EXECUTIVE COUNCIL REDACTED
Transcription
EXECUTIVE COUNCIL REDACTED
EXECUTIVE COUNCIL PUBLIC REDACTED Title of Report: Pay Benchmarking Paper No: 148 /14 Date: 16 July 2014 Report of: Director of Human Resources 1.0 Purpose Hay Group were commissioned to conduct a review of pay rates and provide data to allow comparisons to be made against international markets. 2.0 Recommendations 2.1 That Executive Council is advised to: (a) Note the contents of the HAY Group Benchmarking report May 2014 3.0 Additional Budgetary Implications 3.1 None. 4.0 Background The aim of the review was to benchmark existing FIG pay rates with those from other international comparators that are likely to be sources of future employees. FIG use a Hays job evaluation system and Hay Group were best placed to provide comparable data sets from an international perspective. To use an alternative data source would have required a full job evaluation review before benchmarking could be undertaken. This benchmarking was not intended to assess relocation packages or allowances for international workers nor does it cover the relative economic or cost of living differences. It is solely to guide to give an indication of basic pay for equal work against the international comparators. It is recommended that this is an area of research that should be undertaken in 2014/15. 5.0 Summary of Report The overall finding of the benchmarking was that FIG grades and basic salaries were closely aligned with UK public sector median pay rates. Where they differ, this is a consequence of skill shortages reflecting specific issues either in the international comparator or in the Falkland Islands. In addition to the FIG pay scales being benchmarked internationally, 100 specific job roles were selected by departments to be benchmarked against the UK market. The analysis shows that there was very close alignment with jobs of equal job weight. The only outliers’ were 5 roles which attracted a median salary in the UK above the FIG maximum and 2 which were paid higher rates in the Falkland Islands compared to the UK. This provides a very high level of confidence that our current pay scales are comparable with the UK market. That said, the following should be addressed though new work streams: • Policing grades in FIG did not correlate directly to UK police grades. Based on current job evaluation scores, the salary is comparable with the UK median for the job weight. This suggests that we are paying an appropriate rate to our police officers but the role of a police officer in the Falklands does not carry the same levels of knowledge, responsibility or experience. A review of the role and responsibility of police grades should be undertaken. • FIG pay scale has several overlaps which require realignment with the grade structure. This should be addressed by reviewing the pay scales and transitioning a new pay scale linked to a pay strategy. • While basic salaries may be comparable, there has been no progression along the scales in recent years. This is creating multiple reference points on the pay scale and is not sustainable. This is also counter to our current pay approach of rewarding people for time served. This should be reviewed with a new pay strategy being developed. • Basic pay levels being equal will not be sufficient in attracting contract officers in an international market. Overall relocation and remuneration packages for contract officers should be benchmarked to ensure they are competitive in the international markets we operate. • Market data for UK NHS grades does not reflect the reality of those in UK private practice and working partly for the NHS. This is a typical arrangement in many of the medical grades where UK staff will command much higher salaries than the NHS comparison data. A review of the staffing model for FIG medical grades should be undertaken to ensure we can continue to attract suitably qualified staff and where possible secure a talent pipeline that is sustainable in the longer term. • There were some examples of salary difference as a result of local market pressures. These are best addressed by the introduction of temporary market supplements or recruitment and retention premium. Hays have provided market data for other international countries. Foreign exchange rates are a significant influencer and this data is only valid on the date the exchange rate was calculated (1 May 2014). Based on the median values, the data would suggest that we are not competitive against the majority of international markets other than Chile and Uruguay. Recruitment of professional and senior staff from both these countries would be challenging given that they are both importers of these skills given their own economic positions. Chile is potentially a source of economic labour in the context of core FIG grades. Country Australia Canada New Zealand USA Chile Uruguay Impact on FIG grades (I to C) Not competitive Not competitive Not competitive Not competitive Competitive Competitive core Impact on senior positions (B to A1) Not competitive Not competitive Not competitive Not competitive Not competitive Competitive No cost of living analysis has been considered as part of this benchmarking but is unlikely to influence the results significantly given the favourable income tax rates in the Falkland Islands. In summary, our rates of basic pay for local staff and contract staff are broadly comparable for work of equal value in the UK. We are not competitive in the majority of the international markets surveyed. 6.0 Financial Implications None for the purpose of this paper 7. Legal Implications None for the purpose of this paper 8. Human Resources Implications None for the purpose of this paper. 05 | 2014 Falklands Islands Government International Data Provision 2 FIG International Data Provision Contents 1- Executive Summary 3 2- Introduction 4 3- FIG pay scales benchmark 5 - UK 5 - Australia 7 - Canada 9 - New Zealand 11 - USA 13 - Chile 15 - Uruguay 17 4- Individual job UK Benchmark 19 - Other countries 22 5- Country Practices & Country Indicator 23 6- Appendices UK Public Data 24 - Other countries © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved 33 www.haygroup.com 3 FIG International Data Provision 1. Executive Summary Overall Summary The aim of the review is to benchmark existing pay rates from Falklands Island Government (FIG) with those from other comparable international comparators that are likely to be future sources of employees. Based on our public sector Paynet remuneration databases, the current FIG salary grades have been compared and benchmarked against the UK but also US, Chile, Uruguay, Australia, Canada and New Zealand. Overall FIG grades are aligned with the UK public sector market median, notably for grades I, H2, G1, F, E1 and D1. Only one grade (H1) appears to be more competitive than the UK public sector, remunerating close to £1,000 more than the UK market. A shift can be noticed for grades such as E2, D2 and C, in which FIG grades pay markedly less than the UK public sector. Grades (B & A) appear to be in-line with UK public sector market, notably at market median level. The higher grades (A1, A2 & A3) are competitive against the UK public sector median and lower end of the scale (lower quartile and lower decile). In contrast, these grades are trailing behind the market for the upper decile. Some overlaps between grades can be noticed, notably between H2 and G1; as well as D1 and D2. The individual analysis reveals that only a handful of roles are outside the minimum and maximum FIG pay ranges. Within grades I – C, roles such as HGV driver, plant operator, cook, social work assistant, meat hygiene inspector, building advisor and financial accountant were outliers against the UK median. Caveats to be considered are that no cost of living has been adopted and benchmark data are provided in local currency. Publicly available data as well as reward/economic practices can help supplement the HayGroup pay data for contextual information for each respective country. Nonetheless, it was difficult to find public data for many Commonwealth countries and South American countries. This report compares local base salaries and does not include any enhancements paid to expatriates. Whether a particular salary is sufficient to retain or attract particular groups of staff has not been considered in this research. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 4 FIG International Data Provision 2. Introduction Context of the project The Falkland Islands Government (FIG) employ a range of people to perform most of the functions associated with any local authority and in addition provide the services also associated with the NHS and Central Government departments. The aim of the review is to benchmark your existing pay rates with those from other comparable international comparators that are likely to be future sources of employees. International comparators are likely to include public sector organisations in the UK, US, Chile, Uruguay, Australia, Canada and New Zealand. You have provided FIG pay scales as well as number of roles to be reviewed, which were previously slotted using our proprietary job evaluation methodology to provide an accurate assessment of job size. All reward information will be taken from our PayNet Remuneration Databases or available published data. In addition, we propose to provide in separate reports, country political and economic environment and economic indicator as well as country reward practices. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 5 FIG International Data Provision 3. FIG pay scales benchmark Based on our public sector Paynet remuneration databases, the current FIG salary grades have been compared and benchmarked. Each FIG grade is associated to our HayGroup methodology, making a direct link to the Paynet databases. For grades I to C, step 4 is linked to the public sector market median, with an increment step of +3.5% or -3.5% along the scale. For grade B to A3, a different approach has been taken. The first quartile is associated to the lower decile, second quartile to the lower quartile, mid-point to the median, third quartile to the upper quartile and finally fourth quartile to the upper decile of the public sector market. Please bear in mind that the benchmark is in local currency with no cost of living consideration. The countries outside the UK have been converted to GBP, based on the conversion rates from the 1st May 2014 UK Table 1 FIG – Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup UK Public sector (Grades I – C) Grade I (GBP) UK Public (GBP) H1 UK Public (GBP) H2 UK Public (GBP) G1 UK Public (GBP) G2 UK Public (GBP) F UK Public (GBP) E1 UK Public (GBP) E2 UK Public (GBP) D1 UK Public (GBP) D2 UK Public (GBP) C UK Public (GBP) KnowHow 57 66 76 87 100 115 132 152 175 200 230 Step 1 12,463 12,275 14,304 13,427 14,304 14,250 16,158 15,466 16,158 17,183 19,146 19,449 22,304 22,014 22,304 24,096 27,624 27,050 27,624 30,539 33,003 34,256 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Step 2 12,896 12,721 14,809 13,914 14,809 14,766 16,734 16,027 16,734 17,806 19,847 20,155 23,110 22,812 23,110 24,970 28,620 28,031 28,620 31,647 34,202 35,498 Step 3 13,347 13,182 15,333 14,419 15,333 15,302 17,338 16,609 17,338 18,452 20,568 20,885 23,955 23,640 23,955 25,876 29,662 29,047 29,662 32,795 35,434 36,786 Step 4 13,812 13,660 15,870 14,942 15,870 15,857 17,967 17,211 17,967 19,121 21,302 21,643 24,813 24,497 24,813 26,814 30,736 30,101 30,736 33,984 36,725 38,120 Step 5 14,297 14,138 16,420 15,465 16,420 16,412 18,622 17,813 18,622 19,790 22,075 22,401 25,711 25,354 25,711 27,752 31,850 31,155 31,850 35,173 38,055 39,454 Step 6 14,782 14,633 16,991 16,006 16,991 16,986 19,270 18,437 19,270 20,483 22,847 23,185 26,622 26,242 26,622 28,724 32,964 32,245 32,964 36,405 39,385 40,835 Step 7 15,274 15,145 17,580 16,566 17,580 17,581 19,945 19,082 19,945 21,200 23,654 23,996 27,545 27,160 27,545 29,729 34,117 33,374 34,117 37,679 40,768 42,264 Step 8 Step 9 18,196 18,196 18,825 18,833 20,647 21,942 21,354 22,710 28,502 30,770 29,511 31,847 35,304 38,997 36,548 40,362 www.haygroup.com 6 FIG International Data Provision Overall FIG grades are aligned with the UK public sector market median, notably for grades I, H2, G1, F, E1 and D1. Only one grade (H1) appears to be more competitive than the UK public sector, remunerating close to £1,000 more than the UK market. A shift can be noticed for grades such as E2, D2 and C, in which FIG grades pay markedly less than the UK public sector. Some overlaps between grades can be noticed, notably between H2 and G1; as well as D1 and D2. Table 2 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup UK Public sector (Grades B – A3) Grade Grade B (GBP) UK Public (GBP) Grade A (GBP) UK Public (GBP) Grade A1 (GBP) UK Public (GBP) Grade A2 (GBP) UK Public (GBP) Grade A3 (GBP) UK Public (GBP) KnowHow 264 304/350 400 460 528 Lower Decile 37,144 36,996 44,417 47,098 66,471 61,015 83,073 70,915 94,114 84,320 Lower Quartile 40,421 39,568 49,980 51,122 70,364 65,334 87,228 78,705 102,416 91,057 Median 43,690 43,152 55,542 54,985 74,254 71,217 91,376 86,687 110,723 100,770 Upper Quartile 46,966 47,645 61,112 61,722 78,147 80,000 95,529 99,144 119,024 118,514 Upper Decile 50,242 54,743 66,674 73,468 82,039 94,159 99,683 119,020 127,333 138,839 Grades (B & A) appear to be in-line with UK public sector market, notably at market median level. The higher grades (A1, A2 & A3) are competitive against the UK public sector median and lower end of the scale (lower quartile and lower decile). In contrast, these grades are trailing behind the market for the upper decile. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 7 FIG International Data Provision Australia Table 3 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup AUS Public sector (Grades I – C) Grade I (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP H1 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP H2 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP G1 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP G2 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP F (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP E1 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP E2 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP D1 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP D2 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP C (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP KnowHow Step 1 12,463 Step 2 12,896 Step 3 13,347 Step 4 13,812 Step 5 14,297 Step 6 14,782 Step 7 15,274 14,304 14,809 15,333 15,870 16,420 16,991 17,580 14,304 44,011 24,168 16,158 44,364 24,362 16,158 49,803 27,350 19,146 54,173 29,751 22,304 55,874 30,685 22,304 62,674 34,419 27,624 73,390 40,303 27,624 83,160 45,668 33,003 92,025 50,537 14,809 45,607 25,044 16,734 45,973 25,245 16,734 51,609 28,342 19,847 56,138 30,830 23,110 57,901 31,798 23,110 64,947 35,667 28,620 76,052 41,765 28,620 86,176 47,325 34,202 95,363 52,370 15,333 47,261 25,953 17,338 47,640 26,161 17,338 53,481 29,370 20,568 58,174 31,948 23,955 60,001 32,951 23,955 67,303 36,961 29,662 78,811 43,280 29,662 89,302 49,041 35,434 98,822 54,269 15,870 48,975 26,894 17,967 49,368 27,110 17,967 55,421 30,435 21,302 60,284 33,106 24,813 62,177 34,146 24,813 69,744 38,302 30,736 81,669 44,849 30,736 92,541 50,820 36,725 102,406 56,238 16,420 50,689 27,835 18,622 51,096 28,059 18,622 57,361 31,500 22,075 62,394 34,265 25,711 64,353 35,341 25,711 72,185 39,642 31,850 84,527 46,419 31,850 95,780 52,599 38,055 105,990 58,206 16,991 52,463 28,809 19,270 52,884 29,041 19,270 59,368 32,603 22,847 64,578 35,464 26,622 66,606 36,578 26,622 74,712 41,030 32,964 87,486 48,044 32,964 99,132 54,440 39,385 109,700 60,243 17,580 54,299 29,818 19,945 54,735 30,057 19,945 61,446 33,744 23,654 66,838 36,706 27,545 68,937 37,858 27,545 77,326 42,466 34,117 90,548 49,725 34,117 102,602 56,345 40,768 113,539 62,352 Step 8 Step 9 18,196 56,200 30,861 18,825 58,167 31,941 20,647 63,597 34,925 21,354 65,823 36,147 28,502 80,033 43,952 29,511 82,834 45,490 35,304 106,193 58,317 36,548 109,910 60,358 57 66 76 87 100 115 132 152 175 200 230 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 8 FIG International Data Provision Table 4 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup AUS Public sector (Grades B – A3) Grade Grade B (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP Grade A (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP Grade A1 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP Grade A2 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP Grade A3 (GBP) AUS Public (AUD) Indicative GBP KnowHow 264 304/350 400 460 528 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Lower Decile 37,144 90,522 49,720 44,417 114,917 63,120 66,471 143,232 78,674 83,073 178,343 97,974 94,114 Lower Quartile 40,421 100,403 55,147 49,980 131,098 72,007 70,364 168,173 92,373 87,228 211,930 116,425 102,416 231,037 126,908 Median 43,690 120,821 66,362 55,542 150,840 82,851 74,254 193,789 106,456 91,376 251,135 137,954 110,723 259,363 142,468 Upper Quartile 46,966 136,391 74,914 61,112 174,186 95,674 78,147 224,065 123,088 95,529 304,396 167,212 119,024 323,231 177,550 Upper Decile 50,242 149,139 81,916 66,674 197,576 108,524 82,039 249,445 137,030 99,683 347,118 190,680 127,333 www.haygroup.com 9 FIG International Data Provision Canada Table 5 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup CAN Public sector (Grades I – C) Grade I (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP H1 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP H2 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP G1 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP G2 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP F (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP E1 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP E2 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP D1 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP D2 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP C (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP KnowHow 57 66 76 87 100 115 132 152 175 200 230 Step 1 12,463 35,435 19,104 14,304 37,972 20,471 14,304 38,586 20,802 16,158 39,770 21,432 16,158 41,546 22,388 19,146 47,109 25,387 22,304 51,448 27,726 22,304 53,984 29,094 27,624 61,330 33,056 27,624 67,071 36,151 33,003 74,301 40,046 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Step 2 12,896 36,720 19,797 14,809 39,349 21,213 14,809 39,986 21,556 16,734 41,212 22,210 16,734 43,053 23,200 19,847 48,818 26,307 23,110 53,314 28,732 23,110 55,942 30,149 28,620 63,554 34,255 28,620 69,504 37,462 34,202 76,996 41,499 Step 3 13,347 38,052 20,515 15,333 40,776 21,982 15,333 41,436 22,338 17,338 42,707 23,015 17,338 44,615 24,042 20,568 50,588 27,262 23,955 55,247 29,774 23,955 57,971 31,242 29,662 65,859 35,498 29,662 72,025 38,821 35,434 79,788 43,004 Step 4 13,812 39,432 21,259 15,870 42,255 22,780 15,870 42,939 23,149 17,967 44,256 23,850 17,967 46,233 24,914 21,302 52,423 28,250 24,813 57,251 30,854 24,813 60,074 32,375 30,736 68,248 36,785 30,736 74,637 40,229 36,725 82,682 44,564 Step 5 14,297 40,812 22,004 16,420 43,734 23,577 16,420 44,442 23,959 18,622 45,805 24,685 18,622 47,851 25,786 22,075 54,258 29,239 25,711 59,255 31,934 25,711 62,177 33,508 31,850 70,637 38,073 31,850 77,249 41,637 38,055 85,576 46,124 Step 6 14,782 42,241 22,774 16,991 45,265 24,402 16,991 45,997 24,797 19,270 47,408 25,548 19,270 49,526 26,688 22,847 56,157 30,262 26,622 61,329 33,052 26,622 64,353 34,681 32,964 73,109 39,405 32,964 79,953 43,094 39,385 88,571 47,738 Step 7 15,274 43,719 23,571 17,580 46,849 25,256 17,580 47,607 25,665 19,945 49,067 26,443 19,945 51,259 27,623 23,654 58,122 31,322 27,545 63,475 34,208 27,545 66,605 35,895 34,117 75,668 40,784 34,117 82,751 44,603 40,768 91,671 49,409 Step 8 Step 9 18,196 49,273 26,563 18,825 50,998 27,493 20,647 53,053 28,589 21,354 54,910 29,590 28,502 68,936 37,151 29,511 71,349 38,452 35,304 85,648 46,164 36,548 88,645 47,779 www.haygroup.com 10 FIG International Data Provision Table 6 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup CAN Public sector (Grades B – A3) Grade Grade B (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP Grade A (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP Grade A1 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP Grade A2 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP Grade A3 (GBP) CAN Public (CAD) Indicative GBP KnowHow 264 304/350 400 460 528 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Lower Decile 37,144 73,453 39,686 44,417 87,247 47,135 66,471 103,688 56,008 83,073 120,232 64,937 94,114 133,960 72,351 Lower Quartile 40,421 82,627 44,643 49,980 96,945 52,373 70,364 115,672 62,476 87,228 130,466 70,464 102,416 147,562 79,698 Median 43,690 91,700 49,545 55,542 107,225 57,926 74,254 128,319 69,307 91,376 143,123 77,299 110,723 165,709 89,499 Upper Quartile 46,966 99,648 53,835 61,112 116,925 63,158 78,147 141,579 76,468 95,529 160,545 86,708 119,024 182,112 98,358 Upper Decile 50,242 109,773 59,305 66,674 126,117 68,123 82,039 154,531 83,461 99,683 174,758 94,384 127,333 200,000 108,019 www.haygroup.com 11 FIG International Data Provision New Zealand Table 7 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup NZ Public sector (Grades I – C) Grade I (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP H1 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP H2 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP G1 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP G2 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP F (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP E1 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP E2 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP D1 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP D2 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP C (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP KnowHow Step 1 12,463 Step 2 12,896 Step 3 13,347 Step 4 13,812 Step 5 14,297 Step 6 14,782 Step 7 15,274 14,304 14,809 15,333 15,870 16,420 16,991 17,580 14,304 30,958 15,791 16,158 34,968 17,836 16,158 36,530 18,633 19,146 40,557 20,687 22,304 44,451 22,673 22,304 49,035 25,012 27,624 54,587 27,842 27,624 63,403 32,339 33,003 73,703 37,591 14,809 32,081 16,364 16,734 36,236 18,483 16,734 37,855 19,309 19,847 42,028 21,437 23,110 46,063 23,496 23,110 50,813 25,919 28,620 56,566 28,852 28,620 65,703 33,512 34,202 76,376 38,955 15,333 33,244 16,958 17,338 37,550 19,153 17,338 39,228 20,009 20,568 43,552 22,215 23,955 47,734 24,348 23,955 52,656 26,859 29,662 58,618 29,899 29,662 68,086 34,728 35,434 79,146 40,368 15,870 34,450 17,573 17,967 38,912 19,848 17,967 40,651 20,735 21,302 45,132 23,021 24,813 49,465 25,231 24,813 54,566 27,833 30,736 60,744 30,983 30,736 70,555 35,987 36,725 82,017 41,832 16,420 35,656 18,188 18,622 40,274 20,543 18,622 42,074 21,461 22,075 46,712 23,826 25,711 51,196 26,114 25,711 56,476 28,807 31,850 62,870 32,067 31,850 73,024 37,247 38,055 84,888 43,296 16,991 36,904 18,824 19,270 41,684 21,262 19,270 43,546 22,212 22,847 48,347 24,660 26,622 52,988 27,028 26,622 58,452 29,815 32,964 65,070 33,190 32,964 75,580 38,550 39,385 87,859 44,811 17,580 38,195 19,483 19,945 43,142 22,006 19,945 45,070 22,989 23,654 50,039 25,523 27,545 54,843 27,974 27,545 60,498 30,859 34,117 67,348 34,351 34,117 78,226 39,900 40,768 90,934 46,379 Step 8 Step 9 18,196 39,532 20,165 18,825 40,916 20,871 20,647 46,648 23,794 21,354 48,281 24,627 28,502 62,616 31,939 29,511 64,807 33,057 35,304 80,963 41,296 36,548 83,797 42,742 57 66 76 87 100 115 132 152 175 200 230 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 12 FIG International Data Provision Table 8 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup NZ Public sector (Grades B – A3) Grade Grade B (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP Grade A (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP Grade A1 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP Grade A2 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP Grade A3 (GBP) NZ Public (NZD) Indicative GBP KnowHow 264 304/350 400 460 528 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Lower Decile 37,144 81,887 41,852 44,417 101,907 52,083 66,471 130,988 66,959 83,073 159,925 81,746 94,114 177,527 90,736 Lower Quartile 40,421 87,696 44,821 49,980 112,985 57,745 70,364 146,000 74,633 87,228 168,582 86,172 102,416 189,528 96,877 Median 43,690 96,645 49,394 55,542 125,522 64,158 74,254 160,000 81,790 91,376 182,692 93,378 110,723 211,667 108,193 Upper Quartile 46,966 107,567 54,972 61,112 138,271 70,675 78,147 175,145 89,532 95,529 203,046 103,782 119,024 238,140 121,725 Upper Decile 50,242 119,864 61,260 66,674 152,389 77,898 82,039 190,368 97,308 99,683 224,526 114,757 127,333 274,346 140,235 www.haygroup.com 13 FIG International Data Provision USA Table 9 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup US Public sector (Grades I – C) Grade I (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP H1 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP H2 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP G1 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP G2 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP F (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP E1 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP E2 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP D1 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP D2 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP C (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP KnowHow 57 66 76 87 100 115 132 152 175 200 230 Step 1 12,463 23,757 14,049 14,304 26,691 15,784 14,304 28,252 16,708 16,158 28,626 16,929 16,158 34,289 20,279 19,146 34,313 20,293 22,304 35,624 21,069 22,304 38,998 23,064 27,624 62,178 36,776 27,624 65,716 38,869 33,003 69,456 41,081 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Step 2 12,896 24,619 14,558 14,809 27,659 16,356 14,809 29,277 17,314 16,734 29,664 17,543 16,734 35,533 21,014 19,847 35,558 21,029 23,110 36,917 21,833 23,110 40,412 23,901 28,620 64,433 38,110 28,620 68,100 40,279 34,202 71,975 42,571 Step 3 13,347 25,512 15,086 15,333 28,662 16,950 15,333 30,339 17,942 17,338 30,740 18,180 17,338 36,822 21,777 20,568 36,848 21,792 23,955 38,255 22,625 23,955 41,878 24,768 29,662 66,770 39,492 29,662 70,569 41,739 35,434 74,586 44,115 Step 4 13,812 26,437 15,634 15,870 29,702 17,564 15,870 31,439 18,593 17,967 31,855 18,839 17,967 38,157 22,566 21,302 38,184 22,582 24,813 39,643 23,446 24,813 43,397 25,666 30,736 69,192 40,925 30,736 73,129 43,253 36,725 77,291 45,715 Step 5 14,297 27,362 16,181 16,420 30,742 18,179 16,420 32,539 19,244 18,622 32,970 19,498 18,622 39,492 23,356 22,075 39,520 23,373 25,711 41,031 24,266 25,711 44,916 26,564 31,850 71,614 42,357 31,850 75,689 44,767 38,055 79,996 47,315 Step 6 14,782 28,320 16,747 16,991 31,818 18,815 16,991 33,678 19,917 19,270 34,124 20,181 19,270 40,875 24,174 22,847 40,904 24,191 26,622 42,467 25,116 26,622 46,488 27,494 32,964 74,120 43,840 32,964 78,338 46,334 39,385 82,796 48,971 Step 7 15,274 29,311 17,333 17,580 32,931 19,474 17,580 34,857 20,615 19,945 35,318 20,887 19,945 42,305 25,020 23,654 42,335 25,037 27,545 43,953 25,995 27,545 48,115 28,456 34,117 76,714 45,374 34,117 81,079 47,956 40,768 85,694 50,685 Step 8 Step 9 18,196 36,077 21,336 18,825 37,340 22,083 20,647 43,786 25,895 21,354 45,319 26,802 28,502 49,799 29,452 29,511 51,542 30,483 35,304 83,917 49,634 36,548 86,854 51,371 www.haygroup.com 14 FIG International Data Provision Table 10 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup US Public sector (Grades B – A3) Grade Grade B (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP Grade A (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP Grade A1 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP Grade A2 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP Grade A3 (GBP) US Public (USD) Indicative GBP KnowHow 264 304/350 400 460 528 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Lower Decile 37,144 58,130 34,393 44,417 84,421 49,948 66,471 97,987 57,973 83,073 101,254 59,902 94,114 121,006 71,593 Lower Quartile 40,421 66,321 39,239 49,980 96,655 57,186 70,364 112,355 66,474 87,228 124,123 73,436 102,416 133,924 79,235 Median 43,690 77,101 45,617 55,542 108,533 64,214 74,254 119,583 70,746 91,376 130,551 77,239 110,723 140,458 83,101 Upper Quartile 46,966 91,732 54,274 61,112 121,823 72,076 78,147 132,522 78,400 95,529 143,718 85,029 119,024 145,342 85,992 Upper Decile 50,242 106,191 62,829 66,674 134,684 79,685 82,039 153,959 91,083 99,683 184,802 109,338 127,333 210,558 124,578 www.haygroup.com 15 FIG International Data Provision Chile Table 11 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup Chile Public sector (Grades I – C) Grade Know-How I (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 12,463 12,896 13,347 13,812 14,297 14,782 15,274 14,304 14,809 15,333 15,870 16,420 16,991 17,580 4,358,897 4,516,992 4,680,820 4,850,591 5,020,362 5,196,074 5,377,937 4,565 4,730 4,902 5,080 5,257 5,441 5,632 Step 8 Step 9 57 Indicative GBP H1 (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) 66 Indicative GBP H2 (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) 76 14,304 14,809 15,333 15,870 16,420 16,991 17,580 18,196 18,825 5,112,274 5,297,693 5,489,838 5,688,951 5,888,064 6,094,147 6,307,442 6,528,202 6,756,689 6,836 7,075 Indicative GBP 5,353 5,548 5,749 5,957 6,166 6,382 6,605 G1 (GBP) 16,158 16,734 17,338 17,967 18,622 19,270 19,945 5,960,122 6,176,292 6,400,303 6,632,438 6,864,573 7,104,833 7,353,503 6,241 6,468 6,702 6,945 7,188 7,440 7,700 Chile Public (CLP) 87 Indicative GBP G2 (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) 100 16,158 16,734 17,338 17,967 18,622 19,270 19,945 20,647 21,354 6,960,222 7,212,665 7,474,265 7,745,352 8,016,439 8,297,015 8,587,410 8,887,970 9,199,049 9,307 9,632 Indicative GBP 7,288 7,552 7,826 8,110 8,394 8,688 8,992 F (GBP) 19,146 19,847 20,568 21,302 22,075 22,847 23,654 8,716,370 9,032,508 9,360,112 9,699,598 10,039,084 10,390,452 10,754,118 9,127 9,458 9,801 10,157 10,512 10,880 11,261 Chile Public (CLP) 115 Indicative GBP E1 (GBP) 22,304 23,110 23,955 24,813 25,711 26,622 27,545 10,604,594 10,989,217 11,387,789 11,800,818 12,213,847 12,641,331 13,083,778 Indicative GBP 11,105 11,507 11,925 12,357 12,790 13,237 13,701 E2 (GBP) 22,304 23,110 23,955 24,813 25,711 26,622 27,545 28,502 29,511 13,740,569 14,238,931 14,755,369 15,290,538 15,825,707 16,379,607 16,952,893 17,546,244 18,160,363 14,388 14,910 15,451 16,011 16,572 17,152 17,752 18,373 19,016 Chile Public (CLP) Chile Public (CLP) 132 152 Indicative GBP D1 (GBP) 27,624 28,620 29,662 30,736 31,850 32,964 34,117 17,964,321 18,615,877 19,291,064 19,990,740 20,690,416 21,414,580 22,164,091 Indicative GBP 18,811 19,493 20,200 20,933 21,666 22,424 23,209 D2 (GBP) 27,624 28,620 29,662 30,736 31,850 32,964 34,117 35,304 36,548 23,247,638 24,090,817 24,964,577 25,870,028 26,775,479 27,712,621 28,682,562 29,686,452 30,725,478 24,343 25,225 26,140 27,088 28,037 29,018 30,033 31,085 32,173 Chile Public (CLP) Chile Public (CLP) 175 200 Indicative GBP C (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) Indicative GBP 230 33,003 34,202 35,434 36,725 38,055 39,385 40,768 30,351,059 31,451,875 32,592,616 33,774,732 34,956,848 36,180,337 37,446,649 31,781 32,933 34,128 35,365 36,603 37,884 39,210 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 16 FIG International Data Provision Table 12 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup Chile Public sector (Grades B – A3) Grade Grade B (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) Indicative GBP Grade A (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) Indicative GBP Grade A1 (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) Indicative GBP Grade A2 (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) Indicative GBP Grade A3 (GBP) Chile Public (CLP) Indicative GBP KnowHow 264 304/350 400 460 528 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Lower Decile 37,144 29,235,631 30,628 44,417 43,870,942 45,960 66,471 66,095,626 69,242 83,073 76,126,848 79,751 94,114 103,450,984 108,372 Lower Quartile 40,421 35,044,016 36,714 49,980 53,262,709 55,799 70,364 77,265,918 80,944 87,228 95,456,680 100,001 102,416 120,524,170 126,257 Median 43,690 43,421,766 45,491 55,542 64,201,896 67,259 74,254 91,470,660 95,825 91,376 113,325,168 118,719 110,723 142,736,752 149,534 Upper Quartile 46,966 53,069,361 55,597 61,112 77,152,663 80,826 78,147 108,236,478 113,389 95,529 135,774,720 142,237 119,024 166,022,368 173,928 Upper Decile 50,242 63,044,365 66,047 66,674 93,440,560 97,890 82,039 128,719,747 134,847 99,683 163,865,702 171,665 127,333 199,207,204 208,693 www.haygroup.com 17 FIG International Data Provision Uruguay Table 13 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup Uruguay Public sector (Grades I – C) Grade KnowHow I (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 12,463 12,896 13,347 13,812 14,297 14,782 15,274 Step 8 Step 9 57 Indicative GBP H1 (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) 66 14,304 14,809 15,333 15,870 16,420 16,991 17,580 251,001 260,105 269,539 279,315 289,091 299,209 309,682 Indicative GBP 6,446 6,680 6,922 7,173 7,424 7,684 7,953 H2 (GBP) 14,304 14,809 15,333 15,870 16,420 16,991 17,580 18,196 18,825 306,182 317,287 328,795 340,720 352,645 364,988 377,762 390,984 404,668 7,863 8,149 8,444 8,750 9,057 9,374 9,702 10,041 10,393 Uruguay Public (UYU) 76 Indicative GBP G1 (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) 87 16,158 16,734 17,338 17,967 18,622 19,270 19,945 322,161 333,846 345,954 358,502 371,050 384,036 397,478 Indicative GBP 8,274 8,574 8,885 9,207 9,530 9,863 10,208 G2 (GBP) 16,158 16,734 17,338 17,967 18,622 19,270 19,945 20,647 21,354 356,488 369,418 382,816 396,701 410,586 424,956 439,829 455,224 471,156 9,156 9,488 9,832 10,188 10,545 10,914 11,296 11,691 12,101 Uruguay Public (UYU) 100 Indicative GBP F (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) 115 19,146 19,847 20,568 21,302 22,075 22,847 23,654 374,561 388,146 402,224 416,812 431,400 446,499 462,127 Indicative GBP 9,620 9,969 10,330 10,705 11,080 11,467 11,869 E1 (GBP) 22,304 23,110 23,955 24,813 25,711 26,622 27,545 431,269 446,911 463,120 479,917 496,714 514,099 532,093 11,077 11,478 11,895 12,326 12,758 13,204 13,666 Uruguay Public (UYU) 132 Indicative GBP E2 (GBP) 22,304 23,110 23,955 24,813 25,711 26,622 27,545 28,502 29,511 554,867 574,991 595,846 617,457 639,068 661,435 684,586 708,546 733,345 Indicative GBP 14,251 14,768 15,304 15,859 16,414 16,988 17,583 18,198 18,835 D1 (GBP) 27,624 28,620 29,662 30,736 31,850 32,964 34,117 658,667 682,556 707,312 732,966 758,620 785,172 812,653 16,917 17,531 18,167 18,826 19,485 20,167 20,872 Uruguay Public (UYU) Uruguay Public (UYU) 152 175 Indicative GBP D2 (GBP) 27,624 28,620 29,662 30,736 31,850 32,964 34,117 35,304 36,548 802,106 831,197 861,345 892,585 923,825 956,159 989,625 1,024,262 1,060,111 Indicative GBP 20,602 21,349 22,123 22,925 23,728 24,558 25,418 26,307 27,228 C (GBP) 33,003 34,202 35,434 36,725 38,055 39,385 40,768 993,419 1,029,450 1,066,787 1,105,479 1,144,171 1,184,217 1,225,664 25,516 26,441 27,400 28,394 29,388 30,416 31,481 Uruguay Public (UYU) Uruguay Public (UYU) Indicative GBP 200 230 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 18 FIG International Data Provision Table 14 FIG - Salary grades effective 1st July 2013 Vs HayGroup Uruguay Public sector (Grades B – A3) Grade Grade B (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) Indicative GBP Grade A (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) Indicative GBP Grade A1 (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) Indicative GBP Grade A2 (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) Indicative GBP Grade A3 (GBP) Uruguay Public (UYU) Indicative GBP KnowHow 264 304/350 400 460 528 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved Lower Decile 37,144 910,211 23,383 44,417 1,208,338 31,036 66,471 1,474,263 37,868 83,073 1,633,550 41,958 94,114 1,978,820 50,829 Lower Quartile 40,421 1,141,186 29,316 49,980 1,522,548 39,108 70,364 1,953,476 50,175 87,228 1,977,224 50,787 102,416 2,263,487 58,141 Median 43,690 1,374,121 35,297 55,542 1,898,170 48,756 74,254 2,358,237 60,571 91,376 2,827,962 72,639 110,723 3,371,972 86,614 Upper Quartile 46,966 1,632,984 41,946 61,112 2,242,233 57,594 78,147 3,174,060 81,526 95,529 3,503,016 89,978 119,024 4,282,852 110,015 Upper Decile 50,242 1,776,211 45,622 66,674 2,629,754 67,548 82,039 3,610,299 92,730 99,683 5,004,075 128,535 127,333 5,842,803 150,085 www.haygroup.com 19 FIG International Data Provision 4. Individual Job Benchmark Based on a job title analysis from the public sector Paynet remuneration databases, selected FIG roles have been compared and benchmarked. Each FIG role is associated to our HayGroup methodology, making a direct link to the Paynet databases. Please bear in mind that the benchmark is in local currency with no cost of living consideration. UK The individual analysis reveals that only a handful of roles are outside the minimum and maximum FIG pay ranges. Within grades I – C, roles such as HGV driver, plant operator, cook, social work assistant, meat hygiene inspector, building advisor and financial accountant were outliers against the UK median. Where individual data is unavailable or is insufficient we have used the national public sector market median of comparable weighted jobs. Job weight has been taken from the current “know how” score as recorded through existing job evaluation data. This is particularly relevant where job weights are not consistent with job titles. This is highlighted * in the median column. Table 14 FIG Individual role Vs UK Public sector job titles (Grade I – C) Grade KnowHow FIG pay min (GBP) Director of Health I 57 12,463 15,274 UK Median (GBP) 13,353 Home Help Director of Health I 57 12,463 15,274 13,353 Accounts Clerk Director of Health H1 66 14,304 17,580 14,942* Driver/Handyman Director of Health H1 66 14,304 17,580 14,942* Junior Technician Director of Public Works H1 66 14,304 17,580 14,942* Evening Security Officer Director of Health H2 76 14,304 18,825 16,674 15,857* Title Directorate Cleaner/General Assistant Labourer FIG pay max (GBP) H2 76 14,304 18,825 Agricultural Assistant Director of Public Works Director of Natural Resources G1 87 16,158 19,945 Auxiliary Nurse Director of Health G1 87 16,158 19,945 17,211* Customer Services Officer Director of Central Services G1 87 16,158 19,945 16,624 HGV Driver Director of Public Works G1 87 16,158 19,945 20,380 Laboratory Assistant Director of Health G1 87 16,158 19,945 17,211* Learning Support Assistant Director of Education G1 87 16,158 19,945 16,305 Paralegal Attorney General G1 87 16,158 19,945 17,211* Plant Operator/Handyman G1 87 16,158 19,945 15,444 Probationer Constable Director of Public Works Director of Community Safety G1 87 16,158 17,338 Administrative Assistant Various G2 100 16,158 21,354 19,751 Laboratory Technician Director of Education G2 100 16,158 21,354 19,121* Sports Attendant Director of Central Services G2 100 16,158 21,354 19,121* © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved 17,211* 17,211* www.haygroup.com 20 FIG International Data Provision FIG pay max (GBP) UK Median (GBP) Grade KnowHow FIG pay min (GBP) Various F 115 19,146 23,654 21,565 Carpenter Director of Public Works F 115 19,146 23,654 20,822 Cook Director of Central Services F 115 19,146 23,654 17,801 Title Directorate Administrative Officer Customs/Immigration Officer Director of Community Safety F 115 19,146 23,654 21,643* Dental Nurse Director of Health F 115 19,146 23,654 21,643* Electrician Director of Public Works F 115 19,146 23,654 20,822 Filtration Plant Operator Director of Public Works F 115 19,146 23,654 20,822 Firefighter Director of Community Safety F 115 19,146 23,654 21,643* Fitter Director of Central Services F 115 19,146 23,654 20,822 Legal Secretary Attorney General F 115 19,146 23,654 21,519 Maintenance Technician Director of Education F 115 19,146 23,654 20,822 Mechanic Director of Public Works F 115 19,146 23,654 20,822 Plumber Director of Public Works F 115 19,146 23,654 20,822 Police Constable Director of Community Safety F 115 19,146 23,654 21,643* Prison Officer Director of Community Safety F 115 19,146 23,654 21,643* Receptionist Director of Central Services F 115 19,146 23,654 21,519 School Secretary Director of Education F 115 19,146 23,654 21,519 Senior Police Constable Customs/Immigration Team Leader Director of Community Safety E1 132 19,146 23,654 24,497* Director of Central Services E1 132 22,304 27,545 Fisheries Observer Director of Natural Resources E1 132 22,304 27,545 24,497* Fisheries Scientist Director of Natural Resources E1 132 22,304 27,545 24,497* Foreman Director of Public Works E1 132 22,304 27,545 23,503 Housing Officer Director of Public Works E1 132 22,304 27,545 23,990 PA Personal Assistant Various E1 132 22,304 27,545 25,388 Senior Staff Nurse Director of Health E1 132 22,304 27,545 24,497* Social Work Assistant Director of Health E1 132 22,304 27,545 21,929 Staff Nurse Director of Health E1 132 22,304 27,545 24,497* Watch Manager (Fire) Director of Community Safety E1 132 22,304 27,545 24,497* Biomedical Technician Director of Health E2 152 22,304 29,511 26,591 24,497* Practice Nurse Director of Health E2 152 22,304 29,511 26,814* Biomedical Scientist Director of Health D1 175 27,624 34,117 29,832 Designer/Draughtsman Director of Public Works D1 175 27,624 34,117 30,101* District Sister Director of Health D1 175 27,624 34,117 30,101* Immigration Officer Director of Community Safety D1 175 27,624 34,117 30,101* Internal Auditor Director of Central Services D1 175 27,624 34,117 28,070 Midwife Director of Health D1 175 27,624 34,117 30,101* Sergeant (Police) Director of Community Safety D1 175 27,624 34,117 30,101* Theatre Charge Nurse Director of Health D1 175 27,624 34,117 30,101* © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 21 FIG International Data Provision Grade KnowHow FIG pay min (GBP) Director of Natural Resources D2 200 27,624 36,548 33,984* Health Visitor Director of Health D2 200 27,624 36,548 33,984* Licensed Aircraft Engineer Director of Central Services D2 200 27,624 36,548 33,984* Meat Hygiene Inspector Director of Natural Resources D2 200 27,624 36,548 39,289 Social Worker Director of Health D2 200 27,624 36,548 32,804 Surveyor Director of Public Works D2 200 27,624 36,548 36,174 Title Directorate Fisheries Protection Officer FIG pay max (GBP) UK Median (GBP) Ward Manager Director of Health D2 200 27,624 36,548 33,984* Agricultural Advisor Director of Natural Resources C 230 33,003 40,768 38,120* Building Advisor Head of Policy C 230 33,003 40,768 43,823 Capital Accountant Financial Secretary C 230 33,003 40,768 41,085 Chief Nursing Officer Director of Health C 230 33,003 40,768 38,120* Crown Council Attorney General C 230 33,003 40,768 35,662 Environmental Officer Head of Policy C 230 33,003 40,768 39,289 Financial Accountant Fisheries Scientist (stock assessment) Financial Secretary C 230 33,003 40,768 41,085 Director of Natural Resources C 230 33,003 40,768 Inspector (Police) Director of Community Safety C 230 33,003 40,768 38,120* Leisure Centre Manager Director of Central Services C 230 33,003 40,768 38,120* Nurse Practitioner Director of Health C 230 33,003 40,768 39,945 Personnel Officer Director of Human Resources C 230 33,003 40,768 36,423 Pharmacist Director of Health C 230 33,003 40,768 38,120* Physiotherapist Director of Health C 230 33,003 40,768 38,120* Pilot (light aircraft) Director of Central Services C 230 33,003 40,768 38,120* Speech & Language Therapist Director of Health C 230 33,003 40,768 38,120* Teacher (Primary) Director of Education C 230 33,003 40,768 36,225 Teacher (secondary School) Director of Education C 230 33,003 40,768 36,225 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved 35,027 www.haygroup.com 22 FIG International Data Provision For grades B – A3, only the marine officer stands out of pay ranges Table 15 FIG Individual role Vs UK Public sector job titles (Grade B– A3) FIG pay max (GBP) UK Median (GBP) 46,109 Grade KnowHow FIG pay min (GBP) Financial Secretary B 264 37,144 50,242 Director of Health B 264 37,144 50,242 Power Generation Manager Director of Public Works B 264 37,144 50,242 43,152* Roads Engineer Director of Public Works B 264 37,144 50,242 41,421 Veterinary Officer Director of Natural Resources B 264 37,144 50,242 43,152* Head Regulatory Services Attorney General A 304 44,417 66,674 50,689 Senior Veterinary Officer Director of Natural Resources A1 400 66,471 82,039 71,217* Chief Medical Officer Director of Health A2 460 83,073 99,683 86,687* Executive Director Various A1/A2 460 66,471 99,683 97,313 Dental Surgeon Director of Health A 350 44,417 66,674 54,985* Headteacher (Primary) Director of Education A 350 44,417 66,674 53,263 headteacher (secondary) Director of education A 304 44,417 66,674 53,263 Legislative Drafter Attorney General A 350 44,417 66,674 51,461 Marine Officer Director of Natural Resources A 350 44,417 66,674 74,675 Medical Officer Director of Health A 350 44,417 66,674 54,985* Senior Agricultural Advisor Director of Natural Resources A 350 44,417 66,674 54,985* Senior Fisheries Scientist Director of Natural Resources A 350 44,417 66,674 54,985* Title Directorate Head of Taxation Medical Engineering Manager 43,152* Other Countries Individual role analyses for the other countries can be found on a separate excel spreadsheet. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 23 FIG International Data Provision 5. Reward Practices and Country Economic Indicator Reward practices and country economic indicator reports for each country (except Uruguay) can be found on separate pdf documents. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 24 FIG International Data Provision 6.Appendices The following section includes data that can be supplemented to HayGroup data. It includes public data for health, teaching and police where applicable and available UK Health Pay scales NHS Agenda for Change pay scales – 2013/2014 Effective from 1 April 2013 The minimum starting salary for a registered nurse is £21,388 To calculate hourly rate, divide the annual basic salary by 52.14 and then by 37.5 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 25 FIG International Data Provision Police Pay Scales Pay The pay of all officers, that is, the federated ranks, superintendents, chief officers and police cadets is increased by: •1% with effect from 1 September 2013 The two-year government imposed pay freeze on public sector pay will expire at the earliest on August 31, 2013. Following the ratification by the Home Secretary of the recommendations from the two Winsor reports relating to aspects officer pay, the pay of sergeants, inspectors and chief inspectors is correct as of April 2013. CONSTABLES' PAY Pay point With effect from 1 September 2010 With effect from April 2013 0 (a) £23,259 £19,000 1 (b) £25,962 £21,000 2 £27,471 (a) £22,000 3 £29,148 £23,000 4 £30,066 £25,500 5 £31,032 £27,000 6 £31,917 £31,032 7 £32,703 £36,519 8 £33,753 n/a 9 £35,796 n/a 10 £36,519 (b) n/a (a) On commencing service if the recruit has no policing qualification (b) On commencing service if the recruit has a new certified policing qualification, or previous experience as a special constable or PCSO; or on completion of basic training for those who entered on pay point 0. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 26 FIG International Data Provision SERGEANTS' PAY Pay point With effect from 1 September 2010 With effect from April 2014 0 £36,519 (a) n/a 1 £37,767 (b) £37,767 2 £39,036 £39,036 3 £39,867 £39,867 4 £41,040 (c) £41,040 (a) Entry point for officers promoted from constables' pay point 9 or less. (b) Entry point for officers promoted from constables' pay point 10. (c) Officers who have been on this point for a year will have access to the competence related threshold payment. INSPECTORS' PAY (London salaries in brackets) With effect from April 2013 Pay point With effect from 1 September 2010 0 £46,788 (£48,840) £46,788 (£48,840) 1 £48,108 (£50,163) £48,108 (£50,163) 2 £49,428 (£51,489) £49,428 (£51,489) 3 £50,751 (a) (£52,818) (a) £50,751 (a) (£52,818) (a) CHIEF INSPECTORS' PAY (London salaries in brackets) Current Figures (2013) Pay point With effect from 1 September 2010 1 £51,789(a) (£53,853)(a) £51,789(a) (£53,853)(a) 2 £52,830 (£54,888) £52,830 (£54,888) 3 £53,919 (b) (£55,980) (b) £53,919 (b) (£55,980) (b) (a) Entry point for an officer appointed to the rank, unless the chief officer of police assigns the officer to the higher point. (b) Officers who have been on this point for a year will have access to the competence related threshold payment. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 27 FIG International Data Provision CHIEF INSPECTORS IN POST AT 31 AUGUST 1994 (London salaries in brackets) Annual salary with effect from 1 September 2009 Annual salary with effect from 1 September 2010 £53,439 (a)(£55,440) (a) £54,801 (a) (£56,853) (a) (a) Officers on this point will have access to the competence related threshold payment. SUPERINTENDENT'S PAY Pay point With effect from 1 September 2009 With effect from 1 September 2010 1. £60,750 £62,298 2. £63,255 £64,869 3. £65,760 £67,437 4. £68,274 £70,014 5. £70,779 £72,585 CHIEF SUPERINTENDENT'S PAY Pay point With effect from 1 September 2009 With effect from 1 September 2010 1. £72,543 £74,394 2. £74,607 £76,509 3. £76,680 £78,636 SUPERINTENDENT RANGE 2 NOT PROMOTED TO CHIEF SUPERINTENDENT Pay point With effect from 1 September 2009 With effect from 1 September 2010 1. £69,558 £71,331 2. £70,761 £72,564 3. £72,315 £74,160 4. £74,022 £75,909 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 28 FIG International Data Provision CHIEF OFFICER'S PAY Pay Structure for chief constables and deputy chief constables from April 2013 Forces CC Salary DCC Salary MPS (4XACs) West Midlands Greater Manchester £181,455 £139,119 (MPS 8xDACs) West Yorkshire £169,359 £135,489 Thames Valley £160,290 £132,237 Merseyside Northumbria £157,260 £129,744 Hampshire £154,233 £127,248 Kent Lancashire Devon & Cornwall £151,215 £124,749 South Yorkshire Essex Avon & Somerset Sussex South Wales £148,194 £122,256 Nottinghamshire Lothian & Borders £142,143 £117,264 Hertfordshire West Mercia Cheshire Humberside Staffordshire Leicestershire Derbyshire £139,119 £114,771 Surrey Norfolk £136,092 £112,278 Cleveland Durham Cambridgeshire North Wales North Yorkshire Gwent Grampian Northamptonshire Suffolk Dorset Wiltshire Bedfordshire £133,068 £109,782 Gloucestershire Lincolnshire Cumbria Warwickshire Dyfed-Powys Tayside £130,044 £108,873 Police Scotland £208,100 £169,000 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com FIG International Data Provision 29 Metropolitan Police Service Commissioner - £260,088 Deputy Commissioner - £214,722 Police Service of Northern Ireland Chief Constable - £179,205 Deputy Chief Constable - £145,605 Assistant Chief Constables and Commanders 1.£84,003 2.£86,805 3.£89,607 4.£92,403 5.£95,208 6.£98,004 City of London Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner Commissioner - £160,902 Assistant Commissioner - £132,714 Chief Officers on protected pay rates New salaries for those Chief Officers on protected salaries as listed below. The April 2003 PNB Agreement on the pay and conditions of Chief Police Officers included protected salaries for certain Chief Officers. The protection only applies while the Chief Officer is in post as shown below, with their successors being paid in accordance with the new pay structure shown above. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com FIG International Data Provision 30 NAHT - Teaching Pay scales Leadership Group Pay Spine 2013 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com FIG International Data Provision 31 Pay Scale for Classroom Teachers © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com 32 FIG International Data Provision Pay International Teacher’s salaries Annual statutory salaries in public institutions, minimum training Equivalent USD converted using PPPs Scale for Classroom Teachers 2013 or latest available year Primary education Lower secondary education Upper secondary education Salary Salary Salary Initial Maximum Initial Maximum Initial Maximum Australia 34 610 48 522 34 746 49 144 34 746 49 144 Canada 35 534 56 349 35 534 56 349 35 534 56 569 Chile 17 385 31 201 17 385 31 201 18 034 33 002 New Zealand 28 225 41 755 28 251 42 241 28 277 42 726 United States 37 595 53 180 37 507 56 364 38 012 56 303 © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com FIG International Data Provision 33 Other countries Further publicly available data can be found on a separate folder. © 2014 Hay Group. All rights reserved www.haygroup.com Hay Group 33 Grosvenor Place London SW1X 7HG www.haygroup.com