German Norwegian Energy Forum

German Norwegian Energy Forum
Transformative Forces in the Energy Market
Photo: Per Eide, visitnorway.com
Gemeinschaftshaus der Nordischen Botschaften in Berlin
October 22, 2015
Programme
Moderator: Jørgen Festervoll, ADAPT Consulting AS
12:00
Registration, Refreshments and Finger Food
12:30
Welcome and Introduction
Elisabeth Walaas, Norwegian Ambassador to Germany
12:50
What is shaping the Energy Markets of tomorrow?
Prof. Dr. Marc Oliver Bettzüge, Institute of Energy Economics at the University
of Cologne
13:10
A new Market Design for the German Electricity Market - Local and European
Context
Claas F. Hülsen, Head of Department Market & Policy Development, DNV GL-Energy
13:30
Energy Markets Towards 2050: They call it Disruption but it might be a Revolution
Stefan Göbel, Head of Trading & Origination, Statkraft Markets GmbH
13:50
Coffee break
14:30
Prosumer Empowerment driving local Energy Market Design
Dieter Hirdes, NCE Smart Energy Markets, Coordinator of the Horizon 2020
EMPOWER project
14:50
From Idea to Installation – Project & Corporate Financing for a New Energy Storage
Technology
Dr. Christian Thiel, CEO, EnergyNest AS
15:10
Intraday Real-Time Data and their Value for Competitive Portfolio Management
Christopher Koch, Portfolio Management CWE, Markedskraft Deutschland GmbH
15:30
Changing Energy Behaviour
Line Riise Jensen, Director Corporate Sales, ECOHZ AS
15:50
Coffee break
16:30
Norwegian Gas – Key to Germany’s Energy Transformation
Rannveig Sofie Stangeland, Vice President, Government and Regulatory
Affairs, Statoil
16:50
Realizing the Potential of Hydropower Flexibility in European Markets by closer
Stakeholder Cooperation
Øyvind Stakkeland, Director, Agder Energi
17:10
How do the Nordic TSOs respond to the Challenges that the Nordic Power
System is facing due to a significant Increase in Interconnector Capacity
towards 2020
Ingard Moen, Senior Vice President – Grid Planning and Analysis, Statnett SF
17:30
Panel Discussion: Predictions for 2020
18:00
Reception and Buffet Dinner hosted by Elisabeth Walaas, Norwegian Ambassador
to Germany
2 Transformative Forces in the Energy Market 2015
Speakers
Marc Oliver Bettzüge
Managing Director, Institute of Energy Economics at the University of Cologne
Professor Bettzüge has been full professor and Head of the Chair of Energy
Economics at the University of Cologne since 2007. After studying mathematics and economics at the Universities of Bonn, Cambridge and Berkeley, he
received his doctorate in economics with a thesis on „Financial Innovation
from a General Equilibrium Perspective.“ Professor Bettzüge worked as a
researcher at the Universities of Bonn and Zurich, and also as a management
consultant with internationally renowned consulting firms. Prior to his
appointment to the University of Cologne, he held the position of partner and
Vice President with the strategy consultancy Boston Consulting Group (BCG).
Claas F. Hülsen
Head of Department Market & Policy Development, DNV GL-Energy
Claas F. Hülsen has joined DNV GL in 2005, where he primarily works in the
fields of Management and Business Consulting especially regarding market
rules and processes, and corporate strategy. He holds a degree in Business
Administration from the University of Hamburg and has about 15 years of
extensive experience in the energy sector. In this role with DNV GL and in his
previous experience in the consulting industry he was responsible for a large
number of different customers in the energy market varying from governmental institutions, associations to various international energy companies.
He is Manager of the Bonn office of DNV GL.
Stefan Göbel
Head of Trading & Origination, Statkraft Markets GmbH
Stefan-Jörg Göbel is the Head of Trading & Origination for Statkraft in Continental Europe. Thus he is responsible for all wholesale activities in power
and fuels. He is a Managing Director of Statkraft Markets GmbH, the group`s
central trading entity for Continental Europe. His responsibility comprises
proprietary and customer trading, cross-border arbitrage from the UK to
Turkey and from Poland to Spain, trading services, complex cross-commodity
off-take and purchase agreements and market access services for renewables. He also oversees the German communication and public affairs activities.
3
Dieter Hirdes
Special Advisor, NCE Smart Energy Markets
Dieter Hirdes is an ICT specialist with 25 years of experience in project management and system development of ICT systems for the energy sector. He
is a co-founder of the NCE Smart Energy Markets cluster and served as Project
Manager in its first years. From 2003 to 2011, he was CEO of Smart Innovation
Østfold, now serving as R&D coordinator of the company with a track record
of 18 and more SmartGrid related R&D projects totaling Euro 32 million in project revenues. Currently, Dieter Hirdes is the coordinator of the Horizon 2020
project EMPOWER.
Christian Thiel
CEO, EnergyNest AS
Christian Thiel is a Chief Executive with focus on bringing new technologies
from idea to installation. His primary experience comprises the energy and
energy-related technology sector – ranging from e-mobility over renewable energies to energy storage. Christian joined EnergyNest in 2014 and has
previously been working for BMW Group, UBS Investment Bank, McKinsey as
well as SENVION. Christian holds a PhD in Economics, a Diploma in Business
Administration as well as a B.A. in European Business.
Christopher Koch
Portfolio Management CWE, Markedskraft Deutschland GmbH
Christopher Koch is working for the continental portfolio management team of
Markedskraft. His main tasks include the analysis and assessment of trading
strategies and the evaluation of fundamental forecasts. He also concentrates on price forecasting for the EPEX SPOT intraday market. Additionally he
is involved in product development for the short-term markets and jointly
responsible for Markedskraft’s association work. Besides his operations at
the central western European energy markets, he also gained experience in
projects at the Spanish short-term markets.
4 Transformative Forces in the Energy Market 2015
Line Riise Jensen
Director Corporate Sales, ECOHZ AS
ECOHZ is a leading international specialist and provider of global renewable energy solutions to large enterprises and electricity suppliers. Line Riise
Jensen has broad international experience through various positions in sales,
business development and project management within the telecom sector for
more than ten years before joining ECOHZ and the renewable energy sector in
2008. She holds a Master of Science Degree in Business Administration from
Norway, in addition to university studies abroad.
Ranngveig Sofie Stangeland
VP Governmental, Regulatory and Management Affairs, Marketing & Trading, Statoil ASA
Rannveig S. Stangeland holds a master degree from London School of Economics (LSE) and a bachelor’s degree in political science from the University of
Oslo and Amsterdam. Her responsibilities cover energy policy- and regulatory
issues relating to Statoil’s downstream business and relations with Petoro
which handles the Norwegian state’s direct financial interests (SDFI) linked
to Statoil’s marketing activities. Since joining Statoil in 1996 she has held a
variety of positions including responsibilities within communication both
upstream and downstream, part of Statoil’s IPO project, VP communication for
natural gas, head of natural gas strategy etc. She currently serves as chair of
the Norwegian Gas Association.
Øyvind Stakkland
Director, Agder Energi AS
Øyvind Stakkeland holds a Master of Science degree from the Norwegian
University of Technology and Science (NTNU) in Trondheim. Since he graduated
in 1988 he has been working in consultancy and in the industry. In 1998 he
started in the renewable energy business at the utility company Agder Energi.
At Agder Energi Øyvind Stakkeland had different positions within business development, including wind and interconnector projects, and within regulatory
work and strategy development.
5
Ingard Moen
Senior Vice President – Grid Planning and Analysis, Statnett SF
Ingard Moen has been with Statnett since 2010. He began his career in the
electricity industry in 1999 as Senior Market Analyst at Electrabel Nordic
(Oslo). He moved to Brussels in 2005 and worked as Senior Energy Market
Analyst and Head of Market analysis at Electrabel Trading & Portfolio Management. In 2008 he returned to Oslo to become Senior Energy Market Analyst
– Nordic Region at EDF Trading. In Statnett he has been involved in developing
the German and UK interconnector projects. Currently he is heading Statnett`s
grid planning and analysis section.
Jørgen Festervoll
Partner ADAPT Consulting AS
Jørgen Festervoll is a partner at ADAPT, a consulting firm specializing in energy
and climate related issues. As a trusted advisor for a range of Norwegian and
international clients, he has provided advise on issues ranging from strategy
and business development to M&A, due diligence processes and PPA negotiations as well as regulatory issues and market design. He has been lead consultant on several CCGT projects including CCS studies. He is also an expert on
energy efficiency, smart grid, DM and distributed production. Mr. Festervoll is
frequently used as a speaker and moderator.
6 Transformative Forces in the Energy Market 2015
Participants
acatech - National Academy of Science and Engineering
ADAPT Consulting AS
Advance Business Partner AS
AF Gruppen
Agder Energi AS
Agder Energi Vannkraft AS
Agora Energiewende
Aquila Capital Concepts GmbH
Arendals Fossekompani
Argus Media
Art & Life
Auswärtiges Amt
Auswärtiges Amt
Auswärtiges Amt
Auswärtiges Amt
BDEW e.V.
Bergen Energi
Bergen Energi
BI Norwegian Business School
Borderstep Institute for Innovation and Sustainability
Bulk Infrastructure AS
Bundeskanzleramt
Bundesministerium für Ernährung und Landwirtschaft Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Energie
Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Energie
Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Energie
Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Energie
Bundesverband der Deutschen Industrie e.V.
Bundesverband der Deutschen Industrie e.V. Bundesverband Kraft-Wärmekopplung e.V. (B.KWK)
Bundesverband Neue Energiewirtschaft e.V. (bne)
Burson-Marsteller
Cambi Deutschland GmbH
CICERO Centre for International Climate and Environmental
Research Oslo
Covestro Deutschland AG
CURRENTA GmbH &Co. OHG
DEKRA e. V. Deutsche Bahn AG
Deutsche Bahn AG
Deutscher Bundestag, MdB-Büro
Deutscher Sparkassen- und Giroverband
Kathrin Goldammer
Jørgen Festervoll
Tore Karlstad
Tor Olsen
Øyvind Stakkeland
Robert Palme
Stephanie Ropenus
Roman Rosslenbroich
Torkil Mogstad
Chloe Jardine
Cathrin von Seld-Thiel
Guido Brückelmann
Dr. Holgar Karl Kolley
Peter Fischer
Holgar Kolley
Barbara Willich
Heiner Walbaum
Stefan Sanne
May-Britt Moxness
Linda Bergset
Peder Nærbø
Dr. Susanne Parlasca
Clemens Neumann
MDgt‘in Ursula Borak
Andreas Obersteller MDG
Dr. Dieter Mentz
Bernd Kloke
Dennis Rendschmidt
Anne Feldhusen
Wulf Binde
Karsten Wiedemann
Christian Thams
Henrik Kruchen
Anne Therese Gullberg
Ulrich Garthe
Dr.-Ing. Ilka Teermann
Christopher Fürst
Werner Raithmayr
Dr. Volker Kefer
Kathrin Kortmann
Astrid Beste
7
DEW21
DLA Piper Norway
DLA Piper Norway
DNV GL-Energy
DNV GL-Energy
DONG Energy Markets GmbH
Dow Deutschland Inc
E.ON SE
E.ON SE ECG Energie-Consulting GmbH
ECOHZ AS
ECOHZ AS
EFET Deutschland
Embassy of Canada
Embassy of the Republic of Poland
Enegia Portfolio Services
energiegewinn
EnergyNest AS
enerion
enerion
enervis energy advisors GmbH
EnviTech
EnviTech AS
Enwa
Erste Lesung GmbH
EUCERS - European Centre for Energy and Resource
Security King‘s College London
European Commission
European Energy Exchange AG
EVM GmbH
Evonik Technology & Infrastructure GmbH
EW Medien und Kongresse GmbH
EWI Köln
ExxonMobil
Federal Ministry of Economic Affairs and Energy
Fichtner Management Consulting AG
Frankfurter Allgemeine Forum
Fraunhofer IWES
Fred. Olsen Windcarrier
Freie Jounalistin
Freie Universität Berlin
GasVersorgung Süddeutschland GmbH 8 Transformative Forces in the Energy Market 2015
Frank Dr. Brinkmann
Anders Lenborg
Christoph Morck
Dr. Andreas Schröter
Claas F. Hülsen
Matthias Wendel
Birgit Ortlieb
Joachim Lang Dr.
Dr. Joachim Lang
Dr. Jürgen Joseph
Line Riise Jensen
Birgit Nielsen Scholtholt
Barbara Lempp
Habib Massoud
Iwona Jakuszko-Dudka
Michael Weber
Dr. agr. Olaf Schätzchen
Dr. Christian Thiel
Philipp Klever
Malte Jensen
Sebastian Klein
Stein Jørgen Ryan
Dag Joar Larsen
Ketil Tømmernes
Jonas Quincke
Philipp Offenberg
Martin Stasek
Robert Gersdorf
Olaf Schneider
Dr. Jan Brübach
Christina Berlin
Prof. Dr. Marc Oliver Bettzüge
Axel von Maltzahn
Andreas Obersteller
Sabine Siebald
André Philip Pantel
Dr. Stefan Bofinger
Felix Fliege
Astrid Fischer
Lutz Mez
Helmut Kusterer
GePe Geoservice
GO2-markets GmbH
GO2-markets GmbH
GO2-markets.com
GP Geoservice GmbH
GP JOULE GmbH Gridacy GmbH
Grundgrün Energie GmbH
GWI Bauunternehmung GmbH
Hill+Knowlton Strategies
Holcim AG
HUMBOLDT VIADRINA Governance Platform
Hydro Aluminium Rolled Products GmbH
IMPaC Offshore Engineering
Innovation Norway
Innovation Norway
Innovation Norway
Innovation Norway
Innovationsforum Energiewende e.V.
INTPOW Norwegian Renewable Energy Partners
IST GmbH - Gesellschaft für angewandte Sozial-
wissenschaft und Statistik
JB EMS Executive & Management Services
KfW IPEX-Bank GmbH KlimaExpo.NRW
Lekker Energie GmbH
LichtBlick SE
Lyse AS
Lyse AS
Markedskraft Deutschland GmbH
MeteoGroup
Miljøbygg Norge AS
Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems Europe GmbH
Montel
N2 Applied AS
N2 Applied AS
Nasdaq
Nasdaq
NCE Smart Energy Markets
N-ERGIE Aktiengesellschaft
Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Norwegische Botschaft
Katarzyna Marks
Jennifer Rosner
Paul Petereit
Agneta Ersova
Marcin Pussak
Timo Bovi
Dr. Kai Wu
Sandra Lenz
Karl-Jürgen Athens
Christina Heß
Werner Carstensen
Katja Treichel
Thomas Mock
Joachim Berger
Bjørn Petter Skjeltorp
Gerda Geyer
Henning Kloster-Jensen
Katja Kerschke
Werner Voss
Jon Dugstad
Prof. Dr. Wolf Schluchter
Jürgen Beigel
Dr. Heinz Staake
Dr. Heinrich Dornbusch
Josef Thomas Sepp
Anna Kamlage
Eimund Nygaard
Ove Jølbo
Christopher Koch
Lutz Bertram
Knut Hovland
Robert Kammel
Jörg Schultheiss
Grete Sønsteby
Rune Ingels
Konstantin Lenz
Anja Weiss
Dieter Hirdes
Ingo Sigert
Knut-Are Okstad
Liv Maren Røste
9
Norwegische Botschaft
Norwegisches Honorarkonsulat Hamburg
nuances GmbH & Co KG
Nymoen Strategieberatung GmbH & Co.KG
Plambeck Holding GmbH
Renewables Grid Initiative
Rolls-Royce Power Systems AG
Royal Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Seatower
Siemens AG
Siemens AG
Sogn og Fjordane County municipality
Stadtwerke Annaberg-Buchholz
Stadtwerke München GmbH
Stadtwerke Wolfsburg AG
Statkraft AS
Statkraft Markets GmbH
Statkraft Markets GmbH
Statnett SF
Statnett SF
Statoil ASA
Statoil ASA
Statoil ASA
Statoil ASA
Statoil ASA
STEAG GmbH
Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik
Strategisk Bedriftsutvikling AS
Swiss Re Capital Markets Limited Swissgrid
TenneT
TenneT
Tocircle Industries AS
TrailStone GmbH
TRETTIN - Rechtsanwaltskanzlei
Umweltbundesamt (Federal Environment Agency)
University of Flensburg
VDI/VDE Innovation + Technik GmbH
Verband der Industriellen Energie- und Kraftwirtschaft e.V.
VNG - Verbundnetz Gas AG
Wacker Chemie AG
Weltenergierat – Deutschland e.V. 10 Transformative Forces in the Energy Market 2015
Tobias Frambe Svenningsen
Detlef Palm
Markus Rosenthal
Dr. Håvard Nymoen
Norbert Plambeck
Julien Sialelli
Karsten Suchier
Jon Hansen
Niels Brix
Victoria Orioli
Nils Müller
Audun Erik Sunde
Jörg Tettewitz
Gregor Neunzert
Dr. Frank Kästner
Sascha Schröder
Claudia Gellert
Stefan-Jörg Göbel
Ingard Moen
Carl-Jørgen Greidung
Rune Valen
Christian Schülke
Tobias Naeschke
Rannveig Sofie Stangeland
Trine Kloster
Gregor Timmerhaus
Christian Opitz
Erling Eriksen
Teresa Schorstein
Christian Kunze
Markus Nalepinski
Gunnar Spengel
Nico Hytten
Felix Buchholz
Dirk Trettin
Mark Nowakowski
Irina Stamo
Dr. Werner Wilke
Barbara Minderjahn
Jörn Lachmann
Christian Essers
Nicole Kaim-Albers
Weltenergierat – Deutschland e.V. Wintershall
Wintershall Holding GmbH
Wintershall Holding GmbH
Wintershall Holding GmbH
Wintershall Holding GmbH
Dr. Frank Holtrup
Andre Findeisen
Jürgen Möpert
Cristina-Cezara Missing
Ludger Radermacher
Georg Hiemann
Matthias Dornfeldt
11
Notes
12 Transformative Forces in the Energy Market 2015
Notes
13
Notes
14 Transformative Forces in the Energy Market 2015
Notes
15
In cooperation and with the kind support of:
Organized by
Innovation Norway
Caffamacherreihe 5
D-20355Hamburg
www.innovationnorway.no
Contact:
Gerda Geyer
Head of Energy & Environment
Telephone: (+49) 40 22 94 15 58
[email protected]