Submission Point and Decision by Submitter

Transcription

Table A: Submission Point and Decision by Submitter
It is noted that some decision points in the summary of submission did not seek a decision. These
submissions are not included in this summary of decisions table.
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Further submitters (support / oppose submission)
Decision
530/1
Adolph, Debra
Reject
215/1
Aislabie, Jessica
Accept in part
FS604/39 - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees - Support
215/2
Aislabie, Jessica
Reject
450/1
Alispahic, Gabrielle and Sam
Reject
450/2
Accept in part
450/3
Reject
450/4
Reject
450/5
Accept in part
450/7
Reject
450/8
Reject
450/9
Reject
450/10
Accept
450/11
Reject
450/12
Reject
450/13
Reject
450/14
Reject
450/15
Reject
450/16
Accept
450/17
Accept
450/18
Reject
450/19
Reject
493/1
Alispahic, Natalie
Reject
493/2
Alispahic, Natalie
Reject
493/3
Alispahic, Natalie
Reject
493/4
Alispahic, Natalie
Accept
493/5
Alispahic, Natalie
Reject
493/6
Alispahic, Natalie
Reject
493/7
Alispahic, Natalie
Accept in part
17/1
Alkel Constructors Limited
Accept
112/1
Allan, David
Accept in part
FS604/40 - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees (Support)
112/2
Allan, David
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 1
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
540/1
Allen, Kevin Eric
Reject
FS577/1 - Allen, Kevin Eric - Oppose
540/2
Allen, Kevin Eric
Reject
540/3
Allen, Kevin Eric
Accept in Part
180/1
Anae, Arthur John
Accept in part
392/1
Anderson, Audrey
Accept in part
392/2
Anderson, Audrey
Reject
392/3
Anderson, Audrey
Reject
392/4
Anderson, Audrey
Accept
392/5
Anderson, Audrey
Reject
392/6
Anderson, Audrey
Reject
392/7
Anderson, Audrey
Reject
392/8
Anderson, Audrey
Reject
439/1
Anderson, Innes McRae
Accept in part
439/2
Reject
439/3
Reject
439/4
Accept
439/5
Reject
439/6
Reject
439/7
Reject
439/8
Reject
439/9
Reject
439/10
Accept in part
458/1
Anderson, John
Reject
458/2
Anderson, John
Accept
458/3
Anderson, John
Reject
458/4
Anderson, John
Reject
458/5
Anderson, John
Accept in part
458/6
Anderson, John
Accept in part
458/7
Anderson, John
Reject
458/8
Anderson, John
Accept in part
458/9
Anderson, John
Reject
458/10
Anderson, John
Accept in part
458/11
Anderson, John
Reject
458/12
Anderson, John
Reject
458/13
Anderson, John
Reject
458/14
Anderson, John
Reject
284/1
Andrew, L J and N E
Accept in part
284/2
Andrew, L J and N E
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 2
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
284/3
Andrew, L J and N E
Reject
284/4
Andrew, L J and N E
Accept
284/5
Andrew, L J and N E
Reject
284/6
Andrew, L J and N E
Reject
284/7
Andrew, L J and N E
Reject
284/8
Andrew, L J and N E
Reject
387/1
Anglesea Consulting Ltd
Accept in part
387/2
Reject
387/3
Reject
387/4
Accept
387/5
Reject
387/6
Reject
387/7
Reject
387/9
Reject
387/8
Accept
326/1
Appleton, Gordon George
Accept in part
326/2
Reject
326/3
Reject
326/4
Accept
326/5
Reject
326/6
Reject
326/7
Reject
326/8
Reject
356/1
Appleton, Lester Winston
Accept in part
356/2
Reject
356/3
Reject
356/4
Accept
356/5
Reject
356/6
Reject
356/7
Reject
356/8
Reject
177/1
Awhitu, Lucy
Insufficient detail
on changes
sought
177/2
Awhitu, Lucy
Reject
177/3
Awhitu, Lucy
Reject
177/4
Awhitu, Lucy
Reject
177/5
Awhitu, Lucy
Accept
177/6
Awhitu, Lucy
Reject
177/7
Awhitu, Lucy
Reject
177/8
Awhitu, Lucy
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 3
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
177/9
Awhitu, Lucy
Reject
177/10
Awhitu, Lucy
Reject
483/1
Baines, Martin Hamer
Accept in part
483/2
Reject
483/3
Reject
483/4
Accept
483/5
Reject
483/6
Reject
483/7
Reject
483/8
Reject
118/1
Ball, Bryce
Reject
FS561/1 - Stuart, Ian William – Support
406/1
Ball, Cyril
Reject
470/1
Ball, Kevin Wilfred
Accept in Part
470/2
Ball, Kevin Wilfred
Reject
470/3
Ball, Kevin Willfred
Accept
341/1
Ballantyne, I K
Accept in part
341/2
Ballantyne, I K
Reject
341/3
Ballantyne, I K
Reject
341/4
Ballantyne, I K
Accept
341/5
Ballantyne, I K
Reject
341/6
Ballantyne, I K
Reject
341/7
Ballantyne, I K
Reject
341/8
Ballantyne, I K
Reject
100/1
Ballard, Helen
Accept in part
100/2
Ballard, Helen
Reject
99/1
Ballard, Luke
Accept in part
99/2
Ballard, Luke
Reject
83/1
Beach Caughey, Elizabeth
Accept in part
83/2
Beach Caughey, Elizabeth
Reject
488/1
Beatty, Michael and Jan
Accept in part
488/2
Beatty, Michael and Jan
Accept in part
327/1
Bennett, Kawyn
Accept in part
327/2
Bennett, Kawyn
Reject
327/3
Bennett, Kawyn
Reject
327/4
Bennett, Kawyn
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 4
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
327/5
Bennett, Kawyn
Reject
327/6
Bennett, Kawyn
Reject
327/7
Bennett, Kawyn
Reject
327/8
Bennett, Kawyn
Reject
532/1
Berghan, Gayleen
Reject
385/1
Beskeen, Andrew
Reject
385/2
Beskeen, Andrew
Reject
385/3
Beskeen, Andrew
Reject
385/4
Beskeen, Andrew
Accept
4/1
Biddles, Christopher
Reject
4/2
Reject
4/4
Accept in part
4/4
Reject
4/5
Accept
423/1
Biddles, Elizabeth Anne
Accept in part
(insomuch as
changes made to
provide for Bayly
Town Camp)
FS578/1 - Woodhams, Louise - Oppose
FS580/1 - Kidd, Penelope – Support
FS582/1 - Mills, Stephen - Support
423/2
Biddles, Elizabeth Anne
Reject
FS573/1 - Pryde, Arthur - Support
FS578/2 - Woodhams, Louise - Support
FS580/2 - Kidd, Penelope - Support
FS582/2 - Mills, Stephen - Support
FS593/4 - Lee, Michael - Support
FS605/4 - Blackmore, Ross - Support
474/1
Biddles, Kim and Viv
Accept in part
411/1
Birt, Derek
Accept
411/2
Birt, Derek
Reject
411/3
Birt, Derek
Accept
411/4
Birt, Derek
Accept
411/5
Birt, Derek
Accept
411/6
Birt, Derek
Accept in part
98/1
Bishop, Julie Maria
Accept in part
98/2
Bishop, Julie Maria
Reject
92/1
Bishop, Robert Alan
Reject
92/2
Bishop, Robert Alan
Reject
92/3
Bishop, Robert Alan
Accept in part
92/4
Bishop, Robert Alan
Reject
92/5
Bishop, Robert Alan
Reject
92/6
Bishop, Robert Alan
Accept
92/7
Bishop, Robert Alan
Reject
92/8
Bishop, Robert Alan
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 5
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
92/9
Bishop, Robert Alan
Reject
128/1
Blackey, David Roy
Reject
415/2
Blaxall, Douglas
Accept
415/1
Blaxall, Douglass
Reject
416/1
Blitvic, Dwayne
Accept in part
416/2
Blitvic, Dwayne
Reject
416/3
Blitvic, Dwayne
Reject
416/4
Blitvic, Dwayne
Accept
416/5
Blitvic, Dwayne
Reject
416/6
Blitvic, Dwayne
Reject
416/7
Blitvic, Dwayne
Reject
416/8
Blitvic, Dwayne
Reject
422/1
Blitvic, Elaine
Accept in part
422/2
Blitvic, Elaine
Reject
422/3
Blitvic, Elaine
Reject
422/4
Blitvic, Elaine
Accept
422/5
Blitvic, Elaine
Reject
422/6
Blitvic, Elaine
Reject
422/7
Blitvic, Elaine
Reject
422/8
Blitvic, Elaine
Reject
440/1
Blitvic, Ivan
Accept in part
440/2
Blitvic, Ivan
Reject
440/3
Blitvic, Ivan
Reject
440/4
Blitvic, Ivan
Accept
440/5
Blitvic, Ivan
Reject
440/6
Blitvic, Ivan
Reject
440/7
Blitvic, Ivan
Reject
440/8
Blitvic, Ivan
Reject
185/1
Bloxwich, Sharon Elizabeth
Reject
185/2
Accept in part
185/3
Reject
185/4
Reject
185/5
Accept
185/6
Reject
185/7
Reject
185/8
Reject
185/9
Reject
432/1
Blythen, Grant Terence
Accept in Part
FS560/2 - Stuart, Ian William - Support
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 6
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
432/2
Blythen, Grant Terence
Accept
146/1
Booth, Margaret Ann
Accept
394/1
Borger, Bert
Accept
394/2
Borger, Bert
Accept
394/3
Borger, Bert
Reject
FS589/26 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc. - Oppose
533/1
Botica, Groz and Jose
Accept in Part1
426/1
Bower, Elizabeth
Reject
525/1
Bowring, Ian and Glenda
Accept
525/2
Accept
525/3
Accept
525/4
Reject
480/1
Bracey, Mark Stanley
Accept
480/2
Bracey, Mark Stanley
Reject
183/1
Bracey, Robin and Glenys
Reject
201/1
Bradley, Aaron and Joanne
Accept
464/1
Brian McEwing, Julie Geange
Reject
464/2
Accept
464/3
Accept in Part
464/4
Reject
464/5
Accept
464/6
Accept
464/7
Accept
464/8
Reject
464/9
Accept in part
464/10
Accept in part
464/11
Reject
464/12
Accept in part
464/13
Accept in part
464/14
Reject
464/15
Accept
464/16
Accept in part
FS602/5 - Meridian Energy Ltd - Support
464/17
Accept in part
464/18
Accept
464/19
FS570/1 - Vincent, Robert Marshall - Support
Reject
1
Unclear from submission is specific changes sought on their property made in the review of the ONL
boundary on this site.
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 7
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
464/20
Reject
464/22
Reject
464/23
Accept (in that all
deleted)
464/24
Accept
464/21
Accept in part
FS589/75 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc. - Support
464/25
Reject
464/26
Accept in part
464/27
Reject
464/28
Accept
464/29
Reject
464/30
Accept in part
464/31
Accept in part
FS589/74 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc - Support in part
126/1
Brown Richter, Laurie and Ingrid
Accept in part
370/1
Brown, Aland and Judith
Accept in part
370/2
Reject
370/3
Reject
370/4
Accept
370/5
Reject
370/6
Reject
370/7
Reject
370/8
Reject
218/1
Brown, Brenda
Accept in part
218/2
Brown, Brenda
Reject
295/1
Brown, Stuart WJ
Accept in part
295/2
Brown, Stuart WJ
Reject
295/3
Brown, Stuart WJ
Reject
295/4
Brown, Stuart WJ
Accept
295/5
Brown, Stuart WJ
Reject
295/6
Brown, Stuart WJ
Reject
295/7
Brown, Stuart WJ
Reject
295/8
Brown, Stuart WJ
Reject
151/1
Browns Road Trust
Reject
151/2
Browns Road Trust
Reject
433/1
Bryham, Gregory Paul
Accept in Part
433/2
Accept in Part
433/3
Accept in Part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 8
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
433/4
Accept in Part
505/1
Bryham, Shelley Anne
Accept
505/2
Accept
505/3
Accept
242/1
Buckthought, Ronald Graham
Reject
242/2
Buckthought, Ronald Graham
Accept in part
459/1
Bull, John
Reject
459/2
Bull, John R L
Reject
459/3
Bull, John R L
Reject
459/4
Bull, John R L
Accept in part
459/5
Bull, John R L
Accept in part
459/6
Bull, John R L
Reject
459/7
Bull, John R L
Reject
459/8
Bull, John R L
Reject
459/9
Bull, John R L
Reject
459/10
Bull, John
Reject
459/12
Bull, John R L
Reject
459/14
Bull, John R L
Reject
308/1
Bull, Jospeh Arthur
Accept in part
308/2
Bull, Jospeh Arthur
Reject
308/3
Bull, Jospeh Arthur
Reject
308/4
Bull, Jospeh Arthur
Accept
308/5
Bull, Jospeh Arthur
Reject
308/6
Bull, Jospeh Arthur
Reject
308/7
Bull, Jospeh Arthur
Reject
308/8
Bull, Jospeh Arthur
Reject
149/1
Bull, P
Accept in part
149/2
Bull, P
Accept in part
149/4
Bull, P
Accept
141/9
Bull, P
Reject
149/1
Bull, P
Accept in part
229/1
Bunting, Penelope Ann
Accept in part
229/2
Reject
229/3
Reject
229/4
Accept
229/5
Reject
229/6
Reject
229/7
Reject
229/8
Reject
459/11
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 9
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
167/1
Burke, Julie
Accept
153/1
Calmore-Williams, Darrell John
Accept in part
153/2
Reject
153/3
Reject
153/4
Accept
153/5
Reject
153/6
Reject
153/7
Reject
153/8
Reject
395/1
Calveley, C
Reject
395/2
Calveley, C
Reject
395/3
Calveley, C
Reject
395/4
Calveley, C
Reject
395/5
Calveley, C
Reject
FS589/36 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc - Support
395/6
Calveley, C
Reject
395/7
Calveley, C
Reject
395/8
Calveley, C
Reject
395/9
Calveley, C
Accept in part
395/10
Calveley, C
Reject
395/11
Calveley, C
Reject
395/12
Calveley, C
Accept
395/13
Calveley, C
Reject
395/14
Calveley, C
Accept in part
475/1
Campbell, Len
Accept
475/2
Campbell, Len
Reject
555/1
Carter, W M
Accept in part
555/2
Carter, W M
Reject
555/3
Carter, W M
Reject
555/4
Carter, W M
Accept
555/5
Carter, W M
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 10
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
555/6
Carter, W M
Reject
555/7
Carter, W M
Reject
555/8
Carter, W M
Reject
396/1
Cattle Mountain Run Ltd
Reject
396/2
Reject
396/3
Reject
396/4
Reject
396/5
Reject
396/6
Reject
396/7
Accept in part
396/8
396/9
396/10
Reject
Accept in part
Reject
396/11
Accept
396/12
Accept
396/13
Reject
396/14
Accept in part
84/1
Caughey, David E.
Accept in part
84/2
Caughey, David E.
Reject
64/1
Caughy, Lucy
Accept in part
65/2
Caughy, Lucy
Reject
531/1
Causer, Gary C
Accept in part
531/2
Causer, Gary C
Reject
545/1
Causer, Lynne
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 11
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
545/2
Causer, Lynne
Reject
18/1
Chambers, Delwyn
Accept in part
18/2
Chambers, Delwyn
Reject
193/1
Chambers, Ken and Delwyn
Reject
377/1
Charlene Walker-Grace and others,
Accept in part
66/1
Chases Gorge Camp Club
Reject
66/2
Chases Gorge Camp Club
Accept in part
485/1
Chick, Melanie and Alden
Reject
485/2
Reject
485/3
Reject
485/4
Reject
135/1
Christie, Nellie Maude
Accept in part
135/2
Reject
135/3
Reject
FS604/302 – Thomas Coates Estate Trustees - Support
469/1
Christopher Alver, Kerry Lee Turek
Accept in part
469/2
Reject
469/3
Reject
469/4
Accept
469/5
Reject
469/6
Reject
469/7
Reject
469/8
Reject
164/1
Clarry, Kevin George
Accept in part
164/2
Clarry, Kevin George
23/1
Coates Foote, Beatrice
23/2
Coates Foote, Beatrice
62/1
Coates, Arthur Eric
Reject
Accept in part
Reject
Accept in part
62/2
Coates, Arthur Eric
Reject
262/1
Coates, Edward and Majorie
Accept
FS589/60 - Farmers of New Zealand (Oppose)
188/1
Coles, Peter and Rose
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 12
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
58/1
Collings, Andrea
Reject
299/1
Combe Head Farms
Reject
299/2
Combe Head Farms
Accept
299/3
Combe Head Farms
Reject
114/1
Cooke, David
Accept in part
114/2
Cooke, David
Reject
79/1
Cooper, Wendy L
.
79/2
Accept in part
Cooper, Wendy L.
Reject
103/1
Cooper-Davies, Peter
Accept in part
103/2
Cooper-Davies, Peter
Reject
322/1
Crawford, Morag Seonaid
Accept in part
322/2
Reject
322/3
Reject
322/4
Accept
322/5
Reject
322/6
Reject
322/7
Reject
322/8
Reject
436/1
Croathwaite, Helen Mary
Reject
436/2
Croathwaite, Helen Mary
Reject
144/1
Crown Forestry, MAF
Accept
144/2
Crown Forestry, MAF
Accept in part
71/1
Cullen, Bruce Trevor
Accept in part
71/2
Cullen, Bruce
Accept
503/1
Cullen, Shane Noel
Accept
503/2
Cullen, Shane Noel
Accept
503/3
Cullen, Shane Noel
Reject
503/4
Cullen, Shane Noel
Reject
503/5
Cullen, Shane Noel
Accept in part
503/6
Cullen, Shane Noel
Reject
503/7
Cullen, Shane Noel
Reject
63/1
Cullen, Stephen
Accept
90/1
Curreen, Helen
Reject
90/2
Curreen, Helen
Reject
90/3
Curreen, Helen
Reject
90/4
Curreen, Helen
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 13
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
90/5
Curreen, Helen
Reject
233/1
Dalbeth, Herbert
Reject
443/1
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Accept in part
443/2
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Reject
443/3
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Reject
443/4
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Accept
443/5
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Reject
443/6
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Reject
443/7
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Reject
443/8
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Reject
443/9
Dalbeth, Joanne Gay
Reject
137/1
Dalbeth, Valerie
Accept in part
137/2
Dalbeth, Valerie
Reject
137/3
Dalbeth, Valerie
Reject
137/4
Dalbeth, Valerie
Accept
137/5
Dalbeth, Valerie
Reject
137/6
Dalbeth, Valerie
Reject
137/7
Dalbeth, Valerie
Reject
137/8
Dalbeth, Valerie
Reject
137/9
Dalbeth, Valerie
Reject
495/1
Dassler, Neville James
Reject
495/2
Dassler, Neville James
Accept in part
155/1
Davey, Deborah
Accept in part
155/2
Davey, Deborah
Reject
477/1
Davey, Louanne
Accept in part
477/2
Davey, Louanne
Reject
477/3
Davey, Louanne
Reject
477/4
Davey, Louanne
Accept
477/5
Davey, Louanne
Reject
477/6
Davey, Louanne
Reject
477/7
Davey, Louanne
Reject
477/8
Davey, Louanne
Reject
339/1
Davies, Rhys John
Accept in part
339/2
Davies, Rhys John
Reject
339/3
Davies, Rhys John
Reject
339/4
Davies, Rhys John
Accept
339/5
Davies, Rhys John
Reject
339/6
Davies, Rhys John
Reject
339/7
Davies, Rhys John
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 14
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
339/8
Davies, Rhys John
Reject
506/1
Davis Paniora, Sonya Blitvic
Accept in part
506/2
Reject
506/3
Reject
506/4
Accept
506/5
Reject
506/6
Reject
506/7
Reject
506/8
Reject
270/1
Dawson, Elizabeth Jane
Accept
219/1
de Graaf, Adrianus
Accept in part
219/2
de Graaf, Adrianus
Reject
220/1
de Graaf, Josina
Accept in part
220/2
de Graaf, Josina
Reject
373/1
Department of Conservation, Director General of Conservation
Accept in part
FS608/1 - Northland Regional Council - Oppose
373/2
Accept in part
FS608/2 - Northland Regional Council - Oppose
373/3
Accept in part
373/4
Accept in part
373/5
Accept in part
FS601/2 - TrustPower Ltd - Oppose
373/6
Reject
373/7
Accept in part
373/8
Reject
373/9
Accept in part
373/10
Accept
373/11
Accept
373/12
Accept
373/13
Reject
373/14
Accept in part
373/15
Accept in part
FS606/1 - Federated Farmers of New Zealand - Oppose
373/16
Accept in part
373/17
Accept
373/18
Reject
373/19
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 15
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
373/20
Accept in part
FS606/3 - Federated Farmers of New Zealand - In Part
373/21
Accept in part
373/22
Accept in part
FS589/3 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc. – Oppose
FS602/3 - Meridian Energy Ltd - Oppose
373/23
Accept in part
373/24
Accept in part
373/25
Accept in part
FS601/9 - TrustPower Ltd – Oppose
373/26
Accept in part
373/27
Accept in part
36/1
Dick, Alison
Accept in part
36/2
Dick, Alison
Reject
37/1
Dick, Anna
Accept in part
37/2
Dick, Anna
Reject
34/1
Dick, Fiona
Accept in part
34/2
Dick, Fiona
Reject
35/1
Dick, Laura
Accept in part
35/2
Dick, Laura
Reject
38/1
Dick, Phillip
Accept in part
38/2
Dick, Phillip
Reject
424/1
Dix, Elizabeth Anne
Accept in part
424/2
Dix, Elizabeth Anne
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 16
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
424/3
Dix, Elizabeth Anne
Reject
424/4
Dix, Elizabeth Anne
Accept
424/5
Dix, Elizabeth Anne
Reject
424/6
Dix, Elizabeth Anne
Reject
424/7
Dix, Elizabeth Anne
Reject
424/8
Dix, Elizabeth Anne
Reject
504/1
Dix, Trevor Quintin
Accept in part
504/2
Dix, Trevor Quintin
Reject
504/3
Dix, Trevor Quintin
Reject
504/4
Dix, Trevor Quintin
Accept
504/5
Dix, Trevor Quintin
Reject
504/6
Dix, Trevor Quintin
Reject
504/7
Dix, Trevor Quintin
Reject
504/8
Dix, Trevor Quintin
Reject
213/1
Donaldson, Craig
Accept in part
213/2
Donaldson, Craig
Reject
280/1
Donaldson, Douglas and Lenore
Accept in part
280/2
Reject
280/3
Reject
280/4
Accept
280/5
Reject
280/6
Reject
280/7
Reject
280/8
Reject
352/1
Donegan, Julia
Accept in part
352/2
Donegan, Julia
Reject
352/3
Donegan, Julia
Reject
352/4
Donegan, Julia
Accept
352/5
Donegan, Julia
Reject
352/6
Donegan, Julia
Reject
352/7
Donegan, Julia
Reject
352/8
Donegan, Julia
Reject
455/1
Douglas Hilton Family Trust
Accept
455/2
Accept
455/3
Reject
189/1
Downey, Dennis and Kerry
Reject
537/1
Drake, Bridget Elizabeth Caughey
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 17
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
537/2
Drake, Bridget Elizabeth Caughey
Reject
536/1
Drake, Libby
Accept in part
536/2
Drake, Libby
Reject
535/1
Drake, Rachel Lucy Caughey
Accept in part
535/2
Drake, Rachel Lucy Caughey
Reject
263/1
Draper, William
Accept in part
263/2
Draper, William
Reject
263/3
Draper, William
Reject
263/4
Draper, William
Accept
263/5
Draper, William
Reject
263/6
Draper, William
Reject
263/7
Draper, William
Reject
263/8
Draper, William
Reject
281/1
Drinnan, Stephen Rex
Accept in part
281/2
Reject
281/3
Reject
281/4
Accept
281/5
Reject
281/6
Reject
281/7
Reject
281/8
Reject
509/1
Dropulich, Tania Jane
Reject
15/1
Drury, Graham Maxwell
Reject
15/2
Drury, Graham Maxwell
Accept in part
529/1
Duck Nominees Ltd
Reject
FS576/20 - Friends of the Brynderwyns Society Incorporated - Oppose
178/1
Duder, David and Gay
Reject
178/2
Duder, David and Gay
Reject
467/1
Dugdale, Kenneth
Accept
467/2
Dugdale, Kenneth
Accept
467/3
Dugdale, Kenneth
Reject
467/4
Dugdale, Kenneth
Reject
467/5
Dugdale, Kenneth
Accept in part
467/6
Dugdale, Kenneth
Reject
467/7
Dugdale, Kenneth
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 18
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
74/1
Dyer, Murray
Accept in part
FS604/91- Thomas Coates Estate Trustees - Support
74/2
Dyer, Murray
Reject
447/2
Edwards, Graeme Robert
Reject
447/1
Edwards, Graeme Robert
Reject
444/1
Elliott, Jan
Reject
444/3
Elliott, Jan
Reject
444/6
Elliott, Jan
Accept in part
444/7
Elliott, Jan
Reject
444/8
Elliott, Jan
Reject
444/9
Elliott, Jan
Reject
444/10
Elliott, Jan
Accept in part
444/11
Elliott, Jan
Reject
444/12
Elliott, Jan
Reject
444/13
Elliott, Jan
Reject
444/14
Elliott, Jan
Reject
13/1
Ellis, Lance
Accept in part
13/2
Ellis, Lance
Accept in part
528/1
Ellis, Rhonda
Reject
528/2
Ellis, Rhonda
Reject
147/1
Engeler, George
Accept in part
147/2
Engeler, George
Reject
147/3
Engeler, George
Reject
147/4
Engeler, George
Accept
147/5
Engeler, George
Reject
147/6
Engeler, George
Reject
147/7
Engeler, George
Reject
147/8
Engeler, George
Reject
452/8
Environmental Defence Society Inc
Reject
FSFS606/12 - Federated Farmers of New Zealand - Oppose
452/11
Environmental Defence Society Inc
Reject
452/1
Environmental Defence Society Inc.
Accept in part
452/2
Accept
452/4
Accept in part
452/5
Accept in Part
FS606/9 - Federated Farmers of New Zealand – Oppose
452/6
Accept in part
FS606/10 - Federated Farmers of New Zealand - Oppose FS602/20 - Meridian Energy Ltd - Oppose
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 19
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
452/7
Reject
452/9
Accept in part
452/10
Reject
452/12
Reject
452/13
Accept in part
454/1
Environs Holdings Ltd
Accept in part
FS592/1 - Environs Holdings Ltd - Support
454/2
Accept in part
454/3
Reject
76/1
Evelyn Salvigny
Accept in part
76/2
Evelyn Salvigny
Reject
283/2
Farmers of New Zealand Inc
Accept
283/3
Accept
283/6
Reject
283/8
Reject
283/41
Reject
283/58
Reject
283/59
Reject
283/60
Reject
283/61
Reject
283/62
Reject
283/63
Reject
283/69
Reject
283/81
Reject
283/82
Reject
283/83
Reject
283/84
Reject
283/85
Reject
283/86
Reject
283/87
Reject
283/105
Reject
283/109
Accept in part
283/109
Accept in part
283/1
Farmers of New Zealand Inc.
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 20
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
283/4
Accept in part
283/5
Reject
283/7
Accept in part
283/9
Accept in part
283/10
Reject
283/10
Reject
283/11
Accept in part
283/12
Reject
283/13
Accept in part
283/14
Reject
283/15
Reject
283/16
Accept in part
283/17
Accept in part
283/18
Accept in part
283/19
Reject
283/20
Reject
283/21
Accept in part
283/22
Accept in part
283/23
Reject
283/24
Accept
283/25
Accept in part
283/26
Reject
283/27
Accept in part
283/28
Accept in part
283/29
Reject
283/30
Accept
283/31
Accept in part
283/32
Reject
283/33
Reject
283/34
Accept in part
283/35
Reject
283/36
Reject
283/37
Accept in part
283/38
Reject
283/39
Accept
283/40
Accept
283/42
Accept in Part
283/43
Reject
283/44
Accept in part
283/45
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 21
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
283/46
Accept in part
283/47
Accept in part
283/48
Accept
283/49
Accept
283/50
Accept in part
283/51
Accept
283/52
Reject
283/54
Accept in Part
283/55
Accept
283/56
Accept
283/57
Reject
283/64
Accept
283/65
Accept
283/66
Accept
283/67
Accept
283/68
Accept
283/70
Accept
283/71
Accept
283/72
Accept
283/73
Accept
283/74
Accept
283/75
Accept
283/76
Accept
283/77
Accept
283/78
Accept
283/79
Accept
283/80
Reject
283/88
Accept
283/89
Accept
283/90
Accept
283/91
Accept
283/92
Accept
283/93
Reject
283/94
Reject
283/95
Accept
283/96
Accept
283/97
Accept
283/98
Accept
283/99
Accept
283/100
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 22
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
283/101
Accept
283/102
Accept
283/103
Accept
283/104
Reject
283/106
Accept
283/107
Accept in part
283/107
Accept in part
283/108
Accept in part
283/112
Reject
453/1
Federated Farmers of New Zealand
Accept
453/2
Accept
453/3
Accept
FS589/80 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc. – Support
FS603/2 - Environmental Defence Society Inc. - Oppose
453/4
Accept in part
453/5
Accept
453/6
Reject
453/7
Reject
453/8
Accept
453/9
Reject
453/10
Accept in part
FS603/3 - Environmental Defence Society Inc. - Oppose
453/11
Reject
453/12
Accept in part
453/13
Reject
453/14
Reject
453/15
Reject
453/16
Reject
453/17
Reject
453/18
Reject
453/19
Accept in part
265/1
Fernandez, Blodwen
Accept in part
265/2
Fernandez, Blodwen
Accept in part
264/1
Fernandez, Jenni
Accept in part
264/2
Fernandez, Jenni
Reject
264/3
Fernandez, Jenni
Reject
264/4
Fernandez, Jenni
Accept
264/5
Fernandez, Jenni
Reject
264/6
Fernandez, Jenni
Reject
264/7
Fernandez, Jenni
Reject
264/8
Fernandez, Jenni
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 23
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
541/1
Findley, Christine
Reject
FS559/1 - Findley, Christine - Oppose
541/2
Findley, Christine
Reject
FS559/2 - Findley, Christine - Oppose
539/1
Findley, Paul
Reject
FS558/1 - Findley, Paul - Oppose
539/2
Findley, Paul
Reject
539/3
Findley, Paul
Reject
175/1
Finlayson, Kenneth Carran Maclean
Accept
175/2
Accept
175/3
Accept in Part
162/1
Finncane, Gary Philip Morris
Accept
162/2
Reject
162/3
Reject
430/1
Fish, Isabel
Reject
430/2
Fish, Isabel
Accept in part
430/3
Fish, Isabel
Reject
430/4
Fish, Isabel
Reject
430/5
Fish, Isabel
Accept
430/6
Fish, Isabel
Reject
430/7
Fish, Isabel
Reject
430/8
Fish, Isabel
Reject
430/9
Fish, Isabel
Reject
430/10
Fish, Isabel
Reject
510/1
Fish, Terence Henry
Accept in part
510/2
Fish, Terence Henry
Reject
510/3
Fish, Terence Henry
Reject
510/4
Fish, Terence Henry
Accept
510/5
Fish, Terence Henry
Reject
510/6
Fish, Terence Henry
Reject
510/7
Fish, Terence Henry
Reject
510/8
Fish, Terence Henry
Reject
68/1
Fisher, Claire
Accept in part
340/1
Fisher, P R
Reject
340/2
Fisher, P R
Accept in part
228/1
Flavell-Johnson, Alex
Accept in part
527/1
Flavell-Johnson, Alex and others
Accept in part
437/1
Fletcher, Ian
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 24
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
437/2
Fletcher, Ian
Reject
524/1
Fletcher, Yvonne
Accept in part
524/2
Fletcher, Yvonne
Reject
442/1
Forde, Jeanette
Reject
FS599/2 - Stuart, Helen - Support
442/1
Forde, Jeanette
Reject
442/3
Forde, Jeanette
Accept in part
442/4
Forde, Jeanette
Accept in part
442/5
Forde, Jeanette
Accept in part
442/6
Forde, Jeanette
Reject
FS599/7 - Mangawhai Ratepayers and Residents Association - Support
442/7
Forde, Jeanette
Reject
442/8
Forde, Jeanette
Accept in part
FS5999/9 Stuart, Helen - Support
442/2
Forde, Jeanette
Reject
235/1
Forrest, Logan James
Accept in part
235/2
Reject
235/3
Reject
235/4
Accept
235/5
Reject
235/6
Reject
235/7
Reject
235/8
Reject
235/9
Reject
235/10
Reject
192/1
Foster, William Rowand
Reject
192/2
Foster, William Rowand
Reject
451/1
Friends of the Brynderwyns Society Incorporated
Accept in part
451/2
Accept
451/3
Accept in part
451/4
Accept in part
451/5
Accept in part
451/6
Accept in part
451/7
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 25
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
451/8
Accept
451/9
Accept in part
451/10
Accept in part
451/11
Accept in part
451/12
Accept in part
451/13
Accept in part
451/14
Accept in part
451/15
Accept in part
451/16
Reject
451/17
Reject
451/18
Reject
451/19
Reject
451/20
Accept in part
451/21
Reject
451/22
Accept in part
451/23
Accept in part
451/24
Accept in part
451/25
Accept in part
451/26
Accept in part.
451/27
Reject
451/28
Accept in part
451/29
Accept in part
451/30
Reject
451/31
Accept in part
451/32
Accept in part
451/33
Reject
451/34
Accept
451/35
FS604/43 - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees - Oppose
Accept in part
451/36
Reject
451/37
Reject
451/38
Reject
451/39
Accept in part
451/40
Accept in part
451/44
Accept in part
451/45
Accept in part
451/46
Accept in part
451/47
Accept in part
451/48
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 26
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
451/49
Reject
451/50
Accept in part
451/51
Accept in part
451/52
Accept in part
451/53
Accept in part
451/54
Reject
451/55
Accept in part
451/56
Accept in part
451/57
Reject
451/58
Accept in part
451/59
Accept in part
451/60
Reject
451/61
Reject
451/62
Reject
451/63
Reject
451/64
Reject
451/65
Reject
451/66
Reject
451/67
Accept
451/68
Accept in part
451/69
Accept in part
451/70
Reject
451/71
Reject
165/1
Furze, Merrill
Accept in part
FS604/217- Thomas Coates Estate Trustees - Support
165/2
Furze, Merrill
Reject
157/1
Furze, Peter
Accept in part
157/2
Furze, Peter
Reject
552/1
Gary, Daniel Tiara
Accept in Part
552/1
Gary, Daniel Tiara
Accept in Part
482/1
Gash, Mark William
Reject
482/2
Gash, Mark William
Accept
482/3
Gash, Mark William
Reject
347/1
Gatti, Susan
Accept in part
347/2
Gatti, Susan
Reject
347/3
Gatti, Susan
Reject
347/4
Gatti, Susan
Accept
347/5
Gatti, Susan
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 27
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
347/6
Gatti, Susan
Reject
347/7
Gatti, Susan
Reject
347/8
Gatti, Susan
Reject
478/1
George, Mack Russell
Accept
166/1
Gillatt, Roger and Barbara
Accept in part
166/2
Reject
166/3
Reject
166/4
Accept
166/5
Reject
166/6
Reject
166/7
Reject
166/8
Reject
544/1
Gledhill, Charles
Accept in part
544/2
Gledhill, Charles
Reject
354/1
Godfrey, Ian Rex
Accept in part
354/2
Godfrey, Ian Rex
Reject
354/3
Godfrey, Ian Rex
Reject
354/4
Godfrey, Ian Rex
Accept
354/5
Godfrey, Ian Rex
Reject
354/6
Godfrey, Ian Rex
Reject
354/7
Godfrey, Ian Rex
Reject
354/8
Godfrey, Ian Rex
Reject
5/1
Goulding & Gunson, Timothy John & Craig Wesley
Reject
526/1
Goulding, Timothy
Reject
526/2
Goulding, Timothy
Reject
526/3
Goulding, Timothy
Accept
526/4
Goulding, Timothy
Accept in part
526/5
Goulding, Timothy
Reject
526/6
Goulding, Timothy
Reject
526/7
Goulding, Timothy
Accept
526/8
Goulding, Timothy
Reject
526/9
Goulding, Timothy
Reject
526/10
Goulding, Timothy
Reject
526/11
Goulding, Timothy
Reject
259/1
Graham Leonard Hawkes, Robert G McLennan
Accept in part
259/2
Reject
259/3
Reject
259/4
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 28
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
259/5
Reject
259/6
Reject
259/7
Reject
259/8
Reject
479/1
Grand, Marcel Jean
Reject
414/1
Green, Donna
Accept in part
414/2
Green, Donna
Reject
414/3
Green, Donna
Reject
414/4
Green, Donna
Accept
414/5
Green, Donna
Reject
414/6
Green, Donna
Reject
414/7
Green, Donna
Reject
414/8
Green, Donna
Reject
520/1
Green, Vivian
Accept in part
520/2
Green, Vivian
Accept in part
281/1
Greenslade, Melanie
Accept in part
172/1
Greenway Estate
Accept in part
519/1
Greer, John Foster
Accept
519/2
Greer, John Foster
Accept
254/2
Greville, John Willis
Reject
254/3
Reject
254/4
Accept in part
254/6
Reject
492/1
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/4
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/5
Grierson, Monique
Accept in part
492/7
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/8
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/9
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/10
Grierson, Monique
Accept
492/11
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/12
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/13
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/14
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/15
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/16
Grierson, Monique
Accept
492/17
Grierson, Monique
Accept
492/18
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/19
Grierson, Monique
Reject
492/3
Grierson, Monique
Reject
268/1
Grieve, James
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 29
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
268/2
Grieve, James
Accept in part
266/1
Grieve, John Gibson
Accept in part
266/2
Grieve, John Gibson
Accept in part
269/1
Grieve, Justin Matthew
Accept in part
269/2
Grieve, Justin Matthew
Accept in part
267/1
Grieve, Laura
Accept in part
FS599/1 - Stuart, Helen (Support)
272/1
Grieve, Shaye
Accept in part
272/2
Grieve, Shaye
Accept in part
145/1
Groupsky, Patrick
Reject
145/2
Groupsky Patrick
Reject
123/1
Grove, Peter
Reject
123/2
Grove, Peter
Reject
289/1
Guest, W J and N M
Accept in part
289/2
Guest, W J and N M
Reject
289/3
Guest, W J and N M
Reject
289/4
Guest, W J and N M
Accept
289/5
Guest, W J and N M
Reject
289/6
Guest, W J and N M
Reject
289/7
Guest, W J and N M
Reject
289/8
Guest, W J and N M
Reject
43/1
Gunnery, Lisa
Accept in part
FS604/164 - - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees - Support
43/2
Gunnery, Lisa
Reject
253/1
Guy, David and Bev
Accept in part
102/1
Hacker, Shaun
Accept in part
102/2
Hacker, Shaun
Reject
170/1
Hadlow, C L
Accept in part
170/2
Hadlow, C L
Reject
170/3
Hadlow, C L
Reject
170/4
Hadlow, C L
Accept
170/5
Hadlow, C L
Reject
170/6
Hadlow, C L
Reject
170/7
Hadlow, C L
Reject
170/8
Hadlow, C L
Reject
159/1
Hales, Des
Accept in part
159/2
Hales, Des
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 30
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
163/1
Hales, G and J
Accept in part
163/2
Hales, G and J
Reject
11/1
Hales, Graeme
Accept
160/1
Hales, Renee
Accept in part
160/2
Hales, Renee
Reject
502/6
Halse, Robyn
Reject
502/1
Halse, Robyne
Accept in part
502/2
Halse, Robyne
Reject
502/3
Halse, Robyne
Reject
502/4
Halse, Robyne
Accept
502/5
Halse, Robyne
Reject
502/7
Halse, Robyne
Reject
502/8
Halse, Robyne
Reject
150/1
Hames, Ken
Reject
150/2
Hames, Ken
Accept in part
7/2
Hancock Forest Management NZ
Accept in part
7/4
Hancock Forest Management NZ
Reject
7/2
Hancock Forestry Limited
Accept
45/1
Hardie Neil, Alistair
Accept in part
45/2
Hardie Neil, Alistair
Reject
47/1
Hardie Neil, Anna
Accept in part
47/2
Hardie Neil, Anna
Reject
51/1
Hardie Neil, Bruce John
Accept in part
51/2
Hardie Neil, Bruce John
Reject
FS602/14 - Meridian Energy Ltd (Support)
48/1
Hardie Neil, David
Accept in part
48/2
Hardie Neil, David
Reject
50/1
Hardie Neil, Jenneane
Accept in part
50/2
Hardie Neil, Jenneane
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 31
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
44/1
Hardie Neil, Jonathan
Accept in part
44/2
Hardie Neil, Jonathan
Reject
49/1
Hardie Neil, Timothy
Accept in part
49/2
Hardie Neil, Timothy
Reject
413/1
Hardie-Neil, D J
Accept in part
413/2
Hardie-Neil, D J
Reject
316/1
Hardy, Isabell
Accept in part
316/2
Hardy, Isabell
Reject
316/3
Hardy, Isabell
Reject
316/4
Hardy, Isabell
Accept
316/5
Hardy, Isabell
Reject
316/6
Hardy, Isabell
Reject
316/7
Hardy, Isabell
Reject
316/8
Hardy, Isabell
Reject
198/1
Hare, Stephen
Reject
26/1
Harfoot, Christopher
Accept in part
26/2
Harfoot, Christopher
Reject
24/1
Harfoot, Cynthia
Accept in part
24/2
Harfoot, Cynthia
Reject
473/1
Harfoot, Kieran Gibbs
Accept in part
473/2
Harfoot, Kieran Gibbs
Reject
334/1
Harfoot, Tracey Ellice
Accept in part
334/2
Harfoot, Tracey Ellice
Reject
125/1
Hargrave, Patricia Rachel Constance
Accept in part
125/2
Hargrave, Patricia Rachel Constance
Accept in part
391/1
Hargreaves, Anthony and Lindsey
Reject
391/2
Reject
391/3
Reject
362/1
Hargreaves, David and Mary
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 32
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
362/2
Reject
362/3
Reject
362/4
Accept
362/5
Reject
362/6
Reject
362/7
Reject
362/8
Reject
320/1
Harrison, Donald Joseph
Accept in part
320/2
Reject
320/3
Reject
320/4
Accept
320/5
Reject
320/6
Reject
320/7
Reject
320/8
Reject
260/1
Hastie, Deborah
Reject
260/2
Hastie, Deborah
Reject
FS604/233 -Thomas Coates Estate Trustees - Oppose
260/3
Hastie, Deborah
Accept
397/2
Hawley, Catherine and John
Accept in part
397/2
Accept
397/3
Accept in part
397/4
Accept in part
397/5
Accept in part
397/6
Accept
397/7
Accept
397/8
Accept
397/9
Accept in part
397/10
Accept in part
397/11
Accept in part
397/12
Accept in part
397/13
Accept in part
397/14
Accept in part
397/15
Reject
397/16
Reject
397/17
Reject
397/18
Reject
397/19
Reject
397/20
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 33
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
397/21
Accept in part
397/22
Accept in part
397/23
Accept in part
397/24
Accept in part.
397/25
Reject
397/26
Accept in part
397/27
Accept in part
397/28
Reject
397/29
Accept in part
397/30
Accept in part
397/31
Accept in Part
397/32
Reject
397/33
Reject
397/34
Reject
397/35
Reject
397/36
Accept
397/37
Accept in part
397/38
Accept
397/38
Accept in part
397/40
Reject
397/41
Accept in part
397/42
Accept in part
397/43
Reject
397/44
Accept
FS598/2 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc (Oppose)
397/45
Accept in part
397/46
Reject
397/47
Reject
397/48
Accept in part
397/49
Accept in part
397/50
Accept in part
397/54
Accept in part
397/55
Accept in part
397/56
Accept in part
397/57
Accept in part
397/58
Accept
397/59
Accept in part
397/60
Reject
397/61
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 34
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
397/62
Reject
397/63
Accept in part
397/64
Accept in part
397/65
Reject
397/66
Accept in part
397/67
Accept in part
397/68
Reject
397/69
Reject
397/70
Accept in part
397/71
Accept in part
397/72
Reject
397/73
Reject
397/74
Reject
397/75
Reject
397/76
Reject
397/77
Reject
397/78
Accept
397/79
Accept in part
397/80
Accept in part
397/81
Reject
397/82
Reject
397/83
Reject
397/39
Reject
489/1
Hayes, Michael Walter
Reject
489/2
Reject
489/5
Reject
489/6
Reject
489/4
Reject
358/1
He, Lisa
Accept in part
358/2
He, Lisa
Reject
358/3
He, Lisa
Reject
358/4
He, Lisa
Accept
358/5
He, Lisa
Reject
358/6
He, Lisa
Reject
358/7
He, Lisa
Reject
358/8
He, Lisa
Reject
104/1
Heggie, Alastair
Accept in part
104/2
Heggie, Alastair
Reject
333/1
Henry, Richard
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 35
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
333/2
Henry, Richard
Reject
333/3
Henry, Richard
Accept in part
20/1
Hensman, Peter
Reject
20/2
Hensman, Peter
Reject
20/3
Hensman, Peter
No Decision
Sought
556/1
Herewood, W
Accept in part
353/1
Hetherington, Desmond Wayne
Accept in part
353/2
Reject
353/3
Reject
353/4
Accept
353/5
Reject
353/6
Reject
353/7
Reject
353/8
Reject
12/1
Hewetson, Terry
Reject
390/1
Heywood, Anne
Accept in part
390/2
Heywood, Anne
Accept in part
390/3
Heywood, Anne
Accept in part
390/4
Heywood, Anne
Reject
97/1
Hindrup, Ray
Accept in part
97/2
Hindrup, Ray
Accept in part
97/3
Hindrup, Ray
Reject
97/4
Hindrup, Ray
Reject
97/5
Hindrup, Ray
Accept
97/6
Hindrup, Ray
Reject
97/7
Hindrup, Ray
Reject
97/8
Hindrup, Ray
Reject
97/9
Hindrup, Ray
Reject
543/1
Hislop, Alexandra
Reject
496/2
Historic Places Trust
Accept in part
496/1
Historic Places Trust, NZ
Accept in part
393/1
Hita, Ben
Reject
393/2
Hita, Ben
Reject
108/1
Hodges, Richard Donald
Accept in part
108/2
Hodges, Richard Donald
Reject
110/1
Hogan, Jonathon
Accept in part
110/2
Hogan, Jonathon
Reject
110/3
Hogan, Jonathon
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 36
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
110/4
Hogan, Jonathon
Accept
110/5
Hogan, Jonathon
Reject
110/6
Hogan, Jonathon
Reject
110/7
Hogan, Jonathon
Reject
110/8
Hogan, Jonathon
Reject
110/9
Hogan, Jonathon
Accept
110/10
Hogan, Jonathon
Accept in part
110/11
Hogan, Jonathon
Reject
255/2
Hogan, Jonathon Peter
Accept in part
255/3
Hogan, Jonathon Peter
Accept in part
14/1
Hogan, Lewis
Accept in part
14/2
Hogan, Lewis
Accept in part
14/3
Hogan, Lewis
Accept in part
14/4
Hogan, Lewis
Accept
428/1
Hooker, Gary
Accept in part
428/2
Hooker, Gary
Reject
428/3
Hooker, Gary
Reject
428/4
Hooker, Gary
Accept
428/5
Hooker, Gary
Reject
428/6
Hooker, Gary
Reject
428/7
Hooker, Gary
Reject
428/8
Hooker, Gary
Reject
140/1
Hosking, Estelle
Accept in part
140/2
Hosking, Estelle
Reject
317/1
House, Stuart Henderson
Accept in part
317/2
Reject
317/3
Reject
317/4
Accept
317/5
Reject
317/6
Reject
317/7
Reject
317/8
Reject
302/1
Howard, Marie Hazel
Accept in part
302/2
Howard, Marie Hazel
Reject
302/3
Howard, Marie Hazel
Reject
302/4
Howard, Marie Hazel
Accept
302/5
Howard, Marie Hazel
Reject
302/6
Howard, Marie Hazel
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 37
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
302/7
Howard, Marie Hazel
Reject
302/8
Howard, Marie Hazel
Reject
252/1
Howell, Michael
Accept in part
252/2
Howell, Michael
Reject
224/1
Howse, Bryan
Accept in part
224/2
Howse, Bryan
Reject
223/1
Howse, Catarina
Accept in part
223/2
Howse, Catarina
Reject
225/1
Howse, Stephanie
Accept in part
225/2
Howse, Stephanie
Reject
67/1
Investments, Poutu
Reject
67/2
Investments, Poutu
Accept
67/3
Investments, Poutu
Reject
331/1
Iona Farms Ltd
Accept in part
331/2
Iona Farms Ltd
Reject
331/3
Iona Farms Ltd
Reject
331/4
Iona Farms Ltd
Accept
331/5
Iona Farms Ltd
Reject
331/6
Iona Farms Ltd
Reject
331/7
Iona Farms Ltd
Reject
331/8
Iona Farms Ltd
Reject
2/1
James Tetuhi
Reject
181/1
James, John Ivor
Reject
288/1
Jef FS Family Trust
Accept in part
288/2
Jeffs Family Trust
Reject
288/3
Jeffs Family Trust
Reject
288/4
Jeffs Family Trust
Accept
288/5
Jeffs Family Trust
Reject
288/6
Jeffs Family Trust
Reject
288/7
Jeffs Family Trust
Reject
288/8
Jeffs Family Trust
Reject
476/1
Jennings, Lorraine
Accept in part
476/2
Jennings, Lorraine
Reject
456/1
Jepson, Craig
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 38
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
456/2
Jepson, Craig
Accept
456/3
Jepson, Craig
Reject
456/4
Jepson, Craig
Reject
456/5
Jepson, Craig
Accept in part
456/5
Jepson, Craig
Accept in part
456/6
Jepson, Craig
Reject
456/7
Jepson, Craig
Reject
258/1
John K Nielsen, Darwin S Linthicum
Accept in part
258/2
Reject
258/3
Reject
258/4
Accept in part
258/5
Reject
258/6
Accept in part
258/7
Accept in part
258/8
Accept in part
258/9
Reject
258/10
Accept in part
258/11
Accept
258/12
Accept in part
258/13
Accept in part
258/14
FS589/27- Farmers of New Zealand Inc. - Support
Reject
258/15
Accept in part
542/1
Jones, Charlotte
Reject
542/2
Jones, Charlotte
Reject
542/3
Jones, Charlotte
Reject
542/4
Jones, Charlotte
Reject
425/1
Jones, Elizabeth
Accept
425/2
Jones, Elizabeth
Reject
176/1
Jones, Graham Laurence
Accept in part
176/2
Reject
176/3
Reject
176/4
Accept
176/5
Reject
176/6
Reject
176/7
Reject
462/1
Joydon's Pearl st Association
Accept
462/2
Accept
462/3
Joydon's Pearl St Association
Reject
462/4
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 39
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
462/5
Accept in part
462/5
Accept in part
462/6
Reject
462/7
Reject
251/1
Jurrtich, Victor Raymond and Corile
Reject
277/1
Kai Iwi Farms Ltd
Accept in part
277/2
Kai Iwi Farms Ltd
Accept
282/1
Kaipara Citizens and Ratepayers Association
Accept in part
282/2
Reject
282/3
Reject
282/4
Reject
282/5
Reject
463/1
Kaipara District Council
Accept
463/2
Accept (in that all
deleted)
463/3
Accept
463/4
Accept
463/5
Accept
463/6
Accept
463/7
Accept in part
FS601/5 - TrustPower Ltd – Support
463/8
Reject
FSFS602/18 - Meridian Energy Ltd - Oppose
463/9
Accept in part
463/10
Accept in part
463/11
Accept in part
FSFS589/66 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc. – Support
FSFS589/71 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc. - Oppose
463/12
Accept in part
463/13
Accept in part
463/14
Accept
463/15
Accept in part
463/16
Accept in part
463/17
Accept in part
463/18
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 40
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
463/19
Accept in part
463/20
Accept in part
463/21
Accept in part
463/22
Accept in part
463/23
Accept in part
FS575/1 - Hawley, Catherine and John - Oppose
463/24
Accept in part
463/25
Accept in part
463/26
Accept in part
463/27
Accept in part
463/28
Accept in part
463/29
Accept in part
463/30
Accept in part
463/31
Accept in part
463/32
Accept in part
463/33
Accept in part
463/34
Accept in part
463/35
Accept in part
463/36
Accept in part
463/37
Accept in part
463/38
Accept in part
463/39
Accept in part
51/1
Kay, Fay
Accept in part
52/2
Kay, Fay
Reject
FS604[52] - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees (Support)
158/1
Keay, D G
Accept in part
158/2
Keay, D G
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 41
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
161/1
Keay, Jocelyn
Accept in part
161/2
Keay, Jocelyn
Reject
136/1
Kehely, Trevor
Accept in part
136/2
Kehely, Trevor
Reject
60/1
Kelly Family Trust, Derek and Kathleen
Reject
231/1
Kelly, June
Reject
231/2
Kelly, June
Reject
231/3
Kelly, June
Accept in part
323/1
Kemp, Harry
Accept in part
323/2
Kemp, Harry
Reject
323/3
Kemp, Harry
Reject
323/4
Kemp, Harry
Accept
323/5
Kemp, Harry
Reject
323/6
Kemp, Harry
Reject
323/7
Kemp, Harry
Reject
323/8
Kemp, Harry
Reject
109/1
Kerrigan, Graham
Accept in part
109/2
Kerrigan, Graham
Reject
402/1
Knox, Colin
Accept in part
427/1
Knox, Freda Alice
Reject
419/1
Konings, Ethel
Reject
105/1
Laker, Colin
Accept in part
105/2
Laker, Colin
Reject
355/1
Lardner, Michael and Beverley
Accept in part
355/2
Reject
355/3
Reject
355/4
Accept
355/5
Reject
355/6
Reject
355/7
Reject
355/8
Reject
546/1
Latimer, Barry Thomas
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 42
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
546/2
Latimer, Barry Thomas
Reject
410/1
Lau, Diana
Accept in part
410/2
Lau, Diana
Reject
41/1
Le Gallais, Leddra Martin
Reject
156/1
Leabourn, Maxwell Charles
Reject
156/2
Accept in part
156/3
Accept
156/4
Reject
19/1
Leaf, Julia
Accept in part
19/2
Leaf, Julia
Reject
380/1
Leaf, Philip Bruce
Reject
351/1
Lees, Tom
Accept in part
351/2
Lees, Tom
Reject
351/3
Lees, Tom
Reject
351/4
Lees, Tom
Accept
351/5
Lees, Tom
Reject
351/6
Lees, Tom
Reject
351/7
Lees, Tom
Reject
351/8
Lees, Tom
Reject
351/9
Lees, Tom
Reject
89/1
Leeves, John Ronald
Reject
246/1
Legarth, F J (John) and Marlen
Accept in part
246/2
Accept in part
246/3
Reject
246/4
Reject
246/5
Accept
246/6
Reject
246/7
Reject
246/8
Reject
246/9
Reject
245/1
Legarth, Larson
Accept in part
245/2
Legarth, Larson
Reject
245/3
Legarth, Larson
Accept in part
245/4
Legarth, Larson
Reject
245/5
Legarth, Larson
Reject
245/6
Legarth, Larson
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 43
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
245/7
Legarth, Larson
Reject
245/8
Legarth, Larson
Reject
245/9
Legarth, Larson
Reject
245/10
Legarth, Larson
Reject
500/1
Legarth, Olivia
Reject
500/2
Legarth, Olivia
Accept in part
500/3
Legarth, Olivia
Accept in part
500/4
Legarth, Olivia
Accept in part
500/5
Legarth, Olivia
Accept in part
500/6
Legarth, Olivia
Reject
500/7
Legarth, Olivia
Reject
500/8
Legarth, Olivia
Reject
500/9
Legarth, Olivia
Reject
500/10
Legarth, Olivia
Reject
500/11
Legarth, Olivia
Accept
249/1
Li Liangren Family Trust
Accept
249/2
Accept
249/3
Accept
249/4
Accept
238/1
Light House Lodge
Accept in part
238/2
Light House Lodge
Accept in part
200/1
Lindar Downs Limited
Reject
200/2
Lindar Downs Limited
Reject
307/1
Linder Downs Ltd
Accept in part
307/2
Linder Downs Ltd
Reject
307/3
Linder Downs Ltd
Reject
307/4
Linder Downs Ltd
Accept
307/5
Linder Downs Ltd
Reject
307/6
Linder Downs Ltd
Reject
307/7
Linder Downs Ltd
Reject
307/8
Linder Downs Ltd
Reject
257/1
Linthicum, Darwin
Reject
338/1
Linton, David
Accept in part
338/2
Linton, David
Reject
338/3
Linton, David
Reject
338/4
Linton, David
Accept
338/5
Linton, David
Reject
338/6
Linton, David
Reject
338/7
Linton, David
Reject
338/8
Linton, David
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 44
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
369/1
Lisa Sellar, Aaron de Iange
Accept in part
369/2
Reject
369/3
Reject
369/4
Accept
369/5
Reject
369/6
Reject
369/7
Reject
369/8
Reject
468/1
Littlejohn, Kenneth W
Reject
222/1
Loftus, Beverly
Accept in part
222/2
Loftus, Beverly
Reject
332/1
Ludvigson, Tanya
Accept in part
332/2
Ludvigson, Tanya
Reject
332/3
Ludvigson, Tanya
Accept in part
332/4
Ludvigson, Tanya
Accept
332/5
Ludvigson, Tanya
Reject
332/6
Ludvigson, Tanya
Reject
332/7
Ludvigson, Tanya
Reject
332/8
Ludvigson, Tanya
Reject
332/9
Ludvigson, Tanya
Reject
293/1
Lulich, Leonard S
Accept in part
293/2
Lulich, Leonard S
Reject
293/3
Lulich, Leonard S
Reject
293/4
Lulich, Leonard S
Accept
293/5
Lulich, Leonard S
Reject
293/6
Lulich, Leonard S
Reject
293/7
Lulich, Leonard S
Reject
293/8
Lulich, Leonard S
Reject
285/1
Lupton, Ian Christopher
Accept in part
285/2
Reject
285/3
Reject
285/4
Accept
285/5
Reject
285/6
Reject
285/7
Reject
285/8
Reject
361/1
Lusty, David James
Accept in part
361/2
Lusty, David James
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 45
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
361/3
Lusty, David James
Reject
361/4
Lusty, David James
Accept
361/5
Lusty, David James
Reject
361/6
Lusty, David James
Reject
361/7
Lusty, David James
Reject
361/8
Lusty, David James
Reject
107/1
Lyne, Brendan Charles Daniel
Accept in Part
107/2
Lyne, Brendan Charles Daniel
Accept in Part
195/1
Mace, Megan and Andy
Reject
286/1
MacLean Partnership, Cameron MacLean
Reject
286/2
Reject
286/3
Accept
286/4
Accept in part
286/5
MacLean Partnership
Reject
286/6
Reject
286/7
Accept
286/8
MacLean Partnership
Reject
286/9
Reject
286/10
MacLean Partnership
Reject
286/11
MacLean Partnership
Reject
287/1
MacLean, Angus
Accept in part
287/2
MacLean, Angus
Reject
287/3
MacLean, Angus
Reject
287/4
MacLean, Angus
Accept
287/5
MacLean, Angus
Reject
287/6
MacLean, Angus
Reject
287/7
MacLean, Angus
Reject
287/8
MacLean, Angus
Reject
152/1
MacMillan, Alison
Reject
152/2
MacMillan, Alison
Accept in part
174/1
Mahuta Community Water Supply Association Ltd
Accept in part
174/2
Accept in part
174/3
Accept in part
174/4
Reject
174/5
Reject
174/6
Accept
174/7
Reject
174/8
Reject
174/9
Reject
174/10
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 46
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
389/1
Malam, Anne Marie
Accept in part
389/2
Malam, Anne Marie
Reject
389/3
Malam, Anne Marie
Reject
389/4
Malam, Anne Marie
Accept
389/5
Malam, Anne Marie
Reject
389/6
Malam, Anne Marie
Reject
389/7
Malam, Anne Marie
Reject
389/8
Malam, Anne Marie
Reject
484/1
Mangawhai Ratepayers and Residents Association
Reject
484/2
Reject
484/3
Accept
484/4
Reject
484/5
Accept
484/6
Reject
484/7
Reject
484/8
Mangawhai Residents and Ratepayers Association
Accept
484/9
Mangawhai Residents and Ratepayers Association
Accept
484/10
Reject
484/11
Reject
484/12
Accept
FS604/41 - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees (Oppose)
484/13
Accept
484/14
Accept
484/15
Reject
484/16
Accept
484/17
Accept
484/18
Accept in part
484/19
Accept
484/20
Accept
484/21
Accept
484/22
Accept
484/23
Reject
484/24
Reject
484/25
Reject
484/26
Reject
484/27
Reject
484/28
Reject
484/29
Reject
484/30
Reject
484/31
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 47
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
484/32
Reject
484/33
Reject
484/34
Reject
484/35
Reject
484/36
Reject
484/37
Reject
484/38
Reject
484/39
Accept in part
484/40
Accept in part
93/1
Mannix, Mike
Accept in part
93/2
Mannix, Mike
Reject
94/1
Mannix, Valerie
Accept in part
94/2
Mannix, Valerie
Reject
301/1
Manson, Ngaire Mirabel
Accept in part
301/2
Reject
301/3
Reject
301/4
Accept
301/5
Reject
301/6
Reject
301/7
Reject
301/8
Reject
343/1
Martin, Graeme and Trudi-Anne
Accept in part
343/2
Reject
343/3
Reject
343/4
Accept
343/5
Reject
343/6
Reject
343/7
Reject
343/8
Reject
378/1
Marunui Conservation Ltd
Accept in part
378/2
Accept
378/3
Accept in part
378/4
Accept in part
378/5
Accept in part
378/6
Accept in part
378/7
Accept in part
378/8
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 48
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
378/9
Accept in part
378/10
Accept in part
378/11
Accept in part
378/12
Accept in part
378/13
Accept in part
378/14
Accept in part
378/15
Accept in part
378/16
Reject
378/17
Reject
378/18
Reject
378/19
Marunui Conservation Ltd.
Reject
378/20
Reject
378/21
Reject
378/22
Accept in part
378/23
Reject
378/24
Accept in part
378/25
Accept in part
378/26
Accept in part
378/27
Reject
378/28
Accept in part
378/29
Accept in part
378/30
Reject
378/31
Accept in part
378/32
Accept in part
378/33
Reject
378/34
Accept
378/35
Accept in part
378/36
Reject
378/37
Reject
378/38
Reject
378/39
Accept in part
378/40
Accept in part
378/44
Accept in part
378/45
Accept in part
378/46
Accept in part
378/47
Accept in part
378/48
Accept in part
378/49
Reject
378/50
Accept in part
378/51
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 49
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
378/52
Accept in part
378/53
Accept in part
378/54
Reject
378/55
Accept in part
378/56
Accept in part
378/57
Reject
378/58
Accept in part
378/59
Reject
378/60
Reject
378/61
Reject
378/62
Reject
378/63
Reject
378/64
Reject
378/65
Reject
378/66
Reject
378/67
Accept
378/68
Accept in part
378/69
Accept in part
378/70
Reject
378/71
Reject
179/1
Matheson, Noeline Ann
Accept in part
256/1
Mathhew Bradbury, Alison Stillwell
Reject
244/1
Maude, Cynthia Joy
Accept in part
244/2
Maude, Cynthia Joy
Accept in part
244/3
Maude, Cynthia Joy
Accept in part
244/4
Maude, Cynthia Joy
Reject
449/1
Maurie, Graham Neil Kenneth
Accept
449/2
Accept
449/3
Reject
449/4
Reject
449/5
Accept in part
449/6
Reject
449/7
Reject
382/1
McCahon, Allister D and A Maree
Accept in part
382/2
Reject
382/3
Reject
335/1
McCarthy, Douglas James and Neto Barbara
Accept in part
335/2
Reject
335/3
Reject
335/4
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 50
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
335/5
Reject
335/6
Reject
335/7
Reject
335/8
Reject
335/9
Accept in part
87/1
McConell, Alfred William
Accept in part
87/2
McConell, Alfred William
Reject
86/1
McConell, Judith Mary
Accept in part
86/2
McConell, Judith Mary
Reject
511/1
McDermott, Terrence
Accept
511/2
McDermott, Terrence
Accept
511/3
McDermott, Terence
Reject
366/1
McEvoy, R J and A
Accept in part
366/2
McEvoy, R J and A
Reject
366/3
McEvoy, R J and A
Reject
366/4
McEvoy, R J and A
Accept
366/5
McEvoy, R J and A
Reject
366/6
McEvoy, R J and A
Reject
366/7
McEvoy, R J and A
Reject
366/8
McEvoy, R J and A
Reject
384/1
McGillivray, Andrew and Christine
Reject
384/2
McGillivray, Andrew and Christine
Accept in part
554/1
McKinnon, Ian Donald
Accept in part
85/1
McQuinlan, Katrina
Accept in part
85/2
McQuinlan, Katrina
Reject
291/1
McShane, Owen
Reject
291/2
McShane, Owen
Reject
291/3
McShane, Owen
Reject
291/4
McShane, Owen
Reject
291/5
McShane, Owen
Accept in part
291/6
McShane, Owen
Reject
291/7
McShane, Owen
Reject
486/1
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/2
Meridian Energy Ltd
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 51
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
486/3
Meridian Energy Ltd
Reject
486/4
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept
486/5
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/6
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/7
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/8
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/9
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/10
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/11
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/12
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/13
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
FS575/11 - Hawley, Catherine and John – Oppose
486/14
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/15
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/16
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept
486/17
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/18
Meridian Energy Ltd
Reject
FSFS575/14 - Hawley, Catherine and John - Oppose
FSFS576/14 - Friends of the Brynderwyns Society Incorporated - Oppose
486/19
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept
486/20
Meridian Energy Ltd
Reject
486/21
Meridian Energy Ltd
Reject
486/22
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/23
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/24
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/25
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
486/26
Meridian Energy Ltd
Accept in part
30/1
Meyer, Mark William
Reject
111/1
Michael, Joe
Accept in part
111/2
Michael, Joe
Reject
311/1
Midgley, Steve and Lynette
Accept in part
311/2
Reject
311/3
Reject
311/4
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 52
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
311/5
Reject
311/6
Reject
311/7
Reject
311/8
Reject
312/1
Midgley, Tyron and Sarah
Accept in part
312/2
Reject
312/3
Reject
312/4
Accept
312/5
Reject
312/6
Reject
312/7
Reject
312/8
Reject
401/1
Milich, Clem
Accept in part
73/1
Millar, Jessie
Accept in part
73/2
Millar, Jessie
Reject
278/1
Miller, James Wynard
Accept in part
278/2
Reject
278/3
Reject
278/4
Accept
278/5
Reject
278/6
Reject
278/7
Reject
278/8
Reject
279/1
Miller, Shirley Dawn
Accept in part
279/2
Reject
279/3
Reject
279/4
Accept
279/5
Reject
279/6
Reject
279/7
Reject
279/8
Reject
113/1
Miller, Todd
Accept in part
113/2
Miller, Todd
Reject
490/1
Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry
Accept in part
516/1
Morgan, Tracey Lee
Reject
21/1
Morris, Kay
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 53
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
21/2
Morris, Kay
Reject
375/1
Morrison, Margaret
Accept in part
FS573/2 - Pryde, Arthur (Support)
FS587/1 - Morrison, David Max (Support)
FS591/1 - Morrison, Colin Glen (Support)
FS593/3 - Lee, Michael (Support)
FS605/3 - Blackmore, Ross (Support)
169/1
Mulherm, M E
Accept in part
169/2
Mulherm, M E
Reject
169/3
Mulherm, M E
Reject
169/4
Mulherm, M E
Accept
169/5
Mulherm, M E
Reject
169/6
Mulherm, M E
Reject
169/7
Mulherm, M E
Reject
169/8
Mulherm, M E
Reject
329/1
Murphy, Denise-Gae
Accept in part
329/2
Murphy, Denise-Gae
Reject
329/3
Murphy, Denise-Gae
Reject
329/4
Murphy, Denise-Gae
Accept
329/5
Murphy, Denise-Gae
Reject
329/6
Murphy, Denise-Gae
Reject
329/7
Murphy, Denise-Gae
Reject
329/8
Murphy, Denise-Gae
Reject
491/1
Murray, Moengaroa Sharon
Reject
491/2
Reject
491/3
Reject
491/4
Accept
491/5
Reject
491/6
Reject
491/7
Reject
491/8
Reject
491/9
Accept in part
491/10
Reject
142/1
Murray, Reade Patrick
Accept in part
142/2
Reject
142/3
Reject
142/4
Accept
142/5
Reject
142/6
Reject
142/7
Reject
142/8
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 54
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
204/1
Musgrave, Brigette
Accept in part
204/2
Musgrave, Brigette
Reject
534/1
Neale, Richard
Accept in part
534/2
Neale, Richard
Reject
16/1
Neil, Robyn
Accept in part
16/2
Neil, Robyn Patricia
Accept in part
16/3
Accept in part
16/4
Accept in part
46/1
Neil, Sue
Accept in part
46/2
Neil, Sue
Reject
61/1
Nelson, Peter and Ketch
Accept
350/1
Neverfail Family Trust
Accept in part
350/2
Reject
350/3
Reject
350/4
Accept
350/5
Reject
350/6
Reject
350/7
Reject
350/8
Reject
236/1
New Zealand Historic Places Trust
Accept in part
236/2
New Zealand Historic Places Trust
Accept in part
471/1
Nicholas, Kevin and Judy
Accept
FS577/1 - Simpkin, William – Oppose
FS588/1 - Leigh-MacKenzie, Chris - Support
471/2
Nicholas, Kevin and Judy
Accept
FS577/2 - Simpkin, William – Oppose
FS588/2 - Leigh-MacKenzie, Chris - Oppose
407/1
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/2
Nickolson, Dave
Accept in part 2
407/3
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/4
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/5
Nickolson, Dave
Accept in part
407/7
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
2
In that offer of site review was made.
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 55
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
407/8
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/9
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/10
Nickolson, Dave
Accept
407/11
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/12
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/13
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/14
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/15
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/16
Nickolson, Dave
Accept
407/17
Nickolson, Dave
Accept
407/18
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
407/19
Nickolson, Dave
Reject
243/1
Nicoll, Geoffrey
Accept in part
243/2
Nicoll, Geoffrey
Accept in part
498/1
Northland Regional Council
Reject
FS603/1 - Environmental Defence Society Inc. - Support
498/2
Accept In Part
FS589/19 – Farmers of New Zealand Inc - Oppose
498/3
Accept In Part
FS602/13 - Meridian Energy Ltd – Oppose
FS606/20 – Farmers of New Zealand Inc - Oppose
498/4
Reject
FS602/29 - Meridian Energy Ltd – Oppose
498/5
Reject
498/6
Reject
498/7
Accept
498/8
Accept in part
498/9
Reject
FS606/15 - Federated Farmers of New Zealand - Support
498/10
Reject
FS606/16 - Federated Farmers of New Zealand - Support
498/11
Accept in part
FSFS602/30 - Meridian Energy Ltd - Support
498/12
Reject
498/13
Accept in part
498/14
Accept in part
498/15
Accept
498/16
Reject
498/17
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 56
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
498/18
Accept in part
499/1
Northpower Ltd
Accept in part
FS598/1 - Stuart, Helen – Oppose
499/2
Northpower Ltd
Accept in part
FS575/7 - Hawley, Catherine & John - Oppose
FS601/11 - TrustPower Ltd - Support
FS576/7 - Friends of the Brynderwyns Society Inc. - Oppose
FS598/2 - Stuart, Helen - Oppose
499/3
Northpower Ltd
Reject
FS598/3 - Stuart, Helen
499/4
Northpower Ltd
Reject
FS560/5 - Stuart, Ian William - Oppose
499/5
Northpower Ltd
Reject
499/6
Northpower Ltd
Reject
499/7
Northpower Ltd
Reject
FS598/7 - Stuart, Helen
FS560/7 - Stuart, Ian William
499/8
Northpower Ltd
Reject
499/9
Northpower Ltd
Accept in part
499/10
Northpower Ltd
Reject
499/11
Northpower Ltd
Reject
FS602/28 - Meridian Energy Ltd - In part
497/1
NZ Native Forests Reforestation Trust
Accept in part
171/1
Oceanview Mahuta Ltd
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 57
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
171/2
Reject
171/3
Reject
171/4
Accept
171/5
Reject
171/6
Reject
171/7
Reject
171/8
Reject
33/1
O'Conner, Erin
Accept in part
33/2
O'Conner, Erin
Reject
197/1
O'Connor, Alwyn
Accept in part
197/2
O'Connor, Alwyn
Reject
196/1
O'Connor, Helen Beatrice
Accept in part
196/2
Reject
196/3
Accept
434/1
O'Connor, Huw
Accept in part
434/2
O'Connor, Huw
Reject
292/1
Oneriri Land Holdings Ltd
Accept
191/1
Onewa Estate Limited
Accept in Part
191/2
Accept in part
191/2
Accept in part
191/3
Accept in Part
191/4
Reject
191/5
Reject
191/6
Accept
69/1
Osbaldiston, Lynette Ann
Accept in part
420/1
O'Sullivan, Emma
Accept in part
420/2
O'Sullivan, Emma
Reject
360/1
O'Sullivan, Paul
Accept in part
360/2
O'Sullivan, Paul
Reject
319/1
Otway, Brian Kay
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 58
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
319/2
Otway, Brian Kay
Reject
319/3
Otway, Brian Kay
Reject
319/4
Otway, Brian Kay
Accept
319/5
Otway, Brian Kay
Reject
319/6
Otway, Brian Kay
Reject
319/7
Otway, Brian Kay
Reject
319/8
Otway, Brian Kay
Reject
115/1
Ovesen, Vicki
Accept in part
115/2
Ovesen, Vicki
Reject
487/1
Paerata-Hart, Marilee Herat
Accept in Part
487/1
Paerata-Hart, Marilee Herat
Accept in Part
315/2
Painanui Farm Ltd
Accept
315/3
Painanui Farm Ltd
Accept
315/5
Painanui Farm Ltd
Reject
316/6
Painanui Farm Ltd
Reject
315/1
Painanui Farm Ltd
Accept
315/4
Painanui Farm Ltd.
Reject
119/1
Paine, Robin George Porter
Reject
134/1
Palmer Shanahan, Margaret, Brain, Kate and Jeremy
Reject
134/2
Palmer Shanahan, Margaret, Brian, Kate and Jeremy
Reject
216/1
Parker, Scott
Accept in part
216/2
Parker, Scott
Reject
342/1
Parsons, Eric and Jillian
Accept in part
342/2
Reject
342/3
Reject
342/4
Accept
342/5
Reject
342/6
Reject
342/7
Reject
342/8
Reject
57/1
Paterson, Cam
Accept in part
57/2
Paterson, Cam
Reject
56/1
Paterson, Carol Lynne
Accept in part
56/2
Paterson, Carol Lynne
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 59
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
553/1
Paterson, CR and CL
Accept in part
553/2
Paterson, CR and CL
Reject
553/3
Paterson, CR and CL
Reject
553/4
Paterson, CR and CL
Accept
553/5
Paterson, CR and CL
Reject
553/6
Paterson, CR and CL
Reject
553/7
Paterson, CR and CL
Reject
553/8
Paterson, CR and CL
Reject
55/1
Paterson, Ken
Accept in part
55/2
Paterson, Ken
Reject
53/1
Paterson, Scott
Accept in part
53/2
Paterson, Scott
Reject
54/1
Paterson, Varina
Accept in part
54/2
Paterson, Varina
Reject
207/1
Paton, A H
Accept in part
FS604/161 - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees
207/2
Paton, A H
Reject
207/3
Paton, A H
Reject
FS604/163 - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees – Support
205/1
Paton, Barry
Accept in part
205/2
Paton, Barry
Reject
205/3
Paton, Barry
FS604/312 – Thomas Coates Estate Trustees
No Decision
Sought
247/1
Percy, Rachel
Accept
247/2
Percy, Rachel
Accept
247/3
Percy, Rachel
Accept
28/1
Pettit, Martyn Charles
Accept in part
31/1
Pilbrow, Elizabeth Coates
Accept in part
190/1
Pirie, James and Stephanie
Reject
190/2
Reject
190/3
Accept in part
190/4
Reject
190/5
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 60
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
190/6
Accept
190/7
Reject
190/8
Reject
190/9
Reject
190/10
Reject
59/1
Plooy, Steven Phillip
Reject
274/1
Poole, Raymond George
Accept in part
274/2
Reject
274/3
Reject
274/4
Accept
274/5
Reject
274/6
Reject
274/7
Reject
274/8
Reject
438/1 & 438/3
Pouto Topu A Trust
No decision
sought
438/2
Pouto Topu A Trust
Reject
438/4
Pouto Topu A Trust
Reject
438/5
Pouto Topu A Trust
Accept in part
438/6
Pouto Topu A Trust
Accept in part
FS589/18 - Farmers of New Zealand - Support
371/1
Preston, Alan
Accept
371/2
Preston, Alan
Accept
371/3
Preston, Alan
Reject
371/4
Preston, Alan
Accept
371/5
Preston, Alan
Reject
371/6
Preston, Alan
Reject
371/7
Preston, Alan
Reject
371/8
Preston, Alan
Reject
371/9
Preston, Alan
Accept in part
371/10
Preston, Alan
Accept in part
371/11
Preston, Alan
Reject
371/12
Preston, Alan
Reject
FS589/30 - Farmers of New Zealand Inc - Oppose
371/13
Preston, Alan
Reject
148/1
Property Applications NZ Ltd
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 61
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
386/1
Pryde, Arthur
Accept in part
FS572/2 - Hayes, Joanna - Support
FS581/2 - Little, Pamela - Support
FS593/2 - Lee, Michael - Support
FS605/2 - Blackmore, Ross - Support
27/1
Pryde, Gordon
Accept in part
FS567/1 - Pryde, William (Support)
FS568/1 - Grant, Ronald Hugh (Support)
FS572/1 - Hayes, Joanna (Support)
FS579/1 - Pryde, Sandra (Support)
FS581/1 - Little, Pamela (Support)
FS593/1 - Lee, Michael (Support)
FS605/1 - Blackmore, Ross (Support)
494/1
Puharich, Nicola Margaret
Accept in part
494/2
Reject
494/3
Accept in part
494/4
Reject
494/5
Accept in part
494/6
Accept in part
494/7
Accept
494/8
Accept in part
494/9
Reject
494/10
Accept in part
494/11
Accept
494/12
Accept
139/1
Pukepohatu Association
Accept
FS 604/219 - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees (Oppose)
139/2
Pukepohatu Association
Reject
FS604/220 - Thomas Coates Estate Trustees - Oppose
314/1
Puoto Farms Ltd
Accept in part
314/2
Puoto Farms Ltd
Reject
314/3
Puoto Farms Ltd
Reject
314/4
Puoto Farms Ltd
Accept
314/5
Puoto Farms Ltd
Reject
314/6
Puoto Farms Ltd
Reject
314/7
Puoto Farms Ltd
Reject
314/8
Puoto Farms Ltd
Reject
314/9
Puoto Farms Ltd
Accept in part
127/1
Reddy, Adrian
Accept in part
127/2
Reddy, Adrian
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 62
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
261/1
Reddy, Adrian and Elaine
Accept in part
328/1
Reed, Douglas
Accept in part
328/2
Reed, Douglas
Reject
328/3
Reed, Douglas
Reject
328/4
Reed, Douglas
Accept
328/5
Reed, Douglas
Reject
328/6
Reed, Douglas
Reject
328/7
Reed, Douglas
Reject
328/8
Reed, Douglas
Reject
357/1
Reid, R T S
Accept in part
357/2
Reid, R T S
Reject
357/3
Reid, R T S
Reject
357/4
Reid, R T S
Accept
357/5
Reid, R T S
Reject
357/6
Reid, R T S
Reject
357/7
Reid, R T S
Reject
357/8
Reid, R T S
Reject
77/1
Rimmer, Bernie
Accept in part
77/2
Rimmer, Bernie
Reject
78/1
Rimmer, Glennis
Accept in part
78/2
Rimmer, Glennis
Reject
379/1
Roadley, Rex
Reject
379/2
Roadley, Rex
Reject
184/1
Robertson, James and Sandy
Accept
184/2
Robertson, James and Sandy
Accept in Part
368/1
Robinson, Asa
Accept in part
368/2
Robinson, Asa
Reject
368/3
Robinson, Asa
Reject
368/4
Robinson, Asa
Accept
368/5
Robinson, Asa
Reject
368/6
Robinson, Asa
Reject
368/7
Robinson, Asa
Reject
368/8
Robinson, Asa
Reject
368/9
Robinson, Asa
Accept
412/1
Robinson, Derek
Accept in part
379/3
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 63
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
336/1
Robinson, Derek and Patricia
Accept in part
336/2
Reject
336/3
Reject
336/4
Accept
336/5
Reject
336/6
Reject
336/7
Reject
336/8
Reject
234/1
Robinson, Harold and Raewyn
Accept in part
234/2
Robinson, Harold and Raewyn
Accept in part
138/1
Robinson, Paula
Accept
276/1
Robinson, Perrin
Accept in part
276/2
Robinson, Perrin
Reject
276/3
Robinson, Perrin
Reject
276/4
Robinson, Perrin
Accept
276/5
Robinson, Perrin
Reject
276/6
Robinson, Perrin
Reject
276/7
Robinson, Perrin
Reject
276/8
Robinson, Perrin
Reject
276/9
Robinson, Perrin
Accept
101/1
Robinson, Raelene
Accept in part
101/2
Robinson, Raelene
Reject
208/1
Rodgers, Neil and Sarah
Accept in part
208/2
Rodgers, Neil and Sarah
Reject
40/33
Rogers, Eileen Valarie
Accept in part
40/4
Rogers, Eileen Valarie
Reject
250/1
Rogers, Nona
Accept in part
250/2
Rogers, Nona
Reject
250/3
Rogers, Nona
Accept in part
3
Submission Point numbering starts at 40/3
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 64
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
206/1
Rogers, Roy John
Accept in part
206/2
Rogers, Roy John
Reject
388/1
Ross, Angus and Sharon
Accept in part
388/2
Reject
388/3
Reject
388/4
Accept
388/5
Reject
388/6
Reject
388/7
Reject
388/8
Reject
466/1
Rountree, Kelvin Bruce
Reject
466/2
Rountree, Kelvin Bruce
Accept in part
465/1
Rowbotham, Mark Watson
Accept
465/2
Accept
465/3
Reject
465/4
Reject
465/5
Accept in part
465/5
Accept in part
465/6
Reject
465/7
Reject
22/1
Rowe, Graeme and Pam
Accept in part
337/1
Ruiterman, A T
Accept in part
337/2
Ruiterman, A T
Reject
337/3
Ruiterman, A T
Reject
337/4
Ruiterman, A T
Accept
337/5
Ruiterman, A T
Reject
337/6
Ruiterman, A T
Reject
337/7
Ruiterman, A T
Reject
337/8
Ruiterman, A T
Reject
96/1
Russell, Ian
Accept in part
96/2
Russell, Ian
Reject
96/3
Russell, Ian
Reject
96/4
Russell, Ian
Accept
96/5
Russell, Ian
Reject
96/6
Russell, Ian
Reject
96/7
Russell, Ian
Reject
96/8
Russell, Ian
Reject
239/1
Russell, Keith Ernest
Accept in part
239/2
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 65
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
239/3
Reject
239/4
Reject
239/5
Accept
239/6
Reject
239/7
Reject
239/8
Reject
239/9
Reject
82/1
Salvigny, Brian
Accept in part
82/2
Salvigny, Brian
Reject
75/1
Salvigny, Gary
Accept in part
75/2
Salvigny, Gary
Reject
372/1
Sandford, Alan Paul
No decision
sought
372/2
Sandford, Alan Paul
Accept in part
372/3
Sandford, Alan Paul
Accept in Part
372/4
Sandford, Alan Paul
Accept in Part
548/1
Sands, Phill
Accept in part
548/2
Sands, Phill
Reject
304/1
Sapiatzer, Peter
Accept in part
304/2
Sapiatzer, Peter
Reject
304/3
Sapiatzer, Peter
Reject
304/4
Sapiatzer, Peter
Accept
304/5
Sapiatzer, Peter
Reject
304/6
Sapiatzer, Peter
Reject
304/7
Sapiatzer, Peter
Reject
304/8
Sapiatzer, Peter
Reject
310/1
Savage, Keith and Velma
Accept in part
310/2
Reject
310/3
Reject
310/4
Accept
310/5
Reject
310/6
Reject
310/7
Reject
310/8
Reject
310/9
Reject
538/1
Schick, Gordon (Gus)
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 66
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
538/2
Reject
538/3
Accept
538/3
Accept
303/1
Schmist-Sapiatzer, Sabine
Accept in part
303/2
Reject
303/3
Reject
303/4
Accept
303/5
Reject
303/6
Reject
303/7
Reject
303/8
Reject
303/9
Accept
550/1
Schultz, Ben
Accept in part
550/2
Schultz, Ben
Reject
549/1
Schultz, Jennie
Accept in part
549/2
Schultz, Jennie
Reject
551/1
Schultz, L A
Accept in part
551/2
Schultz, L A
Reject
547/1
Schultz, Ralph Fredrick
Accept in part
547/2
Schultz, Ralph Fredrick
Reject
106/1
Seddon, David
Accept in part
106/2
Seddon, David
Reject
3/1
Sellars, Chris
Accept in part
3/2
Sellars, Chris
Reject
3/3
Sellars, Chris
Reject
3/4
Sellars, Chris
Accept
3/5
Sellars, Chris
Reject
3/6
Sellars, Chris
Reject
3/7
Sellars, Chris
Reject
3/8
Sellars, Chris
Reject
3/9
Sellars, Chris
Accept in part
359/1
Sharp, Richard
Accept in part
359/2
Sharp, Richard
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 67
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
359/3
Sharp, Richard
Reject
405/1
Shearer, Craig
Reject
405/2
Shearer, Craig
Reject
FS602/17 - Meridian Energy Ltd (In Part)
405/3
Shearer, Craig
Accept
405/4
Shearer, Craig
Reject
405/5
Shearer, Craig
Accept in Part
405/5
Shearer, Craig
Accept in part
405/6
Shearer, Craig
Reject
404/1
Sidwell, Craig
Reject
404/2
Sidwell, Craig
Reject
404/3
Sidwell, Craig
Reject
404/4
Sidwell, Craig
Accept
404/5
Sidwell, Craig
Reject
404/5
Sidwell, Craig
Reject
404/6
Sidwell, Craig
Reject
404/7
Sidwell, Craig
Reject
404/8
Sidwell, Craig
Reject
273/1
Sidwell, Penelope Mae
Accept in part
273/2
Reject
273/3
Reject
273/4
Accept
273/5
Reject
273/6
Reject
273/7
Reject
273/8
Reject
173/1
Sills, Val Winston
Accept in part
173/2
Sills, Val Winston
Reject
173/3
Sills, Val Winston
Reject
173/4
Sills, Val Winston
Accept
173/5
Sills, Val Winston
Reject
173/6
Sills, Val Winston
Reject
173/7
Sills, Val Winston
Reject
173/8
Sills, Val Winston
Reject
457/1
Simpkin, Jonathan
Accept in part
507/1
Simpkin, Stephen
Reject
507/2
Simpkin, Stephen
Reject
194/1
Smith, Clive McLaren
Accept
194/2
Smith, Clive McLaren
Accept
70/1
Smith, Edward John
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 68
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
70/2
Smith, Edward John
Reject
FS575/16 - Hawley, Catherine and John – Oppose
70/3
Smith, Edward John
Reject
70/4
Smith, Edward John
Reject
70/5
Smith, Edward John
Accept in part
70/6
Smith, Edward John
Reject
70/7
Smith, Edward John
Reject
70/8
Smith, Edward John
Accept
70/9
Smith, Edward John
Reject
70/10
Smith, Edward John
Reject
70/11
Smith, Edward John
Reject
70/12
Smith, Edward John
Reject
116/1
Smith, Georgie
Accept in part
116/2
Smith, Georgie
Reject
321/1
Smith, Kevin and Merilyn
Accept in part
321/2
Reject
321/3
Reject
321/4
Accept
321/5
Reject
321/6
Reject
321/7
Reject
321/8
Reject
203/1
Smith, Merilyn
Reject
203/2
Smith, Merilyn
Accept in Part
120/1
Sommerville, Carolyn Louise
Accept in part
120/2
Sommerville, Carolyn Louise
Reject
64/1
Sommerville, Marcus
Accept in part
64/2
Sommerville, Marcus
Reject
408/1
Sommerville, Monika and John
Reject
408/2
Sommerville, Monika and John
Accept
472/1
Sowter, Kevin
Reject
95/1
Staff, Linda
Accept in part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 69
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
95/2
Staff, Linda
Reject
460/1
Starr, John
Accept in part
143/1
Steiner, Marjory and Frank
Accept in part
143/2
Reject
143/3
Reject
143/4
Accept
143/5
Reject
143/6
Reject
143/7
Reject
143/8
Reject
143/9
Accept in part
448/1
Stevens, Gary
Accept in Part t
275/1
Stevens, Gary
Accept in Part
275/2
Stevens, Gary
Reject
241/1
Stevens, Grant Richard
Accept in part
300/1
Stopher, Allan
Accept in part
300/2
Stopher, Allan
Reject
300/3
Stopher, Allan
Reject
300/4
Stopher, Allan
Accept
300/5
Stopher, Allan
Reject
300/6
Stopher, Allan
Reject
300/7
Stopher, Allan
Reject
300/8
Stopher, Allan
Reject
32/1
Stratford, G.
Accept in part
32/2
Stratford, G.
Reject
81/1
Stuart, Ian William
Accept in part
81/2
Stuart, Ian William
Reject
81/3
Stuart, Ian William
Accept in part
81/4
Stuart, Ian William
Reject
81/5
Stuart, Ian William
Reject
81/6
Stuart, Ian William
Reject
324/1
Subritzky, Desmond
Accept in part
324/2
Subritzky, Desmond
Reject
324/3
Subritzky, Desmond
Reject
324/4
Subritzky, Desmond
Accept
324/5
Subritzky, Desmond
Reject
324/6
Subritzky, Desmond
Reject
324/7
Subritzky, Desmond
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 70
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
324/8
Subritzky, Desmond
Reject
345/1
Tantrum, Trevor and Avirl
Accept in part
345/2
Reject
345/3
Reject
345/4
Accept
345/5
Reject
345/6
Reject
345/7
Reject
345/8
Reject
330/1
Taurua, Bernice
Accept in part
330/2
Taurua, Bernice
Reject
330/3
Taurua, Bernice
Reject
330/4
Taurua, Bernice
Accept
330/5
Taurua, Bernice
Reject
330/6
Taurua, Bernice
Reject
330/7
Taurua, Bernice
Reject
330/8
Taurua, Bernice
Reject
403/1
Taurua, Colin
Reject
403/2
Taurua, Colin
Reject
72/1
Tawharu, Anna
Accept in part
72/2
Tawharu, Anna
Reject
154/1
Taylor, Joan Eva
Reject
154/2
Taylor, Joan Eva
Reject
154/3
Taylor, Joan Eva
Accept in part
154/4
Taylor, Joan Eva
Reject
154/5
Taylor, Joan Eva
Reject
154/6
Taylor, Joan Eva
Accept
154/7
Taylor, Joan Eva
Reject
154/8
Taylor, Joan Eva
Reject
154/9
Taylor, Joan Eva
Reject
154/10
Taylor, Joan Eva
Reject
202/1
Taylor, Leslie James
Accept
202/2
Reject
FS575/18 - Hawley, Catherine and John (Oppose)
FS576/18 - Friends of the Brynderwyns Society Incorporated (Oppose)
202/3
4
Accept in Part4
Recognition of cross boundary issues with Whangarei District Council.
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 71
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
202/4
Reject
515/1
Te Roroa Whatu Ora Trust
Accept
515/3
Reject
515/4
Te Roroa Whatua Ora Trust
Reject
515/5
Reject
515/6
Reject
515/7
Accept in part
515/8
Reject
515/9
Reject
515/10
Reject
515/11
Te Roroa Whatua Ora Trust
Accept in part
515/12
Accept in part
515/13
Accept
374/1
Te Runanga O Ngati Whatua
Reject
374/2
Te Runanga O Ngati Whatua
Reject
374/3
Te Runanga o Ngati Whatua
Reject
514/1
Te Uri o Hau Incorporated
Accept in part
514/2
Reject
514/3
Reject
514/4
Accept
514/5
Reject
514/6
Reject
514/7
Reject
514/8
Reject
514/9
Te Uri o Hau Inc.
Accept in Part
9/1
Templar, Bernard and Jenny
Accept in part
512/1
The Bream Tail Residents Association
Reject
512/2
Reject
512/3
Reject
513/1
The Welch Investment Trust
Reject
508/1
Theobald, Stephen John
Accept in part
508/2
Accept in part
508/3
Reject
518/1
Thomas Coates Estate Trustees : Ward, Wayne
Reject
518/2
Thomas Coates Estate Trustees
Reject
518/3
Reject
518/5
No decision
sought
518/6
Thomas Coates Estate Trustees : Ward, Wayne
Reject
518/7
Accept in part
518/4
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 72
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
518/8
Accept in part
518/9
Accept in part
518/10
Accept in part
518/11
Reject
518/12
Reject
518/13
Reject
409/1
Thomson, David Ronald
Accept in part
409/2
Thomson, David Ronald
Reject
446/1
Toia, Harerei and others
Reject
182/1
Toko, Francis George
Reject
121/1
Torr, Anna
Accept in part
121/2
Torr, Anna
Reject
122/1
Torr, Craig
Accept in part
122/2
Torr, Craig
Reject
523/1
Transition Town Kaiwaka
Reject
523/2
Reject
523/3
Reject
523/4
Reject
523/5
Reject
523/6
Accept in part
517/1
Transpower NZ Ltd
Accept in part
517/2
Transpower NZ Ltd
Accept in part
517/3
Transpower NZ Ltd
Reject
517/4
Transpower NZ Ltd
Accept in part
517/5
Transpower NZ Ltd
Accept in part
517/6
Transpower NZ Ltd
Accept in part
517/7
Transpower NZ Ltd
Accept in part
517/8
Transpower NZ Ltd
Reject
517/9
Transpower NZ Ltd
Reject
517/10
Transpower NZ Ltd
Accept in part
305/1
Tregidga, Reginald Charles
Accept in part
305/2
Reject
305/3
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 73
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
305/4
Accept
305/5
Reject
305/6
Reject
305/7
Reject
305/8
Reject
305/9
Reject
25/1
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/2
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/3
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/4
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/5
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/6
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/7
TrustPower Ltd
Reject
25/8
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/9
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/10
TrustPower Ltd
Accept
25/11
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/12
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/13
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/14
TrustPower Ltd
Reject
25/15
TrustPower Ltd
Accept
25/16
TrustPower Ltd
Reject
25/17
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/18
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/19
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/20
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/21
TrustPower Ltd
Reject
25/22
TrustPower Ltd
Accept
25/23
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/24
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
25/26
TrustPower Ltd
Reject
25/27
TrustPower Ltd
Accept in part
348/1
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Accept in part
348/2
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Reject
348/3
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Reject
348/4
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Accept
348/5
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Reject
348/6
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Reject
348/7
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Reject
348/8
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 74
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
348/9
Tutamoe Farm Trust
Reject
400/1
Underwood, Christine
Accept in part
400/2
Underwood, Christine
Reject
417/1
Underwood, Dwayne
Accept in part
417/2
Underwood, Dwayne
Reject
130/1
Underwood, E C
Accept in part
130/2
Underwood, E C
Reject
421/1
Underwood, Emily
Accept in part
421/2
Underwood, Emily
Reject
210/1
Underwood, Francesca
Accept in part
210/2
Underwood, Francesca
Reject
435/1
Underwood, Harley
Accept in part
435/2
Underwood, Harley
Reject
221/1
Underwood, Karla
Accept in part
221/2
Underwood, Karla
Reject
88/1
Underwood, Kendon
Accept in part
88/2
Underwood, Kendon
Reject
8/1
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
8/2
Underwood, Kenneth
Accept in part
8/3
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
8/4
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
8/5
Underwood, Kenneth
Accept
8/6
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 75
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
8/7
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
8/8
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
8/9
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
8/10
Underwood, Kenneth
Accept in part
8/11
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
8/12
Underwood, Kenneth
Reject
217/1
Underwood, P R
217/2
Underwood, P R
Accept in part
Reject
129/1
Underwood, Rayma
Accept in part
129/2
Underwood, Rayma
Reject
297/1
Underwood, Steven and Fracesca
Accept in part
297/2
Reject
297/3
Reject
297/4
Accept
297/5
Underwood, Steven and Francesca
Reject
297/6
Reject
297/7
Reject
297/8
Reject
209/1
Underwood, Steven E
Accept in part
209/2
Underwood, Steven E
Reject
227/1
Underwood, Troy
Accept in part
227/2
Underwood, Troy
Reject
309/1
Urlich, Lorraine Tereza
Accept in part
309/2
Reject
309/3
Reject
309/4
Accept
309/5
Reject
309/6
Reject
309/7
Reject
309/8
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 76
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
363/1
Vallance, John And Cathy
Accept in part
363/2
Reject
363/3
Reject
363/4
Accept
363/5
Reject
363/6
Reject
363/7
Reject
363/8
Reject
522/1
Vallancey, William
Accept in part
FS566/1 - Vallancey, William - Support
522/2
Vallancey, William
Reject
FS566/2 - Vallancey, William (Support)
522/3
Vallancey, William
Accept in part
522/4
Vallancey, William
Accept in part
522/5
Vallancey, William
Accept in part
FS566/5 - Vallancey, William - Support
318/1
van den Bogaart, Cecelia
Accept in part
318/2
Reject
318/3
Reject
318/4
Accept
318/5
Reject
318/6
Reject
318/7
Reject
318/8
Reject
117/1
Van Rooyen, Steph
Accept in part
117/2
Van Rooyen, Steph
Reject
346/1
Vincent, Reuben
Reject
501/1
Vincent, Robert Marshall
Reject
501/2
Vincent, Robert Marshall
Accept in part
42/1
Vitasovich, Angela
Accept in part
226/1
Waetford, Dezarae
Accept in part
226/2
Waetford, Dezarae
Reject
306/1
Walker, John and Sjannie
Accept in part
306/2
Reject
306/3
Reject
306/4
Accept
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 77
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
306/5
Reject
306/6
Reject
306/7
Reject
306/8
Reject
381/1
Ward, Allison Anne
Accept in part
381/2
Ward, Allison Anne
Reject
381/3
Ward, Allison Anne
Reject
381/4
Ward, Allison Anne
Accept
381/5
Ward, Allison Anne
Reject
381/6
Ward, Allison Anne
Reject
381/7
Ward, Allison Anne
Reject
381/8
Ward, Allison Anne
Reject
399/1
Ward, Chris
Accept in part
399/2
Ward, Chris
Reject
399/3
Ward, Chris
Reject
399/4
Ward, Chris
Accept
399/5
Ward, Chris
Reject
399/6
Ward, Chris
Reject
399/7
Ward, Chris
Reject
399/8
Ward, Chris
Reject
187/1
Ward, Natalie
187/2
Ward, Natalie
Reject
521/1
Ward, Wayne
Reject
521/2
Ward, Wayne
Reject
521/3
Ward, Wayne
Reject
398/1
Waring, Chris and Lorrain
Reject
364/1
Warnes, Stuart
Accept in part
364/2
Warnes, Stuart
Reject
364/3
Warnes, Stuart
Reject
364/4
Warnes, Stuart
Accept
364/5
Warnes, Stuart
Reject
364/6
Warnes, Stuart
Reject
364/7
Warnes, Stuart
Reject
364/8
Warnes, Stuart
Reject
168/1
Watson, Michael Alexander Claude
Accept in part
168/2
Watson, Michael Alexander Claude
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 78
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
91/1
Watt, Kevin Murray
Accept in part5
91/2
Watt, Kevin Murray
Accept in part
141/1
Wattam, Eleanor and Stanton
Accept in part
141/2
Reject
141/3
Reject
141/4
Accept
141/5
Reject
141/6
Reject
141/7
Reject
141/8
Reject
141/9
Reject
131/1
Wattam, Eleanor Jean
Accept in part
131/2
Wattam, Eleanor Jean
Reject
133/1
Wattan, Stan
Accept in part
133/2
Wattan, Stan
Reject
10/1
Whangarei District Council
Accept in part
10/2
Accept in part
10/3
Accept in part
124/1
Whitaker, Alan and Margaret
Accept in part
214/1
Whitburn, Robyn
Accept in part
214/2
Whitburn, Robyn
Reject
367/1
Wilkinson, Peter and Dawn
Accept in part
367/2
Reject
367/3
Reject
367/4
Accept
367/5
Reject
367/6
Reject
367/7
Reject
367/8
Reject
211/1
Willcox, Peter
Accept in part
211/2
Willcox, Peter
Reject
5
Insomuch as the issue and management of pests is recognised in the Plan.
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 79
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
212/1
Willcox, Rita
Accept in part
212/2
Willcox, Rita
Reject
349/1
Williams, Murray
Accept in part
349/2
Williams, Murray
Reject
349/3
Williams, Murray
Reject
349/4
Williams, Murray
Accept
349/5
Williams, Murray
Reject
349/6
Williams, Murray
Reject
349/7
Williams, Murray
Reject
349/8
Williams, Murray
Reject
248/1
Williams, Rachael
Reject
294/1
Williamson, Robert John
Accept in part
294/2
Reject
294/3
Reject
294/4
Accept
294/5
Reject
294/6
Reject
294/7
Reject
294/8
Reject
418/1
Wills, Edward
Reject
418/2
Wills, Edward
Reject
418/3
Wills, Edward
Accept in part
418/4
Wills, Edward
Reject
418/5
Wills, Edward
Reject
418/6
Wills, Edward
Accept
418/7
Wills, Edward
Reject
418/8
Wills, Edward
Reject
418/9
Wills, Edward
Reject
418/10
Wills, Edward
Reject
132/1
Wilson, Peter and Liliam
Accept in part
132/2
Wilson, Peter and Liliam
Reject
298/1
Windy Hill Family Trust
Accept in part
298/2
Reject
298/3
Reject
298/4
Accept
298/5
Reject
298/6
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 80
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
298/7
Reject
298/8
Reject
365/1
Wood, Steven and Susan
Accept in part
365/2
Reject
365/3
Reject
365/4
Accept
365/5
Reject
365/6
Reject
365/7
Reject
365/8
Reject
296/1
Woodcock, Rodney
Accept in part
FS612/1 - Woodcock, Rodney - Oppose
296/2
Woodcock, Rodney
Reject
FS612/2 - Woodcock, Rodney (Oppose)
296/3
Woodcock, Rodney
Reject
296/4
Woodcock, Rodney
Accept
296/5
Woodcock, Rodney
Reject
296/6
Woodcock, Rodney
Reject
296/7
Woodcock, Rodney
Reject
296/8
Woodcock, Rodney
Reject
383/1
Woodcock, Simon and Jones, Maree
Reject
383/2
Reject
383/3
Accept in part
383/4
Reject
383/5
Accept
383/6
Reject
383/7
Reject
383/8
Reject
383/9
Reject
383/10
Accept in part
383/11
Accept in part
313/1
Wordsworth, Stanley James
Accept in part
313/2
Reject
313/3
Reject
313/4
Accept
313/5
Reject
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 81
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3
Submission /
Sub Point
Submitter Name
Decision
313/6
Reject
313/7
Reject
313/8
Reject
1/1
Worsfold, Heath
Reject
1/2
Worsfold, Heath
Accept in part
1/3
Worsfold, Heath
Reject
344/1
Wright, Rawson
Accept in Part
199/1
Wrightson, Michael
Reject
199/2
Wrightson, Michael
Accept in Part
199/3
Wrightson, Michael
Accept in part
39/1
Young, Jennifer Margaret
Accept in part
39/2
Young, Jennifer Margaret
Reject
80/1
Young, Rebecca Diana
Accept in part
80/2
Young, Rebecca Diana
Reject
240/1
Younger, Michael Paul and Cindy May
Accept in Part
Beca // 01 May 2012 // Page 82
4213629 // NZ1-5810101-3 0.3

Submission Point and Decision by Submitter

Transcription

Similar documents

Earth Stove,...Wood Stove parts lists for

2015 wholesale pricebook - Star Spangled Novelties

Scaffold Catalog - Granite Industries

SOUNDCRAFT PRICE LIST JANUARY 2009