docClean Air Markets Data and Maps EPA
download 
Report Transcription
Clean Air Markets Data and Maps EPA
Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Appendix -2 Plant by Plant Comparison of CARMA and USEPA/Clean Air Markets Data (CAMD) for the Year 2007 Notes: (1) ORIS refers to the IDs of utility plants given by the Office of the Regulatory Information System (ORIS). It is now assigned by EIA and is used as a unique plant identification code for many EPA electric power databases, too. USEPA values - CARMA values USEPA values (2) Columns with “%Diff “ are calculated as: (3) The website for information on USEPA/CAMD is: http://camddataandmaps.epa.gov/gdm/index.cfm?fuseaction=iss.isshome Performeks www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 ALABAMA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA Autauga 1. E B Harris Generating Plant ELMER B HARRIS 7897 12367 1,415,320 981,978 30.62% 813 918 -13.0% 3,483,813 2,138,503 38.6% 2. Tenaska Central Alabama Gen Station TENASKA CENTRAL ALABAMA 55440 45073 297,532 240,770 19.08% 856 1,093 -27.6% 694,790 440,654 36.6% 3. Tenaska Lindsay Hill TENASKA LINDSAY HILL 55271 45079 392,980 321,927 18.08% 836 978 -17.0% 940,013 658,196 30.0% Calhoun 4. Calhoun Power Company I, LLC CALHOUN ENERGY 55409 6728 297,729 83,540 71.94% 1,298 1,616 -24.5% 458,759 103,385 77.5% Colbert 5. Colbert COLBERT 47 9045 7,962,886 7,316,854 8.11% 1,955 2,206 -12.8% 8,147,591 6,634,727 18.6% Covington 6. McWilliams MCWILLIAMS REPOWER 533 27865 462,535 578,503 -25.07% 1,282 3,745 -192.1% 721,521 308,922 57.2% Jackson 7. Widows Creek WIDOWS CREEK 50 49756 11,247,466 9,976,111 11.30% 2,098 2,226 -6.1% 10,723,664 8,962,394 16.4% Lee 8. Plant H. Allen Franklin FRANKLIN (AL) 7710 14020 1,565,035 1,110,079 29.07% 846 970 2,288,025 38.2% Mobile 9. Barry BARRY 3 3437 13,024,927 12,800,000 1.73% 1,626 1,718 -5.6% 16,016,146 14,900,000 7.0% 10. Hog Bayou Energy Center HOG BAYOU ENERGY 55241 18079 41,230 107,392 -160.47% 827 2,736 -230.8% 99,679 78,490 21.3% 11. Theodore Cogeneration THEODORE COGEN 7721 45344 664,780 749,712 -12.78% 812 1,583 -95.1% 1,638,203 946,931 42.2% 12. Decatur Energy Center DECATUR ENERGY 55292 10434 1,212,350 154,317 87.27% 1,192 941 21.1% 2,033,442 327,959 83.9% 13. Morgan Energy Center MORGAN ENERGY 55293 29450 1,385,693 442,871 68.04% 840 1,229 -46.4% 3,300,575 720,428 78.2% Shelby 14. E C Gaston EC GASTON (AL) 26 11771 12,903,601 12,200,000 5.45% 2,005 2,017 -0.6% 12,873,514 12,100,000 6.0% Talladega 15. AMEA Sylacauga Plant SYLACAUGA 56018 44153 14,771 8,974 39.24% 1,127 223 80.2% 26,222 80,604 -207.4% Walker 16. Gorgas GORGAS TWO 8 15551 7,661,432 8,257,516 -7.78% 1,953 2,120 -8.6% 7,846,563 7,790,890 0.7% Washington 17. Charles R Lowman CR LOWMAN 56 9638 4,376,875 4,824,722 -10.23% 2,238 2,441 -9.1% 3,911,643 3,953,023 -1.1% 18. Washington County Cogen (Olin) WASHINGTON COUNTY (AL) 7697 49102 548,072 464,462 15.26% 814 1,572 -93.1% 1,346,449 590,872 56.1% Morgan CARMA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % -14.7% CAMD-EPA CARMA 3,700,970 Diff. % ARIZONA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Apache 19. Coronado Generating Station CORONADO 6177 9441 6,610,737 6,313,500 4.50% 2,038 2,161 -6.0% 6,488,089 5,843,046 9.9% 20. Springerville Generating Station SPRINGERVILLE 8223 42834 9,330,886 9,733,431 -4.31% 1,875 2,133 -13.8% 9,953,807 9,125,557 8.3% Page 1 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 ARIZONA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Cochise 21. Apache Station APACHE 160 1804 3,713,481 3,389,694 8.72% 2,176 2,627 Coconino 22. Navajo Generating Station NAVAJO 4941 30729 20,178,992 19,900,000 1.38% 2,110 2,263 Maricopa 23. Agua Fria Generating Station AGUA FRIA 141 432 131,172 201,159 -53.36% 1,232 1,424 -15.6% 213,019 282,586 -32.7% 24. Arlington Valley Energy Facility ARLINGTON VALLEY 55282 2062 656,747 1,334,376 -103.18% 815 2,173 -166.7% 1,612,287 1,228,387 23.8% 25. Gila River Power Station GILA RIVER 55306 15141 3,172,449 3,154,743 0.56% 810 1,293 -59.7% 7,837,996 4,879,993 37.7% 26. New Harquahala Generating Company, LLC HARQUAHALA VALLEY 55372 17008 1,268,729 17,691 98.61% 1,277 1,841 -44.1% 1,986,323 19,219 99.0% 27. Kyrene Generating Station KYRENE 147 23614 373,066 827,608 -121.84% 868 1,650 -90.0% 859,572 1,003,393 -16.7% 28. Mesquite Generating Station MESQUITE POWER 55481 28247 3,456,997 2,673,819 22.65% 840 872 -3.8% 8,230,907 6,131,193 25.5% -20.7% CAMD-EPA CARMA 3,412,678 Diff. % 2,580,930 24.4% -7.3% 19,128,128 17,600,000 8.0% 29. Ocotillo Power Plant OCOTILLO 116 32244 121,481 176,658 -45.42% 1,330 1,475 -10.9% 182,733 239,602 -31.1% 30. Redhawk Generating Facility REDHAWK 55455 37008 1,848,331 1,034,122 44.05% 1,347 952 29.3% 2,744,495 2,173,002 20.8% 31. Santan SANTAN 8068 39763 1,683,518 560,234 66.72% 877 2,358 -168.7% 3,837,592 475,214 87.6% 32. APS West Phoenix Power Plant WEST PHOENIX 117 49490 775,029 1,001,028 -29.16% 972 1,878 -93.2% 1,594,528 1,066,074 33.1% 33. Griffith Energy LLC GRIFFITH ENERGY 55124 15979 848,203 971,375 -14.52% 830 1,793 -116.0% 2,043,467 1,083,227 47.0% 34. South Point Energy Center, LLC SOUTH POINT CALPINE 55177 42644 920,081 1,242,245 -35.01% 827 1,083 -31.0% 2,226,268 2,294,826 -3.1% Navajo 35. Cholla CHOLLA 113 8542 9,041,223 8,025,604 11.23% 2,069 2,414 -16.7% 8,740,711 6,650,282 23.9% Pima 36. De Moss Petrie Generating Station DE MOSS PETRIE 124 10402 15,384 28,314 -84.05% 1,540 2,109 -36.9% 19,976 26,856 -34.4% 37. Irvington Generating Station H WILSON SUNDT 126 16440 1,067,132 1,067,228 -0.01% 1,872 1,903 -1.6% 1,140,019 1,121,653 1.6% 38. Desert Basin Generating Station DESERT BASIN 55129 10647 813,835 1,200,450 -47.51% 959 1,156 -20.6% 1,698,129 2,076,546 -22.3% 39. APS Saguaro Power Plant SAGUARO 118 38684 85,925 52,514 38.88% 1,420 1,649 -16.1% 120,981 63,706 47.3% 40. Sundance Power Plant SUNDANCE 55522 43827 91,661 110,406 -20.45% 1,249 1,230 1.5% 146,726 179,485 -22.3% Mohave Pinal Page 2 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 ARKANSAS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Benton 41. Flint Creek Power Plant FLINT CREEK (AR) 6138 13619 3,927,688 3,976,947 -1.25% 2,073 2,402 -15.9% 3,789,003 3,311,594 12.6% Franklin 42. Thomas Fitzhugh THOMAS B FITZHUGH 201 45388 65,105 35,530 45.43% 1,136 1,870 -64.6% 114,644 38,010 66.8% Hot Spring 43. KGen Hot Spring LLC HOT SPRING 55418 18546 467,244 551,526 -18.04% 888 2,042 -129.8% 1,051,854 540,229 48.6% 44. Hot Spring Power Co., LLC HOT SPRING POWER 55714 18547 717,843 771,667 -7.50% 1,172 876 25.2% 1,225,357 1,761,710 -43.8% 45. Lake Catherine LAKE CATHERINE 170 24215 24,493 110,496 -351.13% 1,449 1,627 -12.3% 33,801 135,824 -301.8% Independence 46. Independence INDEPENDENCE (AR) 6641 19354 13,839,850 12,200,000 11.85% 2,190 2,259 -3.2% 12,639,772 10,800,000 14.6% Jefferson 47. Pine Bluff Energy Center PINE BLUFF ENERGY 55075 34738 484,773 857,538 -76.89% 820 1,289 48. White Bluff WHITE BLUFF 6009 49668 11,053,731 12,400,000 -12.18% 2,119 2,262 Lafayette 49. Harvey Couch HARVEY COUCH 169 17079 25,944 22,224 14.34% 1,719 2,090 -21.6% 30,185 21,265 29.6% Union 50. Union Power Station UNION POWER 55380 47192 1,638,148 2,323,538 -41.84% 992 1,959 -97.4% 3,301,598 2,371,734 28.2% -57.2% CAMD-EPA CARMA 1,182,946 Diff. % 1,330,937 -12.5% -6.7% 10,430,699 11,000,000 -5.5% CALIFORNIA Power Plant Name and Location by County County Contra Costa S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA Plant IDs ORIS CARMA Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 51. Contra Costa Power Plant CONTRA COSTA 228 9298 90,721 478,415 -427.35% 1,225 1,234 -0.7% 148,071 775,283 -423.6% 52. Delta Energy Center, LLC DELTA ENERGY 55333 10557 2,205,555 2,417,681 -9.62% 813 905 -11.3% 5,422,871 5,341,291 1.5% 53. Los Medanos Energy Center, LLC LOS MEDANOS 55217 25931 1,546,010 3,144,705 -103.41% 794 2,000 -152.0% 3,895,702 3,144,349 19.3% 54. Pittsburg Power Plant (CA) PITTSBURG 271 34900 136,556 1,132,542 -729.36% 1,347 1,337 0.7% 202,822 1,694,249 -735.3% 55. Riverview Energy Center RIVERVIEW ENERGY (CA) 55963 37687 16,397 13,807 15.80% 1,189 991 16.6% 27,580 27,862 -1.0% 56. CalPeak Power - Panoche LLC CALPEAK PANOCHE 55508 6759 7,444 3,738 49.79% 1,236 1,259 -1.9% 12,049 5,935 50.7% 57. Fresno Cogeneration Partners, LP FRESNO COGEN 10156 14140 32,865 16,486 49.84% 1,194 1,563 -30.9% 55,054 21,096 61.7% Humboldt 58. Humboldt Bay HUMBOLDT BAY 246 18870 365,324 272,722 25.35% 1,503 1,176 21.8% 486,170 463,856 4.6% Imperial 59. El Centro EL CENTRO 389 12069 269,356 303,814 -12.79% 1,466 1,257 14.2% 367,490 483,224 -31.5% Kern 60. Elk Hills Power ELK HILLS POWER 55400 12322 1,505,361 1,765,732 -17.30% 826 960 -16.2% 3,644,231 3,678,411 -0.9% Fresno Page 3 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 CALIFORNIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CO2 Intensity County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Kern 61. La Paloma Generating Plant LA PALOMA 55151 23879 2,812,443 5,384,354 -91.45% 883 62. Pastoria Energy Facility PASTORIA (TEJON) 55656 33906 2,071,866 771,667 62.75% 63. Sunrise Power Company SUNRISE POWER PROJECT 55182 43892 1,528,392 2,799,554 64. Hanford Energy Park Peaker HANFORD ENERGY PARK 55698 16838 23,232 65. Henrietta Peaker Plant HENRIETTA SUBSTATION 55807 17540 Kings Los Angeles CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 2,101 -138.0% 6,370,281 5,125,182 19.5% 833 855 -2.6% 4,976,998 1,805,930 63.7% -83.17% 807 1,874 -132.1% 3,785,553 2,987,171 21.1% 6,539 71.85% 1,258 997 20.8% 36,937 13,120 64.5% 13,330 9,356 29.81% 1,223 1,291 -5.6% 21,807 14,491 33.5% 66. AES Alamitos AES ALAMITOS 315 320 994,779 1,989,822 -100.03% 1,293 1,431 -10.7% 1,538,175 2,780,313 -80.8% 67. AES Redondo Beach AES REDONDO BEACH 356 341 343,210 798,467 -132.65% 1,292 1,291 0.1% 531,398 1,237,011 -132.8% 68. Broadway BROADWAY (CA) 420 5860 9,391 50,781 -440.72% 1,395 1,131 18.9% 13,467 89,761 -566.5% 69. Carson Cogeneration Company CARSON COGEN 10169 7252 207,299 408,270 -96.95% 986 2,483 -151.7% 420,315 328,874 21.8% 70. Glenarm GLENARM 422 15301 24,331 32,679 -34.31% 1,309 586 55.2% 37,177 111,571 -200.1% 71. Grayson GRAYSON 377 15828 139,125 184,017 -32.27% 2,110 2,470 -17.1% 131,844 148,981 -13.0% 72. Harbor Generating Station HARBOR 399 16918 140,435 196,597 -39.99% 1,145 1,240 -8.3% 245,239 316,983 -29.3% 73. Haynes Generating Station HAYNES 400 17264 2,019,802 1,957,786 3.07% 974 1,857 -90.7% 4,146,446 2,107,986 49.2% 74. Lake LAKE (CA) 7987 24204 4,992 48,328 -868.07% 1,230 2,083 -69.3% 8,117 46,402 -471.7% 75. Magnolia MAGNOLIA 56046 26671 328,971 275,048 16.39% 447 935 -109.2% 1,471,493 588,068 60.0% 76. Malburg Generating Station MALBURG 56041 26860 341,470 170,520 50.06% 930 1,118 -20.3% 734,526 305,018 58.5% 77. Olive OLIVE 6013 32543 1,664 37,960 -2180.92% 1,576 2,072 -31.5% 2,112 78. Scattergood Generating Station SCATTERGOOD 404 40145 1,006,825 1,166,175 -15.83% 1,330 1,361 -2.3% 1,513,484 1,713,650 -13.2% 79. Valley Gen Station VALLEY (CA) 408 47767 1,340,037 1,873,015 -39.77% 843 3,526 -318.1% 3,178,034 1,062,425 66.6% Monterey 80. Moss Landing MOSS LANDING 260 29564 3,429,064 2,714,938 20.83% 875 973 -11.1% 7,834,343 5,581,235 28.8% Orange 81. AES Huntington Beach AES HUNTINGTON BEACH 335 331 905,557 1,389,219 -53.41% 1,367 2,224 -62.7% 1,325,262 1,249,412 5.7% Riverside 82. Indigo Generation Facility INDIGO ENERGY 55541 19390 52,992 61,624 -16.29% 1,274 1,393 -9.4% 83,217 88,458 -6.3% Sacramento 36,639 -1634.8% 83. Carson Cogeneration CARSON ICE-GEN 7527 7253 240,734 319,698 -32.80% 1,211 1,847 -52.5% 397,525 346,254 12.9% 84. Cosumnes Power Plant COSUMNES 55970 9524 1,480,952 545,069 63.19% 1,172 904 22.8% 2,526,964 1,205,510 52.3% 85. Sacramento Power Authority Cogen SPA CAMPBELL 7552 42724 524,239 547,652 -4.47% 831 778 6.3% 1,261,775 1,407,320 -11.5% Page 4 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 CALIFORNIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA San Bernardino 86. Agua Mansa Power AGUA MANSA 55951 436 29,636 23,510 20.67% 1,154 1,602 -38.8% 51,357 29,347 42.9% 87. Coolwater Generating Station COOL WATER 329 9313 421,624 277,823 34.11% 1,194 1,287 -7.8% 706,474 431,691 38.9% 88. High Desert Power Project HIGH DESERT 55518 17730 1,921,877 1,686,371 12.25% 1,325 876 33.8% 2,901,771 3,848,725 -32.6% 89. Mountainview Power Company, MOUNTAINVIEW POWER LLC 358 29685 2,705,366 1,146,593 57.62% 814 826 -1.5% 6,646,028 2,775,292 58.2% 90. CalPeak Power - Border LLC CALPEAK BORDER 55510 6756 23,431 8,366 64.29% 1,238 1,327 -7.2% 37,838 12,608 66.7% 91. CalPeak Power - El Cajon LLC CALPEAK EL CAJON 55512 6757 19,764 16,183 18.12% 1,265 1,264 0.0% 31,255 25,600 18.1% 92. CalPeak Power - Enterprise LLC CALPEAK ENTERPRISE 55513 6758 16,142 8,452 47.64% 1,251 1,250 0.1% 25,802 13,521 47.6% 93. Chula Vista Power Plant CHULA VISTA 55540 8624 1,627 26,728 -1542.98% 1,820 1,488 18.2% 1,788 94. Larkspur Energy Faciity LARKSPUR 55542 24577 31,839 31,158 2.14% 1,293 1,407 -8.8% 49,233 44,297 10.0% 95. Miramar Energy Facility MIRAMAR ENERGY 56232 28722 4,281 26,108 -509.83% 1,076 1,369 -27.2% 7,957 38,155 -379.5% 96. Palomar Energy PALOMAR ENERGY 55985 33559 1,403,805 529,111 62.31% 820 847 -3.2% 3,421,860 1,249,743 63.5% San Francisco 97. Potrero Power Plant POTRERO 273 35622 315,982 551,942 -74.68% 1,282 1,118 12.8% 492,790 987,014 -100.3% San Joaquin 98. Tracy Peaker TRACY PEAKER 55933 46243 10,111 12,609 -24.70% 1,416 1,394 1.6% 14,280 18,089 -26.7% San Luis Obispo 99. Morro Bay Power Plant, LLC MORRO BAY 259 29492 305,629 190,698 37.60% 1,133 1,741 -53.7% 539,554 219,099 59.4% Santa Clara Donald Von Raesfeld DONALD VON RAESFELD 56026 11108 268,877 137,949 48.69% 917 988 -7.7% 586,163 279,309 52.3% GILROY ENERGY 100. CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N San Diego CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 35,931 -1909.5% 101. Gilroy Energy Center, LLC 55810 15167 50,910 39,892 21.64% 1,081 574 46.9% 94,208 138,913 -47.5% 102. Los Esteros Critical Energy Fac LOS ESTEROS 55748 25919 40,168 244,059 -507.59% 1,175 1,146 2.5% 68,374 426,095 -523.2% 103. Metcalf Energy Center METCALF ENERGY CENTER 55393 28261 1,337,585 593,113 55.66% 927 850 8.4% 2,884,799 1,395,732 51.6% Shasta 104. Redding Power Plant REDDING 7307 37005 96,630 250,307 -159.04% 1,468 2,008 -36.7% 131,614 249,313 -89.4% Solano 105. CalPeak Power - Vaca Dixon LLC CALPEAK VACA DIXON 55499 6760 7,719 4,250 44.95% 1,257 1,069 15.0% 12,282 7,952 35.3% 106. Wolfskill Energy Center WOLFSKILL 55855 50161 13,017 21,463 -64.89% 1,205 1,249 -3.7% 21,612 34,358 -59.0% Stanislaus 107. Almond Power Plant ALMOND 7315 1057 53,003 65,680 -23.92% 1,166 2,380 -104.1% 90,896 55,196 39.3% 108. Ripon Generation Station RIPON MID 56135 37610 20,981 52,318 -149.37% 1,270 1,298 -2.2% 33,028 80,604 -144.0% 109. Walnut Energy Center WALNUT ENERGY 56078 48938 663,350 12,997 98.04% 950 193 79.7% 1,396,180 135,021 90.3% Page 5 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 CALIFORNIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Stanislaus 110. Woodland Generation Station WOODLAND AVENUE 7266 50204 203,358 335,207 -64.84% 1,018 2,234 -119.5% 399,496 300,072 24.9% Sutter 111. Feather River Energy Center FEATHER RIVER ENERGY 55847 13253 15,978 14,741 7.74% 1,189 1,275 -7.2% 26,870 23,115 14.0% 112. Calpine Sutter Energy Center SUTTER POWER 55112 43994 1,119,265 1,431,251 -27.87% 773 1,024 -32.4% 2,895,912 2,795,958 3.5% 113. Yuba City Energy Center YUBA CITY 10349 50942 15,434 9,807 36.45% 1,159 1,087 6.2% 26,635 18,038 32.3% 114. Mandalay Generating Station MANDALAY 345 27001 275,927 410,753 -48.86% 1,156 1,257 -8.7% 477,392 653,774 -36.9% 115. Ormond Beach Generating Station ORMOND BEACH 350 32871 619,648 1,391,958 -124.64% 1,184 1,258 -6.2% 1,046,371 2,213,689 -111.6% Ventura CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % COLORADO Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Adams 116. Blue Spruce Energy Center BLUE SPRUCE 55645 4980 353,660 216,119 38.89% 1,478 1,269 14.1% 478,652 340,513 28.9% 117. Frank Knutson Station FRANK R KNUTSON 55505 13999 177,994 83,707 52.97% 1,501 1,364 9.1% 237,194 122,721 48.3% 118. Valmont VALMONT (CO) 477 47793 1,464,298 1,472,534 -0.56% 2,079 2,480 -19.3% 1,408,777 1,187,459 15.7% 119. Valmont Combustion Turbine Facility VALMONT BHEC 55207 47795 10,753 1,958 81.79% 1,200 1,256 -4.6% 17,923 3,119 82.6% 120. Arapahoe ARAPAHOE 465 1899 1,368,739 1,266,510 7.47% 2,543 4,410 -73.4% 1,076,484 574,347 46.6% 121. Arapahoe Combustion Turbine ARAPAHOE BHEC 55200 1900 138,747 168,056 -21.12% 963 2,182 -126.6% 288,079 154,006 46.5% 122. Martin Drake DRAKE 492 11311 2,256,177 2,003,457 11.20% 2,149 2,066 3.8% 2,099,855 1,939,020 7.7% 123. Front Range Power Plant FRONT RANGE POWER 55283 14213 1,278,399 1,246,724 2.48% 890 992 -11.5% 2,873,036 2,512,802 12.5% 124. Ray D Nixon RD NIXON 8219 36936 1,706,023 1,965,436 -15.21% 2,099 2,185 -4.1% 1,625,930 1,799,303 -10.7% Larimer 125. Rawhide Energy Station RAWHIDE 6761 36879 2,441,148 2,787,770 -14.20% 1,916 2,901 -51.4% 2,547,805 1,921,943 24.6% Lincoln 126. Limon Generating Station LIMON 55504 25350 104,252 83,707 19.71% 1,468 1,364 7.0% 142,068 122,721 13.6% Mesa 127. Cameo CAMEO 468 6823 335,331 631,592 -88.35% 2,435 2,710 -11.3% 275,471 466,077 -69.2% Moffat 128. Craig CRAIG (CO) 6021 9646 11,492,044 11,400,000 0.80% 2,092 2,245 -7.3% 10,984,037 10,200,000 7.1% Montrose 129. Nucla NUCLA 527 31945 885,588 952,048 -7.50% 2,288 2,511 -9.7% 2.0% Denver El Paso CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Boulder CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA 774,125 758,408 Diff. % Page 6 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 COLORADO Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Morgan 130. Manchief Station MANCHIEF 55127 26994 214,817 45,183 78.97% 1,246 1,187 4.7% 344,746 76,117 77.9% 131. Pawnee PAWNEE 6248 34006 4,097,660 4,205,529 -2.63% 2,040 2,605 -27.7% 4,017,870 3,229,165 19.6% Pueblo 132. Comanche (470) COMANCHE (CO) 470 9161 5,029,913 5,288,561 -5.14% 2,055 2,731 -32.9% 4,894,646 3,873,240 20.9% Routt 133. Hayden HAYDEN 525 17260 4,298,546 4,151,893 3.41% 2,195 2,474 -12.7% 3,916,246 3,355,944 14.3% Weld 134. Fort St. Vrain FORT ST VRAIN REPOWER 6112 13866 1,842,759 729,387 60.42% 889 890 -0.1% 4,147,460 1,639,463 60.5% 135. Rocky Mountain Energy Center ROCKY MOUNTAIN ENERGY 55835 37867 1,251,006 861,378 31.15% 892 921 -3.2% 2,804,203 1,870,761 33.3% CONNECTICUT Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS Fairfield 136. Bridgeport Energy BRIDGEPORT ENERGY 137. Norwalk Harbor Station NORWALK HARBOR 138. Devon DEVON 139. Milford Power Company LLC 140. Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) CAMD-EPA CARMA 55042 5783 1,080,187 1,303,369 -20.66% 1,270 845 33.4% 1,701,187 3,083,993 -81.3% 548 31785 308,323 354,645 -15.02% 1,964 2,251 -14.6% 313,908 315,166 -0.4% 544 10705 10,856 52,070 -379.62% 1,604 2,107 -31.4% 13,540 49,425 -265.0% MILFORD POWER 55126 28535 1,249,356 2,118,931 -69.60% 843 1,712 -103.1% 2,964,869 2,475,351 16.5% New Haven Harbor NEW HAVEN HARBOR 6156 31056 557,699 504,015 9.63% 1,930 1,815 6.0% 578,028 555,517 3.9% 141. Wallingford Energy WALLINGFORD WTE 55517 48928 166,003 2,874 98.27% 1,159 85 92.6% 286,545 67,484 76.4% New London 142. Montville MONTVILLE 546 29378 86,790 190,349 -119.32% 1,818 2,225 -22.4% 95,485 171,100 -79.2% Windham 143. Lake Road Generating Company LAKE ROAD (CT) 55149 24256 1,527,783 1,993,697 -30.50% 1,307 1,728 -32.2% 2,338,386 2,308,136 1.3% New Haven Diff. % CO2 Intensity CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % DELAWARE Power Plant Name and Location by County County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA Kent 144. McKee Run MCKEE RUN 145. NRG Energy Center Dover 146. 147. Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 599 27837 17,068 114,489 -570.78% 1,598 1,942 -21.5% 21,360 117,924 -452.1% NRG ENERGY DOVER 10030 31919 11,472 189,918 -1555.51% 1,155 2,761 -138.9% 19,857 137,591 -592.9% Van Sant VAN SANT 7318 47829 1,689 2,601 -53.95% 1,040 884 15.0% 3,248 5,886 -81.2% Warren F. Sam Beasley Pwr Station WARREN F BEASLEY 7962 49067 29,100 19,030 34.61% 1,149 1,075 6.5% 50,651 35,409 30.1% Page 7 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 DELAWARE Power Plant Name and Location by County County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA New Castle 148. Edge Moor 149. 150. Sussex Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % EDGE MOOR 593 11830 1,964,871 2,054,703 -4.57% 1,890 2,213 -17.1% 2,078,760 1,856,962 10.7% Hay Road HAY ROAD 7153 17249 440,867 464,636 -5.39% 815 698 14.4% 1,081,549 1,331,326 -23.1% Indian River INDIAN RIVER (DE) 594 19375 4,165,866 3,557,771 14.60% 2,026 2,204 -8.8% 4,111,804 3,228,551 21.5% DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA Power Plant Name and Location by County County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA District of Columbia 151. Benning BENNING Plant IDs ORIS CARMA 603 4064 Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA 35,209 CARMA 43,946 Diff. % -24.81% CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA 970 4,116 Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % -324.2% CAMD-EPA CARMA 72,576 Diff. % 21,354 70.6% FLORIDA Power Plant Name and Location by County County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA Alachua 152. Deerhaven 153. J R Kelly Bay 154. Brevard Broward Duval Escambia Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % DEERHAVEN 663 10480 1,743,360 1,516,282 13.03% 2,060 2,207 -7.1% 1,692,182 1,373,877 18.8% JR KELLY 664 20625 130,522 189,231 -44.98% 1,503 1,260 16.2% 173,637 300,290 -72.9% Lansing Smith Generating Plant LANSING SMITH 643 24521 3,785,981 3,792,429 -0.17% 1,606 1,677 -4.4% 4,713,518 4,521,679 4.1% 155. Cape Canaveral CAPE CANAVERAL 609 7039 1,620,908 2,241,247 -38.27% 1,480 1,631 -10.2% 2,190,616 2,748,218 -25.5% 156. Indian River (683) INDIAN RIVER (FL) GT 683 19376 20,873 187,227 -797.00% 1,659 1,283 22.7% 25,160 157. Indian River (55318) INDIAN RIVER (FL) RELIANT 55318 19377 209,839 6,177 97.06% 1,513 1,163 23.1% 277,456 10,620 96.2% 158. Oleander Power Project OLEANDER 55286 32526 360,886 345,666 4.22% 1,322 1,541 -16.5% 545,860 448,672 17.8% 159. Lauderdale LAUDERDALE 613 24688 2,377,183 2,294,906 3.46% 1,350 972 28.0% 3,521,884 4,719,995 -34.0% 160. Port Everglades PORT EVERGLADES 617 35451 2,422,109 3,654,941 -50.90% 1,636 1,727 -5.6% 2,960,870 4,231,950 -42.9% 161. Brandy Branch BRANDY BRANCH 7846 5619 693,979 281,378 59.45% 1,328 1,063 19.9% 1,045,342 529,399 49.4% 162. J D Kennedy JD KENNEDY 666 20213 47,349 21,991 53.56% 1,246 541 56.6% 76,025 81,363 -7.0% 163. Northside NORTHSIDE 667 31767 4,902,453 4,686,062 4.41% 1,974 1,935 2.0% 4,966,431 4,844,684 2.5% 164. St. Johns River Power ST JOHNS RIVER 207 42958 10,344,332 10,100,000 2.36% 2,024 2,160 -6.7% 10,219,444 9,320,629 8.8% 165. Crist Electric Generating Plant CRIST 641 9712 7,298,602 5,737,312 21.39% 2,149 2,122 5,406,846 20.4% 1.2% CAMD-EPA CARMA 6,794,088 Diff. % 291,794 -1059.8% Page 8 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 FLORIDA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Hardee 166. Hardee Power Station HARDEE POWER 50949 16932 9,811 167. Midulla Generating Station PAYNE CREEK 7380 34014 427,239 1,364,690 168. Vandolah Power Project VANDOLAH 55415 47842 134,924 169. Bayside Power Station BAYSIDE (FL) 7873 3676 170. Big Bend BIG BEND (FL) 645 Indian River 171. Vero Beach Municipal VERO BEACH Jackson 172. Scholz Electric Generating Plant Lee 173. Leon Diff. % Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 1,392 1,328 4.6% 14,097 -219.42% 1,394 1,183 15.1% 613,034 2,306,498 -276.2% 143,455 -6.32% 1,235 1,593 -29.1% 218,564 180,059 17.6% 3,344,102 1,028,146 69.25% 1,313 777 40.8% 5,094,582 2,644,874 48.1% 4552 10,469,398 10,700,000 -2.20% 2,289 2,369 -3.5% 9,146,898 9,017,576 1.4% 693 48122 51,499 18,451 64.17% 1,514 1,525 -0.7% 68,038 24,202 64.4% SCHOLZ 642 40252 572,228 531,157 7.18% 2,601 2,662 -2.3% 440,027 399,097 9.3% Fort Myers FORT MYERS 612 13852 4,150,268 4,073,429 1.85% 1,297 957 26.2% 6,402,028 8,509,372 -32.9% 174. Arvah B Hopkins AB HOPKINS 688 72 578,628 851,895 -47.23% 1,304 1,496 -14.7% 887,659 1,139,125 -28.3% Manatee 175. Manatee MANATEE 6042 26973 5,738,612 11,700,000 -103.88% 1,422 2,753 -93.6% 8,070,900 8,482,813 -5.1% Miami-Dade 176. Cutler CUTLER (FL) 610 9931 89,845 151,653 -68.79% 1,545 1,483 4.0% 116,278 204,484 -75.9% Monroe 177. Stock Island STOCK ISLAND 6584 43402 1,438 36,725 -2453.91% 1,513 4,376 -189.2% 1,901 16,785 -783.0% Hillsborough Orange 230,713 -2251.64% CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA 347,526 -2365.3% 178. Stanton A CH STANTON A 55821 7788 1,137,137 1,312,185 -15.39% 1,149 1,015 11.7% 1,978,745 2,586,843 -30.7% 179. Orlando CoGen ORLANDO COGEN 54466 32858 457,836 738,113 -61.22% 936 1,798 -92.2% 978,478 820,871 16.1% 180. Cane Island CANE ISLAND 7238 6953 657,925 666,714 -1.34% 953 972 -2.1% 1,381,241 1,371,413 0.7% 181. Intercession City INTERCESSION CITY 8049 19502 597,339 551,641 7.65% 1,669 1,408 15.6% 715,755 783,507 -9.5% Palm Beach 182. Riviera RIVIERA 619 37694 1,509,900 2,162,567 -43.23% 1,539 1,693 -10.0% 1,962,535 2,554,606 -30.2% Pasco 183. Anclote ANCLOTE 8048 1475 3,086,685 4,918,206 -59.34% 1,783 2,046 -14.7% 3,461,481 4,808,456 -38.9% 184. Shady Hills SHADY HILLS 55414 40882 720,618 329,813 54.23% 1,367 1,549 -13.3% 1,054,131 425,732 59.6% 185. Auburndale Cogeneration Facility AUBURNDALE 54658 2514 352,141 427,317 -21.35% 1,265 440 65.2% 556,666 1,940,366 -248.6% 186. Hines Energy Complex HINES 7302 17866 3,317,971 3,742,206 -12.79% 1,314 1,084 17.5% 5,050,696 6,906,982 -36.8% 187. Charles Larsen Memorial Power Plant LARSEN MEMORIAL 675 24588 83,668 63,484 24.12% 1,594 1,660 -4.1% 104,948 76,482 27.1% 188. Orange Cogeneration Facility ORANGECO 54365 32785 191,085 528,548 -176.60% 398 2,581 -547.8% 959,065 409,521 57.3% Osceola Polk Page 9 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 FLORIDA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CO2 Intensity County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Polk 189. Osprey Energy Center OSPREY ENERGY CENTER 55412 33041 1,003,647 1,385,365 -38.03% 876 190. Tiger Bay TIGER BAY COGEN 7699 45539 385,202 490,313 -27.29% 191. Putnam PUTNAM (FL) 6246 36210 546,098 491,977 192. Seminole (136) SEMINOLE (FL) 136 40602 9,863,224 Saint Lucie 193. Henry D King HD KING 658 17293 Santa Rosa 194. Santa Rosa Energy Center SANTA ROSA ENERGY 55242 Suwannee 195. Suwannee River SUWANNEE RIVER Volusia 196. Debary 197. 198. Putnam Wakulla CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 2,567 -193.1% 2,291,442 1,079,210 52.9% 1,419 1,097 22.7% 542,807 893,877 -64.7% 9.91% 1,137 1,199 -5.5% 960,770 820,521 14.6% 8,709,828 11.69% 1,962 1,909 2.7% 10,056,638 9,123,788 9.3% 8,306 10,630 -27.98% 1,756 2,532 -44.2% 9,462 8,397 11.3% 39737 2,597 16,171 -522.68% 1,695 1,703 -0.5% 3,065 18,985 -519.4% 638 44013 267,719 528,886 -97.55% 1,639 4,712 -187.4% 326,651 224,497 31.3% DEBARY 6046 10427 121,634 325,784 -167.84% 1,840 1,598 13.1% 132,209 407,691 -208.4% Sanford SANFORD (FL) 620 39551 5,255,488 6,267,575 -19.26% 1,341 1,149 14.3% 7,839,253 10,900,000 -39.0% S O Purdom PURDOM 689 36178 702,681 502,280 28.52% 1,396 1,007 27.8% 1,006,880 997,471 0.9% GEORGIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Bartow 199. Bowen BOWEN 703 5475 23,243,818 20,500,000 11.80% 1,934 1,985 Chatham 200. Kraft KRAFT 733 23073 1,653,099 1,357,491 17.88% 2,408 2,393 0.6% 1,373,042 1,134,694 17.4% Cobb 201. Jack McDonough MCDONOUGH 710 27817 3,888,518 3,212,548 17.38% 1,912 2,005 -4.9% 4,067,944 3,204,132 21.2% Coweta 202. Yates YATES 728 50730 8,077,423 6,095,099 24.54% 1,995 2,140 -7.3% 8,098,861 5,696,348 29.7% Dougherty 203. Mitchell (GA) MITCHELL (GA) 727 28810 679,637 442,627 34.87% 2,209 2,739 -24.0% 615,438 323,238 47.5% Effingham 204. Effingham County Power, LLC EFFINGHAM COUNTY 55406 11884 506,358 602,264 -18.94% 1,314 1,517 -15.4% 770,689 794,089 -3.0% Floyd 205. Hammond HAMMOND 708 16788 5,188,147 4,097,816 21.02% 2,037 2,152 -5.7% 5,094,821 3,808,251 25.3% Glynn 206. McManus MCMANUS 715 27851 21,800 40,064 -83.78% 2,589 2,740 -5.9% 16,843 29,242 -73.6% Heard 207. Chattahoochee Energy Facility CHATTAHOOCHEE 7917 8065 652,671 398,590 38.93% 1,247 918 26.4% 1,046,938 868,582 17.0% 208. Heard County Power, LLC HEARD COUNTY 55141 17301 32,642 766 97.65% 1,291 2,902 -124.8% 50,566 528 99.0% -2.6% 24,037,959 20,600,000 Diff. % 14.3% Page 10 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 GEORGIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Houston 209. Mid-Georgia Cogeneration MID-GEORGIA COGEN 55040 28379 130,978 15,688 88.02% 915 995 -8.8% 286,428 31,536 89.0% Jackson 210. Dahlberg (Jackson County) DAHLBERG 7765 10055 177,150 127,575 27.99% 1,398 3,348 -139.5% 253,483 76,206 69.9% Mitchell 211. Baconton BACONTON 55304 2783 18,995 1,039 94.53% 1,170 1,408 -20.4% 32,476 1,476 95.5% 212. Sowega Power Project SOWEGA 7768 42712 21,063 20,746 1.50% 1,173 183 84.4% 35,904 226,460 -530.7% 213. Scherer SCHERER 6257 40191 27,231,087 25,300,000 7.09% 2,059 2,180 -5.9% 26,455,146 23,200,000 12.3% 214. Smarr Energy Facility SMARR ENERGY 7829 42133 28,468 2,608 90.84% 1,389 2,391 -72.2% 41,005 2,181 94.7% Polk 215. Sewell Creek Energy SEWELL CREEK (GA) 7813 40840 103,227 15,411 85.07% 1,352 1,829 -35.3% 152,698 16,854 89.0% Talbot 216. Talbot Energy Facility TALBOT ENERGY 7916 44464 136,925 70,205 48.73% 1,501 1,500 0.1% 182,411 93,610 48.7% Walton 217. Doyle Generating Facility DOYLE 55244 11294 38,099 29,134 23.53% 1,463 1,478 -1.0% 52,092 39,422 24.3% 218. Walton County Power, LLC WALTON COUNTY 55128 48964 55,750 454 99.19% 1,194 2 99.9% 93,387 531,058 -468.7% 219. Washington County Power, LLC WASHINGTON COUNTY (GA) 55332 49103 53,116 1,244 97.66% 1,241 1,726 -39.2% 85,634 1,441 98.3% Washington CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Monroe CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % ILLINOIS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Christian 220. Kincaid Station KINCAID 876 22210 7,694,870 8,245,385 -7.15% 2,212 2,219 -0.3% 6,956,953 7,431,071 -6.8% Clay 221. Raccoon Creek Power Plant RACCOON CREEK 55417 36455 37,242 27,788 25.38% 1,464 1,483 -1.3% 50,872 37,466 26.4% Cook 222. Crawford CRAWFORD 867 9667 3,185,926 3,471,341 -8.96% 2,181 2,398 -10.0% 2,921,624 2,895,156 0.9% 223. Fisk FISK 886 13531 1,784,715 1,988,449 -11.42% 2,031 2,509 -23.5% 1,757,377 1,585,081 9.8% 224. Southeast Chicago Energy Project SOUTHEAST CHICAGO 55281 42677 8,996 19,016 -111.38% 1,451 1,874 -29.2% 12,404 20,299 -63.6% Crawford 225. Hutsonville HUTSONVILLE 863 18975 1,112,023 897,362 19.30% 2,464 2,358 4.3% 902,720 761,169 15.7% Fayette 226. Freedom Power Project FREEDOM POWER 7842 14089 4,432 162 96.33% 1,112 1,286 -15.6% 7,971 253 96.8% Ford 227. Gibson City Power Plant GIBSON CITY 55201 15102 28,882 2,712 90.61% 1,301 4,151 -219.0% 44,388 1,306 97.1% Fulton 228. Duck Creek DUCK CREEK 6016 11436 572,743 2,544,899 -344.34% 2,219 2,545 -14.7% 516,141 1,999,925 -287.5% Page 11 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 ILLINOIS Power Plant Name and Location by County County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA Jackson 229. Grand Tower Jasper 230. Kane Lake Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) CARMA GRAND TOWER 862 15747 278,952 148,898 46.62% 1,064 1,385 -30.2% 524,524 215,025 59.0% Newton NEWTON 6017 31149 9,544,417 7,798,570 18.29% 2,159 2,211 -2.4% 8,839,559 7,054,827 20.2% 231. Rocky Road Power, LLC ROCKY ROAD 55109 37874 46,103 20,351 55.86% 1,376 1,803 -31.0% 66,989 22,577 66.3% 232. Waukegan WAUKEGAN 883 49185 5,335,155 4,906,155 8.04% 2,087 2,275 -9.0% 5,112,704 4,313,976 15.6% 233. Zion Energy Center ZION ENERGY 55392 51243 136,793 27,024 80.24% 1,333 1,809 -35.7% 205,241 29,881 85.4% 234. Venice VENICE 913 48053 177,661 5,648 96.82% 1,203 6,000 -398.6% 295,274 1,883 99.4% 235. Wood River Power Station WOOD RIVER (IL) 898 50192 3,001,465 2,579,302 14.07% 1,974 2,150 -8.9% 3,040,826 2,399,437 21.1% Marion 236. Kinmundy Power Plant KINMUNDY 55204 22286 13,379 3,561 73.38% 1,349 3,052 -126.2% 19,829 2,334 88.2% Mason 237. Havana HAVANA 891 17208 3,678,169 2,381,575 35.25% 2,127 2,239 -5.3% 3,458,164 2,127,171 38.5% Montgomery 238. Coffeen COFFEEN 861 9006 6,594,766 6,698,596 -1.57% 2,127 2,322 -9.2% 6,199,565 5,769,156 6.9% Morgan 239. Meredosia MEREDOSIA 864 28174 2,140,168 1,808,501 15.50% 2,813 3,190 -13.4% 1,521,467 1,134,030 25.5% Peoria 240. E D Edwards ED EDWARDS 856 11804 5,989,144 4,696,431 21.58% 2,396 2,222 7.3% 5,000,160 4,227,404 15.5% Perry 241. Pinckneyville Power Plant PINCKNEYVILLE 55202 34729 124,944 40,541 67.55% 1,376 1,326 3.6% 181,610 61,158 66.3% Putnam 242. Hennepin Power Station HENNEPIN 892 17534 2,283,908 2,169,315 5.02% 2,065 2,185 -5.8% 2,212,487 1,985,831 10.2% Randolph 243. Baldwin Energy Complex BALDWIN 889 3012 14,135,508 13,600,000 3.79% 1,979 2,081 -5.2% 14,288,585 13,100,000 8.3% Rock Island 244. Cordova Energy Company CORDOVA ENERGY 55188 9377 293,334 183,896 37.31% 902 1,262 -39.9% 650,515 291,416 55.2% Sangamon 245. Dallman DALLMAN 963 10133 2,348,051 2,717,882 -15.75% 1,723 2,797 -62.3% 2,725,154 1,943,300 28.7% 246. Interstate INTERSTATE 7425 19510 14,701 3,701 74.83% 1,563 1,761 -12.6% 18,813 4,204 77.7% 247. Lakeside LAKESIDE (IL) 964 24275 365,728 214,975 41.22% 1,303 2,474 -89.8% 561,163 173,756 69.0% Shelby 248. Reliant Energy Shelby County SHELBY COUNTY (IL) 55237 41066 35,163 6,637 81.12% 1,052 1,568 -49.1% 66,869 8,463 87.3% Tazewell 249. Powerton POWERTON 879 35689 9,015,927 9,899,173 -9.80% 2,038 2,241 -10.0% 8,847,139 8,833,628 0.2% Vermilion 250. Tilton Power Station TILTON 7760 45566 61,157 49,716 18.71% 1,406 1,394 0.9% 87,015 71,350 18.0% 251. Vermilion Power Station VERMILION 897 48111 980,316 1,086,201 -10.80% 2,232 2,292 -2.7% 878,393 947,977 -7.9% Madison CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity ORIS Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Page 12 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 ILLINOIS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Will 252. Crete Energy Park CRETE ENERGY 55253 9695 11,872 1,122 90.55% 1,507 6,000 -298.0% 15,751 374 97.6% 253. Elwood Energy Facility ELWOOD ENERGY 55199 12401 202,848 1,448,664 -614.16% 1,252 1,099 12.3% 324,010 2,637,331 -714.0% 254. Lincoln Generating Facility LINCOLN PROJECT 55222 25365 15,359 5,881 61.71% 1,463 2,189 -49.7% 20,999 5,372 74.4% 255. Will County WILL COUNTY 884 49841 6,089,674 5,234,976 14.04% 2,053 2,285 -11.3% 5,932,439 4,582,364 22.8% 256. Marion MARION (IL) 976 27335 2,716,811 2,943,494 -8.34% 2,804 2,997 -6.9% 1,937,589 1,964,037 -1.4% Williamson CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % INDIANA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Dearborn 257. Lawrenceburg Energy Facility LAWRENCEBURG 55502 24766 432,271 19,730 95.44% 1,331 5,374 -303.7% 649,499 7,343 98.9% 258. Tanners Creek TANNERS CREEK 988 44654 6,025,709 5,963,199 1.04% 1,875 2,074 -10.6% 6,427,038 5,749,997 10.5% Floyd 259. R Gallagher GALLAGHER 1008 14525 3,180,459 3,382,653 -6.36% 1,915 2,145 -12.0% 3,321,990 3,153,368 5.1% Gibson 260. Gibson GIBSON 6113 15101 22,409,315 20,400,000 8.97% 1,796 1,930 -7.4% 24,951,353 21,100,000 15.4% Greene 261. Worthington Generation WORTHINGTON SUBSTATION 55148 50256 22,926 65,328 -184.95% 1,187 1,870 -57.5% 38,629 69,871 -80.9% Hamilton 262. Noblesville NOBLESVILLE 1007 31497 197,375 222,181 -12.57% 1,385 2,299 -66.0% 284,916 193,264 32.2% Henry 263. Henry County Generating Station HENRY COUNTY (IN) 7763 17546 53,217 37,793 28.98% 1,148 1,336 -16.4% 92,681 56,570 39.0% Jasper 264. R M Schahfer Generating Station RM SCHAHFER 6085 37735 12,289,294 11,000,000 10.49% 2,250 2,356 -4.7% 10,922,650 9,309,784 14.8% Jefferson 265. Clifty Creek CLIFTY CREEK 983 8892 8,099,448 8,012,940 1.07% 1,810 1,953 -7.9% 8,951,782 8,207,173 8.3% Knox 266. Wheatland Generating Facility LLC WHEATLAND 55224 49629 17,279 2,667 84.56% 1,555 2,120 -36.4% 22,231 2,516 88.7% Lake 267. State Line Generating Station (IN) STATE LINE 981 43197 3,430,009 3,362,254 1.98% 2,017 2,321 -15.1% 3,401,115 2,897,624 14.8% LaPorte 268. Michigan City Generating Station MICHIGAN CITY 997 28367 2,895,808 3,139,297 -8.41% 2,097 2,333 -11.3% 2,762,026 2,690,727 2.6% Lawrence 269. Hoosier Energy Lawrence Co Station LAWRENCE STATION 7948 24763 39,673 147,119 -270.83% 1,191 1,200 -0.8% 66,616 245,174 -268.0% Page 13 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 INDIANA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Madison 270. Anderson ANDERSON (IN) 7336 1493 5,472 3,022 44.77% 1,528 778 49.1% 7,161 7,765 -8.4% Marion 271. Georgetown Substation GEORGETOWN (IN) 7759 14978 42,944 6,721 84.35% 1,480 6,000 -305.3% 58,019 2,240 96.1% 272. Harding Street Station (EW Stout) HARDING STREET 990 16939 3,831,144 3,965,938 -3.52% 1,862 2,058 -10.5% 4,114,778 3,854,029 6.3% Morgan 273. IPL Eagle Valley Generating Station EAGLE VALLEY 991 11646 1,596,416 1,493,916 6.42% 2,025 2,186 -8.0% 1,576,886 1,366,808 13.3% Pike 274. Frank E Ratts FRANK E RATTS 1043 13996 1,883,713 1,635,472 13.18% 2,042 1,923 5.8% 1,845,105 1,700,725 7.8% 275. Petersburg PETERSBURG (IN) 994 34416 13,077,495 12,500,000 4.42% 2,021 2,219 -9.8% 12,942,205 11,300,000 12.7% Porter 276. Bailly Generating Station BAILLY 995 2917 2,891,039 3,793,230 -31.21% 2,212 2,472 Spencer 277. Rockport ROCKPORT (IN) 6166 37853 15,488,966 16,600,000 -7.17% 1,825 Sullivan 278. Merom MEROM 6213 28199 7,149,683 6,764,510 5.39% Vermillion 279. Cayuga CAYUGA 1001 7513 6,583,396 6,914,400 280. Vermillion Energy Facility VERMILLION COUNTY 55111 48112 99,239 281. Sugar Creek Power Company, LLC SUGAR CREEK 55364 43675 282. Wabash River Gen Station WABASH RIVER 1010 Warrick 283. F B Culley Generating Station FB CULLEY Wayne 284. Richmond (IN) 285. 286. Wells CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Vigo CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % -11.7% CAMD-EPA CARMA 2,613,724 Diff. % 3,069,380 -17.4% 1,942 -6.4% 16,972,671 17,100,000 -0.8% 2,029 2,180 -7.4% 7,048,652 6,206,572 11.9% -5.03% 1,785 2,047 -14.7% 7,374,606 6,754,537 8.4% 4,402 95.56% 1,651 1,543 6.5% 120,246 5,705 95.3% 130,324 201,680 -54.75% 898 2,054 -128.8% 290,277 196,364 32.4% 48763 5,710,477 4,738,145 17.03% 2,498 1,970 21.1% 4,572,705 4,809,120 -5.2% 1012 13245 3,317,448 3,335,561 -0.55% 3,041 2,556 15.9% 2,181,796 2,609,497 -19.6% RICHMOND (IN) 7335 37358 1,934 2,106 -8.87% 1,601 1,762 -10.1% 2,416 2,390 1.1% Whitewater Valley WHITEWATER VALLEY 1040 49718 515,677 684,218 -32.68% 2,350 2,483 -5.7% 438,788 551,032 -25.6% Montpelier Electric Gen Station MONTPELIER (IN) 55229 29362 44,018 12,643 71.28% 1,381 1,355 1.9% 63,738 18,658 70.7% IOWA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Allamakee 287. Lansing LANSING 1047 24518 2,092,405 1,707,697 18.39% 2,710 2,385 12.0% 1,543,979 1,432,309 7.2% Audubon 288. Exira Station EXIRA 56013 12984 38,165 11,020 71.12% 1,134 290 74.4% 67,330 76,081 -13.0% Page 14 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 IOWA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Black Hawk 289. Streeter Station STREETER 1131 43536 124,338 185,075 -48.85% 2,287 2,866 -25.4% 108,752 129,138 -18.7% Cerro Gordo 290. Emery Station EMERY 8031 12439 731,076 167,256 77.12% 861 757 12.1% 1,698,586 442,069 74.0% 291. Lime Creek LIME CREEK 7155 25339 38,222 6,031 84.22% 2,231 2,580 -15.6% 34,268 4,675 86.4% Clay 292. Earl F Wisdom EARL F WISDOM 1217 11649 109,036 98,074 10.05% 2,619 2,575 1.7% 83,279 76,184 8.5% Clinton 293. Milton L Kapp ML KAPP 1048 28900 1,260,776 1,456,903 -15.56% 2,158 2,430 -12.6% 1,168,488 1,199,093 -2.6% Des Moines 294. Burlington (IA) BURLINGTON (IA) 1104 6339 1,551,487 1,432,364 7.68% 2,355 2,843 -20.7% 1,317,633 1,007,817 23.5% Dubuque 295. Dubuque DUBUQUE 1046 11431 453,843 458,063 -0.93% 2,683 2,909 -8.4% 338,339 314,946 6.9% Muscatine 296. Fair Station FE FAIR 1218 13252 274,163 430,139 -56.89% 2,450 2,746 -12.1% 223,845 313,227 -39.9% 297. Muscatine MUSCATINE 1167 30062 2,066,156 2,121,673 -2.69% 2,399 3,301 -37.6% 1,722,628 1,285,463 25.4% 298. Greater Des Moines Energy Center GREATER DES MOINES 7985 15851 499,785 211,501 57.68% 1,330 3,036 -128.2% 751,415 139,317 81.5% 299. Pleasant Hill Energy Center PLEASANT HILL 7145 35017 12,391 12,844 -3.66% 1,755 1,919 -9.3% 14,119 13,388 5.2% Scott 300. Riverside (1081) RIVERSIDE (IA) 1081 37664 799,722 981,099 -22.68% 2,095 2,797 -33.5% 763,628 701,499 8.1% Story 301. Dayton Avenue Substation DAYTON AVENUE 6463 10371 288 17,604 -6008.41% 1,796 1,271 29.2% 321 Wapello 302. Ottumwa OTTUMWA 6254 33178 4,664,793 2,291 2,342 -2.3% 4,073,095 4,983,843 Diff. % -6.84% CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Polk CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 27,709 -8531.9% 4,255,642 -4.5% KANSAS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Barton 303. Great Bend Station aka Arthur Mullergren ARTHUR MULLERGREN 1235 2163 111,630 67,338 39.68% 1,274 1,190 6.6% 175,238 113,192 35.4% Cherokee 304. Riverton RIVERTON 1239 37684 802,929 590,023 26.52% 2,391 4,609 -92.8% 671,689 256,038 61.9% Cowley 305. East 12th Street EAST TWELFTH STREET 7013 11700 461 23,241 -4944.62% 866 1,504 -73.6% 1,064 Douglas 306. Lawrence Energy Center LAWRENCE (KS) 1250 24756 4,320,499 5,218,848 -20.79% 2,249 2,872 -27.7% 3,842,478 3,633,664 5.4% Finney 307. Garden City GARDEN CITY 1336 14672 23,274 22,657 2.65% 1,163 1,370 -17.8% 40,023 33,070 17.4% 308. Holcomb HOLCOMB 108 18164 3,081,538 2,782,713 9.70% 2,005 2,038 -1.6% 3,073,698 2,731,407 11.1% 30,913 -2805.3% Page 15 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 KANSAS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Ford 309. Fort Dodge aka Judson Large JUDSON LARGE 1233 20664 320,899 209,833 34.61% 1,268 1,464 -15.4% 506,190 286,705 43.4% Johnson 310. West Gardner Generating Station WEST GARDNER 7929 49460 73,477 15,751 78.56% 1,480 1,628 -10.0% 99,325 19,351 80.5% Labette 311. Neosho Energy Center NEOSHO 1243 30896 6,626 57,756 -771.67% 1,367 1,403 -2.6% 9,693 82,321 -749.3% Linn 312. La Cygne LA CYGNE 1241 23746 11,159,641 11,900,000 -6.63% 2,014 2,329 -15.7% 11,083,468 10,200,000 8.0% McPherson 313. McPherson 3 MCPHERSON THREE (KS) 7515 27860 22,569 8,074 64.23% 1,612 1,497 7.1% 27,998 Montgomery 314. Coffeyville COFFEYVILLE 1271 9007 1,143 7 99.40% 1,615 0 100.0% 1,415 Pottawatomie 315. Jeffrey Energy Center JEFFREY 6068 20255 16,845,936 16,300,000 3.24% 2,058 2,335 Reno 316. Hutchinson Energy Center HUTCHINSON (KS) 1248 18968 104,183 181,840 -74.54% 1,289 2,838 -120.2% 161,623 128,132 20.7% Sedgwick 317. Gordon Evans Energy Center GORDON EVANS 1240 15541 409,629 568,592 -38.81% 1,321 1,871 -41.6% 620,205 607,877 2.0% 318. Murray Gill Energy Center MURRAY GILL (KS) 1242 30040 126,101 229,534 -82.02% 1,435 2,288 -59.4% 175,741 200,633 -14.2% Seward 319. Cimarron River CIMARRON RIVER 1230 8727 94,465 41,053 56.54% 1,387 1,268 8.5% 136,245 64,745 52.5% Shawnee 320. Tecumseh Energy Center TECUMSEH (KS) 1252 44941 1,819,229 1,680,014 7.65% 2,286 2,572 -12.5% 1,591,869 1,306,480 17.9% Wyandotte 321. Nearman Creek NEARMAN CREEK 6064 30794 2,170,457 2,225,889 -2.55% 2,376 2,594 -9.2% 1,827,319 1,715,935 6.1% 322. Quindaro QUINDARO THREE 1295 36398 1,457,132 1,154,752 20.75% 2,262 2,426 -7.3% 1,288,450 951,881 26.1% 10,784 61.5% 69,777 -4831.3% -13.5% 16,369,404 13,900,000 15.1% KENTUCKY Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CO2 Intensity S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Boone 323. East Bend EAST BEND 6018 11661 3,871,543 4,332,392 -11.90% 1,857 2,142 Carroll 324. Ghent GHENT 1356 15080 12,561,781 12,200,000 2.88% 1,943 2,037 Clark 325. William C. Dale DALE 1385 10114 1,186,544 1,371,488 -15.59% 2,165 2,100 3.0% 1,096,004 1,306,446 -19.2% 326. Smith Generating Facility JK SMITH 54 20482 327,283 209,757 35.91% 1,718 3,016 -75.6% 381,029 139,099 63.5% 327. Elmer Smith ELMER SMITH 1374 12368 2,710,250 3,168,373 -16.90% 2,216 2,736 -23.5% 2,446,309 2,315,963 5.3% Daviess CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County Diff. % -15.3% CAMD-EPA CARMA 4,169,765 Diff. % 4,045,681 3.0% -4.8% 12,930,795 12,000,000 7.2% Page 16 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 KENTUCKY Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Hancock 328. Coleman COLEMAN (KY) 1381 9060 3,653,553 3,326,093 Henderson 329. Henderson I HENDERSON ONE 1372 17508 8,179 Jefferson 330. Cane Run CANE RUN 1363 6954 3,787,734 3,243,856 331. Mill Creek MILL CREEK (KY) 1364 28547 10,918,631 332. Paddy's Run PADDYS RUN 1366 33389 Lawrence 333. Big Sandy BIG SANDY 1353 Marshall 334. Marshall MARSHALL COUNTY Mason 335. H L Spurlock McCracken 336. Mercer Muhlenberg Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 8.96% 2,273 2,306 -1.5% 3,214,910 2,884,627 10.3% 376,003 -4497.07% 2,906 3,922 -35.0% 5,630 14.36% 1,959 2,030 -3.6% 3,866,865 3,195,925 17.4% 9,638,247 11.73% 1,896 2,016 -6.3% 11,518,858 9,563,065 17.0% 38,858 17,078 56.05% 1,164 1,280 -10.0% 66,773 26,683 60.0% 4582 7,177,086 5,807,432 19.08% 1,821 1,790 1.7% 7,884,188 6,489,388 17.7% 55232 27429 92,258 456,287 -394.58% 1,460 1,199 17.9% 126,366 760,903 -502.1% HL SPURLOCK 6041 18011 8,156,403 5,293,166 35.10% 2,595 2,838 -9.3% 6,285,404 3,730,845 40.6% Shawnee SHAWNEE (KY) 1379 41027 10,608,452 9,851,850 7.13% 2,073 2,210 -6.6% 10,233,327 8,916,107 12.9% 337. E W Brown EW BROWN 1355 12964 4,302,393 4,108,359 4.51% 1,944 2,148 -10.5% 4,425,931 3,825,803 13.6% 338. Green River GREEN RIVER 1357 15886 1,169,616 877,658 24.96% 2,187 3,111 -42.3% 1,069,639 564,209 47.3% 339. Paradise PARADISE 1378 33716 14,218,230 14,500,000 -1.98% 3,218 2,094 34.9% 8,837,048 13,900,000 -57.3% Ohio 340. D B Wilson DB WILSON 6823 10380 3,881,863 4,096,916 -5.54% 2,258 2,178 3.5% 3,438,206 Oldham 341. Bluegrass Generation Company, LLC BLUEGRASS 55164 4986 7,440 105 98.59% 1,317 0 100.0% 11,301 Pulaski 342. John S. Cooper JS COOPER 1384 20628 1,931,759 2,290,463 -18.57% 1,846 2,020 -9.4% 2,092,674 2,267,849 -8.4% Trimble 343. Trimble County TRIMBLE COUNTY 6071 46417 3,912,618 4,208,310 -7.56% 1,704 2,218 -30.2% 4,593,523 3,794,555 17.4% Woodford 344. Tyrone TYRONE (KY) 1361 46886 514,928 313,909 39.04% 2,402 2,625 -9.3% 428,764 239,192 44.2% 191,742 -3305.7% 3,761,911 -9.4% 564,929 -4898.9% LOUISIANA Power Plant Name and Location by County County Caddo Calcasieu S. N Plant IDs CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 345. Arsenal Hill Power Plant ARSENAL HILL 1416 2144 73,421 81,487 -10.99% 1,711 2,741 -60.2% 85,832 59,459 30.7% 346. Lieberman Power Plant LIEBERMAN 1417 25265 81,572 12,227 85.01% 1,365 1,059 22.4% 119,516 23,091 80.7% 347. Calcasieu Power, LLC CALCASIEU 55165 6689 42,867 14,730 65.64% 1,280 1,175 8.2% 66,970 25,069 62.6% Page 17 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 LOUISIANA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CO2 Intensity S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Calcasieu 348. R S Cogen RS COGEN 55117 38268 1,675,693 1,846,197 -10.18% 1,117 1,174 -5.1% 3,000,651 3,144,112 -4.8% 349. R S Nelson RS NELSON COGEN 1393 38270 5,102,118 118,088 97.69% 2,084 147 92.9% 4,897,096 1,605,419 67.2% De Soto 350. Dolet Hills Power Station DOLET HILLS 51 11055 4,551,483 5,741,962 -26.16% 2,205 2,383 -8.1% 4,129,010 4,819,325 -16.7% East Baton Rouge 351. Louisiana 1 LOUISIANA ONE 1391 26000 1,955,527 1,874,990 4.12% 1,126 2,155 -91.4% 3,473,598 1,740,114 49.9% Evangeline 352. Evangeline Power Station (Coughlin) EVANGELINE 1396 12937 806,389 450,558 44.13% 902 1,172 -30.0% 1,788,336 768,731 57.0% Iberville 353. Carville Energy Center CARVILLE ENERGY 55404 7275 1,075,467 943,319 12.29% 848 1,236 -45.8% 2,536,839 1,526,567 39.8% 354. Willow Glen WILLOW GLEN 1394 49868 152,932 373,834 -144.44% 1,361 1,900 -39.6% 224,817 393,585 -75.1% Jefferson 355. Ninemile Point NINEMILE POINT 1403 31347 3,762,472 3,184,977 15.35% 1,678 1,303 22.3% 4,484,678 4,888,524 -9.0% Lafayette 356. Doc Bonin BONIN 1443 5238 36,965 335,313 -807.10% 1,190 1,317 -10.6% 62,124 509,298 -719.8% 357. Hargis-Hebert Electric Generating Statio HARGIS-HEBERT 56283 16964 113,163 55,060 51.34% 1,363 1,293 5.1% 166,102 85,159 48.7% 358. T J Labbe Electric Generating Station TJ LABBE 56108 45678 62,972 55,060 12.56% 1,379 1,293 6.2% 91,317 85,159 6.7% Orleans 359. Michoud MICHOUD 1409 28373 1,278,468 1,440,090 -12.64% 1,328 1,378 -3.7% 1,925,033 2,090,522 -8.6% Ouachita 360. Perryville Power Station PERRYVILLE (LA) 55620 34336 1,065,555 810,149 23.97% 1,022 1,064 -4.1% 2,084,476 1,522,567 27.0% 361. Quachita Power, LLC QUACHITA 55467 36321 699,945 153,092 78.13% 882 976 -10.7% 1,587,414 313,559 80.2% 362. Sterlington STERLINGTON 1404 43336 34,319 115,944 -237.84% 1,205 1,479 -22.7% 56,965 156,785 -175.2% 363. Big Cajun 1 BIG CAJUN ONE 1464 4557 22,313 1,647 92.62% 1,476 1,590 -7.7% 30,242 2,072 93.1% 364. Big Cajun 2 BIG CAJUN TWO 6055 4558 13,736,733 14,300,000 -4.10% 2,086 2,359 -13.1% 13,169,327 12,100,000 8.1% 365. D G Hunter DG HUNTER 6558 10729 289 125,175 43213.76% 1,637 1,323 19.2% 353 366. Rodemacher Power Station (6190) RODEMACHER 6190 37887 3,947,442 4,038,579 -2.31% 1,853 2,230 -20.4% 4,261,306 3,622,181 15.0% 367. Taft Cogeneration Facility TAFT PLANT 55089 44274 2,111,296 2,019,946 4.33% 1,389 2,816 -102.7% 3,039,707 1,434,505 52.8% 368. Waterford 1 & 2 WATERFORD 8056 49129 578,209 2,002,969 -246.41% 1,893 2,040 -7.7% 610,759 1,963,592 -221.5% 369. Morgan City Electrical Gen Facility MORGAN CITY 1449 29448 36,864 70,263 -90.60% 2,819 1,822 35.4% 26,158 77,133 -194.9% Pointe Coupee Rapides Saint Charles Saint Mary CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 189,210 53500.6% Page 18 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 LOUISIANA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Saint Mary 370. Teche Power Station TECHE 1400 44925 643,560 565,169 12.18% 1,240 1,282 -3.4% 1,038,111 881,839 15.1% Terrebonne 371. Houma HOUMA 1439 18589 12,169 77,705 -538.57% 1,592 1,752 -10.1% 15,292 88,682 -479.9% MAINE Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Cumberland 372. William F Wyman WYMAN 1507 50363 357,639 653,746 -82.79% 1,758 1,766 -0.5% 406,954 740,389 -81.9% Franklin 373. Androscoggin Energy ANDROSCOGGIN COGEN 55031 1534 349,532 500,698 -43.25% 1,371 1,386 -1.1% 509,822 722,406 -41.7% Hancock 374. Bucksport Clean Energy BUCKSPORT MILL 50243 6119 708,412 1,678,748 -136.97% 1,146 1,785 -55.8% 1,236,828 1,880,791 -52.1% Penobscot 375. Maine Independence Station MAINE INDEPENDENCE 55068 26732 831,252 1,177,395 -41.64% 1,403 924 34.1% 1,184,886 2,548,360 -115.1% MARYLAND Power Plant Name and Location by County County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA Anne Arundel 376. Brandon Shores 377. Cecil Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA BRANDON SHORES 602 5615 8,105,262 7,928,767 2.18% 1,811 1,845 -1.9% 8,952,241 8,594,710 4.0% Herbert A Wagner HA WAGNER 1554 16446 3,340,874 3,673,397 -9.95% 2,112 2,183 -3.4% 3,163,573 3,365,411 -6.4% 378. Rock Springs Generating Facility ROCK SPRINGS 7835 37836 91,083 204,532 -124.56% 1,308 1,221 6.6% 139,312 334,894 -140.4% Charles 379. Mirant Morgantown MORGANTOWN 1573 29454 6,747,408 6,208,733 7.98% 1,827 1,902 -4.1% 7,384,397 6,529,442 11.6% Dorchester 380. Vienna VIENNA 1564 48247 35,539 57,534 -61.89% 2,184 3,414 -56.3% 32,543 33,703 -3.6% Montgomery 381. Mirant Dickerson DICKERSON 1572 10804 3,133,017 3,356,682 -7.14% 1,874 1,960 -4.6% 3,343,103 3,424,448 -2.4% Prince George's 382. Mirant Chalk Point CHALK POINT 1571 7836 5,292,022 6,624,378 -25.18% 1,930 2,194 -13.7% 5,485,278 6,037,703 -10.1% 383. Panda Brandywine PANDA BRANDYWINE 54832 33628 280,860 62,111 77.89% 953 288 69.8% 589,516 431,320 26.8% 384. R. Paul Smith Power Station RP SMITH 1570 38266 754,854 400,652 46.92% 2,164 2,321 -7.2% 697,566 345,262 50.5% Washington Diff. % CO2 Intensity Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Page 19 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 MASSACHUSETTS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CO2 Intensity County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Barnstable 385. Canal Station CANAL 1599 6917 2,082,290 4,876,581 -134.19% 1,697 1,704 Bristol 386. Brayton Point BRAYTON POINT 1619 5672 7,879,629 6,548,171 16.90% 1,748 387. Cleary Flood CLEARY FLOOD 1682 8865 21,410 62,872 -193.66% 388. Dartmouth Power DARTMOUTH 52026 10288 62,020 73,287 389. Dighton DIGHTON 55026 10862 121,426 Essex 390. Salem Harbor SALEM HARBOR 1626 38930 Hampden 391. Berkshire Power BERKSHIRE POWER 55041 392. Masspower MASSPOWER 393. Mount Tom 394. Energy Output (MWh) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % -0.4% 2,454,208 5,723,520 -133.2% 1,848 -5.7% 9,014,123 7,086,237 21.4% 1,466 2,329 -58.9% 29,216 53,996 -84.8% -18.17% 1,046 1,020 2.5% 118,530 143,636 -21.2% 596,147 -390.96% 966 2,197 -127.4% 251,382 542,784 -115.9% 2,078,419 2,270,410 -9.24% 2,040 2,133 -4.5% 2,037,245 2,128,888 -4.5% 4169 448,775 553,015 -23.23% 843 875 -3.8% 1,064,344 1,263,634 -18.7% 10726 27565 195,406 622,873 -218.76% 1,409 1,084 23.1% 277,363 1,148,971 -314.2% MOUNT TOM 1606 29665 1,166,926 963,679 17.42% 1,949 2,003 -2.8% 1,197,338 962,170 19.6% West Springfield WEST SPRINGFIELD 1642 49511 147,329 106,507 27.71% 1,785 3,643 -104.1% 165,115 58,473 64.6% 395. Kendall Square KENDALL SQUARE 1595 21839 771,128 391,752 49.20% 856 1,573 -83.8% 1,802,144 498,118 72.4% 396. Lowell Cogeneration Company LOWELL COGEN 10802 26039 1,333 1,664 -24.85% 1,678 3,206 -91.1% 1,589 1,038 34.7% 397. ANP Bellingham Energy Project BELLINGHAM ANP 55211 3970 1,134,579 1,167,619 -2.91% 1,350 1,739 -28.8% 1,680,725 1,343,148 20.1% 398. Bellingham BELLINGHAM COGEN 10307 3971 263,823 1,103,807 -318.39% 1,368 1,205 11.9% 385,709 1,831,552 -374.9% 399. Fore River Station FORE RIVER 55317 13767 1,445,546 885,277 38.76% 820 1,207 -47.3% 3,527,707 1,466,763 58.4% Suffolk 400. New Boston NEW BOSTON 1589 31036 8,987 107,593 -1097.18% 1,297 2,661 -105.3% 13,863 80,855 -483.2% Worcester 401. Millennium Power Partners MILLENNIUM 55079 28565 813,949 441,693 1,270 817 35.7% 1,281,992 1,081,295 15.7% Middlesex Norfolk 45.73% CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % MICHIGAN Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Bay 402. J C Weadock JC WEADOCK 1720 20211 2,013,672 2,143,112 -6.43% 2,041 2,236 -9.6% 1,973,292 1,916,772 2.9% Eaton 403. Erickson ERICKSON 1832 12653 1,348,921 906,512 32.80% 2,383 2,518 -5.7% 1,132,121 719,966 36.4% Hillsdale 404. Endicott Generating JR ENDICOTT 4259 20624 744,357 564,185 24.21% 3,138 3,529 -12.5% 474,343 319,722 32.6% Huron 405. Harbor Beach HARBOR BEACH 1731 16919 90,876 256,310 -182.04% 2,189 2,281 -4.2% 83,011 224,724 -170.7% Page 20 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 MICHIGAN Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Ingham 406. Eckert Station ECKERT 1831 11784 2,314,404 2,300,262 0.61% 2,601 2,889 -11.1% 1,779,471 1,592,197 10.5% Marquette 407. Presque Isle PRESQUE ISLE 1769 35828 4,210,477 3,950,044 6.19% 2,244 2,425 -8.1% 3,752,974 3,257,422 13.2% 408. Shiras SHIRAS 1843 41412 424,146 420,226 0.92% 2,803 2,794 0.3% 302,594 300,785 0.6% 409. Michigan Power Limited Partnership MICHIGAN POWER COGEN 54915 28368 409,292 557,941 -36.32% 1,132 1,398 -23.5% 723,111 798,359 -10.4% 0.3% 2,576,510 2,476,012 3.9% -3.0% 21,855,670 16,400,000 25.0% Monroe CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Mason Diff. % CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 410. J R Whiting JR WHITING 1723 20626 2,901,091 2,780,308 4.16% 2,252 2,246 411. Monroe MONROE (MI) 1733 29176 20,607,472 15,900,000 22.84% 1,886 1,942 Montcalm 412. Renaissance Power RENAISSANCE POWER 55402 37131 234,849 57,311 75.60% 1,281 139 89.2% 366,678 825,450 -125.1% Muskegon 413. B C Cobb BC COBB 1695 3696 2,278,267 2,318,980 -1.79% 1,955 3,075 -57.3% 2,331,015 1,508,413 35.3% Ottawa 414. James De Young JAMES DEYOUNG 1830 20093 173,653 412,079 -137.30% 2,964 3,014 -1.7% 117,157 273,414 -133.4% 415. J B Sims JB SIMS 1825 20206 507,562 362,802 28.52% 2,064 1,750 15.2% 491,906 414,594 15.7% 416. J H Campbell JH CAMPBELL 1710 20322 8,796,026 9,703,140 -10.31% 2,038 2,105 -3.3% 8,631,708 9,219,711 -6.8% 417. Belle River BELLE RIVER 6034 3950 8,580,419 9,884,783 -15.20% 1,993 2,145 -7.6% 8,608,864 9,218,371 -7.1% 418. Greenwood GREENWOOD (MI) 6035 15923 392,109 407,203 -3.85% 1,545 1,786 -15.6% 507,528 455,987 10.2% 419. St. Clair ST CLAIR 1743 42915 8,102,594 7,769,158 4.12% 1,951 2,138 -9.6% 8,304,905 7,267,745 12.5% 420. Dearborn Industrial Generation DEARBORN INDUSTRIAL 55088 10422 62,420 1,537,397 -2363.00% 232 2,338 -908.2% 538,281 1,314,966 -144.3% 421. Delray DELRAY 1728 10551 20,149 22,681 -12.57% 1,364 1,489 -9.1% 29,535 30,473 -3.2% 422. Mistersky MISTERSKY 1822 28796 310,059 406,311 -31.04% 4,614 2,971 35.6% 134,411 273,496 -103.5% 423. Sumpter Plant SUMPTER TOWNSHIP 7972 43797 49,334 18,283 62.94% 1,466 1,595 -8.8% 67,316 22,932 65.9% Saint Clair Wayne MINNESOTA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Blue Earth 424. Mankato Energy Center MANKATO ENERGY 56104 27086 337,285 329,968 2.17% 902 824 8.6% 747,911 800,731 -7.1% Carver 425. Minnesota River Station MINNESOTA RIVER 7844 28677 7,478 4,504 39.77% 1,351 1,484 -9.9% 11,073 6,069 45.2% Cook 426. Taconite Harbor Energy Center TACONITE HARBOR 10075 44245 1,752,752 1,714,720 2.17% 2,229 2,628 -17.9% 1,572,423 1,304,957 17.0% Page 21 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 MINNESOTA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Dakota 427. Black Dog BLACK DOG 1904 4846 2,116,168 2,107,792 0.40% 1,860 2,317 -24.6% 2,275,679 1,819,236 20.1% Hennepin 428. Riverside (1927) RIVERSIDE (MN) 1927 37668 2,785,184 2,738,161 1.69% 2,376 2,555 -7.5% 2,343,973 2,143,633 8.5% Itasca 429. Boswell Energy Center BOSWELL 1893 5400 8,127,100 7,149,949 12.02% 2,222 2,262 -1.8% 7,313,529 6,322,904 13.5% Martin 430. Fox Lake FOX LAKE 1888 13955 66,707 51,953 22.12% 1,813 2,213 -22.1% 73,598 46,946 36.2% 431. Lakefield Junction Generating LAKEFIELD JUNCTION 7925 24269 278,008 117,914 57.59% 1,413 1,304 7.7% 393,595 180,784 54.1% McLeod 432. Hutchinson - Plant 2 HUTCHINSON (MN) 6358 18969 16,516 12,315 25.43% 1,533 1,593 -3.9% 21,554 15,462 28.3% Mower 433. Northeast Station NORTHEAST (MN) 1961 31750 110,960 221,450 -99.58% 2,719 3,044 -11.9% 81,612 145,515 -78.3% Olmsted 434. Cascade Creek CASCADE CREEK 6058 7305 40,080 3,211 91.99% 1,250 1,290 -3.2% 64,117 4,979 92.2% 435. Silver Lake SILVER LAKE (MN) 2008 41742 256,161 425,524 -66.12% 2,378 2,340 1.6% 215,406 363,663 -68.8% Otter Tail 436. Hoot Lake HOOT LAKE 1943 18351 1,227,768 939,669 23.47% 2,424 2,551 -5.2% 1,013,049 736,728 27.3% Ramsey 437. High Bridge HIGH BRIDGE 1912 17728 1,119,674 2,056,278 -83.65% 2,385 2,868 -20.3% 939,089 1,433,843 -52.7% Rice 438. Faribault Energy Park FARIBAULT ENERGY 56164 13189 153,340 245,234 -59.93% 1,015 1,154 -13.7% 302,161 424,857 -40.6% Saint Louis 439. Laskin Energy Center LASKIN 1891 24653 881,292 935,891 -6.20% 2,728 3,037 -11.3% 646,051 616,300 4.6% Scott 440. Blue Lake Generating Plant BLUE LAKE (MN) 8027 4969 86,947 11,596 86.66% 1,394 6,000 -330.4% 124,743 3,865 96.9% Sherburne 441. Sherburne County SHERBURNE COUNTY 6090 41124 18,254,456 17,900,000 1.94% 2,137 2,308 -8.0% 17,082,578 15,500,000 9.3% Washington 442. Allen S King ALLEN S KING 1915 1007 909,828 3,401,963 -273.91% 2,231 2,217 0.7% 815,489 3,069,375 -276.4% 443. Cottage Grove Cogeneration COTTAGE GROVE 55010 9547 432,323 270,569 37.42% 836 973 -16.3% 1,033,654 556,192 46.2% MISSISSIPPI Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Attala 444. Attala Generating Plant ATTALA ENERGY 55220 2482 920,611 260,746 71.68% 1,145 724 36.7% 1,608,479 719,833 55.2% Benton 445. Magnolia Facility MAGNOLIA ENERGY 55451 26672 1,041,434 291,393 72.02% 894 1,356 -51.7% 2,330,476 429,787 81.6% Page 22 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 MISSISSIPPI Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Coahoma 446. Crossroads Energy Center (CPU) CROSSROADS ENERGY 55395 9746 12,118 Harrison 447. Watson Electric Generating Plant JACK WATSON 2049 19990 4,998,135 5,075,000 Hinds 448. Rex Brown REX BROWN 2053 37247 183,045 Jackson 449. Daniel Electric Generating Plant VJ DANIEL 6073 48556 Jefferson Davis 450. Silver Creek Generating Plant SILVER CREEK 7988 Jones 451. Moselle Generating Plant MOSELLE Lamar 452. R D Morrow Senior Generating Plant Lauderdale 453. Panola Diff. % Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 1,405 1,276 9.2% 17,251 -1.54% 1,956 2,186 -11.8% 5,111,554 4,643,499 9.2% 212,731 -16.22% 2,012 2,150 -6.8% 181,944 197,924 -8.8% 9,375,199 9,094,414 2.99% 1,984 1,799 9.3% 9,451,932 10,100,000 -6.9% 41739 19,393 4,661 75.97% 1,346 2,276 -69.1% 28,814 4,096 85.8% 2070 29547 197,644 362,693 -83.51% 1,321 1,111 15.9% 299,326 653,176 -118.2% MORROW 6061 29498 3,467,003 3,167,595 8.64% 2,383 2,473 -3.8% 2,910,034 2,562,080 12.0% Sweatt Electric Generating Plant SWEATT 2048 44101 15,635 1,338 91.44% 1,129 54 95.2% 27,689 49,735 -79.6% 454. Batesville Generation Facility BATESVILLE 55063 3558 939,015 758,152 19.26% 1,011 1,040 -2.9% 1,858,079 1,458,529 21.5% Smith 455. Sylvarena Generating Plant SYLVARENA 7989 44159 93,803 102,832 -9.63% 1,750 1,840 -5.1% 107,210 111,800 -4.3% Warren 456. Baxter Wilson BAXTER WILSON 2050 3631 1,273,904 760,838 40.28% 1,363 1,690 -24.1% 1,869,873 900,262 51.9% 457. Warren Peaking Power Facility WARREN POWER 55303 49071 2,705 187,920 -6846.63% 1,431 1,283 10.4% 3,780 458. Gerald Andrus GERALD ANDRUS 8054 14991 940,519 1,315 1,788 -36.0% 1,430,537 Washington 201,909 -1566.13% CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA 1,972,529 -109.73% 316,485 -1734.6% 292,957 -7650.2% 2,205,924 -54.2% MISSOURI Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Audrain 459. Audrain Power Plant AUDRAIN COUNTY 55234 2523 49,261 456,287 -826.27% 1,447 1,199 17.1% 68,084 Boone 460. Columbia Energy Center (MO) COLUMBIA ENERGY CTR 55447 9146 9,023 3,074 65.93% 1,439 1,703 -18.4% 12,545 3,610 71.2% Buchanan 461. Lake Road LAKE ROAD (MO) 2098 24257 824,749 926,647 -12.36% 2,169 2,856 -31.7% 760,323 648,878 14.7% Cass 462. South Harper Peaking Facility SOUTH HARPER 56151 42616 135,937 183,268 -34.82% 1,495 1,180 21.0% 181,866 310,556 -70.8% Dunklin 463. St. Francis Power Plant ST FRANCIS (MO) 7604 42929 381,034 397,622 -4.35% 914 1,797 -96.6% 833,913 442,564 46.9% Franklin 464. Labadie LABADIE 2103 24016 18,714,010 16,400,000 12.37% 1,880 1,849 1.7% 19,906,690 17,700,000 11.1% 760,903 -1017.6% Page 23 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 MISSOURI Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CO2 Intensity S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Greene 465. James River JAMES RIVER 2161 20095 1,401,226 2,063,133 -47.24% 2,095 2,310 -10.3% 1,337,831 1,786,012 -33.5% 466. McCartney Generating Station MCCARTNEY 7903 27797 32,117 8,983 72.03% 1,448 1,667 -15.1% 44,367 10,776 75.7% 467. Southwest SOUTHWEST 6195 42697 1,445,745 1,666,341 -15.26% 1,947 2,367 -21.6% 1,485,121 1,407,832 5.2% Henry 468. Montrose MONTROSE 2080 29373 3,757,492 3,886,678 -3.44% 2,266 2,543 -12.3% 3,317,030 3,056,310 7.9% Jackson 469. Blue Valley BLUE VALLEY 2132 4983 189,022 468,666 -147.94% 2,532 2,803 -10.7% 149,301 334,404 -124.0% 470. Hawthorn HAWTHORN 2079 17244 4,464,882 5,028,824 -12.63% 2,039 2,355 -15.5% 4,378,759 4,270,732 2.5% 471. Sibley SIBLEY (MO) 2094 41563 3,296,383 3,252,223 1.34% 2,059 2,253 -9.4% 3,202,001 2,886,915 9.8% 472. Empire District Elec Co Energy Ctr EMPIRE ENERGY CENTER 6223 12463 52,512 23,670 54.92% 1,384 1,155 16.5% 75,887 40,985 46.0% 473. State Line (MO) STATE LINE (MO) 7296 43198 865,454 542,942 37.27% 1,303 939 28.0% 1,328,298 1,156,967 12.9% Jefferson 474. Rush Island RUSH ISLAND 6155 38371 6,908,724 6,827,768 1.17% 1,862 1,797 3.5% 7,420,913 7,599,752 -2.4% Johnson 475. Holden Power Plant HOLDEN 7848 18167 40,134 3,289 91.81% 1,539 1,349 12.4% 52,140 4,877 90.6% New Madrid 476. New Madrid Power Plant NEW MADRID 2167 31075 7,640,456 7,647,257 -0.09% 1,941 1,999 -3.0% 7,871,785 7,651,506 2.8% Nodaway 477. Nodaway Power Plant NODAWAY COUNTY 7754 31501 6,306 2,787 55.80% 1,413 5,341 -277.9% 8,924 1,044 88.3% Osage 478. Chamois Power Plant CHAMOIS 2169 7867 439,905 575,923 -30.92% 2,177 2,493 -14.5% 404,127 462,093 -14.3% Pike 479. Peno Creek Energy Center PENO CREEK 7964 34246 108,791 27,180 75.02% 1,319 3,947 -199.3% 164,957 13,771 91.7% Platte 480. Iatan IATAN 6065 19053 4,427,207 5,649,125 -27.60% 2,004 2,210 -10.3% 4,417,381 5,111,482 -15.7% Randolph 481. Thomas Hill Energy Center THOMAS HILL 2168 45390 7,640,899 8,348,213 -9.26% 2,085 2,208 -5.9% 7,328,490 7,561,798 -3.2% Saint Charles 482. Sioux SIOUX 2107 41859 6,460,311 6,042,791 6.46% 1,833 1,959 -6.9% 7,050,014 6,169,215 12.5% Saint Louis 483. Meramec MERAMEC 2104 28141 6,929,442 6,634,547 4.26% 2,196 2,581 -17.5% 6,309,912 5,140,420 18.5% Scott 484. Sikeston SIKESTON 6768 41692 2,452,275 2,274,270 7.26% 2,251 2,578 -14.5% 2,179,062 1,764,249 19.0% Stoddard 485. Essex Power Plant ESSEX (MO) 7749 12834 6,798 1,547 77.24% 1,339 30 97.8% 10,156 104,818 -932.1% Jasper CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Page 24 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 MONTANA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Big Horn 486. Hardin HARDIN 55749 16938 950,823 725,353 23.71% 2,325 2,860 -23.0% 817,861 507,254 38.0% Richland 487. Lewis & Clark LEWIS & CLARK 6089 25156 501,258 547,079 -9.14% 2,928 3,059 -4.5% 342,354 357,627 -4.5% Yellowstone 488. J E Corette JE CORETTE 2187 20215 1,522,728 1,497,798 1.64% 2,423 2,685 -10.8% 1,257,002 1,115,865 11.2% NEBRASKA Power Plant Name and Location by County County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA Adams 489. Gerald Whelan Energy Center WHELAN Dodge 490. Lon D Wright Power Plant Douglas 491. Gage Hall Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) CARMA 60 49658 640,571 706,547 -10.30% 2,385 2,529 -6.0% 537,191 558,824 -4.0% LD WRIGHT 2240 24788 479,379 645,852 -34.73% 2,137 3,405 -59.3% 448,579 379,389 15.4% North Omaha Station NORTH OMAHA 2291 31708 3,842,084 4,032,568 -4.96% 2,117 2,181 -3.0% 3,629,878 3,698,309 -1.9% 492. Beatrice BEATRICE 8000 3726 229,971 260,928 -13.46% 1,117 911 18.4% 411,855 572,562 -39.0% 493. C W Burdick BURDICK 2241 6276 12,783 2,561 79.97% 1,634 1,591 2.6% 15,642 3,219 79.4% 494. Platte PLATTE 59 35002 816,907 846,915 -3.67% 2,434 2,860 -17.5% 671,259 592,170 11.8% 495. Rokeby ROKEBY 6373 37942 21,490 15,515 27.81% 1,470 1,131 23.0% 29,235 27,423 6.2% 496. Salt Valley Generating Station SALT VALLEY 7887 39004 113,831 74,016 34.98% 1,064 1,089 -2.3% 214,052 135,990 36.5% 497. Sheldon SHELDON (NE) 2277 41073 1,881,365 1,847,567 1.80% 2,240 2,637 -17.7% 1,679,634 1,401,167 16.6% Lincoln 498. Gerald Gentleman Station GERALD GENTLEMAN 6077 14992 10,684,738 11,100,000 -3.89% 2,254 2,356 -4.5% 9,481,270 9,386,333 1.0% Otoe 499. Nebraska City Station NEBRASKA CITY 6096 30801 4,459,195 4,552,760 -2.10% 1,985 2,029 -2.2% 4,492,017 4,487,310 0.1% Lancaster CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity ORIS Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % NEVADA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Clark 500. Apex Generating Station APEX (TX) 55514 1821 793,212 928,227 -17.02% 1,312 1,060 19.2% 1,208,842 1,751,469 -44.9% 501. Chuck Lenzie Generating Station CHUCK LENZIE 55322 8609 2,946,053 1,141,763 61.24% 844 800 5.3% 6,977,941 2,854,873 59.1% 502. El Dorado Energy EL DORADO ENERGY 55077 12096 1,096,069 1,295,577 -18.20% 1,052 1,106 -5.1% 2,083,236 2,341,828 -12.4% Page 25 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 NEVADA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Clark 503. Harry Allen HARRY ALLEN 7082 17035 47,937 29,577 38.30% 1,399 1,679 -20.0% 68,549 35,242 48.6% 504. Reid Gardner REID GARDNER 2324 37083 4,718,754 5,258,956 -11.45% 2,301 2,573 -11.8% 4,101,188 4,087,523 0.3% 505. Sunrise SUNRISE (NV) 2326 43889 43,358 26,128 39.74% 1,190 4,301 -261.4% 72,873 12,150 83.3% Humboldt 506. North Valmy NORTH VALMY 8224 31736 3,695,051 4,386,770 -18.72% 2,046 2,144 -4.8% 3,612,056 4,091,662 -13.3% Lyon 507. Fort Churchill FORT CHURCHILL 2330 13827 578,658 681,077 -17.70% 1,183 1,510 -27.6% 977,965 902,316 7.7% NEW HAMPSHIRE Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Merrimack 508. Merrimack MERRIMACK 2364 28204 3,726,216 3,371,042 Rockingham 509. Granite Ridge Energy GRANITE RIDGE 55170 15783 1,191,488 1,217,049 -2.15% 510. Newington NEWINGTON 8002 31132 343,496 1,995,502 -480.94% 511. Newington Power Facility NEWINGTON ENERGY 55661 31134 1,284,042 1,179,174 8.17% 512. Schiller SCHILLER 2367 40200 1,301,733 593,260 54.43% 9.53% CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA 2,151 Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 2,175 -1.1% 3,464,593 3,100,511 10.5% 1,309 1,064 18.7% 1,820,720 2,287,490 -25.6% 2,025 2,033 -0.4% 339,299 1,963,151 -478.6% 862 1,063 -23.4% 2,980,885 2,217,681 25.6% 2,480 1,195 51.8% 1,049,788 993,017 5.4% NEW JERSEY Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Bergen 513. Bergen BERGEN 2398 4127 2,380,464 2,159,245 9.29% 1,444 1,048 27.4% 3,297,183 4,119,779 -24.9% Burlington 514. Burlington Generating Station BURLINGTON (NJ) 2399 6341 137,877 92,875 32.64% 1,200 1,793 -49.4% 229,703 103,571 54.9% Cape May 515. B L England BL ENGLAND 2378 4833 1,681,692 1,709,901 -1.68% 2,115 2,602 -23.0% 1,590,489 1,314,430 17.4% Cumberland 516. Sherman Avenue SHERMAN AVENUE 7288 41129 936 1,180 -25.98% 37 55 -48.6% 50,563 42,865 15.2% Essex 517. Newark Bay Cogen NEWARK BAY 50385 31103 39,636 180,252 -354.77% 1,416 1,112 21.5% 55,971 324,334 -479.5% Hudson 518. Hudson Generating Station HUDSON 2403 18799 2,618,709 3,507,901 -33.96% 2,265 1,794 20.8% 2,312,405 3,910,874 -69.1% 519. Kearny Generating Station KEARNY (NJ) 2404 21729 110,746 98,108 11.41% 1,062 1,694 -59.4% 208,498 115,860 44.4% 520. Gilbert Generating Station GILBERT 2393 15144 33,736 64,454 -91.05% 1,709 1,823 -6.7% 39,488 70,731 -79.1% Hunterdon Diff. % CO2 Intensity Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Page 26 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 NEW JERSEY Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Mercer 521. Mercer Generating Station MERCER 2408 28157 3,282,313 2,358,153 28.16% 2,044 1,937 5.2% 3,211,759 2,434,874 24.2% Middlesex 522. AES Red Oak AES RED OAK 55239 340 1,097,069 745,195 32.07% 1,289 1,034 19.8% 1,702,490 1,441,063 15.4% 523. North Jersey Energy Associates SAYREVILLE COGEN 10308 40123 401,171 363,997 9.27% 1,333 1,021 23.4% 602,123 712,905 -18.4% 524. Sewaren Generating Station SEWAREN 2411 40839 122,919 301,080 -144.94% 1,691 1,952 -15.4% 145,352 308,416 -112.2% Ocean 525. Ocean Peaking Power, LP OCEAN PEAKING 55938 32217 91,420 180,815 -97.79% 1,245 1,442 -15.9% 146,894 250,772 -70.7% Salem 526. Deepwater DEEPWATER (NJ) 2384 10460 521,754 505,225 3.17% 1,891 2,593 -37.1% 551,935 389,757 29.4% 527. Pedricktown Cogeneration Plant PEDRICKTOWN 10099 34098 80,554 102,222 -26.90% 1,111 1,089 1.9% 145,071 187,723 -29.4% 528. Linden Generating Station LINDEN 2406 25375 949,824 1,415,226 -49.00% 1,371 2,831 -106.5% 1,385,326 999,768 27.8% 529. Linden Cogeneration Facility LINDEN COGEN 50006 25376 746,458 690,776 7.46% 238 275 -15.6% 6,277,861 5,026,642 19.9% Union Diff. % CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % NEW MEXICO Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Bernalillo 530. Person Generating Project PERSON PEAKING 55039 34339 5,301 4,632 12.61% 1,122 75 93.3% 9,452 531. Reeves Generating Station REEVES 2450 37042 51,481 78,231 -51.96% 1,418 1,517 -7.0% 72,598 103,107 -42.0% 532. Afton Generating Station AFTON (NM) 55210 367 46,604 20,277 56.49% 1,185 3,296 -178.2% 78,661 12,304 84.4% 533. Rio Grande RIO GRANDE 2444 37533 445,862 460,137 -3.20% 1,270 1,380 -8.6% 702,167 667,051 5.0% Hidalgo CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Dona Ana CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 122,721 -1198.4% 534. Lordsburg Generating Station LORDSBURG PNM 7967 25864 55,804 47,779 14.38% 1,232 1,424 -15.6% 90,621 67,128 25.9% 535. Pyramid Generating Station PYRAMID 7975 36245 51,268 15,727 69.32% 1,215 1,263 -4.0% 84,381 24,898 70.5% 536. Cunningham CUNNINGHAM 2454 9879 958,990 754,383 21.34% 1,314 1,270 3.4% 1,459,101 1,187,881 18.6% 537. Maddox MADDOX 2446 26546 295,937 338,480 -14.38% 1,185 1,390 -17.3% 499,374 487,102 2.5% Luna 538. Luna Energy Facility LUNA ENERGY 55343 26259 1,175,375 545,069 53.63% 865 819 5.4% 2,718,169 1,331,852 51.0% McKinley 539. Prewitt Escalante Generating Station ESCALANTE 87 12725 1,967,641 1,923,513 2.24% 2,008 2,089 -4.0% 1,959,707 1,841,611 6.0% San Juan 540. Bluffview Power Plant BLUFFVIEW 55977 4994 199,131 78,371 60.64% 963 1,143 -18.7% 413,524 137,140 66.8% Lea Page 27 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 NEW MEXICO Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA San Juan 541. Four Corners Steam Elec Station FOUR CORNERS 2442 13942 15,084,774 14,800,000 1.89% 1,922 2,000 542. Milagro Cogeneration and Gas Plant MILAGRO COGEN 54814 28504 444,025 503,042 -13.29% 966 4,868 543. San Juan SAN JUAN (NM) 2451 39337 11,491,631 13,000,000 -13.13% 1,865 2,162 Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % -4.1% 15,700,444 14,800,000 -404.1% 919,450 5.7% 206,652 77.5% -15.9% 12,326,477 12,000,000 2.6% NEW YORK Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Albany 544. Bethlehem Energy Center (Albany) BETHLEHEM ENERGY 2539 4283 675,520 821,074 -21.55% 606 882 -45.6% 2,230,646 1,862,423 16.5% Allegany 545. Allegany Station No. 133 ALLEGANY STATION 10619 999 38,380 45,654 -18.95% 943 1,005 -6.6% 81,437 90,889 -11.6% Bronx 546. Harlem River Yard HARLEM RIVER YARDS 7914 16981 60,512 108,374 -79.10% 1,275 1,299 -1.8% 94,890 166,872 -75.9% 547. Hell Gate HELL GATE NYPA 7913 17440 66,668 106,220 -59.33% 1,251 1,332 -6.5% 106,617 159,481 -49.6% Cattaraugus 548. Indeck-Olean Energy Center INDECK OLEAN 54076 19351 123,605 112,317 9.13% 995 1,289 -29.5% 248,418 174,338 29.8% Chautauqua 549. Dunkirk DUNKIRK 2554 11516 3,664,079 3,786,316 -3.34% 2,010 1,917 4.6% 3,645,932 3,950,948 -8.4% Erie 550. Huntley Power HUNTLEY 2549 18922 2,897,734 3,658,604 -26.26% 2,103 3,040 -44.6% 2,756,314 2,406,830 12.7% 551. Indeck-Yerkes Energy Center INDECK-YERKES 50451 19353 12,360 22,802 -84.49% 1,105 1,289 -16.6% 22,362 35,368 -58.2% Genesee 552. Batavia Energy BATAVIA ALLIANCE 54593 3554 9,715 16,062 -65.34% 1,478 1,308 11.5% 13,144 24,569 -86.9% Greene 553. Athens Generating Company ATHENS GENERATING 55405 2437 2,080,145 1,220,035 41.35% 828 1,359 -64.3% 5,027,360 1,794,891 64.3% Jefferson 554. Carthage Energy CARTHAGE ENERGY 10620 7265 13,299 3,481 73.83% 1,020 1,437 -40.9% 26,081 4,844 81.4% Kings 555. Brooklyn Navy Yard Cogeneration BROOKLYN NAVY YARD 54914 5935 1,128,320 2,253,103 -99.69% 1,375 2,568 -86.7% 1,641,131 1,754,882 -6.9% Nassau 556. Bethpage Energy Center BETHPAGE ENERGY 50292 4285 240,941 79,909 66.83% 1,022 555 45.7% 471,723 288,002 38.9% 557. E F Barrett EF BARRETT 2511 11882 923,028 886,997 3.90% 1,225 1,431 -16.8% 1,506,878 1,239,925 17.7% 558. Freeport Power Plant No. 2 FREEPORT TWO 2679 14096 35,050 58,297 -66.33% 1,244 1,421 -14.2% 56,343 82,079 -45.7% 559. Glenwood GLENWOOD (NY) 2514 15333 149,392 286,766 -91.95% 1,302 1,610 -23.6% 229,422 356,196 -55.3% Page 28 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 NEW YORK Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Nassau 560. Glenwood Landing Energy Center GLENWOOD LANDING 7869 15334 75,591 24,921 67.03% 1,108 6,000 -441.5% 136,441 8,307 93.9% New York 561. East River EAST RIVER 2493 11692 2,165,403 4,857,353 -124.32% 1,870 2,156 -15.3% 2,315,546 4,505,179 -94.6% Niagara 562. AES Somerset (Kintigh ) AES SOMERSET 6082 343 5,289,504 5,395,250 -2.00% 1,788 1,824 -2.0% 5,917,056 5,915,186 0.0% 563. Niagara Generation, LLC NIAGARA FALLS 50202 31183 254,677 443,669 -74.21% 2,648 3,268 -23.4% 192,323 271,528 -41.2% Oneida 564. Sterling Power Plant STERLING COGEN 50744 43335 3,521 2,957 16.00% 1,423 953 33.0% 4,950 6,205 -25.4% Onondaga 565. Carr Street Generating Station CARR STREET 50978 7216 27,831 1,574 94.35% 1,295 6,000 -363.2% 42,968 525 98.8% 566. Onondaga Cogeneration ONONDAGA COGEN 50855 32699 4,157 18,478 -344.48% 1,312 1,257 4.2% 6,338 29,401 -363.9% 567. Project Orange Facility PROJECT ORANGE 54425 35911 152,146 244,940 -60.99% 1,212 3,707 -205.7% 250,964 132,147 47.3% 568. WPS Syracuse Generation, LLC WPS SYRACUSE 10621 50269 33,890 26,318 22.34% 938 1,350 -43.9% 72,262 39,000 46.0% 569. Dynegy Danskammer DANSKAMMER POINT 2480 10213 2,746,225 2,099,441 23.55% 2,032 1,949 4.1% 2,702,823 2,154,220 20.3% 570. Dynegy Roseton ROSETON 8006 38079 898,675 3,732,765 -315.36% 1,585 1,875 -18.3% 1,134,052 3,980,704 -251.0% Oswego CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Orange CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 571. Indeck-Oswego Energy Center INDECK OSWEGO 50450 19352 13,535 5,190 61.65% 1,045 950 9.1% 25,907 10,927 57.8% 572. Independence INDEPENDENCE STATION 54547 19359 1,071,993 754,644 29.60% 906 1,138 -25.6% 2,366,415 1,325,839 44.0% 573. Astoria Energy ASTORIA ENERGY 55375 2394 1,398,139 545,069 61.01% 746 904 -21.2% 3,747,570 1,205,510 67.8% 574. Bayswater Peaking Facility BAYSWATER PEAKER 55699 3680 57,398 116,534 -103.03% 1,380 1,568 -13.6% 83,175 148,679 -78.8% 575. Charles Poletti CHARLES POLETTI 2491 8004 1,301,207 4,297,005 -230.23% 1,358 1,721 -26.7% 1,915,842 4,993,101 -160.6% 576. Far Rockaway FAR ROCKAWAY 2513 13172 166,158 139,056 16.31% 1,254 1,267 -1.1% 265,093 219,464 17.2% 577. Ravenswood Generating Station RAVENSWOOD 2500 36869 2,911,690 4,473,558 -53.64% 1,257 1,987 -58.1% 4,632,932 4,503,506 2.8% 578. Vernon Boulevard VERNON BOULEVARD 7909 48119 69,979 71,146 -1.67% 1,176 1,215 -3.3% 119,045 117,155 1.6% Rensselaer 579. Rensselaer Cogen RENSSELAER COGEN 54034 37164 9,327 2,126 77.21% 1,248 1,425 -14.2% 14,953 2,984 80.0% Richmond 580. Arthur Kill ARTHUR KILL 2490 2162 975,883 592,028 39.33% 1,272 1,400 -10.1% 1,533,984 845,618 44.9% 581. Pouch Terminal POUCH TERMINAL 8053 35640 89,585 56,849 36.54% 1,152 1,246 -8.2% 155,586 91,228 41.4% 582. Bowline Generating Station BOWLINE POINT 2625 5480 501,132 1,090,259 -117.56% 1,538 1,780 -15.7% 651,828 1,225,253 -88.0% Queens Rockland Page 29 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 NEW YORK Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Saint Lawrence 583. Massena Energy Facility MASSENA ENERGY 54592 27558 7,155 1,747 75.59% 1,704 1,329 22.0% 8,398 2,629 68.7% Saratoga 584. Indeck-Corinth Energy Center CORINTH 50458 9383 248,973 466,036 -87.18% 948 1,108 -16.9% 525,234 841,007 -60.1% Suffolk 585. Northport NORTHPORT 2516 31766 4,036,116 5,075,846 -25.76% 1,390 1,560 -12.2% 5,808,752 6,508,679 -12.0% 586. Pinelawn Power PINELAWN POWER 56188 34753 168,116 70,171 58.26% 1,172 937 20.0% 286,883 149,713 47.8% 587. Port Jefferson Energy Center PORT JEFFERSON 2517 35467 958,900 1,560,828 -62.77% 1,318 1,574 -19.4% 1,455,123 1,983,816 -36.3% 588. PPL Shoreham Energy PPL SHOREHAM 55787 35723 33,897 28,769 15.13% 1,570 1,682 -7.1% 43,174 34,203 20.8% 589. Richard M Flynn (Holtsville) RM FLYNN 7314 37734 407,115 569,547 -39.90% 1,362 973 28.6% 597,601 1,170,828 -95.9% Tompkins 590. AES Cayuga, LLC AES CAYUGA 2535 324 2,370,486 2,277,623 3.92% 1,912 2,198 -15.0% 2,480,089 2,072,464 16.4% Wyoming 591. Indeck-Silver Springs Energy Center SILVER SPRINGS (NY) 50449 41745 7,654 52,783 -589.64% 1,142 1,166 -2.0% 13,402 90,572 -575.8% Yates 592. AES Greenidge AES GREENIDGE 2527 327 780,467 925,520 -18.59% 2,188 2,107 3.7% 713,360 878,555 -23.2% NORTH CAROLINA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Buncombe 593. Asheville ASHEVILLE 2706 2281 2,583,740 2,345,949 9.20% 1,884 2,411 Catawba 594. Marshall MARSHALL (NC) 2727 27428 14,525,077 12,600,000 13.25% 1,859 1,628 Chatham 595. Cape Fear CAPE FEAR 2708 7043 1,977,162 1,780,417 9.95% 1,758 2,197 -24.9% 2,248,940 1,620,850 27.9% Cleveland 596. Cliffside CLIFFSIDE 2721 8887 4,199,413 3,591,433 14.48% 1,937 2,085 -7.6% 4,335,755 3,445,542 20.5% Craven 597. Craven County Wood Energy CRAVEN COUNTY BIOMASS 10525 9664 526,054 26,558 94.95% 2,523 169 93.3% 416,947 314,837 24.5% Gaston 598. G G Allen ALLEN (NC) 2718 1006 6,949,546 5,864,203 15.62% 1,881 1,904 -1.2% 7,389,773 6,160,272 16.6% 599. Riverbend RIVERBEND (NC) 2732 37657 2,390,418 1,676,043 29.88% 1,985 2,156 -8.6% 2,408,092 1,555,075 35.4% Halifax 600. Rosemary Power Station ROSEMARY 50555 38065 55,379 88,471 -59.76% 1,574 1,603 -1.8% 70,355 110,389 -56.9% New Hanover 601. L V Sutton LV SUTTON 2713 26372 3,267,479 3,090,811 5.41% 2,035 2,392 -17.6% 3,211,993 2,584,412 19.5% Person 602. Roxboro ROXBORO 2712 38220 14,399,402 15,100,000 -4.87% 3,901 2,052 47.4% 7,382,730 14,700,000 -99.1% -28.0% CAMD-EPA CARMA 2,742,840 Diff. % 1,945,766 29.1% 12.4% 15,627,614 15,500,000 0.8% Page 30 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 NORTH CAROLINA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA Richmond 603. Richmond County Plant RICHMOND COUNTY 7805 37363 1,279,081 949,758 25.75% 1,373 1,166 15.1% 1,863,283 1,629,690 12.5% Robeson 604. W H Weatherspoon WEATHERSPOON 2716 49228 1,200,517 666,267 44.50% 2,357 2,470 -4.8% 1,018,792 539,431 47.1% Rockingham 605. Dan River DAN RIVER 2723 10187 1,230,600 826,775 32.82% 2,157 2,359 -9.4% 1,140,945 700,934 38.6% 606. Rockingham County Combustion Turbine ROCKINGHAM COUNTY 55116 37849 205,392 62,660 69.49% 1,275 1,290 -1.2% 322,298 97,157 69.9% 607. Buck BUCK (NC) 2720 6104 1,803,199 1,626,487 9.80% 1,950 2,130 -9.2% 1,849,007 1,527,427 17.4% 608. Plant Rowan County ROWAN COUNTY 7826 38210 457,206 176,125 61.48% 1,316 1,125 14.5% 694,597 313,069 54.9% 609. H F Lee Steam Electric Plant LEE (NC) 2709 24889 2,501,476 2,060,736 17.62% 1,849 2,427 -31.2% 2,705,146 1,698,066 37.2% Wayne Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Rowan CARMA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % NORTH DAKOTA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % McLean 610. Coal Creek COAL CREEK 6030 8953 10,141,763 10,600,000 -4.52% 2,190 2,747 -25.5% 9,262,539 7,689,956 17.0% Mercer 611. Antelope Valley ANTELOPE VALLEY 6469 1705 7,923,701 8,109,317 -2.34% 2,278 2,376 -4.3% 6,957,780 6,825,797 1.9% 612. Coyote COYOTE 8222 9621 3,847,819 4,111,459 -6.85% 2,404 2,550 -6.1% 3,200,659 3,224,749 -0.8% 613. Leland Olds LELAND OLDS 2817 24967 5,204,974 5,690,539 -9.33% 2,184 2,572 -17.8% 4,767,132 4,425,640 7.2% Morton 614. R M Heskett HESKETT 2790 17639 682,083 840,850 -23.28% 2,517 2,771 -10.1% 541,941 606,877 -12.0% Oliver 615. Milton R Young MR YOUNG 2823 29726 5,315,208 6,160,431 -15.90% 2,160 2,572 -19.1% 4,921,894 4,789,516 2.7% OHIO Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Adams 616. Killen Station KILLEN 6031 22164 4,414,559 4,258,296 3.54% 1,972 2,003 -1.6% 4,477,454 4,250,950 5.1% Ashtabula 617. Ashtabula ASHTABULA 2835 2312 1,686,152 1,331,655 21.02% 2,161 4,365 -102.0% 1,560,385 610,108 60.9% Butler 618. Madison Generating Station MADISON GENERATING 55110 26577 156,708 456,287 -191.17% 1,632 1,199 26.5% 192,027 760,903 -296.2% 619. Woodsdale WOODSDALE 7158 50214 114,701 24,700 78.47% 3,377 2,336 30.8% 67,937 21,144 68.9% Page 31 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 OHIO Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Clermont 620. Walter C Beckjord Generating Station WC BECKJORD 2830 49219 6,448,923 6,330,286 1.84% 1,937 2,218 -14.5% 6,658,883 5,709,021 14.3% 621. W H Zimmer Generating Station ZIMMER 6019 51236 7,329,384 8,597,428 -17.30% 1,630 1,816 -11.4% 8,992,726 9,466,519 -5.3% Coshocton 622. Conesville CONESVILLE 2840 9248 11,104,478 9,059,955 18.41% 1,990 2,327 -16.9% 11,160,797 7,786,718 30.2% Cuyahoga 623. Lake Shore LAKE SHORE 2838 24259 1,422,268 895,106 37.06% 2,189 2,434 -11.2% 1,299,189 735,471 43.4% Darke 624. Greenville Electric Gen Station GREENVILLE SUBSTATION 55228 15921 34,169 40,513 -18.57% 1,286 1,320 -2.6% 53,124 61,364 -15.5% Defiance 625. Richland Peaking Station RICHLAND SUBSTATION 2880 37357 39,623 36,907 6.85% 1,779 1,867 -4.9% 44,551 39,544 11.2% Gallia 626. Gen J M Gavin GAVIN 8102 14787 19,141,670 18,700,000 2.31% 1,883 2,030 -7.8% 20,328,099 18,400,000 9.5% 627. Kyger Creek KYGER CREEK 2876 23575 6,857,137 7,326,299 -6.84% 1,861 1,987 -6.8% 7,368,607 7,374,339 -0.1% Hamilton 628. Miami Fort Generating Station MIAMI FORT 2832 28338 7,151,403 7,546,313 -5.52% 1,933 2,123 -9.8% 7,399,487 7,109,311 3.9% Henry 629. AMP-Ohio Gas Turbines Napoleon NAPOLEON (OH) 55264 30544 334 31,686 -9397.63% 1,627 1,469 9.8% 410 Jefferson 630. Cardinal CARDINAL 2828 7121 10,598,682 10,100,000 4.71% 1,891 1,885 0.3% 11,210,962 10,700,000 4.6% 631. W H Sammis WH SAMMIS 2866 49619 15,677,291 13,800,000 11.97% 1,924 2,062 -7.2% 16,293,583 13,400,000 17.8% Lake 632. Eastlake EASTLAKE 2837 11720 7,858,316 6,355,190 19.13% 1,840 2,048 -11.3% 8,539,353 6,207,319 27.3% Lawrence 633. Hanging Rock Energy Facility HANGING ROCK 55736 16841 777,433 516,946 33.51% 922 1,932 -109.6% 1,686,291 535,005 68.3% Lorain 634. Avon Lake Power Plant AVON LAKE 2836 2655 2,979,805 2,574,369 13.61% 2,174 2,309 -6.2% 2,741,842 2,230,015 18.7% 635. West Lorain WEST LORAIN 2869 49477 45,941 61,123 -33.05% 1,403 1,215 13.4% 65,481 100,635 -53.7% Lucas 636. Bay Shore BAY SHORE 2878 3637 4,753,101 3,979,262 16.28% 2,789 2,198 21.2% 3,409,020 3,620,736 -6.2% Montgomery 637. Frank M Tait Station FM TAIT 2847 13669 15,796 4,735 70.03% 1,685 2,740 -62.6% 18,746 3,456 81.6% 638. O H Hutchings HUTCHINGS 2848 18967 749,487 596,514 20.41% 2,168 2,922 -34.8% 691,437 408,224 41.0% 639. Tait Electric Generating Station TAIT 55248 44350 51,593 2,101 95.93% 1,548 5,616 -262.7% 66,643 748 98.9% Trumbull 640. Niles NILES (OH) 2861 31327 1,288,903 1,080,136 16.20% 2,018 2,176 -7.8% 1,277,229 992,653 22.3% Van Wert 641. Robert P Mone ROBERT P MONE 7872 37760 106,302 46,789 55.98% 1,253 1,192 4.9% 169,676 78,499 53.7% Vinton 642. Rolling Hills Generating LLC ROLLING HILLS 55401 37954 23,250 2,997 87.11% 1,283 1,628 -27.0% 36,254 3,681 89.8% 43,151 10424.5% Page 32 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 OHIO Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Washington 643. Muskingum River MUSKINGUM RIVER 2872 30079 8,050,570 7,298,625 9.34% 1,808 1,867 -3.3% 8,904,668 7,817,619 12.2% 644. Waterford Plant WATERFORD ENERGY 55503 49134 268,868 37,495 86.05% 1,301 1,241 4.6% 413,383 60,440 85.4% 645. Troy Energy, LLC TROY ENERGY 55348 46497 58,083 10,439 82.03% 1,324 1,861 -40.5% 87,714 11,221 87.2% Wood Diff. % CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % OKLAHOMA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA Caddo 646. Anadarko ANADARKO (OK) 3006 1440 9,864 647. Southwestern SOUTHWESTERN 2964 42702 Choctaw 648. Hugo HUGO 6772 Comanche 649. Comanche (8059) COMANCHE (OK) Kay 650. Ponca Mayes 651. CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 347,807 -3425.88% 1,164 915 21.4% 16,948 760,289 -4386.0% 454,242 432,962 4.68% 1,188 1,478 -24.4% 764,911 585,947 23.4% 18816 3,544,815 3,547,033 -0.06% 2,245 2,229 0.7% 3,158,227 3,182,224 -0.8% 8059 9162 591,756 597,920 -1.04% 1,803 1,177 34.7% 656,335 1,015,808 -54.8% PONCA 762 35250 45,440 129 99.72% 1,033 383 62.9% 87,953 673 99.2% Chouteau Power Plant CHOUTEAU 7757 8580 799,269 459,043 42.57% 860 925 -7.6% 1,858,614 992,000 46.6% 652. Grand River Dam Authority GRDA 165 15832 8,381,481 7,925,736 5.44% 2,235 2,425 -8.5% 7,499,358 6,535,968 12.8% McClain 653. McClain Energy Facility MCCLAIN 55457 27798 1,360,007 1,057,997 22.21% 1,272 819 35.6% 2,138,790 2,583,703 -20.8% Muskogee 654. Muskogee MUSKOGEE 2952 30080 9,191,321 10,600,000 -15.33% 1,962 2,259 -15.1% 9,367,367 9,346,346 0.2% Noble 655. Sooner SOONER 6095 42504 6,944,457 7,308,236 -5.24% 2,015 2,235 -10.9% 6,891,815 6,540,748 5.1% Oklahoma 656. Horseshoe Lake HORSESHOE LAKE 2951 18485 792,177 677,841 14.43% 1,299 1,160 10.7% 1,219,585 1,168,373 4.2% 657. Redbud Power Plant REDBUD 55463 37001 1,332,897 273,826 79.46% 888 1,288 -45.0% 3,000,413 425,109 85.8% Pittsburg 658. Tenaska Kiamichi Generating Station TENASKA KIAMICHI 55501 45078 2,381,684 1,686,083 29.21% 830 1,032 -24.4% 5,738,326 3,266,713 43.1% Seminole 659. Seminole (2956) SEMINOLE (OK) 2956 40603 2,483,797 2,371,105 4.54% 1,327 1,355 -2.2% 3,744,364 3,499,208 6.5% Tulsa 660. Green Country Energy, LLC GREEN COUNTRY ENERGY 55146 15862 1,313,024 1,490,899 -13.55% 840 1,096 -30.5% 3,127,094 2,720,149 13.0% 661. Riverside (4940) RIVERSIDE (OK) 4940 37670 1,344,122 879,020 34.60% 1,207 1,386 -14.8% 2,226,890 1,268,748 43.0% 662. Tulsa TULSA 2965 46677 305,196 86,265 71.73% 1,413 624 55.8% 432,115 276,554 36.0% Page 33 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 OKLAHOMA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Woodward 663. Mooreland MOORELAND 3008 29395 Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA 151,147 CARMA 37,968 Diff. % 74.88% CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA 1,187 1,279 Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % -7.8% CAMD-EPA CARMA 254,659 Diff. % 59,359 76.7% OREGON Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Columbia 664. Port Westward PORT WESTWARD 56227 35500 747,238 410,208 45.10% 857 890 -3.8% 1,744,433 922,178 47.1% Morrow 665. Boardman BOARDMAN (OR) 6106 5022 4,813,294 4,028,869 16.30% 2,084 2,312 -10.9% 4,618,225 3,485,590 24.5% PENNSYLVANIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Adams 666. Hunterstown Combined Cycle HUNTERSTOWN 55976 18911 530,540 145,646 72.55% 1,305 560 57.1% 813,357 519,904 36.1% Allegheny 667. Brunot Island Power Station BRUNOT ISLAND 3096 6011 23,116 6,849 70.37% 5,070 3,675 27.5% 9,118 3,728 59.1% 668. Cheswick CHESWICK 8226 8240 2,903,425 3,161,209 -8.88% 1,882 2,169 -15.3% 3,085,749 2,914,312 5.6% Armstrong 669. Armstrong Power Station ARMSTRONG 3178 2075 2,200,731 2,099,231 4.61% 1,936 2,017 -4.2% 2,273,218 2,081,295 8.4% Beaver 670. Bruce Mansfield BRUCE MANSFIELD 6094 5973 17,387,361 17,400,000 -0.07% 1,795 1,900 -5.9% 19,370,632 18,300,000 5.5% Berks 671. Ontelaunee Energy Center ONTELAUNEE 55193 32719 498,388 1,139,831 -128.70% 818 2,247 -174.6% 1,218,024 1,014,610 16.7% 672. Titus TITUS 3115 45672 1,481,640 1,208,617 18.43% 2,001 2,218 -10.8% 1,480,981 1,090,000 26.4% Chester 673. Cromby CROMBY 3159 9731 1,062,055 1,228,543 -15.68% 2,296 3,017 -31.4% 925,240 814,408 12.0% Clearfield 674. Shawville SHAWVILLE 3131 41029 3,577,585 3,106,915 13.16% 1,924 2,036 -5.8% 3,718,112 3,051,380 17.9% Delaware 675. Eddystone Generating Station EDDYSTONE 3161 11809 3,855,827 4,127,794 -7.05% 2,257 2,717 -20.4% 3,416,656 3,038,057 11.1% 676. Liberty Electric Power Plant LIBERTY ELECTRIC 55231 25223 750,646 603,931 19.55% 1,281 930 27.4% 1,171,925 1,298,711 -10.8% Erie 677. North East Cogeneration Plant NORTH EAST COGEN 54571 31673 14,124 9,165 35.11% 1,189 1,158 2.6% 23,749 15,829 33.3% Fayette 678. Fayette Energy Facility FAYETTE COUNTY 55516 13238 303,637 203,082 33.12% 927 1,480 -59.7% 655,396 274,455 58.1% Franklin 679. Chambersburg Units 12 and 13 CHAMBERSBURG 55654 7853 76,215 19,741 74.10% 1,195 1,522 -27.3% 127,504 25,934 79.7% Page 34 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 PENNSYLVANIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Indiana 680. Homer City HOMER CITY 3122 18278 13,576,987 12,800,000 5.72% 1,870 1,954 Lawrence 681. New Castle NEW CASTLE 3138 31040 1,570,507 1,668,884 -6.26% 2,033 2,269 -11.6% 1,544,709 1,470,996 4.8% Lebanon 682. AES Ironwood AES IRONWOOD 55337 332 1,050,916 467,094 55.55% 1,354 936 30.8% 1,552,842 997,707 35.7% Montour 683. Montour PPL MONTOUR 3149 35721 9,252,615 8,964,147 3.12% 1,746 1,856 -6.3% 10,599,353 9,662,046 8.8% Northampton 684. Lower Mount Bethel Energy LOWER MOUNT BETHEL 55667 26078 550,914 528,248 4.11% 853 3,122 -265.8% 1,291,050 338,375 73.8% 685. Portland PORTLAND (PA) 3113 35533 2,384,956 2,158,917 9.48% 1,987 2,025 -1.9% 2,400,964 2,132,117 11.2% 686. Martins Creek PPL MARTINS CREEK 3148 35720 1,670,459 3,007,054 -80.01% 1,931 2,056 -6.5% 1,730,439 2,925,009 -69.0% Northumberland 687. Mt. Carmel Cogeneration MOUNT CARMEL POWER 10343 29626 525,415 569,111 -8.32% 3,363 3,375 -0.4% 312,482 337,265 -7.9% Philadelphia 688. Grays Ferry Cogen Partnership GRAYS FERRY 54785 15826 208,660 327,667 -57.03% 1,449 1,200 17.1% 288,057 545,953 -89.5% 689. Schuylkill SCHUYLKILL 3169 40303 81,024 74,658 7.86% 1,884 2,124 -12.8% 86,026 70,293 18.3% Schuylkill 690. WPS Westwood Generation, LLC WESTWOOD GENERATION 50611 49591 307,963 421,536 -36.88% 3,504 4,576 -30.6% 175,787 184,244 -4.8% Venango 691. Handsome Lake Energy HANDSOME LAKE 55233 16832 104,308 10,140 90.28% 1,482 1,336 9.8% 140,811 15,181 89.2% Washington 692. Elrama ELRAMA 3098 12379 2,343,368 2,440,330 -4.14% 2,100 2,627 -25.1% 2,231,970 1,857,542 16.8% 693. Mitchell Power Station MITCHELL (PA) 3181 28811 908,845 1,500,480 -65.10% 1,908 2,071 -8.5% 952,496 1,449,315 -52.2% 694. Brunner Island PPL BRUNNER ISLAND 3140 35718 9,380,958 9,117,831 2.80% 1,707 1,774 -3.9% 10,988,384 10,300,000 6.3% York Diff. % CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % -4.5% 14,522,855 13,100,000 9.8% RHODE ISLAND Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Newport 695. Tiverton Power TIVERTON 55048 45674 529,381 769,838 -45.42% 857 879 -2.6% 1,235,575 1,751,693 -41.8% Providence 696. Manchester Street MANCHESTER STREET 3236 26991 682,136 352,279 48.36% 1,490 1,241 16.7% 915,513 567,614 38.0% 697. Pawtucket Power Associates, LP PAWTUCKET EMI 54056 34007 18,642 3,971 78.70% 1,035 69 93.3% 36,033 115,010 -219.2% 698. Rhode Island State Energy Partners RI STATE ENERGY 55107 37302 1,187,053 391,409 67.03% 824 849 -3.1% 2,882,700 922,277 68.0% Page 35 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 SOUTH CAROLINA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA Aiken 699. Urquhart URQUHART 3295 47406 1,209,994 800,842 33.81% 1,700 1,513 11.0% 1,423,176 1,058,564 25.6% Anderson 700. W S Lee LEE (SC) 3264 24890 1,656,246 1,151,181 30.49% 1,984 2,270 -14.4% 1,669,868 1,014,425 39.3% 701. John S. Rainey Generating Station RAINEY 7834 36560 573,467 925,529 -61.39% 1,455 977 32.8% 788,144 1,894,213 -140.3% 702. Williams AM WILLIAMS 3298 1261 3,487,115 3,565,825 -2.26% 1,694 1,988 -17.3% 4,116,215 3,587,905 12.8% 703. Cross CROSS 130 9740 13,443,593 15,000,000 -11.58% 2,010 2,065 -2.7% 13,379,077 14,600,000 -9.1% 704. Jefferies JEFFERIES 3319 20249 2,168,444 2,224,442 -2.58% 2,229 2,240 -0.5% 1,945,684 1,985,774 -2.1% Charleston 705. Hagood HAGOOD 3285 16544 27,438 16,851 38.59% 1,761 1,765 -0.2% 31,164 19,094 38.7% Cherokee 706. Broad River Energy Center BROAD RIVER 55166 5853 482,138 310,941 35.51% 1,305 1,620 -24.1% 738,864 383,841 48.0% Colleton 707. Canadys Steam CANADYS 3280 6910 2,391,407 2,947,657 -23.26% 1,953 2,166 -10.9% 2,449,289 2,721,252 -11.1% Darlington 708. Darlington County DARLINGTON (SC) 3250 10267 91,055 8,944 90.18% 1,220 1,798 -47.4% 149,301 9,947 93.3% Georgetown 709. Winyah WINYAH 6249 49997 8,608,578 8,585,641 0.27% 2,084 2,228 -6.9% 8,261,695 7,707,581 6.7% Lexington 710. McMeekin MCMEEKIN 3287 27852 1,467,091 1,474,804 -0.53% 1,746 1,956 -12.1% 1,680,963 1,507,985 10.3% Orangeburg 711. Cope Station COPE 7210 9335 3,280,935 3,776,153 -15.09% 1,886 2,073 -9.9% 3,478,666 3,642,400 -4.7% Richland 712. Wateree WATEREE (SC) 3297 49128 3,984,995 4,664,244 -17.05% 1,733 1,842 -6.3% 4,598,325 5,064,693 -10.1% Berkeley CARMA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % SOUTH DAKOTA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Beadle 713. Huron HURON 3344 18947 7,947 132 98.34% 2,113 6,000 -184.0% 7,522 44 99.4% Brown 714. Groton Generating Station GROTON (SD) 56238 16100 37,787 52,318 -38.46% 946 1,298 -37.2% 79,868 80,604 -0.9% Grant 715. Big Stone BIG STONE 6098 4589 2,947,753 4,210,407 -42.83% 2,263 2,320 -2.5% 2,605,307 3,630,259 -39.3% Minnehaha 716. Angus Anson ANGUS ANSON 7237 1585 227,833 169,665 25.53% 1,588 1,641 -3.3% 286,885 206,823 27.9% Pennington 717. Lange LANGE 55478 24455 19,681 15,090 23.32% 1,181 1,256 -6.4% 33,338 24,031 27.9% Page 36 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 TENNESSEE Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Anderson 718. Bull Run BULL RUN (TN) 3396 6223 6,768,029 4,523,043 33.17% 1,940 1,872 3.5% 6,979,100 4,833,382 30.7% Hawkins 719. John Sevier JOHN SEVIER 3405 20526 4,887,748 5,198,875 -6.37% 1,891 2,131 -12.7% 5,168,778 4,880,013 5.6% Haywood 720. Brownsville Power I, LLC BROWNSVILLE (TN) 55081 5969 39,897 8,829 77.87% 1,376 1,518 -10.3% 58,011 11,634 79.9% 721. Lagoon Creek LAGOON CREEK 7845 24130 226,782 105,049 53.68% 1,452 1,225 15.7% 312,283 171,536 45.1% Humphreys 722. Johnsonville JOHNSONVILLE (TN) 3406 20539 9,356,114 7,735,183 17.32% 2,102 2,154 -2.5% 8,903,301 7,182,055 19.3% Roane 723. Kingston KINGSTON 3407 22265 10,945,350 10,100,000 7.72% 2,019 2,278 -12.9% 10,842,629 8,840,685 18.5% Shelby 724. Allen TH ALLEN 3393 45274 5,476,954 4,810,530 12.17% 1,870 2,076 -11.0% 4,634,324 20.9% Stewart 725. Cumberland CUMBERLAND (TN) 3399 9868 17,957,234 19,600,000 -9.15% 1,984 2,151 -8.4% 18,100,379 18,200,000 -0.6% Sumner 726. Gallatin GALLATIN 3403 14527 8,007,616 6,817,369 14.86% 2,024 1,959 3.2% CAMD-EPA CARMA 5,856,397 7,913,027 Diff. % 6,961,341 12.0% TEXAS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Atascosa 727. San Miguel SAN MIGUEL 6183 39403 3,589,409 3,750,801 -4.50% 2,361 2,787 -18.0% 3,041,014 2,692,092 11.5% Bastrop 728. Bastrop Clean Energy Center BASTROP ENERGY 55168 3530 1,035,992 1,135,803 -9.63% 1,465 2,126 -45.1% 1,414,174 1,068,720 24.4% 729. Lost Pines 1 LOST PINES 55154 25973 1,392,680 1,427,878 -2.53% 1,334 969 27.4% 2,088,215 2,948,178 -41.2% 730. Sim Gideon SIM GIDEON 3601 41758 682,035 600,404 11.97% 1,267 1,250 1.4% 1,076,743 960,898 10.8% 731. J K Spruce JK SPRUCE 7097 20483 4,560,391 5,577,214 -22.30% 2,136 2,285 -7.0% 4,270,895 4,881,262 -14.3% 732. J T Deely JT DEELY 6181 20630 10,349,503 7,177,219 30.65% 3,695 2,414 34.7% 5,602,197 5,946,450 -6.1% Bexar Diff. % CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 733. Leon Creek LEON CREEK 3609 25027 78,382 110,666 -41.19% 1,241 1,708 -37.7% 126,348 129,570 -2.6% 734. O W Sommers OW SOMMERS 3611 33259 1,009,428 449,521 55.47% 1,382 1,397 -1.1% 1,461,213 643,467 56.0% 735. V H Braunig VH BRAUNIG 3612 48178 1,191,716 366,544 69.24% 2,562 1,240 51.6% 930,379 591,403 36.4% 736. W B Tuttle WB TUTTLE 3613 49215 13,599 5,213 61.66% 1,447 3,096 -113.9% 18,794 3,368 82.1% Bosque 737. Bosque County Power Plant BOSQUE COUNTY 55172 5389 406,490 617,067 -51.80% 1,370 870 36.5% 593,578 1,418,629 -139.0% Brazoria 738. Sweeny Cogeneration Facility SWEENY 55015 44104 2,629,647 5,090,922 -93.60% 1,426 3,069 -115.3% 3,689,326 3,317,616 10.1% Page 37 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 TEXAS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Brazos 739. Dansby DANSBY 6243 10211 214,111 249,739 -16.64% 1,250 1,378 -10.2% 342,496 362,362 -5.8% Cameron 740. Silas Ray SILAS RAY 3559 41701 34,032 65,377 -92.10% 1,496 1,459 2.4% 45,500 89,600 -96.9% Cherokee 741. Stryker Creek STRYKER CREEK 3504 43571 527,995 358,925 32.02% 1,276 1,443 -13.1% 827,829 497,364 39.9% Collin 742. Ray Olinger RAY OLINGER 3576 36881 206,744 454,825 -119.99% 1,304 1,589 -21.8% 317,084 572,632 -80.6% Dallas 743. C E Newman CE NEWMAN 3574 7530 777 978 -25.82% 2,722 17 99.4% 571 744. Lake Hubbard LAKE HUBBARD 3452 24238 417,941 503,538 -20.48% 1,335 1,303 2.4% 626,120 773,097 -23.5% 745. Mountain Creek Generating Station MOUNTAIN CREEK 3453 29670 280,522 339,701 -21.10% 1,385 1,545 -11.6% 405,102 439,610 -8.5% Denton 746. Spencer SPENCER (TX) 4266 42762 57,222 26,329 53.99% 1,536 6,000 -290.7% 74,518 8,776 88.2% Ector 747. Odessa-Ector Generating Station ODESSA/ECTOR 55215 32271 1,966,865 3,887,915 -97.67% 1,447 1,837 -26.9% 2,718,017 4,232,402 -55.7% 748. Quail Run Energy Center QUAIL RUN 56349 36327 153,371 276,616 -80.36% 942 920 2.3% 325,519 601,126 -84.7% El Paso 749. Newman NEWMAN 3456 31136 1,304,205 1,073,999 17.65% 1,414 1,462 -3.4% 1,844,915 1,468,961 20.4% Ellis 750. Midlothian Energy MIDLOTHIAN 55091 28433 2,968,562 3,249,736 -9.47% 862 1,033 -19.8% 6,885,475 6,290,630 8.6% Fayette 751. Sam Seymour FAYETTE (TX) 6179 13237 13,297,420 12,000,000 9.76% 2,074 2,105 -1.5% 12,823,492 11,400,000 11.1% Fort Bend 752. Brazos Valley Energy, LP BRAZOS VALLEY 55357 5678 1,212,102 1,310,724 -8.14% 861 1,343 753. W A Parish WA PARISH 3470 48755 20,949,613 20,000,000 4.53% 1,963 754. Big Brown BIG BROWN 3497 4556 9,956,682 9,841,515 1.16% 755. Freestone Power Generation FREESTONE 55226 14097 1,808,739 2,112,030 Goliad 756. Coleto Creek COLETO CREEK 6178 9066 4,384,926 Gregg 757. Knox Lee Power Plant KNOX LEE 3476 22586 Grimes 758. Tenaska Frontier Generation Station TENASKA FRONTIER 55062 Guadalupe 759. Guadalupe Generating Station GUADALUPE POWER 760. Rio Nogales Power Project, LP RIO NOGALES Freestone CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % -55.9% CAMD-EPA CARMA 2,814,037 Diff. % 116,915 20375.5% 1,952,377 30.6% 2,133 -8.6% 21,342,022 18,800,000 11.9% 2,191 2,385 -8.9% 9,090,235 8,254,467 9.2% -16.77% 1,415 950 32.9% 2,556,871 4,446,741 -73.9% 5,039,538 -14.93% 1,995 3,526 -76.7% 4,395,901 2,858,737 35.0% 255,739 288,368 -12.76% 1,306 1,477 -13.1% 391,660 390,502 0.3% 45075 1,896,991 3,474,098 -83.14% 802 1,933 -141.1% 4,731,508 3,593,835 24.0% 55153 16171 1,849,954 2,016,368 -9.00% 1,394 1,081 22.5% 2,653,563 3,732,287 -40.7% 55137 37566 1,116,749 1,478,274 -32.37% 997 1,097 -10.1% 2,241,308 2,695,374 -20.3% Page 38 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 TEXAS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CO2 Intensity S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Harris 761. AES Deepwater, Inc. AES DEEPWATER 10670 325 1,292,530 1,659,045 -28.36% 2,484 3,754 -51.1% 1,040,759 883,986 15.1% 762. Channel Energy Center CHANNEL 55299 7956 1,695,248 1,743,728 -2.86% 833 1,386 -66.3% 4,068,405 2,515,869 38.2% 763. Altura Channelview Cogen Facility CHANNELVIEW 50815 7959 2,065,947 3,157,221 -52.82% 1,315 1,322 -0.5% 3,141,160 4,777,300 -52.1% 764. Deer Park Energy Center DEER PARK ENERGY 55464 10467 4,057,253 3,583,661 11.67% 839 1,394 -66.2% 9,675,375 5,140,725 46.9% 765. Greens Bayou GREENS BAYOU 3464 15911 154,164 149,927 2.75% 1,467 3,683 -151.1% 210,235 81,411 61.3% 766. Sam Bertron SAM BERTRON 3468 39075 190,723 225,166 -18.06% 1,220 1,526 -25.1% 312,784 295,082 5.7% 767. San Jacinto Steam Electric Station SAN JACINTO 7325 39305 791,487 1,888,174 -138.56% 1,625 2,869 -76.6% 974,396 1,316,449 -35.1% 768. Harrison County Power Project HARRISON COUNTY 55664 17025 563,032 255,462 54.63% 880 1,029 -17.0% 1,280,272 496,466 61.2% 769. H W Pirkey Power Plant PIRKEY 7902 34852 5,738,749 6,036,741 -5.19% 2,219 2,316 -4.4% 5,171,261 5,212,533 -0.8% Hays 770. Hays Energy Project HAYS ENERGY 55144 17265 1,571,224 2,953 99.81% 1,353 2,968 -119.4% 2,323,197 1,990 99.9% Henderson 771. Trinidad TRINIDAD (TX) 3507 46427 56,550 36,173 36.03% 1,469 1,611 -9.7% 77,009 44,920 41.7% Hidalgo 772. Frontera Generation Facility FRONTERA 55098 14216 1,033,988 964,969 6.67% 1,443 1,971 -36.6% 1,432,629 979,049 31.7% 773. Calpine Hidalgo Energy Center HIDALGO ENERGY 7762 17684 792,021 818,313 -3.32% 1,364 1,108 18.7% 1,161,543 1,477,017 -27.2% 774. Magic Valley Generating Station MAGIC VALLEY (TX) 55123 26659 1,271,133 1,176,180 7.47% 745 908 -21.8% 3,410,429 2,591,148 24.0% 775. Decordova DECORDOVA 8063 10443 104,962 225,529 -114.87% 1,316 2,209 -67.9% 159,506 204,172 -28.0% 776. Wolf Hollow I, LP WOLF HOLLOW 55139 50146 1,546,881 1,209,959 21.78% 1,342 1,092 18.6% 2,305,557 2,215,168 3.9% Howard 777. C. R. Wing Cogeneration Plant CR WING COGEN 52176 9639 352,689 512,364 -45.27% 1,081 2,241 -107.3% 652,507 457,258 29.9% Hunt 778. Power Lane Steam Plant POWERLANE 4195 35687 9,325 6,516 30.12% 1,899 4,403 -131.8% 9,818 2,959 69.9% Hutchinson 779. Blackhawk Station BLACK HAWK COGEN 55064 4848 1,200,012 2,139,438 -78.28% 1,338 3,161 -136.2% 1,793,119 1,353,540 24.5% Jefferson 780. Exxonmobil Beaumont Refinery BEAUMONT REFINERY 50625 3746 1,815,560 3,611,898 -98.94% 834 6,000 -619.2% 4,352,554 1,203,966 72.3% Johnson 781. Johnson County Generation Facility JOHNSON COUNTY 54817 20534 642,277 302,839 52.85% 959 1,017 -6.0% 1,339,376 595,660 55.5% Kaufman 782. FPLE Forney, LP FORNEY 55480 13793 3,700,278 3,217,881 13.04% 1,297 859 33.8% 5,705,952 7,493,411 -31.3% Lamar 783. Lamar Power (Paris) LAMAR ENERGY 55097 24313 2,018,715 1,625,509 19.48% 1,106 998 9.7% 3,651,819 3,257,355 10.8% Harrison Hood CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Page 39 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 TEXAS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Lamar 784. Paris Energy Center PARIS (TX) 50109 33784 214,808 1,736 99.19% 1,234 7 99.4% 348,283 477,729 -37.2% Lamb 785. Plant X PLANT X 3485 34968 900,391 976,769 -8.48% 1,264 1,336 -5.7% 1,424,135 1,461,896 -2.7% 786. Tolk Station TOLK 6194 45857 7,638,638 7,756,687 -1.55% 2,027 2,048 -1.1% 7,537,505 7,573,668 -0.5% 787. Alex Ty Cooke Generating Station COOK 3602 9309 82,456 44,165 46.44% 1,489 1,430 4.0% 110,757 61,782 44.2% 788. Jones Station JONES 3482 20561 1,180,501 1,392,799 -17.98% 1,207 1,273 -5.4% 1,955,556 2,188,609 -11.9% 789. J Robert Massengale Generating Station MASSENGALE 3604 27559 100,811 54,639 45.80% 954 1,004 -5.2% 211,427 108,877 48.5% 790. Lake Creek LAKE CREEK (TX) 3502 24226 51,011 51,543 -1.04% 1,374 1,507 -9.7% 74,253 68,412 7.9% 791. Tradinghouse TRADINGHOUSE CREEK 3506 46247 280,221 214,605 23.42% 1,317 1,408 -7.0% 425,690 304,785 28.4% Milam 792. Sandow SANDOW 6648 39530 5,413,397 5,284,035 2.39% 2,241 2,305 -2.8% 4,830,430 4,584,580 5.1% Mitchell 793. Morgan Creek MORGAN CREEK 3492 29449 4,643 131,733 -2737.13% 1,465 2,195 -49.8% 6,337 Montgomery 794. Lewis Creek LEWIS CREEK 3457 25157 1,256,425 1,147,705 8.65% 1,347 1,302 3.3% 1,865,504 1,762,996 5.5% Moore 795. Moore County Station MOORE COUNTY 3483 29393 22,614 20,769 8.16% 1,653 1,742 -5.4% 27,360 23,848 12.8% Morris 796. Lone Star Power Plant LONE STAR 3477 25773 4,813 401 91.67% 1,245 6,000 -381.9% 7,731 134 98.3% Nolan 797. Sweetwater Generating Plant SWEETWATER 50615 44105 141,748 157,395 -11.04% 1,188 1,604 -35.0% 238,704 196,269 17.8% Nueces 798. Barney M. Davis BARNEY DAVIS 4939 3380 187,504 791,444 -322.09% 1,259 2,425 -92.6% 297,869 652,656 -119.1% 799. Corpus Christi Energy Center CORPUS CHRISTI ENERGY 55206 9453 1,517,944 1,333,420 12.16% 851 1,354 -59.1% 3,567,702 1,969,797 44.8% 800. Sabine SABINE 3459 38564 2,947,678 3,105,980 -5.37% 1,244 1,266 -1.8% 4,738,875 4,905,599 -3.5% 801. Sabine Cogeneration Facility SABINE COGEN 55104 38565 472,948 419,838 11.23% 1,807 1,258 30.4% 523,579 667,619 -27.5% 802. SRW Cogen Limited Partnership SRW COGEN 55120 42887 1,725,591 2,833,413 -64.20% 1,031 2,312 -124.3% 3,348,646 2,451,192 26.8% Palo Pinto 803. R W Miller RW MILLER 3628 38426 233,416 269,137 -15.30% 1,362 1,463 -7.4% 342,750 367,824 -7.3% Potter 804. Harrington Station HARRINGTON 6193 17015 8,265,848 9,460,767 -14.46% 2,117 2,280 -7.7% 7,810,504 8,300,534 -6.3% 805. Nichols Station NICHOLS 3484 31202 848,973 690,896 18.62% 1,256 1,318 -4.9% 1,351,500 1,048,322 22.4% 806. Twin Oaks Power, LP TWIN OAKS 7030 46859 2,738,265 2,845,097 -3.90% 2,087 2,341 -12.2% 2,623,616 2,430,588 7.4% McLennan Orange Robertson CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Lubbock CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 120,028 -1794.1% Page 40 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 TEXAS Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Rusk 807. Martin Lake MARTIN LAKE 6146 27457 21,821,564 19,800,000 9.26% 2,243 2,308 808. Tenaska Gateway Generating Station TENASKA GATEWAY 55132 45076 1,732,104 1,542,328 10.96% 853 San Patricio 809. Gregory Power Facility GREGORY POWER 55086 15931 1,877,652 1,856,829 1.11% Tarrant 810. Handley Generating Station HANDLEY 3491 16829 216,619 805,026 Titus 811. Monticello MONTICELLO (TX) 6147 29346 18,300,186 Travis 812. Decker Creek DECKER 3548 10442 813. Holly Street HOLLY STREET 3549 814. Sand Hill Energy Center SAND HILL Victoria 815. Sam Rayburn Plant Ward 816. Webb Wharton Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % -2.9% 19,460,252 17,100,000 12.1% 902 -5.7% 4,059,236 3,420,468 15.7% 851 1,064 -25.0% 4,411,503 3,490,489 20.9% -271.63% 1,453 1,610 -10.7% 298,078 1,000,279 -235.6% 16,300,000 10.93% 2,227 2,341 -5.1% 16,432,428 14,000,000 14.8% 685,921 902,212 -31.53% 1,236 1,248 -1.0% 1,110,280 1,445,906 -30.2% 18220 271,244 280,467 -3.40% 1,355 1,437 -6.1% 400,394 390,349 2.5% 7900 39501 795,356 530,245 33.33% 835 1,688 -102.3% 1,906,016 628,210 67.0% SAM RAYBURN 3631 39076 359,469 437,667 -21.75% 1,400 2,025 -44.7% 513,580 432,265 15.8% Permian Basin PERMIAN BASIN 3494 34322 253,080 645,737 -155.15% 1,484 2,219 -49.5% 341,050 582,002 -70.7% 817. Laredo LAREDO 3439 24569 547,240 498,846 8.84% 1,275 1,577 -23.7% 858,553 632,621 26.3% 818. Colorado Bend Energy Center COLORADO BEND 56350 9123 131,245 276,616 -110.76% 944 920 2.5% 278,182 601,126 -116.1% 819. New Gulf Power Facility NEWGULF 50137 31127 7,452 2 99.97% 1,590 0 100.0% 9,372 Wilbarger 820. Oklaunion Power Station OKLAUNION 127 32454 4,555,053 5,016,390 -10.13% 2,037 2,099 -3.0% 4,473,120 4,780,529 -6.9% Yoakum 821. Mustang Station MUSTANG STATION 55065 30094 1,122,456 1,755,298 -56.38% 953 999 -4.8% 2,355,536 3,513,633 -49.2% Young 822. Graham GRAHAM 3490 15691 563,508 331,363 41.20% 1,333 675 49.4% 845,181 981,717 -16.2% 259,474 -2668.6% UTAH Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Carbon 823. Carbon CARBON 3644 7107 1,536,505 1,243,083 Emery 824. Hunter HUNTER 6165 18905 10,431,321 825. Huntington HUNTINGTON 8069 18913 7,223,031 826. Currant Creek Power Project CURRANT CREEK 56102 9899 1,439,112 Juab Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA 1,434,467 1,118,752 Diff. % 19.10% 2,142 2,222 -3.7% 22.0% 10,600,000 -1.62% 2,022 2,068 -2.3% 10,320,274 10,200,000 6,169,905 14.58% 1,909 1,930 -1.1% 7,568,444 6,392,317 15.5% 465,535 67.65% 782 801 -2.4% 3,681,175 1,162,606 68.4% 1.2% Page 41 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 UTAH Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Millard 827. Intermountain INTERMOUNTAIN 6481 19506 15,694,058 16,100,000 -2.59% 2,042 2,007 Salt Lake 828. Gadsby GADSBY 3648 14479 483,433 204,091 57.78% 1,371 1,406 -2.5% 705,083 290,400 58.8% 829. West Valley Generation Project WEST VALLEY 55622 49515 444,928 515,909 -15.95% 1,301 2,323 -78.6% 683,986 444,118 35.1% Uintah 830. Bonanza BONANZA 7790 5218 4,083,840 4,375,652 -7.15% 2,247 2,496 -11.1% 3,635,491 3,506,155 3.6% Utah 831. Nebo Power Station NEBO (PAYSON) 56177 30800 303,700 38,391 87.36% 857 344 59.8% 708,770 223,092 68.5% 1.7% 15,371,980 16,000,000 -4.1% VERMONT Power Plant Name and Location by County County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA Chittenden 832. J C McNeil JC MCNEIL Plant IDs ORIS CARMA 589 20210 Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA 470,815 CARMA 362,395 Diff. % 23.03% CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA 2,972 Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % 3,907 -31.4% CAMD-EPA CARMA 316,808 Diff. % 185,530 41.4% VIRGINIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Accomack 833. Commonwealth Chesapeake COMMONWEALTH CHESAPEAKE 55381 9186 43,208 196,882 -355.67% 1,687 2,212 -31.1% 51,234 178,050 -247.5% Alexandria (City) 834. Mirant Potomac River POTOMAC RIVER 3788 35619 1,776,053 2,459,463 -38.48% 2,219 2,353 -6.0% 1,600,700 2,090,326 -30.6% Buchanan 835. Buchanan -- Units 1 and 2 BUCHANAN COUNTY 55738 6083 46,203 23,004 50.21% 1,153 1,203 -4.4% 80,125 38,230 52.3% Caroline 836. Ladysmith Combustion Turbine Sta LADYSMITH SUBSTATION 7838 24085 132,663 45,623 65.61% 1,280 1,481 -15.7% 207,318 61,614 70.3% Chesterfield 837. Chesterfield Power Station CHESTERFIELD 3797 8235 8,728,350 7,489,167 14.20% 1,772 1,693 4.5% 9,850,571 8,846,920 10.2% Fauquier 838. Marsh Run Generation Facility MARSH RUN 7836 27422 191,502 69,410 63.76% 1,362 6,000 -340.4% 281,133 23,137 91.8% Fluvanna 839. Bremo Power Station BREMO BLUFF 3796 5732 1,534,214 1,477,118 3.72% 1,939 2,180 -12.4% 1,582,335 1,355,323 14.3% Giles 840. Glen Lyn GLEN LYN 3776 15295 1,654,470 1,356,287 18.02% 2,053 2,137 -4.1% 1,611,816 1,269,174 21.3% Halifax 841. Clover Power Station CLOVER 7213 8920 7,360,175 7,359,707 0.01% 2,052 2,099 -2.3% 7,173,278 7,013,426 2.2% Hanover 842. Doswell Limited Partnership DOSWELL 52019 11247 65,046 748,507 -1050.73% 68 1,024 -1409.0% 1,917,063 1,461,954 23.7% Page 42 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 VIRGINIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Prince William 843. Possum Point Power Station POSSUM POINT 3804 35609 1,605,715 2,030,458 -26.45% 1,032 1,029 0.3% 3,111,380 3,945,897 -26.8% Russell 844. Clinch River CLINCH RIVER (VA) 3775 8893 3,788,437 3,679,650 2.87% 1,756 1,898 -8.1% 4,314,564 3,877,521 10.1% Washington 845. Wolf Hills Energy WOLF HILLS 55285 50145 140,131 754 99.46% 1,336 1,092 18.3% 209,765 1,380 99.3% York 846. Yorktown Power Station YORKTOWN 3809 50915 2,834,974 4,971,598 -75.37% 1,859 1,835 1.3% 3,050,772 5,418,659 -77.6% WASHINGTON Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Benton 847. Finley Combustion Turbine FINLEY 7945 13489 316 2,547 -705.65% 1,524 1,550 -1.7% 415 3,287 -691.9% Clark 848. River Road RIVER ROAD 7605 37647 640,904 1,431,143 -123.30% 822 1,697 -106.4% 1,559,022 1,686,556 -8.2% Skagit 849. Fredonia Generating Station FREDONIA (WA) 607 14085 13,151 8,344 36.55% 1,337 1,107 17.2% 19,674 15,073 23.4% Whatcom 850. Encogen Generating Station ENCOGEN NORTHWEST 7870 12489 94,207 305,477 -224.26% 1,434 1,417 1.2% 131,384 431,145 -228.2% WEST VIRGINIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Grant 851. Mount Storm Power Station MOUNT STORM 3954 29661 10,700,711 12,700,000 -18.68% 1,989 2,212 -11.2% 10,762,194 11,500,000 -6.9% Harrison 852. Harrison Power Station HARRISON 3944 17024 13,570,101 14,200,000 -4.64% 1,858 2,209 -18.9% 14,609,662 12,900,000 11.7% Kanawha 853. Kanawha River KANAWHA RIVER 3936 21145 2,182,018 1,819,781 16.60% 1,848 1,876 -1.5% 2,361,048 1,940,310 17.8% Marion 854. Rivesville Power Station RIVESVILLE 3945 37692 349,501 229,736 34.27% 2,583 2,723 -5.4% 270,579 168,719 37.6% Marshall 855. Kammer KAMMER 3947 21094 3,991,447 3,243,981 18.73% 1,885 1,877 0.4% 4,235,691 3,456,181 18.4% 856. Mitchell (WV) MITCHELL (WV) 3948 28812 9,033,512 8,478,185 6.15% 1,919 1,880 2.0% 9,414,785 9,017,608 4.2% 857. Mountaineer (1301) MOUNTAINEER 6264 29683 9,846,831 7,726,502 21.53% 1,951 1,861 4.6% 10,094,197 8,305,266 17.7% 858. Phil Sporn PHILIP SPORN 3938 34530 6,153,309 5,406,909 12.13% 1,873 1,950 -4.1% 6,572,033 5,546,547 15.6% 859. Fort Martin Power Station FORT MARTIN 3943 13847 6,726,767 7,328,248 -8.94% 1,859 1,930 -3.8% 7,237,706 7,595,337 -4.9% Monongalia CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) S. N Mason Diff. % CO2 Intensity County Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Page 43 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 WEST VIRGINIA Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Pleasants 860. Pleasants Power Station PLEASANTS 6004 35027 7,485,163 6,721,762 10.20% 1,740 2,217 -27.4% 8,602,327 6,063,039 29.5% 861. Willow Island Power Station WILLOW ISLAND 3946 49869 799,862 597,188 25.34% 2,159 2,340 -8.4% 740,785 510,381 31.1% Preston 862. Albright Power Station ALBRIGHT 3942 853 1,610,136 1,200,372 25.45% 2,174 2,494 -14.7% 1,481,483 962,704 35.0% Wayne 863. Big Sandy Peaker Plant BIG SANDY PEAKER 55284 4583 121,755 1,863 98.47% 1,116 1,625 -45.5% 218,150 2,294 98.9% 864. Ceredo Generating Station CEREDO 55276 7715 96,656 1,401 98.55% 1,439 2,670 -85.5% 134,305 1,050 99.2% WISCONSIN Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Ashland 865. Bay Front BAY FRONT 3982 3635 Brown Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA 565,192 CARMA Diff. % 428,415 24.20% CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA 2,933 2,876 Energy Output (MWh) Diff. % 2.0% CAMD-EPA CARMA 385,364 Diff. % 297,942 22.7% 866. Depere Energy Center DEPERE ENERGY CENTER 55029 10611 48,619 78,317 -61.08% 1,362 1,421 -4.3% 71,368 110,238 -54.5% 867. Pulliam JP PULLIAM 4072 20622 2,913,320 3,166,700 -8.70% 2,313 2,824 -22.1% 2,519,080 2,242,359 11.0% 868. Alma ALMA 4140 1033 1,266,274 1,080,609 14.66% 3,014 2,302 23.6% 840,318 938,951 -11.7% 869. J P Madgett MADGETT 4271 26558 2,730,074 2,408,667 11.77% 2,047 2,295 -12.1% 2,667,126 2,099,157 21.3% Columbia 870. Columbia COLUMBIA (WI) 8023 9144 8,198,904 8,565,041 -4.47% 2,117 2,405 -13.6% 7,744,524 7,122,412 8.0% Dane 871. Blount Street BLOUNT STREET 3992 4959 273,621 731,046 -167.17% 2,499 2,896 -15.9% 218,971 504,925 -130.6% 872. Rockgen Energy Center ROCKGEN 55391 37848 64,108 183,058 -185.55% 1,378 1,408 -2.2% 93,067 260,070 -179.4% 873. West Campus Cogeneration Facility WEST CAMPUS 7991 49434 131,662 166,511 -26.47% 1,010 910 9.9% 260,719 366,027 -40.4% Fond du Lac 874. South Fond Du Lac SOUTH FOND DU LAC 7203 42606 65,234 27,165 58.36% 2,033 2,727 -34.1% 64,178 19,925 69.0% Grant 875. Nelson Dewey NELSON DEWEY 4054 30877 1,710,358 1,624,786 5.00% 2,620 2,653 -1.3% 1,305,598 1,224,866 6.2% Jefferson 876. Concord CONCORD 7159 9215 145,814 18,242 87.49% 1,611 2,009 -24.7% 181,068 18,163 90.0% Kenosha 877. Pleasant Prairie PLEASANT PRAIRIE 6170 35019 9,487,843 9,689,624 -2.13% 2,222 2,331 -4.9% 8,540,834 8,313,535 2.7% Marathon 878. Weston WESTON (WI) 4078 49578 3,173,658 4,396,022 -38.52% 2,172 2,724 -25.4% 2,922,021 3,227,492 -10.5% Marinette 879. West Marinette WEST MARINETTE 4076 49480 92,186 57,697 37.41% 1,525 925 39.3% 120,875 124,696 -3.2% Buffalo Page 44 of 45 www.performeks.com Carbon Monitoring for Action (CARMA): Climate Activism Built on Specious Data / A Due Diligence Report on CARMA’s Data and Methodology Comparison of USEPA and CARMA Data for the Year 2007 WISCONSIN Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % Outagamie 880. Fox Energy Company LLC FOX ENERGY 56031 13953 170,257 585,408 -243.84% 777 838 -7.8% 438,008 1,397,059 -219.0% 881. Island Street Peaking Plant ISLAND STREET PEAKING 55836 19723 25,795 2,296 91.10% 1,273 107 91.6% 40,535 42,723 -5.4% Ozaukee 882. Port Washington Generating Station PORT WASHINGTON WEP 4040 35499 807,155 545,069 32.47% 855 864 -1.1% 1,889,100 1,262,363 33.2% Rock 883. Riverside Energy Center, LLC RIVERSIDE ENERGY (WI) 55641 37672 587,824 574,136 2.33% 806 2,284 -183.3% 1,458,404 502,737 65.5% 884. Rock River ROCK RIVER (WI) 4057 37834 29,010 146,230 -404.06% 1,628 1,714 -5.3% 35,640 170,599 -378.7% Sheboygan 885. Sheboygan Falls Energy Facility SHEBOYGAN FALLS 56166 41042 25,113 173,595 -591.25% 1,324 1,185 10.5% 37,947 292,957 -672.0% Vernon 886. Genoa GENOA-3 4143 14950 2,204,412 1,856,227 15.79% 1,868 1,956 -4.7% 2,360,109 1,898,428 19.6% Washington 887. Germantown Power Plant GERMANTOWNGERMANTO WN 6253 15016 34,254 9,259 72.97% 1,558 970 37.7% 43,980 19,091 56.6% Winnebago 888. Neenah Energy Facility NEENAH ENERGY 55135 30834 72,452 45,948 36.58% 1,338 1,494 -11.7% 108,284 61,496 43.2% WYOMING Power Plant Name and Location by County Plant IDs County S. N CAMD-EPA CARMA ORIS CARMA Campbell 889. Wygen I WYGEN 55479 50358 890. Wyodak WYODAK 6101 Converse 891. Dave Johnston DAVE JOHNSTON Lincoln 892. Naughton Platte 893. Sweetwater 894. Annual CO2 Emissions (tons) CAMD-EPA CO2 Intensity CAMD-EPA CARMA Energy Output (MWh) CARMA Diff. % Diff. % CAMD-EPA CARMA Diff. % 912,112 1,070,002 -17.31% 2,332 1,767 24.2% 782,324 1,210,899 -54.8% 50371 3,416,990 3,475,464 -1.71% 2,167 2,563 -18.3% 3,154,001 2,712,280 14.0% 4158 10336 7,570,888 6,959,361 8.08% 2,439 2,411 1.2% 6,207,238 5,773,455 7.0% NAUGHTON 4162 30719 6,089,651 5,777,684 5.12% 2,177 2,216 -1.8% 5,594,646 5,214,953 6.8% Laramie River LARAMIE RIVER 6204 24557 14,978,559 10,100,000 32.57% 2,264 815 64.0% 13,232,062 24,800,000 -87.4% Jim Bridger JIM BRIDGER 8066 20398 16,045,976 16,500,000 -2.83% 1,999 2,257 -12.9% 16,053,535 14,700,000 8.4% Page 45 of 45 www.performeks.com
s R iver
e
