H A DBQ OW TO

HOW TO ADDRESS A DBQ
•AP
means Address the Prompt!
•You
are a lawyer, creating a stand and then proving it
using the evidence from the Exhibits A-G
•Don’t tell me what a documents says, tell me WHAT IT
MEANS! (how does it prove your point)
•Do not use extensive quotes….I know the Docs, don’t
waste valuable time
•Always check the context, and, if you can, take a
sentence or two to explain that context.
•Remember, there can be more than one “right”
answer…you are being graded on how
well you prove your point
•Thesis,
not Topic
•Analyze,
Analyze and Analyze….Why
Something Happened
•Remember, the Prompt is a key for you to talk about
the ongoing Dynamics and Themes (Conflicts!)we
stress in class….cite those themes, define and explain
them!
PART I: LETS GET STARTED…THE
PROMPT

Many Times the Prompt consists of two parts. A
statement (which may or may not be accurate…a
trick to get you to address COMPLEXITY),
followed by the actual question.
The issue of territorial expansion sparked
considerable debate in the period 1800–1855. (The
statement)
Analyze this debate and evaluate the influence of
both supporters and opponents of
territorial expansion in shaping federal government
policy.
Use the documents and your knowledge of the years
1800–1855 in your answer.
OR
"From 1781 to 1789 the Articles of Confederation provided
the United States with an effective government."
Using the documents and your knowledge of the period,
evaluate this statement.
It was the strength of the opposition forces, both liberal
and conservative, rather than the ineptitude and
stubbornness of President Wilson that led to the Senate
defeat of the Treaty of Versailles.
Using the documents and your knowledge of the period
1917-1921, assess the validity of this statement.

Or sometimes it is a single sentence question.
Analyze the changes that occurred during the 1960's in
the goals, strategies, and support of the movement for
African American civil rights.
Use the documents and your knowledge of the history of
the 1960's to construct your response.
Although New England and the Chesapeake region were
both settled largely by people of English origin, by 1700
the regions had evolved into two distinct societies.
Why did this difference in development occur?
Use the documents AND your knowledge of the colonial
period up to 1700 to develop your answer.

Using this last prompt, lets begin to look at how
to construct a response….Let’s build an answer,
then prove why it is a good answer…
First, let’s take a second and quickly brainstorm in preparation for the
question
Write down all the key words that you remember about
colonial Virginia.
Jamestown, John Smith, Dying Times, gold and tobacco, rich
landowners, indentured servants, rivers, Governor Berkeley,
Indians, hierarchy, enfranchisement, Bacon’s Rebellion
Write down all the key words that you remember
about New England
Puritans, Pilgrims, The Great Migration, John Winthrope and a
City on a Hill, ordered society, community=unity, Charter of
Massachusetts, the General Council, New England Town Platte,
Congregationalism, Half-way Covenant, God is a God of Order,
Education, Ministers, Boston

First, you may have noticed that I have
already highlighted some words in red.
Let’s talk about why we need to be real
careful in reading the prompt. Remember, the prompt
Although New England and the
Chesapeake region were both
settled largely by people of
English origin, by 1700 the regions
had evolved into two distinct
societies.
Why did this difference in
development occur?
Use the documents AND your
knowledge of the colonial period
up to 1700 to develop your answer.
America, or in this case, the
World, can be a better place
is a key to open a door
that lets you talk about
a particular conflict or
dynamic in American
History.
What is the thing that
the writer is implying
doesn’t make sense, or
seems odd?
Right!…these two regions
were settled for two
different reasons…what
were they? What two
themes then come into
play?
Freedom of Economic Opportunity
Although New
England and the
Chesapeake region
were both settled
largely by people of
English origin, by
1700 the regions
had evolved into
two distinct
societies.
Why did this
difference in
development occur?
Use the documents
AND your
knowledge of the
colonial period up
to 1700 to develop
your answer.
Now, we have identified that that it seems
strange that people from the same country
and culture can make two, so different, subcultures. We are thinking that it may have
something to do with the reason behind the
settlement of the two regions.
Know this….the AP Assessor will spend less
than 3 minutes reading your essay…..I
know, NOT FAIR…you spend a year
learning to construct them and then an
hour of stress writing……but….guess
what…they know what they are doing. Here
is why……
They spent a great deal of time at a table
with other history people going over all
the possible answers, primed themselves
and know exactly what to look for…
It is your job, from the opening line
of your first paragraph to convince
them you know what you are
doing!
Although New
England and the
Chesapeake
region were both
settled largely by
people of English
origin, by 1700
the regions had
evolved into two
distinct societies.
Why did this
difference in
development
occur?
Use the
documents AND
your knowledge
of the colonial
period up to 1700
to develop your
answer.
1st sentence: The “Grabber”
•Simple, ho-hum…., snoozing Assessor
Answer: By 1700 two distinct cultures
developed in the American Colonies. One
in the New England region and the other
in the South, first settled around
Chesapeake Bay in Virginia and
Maryland.
•More involved, showing you understand the
importance of the questions…Makes the
Assessor pay attention!
•Answer: To this day, Virginia is famous
for its hospitality, genteel manners,
important families and well-preserved
farming mansions, called Plantations.
New England on the other hand, is
famous for its little villages, neatly laid
out and small picturesque farming
communities filled with highly
opinionated, independent minded New
Englanders
Although New
England and the
Chesapeake region
were both settled
largely by people of
English origin, by
1700 the regions
had evolved into
two distinct
societies.
Why did this
difference in
development occur?
Use the documents
AND your
knowledge of the
colonial period up
to 1700 to develop
your answer.
Most engaging, shows you understand how
important this dynamic is in American
History….makes the assessor smile!
When we think of Virginia, we visualize
a small elite group of American
“nobles”, planters, overseeing huge
landed manors worked by white serfs,
called indentured servants, and later,
black slaves. A society dominated by
men of privilege, who know they are the
born, rightful leaders of their white
and black underlings. Contrast this
with Massachusetts and Connecticut,
the heart of New England. Small,
intimate villages, centered around the
all important church. A people of
strong beliefs, hard working families
and a morally surety. How can two so
contrasting societies claim to have
come from the same family, the same
mother?
Although New
England and the
Chesapeake region
were both settled
largely by people of
English origin, by 1700
the regions had
evolved into two
distinct societies.
Why did this
difference in
development occur?
Use the documents
AND your knowledge
of the colonial period
up to 1700 to develop
your answer.
Now, lets get the next TWO ideas in….we
need to give the opening some
context…just enough to set the stage for
the thesis, or answer you are going to
propose of the Question: WHY THE
DIFFERENCE. Remember this?
Right!…these two regions were
settled for two different
reasons…what were they? What
two themes then come into play?
So, write the next two Sentences…one
about the motives for the Settling of
New England and one about the settling
of Virginia and Maryland.
Key Terms: Great Migration, Gold,
Tobacco, Land Grants and Charters,
Puritans, Indentured Servants,
Gentlemen Farmers, City on a Hill,
etc.
SO, THIS IS WHAT THE OPENING LOOKS
LIKE
Opening sentence….the grabber that lets the
assessor know why this prompt address
something really important in American
History…why are we who we are
 Context sentence(s) ……New England was
settled….
 Context sentence(s)….. The Chesapeake region,
centered in Virginia was settled….

Now we are ready for your Thesis….why you
think New England and the Chesapeake region
ended up so different from each other, even
though they were both settled by English people.
Although New England
and the Chesapeake
region were both settled
largely by people of
English origin, by 1700
the regions had evolved
into two distinct
societies.
Now, write your own Thesis
Why did this difference
in development occur?
Use the documents AND
your knowledge of the
colonial period up to
1700 to develop your
answer.
So, it could look like this………



To this day, Virginia is famous for its hospitality, genteel manners,
important families and well-preserved farming mansions, called
Plantations. New England on the other hand, is famous for its
little villages, neatly laid out and small picturesque farming
communities filled with highly opinionated, independent minded
New Englanders.
It is important to understand that people came to these two regions
for very different purposes. The people who shaped New England
were Puritans, religious immigrants from England looking to
establish an ordered, unified community, dedicated to living the
vision of building a Godly society. The Chesapeake, dominated by
Virginia, with its capital at Jamestown, from the very beginning
was an economic venture…..people came to get ahead. Some of
Virginia’s first families were Gentry class, looking to live like the
nobility of England, with huge tracts of land. Others, sold away
their rights and their freedoms to just get to Virginia, in hopes
that one day, they could own their own land and build their own
futures. Later, other came who were owned, with no futures, by the
planter class.
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new
cultures in these regions. One population was drawn from
families seeking to create a better world for all, while the other
was built by individuals seeking their own private economic
dreams.
Please identify the three parts of the opening paragraph
Now…how do we use the documents and prior knowledge to prove this?
LOOKING FOR EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THE
THESIS: DIFFERENCES IN THE REGIONS ARE
THE RESULT OF DIFFERENT PURPOSES FOR
COMING





What will this evidence look like
As each group works to accomplish its purposes, the
face problems and create solutions that reflect this
difference in purpose
Either: We are Marching to Zion: Building the Godly,
ordered Society
 v.
I
How can
get more money, even at the expense of
others.
We will highlight and notate each document when we
find this evidence to support our thesis
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new cultures in these regions. One
population was drawn from families seeking to create a better world for all, while the other was
built by individuals seeking their own private economic dreams.
Document A
Source: John Winthrop, A Model of Christian Charity
(Written on board the Arbella on the Atlantic
Ocean, 1630)
God Almighty in his most holy and wise providence
hath so disposed of the condition of mankind, [that]
in all times some must be rich, some poor, some high
and eminent in power and dignity, other mean and
in subjection.... [Yet] we must be knit together in this
work as one man. We must entertain each other in
brotherly affection, we must be willing to abridge
ourselves of our superfluities, for the supply of others'
necessities. We must uphold a familiar commerce
together in all meekness, gentleness, patience, and
liberality. We must delight in each other, make others'
conditions our own, rejoice together, mourn
together, labor and suffer together, always having
before our eyes our commission and community in the
work, our community as members of the same body.
So shall we keep the unity of the spirit in the bond of
peace.... We must consider that we shall be as a city
upon a hill. The eyes of all people are upon us, so that
if we shall deal falsely with our God in this work we
have undertaken, and so cause him to withdraw his
present help from us, we shall be made a story and a
by-word through the world. We shall open the
mouths of enemies to speak evil of the ways of God....
shall shame the faces of many of God's worthy
servants, and cause their prayers to be turned into
curses upon us.
Context: Winthrop, Puritan governor
Occasion…starting the new colony, the Landing and
establishing
•God’s ordered, righteous city will be a place where men
work together to help each other
•God’s, ordered and righteous city will be a place where
the concern for others is as important as our own welfare
•This is will be a new place, and experiment in righteous
living that the whole world will look to and judge if God is
right
This unity, sense of
cooperative community is
different than England, and
much different than the
purposes for the Virginia
colony
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new cultures in these regions. One
population was drawn from families seeking to create a better world for all, while the other was
built by individuals seeking their own private economic dreams.
Document B
Source: Ship's List of Emigrants Bound for New England John Porter, Deputy Clerk to
Edward Thoroughgood Weymouth the 20th of March, 1635
1. Joseph Hull, of Somerset, a minister, aged 40 years
Context: New England Manifest, height of the Great Migration
2. Agnes Hull, his wife, aged 25 years
3. Joan Hull, his daughter, aged 15 years
4. Joseph Hull, his son, aged 13 years
What seems to be the connection between these passengers?
5. Tristram, his son, aged 11 years
6. Elizabeth Hull, his daughter, aged 7 years
7. Temperance, his daughter, aged 9 years
8. Grissel Hull, his daughter, aged 5 years
9. Dorothy Hull, daughter, 3 years
10. Judith French, his servant, aged 20 years
11. John Wood, his servant, aged 20 years
12. Robert Dabyn, his servant, aged 28 years
13. Musachiell Bernard, of Batcombe, clothier in the county of Somerset, 24 years
14. Mary Bernard, his wife, aged 28 years
15. John Bernard, his son, aged 3 years
16. Nathaniel, his son, aged 1 year
21. Timothy Tabor, in Somerset of Batcombe, tailor, aged 35 years
22. Jane Tabor, his wife, aged 35 years
23. Jane Tabor, his daughter, aged 10 years
24. Anne Tabor, his daughter, aged 8 years
What prior knowledge can be applied
25. Sarah Tabor, his daughter, aged 5 years
26. William Fever, his servant, aged 20 years
•Entire congregations came
27. John Whitmarke, aged 39 years
•91% of New England immigrants came as families
28. Alice Whitmarke, his wife, aged 35 years
29. James Whitmarke, his son, aged 5 years
•The little Commonwealth
30. Jane, his daughter, aged 7 years
•Would be easy to organize towns and villages along family lines
31. Onseph Whitmarke, his son, aged 5 years
32. Rich. Whitmarke, his son, aged 2 years
•Families seek order, stability and help each other
74. Robert Lovell, husbandman, aged 40 years
•These are all going to create this new society, the City on the Hill
75. Elizabeth Lovell, his wife, aged 35 years
76. Zacheus Lovell, his son, aged 15 years
77. Anne Lovell, his daughter, aged 16 years
78. John Lovell, his son, aged 8 years
79. Ellyn, his daughter, aged 1 year
80. James, his son, aged 1 year
81. Joseph Chickin, his servant, 16 years
82. Alice Kinham, aged 22 years
83. Angell Hollard, aged 21 years
84. Katheryn, his wife, 22 years
85. George Land, his servant, 22 years
86. Sarah Land, his kinswoman, 18 years
103. John Hoble, husbandman, 13 years
104. Robert Huste, husbandman, 40 . . .
We can see the unity, stability and
order, purpose of Puritan society,
is built on large, unified families,
that will create a stable and
mutually support culture
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new cultures in these regions. One
population was drawn from families seeking to create a better world for all, while the other was
built by individuals seeking their own private economic dreams.
Document C
Source: Ship's List of Emigrants Bound for Virginia
Ultimo July, 1635
These underwritten names are to be transported to Virginia, embarked in the Merchant's Hope, Hugh
Weston, Master, per examination by the minister of Gravesend touching' their conformity to the Church
discipline of England, and have taken the oaths of allegiance and supremacy:
Edward Towers 26
Allin King 19
Henry Woodman 22
Rowland Sadler 19
Context: Immigrants for Virginia
Richard Seems 26
Jo. Phimps 28
Same year as the ship that landed in New England
Vyncent Whatter 17
Daniel Endick 16
James Whithedd 14
Jo. Chalk 25
Jonas Watts 21
Jo. Vynall 20
Peter Loe 22
Edward Smith 20
What do these people have in common?
Geo. Brocker 17
Jo. Rowlidge 19
Henry Eeles 26
Wm. Westlie 40
Jo. Dennis 22
Jo. Smith 18
Prior Knowledge:
Tho. Swayne 23
Jo. Saunders 22
•Mostly male
Charles Rinsden 27
Tho. Bartcherd 16
Jo. Exston 17
Tho. Dodderidge 19
•Mostly single
Wm. Luck 14
Richard Williams 18
•Mostly young
Jo. Thomas 19
Jo. Ballance 19
Jo. Archer 21
Wm. Baldin 21
•The ideal indentured servant
Richard Williams 25
Wm. Pen 26
•Headrights given up, 5-7 years of labor
Francis Hutton 20
Jo. Gene 24
Savill Gascoyne 29
Henry Baylie 18
•High demand for cheap labor
Rich. Bulfell 29
Rich. Anderson 50
•Uneducated and poor
Rich. Jones 26
Robert Kelum 51
Tho. Wynes 30
Richard Fanshaw 22
•They live and hope for the chance to get their own land
Humphrey Williams 22
Tho. Bradford 40
•They will only get the cheapest land, land on the frontier
Edward Roberts 20
Wm. Spencer 16
Martin Atkinson 32
Marmaduke Ella 22
•The will always be remembered as former indentured servants
Edward Atkinson 28
Wm. Edwards 30 Women
Nathan Braddock 31
Jeffrey Gurrish 23
Henry Carrell 16
Tho. Tyle 24
Gamaliel White 24
Richard Marks 19
Tho. Clever 16
Jo. Kitchin 16
Edmond Edwards 20
Lewes Miles 19
Jo. Kennedy 20
Sam Jackson 24
•Occupy much lower status than the elite planter/landowning class
Ann Swayne 22
Eliz. Cote 22
Ann Rice 23
Kat. Wilson 23
Maudlin Lloyd 24
Mabell Busher 14
Annis Hopkins 24
Ann Mason 24
Bridget Crompe 18
Mary Hawkes 19
Ellin Hawkes 18
Here, we see the strong desire for economic
freedom, but there is no inherent social
structure, very little opportunity for the stability
of families…..their social status and age will
make a competitive and sometimes violent
society. Most dangerous animal on the planet is
the young, single male human.
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new cultures in these regions. One
population was drawn from families seeking to create a better world for all, while the other was
built by individuals seeking their own private economic dreams.
Document D
Source: Articles of Agreement, Springfield,
Massachusetts, 1636
We whose names are underwritten, being
by God's providence engaged together to
make a plantation...do mutually agree to
certain articles and orders to be observed
and kept by us and by our successors ....
1. We intend by God's grace, as soon as we
can, with all convenient speed, to procure
some Godly and faithful minister with
whom we purpose to join in church
covenant to walk in all the ways of Christ.
2. We intend that our town shall be
composed of forty families.... rich and poor.
3. That every inhabitant shall have a
convenient proportion for a house lot, as
we shall see [fit] for everyone's quality and
estate ....
5. That everyone shall have a share of the
meadow or planting ground ....
Context: Height of Great Migration, City on the Hill is a
vivid desire. Articles of Agreement implies what idea?
You can tie in the idea of the elect voting on ministers and
town policies at Town Meetings of all citizens..pure
democracy flourishes in NE…unheard of in Chesapeake.
•What is first on the list and how does this relate to purpose
•The Little Commonwealth is the basis for a stable,
communal society, God is the God of order.
•We are a community….Puritan view of Gods society..we
share the work, the wealth and the suffering together
We still see the divinely
inspired purpose is strong in
the minds of Puritans….God,
order, family and community
united in one purpose…a truly
unique society….
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new cultures in these
regions. One population was drawn from families seeking to create a better world for
all, while the other was built by individuals seeking their own private economic
dreams.
Document E
Source: Wage and Price
Regulations in Connecticut, 1676
Whereas a great cry of oppression
is heard among us, and that
principally pointed at workmen
and traders, which is hard to
regulate without a standard for
pay, it is therefore ordered that . .
. [prices and wages] be duly set at
each of our General Courts
annually, . . . [A]II breaches of
this order to be punished
proportionable to the value of the
oppression. . . . This court . . . in
the interim recommends [that] all
tradesmen and laborers consider
the religious end of their callings,
which is that receiving such
moderate profit as may enable
them to serve God and their
neighbors with their arts and
trades comfortably, they
do not enrich themselves
suddenly and inordinately (by
oppressing prices and wages to
the impoverishing [of] their
neighbors . . . live in the practice
of that crying sin of oppression,
but avoid it.
Context: how many years after the Great
Migration and why is this important to
think about? Does the need for such a
law show a weakening of the City on a
Hill Purpose. This is a good place to also
talk about the Halfway Covenant as a
sign of the weakening purpose
What is the great Sin…how does relate to
the Puritan purpose of settling NE?
What does the new law do and how does
the law reflect that purpose?
What is meant by referring to the
“religious end” of their calling….how does
this relate to the Puritan Purpose and
how is this different than everywhere else
What is the “sin of oppression”
We are now 40 years after the enthusiasm of the City on
the Hill, and New Englanders are finding they have to
make a living, and profits are nice. But, the Puritan
dream of an ordered, stable and cooperative society is
still the goal of the government. While weakening, this
unique purpose is still defining New England economics,
political and social life.
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new cultures in these
regions. One population was drawn from families seeking to create a better world for
all, while the other was built by individuals seeking their own private economic
dreams.
Document F
Context: Written several years after the first years of Jamestown (1607).
Source: Captain John Smith,
John Smith, a military man, eventual had to take the colony over and force
History of Virginia, 1624
rules that allowed everyone to survive better/facts you may want to tie in:
When the [large ship] departed, . . . those of
Smith is writing this to enlarge his role. Half the new colonist died every
us that had money, spare clothes, credit to
year. Jamestown was located in unhealthy bottomlands. The colony went
give bills of payment, gold rings, fur, or
broke and the King eventually had to take over…why?
any such commodities, were ever welcome
to [purchase supplies. The rest of us
patiently obeyed our] vile commanders
and [bought] our provisions at fifteen
times the value yet did not repine but
fasted, lest we should incur the censure of
[being] factious and seditious persons Our
ordinary [food] was but meal and water so
that this little relieved our wants, whereby
with the extremity of the bitter cold frost
more than half of us died. The worst
[among us were the gold seekers who] with
their golden promises made all men their
slaves in hope of recompenses. There was
no talk . . . . but dig gold, wash gold, refine
gold, load gold. . . . Smith, perceiving [we
lived] from hand to mouth, caused the
pinnace [small ship] to be provided with
things fitting to get provision for the year
following. [Two councillors] Wingfield and
Kendall, . . . strengthened themselves with
the sailors and other confederates [and
planned to go] aboard the pinnace to alter
her course and to go for England. Smith
had the plot discovered to him. Much
trouble he had to prevent it, till with store
of saker and musket shot he forced them to
stay or sink in the river; which action cost
the life of Captain Kendall. These brawls
are so disgustful, as some will say, they
were better forgotten.
Whom did everyone seem to be looking out for…cite evidence for your
answer. If you had no money, how could you buy things at 15 times their
value?
Why were the gold seekers hurting the colony?
Mutiny…what does this say about the order, stability and cooperation in
the colony
What was causing the “brawls”
The settlers of Jamestown show every evidence of being out for
themselves, and only themselves. These folks are showing the
worst of the pursuit of economic dreams…at the cost of your
neighbor. Much is made of how badly they treated the Native
Americans, but they treated each other just as bad. Price
gouging, lying, forced or manipulated servitude, mutiny, and
worse, watching your neighbor die when you had the means to
help created a competitive, survival-of –the fittest atmosphere
that is a perfect breeding ground for a competitive, dangerous,
violent society…just waiting for an authority to come and
“force” order on them.
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new cultures in these
regions. One population was drawn from families seeking to create a better world for
all, while the other was built by individuals seeking their own private economic
dreams.
Document G
Source: Governor Berkeley and His
Council on Their Inability to Defend
Virginia Against a Dutch Attack,
December 1673
We thought it our duty . . . to set forth in
this our Declaration, the true state and
condition of this countryin general and
our particular . . . disabilit[y] to . . .
[engage in] war at the time of this
invasion [by the
Dutch]. . . . [We] therefore do most humbly
beseech your majesty and your most
honorable council to consider that
Virginia is intersected by so many vast
rivers as makes more miles to defend than
we have men of trust to defend them. For
by our nearest computation we leave at
our backs as many servants (besides
Negroes) as there are freemen to defend
the shores and all our frontiers [against]
the Indians. . . . [This] gives men fearful
apprehensions of the danger they leave
their estates and families in, while they
are drawn from their houses to defend the
borders. Also at least one third [of the
freemen available for
defense] are single freemen (whose labor
will hardly maintain them) or men much
in debt, . . . [whom] we may reasonably
expect upon any small advantage the
enemy may gain upon us, . . . [to defect] to
them in hopes of bettering their condition
by sharing the plunder of the country
with them.
Context: this is very important because it allows you to
demonstrate prior knowledge to show what kind of society
Virginia had become in the 50 years since Smith wrote.
•A royal colony, run directly by the King’s nobleman
•Berkeley, a former Cavalier (supporter of the monarchy)
encourage noble friends to migrate…these become the planters
and were his Council.
•Berkeley was a firm believer in the English hierarchy, so this
system of landed nobles dominating a much larger population of
poorer whites and black slaves was his ideal. Stable and
ordered, yes…cooperative…hmmm…what evidence of
“cooperation” between social classes does the document show?
•What is Berkeley’s greatest fears as he tries to organize his
colonist to resist a threatened Dutch invasion?
•What does this show us about Virginia class structure?
•American theme…everyone deserves respect….idealized in
NE, how does this ideal play out in Virginia
•What do you think the planters get out of this whole system
The self-destructive chaos of 50 years before, seemed to
have been resolved with the imposing of King’s rule in
Virginia. However, Governor Berkeley’s concerns are
more directed at betrayal by his own people than fear
of a Dutch attack. This veneer of order lays on top of a
strict class system that seems to have bred distrust and
fear of each other…a fear Berkeley expresses when he
talks of his own poorer people robbing and deserting to
the Dutch to achieve their economic dreams.
It is this difference in motivation that led the growth of two new cultures in these
regions. One population was drawn from families seeking to create a better
world for all, while the other was built by individuals seeking their own private
economic dreams.
Document H
Context: It is so important that you have already introduced
Source: Bacon's "Manifesto: 'justifying
Berkeley’s role in creating an English hierarchy in Virginia…a few
his rebellion against Virginia
privileged favorites sit on the council, make all the rules and get all
Governor Berkeley in 1676'"
the financial benefits…this is the English nobility’s view of a stable,
We cannot in our hearts find one single
ordered society. Next, you need to provide the context of Bacon’s
spot of rebellion or treason or that we
rebellion….the frontiersmen, sons of indentured servants pushed to
have in any manner aimed
the poor and dangerous lands to the west while the nobility (planters)
at subverting the settled government. .
control the rich bottom lands with easy access to sea and trade.
. . All people in all places where we
These men had been given permission to defend themselves against
have yet been can attest our
civil, quiet, peaceable behavior far
Indian attacks that their new settlements provoke. When the
different from that of rebellion. . . . Let
viciousness of Bacon’s militia threaten to provoke a wider Indian war,
truth be bold and all the world
Berkeley called them back. Bacon’s poor frontiersmen so this as yet
know the real foundations of
another oppression by the governor, they turned around and marched
pretended guilt. . . . Let us trace . . .
to Jamestown to the force concessions on the governor (King John
[the] men in authority and favor to
and Magna Carta). Bacon died of disease and the “rebellion” fizzled.
whose hands the dispensation of the
This document is Bacon’s explanation as to why they are marching
countr[y's] wealth has been committed.
on Jamestown
Let us observe the sudden rise of their
estates ... [compared] with the quality
in which they first entered this
country. Let us consider their sudden
advancement. And let us also consider
whether any public work for our safety
and defense or for the advancement
and propagation of trade, liberal arts
or sciences is in any [way] adequate to
our vast charge. Now let us compare
these things together and see what
sponges have sucked up the public
treasure and whether it has not been
privately contrived away by unworthy
favorites and juggling
parasites whose tottering fortunes
have been repaired and supported at
the public charge.
•What did Bacon say about being labeled as “rebels”
•Who does Bacon say the real criminals are?
•What evidence does he present?
•What does this show about the feelings of the lower class whites
towards the upper class whites?
•Compare this with the previous document which show feelings of
upper towards lower class.
The class tensions we saw in Berkeley’s letter to the King
comes to a head with the poor whites marching on
Berkeley’s capital in Bacon’s “rebellion”. The denial of
economic freedom to a majority of the poor whites by the
elites of Virginia erupt in violence…first toward Native
Americans, then a Civil War of poor against the planter
elites. Stability is a fragile thing is this society
PART III: FINALLY, THE WRITING!
As we practice, all the prep work we have just
modelled should take you 15-20 minutes
 Now you have to put it together
 You need to use the documents to support, or
“prove” the thesis you presented at the end of the
first paragraph.
 At the end of each point, or document treatment,
include language to tie back to the thesis
 This ………..shows clearly that the purpose of
the NE colonies is leading them down a very
different road than what was evolving in
Virginia.

THINGS TO THINK OF AS YOU BEGIN TO
WRITE





Did we see change over time…a big thing for AP DBQ’s
Did New England move away from their original purpose
God’s ideal society….if so why
Did Virginia develop away from the economic free-for-all
we see in the Jamestown doc…..if so, why
Be sure to include a conclusion, something more than
simply restating the Thesis
The distinct British subcultures that developed in
New England and the Chesapeake regions were the
results of original purpose, and the particular people
those purposes attracted to the colonies. These
original settlers met differing economic and
environmental conditions and adapted to these
conditions. It is hard to believe these unique cultures
developed in such close proximity. Even harder to
believe, the grandsons of these original settlers
would unite to make a new nation a century later.
Now…write it…..Good luck! Address the Prompt and Prove your Point!