Recruitment of Dutch Nationals in the United States for the
Transcription
Recruitment of Dutch Nationals in the United States for the
Recruitment of Dutch Nationals in the United States for the Netherlands Armed Forces in the Second World War by Gerlof Homan Sununary A study of Dutch recruitment of Netherlands citizens during the Second World War and the response of Dutch immigrants residing in the United States. An attempt to "xplain the limited response. , Outline 1. Dutch recruitment policies 1940-1945. 2-. U.S. Cooperation with Dutch authorities 1940. 3. U.S. Cooperation with Dutch authorities 1941-1945. 4. Response of Dutch immigrants to the call. 5-. Assessment Bibliography Th. paper is based on unpublished archival materials. I can only • recommend my forthcoming article in Hededelingen van de Secti. Militaire Geschiedenis Landmachtstaf. Gerlof Homan HECIW I 'I'r1EN'1' OF DUTCIl tJlI'J'JUN/,LS IN TIlE UNl'l'IW S'l'II'l'ES FOR 'l'IIE NE'l'HEHLANDS AHMED FUHCES IN 'l'HE SECUIJD I'/URLD WAH Unlike the French yuverIlillellL vlhictl"cuncluded an armistice with the victorious Nazi rEo'\jime on June 2:<, lY4U, IVithclrawing from further lJarticil!ation in the war, tll'e N'~therland,; deClded to continue the struggle after the surrellder of its armed forces on May IS:' However I the Nether lallds government in ex ile in London had very limited military ['esources to fight the A'ds powers. veiy few men escaped to England in May 194U ~Ie[e they and others formed a small fighting ullit lat',er called the Princess Irene Br ig ade. Furthermore, va[' lOUS naval vessel s '-'nel shi.ps ot 'the Dutch merchant marine contributed to th,~ war ettot"f:. In order to incLease the size of its fightin,:) unit in England, to arouse interest in the war e[fort i",mong Netherlanders abroad, and to impress the IIllies of its determination to combat the AX:1S powers, the Netherlands government decided to recruit nationals residing in various nutiolls uc to petGuClde them to enlist in its armed forces. Speciul efforts were to be made to recruit men in South !lmel-ica,-South Atrica, Canada, alld the United States. Dutch nationals ill the United States the Netherlands ':lQvernrnent could uraw ulJoli were d sUlall number, of employees with various shipping and ot:her firms, a few refugees from the occupied homeland, and illuni<]t".ants. It wus particularly from this latter group Dutch of [iciillf; llOP"O to I){:' able to recrui t many youny men. Thi s paper 1 discusses es~ecially 2 the recruitment of such permanent Dutch residents in the United States and is based on unpublished Dutch and Aillerican archival sources. I also tried to communicate with Dutch nationals who in 1939 were immigrants in the United States and who served in the Princess Irene Brigade by placing announcements in the D.1.S. Magazine and The Windmill Herald. Although more than 400 Dutch- Americans served in the Netherlands armed forces during World War 1 II I did not have much of a response. It is difficult to believe that all or most of them are no longer living .today. I hope this article might stimulate them to conta(;t me. Already ill May 1940, shortly after the defeat of Dutch armed forces at the hand of the Nazi juggernaut, some efforts were made ;,! to recruit Netherlanders in the United States. As \, ill be seen below, these efforts did not produce the expected results. August 8, On 1940, by royal decree, all Netherlanders in the United Kingdom, United States, and Canada who were born between January 1,1904 and January 1, 1921, were ordered to register tor military duty with Dutch officials in those countries. Later in the war, the decree was modified to include Netherlanders in other parts of the world and those born between January 1, and December 31, 1924. born between January 1; 1900 During the latter part ot the war thqse 1904 and January 1,. eligible for military conscription. 1927 were declared Furthermore, the decree ot August 1940 made it possible for men between the ages of 3 55 to enilst in the Netherlands Armed ~orces. 18 and 'the task of registering Netherlanders in the United States was initially undertaken by the Netherlands Consulate General in J New York. In December 1~40 a special Registration Bureau was established in New York wh ich ",as headed by a Consul General in Special Service, M.J. van Schreven who was later succeeded by 4 S.J. van den Bergh and A. Kerkhoven. Later, in March and May 1941, registration bureaus were established in Chicago, San Francisco, and Los Angeles, close to the major centers of Dutch settlements in the United States, which were supervised by the' New York attice. The entire recruitment system in the United States as well as in Canada was under the supervision and direction of Lieutenant Colonel G.J. Sas the head of the Netherlands military mission in Canada. Sas seems to have spent much of ilis time and energy on recruitment efforts and work in the United States. Much to his chagrin he One of the major problems Dutch officials faced from the very beginning was how to obtain names and addresses of Netherlanders residing in the United States and how to inform them of their military duty "Iithout violating American laws. According to American officials neutrality legislation forbade 6 recruitment of foreign nation"ls residing in the United States • • This was incorrect, however. Criminal Code ot But recruitment did violate the 1909 as amenU!!d in 1917. Section lOot that Code stipulated that it was illegal to enlist or to hire or retain another person to enlist ()r enter himself, or to go beyond the llmits ot tiIe juru:aJiction of the United States with intent to be enlisted or enter-ed in the service of any [orelgll prince, State, colony, district, or people as u sol<iier or as a mari~e or I, seaman on board ot any v\':-;~.~el ot h'ur.· •••• However, the art iole al so prov lded tha t the law would rot appl y to "any citizens or subjects "I. ~ny counery engaged in war with E 7 • country with which the Unlted ~laces is at war Un t iJ " December 1941 the United Stal",; was a neutral power and not a cobelligerent or ally ot lhe ,·Jethel-l'lI1ds. Thus during much of this period American officiale; insisted thilt the law be respected. ~tates Officially, the Uniled did not approve of conscription of Dutch nati')tlais residing as permanent residents in the United Stiltes and even '-larned Netherlands otficials not to make any recrui tment . propacp'ncia. Yet, at the same time the American government aoKnowl",u<il'ci that tlle "liability ot any such . persons for service in the LJul:ch i1l:lIled torces was a matter for 8 the decision ot the Dutch government." This kind of ambiguity made it difficult for Netherlands authorities to determine how much freedom they would hil\le ill l-ecruiting niltionills ot the Netherlands. l'hey simply wouJd have to test the wate-rs. In the summer ot 1940 tlwy placed an announcement in the Knickerbocker, posted a call Lor In i t i cilry serv ice in Ne ther lands consulates, and informed varIOUS Dutch organizations. In July 1940, A. Hartog, the Netherlands consul general in Los Angeles,. placed an announcement in local papers and in store windows, and 9 Apparently, American officials informed local ministers. considered all of this a violation of the law, and in August of that year Hartog was instruct,'d by A. minister to Washington, Loudon, the Netherlands to try to persuade local editors to refe! 10 to the royal decree in their editorial pages. Dutcn officials also contacted various Americnn bUSinesses sl1ch as Shell Oil Corporation of Texas anu tile [<"li()n.!l BLass Company of Grand 11 Rapids, Michigan, to prOVl(Je l!"-'1Il wittl naliles of Dutch employees. However, not all of these finn,; were, 'l!'ry cooper.ative including branches of Dutch businesses i" the United States who were often anxious to keep their employees. O,nce names and addressee; Wfne obtained, circulars were sent to the men in whIch they were requested to register tor military service. 'American official s otJ4ected to this type of 1~41, communication, however, and ill January iniormed Dutch authorities to cease all reCt"lHtment propilganda. Loudon promised to discontinue the use ot tlie circular, but apparently, the 1 :L practice was resumed shortJy ,.J teL However, obtaining the nc,mes of el 19 ible men continued to remain a difficult task. 'l'hus, December 1941 Dutch officials in the summer and again in ROI~ht to ~esolve their problem by requesting American authoriti(':; to allow them to insr,.>ect all, alien registration cords of Dutch citizens born between 1904 and 13 1924. Until very recently, ,ltl alienn residing in the United ~eport States were required by law tu anflually their status and lniti~lly, presence in the United Stnl.<.'". the Stilte Department seemed sympathetic to that r'Jq'lwst whiCh carne at a time when the United States was no longer "",1 ietly "l)s(ot:ving its nelltrality in the war as it had been in I~I\(). Naturalization Service too!, rejected it with the ,1 [Jowever, tlle .lmmiCjr:ation and "im vic\', of the ,-",quest and observ~tl0n tllat a study ut millions of registration cards would simp! \' involve too nlur,h work while making them available to a 1"0"'191\ l!0Vier "lould create "all 14 embarrassing pu,cedellt." In the early summer of 1~J<! 1 r.he UnIted 31>11·.es made some minor concessions. posters in the Netherlands Coltul.lates and wade it {Jossible for Dutch officials to draw upun l.il'e t>onl u1 "u-cal] cd declarant aliens. Declarant aliens were immigrants who h2d indicated their wish to become citizens ot ttl'" Un ited !States }JY a],!],!lying for socalled first papers. 8}:' the to'elective Tcaining and Service Act of 1940, declarant aliens had I:egistf'r ror ndJitar:y service :.0 and were subject to conscriptlutl. Dutch officii,Is mistakenly believed this number of decLn ,lilt Dutcil llation,ols to be larger than that of the them. However, non-declar~llt ~hey nnd were very were ull . . d)l(~ l:o du ~nxious lH-=c':Juse SU tIl conscript declarant aliens were to register for Ampcican military service. Furthermore, American officl';J.'; a'lt:eed in January 1941 that: declarant aliens were not perm i tted to "eturn their first papers and would be punished if they ['eLused to re'Jiste!:" under the 15 Selective Service Act. Th" concf,ssion of June 1941 made it possible, however, ror: declal'dllL <Iliens, who hE,Ci iJeen classiLied I-A by their local draft boards, that is those to be called first, to be reclassified 11-11 ()l defelTed status. Once they had been reclassified as such, til','Y could be dr.:tfted by the Dutch 16 government. After the United States '''ntry into the we,r the Netherlands expected to secure much mot'e C()()lJet'ut ion trom Allier: lcan off icials. It would take some tillle,~ howcov ',c I: , before npw agreement was ,1 negotiated, and even then Dutcll ufticials were not entirely satisfied. In January 19 112 tllPY obt«il1"d i1 mG:inr concession when C(~ h:::.r the United States agceed to all lluliH~::..i alJ{J uddcesses of Netherlanders registered un,i"" the Ame!:ic,J" Sel"ctive Training 17 and Service Act. l'his CCIlCt.:;GIOIl re!;olved one ot the major problems Dutch officials had ('ftcountered in the) preceding months. However, in late ~larch the Unll"d States informed Dutch officials that only Dutch subjects who \,f)re non-ueclarant aliens could be accepted for military service in the Netherlancs Armed Forces; .thus henceforth so-called declurant aliens could no longer be drafted. Dutch officials we~~ qUIck tu point O(!t that this new regulation reduced the pool ul in their opinion, the numbl~l· uVililable [Jotential dt-aftees since ()!' dec13Lz~nl alietl~, \'IOS larger than III that of the non-declarants. mistaken in their estimate; fIe; the:. ".i II nUlflbe~ be, shown beclow, they were ut non-(Ieclm:ants was larger than those of the dec_luctlnts. In spite ot Netherlands 1.'luLest- th,; Unitecl States refused to alter its policy. On May 0, l'H;l., U!(, IJ(, 1-'cI I:" Lrnelil, of State informed Loudon that the olel 1"1.1 wy hilt! b:'en instItuted before the Un i ted St a te G en te tOed tlJ(' 'di.! J: • "the most llberal regime _, can be placed in etfect hU1l1 rOt" flt.~\·.' Ttlr' po.1 ley constituted [.>racticuule ·point ot VieW which ill. 1 til<' V ill. i"uG b<,'.J.i iqC.'J:ent 19 countr ies." Most Itl<ely, ::il'..' fHl"l lIme[·i":1Il p-,.l icy was motivated its own armed forces. aliens in the Unlted Stal'.'"" \-,,,:; COllIlJUt-"LIV·.,ly ",Il,.,.ll it those of other nationalities were adeled til'.' toted ti'}ure rniqht have been considerable. Further protests J.)y !JuLcll ofticial,; bcollqhl no changes and finally, on July 8, 1942, tit" I",the! jam]:; ,mci tlte United States reached an agreement that coltl trmed prey ious understandings. Furthermore, it stipulated thilL the NeLi!",,:lanus' v,ould not use "any threats or compulSion of: nltY n,lture to irtlluCe any person in the United States to enlist in its ar'meo forces" accept enlistments of aliens becoming American citizens WIIO and not to had declared their intent of I<'ho were :oubject to registration 20 under the Selective Service Act. ,lilO Apparently, there were no further major prol-,lems between Dutch and American officials. Especially state Selective Service Boards were very cooperatlve ill providinq names and addresses. After the names had beell secuted circulars were sent to the men requesting them to register. Jl no reply had been obtained within eight days a new letter l'lould be sent. it again no reply was received a staff member would visit the young man trying to persuade him to comply. Subseyuentiy, the local draft board was notified of the agreement or Li,e decision. Finally, in spite of the restriction to draw upon declarant aliens, Dutch officials were still able to enlist them if the local drait board was will ing to gr an t a release. 21 were seldom granted. However, apparently such releases The only major problem alter July 1,),12 between American and Dutch officials concerrling recLuitment was the de Voyel affair. 22 While American officialS hac! n,"dered their "Ilalued assistance" in returning a few deserters to Netherlanlls authorities they stubbornly retused to comply IYith Dutch requests to hand over de Vogel to them. Even Ministet: Loudon Ivas unable to secure American compliance and cooper:"tion. I 'I Char l'~s t;In i1 Ue \logel was born in the Nethet:lands ca. l~lIU. In I~L) ne selved tor a shot:t time in a Dutch officers traillinq school and later went to the Netherlands army. Ind~es where he lH'c:ame a cot'poral in the colonial From 1938 to 1940 he visited California where he married an American citizen. In 1940 he ['eturned to the indies and early 1941 was admitted as an immigrilnt to the United States. of that yeat: he reg~stered In July for ilmet:ican military sel'vice and was given a 4-C or alien status hy the Selective Service Board of Glendale, California. In Octouor 1941 he applied tor his first papers declaring his intentioll of becoming an American citizen. However, Get:ard J. Drosto, head or the Netllet:lands Reg istration Bureau and Cotl,'ui l;"tlerol in Los An'Je1'eS infor'med de Vogel of his military duty UlIcH,r' the t:0ial decree ut August 1940. De Vogel complied and aftet: til:; medical '·'xaminatlon was ordered to proceed to Stratford, OntaL'lU tor' militat:y traininq. In February 1942, his local drait bpat:"d released Ilim [t:"om any military obligation ulldet: tile c;'clectlve; Service same month de Vogel proceeded '.0 Canaela. rank of corporal, de Vogel was sent to until April 1943. ACL and in the !lfter he obtained the Cura~ao whet:"e he remained Subsequently, lie was ot:"dered to return to Canada via Los Angeles where '''2 W,IS petmitted to settle some personal affairs. However, upon bis arcivill in Los Angeles he informed officials of the He"lutration Bureau that he was unwilling to proceed to Canada. Instead, he recegistered with his local dratt board in Gletldale which Classified him I-A and ~3 ordered his induction. Dutch authorities inform"d !lmericzm officiz:ds of de Vogel's ,n , .! desertion and requested his ~I ~est. The lJ(~jJilrtlllent ()I war complied, and on June 21 de Vogel was arrested in Los Angeles. Subsequently, the inspector G'''IH"rai ot ttl., Ninth Service Conunand of the u.S. Army investigated the matt"r and recommended, on July 27 to the Inspector General uc \,ashington, D.C., to determine if 'de Vogel's enlistment had not lwen in v iolation of Section 10 of the U.S. Criminal Code or "oehet'WIse u'lJlcllvtul." 'l'lle investigating officer ofttle Ninth Service Commz'nd also questioned Droste whodefenJed his decision to inJuct de Vogel by correctly pointing out that at the time of the lotter's induction "no agreement had been reached between tne Unit~d States Government and the Ne ther lanrL; Gover'nmen t [or enI i st ing of 24 Netherlands nationals in the UrllteJ States." October 5, However, on 1943, the American Judge Advocate General agreed with the Ninth Service Conunand's conclusions that de Vogel h.ad been inducted in violation of the U.S. Criminal Code. Furthermore, 25 he even recommended possible criminal actIon against Droste. Subsequestly, in October, Secretary of War Henry Stimson ordered 26 However, de Vogel's release dnd induction Into the U.S. AUIIY. Stimson decided not to instigate legal proceedings against Droste by exercising his prerogatives under a I?rovisiolJ,ot the same Article 10 of the Criminal violated. CoJ~ that supposedly had been The provision on which StimsolJ Dassd his decision not to prosecute stipulated that the law would not apply to citizens of nations who were engaged in a wiJr <''Jaillst a country with which 27 the United States was also ilt viar. In April ancl Nay 1944, i'1illtster: Loudon til",d his protests with American authorities by U'Jlt'~lIcllr;9 that at the time 01' de Vogel's ~egistration with the ;;elective ;;ervice he was an "enrolled member of the Anneci Fo['ces oj: the NptherlaJlds." Therefore, the Netherlands miniL;ter: contended, dt~ Vogel's :<8 registration could not have be2n accf'pted. The ;;tate Department replied that on the basis of all thE' available evidence, de Vogel had been inducted a result ot "threats and :<9 other improper representations by DutCh officials." Dutch officials denied such allegations and contended tildt de Vogel's induction had occurred at a time when there .ias no agreement between the Netherlands and th" June 24, and October 13, Cordell Hull tha t United StilL,:,;. Fut-thermore, on LouJon inLocmed secretary of State 1"44, the prov is iUIl', a l the Cr im ini.1 Code were not applicable because de Vogel \vClS not an Amet ican citizen at the time of his induction into lli., N.?therlan<ls Arltled Forces. Finally, the Netherlands mirlister cO[lcludecl that "no matter whatever the merits of the C21'''' may be ttH~, UlJilateraJ induction of a soldier into the army of Ule Uniti,(1 States who is in the active service of the Armed ~)LC8S of a country which is allied with the United States in the present war, ~rl is Dctiorl which is not furthering the close cooperiltioll Glnd har.mony which should exist, between the at'med torc""s at countries fightillg the same 30 enemy. It However", Hull and Stlln!iOn reCused to budge, and de Vogel r-ernained in the U.S. Army. Ivhat were the merits of the case? know if Droste used" improper Unfortullately, we do n.ot l:eln.~selltotions" Vogel to join the Netherlands ilrmecl ForctC,". to [.ler-suade de Perhaps he told him and other Netherlands nationals tit pOSSible "dire consequences" if he would not comply. Ho"L ILJ.'.dy, Llli,; '''IlPLy threat had been used by other Dutch officials ever since 1940 but had never led to any kind of confrontation wlth Alllerican authorities. the agreement ot July 8, 1911~, been v iolat,~d Nor had since de Vogel had been inducted into the NetherJ.illlds Armed Forces in February 1942. One could argue, although Amet"lCan officials did not press this point, that de Vugel should not have been drafted because he was a so-called declarant alien. As will be ("ecalled ,American authorities stipulated in March 19.2 that such inaividuals were not to be inducted into the Netilerlands Armed Forces. However, de Vogel's Selective Servic,,· ll().:Jld hOld released hlill trom any American military obligation. Thus de VOSlel' s illduction seems to have been proper and not in v i.olat ion ot any a.greements or understandings. case. American officials oVArreacted and misj udged the Perhaps even Stimson [inally realizeu t1wt the American case was not too persuasive Wh'!ll in November 1944 he declared the case clf)"ed not because de Vuyel had b~en improperly inducted but because he had become an Amer lcan c·i t i zen and was now serv ing in 31 the American Armed Forces. ilpparently, de Vogel had quickly completed his naturalization pt"ocess \vhile seLving in the U.S. Army. He was· now. completely SCire from allY !dnd at prosecution by Dutch authorities. How did Dutch nationals I.iving in the United Stutes respond to the call for military serVlce in the armed lorces of the land of their birth? Recipients al the Dutch circulut: ot: notitication requesting them to register "ilUI a Netl,prlancb Hegistration Bureau often had a great varlet".y ot concerns 311d questions. They wanted to lenovi if Dutch authU'"llies had tile P"vl('t to conscript them and what the penalty LOl" [""tused v,ould b",. They also wanted to know if declarant aliens cOllld be conscripted. Some were concerned that a person who hi"'l taken out t irst I!"I!ers might no longer qualify for American clLizenshiI! it he would serve with the Netherlands Armed Forces. uthers wondered it they could serve while .they were registen:d Undel" the SeJpctive Service Act. A few individuals were concerned about the problem ot reentry into the United States atter tilcey had completed their military service with the Netherlands l,cmed Forces. One person even wanted to know what would 'haf'IX!n to him it he rc·[used to serve but would might some day retlJClI to tlle Neth,,"l'J',cis tor a visit! Finally, there were question,; .,ilOUt Ulllli.ly "ll()vl'lIlCCs and 32 maintenance. Perhaps one ot the most typical illljul.t Broersma, Bellflower, Calitol:1l1il. [0S cmne from Roy I·limy lfldivlduals of Dutch extraction who had first lived in 10\'''' settled in the Los Angeles area where they lived i,n suell cOllllnunities as BelltloVier and 33 Hynes. 'l'he latter even beci.HIII? Known as Little Nethcl:lands. Roy Broersma arrived in the United Sti.ltes in 1926 "nd settled in Bellflower where he became u (iillry tunnel:. in /IUljust 1941 he received a summons to join thf' Nether.lands Armed Forces in Canada. This call prompteu his illyuil:Y with the State Department which had received similar inqult" ies in prev ious months from anxious Dutch nationals. BrOE;t:sma wrote Oil August 20, 1941 I have been informed by an dljent of the HOlland Government that 1 have teo ljo to C<:tlluua to Join the Dutch Forces there and h~ve to leave tl:(~ Los Angeles Wednesday August 27, 1~41. 1 "have been a resident alien of this country for 15 years and I am married and have dairy business ul my own. /\tld 1 also have JI filed fot" my fit"st citi"'.:11 put)"t":>. 1I,1S ttl" ilullund Government authority to ,nuke me joi~ the Dutch Military Forces in Canada. Ot" will the [\lnerican Government force me to leave this cOllntr-y. I I,ave never- been in [the] Dutch Army belu,·!. J wOllJd 'jr-',atly il[Jpreciate [an) answer betore Wedne>;day Aug. 27, 1941. I am enclosing a [sic) enveloppe lsic] with stamp. 34 To these and other inquir ips the State Department tried to reply as well as it could. Thus it r-eilssur-ed the inqUIrers that Du teh author i ties had no powe r to force th'~m to compl y wi th Du tch 35 draft laws. The problem of reentr-y permits was not fully resolved until after Pearl Har-bot". Until that tIme recruits were able to obtain reentry permits as long as they would not divulge 36 the reasons for their depar-ture iro", the United States. Bany inquiries of Dutch nationals were probably attempts to find legitimate excuses to ev·ade induction in the Nether-lands Armed Forces. Netherlands officials soon complained and during the ent"lre war continued to feel u sense oL Lr-ustr-ation over the lack of response by Dutch nationals to t"ally to the suppot"t of their fatherland in time ot need. ll.!.ready in th'.~ summer- at 1940, shortly after the Nazi assaul t on the Nether-lands when one would have expected a considerabl'" CHllUunt oL enU,usiilsm and patriotism, Dutch officials voiced their- uisapPolfltment. Thus they 37 complained that while a few llulldr-,"ci vol unteereu in [-lay 1940, few did in the months follOl"iflq. that he was "at a loss to know In late ~hat 1940 Bar-tog lamented 38 to do abuut it In " October 1942 Loudon expressed his d ismay that some 90"1 39 Netherlandet"s had not respond(-:d to the call to ("'listerAugust 1943 Dijxhoot"n charged there wee", at least 703 40 "deserters." In December- 1Y~1 Sas complained about the "indolence and unwillingness tu ",,,ke SdCr-lfice"s" illld even and in 1 . ,' 41 "obstruction" on the part ot countrYIll<en. hiS W.f. Kroon, head of the Registration Bureau in Chicago, voiced his anger and frustration at W.J. vun Wagt""<loIlK draft call. Van Wagtendonk WLlS WilD t'eLused to respond to the born in .Java, graduated at the University of Utrecht and Colile to the United States in 1939 where he studied at Stanford Univpr~;i ty and later tauqht chemistry at 4L Oregon State College. h(~ Sinc'l l'eiusecl to r"9 ister with the Chicago bureau, Kroon accus"d him ot beln'J a clri'ltt evader and expressed his anger by sayillg it was "beyond his imagination" to understand why a "learned mall" \vould [',.,fuse to do his (Juty to the 43 Netherlands without "sound n,il>;on." Apparently, One of the lLq.i.tiul<ite means ot r,scaping conscription was to change one' s stat.us trom llon-declurant to declarant alien. Thus Pastor J<.!cob Van Dyke of the f'irst Christian Reformed Church at Ireton, young men in his congregation 44 On tile their first papers. I lO\,/i;l, (1oti<.:eu thilt many iltlH,r suclrJenly df-,cidcd to take out o~ller hand there were also some who, in order to escape American military servic", changed their status from declarant to non-de.clarant alien! Furthermore, 53 45 men obtained a legitimate escape by receivinJ a deferment. Some Dutch shipping firms in New York were able to persuade Netherlands authol'ities to <Jt"'II\: special status which requi~ed ,·;Qllie 50 of theIL' employees tllem to perform Weekly military exercises while they were petloitted to keep their regular employment. This was the so cdlled "fOUl1tilinpel! brigade" whose members would now also be pcotC!cted ",gainst a f,'ossible American 46 draft call. J/ D. Hudig, President of th,> Netherlands Shi.,ping and Trade Commission in New York, even chaL'"ed that young !lien who wanted to serve were dissuaded not to enlist because thE'y were told their office work was more important than milita~y service. contended that Loudon had at'Pl'oved of this policy. Hudig even l'his accusation brought a quick reSponse frum the Netheclands minister who informed his fore'ign minister in London that they were doing 47 "everything possible" to Yet, a special Advisory per311ud'~ Conllnis~-ion NetherliHldet's to register. established in 1941 to hear and decide requests of defermellt resigned in 1"42 because 4B Dijxhoorn granted exem[Jtions t() one or two iqdividuals. The lack of response about' Vlhich Dutch officials complained can be explained in part by the ",ttituue ot mallY Dutch immigrants in the United States. [.lost of tilem he,d left their nutive land because of frustration and tailuce ove,' their station in life ill the Netherlands. ~Iany had (1(>1'1'" much better in their adopted land while the country of their bicLtl o[tell reminded them of less pleasant experiences. Furthenllor:e, they had emotiollully and mentally identified themselves I-lith the United Slates ilnd gradually loosened theh' ties Vii til the 01 d \'/or: lei. There might also have been materialistic l'eclL>OllS since many illunigrants expected to receive more pOly ane1 benefIts in the American Forces. However, the pay ot a soldieL ill the iJuLch and tllllerican Forces 49 was about the same, $21 per lIIunth, 'vll U e the l amo us Serv icemen Readjustment Act which granted cOllsiderutJle benetiLs tu American veterans was not passed until June 1944 a yea~ in which recruitment of Netherlanders til the United Stal:e's had virtually come to a halt. Some 200 Nettl"t'landet'!5 did seLve in the American Armed forces. Perhaps mosL ul Lllese were declCllilnt aliens. All Netherlanders serving in the IIi[ler iCClll Forc",s were given the option to enlist in Dutch milltilry service. Apl.~rentlY, few of 50 them did. Finally, there were undoubtedly many so-called "tepid" Netherlanders, ~s Luudun c~lled them, "'he simply were not eager or anxious to serve eitl1"t' in the Npther.lands or the American Armed Forces and wllo could trunK ot Hiany excuses tor 51 their failure to respond. What could Dutch officiuls do to persuade Ulese tepid countrymen who refused to set·v(-~? The y lwei litlIe if any power of American authoriti(',·; would most certainly not coercion. 52 in I:D und ing up cooperate, as happened in Sou til Atr ica, recalcitrant Netherlanders. Nur could they as Belgian officials did, threaten to confiscate [".-uperties 0'. Cutch nationals in :'3 their native land if they hLld any. At best they could refuse to renew their passports or nul. to rene/pI: thpm consular 54 services. Of course they could always threat",n their countrymen with "dire conseyu"'llc'=s" it they n,fused to comply. 'l'hus N. van Leeuwen was told by a Dutch ottici"l in New York if he refused to go to Canada he would encourlter great difficulty in becoming an American citizen. Furthermot'e, they wat'ned .him that "there were other means" by which they could pul pressure on him. Van Leeuwen did not seem to be impressed and considet'ed the 55 threats very vague and an attempt to SCil['(' him. Similarly, B.C.G. Buss of New York, who dc'nied ever having been a Dutch national and retused to t'e<Jist(c"-, wClS lnlonncu in september 1941 by Van Schreven to appear at his bureilll betw,-~eL 3 ano 5 p.m. or SG be faced with "dire COnse4UCIlL'I:;j." Yet, the response of Neth('t:landers in the United States to iOl~C'=S the call for military duty in the anned ut the land of their origin, was not as negative as we have been led to believe. Dutch officials estimated that in 1940 thet:e were some 32,000 Netherlanders in the United States of which sorne ten percent or 57 3200 were eligible for rnilitat:y service. Other so urces 58 estimated the number of elig ib.le rnen to be S,OOO or 10,000. Neither one of these estimates lS correct. The census of 1940 shows that the tota'l number vf Netherlanders in the United States at that time was 108,640. Of tllese 7ll,00U were naturalized, 8,560 had obtained their firsL l'apers, 13, UOO wene non-declarant ille(~al aliens, and 8200, many of whorn lIliyht have be"n had not provided any information on their- citizenship. residents, -rhe figures for the Dutch male population in tile United States were 47,360 naturalized, 6,00U decldr-ant and h,140 nOll-declarant :.,S; aliens, and 4,440 having repot~t<"U no inioLlllatlon. Thus ~the principal pool upon which th-,' Netherlands r.OUld dr'aw was that of the 'non-declarant aliens to WhlCh one could ddd, but Ivith a high degree of uncertainty, the 4,440 who had not reported their citizenship status. Of the posslble tutal at only one-tourth or some 2,64~ 1U,5BO men perhaps wns of rnillLur-y ade but in reality this figure is muc!. lower. It is not easy to determill(~ how many m~n Wf.".:e notttied by Dutch Registration bureaus ot tllelr milltary ducy. ,figures might not be completeJ\' ["cliable bc>caus men were not 1 tied fIIore thall on<:'c. is incomplete. l:'Ul the.tHlOt'2, We do know that: at least 1~"3 p The available in various cases SUllie=- 01 tne data wecc notified by 1 ""' .'- ~ mid-January 1941 and that by ttl '-~ e !J{j oL 1"41 L, () 0 U had been 60 notified. Let us assume thLl t 2645 men w~re SE:' II t a cit-cular requesting them to register. respond to this notificati.on examined; furthet-more, <"l 1"'Je do .Know that [u..l thu l some 12UO "'Ie re medically 1 '>~tJ mell did 640 ill<.ilc:o.ted ",itilel- b'-"tote or after the medical examination they did nut I-Junt to serve. Of the remainder 53 were granted a deferment Ol '""eltlptloll o.lld 47~ ;,ere- rejected for medical reasons. 'I'he peLcnntage at Lejectees WuS so high because Dutch military duthotilles expected all the men to do combat duty. Thus it happerwd thut indlvi.duals who were rejected for Dutch military service wer,' ,hutted by the Uni-ted States. Finally, 420 men were accepted lOl' SelCV icl' anei spnt to Canada and 61 England. _Thus or a possible total of 2645 men 420 or 16% served. ConsideLing the varioLls CilculI!Stunces discussed above and the mentality of many immiglCants tllis response to the call to arms to help their tatherluno in tillle ot yreat need was not as negative as was often alleged. This f 19ure also compares well with percentages given for SOllth Atrico., At'gentina, and Canada 6<' which were 33%, 17%, and 13%, t'espectively. Perhaps it could be al'gued that more men would have been drafted if Amerlcan authorities had been more ccoperative and 63 helpful in 1940 and 1941. Th is ish ig hl Y un] iKely. Al though recruitment became much easiet In 1<)4;1 because nameS and addresses were now more readily availaule, it seems that Dutch authorities had notified mose loen by the end at Furthermore, relatively few In',!} w~re lY41. draLtr,d trom 19'1:< to 1945 when recruitment was supposedly much easier. By late 1943 Dutch recr'ultmenL ulficlills cuncluded that they had more Or" less exhausted the l!ool at available manpower in the 64 United States. 'rhus in August 1942 Dijxlloorn ordered the closing of all the bureaus and transferred their activities to 65 T. Elink Schuurman, the Consul the consulates and the embassy. General in New York, would no\~ have to assume tile task of supervising recruitment in the United States a duty he did not accept with great alacrity since> he considered it more important to cultivate beeter relationships with the NetilPrlands 66 community. Yet, he continued to be assisted by A. Kerkhoven and others who shouldered mOSL ot the ildlOinistrative responsibil i ty. Very few men were calh,d lip in the ",er iod 19'13-1945 and Kerkhoven and his staff wet"e llIilinly preoccu[Jied with handling administrative matters concerning "men already ser-ving. period November 1943 to ~lay 1 ~4:'. For the b5 men ('e':lister-ed ot which 49 were called up for a medicill examination ilno 2" inducted. Most tikely most of these men were i!~ivlduals who ,night be called up by the American Selective Ser-Vice System but who ",reter-red to 67 serve in the Netherlands ar-med tot"ces. Because of the limited recruitment possibilities and the approaching and expected libe>rution of the Neth;"Llands in the fall of 1944 the Netherlands minister at ..ar, O.C.A. van Lidth de Jeude, decided in August 19'1'1 overseas. Lu discontinue recruitment 'I'here were to be no more dt"att cal.is p.xcept in certain categories, he instructed. But Ile also warnEd that tile Allies not be informed of this decision tormi s in terpre ted. f~ar that it might be It was agreed only to reyistec ar,cl not to 21 68 conscript the men but to accept them as t'lllistees. Thus only a few men left for England in 1945 and by the tall of that year all recruitment activities ceased ill the United States. The war in Europe and the Far East had now come to an end, and the men who survived came home. Did any at them ever regret the decision to serve their native land? It is difficult to 3nswer that question until I hear from many Dutch-Amecicans who served in the Princess Irene Brigade. Since I like t" make i) similac study of Dutch- Canadians who served I like to hear from them as well. 69 address is listed below. My ·r 1. I would llKe to express my sincere ap[.>reciation to Mr. and Mrs. Cnossen, Escondido, California, Mr. Jan Peyrot, Glastonbury, Connecticut, and Nr. John Pais, Carmel., California, for furnishing me with valuable information. !'iessrs. Cnossen, Peyrot, dnLl Pais are veterans of the Princess Irene Brigade. 1 also wrote to many members of the Vereniging van Oudstr iju(=(s van de !\OnlIlJdiJke Brigade "Prinses Irene" residing in the United States. However, all of those who responded to my inquI~y came to the United States after World War 11. 2. See A. Loudon to Netherl~nds Govenllnenc, Nay 15, 1940 and other documents in Gezantschap WashIngton, P-1.8. Recrutering van Netherlanders in de Verenigcle Staten. Londons Archiet Ministerle van BuitenlanJse Zaken, 'rhe Hague. Hereafter, Buitenlandse :Oaf,en cited as BZ. 3. 'rhere is some confUSIon about those '~li'.llb.le tor milltary conscr ipt ion. Londons I\rch ie t, AZ/,) Z REg. Alg. AI, doos 396. Archiet BZ; A. Ker,;l\uven to Louuon, t'ebLuacy 11, 1944 and Reccuitinq Rules Eor lise in the United States of Arner ica, Febr uary .3, l;l <i.j • Ge Zdll t sch at-' Was h 1 ng ton, P8.1./41.1. Reccutering In de Verenigcie St"ten. Archief BZ. See also copy of a reglsLccltlon torm 1i1 Gezantschap Washington, P-8.1/41.2. RegistrHtie Bureau N~w York. Acchief BZ. 4. Kingdom of the NetheclancL;. Stat,?n Generai'll, Tweede Kamer. Enquete Commissie l<eyer im;sbeieici jCJ40- 1'J<lS. Vecslag houdende de uItkomsten van h=t oncler«oeJ-: (The Haque, 1946), 8 A and B:66-70 and bi:i la'je1, p. 13; biJ'lage 5, p. 22. 5. Enquete Commissie, Versluq, 8 A and D: 55.; G.J. Sas to Minister of War, January'!, 1!:>42. Gezantsct1a[.> Washington, P-8.1/41.1. l<ecrutering 111 ue Vel'enigd(= St"ten. "rchief BZ. 6. Memo Ray Atherton, January :U, 1941. Records of the Department of State, HSb.2L2L/2~. l<~cord GCoup 59. National Acchives, Washlt.gton, D.C,; Sas tc ~1inister of Wac, December 1, 1941. GezanLschap Washlligton, l'-tJ.l/41.1 Recruter ing in -de Veren ique Sta ten. l\rch ip l BZ. Bereaftec Recocds of the Departmene of State, Record Gcoup 59 cited as RG 59 with appropriate decimal file number. 7. 'rhe Statutes at Lacge u[ the Uniu,d St:,t"s or Alnecica • • • (Washington, D.C., 191(3), 4U:39-<\O. 8. Green H. Hackworth to Renee Lord, i'lal'ch 15, 856.2222/;04. RG 59. 19·41. 9. ., Consul General J.A. SetJUllrman to Loudon, June 21, 1940. Gezantsehap Washington, 1'-1.t!. Recruterillg van Nederlanders in de Verenigde Staten. InsU"ucties New YorK. Archief BZ, A. Hartog to Loudon, July (" I ':i 4 O. Ge zan t seh"IJ wash ington, P-1. 8. Recrutering van Nederlancl<ec3 in de Verenigoe Staten. Instructies Los Angeles. Arehief BZ. 10. Loudon to Hartog, June 28, 1940. Gezantschap Washington, p1.8. Recrutering van Neclerl-anders in de Verenigde Staten. Instructies Los Angeles. Archiet BZ. 11. E.A. Bunge, Netherlands Consul ill Port Ai:: th ur, to Texas Shell Oil Corporation, Apt"il 7, 1941. Ge zan tschap Washington, P-l.8./41.1. Recruterlng in de Veren igde Staten. Archief BZ, State Departmellt to F.B.I., August 6, 1943. 8~6.2222/5t!. RG 59, 12. Atherton Memo January 22, 13. Memo Hugh S. Cumming ,Au'just 4, 1 ':I<±1. 856.2222/33. RG 59, Memo Netherlands Legatiull, December 12, 1941 ana Cordell Hull to Hen'ry Stimsoll, January 21, I'Hl. fJS6.2222/37 and 856.2222/38. RG 59. 14. Department of State to Netherlands Legation. August 7, 1941 and Department of Justice to Secretary ot State, January 14, 1942. 856/2222/33 and 856.2222/42. Ibid. Dijxhoorn even tried to obtain the census clata but was told that such information was secret. Enquete Commissie, Verslag, 8 A and B: 70. 15. Van Schreven to ?, March 26, 1941. Gezantschap Washington, P-8.1/41.1. Hecrutering ill de Verenigde Stilten. Archief BZ; F.C.L. Weijerman, Mili~ary Attach~, Netherlands Legation, washington, D.C. t.o Van Sctlreven, January 14, 1941. Gezantschap Washington, P-8.1/41.1. Reerutering in de Verenigde Staten. Archlei BZ. 1 6. Loudon to Hull, April 17, 17. Ib id • 18. Ib id • 19. Hull to Loudon, Hay 6, 20. Charles 1. Bevans, ed., 'l'Leaties Clnd Other lnternational Agreements of the United ~;tates ot America, 11"16 1949 (Washington-,-D.C., 19n), 10,149=153. Apparently, the stipulation that Netherl,lfluers who were declarant aliens could not enlist in the l'.etherlancis "Armed f'or'ces was not rigidly adhered to. See K"rkiloven to Loudun, February 11, 1944. Gezantschap Washington, P-U. 1/41. 1. Recrutering in de Ve~enigde Staten. Archief B~ • 19 .. 1.856.2222/25. RG 59. 1942. 1942. 81 1 • 2222/7 1 2. RG 59. Ibid. ., 21. Report on recruitment by Consul Geller-al '1'. EllrlK Schuurman to BZ, March 8, 1944. Lolldons Archie!', AZ/JZ. Reg. 7A. Reorganisatie en ophetfillg van het Nederlandse Detachment in Canada en van de recruter-lngsbureaux •.•. Ar-chief BZ., Recruitment Rules for Use in the united States of North America • • • , Febr.uary 3, 1944. Gezantschap I"/ashington, p8.1/41.1. Recrutering in de Verenigtle Staten. Archief BZ. 22. Loudon to Department of State, April 25, 1944.251.2 Netherlands. Records of the Ar-my Start. Record Group 319. National Archives, Washington, U.C. 23. Most of the information on the de Vogel caEe was obtained from a report by Najor William J. Ivynn to the commanding gener al We s te rn De ten se Command and Fo ur th Army, June 21, 1943 and Report to the Inspector General, September 1, 1943. Records of the Office of the Nljutant General, AG 091.713. Record Group 407. National Archives, \'iashington, D.C.; Charles de Vogel to Sta te Uepar tmen t, Hay 18, ·1943. 856.2222/51. RG 59. 24. Report to Inspector Genet·al, September 1, 1943. Records of the Oftice of the Atlj utant: hecords of the vttice of the Adjutant General, AG 091.11 J. RG 407. 25. Major General Myron C. Cr:alller, Judge Advocate General, to Adjutant General, October 5, 1943. Ibid. 26. War Department to Adjutant General, October 11, 27. War Department to Inspector- General, November 30, 28. Memo Netherlands Legation April 25, Netherlands. RG 319. 29. Memo Raymond T. 30. Loudon to Hull, June 24, 1<)44; and October 13, 856.2226/G-2444, 856.2226/1 U-1344. Ibid. 31. Stimson to Hull, November 16, 1944. 856.2226/11-1644. Ibid. Droste could be rather persistent. See the case of Olof T.C.C. Janssen. 356.117/43. Ibid. 32. See 856.2221-2222 and 356.117. RG 59. 33. On Dutch settlement in the Los Angeles area see Jacob van Hinte, Netherlanders iIl America, transl. Adriaan de Wit (Grand Rapids, 1985},pp. 808-809 ana Gerald F. DeJong, The Dutch in America, 1609-19}4 (Boston, 1975), kJ. 165. 34. 856.2222/31. RG 59. 35. 8~6.2222. Ibid • Yingling, Nay 22, 1943. Ibid. 1943. Ibid. 1944. 251.2 1944. 856.22:<6/4. RG 59. 1944. 36. Enquete Commissie, Versli19, 8 A i1nu B: 69. 37. Loudon to Government in London, Hay 15, 1940. Gezantschap Wash'ington, P-l.8. Recrutecing in de Verenigde Staten. London. Archief BZ. 38. Hartog to Loudon, July 6, 1940. Gezantschap Washington, P1.8. Recrutering van Netherlanders in de Verenigde Staten. Instructies Los Angeles. Archief BZ. 39. Loudon to Buitenlandse Zaken, October 12, 1942. Gezantschap P-8/41.1. Recrutering in de Vel:enigde Staten. Archief BZ. \~ashington, 40. Dijxhoorn to Buitenlandse Zaken, August 27, 1943. Londons Archief. AZ/JZ Reg. 7A. Heorganisatie en opheffing van het Nederlandse Detachement in Canada en de recruter ingsbureaux .... il.t"chief BZ. 41. Sas to Min ister of War, December 1, 1941. Ge zantschap Washington, P-8/41.1. Recnltet-ing in de Verenigde Staten. Archief BZ. 42. P.A. Gilfillan, Acting President Oregon State College to State Department, Januat-y 1:<, 1942. 356.117/46. RG 59. 43. Kroon to Van Wagtendonk, December 31, 1941. Ibid. 44. Dr. Louis Y. Van Dyke' to author October 27, 1987. 45. Enquete Commissie, Verslag, 8 A and B:72. 46. Ibid., pp. 47. Hudig to Minister M.P.L. Steenberghe, May 29, 1941. Gezantschap Washington, [>-1.3. Rappnt:"ten <'an BZ van Hare Majesteits Gezant te Washington. Archief BZ; Loudon to BZ, July 16, 1941. Ar,chief BZ. 48. Enquete Commissie, Verslu<j, 8 A andB:7:Z and bijlage 1, pp. 13-14. 49. Ibid., bijlage 1, p. 6; Statutes Jt Large of the United States of America . (Washington, D.C., 1941),54:895; On benefitS-see also KerJdjo'llen to H. N. Boon June 6, 1944 and extract at Handbao), tot: Secv icemen and Sel.v icewomen • • • of World War 11 and 'l'heTCOel,ienuents. GezantschclLJ Washington.P-8.1/4~2-.-Registratle Bureau New YorJe An.:hief BZ. 50. Kart OVerzicht betretfeillie de t:ecrutering in Canada, U.S.A. en Argen tin i.:!. London, ['Ii'! loch '2 'I , 1 'J 44. Londans I\rch ief , AZ/JZ Reg. 1\1g. E. Vel'sl.:,,) van rect:uter ing i.ll Canada, U.S.A., en Argerltini~. Ac~hiet BZ. 71 and 83 and biJlage 1, p. 10. 51. Loudon to BZ May 29, 19,11. Gezantschap Washington, P-1-3. Rapporten aan BZ van Hare Majesteits GezallL te Washington. Archief BZ. 52. On this see Enquete Commissie, Verslag, 8 A and B: 73-80. 53. Ibid., p. 69. 54. Loudon to Buitenlandse Zaken, October- 12, 1;14<:, Kerkhoven to Loudon, February 11, 1944. Gezantschap Wastlington, P.,. 8.141.1. Recruter ing in (1e Verenigde Staten. ilrchief BZ. 55. N. van Leeuwen to State DeiJaLtment:. 856.2222/22. RG 59. 56. B. C. G. Buss to Department of State, September 27, 856.2222/35. Ibid. 57. Enquete Commissie, Verslaq, U II and B: 7<:. 58. Uecemuet- ;<9, 1940. 1;141. Kort overzicht betrett'onci,' de recLutering in Canada, U.S.A. London, Haren L1, 1~'i4. Ll:;t\c!ons L\rchief, AZ/JZ Reg. Alg. E. VeLslaq van recruterHlg in Canada, U.S.A., en Argentinie. l\ccilier llZ; "Iemo Cununinq, August 4, 1941. 856.2222/33. RG 5,). en Argentini~. 59. United States Department ( ) t Commerce. BULeau of the Census. Sixteentil Census of -the United States: 19Lu. Population (Washington, D.C.-,-1~4J), iJ. 81. 60. Kort overzicht betrettende de recr-utering in Canada, U.S.A., en ArgentinilL London, ['[Llcch 27, 1"44. Londons Archief AZ/JZ Reg. Alg. E. Vecslag- van LecLutering in Canada, U.S.A., en ArgentlniA. IIcciliet BZ. 61. EnquEhe Commissie, VerslihJ. 8A and B, bijlage 1, pp. 62. Kort overzicht betrertende de recrutering in Canada, U.S.A., en Argentinie. London, March 2'l, 1944. Lonclons Archief AZ/JZ Reg. Alg. E. Veralag van recrutering in Canada, U.S.A., en Argentinie. llrchiel HZ. 63. Enqu~te Commissie, 64. Already in July 1942 Van SchLeven concluded that after the U.N. Declaration Netherlands recrUItment oL<janization had lost all "viability" anti considered curtailing its task after August 1 of that year. Vall Schreven to Loudon, July 27, 1942. Gezantschap Washingtul1, P-8. 1/41.2. Recruteringsbureau New York. Archiet BZ. 65. Dijxhoorn to Buitenlandse ZaKen, August 2"1, 1943. Londons Archief, AZ/JZ Reg. Aig. 1::.- Verslag van recLutering in Canada, U.S.A., en Argentinie. ArchieL BZ. Vers12Y, 8 A anu B, bijlage 1, p. 15-16. 15. Oc lob", r <: 'oJ, 66. El ink Sch uurman to /3u i te Ill" IlU se Z<.!j,en, Ibid. 1943. 67. Elink Schuurman to Buitenlanus Zaken, June 5, 68. O.C.A. Lidth de Jeude to lluitenlandse Zal<.en, August 28, 1944, to Minister of Colonies, Se",tember 13, 1944, to Van Kleffens, September 13 alld :i'oJ, l'oJ44, Van Kleftens to Van Lidth, September 25, 1~44, and t ( l Loudon, October 2, 1944. Londons Archie!:, AZ/JZ A Ill. Hey. illyelfieen, doos 396. Archie!: BZ. 69. Department of History, Illinois b 1761 1945. Ibid. illinOiS State University, Normal,