submitter
Gerard Thompson, Planning
Peter Holdem, Sumbitter
Hamish Firth, Planning
Paul Spackman, Corporate
Luke Niue
Bianca Tree, Legal
Wayne Bredeimjer, Urban Design
Clare Covington, Planning (For
Melanesian Mission Trust Board)
Mr Liggins (For Melanesian Mission Trust
Board)
Alastair Kay, Submitter
James Hook, Planning
18
TUESDAY, 5 APRIL 2016 – CBD HEARING ROOM 1
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany, Ann Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Erin Woolley (Legal), Marie Stainwright (Planning), Timothy
Segedin (Transport), Anna Papaconstantinou (Planning), Ryan Bradley (Planning),
Lindsay Wilson (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
5481
5491
5484
1936, FS 958
Kiwi Self Storage
Cawley Street Investments
Carr Road Investments
Joan, Peter and Richard Hanson
1975
268, FS 2191
104
310
Neville Fong
G B M and R J Connell and J G
Samuel
Thomas Bretherton
Nicolas Colwell
FS 3044
259
3162
1673, FS 2050
FS 419
Marie Taylor et al
Grant D Owen
Robert Bode
Margot Orr
Passion Fruit Trust
1822
4746
EJV Property Investments Limited
Anne G S Gambrill
2388
Michael T Y Park
FS 3907
1764
Matakana Museum Ltd
Ngati Whatua o Kaipara and Te
Kawerau a Maki
4321
Te Kawerau Iwi Tribal Authority Inc
Alan Tribity, Planning
Andrew Frasher, Kiwi Corporate
Joan Hanson, Submitter
Peter Hanson, Submitter
Thomas Bretherton, Submitter
Nicolas Colwell, Submitter
Damaris Swinburn, Submitter
Simone Mekegg, Submitter
Grant D Owen, Submitter
Robert Bode, Submitter
Margot Orr, Submitter
Troy Churton, Submitter
Mark Vinall, Planner
Andrew Fasler, Submitter
Anne G S Gambrill, Submitter
James Hook, Planner
Alan Webb, Legal
Samuel Equab, Economics
John Baker, Corporate
John Dare, Developer
Rob Enright Legal
Te Warena Taua, ONZM, as Chair of
Kawerau, Trustee and kaumatua
Edward Ashby, Representative for
Kawerau
Jessica Reaburn, Ecology
Peter Reaburn, Planning
Chris Scholder, Engineer
081 HEARING RECORD
19
WEDNESDAY, 6 APRIL 2016 – CBD HEARING ROOM 1
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Les Simmons, Alan Watson (morning session), Jan
Crawford (afternoon session)
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Melinda Dickey (Legal), Rob O’Connor (Legal), Rachel Ward (Legal), Anna
Papaconstantinou (Planning), Tim Solomon (Planning), Cosette Saville (Planning),
Mr Lindsay (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
4292
Cotter House and Bluetang Group Ltd
and Hearing Association Auckland Inc
1053
4799, FS 2648
Walton Properties Ltd
Ian Cowper
5305
Jane G Hyde-Hills
5980
5253, FS 3297
Hauraki Gulf Investment Ltd
Eden Park Neighbours Association
Inc
Plaza Holdings Limited
Dominion Partnership
CJ Stamford Trust
Akarana Golf Club
Springleigh Residents Association
New Zealand Ltd
Kiwi Income Property Trust and Kiwi
Property Holdings Ltd (now known as
Kiwi Property Group Ltd)
205
H J Wernham
993
FS 3893
3210
5080
4612
5219
Carolyn C Falkner
Peng Chen
Gordon A Kopu et al
Babu G Singh
Duncan McKenzie
Hartwig Clasen
2940
9427
Royal Oak Baptist Church
Iain and Joanne Bremner
A M Finnigan, Carytids Trustee Ltd
and Tinos Trustee Ltd
The Department of Corrections
5929, FS 1353
2928, FS 3073
1895
4741
6261
FS 786
2632, FS 2963
873
6230
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
John Childs
Nick Rae, Urban Design
Angela Goodwin, Planning
Jane G Hyde-Hills, Submitter
Olivia Thomas, Submitter
Philip Brown, Planner
Paul Dyson, Corporate
Mark Donnelly, Submitter
Russell Baikie, Planning
Hiltrud Gruger, Submitter
Clare Covington, Planning
Dr Wernham, Submitter
Julian King
Carolyn Falkner, Submitter
Jim Gleeson
Paul Arnesen, Planning
Philip Church
20
THURSDAY, 7 APRIL 2016 – CBD HEARING ROOM 1
Panel
Members:
Les Simmons (Chairperson), Des Morrison (Chairperson for final submitter), Alan
Watson
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Melinda Dickey (Legal), Matthew Alan (Legal)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
FS 1237
4954
2203, FS 3139
2201
7100
John R Holmes
Peter J Don and Fay Hutchison
Rutherford Rede
Webster and Co – Chartered
Accountants
Chivalry Enterprises Limited
FS 2774
2070
2403
1899, FS 748
FS 2345
1961
7762, FS 1271
7783, FS 1268
2937
7005, FS 3790
FS 1770
David A Alison
Gunn Family Trust
Basil Denee
Lydia Hewitt
Mary Daysh
Paul R Gregory
Trevor R Lund
Lynne Butler
Donald M Bunting
Robert E Tait
Kanji Chimanlal et al
1585, FS 3290
2005
2006
2009
1252, FS 3075
1253
FS 618
213
Parawanui Properties Ltd
Henry Family Trust
Karl L Henry
Jeanette B Henry
Chitow Trust
Paris Family Trust
Willy Sussman
Erika Whittome
Manu Bhanabhai and DW Trust
Management Ltd
John and Penny Kernohan
William and Ann Still
Karlos Litt
2409, FS 1290
1257
1238
4576
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
John Holmes, Submitter
David Wren, Planner
David Wren, Planner
David A Alison
John Lovett, Planner
Adam Wild, Planner
Lydia Hewitt, Submitter
Mary Daysh, Submitter
Ms Patterson, Submitter
Jeremy Brabant, Leal
Michael Parsonson, Planning
Richard Nash, Architect
SE Anderton, Legal
21
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Alan Watson, Jan Crawford
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Melinda Dickey (Legal), Steve van Campen (Planning), Gerv Singh (Planning),
Lindsay Withall (Planning), Cosette Saville (Planning), Tim Soloman (Planning),
Hamish Scott (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
5456
6513
2182
3408
Manukau Road Partnership
Briar H Wilson
John and Anne-Marie Drillien
Tuperiri Road Residents Association
3840, FS 1374
Pukehana Avenue Resident Group
8951
3357
3587
3043
231
3288
283
CP Investments Limited
Penlan Properties Ltd
Chi-Chieh Hsu
Turo and Shona Tuala et al
Anning Xie
Ranfurly Care Society Incorporated
Mo and Qiu Family Trust
871
1106
Hauraki Meadows Limited
Yu Yi
5790, FS 2573
Cornwall Park Trust Board
5716
Auckland Council
3434
Kimberley Trust and Kimberley
Housing Charitable Trust
081 HEARING RECORD
Maree Weston, Submitter
Angela Borich, Planning
Brett Black, Submitter
Graham Jull, Corporate
Linda Qiu, Submitter
Yu Yi, Submitter
Andrew Murray, Transport
Alistair Lovell, Auckland Transport
Brianna Parkinson, Legal
Kevin Brewer, Urban Design
Mr Clark, Traffic
22
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Thomas Erikson, Philippa Geere-Watson
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Rob O’Connor (Legal), Melinda Dickey (Legal), Leanne
Lucas (Planning), Matthew Riley (Urban Design), Ross Cooper(Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
2219
FS 3054
FS 193
Tuhimata Street Residents Group
Peter D Ellis, Cherryl D Ellis and John
K Radley
Overland Development Ltd (previously
Green Village Development Limited)
Kathryn E Davies
Squirrel Trust
The Neighbours of Mission Bay
Crescent Land Society
Michael J and Sandra E Cameron
5649, FS 1182
6240
7094-5
547
4223
2648
Ancona Properties Ltd
CIT Holdings Ltd
Kohimarama Trust Ltd
Andrew and Pauline McPherson
Ali and Farida Memon
Robert and Veronica Schoonraad
869
3532
FS 459
FS 3021
Represented by
Jason Evans, Urban Design
Philip Wells, Resident
Graham Pearce, Resident
Elizabeth Stewart, Planning
Gill Chappell, Legal
Stuart Mackie, Urban Design
Kathryn E Davies, Submitter
James Hook, Planner
Michael Cameron, Submitter
Mike Markham, Corporate
Greg Oliver, Corporate
Andrew McPherson, Submitter
Stephanie de Groot, Legal
Tapert Family Trust
Civil Cost Limited
Oyster Management Ltd
FM Trustees 504 Ltd and C. and R.
1004
Adams Trust
4903
John Childs
4575
CJ Melrose Trust
4581
J D Rai and Sons Limited
Kohimarama Neighbourhood Group (Gill Chappell) cross-examined Amelia Linzey and Matt
Lindenberg from Housing New Zealand
FS 1263
Carol Miles
FS 1299
Helen E Halliday
FS 1282
Gillian E Jones
FS 1289
Jane Williams
FS 3227
Jacqui Fillmore
Jen Duder, Submitter
FS 1313
Maryanne Dransfield
James Hook, Planner
4266
1173, FS423
1499, FS 1291
081 HEARING RECORD
23
FS 3225
FS 3230
FS 682
FS 1022
FS 1301
FS 3035
FS 1310
FS 1316
FS 1312
FS 3226
FS 1218
FS 700
FS 701
FS 707
FS 1317
FS 679
FS 3211
FS 3039
FS 3228
FS 1303
FS 742
FS 3224
FS 1292
FS 704
441
FS 1306
FS 3037
FS 329
FS 1286
FS 1249
081 HEARING RECORD
Marilyn Bray
Michael Bristow
Richard Thompson
Rory Thompson
Vidas Petraska
Bill Whitburn
Cyril and Sheila Bosch
Eva Thompson
James L Halliday
Jeanette Bristow
Mary B Decleene
Kate Thompson
Philippa Schaab
Ruth Phipps
Murray Carlisle
Rosanna Thompson
Stewart Taylor
Steve Malam
Alan Beggs
Annette Petraska
Anthony R Decleene
Dee Black
Heather Leather
Garry R Phipps
Jen Duder
Jason Miles
Kaye Wilson
Kohimarama Neighbourhood Group
Richard S Jones
Robert Wallace
24
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Alan Watson, Les Simmons
IHP Officers:
Matthew Gouge, Ann Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Tim Fischer (Legal), Jeremy Wyatt (Planning), Peter Nunns
(Economics), Lindsay Wilson (Planning), Marie Stainwright (Planning), Leanne
Lucas (Planning), Anna Papaconstantinou (Planning), Peter Barnes (Planning), Jo
Machado (Planning), Sisira Jayasinghe (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
3596
Liz Stewart and Keith Littmoden
6150, FS2570
6356
FS846
NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited
Body Corporate 197887
Represented by
Susan Rhodes, Legal
Mike Shatford, Corporate
Helen Hamilton, Planning
Brett Smithies, Property
Kate Morrissey
Kate Morrissey
Scarbro Construction Holdings
Limited and BC Scarborough Family
6978, FS3706 Trust
Mark Benjamin, Planning
Belmont Estates Limited and Infineon Adam Thompson, Economics
4143, FS2928 Properties Limited
Mike Urquhart, Corporate
The National Trading Company of New Zealand Limited cross-examined Jeremy Wyatt from
Auckland Council
2632, FS2963 New Zealand Limited (Lunn Ave)
Helen Atkins, Legal
Wayne Bredemeijer, Urban Design
Mr Morris, Corporate
4816
B and Z Finance Limited
Frank and Gwynneth Lawlor, Jean
950
Carbon and Rita Radley
2436
R M Lerner and J K Radley
J Radley, Submitter
Richard Matthews, Planning
4112, FS3028 Wilson Hellaby Group of Companies
Bruce Fyfe, Corporate
ACI Operations New Zealand Limited
Jo Bain, Legal
852, FS2229
(O-I New Zealand)
Andrea Brabant, Planning
5812
Downer New Zealand Limited
Penny Garland, Corporate
Helen Atkins, Legal
Jenny Simpson, Air Quality
Andrew Wilkinson, Planning
853, FS3374
James Fletcher Drive Industry Group
Tony Keenan, Corporate
5319, FS1674 Mountwel Properties
Glenn Teal, Planning
Bianca Tree, Legal
4868, FS884
DB Breweries Limited
081 HEARING RECORD
25
Panel
Members:
Greg Hill (Chairperson), Peter Fuller
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany, Philippa Geere-Watson
Council
officers:
Brenda Milo (Legal), Rachel Ward (Legal), Gerv Singh (Planner), Tim Soloman
(Planner), Lindsay Wilson (Planner), Leanne Lucas (Planner)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
892, FS 918
Sean Zhang
3477
47
1601
FS 2192
7094
FS 3409
Dilworth Trust Board
James J Gallagher
T and J Mead
Frances Battersby
Melanesian Mission trust Board
Trust Management on behalf of Saint
Johns College Trust Board et al
4823
Stephen Davis
FS 3895
6444, FS 3401
Augusta Capital Limited
Civic Trust Auckland
OraTaiao: The New Zealand Climate
and Health council
7051
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Daniella Holschier, Planning
Sean Zhang, Submitter
Claire Covington, Planning
Stephen Davis, Submitter
Leo Hill, Transport
Matthew Riley, Urban Design
Allan Matson, Submitter
Darren Milner, Submitter
26
Panel
Members:
Les Simmons (Chairperson), Des Morrison, Alan Watson
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Hamish Scott (Planning), Lindsay Wilson (Planning),
Panjama Ampanthong (Planning), Barbara-Ann Overwater (Planning), Wayne Siu
(Planning), Martin Peake (Traffic and Transportation), Kate Stubbing (Legal)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
6247, FS3350
Samson Corporation Limited and
Sterling Nominees Limited
5968, FS1690
FS 3923
Masfen Holdings Limited
Residents of Parnell
FS1769
Radley and Company Limited
5662
The University of Auckland
(Newmarket Campus)
Peter G Buchanan
1054
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Jeremy Brabant, Legal
Marco Creemers, Corporate
Russell Bartlett, Legal
Ian Munro, Urban Design
Elizabeth Brown, Submitter
John Radley, Corporate
James Mooney, Urban Design
Karl Hancock, Traffic engineering
Karl Cook, Planning
Peter G Buchanan
27
Panel
Members:
Greg Hill (Chairperson), Peter Fuller
IHP Officers:
Alison Stilwell, Thomas Erikson
Council
officers:
Melinda Dickey (Legal), Brenda Milo (Legal), Marie Stainright, (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
FS 3784
Captain Springs 2015 Ltd (Successor
to Captain Springs Ltd Partnership)
2449, FS1663
2785
1643
Winnie Guan
Greg Covey (Covey Family Trust)
Katherine F Mahoney
Tony Gapes, Corporate
Winnie Guan, Submitter
Mike Carter, Submitter
2427
Wilkinson Road Limited Partnership
5150
6852
3769
4107
Sultan Trust
Ellerslie Residents Association
Point Chevalier Residents Against
THABs Incorporated
Jim Rendell
Annette Munro
Kerryn Law
Hans Heumann
Arthur Street Ellerslie Petition and 71
Signatures
Pohutukawa Kindergarten
4075
3989
Andrew Gibson
Susan Rhodes
2007, FS56
FS693
FS128
FS2064
2976
FS 3916
Greg and Sarah Clark et al
FS 3921
3726
Parnell Community Committee
Briar Green and Rick Pearson
5153, FS 2762
Grey Lynn Residents Association
3500
B and M Jujnovich
Rentyn and Colleen Turner Family
Trust
James Willoughby
4703
1137
081 HEARING RECORD
Stephanie Hantler, Planning
Matt Riley, Urban Design
Bruce Catley, Submitter
Bryce Bartley, Submitter
Jim Rendall, Submitter
Annette Munro, Submitter
Ron Law
David Jeffrey, Submitter
Melanie Matson, Submitter
Marlene and Kim Sutterton
Andrew Gibson, Submitter
Jeremy Treadwell, Submitter
Allison Arthur-Young, Legal
Simon Pilkinton, Legal
Luke Niue, Submitter
Nicola Legat, Submitter
Liz Hancock, Submitter
Tania Mace, Submitter
Submitter representative
R Turner, Submitter
28
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Les Simmons, Alan Watson, Peter Fuller
IHP Officers:
Phil Chung, Ann Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
John Burns (Legal), Peter Reaburn (Planning), Erin Woolley (Legal), Trevor Mackie
(Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
6225 FS3419
8262
4582, FS3478
6371
3111
3114
FS 2107
4671
7039
4071
Bayswater Marina Limited
Margaret Walsh
Bayswater Community Committee
Incorporated
Peter Rothwell
Brian Stafford-Bush
Paddy Stafford-Bush
Malcolm and Cherie Lane
Gay Richards
5280, FS3199
5478, FS2558
Michael Kwok and Brianna Parkinson
Peter V Hendriksen
The Urban Design Forum New
Zealand
The New Zealand Institute of
Architects
Generation Zero
5367
AJ and T L Field
3373, FS1178
Northcote Rd 1 Holdings Limited
3249, FS1179
W Smale Limited
5277, FS3235
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Derek Nolan, Legal
Simon Herbert, Corporate
Brett Harries, Transport
John Goodwin, Landscape
David Gibbs, Urban Design and
Architecture
Brian Stafford-Bush
Malcolm Lane
Ms Stafford-Bush
Gay Richards, Chair
Brianna Parkinson, Submitter
Bruce McKenzie, Landscape
Kevin Brewer, Urban Design
Ian Clark, Traffic
Dave Serjeant, Planning
Julie Stout, Submitter
Tanya Field
John Goodwin, Urban Design
29
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson), Les Simmons, Alan Watson, Peter Fuller
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Erin Woolley (Legal), Trevor Mackie (Planning), Rachel Davison (Legal), Ewen
Patience (Planning), Melinda Dickey (Legal)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
6335
FS 3091
9377
FS 3107
8968
6631
4203, FS2562
3263
3088
3571
Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited
AJK Investments Limited
Aryan Equities Limited
G&C Worger Family Trust
Monte Holdings Limited
Stingray Bay Farms Limited
Monaro Properties Limited and
Takapuna Properties Limited
Crown Mutual Limited and Crown
Pacific Finance Limited and State
Advances Corporation Limited
Devonport Heritage Incorporated
Trish and Joe Dean
Iain Rea
5599
5595
Atlas Concrete Limited (Wairau Road
Milford)
Atlas Concrete Limited (Rosedale)
FS3843
New Zealand Sugar Company Limited
3776, FS2797
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Brad Nobilio, Planning
Benjamin James Wiltshire, Architecture
Trish Deans
Keith Berman, Legal
Brett Harries, Traffic
Natasha Garvan, Legal
John Ellis, Corporate
Rod Clough, Heritage
Rachel de Lambert, Landscape and visual
Catherine Clarke, Planning
30
Panel
Members:
Des Morrison (Chairperson) Alan Watson, Les Simmons, Peter Fuller (am session
only)
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Erin Woolley (Legal), Melean Absolum (Landscape), Terry
Conner (Planning), Robert Hillier (Geotechnical), Ewan Patience (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
1907
Judith Herbert
Represented by
Sarah Robson, Planning
Mark Lockhart, Landscape
Chris Wedding, Ecologist
Shane Lander, Geotechnical
4981
Kotewell Trustee Ltd
Johnathan Oram, Corporate
rd
7103, FS 2630 3 Fairway Development Ltd
4822
Bungalo Holdings Limited
6014
Heletranz Limited
Steve Clark, Corporate
North Eastern Investments Limited and Heritage Land Limited cross-examined Ewen Patience from
Auckland Council
John Maassen, Legal
John Farquhar, Corporate
North Eastern Investments Limited
Brett Harries, Transport
857
and Heritage Land Limited
Paul Thomas, Planning
081 HEARING RECORD
31
Panel
Members:
Les Simmons (Chairperson), Des Morrison, Alan Watson (excused for second half
of first session)
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Tim Fischer (Legal), Deborah Riley (Legal), Erin Woolley
(Legal), Gurv Singh (Planning), Hamish Scott (Planning), Jeremy Wyatt (Planner),
Alistair Lovell (Auckland Transport)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
FS 3143
AUT Millennium Ownership Trust
2748, FS 2878
The Warehouse Limited
6640
Wairau Park Syndicate
4287, FS2768
Fairmont Investment Corporation Ltd
2554
Wairau Valley Property Owners
Collective
5133, FS 2923
4691
Okura Holdings Limited
Long Bay Communities Limited
5716
4462, FS
3673, FS 1235
Auckland Council – Weiti Precinct
5466, FS 2696
Okura Environmental Group
General Trust Board of the Diocese of
Auckland
Jill Gregory, Legal
Vern Warren, Planning
Robert Pryor, Landscape
Daniel Shaw, Planning
Adam Thompson, Economics
Daryl Devereux, Submitter
Frank McGuckian, Submitter
Neil Dowsett, Submitter
Barry Kirk- Burnnard, Submitter
Brigid Kelly, Legal
Karl Cook, Planning
Neil Donnelly, Planning
Erin Woolley, Legal
Nicholas Vigar, Stormwater
Megan Carbines, Marine Ecology
Alan Webb, Legal
Fiona McLaughlin, Submitter
Andreas Roa, Stormwater
Samuel Morgan, Geology
4422
081 HEARING RECORD
Long Bay – Okura Great Park Society
32
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Phil Chung, Philippa Geere-Watson
Council
officers:
Diana Hartley (Legal), Erin Woolley (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal), David Mead
(Planning), Nicholas Vigar (Planning), Martin Peake (Auckland Transport), Alistair
Lovell (Auckland Transport)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
5795, FS 3284
5828, FS 3284
5047
2235
1227
1708
2502
2505
Fu Mei Yeh
Joe Zhao
Bin Chen et al
Okura Rural Landowners Group
Peter W Grenfell
Gail Warman
Jennifer T Stokes
Laures G Warman
Warman Family Trust and JD Warman
and Botany Downs Trustee Co
Limited
Rapata Family Trust and Eiberg
Family Trust Partnership
Michael Eiberg
2508
4283
3736
5796, FS 2835
4462, FS 3673
FS 1235
Weiti Development LP and Green and
McCahill Holdings Ltd
3214, FS 2901
Long Bay – Okura Great Park Society
East Coast Bays Coastal Protections
Society
4282, FS 3365
Albany North Land Owners Group
081 HEARING RECORD
Bronwyn Carruthers, Legal
Evan Williams, Corporate
Joseph Phillips, Traffic
John Goodwin, Landscape
Dave Slaven, Ecology
Stephen Priestley, Engineering
Sharon de Luca, Marine Ecology
Sean Grace, Planning
Sam Morgan, Geology
Fiona McLaughlin, Submitter
Lezette Reid, Submitter
Maree Baker-Galloway, Legal
Gary Clark, Infrastructure
33
SOUTH PANEL
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Jan Crawford, Paula Hunter, Stuart Shepherd, Judge
Kirkpatrick, Greg Hill, Peter Fuller and David Hill
IHP Officers:
Mathew Gouge and Dana Danilova
Council
officers:
Melinda Dickey, Legal
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
Housing New Zealand Corporation
Matt Lindenberg, Planning
Brendon Liggett, Corporate
Patrick Doherty, Corporate
David Hermans, MBIE
Tim Heath, Economics
Phil Osborne, Economics
Alex Fullerton, GIS
Carl Lucca, Urban Design
839, FS 3338
081 HEARING RECORD
34
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Stuart Shepard, David Hill, Judge Kirkpatrick
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Erin Woolley (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal), Diana Hartley (Legal), Robert Scott
(Planning), Trevor Mackie (Planning), Tim Grace (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
5723, FS 2039
2968
2444, FS 2919
Progressive Enterprises Limited
Westfield (New Zealand) Limited (now
known as Scentre (New Zealand)
Limited)
Argosy Property Limited
5259, FS 2733
Hugh Green Limited
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Mike Foster, Planning
Tim Grace, Planning
Francelle Lupis, Legal
Rachel de Lambert, Visual Expert
Matt Norwell, Planning
Asher Davidson, Legal Megan Tongue,
Landscape
Emma Bayly, planning Mr Russell Baikie,
planning Shane Lander (Geotech) Darren
Fidler, (Transport) Grant Petersen, Water
& Resource
John Tik, Infrastructure Darren Fidler,
(Transport)
Mike Chapman, (Stormwater)
Dr Gary Bramley, Terrestrial Ecology
Richard Montgomerie, Aquatic Ecology
Sam Coles, (Urban Design)
Patrick Gavaghan (Engineering)
35
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Stuart Shepard, David Hill, Jan Crawford
IHP Officers:
Dana Danilova, Ann Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
Melinda Dickey (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal), Tim Fischer (Legal)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
The Urban Design Forum New
Zealand
The New Zealand Institute of
Architects
9.30am – 11.00am
5277, FS 3235
5280, FS 3199
David Gibbs, Residential zoning and planenabled capacity
Adam Thompson, Economics and
Property Market Analysis
Niko Elsen, Generation Zero 7 Central City
Centre Fringe
5478, FS2558
081 HEARING RECORD
Generation Zero
John Mackay, Business Zones,
Greenfields Development, Franklin,
Pukekohe , Manukau, Lincoln Road,
Devonport, Takapuna, East Coast Bays,
Albany & Greenhithe (Windsor Park),
Rosedale, Wairau & Barrys Point (Light
Industry), Glenfield, Northcote, Birkenhead
(Wairau, Constellation), Smales Farm &
Rodney
Greg Boyden, Central City Centre Fringe
Ken Crosson Central City Centre Fringe
Ron Seeto, Ellerslie
Paul Edmond, Sub- regional and Precincts
Paul Edmond, Orakei, St Heliers,
Panmure, Glen Innes
Bobby Shen, Puketapapa, Albert Eden
John Mackay, Onehunga
Ron Seeto, Omaha/Leigh
Kester Ko, Howick & Papakura
Stuart Mackie, Manurewa
Kitty Fan, Otara-Papatoetoe
Kate Watson, West
Lincoln Road
36
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Stuart Shepherd, David Hill
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Todd Webb (Planning), Dr Curran-Cournane (Land and Soil
Science) Melean Absolum (Landscape)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
5528, FS 3303
FS 1852
FS 1858
FS 1861
5370, FS 3306
FS 3305
6914
FS 1879
FS 1951
FS 2037
FS 2890
FS 3495
FS1820
FS1875
FS2042
FS1869
9128, FS 1827
5346
Templemore Land Company Limited
Carol and Carl Vessey
Richard F Thomas
M I Wood Trust
John M Gilbert
P D Gilbert
Timothy M Wood
James M Black
Susan and Owen Young
M I Wood
Rainbow Park Nurseries Limited
Doug Penman
HAR and CI Eyre
Delowar Hossain
Stephen and Kim Lowe
Owen Finlay
Robert P Blows
Neil Construction Limited
4422, FS 2150
The General Trust Board of the
Diocese of Auckland
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
John Gilbert, Client
Dr Peter Singleton, Soil quality
John Goodwin, Urban design and
landcape
Robert P Blows
Derek Nolan, Legal
Rachel de Lambert, Landscape
Adam Wild, Heritage
37
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Stuart Shepherd, David Hill, Paula Hunter (a.m. only)
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Rachel Davison (Legal), Alistair Lovell (Auckland Transport), Ross Moffat
(Planning), Matt Spiro (Planning), Douglas Sadlier (Planning), Chloe Trenouth
(Planning), David Wong (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
883, FS 3315
Ngati Whatua Orakei Whai Rawa
Limited
1725
New Zealand Transport Agency
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Kate Healy, Corporate
Graeme McIndoe, Urban Design
Fraser Colgrave, Economic
Matt Flannery, Civil Engineerin
Leo Hills, Traffic
Christine Sheard, Legal
Cath Heppelthwaite, Planning
Leo Hills, Transport
Mike Wood, Corporate
Patrick Buckley, Corporate
Jeremy Blake, Planning
38
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Stuart Shepherd, David Hill, Jan Crawford (am only),
Paula Hunter (pm only)
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany, Dana Danilova, Philippa Geere-Watson
Council
officers:
Diana Hartley (Legal), Alistair Cribbens (Auckland Transport)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
Daniella Holschier, Planning
Jason Adams, CDL
Peter Boselmann, Geotechnical
Engineering
Bronwyn Rhynd, Stormwater
Geoff Webster, Infrastructure
Bryce Hall, Transport and Traffic engineer
3159, FS 3212 CDL Land New Zealand Limited
Dennis Scott, Urban Design
Michael Gimblet, Corporate
6193
Goodman Property Trust
Douglas Allan on behalf of Goodman Property Trust cross-examined Benjamin Frost from Auckland
Council
081 HEARING RECORD
39
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), David Hill, Stuart Shepherd, Jan Crawford (Session 1
and 2)
IHP Officers:
Thomas Erikson, Philip Chung
Council
officers:
Heather Ash (Legal), Mark Tollemache (Planning), Evan Keating (Auckland
Transport) , Eryn Shields (Planning), Tim Fisher (Legal), Matthew Allan (Legal), Joe
Jeffries (Planning), Terry Conner (Planning), Robert Hillier (Geotechnical), Jon Rix
(Stormwater), Ian Cowper (Legal)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
5000, FS 855
Max Dunn, Planning
5323
3108
2547
Les Mills Holdings Limited
Vuksich and Borich Limited and Cook
Group Holdings Limited
Dairy Flat West Landowners Group
Top Harbour Limited
Sustainable Property Investments
Limited
Richard Vaughan
Susan and Ray Harrison
5882, FS 3324
Chris Dickson
3653, FS 2684
6391, FS 3476
6159
6030
5501
Y Zhang and H L Developments
Albany Limited
RSSB NZ Limited
5165
5819, FS 3309
FS 3910
081 HEARING RECORD
New Zealand Retail Property Group
Fletcher Building Group
Mary Qin
Debbie Tilley, Planning
Sally Peake, Landscape
Chris Dickson, Submitter
Chris Solleder, Engineering
Chris Solleder, Engineering
Campbell Barbour, Corporate
Mary Qin, Submitter
40
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), David Hill, Stuart Shepherd, Paula Hunter (session 2
only)
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Matthew Alan (Legal), Rob O’Connor (Legal), Stephen Brown (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
4909, FS 3058
Todd Property Group Limited
4827
FS 1936
FS 2436
Bob Lack and Pinewoods Motor Park
James H Young
Barbara A Scarfe
General Trust Board of the Anglican
Diocese of Auckland
John S Morton
Michael P Glading
Waiuku Collective Group
Brookdale Limited
BKB Family Trust
Short Family Trust
Tripp Andrews Surveyors Limited
Whatihua Limited
Alastair White, Planning
Cameron McGregor, Corporate
Bob Lack, Submitter
James H Young, Submitter
Barbara A Scarfe, Submitter
8932
FS 1682
FS 1748
5147, FS 1448
3599
5093
2215
FS 2880
FS 2879
081 HEARING RECORD
Clare Covington, Planning
John Morton
Ron Batty
Nick Williamson, Planning
Paul Sands, Submitter
Janine Maxwell, Submitter
Peter Nichols, Land Surveyor
41
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Judge Kirkpatrick, David Hill, Stuart Shepherd, Greg
Hill, Paula Hunter, Janet Crawford
IHP Officers:
Matthew Gouge, Ann-Marie Callaghan
Council
officers:
Melinda Dickey (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
Richard Burton, Planning
Gregory Sparling
Graeme Popplewell
Stephen Matthews, Architect
Ben Grimer
David Thomas
Kay Morris
John McCaffery
1473, FS 412
Auckland 2040 Incorporated
Neil Solomon
1527
Waikauri Bay Reserve Limited
Richard Burton, Planning
Ian Mayhew
5716
Auckland Council
Jon Rix
Karl Schweder cross-examined Robert Pryor, Craig Cairncross, Ian Mayhew and Jon Rix from
Auckland Council
Dan Madsen on behalf Linda M and Stewart D Sloane and Lee A Cochrane Park, Kana Holdings
(1963) Limited, Mohan Parsot and Pukekohe Hill East Group cross-examined Robert Pryor, Craig
Cairncross, Ian Mayhew and Jon Rix from Auckland Council
6871, FS 2259 Karl Schweder
859, FS 3154
Denis Schweder
FS 3285
Madsen Lawrie Consultants Limited
Linda M and Stewart D Sloane and
6350
Lee A Cochrane
6323
Kana Holdings (1963) Limited
Karl Schweder
6346
Mohan Parsot
Denis Schweder
FS 3902
Pukekohe Hill East Group
Dan Madsen
6875
Maria Schweder
Karl Schweder
6874
Flynn Bros Limited
FS 653
Searle Holdings Limited
3344
Kinny International Limited
David Lawrie
081 HEARING RECORD
42
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Stuart Shepherd, David Hill, Janet Crawford (Session 3)
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany, Thomas Erikson
Council
officers:
Lisa Jack (Legal), Marie Stainwright (Planning), Joy La Nauze (Planning), Alison
Pye (Planning), Matthew Allan (Legal), Diana Hartley (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal),
Ryan Bradley (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
3621
Abu Hoque, Urban Designer
6799
York Investment Limited
Te Atatu Peninsula Business
Association
3766, FS 2977
Transpower New Zealand Limited
6650
1682
6834
Summerset Group Holdings Limited
John and Jane Taylor
Peter Reid and Daniel Thomas
1553
4785
4790
Cedel Downs Stud
P and R Tubberty Family Trust
Jobridge Limited
6424
2056
4724
5264
Toby G Mandeno
Preserve Piha Limited
John and Pien Wise
Oratia Foothills Limited
5265
Ali Sheer
081 HEARING RECORD
Robynne Pringle, Corporate
Luke Hinchey, Legal
Sylvia Allan, Planning
Craig Moriarty, Planning
Aaron Smail, Corporate
David Wren, Planner
Warren Flaunty, Submitter
Josh Tubberty, Submitter
Peter Tubberty, Submitter
Toby G Mandeno, Planning
Shelia Mandeno, Submitter
Barry Kaye, Submitter
Setareh Masoud-Ansari , Legal
Kim Aukett, Planning
Barry Kaye, Planning
Jessica Parulian, Planning
Geraldine Bayly, Landscape
43
Panel
Members:
Stuart Shepherd (Chairperson), Jan Crawford, David Hill
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Tim Fischer (Legal), Ryan Bradley (Planning), Joanna Hart (Planning), Heather Ash
(Legal), Alison Pye (Planning), Raj Maharjan (Planning), Anna Papaconstantinou
(Planning), Eryn Shields (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
4690
6937
6781
6812
4382
7078
6200
5638
Robert V Watt
Waimauku United Landowners Group
Craig Booth
Michael Ward
Julius Yang
John Francis
John and Gillian Wood
Magsons Investments Limited
Robert V Watt
FS 3882
Dave and Natalie Curteis
3590
5607
3794
7081
Anderson and O’Leary Limited
Allan and Jetta Laurenson
Caddyshack Racing Limited
Thomas Richard and Company
Limited
3859
Hobsonville Land Company Limited
7019
Addams Trust Company Limited
2959, FS 3147
Waitakere Ranges Protection Society
6096, FS 668
Bunnings Limited
081 HEARING RECORD
John Francis, Horticulturist
Christopher Solleder, Engineering
John Wood
Kay Panther Knight, Planning
Jono Ryan, Planning
Andrew Anderson, Submitter
Brian Cowley, Cadastral Surveyor
Pete Sinton, Planning
Steve Williams, Submitter
Giles Bramwell, Planning
David Ison, Corporate
Lahiru Wijewardhana, Planning
Steven Rankin, Engineering
Adam Buttling, Corporate
Rob Enright, Legal
Matthew Norwell, Planning
David Boersen, Corporate
44
THURSDAY, 31 MARCH 2016 – HENDERSON
Panel
Members:
Stuart Shepherd (Chairperson), John Kirikiri and David Hill
IHP Officers:
Christopher Turbott and Dana Danilova
Council
officers:
Diana Hartley (Legal), Ryan Bradley (Planning), Stephen Brown (Landscape), Eryn
Shields (Planning), Alison Pye (Planning), Raj Marajan (Planning), Fiona CurranCournane (Land and soil science), Erin Woolley (Legal), Sukhdeep Singh
(Planning) and Nigel Lloyd (Acoustics)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
2153
FS 3896
FS 3897
FS 3898
West Harbour Esplanade Residents
Group
Ian G Shaw
Taupaki residents and Ratepayers
Association
(IPL) Industrial Processors Limited
W D Mackenzie Transport Ltd
Fantail Management Limited
363
Ljubo and Lucija Tvrdeich
3504
Joanne Sunde and Tim Rickards
48
Hong Hao
9406
Robert A Culver
6714
7142
2032
3764
3595
3774
5609
7186
7194
7212
7215
7217
7173
7187
3036
7197
7183
Delegat’s Wine Estate Ltd
Coatesville Rezoning Group
Gavin J & Elizabeth F Alexander
Peter and Angela Hampson
Alan J Curtis
Michael R and Maria E Ellis
Pierre and Claire Fonteny
Shona Davies-Stone
Laura R Hamlet
Robert S and Jillian M Rowdon
Grant A Campbell
Simon T Cox
Otangaroa Te Kopuru No 7 Trust
Warren and Cate Haigh
Peter J and Elizabeth M Hedley
Marise Bowden
Michelle and Kerry Conway
Coatesville Resident and Ratepayers
Association
5396
1203
7240
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Stuart Webb, Submitter
Ian Shaw, Submitter
Jeremy Brabant, Legal
Ivan Tvrdeich, Submitter
Kathleen Vitasovich, Submitter
Joanne Sunde, Submitter
Tim Rickards, Submitter
Hong Hao, Submitter
Mr Hao, Submitter
Robert Culver, Submitter
Jim Delegat, Corporate
Alan Curtis, Submitter representative
Gavin Alexander, Submitter representative
Jo Young, Planning
Bryce Hall, Traffic Engineering
James Bentley, Landscape
Brian Hedley, Submitter
Mike Rowe, Submitter
45
1254
Dani Chen et al
6171
6709
FS 2293
3805
7090
805
Ian and Barbara Dutton
Kumeu-Huapai Residents &
Ratepayers Association
Dysart Lane Area
Pomona Road Group
Carl and Joanne Price
Bruce Carter
3800
Peter Sinton and Graham McIntyre
FS 3880
4416
4410
4406
Bunty Condon
Marconi and Margaret A Furtado
Martin and Valerie O’Brien
Ian D and Karen A Chisholm
838, FS 2265
New Zealand Defence Force
FS 3918
Frank and Tiziana Austin
081 HEARING RECORD
Ken Mackenzie, Submitter
Ian Dutton, Submitter
Barbara Dutton, Submitter
Mark Hall, Submitter
Bruce Carter, Dysart Lane Area
Jenny Lawry, Pomona Road Group
Perry Blackmore, Submitter
Peter Sinton, Submitter
Graham McIntyre, Submitter
Bunty Condon, Submitter
Margaret Furtado, Submitter
Martin O’Brien, Submitter
Dave Chisholm, Submitter
Karen Baverstock, Planning
Rob Owen, Corporate
Malcolm Hunt, Noise
Frances Komoroske
Ian Graham
Bruce Spooner
46
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), David Hill, Jan Crawford
IHP Officers:
Phil Chung (Planner), Ann Marie Callaghan (Hearing Administrator)
Council
officers:
Tim Fischer (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal), Joy LaNauze (Planning), Cindy Yin
(Planning), Jacky Bartley (Planning), Vrinda Moghe (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
2011
Peter Jones
4930
Ray Wallace Limited
2196
Orepunga Farms Limited
3942
Cazadora Holdings Limited
2807
Ray Bosher and Bosher Family Trust
AMP Capital Investors NZ Ltd and
PSPIB Waiheke Inc
2575, FS 831
AMP Capital Property Portfolio
Limited et al (Succeeded by PSPIB
5883, FS 2708 Waiheke Incorporated)
1731, FS 3505 Fletcher Residential Limited
6930
Auckland Maritime Foundation
A M Finnigan and Ellis Gould Tinos
123
Trustee Limited
Capacity Modelling for Residential
5716
Auckland Council
839, FS 3338
Housing New Zealand
2240, FS 3209
5277, FS 3235
2936
5145
Frank and Juliet Reynolds
Urban Design Forum
Land Solutions Ltd
Auckland Developers Group
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Karyn Kurzeja, Planner
Robert Wallace, Corporate
Brianna Parkinson, Legal
Leo Hills, Traffic
Brett Chick, Engineer
Braedon Makgill, Landowner
Linda Norman, Wastewater/Stormwater
Daniel Nakhle, Corporate
Luke Hinchey, Legal
Bianca Tree, Legal
Susannah Tait, Planning
Daryl Hughes, Transport
Robert Philpott, Economic
David Cosgrove, Corporate
Ian Craig, Planning
David Hay, Planning
Peter Neeve, Planning
Heather Ash, Legal
Kyle Balderston
Dr Douglas Fairgray
David Hermans, MBIE
Tim Heath, Economics
Phil Osborne, Economics
Kelvin Norgrove, Economics
Jon Maplesden, Planning
47
TUESDAY, 5 APRIL 2016 – MANUKAU
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), David Hill, Stuart Shepherd
IHP Officers:
Matthew Gouge, Thomas Erikson
Council
officers:
Rob O’Connor (Legal), Diana Hartley (Legal), Anna Jennings (Planning), Sisira
Jayasinghe (Planning), Joy La Nauze (Planning), Danni Briggs (Planning), Roger
Eccles (Planning), Barry Mosley (Planning), Michael Luong (Planning), Craig
Cairncross (Planning), Trevor Watson (Planning), Dr Fiona Curran-Cournane (Land
and Soil Science)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
4218
7229
2690
2821
1139
Howick Ratepayers and Residents
Association Inc.
Cockle Bay Residents and
Ratepayers Association Incorporated
Diane D Maloney
Kenneth Manley and Jennifer Walker
Ronald H Lever
Plymouth Brethren Christian Church
1030
881, FS 2001
880
1606
MD Holdings Limited
Sandra L and Mavis J Hirstich
Mavis J Hirstich
Benjamin Ross
2705, FS 216
4500, FS 2598
6328
FS 236
Counties Power Limited
M and B Chhagan
Talwan Trustee Company Limited
1355
6120
Scott B Gavin
Auckland Gliding Club Incorporated
6826
Mark O'Kane and Family
1684
4341
FS 662
Balle Group of Companies and the
Burns Family Trust
Li Xie and Liu Ya Jun
Robert and Kathleen Thickpenny
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Gayleen Mackereth, Submitter
Laurie Slee, Chairperson
Graeme Lane, Committee member
Sally Peake, Urban Design
Mike Welsh, Submitter
Jill Hirstich
Christine Coste, Planning
Rachel Bilbe, Expert
Dan Madsen, Planning
Scott B Gavin
Judith Gavin
Russell Jones, Submitter
Helen Atkins, Legal
Sally Peake, Landscape Architect
Mark O’Kane, Submitter
John O’Kane, Submitter
Sir William Birch, Planning
Toby Mandeno, Planning
Dacey Balle, Corporate
David Lawrie, Planning
48
WEDNESDAY, 6 APRIL 2016 – MANUKAU
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Diana Hartley (Legal), Heather Ash (Legal), Craig Cairncross (Planning), Melean
Absolum (Landscape), Barry Mosley (Planning), Patrick Clearwater (Planning),
Shona Myers (Ecology)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
4022
FS 2892
5797
6434
6739
Dalkara GP Limited (Te Mahia Village
P L and R M Reidy and A J and P M
Kloeten and Ruatotara Limited
Horticulture New Zealand and
Pukekohe Vegetable Growers
Association
Birch Hill Trust
Landview Farms Limited
Fernando and Jill Sousa
6653
6885
9300, FS 465
Heather Ballantyne
Bridge City Properties Limited
Kieran Fitzsimmons
2412, FS 2993
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Roger Harlcay, Corporate
David Harclay, Submitter
Helen Atkins, Legal
Vance Hodgson, Planning
Bridget Gilbert, Landscape Architect
Fraser Walsh, Engineering Geologist
Graeme Lawrence, Planning
Grant Main, Submitter
Paul Sousa, Planning
Heather Ballantyne, Submitter
49
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Lisa Jack (Legal), Anna Jennings (Planning), Vanessa Evitt (Legal), Sukhdeep
Singh (Planning), Jym Clarke (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
5676
5679
Home Base Botany Ltd
Synergy Properties Sylvia Ltd
5716
4015
Auckland Council
Darley Investments Limited and
Carhart Investments Limited
5682, FS3191
Wiri Oil Services Limited
FS 2839
Liquigas Limited
4852 (from
topic 080)
Independent Maori Statutory Board
2461, FS 599
6488 (from
topic 080)
6493 (from
topic 080)
081 HEARING RECORD
Fletcher Concrete and Infrastructure
Limited
Nga Mana Whenua o Tamaki
Makaurau
Marutuahu Iwi
Represented by
Iain McManus, Planning
Vanessa Evitt, Legal
Sukhdeep Singh, Planning
Rob Enright, Legal
Ian Cummings, Operational overview
Jenny Polich, Risk Assessment
David le Marquand, Planning
Greg Akehurst, Economic
Ian Twomey, Economic
Georgina McPherson, Statutory
assessment
Andrew Curtis, Air Quality
Dave Goodwin, Engineering
Anneke Theelen, Legal
Albert de Geest, Corporate
Helen Hamilton, Planning
Damian Phillis, Risk
Paul F Majurey, Legal
Phil Mitchell, Planning
Karen Wilson, Cultural
Bill Loutit, Legal
Nicholas Hardy, Risk
Paul F Majurey, Legal
50
MONDAY, 11 APRIL 2016 – MANUKAU
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Andrew Green (Legal), Rob O’Connor (Legal), Rachel Davidson (Legal), Deborah
Riley (Legal), Todd Webb (Planning), Patrick Clearwater (Planning), Roger Eccles
(Planning), Vrinda Moghe (Planning), Jacqueline Bartley (Planning), Joy La Nauze
(Planning), Sisira Jayasinghe (Planning), Michael Luong (Planning), Stephen
Brown (Landscape), Evan Keating (Auckland Transport)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
3933
Acorn Parish Holdings
John and Adriana Self and Roger
Clark
Morgan Family Trust
Favona Road Landowners
Land Solutions Ltd
Kirkdale Investments Ltd
Alfriston Landowners Group and
Associated Parties
Eastern Alfriston Association
FS 496
3898
4001
2936
3511
2947
3069
3866 (from
topic 017)
1291
Self Trust (Gock Family Trust)
FP Williams and SR Williams Trust
Partnership
6386, FS 3321
6230
Te Akitai Waiohua Waka Taua Trust
The Department of Corrections
9442
Sewu Family Trust
4792
MLW Adams Family Trust
Board of Airline Representatives of
New Zealand Incorporated
Lai Yip and Huichan Pan
5128
2410
6589
6208
5551
6872
1350
3243
081 HEARING RECORD
Jonathan Polglase
Furu Ding (Eastfield Development Ltd)
Duckie Investment Company Limited
Murphys Development Limited
Singyip Estate Limited
Dong Global Investments Limited
Represented by
Alan Webb, Legal
Jon Maplesden, Planning
Gock Family Trust, Submitter
Dennis Scott, Landscape
Emma Bayley, Planning
Russell Gibb, Heritage
Karen Wilson and Nigel Denny, Corporate
Jo Bain, Legal
Ms Tan, Submitter
Julian Dawson, Legal
Mr Adams, Submitter
Kristina Cooper, Legal
Karl Cook, Planning
Jonathan Polglase, Submitter
51
4885, FS 1180
TONEA Properties (New Zealand)
Limited
4769, FS 1429
Wallace Group Limited
081 HEARING RECORD
Bryce Hall, Traffic
Tim Heath, Retail Economic
Mr Wallace, Corporate
52
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Greg Hill, David Hill, Jan Crawford (Session 2)
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Heather Ash (Legal), Barry Mosley (Planning), Daniel Newman (Watercare), Tracey
Oplencourt (Planning), Vrinda Moghe, (Planning), Todd Webb (Planning), Timothy
Segedin (Transport), Evan Kei (Auckland Transport), Matthew Allan (Legal),
Deborah Reily (Legal), Lisa Jack (Legal), Mr Newman (Watercare)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
5163
2240, FS 3209
1817, FS 2966
Kingseat Group
Frank and Juliet Reynolds
Linwood Acres Limited
5257, FS3435
5338, FS3132
3456, FS3170
6665
7421
Karaka Estate Limited and Kingseat
Farms Limited
New Zealand Bloodstock Limited
Clevedon Cares Incorporated
Hololio Farm
Clevedon Business Association
5925, FS 877
Karaka North Village Limited
4004
2367
2415
2551
5416
Karaka Village (1995) Limited et al
Stratford Properties Limited
Netherlea Holdings Limited
Roscommon Properties Limited
Trent and Katherine Archer
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
William Thresher, Landscape
Phil Comer, Planning
Daniel Nakhle, Corporate
Derek Nolan, Legal
Nicholas Rae, Urban Design
Carey Pearce, Planning
Mary Whitehouse
Josephine Elworthy
Bruce McKenzie, Landscape
Andreas de Graaf, Urban Design
Robert Wallace, Corporate
Anthony Bryce, Wastewater
Bryce Hall, Traffic
Nick Grala, Planning
Renee Fraser-Smith, Planning
Mike Smith, Infrastructure
Tim Grace, Planning
Bridget Gilbert, Landscape/visual
53
WEDNESDAY, 13 APRIL 2016 – HENDERSON
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Stuart Shepherd, David Hill and Jan Crawford
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Heather Ash (Legal), Ryan Bradley (Planning), Fiona Curran-Cournane (Land and
Soil Science), David Hookway (Planning), Jeremy Wilson (Legal), Raj Maharjan
(Planning), Robert Hillier (Geotechnical), Bridget Gilbert (Landscape), Douglas
Sadlier (Planning), Eryn Shields (Planning), Cara Francesco (Historic Heritage),
Lisa Jack (Legal) and Kimberley Edmonds (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
FS 2554
Mike Wood
4844
C Zambucka
9438
6512
6603
N E and E M Norton
Michael Coote
Patricks Bay Development
Pohutukawa Property Development
Company Limited
Kumeu Agricultural and Horticultural
Society
The Mill Industrial Park Limited
Juderon Family Trusts
Ron Law
Karen and Vince Godek
Malcolm Woolmore
Mike and Margie Dutton
Murray and Rachel Nelson
Ian P and Sandra W Harper
Neil Norton, Submitter
6522
2000
3260
5517
5680, FS 2221
5273, FS 3053
6351, FS 2101
5905, FS 2063
7297, FS 505
1329
5691, FS 2100
Anne and Jim Leyland
FS 2997
820, FS 802
FS 2223
2545
Anu and Astrid Ram
Suzanne W Kumar
Des and Chris Rankin
Waitakere Arts Cultural Development
Trust
6902, FS 1279
Corban Winery Estate Heritage
Preservation and Development Trust
3758, FS 3244
RJ and AE Richardson Trust
081 HEARING RECORD
Daniel Nakhle, Submitter
Ron Law, Submitter
Ron Law
Anne Leyland
Ron Law
Malcolm Woolmore
Anu Ram
Ron Law
Adon Kumar, Submitter
Robert Makgill, Legal
Assid Corban, Corporate
Dave Pearson, Heritage
Rose Evans, Museum Collections
Ian Constable, Traffic
Roy Richardson
54
THURSDAY, 14 APRIL 2016 – HENDERSON
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Heather Ash (Legal), Eryn Shields (Planning), Alison Pye (Planning), Diana Hartley
(Legal), Jarette Wickham (Planning), Greg Akehurst (Economics), Derek Foy
(Economics), Stuart Bracey (Auckland Transport), Sean Bignell (DPO Infrastructure
Funding), Daniel Newman (Watercare) and Lisa Jack (Legal)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
3035
Stride Holdings Ltd (formerly DNZ
Holdings Limited)
4778, FS 2660
I B and G A Midgley
5715
5788
4373
4740
5388
Auckland Council (Redhills)
Mr and Mrs S Nuich Trust
Westgate Partnership
Orchid Plant Trust
Peter Bolam, Orchid Plant Trust and
Plantarama
3320
7370, FS 2676
5259, FS 2733
Peter Bolam
New Sun Developers Limited
Hugh Green Limited
4373
6215, FS 1655
3429
Westgate Partnership
The Neil Group
Brigham Creek Business Park
New Zealand Limited (Hobsonville)
Progressive Enterprises Limited
Bianca Tree, Legal
Jarette Wickham, Planning
Greg Akehurst, Economics
Derek Foy, Economics
Ian Clark, Transport
Stuart Bracey, Auckland Transport
Sean Bignell, DPO Infrastructure Funding
Sue Simons, Legal
Henry Norcross, Corporate
Treffery Barnett, Environmental
Tony Lovelock, Infrastructure
Karen Joubert, Planning
Emma Bayly, Planning
Emma Bayly, Planning
Russell Baikie, Planning
Matthew Hickson, Transport
Giles Bramwell, Planning
Rebecca Eaton, Legal
2632, FS 2963
5723, FS 2039
081 HEARING RECORD
55
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), Stuart Shepherd, David Hill, Greg Hill (session 2 only)
IHP Officers:
Thomas Erikson and Dana Danilova
Council
officers:
Matthew Allan (Legal), Joy La Nauze (Planning), Diana Hartley (Legal), Ryan
Bradley (Planning), Evan Keating (Auckland Transport), Brenda Milo (Legal),
Vrinda Moghe (Planning), Todd Webb (Planning), Michael Luong (Planning), Craig
Cairncross (Planning) Cindy Yin (Planning), Tim Fischer (Legal), Jeremy Wyatt
(Planning), Natalie Hampson (Economics)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
877
Transpacific Industries Group (New
Zealand) Ltd (now known as Waste
Management NZ)
878, FS 2141
Waste Disposal Services
4419
4192
Auckland Planning Limited
Karaka Harbourside Estate Limited
(previously under H K Hattaway Ltd,
Conmara Farms)
3644, FS 2965
Karaka Harbourside Estate Limited
3700
5164
6619
5167
5170
1223, FS 1011
Takanini Properties Limited
The Maskell Trust
Evans Family Trust
W C and E J Dickens
Brookby Equestrian Park Limited
YLH Holdings Limited
5371
3396
Maraetai Land Development Limited
Orua View Company Limited
3091
Ormiston Centre Ltd (submission
formerly by Firmount Trust)
FS 1741
Lion-Beer, Spirits and Wine (NZ)
Limited
081 HEARING RECORD
Represented by
Jill Gregory, Legal
Ian Kennedy, Corporate
Ian Kennedy, Corporate
Sarah McCarter, Planning
Berry Simons, Legal
George Hollis, Property
Graham Power, Planning
Rodney Hutchison, Geotechnical
Hanani Aickin, Ecology
Rob Pryor, Landscape
Philip Comer, Planning
Melissa Davis, Landscape
Grant Brembner, Corporate
David Jamison, Submitter
Mike Yu, Planning
Sarah Tucker, Corporate
Mark Partridge, Corporate
56
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Matthew Gouge, Philippa Geere-Watson
Council
officers:
Tim Fischer (Legal), Matthew Allan (Legal), Rob O’Connor (Legal), Mr Newman
(Watercare), Evan Keating (Auckland Transport), Jon Rix (Stormwater), Joy La
Nauze (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
FS 2240
6342
7364
5097,4957
5542
9106
9107
5110
7582
5064, FS 2799
4745
Counties Racing Club Inc
T and K Whitton
John Farrell Nurseries Ltd and
Brendon Farrell Ltd
JPR Enterprises Ltd
Derek Sullivan and Wendy Dragt
Counties Storage Ltd
L and L Enterprises
Nicky Wijdeven
Anthony Wijdeven
Auckland University of Technology
Lewis J Dawson
2402
4051
5135
6401
2319
4012
500 Ti Rakau Limited
Tim Knight
Wanderers Mangere Bridge Limited
Hemant Kalyanji
Motleon Limited
Nakhle Investment Trust
4986
FS 988
FS 406
Takanini Central
Auton and Associates Limited
Coronation Gardens Limited
6629
Southern Heritage Limited
081 HEARING RECORD
Rowan Ashton, Legal
Derek Sullivan, Landowner
Dan Madsen, Water and Wastewater
Ida Dowling, Traffic
Craig Martell, Water
Mark McKearney, Submitter
Joseph Zou, Planning
Mahini Hallikeri, Planning
Leigh Auton, Submitter
Con Lu, Submitter
Gary Robertson, Submitter
57
Panel
Members:
IHP Officers:
Council
officers:
Heather Ash (Legal), Diana Hartley (Legal), Tim Fisher (Legal), Matthew Allan
(Legal), Cindy Yin (Planning), Todd Webb (Planning), Joy La Nauze (Planning),
Craig Cairncross (Planning), Stephen Brown (Landscape), Natalie Hampson
(Economics), James Fairgray (Economics), Evan Keating (Auckland Transport),
Jon Rix (Stormwater), Robert Hillier (Geotechnical)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
3099, FS1228 The Pakuranga Hunt
Mr Bennett, Corporate
3081
Fulton Bloodstock Limited
Kerry Fulton, Submitter
6523, FS2422 Federated Farmers of New Zealand
Richard Gardner, Planning
John Parlane, Traffic
Karaka Centre Limited and Karaka
Mark Tansley, Retail
1819, FS3210 Lakes Limited
Phil Comer, Planning
Karaka Centre Limited and Karaka Lakes Limited (Douglas Allan) cross-examined Natalie Hampson
from Auckland Council
Phil Heffernan, Planning
Matthew Prasad, Urban Design
James Whitlock, Acoustics/Noise
Fraser Colgrave, Economics
3809, FS1965 Pukekohe South Residents Group
Michael Nixon, Transportation
081 HEARING RECORD
58
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), David Hill, Stuart Shepherd, Jan Crawford (session 3
only)
IHP Officers:
Sarah El Karamany, Thomas Erikson
Council
officers:
Rachel Davidson (Legal), Lisa Jack (Legal), Rob O'Connor (Legal), Matthew Allan
(Legal), Rachel Ward (Legal), Anna Jennings (Planning), Craig Cairncross
(Planning), Marie Stainwright (Planning), Todd Webb (Planning), Roger Eccles
(Planning), Sukhdeep Singh (Planning), Danni Briggs (Planning)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
2405, FS1676
Broadway Property Group
FS1005
NCB 2000 Limited
2958
5253, FS3297
5462
3940
FS 3922
5814
Camperdown Holdings Limited
Wesley College Trust Board and
Grafton Downs Limited
The Warehouse Limited
Kiwi Income Property Trust and Kiwi
Property Holdings Limited (now
known as Kiwi Property Group Ltd)
Manukau Golf Club Incorporated
Bianconi Investments Limited
Gail Selby-Brown
Te Kawerau Iwi Tribal Authority
Scott Kennedy, Corporate
Leo Hills, Traffic
Mr Meurr, Submitter
4877
Ghanshyam Trust
4767
2748, FS2878
081 HEARING RECORD
Sue Simons, Legal
Philip Comer, Planning
Maurice Kiely, Architecture
Ranjna Patel, Submitter
Dr Kanti Patel, Submitter
Bryce Hall, Traffic
59
Panel
Members:
John Kirikiri (Chairperson), David Hill, Stuart Shepherd, Janet Crawford (1st
session), Judge Kirkpatrick (1st session)
IHP Officers:
Kylie Gemmell, Thomas Erikson
Council
officers:
Rachel Davidson (Legal), Tim Fisher (Legal), Matthew Allan (Legal), Roger Eccles
(Planning), Chloe Trenouth (Planning), David Wong (Planning), Nicholas Lau
(Planning), Michael Luong (Planning), Peter Reaburn (Planning), Todd Webb
(Planning), Joy La Nauze (Planning), West Fynn, (Arborist), Terry Church
(Auckland Transport), Evan Keating (Auckland Transport)
Sub. No.
Submitter Name
Represented by
839, FS3338
4845, FS1703
Housing New Zealand Corporation
Southern Gateway Consortium
Tunicin Investments Limited and
Airface Limited
James Kirkpatrick Group Limited
Landplan Property Partners Manukau
Limited and Reading Properties
Partners Limited
Southern Gateway Consortium:
Marija Batistich, Legal
Ian Boothroyd, Ecology
Geoff Webster, Surveying
Rod Cough, Heritage
4813
1889-9, 10
4938
FS 2834
6386
7318
Auckland International Airport Limited
Te Akitai Waiohua Waka Taua Trust
110 Formosa (NZ) Limited (successor
to Baoland Holdings Limited and Hui
Feng Holdings Limited)
6235
Hui Feng Holdings Limited
868
FS1250
New Zealand Steel Limited
Auckland Chamber of Commerce
081 HEARING RECORD
Auckland International Airport Limited:
Judith Makinson, Transport
Greg Osborne, Planning
Kelly Rowland, Corporate
Catherine Reaburn , Planning
Shane Lander, Geotechnical
Will Thresher, Urban Design
Chris Shortt, Civil Engineer
Daryl Hughes, Traffic Engineer
Catherine Sommerville, Legal
Nevil Hegley, Noise
Andrea Rickard, Planning
Claire Jewell, Corporate
Tony Garnier
60
SUBMITTERS TABLING EVIDENCE
Sub. No.
Submitters Name
1705
Southgate Centre Limited and Retail Holdings Limited (now known as Southgate
Centre Limited and UP Management Limited)
WDP Investments Limited
Leanne M C Nixon et al
Victoria E Bethell
Wayne Lees
Z Energy Limited
Ormiston Joint Venture Limited
Portage and Waitakere Licensing Trusts and West Auckland Trust Services Limited
The Levene Trust
Jason and Sally Galea
New Zealand Refining Company Limited
Lily Investment 227 Limited and Lily Investment Company Limited
Radio New Zealand Limited
McDonalds Restaurants (NZ) Limited
The Strand Trust
K Vernon
The Salvation Army
Square and Main Street Limited
Tony Keenan
Belmont Hauraki Community Association
Micheal Chong
Micheal Chong
Helen Chong
Tyler-Davies Group Ltd
Vicki Huntley
Remuera Community Committee Incorporated (Remuera Residents Association)
National Asset Group
Babich Wines Limited
Marie Dyhrberg
Portland Family Trust
Neil Construction Limited
Masons TCLM Limited
David and Ailsa Bunker
Judith M Fry
Charles G Laws
Carl Stougie
Friars Minor of New Zealand Trust Board
Fluker Surveying Limited
Geoff Bennett
Tram Lease Limited and Viaduct Harbour Holdings Limited and Viaduct Harbour
Management Limited
Albany Investment and Development Limited
Anna Atkinson
FS2021
FS1767
4971
6988
2567
3963
3676
4841
2407
4734
5537
2750, FS3525
4857, FS2925
4307, FS3051
FS 347
7398
5240
FS3373
849, FS3372
1365
249
76
5559
FS1302
2932
6548
6206
6828
835
5346
3194
962
274
338
3465
4899
5854
2791
5566, FS3168
6838
7993 FS1524
081 HEARING RECORD
61
1680
6258
FS 3236
6670
081 HEARING RECORD
Anita T Arlov
Martin J Jones
Westhaven Marina Users Association Inc
Denise and Allen Tonkin
62

Hearing Record - Auckland Council

Transcription

Similar documents

No. 5 - Thursday, 28 January 2016

here