Lvtv [40\\(

To
The Chairman
National Conrmission for Schedule Castes'
Lok NaYak Bhawan, Khan Market'
Government of India,
New Delhi.
Memo No DMER tzolsl i-"i :\-ii-
itr{
Dated:
c.'d
j,*rl.'+r.'
l-t,
j'
students (nursing
Subject: Representation from Kumari Meenu and others'
\Course), BIT'S college, Mohana, Sonipat'
Haryana'
complaint Ref. No. 150607605034244 (with the chairman)
Refeience: File No'16.1 75.Hr'2015'ESDW'
Please refer
comrnission rast heard
to the complaint before the Hon'ble chairman of the
on 14.g.2015. rt is hereby
rnformed that the issue has been
necessary order passed in this
sorted out at the level of the Directorate. A copy of the
,A!
-'s':
12'10'2'015'
regard is also placed herewith. Next date in the matter is
close the case/
Since the matter has been resolved, you are requested to
1I llI qrant exentption from appearance on rthe next+rdate'
Lvtv (t^
4
[40\\(
4;*)
I
(
.-)-
\
s
I Wv '
) Lt
^O
* .!;.?lw'
.(
04|)
>9Y
Fndt
\.
r-
E=L.ru
and Research,
Eclucation
-1 MedicalHarYana'
olu
Panchkula
N-g.DMER/2015/
Dated:
,"'
../' ',,..., A copy- is forwarded to the PS to Chief Secretary for information of trvorthy
Government of Haryana, Medical Educatlon and Res;earch
/Cni*f Secretary atocopy
nas been sent by fax and personally to the Commission for
./ Department that
r /'
rnformation
ui
, (-^->{--'
o.*.L
A .;-,-..,-.:-:*.:--i grrfctor,
bW
I Medical Eriucation and Research'
llarYana, Panchkular'
69
otqer
Sections 10 and 12 of the Haryana Private Health Sciences F,ducational
Institutions (F{egulation of adrnission, fixatiort of fere and maintenance of
Ilducational standards) Arct. 2012 ort tlte representation of Kumari Meenu and
other students (NursinE course), BITS College, Mohana Sonepat' Haryana
L,lrrder
regarding admission, acadernic year 20'14-15
-fhts matter was. for thc first tirre, brougfrt to the knowledge of the
trndersigned on 7.g.201b rnrhen a copy o1'tlre drrection
to file reply and
appear
was
before the S C Cornrrrission received by the Chief Sec;retary l-laryana
forwardecj to the undersigrred. F3ackground of tirel rnatte r is llke this.-
j.
The cornplaipant Kurlari Meenu and sonrel otl-rer,qirls of S
C category
took ercirrission,in nursrng school of ulTS, Mohana Soncpat in tl're morrth
of June, ZAi4.
-fokerr arnournts
of fee rarrging frorn Rs.2000/- to
Rs 5000/- was taken against tire prescribeci
fee of
ANM anci l(s.2,20,000/- for GNM or:t of ihis tls
F(s 1,iJ8,000/- for
5O0O/:.
was for the
pLtrpose of clinical trarnrnST fee to be paid to the Goverrtrnent hospital for
I
clinical traiining, and lab-expenses
etc
'T'hrus
this was almost a
free
admission in arpttcipation of the payrlent of stipend by the Governrnent
to these S
C
students after conrpletion o1'eat;h )re;ar of thetr course
i
l
ti:,revbiling practice was
to enroll for tfre
50%, seats through
i
centralized onli:ne counseling by DMt-R and rest 50(/o by the irtstitutes
I
jhis 50% wars calculated as per INC approval only
.ffrerefore
the
I
instrtr-rte shoulcj not have gone oeyond the eqrral fralf to be done
by
i,l
\i
""t.,
thern
2
I
lhese
adnrissipns had beert started in thet month of June,2014
has been
a.l praic:trcr-:
prior to a year'2014 to elnrctll students as pef IINRC
verif,ication/reconrmerrcjatron
ir
-This
to INC which is the apex body authorized
I
I
t_
t-----I
I
'---'-^"1 for these cc
to grant aPPrrovlals
'urses
i
under the relevani INC Act
l
because the tNClappr:ovals are received late'
. I
.-,--:^^r!.,!^^;
----. it was categorically
decided and intimated to
ln the lyear 2014,
I l-".
a circular-letter d'ated 27/4/Nursing
of A
way nf
by \^,/r\r
all the institutbs h,r
I
i
I
sed as annexure 'l')
DGMER/20114/b650 dated 14.5'2014 (copy enclo
I
another letter
that no acinitis{ions be done beyond INC approvals and
I
rl
enclosed
dated 13 B.2Oil4 was issued in the this regard (copy
as
i
by INC only on
annexure'lt') dut in this case INC approval was issued
in July, 2014 were to
19,1 2015 wh{reas admrssions had been slarted
l
nf
r{o in
16ti^inotinrr
ut
-l ^^, / TL..-.
In anttctpattort
institute
the i^-fiir
Thtts, +!.^
close bV ll.d.ZOlq.
-t
the
r'rru INC
ii.',.',1', I'uu^ the
rr')l of exceecling the approvals of these
r'rrY risk
appfOVal KnO\ttlgly innk
l
'2013-14 which had been issued by
institutes for tlre academic year
I
I
INC
i.
,r. anllexure
l ,.-... ^^,..1^..^.{ aS
rscrti fOf
J\.,' SeatS
rur ?0
-n}"r6vlrrr,'lll'\
rrr / fnr
March,i 2014 (copy enclosed
120 admtsslons
ANM and 40 deats for GNM and went ahead with total
l
r - - A \ rni,r ^...1 AA ,,nrlar
Al\lYl i,{l(r uu ur r\rq;r
(OU unCIer
I
:
on
receivirrg
,'1
vnNM)
ihe
comptaint and before the first hearing before
"
Cs, the
llon,ble Chairrr]ran, National Commtssion for S
I
undersigned
I
as Deputy
t tn Dr Nl;rlti
entrusted ar p[elirninary Inqulry LU L-lr'rvr(1rrr' \Officiatrng
I
1,,,.-
deptt' under section 10(1)
Director, in Me$ical Educatron and Research
I
of the Hariyar]ra
f
Prrvate Flealth Sciences Educational lnstitutions'
adrnission, fixation c)f
fee ancl maintenance of '-l\
.'!
i
-J..-.+^.,
the
officer conducted
Inquiry
The
2012.
Act,
stfndards)
F-ducational
.t
l
preliminary ,induiry before
ihe first date of hearing and
submitted
date On 28 9 2015'
preliminary leplort to the undersigned on the sarne
I
i
1
'rnnrrirrr f)ffinor hy
u) wa! of an executiveshe was appoi]nted as regular hnqulry ullruer
report' has pointecl out that
order as a statirtory requiremeni. she, irr the
4^
r\ .2j4
. ; .I
and tssited fresh
v L\
t
HNRC had irispected the lnstltute on /
I
i
i?.
,"..)
i
il\
t\
\t\
'14
ii...*.
lffi
,l
F.i$|
I
. -l-the comPlainants has to
misston of th
old verifrcatiori ariO tnerefore the admissron
i
be cancelled
,
I
]
l
*ot
The instit,{,tt
dated 12 g 2015
r
asrJSe notice
f evT carJse
issued a show
l
(copy enclosecl
!t
theY were called upon
ry which the'
tnnt^ure 'V') by
to
be penalized for violating
;hould not be
explain ancl shovfi cause why they should
I
I
the instructtons
]
explair:red that they did it as
ly have explt
The respfndents in their reply
I
I
HNRC verification and INC
rs about HNI
per past praciticei and that intimations
i
admissions had beert comPleted
se admissior
approval was ,eiteived after all these
I
I
Jot
I
They
lna{e
whom to ask to leave'
keep and wh'
decide whom to keeP
students enrolled in excess
at these stud
furtirer stated that
offered to withdraw and their
e and offere
had been inforrired about the issue
l
I
Irt
small toKen amount
efuncj small
they did not refuncj
alreacly
i
iom l-lon'ble High Court and
:t relref f iom
received in the l.op. they would get
their risk arrd responsibility'
inue at thetr
allowed the coinplainantq to continue
I
were verY well aware of the
nants were
They contendep that the complainants
I
clid nnot have anything else at
tfrey did
ls they
developments {nd still contrnued as
pairJ by
bY them TheY were also
een paid
uto'nts had been
hand and not
fiig
Ll"
I
l
taking
"f,unu"
as Per cletails
numb
lut 30 number
The isslue remains of about
]
I
i
below:-
I
I
i
I
N;t"
I tne
I
Il.lll
-' '-'-'-.t'-
.----.---.--.-
:* ---
I
coufse
I I
I
of
)C
I
I
SC i SC
ldrnrssiorrs i
lcandidatesiadrntsslons
,--r,lnd
)ancellecl lrert t
laclmitted lcancelled
I
,,,
t"k"n |
I
i--- t .i-=.-'-i;-;--*---loa
26
i18
tsu
iANMi
i,o
!11
llii
tlr
-_-.._-i38
___r-_ +_.__,-.4
lcNM
lti--l I
l._
L--'-
_.--l
r'--.
'fotal i Balance 1o l,u
of
;f
No
r't;i
utai-i.to
No
i
rotar
;f
i
i i
No be adlusted
I
I
given
--l TB
je-
-i -----'r------- -- ----1.--'-
i4
I
I
.'
I
I
i
- l-;-'"'-:---;-'--"-----'-'---l
12
16
,ll
.1- - -- ------]
___ _-i-
I
,
l',
t'
l
t
I
I
!l
I.__l-I
l
I
I
l
I
: .,__'_r^!:
Attendartrce details against requirem(:nt of 7SQ/o and tl're amounts
I
received is
i
ais
I
..--
i\ /l:
alrrnexure'Vl'
.-
rl
explored possibilities
lhe
r r rv undersigned
v,,y
of adjusting them as a
1
ii
taking
soecial case tolsave a year of the students while stnrultaneously
I
action againist !he Institute under the relevant legal provisions Keeping
_l
I
I
in view the Conhplications created by responcjents placing a year of the
I
poor hapless SIC girls at stake, the followirrg options are offered to the
I
I
students as sol|-ttions:rl
I
|
..\rnnlotod thrr
t J /t'
v' 7\o/,,
vvu" v'| 'l '|vr '|! gf
!' r\' Irrrnttirement
l-lhe studerlts who f'-.\/.'
' - --'
i)'l
i
I
.l
I
a[tendance and are willing
t,
to deposit the clinical-fee
as
I
l-escribed
pI
,I
shall be readjusted irr the nearby Government
I
i,^r'*,,*^-. ^{ rhoir
<:V<lrr rrt VaCancieS Whefevef
ur rur\-s ;anainsi
LllUll r.hnir:r'
lfnSIlIUIgS Ol
,
,I
I
I
I
vhcant-seats are available ancj they shall complete the
I
I
, course from their new institute (Government)
!l
by regular
I
I
(there
,lttenrjance
is no fee in Government in:;titutes)
rvvr
rvur
\rl
9llLvr
I
I
ii\
tt
J
tf'"v
rlr rvJ
can ioin the fresh course in this year in this Institute
\/ul
tl
i
navino
anv
r/vithnrrt
vfrLlrve!
Yu,t"'v
-"J
fee. ln
tl^rat case.
in view of the fee-
I
I
qoncession allowed by
I
the Institute, penalty shall
be
I
I
rbcjuced to Rs 1 lakh instead of Rs 4 lakh;
I
I
iii)
1
Jlre students can deposit balance fee with the Institute
I
I
minralo
them in Some local recognized self
-r-,ar
ulrf,"
llll9ldtv
>lldll
,r..)
rlt
rlflst-tc€cj institute against vacancies with the concurrence
il
L
\
,.1
l'
i.\
j{
I
:l
clt tf,e Directorate allowing ther migration.
I
I
Un tne otrlerlstde, the respondents
are
imposed a fine of the Rs' 4
I
lakhs undef Sdctions 10 and 12of the Act bid for violation the directions
I
'I
I
and
of the Directof, Medical Eclucation and Research dated 14 5'2014
I
l
rl
I
l;
lt 'i
rl
iffi
|
I
,.:iE:r,
r@
I
t-'
ll
i
t------'.'----I
-
'
-.--*
-r--'-f
I
way of demand draft
13.8.2015 They lshall denosit the arrrount by
irr
,l
or in the treasury oy
favour of Diredtor[ fVeOicaf Education and Research
i
,^,i*trin '110
o days
e{rvq frnnr
isSUe of
fronr the issue
' r,,,r^ wrthin
panchkula
way of chailan of vuut* at
I
il
order under thle rPlevant fleao
I
t-towe,,1er,l
,I
the respondents are warned not to repeat
such
,i
,r:r.--r:r:^^l^/Nlnf'
essentiality certificate/Noc
their
withcJraw
to
action
otherwiise
violations
issued
t.
do not deposit
theln {nrtt uu initiated. In case c;omplainants
I
ha inttfatgd
1., I. r^.,.,irt-.1rorrrrl Nr
rl
snarr oe
U' ^F.nll
^ ra
^f N U
fee. further aqtioh for withdrawal of
A
pt tfris order be s erved to the respondents bY the
i
copy
I
I
Regist ereo-posI
I
I
for comPliance
wt thin
10 daYs failing which further
wrthout any further notice
acllon shall be t Nken against the res pondents
I
, ..-''
-..-_rr.-.'
,:1-
-.
-?"
!e.['-a'
-t.::t'"
...,"''i"
Director,
"lMedi,:al Education and Research,
HarYana, Panchkula'
A copy
e servecj to the complainants by regrster'e-Q'peet
--
-,
'
"-,
.7' ,,,.,t
t;'Y'
<t.--.'.'t1;nr-'-;:' Dit.'gctor'
tvtrSdical Education and Research'
Harvana, Panchkula'
t:1."