“side car” issue - Climate Action Network

“side car” issue - Climate Action Network

!!!!!!!!!
"#$!%&&'(%)*'!$'+'),'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!-!(./.01.2!3454
6789:/9;
<=>.!?2:/.=
@=>.A2:/.=BCDC9:E8DCF72A
GF,F)F;!H5!I5J!KL-!3J4L
&.ME/7;!HL3!5!-II!54I!L--N
!"#$%&'()&*+&%,-&.()&/0(#1-12&34%&5&!*$$"6$&7&8(9(1(&:(;-$&<$%&=6(>-&?-%&/@("9
6:8/D8O!&.ME/7!P!6:8:Q:!78/.!:A:E8!977@!9R.!5C9!S>:/.!"7CCE>!7T!9R.!(:=!97Q:=!:9!9R.!
G8E9.Q!U:9E78C!/>E0:9.!8.A79E:9E78CO!9REC!9E0.!T72!/:>>E8A!9R.!EQ.:!9R:9!9R.!1EAA.C9!
S7>>D9.2C!CR7D>Q!9:@.!78!9R.!1EAA.C9!S7>>D9E78!2.QD/9E78C!:!VCEQ.!/:2W!ECCD.F!*REC!EC!
6:8:Q:XC!CEM9R!"7CCE>!E8!6:8/D8F!Y:SD:!U.Z!?DE8.:!Z78!E9C!TE2C9!"7CCE>O!/70E8A!E8!
38Q!S>:/.O!T72!Z:9.2E8A!Q7Z8!.8[E2780.89:>!:8Q!C7/E:>!C:T.AD:2QC!E8!:!S79.89E:>!$'((!
T72.C9!S279./9E78!:A2..0.89F!*R.!G8E9.Q!,9:9.C!.:28.Q!:!"7CCE>!T72!9R.!9RE2Q!Q:=!E8!:!
27ZO!9REC!9E0.!T72!1>7/@E8A!S27A2.CC!78!:!R7C9!7T!ECCD.C!D8>.CC!Q.[.>7SE8A!/7D892E.C!
977@!78!072.!/700E90.89CF
#8!:!S7CE9E[.!879.O!:!>:2A.!1>7/!7T!9R.!/7D892E.C!07C9!R:20.Q!1=!/>E0:9.!/R:8A.!
E0S:/9CO!.CS./E:>>=!C.:!>.[.>!2EC.O!.:28.Q!9R.!TE2C!$:=!7T!9R.!(:=!:9!9R.!6:8/D8!
8.A79E:9E78C!T72!SD99E8A!9R.!2.T.2.8/.!97!9R.!C:T.!DSS.2!>E0E9!97!9.0S.2:9D2.!2EC.O!5FL\!
6.>CEDCO!1:/@!E8!9R.!8.A79E:9E8A!9.M9F
*R.!"7CCE>C!:8Q!$:=!7T!9R.!(:=O!:C!S2.C.89.QO!2.:Q;
V*R.!G8E9.Q!,9:9.C!7T!)0.2E/:!ZE8C!9R.!N2Q!S>:/.!"7CCE>F!G<!Z.:9R.2!T72./:C9C!Z:28!
9R:9!6R2EC90:C!/7D>Q!1.!/:8/.>.Q!QD.!97!:!78/.]E8]:]>ET.9E0.!/7>Q!T2789!/70E8A!T270!
9R.!U729RO!1D9!E9!C..0C!:!CE0E>:2!/7>Q!T2789!R:C!:>2.:Q=!:22E[.Q!T270!^:CRE8A978F!G,!
7TTE/E:>C!E8QE/:9.Q!97Q:=!9R:9!9R.=!Z78X9!:>>7Z!07[.0.89!78!:Q:S9:9E78O!/:S:/E9=!
1DE>QE8A!72!9./R87>7A=!D89E>!Q.[.>7SE8A!/7D892E.C!07[.!072.!78!&$_!:8Q!&E9EA:9E78!
[email protected]!9R.0!R:SS=F!*R27ZE8A!DS!CD/R!27:Q1>7/@C!97!S27A2.CC!EC!:9!7QQC!ZE9R!ZR:9!
)01:CC:Q72!,9.28!C:EQ!RE0C.>TO!`+.9`C!879!Q7!879RE8AFFF+.9`C!879!1.!RD8A!DS!T72!=.:2!
:T9.2!=.:2!:T9.2!=.:2F`
a072.b
c.9!879RE8A!1D9!1>7/@E8A!:8Q!1>:0E8A!:SS.:2C!97!1.!:>>!9R:9!9R.!Z72>Q!0:=!A.9!T270!
9R.!G,!R.2.!E8!6:8/D8F!*R.!Q.:>!1:/@!E8!d:>E!:A2..Q!1=!9R.!S2.[E7DC!G,!Y2.CEQ.89O!
?.72A.!^F!dDCRO!Z:C!9R:9!9R.!G,!Z7D>Q!/D9!E9C!.0ECCE78C!:8Q!S27[EQ.!TE8:8/.!:8Q!
9./R87>7A=F!%8!T:/9O!9R:9XC!S2.99=!0D/R!9R.!Q.:>!:A2..Q!97!:>07C9!9Z7!Q./:Q.C!:A7!1=!
REC!T:9R.2e
*R.!Z72>Q!.MS./9C!.[.8!072.!T270!Y2.CEQ.89!#1:0:O!ZR7!78>=!:!=.:2!:A7!Z:C!
:Z:2Q.Q!:!U71.>!Y.:/.!Y2Ef.!T72!REC!S79.89E:>!97!/7892E1D9.!97!0D>9E>:9.2:>!
/77S.2:9E78O!E8/>DQE8A!/77S.2:9E78!78!/>E0:9.F
U7!78.!Z:89C!97!AE[.!:879R.2!>D0S!7T!/7:>!97!9R.!/7D892=!Z.!:>>!8..Q!T72!:!92D>=!
A>71:>!/>E0:9.!C7>D9E78F!,7!>.9XC!0:@.!9REC!9R.!>:C9!78.!Z.!.[.2!AE[.!97!9R.!G,!:8Q!DC.!
E9!97!TE2.!DS!9R.E2!Q.>.A:9E78!97!SD9!9R.!`c.C!^.!6:8`!E897!6:8/D8eg
gY:SD:!U.Z!?DE8.:!.:28C!9R.!38Q!S>:/.!"7CCE>F!%8!9R.E2!Q.CS.2:9E78!97!A.9!:!$'((!
:A2..0.89!:9!:>>!/7C9CO!Y:29E.C!R:[.!1..8!SDCRE8A!T72!Z.:@.2!:8Q!Z.:@.2!9.M9!:>07C9!
78!:!Q:E>=!1:CECF!*R.!E0S>.0.89:9E78!7T!9R.!C7/E:>O!.8[E2780.89:>!:8Q!A7[.28:8/.!
C:T.AD:2QC!EC!hDC9!:17D9!:9!27/@!179970F!,70.!/7D892E.C!Z:89!87!0./R:8EC0!9R:9!
Z7D>Q!AD:2:89..!/70S>E:8/.O!:8Q!E8C9.:Q!S27S7C.Q!:!Z.:@!C=C9.0!97!`078E972!:8Q!
E8T720`!R7Z!9R.!C:T.AD:2QC!:2.!:QQ2.CC.QO!1D9!T72!YU?O!.[.8!9R:9!Z:C!977!C9278Ae
YU?!R:C!87Z!S27S7C.Q!97!Z.:@.8!9R.!9.M9!.[.8!TD29R.2!97!CE0S>=!.C9:1>ECR!:!S27/.CC!
97!78>=!CR:2.!E8T720:9E78!]!ZE9R!87!:/9D:>!71>EA:9E78!97!Q7!C7F!)8Q!Z.!:>>!@87Z!R7Z!
S772!YU?!EC!:9!CR:2E8A!E8T720:9E78F!^.!0DC9!:C@!]!CR:2.!ZE9R!ZR7i!*R.0C.>[.C!
S.2R:SCe!^.!R7S.!7D2!T2E.8QC!E8!YU?!ZE>>!CR:2.!ZE9R!9R.!Z72>Q!ZR:9`C!A7E8A!78!
1.RE8Q!9R.!C/.8.C!E8!9R.E2!/7D892=!.CS./E:>>=!ZE9R!/:2178!/7Z17=C!2EQE8A!E897!97Z8!
C9.:>E8A!>7/:>!S.7S>.C!>:8Q!:8Q!2EAR9CF!,7!T72!9R:9!/>:8A.2O!:!T7CCE>!97!YU?Fg
V*R.!5C9!S>:/.!"7CCE>!A7.C!97!6:8:Q:F!%8!:!12E.TE8A!ZE9R!h7D28:>EC9C!9REC!0728E8AO!
6:8:Q:XC!.8[E2780.89!0E8EC9.2!QEC0ECC.Q!9R.!S2E8/ES>.!7T!REC972E/:>!2.CS78CE1E>E9=!:C!:!
jCEQ./:2X!ECCD.F
*R:9XC!:!S2.99=!/78[.8E.89!C9:8/.!T72!:!/7D892=!E8!9R.!97S!9E.2!7T!/D0D>:9E[.!
A2..8R7DC.!A:C!.0E99.2CF!dD9!0:=1.!E9XC!879!CD2S2ECE8A!9R:9!6:8:Q:!/78CEQ.2C!
REC972E/:>!2.CS78CE1E>E9=!:C!879RE8A!072.!9R:8!:!QEC92:/9E8A!CEQ.!ECCD.!k!:T9.2!:>>O!9REC!
EC!9R.!C:0.!A7[.280.89!9R:9!Q./EQ.Q!<=797!9:2A.9C!Z.2.!7S9E78:>F
a072.b
^E9R!9R:9!@E8Q!7T!:99E9DQ.O!E9XC!879!CD2S2ECE8A!9R:9!9R.!2.C9!7T!Z72>Q!R:C!C9:29.Q!97!
/78CEQ.2!6:8:Q:!:!jCEQ./:2X!/7D892=F!)8Q!6:8:Q:XC!/D22.89!A7[.280.89!C..0C!97!1.!
072.!/78/.28.Q!:17D9!A.99E8A!7E>!E897!9R.!9:8@!9R:8!:17D9!9R.!C:T.9=!7T!9R.!
S:CC.8A.2CFW
g*R.!)>>E:8/.!7T!,0:>>!%C>:8Q!,9:9.CO!,0:>>!%C>:8Q!(.[.>7SE8A!,9:9.CO!:8Q!+.:C9!
(.[.>7S.Q!67D892E.C!ZE8!9R.!TE2C9!$:=!7T!9R.!(:=!E8!6:8/D8O!:8Q!ZR:9!:!12EAR9!78.!E9!
ECe!$.9D28E8A!9R.!2.T.2.8/.!97!5FL!Q.A2..C!6!E8!9R.!,R:2.Q!_ECE78!9.M9!EC!/2D/E:>!T72!
CRE8E8A!C70.!>EAR9!78!9R.!>E8.!1.9Z..8!CD2[E[:>!:8Q!Q.C92D/9E78!T72!C70.!8:9E78CF!"72!
@..SE8A!7D2!:99.89E78O!:8Q!9R.!9.M9O!78!ZR:9!0:99.2C!07C9O!)#,%,O!9R.!,%(,O!:8Q!9R.!
+(6C!.:28!:!$:=!7T!9R.!(:=Fg
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
!"#$%&'!(!"#$%"&'()*+%",-+(./"0%+1.23"(4"*"1.2'51(5%"/%+1.23".6"2.78$'9":;;"
0./<=.>%2/)%/+*'"?28*/(@*+(./4"A0=?4B"1.23(/8"+."C2.).+%"8.>%2/)%/+"*/5"
(/5(>(57*'"*-+(./"+."'()(+"$7)*/<(/57-%5"-'()*+%"-$*/8%"+."%-.'.8(-*''9"474+*(/*D'%"
'%>%'4E"ZZZF/>E0:9.8.9Z72@F72A"
!"#$%&%)*&+#,,-.,!"#$%"F.44('".6"+$%"G*9"*1*254"1%2%"6(24+"C2%4%/+%5"*+"+$%"-'()*+%"
+*'34"(/"HIII""(/"J.//K"(/(+(*+%5"D9"+$%"=%2)*/"0=?"F.27)E"G72(/8"L/(+%5"0*+(./4"
-'()*+%"-$*/8%"/%8.+(*+(./4"AZZZFD8T///FE89BK")%)D%24".6"+$%"&'()*+%",-+(./ "
0%+1.23"A&,0BK">.+%"6.2"-.7/+2(%4"M758%5"+."$*>%"5./%"+$%(2"ND%4+N"+."D'.-3"C2.82%44"
(/"+$%"/%8.+(*+(./4"(/"+$%"'*4+"5*94".6"+*'34E"#$%"O*9".6"+$%"G*9K"*"/%1%2"*1*25K"
$./.24"-.7/+2(%4"+$*+"$*>%"5./%"4.)%+$(/8"%P-%C+(./*'"+.").>%"+$%"/%8.+(*+(./4"
6.21*25E
lll