doc2016 Sale Study - St. Clair Shores, MI
download 
Report Transcription
2016 Sale Study - St. Clair Shores, MI
2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-01-102-020 09-14-01-102-041 09-14-01-103-004 09-14-01-103-010 09-14-01-103-051 09-14-01-104-009 09-14-01-104-033 09-14-01-105-012 09-14-01-105-031 09-14-01-128-021 09-14-01-151-027 09-14-01-154-002 09-14-01-155-002 09-14-01-155-010 09-14-01-301-018 09-14-02-126-013 09-14-02-128-019 09-14-02-128-021 09-14-02-128-023 09-14-02-129-006 09-14-02-129-017 09-14-02-155-004 09-14-02-155-031 09-14-02-155-048 09-14-02-155-051 09-14-02-155-056 09-14-02-155-077 09-14-02-157-002 09-14-02-176-023 09-14-02-177-006 09-14-02-177-012 09-14-02-177-023 09-14-02-177-044 09-14-02-177-044 09-14-02-178-004 09-14-02-178-006 09-14-02-178-008 09-14-02-178-019 09-14-02-178-021 09-14-02-178-046 09-14-02-178-051 Sale Date 11/15/2013 12/11/2014 10/1/2014 8/2/2015 6/5/2015 2/13/2015 3/18/2014 10/30/2014 8/7/2014 10/31/2014 7/6/2015 12/19/2014 8/19/2015 11/21/2014 10/22/2013 10/18/2013 9/4/2014 11/22/2013 11/4/2014 2/6/2014 6/19/2014 11/7/2014 7/18/2014 8/14/2015 4/1/2015 10/3/2013 2/20/2015 6/26/2014 6/18/2014 11/3/2014 10/24/2014 5/14/2015 1/14/2014 4/16/2014 6/5/2014 6/27/2014 11/21/2014 2/6/2015 8/29/2014 7/2/2015 8/28/2015 Grantor GRICIUS RONALD J & STANKEGRICIUS KA JACOB, JOHN WERBACK RICHARD MCFAUL FAMILY TRUST TAVA, TROY/JENNIFER ZECH, JOHN/JEANETTE MCCROSSIN, SAMANTHA SMART, STANLEY B. KUEHN, KELLY MCBRIDE, JOSHUA DWAYNE ZAJAC, JASON A WEICHEL, BOBBIE JO BURTCH, JOHN/SHAWN COLOMBO, DIANE N. - TRUST HARCHICK DAVID R ZERILLI GARY VESTA PROPERTY GROUP LLC GG & K PROPERTIES LLC BOWIN, MICHAEL SAAL INVESTMENTS 2013 LLC YUCE REAL ESTATE LLC BARNES, BETTY JANE - TRUST THURMOND, MELISSA L. LINHARDT JR, ARNOLD IVINSON, BRENDA/KENNETH COURY DARRYL P & PATRICIA PICARD, LOUISE FRASARD-BRUDER, CHERYL A KETELHUT, JACK W VAN HEVEL, RAYMOND RICHARD TRENT BUCCI, DOMINICO LEVAI, TIBOR/MARIA SLEEK, GARY ZENO HOLDINGS LLC DEFELICE, GILDA/ITALO CYBULSKI, MARY SAULLO KELLY FRANK, ROBERT/DIANE PIGULA, GWENDOLYN J/ ROBERT A REDLAWSK, MELVIN/P CIMINELLI, ANGELENE Grantee REYGAERT PAUL A KOCH ALLISON YANDURA CHRISTINE A RUGGIERO RICHARD & WYFFELS JENNIFER VALKEN JEFFREY R DIAMOND ANN LEVERENCE RICKY D JR BRIESCH CHRISTOPHER A ROTHENHAUSER SHEILA D SOBH ALI HILTON JAMES D VICTOR JESSICA C AHO GEORGE GUY & NOWAK RENEE M TROMBLY DANIEL & MARTHA LAMB SUSAN MARIE CONROY CHAD J & KENDRA S HOSNER CHARLES STIER LEWIS W & JANICE L WRIGHT ALEXANDER A STUDNIK LLC STEFANOSKI JOVICA HERING DIANA FORTHOFFER JOLA CMJ INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LONDO ARTHUR TOPCIU ARTAN MOSORJAK JOAN JJB INVESTMENT LLC NASSAR GARY S II BAILLEAUX CARRIE LUBANSKI JACLYN M PELLETIER ASHLEY M ZENO HOLDINGS LLC MARGGRANDER ERIC M GREENARCH THOMAS W MCKEE JENNIFER SMITH SUSAN KELLY DAVIS LINWOOD DAY POLJANAC WENDY MATHIS FRANK E & DEBRA S BOLUS JEFFREY M WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD Class 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 125,000 82,000 132,000 115,000 135,000 107,000 128,000 95,000 78,900 440,000 82,000 120,000 430,000 429,000 105,000 109,000 122,000 102,000 116,000 69,685 44,900 31,000 38,550 37,500 40,000 39,000 32,268 115,500 97,500 116,000 107,000 127,000 76,000 124,900 119,000 108,300 123,000 128,000 87,000 136,000 139,900 SEV 41,600 54,100 52,600 54,700 60,500 45,700 45,700 31,200 21,900 275,900 34,300 45,700 171,100 146,900 38,500 39,400 37,500 38,300 44,400 31,600 18,600 9,800 17,900 18,700 19,300 14,000 9,500 40,300 32,200 39,200 40,500 45,000 40,000 41,000 49,700 48,100 41,700 44,100 48,900 53,300 50,100 Ratio 33.28 65.98 39.85 47.57 44.81 42.71 35.70 32.84 27.76 62.70 41.83 38.08 39.79 34.24 36.67 36.15 30.74 37.55 38.28 45.35 41.43 31.61 46.43 49.87 48.25 35.90 29.44 34.89 33.03 33.79 37.85 35.43 52.63 32.83 41.76 44.41 33.90 34.45 56.21 39.19 35.81 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-02-178-054 09-14-02-179-024 09-14-02-180-004 09-14-02-183-005 09-14-02-183-006 09-14-02-183-015 09-14-02-183-019 09-14-02-202-008 09-14-02-202-020 09-14-02-203-010 09-14-02-203-022 09-14-02-205-003 09-14-02-205-012 09-14-02-206-012 09-14-02-207-004 09-14-02-207-007 09-14-02-207-031 09-14-02-207-035 09-14-02-208-015 09-14-02-208-042 09-14-02-208-049 09-14-02-227-008 09-14-02-228-041 09-14-02-228-043 09-14-02-229-005 09-14-02-229-019 09-14-02-230-004 09-14-02-233-010 09-14-02-233-011 09-14-02-233-026 09-14-02-252-011 09-14-02-252-033 09-14-02-253-026 09-14-02-253-027 09-14-02-253-032 09-14-02-253-032 09-14-02-254-006 09-14-02-255-016 09-14-02-255-030 09-14-02-256-003 09-14-02-257-003 Sale Date 9/15/2014 10/7/2014 3/26/2014 7/31/2015 10/10/2014 4/30/2014 6/8/2015 8/15/2014 11/25/2013 11/27/2013 12/31/2013 5/21/2014 5/21/2015 6/30/2014 10/29/2014 8/26/2015 7/17/2015 7/2/2015 7/23/2014 9/23/2015 7/10/2015 11/21/2014 12/17/2014 8/27/2014 10/9/2014 5/18/2015 12/12/2013 12/18/2013 5/29/2015 4/30/2015 6/4/2015 10/28/2013 4/29/2015 4/17/2014 3/12/2014 6/10/2015 5/26/2015 11/4/2013 6/10/2015 1/14/2014 12/18/2013 Grantor LOUKAS EDWARD WINESKI, LEONARD/HOWARAH, JENNIFER SULFLOW, GERALD/SANDRA - ET AL TURLEY, MATTHEW/KLOS, ANNETTE TNB CONNECT LLC TNB CONNECT LLC DETTLOFF, DONALD/SANDRA BERKELEY DEVELOPMENT CO LLC MCAULEY, ROSE PALMER PARK PROPERTIES LLC GRAHAM, HAROLD/KRISTIN TURNER, STEVEN P. SAYLES, RONALD - TRUST BUDZYNSKI, KEVIN/CAMPBELL, CYNTHIA RICE, DANNY/STEHANIE KRAVITZ PROPERTIES, LLC HARSEN, JEFFREY/CONCETTA BORLAND GROUP LLC PIERCE, JOSEPH VARIO, CHERYL HUTCHINSON, JOEL PAYE, CLARENCE/PATRICIA SAURINE, CHRIS/DONITA HENSEL, CHELSEY PALADIN FUND II LLC WOJCIK CHRISTY SPARTAN EQUITIES HIGH YIELD SOUTHWEST HOUSING SOLUTIONS CORP LOMBARDI, MARK A. HILT, SCOTT L DAVIS, MICHAEL MALONE PATRICIA J BOWMAN, JASON RUMMELL, ROBERT PREFERRED HOMES MICHIGAN LLC DESERT FUND ONE LLC BURGESS, ERIC J WARE, WILBUR IRVING HACHEY, MICHELLE L. VITELLI JOHN THOMAS, ROBERT F./M. Grantee ONEIL KYLE B SLEZAK MICHAEL & ASHLEY HARMS LESLIE J JR VIGER JASON & MACKEY JESSICA SHABAZZ JALIL RUGGIRELLO ALEXANDER & LINDA MARTIN LISA J HARRISON JACOB & NEWLAND STEPHENI JAKUBIEC RAYMOND ABEL MARY C GLOMBOSKI PAULA MULLIGAN GREGORY JR & YURK LHEA LANDERS BRIAN & LENA LANEY NICOLE RENEE HADDAD TONY & DANA BROZO CHRISTOPHER FIGIEL STEPHANIE PSN PROPERTIES LLC SZYCHULSKI CHRISTOPHER YASBECK WILLIAM HESS CHRISTOPHER & THERESA ORSI MATTHEW DAVID FILIPEK RAYMOND & LOUGHMAN NICOLLE KAHL COLLEEN CONSTANTIA 4 LLC TURNER TEQUISHA S HEROD CHRISTOPHER M ANTIEAU DENISE M BECK LAUREN J LEE MAXWELL N JR DDN ENTERPRISE INC GOLLEHUR JACOB RUSSELL INVESTMENTS INC HEAD SHANNON DESERT FUND ONE LLC KISLER INVESTMENTS LLC CILLUFFO JOSEPH J JR CAPERTON BEVERLEE A SCHAFER RACHEL BUCHHOLZ NICHOLAS & ERICA CASTELLANO COURTNEY L Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 155,000 124,900 124,900 141,000 199,000 132,000 134,900 150,000 76,000 114,000 66,000 134,000 145,500 104,900 58,500 85,000 105,000 52,500 108,000 106,000 132,000 130,000 147,000 125,000 51,000 58,000 69,000 64,000 86,000 75,000 56,000 95,500 19,000 87,000 60,000 70,460 105,500 76,000 147,500 125,000 77,000 SEV 51,200 41,000 43,000 55,900 49,400 41,600 61,100 65,500 31,800 38,300 41,200 50,300 62,300 31,600 28,300 36,600 42,600 33,400 39,500 43,400 58,500 46,100 63,500 47,300 30,400 40,900 33,200 18,300 44,500 36,700 29,200 33,600 8,900 41,000 23,700 27,600 31,000 36,300 57,100 40,600 33,600 Ratio 33.03 32.83 34.43 39.65 24.82 31.52 45.29 43.67 41.84 33.60 62.42 37.54 42.82 30.12 48.38 43.06 40.57 63.62 36.57 40.94 44.32 35.46 43.20 37.84 59.61 70.52 48.12 28.59 51.74 48.93 52.14 35.18 46.84 47.13 39.50 39.17 29.38 47.76 38.71 32.48 43.64 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-02-257-004 09-14-02-257-006 09-14-02-257-007 09-14-02-257-007 09-14-02-257-013 09-14-02-277-002 09-14-02-277-002 09-14-02-277-006 09-14-02-277-017 09-14-02-277-019 09-14-02-277-037 09-14-02-278-029 09-14-02-278-034 09-14-02-278-034 09-14-02-278-047 09-14-02-279-016 09-14-02-279-016 09-14-02-279-039 09-14-02-279-041 09-14-02-302-007 09-14-02-302-008 09-14-02-302-008 09-14-02-302-008 09-14-02-302-011 09-14-02-304-013 09-14-02-304-033 09-14-02-305-039 09-14-02-305-044 09-14-02-306-025 09-14-02-306-038 09-14-02-306-047 09-14-02-306-067 09-14-02-307-023 09-14-02-307-026 09-14-02-307-039 09-14-02-328-027 09-14-02-329-008 09-14-02-333-013 09-14-02-333-020 09-14-02-333-026 09-14-02-335-003 Sale Date 8/13/2015 6/23/2014 10/18/2013 4/24/2014 11/28/2014 10/15/2013 6/17/2014 12/9/2013 7/25/2014 8/20/2015 10/30/2013 7/17/2014 10/16/2013 12/17/2014 5/28/2014 11/8/2013 9/11/2015 11/5/2013 8/31/2015 6/27/2014 12/18/2013 12/18/2013 7/13/2015 12/5/2014 10/25/2013 8/26/2015 6/4/2014 8/19/2015 7/3/2014 12/18/2014 2/18/2015 2/25/2015 9/15/2015 5/6/2015 7/3/2014 9/15/2014 10/10/2014 5/1/2015 8/14/2015 5/29/2015 6/16/2015 Grantor CARLON, ROBERT/JANET ONE PUTT MANAGEMENT LLC FAST CASH FOR HOMES LLC GG & K PROPERTIES LLC LUETTICKEN, STEPHANIE VOSS ROBERT C & MARY ANN C TRUST SHADOW LLC KAUFMAN, PAUL KRAVITZ PROPERTIES, LLC INGOGLIA, PETER A HUDGENS DON G & JACLYN M HERING, MATTHEW MARZAN CHRISTIAN N & CHERILYN A SHANER, JUSTIN TRUPIANO THAIS KREBS, ELEANOR D. ORR, LYNDEY M/ NATHAN W KETELHUT CHRISTOPHER & JENNIFER BAJIS, SANDRA L COE, KATHLEEN DHJ PROPERTIES LLC TRUPIANO, ROSEMARY KAMIL-SALMAN AL- QASSAB, ZAHER BIDIGARE, MICHAEL A BANDEMER GEORGE M & SALLY A BREESE, JASON SPARTAN EQUITIES HIGH YEILD FUND I ELDERSON, DENNIS F/FRANCES C PALUZZI, JAMES J WINCZNER, PHYLLIS R. BOVE JOHN & SHARON LOVEJOY, JOSEPH/JACQUELINE KOWALEWSKI, ANNETTE INCH MICHAEL E JIMED LLC NABOZNY, JARED M WIDLICKA, JONATHAN/ROZANA DOMBROW, DARYL M ENGLISH JR., EUGENE WOCHOSKI, KATHLEEN ROJEWSKI FAMILY TRUST Grantee VACHON ERIC SOKOL RHONDA M GG & K PROPERTIES LLC TALOS JOHN & VINEYARD BRITANI ALLIANZ A G SHADOW LLC PONTE NICHOLAS G GEP PROPERTIES LLC STEAKLEY JOHN & KRISTY BLASKOWSKI JOSHUA LINVILLE SCOTT M EARLE CLIFFORD & SCHENCK LINDA SHANER JUSTIN A BONELLO VICTOR J MIKES CONSTRUCTION LLC ORR NATHAN W & LYNDSEY M BACKUS GEORGE M JR COMBE REBECCA D HARRINGTON JAMES R CANTY JON F & NADINE TRUPIANO ROSEMARY ALQASSAB ZAHER KAMILSALMAN FAN HOLDINGS LLC HAMAMA MARY RICHARDSON GARRY & SARAH PHIPPS ALISE HALL PHILLIP & NANCY CORCORAN PATRICK III BRICKER LISA GABOW JAMES TYMOSIAK HUBERT HOTCHKISS TRAVIS & LESHIA KLENK KAREN HAM JAMES J & HELENA S DENNIS WILFRED & MARGARETE TRUST MISURACA YVONNE WISEMAN TIMOTHY & NORTON GRACE HERR SALEM & KELLI J VERHAGEN JAMES SCHEUERMAN ERIC & HEBBARD CHRISTOPH KEELEAN JOSHUA & AMY Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 115,000 64,500 60,437 126,000 38,880 61,900 105,000 68,000 100,000 91,000 117,000 119,500 98,000 122,000 60,000 93,000 108,900 160,000 110,000 32,500 36,000 34,100 32,000 40,000 103,000 132,900 58,000 95,000 142,000 115,000 108,000 85,000 97,000 100,000 95,000 120,000 130,100 199,000 100,500 122,000 99,900 SEV 45,400 22,600 39,800 41,100 26,600 31,900 32,500 32,300 37,100 33,700 42,500 39,400 40,700 42,200 34,000 36,900 43,000 69,200 37,600 15,300 12,200 12,200 15,800 15,100 48,200 45,800 31,900 26,300 53,000 49,200 35,800 41,200 34,300 34,300 32,500 41,100 46,200 94,500 40,400 44,900 43,200 Ratio 39.48 35.04 65.85 32.62 68.42 51.53 30.95 47.50 37.10 37.03 36.32 32.97 41.53 34.59 56.67 39.68 39.49 43.25 34.18 47.08 33.89 35.78 49.38 37.75 46.80 34.46 55.00 27.68 37.32 42.78 33.15 48.47 35.36 34.30 34.21 34.25 35.51 47.49 40.20 36.80 43.24 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-02-335-007 09-14-02-335-009 09-14-02-336-011 09-14-02-336-030 09-14-02-336-030 09-14-02-336-035 09-14-02-336-036 09-14-02-351-001 09-14-02-351-006 09-14-02-351-013 09-14-02-351-021 09-14-02-351-031 09-14-02-351-046 09-14-02-351-064 09-14-02-352-002 09-14-02-352-003 09-14-02-352-008 09-14-02-352-027 09-14-02-376-002 09-14-02-376-007 09-14-02-376-014 09-14-02-376-020 09-14-02-377-020 09-14-02-377-021 09-14-02-378-026 09-14-02-379-001 09-14-02-379-008 09-14-02-379-011 09-14-02-379-017 09-14-02-380-029 09-14-02-381-006 09-14-02-381-011 09-14-02-381-020 09-14-02-401-002 09-14-02-401-002 09-14-02-403-006 09-14-02-404-010 09-14-02-404-011 09-14-02-404-035 09-14-02-405-009 09-14-02-405-016 Sale Date 8/5/2015 8/11/2014 8/21/2015 10/29/2013 6/20/2014 6/25/2015 3/12/2015 8/25/2015 1/31/2014 7/22/2015 3/26/2014 6/26/2015 2/26/2014 1/22/2015 12/2/2014 7/20/2015 1/3/2014 8/4/2014 9/4/2014 11/13/2013 4/21/2014 8/21/2014 7/24/2015 7/25/2014 8/5/2014 10/11/2013 6/18/2014 1/9/2015 3/25/2015 8/31/2015 7/31/2014 2/6/2015 8/21/2014 6/20/2014 10/24/2014 5/23/2014 8/7/2014 11/1/2013 5/28/2014 8/28/2015 9/17/2015 Grantor JEANGUENAT, GENE T./N. MALLON, ROBERT/KATHY DAMM GLORIA JUNE FAMILY TRUST PETRACCA JOSEPH A TRUST PREUTHUN, PAULA - TRUST ELSEY RICHARD L FAMILY TRUST KORTE LORRAINE M TRUST QUENNEVILLE, BRIAN J/ PAOLINE A RECZEK, MARK A./MICHELLE PELTIER, ANN MARIE/ EDWARD BALTAZAR, ELIZABETH/ ROMMEL CALLOS SCHADE, NICHOLAS RAYNER, JOSEPH H FLEMMING, KURT/LANE, BRENDA DHANIS-ROUSE, PATRICE ETAL SPOT REALTY INC DG RESIDENTIAL SALES LLC KOHLER, CHARLES B HALL, EARL - TRUST EADDY, EILEEN MARTINEZ/ GLENN MARTIN, TIMOTHY SOUTHWEST HOUSING SOLUTIONS CORP NIEMASZ, TOM FLOHR WILLY CHRONIS, KIM DAVIS DOUGLAS A & LAURA DEBONO DENISCIA MILLER, JOYCE - TRUST COUREY, MARIANNE SMITH, CANDACE L/ MATTHEW J KIELKUCKI, JACQUELYN M/ MARC FREUND LINDA BOLEK, MADONNA/ ST AUBIN, GEORGE J ZIELINSKI, DAVID RAAD RICHARD & KAREN CROFF, REBECCA L MURPHY, BRYAN MORAN DANNY T & MARGARET E SCHELL, WILLIAM/C. FOWLER, KENNETH LIVELY, SEAN Grantee RESPONDEK RICHARD DONEGAN ROBERT B JR & SUNUN H TIRY NICHOLAS R PREUTHUN PAULA TRUST WENTZ JANET K SAAD FAMILY LLC DANGELO MICHAEL T & SUSAN LYNN PINTOSKI STEPHEN & DANIELLE PIKARSKI LISA BEARDSLEY JAMES L & CHERISH GIORDANO VICKI YAGHNAM PATRICK SILAGE KEITH M & JENNA M DILLARD DARA LAVERE SHANON M CULLENBINE ROY JOSEPH PRANGER JEFFREY C ELBERSON MATTHEW & SIERRA WALSH TIMOTHY & PROVENCHER NICOLE SHKEMBI AUREL & BRUNILDA SANITATE CASEY R HERRERA ALEX & PAULINE CHOICE SHEMCHIA INEZ KOVALCIK JANET M SCHOENFELD LINDSEY GOLEMBA VALERIE LONG KEVIN KOWALESKI JEFFREY M RENNON PETER & LILLIAN CUFFARO JEREMIE J KALETA ROCCO & SARAH LABUHN KATHERINE A PUDRITH DEREK RAAD RICHARD & KAREN PREISTER CHRISTOPHER & WINALIS DAYN RUTHERFORD SAMANTHA LIDEN DONALD C JR & HOLLIE NEVEJANS GEORGE SIEGLER MELISSA R KLOKA ROBERT JJB8 INVESTMENT LLC Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 125,000 96,000 98,000 119,500 112,000 96,000 95,000 150,000 126,000 115,000 101,500 133,000 142,100 127,500 58,000 109,500 120,000 175,000 117,500 120,000 122,700 69,900 83,500 64,000 119,800 62,000 84,800 127,900 105,000 122,500 138,000 82,000 80,000 85,500 122,000 120,000 141,000 119,900 128,750 146,500 131,000 SEV 55,300 39,900 47,500 32,600 37,900 46,700 37,700 50,500 42,700 51,600 35,500 44,600 44,900 42,400 19,900 43,900 40,700 48,100 39,200 47,900 49,400 34,600 35,500 29,800 39,800 34,200 30,700 47,800 33,700 58,900 51,200 37,600 33,800 36,400 36,400 39,100 52,900 45,900 41,600 57,900 54,200 Ratio 44.24 41.56 48.47 27.28 33.84 48.65 39.68 33.67 33.89 44.87 34.98 33.53 31.60 33.25 34.31 40.09 33.92 27.49 33.36 39.92 40.26 49.50 42.51 46.56 33.22 55.16 36.20 37.37 32.10 48.08 37.10 45.85 42.25 42.57 29.84 32.58 37.52 38.28 32.31 39.52 41.37 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-02-405-021 09-14-02-405-024 09-14-02-405-040 09-14-02-427-003 09-14-02-427-014 09-14-02-427-021 09-14-02-427-023 09-14-02-429-004 09-14-02-452-007 09-14-02-452-014 09-14-02-452-037 09-14-02-453-017 09-14-02-453-021 09-14-02-453-030 09-14-02-453-030 09-14-02-453-038 09-14-02-454-016 09-14-02-454-019 09-14-03-178-021 09-14-03-178-026 09-14-03-178-031 09-14-03-178-035 09-14-03-178-050 09-14-03-202-006 09-14-03-202-009 09-14-03-202-024 09-14-03-202-028 09-14-03-202-030 09-14-03-202-032 09-14-03-202-046 09-14-03-202-055 09-14-03-202-067 09-14-03-202-070 09-14-03-202-078 09-14-03-202-096 09-14-03-202-099 09-14-03-202-100 09-14-03-203-002 09-14-03-203-004 09-14-03-203-006 09-14-03-203-010 Sale Date 5/6/2015 8/21/2015 2/27/2015 6/12/2015 2/20/2015 9/15/2015 12/23/2013 11/8/2013 3/28/2014 5/8/2014 11/22/2013 2/27/2014 12/10/2014 10/7/2014 5/21/2015 6/12/2015 9/4/2014 5/28/2014 11/12/2014 6/17/2015 5/21/2015 2/18/2014 1/22/2015 2/28/2014 1/21/2014 6/19/2015 6/20/2014 9/25/2015 10/3/2014 6/12/2015 11/26/2013 6/30/2015 6/3/2015 2/9/2015 6/4/2014 3/12/2014 10/23/2013 10/7/2013 4/9/2015 11/26/2013 2/13/2015 Grantor COMITO, DOROTHY C. WRIGHT, JOSEPH A. LANE, LONNIE/MAGDALENA PRIESKORN ERIC REARDON JR., RICHARD/JENNIFER SPARKS, RICK GRAVES, DONALD/ ERNEST CLAERHOUT SCOTT & LEIGHA SUBIC, MICHAEL SHAMROCK ACUISITIONS LLC LEVINE, JOAN - TRUST CIMINI NICOLE BASELINE FINANCIAL LLC COMERICA BANK SHEPHERD, DERIC E SAELENS, JAMES H - TRUST GALVAN, MAURO/MICHELLE KAISER, ROBERT P BRENNAN, JOHN/TISKA, TERRY WOLNY, LORI MARIE KORDICH, DOROTHY GIANNOSA DOMENIC JAMES & ALBERT ANG CLOGG, E. SUZANNE BROWN ROSEMARY TRUST BRANDLE, FREDRICK/CAROLE MADA, SAMUEL M BETTINI, BETHANY THUN, JUDITH - TRUST LA COMMARE, CHRISTINA PEABODY, JAMES/MICHELLE RODGARD, HAROLD H. CAMPBELL, HALL/BRUCE/SCOTT CATINELLA, CARL - TRUST CHAIRMAN, DELORIS A/ VAN R RANNO, PHILIP S. GUZIK ANDREW R JONES ORENDALL M GOYETTE JOAN M SAMANI, KAVEH/ALHAM MORTENSON, ELAINE TOMCZAK, ERIN Grantee BUBECK CHARLES & SNYDER RUTH ANN JAGIELSKI MICHAEL D GUINANE DAVID IRA HAGEMANN GREGORY CARIGNAN SCOTT & MELISSA PIREH YOUSHIA EDWARD BOBEK MATTHEW M BUTTERY RONALD G & SUSAN R WINTERFIELD HEATHER S SHERLOCK KERRY GUDENAU NEIL T MJW SPLASH LLC JOHNSON JOSHUA M SHEPHERD DERIC E BROWN KURT SERRA ANTHONY GALVAN STEPHANIE NUSBAUM MABELLE VALENCIA ALVIN & PANICH TAMINIE QUIGLEY RYAN KECK DAVID H JR & BARBARA CHRISTMAN, WILLIAM BIDOUL THOMAS A KOERNER JOHN H & ALICE A ZIN CHRISTOPHER D & HOOKER MARY E PSARI NERTIL & TUKE LORELA KRZYMINSKI STACY ROACH KENNETH R & HELEN UPSHAW RUTH NOVAK JOHN A BRADLEY MARY LOU STAWIASZ, SEAN ROBINSON KAREN GROSFIELD MERRILL F JOHNSON ALEX F ESTES GREG & LORI DAVIS NORMAN A JR MILHIM NORMA POWELL ROBERT & MARY MCCARROLL MARGARETE ALEXANDER RENEE Class LC WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 Sale Price 90,000 122,000 100,000 110,000 130,000 109,000 82,000 133,000 118,000 127,000 85,000 61,000 128,000 57,000 105,000 75,000 101,000 62,000 80,000 80,000 80,000 65,000 80,000 69,900 81,000 82,500 80,000 80,000 76,000 79,000 67,000 70,000 80,000 70,000 78,950 75,000 71,000 85,000 72,500 90,000 83,000 SEV 43,300 48,900 31,000 41,600 46,000 36,700 36,500 53,000 51,100 44,500 36,000 38,700 44,100 28,700 37,800 37,500 44,600 22,700 28,100 39,800 32,800 26,600 28,100 27,500 28,800 35,700 33,100 32,600 26,900 32,600 27,500 32,600 32,600 27,700 26,900 33,100 28,800 31,000 36,300 31,000 33,500 Ratio 48.11 40.08 31.00 37.82 35.38 33.67 44.51 39.85 43.31 35.04 42.35 63.44 34.45 50.35 36.00 50.00 44.16 36.61 35.13 49.75 41.00 40.92 35.13 39.34 35.56 43.27 41.38 40.75 35.39 41.27 41.04 46.57 40.75 39.57 34.07 44.13 40.56 36.47 50.07 34.44 40.36 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-03-203-031 09-14-03-203-034 09-14-03-203-049 09-14-03-203-062 09-14-03-204-025 09-14-03-204-026 09-14-03-204-027 09-14-03-204-066 09-14-03-204-071 09-14-03-204-074 09-14-03-204-077 09-14-03-204-078 09-14-03-204-095 09-14-03-204-104 09-14-03-206-016 09-14-03-206-023 09-14-03-206-029 09-14-03-206-033 09-14-03-227-040 09-14-03-227-046 09-14-03-227-048 09-14-03-251-107 09-14-03-251-108 09-14-03-251-114 09-14-03-251-116 09-14-03-251-122 09-14-03-251-128 09-14-03-251-138 09-14-03-251-149 09-14-03-251-167 09-14-03-251-168 09-14-03-251-180 09-14-03-277-021 09-14-03-277-040 09-14-03-277-046 09-14-03-326-012 09-14-03-326-013 09-14-03-326-031 09-14-03-327-034 09-14-03-327-071 09-14-03-327-072 Sale Date 12/27/2013 2/4/2015 6/30/2015 12/17/2014 3/14/2014 5/30/2014 1/24/2014 4/30/2014 8/6/2015 4/17/2015 6/16/2014 6/12/2015 2/6/2015 3/31/2014 4/30/2015 6/19/2015 6/20/2014 12/19/2013 5/27/2015 12/5/2014 5/22/2015 5/8/2014 5/20/2015 1/7/2015 4/30/2015 4/4/2014 5/30/2014 5/22/2015 8/18/2014 11/20/2014 10/25/2013 7/30/2014 11/1/2013 5/28/2014 8/27/2015 5/29/2015 5/28/2014 6/26/2015 10/15/2014 10/3/2014 12/20/2013 Grantor FRAMPTON, ELWIN - TRUST PORTA, ANTHONY M GIACALONE, JENNIE - TRUST MARSHALL, MORRISON/LOIS GILES WILLIAM L GRIFO, ELEANOR WALSH SALLY W AMATO, JEFFREY A/ PAMELA MAROZI, KAREN K DALY MATTHEW J BRADLEY BRIAN & WHITTAKER JAMES KOSMECKI, ROBERT AYRAULT, ELSIE -TRUST KIESGEN, GREGORY STIEBER PATRICIA E MANCHESTER-ST CLAIR INVESTMENTS LLC MANCHESTER-ST CLAIR INVESTMENTS LLC HARRY MAJOR MACHINE & TOOL CO CUNNINGHAM, MICHAEL KUCZERA RENATA ANKOBEA-ANSAH, ROBERT POKER EUGENE E TRUST KEATING, HENRY/ELIZABETH HIRSCHFIELD, SIDNEY STEEPE, DONALD F. JJ INVESTMENT INC MEREDITH WILLIAM LANGFORD, JAMES/MARY - TRUST KOSTRACH, BETTY/ DONALD MATTHAI CONSTANCE L TRUST WILSON KARL T & SANDRA M MOCERI THERESA MARIE LIETKE FRANK G NGUYEN, HAI THI/ PHAM, HONG VAN MANSFIELD, DAVID J BUNETTA, RIANA HATCHER, GREGORY BISSELL, MICHELLE C. MANNA DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION BULLO, JAMES D. LOUKAS EDWARD A Grantee HOFFMAN MICHAEL & SUSAN FALVEY ANDREW D & GEORGINA HASSEBROCK JOY L METZNER GRACE REDDING LUCY V TRUST VOELKER HAROLD F & NANCY DUNGAN DONALD G & SUSAN A VANEGMOND NANETTE C CALDERWOOD RITA BAWKON BONNIE VOELKER EVA MARIE KIM YOUNG S LESLIE CHRISTINE M MIELE KRISTINE E ROUHIB VICTORIA KIEFER MARY KOENIG KENNETH S & DOROTHY LAURANNE REAL ESTATE CO LLC THOMAS PHILIP I & KIMBERLY A MYSIEROWICZ WILLIAM BURNS KELLY MAE KNOX DAVID MCKAY KEVIN & BETTE JO GALAT JOSEPH JOHN TRUST DAVIN ROSALIND & ROY TACKETT DORIS VAN BECELAERE GEORGE & AUDREY LEWANDOWSKI EDWARD & SHARON GOODMAN MARJORIE CHEEK DOUGLAS M & SHANNON M HAAS MICHAEL & ROSEMARIE STANEK VERONICA MARIE DETGEN ROBERT A PAPPAS MATTHEW PENNOCK BRANDON J & ALISHA KLANN KYLE R MCQUEEN CYNTHIA LEADER THOMAS C HENDERSON TAHIYAH R CAPRARA BENJAMIN & AUBRY DOLIVO ANTHONY Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 401 401 407 403 403 404 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 65,000 83,000 87,000 91,500 63,500 129,000 94,000 110,000 120,000 92,000 135,000 62,000 114,000 175,000 142,500 147,750 148,000 147,000 160,000 157,500 118,500 75,000 112,000 122,500 127,000 119,900 115,000 118,500 117,500 115,000 105,000 142,000 79,000 85,000 166,000 103,500 100,000 99,000 133,000 130,000 131,000 SEV 23,000 33,500 34,800 27,300 22,300 37,100 29,700 31,800 44,600 46,400 37,100 33,000 35,900 63,200 73,400 73,600 73,200 65,000 62,700 72,100 83,900 37,900 51,100 41,500 55,900 38,300 38,100 55,800 38,000 38,100 37,000 41,600 29,200 58,200 70,700 40,400 37,400 40,100 42,200 45,900 41,600 Ratio 35.38 40.36 40.00 29.84 35.12 28.76 31.60 28.91 37.17 50.43 27.48 53.23 31.49 36.11 51.51 49.81 49.46 44.22 39.19 45.78 70.80 50.53 45.63 33.88 44.02 31.94 33.13 47.09 32.34 33.13 35.24 29.30 36.96 68.47 42.59 39.03 37.40 40.51 31.73 35.31 31.76 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-03-327-081 09-14-03-328-014 09-14-03-328-026 09-14-03-328-037 09-14-03-329-003 09-14-03-329-005 09-14-03-329-007 09-14-03-330-024 09-14-03-330-025 09-14-03-331-005 09-14-03-376-021 09-14-03-377-006 09-14-03-377-026 09-14-03-377-037 09-14-03-378-016 09-14-03-378-020 09-14-03-379-009 09-14-03-380-008 09-14-03-401-023 09-14-03-402-003 09-14-03-402-012 09-14-03-403-008 09-14-03-405-021 09-14-03-407-006 09-14-03-407-024 09-14-03-409-007 09-14-03-426-015 09-14-03-427-004 09-14-03-427-004 09-14-03-427-006 09-14-03-427-007 09-14-03-427-013 09-14-03-428-013 09-14-03-428-015 09-14-03-430-007 09-14-03-431-003 09-14-03-433-005 09-14-03-434-001 09-14-03-434-003 09-14-03-434-004 09-14-03-434-012 Sale Date 6/10/2015 7/17/2015 11/8/2013 8/12/2014 10/23/2013 6/5/2015 6/25/2015 11/14/2014 10/7/2013 8/29/2014 5/28/2015 7/2/2014 10/24/2014 5/1/2015 8/11/2015 1/30/2015 1/10/2015 12/12/2014 11/22/2013 6/11/2014 4/21/2015 11/3/2014 1/16/2015 8/21/2015 3/17/2015 9/15/2015 8/3/2015 9/15/2014 3/19/2015 4/23/2015 5/27/2014 3/25/2015 12/6/2013 11/26/2014 6/19/2015 2/16/2015 11/26/2014 10/16/2013 10/10/2014 5/20/2014 4/30/2015 Grantor LIEBLER, MICHAEL/PAMELA CHARRETTE, BRIAN/BEVERLEY SUDZ, PAMELA S. NFH CAPITAL PTNRS II LLC KOURI MARY D TRUST KUCHENMEISTER, RANDALL OWIESNY, DONNA FARRAR PATRICIA A HANNON DORIS J AMONA, HOSAM/ SNAN, SHIFA 39383 WALDORF LLC 39383 WALDORF LLC LIVING ROOM LLC SPERBER, CARL/JENNIFER HEWITT, WILLIAM M. LASKOWSKI, R.; ET AL. OTT CAROL JEAN ENGHAUSER, KEVIN/REBECCA LAFFEY, JAMES/ROY CHILDERS, TOM/LISA MARY POCKEY, DOUGLAS/ MICHAEL MAURER, JASON/ANGELA PAGLINO, KATHLEEN LOOS, BRIAN E. LANZI, WILLIAM/SUZAN LEMIEUX, STEPHEN ROGER CLAEYS, FRANK/M. GORR, LARRY/DONNA SYLVESTER, CURTIS/ HENDRIE, MICHAEL DOETSCH WEALTH DEFENDER TRUST HOUGH, KENNETH/SUSAN CHESNEY, MARVIN C - TRUST FERSCHNEIDER, DOLORES LUCAS SCOTT ZIOLKOWSKI, STEPHEN/BETTY CLINE JENI L DECKER, ALLAYNA A/ KYLE C HISON ROBERT A & NANCY B PEMBERTON, ANNE/THOMAS ROELANDT, CHARLES/ JAMES/ JULIA LANTZ, CAROL/ MICHELLE Grantee MANGER RYAN VANDEVELDE KEVIN & KIMBERLY PARRINELLO PATRICK W DANGELO CHRISTOPHER LAPENSEE ANJANETTE M THEILER KELLY BONDY ROBERT KLEINER DANIEL P HILL ADAM & SHANEL SINTEBIN MICHAEL YOUNG TREVOR ALLISON CASEY & HERRICK JANELL VIRGA DAVID J VAN SICKLE CHRISTOPHER B GOODBALIAN TERRY A & NANCY B RUTHERFORD KEVIN SAWICKI JOSHUA & CAROLINE BILLS JORDAN P SWAFFORD DAVID E SEMIAN STEVEN MICHELS JEFFREY ALLEN JR CZARNECKI AARON C ABELA ANTHONY P DIAZ GARY & AUDREY SOBCZAK KATI M SELLS NICHOLAS EDWIN & ANDREA DALE MAKOWSKI NICOLE M SYLVESTER CURTIS & HENDRIE MICHAEL MCGHIE JARRETT T NORTHERN DREAMS LLC KURDI BILAL M & MAMOU FATEMA M BAHNWEG ARTHUR F FRIZZLE ANDREW J & SHANNON ETTEL DENISE MOCERI SALVATORE & DAWN CERULLI SARAH GENZMAN MATTHEW FILOZOF RICHARD & HELEN BLACKRIVER DEVELOPERS LLC JANKOWSKI ERICA CONFORTI ERNEST Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD LC WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 Sale Price 113,000 130,000 103,000 111,500 130,000 119,000 135,000 110,000 89,900 125,000 117,500 140,000 116,000 137,000 130,000 114,000 85,000 116,000 85,000 70,000 119,000 128,900 113,900 81,000 79,000 127,000 110,500 85,000 125,000 85,000 76,900 108,000 134,900 105,500 100,000 30,000 92,000 32,500 39,500 37,000 41,000 SEV 46,400 45,600 34,500 40,900 48,000 46,200 49,900 43,200 40,000 42,500 46,700 43,000 41,100 54,900 46,400 41,700 42,500 47,200 41,800 34,100 48,200 43,600 41,100 41,300 28,500 48,400 45,500 43,100 43,100 43,100 40,100 39,000 48,600 34,800 49,400 20,600 36,000 14,400 14,900 14,900 17,300 Ratio 41.06 35.08 33.50 36.68 36.92 38.82 36.96 39.27 44.49 34.00 39.74 30.71 35.43 40.07 35.69 36.58 50.00 40.69 49.18 48.71 40.50 33.82 36.08 50.99 36.08 38.11 41.18 50.71 34.48 50.71 52.15 36.11 36.03 32.99 49.40 68.67 39.13 44.31 37.72 40.27 42.20 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-03-434-014 09-14-03-434-023 09-14-03-434-026 09-14-03-434-030 09-14-03-434-039 09-14-03-434-043 09-14-03-434-049 09-14-03-434-055 09-14-03-451-018 09-14-03-453-012 09-14-03-453-013 09-14-03-454-004 09-14-03-454-011 09-14-03-454-014 09-14-03-476-006 09-14-03-476-013 09-14-03-477-026 09-14-03-477-033 09-14-03-477-033 09-14-03-477-034 09-14-03-478-003 09-14-03-478-014 09-14-03-478-019 09-14-03-478-039 09-14-03-478-047 09-14-03-480-014 09-14-10-126-001 09-14-10-127-007 09-14-10-127-017 09-14-10-128-020 09-14-10-128-021 09-14-10-128-022 09-14-10-128-022 09-14-10-128-025 09-14-10-128-028 09-14-10-128-029 09-14-10-176-001 09-14-10-176-009 09-14-10-177-009 09-14-10-177-011 09-14-10-178-013 Sale Date 3/17/2015 5/4/2015 4/21/2014 12/12/2013 12/16/2014 2/6/2015 10/30/2013 8/28/2014 9/3/2015 5/4/2015 10/18/2013 4/10/2014 6/2/2014 7/13/2015 6/22/2015 8/6/2015 4/28/2014 8/8/2014 3/17/2015 8/31/2015 8/3/2015 6/12/2015 4/17/2014 8/19/2015 10/16/2014 12/11/2014 9/22/2015 11/13/2013 7/7/2014 11/21/2014 11/20/2014 3/18/2015 7/17/2015 10/9/2014 3/20/2015 10/31/2014 12/5/2014 6/13/2014 11/22/2013 4/30/2015 8/5/2014 Grantor NADER JOSEPH N FINDLAY, JAMES CRANDALL PAULA DALLEY, SHIRLEY UJKIC PASHKO FRAMPTON BRIAN MASTRODOMENICO PAT & CAROL ELLIS, EDWARD WELCH CHARLES PATRICK NOFSINGER, G. PHILIP - TRUST BARANICH SUSAN M MILBRAND, F./S. SECRETARY OF HUD THEODOSIS, GREGORY ALAN SEXTON ROBERTA L MACKLEM, CYNTHIA - TRUST VINCENT, KEITH AIELLO, PIETRO/MARJORIE/PRICE, P. BASELINE FINANCIAL LLC LLEC, LLC DELISLE, JOANNE/ROBERT PERRY, DANIELLE M/SCOTT E WALSH, JOHN/PATRICIA SPRINGFIELD JACQUELYN US BANK TRUST MURIEL NORMA LEWANDOWSKI, EDWARD/SHARON-TRUST KERSHAW, GLORIA FISCHER, HENRY DEVINE, THOMAS/TRACI HUERTA, JOSE/EDYTA CUNNINGHAM PATRICIA MALISZEWSKI BRIAN & LAPORTE VICTOR FAST CASH FOR HOMES LLC 31014 MANHATTAN GROUP LLC MCCARTHY, EDMUND J. VALIHORA, PAULA W. KENEFICK, ROBERT M. ARCHIBALD, SUSAN/JOHN - TRUST BERRY, COLLEEN E/JOSEPH M CONTRUCCI, JOHN P./LISA Grantee BLACKRIVER DEVELOPERS LLC SMITH SCOTT DANIELS PATRICIA LONDO ARTHUR NEAL JILL FILIPOVSKI MANAGEMENT LLC NEAL JILL FILIPOVSKI MANAGEMENT LLC KENNEDY LISA M DAVIS LINWOOD JR DOUIAHY JOSEPH S MARIANI STEPHEN & AMANDA CUSUMANO ERIC FRANK DDN ENTERPRISE INC RYCHEL MICHAEL & CATHERINE A JENNINGS PAULETTE OLARIN MATTHEW BASELINE FINANCIAL LLC BACK ERIK KOLLAR JONATHAN MICHELS BRADLEY SMITH SETH H & NEUMAYR MARIA K SPAULDING MAURICE U JR SYLVER MARK COURTESY ENTERPRISES LLC COMBS JEFFREY R XIE MIN HUO & MAN LEE BURLESON VICKIE A DUCHAINE THOMAS MANHATTAN ST PROPERTIES LLC WHITEFIELD JENNIFER MALISZEWSKI BRIAN & LAPORTE VICTOR WARGO MONICA & KRACZKOWSKI ASHLEY GG & K PROPERTIES LLC PAHEL BRIAN TREASVANT KEVIN F GRANITZ STEVEN A & CARRIE L CLARK PHILLIP & KAREN FRASARDBRUDER CHERYL BAKOTICH MICHAEL C & LAUREN M HOSKING SCOTT D Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 36,500 38,000 33,000 38,000 38,112 24,500 36,112 36,108 120,000 123,000 55,000 114,900 78,000 82,000 138,000 128,500 100,000 75,000 122,000 95,000 112,900 134,000 100,000 92,501 75,000 92,000 114,000 118,500 187,000 125,000 139,900 75,600 121,000 81,000 125,000 107,000 140,000 144,000 160,000 157,500 147,000 SEV 15,400 17,900 14,900 14,400 15,300 15,200 14,400 15,200 49,700 47,900 44,100 41,900 39,400 40,500 62,100 46,500 45,100 37,700 37,700 38,100 42,100 53,400 41,800 43,800 38,200 35,600 62,200 53,000 56,800 44,100 50,900 45,100 50,400 42,400 47,600 49,500 45,800 54,600 64,000 70,500 53,600 Ratio 42.19 47.11 45.15 37.89 40.14 62.04 39.88 42.10 41.42 38.94 80.18 36.47 50.51 49.39 45.00 36.19 45.10 50.27 30.90 40.11 37.29 39.85 41.80 47.35 50.93 38.70 54.56 44.73 30.37 35.28 36.38 59.66 41.65 52.35 38.08 46.26 32.71 37.92 40.00 44.76 36.46 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-10-179-013 09-14-10-179-017 09-14-10-179-025 09-14-10-182-005 09-14-10-183-001 09-14-10-201-028 09-14-10-203-027 09-14-10-203-030 09-14-10-204-034 09-14-10-226-015 09-14-10-226-026 09-14-10-226-027 09-14-10-226-029 09-14-10-229-013 09-14-10-229-015 09-14-10-229-015 09-14-10-251-007 09-14-10-252-016 09-14-10-252-031 09-14-10-253-009 09-14-10-253-026 09-14-10-253-039 09-14-10-276-012 09-14-10-276-014 09-14-10-277-029 09-14-10-277-035 09-14-10-277-047 09-14-10-278-025 09-14-10-326-017 09-14-10-326-030 09-14-10-326-035 09-14-10-326-038 09-14-10-326-040 09-14-10-327-003 09-14-10-327-006 09-14-10-327-008 09-14-10-327-013 09-14-10-328-003 09-14-10-328-015 09-14-10-328-041 09-14-10-328-050 Sale Date 8/4/2014 10/10/2013 9/4/2015 6/12/2014 10/25/2013 4/27/2015 1/21/2014 12/23/2014 6/18/2014 12/13/2013 12/3/2014 8/26/2015 1/8/2015 7/10/2015 11/6/2014 6/1/2015 7/29/2014 12/12/2013 10/24/2014 10/2/2014 8/5/2015 5/9/2014 7/24/2015 7/22/2014 7/31/2014 5/8/2015 1/2/2015 7/2/2015 11/12/2014 8/25/2015 6/10/2014 7/23/2014 4/21/2015 8/13/2015 6/30/2015 5/22/2014 3/25/2014 11/6/2014 5/30/2014 12/5/2014 1/29/2014 Grantor CIMINELLI LUCY FAMILY TRUST VANDENBERGHE BRIAN T & BRIT HANDS JR., CHAS H./ANNA TALFORD, ANTOINETTE - TRUST CAFMEYER RENE J R & MARY TROMBLY, ELEANOR - TRUST LEONARD, GERALD/DENISE KOHN, JEANETTE S. - TRUST D.E.T.T.S. LLC WLODECK, GERALD/CASSANDRA STITZEL, JEFFREY PARY, JULIE ANNE/ STEVEN CHRISTY, DANE W/ JULIE E - TRUST CALLIOTTE JEFFREY PRETTY MICHIGAN HOMES LLC VIELLA LLC SPOT REALTY CFP GROUP, LLC HAYDON JAMES E DOBOSZ, ZBIGNIEW/JOLANTA ESLER, GREGORY/RHONDA MERIDIAN SERVICES LLC KIM, II UN /WON SUN WESSELS, EARLE T/RACHEL A DUDEK, DANIEL M. CINAT, CLARA RODGERS, ANN MARIE HALEY, STEPHEN/CHRISTY GELETZKE, RONALD HELTON, CHRISTINA/ CHRISTOPHER MIELKE, JAMES/GERALYN HALL, CATHERINE NICHOLSON, MARION R - TRUST CINAT, CLARA SPITLER, KATHRYN MJS PROPERTIES OF MICHIGAN, LLC KNISEL, DEBORAH/JOHN TRI-COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LINDEN MARGARET TRUST GAGE-TASKER, ROZELLE F - TRUST BOERTMANN, ARALEE Grantee CHAPMAN AMANDA B GOODMAN GARY M SOUTER SCOTT WILSON DONNA M ZAPPA KAREN CASE BASIS INVESTMENTS LLC BALL MATTHEW ALAN & KALINOWSKI NICO OZBUN CHARLES RICHARD FIRMAN MATHEW L DG RESIDENTIAL SALES LLC XENOS DION CARLISLE JEANETTE STARNES TAGGART BONNITA KRENCEWICZ PAUL VIELLA LLC STARK AMANDA K DANIELS CHANEL T NSR TRUST PELLA HOLDINGS LLC WOODRUFF RUSSEL & HEATHER BEST NICHOLAS & ZILINSKI KATELYNN M ASKEW DREW YOON RICHARD HENGEHOLD AMANDA MALISZEWSKI BRIAN EISENHARDT HOWARD JR FRANCIS JASON F & RACHEL L THOMAS DAVID & LISA PRITCHETT BRYAN C & CHRISTA M LI YANG LI YANG LI YANG SLOWINSKI CHRISTOPHER M HAGAN KENNETH D JR SWANEY CATHERINE LAMKEY JOSHUA STOFFEL WILLIAM J JR RAEB KYLE & CANDICE COSTA ANDREW M COSTA ERIN STERLING PROPERTY MANAGEMENT CORP Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 127,900 144,000 144,900 150,000 100,000 75,000 96,000 140,000 55,000 69,900 71,250 68,000 119,000 62,000 54,000 119,000 134,900 225,000 70,000 187,000 183,800 132,000 120,000 110,000 42,500 104,000 150,000 165,000 129,900 86,000 101,900 117,000 92,500 147,000 124,500 112,000 80,000 114,000 112,000 110,000 100,000 SEV 63,600 49,000 68,200 64,200 59,700 52,600 35,400 52,000 23,800 40,600 23,800 33,500 43,200 45,800 37,900 45,500 43,000 85,200 46,000 77,200 77,400 47,900 62,100 31,800 24,300 39,100 56,400 86,700 44,000 42,000 34,000 39,000 37,700 52,600 38,000 37,100 37,000 40,700 42,000 45,800 45,000 Ratio 49.73 34.03 47.07 42.80 59.70 70.13 36.88 37.14 43.27 58.08 33.40 49.26 36.30 73.87 70.19 38.24 31.88 37.87 65.71 41.28 42.11 36.29 51.75 28.91 57.18 37.60 37.60 52.55 33.87 48.84 33.37 33.33 40.76 35.78 30.52 33.13 46.25 35.70 37.50 41.64 45.00 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-10-329-008 09-14-10-329-009 09-14-10-329-026 09-14-10-329-048 09-14-10-329-049 09-14-10-330-007 09-14-10-330-012 09-14-10-330-012 09-14-10-330-019 09-14-10-330-026 09-14-10-330-027 09-14-10-330-028 09-14-10-330-032 09-14-10-330-035 09-14-10-330-035 09-14-10-331-009 09-14-10-376-032 09-14-10-377-004 09-14-10-377-004 09-14-10-377-018 09-14-10-377-026 09-14-10-377-029 09-14-10-378-026 09-14-10-379-016 09-14-10-401-017 09-14-10-403-012 09-14-10-403-028 09-14-10-426-004 09-14-10-427-015 09-14-10-428-010 09-14-10-428-014 09-14-10-451-018 09-14-10-451-034 09-14-10-452-011 09-14-10-453-004 09-14-10-453-008 09-14-10-453-014 09-14-10-453-023 09-14-10-476-013 09-14-10-477-008 09-14-10-477-033 Sale Date 3/5/2015 12/20/2013 10/3/2014 6/19/2015 11/13/2013 7/16/2015 3/26/2015 6/26/2015 10/11/2013 8/18/2015 8/28/2015 7/3/2014 7/14/2014 12/5/2014 6/18/2015 9/29/2015 3/7/2014 3/14/2014 12/12/2014 6/26/2014 2/13/2015 11/4/2014 4/17/2015 10/24/2014 1/27/2014 11/12/2013 11/15/2013 7/31/2014 10/6/2014 6/17/2015 1/27/2015 2/18/2015 5/4/2015 10/30/2013 12/16/2013 10/8/2014 6/9/2014 1/23/2015 10/31/2014 12/24/2014 5/8/2015 Grantor BERNOT PAINTING INC SHEA, FRANCIS/JEAN SRODA LINDA D SKERBE MICHAEL JAYMAR LLC HUELLEMEIER MARY L WHITE JAMES JIMED LLC PICKERING HEATHER M MIRAL, JANELL KLAASSEN ANNA MARIE GOUGH MICHAEL A INGOGLIA, PETER A YAGEMAN, ELDEN - TRUST BASELINE FINANCIAL LLC CARTER, PAULA FIORINI JOSEPHINE LOCKWOOD BONNIE J TRUST RUTHERFORD KEVIN MEDLEY, JOSEPH NG GROUP LLC MANZ, JEAN FLORKEY, MARIA DOMANSKI, HAROLD; ET AL. EPPINGA PETER STEVENSON, HOWARD G/ KAY L - TRUST PUTALA ELEANOR TRUST VERHAMMEAND, SHERRY/KENNETH SHELLEY JUANITA TRUST KEYZER THOMAS BADRAK, KEITH S EDE REVOCABLE TRUST MARTIN ROGER MACLEAN JOSEPH & CHERYL TRUST DEFER ALAN HICKEY, CHARLES R PIZZO, MICHAEL/STEPHANIE ADKINS, KEITH/SHARON KOZEN, PATRICIA/ TIMOTHY L RAYMER, MATTHEW J WEAVER, BRIAN KEITH Grantee TUCKER STEVEN & CONSTANCE BROTHERS KENNETH M VANOOSTERWYK THOMAS & JEAN RYCKMAN TIMOTHY CONTRATTO JERRON JIMED LLC JIMED LLC BURTON JOELLEN L KIEFER SHANNON & KIMBERLY GREENFELDER JONATHON R & KELLY WALKER DONALD DIEHL JAMES & GOUGH KRISTINA VOLLBACH JUSTIN B BASELINE FINANCIAL LLC BAILEY EUGENE A MAUK LARRY P & PEYROLO ROSE PHILLIPS COREY & DANIELLE RUTHERFORD KEVIN FUCHS JEFFREY M & PASKO JAMIE L HADDAD MICHAEL A JR FIELDS RICK A CICOLINI RICHARD L LIETZ JASON PAYE STACY L ITONEY JOHN & TRACEY VUTCI MICHAEL R & ELIZABETH B JANKOWSKI TIARA JOHNSON CHRISTIE A DOMBROWSKI JOHN D & BRENDA PATEREK PETER JAMES ST LOUIS LISA EDE DOUGLAS J & TERESA M TWARDOKUS WARREN MICHALOWICZ MARIA SHTYLLA SONILA SEIDITA FRANK & JAMIE UNDERWOOD JASON DONNELLY JANICE K DANIEL JONATHAN & FERGUSON ALICIA WOJTA DAVID M PATTERSON NORMAN P & MARIETA G Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 152,500 122,000 130,000 84,000 86,130 83,000 82,000 129,900 106,000 102,000 50,000 102,000 73,900 76,500 130,000 120,000 111,000 84,101 118,900 98,000 100,000 81,000 73,000 95,000 84,000 141,000 90,000 125,000 164,900 87,500 64,000 65,000 81,000 84,900 34,000 117,000 112,000 75,675 90,000 100,000 135,000 SEV 52,900 49,200 54,100 39,800 35,900 44,900 44,100 49,100 37,800 38,100 37,200 37,500 34,900 45,600 52,000 38,900 41,900 35,100 36,800 40,600 32,500 33,000 37,400 34,400 45,300 55,700 37,000 45,300 64,700 39,700 41,300 34,300 45,400 26,200 19,700 37,100 30,300 38,300 35,100 35,400 64,600 Ratio 34.69 40.33 41.62 47.38 41.68 54.10 53.78 37.80 35.66 37.35 74.40 36.76 47.23 59.61 40.00 32.42 37.75 41.74 30.95 41.43 32.50 40.74 51.23 36.21 53.93 39.50 41.11 36.24 39.24 45.37 64.53 52.77 56.05 30.86 57.94 31.71 27.05 50.61 39.00 35.40 47.85 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-10-478-003 09-14-11-101-014 09-14-11-102-014 09-14-11-103-008 09-14-11-103-015 09-14-11-103-028 09-14-11-127-006 09-14-11-127-018 09-14-11-127-039 09-14-11-127-039 09-14-11-128-001 09-14-11-128-033 09-14-11-128-035 09-14-11-129-019 09-14-11-129-031 09-14-11-151-016 09-14-11-151-026 09-14-11-151-051 09-14-11-151-058 09-14-11-152-009 09-14-11-152-034 09-14-11-152-048 09-14-11-153-001 09-14-11-153-016 09-14-11-153-025 09-14-11-154-022 09-14-11-176-011 09-14-11-176-016 09-14-11-176-022 09-14-11-176-059 09-14-11-177-016 09-14-11-177-034 09-14-11-178-024 09-14-11-179-008 09-14-11-179-011 09-14-11-179-018 09-14-11-202-009 09-14-11-202-010 09-14-11-203-002 09-14-11-203-005 09-14-11-203-015 Sale Date 8/21/2015 8/17/2015 9/18/2015 10/17/2014 11/13/2013 7/25/2014 1/9/2015 11/4/2013 8/12/2014 7/13/2015 10/8/2013 12/26/2013 12/12/2014 7/10/2015 1/30/2015 4/29/2015 10/31/2014 5/30/2014 8/31/2015 10/31/2013 11/30/2013 12/2/2014 6/3/2015 6/15/2015 6/24/2015 6/5/2015 4/25/2014 10/2/2014 8/21/2015 7/3/2014 1/17/2014 8/13/2014 6/15/2015 7/6/2015 10/24/2014 6/10/2014 7/31/2015 4/17/2015 4/21/2015 2/23/2015 6/1/2015 Grantor TURCZYNSKI, G./P. WOZNIAK, WALDEMAR/BERNADETA MILLER, JACQUELINE H. NFH CAPITAL PARTNERS I LLC MCDONALD JOHN ELLERO CHERYL LABEAU, ALAN E. CLARK BRIAN T & DONNA M ONE PUTT MANAGEMENT LLC RED BEAR PROPERTIES LLC MARSHALL OLSON KIMBERLY A MONTGOMERY, PAUL J. BROWN, MATTHEW C. MODERN REAL ESTATE SOLUTIONS LLC DENISON, BARBARA LEDER, NICOLE AMC INVESTING GROUP LLC SKUPIN JR, MICHAEL HERMAN, GARY B/ TERRY E CHERPES KATHERINE HARTMAN, ANDREW/REBECCA BURSOTT, VICTORIA A JEFFRIES, LISA M. PAYNE, ANDREW S/JENNIFER MAYVILLE, CHRISTIAN COPPENS, BEVERLY DOHERTY, ROSETTE/ LEBRUN, KELLY M LAQUERE, MARK K CARR, BRIAN J. LAMARRE, CHARLES E - ET AL GLAZE, DOROTHY/ MALINOWSKI, JORDAN CAPOCCIA, DOMENICO KOSTANECKI, ADAM/ ROBIN TRIPP, WALTER ZUGHAIB MARCEL MIZE JANE M CLARK, PHILIP/WATTS, ELIZABETH TYRELL, RUSSELL SHAUM, NICOLE M STASINSKI, DAVID COMERICA BANK Grantee KING DANIEL J LUDWICK TAMMY MYERS TITUS & JENNIFER AUITO MICHAEL J REICHLING CHARLES BRIAN GRAEBERT PAUL BOUCHARD ERIC & SIEVERT KATIE ZUBE DAVID J RED BEAR PROPERTIES LLC WILLIAMS TASHA M TRIMPER BETTY GRESHAM NICHOLAS SIMICH MARIE L LIBERTY SOLUTIONS LLC SHOOK MULCAHEY KAREN A REYNOLDS DAVID J RADTKE MARK BABBIT RAYMOND JOHN REIFF RICHARD P JR & BAJIS SANDRA L LENZ ERIC WOLFGANG WILLIAM ROBERT JR & GRAGER GIZICKI CREG G CAMPBELL CARLY J SCHAMBRE JEANNIE D BLACK SPENCER SULTZ TOM & CAROL FERSCHNEIDER CARLIE ANN CRUM CHRISTOPHER BLANE ROJAS JORDAN C HELLE CLIFFORD STIELER VIRGINIA MORDEN JONATHAN J & ASHLEY M LEMMON TODD J JAKUBOWSKI JASON GLEFKE BRYAN E MIZE JANE M & CHRISTINE ROBILLIARD EVAN SHAW STEVEN & SCHEPPMAN ANGELA M FARRUGIA DAWN MUSCAT MICHAEL & PETER DANA TOWNSHIP PROPERTIES LLC Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 117,000 160,100 152,000 110,000 155,900 97,000 109,000 87,300 87,500 94,000 110,000 64,900 97,500 46,000 69,000 103,000 128,000 89,900 175,000 95,000 105,515 83,000 93,000 114,001 138,000 120,000 85,000 130,000 113,000 115,000 103,500 139,500 140,000 122,000 93,000 141,000 97,500 126,000 103,000 49,900 63,499 SEV 49,100 64,600 68,800 52,200 56,000 46,900 42,600 37,200 33,300 35,600 36,900 25,400 39,100 20,800 35,500 38,900 42,100 33,900 89,200 39,300 36,100 30,400 36,200 52,200 52,600 55,000 29,400 39,900 35,500 48,500 31,100 63,700 48,100 47,500 47,400 62,000 32,100 42,200 38,600 33,300 28,900 Ratio 41.97 40.35 45.26 47.45 35.92 48.35 39.08 42.61 38.06 37.87 33.55 39.14 40.10 45.22 51.45 37.77 32.89 37.71 50.97 41.37 34.21 36.63 38.92 45.79 38.12 45.83 34.59 30.69 31.42 42.17 30.05 45.66 34.36 38.93 50.97 43.97 32.92 33.49 37.48 66.73 45.51 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-11-204-023 09-14-11-206-001 09-14-11-206-019 09-14-11-206-039 09-14-11-256-007 09-14-11-257-012 09-14-11-301-015 09-14-11-301-016 09-14-11-303-016 09-14-11-303-019 09-14-11-304-001 09-14-11-304-010 09-14-11-305-001 09-14-11-305-012 09-14-11-307-002 09-14-11-307-024 09-14-11-327-004 09-14-11-327-009 09-14-11-327-034 09-14-11-327-036 09-14-11-329-011 09-14-11-331-008 09-14-11-351-020 09-14-11-351-050 09-14-11-351-051 09-14-11-352-002 09-14-11-352-006 09-14-11-352-011 09-14-11-352-029 09-14-11-352-031 09-14-11-353-005 09-14-11-353-014 09-14-11-353-015 09-14-11-353-023 09-14-11-353-033 09-14-11-353-044 09-14-11-353-053 09-14-11-353-053 09-14-11-354-021 09-14-11-354-030 09-14-11-354-030 Sale Date 3/6/2015 11/18/2013 7/10/2015 6/3/2015 8/24/2015 6/10/2014 8/22/2014 10/15/2013 9/15/2015 6/24/2014 1/30/2015 9/4/2015 7/14/2014 5/30/2014 11/20/2013 7/14/2015 12/16/2014 8/28/2015 2/27/2015 12/3/2013 4/27/2015 10/1/2013 12/5/2014 1/30/2015 1/30/2014 5/8/2014 7/6/2015 6/25/2015 5/4/2015 7/14/2015 2/20/2014 10/10/2014 10/9/2013 4/10/2015 6/26/2015 6/19/2015 1/2/2014 12/31/2014 4/3/2015 9/3/2014 8/21/2015 Grantor ANDERSON, JEFFREY SCOTT/PAULA JEAN SEITAM, ELLEN - TRUST MEGGE, DONNA P CUSUMANO, DOMINIC A. - TRUST 30230 JEFFERSON LLC HAVEY ROSEMARY J TRUST GOTTAGE TRUST GOTTAGE DAVID ADOLFO BOMMARITO, ONOFRIO - TRUST JONES, KELLY/ ROB FIVE STAR ASSET MANAGEMENT LLC JNAN PROPERTIES LLC ENSROTH GEORGE E STABLE PATRICIA HOWE, MARION R. HEATON, GEDIE A MARKUS BEVERLY A STRAKA, ADRIAN NORTHERN DREAMS LLC PARSON, CLAYTON/CYNTHIA ZUNDEL, KENNETH/KATHRYN LANE JANET A & WASSICK KAREN H HEFFNER, THOMAS/JANE MILLER, CONCETTINA M. COLEMAN VELMA M ONEPUTT MANAGEMENT LLC SOMES, BRENDA D. STREEFKERK, JUSTIN LOTHAMMER, LILLI - TRUST IWANICKI, MARK/KERRI RUTHERFORD KEVIN COPENHAFER, DEAN R. MOUTON AARON & JAN RUPER GREGORY CANUP, MELISSA J/TODD M MORPHEW, ROBERT L./KNEPP, HOPE E. SFR VENTURE 2011 1 LLC SHAMROCK AQUISITIONS LLC HERGET DEVELOPMENT CO LLC GEFFE, VERA MAZZOLA, BRUCE A Grantee H3HOLDINGS LLC DOMINICK NORBERT SWEARINGUM GROUP INC TARNACKI LAWRENCE W & LESLIE D MOSURE RUSSELL E & KRISTAN G TAYLOR SHARON E BROWN LISA THILL ZACHARY T & JENNA M CARTER HENRY J COOPER ROBERT & KELLY SHILLER EILEEN CCF2 LLC ROMANO ADAM J BLACKE WILLIAM & MARILYN TARANTINE EDNA JOYCE CLEMENTS RYAN CUCINELLA ANTHONY & LACHELLE BUDOP MICHAEL M KOSEK LAUREN PAESANO STEFANO & DAVID ALEX JOSEPH BARTOLF HAROLD & KATHLEEN M THEIS JOSEPH II & GOODFELLOW AILISA SMITH CURTIS M & MELANIE L AITCHISON DOUGLAS J & RONDA L BELCHER RYAN LUCIDO LANCE HACKER JASON BAUZA PEDRO & MEJIAS BADILLO LINETT OWSLEY MARK & JULIANNE BENSEL MEAGAN A & HADLEY RENEE HARRIS KIMBERLY A KUSCH GARRY & KAREN HAYWARD INVESTMENT GROUP LLC ARCHER TERRY J ROSS MICHAEL & JOANNE SHAMROCK ACQUISITIONS LLC TREADWELL KIARA TREECE WILLIAM J MAZZOLA BRUCE A LIETZ JASON Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 58,000 365,000 310,000 750,000 850,000 250,000 123,000 105,000 108,500 124,900 112,000 73,150 95,000 53,000 50,000 82,700 80,000 134,000 130,000 120,000 106,000 56,000 113,300 106,000 100,500 99,000 110,200 135,000 90,000 128,000 107,000 45,000 81,000 45,750 100,000 130,000 50,500 118,000 89,000 50,000 83,500 SEV Ratio 19,300 210,200 150,200 333,600 357,000 114,000 51,500 46,500 43,100 37,900 44,400 36,300 47,800 40,600 26,200 31,000 51,500 52,900 46,400 44,300 41,200 18,900 42,200 37,600 54,100 29,900 45,700 44,100 35,900 54,700 36,900 35,100 36,300 27,400 41,000 39,400 33,000 35,800 43,500 32,600 35,500 33.28 57.59 48.45 44.48 42.00 45.60 41.87 44.29 39.72 30.34 39.64 49.62 50.32 76.60 52.40 37.48 64.38 39.48 35.69 36.92 38.87 33.75 37.25 35.47 53.83 30.20 41.47 32.67 39.89 42.73 34.49 78.00 44.81 59.89 41.00 30.31 65.35 30.34 48.88 65.20 42.51 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-11-376-032 09-14-11-378-007 09-14-11-378-025 09-14-11-378-038 09-14-11-380-011 09-14-14-101-009 09-14-14-101-025 09-14-14-101-025 09-14-14-101-040 09-14-14-102-007 09-14-14-102-039 09-14-14-103-002 09-14-14-103-011 09-14-14-103-023 09-14-14-103-025 09-14-14-103-037 09-14-14-103-057 09-14-14-126-018 09-14-14-126-020 09-14-14-127-016 09-14-14-128-004 09-14-14-128-012 09-14-14-130-014 09-14-14-131-003 09-14-14-131-010 09-14-14-131-012 09-14-14-131-014 09-14-14-151-020 09-14-14-151-043 09-14-14-151-045 09-14-14-151-061 09-14-14-152-039 09-14-14-153-009 09-14-14-153-019 09-14-14-153-023 09-14-14-153-031 09-14-14-153-055 09-14-14-153-057 09-14-14-154-014 09-14-14-154-018 09-14-14-155-001 Sale Date 7/23/2015 8/5/2014 10/23/2014 3/6/2014 4/30/2015 2/28/2014 12/20/2013 4/28/2014 11/14/2014 7/23/2014 10/20/2014 8/20/2014 4/18/2014 3/28/2014 5/12/2015 4/17/2014 6/5/2015 10/28/2014 2/13/2015 11/13/2013 8/12/2014 10/31/2014 6/1/2015 7/18/2014 6/18/2014 11/21/2013 9/1/2015 5/15/2015 11/8/2013 6/27/2014 5/6/2014 6/19/2015 5/7/2014 6/17/2014 5/8/2015 3/5/2015 8/18/2014 10/31/2014 9/10/2014 7/29/2014 6/17/2014 Grantor WYSOCKI, GAIL E. YOUNG, KEVIN L SOUND SOLUTIONS BOOKKEEPING ANDELEAN DENIS J HANCHERUK, MILTON J. - TRUST ALLARD LINDA M LAYMAN MICHAEL R VITELLI, JOHN T LARIVEE, MATTHEW MOCERI MICHELLE TOTH, JAMES ZALAR, DORA C. WOLNE STEVEN NELSON, MARIA S/STACKPOOLE, MICHAEL FIVE STAR ASSET MANAGEMENT LLC LEFEVERE, MARK/DAVIDSON, MARYL JELSONE, ROBERT W./JOANNE SCRUGGS GLYNN R GAINES JOHN W JIMED LLC JACKSON III, ANGELA/ GARTH L DOWNEY, LORETTA M. BACALL, DORAYD/ JESSICA TAYLOR, JOSEPH/ SHARON VIVIANO, CARL J. BROOKS, BETH ANN SCOTT, RONALD/LENORE SPATH, JOHN/MARCELINE VERHAEGHE JACK TEAM RIEBEL INVESTMENTS 6 LLC MARSHALL DENNIS M HAENKE, DAYNA MARECKI JR., JOHN ONEPUTT MANAGEMENT LLC HUGOS, MARION RWL PROPERTIES LLC CLEVELAND, C. RANDALL/JENNIFER HOWARD, JANNETTE JOHNSONS JR., PATRICK HAMMER, JOHN/ROBERTA PELLERITO, LUCY Grantee PARKER CAITLIN FISCHER EMILY LAMBERT MATTHEW & BARBARA JEFFREY MELISSA M MITCHELL LILLIAN SALLAN JOSEPH VITELLI, JOHN T JOHNSON CHRISTOPHER & DOLAN MARY CLEMENTE JAMES & SHERRIE KROPFREITER KEITH SALISBURY JOHN JR OSBORNE KYLE ZURAWSKYJ PAUL GIBSON BRIANA DUNN CRAIG J KUSCH GARRY & KAREN RUSSELL INVESTMENTS INC THOMAS PHILIP W JR THORNTON RUSSELL E PRIEMER AMANDA J MATLOCK LISA & ELLEN CALANDRINO DAVID BUTT FAUZIA K NEUMANN KATHRYN STATHAM JAMES & JACQUELINE JOSEPH DANIEL & SUSAN TAYLOR THOMAS & KATHLEEN JURCAK CHAD C & DANA R JACQUEMAIN DAVID D JR MEYER TAYLOR R KNOTH MARVIN & COSTOPULOS LINDA KASSIN GERALD J KONDZIOLKA MATTHEW & KLINE KAYLA BROZOWSKI AUDRA KUNNATH MADISON GREGSON EVE A JARVIS DANEIL & LINDA STANCZAK JEFFREY DRYZGA JESSICA VAN OVERBEKE MATTHEW MILO SALES AND INVESTMENTS CO INC Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 404 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 Sale Price 134,000 81,000 121,000 72,500 47,000 62,000 50,100 119,000 130,000 143,000 127,000 87,000 87,000 70,500 75,000 90,000 22,000 122,300 120,000 117,500 138,500 136,000 525,000 233,000 325,000 280,000 505,000 156,000 135,000 100,000 124,000 128,500 117,000 95,000 115,100 100,000 265,000 116,000 118,000 105,000 189,000 SEV Ratio 42,000 30,500 31,200 53,600 25,600 27,500 33,600 35,400 43,400 45,100 44,100 26,800 38,900 32,200 31,100 40,000 8,800 48,900 42,200 30,800 51,600 40,100 241,800 100,200 128,800 103,900 153,500 81,800 44,000 47,700 50,400 60,900 39,400 36,500 48,700 46,900 89,700 53,200 30,500 36,700 126,500 31.34 37.65 25.79 73.93 54.47 44.35 67.07 29.75 33.38 31.54 34.72 30.80 44.71 45.67 41.47 44.44 40.00 39.98 35.17 26.21 37.26 29.49 46.06 43.00 39.63 37.11 30.40 52.44 32.59 47.70 40.65 47.39 33.68 38.42 42.31 46.90 33.85 45.86 25.85 34.95 66.93 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-14-155-003 09-14-14-155-005 09-14-14-176-001 09-14-14-301-011 09-14-14-302-011 09-14-14-302-011 09-14-14-302-016 09-14-14-302-028 09-14-14-302-031 09-14-14-303-008 09-14-14-304-016 09-14-14-304-017 09-14-14-304-020 09-14-14-351-010 09-14-14-352-005 09-14-14-352-019 09-14-14-352-023 09-14-14-352-042 09-14-14-355-020 09-14-14-355-021 09-14-14-356-028 09-14-14-362-012 09-14-14-362-015 09-14-15-101-027 09-14-15-103-021 09-14-15-103-029 09-14-15-103-044 09-14-15-127-012 09-14-15-151-007 09-14-15-151-015 09-14-15-151-022 09-14-15-151-035 09-14-15-152-001 09-14-15-152-032 09-14-15-153-006 09-14-15-153-010 09-14-15-154-011 09-14-15-155-006 09-14-15-176-026 09-14-15-177-018 09-14-15-178-003 Sale Date 3/6/2015 10/27/2014 8/5/2014 3/14/2014 8/5/2014 4/24/2015 2/3/2014 3/6/2015 7/22/2015 3/17/2014 6/5/2014 12/26/2013 3/25/2015 5/6/2015 10/16/2013 11/21/2014 5/8/2015 4/22/2014 10/29/2013 11/10/2014 8/6/2015 8/14/2015 8/8/2014 5/4/2015 7/11/2014 5/13/2014 7/23/2015 6/29/2015 6/12/2015 6/23/2014 8/25/2015 3/26/2015 8/4/2014 1/14/2015 10/10/2014 9/15/2014 4/23/2014 7/8/2015 2/11/2014 2/10/2014 10/13/2014 Grantor SANTI, MARK/MAURA RICCINTO, BRETT/NICOLE VOIKOS, ADELINA B KENNEDY, NANCY M BARR, JAMES/ JULIE LAROCCA, MARINA VANFLETEREN, DOROTHY FECKO, PENNY/MILLER, KYLE MJW SPLASH GRAND LAKE INVESTMENTS LLD MORAN, VICTORIA/MANSOR, NANCY AMEEL, MARK PAUL; ET AL. THOUSAND, MARILYN KLEINOW, SHARON GUTHAT THOMAS J & AUDRIENNE LAUBERT, JANICE DECLERCK, FRANCES RITA KIESGEN, GREGORY L. WESTPHAL DANIEL & MEGHAN HAFER, DALE/MARY JO SOPFE, ELFRIEDE KHAN, MOHAMMAD/DORANI, MOHAMMAD FRANCIS, DEBRA J SCHULZ NANCY A EISELE, SCOTT/LAMBERT, M. DONNELLY, NANCY A. SLOWIK, LORI MADURI, STEPHANIE DOWNEY, JOSEPH/ SANDRA C JOSEPH, MARIE D JACOB, CHACKO ZAWACKI CHRISTINE J LIVERNOIS, KIMBERLY A. POCKEY, MICHAEL MEADLOCK FAMILY TRUST BLITZ, PATRICIA/ ROBINSON, KATHLEEN MALBOUEF EMILY B DOYLE, MARGARET M TRUST DELLACASA SALVATORE BENDER ELIZABETH M TRUST SUKUP, GLORIA L. Grantee GRAY TANYA M HAAG DOUGLAS & BETH UROSEV ILIJA & JOVANKA SLANEC HOWARD C III LAROCCA MARINA PATTON GARY MARROSU JOSEPH & MALINCZAK KELLY THOMAS CHRISTOPHER & DEBORAH ODAY JAMES B WEATHERBY REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS L MILLER RYAN CONSIGLIO RALPH & DENISE METZGER JUSTIN & BETHANY JACQUET ROBERT ZAJAC LAURA MCGRAW KELLIE PERRIN JOHN M VAN HOWE GREG FROST NOEL GUTZ ANN MARIE WILLIAMS LINDA J MOGDIS STEVEN BEAULAC JONATHAN WUMMEL CHARLES O & PATRICIA A GURGUL PAUL & SHAWNA M UNG MUI A TUCKER DAVID & MEDINGER ASHLEY MELOCHE GABRIELLE LEIBY CHARLES R SMALLEY TREVOR & TENBUSCH KERI TROPPER PETER D REEDY JOSHUA B & LINDSEY R RUSSELL PETER J AWDEY KRISTOFER PEREZ ADELA N NEWBERRY ROGER KOPITZKE JOSEPH ROGENSUES ROBERT II & KAREN TRUPIANO ROSEMARY SHOCK CHRISTOPHER & LORRIE JEAN FLAHERTY FRED Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 211,000 232,500 400,000 115,000 72,500 195,000 117,500 120,000 152,000 37,900 90,000 80,500 81,500 109,000 25,000 22,000 30,000 48,500 210,000 143,000 269,000 205,000 145,898 131,900 127,000 104,000 119,000 97,500 168,500 165,000 154,000 165,000 150,000 105,000 142,000 149,000 92,000 135,000 153,000 139,000 150,000 SEV Ratio 120,900 110,700 182,200 24,700 55,200 67,000 35,900 39,900 75,100 13,200 35,200 39,100 35,200 45,500 7,000 7,100 7,500 16,500 94,600 60,000 124,300 79,000 72,900 51,200 44,500 45,000 60,800 35,700 66,100 53,600 68,900 66,900 60,000 47,000 49,600 57,700 41,100 72,200 52,800 58,900 71,500 57.30 47.61 45.55 21.48 76.14 34.36 30.55 33.25 49.41 34.83 39.11 48.57 43.19 41.74 28.00 32.27 25.00 34.02 45.05 41.96 46.21 38.54 49.97 38.82 35.04 43.27 51.09 36.62 39.23 32.48 44.74 40.55 40.00 44.76 34.93 38.72 44.67 53.48 34.51 42.37 47.67 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-15-179-010 09-14-15-201-043 09-14-15-201-045 09-14-15-202-001 09-14-15-202-005 09-14-15-202-022 09-14-15-203-043 09-14-15-203-045 09-14-15-204-013 09-14-15-204-025 09-14-15-204-038 09-14-15-226-015 09-14-15-226-024 09-14-15-226-049 09-14-15-227-011 09-14-15-227-012 09-14-15-227-015 09-14-15-227-027 09-14-15-228-002 09-14-15-228-006 09-14-15-228-016 09-14-15-228-017 09-14-15-228-028 09-14-15-228-034 09-14-15-231-007 09-14-15-251-032 09-14-15-252-013 09-14-15-252-050 09-14-15-252-051 09-14-15-252-057 09-14-15-276-006 09-14-15-276-029 09-14-15-276-043 09-14-15-277-009 09-14-15-278-006 09-14-15-281-016 09-14-15-281-018 09-14-15-301-025 09-14-15-301-032 09-14-15-301-059 09-14-15-301-067 Sale Date 8/17/2015 12/13/2013 11/14/2014 3/30/2015 9/9/2015 5/13/2015 8/21/2014 11/13/2013 4/14/2015 5/15/2015 8/17/2015 12/16/2013 3/10/2015 4/30/2014 11/4/2013 12/6/2013 8/14/2015 6/11/2014 4/8/2015 4/18/2014 3/5/2014 10/30/2014 8/21/2015 11/8/2013 5/20/2015 5/2/2014 4/28/2015 8/13/2014 11/11/2013 9/2/2015 2/4/2015 10/3/2014 5/29/2015 6/19/2015 12/23/2014 7/29/2015 12/31/2014 11/25/2013 11/27/2013 6/27/2014 8/27/2014 Grantor JESKY, JENNIFER L. ROBINSON, KEVIN LATASIEWICZ, KATHERINE BELCHER, JOSEPH/DEBORAH PARRINELLO, JAMES V SR. MIAH, SHUAB TNB CONNECT LLC TNB CONNECT LLC MEAD, FREDERICK/MARK RUPER, VALERIE J. CATALDO DORA BOAK, BONNIE L SABERAN JULIE A HOLLON SR., PHILLIP/VERNECE MCDOWELL BRENDAN M & ELIZABETH A STAY, SCOTT SMOUSE JAMES R PRIMEAU, DOUGLAS J. GAERTNER, DAWN WOJT, BRIAN K ATHANASOPOULOS MARIA & DORA P FLANAGAN, SEAN P MCBRIDE, MARY KORNOWSKY, PAUL/ MARY LIZOTTE, ROBERT REEVES, KENNETH M. HOEKSTRA, NEIL DECRICK, BARBARA HASTINGS CHRISTOPHER G GIUGLARDO, D./D./ FABIN, J. SORROW, CHRISTINA/SEAN LESKA, OLSI GIEFKE, BRYAN WIDD ROSA VERCRUYSSE BETTY LOU TRUST TORTOMOSE, ANTHONY BRENT, ROBERT/MARGARET BILLBURY, TAMMIE BRICKNER, LINDA A. - TRUST BASELINE FINANCIAL LLC SANDNER MICHAEL F Grantee MOSSNER JOAN M PAGLIA PAUL GREENFIELD MARK ANQUETIL DANIEL WISNEWSKI EDWARD H MATTHEWS ARCHIE LEE WOLFER JESSE A & CRYSTAL GASIOROWSKI ANTHONY KOLB KENNETH A & NANCY A RODRIGUEZ ERNESTINO JR CMJ INVESTMENTS AIKIN CHARLES JAMES II BISBY BARRY J & MELISSA A SPUZ CATHERINE A HOWELL PAUL W HORVATH NICHOLAS & JULIE KINSEY LLOYD TRUST MCCORKLE WILLIAM TRI COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS MALASKI THEODORE M CONFORTI ERNEST C CALANDRINO DAWN DERRY SANDRA MACLEAN JOSEPH M & CHERYL L KOWALEWSKI PAUL WILLENBORG MATTHEW & KIROFF ASHLEY GOLDLION REAL ESTATE MANAGEMENT LLC MILLER JANE TRIPP COLIN P & LYNN M MILLER JANE MILLER STEVEN J DALISKY RYAN J GIBSON JAMES R SCORPIO ANTONIO D REETZ ADRIAN LUCIER RYAN WATTS HORACE PERIVOLIOTIS DIMITRI PEARCY JEANIE EKBLAD AARON & LAURA A ZHAO SHANRUAN Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 105,000 108,000 92,000 128,000 107,500 132,000 124,900 121,000 100,000 109,000 68,000 139,000 114,000 120,000 90,750 143,000 137,000 129,000 93,000 100,000 78,000 132,000 111,000 119,000 130,000 123,500 69,018 37,000 30,000 42,000 129,000 155,000 189,900 120,000 154,000 65,500 45,000 74,000 98,000 129,000 87,000 SEV 39,400 35,100 33,500 53,800 49,100 47,300 35,600 32,800 42,300 40,400 42,300 52,200 41,400 34,700 36,900 45,100 48,400 39,500 45,100 40,900 40,200 45,200 44,400 34,100 62,800 42,900 30,500 10,900 10,600 14,900 41,100 51,800 65,500 55,900 51,300 29,700 23,200 30,400 37,700 43,100 40,900 Ratio 37.52 32.50 36.41 42.03 45.67 35.83 28.50 27.11 42.30 37.06 62.21 37.55 36.32 28.92 40.66 31.54 35.33 30.62 48.49 40.90 51.54 34.24 40.00 28.66 48.31 34.74 44.19 29.46 35.33 35.48 31.86 33.42 34.49 46.58 33.31 45.34 51.56 41.08 38.47 33.41 47.01 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-15-301-069 09-14-15-301-087 09-14-15-302-012 09-14-15-302-037 09-14-15-302-056 09-14-15-302-057 09-14-15-302-072 09-14-15-302-073 09-14-15-302-088 09-14-15-302-090 09-14-15-303-005 09-14-15-326-002 09-14-15-326-019 09-14-15-329-005 09-14-15-329-011 09-14-15-329-017 09-14-15-329-028 09-14-15-329-033 09-14-15-331-005 09-14-15-331-009 09-14-15-331-013 09-14-15-351-015 09-14-15-351-023 09-14-15-351-025 09-14-15-351-042 09-14-15-351-045 09-14-15-376-026 09-14-15-377-027 09-14-15-403-022 09-14-15-426-016 09-14-15-427-025 09-14-15-427-026 09-14-15-427-055 09-14-15-427-055 09-14-15-428-005 09-14-15-428-009 09-14-15-428-010 09-14-15-428-018 09-14-15-428-019 09-14-15-428-022 09-14-15-428-033 Sale Date 11/26/2014 9/8/2014 2/13/2015 12/19/2014 8/1/2014 6/10/2015 6/6/2014 11/26/2013 10/25/2013 7/17/2015 10/9/2014 4/10/2015 2/26/2015 9/3/2015 10/1/2013 10/30/2014 5/13/2014 8/8/2014 5/27/2015 8/21/2014 3/7/2014 9/22/2015 11/3/2014 10/8/2013 5/9/2014 8/22/2014 1/31/2014 7/13/2015 12/12/2013 3/21/2014 10/24/2013 1/9/2015 7/30/2014 11/7/2014 3/6/2015 4/13/2015 4/14/2015 5/15/2015 4/14/2015 2/19/2015 6/13/2014 Grantor GEILL, NATALIE POLIZZI SAMUEL HOTTMANN, KENNETH/XIAODONG CARRERI, JOSEPH D WEBB RICHARD H TRUST FERRARO, MICHAEL/SHARON STEUDLE, SHAWN M KURZAWA, ALLEN COLLEY DEWEY & LEANORA FEENEY, THOMAS RJWCO LLC GREEN, COULTER V HENDRIE MICHAEL V WEILER, JODI A BLOOME THOMAS E & DEBORAH M CAPANDA, CHADWICK LANDROVER LAND LLC KETELHUT, RACHEL COPPENS, SCOTT MISANY, WILLIAM J. GLENWOOD TRUST KROCZAK, MARY/PAUL - TRUST SOLOMON, BARBARA J. DOBRINER EDWARD R WESTERMAN WILLIAM C TRUST EBERSPACHER, DEBRA/ KARL - TRUST GOIKE KIMBERLY A ROSSEEL, DANIEL NFH CAPITAL PTNRS II LLC MILIOTO, JAMES/P. MCLELLAN KEVIN FEENEY, DANA M PETTIT, GERALYN/KEENAN ZSA & ZSA LLC AMPOLA, MELISSA M. ARNOLD, JULIA E/ MARTIN, BARBARA J RADTKE, GARY/KNORR, CHRISTINE SCHULTE, EILEEN MARIE SAFFADY, GREGORY/D. MICHIGAN SCHOOLS & GOVERNMENT CREDI VICO, JOHN Grantee RICE AARON M & FREELAND TRACY A KUCZYNSKI RYAN & MAHON MARIA E COLO ROBERT W SOLOMON JOSEPH & LINDSAY RUTHENBERG SUSAN C HARDER DAVID C & JESSICA L AMAN RONALD D RADIMAKER RANDALL & KOLIBA TINA CALCATERRA TAMARA CROFT JENNIFER BENNETT BRUCE A BARKE JASON & JENNIFER HINMAN TERRY & CARRIE BROSNAN JAMES & GREENWELL KATHRYN PINTO JOHN W & VERONICA L ENGLISH DEBRA VAN DORGEN EVAN JOHNSON CHARLES EWALD JAMES MCGREEVY COLIN C TRAVIS DANIEL J & RACHEL COSTANTE JOHN E & LORRI L AGOSTA SALVATORE & DALESSANDRO THOM MURPHY BRYAN VANREYENDAM BRANDON & SPEAR KRYSTLE HAMILTON HEATHER R PAWLAK ANNA HURLBURT KAYLIN M TINDALE BETH A SPIEGEL CRAIG J REDMON VINCENT A & AMANDA M RICHARD MICHAEL & GUMOLA JUSTIN ZSA & ZSA LLC MCNEIL TEO & MARILYN DAVIS MICHELE A CATONI MARY ANN SKOVER MITCHELL & BOOKER CARA M MELDRUM MARTIN K & BROWN BETTY ANN BALINSKI CYNTHIA FRANKLIN JAMIE R HUBER ROSALIE ANNE Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 Sale Price 103,000 149,000 104,000 133,000 95,000 136,000 106,000 55,000 84,000 130,000 116,600 127,500 110,000 91,000 181,875 121,000 98,900 135,000 61,230 80,000 75,000 100,000 76,200 165,000 145,000 142,000 110,000 102,600 95,000 131,849 169,900 57,000 45,000 63,000 70,000 72,000 69,000 65,500 69,000 69,000 70,000 SEV 43,300 47,800 42,200 52,400 46,900 66,200 42,400 36,900 42,100 51,700 44,100 45,400 48,600 43,900 73,400 39,900 45,000 63,200 37,100 27,000 28,800 49,900 52,500 79,300 63,300 48,900 43,900 42,400 23,400 48,700 57,200 34,400 22,700 22,700 23,900 33,100 31,800 31,700 27,400 31,500 22,300 Ratio 42.04 32.08 40.58 39.40 49.37 48.68 40.00 67.09 50.12 39.77 37.82 35.61 44.18 48.24 40.36 32.98 45.50 46.81 60.59 33.75 38.40 49.90 68.90 48.06 43.66 34.44 39.91 41.33 24.63 36.94 33.67 60.35 50.44 36.03 34.14 45.97 46.09 48.40 39.71 45.65 31.86 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-15-428-034 09-14-15-428-039 09-14-15-428-043 09-14-15-452-017 09-14-15-454-016 09-14-15-454-024 09-14-15-455-008 09-14-15-455-010 09-14-15-455-029 09-14-15-455-045 09-14-15-457-003 09-14-15-457-004 09-14-15-457-006 09-14-15-457-019 09-14-15-457-020 09-14-15-476-033 09-14-15-476-037 09-14-15-476-051 09-14-15-476-052 09-14-15-477-003 09-14-15-477-039 09-14-15-477-041 09-14-15-479-001 09-14-15-479-003 09-14-15-481-017 09-14-16-202-026 09-14-16-203-027 09-14-16-203-036 09-14-16-204-013 09-14-16-204-024 09-14-16-204-025 09-14-16-204-039 09-14-16-204-049 09-14-16-205-034 09-14-16-226-014 09-14-16-226-017 09-14-16-226-031 09-14-16-226-035 09-14-16-226-040 09-14-16-226-044 09-14-16-227-007 Sale Date 7/29/2014 12/23/2014 6/29/2015 1/18/2014 5/8/2015 8/18/2015 1/31/2014 8/31/2015 2/27/2014 6/17/2015 11/20/2014 4/9/2015 1/9/2015 5/29/2015 6/19/2014 2/3/2015 8/14/2015 8/27/2015 4/8/2014 8/12/2014 5/15/2014 1/24/2014 5/30/2014 11/27/2013 2/28/2014 6/25/2014 6/16/2014 1/30/2015 3/16/2015 8/13/2015 1/18/2014 2/4/2015 12/15/2014 7/22/2014 3/10/2014 4/15/2014 6/1/2015 6/27/2014 11/3/2014 10/1/2013 11/8/2013 Grantor CAVATAIO VICTOR LESZCZYNSKI, ERIN BRAUN, MARJORIE - TRUST DG RESIDENTIAL SALES LLC FLATT, BEVERLY/ TREUSCH, PAULINE DUPURE, MICHAEL/ LLOMBART, BEVERLY POLIZZI SAM SUTTER, MICHAEL B. DONOFRIO MARC A ROBINSON DENYSE CAROL SHANK, JUNE L. MOORE ARIADNE ROUSOS SEKON, RAJINDER/JASPREET SIKAND MAZZEI DESPOTHEA HERPICK, SCOTT; ET AL. ISELLI, EWALD/DIANE MOERSCHELL, BENNIE K/ ROY H - TRUST HOULE, LISA A/ WAYNE B ENGLISH, TARA L. MILLER, SUZANNE/JASON ROUSSO ISAAC M BROWN TIMOTHY D TRATHEN, ELIZABETH JANE - TRUST CARVER, ERIC CALABRESE KEVIN J CRICK, JOANN F/RONALD W ABRAHAM, LAUREN WIECZERZA, RYAN ELWART, JOSEPH/THERESA CASLER, DAWN/ JOSEPH D BABCOCK, JOHN WARUNEK DEBRA L LONG, MATTHEW BINGHAM, JACQUELYN WOLOCH, ANDREW S. KOPIETZ SHELLEY ANN TANGNEY, SEAN/JESSICA RHODES, STACEY M. GLOVER, JANICE M. WHITBREAD ARNO SMITH STEPHEN M & MEGAN E Grantee MILNER JOHN D DEMATTEIS ANTHONY KELLER FLORENCE TAYLOR CASEY J & RANDI L MCLELLAN KEVIN R CIARMITARO CARLO J & MARY R FRITZ TODD COONEY CHRISTOPHER WAKEFORD DAN BROOKS AMANDA L ROE TIMOTHY & KATHLEEN RONEY STEVEN T & BECHILL JANE C DECLERCQ KATHERINE SERRA MARC FEDOR ALDONA BARNES CHARLES GALLAGHER JANICE ONG KEVIN C HASSIG JEFFREY T SKWIERC HUBERT F III & CARMELITA J RAYNER CHRISTOPHER C HANNON THOMAS & CAROL E JANSSENS LINDA & RAILEY GIOVANINA DOOLEE LLC LOZEN ERIC R COURY CHRISTOPHER & TUCKER RITA BIALAS AARON ALAN & SZOSTEK EVA ANE URBANSKI JOESEPH E OLIVER MARK A MCDONALD MASON G ROBINSON CHRISTOPHER J THOMAS TINA Z LIETAERT CHRISTOPHER & CARRICK LAUR CORRELL CARLENE CRUMP TRACI M CHURCHES SHAUN & SMITH JENNA KOWALSKI JASON & SHERMAN KELLY SCHROCK JEREMY & KATIE HOLMES SCOTT R SCHWENTER DONNA GRACE PHOENIX LISA Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 407 407 407 403 403 404 403 403 404 403 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 82,500 69,900 75,000 176,000 61,000 15,000 154,900 57,900 151,040 109,550 33,000 32,500 32,900 36,000 30,000 137,000 80,000 146,900 85,000 165,000 109,900 46,450 105,000 44,900 92,000 83,000 115,000 135,000 122,000 113,000 115,000 95,000 129,900 107,000 95,000 87,000 142,000 117,500 115,000 99,000 97,000 SEV 34,100 24,900 38,800 46,000 43,000 5,900 59,400 20,800 63,700 43,500 14,200 14,600 14,400 14,500 14,400 44,400 41,800 51,300 46,500 69,300 42,700 27,000 38,300 23,500 36,300 38,900 43,600 42,900 41,200 50,900 42,800 43,800 57,600 38,400 36,700 41,300 51,600 39,900 40,800 36,800 30,300 Ratio 41.33 35.62 51.73 26.14 70.49 39.33 38.35 35.92 42.17 39.71 43.03 44.92 43.77 40.28 48.00 32.41 52.25 34.92 54.71 42.00 38.85 58.13 36.48 52.34 39.46 46.87 37.91 31.78 33.77 45.04 37.22 46.11 44.34 35.89 38.63 47.47 36.34 33.96 35.48 37.17 31.24 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-16-227-019 09-14-16-228-008 09-14-16-228-020 09-14-16-252-005 09-14-16-252-010 09-14-16-254-005 09-14-16-254-007 09-14-16-255-038 09-14-16-256-028 09-14-16-256-032 09-14-16-258-009 09-14-16-258-049 09-14-16-276-011 09-14-16-276-015 09-14-16-276-026 09-14-16-276-034 09-14-16-276-034 09-14-16-276-047 09-14-16-277-003 09-14-16-277-003 09-14-16-277-007 09-14-16-277-010 09-14-16-277-043 09-14-16-277-044 09-14-16-278-009 09-14-16-278-022 09-14-16-279-006 09-14-16-279-017 09-14-16-279-021 09-14-16-279-038 09-14-16-402-022 09-14-16-402-034 09-14-16-403-009 09-14-16-404-010 09-14-16-407-003 09-14-16-407-015 09-14-16-408-020 09-14-16-409-022 09-14-16-410-005 09-14-16-410-007 09-14-16-427-015 Sale Date 9/28/2015 7/1/2014 5/21/2015 6/18/2014 8/26/2015 6/19/2015 6/4/2015 6/26/2015 9/4/2015 5/28/2015 6/8/2015 12/20/2014 10/24/2014 6/20/2014 8/6/2014 10/2/2014 3/6/2015 2/28/2014 11/11/2014 9/29/2015 5/23/2014 4/18/2014 8/5/2014 11/21/2013 4/17/2015 10/10/2013 5/22/2015 10/10/2014 10/28/2013 12/19/2013 9/19/2014 1/21/2015 8/29/2014 5/8/2015 6/26/2015 6/11/2015 1/16/2015 10/30/2013 10/30/2014 8/13/2015 5/23/2014 Grantor SULLIVAN, BRYAN HINDMAN, ROBERT A SHEPHERD, DERIC E HANNAWI, PATRICK J JOY, MICHAEL J./EVA M. RUSAK, JESSICA/KRIS DENNIS, JENNIFER MARIE STATON, RITA M - TRUST DEPAPE, JASON M. PALUSHAJ, DANIEL CELESTINI, MICHAEL D/ STACY HAZELETT, JANET M CAMPO, PAUL M. MATTISON, JAMES B. ROOTS, JR., KENNETH J. CARLINI, ANGELINE C. - TRUST ZENO HOLDINGS LLC ANDREWS STEVEN P PALERMINO BEVERLY MAIORANA, KRISTY/ SORGELOOS, KAREN MANZELLA, LAURA TIMKEN PROPERTIES INC JOQUICO, JENNIFER WATTS INVESTMENTS DRISCOLL, KORI NOVAK ALAN A & JACQUELYN A DYNAMIC PROPERTY SOLUTIONS LLC THOMAS WILLIAM TRUST HOMECORE LLC SMITH, AMANDA L/ BRADLEY M SCRIVO, JASON BARBER, MICHAEL/JOY JEAN MALKOWSKI, MICHAEL L. ADAMS ADA M TRUST EASTERN MANAGEMENT II LLC RUSH, CHARLIE WINN, DEBORAH L - TRUST REEDY JASON & KIMBERLEE A BAKER, CRAIG/ERIKA FRANKS PLACE-ONE LLC COLEMAN TIMOTHY Grantee MCCOLLUM MATTHEW & JESSICA RITTS JAMES M & TINA C CHAPMAN ANDREW JOSEPH GRAY KAITLIN CALCATERA KELLY L TOMICH JOHN & HEATHER BECKTON JOSEPH & LISA THOMAS PHILIP W JR AYERS CHRISTOPHER & BRIOC NICOLE LANTZ MICHELLE M NASH SHAWN RYAN CONSIGLIO RALPH A & DENISE GABON TONY & MAXWELL JULIANNE FULAR ANTHONY & MATSCHE SHANNAN MCCALL MEGHAN S ZENO HOLDINGS LLC BUSCH ROBERT II & MICHELLE LUNDIE JAMES C & JO ANN SORGELOOS KAREN KRUCZYNSKI JOHN & KRISTIN GRAY VERONICA EVANGELISTA MORALES KATIE L WHEATLEY ERIC J & JENNIFER L WAYMASTER CHRISTOPHER M HEFFNER JAKE & ASHLEY SMITH KEITH C & YEE TONY H FRESH START HOMES MICHIGAN 19 LLC LODATO GINO LEBLANC KERRIE ANN BOWLES MATTHEW ALAN & FOSTER KELLY RICHARDSON ERIKA L LAUZON SCOTT T & SHELLEY M VELASGUEZ VANESSA LOCKWOOD JEFFERY JACKSON ROBERT A SR JACKSON CHAVON DONAKOWSKI BARRY DONALD SANDRA L HIGHT EMILY GILREATH WILLIAM C & KAREN JAFFRAY JERRY Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 115,000 129,000 110,000 103,500 134,900 143,800 155,000 20,000 139,980 125,000 109,800 82,000 127,000 110,000 140,500 70,000 136,500 108,000 145,000 148,000 125,000 127,000 110,000 87,400 136,000 94,900 60,000 118,000 122,000 105,000 63,000 160,000 93,000 102,000 72,000 115,900 79,000 134,900 111,900 109,000 70,000 SEV 47,500 39,100 32,800 37,000 52,800 44,900 51,100 8,400 49,900 57,800 45,800 32,400 46,900 44,300 53,200 44,000 44,000 40,700 51,000 58,800 45,800 42,000 40,100 31,200 50,300 35,000 47,100 45,600 30,400 42,600 18,800 70,400 36,700 45,000 26,500 45,100 34,300 44,100 32,400 41,300 39,000 Ratio 41.30 30.31 29.82 35.75 39.14 31.22 32.97 42.00 35.65 46.24 41.71 39.51 36.93 40.27 37.86 62.86 32.23 37.69 35.17 39.73 36.64 33.07 36.45 35.70 36.99 36.88 78.50 38.64 24.92 40.57 29.84 44.00 39.46 44.12 36.81 38.91 43.42 32.69 28.95 37.89 55.71 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-16-428-012 09-14-16-429-018 09-14-16-429-023 09-14-16-431-014 09-14-16-432-001 09-14-16-432-010 09-14-16-452-006 09-14-16-452-015 09-14-16-453-001 09-14-16-453-004 09-14-16-453-025 09-14-16-454-004 09-14-16-454-012 09-14-16-454-018 09-14-16-454-019 09-14-16-454-019 09-14-16-454-035 09-14-16-454-040 09-14-16-454-040 09-14-16-455-013 09-14-16-455-037 09-14-16-455-044 09-14-16-477-015 09-14-16-477-034 09-14-16-477-050 09-14-16-478-002 09-14-16-478-002 09-14-21-204-024 09-14-21-206-012 09-14-21-206-022 09-14-21-206-025 09-14-21-207-002 09-14-21-226-005 09-14-21-226-035 09-14-21-227-006 09-14-21-227-010 09-14-21-227-012 09-14-21-228-006 09-14-21-229-029 09-14-21-229-033 09-14-21-252-006 Sale Date 9/4/2015 3/11/2015 7/6/2015 8/6/2015 5/9/2014 11/14/2014 8/8/2014 5/15/2015 5/29/2015 9/18/2015 10/24/2013 12/27/2013 6/16/2014 6/5/2015 1/9/2015 8/11/2015 7/17/2015 3/31/2014 3/31/2014 12/15/2014 11/6/2013 7/13/2015 6/16/2014 8/26/2014 6/15/2015 2/6/2014 3/20/2015 9/21/2015 5/21/2014 6/13/2014 7/29/2015 2/6/2015 6/20/2014 3/27/2014 6/17/2015 3/2/2015 5/2/2015 1/23/2014 5/2/2014 11/11/2014 10/13/2014 Grantor GROVE, DAWN FIVE STAR ASSET MANAGEMENT LLC LAPOINTE, CHARLES/PATRICIA MCKENNA, DAREN/KIMBERLEY OLEARY KATHERINE ANN TRUST HOLCOMB, RANDY/DARLENE J.A.A.M. INVESTMENTS INC WIECKOWSKI,PATRICK J JOHNSON, KATHLEEN A. CRESWELL, BEVERLY A. JIMCO PROPERTIES LLC HAYDEN, MARILYN JEAN MYER, CHARLES BRIAN/ JULIE SPAHIC, MELISSA M HENSLEY WILLIAM REMOTE RENTALS LLC BENNETT, MILDRED E - TRUST GLAZA, JAMES/ MALEY, ROSE, STRITTMA GLAZA, JAMES/ MALEY, ROSE, STRITTMA DG RESIDENTIAL SALES LLC WASZAK KEITH & JAMIE KAWA, ALBERT/ JOHN REED, JANICE - TRUST DRAGUN, JOSEPH STANLEY BROHL, THOMAS BOELSTLER KURT A RFT 401K TRUST WILKE, HAROLD/MARY JO HOLMES, NATHAN LEONARD, KELLIE YOUNG, CLAUDIA/ LINDA SCHMIDT, BERNADETT A - TRUST STERLING MORTGAGE & INVESTMENT CO SALINIS, CHAD/VALERIE LIMBERG, WALTRAUD MCCAIN III, DONALD E/WENDI M BERZAC, MARGARET - TRUST RUSSELL INVESTMENTS INC STOLZENFELD GLADYS E CUBBA SAM JR NFH CAPITAL PARTNERS II LLC Grantee NELSON ALEXANDRA STAUB JORDAN & ASHLEY LINDSAY GWENDOLYN M MCINTYRE AARON R & BABIUK OLIVIA GREEN KENNETH F & LISA K SALZEIDER TRACY L PALMER GREGORY J & JOHN P II MOORE GLEN DEWAELE SCOTT & WARRIX DEWAELE AIME GAYESKI MARGARET COULSTON NICOLE STOUGH TRACEY A DUVEYOUNG PHILIP PALAZZOLO ROBERT M REMOTE RENTALS LLC WRIGHT MATHEW ARLINGTON PATRICK J & DEBRA A BALL KENNETH D BALL KENNETH D GREEN VELMA DYAMENT THOMAS FRANK ASHWELL GEOFF & KELLY JANOWICZ JUSTIN W CAMARGO ROBERT & AMY HILL JAKE C RTF 401K TRUST BOMBASSEI CHERYL E NAVIN JAMES M THERRIAN ADAM R ROBBINS LISA M PIOSZAK MARK T BERNOT JOHN R & JANICE E SASSER SAMANTHA LUCY JEREMY & AMY BERGERON ROBERT D DOBBS LISA ANN REAL ESTATE ASSETS MANAGEMENT LLC ARCHIBALD SCOTT W & LINDA B ZADICK KATHY HAWK AARON M VANHOESEN DWIGHT D Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 112,500 113,500 135,500 127,000 74,000 115,000 65,000 47,000 97,900 72,000 115,000 118,000 95,000 148,000 66,000 113,900 60,000 63,600 63,600 106,000 125,000 148,000 145,000 99,000 139,000 137,400 139,421 140,500 120,000 118,000 96,000 71,750 97,000 179,000 109,900 121,000 92,500 197,500 142,400 153,000 102,000 SEV 45,400 39,800 54,900 50,100 41,800 42,900 44,500 27,000 46,400 28,000 31,600 42,000 42,400 57,000 45,700 52,000 40,700 38,600 38,600 40,800 53,000 75,400 58,800 49,800 52,600 49,200 55,500 50,900 33,200 50,000 46,300 37,500 38,900 66,300 48,300 44,300 55,000 86,800 57,700 52,800 43,000 Ratio 40.36 35.07 40.52 39.45 56.49 37.30 68.46 57.45 47.40 38.89 27.48 35.59 44.63 38.51 69.24 45.65 67.83 60.69 60.69 38.49 42.40 50.95 40.55 50.30 37.84 35.81 39.81 36.23 27.67 42.37 48.23 52.26 40.10 37.04 43.95 36.61 59.46 43.95 40.52 34.51 42.16 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-21-252-008 09-14-21-252-009 09-14-21-253-058 09-14-21-253-064 09-14-21-254-004 09-14-21-254-008 09-14-21-254-011 09-14-21-254-023 09-14-21-254-024 09-14-21-255-001 09-14-21-256-009 09-14-21-256-009 09-14-21-257-046 09-14-21-258-001 09-14-21-258-022 09-14-21-276-007 09-14-21-277-022 09-14-21-277-026 09-14-21-278-009 09-14-21-278-009 09-14-21-278-018 09-14-21-279-020 09-14-21-279-029 09-14-21-279-034 09-14-21-279-041 09-14-21-280-016 09-14-21-280-044 09-14-21-401-012 09-14-21-402-008 09-14-21-402-017 09-14-21-402-021 09-14-21-402-030 09-14-21-402-047 09-14-21-402-051 09-14-21-403-001 09-14-21-403-007 09-14-21-403-016 09-14-21-403-019 09-14-21-403-024 09-14-21-403-036 09-14-21-403-041 Sale Date 6/12/2015 2/14/2014 3/19/2014 8/21/2014 1/31/2014 7/15/2015 4/21/2014 8/27/2014 4/17/2014 12/17/2013 2/28/2014 8/20/2015 5/15/2014 5/22/2015 7/14/2015 7/29/2014 4/2/2015 6/5/2014 7/7/2014 2/6/2015 1/3/2014 2/27/2015 3/31/2014 8/20/2014 9/17/2015 6/8/2015 5/22/2015 4/20/2015 10/15/2014 5/23/2014 12/9/2013 6/12/2014 7/15/2014 8/8/2014 6/25/2015 7/22/2014 7/24/2014 7/20/2015 6/30/2014 9/3/2015 2/12/2015 Grantor BUDZYN, HOPE/ STANLEY NLTD PROPERTIES LLC MROZ, MATTHEW J MORTIER, RICK/DONNA SHAMROCK ACQUISITIONS LLC KOWALEWSKI, ERIC VOORHEES, KARREN J. YUM, JESSICA L/ MICHAEL B DEMEESTER, ERIC D PUNTURIERE, STEPHEN JOSEPH DOMINIC FERRARI, JEFFREY/OLIVER, AMBER MELCHER, PAMELA ANNETTE CLARK, DUANE M DUBAK, RICHARD/MACKOOL, STACEY POTRYKUS, MARY ANN/FRANCIS J. TRUST LATELLA, SALVATORE - TRUST WEST, MARY A. SIEGEL, ANN P - TRUST MYNET INCORPORATED 27193 LITTLE MACK GROUP LLC BATTAGLIA, CRISTOFARO/FRANSEE, H. WIITANEN, JOSHUA/WIITANEN, LINDSAY SCHLACHTER, SCOTT HEIMES, JEREMY/WIEBELHAUS, RENEE EOVALDI, JOSEPH BAUMGART, RICHARD CONTRERA, AMELIA R ORTEGA, GUDRUN D DOELLE, RENEE M. STANBRIDGE, SHARON NUTTER, III, HERBERT/JENNIFER BURZYCH, SHAUNA MARIE EDWARDS, JENNIFER CHUHRAN JANET QUALEY, MELANIE L. PHILLIPS, STARR FIRCHAU, SAMUEL HOVIS, EDITH E/ MARK D/ ROBERT R SULLIVAN, BETTY/ JOHN D ZEMENS, RACHEL J. Grantee MCKINLEY BRYAN R QUERTERMOUS JENNIFER ZALEWSKI ANDREW J WOZNIAK KEVIN & DEFAUW JENNIFER GAUDINO, RONALD A CHWALEK JAY THOMAS MICHAEL & SOKOLOWSKI STACY GRABOWSKI CAITLIN S PRESTON BROOKE JOHN ENGVALL 401K FERRARI JEFFREY & HUNNAH HAJEK BRANDI BARTHEL JUSTIN & HOOTEN BRANDY CHERRY DANIEL PATRICK ROSINSKI PATRICIA M RAHAMAN JOSE CASCIONE JEROME E & MIRJAM TIMKEN PROPERTIES INC MYNET INCORPORATED FETT MATTHEW L PIOSZAK LISA M BATTAGLIA CRISTOFARO & FRANSEE HEAT LOEFFLER JENNIFER MARIE NEWBERG MICHAEL & DAVID BARAN JOZEF & EWA TEROKOWSKIE ADAM & MICHELLE KADLITZ CHRISTYNE MARIE SULLIVAN ELIZABETH KOWALKE FRED A III WAGNER MATTHEW P & ALICIA M BAHRI KYLE VANITTERSUM GUY BLACK DAVID L GODDARD GRANT NOBAR MICHAEL C KIERNICKI LAWRENCE & STEPHANIE MARTIN STUART & MUNSTERMAN SARA MOSLEY JUSTIN DEJAEGHERE JOHN YACUZZO SALVATORE PICHIERRI DIANA Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 401 401 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 103,000 107,000 101,400 127,500 135,000 132,000 94,900 109,900 117,500 56,000 131,000 140,000 114,000 116,500 124,500 129,000 101,000 75,000 66,500 151,000 70,000 138,900 117,000 110,000 125,000 134,900 102,500 96,000 76,000 89,000 83,000 49,000 139,900 120,000 84,500 65,000 118,000 115,000 71,000 109,000 99,900 SEV 45,600 33,400 48,200 40,100 37,700 44,700 41,000 42,100 44,600 25,100 39,400 56,000 40,200 43,200 46,100 54,200 52,400 47,200 52,100 52,100 37,400 45,000 35,600 44,400 51,200 57,600 44,400 29,100 37,000 32,600 38,600 37,100 55,200 40,500 36,600 30,400 39,300 34,300 38,100 47,300 38,800 Ratio 44.27 31.21 47.53 31.45 27.93 33.86 43.20 38.31 37.96 44.82 30.08 40.00 35.26 37.08 37.03 42.02 51.88 62.93 78.35 34.50 53.43 32.40 30.43 40.36 40.96 42.70 43.32 30.31 48.68 36.63 46.51 75.71 39.46 33.75 43.31 46.77 33.31 29.83 53.66 43.39 38.84 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-21-403-045 09-14-21-403-062 09-14-21-404-033 09-14-21-404-045 09-14-21-426-005 09-14-21-426-010 09-14-21-426-012 09-14-21-426-016 09-14-21-426-028 09-14-21-427-005 09-14-21-427-023 09-14-21-427-045 09-14-21-427-047 09-14-21-427-048 09-14-21-428-001 09-14-21-429-026 09-14-21-451-005 09-14-21-451-011 09-14-21-452-014 09-14-21-452-027 09-14-21-452-032 09-14-21-454-006 09-14-21-454-013 09-14-21-454-039 09-14-21-454-042 09-14-21-454-046 09-14-21-455-006 09-14-21-455-008 09-14-21-455-011 09-14-21-476-014 09-14-21-477-026 09-14-21-477-036 09-14-21-478-039 09-14-21-479-013 09-14-21-479-022 09-14-22-101-022 09-14-22-102-012 09-14-22-102-014 09-14-22-102-026 09-14-22-102-031 09-14-22-102-033 Sale Date 6/3/2015 12/1/2014 9/29/2015 1/15/2014 10/17/2014 8/15/2014 6/24/2015 4/8/2015 1/3/2014 6/9/2014 11/21/2013 7/27/2015 12/20/2013 5/30/2014 1/24/2014 8/5/2015 11/17/2014 6/10/2014 10/4/2013 3/11/2014 7/23/2014 5/22/2015 6/24/2015 9/11/2014 10/6/2014 2/6/2015 9/29/2015 11/12/2014 5/29/2014 11/12/2013 12/15/2014 4/27/2015 11/14/2014 6/11/2014 7/2/2015 5/30/2014 3/31/2015 5/13/2015 6/19/2015 10/8/2013 5/12/2015 Grantor MARTINEK, JOY GEORGE III, KENNETH J/ NICOLE R ODRAKIEWICZ, ROBERT S ROVDA, ROBERT/KIMBERLY DEROSE EDWARD TAYLOR, KATHY/ PAUL C - TRUST SANGRET LAUREN DENEWETH, JEROME/VELETA - TRUST KREBS, SARAH MCKINNEY, JANET M. STEVER, MONICA R. BURKART, JOANNE L. BINDER, KAY C TRI-COUNTY RE HOLDINGS SULLINS, ROY - TRUST LANGLOIS, DOUGLAS M MORIN, DAVID G DAILEY, LORI EMMI MICHAEL TRUST LOSHAW PATRICIA 25527 CULVER LLC PERLMAN, DEBRA R BAKOTICH, LAUREN/MICHAEL ZELLA LOUISE VANACKER, MICHAEL/KRISTI RAHAMAN, JOSE A SCHNEIDER CHARLOTTE M TRUST HUMPHRIES GAYLE SAJE GROUP LLC MARTIN, LORRAINE ANN LEVY, HARRISON - TRUST BOLOGNA, DAVID TIMKEN PROPERTIES INC DEMEY DOUGLAS STEIN, VICTORIA RYAN, PATRICK CHAKLOS MARY TRUST TURSELL BERNIE OLIPHANT MATTHEW GORECKI ARTHUR W & ROSE C MALONEY, BRADY Grantee CLELAND JOSEPH A JR PINKHAM KATE E BROOKS WILLIAM & KARPINSKI ALYSSA WHITMORE LINDSAY COOK MATTHEW WALKER CHRISTOPHER T GRIDLEY LOIS MCGARVAH DONALD S & CAROLYN A MUAZZEM SYED CHUHRAN CRAIG P HISTED CHRISTOPHER J BLACKBURN STEVEN C & CYNTHIA A FREDERICK SUSAN L GEIGER JESSICA L COFFMAN SEAN FOSTER BRADLEY NATSCHKE KRISTOPHER WILLER WILLIAM & MARGUERITE VANNIEULANDE MELISSA J LORDY RONALD D LAFRINIERE MARK & COLLEEN ROLSETH SHAUN HOFBAUER KIMBERLY DECRUYDT ZACHARIAH A BUNGALOW PROPERTIES LLC COSIO KATELYN M THOMPSON MATTHEW & JESSICA NORTON MICHAEL P GRAY DAWN A RUSSO SALVATORE TRI COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS & M NICKELL MATTHEW M JJB2 INVESTMENT LLC CHUHRAN ROSHELL I DYER ERIC B II & ASHLEY L POWELL COOPER JEANETTE GILLIAM TIMOTHY W CONTRERA AMELIA R BENEDETTINI MARK & REBECCA DELL JOSEPH W SMITH EBEN D & RUTH E Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 130,000 140,000 118,000 126,000 68,000 128,900 116,000 127,000 87,900 56,100 113,500 116,000 79,900 111,000 110,000 137,000 90,000 75,000 63,000 40,000 63,000 51,419 79,900 91,500 81,000 98,600 135,000 83,500 118,200 75,900 87,500 117,000 125,000 114,000 127,500 134,000 120,000 128,500 135,000 108,000 125,000 SEV 58,200 43,300 49,000 40,000 25,800 44,400 47,700 58,900 32,100 30,800 38,100 54,600 42,200 37,900 43,300 68,600 33,700 36,100 28,900 24,000 34,700 37,100 32,800 40,700 39,500 39,200 46,200 41,500 41,500 32,800 42,700 50,500 38,000 40,000 40,600 45,200 45,100 57,900 49,200 44,400 53,000 Ratio 44.77 30.93 41.53 31.75 37.94 34.45 41.12 46.38 36.52 54.90 33.57 47.07 52.82 34.14 39.36 50.07 37.44 48.13 45.87 60.00 55.08 72.15 41.05 44.48 48.77 39.76 34.22 49.70 35.11 43.21 48.80 43.16 30.40 35.09 31.84 33.73 37.58 45.06 36.44 41.11 42.40 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-22-102-036 09-14-22-103-016 09-14-22-103-020 09-14-22-103-021 09-14-22-103-031 09-14-22-103-036 09-14-22-103-058 09-14-22-127-007 09-14-22-127-014 09-14-22-127-014 09-14-22-127-015 09-14-22-127-056 09-14-22-128-036 09-14-22-128-038 09-14-22-151-008 09-14-22-151-031 09-14-22-151-031 09-14-22-151-034 09-14-22-151-041 09-14-22-152-007 09-14-22-152-011 09-14-22-152-059 09-14-22-152-061 09-14-22-153-034 09-14-22-153-043 09-14-22-154-018 09-14-22-154-034 09-14-22-154-045 09-14-22-155-003 09-14-22-176-016 09-14-22-176-034 09-14-22-178-035 09-14-22-178-037 09-14-22-179-006 09-14-22-179-025 09-14-22-179-027 09-14-22-180-013 09-14-22-201-034 09-14-22-201-036 09-14-22-201-040 09-14-22-202-044 Sale Date 9/14/2015 6/13/2014 5/6/2015 10/9/2014 1/8/2014 2/13/2015 7/7/2014 6/26/2014 3/7/2014 8/21/2014 8/6/2014 7/20/2015 1/30/2015 6/17/2014 9/8/2015 11/25/2013 6/25/2015 6/10/2014 7/23/2014 9/9/2015 1/9/2015 12/9/2013 8/27/2014 4/22/2014 9/3/2015 4/3/2015 1/10/2014 7/8/2015 4/30/2015 6/29/2015 4/17/2014 10/17/2014 8/8/2014 10/24/2014 3/19/2014 10/10/2014 4/25/2014 7/11/2014 4/16/2014 4/24/2015 11/21/2014 Grantor KLEIN FAMILY TRUST HARRIS PAUL D MCLEAN, AARON J LYONS SARAH BERNICE VORPAGEL DAVID A BAZYDLO, MICHAEL/SHERYL FULTON, MARK/KATHERINE ALEXANDER, STEPHEN K/ STERI, TALIA SPANIOLO JAMIE TNB CONNECT LLC HANNA DAVID RITCHIE, KIRK D. MCDONALD, DANIEL GEHRKE, JEFFREY M GARZA, RODOLFO/DOREEN GREAT LAKES CUSTOM HOMES INC YAMIN, MICHELLE L NYENHUIS, JEFFREY/ KIMBERLY CHAMPAGNE, DOROTHY M WILLIAMS EVELYN J TRUST FELDMAN MICHAEL MANIACI STEPHEN JOSEPH II & LAURA J TRACY, AMY D SPOT REALTY INC WARD, KRISTA M/ PATRICK W SCHWARTZ, ELIZABETH/ MICHAEL J MORRISON, WILLIAM/YVONNE - TRUST LASKOWSKI, ROBERT/ RUSH, RAYMOND ET MCNABNEY, JOHN/SYLVIA FLAHERTY, FRED/CHRISTINE LESLIE, GEORGE PIANELLO, CHRISTINA/ PITTINATO, MAT MURPHY, MAUREEN M - TRUST CHAUVIN, MICHAEL RUSSELL, CHERYL/ROBERT MARCHETTO JOHN C GADY, BENTON R. VANGHELUWE, JULIA FURNO WILLIAM BARTON, ANDREW/ULBRICH, ALEXA HEINRICH LUCILLE TRUST Grantee SOWARDS RAYMOND KEN AHLSTROM GARRETT LOVATI PHILLIP A & SHUKWIT NICOLE A KENDRICK PAULA E KLUG MATTHEW BRUDER CALVIN J CLIFTON BETTY L HINDES MARTHA H TNB CONNECT LLC PELLETIER STEVEN WASUKANIS JOSEPH J II CLOSE LINDSAY A ROSS KATIE BELY LORI WALSH KORY M YAMIN MICHELLE L ROEHL DEREK & CRAIG KRESS CYNTHIA A WILLIS LORNE A II & MELISSA S PALUZZI JAMES J FORTUNA DANIEL A ACCICA PETER CHAPEL JONATHAN H & KYLIE L SKILL HELEN I LOCONSOLE SEAN WENDT RENEE CLISBY ALISON XIE MAN LEE & MIN HUO XIE MANLEE & MAIN HUO GIASSON MARK A BOELSTLER KURT A OROSZ KIMBERLY CONNER LISA G MICHALSKI MICHAEL JASE GROUP LLC TNB CONNECT LLC BAIR ERIC PINERO MARY A RYAN KAREN MCCUNE KYLE R & SHANNON M GARNATZ FRANK & DANIELLE Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 120,000 101,000 140,000 110,000 91,200 165,000 135,000 108,000 69,900 133,000 100,000 170,000 100,000 104,000 136,900 119,000 142,000 152,000 112,000 93,700 110,000 135,000 129,900 104,500 124,000 112,000 87,000 100,000 98,000 144,800 60,000 118,750 130,000 117,000 87,750 75,000 125,000 121,500 101,000 110,000 110,000 SEV 50,400 42,500 53,800 41,200 38,300 75,700 45,800 35,200 38,400 39,900 44,000 63,000 44,700 43,700 52,200 40,600 57,400 59,300 48,000 49,500 46,300 51,200 46,700 38,900 50,000 48,100 35,900 46,400 45,800 60,100 38,300 31,800 45,100 42,500 38,900 39,800 43,500 57,800 44,700 46,600 48,800 Ratio 42.00 42.08 38.43 37.45 42.00 45.88 33.93 32.59 54.94 30.00 44.00 37.06 44.70 42.02 38.13 34.12 40.42 39.01 42.86 52.83 42.09 37.93 35.95 37.22 40.32 42.95 41.26 46.40 46.73 41.51 63.83 26.78 34.69 36.32 44.33 53.07 34.80 47.57 44.26 42.36 44.36 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-22-203-028 09-14-22-203-030 09-14-22-204-026 09-14-22-204-029 09-14-22-205-012 09-14-22-227-003 09-14-22-227-006 09-14-22-229-017 09-14-22-230-022 09-14-22-233-011 09-14-22-251-031 09-14-22-252-038 09-14-22-254-010 09-14-22-254-011 09-14-22-254-012 09-14-22-254-038 09-14-22-254-041 09-14-22-254-053 09-14-22-255-007 09-14-22-255-010 09-14-22-255-019 09-14-22-255-026 09-14-22-276-005 09-14-22-276-015 09-14-22-276-021 09-14-22-277-004 09-14-22-277-010 09-14-22-277-011 09-14-22-277-015 09-14-22-278-001 09-14-22-278-003 09-14-22-280-001 09-14-22-280-002 09-14-22-282-009 09-14-22-284-009 09-14-22-285-003 09-14-22-285-018 09-14-22-301-003 09-14-22-301-025 09-14-22-301-031 09-14-22-302-020 Sale Date 6/2/2015 10/15/2013 7/11/2014 5/28/2015 6/1/2015 2/24/2014 12/16/2013 5/23/2014 7/11/2014 8/29/2014 6/13/2014 6/12/2014 7/8/2015 3/11/2015 9/4/2015 4/30/2014 12/17/2014 4/20/2015 2/28/2014 7/16/2014 7/24/2015 3/13/2014 8/22/2014 9/8/2015 10/4/2013 3/27/2014 12/2/2013 5/2/2014 6/2/2015 1/15/2014 2/17/2015 6/17/2015 6/26/2015 8/14/2015 8/29/2014 6/6/2014 4/13/2015 2/19/2014 5/9/2014 7/14/2015 12/30/2013 Grantor STARR, JOHN/KIMBERLY BYINGTON KAREN M TRUST BRYS, ALFRED/SANDRA DABROWSKI, HENRY SHADOW LLC RAYMON ANTHONY GVB CONSULTING SERVICES INC CHUHRAN, CRAIG/ROSHELL KOENIG, DOROTHY/ KENNETH STEWART, SHARON M MOFFETT, MELISSA HOFFMANN, REBECCA PEDIGO, MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER GADETTE KAREN L GEMI, DONALD RHOADES, LOLA A. MUNRO, JAMES/LYNN NICKELL, MATTHEW M DESCHAINE EDWIN & NORMA TRUST GALINTA, GERARDO/TRACY SCHNEIDER, ARTHUR J. - TRUST ANDERSON MARY J FARR, EMILY KRUS, MARK/DEBRA BARELLO FAMILY & SURVIVORS TRUSTS ZUZANEK, MARIAN MAZZOLA, CLEMENT/RITA MAZZOLA, DEVLIN/MARCO/THOMAS FOXA CYNTHIA A SIERADZK STEPHEN & DIANNE DURR SHIRLEY UROSEV, ILIJA/JOVANKA DEMATTEIS, ANTONIO/TAMMY SMUKAL, RANDALL NIMBACH, LAWRENCE MILLER, JANE RUSSELL INVESTMENTS INC SUMINSKI KENNETH H MACINKOWIVZ, JASON/ MELLISSA REA, KATHLEEN A LIGHT JR, IRENE Grantee LAPENSEE DENNIS G & CHERYL D ADAMS DANIEL A MALKOWSKI MICHAEL L & JAMIE L DUNDAS JEFFREY M HOTCHKISS BRIAN L MCCARVER FRANCES M MARCHESE JACQUELINE ALONGI KELLY FREEMAN PAUL & SARAH KAYODE JUMOKE TAMMINGA WILLIAM BELLOLI GREGORY & GRANT TIFFANY MARKOVITCH RONALD JACYNO LEON MANASSE DANIEL ARMSTRONG KARRIE BURDETTE KEVIN ABDENOUR MICHAEL ROGERS DONNA L YOTT MICHAEL JR KARPINSKI RICHARD & HERCHOCK ELAINE REED MATTHEW G & MARY K KRAVITZ JOHN F DLD INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC JACOBS STEVEN A & JENNIFER L BRISTOL JOHN M & LORI M FEDERIGHE CATHERINE R CORNWELL JOSEPH & BRIGITTE ROSATI CHRISTOPHER SIERADZKI JEREMY MAXWELL DAVID C & LYNN L DEMATTEIS ANTONIO & TAMMY KRUSZYNA TIMOTHY D & NICOLE HEWITT WLLIAM M & AMANDA M CICALA TIMOTHY S & KATHERINE A REPPERT JAMES & HEATHER WOODS CRAIG E & KIRWAY WOODS MICHEL VIGLIOTTI JULIE CZYGAN BRIAN C & SARAH E NIMS AARON S GARRETT ADAM M & MELISSA A Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD LC WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 217,000 138,000 210,500 95,000 37,000 195,000 57,500 208,000 205,000 171,600 110,100 150,000 137,000 126,000 141,000 69,500 110,000 135,000 83,000 153,000 109,600 115,000 101,000 150,000 160,000 150,000 150,000 154,000 188,000 95,000 185,000 365,000 270,000 267,500 220,000 100,000 198,503 78,000 78,000 144,200 76,500 SEV Ratio 112,000 64,100 80,500 55,500 14,000 84,700 32,900 88,500 74,400 70,000 53,400 50,300 57,300 40,800 56,000 30,200 34,400 62,300 34,200 57,800 45,700 39,500 52,300 64,600 91,500 57,400 49,400 54,700 84,100 58,400 65,000 198,700 115,800 114,900 96,800 49,900 99,700 33,900 31,800 43,500 33,200 51.61 46.45 38.24 58.42 37.84 43.44 57.22 42.55 36.29 40.79 48.50 33.53 41.82 32.38 39.72 43.45 31.27 46.15 41.20 37.78 41.70 34.35 51.78 43.07 57.19 38.27 32.93 35.52 44.73 61.47 35.14 54.44 42.89 42.95 44.00 49.90 50.23 43.46 40.77 30.17 43.40 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-22-302-033 09-14-22-302-047 09-14-22-303-015 09-14-22-303-020 09-14-22-303-039 09-14-22-305-004 09-14-22-305-005 09-14-22-327-004 09-14-22-327-006 09-14-22-327-007 09-14-22-328-012 09-14-22-328-013 09-14-22-328-015 09-14-22-328-047 09-14-22-329-010 09-14-22-329-012 09-14-22-330-003 09-14-22-332-018 09-14-22-333-009 09-14-22-333-014 09-14-22-334-013 09-14-22-352-014 09-14-22-353-014 09-14-22-353-021 09-14-22-377-003 09-14-22-377-004 09-14-22-377-004 09-14-22-379-015 09-14-22-380-026 09-14-22-380-026 09-14-22-381-029 09-14-22-382-016 09-14-22-401-014 09-14-22-401-017 09-14-22-402-001 09-14-22-402-012 09-14-22-402-029 09-14-22-402-036 09-14-22-402-040 09-14-22-403-003 09-14-22-403-012 Sale Date 12/30/2014 6/2/2014 8/7/2015 2/3/2015 12/5/2014 12/19/2013 10/14/2014 10/15/2013 9/18/2015 11/26/2014 5/15/2015 7/29/2014 4/14/2014 6/20/2014 11/19/2014 12/26/2013 5/29/2014 3/28/2014 9/10/2014 7/16/2015 8/5/2014 7/25/2014 7/18/2014 12/17/2014 11/11/2014 10/17/2014 6/18/2015 6/23/2015 10/25/2013 5/2/2014 11/21/2014 7/9/2015 8/14/2014 7/24/2014 2/13/2015 4/17/2015 1/9/2014 2/13/2014 5/15/2015 8/19/2015 8/25/2014 Grantor CLOS, GERALD/CAROL KREISELMEIER, CHRISTINA KOPP, DOUGLAS/KELLY CARMEN DAVIS TTEE CP2 INV GROUP JOSEPH, MELAD/C. BIRETTA ERIC CEDERWALL, RICHARD GALANT LORI R GADDY, KATHY DIANE SCHLACHTER, P.L. -TRUSTEE LARIVEE, COURTNEY/LUCIDO, STEVEN NORTHERN DREAM LLC LACO ENTERPRISES LLC FENSKE, JARED SCHUSTER FAMILY TRUST KRZEZEWSKI, DAVID COUVREUR FAMILY TRUST MILLER-MULCASTER, AMY L. LENDA, ANGELA GRANDMA JOANNE LLC BOBBLE CLIP INC. STEINHEISER, BARBARA M. - TRUST TROMBLEY, ALICE - TRUST MCBRIEN, AMBER LYNN MAGRO, FILIPPO/P. VAN DE PUTTE, JAMES F/ NICOLETTE A ROEHRIG, MICHAEL HOWELL, PAMELA KAIDANTZIS JOHN S TRUST MCLELLAN, KEVIN MALONEY, CARYL M/ JAMES/ ETAL SETCHELL, DANIEL CICALA, KATHERINE PAWLUK, ELEANOR - TRUST TORTOMOSE STEPHEN G HOLTON, NORMAN TRUST PENNO, KATHLEEN/JEROME KAUFMAN TODD M FOUTY, DOUGLAS/ANN REED, JANET S - TRUST SZYMANSKI, HENRY J - TRUST Grantee ESSENMACHER JONATHON PERICH BRAD & THOMPSON PATRICIA NEAL SHANE & HEATHER B & W REAL PROPERTY ASSOC LLC BEGIN JAMIE J ARSCOTT JESSICA FOURNIER MICHAEL & LISA VISGER JOAN ALEXANDROU JOSHUA & FERRANTI BRANDI CONSIGLIO RALPH & DENISE FISHER EDWARD MARCUS HANNING RICHARD K JACKSON JOHN ATKINS SEAN & RENEE BIONDO CAROL H WAGNER JILLIAN STRAT KARRY A BOREK JEFFERY GARAVAGLIA ROBERT BEAM BRITTANY CALOCASSIDES JOHN HUGAERT GILBERT F TRUST SMITH ELENA A MILLS MATTHEW O & TINA JONASSEN JOHN ROEHRIG MICHAEL ELSEY DAVID R & MELISSA A LEONARD GARY JR & ALICIA MCLELLAN KEVIN WOODS PATRICIA M BASELINE FINANCIAL LLC SNYDER MITCHEL & HUSEMAN KAREN ROMANELLI CHRIS & MARY BETH BERGERON STEVEN ALEXANDER ALEX P & KELLY EALY DAVID M SORGELOOS MICHAEL K & JACQUELINE E TRIGLIA ALICE M SMYKOWSKI CHELSEA NICOLE BOWMAN DAVID ALAN & AMY MARIE BOKANO WILLIAM A Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 71,500 130,000 149,900 84,000 146,000 94,000 106,000 64,000 49,500 40,740 134,000 115,000 108,500 241,000 99,000 104,000 135,000 105,000 117,000 149,900 88,800 74,500 165,000 139,900 154,000 144,500 157,000 126,000 61,000 105,000 48,900 53,500 155,000 130,000 122,500 127,000 65,000 110,000 134,000 121,900 102,000 SEV Ratio 37,800 51,400 62,500 41,700 57,000 41,600 38,800 32,300 40,400 33,100 35,200 35,000 38,100 119,600 40,000 41,700 53,500 40,800 43,200 62,800 37,700 41,000 71,900 52,600 60,100 47,500 61,600 53,000 36,800 40,000 29,400 26,700 55,100 59,300 42,500 54,500 38,700 39,000 57,300 51,800 40,700 52.87 39.54 41.69 49.64 39.04 44.26 36.60 50.47 81.62 81.25 26.27 30.43 35.12 49.63 40.40 40.10 39.63 38.86 36.92 41.89 42.45 55.03 43.58 37.60 39.03 32.87 39.24 42.06 60.33 38.10 60.12 49.91 35.55 45.62 34.69 42.91 59.54 35.45 42.76 42.49 39.90 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-22-403-017 09-14-22-405-007 09-14-22-406-024 09-14-22-408-001 09-14-22-408-020 09-14-22-426-018 09-14-22-429-018 09-14-22-432-005 09-14-22-434-009 09-14-22-438-001 09-14-22-439-003 09-14-22-451-002 09-14-22-451-025 09-14-22-451-040 09-14-22-452-007 09-14-22-452-013 09-14-22-452-018 09-14-22-452-022 09-14-22-452-041 09-14-22-453-034 09-14-22-480-008 09-14-22-480-016 09-14-22-481-007 09-14-22-481-008 09-14-22-482-005 09-14-22-482-017 09-14-22-483-015 09-14-22-484-018 09-14-22-484-019 09-14-23-102-007 09-14-23-102-027 09-14-23-102-029 09-14-23-103-010 09-14-23-104-003 09-14-23-104-029 09-14-23-104-034 09-14-23-152-013 09-14-23-152-022 09-14-23-153-011 09-14-23-154-016 09-14-23-155-006 Sale Date 7/10/2014 8/24/2015 7/31/2014 3/25/2014 7/24/2014 5/27/2015 10/7/2014 12/30/2013 12/13/2013 3/30/2015 9/19/2014 2/4/2015 8/25/2015 4/2/2014 6/3/2014 8/26/2014 5/7/2015 12/31/2014 8/29/2014 11/15/2013 5/8/2015 12/16/2013 6/26/2015 4/23/2014 8/25/2014 12/18/2014 7/10/2015 2/28/2014 4/4/2014 1/30/2015 10/17/2013 12/30/2014 7/28/2014 11/7/2014 5/9/2014 6/5/2015 10/29/2013 10/18/2013 2/6/2015 4/1/2014 6/15/2015 Grantor SIEJA-BOUMARAFI - TRUST LICARI, JOSEPH SWANQUIST, RICHARD/MARY E. MILES MATTHEW & SHANNON MACOMB COUNTY HABITAT FOR HUMANITY KOTCHER, JR., JOHN H. NUTTS INVESTMENTS LLC WEILMANN III, DONALD SCHLEMER, CHARLES EUGENE MEAD, DONNA M. - TRUST BARNETT MARGARET A ALEXANDER, TONI/TIMOTHY - TRUST SPONKOWSKI, JUDITH KLING BARBARA PINERO, MARY USA RENTAL FUND LLC ALVARO IRENE M MACPHEE, OLIVIA/SCOTT/ANTOINETE VAN GS INVESTMENTS LLC GFD LLC KASTNER, EDWARD/VIRGINIA SNAPP, KELLY DAUGHTREY, GEORGE PINTO, JOHN/VERONICA KEENE, BRIAN STERLING PROPERTY MANAGEMENT INC. CAPALDI, JASON T BROUS ELSA TRUST PIENCINAVES, RUDY A. CAUL, MICHAEL/LINDA JOHNSON ROBERT J & HILDA U SIMONS ROBERT L TRUST MOORE, SHELTON/ARIADNE GRANT CAROL TRERICE, HEATH POST, KRISTIE A TAFURICORNILLIE KATHLEEN A TRUST SALVATORE EVA TRUST LLOYD, LARRY/LINDA VANNESTE HELEN GORDON SHANNON Grantee KRUZEL PATRICK & SOLEY KELLY WOOD PASTERNACKI PAULA MCGHEE NICHOLAS C DEMENT ERIC G POWELL JAIME WHITE MAUREEN LOGIE MOLLY A GENTRY LUCILLE CURCI DENNIS JR & ODBERT RACHEL BENKELMAN JOEL ANDERSEN MARGARET L CORNWELL DANIEL FILIPIAK TYRONE & SHANNON DELGADO DANIEL WRUBEL MATTHEW S A FUND LLC BROW JUDY A RACHO MARILYN & LYNN JOY MORGAN ROBERT J BOYER LEON & NAHUT KALICH, DOMINIC/STONEHILL, KRISTINA LAUBERT BRADLEY K & LEE ANN TOMLINSON ANNE L MCCAY KAREN E COLBOURNE LEWIS MATHIS KIMBERLY S HAGGERTY JAMES P JR PALUZZI JAMES J BLOCH LILLIAN E MYERS JESSE KOCH GEORGE DECOSTER MICHELLE THOMAS GRANT M & ERICA M SERRA VINCENT J & MARIANNA F MICHELS PATRICK J & SHEENA L HAMM ROBERT W & NINA LINCE ALEXANDER J GLOWNIAK SCOTT D & SEIDEL LAURA M TAYLOR STEVEN & CHRISTINE L MIGLIORE SEAN HESSLING JORDAN & ERIN Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 114,380 125,000 210,000 72,200 97,000 120,000 63,000 190,000 112,000 299,000 142,000 149,500 107,000 109,000 90,000 36,500 104,900 135,000 73,500 124,300 110,000 117,000 135,000 157,500 129,000 125,000 185,000 76,000 129,500 265,000 90,000 405,000 210,000 119,000 210,000 79,500 255,000 419,000 380,000 220,000 225,000 SEV Ratio 45,200 41,100 65,000 35,100 48,900 39,300 20,500 74,000 46,300 100,200 92,300 57,700 61,000 46,500 34,700 27,300 45,500 45,100 41,200 57,300 48,700 45,800 55,000 59,100 67,500 53,000 56,400 58,400 54,600 109,400 30,100 198,400 75,800 45,400 103,100 44,300 107,900 165,900 153,000 100,600 107,400 39.52 32.88 30.95 48.61 50.41 32.75 32.54 38.95 41.34 33.51 65.00 38.60 57.01 42.66 38.56 74.79 43.37 33.41 56.05 46.10 44.27 39.15 40.74 37.52 52.33 42.40 30.49 76.84 42.16 41.28 33.44 48.99 36.10 38.15 49.10 55.72 42.31 39.59 40.26 45.73 47.73 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-23-155-009 09-14-23-155-010 09-14-23-156-006 09-14-23-301-013 09-14-23-304-013 09-14-23-304-020 09-14-23-305-005 09-14-23-306-023 09-14-23-306-049 09-14-23-307-016 09-14-23-307-037 09-14-23-308-002 09-14-23-308-019 09-14-23-308-021 09-14-23-309-004 09-14-23-309-009 09-14-23-351-001 09-14-23-352-011 09-14-23-354-014 09-14-23-356-006 09-14-23-360-001 09-14-23-360-008 09-14-23-362-002 09-14-26-104-001 09-14-26-105-038 09-14-26-107-005 09-14-26-107-015 09-14-26-107-025 09-14-26-107-028 09-14-26-108-020 09-14-26-108-023 09-14-26-109-005 09-14-26-109-008 09-14-26-110-001 09-14-26-110-006 09-14-26-153-028 09-14-26-154-019 09-14-26-154-021 09-14-26-155-001 09-14-26-155-005 09-14-26-156-004 Sale Date 6/23/2015 5/29/2015 5/1/2015 6/15/2015 12/26/2014 4/10/2015 4/30/2015 8/15/2014 5/30/2014 7/9/2015 10/15/2014 1/6/2015 8/12/2015 7/1/2015 4/23/2014 10/31/2014 4/14/2015 11/3/2014 11/1/2013 10/10/2013 10/31/2013 6/5/2015 6/22/2015 6/29/2015 9/11/2015 6/18/2015 4/18/2014 8/28/2015 7/21/2015 10/16/2013 10/6/2014 2/19/2015 6/5/2015 10/24/2013 7/9/2015 8/31/2015 4/25/2014 3/6/2015 7/1/2014 4/24/2014 2/6/2015 Grantor PAVLIK FRANCES MARIE TRUST MAILLOUX, JEANNE/ NORMAN - TRUST GARCIA JAMIE L DENNIS, JAMES E. ROTHENHOUSER STEPHANIE SANDERS, KATHLEEN A. MCISAAC, CARRIE A. SHAFER, THOMAS MACIK JR, WILLIAM D PETZER, KRISTINA C. SWICK, RONALD/S. ELAINE JOYCE KARMAN, RUSSELL/SUSAN LUDWICK LIVING TRUST GLODICH LOUIS J JR TRUST KOLODGE, DUSTIN CROOKS, ALBERT B - TRUST TRENDLE JOAN TRUST RITTNER WILLIAM F & BARBARA A LEDIN ALICE Z MANOR DEVELOPMENT SCS LLC KOLIBA, JOSEPH A THOMPSON, PAUL R. SCHOCK, MARK DG RESIDENTIAL SALES LLC WAGNER, MICHAEL LEADER INVESTMENT COMPANY TAYLOR, THOMAS RAYMOND & FLANEGIN, JAMES/JANET - TRUST JACKSON MICHAEL C & THERESE J HAWKINS, JERRY WAGNER, ERYN l CHEN YEE FAMILY TRUST YOSHONIS LEE SWITRAS, MARK/ MATTHEW DISTEL, RICHARD/BRIGID WHIPPLE, ROBERT REYNOLDS, DONALD J. LADNEY, ROBERT SMITH, SHEILA - TRUST VANBELLE, ARLENE Grantee CUDDEBACK MARC & GLOWACZ HEATHER LISAK WAYNE P II MATHEW SHANE M STEMMLER FREDRICK P JR TELMOS LAURENCE F EWALD JAMES N NIEMASZ KELLEY GRIFFIN JAMES D PREGIBON CHARLES EDWARD CRUTCHFIELD STEPHEN & JANELLE BAY VISTA HOMES LLC OSGOOD MELISSA CUSHMAN JAMES PAULUS LAWRENCE M & THERESA R KREIPKE KYLE J JASIOLEK JEREMY KOTCHER JOHN H & KRAUSE JILLIAN MILLER GERALD W SCHMIDT HENRY C & LAURIE B FETT CANDACE POLULAK ANDREA L KUNZE STEVEN & WENDY KURRLE PHILLIP J CYGAN DAVID M II LUNDQUIST JOHN ERIC & CAROLYN ANN AUDISH CHRIS HULET JAMIE L GUZMAN FABRICIO PETER & ANNE MEGAN ZYLA JOE III OZZELLO JASON & KAITLYN DAINTY KIMBERLY BERNIER STEVEN B & SUSAN A MCLEAN CHRISTOPHER A & BUN EYAM LUNDQUIST BRITTA SLINGERLAND AMBER BRANDON MICHAEL K MILLER AARON N TORRICE JEFFERY P STOKES ANDREW M JAMES ASLEIGH TIESLER CHRISTOPHER & ADLER LAURA Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 404 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 233,216 111,450 113,500 199,500 97,000 41,000 119,900 487,050 340,000 345,300 60,000 180,000 269,900 256,000 190,000 270,000 350,000 375,000 239,000 179,900 89,900 150,000 310,000 149,900 389,900 280,000 170,000 575,000 370,000 208,500 365,000 307,000 260,000 232,000 123,000 460,000 200,000 290,000 286,500 258,500 195,000 SEV Ratio 87,000 48,300 28,500 79,300 36,900 21,100 44,000 139,600 160,500 128,900 37,200 98,000 102,700 87,500 93,700 101,800 175,600 154,700 48,600 78,800 40,700 52,400 104,700 54,300 153,700 99,400 93,100 226,800 125,000 107,200 165,800 121,100 98,400 114,600 59,200 169,300 80,200 96,500 136,100 102,100 79,800 37.30 43.34 25.11 39.75 38.04 51.46 36.70 28.66 47.21 37.33 62.00 54.44 38.05 34.18 49.32 37.70 50.17 41.25 20.33 43.80 45.27 34.93 33.77 36.22 39.42 35.50 54.76 39.44 33.78 51.41 45.42 39.45 37.85 49.40 48.13 36.80 40.10 33.28 47.50 39.50 40.92 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-26-352-003 09-14-26-352-006 09-14-26-352-035 09-14-26-352-037 09-14-26-352-038 09-14-26-352-041 09-14-26-352-043 09-14-26-352-044 09-14-26-352-045 09-14-26-352-049 09-14-26-352-064 09-14-27-103-002 09-14-27-104-020 09-14-27-104-022 09-14-27-104-029 09-14-27-105-011 09-14-27-105-017 09-14-27-126-004 09-14-27-128-007 09-14-27-128-022 09-14-27-129-003 09-14-27-130-005 09-14-27-131-009 09-14-27-131-023 09-14-27-131-033 09-14-27-131-034 09-14-27-131-049 09-14-27-131-059 09-14-27-132-014 09-14-27-132-025 09-14-27-132-039 09-14-27-132-048 09-14-27-157-005 09-14-27-158-008 09-14-27-158-028 09-14-27-176-115 09-14-27-177-028 09-14-27-177-059 09-14-27-178-011 09-14-27-178-015 09-14-27-178-021 Sale Date 11/14/2014 6/19/2014 4/17/2015 5/27/2015 7/8/2014 8/12/2014 4/22/2015 8/20/2015 2/21/2014 10/16/2014 6/29/2015 8/4/2015 3/28/2014 6/11/2015 4/30/2015 2/11/2015 10/3/2014 7/18/2014 8/5/2015 5/15/2014 8/18/2015 6/12/2015 8/21/2015 12/29/2014 1/7/2015 5/1/2015 1/24/2014 10/31/2013 4/15/2015 8/22/2014 8/13/2015 9/1/2015 12/5/2014 5/18/2015 8/26/2015 7/8/2014 11/7/2014 6/4/2015 4/22/2014 12/10/2013 7/31/2014 Grantor SHIELD WILLIAM P KARP, RANDALL/OLGA THOMPSON BETTY J FRISBY BARBARA J TRUST LUCAS RUTH M TRUST PALAZZOLO, EDA J - TRUST PROUDFOOT, MARY E PEARCE, JOYCE L - TRUST CIOTTI NANCY THOMAS DAVIS REAL ESTATE CO-SHELBY SMIGELSKI, GERALD A/ LUANA M ZINSER DOROTHY T GORECKI, MICHAEL STANBURY, BRITTANY A VARKULA, JOSEPH/SHARON ASSET REHAB & MAINTENANCE LLC WHITE GREGORY STRABLE III, WILLIAM GERBER, JOHN FERGUSON, JR., JAY/LYNDA STEINMETZ, NICHOLAS GOVER, GLADYS M/ MARL, PATRICIA A VROMAN, DENNIS CONWELL, ROBIN/MICHAEL/SUSAN CHESHIRE HOMES LLC SCS REVERE, LLC NARDUZZI, MICHAEL CULOS ANGELINE TRUST PALOMBIT RUDOLPH J IRA ANNABEL, JASEN M. GM MILLER ENTERPRISES INC. BESHWA ENTERPRISES, LLC NAGRANT, ADRIAN MIDDEL, MARK SMITH, BRADLEY/LINDA BELL BRIAN RENGERS, VINCENT W - TRUST EMOND, JENNIFER VALLEE LILLIAN L SCHOTTHOEFER, SEAN/REGELBRUGGE, D. CALDWELL ELAINE Grantee JOSEPH CHARLOTTE TRUST GRADY KATHLEEN ANN CROOKS ALBERT B TRUST PHILLIPS SARA J STAVALE PAUL & LISA HOBEN JOHN D JR & SUSAN A RECK GORDON A & SUSAN E LENAHAN DANIEL & LAUREN HUIZENGA RONALD F & RUSSETTE ROBERT ROWLANDS MARIE ASKEW LAWRENCE D & SUE ELLEN HARROLD MIKE KINCADE THARA GARZA MICHAEL FRAHM RUSSELL M & ELIZABETH C ATTAR MOUHAMED LEONARD DELARA RACHEL KOTSONIS ANDREAS & GIANNAKAKI ASIMI KOPKE SCOTT KOPKE SCOTT A CONTRERAS CARLOS MANUEL GAMBOA & EL DELONG MEGAN ELLISON DAVID MATI MARY BETH R BOYD LISA M HAYES LAKITA JBH MANAGEMENT INC GRZANKA DAVID A PRZESLAWSKI DANIEL JR BENTON KATHLEEN BILLINGTON JESSICA ALFORD KATHERINE R COLLINS ERIK M & JAIME E LORIA LEO M THOMPSON LIONEL POMORSKI CYNTHIA ANN THOMPSON SANDRA SMART ROBERT E SKLUT JOSEPH S ANDREWS MICHAEL R BITAR BASSAM Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 404 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 199,000 175,000 210,000 200,000 145,000 179,450 200,000 200,000 180,000 179,000 250,000 55,000 149,900 110,000 166,500 122,470 116,000 58,000 12,800 150,000 105,500 52,000 79,900 73,000 48,000 117,900 50,000 84,500 108,000 87,000 80,000 98,000 101,000 93,750 215,000 96,500 110,000 70,000 40,000 104,000 87,500 SEV 67,300 70,200 83,300 83,000 70,200 67,600 83,300 77,700 66,600 67,300 77,300 36,100 61,000 40,000 80,000 41,700 34,000 21,500 5,400 50,400 32,000 19,300 32,700 25,000 19,000 52,000 28,000 32,400 33,800 31,900 25,400 39,700 41,900 35,200 97,400 39,600 41,900 36,900 29,600 39,800 36,800 Ratio 33.82 40.11 39.67 41.50 48.41 37.67 41.65 38.85 37.00 37.60 30.92 65.64 40.69 36.36 48.05 34.05 29.31 37.07 42.19 33.60 30.33 37.12 40.93 34.25 39.58 44.11 56.00 38.34 31.30 36.67 31.75 40.51 41.49 37.55 45.30 41.04 38.09 52.71 74.00 38.27 42.06 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-27-178-044 09-14-27-178-056 09-14-27-201-011 09-14-27-201-024 09-14-27-202-018 09-14-27-202-033 09-14-27-202-050 09-14-27-203-014 09-14-27-204-013 09-14-27-205-017 09-14-27-206-007 09-14-27-207-006 09-14-27-226-012 09-14-27-227-008 09-14-27-227-010 09-14-27-230-006 09-14-27-231-001 09-14-27-233-006 09-14-27-233-008 09-14-27-235-011 09-14-27-237-018 09-14-27-251-010 09-14-27-251-023 09-14-27-252-014 09-14-27-253-005 09-14-27-253-057 09-14-27-258-012 09-14-27-276-017 09-14-27-277-005 09-14-27-277-008 09-14-27-278-007 09-14-27-278-013 09-14-27-278-020 09-14-27-279-034 09-14-27-280-019 09-14-27-280-021 09-14-27-282-003 09-14-27-282-005 09-14-27-283-009 09-14-27-284-004 09-14-27-304-005 Sale Date 10/31/2013 11/26/2013 5/16/2014 2/21/2014 10/8/2013 8/21/2015 8/27/2015 3/13/2015 10/17/2013 4/14/2015 4/29/2014 6/24/2014 9/15/2014 2/25/2015 8/28/2014 8/7/2015 11/25/2014 4/3/2015 6/11/2014 5/30/2014 4/22/2015 10/28/2013 5/22/2014 4/17/2015 8/19/2015 4/14/2015 11/8/2013 12/9/2014 3/13/2015 1/16/2015 5/8/2015 11/14/2014 4/23/2015 4/8/2015 12/15/2014 7/25/2014 1/9/2014 3/28/2014 8/19/2014 6/30/2014 9/19/2014 Grantor JAAM INVESTMENTS INC HAMBRIGHT JR, GERRY/HAMBRIGHT SR, G SCAVO, CELESTE R. MARTINEK JOY DEMERS FRANCIS A & JANICE A TENDIGLIA, DONNA L/ JOSEPH P ELLISTON, KIMBERLY NIZOL, JERRY WIMSATT ROBERT J DDN ENTERPRISE INC POMINVILLE, KYLE AHEARN, GARY/DEE CLIFTON, BETTY L./DEWEY, SHEREE BENJAMIN PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LLC RODRIGUEZ, ALEXANDER SIKES, MARY PERRIN, JOHN MANIERE, GORDON/ WILLIAMS, LAUREN COX, PATRICIA TRAGLE, IV, JOE HERTEL, KEVIN MAJEWSKI EDITH MARCELLA KOPITZKE, JANE KUNNATH, MADISON AWE LOIS M GIANUARIO, JENNIFER N/ MABLE K CUSACK, WANDA F. KRUSZYNA, NICOLE/TIMOTHY DMP HOLDINGS LLC MOLINA, LISA M COLLIER, DONALD BUTLER, LEWIS DROUIN, JR., JOSEPH A. FRANKLIN, BRIAN J MARTIN, MICHAEL L/SUSAN J TATE, SHALENA M CARION, REMI TRUST CAMERON, DONALD L. HOULIHAN, ROBERT S/ RACHELLE A CERRITO, SHERYL L RUSSELL INVESTMENTS INC Grantee COMITO ANTHONY W & KIMBERLY M GRANGER BRETT DUPUIS ELEANOR HUDSON DAVID M LAUGHTON PATRICK & JESSICA STUNDA ROBERT M JR EDGAR THOMAS B BOERTMANN SEAN N & MARY R KELLY ANGEL T LAFRANCE MICHAEL & LAWLER SYDNEY SHAMROCK ACQUISITIONS LLC SYLVESTER DANIELLE YVONNE HOUSTON SARAH F NEWTON II, WILLIAM BRADDOCK FUNKE PATRICE L PANNECOUK DAVID SAARI MATTHEW & DIFALCO LORAINA KVETKO MARTIN R & LAURA L POISSON DAVID QUINN JAMES MOERMAN WILLIAM G & VICKIE CUSTER LEAH M ARNOLD CHERYL KOSZTOWNY LAURA IVANYE MATTHEW HASKINS DAVID M PHILLIPS DEANNA CHRISTOPHER PAIGE E BLUE MOON ACQUISITIONS LLC RUGULSKI REBECCA A ROGERS MICHAEL & HAY KIHMBERLY V THOMAS BRYAN MICHAEL ABAZI ARDIT LUTZ CHARLES LONG MATTHEW MCMILLAN HEATHER J FLORES ERIK S MARTIN RICKEY J SUBLETT RICHARD DODICH SCOTT A & GOTTS JAYME L GRAMER ROBERT M Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 57,500 136,000 84,000 80,000 165,000 75,000 90,000 94,000 56,900 59,700 45,000 84,900 108,000 72,000 105,000 200,000 170,000 226,000 144,500 144,000 56,000 51,000 43,500 75,000 108,000 115,000 100,000 80,000 27,000 63,500 56,450 102,000 109,000 56,000 124,900 103,500 155,000 255,000 255,000 199,395 150,000 SEV 38,300 55,300 32,300 29,500 46,700 26,200 54,400 24,800 32,300 28,800 35,200 36,300 35,600 47,800 39,600 89,300 68,700 94,000 67,700 63,700 36,400 19,500 20,000 26,900 38,800 37,800 41,500 17,800 21,400 23,500 28,300 32,300 43,800 33,400 83,300 63,600 57,900 90,900 98,500 74,400 72,200 Ratio 66.61 40.66 38.45 36.88 28.30 34.93 60.44 26.38 56.77 48.24 78.22 42.76 32.96 66.39 37.71 44.65 40.41 41.59 46.85 44.24 65.00 38.24 45.98 35.87 35.93 32.87 41.50 22.25 79.26 37.01 50.13 31.67 40.18 59.64 66.69 61.45 37.35 35.65 38.63 37.31 48.13 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-27-304-017 09-14-27-304-023 09-14-27-306-007 09-14-27-308-019 09-14-27-327-003 09-14-27-328-007 09-14-27-328-009 09-14-27-328-011 09-14-27-328-029 09-14-27-328-034 09-14-27-329-020 09-14-27-329-021 09-14-27-329-043 09-14-27-330-043 09-14-27-352-031 09-14-27-353-008 09-14-27-353-009 09-14-27-356-005 09-14-27-357-010 09-14-27-357-011 09-14-27-358-001 09-14-27-358-005 09-14-27-377-007 09-14-27-378-008 09-14-27-378-020 09-14-27-378-021 09-14-27-378-031 09-14-27-378-032 09-14-27-379-015 09-14-27-379-036 09-14-27-379-038 09-14-27-380-001 09-14-27-401-001 09-14-27-403-008 09-14-27-403-011 09-14-27-405-011 09-14-27-405-015 09-14-27-406-032 09-14-27-406-036 09-14-27-407-002 09-14-27-407-011 Sale Date 1/29/2015 4/24/2015 12/19/2013 8/25/2015 6/15/2015 4/6/2015 12/9/2014 3/25/2015 11/14/2014 12/6/2013 2/12/2015 8/21/2014 7/24/2014 10/11/2013 4/6/2015 1/10/2014 10/16/2014 5/13/2015 6/29/2015 3/17/2014 2/3/2014 1/29/2015 5/29/2015 5/7/2015 1/14/2015 7/27/2015 3/4/2015 1/20/2015 9/11/2015 11/7/2013 10/2/2014 4/18/2014 6/20/2014 4/9/2015 5/22/2015 1/2/2014 4/25/2014 4/29/2015 5/6/2015 8/31/2015 10/24/2014 Grantor BILLIU, ALEXANDREA SMARTT II, MICHAEL A LIFE AT HOME LLC BOMMARITO, CAROL ANN PALMER PARK PROPERTIES LLC LUCKENBACKER CHRISTOPHER A MESSINA, VINCENT SOLDEN, SARAH J. DYER JR, JOHN L./K.M. CLARK, PAMELA/ ROBERT M VAN GS INVESTMENTS LLC CARSWELL JR., KENNETH/RITA MARTIN, PHILIP BORGIA VITO BRADLEY, KIMBERLY/BARNES, MATTHEW PIETRZAK, KENNETH BLANKINSHIP LEAH NAYLOR, DENISE CHAPERON JR., PAUL DOVE, STEVEN FAST CASH FOR HOMES LLC MALONE AUSTIN TRUST BANTU MARY GJONAJ, JAMIE MCDONALD, WENDY N. MACCHI, THOMAS DANIELS, CHRISTOPHER CULBERTSON, DALE/POWELL, ALISIA DUPUIS, KELLY TRESIK, BARRY D LOLMAUGH, DONNA/WENDI MERIDIAN SERVICES LLC RESIDENTIAL RECONDITIONING LLC BELIVEAU PIERRE THOMPSON, JANET PASKE RONALD S MAURO, CHRISTOPHER/APRIL BARNES DAVID KANABY, WAYNE G. DELFIN, MICHAEL/PATRICIA FIVE STAR ASSET MANAGEMENT LLC Grantee HAYNES MICHAEL & KATHARINE DECHY PAUL SELLEY DARNELL JR MATUSKO RAYMOND R & DONNA L CRAFT TIMOTHY J II OLSEN ERIC & REBECCA BIONDO VITO G JOHNSON TIMOTHY B & STACIE M ADAMS KIMBERLY LYNN SMITH RICHARD L BARRERA MARK MEIER ERIC A & ZIELKE BROOKE A CHAMPION NICHOLE & SHELLEY A 22008 RIDGEWAY LLC SOBANSKI BENJAMIN E & NICOLE L VANNUCK DANIEL JR DELLA TORRE ALEJANDRO VELASQUEZ DANETTE MG1 PROPERTIES LLC KNAPP GAYLE ZENSEN JAMES R SCHEBIL LEIGH ANN BROOKS RYAN NARDELLI HUNTER EGGERT ERICH & SHANAVER EGGERT NIKO KOSTOPOULOS ALEXANDER ARETE MCLAUGHLIN LAUREN BINKOWSKI THEODORE III SEFERAJ EDA RILEY NATALIE ISAAC DANTE & REINERT NICOLE L RACICOT RICHARD BURTON ROBERT & KENNY ALLYSON BECCA05 LLC EVANS TIMOTHY P WALKER JOHN V RINALDI CHRISTINE E AHLES BROOKE KINSORA WILLIAM SMITS EDWARD SHANNON WILLIAM J Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 129,000 109,000 113,000 76,500 110,000 144,000 80,000 130,000 116,500 90,000 93,000 86,000 80,000 53,000 108,500 128,000 61,300 77,000 77,000 67,500 91,000 67,572 80,000 79,000 59,000 47,000 31,000 40,000 92,000 52,000 96,000 44,400 132,500 72,900 80,000 165,000 120,000 107,900 69,000 82,000 86,500 SEV 50,500 46,800 32,900 32,200 46,500 36,500 31,700 42,400 43,300 39,900 39,000 35,400 21,800 25,100 48,000 56,600 37,200 33,500 42,900 17,700 35,100 33,100 26,400 34,700 23,500 32,900 17,200 20,900 48,500 23,200 32,000 37,900 39,200 27,100 42,000 63,800 30,000 41,200 35,100 32,500 31,700 Ratio 39.15 42.94 29.12 42.09 42.27 25.35 39.63 32.62 37.17 44.33 41.94 41.16 27.25 47.36 44.24 44.22 60.69 43.51 55.71 26.22 38.57 48.98 33.00 43.92 39.83 70.00 55.48 52.25 52.72 44.62 33.33 85.36 29.58 37.17 52.50 38.67 25.00 38.18 50.87 39.63 36.65 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-27-407-022 09-14-27-407-022 09-14-27-407-025 09-14-27-407-031 09-14-27-408-003 09-14-27-408-005 09-14-27-408-020 09-14-27-408-033 09-14-27-427-016 09-14-27-428-018 09-14-27-429-001 09-14-27-429-014 09-14-27-429-018 09-14-27-452-012 09-14-27-452-020 09-14-27-452-020 09-14-27-452-028 09-14-27-452-035 09-14-27-453-017 09-14-27-453-023 09-14-27-453-024 09-14-27-453-038 09-14-27-453-043 09-14-27-455-038 09-14-27-455-058 09-14-27-456-008 09-14-27-456-016 09-14-27-476-008 09-14-27-476-011 09-14-27-476-015 09-14-27-477-011 09-14-27-478-027 09-14-27-480-017 09-14-28-203-014 09-14-28-204-001 09-14-28-204-014 09-14-28-204-018 09-14-28-204-018 09-14-28-205-008 09-14-28-205-009 09-14-28-206-002 Sale Date 6/13/2014 5/4/2015 8/4/2015 10/28/2014 7/22/2015 8/17/2015 7/29/2015 10/3/2013 9/15/2014 5/1/2015 11/25/2014 1/27/2015 3/20/2015 5/27/2014 10/27/2014 8/21/2015 9/5/2014 8/14/2015 5/22/2015 6/19/2015 8/7/2015 4/3/2015 2/12/2014 8/7/2015 5/4/2015 9/15/2014 10/23/2013 6/12/2015 9/5/2015 5/14/2014 10/2/2014 8/21/2015 5/29/2015 7/16/2014 1/23/2014 7/24/2014 3/19/2015 8/13/2015 6/13/2014 7/17/2015 12/18/2013 Grantor CREEKBAUM, VICTOR BARRY, TARRAH PARDY, SAMANTHA LADUKE RANDALL J THOMAS, JAMES A. MAHAR, MICHAEL WHITFORD, JOY M. LITTLE TARA D BARNES, FRANK J. ALEXANDER, ALEX/MC ELMEEL, KELLY SCHEMANSKY TINA LYNNE WHITTLE PATRICIA ANN JBH MANAGEMENT INC. MCLELLAN, KEVIN R FAST CASH FOR HOMES LLC EASTPOINTE CAPITAL II LLC GOSS, GARY MARIE FORSTER, CHERI FABIAN, MERISSA E KONKEL, BRYAN J/ LAURA NIELSEN, LAURA MULHOLLAND, TINA M MARINO, JOSEPHINE/SINACOLA, MICHAEL WOODCRAFT, N.J./CHERNENKO, D. CUI, YAN ZHEN RUDALEV LLC TRAUX MATTHEW HARKENRIDER, GLENN BROPHY ALAN & KRISTEN HULET RHONDA TUCKER, DOLORES J. SAJEWSKI, JON PECK, JOSEPH D JACKSON, JASON W. 20000 VALERA LLC BASELINE FINANCIAL LLC RICKERMAN, DOLORES J. OLIPHANT MATTHEW COOK, LYNDSIE LUCIDO, ANTHONY HART, MATTHEW JOHN Grantee BARRY TARRAH A NEECE ANDREW SMITH NICOLE OMALLEY MARY ROULO PAUL DEMBEK WILLIAM DUNAWAY MORGAN BURGESS JON & PAPUGA JENNIFER EDGERLY DARLA L THORP DANIEL & PASZEK SHELBY DELEEUW ALAN MORRIS ELIZABETH A BARILKA MARY CHAFFIN JEREMY EASTPOINTE CAPITAL II LLC GORE STEVEN RUTKOSKE STEPHANIE LYNN GRAMMATICO MICHAEL M COOK STEVEN & KATHERINE ROESNER ADAM KOSTUKOFF VICTOR BREIGHT RYAN PFEIFFER RANDY D CAIN JUSTIN WELL HOMES MI LLC KAMINSKI DOUGLAS K SCHIEBEL CHRISTOPHER COUNTRY CLUB OF CLINTON TOWNSHIP LL BERES JENNIFER MARIE SHAUGHNESSY SUSAN K COUNTRY CLUB CONDOS LLC CARPENTER THOMAS R & JULIE K TURCOTTE KYLE & CARLSON NICOLE BASHI SAMAR PALMER JULIE A DOYLE KYLE W OLIPHANT MATTHEW MERCER ASHLEE HARMAN STEVEN & BUTKOVICH JAMIE MODZELEWSKI JOSEPH REGULSKI ROBERT M Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 67,000 81,000 89,900 118,000 107,375 95,000 103,000 161,200 125,000 99,000 40,000 110,000 83,500 124,000 62,000 94,000 94,000 78,000 115,000 100,000 83,000 78,000 96,500 80,000 45,300 69,000 83,200 15,000 60,100 52,380 9,500 86,500 110,000 89,000 84,900 121,500 83,500 126,000 112,000 115,000 85,000 SEV 33,000 30,700 34,500 28,800 50,700 42,500 42,500 68,300 45,800 34,200 26,400 31,100 37,900 52,600 44,600 49,000 22,900 33,300 34,500 45,000 31,300 28,000 36,000 39,400 22,500 43,600 27,100 6,600 37,700 20,400 6,700 36,000 42,800 37,000 37,300 42,500 50,400 57,500 41,700 46,800 35,300 Ratio 49.25 37.90 38.38 24.41 47.22 44.74 41.26 42.37 36.64 34.55 66.00 28.27 45.39 42.42 71.94 52.13 24.36 42.69 30.00 45.00 37.71 35.90 37.31 49.25 49.67 63.19 32.57 44.00 62.73 38.95 70.53 41.62 38.91 41.57 43.93 34.98 60.36 45.63 37.23 40.70 41.53 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-28-206-007 09-14-28-206-028 09-14-28-206-029 09-14-28-206-031 09-14-28-207-008 09-14-28-207-020 09-14-28-207-051 09-14-28-226-008 09-14-28-226-026 09-14-28-226-026 09-14-28-227-036 09-14-28-228-009 09-14-28-252-029 09-14-28-253-004 09-14-28-253-021 09-14-28-253-027 09-14-28-253-030 09-14-28-254-017 09-14-28-254-039 09-14-28-255-016 09-14-28-256-008 09-14-28-256-010 09-14-28-257-020 09-14-28-276-010 09-14-28-276-023 09-14-28-276-029 09-14-28-277-008 09-14-28-277-011 09-14-28-277-035 09-14-28-278-010 09-14-28-278-052 09-14-28-427-015 09-14-28-427-022 09-14-28-427-029 09-14-28-428-013 09-14-28-429-003 09-14-28-429-006 09-14-28-478-004 09-14-28-479-008 09-14-28-480-002 09-14-28-480-006 Sale Date 5/20/2015 6/1/2015 12/15/2014 11/7/2014 6/3/2015 7/31/2015 2/6/2014 8/27/2015 7/14/2014 12/12/2014 4/15/2014 10/31/2013 8/27/2015 10/11/2013 5/26/2015 11/27/2013 7/30/2014 5/27/2014 6/4/2014 5/5/2015 4/14/2014 6/2/2015 10/21/2014 12/20/2013 5/7/2015 10/2/2013 3/3/2015 6/12/2015 8/15/2014 7/30/2015 12/27/2013 9/19/2014 7/22/2015 10/6/2014 5/29/2015 7/14/2014 10/25/2013 4/16/2015 7/23/2014 6/16/2014 1/15/2014 Grantor MAXWELL, DAVID C. COLLINS-SCHRAM, KELLY CHOCIEMSKI, DANIEL W LOVING, SHAWN/JUANITA KOHN, ROBERT TESCHKE, JUERGEN/ MARGUERITE ELLIS JAMES D BONDRA, JONATHAN RADTKE, DAVID E. TRI COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS & M TROMBLEY, ERIC MCLELLAN KEVIN ELAM, DANA SEMRAU FUNDING LLC REYNOLDS, CHRISTOPHER D/ TERYN RENE RUDDER, ANDREW SPARKS, THERESE E NOGGLE, JEAN/ROBERT PALM SPRINGS LOAN SERVICING LLC MIJATOVICH, PAULINA - TRUST SCHNEIDER, KEVIN/JESSICA SOLEY, JEAN/ PAUL VITRANO, PAUL/H. MARIE DUNLOP, MARGARET/ WILLIAM - TRUST MARSHMAN, GRAYDON/BETTY - TRUST RICKERT LORAINE & PRIEBE DIANE RITTS, R.P./JAKUBIK, J.J. LICAVOLI PHILLIP ISSA, MOUNIBA SLOCUM LAWRENCE H CHIPMAN MICHAEL MOUNTAIN PRIME LLC MANGONE, FIORAVANTE/PAULINE KRAKUS, DONALD DELLAPA, WILLIAM - TRUST LYTLE, THOMAS P ZENO HOLDINGS LLC LOUZON, CHRISTINA LYNN/ JAMES E LABREE HOMES LLC BOLAN, ADAM/SANDRA SCHOLL LOUIS H & SARA Grantee CUMMINGS WENDI WALKER NAT S TILL JOHNATHAN & VANDERZIEL NICOLE DELLEVA JOSEPH M & REBECCA T BITONTI MARK & ZASUCHA MARK LOPEZ DEREK YOUNG KELLY M & AMY C RING AMY TRI COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS & M ORTMANN VINCENT SHARON JONATHAN & POCHMARA DANIELLE HALAS JOSHUA J DIEHL TREVOR PUPA MARGARET W BEDARD MELISSA BUNGALOW PROPERTIES LLC DICKERSON HOULLIES GRYPHON COURY CHRISTOPHER & TUCKER RITA KRYNSKI PAUL TRI COUNTY REALESTATE HOLDINGS & MA SRBINOVICH ROBERT P JR BOJALAD MICHAEL AIELLO ANDREW J MANDLEY MONIQUE TAGGART ASHLEY N POISSON CLAIRE R CLAYTON LATONYA BATSON ANN MARIE BAKER GERALD & JULIANNA BELLESTRI MITCHELL A KANANI MATILDA & SHKELQIM LEEMHUIS RICHARD D JR NELSON SHERRIE ELIZABETH STOKES SEAN & CIAMBELLA DONNA URTEL FAMILY TRUST & URTEL CLAIRE MASAID PAUL & LAUREL MAGGIO ANTHONY PARUCH CHRISTOPHER & VARNAS JESSICA BYRD PAUL BASHI SAMAR MONRO COREY J Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 119,000 97,000 86,000 95,000 85,000 104,000 168,500 118,000 87,000 128,000 119,900 116,000 93,000 90,000 99,900 81,000 116,150 92,000 125,000 92,500 110,000 75,000 114,000 102,000 106,000 115,000 124,500 115,000 107,000 80,100 85,000 27,500 110,000 117,000 127,000 120,000 119,000 125,000 107,000 84,000 88,000 SEV 40,500 44,900 39,600 41,200 46,800 44,100 41,200 48,100 43,500 43,500 42,700 44,200 39,700 38,000 36,700 37,100 39,600 40,700 44,800 44,800 42,400 46,700 43,300 46,100 45,100 40,700 41,800 46,900 40,500 38,600 48,200 16,600 62,700 48,900 76,900 43,500 37,600 53,500 41,100 44,600 37,800 Ratio 34.03 46.29 46.05 43.37 55.06 42.40 24.45 40.76 50.00 33.98 35.61 38.10 42.69 42.22 36.74 45.80 34.09 44.24 35.84 48.43 38.55 62.27 37.98 45.20 42.55 35.39 33.57 40.78 37.85 48.19 56.71 60.36 57.00 41.79 60.55 36.25 31.60 42.80 38.41 53.10 42.95 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-28-480-010 09-14-28-480-015 09-14-28-480-020 09-14-28-480-022 09-14-28-480-023 09-14-28-481-006 09-14-28-481-008 09-14-28-481-010 09-14-28-482-002 09-14-28-485-003 09-14-28-485-007 09-14-28-485-017 09-14-28-486-011 09-14-32-478-004 09-14-32-478-008 09-14-32-478-009 09-14-32-480-005 09-14-32-480-009 09-14-32-480-011 09-14-32-480-013 09-14-33-127-002 09-14-33-127-018 09-14-33-130-004 09-14-33-133-004 09-14-33-133-014 09-14-33-133-016 09-14-33-158-004 09-14-33-159-015 09-14-33-160-011 09-14-33-160-013 09-14-33-160-014 09-14-33-160-014 09-14-33-161-005 09-14-33-176-009 09-14-33-177-015 09-14-33-177-024 09-14-33-177-027 09-14-33-177-028 09-14-33-178-002 09-14-33-178-003 09-14-33-178-013 Sale Date 8/29/2014 3/23/2015 8/18/2014 11/13/2013 11/18/2014 2/5/2015 7/24/2015 7/31/2015 6/27/2014 8/14/2015 8/26/2014 6/24/2014 10/1/2014 6/13/2014 2/9/2015 5/5/2014 4/16/2015 6/12/2014 7/2/2014 2/18/2014 3/19/2015 6/17/2014 9/18/2015 3/20/2015 5/8/2015 7/27/2015 10/30/2014 7/15/2015 6/17/2015 8/14/2015 12/4/2014 9/2/2015 1/30/2015 8/28/2014 7/31/2015 7/17/2014 8/11/2014 10/11/2013 6/25/2014 11/25/2014 1/8/2014 Grantor BDC SERVICES LLC SARRIS, MIKE/ELENA HAMILTON, SEAN D PAYTON DEBORAH K GORNICK, DENISE WINTERS, PATRICK/BETH WELLING, CHRISTOPHER MARYNIAK, JUSTIN TUX CAPITAL LLC JONES TRUST MUSSER, GARY/PATRICIA FREI, HARVEY C.; ET AL. DEWITTE, MICHAEL ELLIS, THOMAS DALLAS EDWARD NANNEY, MARY C. O'NEAL, MARTHA ELAINE DUNLAP, ROCKLIN C/ OTTO, MARY M TAGLIAVIA, ANTIONETTE; ET AL. DANKO JAMES D FEKIN GREGORY J DEWANDELER JAMES CASTLE, NICHOLAS/CATHERINE DEVROY JEWELL G TRUST BALON, TERRANCE L. VANPETEGHEM, LAUREN M/ MAURICE L STARNES, JAMES/ JENNIFER BRYANT, LEE MICHAEL FALVEY, ANDREW/G. GALLAGHER, TONIA M CAPITAL INCOME & GROWTH FUND LLC KRUEGER, THOMAS J - TRUST NUCCI, RUDY TRIMBLE, LINDA/MARABEAS, JOHN SKORUPSKI, CAMILLE - TRUST FARHOOD, CHRISTOPHER/STORM, SARAH PURULESKI, EVAN PETKOF ASIMINA COSNOWSKI, R./PREVOST, A. THORNTON, ROLLAND/DIANE BYCRAFT, MARK L. Grantee DUNN JACOB & POOLE BRIANNA HOWARTH SCOTT A WILSON DANDRE R KETELHUT ROBERT A ROGERS KATHERINE D GOODMAN GLENN BIEHL JEFFREY & NICOLE SNIEZYK ANTHONY II & VALLONI KAITLY SCHEUHER KELBY WENG ZHOU BIN TESCHKE JOSEPH POMERLEAU LINCOLN & MICHELLE GREEN RICHARD & LYNN CAROL M FILES ROSA SIMMONS HERBERT L II GC PLATINUM USA LLC NORTLEY MARK MCBE HOLDINGS LLC SHILBAYEH YASSMINE MARLIN CHARLES & LAURA ALESSI HEATHER WARREN RYAN NALBAND ROBERT LENNING KURTIS W ALEXANDER RONALD M & RITA FICI EDWARD JR & KIRSCHNER KRYSTAL JANINE SHURAFA PROPERTIES LLC BONANNI ANTHONY & MELISSA CASSELL ROBERT T & PATRICIA NUDI ALYSSA KRUEGER THOMAS J TRUST CLANCY SHANE & TECENO CHELSEA BURGESS DARREN & ALPHIA BUNGALOW PROPERTIES LLC KENNEDY MICHAEL J FELTY MELISSA BALINT SHELLEY JARVIS WILLIAM F MACHEMER WILLIAM LAGE VERONICA STANLEY JAMES R & IRVIN STANLEY JEA Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 85,000 74,000 121,000 50,000 90,000 112,900 109,000 109,500 61,000 142,000 168,000 130,000 165,000 61,500 70,000 80,000 23,000 22,500 22,300 25,000 128,000 93,000 132,500 60,000 102,000 132,500 64,000 73,000 92,000 112,000 60,000 119,900 86,600 80,000 115,000 94,900 100,000 96,000 104,900 125,600 62,000 SEV 36,600 42,800 41,700 21,300 25,400 38,800 42,000 43,800 24,600 81,700 63,900 63,600 77,500 34,800 32,200 32,900 11,800 9,200 9,000 9,700 52,800 46,400 47,500 32,500 40,600 45,600 28,900 34,500 37,700 39,600 36,000 40,000 36,400 35,900 47,600 34,400 36,900 37,200 35,600 45,600 40,300 Ratio 43.06 57.84 34.46 42.60 28.22 34.37 38.53 40.00 40.33 57.54 38.04 48.92 46.97 56.59 46.00 41.13 51.30 40.89 40.36 38.80 41.25 49.89 35.85 54.17 39.80 34.42 45.16 47.26 40.98 35.36 60.00 33.36 42.03 44.88 41.39 36.25 36.90 38.75 33.94 36.31 65.00 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-33-179-001 09-14-33-179-005 09-14-33-179-019 09-14-33-179-027 09-14-33-180-005 09-14-33-180-013 09-14-33-180-017 09-14-33-180-024 09-14-33-180-027 09-14-33-180-039 09-14-33-183-007 09-14-33-183-007 09-14-33-184-010 09-14-33-184-011 09-14-33-185-010 09-14-33-185-011 09-14-33-186-005 09-14-33-201-010 09-14-33-201-013 09-14-33-203-019 09-14-33-203-019 09-14-33-203-027 09-14-33-204-022 09-14-33-226-017 09-14-33-226-034 09-14-33-226-046 09-14-33-230-007 09-14-33-230-008 09-14-33-231-013 09-14-33-231-021 09-14-33-232-009 09-14-33-233-025 09-14-33-233-049 09-14-33-251-011 09-14-33-251-017 09-14-33-252-002 09-14-33-252-012 09-14-33-252-022 09-14-33-253-005 09-14-33-253-010 09-14-33-253-011 Sale Date 5/28/2014 5/15/2014 5/9/2014 1/14/2014 7/31/2015 10/18/2013 3/23/2015 1/9/2015 10/3/2014 12/8/2014 12/16/2014 5/11/2015 10/16/2014 11/20/2013 12/3/2013 10/6/2014 8/22/2015 6/15/2015 3/28/2014 11/7/2014 4/10/2015 3/25/2015 1/7/2015 1/26/2015 4/22/2014 3/28/2014 8/31/2015 1/19/2015 8/15/2014 8/6/2015 3/20/2015 5/29/2015 10/25/2013 6/13/2014 10/15/2013 9/14/2015 1/23/2015 12/3/2014 6/23/2014 12/29/2014 9/9/2015 Grantor VIZACHERO, DOMINIC/ MARK KUFFER, KATHLEEN A JOSWIAK, GERALD J./J.A. JOHN GRAHAM INC ALLIANZ A.G. TURNER DAVID & GERALYN HILL, SHANNON M MCCAY, KAREN BLAIR, SHARON/ DIETRICH, GREGORY C BARNES, MARC D. SCHULTZ SUSAN R SASTO CORPORATION INC GARZA, DENISE GRUSE, ROSANNE DENYS, ELEANOR M/ JOSEPH H - TRUST KMIOTEK, JOHN/C. MERSON, EDWARD/AMY BOSCHIAN JAMES ZEDDE, BRITTANY LAGA, PRICILLA J. SASTO CORPORATION INC TBM HOMES LLC LUDWIG, ARNHOLD GUIGNEAUX, SCOTT T PERKINS, LARRY A VANBECELAERE, GEORGE/A. CHRISTE, DAVID W. WANDOR, THADDEUS/DAVID WILKINS, ALAN/JOYCE OWCZAREK, DANIEL BISHOP, PAUL MIERENDORF DONALD/ GERARDA -TRUST LATONA FRANK J YOUNGBLOOD, GERALD HO JADY DOUD, LYNELLE C. ALLIANZ A G MAUL DANA R CAPUANO, NICOLE RADOMSKI, HELEN SINARIS, THEANO/MORRIN, A. ANN Grantee AHEARN JAMES & TAMARA ANDARY STEVEN M HOLMGREN CHAD & SARAH ROCK IT HOMES LLC BCGD LLC SLOGEN PROPERTIES LLC WILSON ROBERT MCCULLEY MATTHEW & HOFER SHELBY ALFIERI MICHAEL G FULGENZI ROBERT E & AIELLO JUSTINA SASTO CORPORATION INC NOWAK REMIGIUSZ WARD SAM E ECHOLS BOBBY R II WAY DARREN J & AMY E PROULX JOSEPH A II & CAROL PARR LINUS E MOCERI MATHEW HART KYLE SASTO CORPORATION INC GARSTKA KRISTIN E HOULE JEREMY & STRZELECKI KIMBERLY SWINNEY KEVIN L & ASHENHURST SARA L KNIGHT LEWIS J III & CASSIE A WATSON TEREHIA DENNISON ROBERT & LEE CYNTHIA KULIGOWSKI MICHAEL R HAMMES DEANNA HANDRAN ELIZABETH A JEROME KEVIN KOONTZ CALEB KENZIE MATTHEW & MARILYN BALINT DAVID THEOBALD HEATHER GRUNEWALD COREY TOMCZAK DENNIS III ROBERTS JEFFREY KIESGEN GREGORY L MCARTHUR ADAM GREEN GINVERA L GREEN KENNETH Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 704 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 87,599 105,500 85,000 70,500 65,000 62,000 103,500 102,000 74,000 106,000 78,000 122,000 111,000 67,000 71,000 74,800 75,000 113,000 103,000 70,000 125,000 110,000 119,525 94,900 116,000 140,000 90,000 126,000 94,000 117,000 82,000 29,000 22,500 106,000 81,000 101,000 85,000 78,000 126,000 84,000 50,000 SEV 37,200 36,000 29,500 29,000 33,300 32,700 32,900 32,500 32,100 41,300 34,900 38,900 33,000 27,900 35,200 36,600 35,500 35,800 34,100 39,400 44,000 35,700 58,600 35,400 36,100 82,700 47,500 50,700 42,200 44,900 32,300 10,100 7,000 33,100 32,600 38,000 35,600 38,200 41,500 34,800 38,400 Ratio 42.47 34.12 34.71 41.13 51.23 52.74 31.79 31.86 43.38 38.96 44.74 31.89 29.73 41.64 49.58 48.93 47.33 31.68 33.11 56.29 35.20 32.45 49.03 37.30 31.12 59.07 52.78 40.24 44.89 38.38 39.39 34.83 31.11 31.23 40.25 37.62 41.88 48.97 32.94 41.43 76.80 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-33-254-012 09-14-33-254-014 09-14-33-254-014 09-14-33-254-019 09-14-33-254-022 09-14-33-255-022 09-14-33-257-018 09-14-33-259-007 09-14-33-259-038 09-14-33-276-014 09-14-33-277-022 09-14-33-277-034 09-14-33-277-053 09-14-33-278-016 09-14-33-278-016 09-14-33-279-033 09-14-33-279-040 09-14-33-279-041 09-14-33-279-051 09-14-33-302-003 09-14-33-302-015 09-14-33-302-025 09-14-33-307-008 09-14-33-308-006 09-14-33-327-003 09-14-33-328-002 09-14-33-328-016 09-14-33-328-017 09-14-33-328-025 09-14-33-329-006 09-14-33-329-028 09-14-33-329-034 09-14-33-330-011 09-14-33-331-003 09-14-33-331-010 09-14-33-331-013 09-14-33-332-006 09-14-33-332-007 09-14-33-332-017 09-14-33-333-002 09-14-33-333-005 Sale Date 12/13/2013 8/22/2014 12/22/2014 3/27/2015 7/21/2014 4/30/2014 10/7/2013 10/23/2013 3/30/2015 11/19/2013 9/8/2015 9/9/2015 8/21/2015 1/27/2014 7/21/2014 10/9/2013 11/10/2014 7/24/2015 5/7/2014 11/18/2013 11/7/2014 11/21/2014 11/20/2013 12/1/2014 7/1/2015 9/2/2014 7/17/2015 2/20/2015 7/3/2014 6/18/2015 10/2/2013 5/15/2015 3/31/2015 10/30/2013 7/28/2015 1/15/2015 1/16/2014 6/23/2015 11/21/2014 9/4/2015 7/23/2014 Grantor ROBERTS, LAURA M. TAYLOR STUART P STABLE HOLDINGS INC RUSSELL, KATHRYN BALL HOLDINGS LLC CMC INVESTMENT LLC WARROW SHAWN D & CHRISTINE HARDY DAVID M & CAROLYN J KONWINSKI, MARK PAGE, MARGARET L. KRUCZYNSKI, JOHN A LITTLE MARIA C ZEISLER, ALICIA PRETTY MICHIGAN HOMES LLC MILLER GEORGE NEMZEK STEPHEN C & KELLY A PICKET FENCE PROPERTIES LLC BMH INVESTMENTS LLC KEARNS, JANET/ RODERICK W - TRUST ROMANO, BEVERLY SHEPPARD ALEXANDER R MURPHY, WILLIAM - TRUST SPARTAN EQUITIES HIGH YIELD BANK OF AMERICA RYMAS ROBERT CLARK, MICHAEL/TERRI VIVIANO MORELL, JOHN HOSTE JOSEPH A JOHNSON, ANDREW J./K. WESLEY, JANET A. -TRUST BIANCHI NICHOLAS C & JODAR LORETTA GERSTNER, JOANNE CAROL COLDICOTT, DAVID KADRICH ROSEMARY LIVINGSTON, JAY B. - TRUSTEE MCLELLAN KEVIN KOCOT, CHRISTINA/LEWICKI, WIESLAWA MITTER, MEGAN E/RYAN W WEBER, MARK J./LORI G. WOODWARD PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LLC MOUSSEAU, PHILIP J. Grantee TUCKER JENNA L STABLE HOLDINGS INC HAMOLLI ARTAN WEISS LYNN MACOMB FUNDING LLC BOBINEY NICOLE MCCORMICK DANIEL FOLEY CHRISTOPHER R FIELDS PATRICIA A 22501 HARPER LLC BOSSACK JORDAN ALAN CIARAMITARO CARLO SIMONETTI EMILY M LABREE HOMES LLC HAKES DAWN NORBERG YVONNE M ORIHUELA VALERIE MARIE PORTER CHARLES D & ALLISON M CULVER WILFRED T III GIPSON PATRICK B SONNTAG PROPERTIES LLC SUNDAY ENTERPRISE INC KYLE BREANA HAZELTON RICHARD SR & CORENE L MG1 PROPERTIES LLC SIKORA KIMBERLY R BAUCH KEVIN PICCIRILLI MELISSA DOUGLAS JAMEL MAYEA JARED M ROFOO NAHLA EDWIN NICHOLAS & RACHEL SKURDA JENNIFER J SLOGEN PROPERTIES GAMBLE J W MCDOWELL RYAN & STEPHANIE MILNER MIA PALMER QUADELL RUSSO SAMUEL LITTLE SHAWN EDWARDS ANGELA Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD LC WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 63,000 27,500 45,700 69,000 41,999 83,000 119,900 75,000 94,900 80,000 81,500 36,000 106,700 30,000 55,625 74,900 89,000 83,000 85,000 19,900 11,000 10,000 108,000 71,900 82,500 134,000 145,100 122,000 143,000 120,000 75,000 137,000 96,000 53,500 123,000 115,000 80,000 119,900 115,000 65,000 64,500 SEV 31,000 18,500 18,500 34,800 33,500 34,600 34,600 40,300 33,400 28,900 25,200 21,800 44,400 21,700 21,900 31,700 30,500 32,800 29,900 5,300 6,400 6,200 44,600 32,000 40,500 45,100 52,400 45,800 43,500 50,500 42,900 51,800 39,700 24,200 42,900 33,400 37,000 41,000 48,400 41,100 35,200 Ratio 49.21 67.27 40.48 50.43 79.76 41.69 28.86 53.73 35.19 36.13 30.92 60.56 41.61 72.33 39.37 42.32 34.27 39.52 35.18 26.63 58.18 62.00 41.30 44.51 49.09 33.66 36.11 37.54 30.42 42.08 57.20 37.81 41.35 45.23 34.88 29.04 46.25 34.20 42.09 63.23 54.57 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-33-333-010 09-14-33-333-012 09-14-33-333-030 09-14-33-334-004 09-14-33-335-008 09-14-33-335-018 09-14-33-335-032 09-14-33-351-021 09-14-33-351-041 09-14-33-351-045 09-14-33-352-019 09-14-33-353-033 09-14-33-353-034 09-14-33-353-040 09-14-33-353-043 09-14-33-355-008 09-14-33-355-011 09-14-33-355-012 09-14-33-355-026 09-14-33-358-005 09-14-33-358-013 09-14-33-359-011 09-14-33-359-014 09-14-33-359-030 09-14-33-359-036 09-14-33-360-006 09-14-33-360-011 09-14-33-360-015 09-14-33-360-016 09-14-33-361-001 09-14-33-361-018 09-14-33-361-023 09-14-33-361-043 09-14-33-361-055 09-14-33-361-079 09-14-33-361-084 09-14-33-376-001 09-14-33-376-005 09-14-33-376-020 09-14-33-377-006 09-14-33-377-007 Sale Date 12/4/2014 8/7/2015 10/21/2013 7/28/2015 11/7/2014 3/19/2015 9/16/2014 3/21/2014 6/22/2015 7/8/2014 12/5/2013 1/16/2015 3/5/2014 4/21/2014 10/30/2014 5/4/2015 6/19/2014 6/29/2015 6/2/2015 6/11/2015 5/5/2015 5/29/2015 2/14/2014 11/14/2014 6/17/2014 11/7/2014 11/1/2013 12/6/2013 4/29/2014 10/24/2014 4/15/2014 10/29/2014 9/3/2014 7/2/2015 11/20/2014 12/23/2013 12/30/2013 8/29/2014 12/13/2013 10/4/2013 7/31/2014 Grantor GOLSON, ANGELA/PERRY SHAHEEN DENISE R KENNEY KANDICE C ALFONSI, CAROLYN/ MICHAEL WILLIAMS, CHARLES T WILLIAMS CHRISTINE ROBERGE, RICHARD L. TOMB, BERTHA - TRUST KOVACH, STEPHEN M JACKSON-MARBURY, BRENDA CASPER, CAROL J. O'CONNOR, BRANDON WILLIAM SMOLINSKI HOLLAND ERIKA K VANDENBROECK RUDY BEARD LOIS JANE TRUST ELLIS, THOMAS MICHAEL PLANT PATRICK A BURNETTE COURTNEY TRUST SDTMM LLC HORMIZ, ANDRE LIKENS, DENNIS/CELIA VANGIESON, JEREMY/ALLISON HENDRIE MICHAEL & SYLVESTER CURTIS THOMAS, RODERICK/LETISHA ORTLEIB, DALE A./MARIE A. NATIONS HOME LOAN CORP BEACHWOOD HOMES LLC OBRIEN, LAWRENCE/FRANCES MISNER, COLIN/DUONG, JACKY DE LODDER, GLENN/ THURSTON, CORALIE THE SALVATION ARMY NESS ARTHUR HALF THAT LLC KNS CAPITAL LLC REINUS INVESTMENT GROUP LLC KAJA HOLDINGS LLC HYSO, STELLA MARY - TRUST MAHER, MICHAEL W. LIGHTLE, S. MCNEIL ROBIN SALAMI, SULE Grantee DWORZECKI ROMAN S LAW MAURICE & NICKELETTE MARINEAU CHARLES A & OSINSKI KARYN PONTELLO TERESA L HADID TARIK MCCLELLAN ELVIN R BATTLE JASON GRANT HELTEN D & HELEN R SCOFIELD BARRY TAYLOR EUTRILLA DANGELO STEFANIE A ANDREWS KATHERINE SMOLINSKI DONETTA MCNALLY SARAH E LAFATA MARY BUCK RUTA ROSHA LIVINGSTON KENNETH & CATHERINE KNOX KEENANN & DANIELLE OLDHAM DEVONTE WEST STANLEY & HOGAINS SHAMEKA MILTON DARNELL MCKAYE CHARLES HOWARD DAVID GORDON LAVITA COSTANTINO JOSEPH & ANNALISE DAVIS JAMES JR RAMBUS BRANDON K & DOMINIQUE L PIPER SHAWNA L KEENEY JOHN & YVETTE BUTTIGLIERI MICHAEL J TRUST KENT QUADIRU W KENNEDY SHERMANE RELICH NICHOLAS C & WENDY K UPSHAW JAQUES ELFAYOUMI AHMED CARLIN ISRAEL & SIMMONS TAVIS CARLI LAWRENCE ARTHUR & BARBARA STUDIER RENAE ARTMAN DON MITCHELL JAMIKA HOWARD BRIAN JERON & HEATHER Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 86,900 116,000 93,000 135,000 150,000 145,000 106,500 60,000 45,000 53,800 50,000 51,750 44,000 55,000 53,000 70,000 38,150 138,000 80,000 125,000 128,900 110,000 110,000 77,000 109,000 125,000 115,500 100,000 117,000 21,000 22,000 25,000 20,419 27,000 16,000 15,500 68,000 124,900 69,500 100,000 142,000 SEV 39,800 59,100 47,600 66,700 69,900 65,500 38,900 26,300 19,600 23,100 21,700 22,200 21,700 24,900 17,200 31,400 30,900 61,400 44,100 50,300 52,000 46,500 47,400 60,900 50,000 50,900 46,500 52,100 61,300 9,900 9,900 9,700 9,700 10,400 9,700 9,600 41,900 47,400 38,400 50,700 60,500 Ratio 45.80 50.95 51.18 49.41 46.60 45.17 36.53 43.83 43.56 42.94 43.40 42.90 49.32 45.27 32.45 44.86 81.00 44.49 55.13 40.24 40.34 42.27 43.09 79.09 45.87 40.72 40.26 52.10 52.39 47.14 45.00 38.80 47.50 38.52 60.63 61.94 61.62 37.95 55.25 50.70 42.61 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-33-402-024 09-14-33-403-016 09-14-33-403-017 09-14-33-403-029 09-14-33-404-002 09-14-33-404-003 09-14-33-404-021 09-14-33-405-006 09-14-33-426-010 09-14-33-426-013 09-14-33-426-020 09-14-33-426-025 09-14-33-427-057 09-14-33-428-047 09-14-33-429-010 09-14-33-429-018 09-14-33-429-038 09-14-33-429-045 09-14-33-430-008 09-14-33-430-021 09-14-33-431-021 09-14-33-431-031 09-14-33-433-001 09-14-33-434-011 09-14-33-435-009 09-14-33-436-010 09-14-33-437-008 09-14-33-452-002 09-14-33-454-010 09-14-33-454-019 09-14-33-454-024 09-14-33-455-003 09-14-33-455-007 09-14-33-455-031 09-14-33-456-018 09-14-33-456-020 09-14-33-456-023 09-14-33-457-006 09-14-33-457-034 09-14-33-457-037 09-14-33-476-005 Sale Date 1/10/2014 1/17/2014 7/21/2014 6/19/2014 9/19/2014 7/11/2014 10/2/2013 12/3/2013 5/7/2014 4/24/2015 1/17/2014 12/30/2014 2/23/2015 6/20/2014 12/5/2014 5/5/2015 10/23/2014 7/31/2015 7/21/2014 4/29/2015 5/30/2014 10/3/2014 8/7/2014 7/23/2015 8/3/2015 7/6/2015 3/25/2015 5/15/2014 8/24/2015 7/29/2015 7/27/2015 11/8/2013 10/15/2014 4/2/2015 12/13/2013 7/24/2015 12/19/2013 1/14/2015 2/20/2015 11/26/2013 11/6/2014 Grantor NG GROUP LLC BST 401K PSP LLC KLOSTERMAN, JENNIFER MASTROIANNI, FRANK ROHAN, ELIZABETH BOYLE, FREDERICK/MICHELE ARBAUGH ROBERT W & DENISE M WALLEMAN, MICHAEL/J. BEVERIDGE, MICHAEL A US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION MAGEL, III, JOHN/BRIDGET ENSROTH, RAY MAJOR, DEBBIE COMBS, LARRY/ SMALLWOOD, GERALDINE PERRY, JAMES A. ZANOTTI STEPHEN RYCKMAN-RATHKA, M./RYCKMAN, TIMOTHY SPRIET, JAMIE/NAIDA, IRENE/ZELLES,E HREBENCHUK, MICHAEL/S. VOGH, SR., ROBERT A./KATHLEEN WILSON, BRUCE/KAREN FARRELL, JOEL SHOVEIN, DAVID M/ KADETS, CHRISTINE D'S PROPERTY RENTAL & MGMT CO LLC CESULSKI, SANDRA/JENNIFER KOWALSKI, DAVID/JEROME FRANCIS MILIUS, GREG/KATIE KLEINER, KATIE M MANSOR, PATRICIA/REN, KRISTIN DUBE, RICHARD C. BRECHT MARK J GIVHAN, JUSTIN D SPOT REALTY INC BOLOGNA GRACE M TRUST LORBITZKI BRIAN PERRY, GERALD/JOAN SPOT REALTY INC BALL HOLDINGS LLC 1 STEPP PROPERTIES LLC DECLERCQ, DANIEL F. BONO, SHERI Grantee WELLS MICHAEL J SHAW CLAY DENNIS TAFT JOHN M II WHITE ANTOINE R ADAMO JAMIE MARYNIAK SHAUN CYBURT PAUL A & SANDERSCYBURT ANNET URBAN ADAM & TROY STEPHANIE CURIS RICHARD T SHORES RENTALS LLC ASCENDANCE HOLDINGS V LLC BARRY DANIEL E & JENNIFER A DOMG INVESTMENTS LLC CREECH JOEY MARIE ZAPORSKI LORI A YUHN ALANA BAUMGART JOHN R PULEO JESSICA R HARDIN GUY II JACKSON DESHANA M HAVEN CHRISTINA E REEDER GERALD P & VICTORIA L HAAS ANTHONY STEWART SHERRY NADROWSKI MICHAEL MEGGE DAVID ALLEN & DAVID WILLIAM BRDAK JASON ANDROS KATHRYN GSCHWENDER LANCE & BURGESON ALYSE BLIEMEISTER DARIAN & RUETER DANIELL ZENO HOLDINGS LLC SLOVER ANTHONY F DISUBI ALAIN CARISSIMI JAMES M & MASHELL D BALKO JEREMY W & JONES AMANDA J BURKE PATRICK L YOUSIF ERIC N MACOMB PACKAGE II LLC LAYHER LAURA DOOLEE LLC HAWKINS HEATHER Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD LC WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 54,000 78,000 69,000 100,000 102,500 105,500 144,000 135,500 81,900 32,200 42,000 92,500 34,000 62,000 93,900 83,100 94,900 97,500 90,000 100,000 99,897 55,000 100,000 58,000 70,000 66,500 134,000 86,000 130,000 155,000 102,500 120,500 124,900 95,000 113,000 120,000 94,900 75,000 90,000 38,000 83,000 SEV 21,100 36,000 28,100 38,700 39,500 38,800 65,700 46,000 44,600 22,500 26,200 51,600 19,200 20,400 31,500 37,700 34,600 49,300 33,200 43,600 43,400 37,400 45,200 15,600 32,100 21,700 50,600 34,200 43,200 49,100 43,600 43,500 41,200 47,100 44,400 60,900 35,300 33,700 46,300 23,500 35,700 Ratio 39.07 46.15 40.72 38.70 38.54 36.78 45.63 33.95 54.46 69.88 62.38 55.78 56.47 32.90 33.55 45.37 36.46 50.56 36.89 43.60 43.44 68.00 45.20 26.90 45.86 32.63 37.76 39.77 33.23 31.68 42.54 36.10 32.99 49.58 39.29 50.75 37.20 44.93 51.44 61.84 43.01 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-33-476-015 09-14-33-477-003 09-14-33-477-010 09-14-33-478-003 09-14-33-478-023 09-14-33-478-025 09-14-33-479-021 09-14-33-479-053 09-14-34-101-011 09-14-34-101-013 09-14-34-102-023 09-14-34-102-034 09-14-34-103-001 09-14-34-103-004 09-14-34-104-009 09-14-34-104-010 09-14-34-104-017 09-14-34-105-010 09-14-34-106-010 09-14-34-131-018 09-14-34-132-021 09-14-34-151-005 09-14-34-151-022 09-14-34-153-003 09-14-34-153-011 09-14-34-155-005 09-14-34-155-017 09-14-34-155-031 09-14-34-156-014 09-14-34-156-018 09-14-34-156-035 09-14-34-156-035 09-14-34-156-035 09-14-34-177-021 09-14-34-177-023 09-14-34-178-003 09-14-34-180-023 09-14-34-180-023 09-14-34-181-006 09-14-34-181-023 09-14-34-181-023 Sale Date 10/25/2013 2/26/2014 7/16/2015 11/8/2013 6/2/2015 6/17/2014 11/27/2013 1/15/2015 12/3/2014 8/15/2014 10/21/2013 10/16/2013 2/3/2014 4/3/2014 4/2/2014 8/10/2015 6/5/2015 3/30/2015 8/31/2015 6/10/2014 10/10/2014 12/17/2014 7/31/2015 1/17/2014 5/22/2015 1/16/2015 9/15/2014 12/18/2014 6/13/2014 6/10/2014 11/1/2013 1/8/2014 1/17/2014 12/31/2013 2/24/2015 2/5/2015 6/4/2014 9/19/2014 5/1/2015 6/19/2014 7/20/2015 Grantor VAN HOET GERALD M WHITE KENNETH HALL, JEANETTE KOSOVEC CATHERINE TRUST MCLELLAN, KEVIN TOLKACZ, ELISABETH L ETAL RUSSO, JEAN DRISCOLL, GARY T. - TRUST WILLIAMS, LORETTA W. VANDERMAAS, H.M./BURGIO, B.L. CORSI JILLIAN DG RESIDENTIAL SALES LLC DEVILLE ROSE FRANCES TRUST REYNAERT MARJORIE TRUST BACHLEDA, GEORGE/ HELEN CHEEK, NOAH M DRAGUN, JOSEPH/LORRAINE INA, JOSHUA N/ NEMEH N WEBER, ARLENE E TYSAR, JESSICA E/ YOUNG, MATTHEW L LATTANZIO, THERESE A THOMPSON JR, T./DEMEY, E. EASTERLY, DAVID JAMES PHILLIPS, HENRY L. GALVIN, STEPHANIE J JOHN GRAHAM INC WERTH, DEBORAH A CANTIN, PATRICIA WEYHING BURT THOMAS LAMBRECHT, JOHN PARDO ISABEL B MALIBU BREEZE PROPERTIES LLC JOHN GRAHAM INC DUCLOS, JANET/CUNNINGHAM/RABAUT FRANCIS, CHRISTOPHER DIATCHUN, DONNA HARTWIG, MARGRET - TRUST TRICOUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS & MA BERGHOFF, SARAH/MOFFETT, AARON CHILDERS, JAMES/ SPARKS, CHRISTINE SUTHERLAND, MELISSA Grantee SCHNEIDER JOSEPH NEMZEK STEPHEN & KELLY BENSON JOHN & PATRICIA BECKMAN DAVID J & JAMES PARENT MATTHEW HULWAY ROBERT L & DEBORAH R HOFFMAN TIMOTHY G SCHUBY THOMAS & BARBARA BEYLERIAN GEORGE SUDLOW KAYLA A DG RESIDENTIAL SALES LLC WHATELEY MICHAEL & SKRIP ANGELA TARANTINE KATHLEEN M MUSTEDANAGIC SEFKA MULVAHILL DONALD & BETTY MCCULLEN JAMES E JOHNSON RICHARD HOIN FRANCIS A & JENNIFER NOFS JEREMY COMMERSON BEN C PERKINS JAMES & CHRISTYNA ANDERSON AARON A GIRARD ANTHONY & SCHULTZ DANIELLE MCLAUGHLIN CHARLES E & LINDA FAY CLAY JANICE MA ZUCCARINI TRUST OSBORNE RACHAEL E FULLAR LEE INVESTMENT REALTY SERVICES LLC SEWELL ADRIENNE JOHN GRAHAM INC BIG MOUNTAIN INVESTORS LLC MALIBU BREEZE PROPERTIES LLC GAVIE SARAH COLLINSON MARK D JR ROTH PATRICK H TRICOUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS & MA GOODWIN CAITLIN J CRONIN KEVIN M & LINDA M SUTHERLAND MELISSA OSBORNE BRYAN & WILSON STACY Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 97,000 85,000 105,500 86,100 122,190 98,500 90,000 91,000 64,000 87,000 68,000 134,900 74,000 78,500 103,000 126,000 120,500 92,000 128,000 90,000 98,500 132,000 110,000 56,000 119,500 141,000 127,000 120,000 36,000 132,000 45,000 73,100 62,500 95,500 123,400 114,000 88,500 126,000 130,000 119,000 129,000 SEV 53,800 36,400 33,800 38,600 38,800 42,100 40,000 38,900 32,900 29,800 31,200 38,700 43,300 40,700 40,900 40,000 47,100 38,100 48,500 44,800 44,900 57,900 50,800 22,600 35,400 54,200 45,900 41,900 16,100 29,900 22,300 22,300 22,300 41,300 38,700 40,000 41,800 41,800 53,300 37,300 57,800 Ratio 55.46 42.82 32.04 44.83 31.75 42.74 44.44 42.75 51.41 34.25 45.88 28.69 58.51 51.85 39.71 31.75 39.09 41.41 37.89 49.78 45.58 43.86 46.18 40.36 29.62 38.44 36.14 34.92 44.72 22.65 49.56 30.51 35.68 43.25 31.36 35.09 47.23 33.17 41.00 31.34 44.81 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-34-181-025 09-14-34-203-004 09-14-34-204-003 09-14-34-206-038 09-14-34-207-029 09-14-34-207-031 09-14-34-208-001 09-14-34-208-020 09-14-34-208-032 09-14-34-226-004 09-14-34-226-010 09-14-34-226-011 09-14-34-227-007 09-14-34-229-012 09-14-34-229-015 09-14-34-229-028 09-14-34-230-014 09-14-34-230-015 09-14-34-230-016 09-14-34-230-020 09-14-34-232-048 09-14-34-251-002 09-14-34-251-006 09-14-34-251-027 09-14-34-252-003 09-14-34-252-008 09-14-34-252-035 09-14-34-252-039 09-14-34-253-001 09-14-34-253-005 09-14-34-253-014 09-14-34-254-007 09-14-34-254-013 09-14-34-255-001 09-14-34-256-002 09-14-34-256-015 09-14-34-257-016 09-14-34-276-002 09-14-34-276-019 09-14-34-276-054 09-14-34-276-056 Sale Date 5/22/2015 6/4/2014 11/8/2013 4/11/2014 8/15/2014 11/21/2014 7/21/2015 7/10/2015 5/9/2014 12/5/2014 7/31/2015 4/2/2015 9/4/2014 2/12/2015 4/21/2015 5/14/2014 9/3/2015 7/11/2014 12/16/2014 2/20/2015 6/30/2015 6/19/2015 5/28/2015 12/10/2013 1/15/2014 7/31/2014 4/25/2014 7/23/2014 8/21/2015 2/21/2014 4/15/2015 6/17/2015 5/29/2014 4/22/2014 10/15/2013 6/27/2014 7/13/2015 5/15/2014 7/2/2015 10/25/2013 7/23/2014 Grantor MYERS MICHAEL A CLAIRWOOD INVESTMENTS, LLC MICHIGAN FORECLOSURE FREEDOM LLC SCHULTZ ERIC C FLATT GREGORY MACASKILL, PETER T./KAREN MICHAEL, SARAH H CEDARS REAL ESTATE GROUP LLC DOVE, STEVE PERRINI, MICHAEL/D. HEMP, ANNIE T. KIRSTEN, ANDREW J MILLER, ANNA MARIE MOTOR CITY INVESTMENT ASSN LLC PAGONAS, ANGELA/ KAREN/ STEPHEN LAMOND FREDERICK GROLEAU, WAYNE SEMA, SOTIR/GONE/CALA, ALKETA JOHNSON, BRIAN V. JOHN GRAHAM INC MULLINS VIVIAN LEE COLLICA, JOHN A. SECCOMBE, MELISSA/ ZIMMER, MICHAEL STACKHOUSE, LAURA BADALAMENTE, FRANK MUER, MICHAEL T. STEWART, THOMAS A./MARY C. HARRISON, STEVEN/REBECCA VANDENBOOM, JEFF H EDWARDS RICHARD T GOODWIN, DANIEL WILSON, RICHARD - TRUST TNB CONNECT LLC WEOT, JOHN K. KAHLICHVITALE DIANE H & LAGUERE LIL SMITH, DANNY/CINDY GEISLER, LILY J. KUBISIAK, CATHERINE - TRUST PIRRONE, JOHN B ETAL REAM JAMES L TRUST JONES, DONALD/KIM M. Grantee STEFANIAK MICHAEL EDDS MICHAEL KENT DANIEL & BARBARA CHRISTMAN THOMAS WALENTY ALLEN J TRUST VENDITTELLI BRADLEY HASHEMI KAVEH A RUSSELL INVESTMENTS INC LIPA RONALD & LAURETTE KIESGEN GREGORY L JEROME HOOVER PAULA M PRENTISS RYAN DUSO LAWRENCE D & KATHLEEN R SIMS DANIEL WEIGOLD JONATHAN A KRUSZYNA TIMOTHY POMICHOWSKI STANISLAW H GRAHAM DONZELLE & CONNIE GRIMES KEVIN K & HUNTER A GREEN APPLE HOMES LLC LEE, JI-HYUN BACKER BENJAMIN T TAYLOR GREGORY YOUNG RAYMOND LOYSON MICHAEL E KALLAS ALBERT & DEBORAH CHOWDHURY SHOWMITRA POWERS ECHOLS ANIKA J BARATTA ANGELINE SETA MATTHEW JOHN & JOHN P RUDD NICHOLAS & BENS CELESTE ROSSI LAUREN DMOCHOWSKI JESSICA BLACK RYAN R THOMAS ROGER & DEBRA A GLEBOCKI RICHARD & PEGGY JORDAN DARRYL WLASIUK SARA KORTE DANIEL RUBINO DANIEL D JR & KATHLEEN SHAFER MELANIE Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 401 403 403 403 403 403 404 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 95,500 95,000 59,900 70,000 103,000 127,900 124,000 20,600 44,000 41,800 58,500 83,000 135,000 85,900 90,000 74,000 7,500 159,000 103,000 75,500 109,000 70,000 150,000 93,500 68,000 112,000 150,000 109,000 118,500 85,000 95,500 126,800 116,000 120,000 90,000 106,100 92,500 113,000 125,500 70,100 124,900 SEV 38,300 48,600 24,500 39,700 44,300 62,000 49,900 6,600 22,100 42,700 42,100 34,200 48,000 32,300 41,000 36,600 5,300 65,000 56,700 29,400 43,700 37,100 50,600 39,000 29,100 39,600 44,100 39,500 46,100 34,800 43,300 44,200 35,900 40,300 32,300 38,900 49,200 45,100 42,600 28,700 37,500 Ratio 40.10 51.16 40.90 56.71 43.01 48.48 40.24 32.04 50.23 102.15 71.97 41.20 35.56 37.60 45.56 49.46 70.67 40.88 55.05 38.94 40.09 53.00 33.73 41.71 42.79 35.36 29.40 36.24 38.90 40.94 45.34 34.86 30.95 33.58 35.89 36.66 53.19 39.91 33.94 40.94 30.02 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-34-278-008 09-14-34-278-041 09-14-34-279-013 09-14-34-280-008 09-14-34-280-015 09-14-34-282-005 09-14-34-282-008 09-14-34-282-012 09-14-34-302-021 09-14-34-302-028 09-14-34-303-009 09-14-34-303-024 09-14-34-304-001 09-14-34-304-005 09-14-34-304-019 09-14-34-305-022 09-14-34-327-009 09-14-34-327-029 09-14-34-327-029 09-14-34-328-012 09-14-34-328-014 09-14-34-328-051 09-14-34-328-053 09-14-34-329-015 09-14-34-329-015 09-14-34-329-018 09-14-34-329-018 09-14-34-329-029 09-14-34-329-030 09-14-34-329-035 09-14-34-330-005 09-14-34-330-008 09-14-34-330-011 09-14-34-330-026 09-14-34-331-012 09-14-34-332-021 09-14-34-332-025 09-14-34-332-031 09-14-34-332-041 09-14-34-334-005 09-14-34-335-005 Sale Date 6/29/2015 1/9/2015 3/6/2015 6/23/2015 6/19/2015 9/10/2015 3/14/2014 3/11/2015 3/12/2014 5/28/2014 8/7/2015 7/9/2015 8/11/2015 12/6/2013 6/13/2014 4/15/2014 12/2/2014 9/9/2014 1/16/2015 4/14/2014 6/20/2014 10/3/2013 8/31/2015 1/31/2014 12/15/2014 12/23/2014 5/22/2015 10/25/2013 11/21/2014 10/28/2013 10/27/2014 3/4/2015 4/6/2015 8/29/2014 6/30/2014 6/30/2014 9/12/2014 10/31/2013 7/27/2015 5/28/2014 1/9/2015 Grantor JECEWSKI, STEVEN/ANNA REDMOND, HELENE GUIDO TRUST SCHWARZ, LORE HELEN CARNEY, DAVID M/ HUNTLEY, RYAN M LOVE, BERNICE - TRUST STAMMAN VIRGINIA BALL TRUST YONKUS JULIE ANNE CLARK, THOMAS A CARDINALI, ANDREW KIESGEN, GREGORY L. DIMICHELE, DAVID/ VINCENT MIRKAZEMI, MEHRAN/FRANCES LANG JEFFREY KIMBLER, TERESA D. ZEDAN, ELIAS SORGI, CHRIS CASTANO, VICTOR HOUSE AND HOME SOLUTIONS LLC SIMPSON, PATRICK R3P INVESTMENTS LLC REED, RUTH WAGGONER, JAMES VITALE, FRANK SELCANIN, PAVLE WEIR SYLVIA M TRUST BOJALAD, MICHAEL HEWITT JESSICA L ROBINSON, MATTHEW TRAJKOV DEAN SULLIVAN VIRGINIA REWARD PROPERTIES LLC POLIZZI, SAMUEL MOUSTAKAS, EVAN/JULIE TRI-COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS & M ARMSTEAD, KEN CIPRIANO, JAMES T/ LISA A HAYDEN THOMAS BENEFIT OF BONACORSI, MICHELLE A. GREENFELDER, III, RUSSELL O. WALCZAK, GREGORY Grantee FOURNIER JEREMY S MCKAY COREY A DITTY SEAN HENDRIX CHRISTOPHER W ACOSTA JASON FOURNIER FLORENCE M TRUST ZAPYTOWSKI JOHN H & MARION FABER KATHLEEN SPOONER LINDSEY A KING NATHANIEL & ALICIA DINGMAN AMBER L OWNERSHIP RESOURCE GROUP LLC ALWARDT TYLER M & WILLIS BREANNA DAVIS DEREK JOHN GRAHAM INC LYON JIMI & DEBORAH SCHERER PAUL HOUSE AND HOME SOLUTIONS LLC HAMOLLI ARTAN YOUSIF JOHN & GIROUX ALEXANDRA VESCO BALABAN JENNIFER CUMULUS PROPERTIES LLC GENNETTE BRANDON J SELCANIN PAVLE DAVIS DOUGLAS S BOJALAD MICHAEL HEPP RYAN K WOLLENWEBER RICHARD L ALFES PATRICK P JACKSON MITCHELL & MICAELA SESTA JESSICA BISSA ADAM G BURNELL BRYAN SEIBERLING KURT N JR & SCHWAGER AMA ROMANELLI JONATHAN C STRONG REX & KAHLICH VITALE DIANE STROH KEVIN DELGADO GARCIA LEONARDO WERNER MICHAEL MIKIEL THOMAS T BOWMER AMANDA Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 140,000 113,500 122,000 108,000 122,000 87,500 85,000 80,000 78,500 93,000 92,000 126,000 115,000 85,000 45,000 99,900 121,000 32,500 45,000 54,400 56,000 85,000 91,000 47,000 103,000 35,000 96,000 119,000 116,000 86,000 100,000 102,500 109,900 109,900 89,500 154,000 83,500 97,000 143,000 125,000 53,000 SEV 60,200 39,400 36,000 46,800 43,600 41,600 30,200 34,400 30,900 38,100 31,100 48,800 37,500 39,000 18,600 35,100 53,900 17,300 17,300 25,400 23,900 36,200 35,400 32,400 31,000 29,500 32,300 34,400 35,200 31,300 36,000 32,600 35,200 42,900 32,400 50,600 30,700 29,300 48,100 42,800 18,800 Ratio 43.00 34.71 29.51 43.33 35.74 47.54 35.53 43.00 39.36 40.97 33.80 38.73 32.61 45.88 41.33 35.14 44.55 53.23 38.44 46.69 42.68 42.59 38.90 68.94 30.10 84.29 33.65 28.91 30.34 36.40 36.00 31.80 32.03 39.04 36.20 32.86 36.77 30.21 33.64 34.24 35.47 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-34-335-011 09-14-34-335-012 09-14-34-336-018 09-14-34-337-012 09-14-34-337-032 09-14-34-354-017 09-14-34-355-005 09-14-34-377-008 09-14-34-377-014 09-14-34-378-019 09-14-34-378-023 09-14-34-378-032 09-14-34-379-003 09-14-34-379-003 09-14-34-379-005 09-14-34-379-030 09-14-34-379-030 09-14-34-379-043 09-14-34-380-006 09-14-34-381-015 09-14-34-382-001 09-14-34-382-010 09-14-34-383-004 09-14-34-401-004 09-14-34-401-004 09-14-34-402-003 09-14-34-402-018 09-14-34-402-018 09-14-34-402-018 09-14-34-402-018 09-14-34-403-001 09-14-34-403-003 09-14-34-403-004 09-14-34-403-010 09-14-34-403-011 09-14-34-403-016 09-14-34-403-026 09-14-34-404-006 09-14-34-404-007 09-14-34-404-010 09-14-34-405-043 Sale Date 12/19/2014 7/8/2014 9/5/2014 10/15/2014 8/28/2015 9/3/2015 7/21/2015 4/15/2014 10/17/2014 2/28/2014 8/10/2015 8/28/2014 11/12/2013 3/12/2015 10/10/2014 1/31/2014 7/29/2014 7/6/2015 11/20/2013 8/22/2014 3/16/2015 6/30/2014 5/27/2015 1/24/2014 3/17/2015 7/31/2015 3/5/2014 8/12/2014 12/8/2014 4/1/2015 7/23/2015 6/20/2014 11/26/2014 1/2/2015 8/19/2015 11/21/2014 12/20/2013 6/12/2014 6/27/2014 7/11/2014 8/29/2014 Grantor GRAUL BERNARD FOWLDS RODGER S BIRKNER, PETER/JIL - TRUST JOHNSTON JR, WILLIAM T. CARBARY, BRIAN/NICOLE CWENGROS, PAUL/D. BOYSEL, LISA/SHANE R HUGHES, KATHRYNN LIETZ, ERIC J ETAL DEJONG ROGER J JIMED LLC JONES, KEVIN/MARGARET RUIZ CARLOS M & FLORA M HOWSON, BARBARA/LOUIS LAGERSTROM, JOJO/ KEITH/ RONALD DE HOSSE JOHN P DDN ENTERPRISE INC MORO, LOUIS LIETAERT, LINDA KOLASKI, DUANE/DENISE IVKOV, MARY/VENTIMIGLIA, J.C. SCHWARTZ, JOHN/ANNE GSR PROPERTIES GORMELY, LOUIS T TRI COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS GOETZ, JOHN N TATONE JOHN R LALONDE DAVID J & CHRISTIANE R MAIR MEGHAN EQUITY TRUST COMPANY ENGLEHARDT TRUST VILLASURDA, CATHERINE M FIVE STAR ASSET MANAGEMENT LLC ANDERSON, AARON A PALAZZOLA, SAM TRUST MARTINEK, KARLA N TNB CONNECT LLC DILLON, PAULINE J - TRUST URBIN, MARIE-LOUISE M TRUST FREEMAN, PAUL SCOTT, DAWN Grantee RASMUSSEN ERIC HAROLD SR & ERIC II BABECKI ANDREW & BREIGHT JULIE VILLARREAL ERNESTO CLUTE BRIAN R & HEATHER L HUTCHISON MADELINE FENECH JOHN RUDGE DUANE SCHLEICHER ERIK & POTTHOFF LINDSAY TRI COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS STAPLETON KATHRYN MLINAC WILLIAM & SARTORI KATERINA ROSS DANIEL HOWSON LOUIS J & BARBARA J FLOYD MARY K GILLENKIRK MICHAEL & OAKLEY TERRI L DDN ENTERPRISE INC EMMONS VICKY L CASTOR PHILLIP & WALLACE ERIN EVANS ROBERT & JEANETTE HAGBERG JACLYN M ALLEMON LAWRENCE & DELFINA BERMAN SPENCER G CARLSON AMY TRI COUNTY REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS & M LUTFY FRANK C MARTIN DANIEL P LALONDE DAVID J & CHRISTIANE R MAIR MEGHAN MIVINS HOMES LLC BARTOLOMEI FREDERICK P DAWSON MADISON STAHL MYRNA SUZANNE MASLOWSKI SEAN P RUTH PAUL ANKENBRANDT AARON E SMITH JILL PERSON PATRICIA STAWARZ CHERYL BRASHAW ALLEN SALKOWSKI DANIEL PULGINI JOHN Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 56,000 85,000 101,800 117,100 109,900 90,000 97,000 101,000 80,000 90,000 106,000 110,000 66,000 87,000 105,100 60,000 104,500 125,000 72,500 93,000 94,900 170,500 72,500 70,000 105,000 124,900 95,000 100,000 75,000 125,000 115,000 110,000 103,500 94,000 89,900 109,900 115,000 90,000 67,500 114,900 103,000 SEV 25,100 38,500 34,800 39,700 36,100 30,300 40,900 42,200 38,500 30,700 36,800 34,100 33,200 36,500 38,300 32,400 35,700 49,800 36,500 36,500 43,600 70,100 45,900 36,300 40,700 50,600 44,200 48,600 48,600 53,700 50,600 37,100 50,800 40,800 34,800 42,300 34,400 44,000 35,500 39,300 26,700 Ratio 44.82 45.29 34.18 33.90 32.85 33.67 42.16 41.78 48.13 34.11 34.72 31.00 50.30 41.95 36.44 54.00 34.16 39.84 50.34 39.25 45.94 41.11 63.31 51.86 38.76 40.51 46.53 48.60 64.80 42.96 44.00 33.73 49.08 43.40 38.71 38.49 29.91 48.89 52.59 34.20 25.92 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-34-407-004 09-14-34-408-010 09-14-34-409-006 09-14-34-410-004 09-14-34-410-006 09-14-34-411-015 09-14-34-411-023 09-14-34-411-026 09-14-34-412-013 09-14-34-428-002 09-14-34-428-007 09-14-34-428-014 09-14-34-429-010 09-14-34-429-025 09-14-34-429-032 09-14-34-429-034 09-14-34-430-001 09-14-34-430-022 09-14-34-431-009 09-14-34-432-001 09-14-34-434-005 09-14-34-434-009 09-14-34-435-004 09-14-34-435-017 09-14-34-436-003 09-14-34-438-004 09-14-34-451-007 09-14-34-451-007 09-14-34-451-009 09-14-34-454-038 09-14-34-455-038 09-14-34-455-041 09-14-34-456-013 09-14-34-456-017 09-14-34-456-026 09-14-34-456-032 09-14-34-456-033 09-14-34-478-005 09-14-34-478-010 09-14-34-478-011 09-14-34-478-023 Sale Date 1/21/2015 12/31/2014 9/5/2014 1/15/2014 10/21/2013 8/11/2015 8/22/2014 4/27/2015 10/31/2014 7/25/2014 3/19/2015 9/5/2014 10/3/2014 11/14/2013 7/31/2014 6/30/2015 11/14/2014 12/19/2013 10/3/2014 8/14/2014 11/14/2013 9/17/2015 6/15/2015 7/9/2014 5/20/2014 5/16/2014 6/8/2015 6/26/2015 8/7/2014 9/10/2015 7/9/2014 8/15/2014 12/3/2014 5/13/2015 8/29/2014 12/9/2014 7/17/2015 3/19/2015 12/19/2014 6/3/2014 11/26/2014 Grantor BIERNACKI, ALINA COLEMAN, TIMOTHY F. HART, JOHN A/ MARIA E TYTRAN, TODD JOSEPH THOMSEN SANDRA WALSH, TERRANCES J./L. STOLARSKI FAMILY TRUST ORLANDO, FRANK WOODS-CARRIER, SHEILA FRITZ, TRACI L. HUBBARD, BRIAN E. DECOSTER, MATTHEW L NFH CAPITAL PARTNERS II LLC KALLMES RICHARD P II & DEBORAH WALCZY, KATHERINE GREIG, DORIS/JANICE PAPAKONSTANTINOU, ACHILLES SAPONARE, DOROTHY KNOPF, LOTTIE MCCLAIN, KEVIN THOMPSON, JOE J. TROMBLEY, JEFFREY F. CAMPBELL, ESTHER P - TRUST DAMPHOUSSE MARIANN SCOTT, JUSTUS / PHYLLIS M/ THOMAS J TOMASEVIC, VIRGINIA P - TRUST GALLINAGH JR., JOHN J MODERN REAL ESTATE SOLUTIONS LLC SUDOMIER MICHAEL P GATLIFF, RUTH/THOMAS - TRUSTEE KIES, HENRY/GRAYCE FRANKS PLACE-ONE LLC MOULIOS, GREGORY/DELPHINE LEWIS, TONISHA APPEL JUANITA M SLOAN, CAROLYNN/BERNARD WHITMORE JR, JOSEPH R. SALLOUM, SADIE/RICHARD KUCHENMEISTER, MELISSA VEIT, WILLIAM R. DOWKER, PAULA M Grantee BRINLEY BILL & KAREN FITZGERALD LISA M SEJFULLA BARDHYL R & LINDA LEE BINGE CHRISTINE MCCOMBS NICHOLAS HESS NICOLE VASQUEZ DAVID & MONIQUE COOPER ANGELA DALSTRA COLIN BURKS RICHARD D & REHS ALISSA M ZENO HOLDINGS LLC BESKANGE CHAD A GRONAN ROSS MCBETH SUSAN HENTRICH CHRISTOPHER & HARBISON JAM KELLEHAN RYAN & MACDONALD JULIE ROSE DIANE KOZAK SCOTT M & KOZAK TAMARA N SAIGH PETER & JOSEPHINE B TRUST MESERVE KRISTIE SMITH THOMAS M JR & SMITH THOMAS M DAVID NICOLLE GALLAGHER MARY DAMPHOUSSE ERIC CALLSEN ROBERT & ELAINE TYMRAK VANESSA K MODERN REAL ESTATE SOLUTIONS LLC SENIOR HOME VESTORS 21 LLC ANDERSON DARLENE M GALVIN STEPHANIE J DALLAS GEORGE & SUZANNE DEBS LISA PUGH GREGORY RYDZEWSKA MALGORZATA CLARK ALPHONSO SIEGER DEBRA KAY BUSH MATTHEW J JARECKI JOHN F & BARBARA L KORTE RICHARD BOERTMANN ROSEANNE VONDETTE LEONE R & LOUIS W Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 110,000 127,000 84,000 33,200 55,000 75,000 87,000 98,000 124,000 95,000 87,500 115,000 90,000 85,000 99,900 95,250 118,000 101,000 125,000 84,900 93,500 106,000 125,000 95,000 125,000 150,500 73,000 79,000 107,000 115,500 124,000 89,000 100,000 102,000 97,000 120,000 91,000 121,000 165,000 155,000 185,000 SEV 45,300 46,600 34,900 27,200 31,600 36,800 34,900 36,400 40,800 40,200 41,800 43,600 41,900 35,500 35,600 42,500 43,900 35,800 58,000 34,200 33,000 35,600 52,300 56,000 56,600 63,100 40,500 40,500 36,000 53,100 57,700 33,000 38,900 45,300 42,200 41,100 37,300 56,000 53,300 58,500 87,400 Ratio 41.18 36.69 41.55 81.93 57.45 49.07 40.11 37.14 32.90 42.32 47.77 37.91 46.56 41.76 35.64 44.62 37.20 35.45 46.40 40.28 35.29 33.58 41.84 58.95 45.28 41.93 55.48 51.27 33.64 45.97 46.53 37.08 38.90 44.41 43.51 34.25 40.99 46.28 32.30 37.74 47.24 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-34-479-011 09-14-34-480-007 09-14-34-481-003 09-14-35-106-002 09-14-35-106-017 09-14-35-106-026 09-14-35-106-030 09-14-35-106-037 09-14-35-106-043 09-14-35-106-055 09-14-35-106-068 09-14-35-106-086 09-14-35-106-126 09-14-35-106-161 09-14-35-106-163 09-14-35-106-168 09-14-35-106-174 09-14-35-106-175 09-14-35-108-021 09-14-35-131-024 09-14-35-132-003 09-14-35-132-004 09-14-35-132-007 09-14-35-132-013 09-14-35-132-019 09-14-35-132-025 09-14-35-132-027 09-14-35-132-037 09-14-35-152-010 09-14-35-152-010 09-14-35-176-004 09-14-35-176-027 09-14-35-176-030 09-14-35-178-019 09-14-35-179-008 09-14-35-180-031 09-14-35-180-034 09-14-35-180-047 09-14-35-302-014 09-14-35-302-026 09-14-35-302-035 Sale Date 3/25/2015 5/15/2015 6/30/2015 11/26/2014 6/30/2014 11/5/2014 12/5/2014 6/22/2015 6/20/2014 11/21/2014 6/25/2015 7/14/2014 8/31/2015 8/28/2014 11/15/2013 5/28/2015 4/1/2014 8/29/2014 6/20/2014 11/1/2013 6/18/2015 3/2/2015 6/15/2015 7/10/2015 3/4/2015 7/20/2015 6/24/2015 11/12/2013 10/28/2014 8/7/2015 9/16/2015 4/30/2015 4/13/2015 7/10/2015 6/26/2015 7/29/2014 7/24/2015 8/3/2015 12/17/2014 10/31/2014 8/25/2015 Grantor VERELLEN, DAWN M MCDONALD, ANN L GROTH, DANIEL J/ LYNN MCCABE PROPERTIES LLC LEONTARAS, MARKO ORTISI, FRANK/PAULINE JACOBS ROSE MARIE ROHN, GERALDINE - TRUST KIESGEN, BRIANNE M/ GREGORY L GUEVARA ROSA J TRUST KIRBY, DAWN CROWE, SARA E. KELLY, ELIZABETH M. -TRUSTEE THE BURT RIVIERA, LLC DERADOORIAN, SARKIS/V. SEITER, SUSAN E SAMMERT LLC DUBEY, MARGARET F. - TRUST PATRICO NANCY HESS THOMAS E & ROMA L MASON, ROBERT J TRUST BARRETT NANCY TAPERT TRUST EVERETT, ROBERT/MYRTLE KIENLE, CONSTANCE G/ ROBERT N KNOTH, MARVIN C.TRUST DALLAS, VICTORIA/EDWARD TAPERT PATRICIA HOEY JANE K TRUST POWERHOUSE PROPERTIES LLC KANE, KEN CAPTON, JAMES FOSSEE, SEAN M. CRONIN LINDA M KOENIG, DIANE A DEMEULENAERE, GEORGINA BAKER JR, ROBERT/FRANCES SLEDZINSKI, NICOLE M NATIONS HOME LOAN MCGRAW, RONALD J. BURNS, BETTY M. JOHNS, HILARY Grantee COLLINS TIMOTHY & MARISA O'SHEA, TAMIKO KREBS ANDREW J HAYOSH JOSEPH S & SHIRLEY M POMICHOWSKI LUKASZ LEMANSKE KAREN A TRUST KEFALLINOS JULIAN AKERS MARGARET M TOTZ JAMES D JR ACHESON KRISTINA KOT STEVEN EDWARDS EMMELYN THERRIAULT CRISTINA M COURY RALPH J JR THOMAS DONALD A & JUDITH E PIERANTONI KAREN J TRUST JEFFREY CHARLES & MONSCHAU DIANE MARSHALL JOSEPH C CARUSO KATHERINE MELLOS BETSY B PARTLAN CHARLES & BRIGGS BROOKE TRU DELAURA FRANK & LINDA AUBREY MICHAEL & CHRISTINA SCHUCH KATHLEEN M TEITGE LOUISE J TRUST PEOPLES ROBERT J TRUST THRASHER JAMES R & ROMA E PALM EDWARD KANE KEN TINCHER MARGUERITE VALENCIA PAUL J OSAER JEFFREY MARSH DAVID & RICHARD MARKHAM SCOTT JOHNSON SCOTT ALLEN EGGERT ERICH R & CAROL M BEDARD MATTHEW J HILL CHRISTOPHER A FENNESSEY DANA SCARFONE MICHAEL S & PATRICIA C SCARFONE MICHEAL S Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 407 407 407 Sale Price 195,500 185,000 168,500 37,500 48,500 66,000 63,000 59,500 63,000 42,000 67,000 62,000 62,000 61,000 54,900 53,700 62,000 63,000 55,000 235,000 277,000 242,500 278,000 249,900 240,000 297,000 258,000 195,000 57,000 109,000 208,000 240,000 160,000 213,000 140,000 115,000 227,900 208,500 68,000 45,000 75,500 SEV Ratio 70,600 76,800 64,000 14,600 20,600 20,600 20,600 25,400 21,500 17,200 22,100 21,500 26,600 21,400 19,700 26,400 20,600 21,500 20,600 103,000 111,600 84,100 111,600 95,200 103,600 121,400 105,400 73,500 32,200 35,900 105,400 91,900 99,100 84,600 83,100 66,400 96,700 106,100 18,000 19,300 24,400 36.11 41.51 37.98 38.93 42.47 31.21 32.70 42.69 34.13 40.95 32.99 34.68 42.90 35.08 35.88 49.16 33.23 34.13 37.45 43.83 40.29 34.68 40.14 38.10 43.17 40.88 40.85 37.69 56.49 32.94 50.67 38.29 61.94 39.72 59.36 57.74 42.43 50.89 26.47 42.89 32.32 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-35-302-040 09-14-35-302-084 09-14-35-302-087 09-14-35-302-102 09-14-35-302-149 09-14-35-302-150 09-14-35-302-155 09-14-35-302-160 09-14-35-302-201 09-14-35-302-214 09-14-35-302-215 09-14-35-302-217 09-14-35-302-230 09-14-35-302-253 09-14-35-302-278 09-14-35-302-324 09-14-35-302-324 09-14-35-302-353 09-14-35-302-358 09-14-35-302-365 09-14-35-302-379 09-14-35-302-395 09-14-35-302-396 09-14-35-302-409 09-14-35-302-410 09-14-35-302-410 09-14-35-302-415 09-14-35-302-470 09-14-35-302-490 09-14-35-302-496 09-14-35-302-498 09-14-35-302-517 09-14-35-302-518 09-14-35-302-519 09-14-35-302-527 09-14-35-302-530 09-14-35-302-536 09-14-35-302-539 09-14-35-304-008 09-14-35-304-009 09-14-35-304-015 Sale Date 5/26/2015 5/30/2014 1/13/2014 12/15/2014 7/16/2014 10/17/2014 7/31/2015 7/25/2014 6/3/2014 3/10/2015 12/20/2013 11/5/2014 2/4/2014 11/21/2014 3/30/2015 10/11/2013 5/27/2015 6/25/2014 7/2/2015 7/1/2014 6/11/2014 6/3/2015 7/9/2014 4/22/2015 8/1/2014 6/17/2015 5/26/2015 7/22/2015 10/10/2014 7/27/2015 1/29/2015 7/18/2014 4/24/2015 3/26/2015 5/28/2014 4/17/2014 12/19/2013 10/9/2013 6/11/2014 3/25/2015 8/25/2015 Grantor PURDY, LINDSAY SHAFER, MARY/ THOMAS SCHUMAKER JR., JOHN MCPHERSON, MICHELLE MEYERS, JEAN SAFINAZ, FATHY K NIEDBALA, JAN/FELICIA WYSZCZELSKI, ROSEMARY LESPERANCE, BLANCHE - TRUST LOPICCOLA MARY ANN FKA WALTERS, DAVID/JOANNE DIXON, TIMOTHY M STEVENS, MARY/BERNS, JIM QAQISH, NICOLE LEVERENZ, JOHN R ARNDT CHARLOTTE A TAKACH, LAURA ELYSE STONER, AMY MAMELKA, KATHLEEN - TRUST KOTAS, COURTENAY PAGE RENNELL, MICHAEL R RICHARDS, JAY E/SEVERINI, JANICE SCHWARTZ, EMILY K. WYKES, NIAL KADRICH, BRYAN/HEATHER DAILEY, CRAIG J PAPINEAU, JOHN/JOANNE KLINK LUCY Q GUZDIAL, BARBARA ROBERGE, AMY COLEMAN, MICHELLE HUMPHRY, NATALIE/SHERRIE STUCKEY, PAUL/PATRICIA ROSSIE, JACOB MICHAEL KAESS, ADA GAIL MELCHER, ELLEN M. OKIE, COLLEEN M - TRUST BALL FORREST L & FLORENCE R MARCOLINI, NICK SOCIA, PHYLLIS - ET AL SAMRA-ABI, CHRISTINE Grantee GIBSON TOUSCANY PEGGY HINLOPEN FRANS JORIS ERNE GARRY & TERRY KULEK ALLYCE N PETERS CAROL E SPIRO ANDI & JULIANA PRESTON MARGARET ELLEN COLLORAFFI ELIZABETH GROEZINGER MADISON P VALICEVIC SHANNON MILLER TYRUS R MARLEY BRIAN E BERNS JAMES W & STEVENS MARY KIRK KOCIAJ XHOANA GROEZINGER MADISON P TAKACH LAURA ELYSE KELLY TALEYA ZUCCA MARISSA CHAMPION ROBERT W HIGBIE KNOELL TRUST FOURNIER FLORENCE M & RAQUEL J BIONDO THOMAS ARAFAT ZAHER SCHWALLBACH HANS & HELGA DAILEY CRAIG J CONN JOHN KENDALL & CHERYL LYNN NEWBOLD WILLIAM BUJAK JENNIFER L MCINTOSH CHRISTINE ANDERSON MELINDA S KOCIAJ XHOANA & COOK VALBONA MEEKS JENNIFER K DEAN MORIAH & REBECCA P GOLLA ERIKA L TEMPLE MICHELE M SCHULTES ERIN E SHERRY JESSICCA MARIE NOVESKI IGOR LISABETH JENNA M MILLER KENNETH R II BALTMANIS DANIEL J Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 407 405 407 403 403 403 Sale Price 70,000 56,000 60,000 48,500 41,000 43,750 48,900 71,000 30,500 65,000 50,100 70,000 51,000 60,000 38,000 40,500 55,000 57,000 60,000 75,000 66,200 67,500 60,000 60,000 58,500 78,500 65,800 50,000 54,000 74,000 60,000 66,500 63,000 65,500 45,000 69,500 47,000 56,000 155,000 124,900 172,000 SEV 23,600 17,400 16,400 13,000 13,000 13,000 12,800 17,400 12,000 17,400 19,000 17,400 17,300 18,300 18,600 19,000 26,800 18,800 24,000 18,800 17,400 23,900 19,100 23,200 18,800 24,400 25,300 23,900 18,900 24,500 17,700 19,000 23,200 20,400 17,700 20,200 16,400 16,400 48,000 52,500 61,300 Ratio 33.71 31.07 27.33 26.80 31.71 29.71 26.18 24.51 39.34 26.77 37.92 24.86 33.92 30.50 48.95 46.91 48.73 32.98 40.00 25.07 26.28 35.41 31.83 38.67 32.14 31.08 38.45 47.80 35.00 33.11 29.50 28.57 36.83 31.15 39.33 29.06 34.89 29.29 30.97 42.03 35.64 2016 Sale Study Parcel Number 09-14-35-305-002 09-14-35-305-007 09-14-35-308-024 09-14-35-327-008 09-14-35-327-008 09-14-35-328-004 09-14-35-351-004 09-14-35-351-016 09-14-35-353-002 09-14-35-353-003 09-14-35-353-013 09-14-35-354-002 09-14-35-354-020 09-14-35-355-001 09-14-35-356-023 09-14-35-377-004 09-14-35-378-015 09-14-35-380-001 Sale Date 8/26/2015 8/3/2015 1/8/2014 1/31/2014 5/9/2014 10/21/2014 10/28/2013 5/29/2015 7/2/2014 4/30/2015 5/29/2014 5/15/2015 11/24/2014 1/17/2014 8/25/2014 11/6/2014 4/21/2015 2/28/2014 Grantor THOMAS AGATHA TRUST MAES, ELAINE GRINVALSKY, HENRY/MARK/VINCENT VIVIANO III, JOSEPH VORHOLT, CINDY K HIBBS, PAUL PEEBLES RUSSELL H & CARRIE I GAGLIO, PHILIP/LISA BERTOVICK GERALDINE E KROMM, ROBERT/C. HALPIN TERESA M TRUST NICOSIA, CAROL ANN/- TRUST VILLAR, DAVID JANKOWSKI, TED/BARB LACLAIR, JAMES/NANCY STOFF WILLIAM & ELLEN TRUST DISKIN, JOEL/KATHLEEN CIARAMITARO GASPER Grantee LIVADICH SEYFUDIN P SIMMEN DANIEL A HANCOCK THOMAS J VORHOLT CINDY K ANDERSON SHARON VALLIERE KAREN ANDERSON DIANA BURT MICHAEL & PALMS BURT MARIE L MICHALEK CHRISTOPHER RUSSO JAMES & SHEILA GG & K PROPERTIES LLC LAETHEM ALYSIA TIBAUDO VITO TRUST CARR KEVIN F & LESLIE KUJAWSKI VANDERMAAS HANS M & BARBARA L MOURAD ANTHONY & ABRAHAM MOLLY WALTERS JOHN A GREEN DAVID & SARA Class WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD WD 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 403 Sale Price 129,000 153,000 148,975 65,000 83,000 185,000 130,000 171,500 122,000 165,000 115,000 163,500 160,000 200,000 212,250 250,000 200,000 195,000 SEV 66,600 68,400 51,800 24,600 25,700 62,100 51,700 73,800 55,900 72,900 62,600 70,200 64,600 76,500 76,100 75,000 75,800 67,200 Ratio 51.63 44.71 34.77 37.85 30.96 33.57 39.77 43.03 45.82 44.18 54.43 42.94 40.38 38.25 35.85 30.00 37.90 34.46
Similar documents
Fall 2006 - Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin
John and Helen Johnson
June Johnson
Elroy and Joan Johnson
Anna Jones
Mary Jones
Carol Justin and Ed Szopinski
Lolita and Dave Kachel
Dennis Kaiser
Ken and Lois Kamps
Esther Kaplan
Carol Kean
Phil ...
