NSEC for Columbia Center for Electronic Transport in Molecular
Transcription
NSEC for Columbia Center for Electronic Transport in Molecular
Center for Electron Transport in Molecular Nanostructures. Columbia University NSE Conference Dec 6, 2011 file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 1 The Columbia Nanocenter 2001-2011. Fundamental physics: Projected limit for conventional siliconbased integrated circuit. Directors: James Yardley Electrical Engineering Tony Heinz Electrical Engineering Ronald Breslow Chemistry Premise: Exploring electron transport in single molecules and molecular nanostructures • Presents major opportunity for fundamental scientific understanding of new nanoscale phenomena. • Offers new opportunities for information processing devices. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 2 The Columbia Nanocenter: Research Team. Chemistry Research Scientists: Ronald Breslow Shalom Wind Louis Brus Mark Hybertsen (BNL) George Flynn Mike Steigerwald Richard Friesner Ann McDermott Colin Nuckolls NSEC Consortium David Reichman Mechanical Engineering Daniel Akins James Hone Ilona Kretzschmar Electrical Engineering Tony Heinz James Yardley Marisa Buzzeo Applied Physics Irving Herman Robert Krchnavek Aron Pinczuk Latha Venkataraman NSEC Encompasses Physics Approx. 75 Researchers Philip Kim Including Graduate Andrew Millis Students And Postdocs. Horst Stormer * * On leave 2009-2010 Phaedon Avouris Zihong Chen Tom Theis (Adv Bd) Graciela Blanchet Ming Zheng Ed Wasserman (Adv Bd) G. Thompson (Adv Bd) Jim Misewich Chuck Black Mark Hybertsen Yumei Zhu …..more. Steven Louie Muhammad Alam file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 3 Research Program: Seeking Fundamental knowledge. Research Platforms • Chemical Synthesis. • Nanoscale Fabrication. • Theory. • Structural Characterization. • Optical Characterization. • Transport Measurement. Molecular Nano-Systems 0-D: Single Molecules 1-D: Carbon Nanotubes 2D Systems: Graphene Nanostructure Contact and Transport Key Research Issues Nanoscale Fabrication and Assembly Nanoscale Characterization file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 4 Outcome #1: Transformative Science and Technology Developed within NSEC. • Developed two robust and very successful platforms for exploration of single molecule conductance. • Created extensive set of chemical design rules for molecular conductance. • Developed theory for molecular conductance with quantitative understanding of many observations. • Demonstrated single molecule interconnection with g0 conductance. • Pioneered new spectroscopic techniques for characterizing Carbon Nanotubes. • Enhanced physical understanding of electronic structure and dynamics for CNT of specified structure. • Have become the leading research program for exploration of the novel transport properties of graphene. • Demonstrated new magnetic and electronic responses for graphenebased devices. • Measured mechanical and electrical properties of single sheets of “defect-free” graphene and related materials. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 5 Evidence: Scientific Publications in “High Impact” Journals. 40 Nature 35 Impact Factor for each venue of publication as defined by ISI (2011). Science 30 25 20 Nature Physics 15 Nano Letters 10 JACS 5 0 1 51 101 151 201 251 301 351 401 451 Publications supported by Columbia NSEC through August, 2011. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 6 Evidence: NSEC Fifty Most Highly-Cited Publications Ordered by Research Thrust. 10000 Carbon Nanotube Graphene Number of Citations Single Molecule Other 1000 100 1 6 Citations from Google Scholar, Nov. 30, 2011 11 16 21 file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 7 Outcome #2: New Paradigm for Interdisciplinary Research. Co-authorship network graph for NSEC publications through 2009. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 8 Outcome #2: New Paradigm for Interdisciplinary Research. Co-authorship network graph for NSEC publications through 2009 by Academic Department. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 9 Outcome #3. Columbia Nanocenter has created new generation of scientists experienced in interdisciplinary and collaborative research. Total Postdocs and PhD Students Graduated Postdocs 49 PhD Students 43 Postdocs to Industry PhD Graduates to Industry 16 19 Postdocs to Academia PhD Graduates to Academia 32 21 92 file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 10 Outcome #3: New Generation of Researchers Experienced in Interdisciplinary and Collaborative Research. Columbia NSEC Alumni who are currently in industrial and business positions. Type Postdoc Graduate Student Graduate Student Graduate Student Graduate Student Graduate Student Postdoc Graduate Student Graduate Student Postdoc Graduate Student Graduate Student Postdoc Graduate Student Postdoc Graduate Student Postdoc Graduate Student Graduate Student Graduate Student Postdoc Graduate Student Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Graduate Student Graduate Student Graduate Student Graduate Student Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc First Oksana Alex Michael Hayn Meninder Iris Jochen Yang Craig Daejin Melinda Matthew Dan Catalin Ming Penelope Lei Zhiyong Jennifer Nicholas Amy Erich Bupesh Yaron Etienne Alex Thomas Ryan Sami Joshua George Libor Hugen X. M. Henry Jordan Elena Last Cherniavskaya Henderson Holman Park Purewal Tam Ulrich Wu Kenesky Eom Han Sfeir Spataru Yin Lewis Zhang Zhou Klare Perl Petros Walter Chandra Cohen De Poortere Hallock Mueller Pearman Rosenblatt Small Tulevski Vyklicky Yan Huang Quinn Stolyarova Department Chemistry Physics Chemistry Electr. Eng. APAM Chemistry Physics Physics Chemistry Chemistry APAM Chemistry Physics App. Phys. Chemistry Chemistry Chemistry Chemistry Chemistry Chemistry Chemistry Mech. Eng. Chemistry Physics Chemistry Chemistry Chemistry Electr. Eng. Physics Chemistry Chemistry Physics Mech. Eng. Chemistry Chemistry Advisor Employment Status Brus Financial analyst at Goldman Sachs Kim Finance Adams Ph.D. Research Director , Lux Research Heinz D. E. Shaw (finance), New York Kim Finance Breslow Consulting firm: McKinsey & Company Stormer Senior Associate at McKinsey & Company Heinz Lansdowne Partners (finance), London, UK Breslow Science Advisor at Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, PC Flynn Post-doctoral fellow at Brookhaven Kim Postdoc, NREL Brus Brookhaven National Laboratories, Staff Scientist Friesner/Hybertsen/Millis Sandia O'Brien Postdoc, Los Alamos National Laboratory Flynn Managing Editor of ACS Nano Friesner Friesner Nuckolls Research Scientist, Porifera Hayward, CA Nuckolls Ironwood Pharmaceuticals, Cambridge, MA. Gibney Brus Sr. Res. Chemist, 3M Hone IBM Nuckolls Staff Scientist - Israel Stormer Intel Corporation Brus Stanford Research Institute Flynn Veeco Instruments Flynn Intel Corporation Heinz/Kim IBM Kim Postdoc, IBM T. J. Watson Research Center Nuckolls Postdoc, IBM, T.J.Watson Research Center Katz Postdoc, IBM, T.J.Watson Research Center Heinz Post-doc with Phadeon Avouris, IBM (starting shortly) Hone Postdoc, Nanoterra Breslow Startup associated with Northwestern Flynn President, Graphene Laboratories (Start up) Employment Type Financial and Market Research Financial and Market Research Financial and Market Research Financial and Market Research Financial and Market Research Financial and Market Research Financial and Market Research Financial and Market Research Legal National Laboratory National Laboratory National Laboratory National Laboratory National Laboratory Other Other Other Research - Chemistry Research - Chemistry Research - Chemistry Research - Chemistry Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Research, Physics and Engineering Startup Startup Startup 35 NSEC grad students or postdocs are currently active in business or industrial research and development. Financial and Market Research 8 Legal 1 National Laboratory 5 Research, Chemistry 4 Research, Physics and Engineering 11 Startup Companies 3 Other 3 file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 11 Outcome #3: New Generation of Educators Experienced in Interdisciplinary and Collaborative Research. Columbia NSEC Alumni who are currently faculty members at major universities. Type Res. Scientist Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Grad Student Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Res. Scientist Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Grad Student Postdoc Postdoc Grad Student Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Grad Student Postdoc Postdoc Post-doc Grad Student Postdoc Postdoc Postdoc Grad Student Name Col. Univ Department Latha Venkataraman APAM Sarbajit Banerjee APAM Alexey Teslja APAM James Dickerson APAM Gordana Dukovic Chemistry Gina Florio Chemistry Anat De Picciotto Chemistry Thuc-Quyen Nguyen Chemistry Shiunchin Chris Wang Chemistry Marisa Buzzeo Chemistry Frank Foss Chemistry Dennis Bong Chemistry Lewei Chen Chemistry Marcus Lay Chemistry Jun Zhu Physics Jie Shan Physics Aditi Mitra Physics Feng Wang Physics Pablo Jarillo-Herrero Physics Kiril Bolotin Physics Mehmet Yilmaz Electrical Eng. Barbaros Oezyilmaz Physics Sunmin Ryu Chemistry Seokwoo Jeon Chemistry Byung Hee Hong Physics Cyrus Hirjibehedin Physics Janina Maultzsch Physics Yann Gallais Physics Christophe Voisin Physics Qian Miao Chemistry Xuefong Guo Chemistry Xiaodong Cui Chemistry Shancai Wang Electrical Eng. Yuanbo Zhang Physics Advisor Position University Academic University Gender Ethnicity Department Location Stormer/Yardley Asst. Prof. Columbia University Applied Physics USA F Herman Asst. Prof. SUNY, Buffalo Chemistry USA Venkataraman Asst. Prof. Fairleigh Dickinson University, Madison, NJ Chemistry USA Herman Asst. Prof. Vanderbilt University Physics USA AA Brus Asst. Prof. Univ of Colorado, Boulder, CO Chemistry USA F Flynn Asst. Prof. St. Johns University Chemistry USA F Nuckolls Asst. Prof. Montclair State College Chemistry USA F Nuckolls Asst. Prof. UC Santa Barbara Chemistry USA F Akins Asst. Prof. New York Institute of Technology Life Science USA F Yardley Asst. Prof. Barnard College Chemistry USA F Breslow Asst. Prof. University of Texas at Arlington Chemistry USA Breslow Asst. Prof. Ohio State University Chemistry USA Brus Asst. Prof. Ohio University Chemistry USA Flynn Asst. Prof. University of Georgia Chemistry USA AA Stormer Asst. Prof. Penn State University Physics USA F Heinz Assoc. Prof. Case Western Reserve Physics USA F Millis Asst. Prof. New York University Physics USA F Heinz Asst. Prof. University of California, Berkeley Physics USA Kim Asst. Prof. MIT Physics USA Kim Asst. Prof. Vanderbilt University Physics USA Osgood Asst. Prof. Fatih University, Buyukcekmece,Turkey Physics Turkey Kim Asst. Prof. National University of Singapore Physics Singapore Brus Asst. Prof. Kyung Hee University, Korea Chemistry Korea Nuckolls Asst. Prof. KAIST, Korea Mat. Sci. and Eng. Korea Kim Asst. Prof. Sungkyukwan University, Korea Chemistry Korea Pinczuk Lecturer London Centre for Nanotechnology Nanotechnology Great Britain Heinz Asst. Prof. Technical U. Berlin, Germany Physics Germany F Pinczuk Asst. Prof. University of Paris 6, Paris, France Physics France Heinz/Hone/Brus Asst. Prof. Ecole Normale Superieure, Paris, France Physics France Nuckolls Asst. Prof. Chinese Univ. of Hong Kong Chemistry China Nuckolls Asst. Prof. Nankai University, Tianjin, P.R. China Chemistry China Brus Asst. Prof. Hong Kong University Physics China Osgood Asst. Prof. Renmin University of China, China Physics China Kim Asst. Prof. Fudan University, China Physics China 34 NSEC grad students or postdocs are currently faculty members at institutions of higher learning worldwide. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 12 Outcome #4: New generation of highly diverse faculty members and scientific leaders for the world’s educational Institutions, experienced in Interdisciplinary and collaborative research. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 13 Latha Venkataraman Gordana Dukovic Chemistry Applied Physics U. Colorado, Boulder. Columbia Univ. Shiunchin Wang Jie Shan Life Science Physics Case Western Univ. NY Inst. of Techn. Gina Florio Chemistry St. John’s Univ. Anat De Picciotto Chemistry Montclair State Univ. Aditi Mitra Physics New York Univ. Jay Dickerson Physics Vanderbilt Univ. Jun Zhu Physics Penn. State Univ. Janina Maultzsch Physics Tech. Universität Berlin Thuc-Quen Nguyen Chemistry U. Cal. Santa Barbara Marisa Buzzeo Chemistry Barnard College Marcus Lay Chemistry Univ. of Georgia file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 14 Outcome #5: New Paradigm for International Research Collaborations. International Collaboration has been driven by the Columbia Nanocenter program for visitors in residence. Italy Alberto Morgante, Trieste Elisa Molinari, Modena Deborah Prezzi – Modena Korea Kwang Kim, Pohang University Grad Students and Postdocs Byung Hee Hong, Sungkyunkwan University Alberto Morgante Elisa Molinari Japan Takao Someya, U. Tokyo Shigeo Marayami, U. Tokyo Many more….. These collaborations have resulted in multiple research papers published or in preparation. Deborah Prezzi file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 15 Jointly sponsored by NSF and by Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA). Close working interaction with member companies: IBM, Freescale, GlobalFoundries (AMD), Texas Instruments, Micron Technology, and Intel. Seeks to develop new devices to replace silicon Field Effect Transistors for processing information. Supplemental NSF program to NSEC. Nonconventional Graphene Switching Devices Graphene Veselago lens Graphene Spintronics Graphene pseudo-spintronics • Active collaboration with IBM – leading to new research program in high speed graphene electronics (DARPA). • An Chen of GlobalFoundries (AMD) in residence for 6 months in 2009. • Collaborative research with Albany Nanocenter on new switching devices. • Continued ongoing Intel interactions. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 16 Columbia Nanocenter Beyond 2011: Through development of basic knowledge in charge transport, the Columbia NSEC has served as a platform for development of many new scientific directions in Nanoscale Science and Engineering. NRI and INDEX (Kim) Nanotechnology for Electronics Beyond Silicon. Graphene MURI (Osgood) DARPA/IBM Graphene (Shepard) Nanoscale Mechanics. Nanoscale Science and Engineering Fundamentals Columbia NSEC Nanoscale Optics BioNano Technology NIH BioNano Program (Sheetz) Chemical Bonding Center (Barber, Nuckolls) Nanoscale Science for Energy Nanoscale Chemistry EFRC (DOE) (Yardley, Heinz, Brus) file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 17 Columbia NSEC Symposium – June 11, 2011 . NSEC Symposium Schedule • All presenters were graduates of the NSEC program including participants who came from Italy, Germany, Japan, and China to attend. • Approximately 40 NSEC alumni attended the symposium. • Approximately 120 people attended the symposium. • Three members of the Outside Advisory Board attended. Friday June 10th Registration/Reception 6:00-7:30 Davis Lobby area (with posters) Dinner – on your own. Saturday June 11th Symposium Location: Davis Auditorium and Lobby 8:00 am CONTINENTAL BREAKFAST and Registration Session I Chair: Jim Yardley 9:00 am Director’s Overview (Yardley, Breslow, Heinz) 9:30 am Takeo Someya (30 min talk, 10 min discussion) 10:10 am Coffee Break 10:40 am Thuc-Quyen Nguyen (30 min talk, 5 min discussion) 11:15 am NSEC and Business Development – Panel with Discussion Elena Polyakova, Hui Zhou, Michael Holman, George Tulevski, Jen Klare 12:00 pm Lunch Break & Poster Session Session II Chair: Ron Breslow 1:15 pm Gordana Dukovic (30 min talk, 5 min discussion) 1:50 pm Janina Maultzsch (30 min talk, 10 min discussion) 2:30 pm Pablo Jarillo-Herrero (30 min talk, 10 min discussion) 2:50 pm Coffee Break Session III Chair: Tony Heinz 3:20 pm Latha Venkataraman (30 min talk, 10 min discussion) 4:00 pm Andrea Young (30 min talk, 10 min discussion) 4:30 pm Alberto Morgante: Reflections on International Collaborations (15 min talk) 4:45 pm Mark Hybertsen: Retrospective and Prospective 5:15 pm Jim Yardley: Closing 5:30 pm END Reception Location: Lerner Hall, Room C555 6:00 pm Reception and Hors d’Oeuvres 7:00 pm Closing remarks and Discussion 8:00 pm Program adjourns. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 18 History: The NSEC Logo. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 19 Extra Slides file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 20 Highly-Cited Publications in Primary NSEC Thrusts. 1000 Carbon Nanotube Thrust Number of Citations "Single Molecule Thrust" Graphene Thrust 100 10 0 5 10 15 20 25 November, 2009 file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 21 Columbia Nanocenter Has Created New Generation of Scientists Experienced in Interdisciplinary and Collaborative Research. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 22 NRI and INDEX The new scientific elements can potentially be self sustaining. However what will NOT be selfsustaining are some very important aspects of the existing NSEC program: Nanotechnology for Electronics Beyond Silicon. • Basic research at the foundations of charge transport. • Active outreach, education and diversity programs. • Seed funding for new faculty members to develop new concepts and ideas. • Synergies that create cross-cutting opportunities. • A large and active community for nanoscale scientific researchers. • A basis to maintain nanoscale fabrication facilities. Chemical Bonding Center (Barber, Nuckolls) Nanoscale Chemistry (Kim) Graphene MURI (Osgood) DARPA/IBM Graphene (Shepard) Nanoscale Mechanics. Nanoscale Optics BioNano Technology NIH BioNano Program (Sheetz) Nanoscale Science for Energy EFRC (DOE) (Yardley, Heinz, Brus) file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 23 A Vision for the New Nanocenter. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 24 Columbia Nanocenter Beyond 2010: CCNY LSAMP (Parker) LSAMP consortium: CCNY U C Berkeley UPR Maryland Outreach, Education, and Diversity NRI and INDEX (Kim) Nanotechnology for Electronics Beyond Silicon. Graphene MURI (Osgood) DARPA/IBM Graphene (Shepard) (Kim, Heinz) Nanoscale Mechanics. NSEC Futures: Seed Fund Technology Transfer and Entrepreneurship (Hone) Columbia NEW NSEC Nanoscale Science and Engineering Fundamentals (NSF or Other Support) Nanoscale Optics (Osgood) BioNano Technology NSEC Infrastructure (Wind) CEPSR Cleanroom NIH BioNano Program (Sheetz) Nanoscale Science for Energy Chemical Bonding Center Nanoscale Chemistry (Barber, Nuckolls) (Nuckolls) (Brus) EFRC (DOE) (Yardley, Heinz, Brus) file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 25 Columbia NSEC: Broader Impacts. NSEC program has impacted many aspects of Nanoscale Science and Engineering, especially including: • • • • Effective interdisciplinary collaborative research. External interactions for research and innovation. Transformative science and technology. Enhanced understanding for Nanoscale Science and Engineering across wide spectrum of the public. • New generation of scientific leaders for the future. • Enhanced diversity in NSEC community and the broader scientific community. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 26 Impact: Effective Paradigm for Collaborative, Cross-Disciplinary University Research Program. • NSEC Program built to emphasize collaboration, especially interdepartmental. • Program and organization built around NSEC challenges and issues. • Strong commitment to teamwork. • Close interaction at grad student and postdoc level. • Collaborations. • 45% of NSEC publications authored by multiple NSEC PI’s. • 70% of top 20 cited papers authored by multiple NSEC PI’s. • Interdisciplinary Research. • 35% of NSEC publications involve NSEC PI’s from multiple departments. • 50% of top 20 cited papers involve NSEC PI’s from multiple departments. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 27 Fundamental Scientific Questions Which Drive Columbia NSEC. What are the fundamental principles that determine electron transport in nanoscale systems of “0-dimension” (single molecules), 1-dimension (carbon nanotubes) and 2-dimensions (graphene)? Major Issues: • Contacting the nanostructure. • Energy level alignments. • Charge redistribution near interfaces. • Transport through the nanostructure. • Scattering mechanisms. • Influence of the environment. • Controlling transport to create functional devices. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 28 Columbia NSEC Organizational Structure. Scientific Directors. Ronald Breslow, Chemistry Tony Heinz, Physics, EE Managing director. James Yardley, Chem. E., EE Associate Director. Latha Venkataraman, Appl. Phys. Outreach, Education, and Diversity Committee. Ronald Breslow (chair) Executive Committee. Dan Akins, Chemistry CCNY Ronald Breslow, Chemistry George Flynn, Chemistry Tony Heinz, EE and Physics Jim Hone, ME Philip Kim, Physics Ilona Kretzschmar, CCNY Chem E Colin Nuckolls, Chemistry Latha Venkataraman, Appl. Phys. James Yardley, Chem. E. Clean Room Committee and Safety Committee. James Yardley (chair) Research Thrusts 2D in Graphene and Related. – Philip Kim 1D in Carbon Nanotubes. – Jim Hone Molecular Transport. – Colin Nuckolls NRI-NSF Initiative Program Leader – Tony Heinz Research Scientists. Shalom Wind Mike Steigerwald Clean Room Supervisor. Geoff Goold Clean Room Process Engineer Linus Fetter Outside Advisory Board. John Brauman (Stanford) Wally Parce (Nanosys) Cathy Taylor (GM, Retired) Tom Theis (IBM) George Thompson (Intel) Edel Wasserman (Dupont) Industrial Advisory Board. Wally Parce (Nanosys) Cathy Taylor (GM, Retired) Tom Theis (IBM) George Thompson (Intel) Edel Wasserman (Dupont) Administration (CISE). Ran Zhao NSEC Program Coordinators. Francisco Monar (Outr, Ed, & Div.) Candy Petrolle (Reports and Finance) Cassie Beirele (Events, 25%) file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 29 Columbia NSEC Research Thrust Structure. Single Molecule Conductance Thrust Columbia University PI’s Colin Nuckolls * Ronald Breslow George Flynn Tony Heinz Ann McDermott Andrew Millis Horst Stormer ** Latha Venkataraman Consortium PI’s Marisa Buzzeo Ilona Kretzschmar Students/Postdocs Associated Researchers Shalom Wind Mark Hybertsen (BNL) Mike Steigerwald Industry Ben Ocko (BNL) Transport in Carbon Nanotube Thrust. Transport in Graphene Thrust Columbia University PI’s Jim Hone * Louis Brus Richard Friesner Tony Heinz Irving Herman Phil Kim Students/Postdocs Consortium PI’s Dan Akins Associated Researchers Shalom Wind Industry Phaedon Avouris (IBM) Zhihong Chen(IBM) Ming Zheng (Dupont) Jim Misewich (BNL) Yimei Zhu (BNL) Columbia University PI’s Phil Kim * Louis Brus George Flynn Colin Nuckolls Aron Pinczuk David Reichman Horst Stormer ** Jim Yardley Students/Postdocs Consortium PI’s Bob Krchnavek Associated Researchers Mark Hybertsen Industry NSF-SIA NRI Program. Graciela Blanchet Columbia University PI’s (Dupont) Ron Pindak (BNL)Tony Heinz* An Chen (Global Phil Kim Horst Stormer ** Foundries) Students/Postdocs Associated Researchers Mark Hybertsen (BNL) Industry Chung Yung Sun (IBM) An Chen (GlobalFoundries) NRI Team (Allen Bowling, TI) Important: Thrust composition changes dynamically. * thrust leader ** on leave, 2009-2010 file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 30 Scientific Publications in “High Impact” Journals. Impact Factor Distribution 35 Nature 30 Impact Factor for each venue of publication as defined by ISI (2008). Science 25 Nature Materials Nature Nanotechnology 20 Nature Physics 15 } 10 Accounts of Chemical Research, Angewandte Chemie } Nano Letters, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. } J. Am. Chem. Soc., Phys. Rev. Letters 5 Phys. Rev. B 0 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 Publications through calendar year 2009. file: NNI NSE Conference Dec 2011 rev 04.pptx Page 31