View Document - A Living Archives
Transcription
View Document - A Living Archives
P.E.I.-NEWSPAPERS AND MAGAZINESISLAND MAGAZINE-VERTICAL FILE P.E.I. COLLECTION U ,> , ; CF U.PiEih Number 11 Spring-Summer 1982 $4.00 ISSN 0384-8175 n r* *- II \ / Contents Articles Lydia's Perilous Landing at St. George's Bay Lydia Cambridge Wright Edited by Nicolas J. de Jong 3 Carrington's Journal: The 1837 Visit of a Barbados Planter Nathaniel T. W. Carrington Edited by James C. Brandow 9 H.B. Sterling's Charlottetown Jim Hornby 16 The C.P. Flockton Comedy Company Reginald Carrington Short Edited by Jim Hornby 23 Some of My Experiences at Sea, Part 1 John Hemphill Edited by Jim Hornby 29 Reviews 34 Contributors 37 Magazine Number 11 Spring-Summer 1982 published by The Prince Edward Island Heritage Foundation |i B^Sfj^ffW The Island Magazine is a semi-annual publication of Prince Edward Island history and folklore. Editor Jim Hornby Editorial Board Robert C. Tuck Ian Ross Robertson * Elinor Vass Bill Ledwell Subscriptions/Distribution Linda Steele Illustrations Hilda Woolnough Anca Laxer Design Design Associates Limited Printing Williams & Crue Limited Typesetting Maritime Photoengravers Limited All correspondence should be addressed to: The Island Magazine The Heritage Foundation P.O. Box 922 Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island We regret that subscriptions are no longer available. Existing subscriptions will be honoured and standing orders may be arranged. Errata Mistakes in the captions of three pictures accompanying last issue's The "Falmouth" Passengers by Andrew B.W. MacEwen are corrected as follows: (p. 13) James McGregor, son of no. 47. His wife Jane Brown, grand-daughter of nos. 4, 41 and 22. (p. 15) Benjamin McEwen, son of nos. 45 and 2 and 26, grandson of no. 24. (p. 16) Catherine Brown, daughter of nos. 41 and 22, grand-daughter of no. 19. Mr. MacEwen informs that he has found some further Falmouth references since the article was published. ^ydia's Perilous landing at St. George's °Bay~ ^ Edited by Nicolas J. de Jong by Lydia Cambridge Wright During the second week of December 1816 Mrs. Charles Wright,1 nee Lydia Cambridge, embarked on the ship Mary2 at Three Rivers. They sailed under Captain William Henly with a cargo of deals (softwood planks) and pine timber for Bristol, England on Sunday evening December 15th. While it was certainly late in the season, the event itself would normally have created no more than a passing interest. However, the passage terminated abruptly, in foul weather, when they grounded on the shores of St. George's Bay, near Antigonish, Nova Scotia, during the early hours of the following Tuesday morning. Lydia Wright, in describing her ordeal to her close friend Miss Mary Stewart 3 almost one month after the shipwreck, provides us with an articulate description of a frightening and tragic event. In addition, she also raises some tantalizing questions while offering an insight to certain of the tensions of Prince Edward Island society of the period. As the Man/ beat her way to the Gut of Canso and the North Atlantic, Lydia Wright would surely have reflected upon the definite, yet unspecified, reason for her winter crossing. She would have thought also of her recent, apparently bitter feud with her immediate family, and of the child she was carrying.4 Married for only a little over a year, her cause was such that she was willing to let circumstances direct her husband's conduct during her absence. Finally, Lydia indicates that Peter Townshend, 5 one of the other two passengers, had reason to show her no particular courtesy and perhaps knew more of her circumstances than she would have wished. Lydia's letter to Mary follows verbatim, with paragraphs added, and blanks indicating where the original is missing or illegible. 1 Lydia Cambridge, daughter of John Cambridge, married Charles Wright on August 16,1815. Charles, born in 1782, was the son of Thomas Wright and Susannah Turner. Lydia's sister Phebe married George Wright, a brother to Charles, on December 28, 1807. (Public Archives of Prince Edward Island (PAPEI) Accession 3069, St. Paul's Anglican Church, Charlortetown, Vol. I.) 2 The ship Mary was built at Murray Harbour and registered on October 28, 1815, # 3 3 . She measured 374 tons and was owned by John Cambridge and his son Lemeul. We know that she did not break up when aground in St. George's Bay since she was registered de novo in P.E.I. on September 18, 1818. Lemeul retained his interest whilst John's passed to his other son Artemus. The Mary was subsequently transferred to Bristol, U.K., on April 17, 1822. (PAPEI, Record Group 9, Customs, Vol. II, Shipping Registers, 1787-1820.) 3 It is believed that this Miss Mary Stewart was the daughter of Mr. Charles Stewart and Mary DesBrisay. She was born in 1794. (Donald F. Stewart, pers. comm..) 4 Charles Wright jun. was born in Halifax, April 7, 1817. (PAPEI, Accession 3156, Elm Ave. Cemetery, Charlortetown, microfilm, reel 2.) 5 Peter Townshend, born January 29, 1798 was the son of William Townshend and Flora Stewart. (PAPEI, St.. Paul's Anglican Church, op. cit.) Antigonish, January 12th, 1817. My dear Mary, 6 Mrs. Stewart was born Hannah Turner and was married to "Hellfire Jack" Stewart. She was therefore Miss Mary Stewart's aunt. (Stewart, pers. comm.. 7 Deadlight, a metal plate, originally of wood or iron which is hinged inboard above a scuttle or port and can be let down and secured by a butterfly nut to protect the glass of the scuttle in heavy weather. You have I doubt not long before this heard of the melancholy events which occurred immediately after our departure from Three Rivers. And I well know the deep interest, and sympathy, they will have excited in the breast of your dear Mother and self. I will now relate the particulars of those occurrences, but will in the first place assure you that tho' I have suffered much I am now restored to as perfect health as when I bade you Farewell. I wrote to you as I promised from Three Rivers, you doubtless heard we sailed from thence on the evening of Sunday the 15th of Dec. The evening was mild and it was hoped a fair wind would next day carry us to the Gut. The severe gale and snow storm which next morning arose was too violent and of too long duration not to be felt by all in Prince Edward Island and must I think have excited serious alarm in the breast of our friends. All whom I have heard speak of it here say it was one of the most severe they ever experienced. Mrs. Stewart 6 and myself were extremely sick, and felt no wish to leave our beds. Towards evening I was better and took some refreshment. Mrs. Stewart declined taking any. I had no return of sea sickness although I hoped providence would preserve us yet I was aware of the danger of our situation, and although I felt perfectly calm and tranquil yet I did not appear to myself to have had any sleep that night and lay as if waiting for the event which soon after took place. About two o'clock on Tuesday morning we struck. I at first felt a momentary hope the ship might be put about but the attempt proved ineffectual her sails and rigging were so frozen she was totally unmanageable. Cap. Henly on finding nothing could be done, came down and requested Mrs. Stewart and me to rise as he then thought we must immediately take to our boats. We hastily threw on our clothes. Cap. Henly said notwithstanding the extreme darkness of the night he could discover land or rocks ahead and very near us. I requested he would not abandon the vessel unless it was absolutely necessary to make the attempt for our preservation, which he promised. She struck repeatedly and with great violence. Almost instantaneously after we first struck, three of our dead lights7 were beaten in by the violence of the waves, the sea beat over the deck and broke in the sky light so that it came pouring in like a torrent and in a very short time there was from three to four feet of water in the cabin. The crew at first retreated to it as the place of greatest safety. I saw paleness and dismay in the countenances of some. By degrees they all found themselves compelled to abandon it, leaving Mrs. Stewart and myself who were holding on our berths. In a very short time the bulkhead which separated the stateroom from the Cabin was dashed away, the waves then beat over me, the water was up to the bottom of my berth. You my dear Mary can have no idea of the horror of the scene, nor do I think any one who has not witnessed a similar one can have an adequate idea of this. In a few minutes to see, chairs, Table, trunks &c. &c. dashed to a thousand pieces all in wild confusion. Finding myself extremely wet I thought I would endeavour to gain Mrs. Stewart's berth, as more sheltered than my own, we were now and had been for a considerable time in total darkness. I got on something that was floating about the stateroom, but it was immediately washed from under me and I was up to my middle in water, on gaining Mrs. Stewarts berth I said I am come into your berth as more sheltered than my own. She replied mine has given way for some time and I am standing in the water. This was the last which passed between us. I then attempted to regain my own, but from its great height and my clothes being so very wet, my efforts to get upon it were ineffectual. In this was the hand of providence displayed in my preservation. Had I succeeded in my attempt I should have perished. I then returned to Mrs. Stewart and after many ineffectual attempts succeeded in getting on the board which served to enclose the lower part of the berth and threw my feet round a post at the upper part. In this perilous situation I remained for a considerable time the sea beating over me and to all human appearance expecting every wave would drown me, yet in this awful situation. I said tho' to all human appearance a few minutes must terminate my existence here yet I am not out of the reach of omnipotence to save and I felt as if I was not to perish. Peter Townshend during this period came repeatedly to the little window of the stateroom which looks into the companion and spoke. I spoke in return but could not distinguish what he said. At last he came to the cabin door and told me two men were coming to take me from the state room. On entering it they went to my berth for me but it was gone so that had I not moved as I did I should have been carried away with it. They on taking me from the place where I was hanging requested I would stand that they might take me up better, but I told them I could not stand. My feet were so benumbed with wet and cold & my hands were nearly in the same state, and I believe ten minutes or a quarter of an hour longer at furtherest would have been too late to have removed me as I should have been unable to have held on. It was with much difficulty from the extreme darkness of the night, the slippery state of the deck, and the thumping of the ship that my removal to the Fore Castle was accomplished and the men very frequently fell down with me. Peter kept with them all the time, indeed nothing could have been more kind and attentive than he was which I feel more sensibly as you are in possession of some circumstances which you know would not authorise me to have expected it. A few minutes after my removal two more of the men returned for Mrs. Stewart but were unable to get into the Cabin, the : made a second attempt with a light about ten minutes after my removal. The last conflict was over, she was on her knees her right arm held up to her head as if supporting it and her bed floating upon her. At this time although I had a perfect recollection of every circumstance which had occurred I was too far exhausted to feel this event as I shoula have done had I not been reduced to an almost similar situation my. elf. It was five in the morning when I was removed. The sailois tore off my wet clothes, put me into one of their hammocks, wrappec me some of their dry Blankets, and afforded me every assistance and kindness humanity could dictate and the means in their power wou'd allow. But their was no fire nor could any be procured. My feet and legs were so benumbed I could not move them for a considerable time and I suffered much from this circumstance, though they were rubbed and a pair of the sailors dry stockings drawn on them. One of their flannel shirts were bound round my head by way of a cap. At length their humane endeavours proved successful and I began to feel Descendents of the Cunningham family continue in business in Antigonish. (B. Mac Vicar, pers. comm..) returning animation. It would have been an affecting sight to an indifferent observer to see a number of rough sailors thus employed. As day approached we discovered we were not above twice the length of the vessel from the shore, but it snowed thick and we could not discover if we were near any habitation. As the day advanced men at different times came down on the beach. They spoke, but we could not distinguish what they said and although we spoke in return with a speaking Trumpet they could not hear us. It however afforded us the consolation of know we were near some habitation. The surf ran so high they could not come off to render us any assistance, nor could we make any attempt to land as none of our boats could have lived in the surf. Tuesday night the violence of the storm began to abate and the unfortunate Mary lay pretty still. Early on Tuesday morning several boats came out of the Harbour of Antigonish, amongst others Mr. John Cunningham8/this gentleman was in Halifax at the time of my mother and my being there on our way to England and lodged at the same house. On Cap. Henly and Mr. Townshend mentioning my name he said he had some knowledge of my family and on coming into the Fore Castle said, he believed he had seen my mother and a younger sister of mine with Mr. Wright in Halifax on our way to England. I replied I was the person he had seen, and had married a brother of Mr. G. Wright. He replied, Madame, I have then seen you in happier circumstances. You, Capt. Henly, and Mr. Townshend can be accommodated at my House and I will immediately take you on shore. I told him I had not a thing to put on but what was quite wet. He said he had a very warm great coat which should be wrapped round me. This over a long cotton night gown such as you know I wear in winter, and which the heat of my body had by this time dryed. Two coloured silk handkerchiefs bound round my head and a red wollen cap drawn over them formed the dress of your poor friend on landing. On arriving at Mr. Cunningham's house which was at some distance from where we landed I was through the kindness of Mrs. C. soon comfortably clothed. I had felt while laying in the Hammock extreme soreness in my legs, and one of my eyes felt as if injured but it was not till I got to Mr. Cunningham's that I discovered my limbs were dreadfully bruised oarticularly my legs, and I had a very black eye. These bruises I suppose I must have received from the frequent falls I received while being conveyed to the fore castle tho' from the benumbed state I was then in I was not sensible of receiving any. My legs, feet and ancles swelled exceedingly so much so that I was not able to wear my own shoes for three weeks. I received every kindness and attention from Mr. & Mrs. Cunningham and every individual of their family, nine children in number, the eldest daughter fourteen years old and a very pretty, sweet dispositioned girl. Capt. Hierlihy called on me immediately on hearing of my being in Antigonish and very kindly invited me to make his house my home, two of the Miss Hierlihy also called and repeated the invitation. This I accepted as soon as I was well enough to go out, I am now at their house where I have experienced the greatest kindness, and attention. I stayed ten days at Mr. Cunningham but as Capt. Henly and Mr. Townshend were staying there and there family were so large I felt unwilling to add to the fatigue of Mrs. Cunningham longer than I could possibly help. This is the sixteenth day since I came here. I leave tomorrow morning and shall be at the Interval tomorrow evening a settlement six miles from this and shall proceed early on Wednesday morning on my way to Pictou. I intend to proceed immediately to Halifax. Mr. Cunningham is going there I go with him. I think myself particularly fortunate in having it in my power to go with him. Indeed I should feel in a very unplesant situation had I to perform a journey of one hundred and fifty miles unaccompanied by a steady respectable person. I little thought when I came to Antigonish that I should have been detained here four weeks, but Mr. Cunningham's business prevented him going sooner. I was in hopes to have got much sooner to Halifax and that an opportunity would have offered for me to have proceeded to England this winter. That I now relinquish, yet I assure you I extremely regret, and that for many reasons, the impracticability of it. As I am compelled to pass the winter in Nova Scotia I think Halifax the most eligible in every respect. I have lost the great part of my clothes, and everything I had prepared for the little stranger so that you cannot wonder at my being extremely anxious to get into winter quarters. I have a great deal to do in little more than two months. Indeed it is impossible for me to get my things done as I wish and intend, however I must do what is most necessary, and leave the ornamental till I have time for it. To stay in Antigonish is out of the question as I could not get anything I want. At Pictou the same objection would in great measure prevail and I should have to pay an exorbitant price nor do I suppose I could procure comfortable Lodgings or proper attendance. I hope to get boarded in some respectable Family and if nothing new occurs during the winter, and Mr. Wright approves of it I will proceed to England as early in the spring as circumstances will possibly admit as I have no intention of returning to Prince Edward Island without attempting to accomplish the object of my visit to England. Oh my dear Mary to what a situation has the conduct of my Father exposed me, to shipwreck, and the borders of the grave! For had not two men at the risk of their own lives attempted to save me I should now have been beyond the shafts of envy and malice which have been so unsparingly aimed at me. Had I perished would not my Father and Mother have felt severe remorse? Would they not have felt they were the cause of my death? How has the late event affected my brother and sister? Has fraternal feelings for a moment prevailed? Or has the selfish principle which they have so strongly evinced made them indifferent to my fate? Be this as it may I doubt not the loss of the Mary will be severely felt by them. I am very anxious to hear from Prince Edward Island. I feel much for Mr. Wright. I know his anxiety must be very great yet though it would give me great pleasure to have him with me this winter, yet as we are situated I cannot wish it. Circumstances will no doubt regulate his conduct. I wrote to him on the day of my landing and entreated he would not attempt to come to me as it would be at the risk of his life. Mr. Colin Macdonald and Mr. Charles Worrall who have been waiting some time at Pictou endeavoring to return to the Island came to Antigonish a few days ago. I saw them at Mr. Cunninghams. They informed me the boat which Mr. Mortimer sent express for Capt. Henly crossed a fortnight before and they hoped got safe over. But from the state of the Gulf they said it was impossible for them to return. I hope they got safe over. I sometimes feel a fear least Mr. Wright should have attempted to return with them and shall not feel quite easy till I hear. I hope and think he would not attempt anything so rash. I have written you a very long letter but both my time and paper remind — I must conclude. I shall not seal this till I arrive at Pictou — on my arrival in Halifax will add a few particulars if I should not be able to do it before. Peter Townshend went to the Gut of Canso in a vessel of Mr. Cunningham's bound from thence to Halifax he hoped to be able to proceed to England this winter but from what I hear there will be no opportunity for a long time. In the Gut he met with a vessel belonging to one of the Nicholasons of Belfast and wrote by him. I hope he succeeded in getting to the Island, so that I expect you will have heard of us by two opportunities. I am sure you will have felt particularly alarmed for me on account of my situation and it is really singular, and very provendential that not withstanding my limbs were so much bruised I did not receive the slightest hurt in my body. Tho' for some days I could with difficulty move I was so extremely stif. The fate of poor Mrs. Stewart I sincerely lament. So happy so rejoiced at the prospect of again meeting her daughter to be taken away as it were in a moment by cruel death and ought I not to be most thankful to that all generous providence which preserved me from such iminent peril and mixed so many mercies with the bitter cup? Who cast me among those who have proved kind friends, and who appear to take a strong interest in me while I have been abandoned as an alien, an outcast by those on whom I have the strongest claim. For what I am preserved Heaven only Knows, perhaps for greater trials. But let me not anticipate the worst but humbly trust that providence whose ways are inscrutable. . . Pictou My dear Mary, 9 The original copy of this letter was loaned for copying to the Public Archives of Canada by the late Group Captain H.R. Stewart. (The PAC reference is M.G. 24, L. 2, Stewart Papers.) This morning I had the pleasure of receiving your letter on my way from Antigonish to this. I find the Post proceeds on his return in the morning and as I shall travel ten miles on my way to Halifax this evening I can only say I will write to you on my arrival in Halifax. Please to write me very often and direct your letters to me to the care of Mr. John Young, Merchant, Halifax.9 II. .4^0* ...^ > ^ * ^ x 09^ii i^r ^ i i l r v ^ ; 4S*&*<-*j JKHHHH|H ""SFSfef ^^M lrt^mi.i^ililiiirmM.1. Sitaa by Nathaniel T.W. Carrington N= lathanielT.W. Carrington (1801-1855), a Barbados sugar planter, sailed with his wife and son from Bridgetown in May, 1837. Before he returned to his home eight months later, he travelled to Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, Boston, New York and Philadelphia. In addition, for five months the Carringtons boarded at a farm in Newton, Long Island (now part of the borough of Queens, New York City). The purpose of the sojourn was the restoration of Mrs. Carrington's health. Nathaniel Carrington landed at Halifax on June 14th and after touring that city, decided to accompany his fellow Barbadian, Reverend John Packer, on a visit to Prince Edward Island. Carrington's journal, it should be noted, was written for his children and never intended for publication. It is now the proud possession of his great-grandson, Roger C.E. Carrington, a solicitor, of Hampshire, England. In transcribing the manuscript, misspellings have been corrected and brackets are used to indicate insertions by the editor. Friday, 7th July. At 4 o'clock this morning the steamboat left the wharf at Pictou for Charlotte Town.1 As it is quite light before this hour, we got up & had a view of the land all the way on. On board the steamer was an Indian Chief, Maltai Sapier, of the tribe inhabiting about Pictou, 16 of whose wigwams we saw on the beach as the boat passed on.2 Maltai is an elderly man, shabbily dressed but very civil, laughing at the many questions put to him without giving answers to such as did not please him. The passengers generally gave him about 20 cents each, for which he seemed grateful. He said he had never been in the steamboat before, admired the velocity and inquired who had been the original inventor. He was going over to Charlotte Town to see his squaw, who had gone over on a visit about a fortnight Edited by James C. Brandow Courtesy PEI Heritage Foundation The Charlottetown waterfront in 1849, painted by George Hubbard. At left is the Pictou steamer Rose. 1 The Cape Breton, Thomas Graham, master. Steamboat ferry service between Pictou and Charlottetown, except during winter months, commenced in 1832. George Patterson, A History of the County of Pictou, Nova Scotia (Montreal, 1877), 395. 2 In 1828 the Indian Civilization Society of Pictou was formed to educate and domesticate the Micmac Indians of the region but all efforts failed. Ibid., 193. This tribe owned no property and pleas to the government in Halifax for funds to purchase land for them fell on deaf ears. As one official observed in 1843: "At present they are driven from place to place, without a resting place for their feet - their game is gone - firewood is denied them, and the very sanctuaries of their dead, are in some instances desecrated and ploughed over." Nova Scotia, House of Assembly, Journals and Proceedings, 1844, Appendix, 121. 3 John Barrow (1772-1863), a son of John Henry and Frances Barrow of Kent, England and Barbados, was assistant judge of the Prince Edward Island Supreme Court from 1828 to 1848. C.R. Allen, Illustrated Historical Atlas of the Province of Prince Edward Island (Philadelphia, 1880), 13. 4 Reverend John Packer (1799-1861) was educated at Codrington College and Trinity College, Cambridge. Ordained a priest in England in 1824, he returned to Barbados where he served as headmaster of the Central School in Bridgetown. He promoted public education, believed slaves had as much capacity for learning as did other people and favored the abolition of slavery. From 1832 to 1837 he was rector of St. Thomas Parish. Because he suffered from asthma, he traveled in hopes of improving his health and in 1837 settled on Prince Edward Island. The following year he returned to Barbados. 5 Reverend Louis Charles Jenkins (1797-1884), son of Dr. John Jenkins of Hereford, England, was ordained deacon in 1820 and settled on Prince Edward Island soon after. From 1824 to 1827, he served at St. Eleanor's Village and in 1828 was appointed rector of St. Paul's Church, Charlottetown. When he involved himself in political issues, he became a controversial figure and in 1854 was dismissed as rector of St. Paul's although he continued to preach there on occasion. At one time he held the post of Secretary of Education and later served as librarian of the Legislative Library. He married Penelope, daughter of Reverend Theophilus and Margaret Stewart Desbrisay, the first rector of St. Paul's Church. They had two sons and five daughters. Hilde Jenkins and Margaret Taylor, The Jenkins Family, Five Generations of Doctors (Privately printed, 1975), 2-4. before. There were 3 other Indians but they were sulky and uncommunicative. On quitting the steamboat & going up the wharf, we met Mr. John Barrow, 3 late of Sunbury Estate, Barbados, and he immediately recognized Mr. Packer, 4 followed us to the boardinghouse, and was very civil & polite. The Revd. Mr. Jenkins of the town called on Mr. Packer and in the evening invited us to tea with himself & family, who are a plain, quiet set of people. He is an Englishman of the Episcopal Church. 5 Saturday, t h e 8 t h July. Mr. Packer and myself walked about the town after breakfast; met with Mr. Barrow who carried us to the church, a neat, plain building of wood. The galleries and pulpit are at least 3 feet too high.6 Ordered a pair of shoes, each [Packer and himself], of a plain, honest man, very much like old Reed in St. Thomas. 7 Visited a bookstore & purchased a small map of the Island. Mr. P. in company with the Revd. Mr. Jenkins called on the governor, Sir Charles Fitzroy, lately arrived to assume the government. 8 At 5 o'clock we went to dine with Mr. Barrow, by his particular request. His wife & daughter, Mrs. Anwyl, were very civil & asked numerous questions about Barbados and its inhabitants.9 They still live in a sumptuous style and evidently regret the loss of their Barbados property and the luxuries afforded by it. In short, they are still great people and do all to show as such. S u n d a y , t h e 9 t h . Today Mr. Jenkins performed the morning service & Mr. P. gave the sermon. We then took an early dinner with Mr. Jenkins as he had to go 7 miles to attend another place of worship on the Malpeque Road 11 & Mr. Packer did the whole of the evening service. In the morning Sir Charles Fitzroy, his lady & 2 sons were present & seemed very 6 St. Paul's Church was consecrated by Bishop John Inglis in 1836 and used till 1896. "The pews were of the high-box style; special ones of double size were provided for the Lieutenant-Governor, the members of the Council, the House of Assembly and the officers of the garrison. Near the entrance two were reserved for strangers. The others were private property and the proprietary rights were jealously guarded." A.B. Warburton, A History of Prince Edward Island (St. John, New Brunswick, 1923), 391. 7 Probably the boot and shoemaking establishment of Robert Weeks (1792-1863) which was on Grafton Street, off Queen Square. He was a native of Cork, Ireland and emigrated to Prince Edward Island in 1823. The Examiner, November 30, 1863. 8 Sir Charles Augustus Fitzroy (1796-1858) was the eldest son of Lord Charles Fitzroy, the general. He served in the Horse Guards, took part in the Battle of Waterloo, and in 1831 was elected to Parliament upon his retirement from active duty. He was appointed lieutenant-governor of Prince Edward Island in 1837 and was knighted before his departure. In 1841 he was made governor and commander-in-chief of the Leeward Islands, governor of New South Wales in 1846 and, from 1850 to 1855, served as governor-general of Australia. Dictionary of National Biography, VII, 202-03 9 Senhouse Barrow, daughter of John and Mary Ward Barrow, was the wife of Lieutenant Colonel Anwyl of the 4th Regiment. The Barbadian, February 16, 1848. 10 Soon after John Barrow settled in Charlottetown, an adverse decision in the Barbados Chancery Court resulted in the loss of Sunbury Plantation, St. Philip's Parish. However, he continued to own other Barbados property in addition to a residence at Hill Park, Kent. In Charlottetown, the Barrows resided at Hillsborough House, a wooden house still standing on the corner of Hillsborough and Dorchester streets. The Barbadian, June 20, 1832 and The Examiner, December 21, 1863. n S t John's Church in the village of Milton, Queens County. 10 "~bv Courtesy Public Archives of PEI Sir Charles Augustus Fitzroy attentive.12 About 400 persons were there. In the evening about 150 to 200 only attended. Monday, 10th July. Today we had proposed going to Mr. Charles Worrell's, about 28 miles on the St. Peter's Road.13 He is a gentleman to whom my mother was 1st cousin, by mother's side, and has been a resident here 34 years but at 5 o'clock in the morning we found it would be impossible to go as it had rained & was then raining very fast and so it continued [the] greater part of the day. The people of this town are not quite so bad as those of Pictou but certainly they have a lazy, indolent appearance generally. Mr. Barrow told us that on his arrival here they were a drunken set but that the temperance societies had done much qood although there was a good deal of it yet to be seen daily in the streets. l 4 The town is small, taking the number of houses, but it occupies a large space as the main streets are laid out 100 feet wide and each house has a space of Vz of an acre to it & a garden, consequently they are far apart from each other. There are many new and fine looking houses. They have a market in a large square and Episcopal, Methodist, Presbyterian and Roman Catholic churches. Tuesday, 11th July. This morning the weather being fair and fine, Mr. Packer and myself started in the waggon with one horse, at 10/ per day hire, for Mr. Worrell's. Boiled on the road 18 miles from town for 2 hours and arrived at Mr. W.'s farm at 2 o'c. We found the old gentleman at home. He is an elderly man (68 years) & having lived so much by himself, he is rather shy and diffident but having made ourselves known as Barbadians, for I would not prematurely declare relationship, he was very civil & polite; showed us his garden (nominally so called) & took a long walk about the farm, pointing out different views & trees, etc. Having returned, dinner was announced & to us a treat: fine, thick, salted fish & eggs, by far better than any we get in Barbados and the old man apologized for the bad fare but as we were uninvited guests, none was needed; & we dined very heartily, when lo and behold, in came a shoulder of cold veal and a fine ham, too late then for our satiated appetites. Mr. Worrell is a small man who reminds me of old Mr. Duesberry, Mrs. Lamming's father.16 He has been a resident here, as I said, for 34 years and is the possessor of 70 thousand acres of land, as he says, but a plat of 1836 shows 5 lots or townships forming the parish of Saint Patrick & each containing 20,000, making of course 100,000 acres.17 He said his farm was between 4 & 500 acres but as he is a meek, quiet man, his labourers & others about him take advantage so that it is badly managed & makes him a small return. His tenants also take advantage & pay him just what and as they choose.18 His friends & acquaintances say that he will not give leases for more than 40 years, consequently but a small portion of his land is cleared and farmed as a man to enter on the thick forest cannot clear, erect necessary buildings and make anything of a farm [in] under 12 to 15 years. It is 7 years at least before he canridthe land of the stumps after having cut down & burned the immense timber trees. Judge how thick the stumps must be when I do solemnly affirm that the trees when felled lie as thick on the ground as our canes when cut. What space, therefore, is there for sowing grain & planting potatoes? Mr. Worrell's farm, therefore, being given on such short leases is but partially cleared, as a native would say, but to us (who are not accustomed even to such trees as the second growth now presents) it is not cleared at all. The large timber trees on the part leased out have been cut down and destroyed in all manner of ways, to the deterioration of the land certainly, as a second growth soon succeeds together with all manner of light shrubs & weeds which consume the alluvial deposit of the forest and render the land exhausted and unfit for cultivation without being highly manured, the means for which are destroyed. And, again, the 2nd growth does not afford timber to build even a common log house. I, therefore, conclude that he has not 10,000 acres of this immense tract of land properly cleared & cultivated.19 We remained with the old gentleman till next morning & as we had some idea of going thence to George Town, distant 24 miles, he very kindly put up a lunch & bottle of port wine for our journey but as his clerk in the store told us the roads were very bad, we abandoned the idea & returned to 12 Sir Charles Fitzroy married twice. His first wife, Lady Mary Lennox, eldest daughter of the fourth Duke of Richmond, died in 1847. They had three sons and one daughter. Burkes Peerage and Baronetage (London, 1975), 146. 13 Charles Worrell (1770-1858), one of the largest land holders on Prince Edward Island, served as justice of the peace, sheriff, lieutenant-colonel in the militia, member of the House of Assembly, 1812-13 and 1818-20, and of the Legislative Council, 1825-36 and 1839-43. Trained as a lawyer in England, he practiced only briefly at Lincoln's Inn and on Prince Edward Island. A reclusive bachelor, he was the son of Jonathan and Catherine Worrell of St. Thomas Parish, Barbados, and Juniper Hall, Surrey, England. His father's sister, Jane, married Dr. John Worrell, her cousin, and their daughter, Jane, was the mother of Carrington. [E.M. Shilstone], "The Worrell Family in Barbados," The Journal of the Barbados Museum and Historical Society, XXIX (November, 1961), 22. See also forthcoming Dictionary of Canadian Biography, VIII. 14 In 1830 a gallon of rum was imported for every man, woman and child on Prince Edward Island. If the temperance societies had any success it was only temporary since the very first article published in The Prince Edward Island Magazine seventy years later (March, 1899), was entitled: "Is there any Practical Way of Dealing with the Liquor Problem in Charlottetown?" 15 Charlottetown had about 3,000 inhabitants at this time while the total population of the island was estimated to be 40,000. [S. Hill], A Short Account of Prince Edward Island (London, 1839), 3, 21. The Old Round Market House, a building of unusual design, was built in 1823 and stood in the center of Queen Square until 1867: "It was a regular polygon of twenty sides, surrounded by a colonade, making the fabric over eighty feet in diameter. From the outer edge of the colonade, strong, round pillars stood opposite each angle as support for the roof, which rose to a central point, ornamented with a cupola several feet in height. It had four double doors and was lighted by sixteen windows." As quoted in Benjamin Bremner, An Island Scrap Book (Charlottetown, 1932), 46. 16 William Duesberry, then 81 years old, of St. Thomas Parish, Barbados, was the father of Eliza, wife of Dynock Lamming, also of St. Thomas Parish. 17 In 1854 the Worrell estate, consisting of 81,303 acres and comprising the whole parish of St. Patrick's in Kings County, was sold to the government for £24,100. In fact, Charles Worrell, then living in London, only received £14,000 in the transaction. Andrew Hill Clark, Three Centuries and the Island (Toronto, 1959), 52, 93. 18 Actually, Mr. Worrell's tenants were engaged in a rent strike at the time and refused to pay him. For a less sympathetic view of Worrell, a "wealthy British capitalist," see Errol Sharpe, A People's History of Prince Edward Island (Toronto, 1976), 63. 19 There is no doubt that proprietors such as Charles Worrell, who is said to have lost £40,000 in his investment, retarded the settlement of Prince Edward Island and delayed its economic development. Two-thirds of all land was held by a few landlords like Worrell who refused to sell or improve their holdings. Dissatisfied tenants attempted to join together in protest but the proprietors' agents, many of whom were public officials, resisted land reform. It was not until 1875 when the Compulsory Land Purchase Act was passed, that this quasi-feudal system of land tenure was finally abolished. Frank MacKinnon, The Government of Prince Edward Island (Toronto, 1951), 105-18, 296-98. 11 20 "Morell House", the Worrell residence located in the small village of Morell, Kings County, was "a mansion of some importance." H.D. McEwen, "Morell, RE. Island," The Prince Edward Island Magazine, III (May, 1901), 92. 21 In 1831, Richard Quin was employed as a school teacher at Brackley Point, Queens County, where he evidently met his wife, Emily McKinnon. He leased "Spring Farm" in 1833 for forty years and in 1836 obtained a license to conduct a tavern on the St. Peter's Road. By 1841, his family included three daughters and one son. Royal Gazette, May 10, 1831; Prince Edward Island, House of Assembly, Journal, 1837, Appendix; and Census of 1841, Public Archives of Prince Edward Island, Charlottetown. 22 John Myrie Holl (1802-1869), farmer and politician, was the son of John and Ann Lewis Holl of London. He was educated at Cheam School, Surrey and resided near Bideford, Devonshire where he met Reverend Lloyd and both men emigrated to Prince Edward Island about the same time. Lieutenant Governor Sir John Harvey remarked that: "Persons of Mr. Holl's class are exactly the description of Emigrant most wanted in this Colony." In 1839 he was appointed to the Legislative Council where he defended the absentee proprietors, opposed the extension of democracy and emerged as the leader of conservative forces. He was elected Premier in 1854 but his administration proved so unpopular it lasted only four months. The following year he returned to England. Dictionary of Canadian Biography, IX, 394-95. 23 Reverend Charles Lloyd (1802-1888), son of Frederick and Julia Vereker Lloyd of Ballymacreace, Ireland, was educated at Westminster and Cambridge. Ordained a priest in 1826, he served as a curate in Devonshire until 1835 when he sailed from Bideford in the Despatch and settled on Prince Edward Island. He became the first principal of the Central Academy in 1836, which in 1860 became Prince of Wales College, and in 1837 was stationed by the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel at Milton, Queens County. His residence, "Abbotsham Grove", was a short distance from John Holl's "Kenwith". In 1857 he returned to England. His last clerical post was vicar of Englishcombe, Somerset. He married Elizabeth, daughter of William Tyeth of Bideforth and they had three sons and two daughters. Sir Bernard Burke, A Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Landed Gentry of Ireland (London, 1904), 344; J.A. Venn (ed.), Alumni Cantabrigienses, 1752-1900 (Cambridge, 1922-54), IV, 186; Royal Gazette, October 6,. 1835. Charlotte Town in time for dinner at the hotel. Mr. Worrell's house is a very large, old, wooden mansion going fast into decay, being upwards of 50 years standing. The rooms are larger than anything I have seen in Halifax or this country and certainly not a very desireable acquisition as it is impossible to heat them in winter with one fire.201 should have said earlier that we took a walk out in the evening to see a small farm on the banks of the Morell River, which the mistress described as the healthiest spot on this whole island. Memo: the lady is an Irishwoman and the farm is for sale. Is the wonder cleared up? I think so. Bears are said to be frequently seen in this neighbourhood. Game (birds) are said to be in plenty in the autumn; we only saw 5 pheasants and 3 partridges on our road. Wednesday, the 12th July. Being fortified for our journey by the kindness of our good host, Mr. W., we quitted early this morning, consulting on the way to the main road, whether we should return to town or go to George Town & run the risk of bad roads. Finally, we concluded to do the former as the wheels of our vehicle were very low and the horse none of the best. We stopped at a log house about 13 miles from Charlotte Town & encountered an interesting Irishman & his very pretty wife (a native). He has just settled down on a farm of 100 acres under wood, has nothing planted & seems very poor. He sells spirits to travelers at an advance of 100 percent but allowed that it was not the most praiseworthy calling & occasioned much evil. This man would become a worthy member of society in another situation. His name is Richard Quin.21 On our getting to town we met Mr. Jenkins and he insisted we should take tea with his family in the evening which we did. Thursday, 13th. An Englishman, Mr. Holl,22 took us to see his farm and the Reverend Mr. Lloyd,23 5 miles on the Malpeque Road. Saw an interesting part of the country, where there is rather better farming than usual and returned to dine with Mr. Holl & his family at 5 o'clock. Courtesy Public Archives of PEI John Myrie Holl 12 24 John McKinnon (1770-1851), a native of South Uist, Scotland, was taken to Prince Edward Island at the age of two. He sailed on the Alexander among Captain John MacDonald's 210 Catholic settlers. Royal Gazette, February 11, 1851; see also J.M. Bumsted, "Captain John MacDonald and the Island," The Island Magazine, 6 (Spring-Summer 1979), 15-20. Friday, t h e 1 4 t h . After breakfast hired a horse & gig & drove out to Brackley Point, 12 miles from town, to see Quin's father-in-law's farm which he told us was for sale. The old man is a Highlander by birth, named John McKinnon, & has resided here 63 years, having brought up a family of 18 children, 16 of whom are now men & women living and doing well. The farm is situated pleasantly on the banks of the [Black] River, famous for fish, ducks, geese, etc. Upon the whole they are an interesting & deserving people. The son, Donald, is a man of m6re information than some of our Barbados worthies possessed of estates. 25 Returned to town for Mr. P. to dress and attend Sir Charles Fitzroy's invitation to dinner at 7 o'clock. We had some thunder and lightening this evening. 25 Donald McKinnon (1811-1865), like his father, became a farmer. Saturday, t h e 1 5 t h July. Walked about the town, visited a house to be let, paid our bills for postage, gig hire, etc. & returned to loll or write journal as we pleased. It being the last Saturday we shall spend on the island for this visit, I will sum up by some general remarks. Viz., the island is without doubt a healthy place, well & abundantly watered, good rich soil, plenty of timber, clear pleasant atmosphere, cloudless sky but unfortunately inhabited by few poor and unenterprising persons, not well versed in agriculture & who are well contented to do as their predecessors did, live cheaply & be satisfied, never looking forward to or thinking of improvements. We have now been here 9 days & have never seen beef for the simple reason that there is absolutely none, even in this town, the metropolis of the island. Visited the market this morning & only saw a little poor veal & small lamb, no feathered stock of any kind although Mr. Donald McKinnon assured us a pair of fowls only sold for 4 to 6d; a goose, 1/ to 15d; a moderate calf, 5/; a lamb, 2/6; a pair of ducks, 15d; etc., beef, when to be had, 3 to 4%, etc., etc. Be it clearly understood that these articles are not so cheap from the extraordinary great quantity but from the poverty of the people who cannot afford to buy but use salt cod and salt meats, which together with the great quantities of rum they drink, accounts for their general sallow look (that is in comparison to the people of Halifax). ORAPTCH STREET i MARKET BUlLi>*iV*3l i 1 PROVINCIAL.1 BUILDING 26 As in Nova Scotia, the timber industry of Prince Edward Island was frequently blamed for the ills of the economy and society: "But this is the very worst branch of trade that a rural population could be called upon to support. It begets dissolute habits, and is a nursery of moral depravity. It has diverted the agriculturist from his more steady pursuits." [Hill], 50. Carrington's remarks about the laziness of Canadians recall Thomas Chandler Haliburton's fictional Yankee pedlar, Sam Slick, in The Clockmaker, the first series of which was published a year previous in Halifax by Joseph Howe. Sam observes in the second (1838) series: "I have often been amazed. . . when travelling among the Canadians, to see the curious critters they be. They leave the marketin' to the women and the business to their notaries, the care of the souls to their priests, and of their bodies to the doctors, and resarve only frolickin', dancin', singin', fiddlin', and gasconadin', to themselves." 1ST. PMJCS1 |. C H U R C H i j I RICHMOND S T R £ E T i Courtesy Public Archives of PEI Another Charbttetown view of 1849 with the round market building, St Paul's, and Stamper's Corner on the extreme right, on the southeast corner of Richmond and Queen. See note 35 further on. 13 27 Charles Ramage Prescott (1772-1859) was the father of Nova Scotia's apple industry and a leading advocate of fruit cultivation. His residence, "Acacia Grove", near Cornwallis, had an outstanding garden where he experimented with many varieties of fruit imported from abroad. A respected figure in Nova Scotia, he was appointed to the "Council of Twelve" in 1825. Arthur Wentworth Hamilton Eaton, The History of Kings County, Nova Scotia (Salem, Mass., 1910), 518-19. Another residence, "Prescott House", which he built at Starr's Point, is now owned by the Nova Scotia Museum and open to the public. Carrington heard of him from Joseph Allison (1785-1839), the wealthy Halifax merchant and banker, who was Prescott's son-in-law. 28 Evidently Carrington did not know that an unseasonable frost had recently destroyed many crops. Only a few months before, seed, grain and potatoes were distributed by the government to poor settlers and the export of grain, meal and potatoes was prohibited. The Acts of the General Assembly of Prince Edward Island from . . . 1773 . . . to . . . 1851 (Charlottetown, 1851-52), I, 537, 564. During the 1830s many complaints and protests were made against the government seeking land reform. In 1839, Lord Durham's Report was severely critical: "Had its natural advantages been turned to proper account, it might at this time have been the grainary of the British Colonies Of nearly 1,400,000 acres contained in the island, only 10,000 are said to be unfit for the plough. Only 100,000 are now under cultivation. No one can mistake the cause of this lamentable waste of the means of natural wealth. It is the possession of almost the whole soil of the island by absentee proprietors, who would neither promote nor permit its cultivation, combined with the defective government which first caused and has since perpetuated the evil." As quoted in MacKinnon, 117. In 1861, another commission on land policy expressed the hope that ". . .Prince Edward Island will yet become, what she ought to be, the Barbadoes of the St. Lawrence." Ibid., 118. They are far behind the people of the States, both here & in Nova Scotia, in regard to farming and gardening. They have no peas, cultivated strawberries, peaches, but few apples of the worse kind, etc. & the people here have not the consolation that the others [Novascotians] have to offer as an excuse: that one man, a Mr. Prescott, has a garden & farm that produces all kinds of vegetables, fruits, etc.27 In all our rides I have not seen an animal fat enough for beef and their horses are miserably poor animals which I conclude to be from the quantity of hay produced which they are obliged to sell to support themselves and families.28 To conclude, the country is a first-rate land, capable of producing anything a winter country can but wants sober, enterprising people with a little money to begin & they may then be induced to follow. The present generation will never see it a flourishing country under the present government;29 if it ever becomes a Yankee land, a few years will suffice to show the change. These remarks will be enough,' more I shall not say. Supped this evening with Mr. Breading & family, the clerk of the church, a good family of people. The lady [is] a native of Bermuda.30 Sunday, the 16th July. The Reverend Mr. Jenkins performed the morning & evening service and Mr. Packer preached upon both occasions; the morning text was, "Thou God seest me," 31 & he gave a good lashing to drunkards. 2 Today we dined with Dr. St. Croix,33 an old fellow very much in person & habits like Mr. Oxley.34 30 Reverend James Breading (1802-1875) of Portsmouth, England, was sent to Prince Edward Island as a teacher by the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in 1820. He taught at the National School or Kent College School, which was also known as the "Breading School," until 1839 when he moved to Nova Scotia. He then attended Kings College, Windsor, was ordained a priest in 1849, and served in several Nova Scotian parishes before he died in Halifax. His wife was Elizabeth Durham, daughter of Captain William Butterfield of Paget, Bermuda. Royal Gazette, September 28, 1830; Acadian Recorder, March 25, 1875. 31 Genesis 16:13. When the Barbados Temperance Society was organized in 1835, Reverend Packer was elected its first chairman. The Barbadian, January 10, 1835. 33 Dr. Benjamin De St. Croix (1776-1848) was Reverend Jenkins' brother-in-law. He was the son of Joshua and Leah Gallaudet De St. Croix and married Margaret, daughter of Reverend Desbrisay in 1824. Qualified to practice medicine in Charlottetown in 1812, he became a leading citizen in the community. 34 William Oxley (1780-1843) of Fairfield Plantation, St. Michael's Parish, Barbados, held many public offices including Master in Chancery, Chief Justice of the Common Pleas for St. Michael's, Lieutenant Colonel of the Royal Regiment of Militia, member of the House of Assembly, as well as vestryman. The Barbadian, July 22, 1843. Courtesy Public Archives of NS The Reverend James Breading 14 Monday, 17th. Breakfasted with Mr. Jenkins & Mr. Packer baptized his infant privately. Mr. P. returned one or 2 calls & I amused myself walking about the town & visiting a bookstore lately established by Mr. Stamper, a gentleman I knew in Halifax.35 Took tea with Mr. Tremaine, son of an old gentleman we knew in Halifax; saw his pretty, interesting sister, Miss Tremaine & ugly wife.36 Tuesday, 18th. Got our luggage ready & paid the landlady her enormous bill of 5/ per day and quitted Charlotte Town & P. E. Island, perhaps forever, on board the steam ferryboat. A little before we quitted Mr. Packer agreed to purchase 1,250 acres of land of the President37 at 13/3 (P.E. currency of 6/ per $).37 Landed at Pictou in the evening, engaged our passage in the coach for Halifax to quit on the following morning & put up for the night at the Royal Oak Hotel. 35 Henry Stamper (1789-1859) was born in Yorkshire, England, and married Catherine Normore, daughter of Joseph and Mary Pippy of Charlottetown. His store, known as "Stamper's Corner," on the south side of Queen Square, was a landmark fondly recalled many years later: "Mr. Stamper was a particularly neat and gentlemanly little Englishman; he was always obliging, had a nicely-kept bookstore, and, as he usually kept the latest English and Colonial newspapers and periodicals, his shop was a favorite resort for the young, and, we may say, some of the older men too, who would meet there to discuss the latest war and society news, talk politics or gossip, criticize the passers by, and sometimes indulge in a little scandal." Elizabeth] L.M.[acdonald], "Charlottetown Fifty Years Ago," The Prince Edward Island Magazine, II (January, 1901), 346. 36 Thomas Boggs Tremaine (1803-1864), a Charlottetown merchant whose store and home were on Queen Street, was the son of Richard and Mary Boggs Tremaine of Halifax. He married his cousin, Elizabeth Allen, daughter of Benjamin and Mary Tremaine of Quebec. His sister, Louisa, also married a cousin, Charles William, son of Jonathan and Mary Lee Tremaine of Halifax. Ebenezer Mack Treman and Murray E. Poole, The History of the Treman, Tremaine, Truman Family in America (Ithaca, New York, 1901), 1,323. ; -t' v IfMMN 37 Edward James Jarvis (1788-1852), Chief Justice of Prince Edward Island from 1827 to 1852, served as president of the Executive Council from 1829 to 1839. Joseph Wilson Lawrence, The Judges of New Brunswick and Their Times (St. John, New Brunswick, 1907), 270-79; Stewart Wallace (ed.), The Macmillan Dictionary of Canadian Biography (Toronto, 1963), 345. Courtesy Public Archives of PEI Chief Justice Edward James Jarvis Courtesy Public Archives of NS Richard Tremaine of Halifax, father of Thomas Boggs Tremaine of Charlottetown. 15 H.B. Sterlings Charlottetown by Jim Hornby The w e s t e n d of Water Street. In the foreground of this well-to-do residential district is a striking view of what was once the Sterling family home (as other, family photos attest). Extensively altered over the years, this building at 21 Water is presently a multi-apartment dwelling with only a side entrance to Water Street In the background, and more recognizable today are 2-6 Water, and 2 Haviland Street (the United Services Officers Club). Or family name. While the architectural firm of David Stirling and his apprentice W.C. Harris is sometimes encountered as "Sterling and Harris," David was clearly a "Stirling," and so the name appears on his and Clara's gravestone in the People's Cemetery. But after David's death in 1888 and up to 1914, two years before her own demise, Clara was always listed as "Sterling" in Island directories. The last reference found for her son (in McAlpine's Maritime Directory, 1900) gives "Sterling, Harry B, electrician, bds, 27 Water" - close to the P.E.I. Electric Light Company at 35-37 Water where he is said to have worked. His life after leaving the Island has not been traced. Harry Sterling was of an age to have grown up just as amateur photography became widely accessible and popular. His focus on streetscapes and notable buildings reflects his father's profession of architecture as well as his own technical skill and eye for composition. In the following descriptions all readings are left-to-right, and dates of the completion of buildings are given in brackets where known. Identifications from the Sterling Collection are in bold face type. "ne of the largest groups of 19th century photographs in our Public Archives is the Sterling Collection, donated by Mr. and Mrs. Jack Wyers of Burlington, Ontario, and primarily the work of photographer Henry Burton Sterling. A few of the photos date to 1862, others to c. 1885; but most dated prints are from 1893-95 and are stamped with the initials H.B.S. The dated ones in this selection (here published for the first time) are 1893-95 except the last and possibly one other. Charlottetown scenes comprise the majority of prints in the Sterling Collection, with others taken in Summerside, Halifax, Montreal, and Boston. This sampling of Sterling's Charlotte- Sources town photos is an introduction to the profusion of images he has All Sterling photographs are reproduced with permission left of the Island capital. (and the kind assistance) of the Public Archives of P.E.I. Of Sterling himself little seems to be known. His father was the Thanks to Irene Rogers for advice; see her Walks in Charlotte well-known architect David Stirling. Born in Galashiels, Scot- Town for more on some of these buildings, and her forthcoming land, in 1822, David Stirling set up operations in Halifax, and book, Charlottetown: The Life in the Houses. Also useful has branched over to Prince Edward Island. Here he met Clara been Mary K. Cullen, "Charlottetown Market Houses 1813Richmond Lea, and they married on December 1, 1869. Their 1958," The Island Magazine, No. 6, pp. 27-32; Ruth Heartz son, known as Harry, was born on October 10,1871, and spent MacKenzie's West Street Revisited; James B. Pollard's Prince most of the next 30 years in Charlottetown. Edward Island: Military and Civil (1898); and Benjamin BremConsistency has not been a feature of the spelling of this ner's Memories of Long Ago (1930). 16 Mil Victoria R o w from t h e Court H o u s e , 1 8 9 3 . The Victoria Row block of Richmond Street was built in brick after the fire of February, 1884. To the left, at the corner of Great George Street, is Queen Square School Still extant are the Newson Block (c. 1885), the Morris Block (1890), the Cameron Block (1884), the Brown Block (1885), and the Stamper Block (1892) at Stampers Corner. Opposite it across Queen Street at far right is London House. Q u e e n S q u a r e from t h e s o u t h w e s t , 1 8 9 3 . Activity is centred at the 1867 Market House on Market Square, the western portion of Queen Square. This area and that occupied by the stone Post Office (1872) next to it are now filled by the Confederation Centre complex. Further along are Province House (1847), now being renovated by Parks Canada, the Court House (1876), and Old St. Paul's Church (1836). This view is a reverse angle of the one above. 17 * The Market House and Queen Street from the top of the Post Office, 1895. London House at the corner is not included, but next to it part of Beer Bros store and sign are visible, followed by GoffBros, then Moore & McLeod (whose window display is just left of the Market), J.B. MacDonald, Geo. Carter & Co. ("Booksellers & Seedsmen"), Watson s Drugstore, (unknown) Boots and Shoes, and Dodd & Rogers Hardware. Despite changes, this block remains much the same today. i^SiH^ft Preparing to move the old St. Dunstan's Cathedral, (1896). This wooden cathedral (1843) is about to be moved on rails some yards north to the grounds of Queen Square School. The spire on its far end, containing a once-familiar town clock, has been removed. South of the church across Dorchester Street is the former Bishop s Palace (1875) at 45 Great George. On this site the first stone St. Dunstans Cathedral was completed in 1907, and ravaged by fire on March 8, 1913, after which the present Basilica was completed in 1919. 18 r~* Corner of Queen and Grafton Streets, 1894. A downto-earth view of city streets; as it is summer, streets are at their firmest and the wooden sidewalks may be ignored. In the corner wooden building are W.D. McKay Woolen Mills and Store (where you could trade wool for "ready-made clothing'), and S.B. Enman grocers. It and the brick-and-stone building next on Queen (built by Benjamin Rogers in 1887) are the site of the recent controversial building erected by the Bank of Commerce. Only the brick Offer Building in the centre of the block, and City Hall (1888), whose belfry is seen across Kent Street, remain today. The chatty trio outside Dodd & Rogers in the foreground are in what is today a busy central intersection. Upper Prince Street, 1 8 9 4 . This block is actually at the top of Prince Street rather than Upper Prince - a separate street extension. The first house, with its elegant tower, is gone, the site now occupied by the First Baptist Church. Next, at 237 Prince is theMacLennan House (1886), the brickPaton House (1882) at 241 Prince, and the mansard-roofed houses at 247-249 Prince and 165 Euston Street. 19 Interior of Exhibition Building. Inside this 1890s building on the Kensington Road is an impressive array of produce, including oysters and ice-cream at right rear, and plants, paintings, cheese and sausage on the gallery level Along the gallery at left is a "God Save the Queen" banner, which may indicate the picture dates from 1897, the year of Victorias Diamond Jubilee. The building was destroyed by fire in April, 1945. I n t e r i o r of M a s o n i c H a l l , l a t e r P r i n c e E d w a r d Theatre, 1 8 9 4 . As in the picture above, this interior photograph is taken before customers arrive. The 1891 Hairs site on Grafton Street is now a parking lot in front of the Prince Edward Cinemas. What a symbol of our changing cultural life! 20 .vife The Ings House, the Esplanade. Dundas Esplanade was named for Lieutenant-Governor George Dundas (1858-70), who was in office when it was laid out on the former Barrack Square in 1864. It ran from the west end of Water Street along the waterfront to Sydney Street; its buildings were on grounds now occupied by the Sacred Heart Home and Charlottetown Hospital. The street commanded a fine view of the Hillsborough Bay and Victoria Park, for those who could afford it. Unidentified house and people. This is the house at 55 Euston Street owned at various times by Dennis Reddin (who may have built it) and J.C. James. This side (whose circular window is now boarded) faces west; today you enter the house from the south (street) side. 21 Steam Navigation Wharf at the foot of Great George Street, 1895. At left is A[lbert] Duchemin& Co. ("The Prince Edward Island Door and Sash Factory"), on a former location of the Revere Hotel. Opposite, the Charlottetown Steam Navigation Co. advertised that "Time from Charlottetown to Boston or Montreal is only 24 hours. Returning [is] 27 hours." The first carbon electric lights were installed in 1885, by the company for whom the photographer worked. And Sterling probably left the Island from here. Connolly's Wharves in winter. These wharves at the foot of Haviland Street were owned by leading city businessman Owen Connolly. Here stands James Barrett's uBee Hive Lumber Yard"; but the bees are hibernating for the winter. Militia at Fort Edward (c. 1897-1902). A display of military might? Here come the boys of the old brigade,'marching from the Drill Shed - seen almost beneath the spire of Kirk of Saint James (1875) - across Victoria Park Roadway, opened in 1897 to honour the Queen. Behind the Drill Shed (whose site is now part of a civil servant parking lot) is seen the four-storey West Kent Public School. Then the West Street mansions: Cundall House (Beaconsfield, 1877), Westbourne (1877), Edenhurst (c. 1865 to 1902), and Riverside (1874). 22 The C.P. Flockton Comedy Company by Reginald Carrington Short Re kegular readers of this magazine will recall "Drama at Abells Cape" by Adele Townshend in No. Six. Mrs. Townshend there mentions Charles P. Flockton, the American actor who was one of the first members of the summer colony of actors and writers that appeared around Fortune Bay until sometime in the 1950s. Mrs. Townshend also referred to the memoir that follows, written by American actor Reginald Carrington Short (who used his first two names as a stage name). Drawn from the New York and Boston theatrical orbit to Flockton's Island retreat, Short and his wife and their friends the Harry Warwicks (who owned a cottage) were regular summer visitors for many years. Edited for publication here, Short's tale of his discovery of the Island as a member of Flockton's illfated summer stock company was preserved in the George Leard Papers in the Public Archives of Prince Edward Island. Grandly entitled "Thespians in Arcady," it was the third chapter (and is likely the only surviving remnant) of his unpublished autobiography. With its mixture of anecdote, folklore and sentiment, Short's prose is appropriately theatrical (including the condescending notes about the locals being "a trifle primitive naturally"). Yet in reading it one gets a sense of a real respect and affection for the Island and its people. Short's enthusiasm for local folklore and legend is sometimes inaccurately rendered, as in the opening section where he garbles the Abell-Pearce story by making Abell the murderer and gives a fanciful origin for the name Fortune. The year of the Flockton Comedy Company's brief tour has not been discovered, but it can be considered turn-of-the-century as something "a few winters later" happened in 1905 (re Cuthbert Cooper). As the story opens, Reginald and his friend Harry have already landed at Abells Cape, ahead of the rest of the Company, which stopped off in Port Hawkesbury to be picked up in Flockton's 30-foot schooner. Their disinclination to trust the comforts of Flockton's Stroller is vindicated when the aptlynamed vessel is overdue arriving. . . . Edited by Jim Hornby Courtesy Public Archives of PEI Elsa (Mrs. Harry) Warwick, actress and model. She and Harry had a cottage which they visited for many summers. 23 _ Abells Cape, situated at the mouth of Fortune River, was at that time a charming old world spot. The original farm house, overlooking the bay, stood among dense woods of fir and spruce. Built somewhere around the middle of the 19th century, it had resisted the ravages of time and appeared to be in a fairly good state of preservation. From the high cliff of red sandstone on which it stood, a narrow path wound its way down to a somewhat delapidated wharf in the immediate foreground. There the local fishermen moored their boats, stowed gear and dried their nets. Nor was romance lacking. Many years previously, murder had been committed in the old barn on the property by the then-owner Abell from whom the Cape derived its name. Moreover, a strong belief persisted among the natives that somewhere on the Cape that much over-rated and maligned pirate, Captain Kidd, had buried his treasure. This fact may have been responsible for the name Fortune Bay on which the Cape itself was situated. Be that as it may, the fact remained that treasure seekers from all parts of Canada and the United States had endeavoured to locate the pirate's hoard, as innumerable shafts and trenches offered mute testimony. Also, there existed a wide belief in Abell's house being haunted, a belief not entirely unrelated to the mischievous activities of John Davidson, Flockie's skipper and caretaker. So efficacious became his ghostly impersonations that no native would venture near the house after nightfall under any considerations. John, having a good job and being well a w a r e of t h e fact, h a d b e e n at considerable pains in developing an efficient t e c h n i q u e calculated t o discourage potential pretenders to his little kingdom of Abells Cape. Whether this more or less romantic background was responsible for the attraction the Cape possessed for thespians, one can only conjecture. The fact remains however, that many v e t e r a n s of the stage were to be encountered there, or in its immediate vicinity, summer after summer. One particularly recalls such old timers as Cooper, Stevenson, Kent, Coghlan, and Glendinning. Although these have long since passed on, they still live in the memories of the older natives who were their contemporaries. Glendinning's S w i m Their activities form the subject of 24 many a tall yarn - John Glendinning's swim for instance, an exploit that has become a species of Fortune Bay saga. It appears that John, a man of parts, especially in his cups, was returning home from Souris o n e sweltering afternoon accompanied by his old crony Frank Hollins. Alas, both beautifully pickled. The old horse shay driven by Frank rattled and rumbled across the Fortune River Bridge. But John had had a b o u t e n o u g h of it. H e r o l l e d , completely clothed, out of the trap and into the river. Frank, quite unconscious of this d e f e c t i o n , was c o n v e y e d homewards by the ancient nag to whom the road was more than familiar. In the meantime Jessie, John's wife, was sitting on the veranda awaiting the revellers. "Where's John?" she enquired, as the conveyance came to a stop. Frank was slumbering peacefully. Every effort to arouse him failed hopelessly. Jessie slapped and pounded him, until finally he muttered something hopelessly unintelligible. To every query Frank merely emitted a grunt. Jessie was in despair. Presently a small round object came bobbing on the surface of the river, a seal perhaps! but no, it did not swim like a seal, what could it be? Closer it came, till finally it reached the wharf. Then, like Neptune emerging from the deep, John Glendinning made his appearance, dead sober. With a twinkle in his eye he exclaimed to Jessie, "Damn fine swim that, good mile and a half, now how about supper." Frank, still oblivious of the entire proceedings, was gently but firmly put to bed. Flockton's friend' The previously mentioned Cuthbert Cooper was an old-timer and interesting character generally. "Coopie" as we used to call him, looked for all the world like a typical village dominie. But he was only a superannuated old actor, whose occupation, like Othello's, was gone. In very truth innocuous desuetude had claimed him as its own. Perhaps life, robbed of all illusions and revealing itself in its utter futility, had crushed him as beneath the wheels of a juggernaut, and perhaps also he had partaken too freely of the waters of Lethe (or call it the grape if you prefer). And so he had fallen by the wayside; but that he had come out of great tribulation was obvious. He and Flockton had been close friends for many years, so it proved no surprise w h e n he a n n o u n c e d his intention of settling in P.E.I. Flockton, it appeared, had offered to make him a small weekly allowance to render his plans feasible. A little cottage, belonging to Flockton, was also placed at his disposal during the remainder of his life. His wants were negligible. Like Flockton, he was always welcome to share the farmers meals. This enabled him to expend, almost exclusively, his small allowance on consolation of the kind already hinted at. My friend Harry, having purchased an acre of land and put up a small cottage thereon, also decided to remain at Fortune Bay over the winter. The two cottages were perhaps 500 yards apart. One bitterly cold mid-winter night with a blizzard "beginning to make," Harry happened to notice a complete absence of smoke from Cooper's chimney. In such a temperature this had very serious implications, leaving him no choice but to investigate. Through the deep snow he reached Cooper's place, pushed the door open and entered the kitchen. Poor old Cooper lay slumped over an extinct s t o v e , b l u e with cold a n d q u i t e unconscious. A coil of rope hung at the back of the door, and taking this down Harry made a couple of loops, which he passed under Cooper's arms. Then, with considerable difficulty, he managed to get the old man on his shoulders and out into the night. All this took time. Meanwhile the blizzard had started in earnest, indeed had become formidable. Visibility was lowered to such an extent that only by following the fence could Harry find his way home. At last, almost exhausted, he reached his door. Laying Cooper on the day-bed he proceeded to render what aid he could. Fortunately plenty of whisky was available. Forcing a good stiff glass-full between Cooper's teeth, he covered him up with rugs, made up the fire and retired for the night. Next morning Cooper seemed little the worse for his brush with the Enemy. In fact he dismissed the whole affair as a mere incident - didn't realize, in all probability, what an exceedingly close shave he had had. But a few winters later brought the tragic finale: a farmer, happening to notice an unfamiliar mound of snow on one of his fields and thinking perhaps some "critter" might have perished and be lying there, kicked the snow away to find, to his amazement Coopie. This time relief had come too late. Coopie's little moment of sleep, borrowed from death, had been repaid in full. 3. A D r a m a and Vl Am Hoi^e^' Roauel. CPT-LooKforx a n d R ^ e ^ . O W o v y faftf/vviffv A\Jr-ec\ u 2.TKe u p - t o - d a t e Uuc^LaUe. Tar<>e. Q.u"WWt Cooper, ReciLi/va\cL C o r r L r ^ t o r ^ H g r r v \J0 ©NT-uxck e n d W Y ^ S v r ^ W W UVIRJQstone. 3. C.Q.r&cftejr SOAG ev^d S3 <g \r\Qj^,, ^ »VN or\e A c t , v^ritfe^ WM L-SHAvwaQi^ TWe soWUevs o l -the- Q^aee.^" - G o ^ d © ^ Aue/\aecL \X. b c o t c K Sor\c\ -^v\c\ ~D 9iAC£_. ^. A K o ^ Q i A t i c "tx^sroa IA o^e_. Act kj^ C^dkt>e.'H~ Qcx>p5-i^ n u "T"Ue.. G-S^SM Lovejr u IS. T U e V33U\ov^ PS\\e*-<^ "Plate-" U'YspejrsonaUotx YYU^ vnri aM -H-divAe. -and Y ^ a ^ W - £<d^j©rd G ' a ^ v 'v£>|pu\a\~ \ ru2.eS v KoxA.O s ^ O v ^ l , IHTERIM The Company Arrives Martha, John Davidson's wife, was expecting the arrival of the C. P. Flockton Comedy Company, and if her greeting to we two of the advance guard lacked cordiality, the reason was not far to seek. Poor Martha was up against a pretty tough proposition. "There was nothing to do with" as she put it. Every sort of domestic essential was lacking, even food. Of that only a small quantity remained - tea, bread, butter, potatoes; of linen, crockery, cutlery, and kitchen utensils there were practically none. However, no use grousing about it, we must make the best of a bad job. After all, the situation had its humorous aspects, and these we must endeavour to exploit. But what about the schooner? Two days elapsed without tidings of any sort. She could not have foundered, as the weather conditions precluded that possibility. Nevertheless, we were beginning to feel considerable anxiety, when around midnight of the third day of our arrival we were aroused from sleep by the sound of voices coming from the wharf. Throwing coats over our shoulders we sallied forth to discern, by the dim light of a lantern, figures moving against a ghostly background of sails, spars and cordage. Yes, all was well; our argonauts were safely come to shore. Slowly they began to stagger up the path towards the house. Pale, unshaven and dishevelled, exhausted by lack of food and sleep, they presented a woebegone aspect. Gradually their story unwound itself. Becalmed for 40 hours, with their scanty supplies of food and water almost exhausted, there had remained no alternative but to take the dinghy, row to the nearest land 10 miles distant, and obtain relief. Fortunately we had a little whisky with us and were able to supply first aid. "Roughing it" We now found ourselves confronted with a situation which might have daunted such an aggregation as the Swiss Family Robinson. Where was food to come from? Flockie was out of the picture — his credit was exhausted at the local store. Short of a miracle on the lines of the 'loaves and fishes" we should be out of luck, and that soon. Harry and I had our trout rods with us, and this seemed to offer a small ray of hope to the famished members of the C. P. Flockton Comedy Company. For we almost detected a cannibalistic gleam in the eyes of the men. With grim determination we set forth to lure a few trout. Well, we caught a few, but it requires a good "mess" to feed a dozen people. Our efforts were received with sniffs! Better had these doubting Thomases exercised a little patience, for next morning some 50 small lobsters, remaining beneath the rocks at low water, fell victims to misplaced confidence and our good fortune. This exploit we capped by spearing an equal number of flounders the very next day. A growing feeling of respect, if not reverence, was now clearly discernible in the attitude of our companions. We swelled visibly. But naturally these piscatorial triumphs could hardly be expected to continue indefinitely. Man proposes and weather disposes. Came a day when neither trout, lobsters nor flounders were available. Apparently nothing remained but starvation. Whether due to hunger one can't say, but suddenly one of us had a lucid interval, or would you call it inspiration? Seagull's eggs! Eureka! The problem was solved. Nothing more nourishing, and we knew where thousands could be obtained - Sea Gull Beach. Good Lord, why hadn't we thought of it before? "Get a pail and come along." Eight quarts of eggs was the result of this brilliant idea. The Flockton Comedy Company was duly informed of their salvation; moreover, that luxury beckoned. Plover's eggs! The Company was duly informed that a delicacy such as plover's eggs was simply snapped up, regardless of cost, by invalids, gourmets, yes even royalty itself. All to no purpose; the eggs were eaten in dead silence. Their funeral oration, pronounced by our ex-barber, proved brief but painful: "Rotten." But now, at the eleventh hour, the tide began to turn. By some miraculous means, known only to himself, Flockie succeeded in re-establishing credit at the local store, with the result that meals occurred at almost regular intervals. A universal feeling of relief and content became a p p a r e n t . Carried away by momentary enthusiasm, our ex-barber was discovered carving his initials on Flockie's mantelpiece in letters six inches high. During all these lean days Harry and I had borne ourselves with that noble patience and resignation which are characteristic of truly great souls. Never a complaint or peevish word passed our lips. In spite of our innate modesty, we were compelled to admit that our behaviour, during these trying circumstances, had been superb. Of course the fact of our having discovered a nearby farm house, where good solid meals were procurable for the modest investment of 15 cents a "throw," may have contributed in some small measure to our cheerful demeanour. Rehearsals, such as they were, demanded but little of our time. This afforded us an excellent opportunity to become acquainted with many of the farmers in the more immediate neighbourhood. And what a fine people they proved to be, a trifle primitive naturally, but of good Scotch and Irish stock, the former predominating. Kindly to a degree, hospitable almost to a fault, they were content to accept you at your face value. Entirely devoid of self consciousness, they also seemed to possess the happy faculty of making you feel perfectly at home. If you were addressed by your christian n a m e , it might be accepted as a sure sign that you had 25 been weighed in the balance and not found wanting. Bim It was my good fortune to meet one particularly interesting type during my Island sojourn, and I take great pleasure in introducing my very good friend Mr. Abimelech Burke, known to all and sundry as "Bim." Cobbler, fiddler and trout fisherman, Bim was a neighbourhood character. It was as a fisherman though that he excelled. No one could tie a fly more expertly, as the local salmon discovered to their undoing. Among his few possessions, two were especially cherished - an ancient fiddle and his trout pole. The latter in Bim's old gnarled hands assumed almost the virtues of a magician's wand. Spliced in a dozen places, battered, bruised and worn, only the consummate skill of its owner enabled him to use it successfully, or, for that matter, at all. His humorous face, tanned by sun and wind to the colour and texture of leather, strongly reminded you of some quaint old gargoyle. His eyes, faded but still alive with humour; his Archaic English, fund of anecdote, understanding and tolerance; these characteristics all contributed to a singular if not unique character. But what interested me most was Bim's unshakeable belief in every form of superstition. Naturally the ghost of Abells Cape and the legend of Kidd's treasure found strong support and confirmation in Bim. And did he love his wee drappie! Sometimes on my return from Souris I would stop in at Bim's and present him with a token of my esteem and regard. A few applications of the ambrosia and Bim, the real Bim, would come to life. Down would come the fiddle; off would go his shoes, the latter gesture an outward sign of the inward and alcoholic state of the country fiddler. Finally the fiddle would be laid aside and the grandfather of all pipes produced. This carefully filled and lighted, he would peer at me thoughtfully over the top of his old patched spectacles and remark tentatively, "I don't suppose you ain't never done no diggin' for treasure have ye?" Reluctantly, I was compelled to reply in the negative. "Don't believe in no such foolishness I The treasure seekers get a shock 26 suppose?" I declared myself open to conviction, and passed the bottle. Bim savoured his drink thoughtfully, a faraway look in his eyes. "Lemme see, must 'a' been four, five year ago. I mind I was doin' a small job o' work one afternoon when five strangers drives up here. Was I Bim Burke they asts, 'Yes,' I sez, 'that's my name, come in won't ye?' They come in and set. 'Pears they're out o' Boston. "Did I know Abells Cape? 'Natcherly,' I sez, 'I was borned right here.' They gams a while, then the beans is spilled. Come to dig for treasure seems like; Kidd's treasure. Was I game to go along? They'd see I didn't lose nothing by it, how about a couple o' dollars win or lose? They has a big passel o' picks, shovels and the like wrapped up in burlap outside the door. We has a few drinks, good stuff too seemed like, brung from Boston too it was. I don't know for why, but it ain't no use diggin' for treasure 'ceptin' at midnight; anyone'lltellye that. "Them fellers has got hold of a map some'rs so we starts early to find the spot marked on it. It was a awful dark night but nacherly they has brung a lantern. At that it must 'a' been a couple hours before they come on what looks like the place marked on the map. Ghost ship "Even then they ain't by no means sure, but anyhow they starts a-diggin'. They was jest gettin' warmed up to their work when out comes the moon from a mess o' clouds, and tho' you won't never believe me, a-standin' up the Bay comes a ship, the likes o' which none o' us ever seen before. Drorin' full she was, a square-rigger, bow an' stern high an' deep in the waist. Yes sir, up she comes 'til she's broadside on to us, down goes her helium and dead into the eye of the wind she comes, then over goes her mud-hook, the chain rattles out through her hawse-pipe and her sails is clewed up ;< "Smart as ye please, overside goes her longboat and into her tumbles the worst looking lot of furriners you ever seen, handkerchers over their heads, belts full o' knives and pistols. Hairy fellers, all o' them. They out oars and come straight for us. "Was you ever really skeered? I mean so's you couldn't move? We was, mortally skeered. But when that there boat shoves her nose up on the beach and them fellers piles out and starts a-comin' right for us, then we come to life and come quickly, I'm tellin' ye. Like the devil hisself was after us. Mebbe he was. Seems like I smelled brimstone. "We gets to my place blowin' like grampusses, all of us shakin' like we had the ague. Come break o' day they lit out for Bear River, where they aimed to take the train for Boston. I mind how they wouldn't even go back and fetch their gear. I still got some on it." I looked sideways at Bim. Was he kidding me, I wondered? He may have been, but I don't think so. How many drinks had the treasure seekers consumed before their adventure? That was what I wanted to know. B e f o r e t h e Public, Briefly The date of our Souris opening was approaching. The little town, agog with curiosity and excitement, awaited the arrival of the C. P. Flockton Comedy Company with feverish impatience. The show to them represented an event of almost national importance. Everyone knew Flockie. They had journeyed from far and near in every style of conveyance known to the Island, to do him reverence. It was scarcely surprising therefore that the curtain rose to a capacity house. A few brief but wellchosen remarks from our impresario opened the proceedings, and what an array of talent was disclosed. "A jennuwine potpurry of moosic," as a radio announcer once had it. Cornet solos, banjo duets, sketches, songs, monologues, and lastly a new contraption, styled the "cinematograph." This film machine, like the wine of Biblical fame, had been kept 'til the last part of the program; it was our piece de resistance. Unfortunately, whether owing to the unskilful manipulation of our ex-barber, or some imperfection in its innards - after a brief but showy exhibition of temperament it decided to call it a performance and sank into oblivion, and that was that! Would that you could have seen Flockie on that memorable occasion. The effect of a capacity audience was simply electrical. Under our eyes a metamorphosis had taken place; from a person he had become a personage. A look of noble pride shone in his eyes. Head erect, chest out, shoulders squared, he looked the very personification of the successful theatrical manager. Only the silk hat and fur coat of tradition were lacking. There followed another almost totally successful night's business, after which began the decline and fall of the Flockton Comedy Company. Four one-night stands, all unprofitable, brought us to Charlottetown, the capital and our Waterloo. Our first night's performance in that delightful little city realized some 30 dollars. Of the entertainment itself let us be charitable and preserve a discreet silence. It was stigmatized by one native as "chronic." I'm still wondering. The audience however did enjoy one good hearty laugh. Again the cinematograph rose to the occassion; a train dashed onto the screen in great style, indeed it would have been perfect had the picture not been upside down. Oh yes, it got a laugh, but also, I fear, was instrumental in handling the coup de grace to the Hockton Comedy Company. Yet, in spite of this fiasco, nine optimists or philanthropists paid admission to the following evening. Then we touched bottom, not even a stray dog in front of the house. It was curtains for the Flockton Comedy Company. All that could be done was to return its members to their homes. But how? Aftermath There remained but to call a meeting of the now defunct company. A very deflated Flockie took the chair. The outlook depicted by him was scarcely encouraging: he was broke, dead broke. "How about getting these people back to the States, you're responsible you know"; he was sorry but what could he do, he hadn't a bean. Finally he consented to entrain for Souris and endeavour to put another mortgage on his property. This having been successfully accomplished, each member of the Company received a steamer ticket to Boston. Harry and I, electing to remain on the Island, were excepted. It is recorded, however, that the said steamer tickets included no such trivial items as meals. For we afterwards learned that but for the kindness of the S.S. Halifax's stewards, our returning thespians would have been without food during the entire journey of nearly two days. Well here we were, Harry and I, footloose and fancy free. As a matter of fact, apart from one's natural sympathy for Flockie in the failure of his venture, we were satisfied with the trend of events, especially as there had never been the slightest doubt in our minds as to the final outcome of the undertaking. This being the case, we had made arrangements at a certain farmhouse, already mentioned, whereby board and lodging would be available for the extremely modest sum of two dollars and fifty cents a week, washing included. We considered it modest, but evidently, the fact having got around, the neighbours did not. We were actually informed by several well-wishers that we were being "took" advantage of. The farmhouse where I now took up residence was situated on the banks of the Fortune River, directly across from Abells Cape. My quarters consisted of a bedroom and the "setting" room, both scrupulously neat and clean. Susie, the eldest daughter, served my three daily meals in the dining room since, for reasons unspecified, I had not been invited to join the family in the kitchen. A scant hundred yards from the front door brought one to the finest trout pool on the river, so that meals could be supplemented almost daily by salmon trout. Here one lived a quiet, uneventful existence, "the world forgetting and by the world forgot" In my humble opinion, only under such circumstances can man achieve real content and peace of mind. 27 If you're inclined to be skeptical, reduce life to its simplest terms and give it a trial; you won't regret it. The family was not much in evidence, being pretty busy with their field work and chores. The little you did see of them, however, went far to increase your opinion of their sterling qualities. Except perhaps in the Scandinavian countries, it would be difficult to duplicate these people anywhere. Before retiring for the night, my host Will would make a practice of paying me a little visit of ceremony. It didn't last long, 20 minutes at the most, but while I appreciated the motive, it must be confessed that it proved a mauvais quart d'heure of the first magnitude. Conversationally we hadn't a single subject in common. Fishing, crops, weather; and once these had been exhausted practically nothing remained. The end of our verbal tether reached, a most embarrassing silence would follow, broken only by the loud ticking of the clock. At last Will would slowly rise to his feet and say, "Well goodnight sir, I hope you'll sleep well," and exit. Then, the night being propitious, one would light a final pipe and stroll down the path to the river. What words ever could depict those nights? Those wonderful nights. Nights apparently peculiar to northern hemispheres. Cool, even cold, displaying the most dazzling constellations imaginable. Often the northern lights flashing across our visible universe added to the splendour of the heavens. Well might the Psalmist exclaim, "In wisdom hast thou made them all." Memory, too, recalls a great yellow moon, reminiscent of an immense Chinese lantern rising slowly and majestically out of the ocean; rising until high above the dark woods of Abells Cape it would shed its luminous reflection over the still waters of the Bay. Denouement Needless to relate, no very joyful feelings dominated Harry and me at the thought of returning to civilization when our summer on the Island drew to a close. We had enjoyed such a vacation as falls to the lot of very few mortals. The inevitable morning arrived when we arose at four to catch the early train at Bear River. Have you ever seen one of those sublime masterpieces of nature before which you can only stand silent and breathless? One of the really few mornings that remain with you, yes, as long as memory lasts. 28 Photo by Jim Hornby Flockton's monument at Abells Cape, containing his ashes. A heavy dew had whitened the fields, creating an almost perfect illusion of hoar frost, while myriads of spider's webs spread upon the grass their exquisite traceries. These, touched by the magic of the early morning sun, flashed and sparkled with prismatic rays like diamond necklaces. Not a cloud in the vast dome of the sky, not even a breath to stir the alders by the brook. Smoke ascending from the chimneys of early risers. A last few farewells and reluctantly we climb into the waiting buggy. "Giddap there." The old nag ambled along at three miles an hour. So enchanting was the panorama that one felt utterly indifferent to anything save the exquisite enjoyment of the moment. Would we make the connection? Oh, what fell Bill! Along the river, past one's favourite trout pool (that's w h e r e I c a u g h t that twopounder), past well remembered farms "Good morning Mrs. Dingwell; yes, got to get back to the States, good-bye, good-bye" - through the fragrant pine woods. Farewell Arcadia, farewell summer! A woman might find relief in tears; being a mere male one must be content to apostrophize the old horse and say "Giddap." Sources While public apathy brought an early end to the C.P. Flockton Comedy Company, interest in the Fortune show-folk has been keen from the outset. As far back as the third volume of The Prince Edward Island Magazine(DecembeY 1901), no fewer than three pieces appeared from the pens of visiting actors: a poem, "An Island Idyl," by "Cuthbert Cooper, New York"; Charles Kent's "Kidd's Treasure"; and "The Murder of Abell" by Flockton himself. Thanks are due to Mrs. Townshend's article already cited, and to the late George Leard and the Leard Papers in PAPEI. Among the dramatis personae buried in Fortune area, Martha and John Davidson lie in Bay Fortune United Church Cemetery, along with Cooper. For many readers, playwright Elmer Harris is the most memorable of the Fortune summer set, as it was in this area his famous Johnny Belinda (first published as The Inner Silence in 1934) is located. Is it farfetched to hear in the name of his play's villain "Locky" an echo of the popular "Flockie" of earlier days? Some of My Experiences at Sea, Part One liMN MfNHii Courtesy Wanson Hemphill John Hemphill about 1900 Edited by Jim by John Hemphill X% early 60 years ago Frederick William Wallace urged Maritimers to learn more about "the brave days of wooden ships." "Fourth place among the shipowning nations," he wrote, "building famous vessels and breeding a class of daring and resourceful seamen who are still a legend among seafarers in British and foreign ships, the Maritime Provinces of Canada seem to have forgotten a part of their history of which they should be inordinately proud." While in recent years much material on shipbuilding and shipping has been gathered by maritime historians, and displayed in museums (such as our own Green Park and the new Maritime Museum of the Atlantic in Halifax), few first-hand accounts exist of the lives of our "daring and resourceful seamen." What follows is such an account, for John Hemphill (1871-1967) speaks with a sailor's memories, His voice is direct and understated, that of a plain man who doesn't waste words, at least not on paper. Yet there is a definite flavour to his words, a fishing-shack bravado about the dangers of the sea by a man who couldn't swim. Several who have read the manuscript agree that they can "feel the salt spray." Hemphill went to sea at 17 from his home in Georgetown and sailed the Atlantic coast from St John's to Boston for a number of years. He later worked at shipbuilding for Daniel Gordon and as a commercial traveller, ran a grocery store in Cardross, and had a small shop in Georgetown where he made woodsleighs and carts. John moved to Covehead in 1939 after the death of his first wife, and it was here that he began to carve ship models. On his third marriage in 1943 he moved to St. Peter's where he lived until shortly before his death in December, 1967. Hemphill's reminiscences of seafaring were written in a scribbler about 20 years ago at the urging of his son Jack. One of the virtues of this writing, a relative lack of self-consciousness, is the result of Hemphill writing for himself and his family rather than for publication. It was decided to make him clearer to the reader by standardizing spelling, adding paragraphing, and capitalizing words as needed. Some apparent capital letters have been left on words where they would not usually appear because they seem part of the author's voice. Otherwise little editing has been done beyond omitting a few repetitious lines and dis- Hornby connected sections. A sample of the author's writing is included with the text. The experiences of which he writes occurred in the late 1890s and the early years after 1900. M, Ly father, Capt Daniel Hemphill, was caught in the great August Gale, the time all the American vessels were lost on the North Shore of P.E.I. Capt Dan Hemphill ran from East Point to Pictou in the same gale, in a vessel called the Lily. He was owner of her. She was a pink[y] and run like a bird I heard my father say. My Father Capt Dan was an old georgeman, a Capt out of Gloucester in about the year 1870, and fished many years out of Souris in his own vessel. My first long voyage was to St Johns, Newfoundland, in the Brig Stella owned by James E. McDonald Cardigan Bridge, and sailed by Capt Neilson. Her mate Donald Steele, better known as bald headed Donald. I had a brother on board, Chas by name, as an able seaman. For my self I served as cook. The Stella was built in Cardigan Bridge by Duncan MacLaren, and I must say a noble little ship she was. They may 29 of St Johns Newfoundland. The Stella had a general cargo, and loaded fish for Pumabook [Corner Brook]. I left the Stella at St Johns. She was sold there, with her cargo offish,and made her trip as usual. l •u * ..i %f> 1 \ mmmmgmm Courtesy Public Archives of PE1 The Stella under construction at Cardigan, late 1890s TkLs&ZUfar IAHU jtmdP^Pn- B^Miopi^/3M{jr^ jiwujutf* predict mud: 1/ t talk about their ships under sail, but the Stella was a bird in a breeze or gale of wind. On our trip from P.E.I, to St Johns we encountered a heavy gale of wind off Cape Royal, about 30 miles from St Johns. When the gale struck us, there was no orders to shorten sail. The Stella hove down on her beam and labored there until all sails were blown off. Then she righted, nothing left but the yards and bolt rope. An able Seaman by the name of George Campbell was at the wheel when the gale hit, and done his best to save the ship. Whether the capt and mate got exited or frightened, I do not know, but they were two dumheads. The evening was coming on and a dark ugly night set in. There was an extra set of sails in the poop deck. They were taken out and bent on, in the darkness of the night. The Stella labored for 7 days at sea before we made the port of St Johns. We were blown unto the banks of Newfoundland with no port in sight for hundreds of miles from the time we took the gale until it was over. Capt or mate kept to the cabin, one in each corner standing there like two statues. Capt Neilson's wife was on board, a 30 nervous wreck, tearing her hair. She was a beautiful woman. When the captain and mate came on deck again, the Stella was glad to see them, for she was on her journey again. When we were out in the gale we seen a beautiful white ship, a hundred tons larger than the Stella. I think she was from Lunenburg N.S. She was a three master, a barkentine. When we sighted her she was only wearing a goosewing topsail, and on the drift. The Stella was wearing a stem stacel [staysail], a foursail [foresail], and a mainsail. This ship was at the mouth of St Johns harbour when the gale came on. She could not make the harbour, so a tug came to her, put a strong hawser on her, and she snapped it off twice and the tug gave up the tow. She went to sea for 9 days, before she made the port of St Johns again. The Stella was 30 miles from St Johns when the gale came on and with getting her back to sail, to weather the gale, we made it in 7 days. There was no rest at sea. She rolled and pitched and threw you out of the bunk. This is a true story of useless captains and mates. These were the days of James E. McDonald, of Cardigan Bridge, and Sir Richard Thorburn, Banks fishing My first experience on the banks, and deep water fishing, was in the Schooner Marguerite, from Beverly Mass. U.S.A. One of the largest bankers out of U.S.A. or other ports at that time. She was a vessel of 135 tons and wore two topmasts. The average banker at that time was about 75 tons. There was a few topsail schooners from Mario [St. Malo] France fishing around us. They were only small. Some times 2 or 3 square rig Barks would lay to, waiting for a shift of wind; they were bound for Halifax. You might say it blowed a gale almost every day. Very few good days. The Nova Scotia vessels did not fish on bad days. We fished every day, Sunday included. No Sunday at rest. Capt Higgins came to Georgetown, he said he was looking for a good man. They sent him down to Panmure Island 3 or 4 miles from Georgetown where I was fishing. I turned my fishing gear over to others, and shipped on the Marguerite. Our first set was off Cape North, C. B. We made a flying set there, with 8 double dories fishing, and loaded them plenty with codfish. A very nice run of fish, but they did not suit the capt in size for the U.S.A. market, so we moved further along, and always had large catches of cod. When we fished in 35 fathoms of water, we would make 2 runs a day. That would be 16 double dories of fish to dress and put away when salted. And when we fished in 135 fathoms of water, we only made one run a day, that would be 8 double dories a day. When our fish were dressed they were spread all over the whole of the vessel, skin down. A Salter with a half bushel basket of salt would throw the salt over them as if he was sowing grain. When you make your vessel ready for bank fishing, you furl your Jibs and hoist them a few feet above the bowsprit. Then take the main boom, drop it down on the church, a heavy standing piece of wood for that purpose. Then place your turnbuckle on both sides of the boom, and set them up tight and she is in trim for fishing. Sometimes at a flying set of trawls your vessel is under Sails jogging around, keeping close to her dorys. The Capt said he fished on the banks for 40 years, and it was the worst season he had seen. We were up before day break, oil cloths on. Waiting for dawn to put our dories over her side. It was a trained job to do so, with her washing her rails under. The wind would whistle through our rigging with a mad roar. Our dories were dropped over the Side and as soon as she was in the water, you were aboard of her. There was no be careful how you got aboard, but we got there. And our food was a V2 gallon of water whether we made the ship or not. I was a bowman in the dory, and hauled the trawl, and passed the fish aft to be taken off by the dory skipper. He is master of the dory. You have to go two years on the banks before you have charge of a dory. The vessel would roll her rails under water, as the dory would wash on top of her rail, and off again with the sea. One day the vessel horsed up with the tide. It had moderated, and her stromtricle did not keep her to the wind. She sucked our dory under her rail, filled her with water. The crew took gaffs, caught us both by the collar of our oilskins and pulled us aboard. There was 135 fathoms of water under us. All of our fish washed out of our dory. They floated and was picked up again. The fog with all the heavy wind would last for days. We run our trawls by compass and found them by compass. If you want to see tide, you will find it in plenty. In the fog when our trawls were hauled and made ready to go to the vessel, I would swing my head around until I would get the best Sound of the foghorn on the vessel, and would swing my hand on the compass to th 2 point of the Sound in my ear, and hit the ship amidships. The dory skipper thought it quite a stunt. The captain would come fored and say boys give her more cable, we are going to have a breeze of wind. When you would think it could blow no harder. One morning after hauling our trawls the wind had shifted giving us a hard berth, with a heavy sea running. We were well loaded down with cod, and taking in water. The dory skipper left the rowing to me, while he done the bailing, but we could not make the vessel with one man rowing. The captain sent a empty dory down to us by bending 2 new coils of rope. When we got holt of the empty dory we did not get into her, but kept pulling on the rope of the empty dory, leaving the empty dory behind us. When the sea would break we would let our dory go back with the sea, then pull her up again, so that we worked our way up to the vessel that way. Then the empty dory was hauled up to the vessel. When our dories came along Side of the vessel, to take out our fish, her bow line was not fastened, it was passed through a fairleader, and the cook attended to it, easing it with the sea, and pulling the dory up again. The storm line was made long, so not to bind her in the sea. Our dories were hoisted on deck, and the plugs taken out of them so that she would be free from water if she boarded a sea. Every man took his turn in watching the ship, and were lucky they were not washed overboard at night. Our Cook was quite deaf, but we got to understand him. We sometimes went to Sydney for our bait and the Magdalen Islands. We had a lot of Halibut that we had caught in our cod trawls, that we were going to trade in for bait at Cape Canso. But the Capt was afraid that they might seize the vessel. So he squared off for the Magdalen Islands, throwing all of the Halibut over. There were many of them, and a waste cf food. One morning as usual we all went out to our trawls it was thick with fog. All returned but one dory. The men in the lost dory were Eddie Muise 16, Saul Spinny 45. Our Capt was heart broken, a man that loved his crew. We layed at anchor for two days, while I stayed on the mast head, only coming down for my meals, watching the fishing vessels, if they had a signal of our men. The Capt fired 24 lbs of powder as a signal for the men, but of no avail. We began to heave up our hawser. That heeled our vessel, in 135 fathoms of water. There was a heavy sea running, and our fishing anchor was caught. We hove on the windlass for hours. Some times our vessel would dip so heavy, that we would slack our hawser to let her rise. She was shipping sea. When we got our anchor, it was broke at the shank. We were caught in the Atlantic cable between Halifax and England. We shaped our course for Sydney C.B. When we came into harbour, Capt went ashore and phoned around with no word of his men. The Capt then set sail for home in U.S.A. to get a new anchor for his vessel. To the surprise of us all, the men turned up. As the story goes, I will relate it. A Norwegian Bark was bound up to some part of New Brunswick, passing a long the North Shore of P. E. I., when her Capt had a dream that bothered him. He drempt he seen two men in a dory, such a course and so many miles. He ordered the mate to swing off the ship to the course he drempt. The mate objected, but the course was run. The Capt put over his log and run his miles, hove his ship to, got his spyglass, and sighted our men. They were out 48 hours, and in Courtesy Wanson Hemphill Photo by Camera Art Drawing by John Hemphill 31 bad shape. He took them aboard, gave them a little wine, but no other foods for a few hours, took the men and dory off to Souris, and the dory was left there. Capt Henry Dicks of Georgetown bought the dory, took her down to the Labrador, and both him and his son were lost on her. It is a ticklish thing on the banks or in heavy sea if you do not handle your dory aright. A safe boat if handled right. [The June 22,1904Charlottetown Herald reported a dispatch stating that "Captain Henry Dicks aged sixty-five and. . . Horatio Dicks aged twenty-five had both been drowned at Labrador on the sixteenth by the upsetting of their dory."] Two trips to Sydney [This is about] my voyage from St. Johns Newfoundland with a Capt Smith of Shelbume N.S. to Sydney C.B. I have forgotten the name of the vessel, but she belonged to C.B. Widden of Bayfield Antigonish [County]. We started from St Johns with a free breeze. She was a vessel of 135 tons, and a two topmaster, and a big old tub she was. She was in the cattle trade. When we left St Johns we had a fair breeze, but not for long. We soon encountered a heavy North wester. We had to shorten close down on sail, and were very busy [to] get her ready. We were now under a double reef foresail, for 2 weeks, and you might say adrift during this time. There was no sun to be had, and we were to the mercy of the Sea and weather. For rest it was scarce. I never had the oilcloths off me during that time. And all were fitted alike. We kept up our regular watch, and the blowing of our foghorn in plenty. At night all things looked so gloomy on watch. The seas would stand up like a great mountain. You would think if it broke on the vessel that she would be swallowed up to the mastheads. A big ocean liner coming up on the crest of a sea like that would be a sad sight to look upon. But as you know at night things always look harder and more fierce. But yet the [sea] was angry. After we had been out for some time and had lost our course, we were still laying to the weather. It had moderated, but where were we. Nothing to pick our vessel up. On a Sunday evening we sighted a steamer, and signaled her. She bore down on us and gave Capt Smith the latitude and longitude. Capt Smith went down aft, and took his course, set all sail, 32 Courtesy George and Donna MacArthur Photo by Camera Art Relief model by John Hemphill and let her go for Arichat. We were somewhere off Sable Island, but we did not see the land. The weather was not so clear to see a distance. When we made Arichat the sea come up so heavy, that it almost was impossible to see the buoys, and to be sure of the channel. It broke from shore to shore, and the Capt was afraid to make the harbour. He was a deep water man; they are not so good on the shore as a coast captain. Our Mate knew the harbour like a book. He was a Capt White. He came to the crew and Said boys are you with me to take the vessel in if the Capt refuses. We all said yes. Then the Mate went to Capt Smith and said square her off for the harbour if not we will take charge of her. The Capt swung her off and made port. We were not into port too long when a wicked squall hove us down on our beam ends. Lucky we had all Sail down, anchored, and furled. When the squall hit us it hove her down on her beam ends, and she spun around like a top on a floor. If we had not made harbour when we did, we might of all been lost. From Arichat she went to Bayfield Antigonish and loaded. I left her there, and came home to Georgetown. I made a voyage on the Dictator owned by Capt Mark Bonnell of Murray Harbour. His vessel was tied up at Georgetown for the winter. The weather kept so fine that Capt Bonnell bent on her Sails to make a trip to Sydney. She was loading for a merchant of Montague Bridge. We began our loading at Lower Montague. It had come a cold night and we were frozen in at Lower Montague. But the Ice broke up and we continued load- ing. This was in the month of January. There was no snow on the ground at that time. We loaded produce at Lower Montague, and came down to the railway wharf at Georgetown to take on some hay. Capt Harpel of the Parthenia loaded at Montague Bridge, at the same time, and came down the river, and out the harbour on his way to Sydney. The sky showed all signs of bad weather. I was Cook, and bald headed Donald was Mate. Crew was Ben [W]right, Milfred Moore. I spoke to Capt Mark and said you should not go out to day. It dont look good. Capt Mark said if Capt Harpel goes we will follow. Capt Harpel went out and was a good stretch ahead of us before we were loaded. When we came out in the gulf, we could not see the Parthenia. She was miles ahead. The wind was varying in different quarters, as it often does before a storm, and [we] made slow progress. Night came on, and when we were about 5 miles from Cape Jack, the wind Jumped into the Northeast with a blinding snow storm. We were then in smooth water, as long as we could hold it. Mr Cameron of Montague Bridge loaded us, and came with us in the vessel. But when we got in this snow storm he changed his mind. He said to me I would give the price of the cargo if I had my feet on shore. I said if we can hold the land we will be all right, but if we go to sea we will have a hard time of it. Capt Mark [needed] to give him self a good clearance as he put her off from shore; he was carrying all lowers on her. I was not afraid, but thought he would tear her to pieces. I said unto Capt Mark why dont you shorten sail. He said I cannot, we are in the bight of Cape George. I said you are not, you are on fishermans bank. You would not have a Sea like this at Cape George. I set down on the afterdeck, holding on by the rail. Looking under the mainboom I saw Cape Bear light, for a moment. They could not believe me. It was a bad storm in such a small gulf, with not much Sea room. The Atlantic is a far better spot in bad weather, plenty water and a long running wave. Yet very dangerous at times. When daybreak came we were about 2 miles off Panmure Island. She washed heavy all that night. About every 15 minutes I would make the crew some tea. There was snow in plenty on them. When we were so handy to Georgetown the Capt thought he would go in. But a heavy breeze Jumped up from the Northwest and drove us off again. We reefed her down to a double reef foresail and run to the straits of Canso. The Sea seemed to [be] running as high as Cape George. When we got to the Straits of Canso Mr Cameron wanted us to land him there. He said he would go the rest of the way by rail. We were going to land him at Port Hawkesbury; we found that our boat had punched a hole in her bottom in the storm. There was a strong tide going east, so we let her go while the men were repairing the boat. When the boat was ready we were down in Port Malcom. They put Mr Cameron on shore there. He was not to handy to the railroad station. He was a very tall man, with long legs, but he found the snow very deep. It looked as if it was four feet had fell that night. Mr Cameron would not go far before he would rest. We were watching him. We then got underway again for Sydney, passing through St Peters locks. That time of year, but the weather was not too cold. We anchored in Pulamong Harbour, in the lakes, and was frozen in on that night, and made up our mind we would get no further. But it broke up, and we set sail for Sydney, and made it all right. We tied her up there for the winter, stripping off all Sail, and leaving a man in Sydney to take care of her, until spring. Then her cargo was taken out. I did not go back in her. On the voyage from Halifax to Sydney, coming down the Shore we broke our main topenlift. We were running free wind, with our mainboom off to the sheet end, guyed by a wire pennant. I wanted the Capt to let her come up in the wind and take the mainsail in, and crutch our main boom, but this he would not do. If the boltrope of the mainsail would give away we could not handle the mainboom very easy. I ordered the men to chop the throat of the mainsail down a bit so that it would make a bag in it, but no one would try to go out on it. There was quite a Sea running, but the wind was not so heavy. When she would roll, she would dip her boom in the swell. So I made up my mind if the Capt was too stubborn, to let us take it in, that I was going [to] that topenlift. I must say it was a crazy thing to do, but I was mad. So they put a life line on me, and out I went, on my hands and knees, to the end of the boom. When I found I needed some more things, I came in, got what I wanted and went out again. I do not know yet how I was not washed off the boom, but I fixed the topenlift and it stayed fixed. I do not know how the rumor got around, but the old Sea Capt said it was never done before on the Halifax shore, and thought it quite a stunt. They seen my work, and said it was a shore job. Sources Wanson Hemphill, Covehead, saw the value and potential of his grandfather's reminiscences, and has contributed largely to the presentation here both of words and pictures. The introductory quotes are from F.W. Wallace's Wooden Ships and Iron Men (London: 1924), p. 3. Hemphill's "experiences" will be concluded in the next issue. Courtesy Margaret Hemphill Photo by Camera Art Model by John Hemphill 33 Reviews The Nellie J. B a n k s by Geoff and Dorothy Robinson. Summerside: the authors, 1980,100 pp., $3.95softcover. A historian once described the history of Newfoundland as being "the story of a struggle between Rum and Religion" and rather optimistically added "with religion slowly getting the upper hand." The statement held equally true in Prince Edward Island, which suffered prohibition on a longer and more drastic scale than did Newfoundland. We have all heard tales of smuggling between St. Pierre and the United States, but the rum-running into Canada has received much less attention and is remembered usually only amongst the older generation, who purchased the smuggled liquor and/or connived at what by 1925 had become a wellorganised business. Canadian liquor usually distilled by the Bronfman family - was exported duty-free from Canada, only to arrive back, almost on the next tide, courtesy of the bootleggers. Surprisingly little has been written about what at its height (between the two world wars) must have been a pretty massive industry. As the authors of this excellent little book point out, hundreds of schooners, aging, increasingly decrepit and no longer of much use in a fishery which was very depressed, were engaged in bootlegging off Canada's East Coast. Given that the people engaged in it kept few records and that many were never caught by customs or police, it might be thought that the history of this important industry - the drinkers would have called it an important social service - could never be written. However the Robinsons, who have had the good fortune to practice medicine in an area of Prince Edward Island which saw much of the rum-running, have managed by dint of long and patient years of interviews, to put together 34 the history of just one of these schooners, the Nellie J. Banks. They also managed to find the ledgers of a prominent St. Pierre supplier, the Moraze brothers. Furthermore since the poor Nellie was apprehended several times by Canadian customs of the RCMP, documentation was available from official sources. The book is sub-titled "the life history of a Nova Scotian schooner with a Newfoundland crew that helped Prince Edward Islanders cope with prohibition," and a fine example of inter-provincial and inter-dominion co-operation it was. The Nellie J. Banks was built in 1910 and was a typical 2-masted schooner of her day. Her small size, only 34.76 registered tons, meant that she was not designed to fish the Grand Banks. Rather she fished around Nova Scotia and in the Gulf, taking at various times whatever species of fish were available - cod, haddock, mackerel and swordfish. In the years after World War One, fishing became increasingly unprofitable and in 1926 the Nellie, by now a fairly old lady, was sold to Captain Dicks of Prince Edward Island. Captain Dicks' occupation, as everyone apparently knew, was running liquor into the Maritimes. He chose Newfoundlanders for her crew and if they seemed to have sometimes drunk more cargo than they sold, that was a tradition on the South and Southwest coasts of Newfoundland, and they never failed to bring the vessel safely through her voyages from St. Pierre to Prince Edward Island. Apparently she was not just any old rum-runner, but specialised, one might almost say "by appointment" as purveyors of liquors to the residents of Prince Edward Island's North Shore. The secret of her success lay in the fact that she was able to take out Newfoundland registry. This gave her British registry, but also enabled her to avoid Canadian laws which tried to prevent smug- gling by empowering Canadian registered vessels to be seized if "hovering" within three miles of the coast. This legal gambit was used extensively by many other runners. The most famous is, of course, the I'm Alone which regularly switched her registry between Yarmouth, Nova Scotia and St. John's, Newfoundland depending upon where the legal advantage seemed to lie. From 1926 to 1938 the Nellie J. Banks traded regularly between St. Pierre and Prince Edward Island. Well known to Canadian authorities, she was arrested in 1928, but a sympathetic judge not only threw out the charges, an embarrassed Customs Department had to pay $5550 in damages. Much of the book deals with the often farcical attempts of the Revenue authorities and the RCMP to halt her activities. In 1938, Britain signed an agreement which allowed Canadian authorities to board, search a n d arrest Britishregistered vessels found "hovering" within 12 miles of the Canadian coast. Captain Lillington, a skilled master and runner, even if he was occasionally dead drunk for days at sea, was unaware of the change of law and hence was easily caught. Even so, a jury of Maritimers refused to convict him, and a frustrated government dropped the case. However the Nellie J. Banks went smuggling no more. Condemned as a lawful prize, she was sold and after engaging in a desultory coasting trade, was laid up in 1950 and burnt three years later. The Robinsons are to be congratulated for telling a fine tale, and more so for the amount of research they must have put into it. Keith Matthews The Comfortable Arts: Traditional S p i n n i n g a n d Weaving in Canada by Dorothy K. Burnham. Ottawa: National Gallery of Canada/National Museums of Canada, 1981, 238 pp., $19.95 softcover. The Craftsman's Way: C a n a d i a n E x p r e s s i o n s by John Flanders. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1981, 202 pp., $37.50 hardcover. Never has the spectacular diversity of talent and tradition employed in producing necessities during pioneer times in Canada been better demonstrated than in the exhibition, "The Comfortable Arts." The best of spinning and weaving in collections from coast to coast was selected by Dorothy Burnham and assembled at the National Gallery in Ottawa. The show opened in September, 1 9 8 1 , a n d w e n t on tour in November. Unfortunately no stops in Prince Edward Island are on its itinerary, but we can still enjoy it vicariously through the catalogue. Mrs. Burnham, co-author of Keep Me Warm One Night, the most definitive work so far published on traditional textiles in Canada, displays her extensive knowledge and experience in this meticulously prepared and extremely detailed catalogue. Every object is illustrated by one or more excellent photographs, every technique by clear drawings. Our understanding is further enhanced by photographs of many artifacts used in home textile production, and the whole is brought to life by reproductions from the works of Paul Kane and other early Canadian artists, and by amusing or affecting anecdotes connected with many of the exhibits. The book is divided into sections along ethnic lines, which results mostly in an easy east to west progression, as Central European influences arrived in western Canada around the turn of the century when institutions such as Eaton's catalogue were replacing homemade in the east. The first section deals with the wide variety of techniques used by the native peoples of Canada, ranging from the practicalities of snowshoe lacing to the unique effects achieved with porcupine quills, and a truly remarkable collection it is. It must evoke the admiration of any craftsman. Before too many pages have been turned, however, the one serious deficiency of this book becomes distres- singly apparent Its only colour illustration is on the cover. Right from the pleasing and lasting colours imparted to porcupine quills and moose hair by Indian women with indigenous dyes, through the imported indigo and cochineal so much used in our own Maritime Provinces, to the startling but no less appealing results achieved by Doukhobor dyers with packaged colours, one constantly regrets this economy. Braiding is a tradition common to Indians and French, which reached its apex in the ceintures flechees - the colourful sashes worn by voyageurs of the North West Company. A number of fine examples are shown, impressive even in black and white. They lead into the French/ Acadian section, with exhibits from the Atlantic coast to Manitoba. A handsome all-linen coverlet from Tignish, now in the collection of le Musee Acadian in Miscouche, represents the traditional white couverture de mariage. Another all-white linen piece from the Island appears in the section on Loyalist traditions. A finely spun and expertly woven tablecloth from the Bedeque area, it is in the collection of the Confederation Art Gallery and Museum. Much of this section is taken up with impressive double-weave coverlets made by professional weavers in Ontario. No evidence has been found of any looms in Prince Edward Island with more than four shafts, so the familiar colonial overshot or "draft weaving" - i s the most complex that could be made here. Within this limitation, many beautiful traditional patterns became popular with the home and itinerant weavers of the Maritimes. A number of fine examples of bed and floor covering in this technique from the Prince Edward Island Heritage Foundation collection are shown in the chapter on Scottish, Irish and English traditions. An enchanting pair of lady's wool drawers - looking very itchy rounds out the Island's contribution. Icelandic, Swedish and Hutterite settlers in western Canada probably all made handwoven fabrics, although few traces have been found. Unquestionably, Ukranians and Doukhobors have made the most memorable fabrics, using a variety of tapestry and rug techniques. The Doukhobors had lived in the Caucasus of central Europe, where there is a strong rug-weaving tradition, and the most astonishing exhibit in the show provides a fitting finale for the book. An eight foot square Oriental-type rug, it is covered with a profusion of flora and fauna in the most brilliant colours imaginable worked in a rich pile weave. The Comfortable Arts is not a text book, nor does it have actual drafts of weaving patterns, but it cannot help but be an inspiration to today's weaver, and a fascinating glimpse into the past for the general reader. A greater contrast than The Craftsmans Way can scarcely be imagined. It is also based on a collection of functional objects, albeit a permanent one - the Massey F o u n d a t i o n Collection of contemporary Canadian crafts - but there the resemblance ends. Over two hundred and fifty colour and b l a c k - a n d - w h i t e p h o t o g r a p h s by photographer/interviewer John Flanders lavishly depict 58 Canadian craftsmen, (whose number includes Island weaver Christine Stanley), and their crafts. Every piece shown is a beautiful, practical object skillfully made of honest materials. Apart from Hart Massey's introduction to the collection and to the book, the text consists almost entirely of craftsmen's personal recollections and philosophical musings. These were transcribed from tape-recorded interviews, so there is page after page of the stilted language which inevitably results from trying to be faithful to the speaker's words as well as thoughts, and the reader is left gasping for a paragraph of clear, concise description of technique. This approach is defended in the introduction, but it is doubtful if expending so much paper to print so few facts is really defensible. However, a truly Canadian craft collection was long overdue, and one can only be grateful to the Massey Foundation for starting one, and to the Museum of Man for caring for it. Mary Burnett 35 A Bridge t o t h e P a s t : Wilmot Valley 1 7 8 4 - 1 9 7 9 by the Wilmot Valley Historical Society. Summerside: privately printed, 1980, 276 pp., $6.95 softcover. The Wilmot Valley history A Bridge to the Past is a fine example of how local history can be both informative and entertaining. The authors took a broader view of history than just Wilmot Valley and the surrounding areas. As a stranger to Wilmot Valley, I was able to gain a deeper insight into the development of a community, and how this progression could take place in any area of Prince Edward Island. From the description of early settlement, the book appears to be thoroughly researched. The first settlement is well documented and clearly illustrated through the use of three maps. To add interest to the dry facts of early land ownership, the book includes delightful stories about William Schurman and a vivid description of the settlers' social life. For a community to develop as a separate entity, it must have certain services to meet the needs of the settlers. In Wilmot Valley the lumber mill, the marble works, the blacksmith, the shoemaker, the machine shop and the carriage and cabinet maker shops became the essential services for the emerging commun- For The S a k e Of The Record by Jean MacFadyen. Summerside: the East Prince Historical Group, 1981, 168 pp., $5.95 softcover. Essentially a collection of Miss MacFadyen's local history writings spanning the postwar decades, this book by accident or design outlines the development of a culture in Eastern Prince County. Her articles document the founding of civic and spiritual assemblies from small groups meeting in homes to the construction of sophisticated social landmarks. The book consists of chapters featuring the histories of communities, churches, schools, hotels, municipal and institutional edifices and "Other Historic Items". In each chapter is a series of journalistic stories written over the years, often updated with a paragraph of contemporary information. The articles, 36 ity. After clearly explaining how each industry operated and sufficiently describing the operators, the authors relate the amusing tale of skunk ranching in Wilmot Valley, which appears proud to have introduced the skunk to Prince Edward Island. To maintain an identity, a community must be tied together through communications. In Chapter III, "Filling in the Gaps," the development of roads, the mail service, and the telephone and electrical services are amply covered. Within Wilmot Valley, the churches and religious organizations had and continue to have a leading role. In an area with such a strong religious nucleus, it is natural that the Sons of Temperance served as an academic and social organization for some seventy years. From about 1845 to 1974, Wilmot Valley had its own school. As the book clearly outlines, especially through the use of old class pictures, the school was the center of the district and produced many excellent scholars. Also, other groups such as the Farmers' Institute, Wilmot Valley Women's Institute, 4-H Club, Allied Youth, Red Cross, and React developed to provide important educational and social functions in a modern community. In Chapter V "A Span, The Length of Memory," the authors provide a glimpse at the human side of a community. With originally published in Maritime newspapers, are written in the style of the postwar period: designed to provide interesting information for the general reader. Often Miss MacFadyen lightens her accounts with little-known facts or comments in the line of what has become known as folk history. Most of the pieces begin with the examination of an existing structure. Information is provided on the^rchitect, contractor, and any remarkable details of construction. The story behind the building then develops and in the telling can be found a valuable insight into the life of 19th century Prince Edward Island. Throughout the book the amazing energy and enterprise of Island residents is made evident. In the midst of difficult conditions, not so far in the past, structures were erected, outgrown, moved about over land, water, or ice, expanded and rebuilt with startling frequency. HI itr&L-lA <i\rK>J=r WSNSB stories of an old-fashioned picnic, salmon poaching and other incidents, the reader can gain some insight into life in Wilmot Valley a few decades ago. The inclusion of the poetry section proves that a small district can produce brilliant scholars but the poems have little relevance to the history of the area. In general, the history of Wilmot Valley is well researched, organized, and written. To make a good history book exceedingly interesting, the authors included many photographs (which compare the old ways with the modern methods of farming and transportation). To make the book a must for the Wilmot Valley residents, A Bridge to the Past provides a complete genealogy of all the people who ever lived or are living in Wilmot Valley. A Bridge to the Past is a credit to the Wilmot Valley Historical Society and to the Wilmot Valley community. Leonard Cusack Architects, contractors, and tradesmen appear again and again with groups intent upon the spark of an idea beyond the struggle to live. Understanding the demands of journalism, one cannot fault the listing of names that would often have been more comfortably housed in a scholarly footnote; indeed in the rhythm of names may be discovered the spreading branches of generations in support of a principle. For The Sake Of The Record is an interesting collection from the work of a well-known local journalist. The stories stand well as journalism, as history, and as a symbol for the achievement of a remarkable woman. Charles W. Meggison Launched from Prince Edward Island: A Pictorial Review of Sail by Nicolas J. deJong and Marven E. Moore. Charlottetown: The Prince Edward Island Heritage Foundation, 1981, 182 pp., $10.95 softcover. The fleet of sailing vessels registered at the port of Prince Edward Island was, by tonnage, the second-largest fleet in 19th century Atlantic Canada. The fleet was considerably larger than those of Halifax, Newfoundland, or Miramichi, and second only to the huge fleet registered at Saint John, New Brunswick. Not only did Island owners register more than 600,000 tons of new shipping in the 19th century, but well over 90 percent of the total was locally-built. The shipbuilding industry not only was a key force in the development of the economy but also stood as the symbol of a rather remarkable achievement by a population which never far exceeded 100,000 souls. This Island success story is well documented in the illustrated history of the shipbuilding industry produced by Nic deJong and Marven Moore. Collecting paintings, illustrations and photographs of over 80 Island-built sailing vessels, the book serves as an attractive and eloquent testimony to the industry of 19th century residents. Vessels of all sizes and rigs are included, but of particular importance is the inclusion of more than 50 schooners, brigantines and brigs. As the authors correctly indicate, it was these smaller vessels of generally less than 500 tons burthen which comprised the bulk of Island output. Some of these vessels were retained by Island owners, but the majority were sold elsewhere. Smaller Island-built vessels were the mainstays of the Newfoundland sealing fleet prior to the 1860s, and throughout the 19th century these craft found ready markets in the United Kingdom and throughout the world. A sense of the diversity of the purchasers of Island-built vessels can be gleaned by reading the disposal information which the authors have included for most vessels. The task of assembling all of this material was indeed arduous, a fact attested to by the diversity of acknowledgements for various illustrations and photographs. The authors are to be congratulated for their industry, which clearly demonstrates the affection they felt for their task. The result is a volume which is both handsome and instructive. Yet as magnificent as is their achievement, this book still leaves the reader with the disquieting sense that it could have been better. In their foreword, the authors state that the principal purpose of the volume is to help people to "appreciate the contribution made by Islanders'' to this vital industry. Unfortunately, several decisions mitigate against the complete attainment of that goal. First of all, the two-and-a-half page foreword is far too brief and encapsulated to provide any context in which to judge that contribution. Was the local shipbuilding industry central to the larger Canadian and trans-Atlantic industries? The answer to that rhetorical question is yes, but a reader can be forgiven for not being able to answer it given the lack of comparative information. As well, the authors have included only the most basic information about each vessel. Nowhere is there any discussion of the quality of construction or the distinctive features of Island-built vessels. This is especially unfortunate because of the stereotyped reputation to which Prince Edward Island vessels have been consigned: the idea that Islandbuilt vessels were poorly constructed. The authors surely know this to be false; indeed, by the 1860s Island vessels had largely shed this stigma, a fact that could have been clearly demonstrated by additional comments on the illustrations. To these quibbles the authors would doubtless plead that they will deal with these and other issues in a companion volume due to appear shortly. This is no doubt the case, but it presents a dilemma in judging the book at hand. Given the authors' rationale, will this book help Islanders to appreciate their heritage? The answer must be a qualified yes, but it leaves us waiting in eager anticipation for the companion volume. And, come to think of it, perhaps the creation of that type of expectation is not a bad idea. Lewis R. Fischer Contributors J a m e s C. Brandow is a New York City schoolteacher who did graduate studies in history at New York University and has several publications to his credit. Mary Burnett is assistant registrar at the Heritage Foundation, and a craftsman knowledgeable in Island textiles. Leonard Cusack is the principal at Kinkora Regional High School. He holds a master's degree in history from UNB. Nicolas J. d e J o n g is the Provincial Archivist, and a seasoned cricketing tourist. Lewis R. Fischer is a member of the Department of History and the Maritime History Group at Memorial University of Newfoundland. He has written extensively on the shipping history of the Island. Keith Matthews is a member of the Department of History at Memorial University of Newfoundland, and Chairman of the Maritime History Group. Charles M e g g i s o n is director of the Eptek National Exhibition Centre in Summerside. Jim Hornby is a folklorist and the editor of The Island Magazine. LIBRARY USE ONLY 37 The Prince Edward Island Heritage Foundation The Prince Edward Island Heritage Foundation, publisher of The Island Magazine, was established in 1970 to preserve and interpret the Island's past. It is governed by a Board of Directors representative of all areas of the Island. Heritage Foundation staff members are actively involved in acquisitions, research, publications, and educational programs. They are also developing genealogical and other historical information services. The Foundation displays and interprets its collection at heritage sites at Green Park, Basin Head, Orwell Corner, Elmira Station, and Eptek Centre. In addition, a series of exhibitions is offered at Beaconsfield, the headquarters of the Foundation. Beaconsfield is a classic Victorian-style house built in 1877 overlooking Charlottetown Harbour and historic Government House. Li, Join With Us You can support our work by becoming a member of the Heritage Foundation. Annual membership fees are $5.00 for adults, $2.00 for students, and $6.00 for organizations. Life memberships are $30.00. Members are kept informed of Foundation activities through a regular newsletter. Make your cheque or money order payable to Prince Edward Island Heritage Foundation, Box 922 Charlottetown Prince Edward Island CIA 7L9. :LY