KentuckianaWorks Human Capital Scorecard

Transcription

June 2013
T
his ninth update of the KentuckianaWorks Human Capital Scorecard includes recently released
data on college attainment of the adult population, enrollments and degrees awarded by level
for postsecondary institutions, the high school graduation rate, and the number of GED
passers. In addition, we present data on educational attainment by age cohort. This release
supersedes previous versions of the Scorecard.
In this release, the data we present on educational attainment has transitioned from using the single
year results from the American Community Survey (ACS) to the three-year estimates. We made this
change primarily due to the greater accuracy of the three-year estimates, which combine three years
of survey data into a much larger sample, thereby cutting margins of error roughly in half. The
increased reliability of the estimates will mean that we can more confidently identify real trends in
the data. Previously, fairly wide year-to-year fluctuations may have occurred simply due to the
margin of error, which could either mask a trend or give a false impression of one. We now have
five consecutive three-year ACS estimates (2005-07 through 2009-11).
The Scorecard provides these key measures of educational activity in the Louisville area along with a
snapshot of where Louisville ranks among 16 comparison Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA)
markets. The KentuckianaWorks’ board believes Louisville’s economic future hinges on having a
flexible and highly educated workforce, and that annual reports on educational attainment and
enrollment are necessary to see if the community’s improvement efforts have been successful.
Hence, the organization has commissioned this annual tracking system, so all stakeholders can
monitor the progress.
We now have data through 2011 and certain patterns are emerging in the Scorecard tracking:
It appears that there has been a real and sustained gain of about 1 percent in the percentage
of Jefferson County and Louisville metro area adults with high school degrees since 2007 or
2008. In addition, the percentage with college degrees continues to climb slowly by about a
half percentage point per three-year estimate. The overall pattern since 2000 is one of
improvement, with a slow, but fairly steady, improvement in the attainment rates for
Jefferson County and Louisville metro area adults.
Of course, the competition is not standing still. According to the Census Bureau, high
school and college attainment rates for all the 15 comparison metropolitan areas have also
risen. Fortunately, since the 2005-07 estimates Louisville’s increases in both high school and
college attainment have ranked 3rd best of the peer group of metros, and this is reflected in
most of the rankings. The rank of the Louisville MSA for both high school and college
attainment has gone up by two spots. Jefferson County’s rank among the central counties of
1
the peer metros also has gone up two spots for high school attainment and one spot for
college attainment. The Louisville MSA is now ahead of Memphis and Dayton in college
attainment.
The overall performance of the Louisville MSA is pulled down by the counties surrounding
Jefferson County, whose high school and, especially, college attainment rates are significantly
less than the MSA’s central county (Jefferson County).
The percentage of people who have completed high school but have no more education has
only begun to drop significantly the last few years. As late as the 2007-09 estimates the
percentages for both the Louisville MSA and Jefferson County were about equal to the 1990
Census results. Consequently, in a category where a low ranking is better (indicating
relatively more people have had postsecondary education), the Louisville MSA is still ranked
number one for the percentage of adults with only a high school education. (Jefferson
County is still fifth among the central counties.)
When we look at the educational attainment of the youngest 10-year age cohorts, those
between the ages of 25-34 and 35-44, the news is uniformly positive, especially for the latter
cohort. The percentages of 25- to 34-year-olds and 35- to 44-year-olds who have a high
school diploma or equivalent appear to have hit plateaus but are significantly higher than the
levels of a decade ago. Similarly, the percentage of 25- to 34-year-olds who have earned a
bachelor’s degree also has hit a plateau, but is much higher than the level of the 2005-07
three-year estimates and is, in fact, the largest increase among the peer metros. For 35- to 44year-olds, the percentages of those who have at least attended some college and those who
have earned a bachelor’s degree are at all-time highs. Most importantly, the percentage of
people who have a high school degree but no more education has dropped significantly for
both cohorts since the 2006-08 three-year estimates. For the 35- to 44-year-old cohort, the
Louisville MSA has dropped the largest amount since 2005-07 among the peers.
GED completions were down markedly in 11 of the 16 comparison metros. The Louisville
MSA’s 6 percent increase was third best; the other peer metros saw their GED completions
fall a collective 6.5 percent from 2010 to 2011. While the pattern is not uniform across the
peers, in many of them it appears that the recession, beginning in 2007, created the impetus
for many people to work on their GEDs. Now, with the “backlog” of potential GED
completers diminished, we may be seeing a return to more normal levels. However, the rate
of GED completions in Louisville MSA has remained relatively constant since 2003. While,
on a per capita basis, the rank of the Louisville MSA dropped to 10th at the height of the
recession, it has now rebounded all the way to 3rd place.
Postsecondary institutions in the Louisville metro area saw enrollment level off in 2011 after
three years of increases. The 1 percent drop in enrollment was due entirely to a 4 percent
drop at postsecondary institutions whose highest degree offered is an associate degree.
Enrollment at institutions granting at least a bachelor’s degree edged up slightly by 0.4
percent. Eight colleges experienced triple-digit enrollment drops, all but one a careeroriented private college: Galen College of Nursing, Jefferson Career and Technical College
(JCTC), Sullivan College of Technology & Design, Brown Mackie College, Spencerian
College, Daymar College, ITT Technical Institute and Sullivan University. Ivy Tech
Community College and the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary both saw enrollment
increase by more than 200 students. Total postsecondary enrollment is still 39 percent
2
greater than it was a decade ago, with full-time enrollment up an even more impressive 56
percent.
The enrollment figures seem to reflect the effects of the economic recession and now the
recovery. But while the Louisville MSA did have a decrease in enrollment, only Jacksonville
among the peer metros experienced an enrollment increase of greater than 2 percent. As a
result, Louisville’s rankings for enrollment per capita remained largely constant.
The big enrollment increase in the latter half of the last decade continued to translate into
more degrees awarded by Louisville area institutions. They awarded over 1,400 more degrees
in 2011 than in 2010, an increase of more than 9 percent. Nearly 1,000 of those degrees were
either awards below the associate level or associate degrees (a nearly 14 percent increase), of
which 475 were given by either Ivy Tech Community College – South Central or Jefferson
Community & Technical College. The increase in bachelor’s degrees was 7 percent, more of
which was evenly divided between Indiana University Southeast, Bellarmine University and
the University of Louisville. First Professional degrees rose by about 19 percent, half of
which can be accounted for by the first graduates of the pharmacy school at Sullivan
University.
In terms of the number of postsecondary degrees granted on a per capita basis, the
Louisville MSA edged up one rank for associate degrees, bachelor’s degrees, and First
Professional degrees. However, in each case Louisville was just returning to a spot it
occupied a couple years earlier. With no increase in graduate degrees, Louisville dropped two
spots to 11th in the rankings among the peers.
Despite another year of award increases, Louisville’s overall rank for awards, degrees and
certificates per capita remained at 9th place. Louisville has been narrowing the gap between it
and the metro areas just ahead of it in the rankings in all of the degree categories. The
Louisville MSA has seen the 4th best increase in total degrees awarded per capita since 2000
among the comparison group of metros, ranking at least 6th best in each of the individual
degree categories. In addition, Louisville is the only one of the 16 peer metro areas that
moved up since 2000 in the degrees awarded per capita rankings in every category of award,
from below-associate certificates and diplomas to graduate and First Professional programs.
The KentuckianaWorks Human Capital Scorecard is produced for KentuckianaWorks by economic and
demographic researchers at the Urban Studies Institute of the University of Louisville. The Scorecard
may be viewed online at www.kentuckianaworks.org or http://usi.louisville.edu. For more
information, contact Barry Kornstein ([email protected]).
3
SCORECARD
Attainment
Louisville Area Human Capital
Educational Attainment ♠
% Adults with high school diploma or higher
% Adults with Bachelor's degree or higher
Components ◙
% Adults with high school only
% Adults some college only
% Adults with Associate's degree only
% Adults with Bachelor's degree only
% Adults with graduate or professional degree
Younger Age Cohorts
% Adults 25-34 yrs old with high school diploma or higher
% Adults 25-34 yrs old with some college or higher
% Adults 25-34 yrs old with Associate's degree or higher
% Adults 25-34 yrs old with Bachelor's degree or higher
% Adults 35-44 yrs old with high school diploma or higher
K-12 Activity, Performance
Performance
Eighth Grade(t-4) Enrollment Based Graduation Rate ♣
Eighth Grade(t-4) Enrollment Based Graduation Rate
Geography
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
1990
72.9%
16.6%
74.1%
19.3%
1990
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
33.0%
18.2%
5.1%
10.1%
6.4%
30.3%
19.3%
5.2%
11.8%
7.5%
1990
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
80.9%
21.2%
81.8%
24.8%
2000
32.3%
21.6%
5.8%
13.1%
8.1%
29.1%
22.4%
5.6%
15.2%
9.6%
2000
84.3%
49.3%
87.5%
58.9%
18.8%
86.0%
51.5%
25.6%
87.4%
53.7%
22.1%
1990
Louisville MSA
Jefferson County
GED Completions (calendar year)▲
Louisville MSA
Postsecondary degrees, academic year ending Spring ▼
All postsecondary awards, degrees, certificates
Louisville MSA
Awards/certificates below associate level
Louisville MSA
Associate's degrees
Louisville MSA
Bachelor's degrees
Louisville MSA
Graduate degrees
Louisville MSA
1st professional degree
Louisville MSA
Postsecondary enrollments, academic year beginning Fall ▼
Total postsecondary enrollments
Louisville MSA
Full-time Louisville MSA
Part-time Louisville MSA
Associate degree granting institutions only Louisville MSA
Undergraduate level, including associate degree granting
Louisville MSA
Graduate & 1st professional level
Louisville MSA
2000
22.1%
2000
75.5%
72.8%
2005-07 2006-08 2007-09 2008-10 2009-11
84.7%
23.3%
85.6%
27.3%
7,391
1,347
1,667
2,462
1,360
555
1990
50,641
25,204
25,437
14,470
42,490
8,151
2000
8,168
1,149
1,815
2,960
1,662
478
2000
51,462
27,614
23,848
14,836
42,357
9,105
86.4%
24.3%
87.5%
28.8%
86.9%
24.8%
87.6%
29.2%
86.8%
25.4%
87.6%
29.6%
2005-07 2006-08 2007-09 2008-10 2009-11
33.3%
21.2%
6.9%
14.2%
9.1%
29.8%
21.9%
6.5%
16.4%
10.9%
33.5%
21.6%
7.0%
14.4%
9.2%
30.4%
22.1%
6.4%
16.6%
11.3%
33.1%
21.9%
7.1%
14.9%
9.4%
29.7%
22.3%
6.7%
17.5%
11.3%
32.4%
22.5%
7.1%
15.3%
9.5%
29.1%
22.7%
6.7%
17.8%
11.4%
31.6%
22.7%
7.2%
15.4%
9.9%
28.4%
22.8%
6.9%
17.8%
11.8%
2005-07 2006-08 2007-09 2008-10 2009-11
88.9%
60.3%
35.0%
26.4%
88.9%
57.4%
34.7%
25.9%
2007
79.0%
75.4%
2,063
1990
85.7%
23.6%
86.7%
27.9%
2007
12,754
3,045
2,517
4,231
2,363
598
2007
62,472
36,188
26,284
21,114
51,583
10,889
89.1%
60.9%
35.4%
27.3%
90.0%
58.4%
35.4%
26.3%
2008
79.7%
77.4%
1,963
2008
13,771
3,679
2,736
4,185
2,473
698
2008
65,352
36,983
28,369
23,291
54,216
11,136
89.6%
62.7%
38.0%
29.8%
90.8%
60.3%
37.0%
27.3%
2009
89.7%
63.9%
38.9%
30.9%
91.2%
62.8%
37.4%
28.3%
2010
89.4%
63.8%
39.2%
30.7%
90.5%
64.2%
38.0%
29.0%
2011
80.1%
77.8%
1,904
2009
13,688
3,076
2,982
4,519
2,477
634
2009
69,445
42,432
27,013
23,785
58,187
11,258
1,807
2010
14,916
3,903
3,149
4,593
2,644
627
2010
72,068
43,645
28,423
23,677
60,109
11,959
1,918
2011
16,342
4,399
3,620
4,930
2,645
748
2011
71,326
43,162
28,164
22,737
58,959
12,367
4
SCORECARD
Performance
Attainment
RANKINGS (out of 16 comparison metro areas)
Geography
Educational Attainment ♠
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
Components ◙
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
Jefferson County
Younger Age Cohorts
% Adults 25-34 yrs old with high school diploma or higher Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
% Adults 35-44 yrs old with high school diploma or higher Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
K-12 Activity, Performance
Eighth Grade(t-4) Enrollment Based Graduation Rate ♣
Louisville MSA
Eighth Grade(t-4) Enrollment Based Graduation Rate
Jefferson County
GED Completions per 100,000 population 18+ years ▲
Louisville MSA
Postsecondary degrees per capita, academic year ending Spring ▼
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Associate's degrees
Louisville MSA
Bachelor's degrees
Louisville MSA
Graduate degrees
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Postsecondary enrollments per capita, academic year beginning Fall ▼
Total postsecondary enrollments
Louisville MSA
Full-time Louisville MSA
Part-time Louisville MSA
Associate degree granting institutions only Louisville MSA
Undergraduate level, including associate degree granting
Louisville MSA
Graduate & 1st professional level
Louisville MSA
1990
2000
12
16
15
15
1990
2005-07 2006-08 2007-09 2008-10 2009-11
12
16
11
12
2000
1
7
11
16
11
5
5
13
13
16
9
8
10
14
8
2000
10
13
15
9
16
13
9
16
16
2
7
7
16
13
6
6
9
15
9
16
2000
8
9
13
13
12
14
14
16
2007
6
5
1990
11
7
7
15
8
5
1990
8
12
6
8
9
8
10
16
7
10
10
15
8
10
10
14
8
10
1
7
8
16
13
5
7
11
14
9
1
7
6
15
12
4
7
8
12
9
1
6
7
15
12
5
7
9
12
9
1
6
10
15
12
5
7
7
12
9
2005-07 2006-08 2007-09 2008-10 2009-11
10
16
1990
11
16
9
11
2005-07 2006-08 2007-09 2008-10 2009-11
2
14
13
16
11
1990
12
16
10
11
2000
13
10
8
15
11
8
2000
11
12
8
11
11
8
7
9
13
13
7
14
14
16
2008
2009
7
8
8
7
4
10
2008
2007
9
3
7
11
8
6
2007
9
10
6
11
11
7
7
11
11
12
6
14
14
15
9
4
5
12
8
5
2008
9
11
6
11
9
6
7
11
11
12
6
12
14
13
2010
7
11
11
12
8
10
14
14
2011
10
6
7
2009
9
6
5
12
9
5
2009
9
11
8
12
11
7
4
2010
9
5
7
13
9
7
2010
11
10
8
12
11
7
3
2011
9
6
6
12
11
5
2011
11
10
8
12
12
7
5
SCORECARD
Louisville Area Human Capital
Notes
References and notes
Available on-line with the latest data, www.kentuckianaworks.org
♠ Educational Attainment rates apply to population aged 25 and older. Source for education attainment in 1990 and 2000: U.S. Bureau of the Census, Summary File
4, 1990 & Summary File 3, 2000. Source for years 2001 through 2011 American Community Survey, with confidence intervals (precision of estimates) varying by
year and place. Because information was not available for all MSAs for the years 2001 through 2004, comparisons were made among central counties. For the
decennial census and 2005-07, the central county of the Richmond MSA is considered to include both the City of Richmond and adjacent Henrico County.
However, the 2001-2004 American Community Surveys (ACS) did not include the city of Richmond VA within detailed Virginia city and county breakdowns;
therefore Richmond is not included in the central county rankings for years 2001-2004. Calculations of educational attainment in the ACS did not include the
group quarters population until 2006. Because many types of GQ populations have educational attainment distributions that are very different from the household
population comparison of the 2006 data with previous years should be done with caution.
◙ These figures reflect only those within the field described and not any higher level of education.
♣ Source: Eighth Grade(t-4) Graduation Rate is calculated from enrollment and diploma data in the Common Core of Data collected by the National Center for
Education Statistics. The rate is constructed by taking the number of diploma recipients for a given school year divided by the fall enrollment for grade 8 from
four years prior. Thus the graduation rate for 2006 is number of diploma recipients for 2005-06 divided by the number of eighth graders in the fall of 2001-02. This
figure has been shown to be very close to and track well over time with Decennial Census data calculations of the percentage of adults who have received regular
high school diplomas. See Heckman, James J. and Paul A. LaFontaine, "The American High School Graduation Rate: Trends and Levels," IZA Discussion Paper
No. 3216, Bonn, Germany, December 2007.
▲ GED figures at the zip code level were obtained from the GED Testing Service, and have been aggregated to the
metro level.
▼ Breakdown of postsecondary awards, degrees, enrollments by type and level, Source: IPEDS, AY 1989-90, 200001, 2001-02, 2002-03, 2003-04, 2004-05, 2005-06, 2006-7, 2007-08, 2008-09, 2009-10, 2010-11, 2011-12; includes all ages.
Research and compilation by University of Louisville
6
7
8
Enrollments and Awards, Louisville MSA Postsecondary Institutions
Postsecondary Enrollments, Fall Semester
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Ivy Tech Communi ty Col lege-South Centra l
Indi a na Univers ity-Southea s t
Mi d-America Coll ege of Funera l Service
Bell a rmi ne Univers i ty
Ga len Col lege of Nurs ing-Louis vil le
Jeffers on Communi ty Col lege/Jeffers on Community & Technol ogy Col lege
Jeffers on Technica l Col lege
Na ti ona l Coll ege of Bus i nes s a nd Tech-Lexi ngton
Loui s vi ll e Bibl e Coll ege
Loui s vi ll e Technica l Ins titute/Sul li va n Col lege of Technology a nd Des i gn
Univers i ty of Loui s vi ll e
Loui s vi ll e Pres byteri a n Theol ogi ca l Semi na ry
RETS El ectronic Ins ti tute/Brown Ma cki e Coll ege-Loui s vil le
The Southern Ba pti s t Theol ogi ca l Semina ry
Spa l ding Uni vers i ty
Spenceri a n Coll ege
Sul liva n Univers ity
Computer Educa ti on Services Inc./Decker Coll ege Of Bus ines s Technol ogy
Cha rles A. Pros s er School of Technol ogy
Kentucky Ca reer Ins titute/Da yma r Coll ege-Loui s vi ll e
ITT Techni ca l Ins titute
Otta wa Uni vers i ty-Jeffers onvi ll e
Decker Coll ege-Louis vil le
Univers i ty of Phoeni x-Loui s vi ll e Ca mpus
ATA Ca reer Educa ti on/ATA Coll ege
DeVry Uni vers i ty-Kentucky
Da yma r Col lege-Onli ne
Da yma r Col lege-Loui s vi ll e
Simmons Col lege of Kentucky
DeVry Uni vers i ty's Kel ler Gra dua te School of Ma na gement-Kentucky
Total, Louisville Metropolitan Area
Awards below Associate level, Academic Year ending Spring
Computer Educa ti on Services Inc./Decker Coll ege Of Bus ines s Technol ogy
Cha rles A. Pros s er School of Technol ogy
Decker Coll ege-Louis vil le
Simmons Col lege of Kentucky
Associate Degrees, Academic Year ending Spring
1,933
6,427
36
2,848
48
9,520
1,512
0
130
612
19,771
250
365
2,320
1,632
201
3,212
90
104
97
354
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
51,462
2,035
6,557
51
2,982
34
9,227
3,246
1,220
0
623
19,682
235
411
2,443
1,670
584
4,402
86
12
86
358
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
55,944
2,716
6,716
51
3,294
44
9,390
3,582
0
0
624
20,416
227
327
2,716
1,702
928
4,646
109
10
113
402
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
58,013
2,917
6,408
61
3,134
45
9,645
3,697
0
0
670
20,605
193
350
2,904
1,658
1,326
4,962
368
2
227
495
48
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
59,715
3,050
6,238
107
2,888
47
10,106
3,694
0
0
645
20,729
184
68
2,983
1,698
1,254
4,860
949
686
296
0
76
79
116
0
0
0
0
0
0
60,753
2,995
6,164
76
2,827
111
14,231
0
0
172
580
20,726
204
92
3,263
1,641
1,327
5,212
0
0
293
714
74
0
296
0
0
0
0
0
0
60,998
3,319
6,183
35
2,878
147
14,707
0
0
0
557
20,785
217
335
3,108
1,697
1,180
4,599
0
0
240
750
71
0
316
224
0
0
0
0
0
61,348
3,181
6,241
35
3,011
145
15,300
0
0
113
654
20,809
204
679
3,114
1,651
1,250
4,538
0
0
319
742
97
0
149
240
0
0
0
0
0
62,472
3,826
6,482
44
3,001
753
15,560
0
0
103
581
20,726
206
1,036
3,506
1,667
1,250
4,708
0
0
521
851
108
0
77
345
1
0
0
0
0
65,352
4,548
6,840
64
3,095
1,288
15,500
0
0
98
635
20,751
212
1,850
3,097
1,994
1,352
5,857
0
0
640
861
127
0
145
457
34
0
0
0
0
69,445
5,014
7,178
84
3,342
948
15,258
0
0
110
719
21,234
230
2,080
2,913
2,346
1,161
6,085
0
0
729
993
144
0
230
567
162
354
187
0
0
72,068
5,299
7,256
61
3,432
838
15,085
0
0
0
590
21,152
229
1,968
3,137
2,432
1,011
5,857
0
0
492
856
154
0
254
504
122
357
131
90
19
71,326
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
76
5
66
0
164
0
6
134
117
7
0
0
181
227
68
97
1
0
0
0
0
0
1,149
67
10
58
2
251
161
1
109
117
16
0
0
215
228
43
7
4
0
0
0
0
0
1,289
61
5
83
23
268
0
1
122
118
36
0
0
211
182
72
4
3
0
0
0
0
0
1,189
70
16
87
41
545
0
0
114
117
9
0
0
335
99
61
0
9
0
0
0
0
0
1,503
110
41
90
90
661
0
5
130
112
5
0
0
403
117
199
0
15
63
0
0
0
0
2,041
101
61
107
120
1,130
0
11
127
109
2
0
0
340
134
0
0
59
0
0
0
0
0
2,301
120
83
132
1,861
0
0
6
99
68
3
0
4
391
145
0
0
28
0
129
0
0
0
3,069
123
65
192
1,763
0
0
2
92
38
1
0
16
384
128
0
0
16
0
225
0
0
0
3,045
180
58
262
2,322
0
0
3
70
31
0
0
0
362
134
0
0
14
0
243
0
0
0
3,679
141
47
301
1,884
0
0
4
74
31
0
0
0
342
63
0
0
12
0
177
0
0
0
3,076
160
60
394
2,351
0
0
6
67
26
18
14
0
335
111
0
0
75
0
268
0
18
0
3,903
252
53
458
2,518
0
0
0
51
24
69
19
0
342
145
0
0
90
0
318
8
49
3
4,399
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
164
120
67
0
0
509
143
130
51
0
0
424
176
125
55
0
0
401
188
140
45
0
0
432
211
145
63
0
0
579
200
116
58
0
0
612
323
113
59
0
0
847
330
125
37
0
129
854
359
98
33
0
178
869
383
102
35
0
160
933
417
76
40
0
151
883
561
90
47
1
186
955
Decker Coll ege Of Bus ines s Technology
65
0
12
191
80
129
15
4
30
270
0
44
115
0
0
0
0
1,815
36
228
5
168
63
122
14
6
19
299
0
26
119
0
0
0
0
1,853
16
0
3
169
70
99
15
7
6
590
0
28
129
0
0
0
0
1,889
38
0
6
210
38
109
4
12
72
412
10
14
102
0
0
0
0
1,832
52
0
5
183
45
120
10
5
189
379
5
22
120
0
0
0
0
2,133
79
0
5
170
48
89
7
29
194
395
0
48
141
0
0
0
0
2,191
0
0
13
201
51
90
8
7
157
413
0
62
114
0
0
0
0
2,458
0
0
10
171
22
93
10
9
115
419
0
56
137
0
0
0
0
2,517
0
0
2
158
19
91
12
6
128
569
0
72
139
3
0
0
0
2,736
0
0
0
171
20
117
9
4
184
623
0
50
150
41
0
0
0
2,982
0
0
5
176
18
254
14
2
197
581
0
94
166
74
0
1
0
3,149
0
0
0
162
19
372
11
3
144
561
0
129
236
117
4
14
8
3,620
9
Enrollments and Awards, Louisville MSA Postsecondary Institutions (continued)
Bachelors Degrees, Academic Year ending Spring
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Masters Degrees, Academic Year ending Spring
DeVry Uni vers i ty's Kel ler Gra dua te School of Ma na gement-Kentucky
Doctoral Degrees, Academic Year ending Spring
First Professional Degrees, Academic Year ending Spring
444
0
348
5
0
1,761
3
0
15
196
188
0
0
0
0
0
2,960
500
0
334
4
0
1,831
1
0
26
225
192
0
0
0
0
0
3,113
523
0
343
4
0
1,883
0
0
18
236
313
0
0
0
0
0
3,320
603
0
404
4
0
1,856
0
0
71
180
209
0
0
0
0
0
3,327
610
0
351
6
0
1,915
0
0
71
221
323
0
4
0
0
0
3,501
614
0
419
8
0
2,164
28
0
51
227
363
8
24
0
0
0
3,906
603
0
407
11
0
2,331
7
0
74
210
369
5
35
2
0
0
4,054
668
0
432
10
0
2,433
9
0
97
185
346
20
20
11
0
0
4,231
664
0
469
19
5
2,407
12
0
96
182
272
19
19
21
0
0
4,185
649
3
429
12
21
2,582
0
0
83
172
452
38
36
42
0
0
4,519
647
5
403
14
18
2,670
13
0
84
172
436
67
38
23
3
0
4,593
729
16
509
0
19
2,776
9
2
78
181
489
58
35
20
8
1
4,930
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
159
198
1
997
14
157
177
6
1,133
12
218
252
1
1,139
10
196
205
5
1,061
15
264
227
9
1,173
12
199
189
5
1,245
10
238
183
4
1,255
16
197
205
5
1,280
10
235
234
3
1,261
14
223
217
2
1,281
33
238
255
0
1,245
38
235
224
0
1251
35
55
78
23
0
0
0
1,525
44
98
23
0
0
0
1,650
53
107
28
0
0
0
1,808
63
159
60
0
0
0
1,764
59
220
96
0
0
0
2,060
76
143
93
0
0
0
1,960
122
208
83
0
7
0
2,116
103
214
86
0
20
0
2,120
119
210
95
0
24
0
2,195
108
205
133
0
10
0
2,212
106
261
171
5
14
0
2,333
105
250
234
15
14
1
2,364
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
76
9
29
23
137
65
7
64
34
170
90
4
57
27
178
89
13
86
49
237
106
6
75
36
223
112
5
82
32
231
144
3
61
49
257
135
6
44
58
243
151
3
84
40
278
142
0
92
31
265
161
0
106
44
311
156
0
89
36
281
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
0
310
37
131
0
478
0
315
27
137
0
479
0
321
30
146
0
497
0
323
36
185
0
544
0
330
26
164
0
520
38
333
30
189
0
590
27
327
28
180
0
562
28
346
22
202
0
598
36
343
32
287
0
698
41
332
10
251
0
634
42
347
5
233
0
627
46
371
9
258
64
748
Note: Jeffers on Community Col lege a nd Jeffers on Technica l Col lege merged to form Jeffers on Community a nd Technica l Col lege i n 2005.
10
11
Postsecondary Degree Report
June 2013
I
n this supplement to the KentuckianaWorks Human Capital Scorecard, we present data on
postsecondary degrees awarded in certain fields that are seen as being the most directly related
to long-term economic development. These strategic fields are the STEM disciplines of Science,
Technology, Engineering and Mathematics, and all healthcare-related fields. The former include
agricultural & plant sciences, environmental science, computer & information sciences, math,
science & technical teacher education, engineering, engineering technology, biology/biological
sciences, mathematics and all the physical sciences. The latter include health occupations, teacher
education, clinical and counseling psychology, chiropractic medicine, dentistry and related fields,
medical doctor training, pharmacist training, nursing, and related health services, allied health and
health sciences fields. The data come from the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System
(IPEDS) administered by the National Center for Educational Statistics.
This report covers data from 2004 through 2011, and certain trends and recent developments are
highlighted below:
In 2011, the overall number of degrees awarded in the STEM fields in the Louisville
Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) increased nearly 14 percent. The gain occurred along a
wide spectrum of degrees, fairly evenly split among associate, bachelor’s and master’s
degrees. Most of the increase in associate degrees occurred at ITT Technical Institute in
three majors - Computer Systems Networking, Electronic and Communications Engineering
Technology, and CAD/CADD Drafting and/or Design. For bachelor’s degrees, the increase
was evenly split between the University of Louisville and Sullivan University, which saw its
first graduates in Computer/Computer Systems Technology. At the master’s degree level,
the increase was due mostly to more graduates at the University of Louisville across several
different engineering fields, but Sullivan University also had its first graduates in Information
Technology.
Overall STEM degrees awarded among the entire group of 16 peer metros rose 11.7 percent
from 2010 to 2011. Louisville’s rankings in terms of STEM degrees per capita are unchanged
from last year, except for awards below the associate degree level, where Louisville dropped
five spots from 4th to 9th. While the number of those awards in Louisville was virtually
unchanged from 2010, six of the peer metros experienced three-digit increases in the
number of awards at this level. Three peer metro areas (Charlotte, Greensboro and
Indianapolis) have increases larger than the number of degrees earned in Louisville.
Louisville’s trend for bachelor’s degrees on a per capita basis is positive, having moved from
15th to 12th since 2004. Louisville postsecondary institutions awarded 108 more bachelor’s
12
degrees in STEM majors in 2011, which was the 6th best increase among the peer metros.
Only Charlotte and Columbus have increases significantly greater than Louisville’s.
On a per capita basis, Louisville has shown the second-best trend among the peer metros
since 2004 in degrees in STEM fields. Indianapolis is first. Louisville has moved up or held
steady in the rankings for total degrees and all levels of degree except for degrees below the
associate level.
Degrees awarded in healthcare-related fields increased almost 18 percent in 2011 (the
increase was just 10.2 percent for the entire group of peer metros). While there were fewer
master’s and doctoral degrees awarded, all the other levels of degree were up by at least 20
percent. The gains below the associate level were spread among several institutions,
especially Jefferson Community and Technical College and the private schools Galen
College of Nursing, Brown Mackie College and ATA College. The three private colleges,
along with Ivy Tech Community College, account for most of the increase in associate
degrees.
Healthcare bachelor’s degrees were up 11 percent, with both Bellarmine University and the
University of Louisville awarding about 20 more degrees than in 2010. In addition, Sullivan
University awarded its first degrees in Health Services Administration. The increase in First
Professional degrees was entirely due to the first Doctor of Pharmacy graduates from
Sullivan University.
In the peer rankings, Louisville stayed in 9th place for all healthcare-related degrees and
awards, but moved up two spots (to 6th) for awards below the associate level, and one spot
for both associate degrees (to 4th) and First Professional degrees (to 9th).
In terms of the percentage of all degrees awarded that are in these strategic sectors,
Louisville generally ranks in the middle of the pack of peer metros. Louisville’s percentage of
degrees in the strategic sectors is above the average for the group of peers for associate
degrees (50 percent versus 42.6 percent), bachelor’s degrees (26.7 percent versus 26.4
percent) and for total degrees awarded (39.6 percent versus 38.6 percent). It is farthest below
the average for the First Professional degree level (44.9 percent versus 56.5 percent). Overall,
Louisville ranks 5th in terms of the percentage of all postsecondary degrees awarded that are
in these strategic sectors.
The KentuckianaWorks Human Capital Scorecard is produced for KentuckianaWorks by economic and
demographic researchers at the Urban Studies Institute of the University of Louisville. The Scorecard
may be viewed online at www.kentuckianaworks.org or http://usi.louisville.edu. For more
information, contact Barry Kornstein ([email protected]).
13
SCORECARD
Notes
Health Care
STEM
Postsecondary Degrees in Strategic Sectors
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics Degrees
Postsecondary degrees, academic year ending Spring
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Associate degrees
Louisville MSA
Bachelor's degrees
Louisville MSA
Master's degrees
Louisville MSA
Doctoral degrees
Louisville MSA
Ranking, per capita (out of 16 comparison metros)
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Associate degrees
Louisville MSA
Bachelor's degrees
Louisville MSA
Master's degrees
Louisville MSA
Doctoral degrees
Louisville MSA
Health Care Related Degrees
Postsecondary degrees, academic year ending Spring
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Associate degrees
Louisville MSA
Bachelor's degrees
Louisville MSA
Master's degrees
Louisville MSA
Doctoral degrees
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Ranking, per capita (out of 16 comparison metros)
2004
2005
1,535
186
541
473
296
39
2004
1,482
151
489
523
272
47
2005
11
7
6
15
6
10
2004
11
6
5
14
6
8
2005
1,926
779
422
290
197
28
210
2004
1,974
709
517
368
100
24
256
2005
2006
2007
1,535
189
456
511
307
72
2006
2008
1,523
182
468
537
263
73
2007
9
5
4
14
6
8
2006
2008
10
3
4
13
6
7
2007
2,600
1,147
630
420
125
35
243
2006
2009
1,635
300
469
513
281
72
2009
9
4
4
13
6
8
2008
2,822
1,238
699
434
172
37
242
2007
2010
1,610
278
399
568
296
69
2010
9
3
4
12
6
9
2009
3,011
1,321
770
470
155
42
253
2008
2011
1,747
275
440
684
276
72
2011
8
4
4
12
6
9
2010
3,272
1,425
913
458
193
28
255
2009
1,990
277
506
792
342
73
8
9
4
12
6
9
2011
3,804
1,752
1,066
473
223
31
259
2010
4,478
2,095
1,305
525
189
28
336
2011
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
11
7
11
11
10
7
Associate degrees
Louisville MSA
10
10
8
9
8
6
5
4
Bachelor's degrees
Louisville MSA
10
10
9
10
10
11
12
12
Master's degrees
Doctoral degrees
References and notes
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
Louisville MSA
9
7
8
13
10
8
12
9
8
11
9
8
11
5
8
11
9
8
11
5
10
13
5
9
10
6
10
7
11
8
9
8
9
6
Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Educational Statistics, The Integrated Postsecondary Education Data
System (IPEDS), data collected during academic years 2004-05, 2005-06, 2006-7, 2007-08, 2008-09, 2009-10, 2010-11, 2011-12.
STEM fields include agricultural & plant sciences, environmental science, computer &
information sciences, math, science & technical teacher education, engineering,
engineering technology, biology/biological sciences, mathematics, and all the physical
sciences.
Health care related fields include health occupations teacher education, clinical and
counseling psychology, chiropractic medicine, dentistry and related fields, medical
Research and compilation by University of Louisville
doctor training, pharmacist training, nursing, and related health services, allied health,
and health sciences fields.
14
Postsecondary Degrees Awarded per 100,000 Residents, 2011
Science, Technology, Engineering, & Mathematics Fields
with Trends Among Louisville and its 15 Competitor Metropolitan Areas
Below Associate
Relative
Level (less than 2
change
years), 2011
Rank since 2004
Dayton
75.35
1
↔
Lexington
73.24
2
↑
Greensboro
59.51
3
↑
Charlotte
34.92
4
↑
Jacksonville
29.33
5
↑
Indianapolis
29.12
6
↑
Columbus
27.07
7
↑
Kansas City
23.29
8
↓
Louisville
21.39
9
↓
Birmingham
17.31
10
↓
Cincinnati
15.34
11
↔
Memphis
11.62
12
↑
Raleigh
11.43
13
↓
Nashville
10.45
14
↑
Richmond
8.82
15
↓
Omaha
5.81
16
↓
Bachelor's
Relative
Degree (includes
change
postbac), 2011 Rank since 2004
Raleigh
217.87
1
↔
Lexington
181.12
2
↔
Columbus
144.90
3
↔
Dayton
109.77
4
↑
Greensboro
100.96
5
↓
Omaha
83.23
6
↑
Nashville
82.92
7
↓
Richmond
81.77
8
↑
Cincinnati
81.24
9
↓
Charlotte
65.94
10
↓
Indianapolis
62.47
11
↑
Louisville
61.17
12
↑
Birmingham
52.81
13
↓
Memphis
40.36
14
↑
Jacksonville
39.11
15
↓
Kansas City
38.19
16
↓
Relative
Doctoral Degree,
change
2011
Rank since 2004
Raleigh
25.18
1
↔
Lexington
22.54
2
↔
Columbus
18.29
3
↔
Nashville
12.68
4
↔
Birmingham
9.45
5
↔
Dayton
7.93
6
↑
Cincinnati
6.55
7
↓
Richmond
5.75
8
↔
Louisville
5.64
9
↑
Omaha
3.99
10
↑
Indianapolis
2.14
11
↑
Greensboro
1.92
12
↓
Memphis
1.89
13
↔
Charlotte
1.67
14
↔
Jacksonville
0.00
15
↑
Kansas City
0.00
15
↔
Dayton
Lexington
Richmond
Louisville
Columbus
Cincinnati
Kansas City
Birmingham
Greensboro
Charlotte
Nashville
Memphis
Omaha
Indianapolis
Jacksonville
Raleigh
Associate Level (2
Relative
years to less than 4
change
years), 2011
Rank since 2004
73.34
1
↔
62.81
2
↑
42.62
3
↓
39.08
4
↑
34.81
5
↑
33.96
6
↑
32.30
7
↑
30.20
8
↓
29.96
9
↑
29.85
10
↑
27.15
11
↓
26.78
12
↑
25.77
13
↓
24.01
14
↓
22.28
15
↓
20.80
16
↓
Dayton
Raleigh
Lexington
Columbus
Greensboro
Louisville
Cincinnati
Omaha
Birmingham
Richmond
Indianapolis
Charlotte
Kansas City
Nashville
Memphis
Jacksonville
Relative
Master's Degree,
change
2011
Rank since 2004
88.95
1
↑
82.77
2
↓
40.06
3
↔
31.64
4
↑
27.63
5
↓
26.41
6
↔
21.28
7
↔
19.61
8
↑
18.81
9
↑
16.46
10
↑
15.46
11
↑
14.43
12
↓
14.32
13
↑
13.30
14
↓
8.98
15
↓
2.21
16
↔
Lexington
Raleigh
Dayton
Columbus
Greensboro
Cincinnati
Richmond
Louisville
Charlotte
Nashville
Omaha
Indianapolis
Birmingham
Kansas City
Jacksonville
Memphis
Total Degrees,
2011
379.76
358.05
355.34
256.72
219.98
158.37
155.43
153.69
146.81
146.49
138.41
133.20
128.59
108.10
92.92
89.62
Relative
change
Rank since 2004
1
↑
2
↓
3
↔
4
↔
5
↔
6
↑
7
↓
8
↑
9
↑
10
↓
11
↓
12
↑
13
↓
14
↓
15
↓
16
↔
Source: Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS), 2004-05, 2011-12.
15
Health Care Related Fields
Below Associate
Relative
Level (less than 2
change
years), 2011
Rank since 2004
Dayton
400.41
1
↑
Jacksonville
362.36
2
↔
Lexington
267.09
3
↑
Memphis
191.08
4
↓
Nashville
187.68
5
↑
Louisville
161.79
6
↑
Kansas City
160.57
7
↓
Cincinnati
154.11
8
↑
Columbus
152.65
9
↓
Charlotte
91.40
10
↓
Indianapolis
88.61
11
↑
Greensboro
79.48
12
↑
Richmond
78.70
13
↓
Raleigh
70.73
14
↑
Birmingham
65.62
15
↓
Omaha
65.21
16
↓
Relative
Bachelor's
Degree (includes
change
Omaha
134.76
1
↔
Columbus
85.29
2
↑
Dayton
64.35
3
↔
Cincinnati
62.63
4
↑
Jacksonville
62.41
5
↑
Lexington
61.97
6
↓
Greensboro
55.41
7
↓
Birmingham
52.28
8
↓
Kansas City
51.83
9
↓
Indianapolis
48.07
10
↓
Nashville
46.01
11
↑
Louisville
40.55
12
↓
Richmond
30.96
13
↔
Memphis
30.48
14
↔
Charlotte
24.39
15
↔
Raleigh
8.85
16
↔
Omaha
Lexington
Birmingham
Jacksonville
Indianapolis
Kansas City
Richmond
Columbus
Louisville
Nashville
Dayton
Cincinnati
Memphis
Charlotte
Greensboro
Raleigh
Relative
change
1st Professional,
2011
Rank since 2004
80.83
1
↔
80.75
2
↔
44.16
3
↑
40.51
4
↑
35.98
5
↑
35.27
6
↓
31.59
7
↓
27.28
8
↓
25.95
9
↓
21.15
10
↓
18.45
11
↑
14.55
12
↓
8.90
13
↓
3.90
14
↓
0.00
15
↓
0.00
15
↓
Dayton
Lexington
Indianapolis
Louisville
Cincinnati
Birmingham
Jacksonville
Kansas City
Columbus
Omaha
Richmond
Charlotte
Nashville
Greensboro
Memphis
Raleigh
Associate Level (2
Relative
change
years), 2011
Rank since 2004
189.03
1
↑
142.10
2
↓
106.27
3
↑
100.78
4
↑
92.61
5
↓
87.88
6
↑
86.90
7
↓
83.79
8
↑
80.07
9
↑
79.92
10
↓
66.25
11
↓
58.15
12
↓
54.54
13
↓
51.71
14
↑
43.83
15
↓
39.79
16
↓
Lexington
Birmingham
Nashville
Omaha
Richmond
Cincinnati
Dayton
Indianapolis
Columbus
Greensboro
Jacksonville
Kansas City
Louisville
Memphis
Charlotte
Raleigh
Graduate, 2011
74.08
69.33
52.62
50.73
39.15
37.37
33.71
30.14
26.20
24.21
18.60
17.49
16.76
14.79
9.13
4.64
Relative
change
Rank since 2004
1
↑
2
↑
3
↑
4
↓
5
↑
6
↑
7
↑
8
↔
9
↓
10
↓
11
↑
12
↓
13
↓
14
↑
15
↓
16
↔
Dayton
Lexington
Jacksonville
Omaha
Columbus
Nashville
Cincinnati
Kansas City
Louisville
Birmingham
Indianapolis
Memphis
Richmond
Greensboro
Charlotte
Raleigh
Total Degrees,
2011
705.95
625.99
570.78
411.46
371.49
362.00
361.27
348.96
345.83
319.27
309.07
289.08
246.66
210.82
186.97
124.02
Relative
change
Rank since 2004
1
↑
2
↔
3
↑
4
↓
5
↑
6
↑
7
↑
8
↓
9
↑
10
↓
11
↑
12
↓
13
↓
14
↑
15
↓
16
↔
16
Percentage of Degrees Awarded in Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics
& Health Care Related Fields, with Ranks Among the Sixteen Competitor Metropolitan Areas, 2011
Below Associate Associate Level
Level Awards Awards (2 years
to less than 4
(less than 2
Metropolitan Area
years)
years)
Birmingham
48.9%
49.7%
Charlotte
57.3%
36.6%
Cincinnati
66.2%
49.8%
Columbus
74.0%
48.4%
Dayton
71.4%
58.0%
Greensboro
37.4%
36.6%
Indianapolis
67.5%
52.9%
Jacksonville
61.1%
21.9%
Kansas City
58.9%
38.1%
Lexington
52.2%
47.5%
Louisville
53.9%
50.0%
Memphis
69.0%
32.3%
Nashville
58.1%
35.8%
Omaha
66.3%
34.6%
Raleigh
48.6%
31.2%
Richmond
61.0%
58.5%
Birmingham
Charlotte
Cincinnati
Columbus
Dayton
Greensboro
Indianapolis
Jacksonville
Kansas City
Lexington
Louisville
Memphis
Nashville
Omaha
Raleigh
Richmond
14
11
6
1
2
16
4
7
9
13
12
3
10
5
15
8
6
11
5
7
2
10
3
16
9
8
4
14
12
13
15
1
Bachelor's
Degree
(includes
postbac)
31.2%
21.8%
24.7%
27.1%
30.6%
20.2%
28.9%
26.8%
25.2%
24.4%
26.7%
21.4%
22.1%
31.1%
38.8%
21.4%
Graduate
Degrees
47.6%
21.4%
28.8%
27.9%
38.2%
24.1%
29.2%
29.5%
22.2%
31.5%
23.9%
19.1%
28.6%
27.0%
40.9%
28.8%
First
Professional
75.5%
41.9%
48.9%
48.0%
43.8%
n/a
71.7%
55.4%
81.1%
73.2%
44.9%
48.0%
63.3%
82.3%
0.0%
69.5%
Total Degrees
44.4%
33.3%
38.5%
37.8%
51.2%
27.1%
43.5%
39.9%
39.4%
38.3%
39.6%
38.1%
34.8%
37.0%
39.2%
36.0%
2
13
10
6
4
16
5
7
9
11
8
14
12
3
1
15
1
15
7
10
3
12
6
5
14
4
13
16
9
11
2
8
3
14
9
11
13
n/a
5
8
2
4
12
10
7
1
15
6
2
15
8
11
1
16
3
4
6
9
5
10
14
12
7
13
Source: Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS), 2011-12.
17
Awards in Strategic Sectors, Louisville MSA Postsecondary Institutions
Science, Technology, Engineering, & Mathematics Fields
Awards below Associate level, Academic Year ending Spring 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Jeffers on Communi ty Col lege/Jeffers on Communi ty & Technology Col lege
Louis vi ll e Technica l Ins ti tute/Sull iva n Col lege of Technol ogy a nd Des i gn
RETS El ectronic Ins ti tute/Brown Ma cki e Col lege-Loui s vi ll e
Sul li va n Univers ity
ATA Ca reer Educa ti on/ATA Col lege
Indi a na Univers i ty-Southea s t
Jeffers on Communi ty Col lege/Jeffers on Communi ty & Technology Col lege
RETS El ectronic Ins ti tute/Brown Ma cki e Col lege-Loui s vi ll e
Decker Coll ege Of Bus i nes s Technol ogy
Kentucky Ca reer Ins titute/Da yma r Coll ege-Louis vi ll e
ITT Technica l Ins ti tute
DeVry Uni vers ity-Kentucky
Indi a na Univers i ty-Southea s t
Bell a rmine Uni vers i ty
Uni vers i ty of Loui s vi ll e
Spa l di ng Uni vers i ty
ITT Technica l Ins ti tute
Uni vers i ty of Phoeni x-Loui s vil le Ca mpus
Bell a rmine Uni vers i ty
9
64
1
44
5
63
0
186
6
36
0
38
2
69
0
151
11
63
0
39
3
71
2
189
15
59
0
36
0
55
17
182
61
141
0
26
0
58
14
300
20
173
0
36
0
37
12
278
35
132
0
39
0
64
5
275
71
144
0
14
0
48
0
277
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
45
18
95
1
87
108
63
4
0
120
0
541
43
8
56
7
83
65
72
0
14
149
0
497
51
11
53
0
96
48
77
0
6
114
0
456
53
3
36
0
131
33
70
0
5
137
0
468
77
8
44
0
120
16
66
0
0
138
0
469
48
5
45
0
120
8
48
0
1
124
0
399
40
7
44
0
141
15
76
0
0
117
0
440
60
4
41
0
134
47
37
0
10
169
4
506
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
64
39
0
350
20
0
0
0
473
48
27
0
434
6
0
0
0
515
51
27
0
420
9
0
4
0
511
54
56
0
407
4
0
15
1
537
64
26
0
399
3
0
15
6
513
56
24
0
453
6
0
22
7
568
55
42
0
557
3
0
24
3
684
61
41
4
600
2
59
24
1
792
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
15
281
0
296
10
262
0
272
9
298
0
307
12
251
0
263
11
270
0
281
13
283
0
296
9
267
0
276
6
323
13
342
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
39
39
47
47
72
72
73
73
72
72
69
69
72
72
73
73
Note: Jeffers on Communi ty Col lege a nd Jeffers on Technica l Col lege merged to form Jeffers on Community a nd Technica l
Col lege i n 2005.
18
Awards in Strategic Sectors, Louisville MSA Postsecondary Institutions
Health Care Related Fields
Awards below Associate level, Academic Year ending Spring 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Ivy Tech Communi ty Coll ege-South Centra l
Ga l en Coll ege of Nurs i ng-Loui s vil le
Jeffers on Communi ty Coll ege/Jeffers on Community & Technology Coll ege
Jeffers on Techni ca l Coll ege
RETS El ectronic Ins titute/Brown Ma ckie Col lege-Loui s vil le
Spenceria n Col lege
Kentucky Ca reer Ins ti tute/Da yma r Col lege-Louis vi ll e
Decker Col lege-Louis vi ll e
ATA Ca reer Educa tion/ATA Col lege
Da yma r Coll ege-Onli ne
Ivy Tech Communi ty Coll ege-South Centra l
Ga l en Coll ege of Nurs i ng-Loui s vil le
Bell a rmine Uni vers ity
Jeffers on Communi ty Coll ege/Jeffers on Community & Technology Coll ege
Uni vers ity of Loui s vil le
RETS El ectronic Ins titute/Brown Ma ckie Col lege-Loui s vil le
Spenceria n Col lege
Kentucky Ca reer Ins ti tute/Da yma r Col lege-Louis vi ll e
ATA Ca reer Educa tion/ATA Col lege
Da yma r Coll ege-Onli ne
Indi a na Uni vers i ty-Southea s t
Otta wa Univers ity-Jeffers onvil le
Uni vers ity of Phoenix-Louis vil le Ca mpus
First Professional Degrees, Academic Year ending Spring
88
90
0
75
0
0
402
0
15
109
0
0
779
83
107
0
124
0
0
338
2
55
0
0
0
709
103
132
368
0
0
1
385
3
28
0
127
0
1,147
87
192
345
0
1
0
384
5
16
0
208
0
1,238
87
262
371
0
0
0
356
2
14
0
229
0
1,321
98
301
512
0
0
0
339
0
10
0
165
0
1,425
65
394
585
0
18
0
335
27
65
0
263
0
1,752
99
458
660
0
69
0
340
48
97
0
318
6
2,095
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
75
0
0
126
28
10
0
173
10
0
0
0
422
77
0
0
194
29
5
0
186
8
18
0
0
517
118
0
0
264
30
17
0
153
9
39
0
0
630
129
129
0
256
0
23
0
113
9
40
0
0
699
140
178
0
247
0
39
1
123
0
39
3
0
770
176
160
0
241
0
66
0
182
22
25
41
0
913
177
151
0
217
0
165
0
190
27
65
74
0
1,066
258
186
1
238
0
234
0
139
33
94
117
5
1,305
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
30
90
102
68
0
0
290
34
130
127
76
0
1
368
57
128
152
83
0
0
420
45
133
189
67
0
0
434
63
152
182
73
0
0
470
52
143
184
78
0
1
458
76
133
183
72
0
9
473
56
154
204
75
28
8
525
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
35
74
88
0
197
31
51
18
0
100
17
48
60
0
125
38
79
55
0
172
10
79
66
0
155
9
114
68
2
193
30
103
90
0
223
19
96
74
0
189
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
16
12
28
14
10
24
15
20
35
13
24
37
18
24
42
12
16
28
16
15
31
11
17
28
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
0
210
0
210
38
218
0
256
27
216
0
243
28
214
0
242
36
217
0
253
41
214
0
255
42
217
0
259
46
226
64
336
Note: Jeffers on Communi ty Coll ege a nd Jeffers on Techni ca l Coll ege merged to form Jeffers on Communi ty a nd Techni ca l
Col lege i n 2005.
19
Postsecondary Degrees Awarded, 2011
Below Associate
Relative
change
Level (less than 2
years), 2011
Rank since 2000
Jacksonville
8,727
1
↑
Kansas City
6,407
2
↓
Dayton
5,632
3
↑
Nashville
5,514
4
↓
Cincinnati
5,471
5
↓
Columbus
4,514
6
↑
Louisville
4,399
7
↔
Charlotte
3,959
8
↑
Memphis
3,893
9
↓
Lexington
3,124
10
↑
Indianapolis
3,103
11
↑
Greensboro
2,717
12
↑
Raleigh
1,969
13
↓
Birmingham
1,921
14
↓
Richmond
1,822
15
↓
Omaha
940
16
↓
Bachelor's
Relative
Degree (includes
change
Columbus
15,802
1
↔
Cincinnati
12,459
2
↔
Nashville
9,419
3
↔
Charlotte
7,429
4
↑
Kansas City
7,338
5
↓
Indianapolis
6,804
6
↑
Raleigh
6,794
7
↓
Richmond
6,696
8
↑
Omaha
6,148
9
↑
Greensboro
5,659
10
↓
Jacksonville
5,150
11
↑
Louisville
4,930
12
↑
Dayton
4,818
13
↓
Lexington
4,770
14
↓
Memphis
4,378
15
↓
Birmingham
3,819
16
↓
Columbus
Jacksonville
Kansas City
Indianapolis
Omaha
Louisville
Birmingham
Cincinnati
Richmond
Nashville
Lexington
Dayton
Memphis
Charlotte
Raleigh
Greensboro
Relative
change
First
Professional, 2011 Rank since 2000
1,057 1
↑
995 2
↑
893 3
↓
892 4
↔
862 5
↔
748 6
↑
662 7
↓
636 8
↑
577 9
↓
540 10
↓
529 11
↓
356 12
↑
246 13
↓
167 14
↑
75 15
↓
0 16
↔
Jacksonville
Kansas City
Cincinnati
Columbus
Indianapolis
Charlotte
Dayton
Nashville
Louisville
Memphis
Birmingham
Omaha
Richmond
Raleigh
Lexington
Greensboro
Associate Level (2
Relative
change
years), 2011
Rank since 2000
6,768
1
↑
6,258
2
↓
5,433
3
↔
4,415
4
↔
4,378
5
↑
4,316
6
↑
3,822
7
↓
3,692
8
↑
3,620
9
↓
2,894
10
↑
2,688
11
↓
2,676
12
↓
2,362
13
↓
2,259
14
↓
2,068
15
↔
1,629
16
↔
Columbus
Cincinnati
Nashville
Raleigh
Kansas City
Indianapolis
Dayton
Richmond
Louisville
Omaha
Birmingham
Charlotte
Lexington
Memphis
Greensboro
Jacksonville
Graduate, 2011
5,067
4,835
4,449
3,206
2,946
2,907
2,888
2,708
2,645
2,418
2,323
2,121
2,079
1,781
1,630
959
Relative
change
Rank since 2000
1
↑
2
↓
3
↔
4
↑
5
↔
6
↑
7
↓
8
↔
9
↔
10
↓
11
↓
12
↑
13
↓
14
↓
15
↓
16
↔
Columbus
Cincinnati
Kansas City
Nashville
Jacksonville
Indianapolis
Charlotte
Dayton
Louisville
Raleigh
Richmond
Memphis
Omaha
Lexington
Greensboro
Birmingham
Relative
change
Total Degrees,
2011
Rank since 2000
30,855 1
↑
28,834 2
↔
23,842 3
↓
23,614 4
↔
22,599 5
↑
18,084 6
↑
17,992 7
↑
17,516 8
↓
16,342 9
↑
14,303 10
↓
14,165 11
↓
13,192 12
↑
13,044 13
↓
12,570 14
↑
11,635 15
↑
11,413 16
↓
20
Education Attainment Rates, Louisville and 15 Comparison Metropolitan Areas, 2009-2011
Percent of Population 25 Years and Older with High School and College Degrees
High School
lower
upper
bound
bound
Estimate
College
lower
bound
Estimate
41.3%
40.8%
33.6%
33.0%
upper
bound
Omaha-Council Bluffs, NE-IA
Kansas City, MO-KS
91.0%
90.1%
90.6%
89.8%
91.5%
90.4%
Raleigh-Cary, NC
Lexington-Fayette, KY
Columbus, OH
Raleigh-Cary, NC
Dayton, OH
90.0%
89.6%
88.8%
89.7%
89.1%
88.3%
90.3%
90.1%
89.2%
Columbus, OH
Kansas City, MO-KS
Charlotte-Gastonia-Concord, NC-SC
33.0%
32.7%
32.6%
32.7%
32.4%
32.2%
33.3%
33.0%
32.9%
Jacksonville, FL
Cincinnati-Middletown, OH-KY-IN
88.5%
88.2%
88.1%
87.9%
89.0%
88.5%
Omaha-Council Bluffs, NE-IA
Richmond, VA
32.5%
31.7%
32.1%
31.3%
33.0%
32.0%
Indianapolis, IN
Nashville-Davidson-Murfreesboro, TN
88.1%
86.8%
87.8%
86.4%
88.5%
87.2%
Indianapolis, IN
Nashville-Davidson-Murfreesboro, TN
30.8%
30.4%
30.4%
30.0%
31.1%
30.7%
Louisville, KY-IN
Lexington-Fayette, KY
86.8%
86.8%
86.4%
87.2%
86.2%
87.4%
Cincinnati-Middletown, OH-KY-IN
Jacksonville, FL
29.3%
27.1%
29.0%
26.7%
29.5%
27.5%
Charlotte-Gastonia-Concord, NC-SC
Richmond, VA
Memphis, TN-MS-AR
86.8%
85.9%
85.2%
86.4%
85.5%
84.7%
87.1%
86.3%
85.6%
Birmingham-Hoover, AL
Greensboro-High Point, NC
Louisville, KY-IN
27.1%
26.1%
25.4%
26.7%
25.7%
27.5%
26.5%
25.1%
25.7%
Birmingham-Hoover, AL
Greensboro-High Point, NC
85.1%
84.2%
84.6%
83.7%
85.5%
84.7%
Memphis, TN-MS-AR
Dayton, OH
25.0%
24.8%
24.7%
24.4%
25.4%
25.2%
41.8%
34.1%
Source: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey, released September 2012.
21
22
Below Associate
Relative
change
Level (less than 2
years), 2011
Rank since 2000
Dayton
666.2
1
↑
Lexington
651.9
2
↑
Jacksonville
641.6
3
↑
Greensboro
371.7
4
↑
Nashville
341.0
5
↔
Louisville
339.7
6
↑
Kansas City
312.1
7
↓
Memphis
293.7
8
↓
Cincinnati
255.9
9
↓
Columbus
242.9
10
↑
Charlotte
220.5
11
↑
Indianapolis
174.5
12
↑
Birmingham
169.7
13
↓
Raleigh
169.2
14
↓
Richmond
143.5
15
↓
Omaha
107.2
16
↓
Bachelor's
Relative
Degree (includes
change
Lexington
995.3
1
↔
Columbus
850.3
2
↑
Greensboro
774.2
3
↓
Omaha
700.9
4
↑
Raleigh
583.9
5
↓
Cincinnati
582.7
6
↑
Nashville
582.4
7
↔
Dayton
569.9
8
↓
Richmond
527.5
9
↔
Charlotte
413.8
10
↔
Indianapolis
382.6
11
↑
Louisville
380.7
12
↑
Jacksonville
378.6
13
↑
Kansas City
357.5
14
↓
Birmingham
337.3
15
↓
Memphis
330.3
16
↓
Lexington
Omaha
Jacksonville
Birmingham
Louisville
Columbus
Indianapolis
Richmond
Kansas City
Dayton
Nashville
Cincinnati
Memphis
Charlotte
Raleigh
Greensboro
Relative
First
change
Professional, 2011 Rank since 2000
110.4
1
↔
98.3
2
↔
73.1
3
↑
58.5
4
↑
57.8
5
↑
56.9
6
↓
50.2
7
↔
45.5
8
↓
43.5
9
↓
42.1
10
↑
33.4
11
↓
29.7
12
↑
18.6
13
↓
9.3
14
↑
6.4
15
↓
0.0
16
↔
Jacksonville
Dayton
Lexington
Omaha
Kansas City
Louisville
Cincinnati
Indianapolis
Charlotte
Columbus
Birmingham
Nashville
Greensboro
Memphis
Raleigh
Richmond
Associate Level (2
Relative
change
years), 2011
Rank since 2000
497.6
1
↔
452.1
2
↑
431.5
3
↓
305.1
4
↔
304.9
5
↔
279.6
6
↑
254.1
7
↔
246.2
8
↑
240.4
9
↑
237.6
10
↑
237.4
11
↓
228.3
12
↑
222.9
13
↑
218.3
14
↓
194.2
15
↓
186.1
16
↓
Lexington
Dayton
Omaha
Raleigh
Nashville
Columbus
Cincinnati
Greensboro
Richmond
Birmingham
Louisville
Indianapolis
Kansas City
Memphis
Charlotte
Jacksonville
Graduate, 2011
433.8
341.6
275.7
275.5
275.1
272.6
226.1
223.0
213.3
205.2
204.3
163.4
143.5
134.4
118.1
70.5
Relative
change
Rank since 2000
1
↔
2
↔
3
↔
4
↔
5
↑
6
↓
7
↑
8
↓
9
↔
10
↔
11
↔
12
↑
13
↓
14
↓
15
↓
16
↔
Lexington
Dayton
Jacksonville
Columbus
Greensboro
Omaha
Nashville
Cincinnati
Louisville
Raleigh
Kansas City
Richmond
Indianapolis
Birmingham
Charlotte
Memphis
Total Degrees,
2011
2622.9
2071.9
1661.4
1660.2
1591.7
1487.2
1460.2
1348.6
1262.1
1229.3
1161.5
1115.9
1016.8
1008.0
1002.1
995.2
Relative
change
Rank since 2000
1
↔
2
↑
3
↑
4
↑
5
↑
6
↓
7
↑
8
↔
9
↑
10
↓
11
↓
12
↓
13
↑
14
↓
15
↔
16
↓
23
Postsecondary Enrollment per 100,000 Residents, 2011
Dayton
Lexington
Omaha
Jacksonville
Greensboro
Kansas City
Columbus
Raleigh
Richmond
Memphis
Charlotte
Louisville
Nashville
Birmingham
Indianapolis
Cincinnati
Relative
Associate Level
change
Only, 2011
Rank since 2000
3,295
1
↔
3,152
2
↔
3,019
3
↑
2,925
4
↑
2,837
5
↑
2,796
6
↓
2,201
7
↑
2,190
8
↓
2,185
9
↓
2,157
10
↓
2,067
11
↑
1,756
12
↓
1,734
13
↓
1,654
14
↔
1,504
15
↑
1,088
16
↓
Lexington
Omaha
Dayton
Raleigh
Nashville
Columbus
Louisville
Cincinnati
Birmingham
Richmond
Greensboro
Kansas City
Indianapolis
Memphis
Charlotte
Jacksonville
Graduate & 1st
Professional
Students, 2011
2,029
1,512
1,088
1,048
1,032
1,017
955
925
843
825
789
651
640
546
508
430
Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Relative
change
since 2000
↔
↔
↑
↓
↑
↓
↑
↑
↑
↓
↔
↓
↔
↔
↔
↔
Lexington
Greensboro
Dayton
Columbus
Omaha
Raleigh
Richmond
Nashville
Kansas City
Cincinnati
Jacksonville
Louisville
Memphis
Charlotte
Indianapolis
Birmingham
All
Relative
Undergraduates,
change
2011
Rank since 2000
9,089
1
↔
7,419
2
↑
7,251
3
↓
6,378
4
↑
6,286
5
↑
5,288
6
↓
5,160
7
↑
5,156
8
↓
5,012
9
↔
4,873
10
↔
4,829
11
↑
4,553
12
↓
4,384
13
↓
4,356
14
↑
4,350
15
↑
4,054
16
↓
Lexington
Dayton
Greensboro
Omaha
Columbus
Raleigh
Nashville
Richmond
Cincinnati
Kansas City
Louisville
Jacksonville
Indianapolis
Memphis
Birmingham
Charlotte
Total
Relative
Postsecondary,
change
2011
Rank since 2000
11,118
1
↔
8,338
2
↔
8,208
3
↑
7,798
4
↑
7,395
5
↑
6,336
6
↓
6,188
7
↔
5,986
8
↔
5,798
9
↑
5,663
10
↓
5,508
11
↔
5,260
12
↑
4,990
13
↑
4,930
14
↓
4,897
15
↓
4,864
16
↓
24

KentuckianaWorks Human Capital Scorecard

Transcription

Similar documents

a printable file of all of our members

Harrods Creek Floodplain

here - Wuol

Allegato - comitatomontecampione.it

Village Shops at Colony Sq 71708 Brchr.p65

MSA TrailReportMaps-UP

year in review - Big Brothers Big Sisters of Kentuckiana

MAP BRO 2015 12BC.indd - Kentucky Bourbon Trail

SLABS | TILES | ACCESSORIES

Commencement at Illinois