Document 6520857
Transcription
Document 6520857
Journal of Public Health | Vol. 32, No. 4, pp. 512 –518 | doi:10.1093/pubmed/fdq008 | Advance Access Publication 3 March 2010 Why do people drink at home? John Foster1, Donald Read2, Sakthidaran Karunanithi3, Victoria Woodward4 1 Family and Mental Health, Greenwich University, London, UK NW School of Public Health, NHS Cumbria, UK 3 NW School of Public Health, North Lancs PCT and North West Strategic Health Authority, Lancaster LA1 1QD, UK 4 Addictive Behaviour, Glyndwr University, Wrexham, UK Address correspondence to John Foster, E-mail: [email protected] 2 A B S T R AC T trend for adults to consume alcohol “at home”. To date this is a development that has received little research attention. Participants and Methods Four focus groups (FG) of current drinkers who drank at home and reflected the views of both genders, differing age bands and living arrangements were conducted. The setting for the study was an economically deprived seaside resort in the North-West of England. Each focus group had two facilators and was taped, transcribed and subject to thematic analysis. FG A: (n¼15; 9 males, 6 females) young people aged 13–21. FG B (n¼4, 1 male, 3 female) volunteers aged 30–50 some of whom had children and were in relationships. FG C (n¼15, 6 males, 9 females) recruited from a residents association-aged 25–70. FG D (n¼4, 1 male, 3 female), aged 20–30 recruited through a local Lesbian and Gay Group. Results The principal reasons for drinking at home concerned convenience, these included cost, safety, social occasions, fear of under age drinkers, child-care, relief of stress. Lesser themes such as the smoking ban also emerged. Conclusions These findings provide data of import to researchers and public health professionals to allow them to produce and target public health messages that take into account that the majority of drinking now takes place “at home”. Keywords alcohol consumption, public health, young people Introduction In a recently conducted systematic review, it was estimated that alcohol consumption was responsible for 31 000 deaths in the UK in 2005 and that the cost of alcohol consumption in 2005 – 06 was £3.0 billion.1 Furthermore, Sir Liam Donaldson2 outlined a number of harms caused by ‘passive drinking’. These were crime, family breakdown, fetal alcohol syndrome, sexual assault and rape, noise and disruption, over burdened NHS, problems at work, unemployment, intimidation, marital problems and drink driving. One of his recommendations to tackle this after similar developments taking place in Scotland was to introduce a minimum price of 50p per unit of alcohol, following the results of a report from the University of Sheffield.3 This has also been one of a number of recommendations made in a recent report by the British Medical Association with the aim of reducing 512 drinking in young people.4 The rationale for the 50p cut-off is that this would have a significant impact upon heavy drinkers and young people whilst increasing the cost of alcohol for ‘controlled drinkers’ only a few pence per week. The importance of Donaldson’s proposal is that it posits a general population approach towards the costs of tackling alcohol-related harm that would involve a paradigm shift in UK alcohol policy as illustrated by this quote from Gordon Brown (the UK prime minister) the morning following the release of Donaldson’s report. ‘We don’t want the John Foster, Principal Research Fellow Donald Read, Speciality Registrar Public Health Sakthidaran Karunanithi, Consultant, Public Health Victoria Woodward, Senior Lecturer # The Author 2010, Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Faculty of Public Health. All rights reserved. Downloaded from http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on October 1, 2014 Background The past 30 years have seen a shift in the culture concerning the consumption of alcohol in the UK. One of these is the increasing W H Y P E O P L E D R I NK AT H O M E Participants and methods The study received ethical approval from the Middlesex University School of Health Studies-Heath Ethics Sub-Committee. The research governance department for Blackpool Primary Health Care Trust (PCT) approved this on the proviso that no participants were recruited through the PCT and that PCT premises could not be used when conducting the research. Blackpool has a population of 150 000, is one of the most densely populated areas of the England outside of London and was once the most popular seaside resort in the UK. However, over time, the resort has gone into steep economic decline and is now heavily reliant on stag and hen parties to maintain it as a viable 12-month destination.11 It has far higher than national/regional average alcohol mortality and morbidity rates and these tend to be concentrated in the most deprived areas of the town.12 The current project employed a qualitative methodology; in this case, four focus groups (FGs) to explore the reasons why the participants elected to drink at home. All the participants were current drinkers who drank both within and outside the home. The aim was to collect a sample that could reflect the views of both genders and differing age bands. Attempts were made to collect more precise data relating to age, educational marital/employment status and income but there was some reluctance to provide these data in three of the four groups and thus a broad sketch of the profile of each group is provided only. All the participants agreed to take part in the FGs after having been shown a participants information sheet and signed a consent form to the effect the proceedings would be taped and transcribed. but their anonymity would be maintained. All four groups were recruited through Blackpool-based voluntary sector organizations or residents groups via personal contacts of the research group. The first group were young people (n ¼ 15; 9 males, 6 females) aged 13 –21. Some were still living at home but none had children. A group of volunteers (1 male, 3 females) aged 30– 50, some of whom had children and were in relationships from a Blackpool-based charity comprised the second group. Another large group (n ¼ 15; 6 males, 9 females) were recruited from a residents association of what they themselves described as a workingclass housing estate. The age of the participants ranged from 25 to 70 with the majority being clustered at 50þ. The final group (n ¼ 4; 1 male, 3 females) (age range 20 – 30) were recruited through a Lesbian and Gay Group. All were currently working, in relationships and one of the women had a child. Each FG was conducted with two facilitators, one who predominantly observed and took notes and the other who facilitated the discussions. A series of themes/prompts were provided for each group as follows: † † † † † Why do you drink at home? On what occasions do you drink in licensed premises? What are your beliefs concerning home drinking? Who makes the decision to drink in your household? What are some of the rituals that surround the drinking that takes place at home? The discussions were free-flowing and organic, and in practice, this structure was rarely followed in a linear fashion. This paper predominantly reports discussions that emanated from the first and second bulleted themes. Each group was taped and subsequently transcribed. Thereafter, it was analysed by the first and second authors independently who agreed the themes that emerged. A procedure was in place for the third author to act as an arbitrator in the case of a dispute. In the event this was not required. Downloaded from http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on October 1, 2014 responsible sensible majority of moderate drinkers to have to pay more or suffer more as a result of the excesses of the minority’.5 The British have been heavy episodic/binge drinkers for many centuries,6 though Foster7 has pointed out that there have been a number of significant changes in drinking culture in the UK over the past 30 years. One of these is the shift towards drinking away from licensed premises. Despite this, the original Alcohol Harm Reduction Strategy for England8 (AHRSE) did not refer to drinking away from licensed premises. This omission was rectified in the second national strategy document—‘Safe, Supportive and Social’,9 which recognized that home drinkers do present a significant health burden. To date, the reasons why adults elect to drink in nonlicensed premises are largely speculative and anecdotal. It is thought that cost and convenience are two of the key variables, particularly in those individuals who have young children. There also may be certain activities which have become increasingly linked to home drinking, such as family parties and barbecues. Research has also shown that a number of key local authority personnel believe that for older people by which they mean 30þ and those with young families, town centres are becoming increasingly unattractive to visit as they are perceived to be overwhelmed by young binge drinkers.10 This paper uses a qualitative methodology to examine some of the reasons put forward for drinking away from licensed premises by male and female participants in the age range 13 – 75. 513 514 J O U RN A L O F P U B L I C H E A LTH Table 1 Themes for drinking away from licensed premises by gender and age Theme Number of Gender, n (%) Age bands, n (%) Males Females 15 times discussed 16 –25 26– 35 36– 45 46– 55 56– 65 .65 Convenience 36 20 (55) 16 (45) 1 (3) 6 (17) 12 (33) 6 (17) 10 (27) 1 (3) 0 Cost 34 21 (61) 13 (39) 2 (6) 5 (15) 12 (35) 3 (8) 9 (26) 2 (6) 1 (4) Safety 33 20 (60) 13 (40) 3 (9) 3 (9) 7 (21) 3 (9) 8 (25) 6 (18) 3 (9) Social occasions 29 11 (38) 18 (62) 1 (4) 9 (30) 10 (34) 2 (8) 5 (16) 1 (4) 1 (4) Child care 18 4 (22) 14 (78) 0 3 (16) 9 (52) 3 (16) 3 (16) 0 0 Stress/reward 13 5 (39) 8 (61) 0 1 (8) 6 (46) 3 (23) 3 (23) 0 0 Fear of under-age drinking 11 3 (27) 8 (73) 0 0 4 (36) 6 (54) 1 (10) 0 0 Smoking ban 6 (60) 4 (40) 1 (10) 3 (30) 4 (40) 1 (10) 1 (10) 0 0 4 1 (25) 3 (75) 0 0 2 (50) 2 (50) 0 0 0 Drink driving 4 2 (50) 2 (50) 0 0 0 1 (25) 3 (75) 0 0 Pre-loading 4 0 4 (100) 0 1 (25) 2 (50) 1 (25) 0 0 0 The data for the age bands have been assigned retrospectively after consultation with the facilitators of the FGs (D.R. and S.K.). The themes were derived by two reviewers affixing codes with reference to the transcripts and field notes and as a result identifying similar phrases and identifying them as themes according the principles outlined by Miles and Huberman.13 The group facilitators (D.R. and S.K.) were able to provide information from the transcripts that allowed the group to construct Table 1, which provides an age and gender split for the comments made. Activities that involved drinking at home which were also discussed, each time by male interviewees—these were, drinking games, listening to music and playing computer games. Also included in this theme is the fact, predominantly discussed by women, that there was no need to order taxis. Cost Results There were a number of themes that emerged from the FG discussions. A summary of the themes and the gender and age distribution of the comments are shown in Table 1. They are presented in order of the most frequently mentioned theme first etc. and each theme is accompanied by an illustrative quote. There was a discussion in FG 1 concerning street drinking that largely related to under-age drinking and this is qualitatively different from other forms of home drinking, thus it is not reported here. A fuller presentation of the data is available in a report published on the Alcohol Education and Research Council website www.aerc.org.uk.14 Convenience The theme of convenience was common for both genders and for individuals aged 16– 55. It is illustrated by a quote from a woman in her mid-50s from a residents association. You can relax more at home. You don’t have to wait at the bar to be served; you can just go and get yourself a drink. You sit down and you are pretty much there for the rest of the night. There was a strong link between convenience and many of the other themes. Cost was discussed most frequently by males and individuals aged 26 –35 and 46– 55. The majority of alcohol purchased was bought in supermarkets or local off licences as illustrated by the following quote from a male in his mid-30s in a relationship but having no children. I have found this week that I have brought more alcohol than I have ever brought in my life because it was cheap. It was a heck of a lot of more than I with normally buy. It was two litre bottles for £20 last week and this week it is 7 pound a bottle. I end up buying double or triple I would normally buy because I’m saving some money on it. Young people under the age of 18 displayed a very different type of drinking. It was a common place for them to club together their monies to buy more alcohol as illustrated by the following quote. When you are out with your mates if there are 10 or 15 of you, if you all put in a tenner that’s £150 between 15 of you to spend on booze so when you’re out and everyone buys booze just with that £10. Say like. . . how much is a bottle of vodka now, about £10 or something? Downloaded from http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on October 1, 2014 10 Accompany to food W H Y P E O P L E D R I NK AT H O M E Safety Also linked to the idea of convenience was the belief that drinking at home was safer than going out. This tended to manifest itself in different ways and was discussed more often by men and individuals in the age ranges 26 –35 and 46 –65. The majority of comments related to a belief that pubs were often unpleasant and violent. There were some specific concerns: younger women believed they were often short-changed in terms of measures of spirits in pubs or they were watered down. Another perceived the danger from pubs was having your drink spiked—again this was an issue for both genders. The quote relating to this is from a young gay man. theme that was more likely to be discussed by young women and is also linked to convenience. The quote below is made by a woman in her early 30s with no children. I think if I have had a particularly stressful day at work. I will get in the bath and open a bottle of wine. Fear of under-age drinkers This was a theme that tended to be discussed by females and those aged 46 –55. The quote below is from a male in his mid-50s. Most of these comments came from members of the residents association. They perceived that a lack of safety in consequence of the amount of under-age drinking and the subsequent public nuisance that the police were either unable or unwilling to tackle. As a result, a number of this group did not want to leave their flats after dark. Gangs of youths drinking and smashing bottles and when you phone the police they come out but they come back again. Loads of time you wake up in the morning and you see all the broken bottles, so they are getting it from somewhere. Social occasions Home drinking was also common as a result of social occasions such as birthdays and having friends or family over for a visit. This was a theme that tended to be discussed by females and those aged 16 –35 and a quote from a woman in early 30s with a family is shown below. I would say birthdays, anniversaries or anything like that. Anything to do with my family where we are all together we always end up having a couple of bottles of wine, special occasions. Child care An issue that was largely pertinent to the young women in their 20s and 30s (though not exclusively) was drinking at home because they had young children to look after or avoiding the cost of babysitters. This clearly has a link to cost and convenience. The illustrative quote comes from a male in his early 30s with a young child. It also illustrates how those participants who had young children had there own self-imposed rituals around drinking in this environment. When I have a drink, I have a nine-year-old son and we don’t make a habit of having a drink when he is up. So we will make sure he goes to bed at nine o’clock, then we will have a drink. Stress/reward Having a drink generally at home ‘to wind down’ was another theme that emerged from the data. It too was a Miscellaneous adult themes There were a number of other themes that encouraged home drinking discussed by the adult groups. Any trends are shown in parentheses. These were: first, the inconvenience resulting from the introduction of the smoking ban in licensed premises ( predominantly discussed by males and individuals in the age range 16– 35). The quote below is from a male in his mid-30s. I found in the past two years, because I am also a smoker, and you can’t smoke in pubs, I go into one of the local bars and they have a little shelter at the back and you can’t see in front of you from all the cigarette smoke. I am a smoker but I don’t want to be gasping for air continuously. So I stay at home and have a glass of wine and a cigarette. Secondly, drinking alcohol as an accompaniment to food (this was predominantly discussed by females and individuals in the age range 26 – 45). The following quote is from a woman in her mid-40s with a family. For me and my situation. I do a lot of entertaining at home so I like to cook. So I usually have a glass of wine with it. Thirdly, drinking at home to prevent drink-driving (discussed equally by both genders, all comments from individuals in the 36– 55 age range); the illustrative quote comes from a woman in her early 40s who is employed with a family. Downloaded from http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on October 1, 2014 Spiking of drinks is also an issue I am really careful about, if I am going to buy a drink it comes in a bottle with a lid on rather than leave my glass there when I go to the loo I will ask someone to watch it for me. Though sometimes this can go wrong, you have somebody watching it for you, what they are doing is putting a pill in their hands and reaching over to get something else, and as they do they drop it into your glass, and they think it’s funny. 515 516 J O U RN A L O F P U B L I C H E A LTH If you are a driver it is safer to drink at home because then you don’t have to worry about driving. Finally, the practice of ‘pre-loading’, this is drinking at home before going out for the evening and was only discussed by females aged 16 –45. The final quote is from a woman in her early 20s who has no family and was working. We never ever go straight out we always meet up at someone’s house before we go out and if I’m being completely honest it’s to get drunk before we go out so that we don’t have to pay extortionate prices when we get out. Discussion Main findings of the current study What is already known on this topic? International research has shown for some years that the majority of drinking takes place outside of licensed premises.15 In the UK, figures from the British Beer and Pub Association have found that more than 80% of all wine purchases in 2007 were off-sales—equivalent figures for spirits were more than 70% and beer/ciders were more than 40%.7 Generally, there has been very little empirical research into the reasons why ‘adults’ elect to drink in non-licensed premises. But gender has been identified as an important demographic factor. The alcohol purchasing patterns of men and women differ. Men are more likely to buy drinks in bars and women are more likely to purchase alcohol in a supermarket. Between 16 and 24 years of age, 45% of women purchase alcohol in bars; after this the figure drops to 26%.16 More recently, research has shown that the increased level of harmful drinking among women aged 45– 64 has been linked to greater home drinking.17 However, most of the research thus far concerning drinking outside licensed premises has been directed at examining the behaviour and motivations of young people. Coleman and Cater18 found that the most common venues for young people to drink (excluding pubs and bars) were ‘at a friends home when parents away’, ‘own home What this study adds? Drinking at home is growing faster than drinking in pubs, clubs, cafes and restaurants. The off-trade consumption of alcoholic drinks is forecast to rise by 15%, from 2008 to 2010, with women being the key growth factor in this trade.25 Despite this, the portrayal of alcohol-related harm is concentrated upon binge drinking6 and the visible consequences presented by problematic drinkers. Furthermore, policy responses tend to be a reaction to the visible problems presented by binge drinking. Public health professionals should provide messages/information that take into account the fact that the majority of drinking now takes place in the home and seek to understand some of the reasons for this change. It is important to recognize that drinking at home is uncontrolled and unregulated. In other data that we intend to publish in future from these FGs, it is clear that one of the attractions of home drinking is ‘lack of scrutiny’. However, it was equally clear that the participants were aware that there were inherent dangers in drinking at home; these were mainly in the form of acute harms, such as getting into fights, arguments and accidents. Home Downloaded from http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on October 1, 2014 This paper has used a qualitative methodology to investigate the reasons why people chose to drink at home. Although a number of subthemes emerged and have been described, the reasons adults give for electing to drink at home concerned convenience. Included in this are issues such as price, safety, fear of under-age drinkers, availability of child care, immediate relief of stress, family occasions, the smoking ban and not having to drink and drive. To our knowledge, this is the first attempt to consider home drinking in such a way. when parents away’ and lastly parks and the streets. Drinking in the park and the street was also related to other high-risk behaviours such as illicit drug use, getting into trouble with the police and unprotected sex. Work from the USA conducted over 15 years ago has confirmed that under-age drinkers had little difficulty in obtaining alcohol from on- or off-premises.19 There has been a body of research that has confirmed the importance of social context in predicting the level of young people’s drinking.20 Research from New Zealand21 has pointed to different gender effects, in particular that adolescent females can be key in either encouraging or discouraging heavy drinking in their peer groups. The role of parents in this area is unproven, though recent research from North-West England found that alcohol-related harms and consumption were lessened in young people15,16 whose parents provided alcohol at home.22 In the context of drinking in young people,18 – 24 recent data from the Scottish Executive23 has documented a behaviour concerning home drinking mainly in young adults 16– 24 (though not exclusively) known as ‘front loading’ or ‘pre-loading’. This is consuming alcohol purchased from a supermarket or off licence and thereafter going out to a pub or night club. This behaviour has been associated with greater alcohol consumption, a higher likelihood of being a victim or perpetrator of violence and greater at risk sexual behaviour.24 W H Y P E O P L E D R I NK AT H O M E drinking is generally portrayed as being safe and responsible. Indeed, the first author has been engaged in debates with local large supermarkets in his locality. Their response to the suggestion that by selling alcohol cheaply, they may be adding to alcohol-related problems is talk in terms of providing a service for ‘responsible consumers’. In order to tackle this vested interest in addition to campaigning for minimal pricing health professionals should be agitating for a fifth licensing objective for England and Wales—the promotion of public health, so that new licensing applications could be refused/challenged on public health grounds. The shortly to be enacted Scottish Licensing legislation has ‘protecting and improving public health’ as a licensing objective.26 517 groups we would like to interview in future would be students, young people with disposable income and individuals from middle class occupations. The gender and age spread in relation to the themes make intuitive sense, for example, that the majority of those who felt child care was an important reason for them to drink at home were young women. However, these may be a function of the make-up of the FGs and how the discussions ensued, thus they should be regarded as indicative only. Our ultimate aim is to use this study to devise a tool to allow for a rigorous epidemiological general population survey with a view to teasing out gender, living arrangements, class, age and ethnic differences in ‘home drinking’. ‘Pre-loading’ i.e. drinking at home before going out to a pub or night club is a topic that has been of increasing research interest and was the subject of a recent set of comment articles in ‘Addiction’.27 In the current study, it was not discussed in the depth that we expected it would be. There are a number of possible explanations for this. Most of our group were either older, working or with families. The young people we interviewed tended to be unemployed. ‘Pre-loading’ seems to be an activity largely confined to young people without dependents who have disposable income. If there had been a greater number of these or students in our sample, this might have become a more prevalent issue. A recently published paper confirmed a perception on the part of female students that the student culture encourages heavy/binge drinking, though no discussion of home drinking or pre-loading was reported.28 There is another possibility; that pre-loading has become so common place that individuals do not make the distinction between drinking at home and then going out. This study was supported by the small grants scheme of the Alcohol Education and Research Council (SG 08/09 101). References 1 Balakrishnan R, Allender S, Scarborough P et al. The burden of alcohol-related ill health in the United Kingdom. J Public Health Med 2009;31:366 – 73. 2 Chief Medical Officer. Passive Drinking—The Collateral Damage from Alcohol. Excerpt from Chief Medical Officers 150th Report. London: Department of Health, 2009. 3 Meier P, Brennan A, Purhouse R et al. Modelling the Potential Impact of Pricing and Promotion Policies for Alcohol in England. Results from the Sheffield Alcohol Policy Model. ScHARR: University of Sheffield, 2009. 4 British Medical Association. Under the Influence—The Damaging Effect of Alcohol on Young People. London, 2009. www.bma.org.uk (10 October 2009, date last accessed). 5 Swane J. Sir Liam Donaldson Unveils Alcohol Minimum Price Plan. Daily Telegraph, 16 March 2009. 6 Plant M, Plant M. Binge Britain: Alcohol and the National Response. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006. 7 Foster JH. The Licensing Act 2003: eighteen months down the road. Drugs Educ Prev Policy 2008;15:1 – 6. Limitations of this study The study has used qualitative methodology throughout and thus suffers from the inherent deficiencies of qualitative work. In short, these are that the sample was not randomly selected and therefore is open to a degree of selection bias. In reality, this is a rich qualitative data set and it is likely that the themes that have emerged from the discussions would be applicable across different settings; however, there remains the possibility that Blackpool is not typical. Research resources meant that there were groups that the research team were unable to access and we are currently seeking additional funding to address these gaps. The 8 The Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit. Alcohol Harm Reduction Strategy for England. London: Cabinet Office, 2004. www.strategy.gov.uk (10 October 2009, date last accessed). 9 Home Office. Safe, Sensible, Social. The Next Step in the National Alcohol Strategy. London: Home Office, 2007. 10 Foster JH, Herring R, Waller S et al. Implementation of the Licensing Act 2003: a national survey. 2008. Available on the Alcohol Education Research Council website. www.aerc.org.uk (10 October 2009, date last accessed). 11 Cook P, Tocque K, Morleo M et al. Opinions on the Impact of Alcohol on Individuals and Communities Early Summary Findings from the North West Big Drink Debate. Liverpool: John Moores University Centre for Public Health, 2008. ISBN-978-1-906591-40-3. Downloaded from http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on October 1, 2014 Funding Some comments relating to our findings concerning ‘pre-loading’ 518 J O U RN A L O F P U B L I C H E A LTH 12 North West Public Health Observatory. Local Area Profiles for England. www.nwph.net/alcohol/lape (10 October 2009, date last accessed). 22 Bellis M, Phillips-Howard P, Hughes K et al. Teenage drinking, 13 Miles M, Huberman M. Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd edn. London and Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1994. protective factors for alcohol-related harms in school children. BMC 14 Foster JH, Reade D, Karunanithi S et al. Towards an explanatory model for home drinking in adults. 2009. Available on the Alcohol Education Research Council website. www.aerc.org.uk (10 January 2010, date last accessed). 15 Single E, Wortley S. Drinking in various settings as it relates to demographic variables and level of consumption: findings from a national survey in Canada. J Stud Alcohol 1993;54:590– 3. 16 Goddard E, Thomas M. Drinking: Adults Behaviour and Knowledge in 1998. London: Office of National Statistics, 1999. 17 National Statistics. Statistics on Alcohol. London: Information CentreLifestyle Statistics, 2006. 19 Forster J, McGovern P, Wagenaar A et al. The ability of young people to purchase alcohol without age identification in north eastern MN, USA. Addiction 1994;89:699 – 705. 20 Thombs D, Beck K, Pleace D. The relationship of social context and expectancy factors to alcohol use intensity among 18– 22 yearolds. Addict Res Theory 1993;1:59– 68. 21 Connolly G, Casswell S, Stewart J et al. Drinking context and other influences on the drinking of 15-year old New Zealand. Addiction 1992;87:1029– 36. Public Health 9:380; doi:10.1186/1471-2458-9-380. 23 Scottish Executive Social Research. The Relationship Between Off-sales and Problem Drinking in Scotland. www.scotland.gov.uk/socialresearch (10 October 2009, date last accessed). 24 Hughes K, Anderson Z, Marleo M et al. Alcohol nightlife and violence: the relative contribution of drinking before and during nights out to negative criminal justice outcomes. Addiction 2008;103:60 – 5. 25 Just-Drinks. Understanding Alcoholic Drinks—Off-trade. just-drinks.com/store/productprint.aspx?id=68758 (10 www. October 2009, date last accessed). 26 Safer Scotland-Scottish Government. What All Licensees Need To Know about Changes in Scottish Alcohol Licensing Laws. 2009. http:// www.infoscotland.com/licensingact/files/Licensing-Act-BriefingPack.pdf (10 October 2009, date last accessed). 27 Room R, Livingston M. Does it matter where the drinking is when the object is getting drunk—for debate. Addiction 2009;104:10– 1. 28 Rhiannon C, Fishlock A, Mulroy A et al. After ‘Unit 1421’: an exploratory study into female students’ attitudes and behaviours towards binge drinking at Leeds University. J Public Health Med 2008; 30:8–13. Downloaded from http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on October 1, 2014 18 Coleman L, Cater S. Under Age ‘Risky’ Drinking: Motivations and Outcomes. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation, 2005. alcohol availability and pricing: a cross-sectional study of risk and