,n!4Ll oqeBrAHa, oH ffBrf,erct 6to4xeroo6paayoqxM, QopMlpyer

B duccepmo\uoHHbtd coeem
505.0O1.08 Ha 6Be
Qu Ho H co60eo yH ueepcume ma
A
oT3blB
obuu,u dn bHozo on noHeH ma Ho
d
ucce p md
qun
l43omoeoi orlbzu 14zopeeHu Ho meMy <nepcneKmueu pebopMupoaaHua Hqnozo Hq
doxodut Qusutecxux nuq KdK uHcmpyMeHmo cotluonhHoi nonumuxu zocydopcmeo,,
npedcmaeneuuyn no coucKaHue yqeHofi cmeneuu xaududama SKoHoMuqeckux HayK
no cneuuo/I'Hocmu 08.00.10 - OuHaHcbL deH KHoe oqpdu,euue u xpedum
B Hacroflqee BpeMt oucKanbHan 3Ha'{xMocrb Ha.nora Ha AoxoAbl Qx3xqecxLlx
,n!4Ll oqeBrAHa, oH ffBrf,erct 6to4xeroo6paayoqxM, QopMlpyer ocHoBHyro Aonlo
AoxoAoB perxoHanbHbrx h MecrHbtx 6togxeroe. BMecre c reM, coqxanbHoe 3HaqeHre
AaHHoro Ha,Iota pea.nx3yercfl He B norHoi Mepe np AocraroqHo BblcoKoM
noreHqrane B AaHHoi o6nacrx. HAO.fl - oAxH ,!3 ocHoBHblx HaroroB, Koropbli
no3Bonfler I MaKc[MarbHoi creneHu pea.nl43oBarb ocHoBHble np!'lHqt4nbl
naao
roo6loxen un: cnpaaeAnreocrb
x
paBHoMepHocrb pacnpeAeneHxt HaroloEoi
Harpy3Kn.
B
n
Pocc|ar,1 BBeAeHa
B 2001 ro4y r AeicrByer flo
Hacrof,qee
BpeMa
ponopq[oHan bHaa uxaaa gaaoroo6/loxeHha AoxoAoB ox3x']ecxt4x n!44 np|4 3ToM,
Bonpoc ee exottot$ta.recxoi t4 coquanbHoi aS$exrranocrn no
cei
AeHb ocraerca
A14CKyCCl..rOHHbrM.
flpoexrst peSopnarpoBaHxa pocctticxoro noAoxoAHoro xaloroo6loxexun,
6a3[pyto[lLrec8 Ha nepexoAe x nporpecchBHot uKare HanoroBblx craaoK,
npeAnaranucb HeoAHoKpaTHo, oAHaKo, He Haunu noAAepxKl4 Ha 3axoHoAaTerbHoM
vpoBHe BBIAy roro, t{To fBnfinrcb t{pe3MepHo KapA[HanbHblMl4 A/ln cBoelo BpeMeH X
He B no.nHoi Mepe yqhrblBarl4 pn4 Qaxropoe, npl4cylllhx coBpeMeHHoi 3KoHoMrKe
r
coqua,nsuoi c$epe.
OAHoBpeMeHHo B orAe/tbHbtx HaygHblx 14ccreAoBaHl4tx HepeAKo nph3HaBanacb
3ddexrxBHocrb nporpeccxBHofi uKa/tbt HanoroBblx craEox
c roqKh 3peHt4fl
coq anbHoi cnpaBeAnxBocrx. TeMa xccreAoBaH[n npNo6peraer oco6oe
enaveHNe,
KolAa Macura6bt AxooepeHl{uaqxh poccl4icKoro o6u{ecrBa no pa3MepaM
AoxoAoB,
cooTHoLJeHIe Eerxqr4H AoxoAoB Ha 6Onee u HaxMeHee o6ecneqeHHbtx rpaxAaH,cHo
c8xAeTenbcTBytoT
$r:uvecxlx nrq
B
o
Heo6xoAt4MocTl4 npeo6pa3oBaHxf, Ha,4OToo6.noxeHhs AoxoAoB
c qenbn ero
aAanraqrt
K pe[JeH14to cot-ll4anbHbtx
roM .l4c.ne nyreM peanta3aqxr nphH4lnoe
KpoMe
coqranuloi cnpaBAe,uBocl4,
roro, rpe6yer ociusrcreHrfl ,t
MexaHx3M Ha.noroBbtx Bbt'{eroB
qacrr
4ocrtxetun 6olttr-rei cotlraluxoi
Ha
coBepuJeHcrBoBaHr,
pa3MepoB
npa
3aAaq rocyAapcrBa,
B/t
tt c$epst
4eicraynqrfi
npraaeteHxF
c
qenb|o
eHHocrl4.
Taxrm o6palom, B Hacroflqee BpeMn xMeercr xeo6xo4raaocru pa3pa6orxx
npoeKTa KoMnrexcxoi peQopmu HAO,n, BMtoqarcqero e ce6n xcnonb3oBaHre Bcex
3,[eMeHToB AaHHoro Ha,nora
B
npoqecce peanr3aqxt cor.lraruxoi norty.ft4(u
rocyAapcrBa, yqxrbtBa|oqero 6loAXerHbte,
nepexoAa
K
coqranbHbte
nporpeccuBHot ruxaae naloroo6noxeH
3KoHoM,4recHhe prcxr4
n or3xqec(vix AA\ A
nocle4creti nepexoAHoro nepxoAa. HecMorpF Ha
Hanrque HayqHo-xcc/leAoBaretbct{trx pa60r no 4anxoi TeMarhke, npo6reMa
Heo6xoAt4Mocrb Mt HytMV3aL\uu
nphMeHeHxfi HAO,o KaK Ha,noroBot-o xHcrpyMeHTa peueHxr col{'lanbHblx 3aAa,.] Bce
xe Aa.neka oT peuleHht, B ToM '-tl4cne h3-3a HeAocTaToLlHocTx ypo8Hn KoMnreKcHocTrl
rccneaoBaH,|i.
BbluJecKa3aHHoe onpeAenrer aKrya.nbHocrb
hcc.neaoBaH
eur6parrofi Vl'3oro}oi O.h.
TeMbl
t,
AocroBepHocrb
r
o6ocxoeaHHocrb HayqHbtx
noloxexli
Axccepraqxx
l4soroaofr O.h, 6a:rpyercr Ha ulxpoxoM aHa,fll43e [cc/leAoBaxNi sapv6exHurx N
oreqecrBeHHbtx yqeHbtx B o6,nacrr taloroo6roxeH[t AoxoAoB
$nzutecxux nnq;
ararrae :apy6exHoro onb|Ta ta,noroo6loxetrn 4oxogoa $rauvecKIx nrq B
pa3BxTblx crpaHax; cxcTeMaTu3a\uu rl o6o6qetur pe3ynbTaToB l4ccreAoBaHffi
o$uqraauuutx crar cl4qecxrx AaHHbtx. l'lpeAnoxeHhff aBTopa 6a:upyorcr la
KoppeKrHbtx AaHHbtx o cTpyRrype x AhHaMl,lKe AOXOAOB HacereHrg, noKa3aretrx
ypoBHfl xt43HX
14
Apyrux MaKpo3KoHoMIqecxhx noxa3aTe/lnx, Ha aBTopcxoM nporHo3e
HAO,ri B 6o4xerur 6rogxernoi ct4creMbt Ha nep[oA Ao 2OI7 rcAa.
nocryn,neHxi or
3KoHoM qecKan qenecoo6pa3Hocrb colyarbHaff onpaBAaHHocrb npeAroxeHui
aETOpa noATBepxAeHbt (oppexTHbtMx pac,JeTaM Be.nhqIH I3MeHeHUn
AOXOAOB
6rc4xeroe, saaorogoi Harpy3Kx. BbtBoAbt t4 pexoMeHAa4l,lt4, coAepxaqxecff
pa6oTe, apryMeHTr{poBaHbt
B
Aocraro'1toi cTenexn.
B
OcHoBHbre BbrEoAbr 14 peKoMeHAaqt,ltl, coAepxaq
HOBh3Hbt, 14Meloq|4e
e
3rleMeHTbl HayqHot
reopeTXqecxoe x npaKTrLlecxoe 3Ha9eHre, cEF3aHbl c peuJeHreM
creAylor4xx 3aAaq:
1.
Pa3pa6oraHa cvcreMa Meponp,4rrufi no pe$opMl4poBaHtlo noAoxoAHoro
naroroo6loxexun Oh3h,recK!4x nvi\ B Pocctt4, ocHoslloi cocraennoqei xoropoi
flB,naercfl nepexoA K nporpeccleuoit uJKa,ne HarotoBblx craBo{ |C,76-77,84-87].l,
2.
HayqHo o6ocHoBaHbt Kpxrepxrl onpeAeneHfiff pa3MepoB AoxoAoB
Hanoron/taTelbu.ll4KoB B qenfx nptiMeHeHxa HaroloBblx craBoK no nporpeccrlBHoi
uKa.ne c yqeroM Heo6xo4utuocrl peujeHxf coq a,nbHoi 3aAa'ltl cHxxeHht ypoBHn
4r,rQQeperqrar4rra o6qecrea no ypoBHflM AoxoAoB (C. 37,93-95);
3.
npeA.noxeHbt KoHKperHble Ben qrHbl Ha,floroBblx cra8ox nporpecc[BHoi
uKarbr, Koropbre 6y4yr cnoco6creoBarb noBbltlteHhto OhcKanbHoro noreHqrara
HAO,n np|4 oAHoBpeMeHHoM cHuxeHu14 |laaorogoi Harpy3Kx B orHoueHrlx ocHoBHot
Maccbl Ha,noronrareruulr.rxoe (c. 23, 36, 93-941;
4.
AoKa3aHa neo6xo4tttuocru xcnorb3oBaHxt g xaaoroo6,noxexr|4 AoxoAoB
$r:rvecxrx nxq Heo6naraeMoro MhHt4MyMa, pacc'luraHHoro c yqeroM
AaHHblx o
AltHaMxKe h pa3Mepax npoxxroeHol'o MxHxMyMa (C.23,93);
5.
npeAnoxeH noaranxuti noAxoA K pea/lx3aqxx npeAnoxeHli aBropa
B
qacrr nepexoAa Ha nporpecc[BHyto uKany Ha,noroBblx craBox, BMloqapull4i 4 3Tana,
c o6octogaxveaa xx noc.neAoBare/lbHocrx, pe3ynbrarhBHocrl,l, coqxa/lbHoro h
3KoHoMr4qecKoro aQ$exra xaxAoro |a3 3TanoB (C.96-99);
6,
ycraHoBleHbt Bo3MoxHbte pacy.t4, cBn3aHHble
npe4roxenri
c pear 3aqxei
aBropa no nepexoAy K nporpecc BHoMy na,noroo6roxeuurc 4oxo4oe
0x3ta,]ecKxx ,rl14q?
a raK]{e
o6ocnogaxst
nyrr
YX MhHxMl'13aLlru, noBbluJatol4xe
nonox renbHbri 3o$exr pe$opmrpoeaH n (C.45,50,65, 100)
nphBeAeHHbre BbtLl'le no3!1|-lxrl xapaxrep
3ytor
ocHoBHble orrl4'll4n
O.h. or paHee npoBeAeHHblx u P'BnAnlcc' KoHKperHblM
np14paqeHveM nayvxutx snatni a rccle4yemoi o6,nacrr.
ArccepraLlfioHHar pa6ora l43oroBoi O.14. xapaKTepy3yerce Ha,luq[eM
BHVTpeHHei toru(A t4 eAhHcrBa. Crpyxrypa pa6orut lorrvecxlt nocneAoBare'nbHa,
vccteAoBaHAA ly'3oroBofr
orrerbHbre acnexTbr lccne4yemoft npo6remaruxr pacxpblBatorcff
aBTopoM
cBoeBpeMeHHo. CTorr orMerxrb rpaMorHocrb l43no)+(eH]44 MarepIa/la. npriseAeHHble
e pa6ore BbrBoAbr s 4ocrarovlofi creneHr npoxnrrccrprlpoBaHbl ra6av'\ann,
rpaQxxaMx, At,tarpaMMaMh. [lprmenneaauri aeropom na6op MeroAoB 14ccreAoaaHrff
(ruero4 aralu:a, cuHTe3a, cpaBHeHtn ra o6o6qextn, rpynrtupoBKt4, MeroA
xaaccrQrxarlti), a raKx<e c[creMHuri no4xo4 x npoBeAeH[]o t4ccneaoBaHu,
o6ecneqnru qe,flocrHocrb pa6orur
r
Aocro8epHocrb c$opanrpoaanuux BbtBoAoB, B
nonHofi Mepe peuJtrb nocraB,neHHbte B Axccepraqrouuoi pa6ore 3aAaq{ r Aocr qb
pe3ynbraroB, coorBercreyrcqux cQopnay,nrpoaannoi aaropoM qenr xccneAoBaHrs.
ABTopeoepar ,4 ony6nxKoBaHHbte aBropoM HayqHbte
crarb[ E flonHoe
Mepe
orpaxaor ocHoBHoe coAepxaH!{e A ccepraqlottoi pa6orur,
OcHoBHbte Hay'lHbte pe3yrbrarbt xcc,fleAoaaH|,4t, 143,[oxeHHbte aBTopoM
I
,qrccepraqroxnoi pa6ore, ony6ruxoBaHbt B r43AaHxrx, peKoMeHAoBaHHbtx BAK
MhHo6pHayK, Pocc\vt. B npoqecce nory,leHls HayqHbtx pe3ynbraroB pa3pa6oroK
ly'3oroBoi
O,14. coaBTopbt He
npfiBnexa.nrcb. B cny,{ae 3alMcrBogaxri
Te(cTe AxccepTaql aBTOpOM AaHbt KOppeKTHbte ccbmKl.1 Ha
^
arep aroe
e
COOTBeTCTBVIOIUhe
,tcToqHr,tKh.
B
ArccepraLlrloHHofi pa6ore tl3oroBoi O,14. raK}Ke coAepxurcfl psA
AhcKycchoHHbrx
noroxeHrt,
B orAenbHbtx cayvanx
rpe6yoqux 6oaee ymv6aextoro
aHa,[ 34:
-
aBTopoM BAocraro'.tHoi creneHh apryMeHThpoeaHa L{e,necoo6pa3Hocrb
no3TanHoro peeopMxpoBaH
r
HAO,fl, B ,{acrHocrl4, BaxHocrb pa3AeneHhn
rex hrl4
Meponpxf,Tl4i Ha orAe,tbHbte 3Tanbt c coorBercrByot4ei nocae4oeatellxoctuto.
OAHaKo, AononHxrerutoi apryiuetraqru rpe6yer pa3AereHhe Meponpnffr i no
14Hbtx
I noeuuetxoi Ha.noToBofi craaxr xa nepestfi
t4 BTopoi 3Tanbt pe$opMxpoBaHvtA u HeBo3MoxHocq no MHeHt,tto aBTopa,
BBeAeH ro teo6.naraeanoro MrHt4MyMa
o6re4lxtru 4atnute Meponphnrhs
-
B
oAHoM 3Tane;
B Altccepraqt4u coAepxhrcfl o6ocHoaaHHoe MHeHre aBropa
o Hantruu
TecHoi a3al4MocBt3r MexAy 3HageHxeM npe4elsnoi craBK[ noAoxoAHoro Harora 14
Berhi{14Hbt cotllta,nbHbtx pacxoAoB rocyAapcrBa. B noATBepxAeHre yxa:arxoi arruclr.r
aBropy qenecoo6pa3Ho 6btno npoBecrh aHa^A3 Ao^U COtl arbHbrx pacxoAoB B
6n4xrnurx pacxo4ax Poccl.ticxofi @e4eparlrt x pa3Br,trbtx crpaH
EBponbt,
xapaKTepu3ylot4xxcg Aocraro'{Ho BbtcoKoi Hano[oBoi craexoi noAoxoAHoro Hanora;
-
npeMaraeMaff aBTopoM xoHqenqrr peQopmupoaaxrn noAoxoAHoro
Ha/roroo6noxeHllr c$oprur.rpoeaua ucxory t43 BaxHocl4 Aocr,4xeH , npuHt]xna
HAOI, oAHaxo, Tpe6yer Aono/lH TelbHoi apryMeHTaqxtl
BO3MOXHOCTb np[MeHeH n npeAnoxeHHot MoAe,nt4 B ycrloBl"ltx xpl43lca B
cnpaBeAn,lBocl4
gxoHoMl4xe, conpoBoxAaloqerocn pocroM
perhoHa.nbHbtx
-
B
t4
6e:pa6orrqut
cHt,lxeHtaeM AoxoAoa
MecrHbtx 6rcA)t{eroB;
Al..lccepraqloHHoil pa6ore aBropoM paccMorpeHbl BHeceHHble paHee
focyAapcrBeHHyto
AyMy npoeKrbl pe$opmrpoearrn HAO.n, Roropbre
B
6blnr'l
orK,noHeHbr. ABTopoM npoBeAeH AocraroqHo no4po6xstfr aHarlh3 AaHHblx npoeKroB
r'l
orpaHeHbr Bo3MolKHbte np!4qxHbt l4x orK.noHeH t TaKXe Bo3MoxHo 6stao 6ut
Sbtaerxrb l(oHxperHbte floroxeHrn 4axnurx pe$op|t, Koropble, no MHeHxrc h3OTOBOi
O.Iy'., He coorBercrBoBa.n14 npxHqhny cnpaBeAnhBocrl.'i Ha.noroooroxeHxfl h
npenlTcrBoea,nu 6bt, B cnyqae ax peatl3a\14t4, Aocr xeHxrl coqxanbHot
cta6r,nunoctr
e o6u-r.ecree
r
peueHrrc 3aAaq coquanbHoi nonv'fv,Rt4 rocyAapcrBa.
BMecre c reM, orMeLleHHble
A
cKycc14oHHble Bonpocbl onpeAen9loT Bo3MoxHoe
pacunpeH[e rpanrq 4a,nutefiruero ccneAoBaHxff 1.4 He MeHFPT o6qefi xonqenquu
BblBoAoB, a MoryT ,ntaLl'lb yrny6wt nx. npoBeAeHHoe aBTopoM tlccreAoBaH]4e
norHocTblo noATBeplxAaeT cAenaHHble rM BbtBoAbl
PaccMorpeB Marep|4a.nbl npoBeAeHHoro l43oroBoi O.Iy'. hccreAoBaHuF Ha reMy:
(llepcneRrrlBbr pe$opturpoeanln Ha.nora Ha 4oxogut $r:nlecxrx nt,tq xaK
xHcrpyMeHTa coLl anbHoi no/].urvKt focyAapcrBa), a [MeHHo: Al4ccepraL{,lto,
asrope$epar Auccepraqx[, ony6alxoaaxrute cayvxute pa6orut, cneAyer cAenarb
cneAynq e BbrBoAbr.
flpeAcraB,nner co6oi HayeHylo
Koropoi coAepxarcF Hay'1Ho o6ocHosaHHble
Avccepraq[fl l43oroBoi
O.IA.
B
3KoHoMl,lqecx14e paapa6orxr no
xea.nladrxaLlhoxHyo pa6ory,
OopMxpoBaH14]o KoMn.neKcHoi KoHqenq]itl
B Pocc' A B coorBercrBt4l,4 c
peOopMxpoBaHl4fl Ha.flora Ha 4oxo4ut $tt:tllecxAx
':'t4\
3aAaqaMr coquansuoi nonvrvt{v
nepcneKTuBy,
tlro uMeer
Pocclicxoi Oe4epaqrr Ha
cpeAHecpoqHylo
cyl4ecrBeHHoe 3HageHt1e AnF peuJeHxfl rocyAapcrBeHHblx
3aAav KaK a o6nact'/' Hanoroeoit, tax
t,t e
o6nacrtl coqxarbHoi notufr4* t.
HaV,{Hbre pe3ynbrarbt, coAepxaqrecn B AxccepraLl,aoHHofi pa6ore
l43oroBofi o.1,4, Ha reMy (nepcneKTl4Bbl peQoptvtupoeaxrn Harora Ha AoxoAbl
$ltarvecxNx
/ll"l KaK
tlHcrpyMeHTa
coqrarbHoi nonvlwKl
rocyAapcrBa),
opveHTrpoBaHbr Ha v3MeHeHrn npxopqreroB rocyAapcrBeHHoi HanoloBot noru'tuK4,
a raKxe coAepxar npeAnoxeH[fl no pe$opMltpoBaHhrc coBpeMeHHoi HaroroBoi
chcreMbt,
qro coorBercrByer orpacnr
flacnopra cneqra,lbHocn4 08.00.10
-
HayK (:xotroltr,lvecxre
xayxr) ta nynxry 2.9
OrHaHcbt, AeHexHoe o6paqetue I KpeA r
(exoaonarvecxue xayxl).
B qeroM, At4ccepraqfifl l43ofoBo', O,h, no caoemy reoperxgecKoMy ypoBHn,
HayqHoi HoBx3He x npaKThqecKoMy 3HaqeHr|o yAoBnerBoprer rpe6oBaH gM n.9
<flonoxeH|4F
o nprcyxAeHxx y,]eHbtx cTeneHefin/ yrBepxAeHHoro nocraHoaneHreM
npaBxrenbcrBa PoccxicKoi OeAepaquu or 24 ceHrfi6pF 2013 r.Ns g42,
npeAtFBnneMbrM
K Al4ccepral{[nM Ha cohcxaHre y,]eHofi creneH!,1
xaHAxAara
(4oxropa) HayK, a ee aBrop, ly'3oroBa Onbra ly'ropeBHa, 3acryxxBaer nphcyxAeHffi
y'{eHoi cTeneH KaHAhAara 3xoHoMt4LtecKrlx HayK no cneq anbHocT[ O8.OO.10 _
Orxarcsr, 4exexloe 06paqeHxe h KpeAhr.
O0hq,aanhH6t, onnoHeHr,
npooeccop KaoeApbl
(Ha,not|4
r
Ha,noroo6,noxeHhe)
SeAepanbHoro f oryAapcraeHHoro
6|oAXerHoro o6pa3oBare.nbHoro
y'rpex{4eHrr BbtcuJef o npo0ecc4oHanbHoro
o6pa3oBaHhr (Poccl4icxt4i s(oHoMq,leckri
yHrBepchrer rM. f.B. nnexaHoBa),
/
r(.3.H., AOqeHT-
,!.ll , A44i4l-f,
rn1 c r
117997, MockBa, crp€MrHHrn n€peyroK, A36
3 (a99) 2 37-93-a6, E m:ir:taxation.depanment@r€!.r
te,eooHi
noAnrcb 3aBepFD:
fi0ij;]h.
Lf1jq
alr;
d0
C coAepxarneu 0T3brBa
oSuq
anbHor0 onn0HeHTa
03HaK0MneH(-a). Koflulo orsbtBa noflyq
<
n(-a)
43 , .z,erAe.2-4-q- ZO1 5^r,
{ , // 1/1Q/,a'&7t
------86.6;Mhn,;-
no"ouapeea Ha4exAa BacrrbeBHa