The Chief Joseph Hatchery 2015 Annual Program Review
Transcription
The Chief Joseph Hatchery 2015 Annual Program Review
The Chief Joseph Hatchery 2015 Annual Program Review March 10-11, 2015 Chief Joseph Hatchery - Central Facility 38 Half Sun Way Bridgeport, WA 98813 This page intentionally left blank. 2015 Chief Joseph Hatchery Annual Program Review Table of Contents Part 1 – Program Overview………………………………………………………………………….…………………………………………1 Part 2 – 2014 Year-in-Review…………………………………………………………………………….……………………………….…19 Hatchery Program Operations…………………………………………………………………………………………………..….…20 Harvest and Brood Collection………………………………………………………………………………………………………….21 Research, Monitoring and Evaluation Programs………………………………………………………………………………21 Part 3 – Current and Future Program Management……………………………………………………………………………..30 Part 4 – Annual Work Plan, CJHP Implementation……………………………………………………………………………….50 Appendices……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………62 This page intentionally left blank. 2015 Chief Joseph Hatchery Annual Program Review Part 1 – Program Overview 1 This page intentionally left blank. 2 3 2015 Annual Program Review G e ne ra l In forma ti on S he e t • What: Fifth Annual Chief Joseph Hatchery Program Review (APR) • Where: Chief Joseph Hatchery - Central Facility, 38 Half Sun Way Bridgeport, WA • When: March 10, 2015 (CCT, State, Fed, PUD and stakeholder meeting) & March 11, 2015 (CCT staff and advisor workshops) Purpose: In 2015 the Colville Tribes are hosting a one-day meeting and one-day workshop for the Chief Joseph Hatchery Program (CJHP) to review and present findings from the previous year and plan for the upcoming fish production, harvest and science monitoring cycle. The first day of the meeting is set aside to present results from 2014 activities and to discuss what we’ve learned. We will review our monitoring and evaluation results, harvest regimes and fish culture and production operations. The second day will be a technical work session for Tribal staff responsible for program implementation. This will be a formal planning session for the upcoming 2015 fish production and research, monitoring and evaluation cycle. The purpose of the work session is to develop a detailed action plan that outlines staff assignments, deliverables, and timelines. The goal of the APR is to inform the funding entities, fish co-managers, and stakeholders of CJH related activities and to increase the overall scientific defensibility and effectiveness of the programs that inform management decisions. In addition, we will review and discuss key assumptions and biological targets for the program in the coming year. Areas of presentation include research, monitoring and evaluation, fish population and harvest monitoring, adult fish management, and fish production. All contribute to integrated discussions at the APR. Information on the CJHP, including all APR materials, can be found at: http://www.colvilletribes.com/cjhp.php 4 Map to Chief Joseph Hatchery – Central Facility: Directions: • • • From the South/West (i.e., Wenatchee, Seattle etc.) o WA97 North to Okanogan, to WA17, Spokane, Grand Coulee Dam exit. Left before the Bridge across Col. R onto Half Sun Way. Nearest regional airport is Wenatchee. From the East (i.e., Spokane etc.) o WA174, WA17 to Bridgeport, cross Col. R bridge then right onto Half Sun Way From the North (i.e., Omak, Okanogan, Canada etc.) o WA97 South to left at WA17, Spokane, Grand Coulee Dam exit. Left before the Bridge across Col. R. at Bridgeport Regional Airport and Carrier (2hr. 35m from the Hatchery): Alaska Airlines 1 Pangborn Drive East Wenatchee, WA 98802 (509) 884-2494 pangbornairport.com Local Accommodations: Lake Pateros Inn 115 S Lake Shore Drive Pateros, WA 98846 (509) 923-2203 [email protected] 5 PepperTree-Best Western 820 Koala Drive, Omak, WA 98841 1-866-234-0762 Omak Inn 912 Koala Drive, Omak, WA 98841 1-866-234-0762 APR Contact Information: Andrea Pearl, Fisheries Biologist Colville Tribes Fish & Wildlife Program Phone: (509) 422-7437 Cell (509) 634-1364 (cell) [email protected] www.colvilletribes.com/cjhp.php Patrick Phillips, Chief Joseph Hatchery Manager II 38 Half Sun Way Bridgeport, WA. 98813 Office# (509) 686-0234 Cell# (509) 631-1870 Fax# (509) 686-0233 [email protected] www.colvilletribes.com/cjhp.php Kirk Truscott, Anadromous Fish Division Manager Colville Tribes Fish & Wildlife Program Phone: (509) 978-8031 [email protected] www.colvilletribes.com Randall Friedlander, Director Colville Tribes Fish & Wildlife Program Phone: (509) 634-2110 [email protected] www.colvilletribes.com Brenda Schmidt, Staff Assistant Colville Tribes Fish & Wildlife Chief Joseph Hatchery Office (509) 422-4580 Cell (509) 634-1543 CJH Fax (509) 686-0233 [email protected] www.colvilletribes.com/cjhp.php 6 Chief Joseph Hatchery Program Kirk Truscott Senior Anadromous Program Manager Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reser vation The Goals for Okanogan Basin Summer‐Fall Chinook are to: Increase abundance, productivity, and temporal‐ spatial diversity of naturally spawning Chinook in the Okanogan Basin Increase harvest for all fishers The Purpose of the CJH Program is to: Increase harvest consistent with the natural production goals Support re‐colonization of habitat 7 The Goals for Okanogan Basin Spring Chinook are to: Restore a harvestable, sustainable naturally spawning spring Chinook population in the Okanogan Basin Harvest for all fishers Contribute to recovery of the UCR ESU The Purpose of the CJH Program is to: Re‐colonize habitat in Okanogan Provide harvest consistent with the natural production goals Program Commitments Adaptively manage Program consistent with “Decision Rules” and “Biological Targets” by adjusting smolt production and broodstock management to meet targets for: pHOS, NOR escapement, pNOB, PNI, and Stray rates Achieve FCRPS and PUD mitigation production 8 Hatchery Production Summer/fall Chinook Spring Chinook Research/Monitoring/Evaluation Within hatchery monitoring Natural population monitoring Summer/Fall Chinook Integrated Yearling Sub‐yearling Segregated Yearling Sub‐yearling Spring Chinook Reintroduction Segregated 9 CJH Su-Fa Chinook Strategy Two Program Components, An Integrated component—releases in Okanogan River A segregated component—releases from CJH Three Phases: Current—Similkameen Mitigation Program 2. Transition (1 and 2)—CJH program with emphasis on harvest augmentation and habitat re‐colonization 3. Long Term—CJH program with emphasis on harvest augmentation and local adaptation of natural populations (i.e. low pHOS, High PNI) 1. Program Type and Purpose Summer Chinook Current Long Term 2009‐2013 Period 2 2019‐2026 Integrated Conservation Integrated Conservation Integrated Conservation and Harvest Integrated Harvest Not Applicable Segregated Harvest (Stepping Stone) Segregated Harvest (Stepping Stone) Segregated Harvest (Stepping Stone) Okanogan River Component Chief Joseph Hatchery Component Transition Period 1 2014‐2018 2027 Spring Chinook Okanogan River Component Chief Joseph Hatchery Component Phase 1‐ Re‐ colonization phase 2‐ Reintroduction Phase 3‐ Integrated Conservation Segregated Conservation Integrated Conservation Integrated Conservation Segregated Harvest Segregated Harvest Segregated Harvest 10 Hatchery Program Step 2 Natural Production Segregated Component. On‐Station Release. Produces fish for harvest. (Ad‐clipped only) Directed Harvest Hatchery Program Step 1 Integrated Component. Produces broodstock for harvest program. (100% CWT and Ad clip) pHOS 2 pHOS 1 NOB pNOB pNOS HOR (Step2) pHOB 1 100% HOB (Step1) pHOB 1 Weir, Hatchery Rack, Selective Harvest to Control pHOS Hatchery Production (Maximum) Current Phase Transition Period 1 2014‐2018 2009‐2013 Long Term Period 2 2019‐2026 2027 800,000 yearlings Okanogan River 576,000 yearlings 875,000 yearlings 875,000 yearlings 600,000 yearlings 600,000 yearlings 300,000 sub‐yearlings Chief Joseph Hatchery 500,000 yearlings No Production 400,000 sub‐yearlings Phase 1‐ Re‐ colonization Phase 2‐ Local Adaptation Phase 3‐ Conservation 2014 ‐ 20?? ? ? Okanogan River Component 200,000 yearlings ? ? Chief Joseph Hatchery Component 700,000 yearlings 700,000 yearlings 700,000 yearlings 11 Key Biological Targets Integrated Program (HSRG) PNI > 0.67 pHOS < 30 Percent Segregated (Stepping stone) Program pHOS < 5 Percent (within and outside Okanogan) Natural Population Natural Origin Spawners (NOR) >5,000 Adults Minimum NOR > 800 How Will Biological Targets be Met? Harvest/Adult Management: Live capture, selective fisheries, hatchery surplusing Mainstem seining Fish platforms Beach seines Sport fishing HOR removal at CJH ladder HOR removal at Okanogan Weir Working with managers to reduce marine and lower Columbia harvest impacts to NOR’s Hatchery Operations Adjust program size consistent with NOR abundance, pHOS and PNI Adjust smolt release numbers to address short‐fall in pHOS and PNI Adjust pNOB to address short‐fall in pHOS and PNI, consistent with NOR abundance targets On‐station release of segregated fish (Stepping Stone) 12 Hatchery Production Segregated spring Chinook Re‐introduction of spring Chinook Segregated summer Chinook Early return Late return Integrated summer Chinook Early return Late return Segregated Spring Chinook Broodstock Leavenworth National Fish Hatchery (LNFH) Brood collected throughout return to LNFH CCT CJH staff collect and transfer to CJH Smolt Release Max. target production‐ 700,000 smolts Release size‐ 30 grams Smolt release location‐ CJH Release date‐ mid‐April 2015 13 Reintroduction of Spring Chinook Broodstock Methow Composite HOB, Winthrop National Fish Hatchery (WNFH) Brood collected throughout the return to WNFH Egg/Fish Transfer CCT CJH staff to transfer eyed‐eggs to CJH (post 2013 brood) USFWS transferred BY‐13 MetComp from Winthrop to Riverside Pond in fall of 2013. Post BY‐13, eyed‐egg transfer from Winthrop NFH to CJH Post BY‐13, pre‐smolt transfer to Tonasket or Riverside ponds Smolt release Target release‐ 200,000 yearling smolts Release size‐ 30 grams Release location‐ Okanogan River Release date‐ mid‐late April Segregated Summer Chinook Broodstock Collection Hatchery origin brood (HOR) Purse seine‐ Okanogan River confluence (July‐early September) CJH ladder (July‐early November) Tangle net‐ (July‐October) Okanogan weir (September‐mid‐October) Smolt Releases Max. target release‐ 500,000 yearling and 400,000 sub‐yearling smolts Release size‐ 45 grams yearling; 11 grams sub‐yearling Release location‐ CJH Release date‐ mid‐late April 2015 (yearlings); mid‐June 2014 (sub‐ yearlings) 14 Integrated Summer Chinook Broodstock Collection Natural Origin Brood (NOR) Purse seine‐ Okanogan River confluence (July‐early September) Tangle net‐ (July‐October) Okanogan weir‐ (September – mid October) Wells Dam (late‐August – September)* Beach seine‐ Okanogan (mid‐September‐early October) CJH ladder (mid September ‐ early November) Smolt Releases Max. target release‐ 800,000 yearling and 300,000 sub‐yearling smolts Release size‐ 45 grams yearling; 11 grams sub‐yearling Release location‐ Okanogan River Omak Acclimation Pond (yearlings) Omak Acclimation Pond (sub‐yearlings) Riverside Acclimation Pond (yearlings) Similkameen Acclimation Pond (yearlings) Release date‐ mid‐late April 2015 (yearlings); mid‐June 2014 (sub‐yearlings) *‐ Contingency collection location based on degree of short‐fall by end of the third week of August. Initiate collection at Wells to attain 75% of end of August collection target. Research/Monitoring/Evaluation Address Key Management Questions Is the hatchery meeting targeted production and within hatchery performance standards? Are hatchery post‐release survival standards being achieved? What is the current status/trends of the naturally‐ spawning population in terms of VSP? What is the current status/trends for hatchery returns and harvest/adult management? Are hatchery program Biological Targets being achieved? Are assumptions about natural production potential valid? 15 Research/Monitoring/Evaluation (Cont.) Facilitate Adaptive Management Within Scientific Framework Assess the validity of Program Key Assumptions Adjust Program Key Assumptions if warranted Provide and update Program Biological Targets, consistent with Program Key Assumptions and hatchery and population status and trends Annually, utilize the In‐Season Implementation Tool (ISIT) to adaptively manage the program CJH program will be implemented through A science “Framework” defined by Key Assumptions, and supported by: Annual Status and Trends updates and In‐season Biological Targets and Informed Decision Making, through adaptive management of which this APR is an important component A unified closely coordinated management program that incorporates mitigation for FCRPS, and mid‐Columbia PUDs Thank you! 16 Adaptive Management Implemented [PRE-SEASON] WORK PLAN UPDATED WORK PLAN (MQ 8) APPT MQ 5 MQ 6 MQ 7 ∙ STATUS AND TRENDS (MQ 1, 2) ∙ PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION (MQ 3) ∙ PROGRAM PERFORMANCE (MQ 4, 5) ANNUAL REPORT ∙ PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS (MQ 6) ∙ RESEARCH ->KEY ASSUMPTIONS (MQ 7) 17 DOCUMENTATION IN-SEASON UPDATES MQ 4 DATA ANALYSIS MQ 3 MONITORING AND EVALUATION, FORECAST MQ 1 MQ 2 2015 MANAGEMENT TARGETS ANNUAL PROGRAM REVIEW DECISION RULES FIELD WORK AND DATA COLLECTION IN-SEASON IMPLEMENTATION TOOL MANAGEMENT QUESTIONS ISIT and the Annual Program Review In-Season Implementation Tool Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Key Assumptions (Working Hypothesis) Status and Trends Decision Rules Biological and Management Targets Annual Program Review Results from Research and M&E, External to Program Results from Program M&E Conservation and Harvest Goals Pre-season Forecast Post-Season Performance Review --Run Reconstruction M&E Results 18 In-Season Updates This page intentionally left blank. 2015 Chief Joseph Hatchery Annual Program Review Part 2 – 2014 Year-in-Review 19 This page intentionally left blank. APR Part 2: 2014 Year-in-Review 2a. Hatchery Production Program (2014 Year-in-Review) Pat Phillips Program Goals • Mitigation production obligations (Chelan, Douglas, Grant PUDs and BPA): o 900,000 spring Chinook o 2,000,000 summer Chinook (1.3M yearlings, 0.7M subyearlings) • CJH Summer Chinook Program Goals o Integrated Enhance natural-origin population Re-establish late-arriving population and improve spawner distribution Provide Tribal and non-tribal harvest opportunities o Segregated: provide consistent Tribal and non-tribal harvest opportunities • CJH Spring Chinook Program Goals o Integrated (“experimental population”) Enhance recovery of UCR spring Chinook Reserve population in case of failure at Methow facility Provide Tribal and non-tribal harvest opportunities o Segregated: provide Tribal and non-tribal harvest opportunities • Hatchery Program Guiding Principles o Conservation principles: PNI, pHOS, stray rates o Aggressive disease management o Integrated program size varies with status of NOR abundance o Adaptively manage program using M&E program data Rearing • Integrated Summer Chinook Rearing – BY 2013 o Subyearlings: 186K released May 2014 at 46 fpp from Omak Pond o Yearlings: 500K at CJH, 300K at Omak Pond, 200K at Similkameen Pond • Segregated Summer Chinook Rearing – BY 2013 o Subyearlings: 257K released May 2014 at 50 fpp o Yearlings: 417K at CJH at 18 fpp • Segregated Spring Chinook Rearing – BY 2013 o CJH: 515K at 20 fpp; 94% cumulative rearing survival o Riverside Pond: 200K at 28 fpp 20 Broodstock Collection and Eggtake • CJH Summer Chinook Broodstock Collection – BY 2014 o 663 NOR (341 Fem, 313 Male, 9 Jacks) o 558 HOR (293 Fem, 258 Male, 7 Jacks) o Survival to spawn (non-jacks) 73-85% • CJH Summer Chinook Egg Take – BY 2014 o 76% of target (1.8M eyed eggs of 2.36M target) o Contributing factors: Lower survival to spawn and fecundity than expected ELISA culling rate • Segregated Spring Chinook Broodstock Collection and Egg Take – BY 2014 o Broodstock collection at Leavenworth NFH (640 adults) o Survival to spawn: 34% (66 Fem, 143 Male) – low due to Columnaris o Eyed-egg take: 788K (75% of target) at Leavenworth and Carson NFH 2b. Spring Chinook 10(j) Process and Approval, Chuck Brushwood • Request to reintroduce UCR spring Chinook into the Okanogan River using ESA 10(j) (experimental, non-essential designation) submitted to NOAA in November 2010 • Under Section 10(j): “experimental” designation if reintroduction is outside current range of species. This allows for more flexible management of the reintroduced population. • Objectives: o Increase spatial structure and abundance of UCR spring Chinook ESU o Reduce proportion of hatchery-origin spring Chinook in Methow Basin o Meet ESA obligations • Request approved and final rule published by NMFS in October 2014 • First releases will be in April 2015 (BY 2013) 2c. Brood Collection, RM&E (2014 Year-in Review) Mike Rayton, Casey Baldwin • Management Issue and Questions o Issue: Late fall run Chinook are being counted at Wells Dam o Question 1: Are unmarked Priest River Hatchery (PRH) fall Chinook showing up in the late collected brood? o Question 2: What is the abundance and proportion of PRH fall Chinook in the CJH ladder? • Results – 2014 o Question 1: In 2014, 76 brood collected late at the weir; 69 spawned 68 otoliths examined; 67 negative, 1 no data. 21 No evidence of unmarked PRH Chinook in late collected brood o Question 2: 603 HORs at CJH Ladder (July-Nov 2014) Ad-present fish: estimated 10% from PRH (59/603) CWT only: estimated 3% from PRH (16/603) • 2015 Recommendations o Analyze RMIS data for ad-clip groups o Repeat otolith evaluation of September 2015 brood o Repeat CCT lab analysis of CWT-only fish collected at ladder o Add PIT tag evaluation to the analysis? o Additional management questions for consideration: If brood are needed from the CJH ladder, what is the best way to minimize risk from PRH strays? Do we want to intentionally propagate “fall” run timing into the program? 2d. Research, Monitoring and Evaluation Programs (2014 Year-in Review) Andrea P., Casey B., John R. Okanogan Rotary Screw Trapping • Monitoring Objectives o Monitor juvenile outmigration abundance and timing o PIT tag juveniles: estimate SAR of natural-origin smolts • 2014 Results o Daily trapping from March 31 to June 28 o Captured 28,851 Chinook (6,777 hatchery, 22,074 wild); PIT tagged 382 fish o Peak outmigration in May and June o Efficiency trials (2 traps operating) ~ 1% recapture rate • 2015 Objectives o Extend trapping season (begin earlier, continue through July) o More efficiency trials to estimate recapture rate Beach Seining and Tagging Operations • Monitoring Objectives o Supplement RST juvenile tagging o SAR estimates, outmigration timing o Adult run size, timing, age composition, gear effects • 2014 Results o 9,133 fish captured o 10% mortality: 5% before tagging, 5% after tagging 22 o Tracked travel times through FCRPS Dams o Larger fish had shorter travel times to Rocky Reach Dam Okanogan Pilot Weir • Weir Objectives o Tet operations, design, and effects on fish (handling, passage, live release) o Estimate adult run timing, abundance o Broodstock collection - NORs o Manage pHOS, PNI • 2014 Results o Weir operated August- Sept when flows < 3,000 cfs o Video monitoring and downstream/upstream fish behavior observations o Daily water quality monitoring (flows, temperature, DO, turbidity, gage height) o Trap totals: 2,219 adult Chinook; 105 jack Chinook; 96 adult sockeye • 2015 Objectives o Continue to monitor fish behavior, water quality, entrainment, and weir effectiveness o Perform live video monitoring to provide real time updates on trap operations Acoustic Evaluation of Sockeye Passage at Pilot Weir • Study Objectives o Is weir delaying sockeye migration, and to what extent? • Methods o Acoustic and PIT tags inserted at Wells Dam o Receivers deployed downstream and upstream of weir location o Travel time compared before and after weir installation • Results o 100% survival from downstream to upstream of weir o Travel time increased post-weir installation, but other factors (flows, water temperature) also changed o Weir appears to cause a slight delay for late arriving sockeye, but not a biologically significant delay Spawning Ground Surveys • Purpose of Monitoring o Estimate escapement – NORs, HORs o Monitor age structure, fish size, spawn timing, and spatial distribution of redds • Methods o Weekly surveys from early October through mid-November (raft, aircraft) 23 o Surveys on Okanogan R. from mouth to Zosel Dam; Similkameen R. from Driscoll Channel to Enloe Dam • 2014 Results o Spawn timing: majority of redds located in first two weeks of October o Majority of redds located in Okanogan from Riverside Bridge to Zosel Dam and lower Similkameen reach (similar to 2012 and 2013 results) Spawning Ground Carcass Analysis • Purpose of Analysis o Estimate pHOS, egg voidance, straying/homing rates, trends in measurable variables like fish length • Methods o Carcasses collected opportunistically during redd surveys and after surveys were completed o Total sampled: 2,452 carcasses (20% sample rate). • 2014 Results o pHOS (based on 5-year running average) has improved o 2014 pHOS was the lowest yet recorded (13%), and less than the target of 30% in all sampled reaches with > 2 recovered carcasses o Stray rate: <5% of HOS from other systems o SAR for BY 2008 was 0.027 (above the long term average) o The proportion of Similkameen program Chinook spawning in other systems is generally low, but is often greater than 5% in the Chelan River o Most HORs and NORs spawn after 3 years in the ocean o Estimated spawning abundance: 10,602 NOS, 1,561 HOS Genetic Analyses • Environmental DNA (eDNA) o 2013 tributary sampling o 2014 basin-wide sampling o 2015 – no sampling planned • Parental-based Tagging (PBT) o Genetic samples collected during Chinook spawning (CJH) o In cooperation with CRITFC 2e. Zosel Adult Passage Video Monitoring Review, Sonya Schaller • Project Goals o Monitor abundance and trends of adults passing Zosel Dam o These estimates contribute to escapement estimates on specific tributaries 24 • Methods o Year-round operation of video equipment from 2005-2015 o Count steelhead, sockeye, Chinook, and coho • Results – Chinook o Peak Chinook counts in October o Recent adult Chinook totals: 2,022 in 2013; 1,614 in 2014 o Also collect data on natural vs. hatchery origin, run timing, gender, jacks, fall-backs, fish size, PIT tags, etc. o Chinook NOR composition has averaged about 80% o The proportion of jacks has decreased from about 35% in 2011 to around 20% in 2014 o New research on fallbacks/reascensions in 2014 PIT tagged fish had 57.7% fallback/reascension rate (26 PIT tagged adults) Use this rate to adjust the video counts downward to remove double counting 2f. Habitat Monitoring – 2014 EDT Updates, John Arterburn 25 Notes 26 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 27 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 28 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 29 This page intentionally left blank. 2015 Chief Joseph Hatchery Annual Program Review Part 3 – Current and Future Program Management 30 This page intentionally left blank. Adaptive Management and Scientific Framework Program Goals for Conservation and Harvest Key Management Questions Research, Monitoring and Evaluation Program Analytical Tools (ISIT) Annual Review and Planning Process • Are program goals being met? 31 Adaptive Management Implemented [PRE‐SEASON] WORK PLAN UPDATED WORK PLAN (MQ 8) APPT MANAGEMENT QUESTIONS FIELD WORK AND DATA COLLECTION 2015 MANAGEMENT TARGETS ANNUAL PROGRAM REVIEW MQ 6 MQ 7 DOCUMENTATION ANNUAL REPORT ∙ STATUS AND TRENDS (MQ 1, 2) ∙ PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION (MQ 3) ∙ PROGRAM PERFORMANCE (MQ 4, 5) ∙ PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS (MQ 6) ∙ RESEARCH ‐>KEY ASSUMPTIONS (MQ 7) 32 IN‐SEASON UPDATES MQ 5 DECISION RULES MQ 4 IN‐SEASON IMPLEMENTATION TOOL MQ 3 DATA ANALYSIS MQ 2 MONITORING AND EVALUATION, FORECAST MQ 1 Conservation and Harvest Goals • Biological Targets for Okanogan Summer Chinook population: • • • • • 7,500 total spawners—5,250 natural origin spawners (NOS) Total pHOS (all programs) < 30% Segregated program pHOS <5% PNI > 0.67 Increase temporal and spatial diversity of spawning/rearing • Harvest Goals: • Harvest full allocation (2015 = 5‐7,000 adult summer/fall Chinook) • Increase % of individual tribal member harvest 33 Key Management Questions • RM&E program is designed to address KMQs and provide data to facilitate adaptive management process Key Management Questions 1. What is the current status and recent historical trend of the naturally‐spawning population in terms of VSP parameters? 2. What is the current status and recent historical trend for hatchery returns and harvest? 3. Is the hatchery program meeting target in‐hatchery performance standards? 4. Are the hatchery post‐release targets met for survival and total catch contribution? 5. Are targets for catch contribution and selectivity for HORs met in Fisheries above Wells Dam? 6. Are negative effects of the hatchery on the natural population outweighed by benefits? 7. Are assumptions about natural production potential valid? 8. How should the program be operated in the coming year? 34 Adaptive Management and Scientific Framework • Given the most recent information and expected adult returns, how should the population be managed in the coming season? • To ensure scientific defensibility, a decision tree has been created based on a working hypothesis to answer this question. • The decision tree is incorporated into the In‐Season Implementation Tool (ISIT) 35 Components of the ISIT • Updated management database • Key Assumptions about the population (working hypothesis) • Status and Trends data • Biological Targets • Decision Rules • Management Targets for upcoming season 36 ISIT and the Annual Program Review In‐Season Implementation Tool Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Key Assumptions (Working Hypothesis) Status and Trends Decision Rules Biological and Management Targets Annual Program Review Results from Research and M&E, External to Program Results from Program M&E Conservation and Harvest Goals Pre‐season Forecast Post‐Season Performance Review ‐‐Run Reconstruction M&E Results 37 In‐Season Updates Key Assumptions NaturalProduction Productivity(Smolts/Spawner) Capacity(Smolts) JuvPassageSurvival OceanSurvival AdultPassageSurvival Fitness PNI TotalpHOS Segr.pHOS OceanHarvestRate LowerColumbiaHarvestRate(Zones1‐6,MouthtoMCN) UpperColumbiaHarvestRate(MCNtoWells) TerminalHarvestRate(PostWells) NaturalOriginSpawners HatcheryProduction LocalBrood YearlingRelease Sub‐yearlingRelease SAR(yearling) SAR(sub‐yearling) ReturnRatetoOkanogan pNOB NOB RelativeReproductiveSuccess OceanHarvestRate LowerColumbiaHarvestRate(Zones1‐6,MouthtoMCN) UpperColumbiaHarvestRate(MCNtoWells) Pre‐terminalHarvestRate(OceantoWells) TerminalHarvestRate(PostWells) HatcherySurplus AverageTerminalHORRun ExpectedHOS 38 Baseline 969 807,784 27.00% 4.10% 83.00% 0.71 0.59 46% 2% 43% 5% 2% 3% 2,644 324 576,000 ‐ 1.43% 0.30% 98% 50% 162 80% 43% 10% 10% 54% 30% 0 3,832 2,631 Integ Biological Targets Transition 1 969 807,784 27.00% 4.10% 83.00% 0.85 < 0.67 0.71 > 30% 42% < 5% 1% 43% 5% 2% 3% < 5,250 2,542 7,500 613 800,000 300,000 1.43% 0.30% 98% 100% 613 80% 43% 10% 10% 54% 30% 2,281 5,322 1,827 Status and Trends 6,000 100% 5,000 80% Catch 4,000 60% 3,000 40% 2,000 Harvest Rates Terminal Harvest 20% 1,000 ‐ 0% 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 CCT Recreational NOR HOR Hatchery Releases and Returns 800,000 4,000 700,000 14,000 600,000 12,000 500,000 3,000 400,000 300,000 2,000 200,000 1,000 100,000 ‐ NOR Escapement 5,000 Smolts released HOR Returns to Wells Dam 6,000 10,000 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 HOR Returns to Wells Dam Predicted Okanogan NOR run from early Wells Dam counts 0 Integrated Hatchery Releases 10,000 20,000 Dam Count 39 30,000 40,000 Decision Rules Purpose of Decision Rules: • Determine program phase (currently in Transition 1) • Calculate Management Targets for upcoming season: • • • • • Escapement: targets for NOS and HOS Harvest: targets for NORs and HORs Weir: removal targets for HORs Smolt releases: size of Integrated program varies Broodstock collection: # of NORS and HORs, pNOB‐ Integrated program • Management Targets are designed to help the program meet its Conservation and Harvest Goals over the long term 40 Decision Rules DECISIONRULES Criteriafortransitions: Current‐>Transition1 Transition1‐>Transition2 Transition2‐>LongTerm 2014‐Facilitiescompletedandtested,fullbroodavailable 2019or5000NORs(5‐yearrollingaverage) 2027‐ 5‐yearrunningaverageNORs: SelectaPhase: 8,232 Transition 1 BiologicalTargetsfortheSelectedPhase↓ Transition 1 Integrated Program Segregated Program MinimumNORescapement Smallestviablehatcheryprogram Max%ofNORusedforBroodstock MaxNumberYearlings MaxNumberSub‐yearlings pNOBTrigger(NORrun) pNOB MaxNumberYearlings MaxNumberSub‐yearlings Backfillw/HORs(Y,N) Baseline Transition 1 Transition 2 Long-term 800 800 800 800 800 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 30% 30% 30% 30% 30% 800,000 215,000 800,000 1,000,000 1,000,000 1,100 300,000 300,000 1,100 1,100 1,100 1,100 100% 100% 100% 30% 30% 500,000 600,000 600,000 500,000 - 400,000 400,000 N N 41 N N N Decision Rules (sliding scale of pHOS and pNOB) pHOS (proportion of Hatchery Origin Spawners) • If pHOS > 0.5 • If pHOS 0.10‐0.25 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.05 1 53% 56% 59% 63% 67% 71% 77% 83% 91% 95% 0.9 50% 53% 56% 60% 64% 69% 75% 82% 90% 95% then pNOB = 1.0 then pNOB > 0.5 0.8 47% 50% 53% 57% 62% 67% 73% 80% 89% 94% pNOB (proportion of Natural Origin Broodstock) 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 44% 40% 36% 31% 25% 47% 43% 38% 33% 27% 50% 46% 42% 36% 30% 54% 50% 45% 40% 33% 58% 55% 50% 44% 38% 64% 60% 56% 50% 43% 70% 67% 63% 57% 50% 78% 75% 71% 67% 60% 88% 86% 83% 80% 75% 93% 92% 91% 89% 86% 42 0.2 18% 20% 22% 25% 29% 33% 40% 50% 67% 80% 0.1 10% 11% 13% 14% 17% 20% 25% 33% 50% 67% 0.0 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Decision Rules DECISIONRULES Criteriafortransitions: Current‐>Transition1 Transition1‐>Transition2 Transition2‐>LongTerm 2014‐Facilitiescompletedandtested,fullbroodavailable 2019or5000NORs(5‐yearrollingaverage) 2027‐ 5‐yearrunningaverageNORs: SelectaPhase: 8,232 Transition 1 BiologicalTargetsfortheSelectedPhase↓ Transition 1 Integrated Program Segregated Program MinimumNORescapement Smallestviablehatcheryprogram Max%ofNORusedforBroodstock MaxNumberYearlings MaxNumberSub‐yearlings pNOBTrigger(NORrun) pNOB MaxNumberYearlings MaxNumberSub‐yearlings Backfillw/HORs(Y,N) Baseline Transition 1 Transition 2 Long-term 800 800 800 800 800 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 30% 30% 30% 30% 30% 800,000 215,000 800,000 1,000,000 1,000,000 1,100 300,000 300,000 1,100 1,100 1,100 1,100 100% 100% 100% 30% 30% 500,000 600,000 600,000 500,000 - 400,000 400,000 N N 43 N N N Management Targets for 2015 MANAGEMENTTARGETS 2014 Use 5 RecentHistory: AverageNOB AverageHOB AveragepNOB yearaverage ManagementTargetsbasedonOkanoganNORForecast 287 101 74% AverageNOS 5,785 AverageHOS 2,350 AveragepHOS 29% AveragePNI 0.72 ExpectedReturnstoWellsDam(mostrecentupdate): NORReturn HORsfromIntegratedProgram HORsfromSegregatedProgram <‐‐Mostrecentyearincludedinrunningaverages 10,296 3,823 ‐ RunsizePredictionfor: 2015 Preseasonforecast(Columbia) 73,000 Appliesuntil: 7/15 WellsDamCountthru7/15 ‐ OkanoganNORForecast: 10,296 HORForecast: 3,823 Harvest* Hatchery andWeir* Integrated Hatchery Program Segregated Hatchery Natural Spawning Escapement HORsretainedinFisheries IncidentalLossofNORs *Partialsourceofbroodstock ReturnofHORstoHatchery HORsretainedatWeir *Partialsourceofbroodstock NaturalOriginBrood(NOB) Hatch.OriginBrood(HOB)‐Okan ProjectedAnnualpNOB‐Okan CumpNOB SmoltRelease‐Okanogan 1,147 246 51 1,313 613 0 100% 88% 1,100,000 Hatch.OriginBrood(HOB)‐CJH SmoltRelease‐CJH 498 900,000 Nat.OriginSpawners(NOS) Hat.OriginSpawners(HOS) TotalNumberofSpawners 9,438 1,313 10,750 pHOS PNI 10% 0.91 ProjectedStatusofBiologicalIndicators*: AverageNOS 7,034 AveragepHOS 23% AveragePNI 0.79 *ExpectedvaluesofBiologicalTargetsifManagementTargetsaremet. 44 What do we expect to achieve under this plan? • Increased abundance of NORs • Meet pHOS and PNI targets • Increased harvest opportunities STATUSOFBIOLOGICALINDICATORS(5‐yearRunningAverages) NOS pHOS PNI Program BiologicalTargets 5,250 30% 0.67 Statusin2014 5,785 29% 0.72 45 ProjectedStatus in2015 7,034 23% 0.79 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 46 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 47 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 48 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 49 This page intentionally left blank. 2015 Chief Joseph Hatchery Annual Program Review Part 4 – Annual Work Plan, CJHP Implementation 50 This page intentionally left blank. Adaptive Management Implemented [PRE-SEASON] WORK PLAN UPDATED WORK PLAN (MQ 8) APPT MQ 5 MQ 6 MQ 7 ∙ STATUS AND TRENDS (MQ 1, 2) ∙ PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION (MQ 3) ∙ PROGRAM PERFORMANCE (MQ 4, 5) ANNUAL REPORT ∙ PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS (MQ 6) ∙ RESEARCH ->KEY ASSUMPTIONS (MQ 7) 51 DOCUMENTATION IN-SEASON UPDATES MQ 4 DATA ANALYSIS MQ 3 MONITORING AND EVALUATION, FORECAST MQ 1 MQ 2 2015 MANAGEMENT TARGETS ANNUAL PROGRAM REVIEW DECISION RULES FIELD WORK AND DATA COLLECTION IN-SEASON IMPLEMENTATION TOOL MANAGEMENT QUESTIONS ISIT and the Annual Program Review In-Season Implementation Tool Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Key Assumptions (Working Hypothesis) Status and Trends Decision Rules Biological and Management Targets Annual Program Review Results from Research and M&E, External to Program Results from Program M&E Conservation and Harvest Goals Pre-season Forecast Post-Season Performance Review --Run Reconstruction M&E Results 52 In-Season Updates Key Management Questions Status and Trends: Implementation: Performance: Effectiveness: Research: Action Plan: 1. What is the current status and recent historical trend of the naturally-spawning population in terms of Viable Salmonid Population (VSP) parameters? 2. What is the current status and recent historical trend for hatchery returns and harvest? 3. Is the hatchery program meeting target in-hatchery performance standards? 4. Are the hatchery post-release targets met for survival and total catch contribution? 5. Are targets for catch contribution and selectivity for HORs met in Fisheries above Wells Dam? 6. Are negative effects of the hatchery on the natural population outweighed by benefits? 7. Are assumptions about natural production potential valid? 8. How should the program be operated in the coming year? KMQ 1 KMQ 2 STATUS AND TRENDS Progress Toward VSP Goal? KMQ 3 IMPLEMENTATION Management Targets Met? KMQ 4 KMQ 5 PERFORMANCE Are Biological Targets Met? KMQ 6 EFFECTIVENESS Do Benefits Outweigh Risks? KMQ 7 RESEARCH STUDIES Key Assumptions Tested? ANNUAL REPORT Adresses KMQs 1-7 a. Record/review VSP targets for the affected natural populations. b. Annual estimates of: spawner abundance, distribution, composition (origin, age, and sex) c. Annual estimates of: total adult equivalent recruitment of NORs by age (brood year) d. Annually updated estimates of recruits per spawner e. Updated estimates of spawner-recruit relationship from empirical observations (a-c) f. Compare estimates of VSP parameters to their targets (hypothesis test) UPDATED ANNUAL ACTION PLAN (KMQ 8) KEY MANAGEMENT QUESTIONS R M&E Activities required to answer the Key Management Questions 1. What is the current status and recent historical trend of the naturally-spawning population in terms of Viable Salmonid Population (VSP) parameters? 2. What is the current status and recent historical trend for hatchery returns and harvest? a. Annual estimates of: smolt releases by age/size for each hatchery program b. Annual estimates of: total adult equivalent recruitment of HORs by brood year for each hatchery program c. Annual contribution to defined fisheries for each hatchery program by brood year 3. Is the hatchery program meeting target in-hatchery performance standards? a. Record of pre-season targets for broodstock selection, mating protocols, life stage survival, marking and genetic sampling b. Annual record of number and source of broodstock spawned c. Record of mating protocols d. Annual estimates of fecundity by age and broodstock source (NOB, HOB) e. Annual estimates of survival by life stage for each program and egg lot f. Record of marking and sampling activities and results g. Annually updated estimates of: pNOB and smolts per spawner for each hatchery program 4. Are the hatchery post-release targets met for survival and total catch contribution? a. Record of pre-season targets for SAR, catch contribution by fishery, maximum contribution to non-Okanogan natural spawning, maximum rate of straying to the Okanogan from CJH released fish, minimum return rate of fish released into the Okanogan River. b. Compare annual estimates from 2. a, b, c to targets in 4.a. View targets as testable hypotheses. 5. Are targets for catch contribution and selectivity for HORs met in Fisheries above Wells Dam? a. Record of target for harvest of HORs from each hatchery program and maximum harvest related mortality to Okanogan NORs by fishery above Wells Dam b. Annually estimate catch and harvest related mortality of HORs and NORs by fishery and gear type and compare to targets. 6. Are negative effects of the hatchery on the natural population outweighed by benefits? 53 a. Record of pre-season targets for maximum contribution to non-Okanogan natural spawning, maximum rate of straying to the Okanogan from CJH released fish, minimum return rate of fish released into the Okanogan River. b. Annually estimate (and compare to targets in 6a) the number of strays from each CJH program to each neighboring population relative to the maximum contribution targets for those populations. View targets as testable hypotheses. c. Annually estimate (and compare to target in 6a) the contribution of each hatchery program to the Okanogan natural escapement--view target as a testable hypothesis. d. Annully evaluate whether hatchery contribution rates to natural spawning are meeting or exceeding HSRG standards for pHOS and PNI for all affected populations. e. Periodically evaluate whether long term targets for conservation and harvest could be met w/o one or more of the hatchery programs. 7. Are assumptions about natural production potential valid? a. Review/update habitat based natural production potential (EDT) b. Review/update assumptions about relative reproductive success of hatchery origin spawners in the wild c. Review/update assumptions about fitness effects of hatchery fish on the naturally spawning population d. Test theoretical natural production potential (based on EDT and Ford genetic fitness) against observed spawner recruit observations. 8. How should the program be operated in the coming year? a. Conduct annual program review (APR) b. Annually refine runsize forecasting and in-season updating methods c. Obtain/collect dam counts and other data as prescribed by the forecasting/updating methods d. Periodically, during the pre-season, update estimated return of Okanogan and CJH origin returns above Wells each year e. Update annual work plan based on most recent results from the RM&E program and the current run forecast. 54 Annual Workplan Sections APR Section # 110 120 130 141 142 151 152 161 162 171 172 181 182 183 190 210 220 230 240 250 261 262 270 Links to KMQs and ISIT Components Work Element Number (BPA) Work Element Name (BPA) 1.1 Produce Environmental Compliance Documentation - Environmental Compliance 165 Produce Environmental Compliance Documentation 1.3 Produce Pisces Status Report - Periodic Status Reports for BPA 185 Produce Pisces Status Report Task 1.2 Administrative Oversight of the Chief Joseph Hatchery M&E Program 119 Manage and Administer Projects 2.4 Assimilate and Analyze ISIT Input Parameters 2.5 Annual Program Review 2.6.1 Produce (Annual) Progress Report Finalize Annual Report from Previous Contract 2.6.1 Produce (Annual) Progress Report Prepare Draft Annual Progress Report (current contract) 2.7 Produce BiOp RPA Report - Biop RPA Reporting NA NA C NA NA NA NA pHOS, PNI pNOB Analyze/Interpret Data I Weir effectiveness pHOS, PNI pNOB 157 Collect/Generate/Validate Field and Lab Data Analyze/Interpret Data J NOS, HOS, % jacks Stray rates (contribute to RMIS database) pHOS, NOS, PNI K NOS, HOS, % jacks Stray rates (contribute to RMIS database) pHOS, NOS, PNI Effectiveness /Other L Spring Chinook presence M Columbia Basin PBT database Analyze/Interpret Data N Spring Chinook presence O Harvest data Analyze/Interpret Data P % Okanogan origin returns, % Okanogan origin harvest Stray rate 156 Develop RM&E Methods and Designs Q R NA NA NA NA 162 Analyze/Interpret Data S Update ISIT Update ISIT Update ISIT Update ISIT T NA NA NA NA Produce (Annual) Progress Report U NA NA NA NA 132 Produce (Annual) Progress Report V NA NA NA NA 202 Produce BiOp RPA Report W NA NA NA NA 162 2.3 Database and Module Maintenance and Enhancement-Summit (contractor) NA Weir effectiveness 1.8.3 Analysis of Water Samples for eDNA 2.2 Study Design on Delayed Adult Mortality at CJH Collection Sites NA H Collect/Generate/Validate Field and Lab Data Collect/Generate/Validate Field and Lab Data 2.1 Retrieve and Analyze CWT Information B See above (WE D) 157 1.9 Estimate Tribal Harvest for Summer/Fall Chinook NA G 1.8.1 Collect Water Samples for eDNA 1.8.2 Collect Tissue Samples for PBT NA Analyze/Interpret Data Mark/Tag Animals 157 162 NA See above (WE D) 162 1.7.2 Analyze Data for Summer/Fall Chinook Spawning Ground Surveys Steelhead take F 1.5.2 Analyze PIT Tag Data 1.7.1 Conduct Spawning Ground Surveys for Summer/Fall Chinook A See above (WE D) 162 162 Implementation /Management Targets E 1.4.2 Analyze Juvenile Chinook Emigration 1.6.2 Analyze Results of Weir Monitoring Performance /Biological Targets Analyze/Interpret Data Collect/Generate/Validate Field and Lab Data 1.6.1 Okanogan River Temporary Weir Operations Research /Key Assumptions For natural origin fish: SAR, juvenile and adult fish passage survival, outmigration timing, adult run timing, stray rates 157 158 Status and Trends D 1.4.1 Monitor Juvenile Chinook Emigration With Rotary Screw Trap 1.5.1 PIT Tag Subyearling Juvenile Chinook Work Element in SOW 157 157 162 160 161 132 Collect/Generate/Validate Field and Lab Data Collect/Generate/Validate Field and Lab Data Create/Manage/Maintain Database Disseminate Raw/Summary Data and Results 55 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 56 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 57 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 58 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 59 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 60 This page intentionally left blank. Notes 61 This page intentionally left blank. 2015 Chief Joseph Hatchery Annual Program Review Appendices 62 This page intentionally left blank. Glossary of Terms and Variables The following is a list of key terms and variables used in the CJHP: HOS = the number of hatchery-origin fish spawning naturally. NOS = the number of natural origin fish spawning naturally. NOB = the number of natural-origin fish used as hatchery broodstock. HOB = the number of hatchery origin fish used as hatchery broodstock. HORs = hatchery-origin recruits. The number of HORs equals the sum of HOS + HOB + hatchery-origin fish intercepted in fisheries. NORs = natural origin recruits. The number of NORs equals the sum of NOB, + NOS + natural-origin fish intercepted in fisheries. pHOS = proportion of natural spawners composed of HORs. Equals HOS/(NOS + HOS). pNOB = proportion of hatchery broodstock composed of NORs. Equals NOB/(HOB + NOB) PNI = proportion of natural influence on a composite hatchery-/natural-origin population. Can also be thought of as the percentage of time the genes of a composite population spend in the natural environment. Equals 1 pNOB/(pNOB + pHOS). SAR = smolt to adult return. 63 This page intentionally left blank. Chief Joseph Hatchery Production Plan Brood Year: Species: Stock: Origin: Program: 2015 Summer Chinook - Early Okanogan Wild Integrated Planting Goal: Pounds: 360,000 Egg Take Goal: 267,000 26,700 158 Adult Goal: Estimated Release Data: Start Date: 04/15/17 Notes: Rearing Summary: Species EA SU Chinook YR End Date: 04/30/17 Num Released fish per lb. Wt. grams 267,000 10 45 Total weight (lb.) Total weight (kg) Life Stage 26,700 12,015 yearlings Release Site Similkameen Number Eyed Eggs 314,280 Number Ponded 298,566 Fed Fry 283,638 Released 267,000 Location Similkameen Egg take goal includes 3% for culling. Adult Goal includes 10% pre-spawn mortality 10% Green to Eyed egg mortality Rearing mortality is 16.7% Source Okanogan Date April Number Green Eggs 349,200 64 Mark Type Tagged Ad Clipped CWT Chief Joseph Hatchery Production Plan Brood Year: Species: Stock: Origin: Program: 2015 Summer Chinook - Late Okanogan Wild Integrated Planting Goal: Pounds: 765,000 Egg Take Goal: 566,000 32,600 340 Adult Goal: Estimated Release Data: Start Date: 04/15/17 05/15/16 Notes: Rearing Summary: Species EA SU Chinook YR EA SU Chinook Sub End Date: 04/30/17 06/01/16 Num Released fish per lb. Wt. grams 266,000 300,000 10 50 45 11 Total weight (lb.) Total weight (kg) Life Stage Release Site 26,600 6,000 11,970 3,300 yearlings sub-yearling Omak Omak Number Ponded 298,193 336,260 Fed Fry 283,283 319,447 Released 266,000 300,000 Location Omak Omak Egg take goal includes 3% for culling. Adult Goal includes 10% pre-spawn mortality 10% Green to Eyed egg mortality Rearing mortality is 15.7% for yearlings, 16.2% for subs. Source Okanogan Okanogan Date April June Number Green Eggs 348,764 393,287 Number Eyed Eggs 313,887 353,958 65 Mark Type Tagged Ad Clipped Ad Clipped CWT CWT Chief Joseph Hatchery Production Plan Brood Year: Species: Stock: Origin: Program: 2015 Summer Chinook - Late Okanogan Hatchery Segregated Planting Goal: Pounds: 620,000 Egg Take Goal: 450,000 29,000 276 Adult Goal: Estimated Release Data: Start Date: 04/15/17 05/15/16 Notes: Rearing Summary: Species EA SU Chinook YR EA SU Chinook Sub End Date: 04/30/17 06/01/16 Num Released fish per lb. Wt. grams 250,000 200,000 10 50 45 11 Total weight (lb.) Total weight (kg) Life Stage Release Site 25,000 4,000 11,250 2,200 yearlings sub-yearling CJ hatchery CJ hatchery Number Ponded 276,977 226,618 Fed Fry 263,128 215,287 Released 250,000 200,000 Location CJ Hatchery CJ Hatchery Egg take goal includes 5% for culling. Adult Goal includes 10% pre-spawn mortality 10% Green to Eyed egg mortality Rearing mortality is 14.4% for yearlings, 16.5% for subs. Source Okanogan Okanogan Date April June Number Green Eggs 323,950 265,050 Number Eyed Eggs 291,555 238,545 66 Mark Type Tagged Ad Clipped Ad Clipped Chief Joseph Hatchery Production Plan Brood Year: Species: Stock: Origin: Program: 2015 Summer Chinook - Early Okanogan Wild Integrated Planting Goal: Pounds: 360,000 Egg Take Goal: 266,000 26,600 158 Adult Goal: Estimated Release Data: Start Date: 04/15/17 Notes: Rearing Summary: Species EA SU Chinook YR End Date: 04/30/17 Num Released fish per lb. Wt. grams 266,000 10 45 Total weight (lb.) Total weight (kg) Life Stage 26,600 11,970 yearlings Release Site Riverside Number Eyed Eggs 314,280 Number Ponded 298,566 Fed Fry 283,638 Released 266,000 Location Riverside Egg take goal includes 3% for culling. Adult Goal includes 10% pre-spawn mortality 10% Green to Eyed egg mortality Rearing mortality is 16.7% Source Okanogan Date April Number Green Eggs 349,200 67 Mark Type Tagged Ad Clipped CWT Chief Joseph Hatchery Production Plan Brood Year: Species: Stock: Origin: Program: 2015 Summer Chinook - Early Okanogan Hatchery Segregated Planting Goal: Pounds: 620,000 Egg Take Goal: 450,000 29,000 276 Adult Goal: Estimated Release Data: Start Date: 04/15/17 05/15/16 Notes: Rearing Summary: Species EA SU Chinook YR EA SU Chinook Sub End Date: 04/30/17 06/01/16 Num Released fish per lb. Wt. grams 250,000 200,000 10 50 45 9 Total weight (lb.) Total weight (kg) Life Stage Release Site 25,000 4,000 11,250 1,800 yearlings sub-yearling CJ hatchery CJ hatchery Number Ponded 276,977 226,618 Fed fry 263,128 215,287 Released 250,000 200,000 Location CJ Hatchery CJ Hatchery Egg take goal includes 5% for culling. Adult Goal includes 10% pre-spawn mortality 10% Green to Eyed egg mortality Rearing mortality is 14.4% for yearlings, 16.5% for subs. Source Okanogan Okanogan Date April June Number Green Eggs 323,950 265,050 Number Eyed Eggs 291,555 238,545 68 Mark Type Tagged Ad Clipped Ad Clipped Chief Joseph Hatchery Production Plan Brood Year: Species: Stock: Origin: 2015 Spring Chinook Leavenworth Hatchery Planting Goal: Pounds: 1,094,400 Egg Take Goal: 700,000 46,667 640 Adult Goal: Estimated Release Data: Start Date: 04/15/17 Notes: Rearing Summary: Species Spring Chinook End Date: 04/30/17 Num Released fish per lb. Wt. grams 700,000 15 30 Total weight (lb.) Total weight (kg) Life Stage 46,667 21,000 yearlings Release Site CJ hatchery Number Eyed Eggs 787,968 Number Ponded 748,570 Fed Fry 711,141 Released 700,000 Location CJ Hatchery Egg take goal includes 20% for culling. Adult Goal includes 10% pre-spawn mortality 10% Green to Eyed egg mortality Rearing mortality is 15.5% Source Leavenworth Date April Number Green Eggs 875,520 69 Mark Type Tagged Ad Clipped Chief Joseph Hatchery Production Plan Brood Year: Species: Stock: Origin: 2015 Spring Chinook Met Comp Hatchery/Wild Planting Goal: Pounds: 326,800 Egg Take Goal: 200,000 13,333 190 Adult Goal: Estimated Release Data: Start Date: 04/15/17 Notes: Rearing Summary: Species Spring Chinook End Date: 04/30/17 Num Released fish per lb. Wt. grams 200,000 15 30 Total weight (lb.) Total weight (kg) Life Stage 13,333 6,000 yearlings Release Site Tonasket Pond Number Eyed Eggs 235,296 Number Ponded 223,531 Fed Fry 212,355 Released 200,000 Location Tonasket Egg take goal includes 20% for culling. Adult Goal includes 10% pre-spawn mortality 10% Green to Eyed egg mortality Rearing mortality is 15.8% Source Met Comp Date April Number Green Eggs 261,440 70 Mark Type Tagged Ad Clipped CWT 71 No rt h r Fo kC ol um aR bi r iv e Mica # * BR I T I S H C O LU MB I A A L B E RTA Upp er C Colu mbia ol um River bi a R ve r i Revelstoke # * # * n R iv er Riv er om ps o e r th i ve dR # *Kerr he a Th Fl a t F la rk Falls Fo # * Thompson M O N TA NA Lower Granite # *Little r ( ! # * Ice Harbor d ran G e er R Missoula iv e ( ! r Cl # *Dworshak ter Riv e r wa r a Cle Goose Fork Clea r wat No # * th Lewiston ar kF o rk Lower Snake River r de Ri v e n Ro Sn Main stem IDAHO Hells Canyon Colu mbia R iver OREGON Flathead Lake h John Day Hungry Horse Reservoir ut iv e r R Mcnary bia m Co lu # * So Kennewick Hungry Horse ad b ia Co l u m il R ive r Sa n po r er ! Pasco ( ( Richland ! (! U N I T E D S TAT E S OF AMERICA ve ut De sch es R Ri N ad # * Po wd e Oxbow r Riv er # * # *Brownlee Cascade # * # * Bend lhe u r Ma Ri r ve H ( ! r R i ve Nampa ( ! Sn ak e Boise Peak ve Ow Arrowrock # * # * Lucky ! ( Ri yh ee # * River Sn Upp er Sn ake River # * r Anderson Ranch en ry' a or sF Idaho Falls t Li R i ve tl e American Falls Pocatello WYO MING Modeled Dam State/Province Stream Centerline 0 50 100 N EVA DA 200 Miles Map Created: 22 JUN 11 Imagery: © 2010 MDA Information Systems, USGS, NASA # * ( ! City ± r ( ! Columbia River Treaty 2014/2024 Review Program Columbia River Watershed Dams CRT Region Jackson Lake Palisades # * ! ( # * k # * ke Owyhee B ois e d R i ve r M ! ( Springfield (! Deadwood oo zie R i ver en W er he Ri v t Fla Wil la m e t te Fo rk Noxon Rapids Falls Butte R iv er r th cK Monroe Street No S Eugene tia m Nine Post * # ## * Mile Falls Coeur * # * Spokane# d'Alene ! ( * Lake Upper R iver # * Pelton * Round # th an r rk S ou River Pelton Rereg C la Columbia Falls ! ( # * Fo r t h Sa n tia m R ive r Ri v er ive r No R ! ( Libby k as Salem e na y ck Willamette K o ot am er ot la C iv i ve r Cabinet Gorge # * Falls Lake # * Pend Oreille r The Dalles ai R Ri v e ! Gresham ( ( ! Portland # *Albeni en e ak Beaverton ( ! Ko a ( ! # *Wanapum Lower # * Monumental Priest # * Rapids m ki Ya ve r Hillsboro # * # *Bonneville # * ! ( # * R iv Ri ! ( Spoka Little Falls Rock Island # * Vancouver r # * ( Tieton Yakima! Lower o l C um b i a Columbia River River Le w is ve Riffe Lake ow litz R C er r Bumping Lake # * # * Long Lake Bonners Ferry WASHINGTON R ive ac s he Ri Kachess # *# *# *Cle Elum Grand Coulee Banks Lake River Keechelus er ne ( Wenatchee! n ay st r ve # * * # *# # *Chelan Sp okane P r ie Ri Rocky Reach Chief Joseph Pen d O reille- # *Priest Lake iv re ille R ve r an Lake Wells Chelan Koo tenai- Rivers Priest Lake dO Ri el n Pe ow Ch Ko o t e Seven Mile # * # * Waneta * # Boundary er iv R Box * # Can yo n River th Upper Bonnington # * # * # *# * Brilliant Arrow Lakes/ Hugh Keenleyside Colu mbia Me can Ri v e r Slocan Mid dle iv Lower Bonnington Corra Linn & Kootenay Canal Projects CANADA Dun Duncan 72 U TA H 73 Contact List: Colville Tribes / Chief Joseph Hatchery Program Updated: March 6, 2015 CCT BPA Contact Group Name Affiliation Phone Cell Phone E-mail Project Role [email protected] COTR / BPA Project Manager (503) 230-4193 [email protected] Contract Approval Manager (503) 230-4412 [email protected] Fish Biologist (RM&E Technical Support) [email protected] VP Environment, Fish and Wildlife [email protected] Director, BPA Fish and Wildlife (509) 978-8005 [email protected] Director, Fish and Wildlife (509) 422-7424 (509) 631-2134 [email protected] F&W Biologist CCT (509) 634-2110 (509) 427-1799 [email protected] Sr. Research Scientist Abraham Best III CCT (509) 634-1230 (509) 634-1230 [email protected] Fisheries Tech. Chuck Brushwood CCT (509) 422-7749 (509) 631-4605 charles,[email protected] Policy Analyst Tony Cleveland CCT (509) 689-0834 [email protected] Hatchery Tech. Teddy Cohen CCT (509) 634-1029 [email protected] Fisheries Tech. Vertis Campbell CCT (509) 634-1201 [email protected] Fisheries Tech. Lincoln Feddersen CCT (509) 634-2110 (509) 634-1232 [email protected] Hatchery Tech. Chris Fisher CCT (509) 422-7427 (509) 631-0773 [email protected] F&W Biologist Tatum Gunn CCT (509) 634-1345 (509) 634-1345 [email protected] Fisheries Tech. Kary Nichols CCT (509) 422-4782 (509) 631-1706 [email protected] Deputy Director, CCT F&W Andrea Pearl CCT (509) 422-7437 (509) 634-1364 [email protected] F&W Biologist John Rohrback CCT (509) 422-7523 (509) 634-1068 [email protected] F&W Biologist Patrick Phillips CCT (509) 631-1870 (509) 631-1870 [email protected] CJHP Manager Mike Rayton CCT (509) 422-7434 (509) 631-0525 [email protected] Selective Harvest Manager Kirk Truscott CCT (509) 664-1227 (509) 978-8031 [email protected] Hatchery Division Manager Francis Somday CCT (509) 634-2238 (509) 631-6100 [email protected] Administration - Executive Dir Sonya Schaller CCT (509) 422-7453 [email protected] F&W Biologist Brenda Schmidt CCT (509) 422-4580 (509) 634-1543 [email protected] OA III CJHP Jennifer Miller CCT (509) 422-7733 (509) 322-3012 [email protected] Fish Biologist/Data Analyst Bill Towey CCT (509) 838-1057 [email protected] CCT Policy Analyst Brian Miller CCT (509) 422-7739 (509) 322-3014 [email protected] F&W Biologist Michael O. Finley CCT (509) 634-2208 (509) 631-4887 [email protected] Chairman, Colville Business Council Cody Desautel CCT (509) 634-2249 [email protected] Land and Property Director Keith Kistler CCT (509) 422-7429 [email protected] Fisheries and Habitat Biologist Sheri Sears CCT (509) 634-2118 [email protected] Biologist/Policy Analyst Michelle Camposbasso CCT (509) 634-2106 [email protected] F&W Biologist Dave Roberts BPA / Portland (503) 230-4511 Peter Lofy BPA / Portland Russell Scranton BPA / Portland Lorri Bodi BPA / Portland Bill Maslen BPA / Portland Randy Friedlander CCT John Arterburn CCT Casey Baldwin (503) 936-2923 (503) 230-4452 (509) 634-1029 (509) 322-2453 74 Contact List: Colville Tribes / Chief Joseph Hatchery Program Updated: March 6, 2015 State/Federal/Tribal Agencies PUDs CCT Consultants Contact Group Name Affiliation Phone Cell Phone E-mail Project Role Dan Warren D.J. Warren & Associates Inc. (541) 929-4639 (541) 602-5950 [email protected] Contracted Project Manager Lars Mobrand D.J. Warren & Associates Inc. (206) 463-3849 (206) 919-3892 [email protected] Senior Biometrician Kevin Malone D.J. Warren & Associates Inc. (360) 353-4996 (425) 753-0011 [email protected] Senior Fisheries Biologist Jeannie Heltzel D.J. Warren & Associates Inc. (541) 974-7982 [email protected] Biometrician Jaze Zwarich Summit Environmental (250) 545-3672 (250) 938-4139 [email protected] Database Consultant Rebecca Lindskoog Summit Environmental (250) 545-3672 (250) 938-5528 [email protected] Database Consultant Shane Bickford DCPUD (509) 881-2208 [email protected] Fisheries and Research Biologist Keith Truscott CCPUD (509) 661-4183 [email protected] Natural Resources Director Tom Dresser GCPUD [email protected] Fisheries and Research Biologist David Duvall GCPUD [email protected] Fisheries and Research Biologist Deanne Pavlik-Kunkel GCPUD [email protected] Hatchery and Habitat Fisheries Program Supervisor Greg Mackey DCPUD (509) 884-7191 [email protected] Fisheries and Research Biologist Catherine Willard USDA-FS (509) 784-1511 [email protected] Resource Management - USDAFS Todd Pearsons GCPUD (509) 754-5088 [email protected] Fisheries and Research Biologist Alene Underwood CCPUD (509)-661-4364 (509)-881-5192 (509) 859-2862 [email protected] Hatchery Program Manager Jim Brown WDFW (509) 754-4624 [email protected] Region 2 Director, WDFW Craig Busack NOAA (503) 230-5412 [email protected] Genetic Research Dave Fast YN (509) 945-8460 [email protected] Recovery Coordinator Bill Gale USFWS (360) 425-6072 [email protected] USFWS Lynn Hatcher NOAA (509) 962-8911 [email protected] Fisheries and Research Biologist Jeff Korth WDFW (509) 765-8255 [email protected] Region 2 Fish Program Manager Ryan Fortier WDFW (509) 997-0048 [email protected] F&W Biologist Charlie Snow WDFW (509) 997-0048 [email protected] F&W Biologist Chris Moran WDFW (509) 664-3148 [email protected] F&W Biologist Matthew Laramie USGS (208) 426-5207 [email protected] Ecologist and MS Student Boise State University Andrew Murdoch WDFW (509) 664-3148 [email protected] F&W Biologist Keely Murdoch YN (509) 548-2206 [email protected] F&W Biologist Michael Humling USFWS (509) 996-2204 [email protected] F&W Biologist Mike Tonseth WDFW (509) 663-9678 [email protected] F&W Biologist (509) 945-8460 (208) 830-8530 75 Contact List: Colville Tribes / Chief Joseph Hatchery Program Updated: March 6, 2015 Other Interested Parties Contact Group Name Affiliation Phone Cell Phone E-mail Project Role Stacy Horton NPCC (509) 623-4386 [email protected] NPCC State Staff Kim Hyatt DFO (250) 756-7000 [email protected] Senior Research Biologist - DFO Greer Maier USCRB (509) 888-7219 [email protected] Natural Resources Program Manager Derek Van Marter USCRB (509) 670-1462 [email protected] Executive Director Howie Wright ONA (250) 707-0095 [email protected] ONA Fish Program Director Richard Bussanich ONA (250) 707-0095 [email protected] Fisheries Biologist Dean Allan DFO (250) 851 4821 [email protected] Resource Management - DFO (509) 669-8737 76 This page intentionally left blank. The Chief Joseph Hatchery 2015 Annual Program Review March 10-11, 2015