Superior Sugar Refining with ISEP® Technology

Superior Sugar Refining with ISEP® Technology
1
SUGAR REFINING PROCESS
BULK RAW SUGAR
AFFINATION
MELT
CLARIFICATION
Decolorization of Raw Sugar
Sugar cane is the primary feedstock for the world’s sugar supply, but sugar cane must be harvested, milled
and refined to produce sugar. Refining is a multi-step process and decolorization is one of the important unit
operations in the production of liquid and crystalline sugar. Sugar colorants can come from natural components
in the cane plant or be developed during processing. Typically, colorants are non-polar, anionic in nature and
span a wide range of molecular weights. Some examples of sugar colorants include polyphenols, melanoidins
and products from hexose degradation. With increasing consumer and market demands for higher quality sugar,
refineries must adopt cost-effective means to remove color bodies from cane sugar.
Decolorization of raw sugar for the production of high-grade sugar products is typically performed with
the assistance of a range of media such as bone char, activated carbon and ion exchange resins. There
are a number of factors that influence a refinery’s decision to adopt a certain technology or combination of
technologies, and, in many cases, ion exchange resins offer the lowest capital and operating costs for both
large and small applications.
Calgon Carbon Corporation (CCC) is a world leader in offering ion exchange technology for sugar decolorization
and deashing. CCC has supplied commercial plants for these processes using IonSEParator (ISEP®) technology
for over 20 years. Our continuous ISEP® technology is reliable, versatile and cost-effective, compared to
alternative technologies and fixed bed systems.
FILTRATION
Benefits of Using ISEP® Continuous Ion
Exchange Resin Technology for Decolorization
Improvements in the efficiency of macroporous strong base anion (SBA)
resins, along with lower capital and operating costs, have increased the
acceptance of ion exchange technology for secondary decolorization in
many refineries. A single SBA resin, or a combination of acrylic and/or
styrenic resins, provides broad and effective color removal, and Calgon
Carbon’s continuous ISEP® system is the most flexible and efficient option
for applying these resin technologies for decolorization.
Calgon Carbon’s ISEP® system easily lends itself to a variety of resin
combinations, process configurations, construction materials and layout
choices. The ISEP® system has proven to use up to 50% less water than
competitive fixed bed systems, while at the same time using up to 50%
less resin. In addition, chemicals consumed and waste volumes generated
during the resin bed regeneration are dramatically reduced due to the
counter-current, multi-pass nature of the continuous system.
DECOLORIZATION
AND DEASHING
EVAPORATION
CRYSTALLIZATION
SEPARATION
Calgon Carbon has installed more than 650 continuous
ISEP® installations in more than 40 applications since 1990.
2
3
Typical Decolorization ISEP® Process Flow Diagram
DECOLORIZED
PRODUCT
SWEETEN-OFF
SWEETEN-ON
EFFLUENT
REGEN
RINSE
Ion Exchange Decolorization with Brine Recovery
BACKWASH
EFFLUENT
REGENERANT
There are many advantages to selecting an ion exchange system over other technologies for cane sugar
decolorization. However, one of the few challenges related to an ion exchange system is the waste from the resin
regeneration process. When an ion exchange resin is exhausted with colorants, the resin must be regenerated
for re-use. Regeneration is accomplished by passing a caustic brine solution through the resin, resulting in a
concentrated brine effluent. Historically, the brine effluent would be disposed of as waste and a new brine solution
would be prepared for each regeneration cycle. However, new technology has made it economically feasible to
recycle the brine effluent.
Calgon Carbon’s continuous ISEP® technology produces significantly less waste brine effluent than fixed bed
systems. While the ISEP® process will still generate some waste brine effluent, refineries can reduce salt usage
and waste volume by up to 90% by utilizing the appropriate brine recovery system.
BACKWASH
SWEETEN-ON
SWEET WATER
ISEP FEED
The core of every ISEP® system is a rotary distributor
that continuously directs the feed, wash, regeneration
and rinse streams through the media cells. This
configuration ensures that all media is in active duty
and the process is advanced through each operation
one step at a time, with a step time proportional to the
color removal load required.
ISEP® Continuous
Ion Exchange Advantages
Syrup Deashing Options in an ISEP®
• Reduced operating costs
Less media
Less water
Fewer chemicals
Less waste
A recent focus of the sugar industry has been low invert liquid
sugar, and the ISEP® system is ideal for this application. An
ISEP® deashing system offers the process advantage necessary
to prevent invert formation and additional color degradation
often generated in traditional fixed bed technologies, while also
eliminating the potential need for a mixed bed ion exchange resin
system with its complicated and difficult regeneration process.
ISEP® systems have been used for decades in syrup deashing
services from corn to beet to cane operations. The ISEP® rotary
distributor technology has stood the test of time and has proven
to improve efficiencies and reduce cost. The flexibility of an ISEP®
system allows for optimization for both high and low ash and
color loads by simply adjusting the valve rotation speed.
4
REGEN
EFFLUENT
• Improved efficiency
Counter current contact
Counter flow regeneration
High ionic/color loading
Nanofiltration systems are being used commercially to recycle the brine effluent produced during the regeneration
process. The utilization of nanofiltration is proven to reduce both salt and water consumption. Studies have
shown that the use of a brine recovery system reduces the operational costs of an ion exchange decolorization
system by over 50% and makes the process more environmentally friendly. By combining the use of continuous
ion exchange with nanofiltration membranes for brine recovery, cane sugar refineries can significantly reduce the
already favorable operational costs of continuous ion exchange.
ISEP® SYSTEM
DECOLORIZED
PRODUCT
FINE LIQUOR FEED
• Reduced media inventory
No dormant media
• Steady-state operation
Consistent product and effluent quality
Concentrated products and effluents
• Reduced manpower — typically
less than one operator per shift
BRINE
RECOVERY
PROCESS
RECYCLE BRINE
BRINE RECOVERY
SYSTEM
• Reduced space requirements
• Chemical regeneration — a major cost
reduction compared to thermal regeneration
70% TO 90% WASTE REDUCTION
5
Operational Cost Comparison for Two Typical Decolorization Systems
Basis: 800 TPD Raw Sugar Plant with 600–800 ICUMSA Feed Color and Brine Recovery
Back-End Refinery
Stand-Alone Refinery
Refined Sugar
Using Fixed Bed
IX Technology
Refined Sugar
Using Calgon Carbon’s
ISEP® Technology
Refined Sugar
Using Fixed Bed
IX Technology
Refined Sugar
Using Calgon Carbon’s
ISEP® Technology
Average Operating
Time Per Year
210 days
210 days
365 days
365 days
Life of Resin Used
in the Process
4 years
4 years
2.3 years
2.3 years
Resin Required
55 cubic meters
18 cubic meters
55 cubic meters
18 cubic meters
Amortized Costs
of Resins/Media
$80,000 USD
$26,000 USD
$139,000 USD
$46,000 USD
Cost of Sweetwater
Evaporation, Rinse Water,
Waste Water
$171,000 USD
$66,000 USD
$297,000 USD
$116,000 USD
Cost of Other
Acids/Chemicals
$106,000 USD
$54,000 USD
$185,000 USD
$94,000 USD
Other Operational Costs
$67,000 USD
$50,000 USD
$116,000 USD
$87,000 USD
Total Costs
$424,000 USD
$196,000 USD
$737,000 USD
$343,000 USD
Annual Sugar Production
168,000 MT
168,000 MT
292,000 MT
292,000 MT
PER METRIC TON COST
$2.52
$1.17
$2.52
$1.17
Ion Exchange in Combination with Activated Carbon
Many sugar refineries are using a combination of ion exchange resins and granular
activated carbon to meet their treatment objectives and overall product quality.
In these applications, the granular activated carbon will perform the primary (gross)
decolorization of the feed, and the feed will then be polished using an ion exchange
resin. In addition to improving product quality, this combination results in longer
service cycles for the activated carbon and ion exchange resin.
Activated carbon removes color by physically adsorbing color molecules as a result
of intermolecular attractions or forces inherent to the carbon surface. The surface
forces create a stronger attraction between the carbon surface and the color
molecule than between the color molecules and the sugar liquor. Activated carbon
is not specific for any type of color, but performs good overall gross color removal.
Further, the massive effective surface area of activatedcarbon allows for a large
quantity of color to be removed without exhausting the adsorbent.
As a global leader in activated carbon and ion exchange systems, Calgon Carbon
is uniquely positioned to provide the best solution for achieving the treatment
objectives of sugar refineries.
54% Lower Operating Cost Using an ISEP®
Calgon Carbon is the preferred solutions provider
for state-of the-art continuous ion exchange systems.
6
7
Calgon Carbon’s Rotary Valve Distributor Technology
Calgon Carbon’s Advanced Rotary Valve Distributor ISEP®–IOVSB
At the heart of every ISEP® system is a single, multi-port,
rotating distributor valve that directs all incoming and
outgoing streams with the most flexibility and efficiency
of any system available. The advanced valve technology
indexes at a specific rate using a minimum of moving parts,
thereby increasing reliability and system up-time. The multiport distributor is configurable for any number of processes
from ion exchange, chromatography, adsorption to even
media cycle testing. In essence, the rotary valve technology
is an elegant continuous media contactor. The flexibility
goes even further because the valves can be configured
for either moving bed (ISEP® technology) or simulated
moving bed technology (ISEP®-IOVSB technology).
In the traditional ISEP® technology, the cells are mounted on
a turntable powered by the valve or by a separate dedicated
drive, while, in the ISEP®-IOVSB technology, the cells are
mounted directly on the floor and the rotation is simulated.
The choice of ISEP® rotary valve configuration
for a particular application is determined by:
• Process design
• Flow rate
• Spacial considerations
The extreme flexibility afforded by the rotary valve allows
for use of any design of cell from a higher aspect ratio to
a lower aspect ratio cell for shallow bed technology. The
use of shallow beds with good distribution further results in
maximum media utilization and reduced pressure. In every
ISEP® system, the media is constantly in use, with none
of the media in an idle state, and this high resin utilization
results in a much lower media inventory than compared to
conventional ion exchange systems. Counter-current and
counter-flow regeneration and rinse steps, along with low
media volume, combine to reduce the amount of chemicals
and effluent required to regenerate and clean the media.
• Overall benefit to customer
• Economics
ISEP®
The ISEP®-IOVSB configuration of the rotary distributor is
the latest offering by CCC, and precludes the need for a
turntable while still maintaining the advantages of Calgon
Carbon’s ISEP® continuous ion exchange technology. When
developing a new rotary valve, it was essential that Calgon
Carbon maintain the design parameters that have made the
ISEP® such a success over the last 25 years. This objective
meant preserving the symmetry, simplicity and flexibility
inherent in the ISEP® system while offering a rotary valve
that allowed for stationary beds. In addition to the stationary
bed component of the design, the IOVSB valve also allows
many variations in layout that can better fit within the
refineries’ space constraints. Along with improved layout,
the IOVSB version can improve access and reduce overall
installation cost and maintenance.
By maintaining flow symmetry throughout the ISEP®-IOVSB
valve design, all process connections sequentially index
through the stationary cells with no loss of flexibility. All
potential process configurations such as up-flow, downflow, series or parallel flow are determined by exterior piping
to the valve and not the valve proper. This allows one valve
design to be used for any number of applications and
installations with minimal spare parts. The ISEP®-IOVSB
is also extremely beneficial in applications with variable
conditions resulting in flow configuration changes, a feature
not available in competing rotary valves of limited flexibility.
Valve symmetry also results in reduction of liquid sealing
surfaces. The ISEP®-IOVSB valve has only two simple
planar surfaces compared to complicated competing rotary
valves of annular faces with multiple O-ring seals.
All the parameters of Calgon Carbon’s ISEP® valve
were maintained in the ISEP®-IOVSB rotary valve:
• Truly continuous process flow
• More flexible equipment layout
• Use of traditional stationary columns
• Reduced maintenance
• Reduction in spare parts inventory
ISEP®-IOVSB
Valve Drive
Top
of Cells
Process Stream
Outlets
Process Stream
Inlets
To the Cells
Stationary Head
and Ports
Rotating Head
and Ports
Process
Streams
Bottom
of Cells
From the Cells
8
9
About Calgon Carbon
Calgon Carbon’s Processing Solutions
Calgon Carbon Corporation is an industry leader through unmatched innovations in the purification, separation, and
concentration of liquids and gases. Throughout our history, Calgon Carbon has been a pioneer in creating new products,
systems and services from the infancy stages to global commercialization. As the industry forerunner in activated carbon,
ultraviolet light disinfection/oxidation and ion exchange technology, Calgon Carbon provides cutting-edge purification
solutions in more than 700 distinct market applications, from purifying sweeteners and pharmaceuticals, air and water,
to separating gases and removing mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants.
Calgon Carbon offers superior processing options using not only regenerable and non-regenerable ion exchange
and adsorbent resins, but also silica gels, activated carbon and molecular sieves based on the unique application.
Since 1990, manufacturers and industries have discovered the exceptional value of Calgon Carbon’s continuous ISEP®
equipment technology for separating, purifying and synthesizing materials. With more than 450 installations in more
than 40 applications, ISEP® continues to prove that it is capable of solving complex problems economically.
N
TIO
IZA ar
R
LO Sug ers
CO
DE Cane eeten or
w
qu ids
c
er S y Li
Oth ewer ctic A
Br & La er
ic Wat
Citr
Each year, hundreds of municipalities, government agencies,
and food, biotech, chemical and pharmaceutical manufacturers
turn to Calgon Carbon to solve their purification challenges.
Technical experts are available to help choose the most costeffective methods to apply its technologies in air, water, process
purification, food and beverage production, site remediation
and marine water treatment. Its goal is to help customers reduce
the time and expense associated with maintaining purification
systems. Protecting the environment is a vital responsibility. The
quality of our lives depends on the purity of the air we breathe,
the water we drink, and the food we eat. Calgon Carbon is
dedicated to providing solutions to address environmental needs.
MINING &
CHEMICALS
Copper
Nickel
Uranium
KNO3 from KCI
DE
AS
Oth Cane HING
Su
er
Pro Brew Swee gar
pan ery ten
e&
Liq ers
Citr Buta uor
ic A ne
cid Diol
s
Calgon Carbon
Ion Exchange
Technologies
DE
CA
TI
2-K ONIZA
Vita LG- TIO
N
Suc min C Na
Oth cinic -Na
e
A
Aci r Orga cid
d S nic
alts
CHROMATOGRAPHY
Pharmaceutical
Amino Acids
Sweeteners
Isomer Separation
S
CID
A
INO e
AM Lysin han
p e
pto
Try reonin e
Th rnitin e
Ca ucin
le
Iso
Pure Water. Clean Air. Better World.
10
11
Calgon Carbon Corporation
Ion Exchange Technologies
3000 GSK Drive
Moon Township, PA 15108
USA
Phone: 1-800-422-6700
Email: [email protected]
www.calgoncarbon.com
© 2014 Calgon Carbon Corporation. All rights reserved.
12