Fatal butane inhalation from gas cartridges: a case report and
Transcription
Fatal butane inhalation from gas cartridges: a case report and
Rom J Leg Med [23] 115-120 [2015] DOI: 10.4323/rjlm.2015.115 © 2015 Romanian Society of Legal Medicine Fatal butane inhalation from gas cartridges: a case report and literature review Kaori Kimura-Kataoka1,*, Junko Fujihara1, Toshihiro Yasuda2, Haruo Takeshita1 _________________________________________________________________________________________ Abstract: Volatile substances are commonly misused with easy-to-obtain commercial products, such as glue, shoe polish, nail polish remover, butane lighter fluid, gasoline and computer duster spray. This report describes a case of sudden death of a 29-year-old woman after presumably inhaling gas cartridge butane from a plastic bag. Autopsy, pathological and toxicological analyses were performed in order to determine the cause of death. Pulmonary edema was observed pathologically, and the toxicological study revealed 2.1μL/mL of butane from the blood. The causes of death from inhalation of volatile substances have been explained by four mechanisms; cardiac arrhythmia, anoxia, respiratory depression, and vagal inhibition. In this case, the cause of death was determined to be asphyxia from anoxia. Additionally, we have gathered fatal butane inhalation cases with quantitative analyses of butane concentrations, and reviewed other reports describing volatile substance abuse worldwide. Key Words: forensic science, butane, inhalation, volatile substance, autopsy, toxicology. V olatile substances are those that vaporize at ambient temperatures, and they are commonly misused with easy-to-obtain commercial products, such as glue, shoe polish, nail polish remover, butane lighter fluid, gasoline, and computer duster spray [1]. There are several methods by which these volatile substances can be inhaled: (1) bagging, whereby volatile substances are placed into a plastic bag and inhaled; (2) sniffing, whereby volatile substances are inhaled directly from the container; (3) spraying directly into the oral or nasal cavities; and (4) huffing, whereby volatile substances are inhaled from a substance-soaked cloth placed over the nose or mouth [1]. Butane, one of the most common volatile substances, has the chemical formula C4H10, with a molecular weight of 58.12. It is highly flammable, colourless, and odourless. Butane and many other volatile substances cross the blood–brain barrier rapidly due to their nonpolar, hydrophobic, lipophilic characteristics, where the concentration peaks are observed within 1 to 3 minutes after inhalation [2, 3]. The most common effects of volatile inhalant use are euphoria, relaxation, vertigo, and headache [4]. According to Garland, 63.7% and 62.9% of adolescent inhalant users experienced euphoria and relaxation, respectively, and volatile substances are presumably inhaled for these positive effects. This report describes a case of sudden death, presumably after inhaling gas-cartridge butane from a plastic bag. An autopsy and pathological and toxicological analyses were performed in order to determine the cause of death. Furthermore, we have gathered fatal butane inhalation cases with quantitative analyses of butane concentrations and reviewed other reports describing volatile substance abuse worldwide. 1) Department of Legal Medicine, Shimane University School of Medicine, Izumo, Shimane, Japan * Corresponding author: MD, PhD, Department of Legal Medicine, Shimane University School of Medicine, 89-1 Enya, Izumo, Shimane 693-8501, Japan, Tel: +81-853-20-2159, Fax: +81-853-20-2155, E-mail: [email protected] 2) Division of Medical Genetics and Biochemistry, Faculty of Medical Sciences, University of Fukui, Fukui, Japan 115 Kimura-Kataoka K. et al. Fatal butane inhalation from gas cartridges: a case report and literature review Case The night before her 30th birthday, a 29-yearold woman was found dead, face down, with her lower body under a kotatsu table (Fig. 1). She was found with a plastic bag attached to her mouth. Butane gas cartridges (liquefied butane; presumably greater than 70% butane) were discovered inside the house: 1 on top of the kotatsu table was almost full, 10 near the table were empty, 1 near the table was half full, and 9 in the kitchen were full. Additionally, there were about 50 more empty gas cartridges in the house (Fig. 2). She had learned how to inhale gas from gas cartridges from her ex-boyfriend and had continued the practice ever since. Moreover, bliseter packages located on the table had 2 empty spaces for Paxil® (paroxetine, antidepressant), 1 empty space for Desyrel® (trazodone, antidepressant), 1 empty space for Lendormin® (brotizolam, sedativehypnotic thienodiazepine), and 1 empty space for Seroquel® (quetiapine, antipsychotic). The woman had been visiting a hospital for mental instability on a regular basis. A forensic autopsy was performed 3 days after the discovery of her death in order to specify the cause of death. Figure 1. Picture taken at the scene (the body had been moved by the discoverer from face-down to face-up position). Closed arrow indicates a white plastic bag. Open arrows indicate gas cartridges. Figure 2. Gas cartridges found in the kitchen. 116 Autopsy findings The body was 147.0 cm in height and weighed 52.0 kg. Bright red liver mortis was present on the anterior surface of the body. Numerous petechiae were observed on the palpebral conjunctiva, lungs, anterior neck, upper chest, and axillary regions. There were several subcutaneous haemorrhages on the lower extremities ranging from 1.0 cm×1.0 cm to 3.0 cm×2.5 cm. There were 6 circular scars of 1.0 cm to 1.5 cm in diameter, which resemble scars from cigarette burns. No apparent traumatic lesions related to the woman’s death were discovered. The heart weighed 255 g, with no apparent arteriosclerosis of coronary arteries. The colour of cardiac blood was dark red and did not contain any coagulation. Viscous fluid with fine foam was observed in the trachea and bronchi. Organ weights were as follows: right lung 345 g, left lung 375 g, liver 1,260 g, spleen 94.1 g, pancreas 95 g, right adrenal gland 4.3 g, left adrenal gland 4.1 g, right kidney 110.1 g, left kidney 105.0 g, and brain 1,330 g. Pathological findings Moderate to severe congestion was evident in most of the organs. Severe fat deposition and mild to moderate adipose infiltration in the heart, pulmonary edema (Fig. 3), and sinusoidal dilation of the liver were observed. No apparent inflammatory lesions or natural diseases related to the woman’s death were found in any organ. Toxicology The concentration of butane in blood samples was determined in triplicate by gas chromatography (GC) using a modified method of Fuke [5]. Blood samples (0.5 mL) were placed into a sealed vial with an internal standard solution containing 0.5 mL of 0.15% acetone. The vial was heated at 60°C for 30 minutes and then cooled down to room temperature. A 1.0 mL headspace sample was injected into the GC. Controls were prepared by adding standard gases (butane, GL sciences; balance Figure 3. Pulmonary edema and congestion of the left lung (HE staining, ×100). Romanian Journal of Legal Medicine gas, nitrogen) after the fortification of 0.5 mL of distilled water and an internal standard solution containing 0.5 mL of 0.15% acetone. Controls were conditioned in the same manner as previously described. The horizontal axis was designated as the amount of standard gas added and the longitudinal axis as the butane and internal standard area ratio. An approximation formula was calculated from the data, and the concentration of butane in the blood was determined. Samples were analysed by GC/MS using an Agilent 6890N with a flame ionization detector. Separation of components was achieved using a 30 m GS-Q capillary column (J&W, 0.53 mm i.d.). The column temperature was maintained at 120°C. The injector and detector temperatures were set at 200 and 250°C, respectively. Helium was used as a carrier gas at a flow rate of 5.8 mL/min. The blood alcohol concentrations were below the detection limit. The qualitative toxicological analysis revealed the presence of paroxetine and trazodone, which are main ingredients of antidepressant drugs. The concentration of butane in the blood was determined to be 2.1 μL/mL. Discussion The causes of death from inhalation of volatile substances have been determined to be cardiac arrhythmia, anoxia, respiratory depression, and vagal inhibition [6]. Cardiac arrhythmia is considered to be the most probable cause of death by inhalation of volatile substances. The association between inhalation of volatile anesthetics and cardiac arrhythmias has been well documented within the long history of anaesthesiology [7–9]. Adrenaline, also known as epinephrine, is a hormone secreted in the medulla of adrenal glands and also at the end of sympathetic nerves in response to fightor-flight situations, such as stress and fear. It is a powerful vasoconstrictor and stimulates the heart [10]. Adrenaline is used to treat cardiac arrest and cardiac dysrhythmia. However, the higher the adrenaline level, the greater the cardiovascular effect and the greater the likelihood of triggering arrhythmias [6, 9]. Shepherd suggests that hallucinations caused by inhalant intoxication provoke disturbing fear and increase the level of adrenaline. Indeed, auditory and visual hallucinations are experienced by adolescent inhalant abusers [4]. Anoxia is a total depletion of oxygen. There must be occlusion of the airways or a decrease in the oxygen concentration of the inhaled air in order to induce anoxia. Anoxia is predominantly associated with inhalation of volatile substances from a plastic bag. As an individual inhales the volatile substance, the consciousness gradually declines, and it becomes difficult for that individual to remove the bag. This situation would result in anoxia and Vol. XXIII, No 2(2015) thus causes death [6]. Volatile substances easily migrate to the central nervous system (CNS). Inhalation of high concentrations of volatile substances would cause respiratory depression and, ultimately, respiratory arrest [3, 6]. Clark exhibited experimentally that exposures to either a CNS depressant or a CNS stimulant resulted in narcosis, shallow respiration, and eventually death from respiratory depression [11]. Although it is often thought that the major causes of death from inhaling volatile substances are cardiac arrhythmia and anoxia, Cronk et al. reported a case of a patient admitted to a hospital due to inhaling a volatile substance [12]. His electrocardiogram only exhibited sinus tachycardia, while he repeatedly suffered respiratory arrest after numerous resuscitation attempts. This case report illustrated that respiratory arrest alone could be a significant cause of sudden death in volatile substance inhalation. Vagal inhibition of the heart is the over activity of the parasympathetic nervous system from stimulation of the laryngeal or pharyngeal mucosa. Such inhibition may occur when swallowing a bolus of food or upon sudden entry of cold water into the pharynx and larynx [13], which resembles the rapid cooling of the mouth or airways by spraying volatile substance gases into those orifices [14]. As previously mentioned, volatile substances can be found in commercial products, such as glue, shoe polish, nail polish remover, lighter fluid, gasoline, and computer duster spray. Depending on the product, gas components could be 100% butane or mixtures of butane, isobutane, propane, and other gases. Table 1 shows 15 fatal butane inhalation case reports, including this case, displaying the blood butane concentration, cause of death, and age and gender of the deceased. All but one case are reports from Japan. This might be because commercially available volatile substances consist mainly of butane in Japan, and the major contents of gas products in other countries may be different. According to Table 1 [15-26], the blood butane concentrations range from 0.11 to 15.3 μL/mL. The most common cause of death was arrhythmia (6 cases), followed by asphyxia due to anoxia (5 cases). Two cases involved a combination of multiple causes. The causes of death for the other 2 cases were determined to be butane poisoning and asphyxia by inhalation of gastric contents. In cases where it was evident that inhalation of gastric contents or vomit caused asphyxia, these were concluded to be the cause of death, regardless of the blood butane concentration. If it was evident that the deceased was using a plastic bag immediately before death to inhale butane, commonly called “bagging,” and the inhalation of butane was proved by toxicological analysis, the cause of death was determined to be asphyxia due to anoxia. On the other hand, the cause of death was decided to be arrhythmia in cases where bagging was denied or the 117 Kimura-Kataoka K. et al. Fatal butane inhalation from gas cartridges: a case report and literature review Table 1. Butane concentration in blood (μL/mL) 0,11 Cause of death 14M Suspected Inhalation Method Bagging Sugie et al. Forensic Sci Int 2004; 143: 211-214. (15) 13M Bagging Al-Alousi. Med Sci Law 1989; 29: 189-208. (16) 24M 16M 13M Unknown Bagging Bagging Sugie et al. Forensic Sci Int 2004; 143: 211-214. (15) Aoki T et al. Acta Crim Jpn 1982; 48: 202-204. (17) Nishi K et al. Jpn J Legal Med 1985; 39: 214-216. (18) Age Gender 0,52 0,65 0,94 Arrythmia Asphyxia by inhalation of gastric contents Arrythmia Asphyxia Arrythmia/lung edema 1,22 Arrythmia M in late teens Bagging Tanaka N et al. Rom J Leg Med 2012; 20: 195-196. (19) 2,1 Asphyxia 29F Bagging This report 2,4 Arrythmia 14M Bagging or sniffing Fuke C et al. Legal Med 2002; 4; 134-138. (5) 2,85 4,6 6,8 Asphyxia Asphyxia Arrythmia Butane poisoning Asphyxia by inhalation of vomit 16M 31M 23F Bagging Bagging No bagging Nagata T et al. Jpn J Legal Med 1977; 31: 161-163. (20) Zhu et al. Jpn J Clin Toxicol 2005; 18: 77-81. (21) Tanaka N et al. Soud Lek 2010; 4: 44-45. (22) 13M Unknown Terada M et al. Jpn J Legal Med 1983; 37: 696. (23) 9,2 Asphyxia 25M Unknown Kawata F et al. Jpn J Forensic Toxicol 1990; 18: 68-69. (24) 10,5 Butane poisoning F in 30’s Bagging Tanaka N et al. Curr Study Environ Med Sci 2010; 3: 15-16. (25) 15,3 Arrythmia 15M Unknown Ago M et al. Legal Med 2002; 4: 133-118. (26) 0,24 7,0 deceased was able to move for a short time after bagging. It seems there is congestion of internal organs and lung edema to some degree [27–29]; however, there are no pathological findings specific to butane inhalation. When relatively high butane concentrations were observed and no other possible causes of death were present, the cause of death was determined to be butane poisoning [25, 26]. In the present case, the woman was found with a plastic bag attached to her mouth, suggesting that she was inhaling gas-cartridge butane from this plastic bag. Autopsy findings, such as multiple petechiae, congestion of internal organs, and the absence of coagulated blood in the heart, indicated that the woman had an acute course from the beginning of the inhalation to the time of death. Pathological analysis also confirmed moderate to severe congestion of most organs. Pulmonary edema was observed microscopically; nevertheless, this finding was not specific to butane inhalation. The qualitative toxicological analysis revealed the presence of paroxetine and trazodone, which are main ingredients of antidepressant drugs. Trazodone is an antidepressant, known to depress the central nervous system. Although a quantitative analysis was not performed, trazodone might have had some competitive impact along with the respiratory depression effect of butane itself, similar to the case reported by Tanaka et al. [25]. The concentration of 118 References butane in the blood was determined to be 2.1 μL/mL, yet this value was not high compared to other cases (Table 1). Since the woman was supposedly inhaling butane from a plastic bag, the cause of death was determined to be asphyxia due to anoxia. By comparing cases of fatal butane inhalation, it could be stated that butane abusers consist mainly of teenagers (Table 1). It is plausible that this is because butane is commercially available in the form of lighter fluid, aerosol spray, and gas cartridges, which could easily be purchased by teenagers [30]. According to Johnston et al., the lifetime prevalence of inhalants for 8th graders, 10th graders, 12th graders, college students, and young adults (ages 19 to 28) has been decreasing in the United States in the 12 years of their study [31]. However, the 2011 ESPAD report by the European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addition reported increases in the percentage of lifetime use of inhalants in 15 out of 36 countries they have monitored [32]. Eleven countries displayed no change, and only 7 countries demonstrated some decrease. Another study in Australia has shown that about 17.3% of students from age 12 to 17 have ever used inhalants in their lifetime [33]. This report summarizes that the percentage of students (ages 12 to 15) who had used inhalants in their lifetime in 2011 was no different from that in 2008 and 2005. Romanian Journal of Legal Medicine Moreover, the male-to-female ratio in Table 1 was 4:1 (80% male). A reasonable explanation for this phenomenon is uncertain, yet 74%, 84.6%, 92.3%, and 83.8% of inhalant users were male in other studies (34– 37, respectively). However, in Australia, slightly greater percentages of female students (ages 12 to 15) who used inhalants over their lifetime were observed [33]. Some reports not included in Table 1 have illustrated fatal butane inhalation by male teenagers [28, 38]. Table 1 shows the cases of only 3 females, which were all reported after 2010. The inhalant abusers consist not only of male teenagers, the possibility an increase in the number of female abusers should be considered. More effective warnings should be given about the dangers and fatalities of inhaling volatile substances, including butane. The present case described fatal butane inhalation, in which we concluded that the cause of death was asphyxia due to anoxia. Many studies over several Vol. XXIII, No 2(2015) years have reported on volatile substances and their fatal outcomes; yet there seem to be no specific remarks concluding that the cause of death is cardiac arrhythmia, anoxia, respiratory depression, or vagal inhibition. Forensic pathologists need to consider the possibility of volatile substance inhalation when sudden deaths are reported, especially in teenagers and young adults. Acknowledgment. The authors are grateful to Dr. Masanori Hasegawa (International Research Institute of Police Science, Department of Forensic Science) for his toxicological analyses. We would also like to thank Prof. Hiroshi Kinoshita (Kagawa University, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Forensic Medicine) for his helpful comments and critical review. Conflict of interest. There was no conflict of interest. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. Garland EL, Howard MO. Volatile substance misuse. CNS drugs 2012; 26: 927-935. Gerasimov MR, Ferrieri RA, Pareto D, Logan J, Alexoff D, Ding YS. Synthesis and evaluation of inhaled butane and intravenously injected acetone as potential radiotracers for studying inhalant abuse. Nucl Med Biol 2005; 32: 201-208. Kamijo, Y. Hydrocarbons and aromatic compounds, in Clinical Toxicology. Tokyo, Igakushoin, 2013, 314-318. Garland EL, Howard MO. Phenomenology of adolescent inhalant intoxication. Exp Clin Psychopharmacol 2010; 18: 498-509. Fuke C, Miyazaki T, Arao T, Morinaga Y, Takaesu H, Takeda T, Iwamasa Teruo. A fatal case considered to be due to cardiac arrhythmia associated with butane inhalation. Legal Med 2002; 4: 134-138. Shepherd RT. Mechanism of sudden death associated with volatile substance abuse. Human Toxicol 1989; 8: 287-292. Garb D, Chenoweth MB. Studies on hydrocarbon epinephrine induced ventricular fibrillation. J Pharmacol 1948; 94: 12-18. Taylor GJ, Harris WS. Cardiac toxicity of aerosol propellants. JAMA 1970; 214: 81-85. Reinhardt CF, Azar A, Maxfield MR, Smith PE, Mullin LS. Cardiac arrhythmias and aerosol “sniffing.” Arch Environ Health 1971; 22: 265279. Katzung BG. Adrenoceptor-activating & other sympathomimetic drugs, in Basic & Clinical Pharmacology, 8th ed. Tokyo: Lang Medical Books, McGraw-Hill, 2001, 120-137. Clark DG, Tinston DJ. Acute inhalational toxicity of some halogenated and non-halogenated hydrocarbons. Human Toxicol 1982; 1: 239247. Cronk SL, Barkley DEH, Farrell MF. Respiratory arrest after solvent abuse. Br Med J 1985; 290: 897-898. Saukko P, Knight B. Deaths from immersion other than drowning, in Knight’s forensic pathology, 3rd ed. London: Hodder Arnold, 2004, 399-400. Adgey AAJ, Johnston PW, McMechan S. Sudden cardiac death and substance abuse. Resuscitation 1995; 29: 219-221. Sugie H, Sasaki C, Hashimoto C, Takeshita H, Nagai T, Nakamura S, Furukawa M, Nishikawa T, Kurihara K. Three cases of sudden death due to butane or propane gas inhalation: analysis of tissues for gas components. Forensic Sci Int 2004; 143: 211-214. Al-Alousi LM. Pathology of volatile substance abuse: a case report and a literature review. Med Sci Law 1989; 29: 189-208. Aoki T, Namiki H, Fukuie N. A case of sudden death after inhaling gas which is used for gas lighters. Acta Crim Jpn 1982; 48: 202-204. Nishi K, Ito Nobuaki, Mizumoto J, Wada K, Yamada T, Mitsukuni Y, Kamimura S. Death associated with butane inhalation: report of a case. Jpn J Legal Med 1985; 39: 214-216. Tanaka N, Kinoshita H, Jamal M, Kumihashi M, Tsutsui K, Ameno K. An autopsy case of fuel gas abuse. Rom J Leg Med 2012; 20: 195-196. Nagata T, kageura M, Hara K, Totoki K. Gas chromatographic determination of butanes in an autopsied case. Jpn J Legal Med 1977; 31: 161-163. Zhu BL, Ishikawa T, Oritani S, Quan L, Li DR, Zhao D, Michiue T, Ogawa M, Maeda H. Five fatalities due to inhalation of “asphyxiant gases”: pathophysiological analysis in autopsy case. Jpn J Clin Toxicol 2005; 18: 77-81. Tanaka N, Kinoshita H, Haba R, Jamal M, Ohkubo E, Ameno K. An autopsy case of butane gas abuse. Soud Lek 2010; 4: 44-45. Terada M, Watanabe S, Kashiwade H, Yoshimura S. An autopsy case of sudden death by butane gas inhalation. Jpn J Legal Med 1983; 37: 696. Kawata F, Ito A, Takeshita T, Ito M. An autopsy case of butane gas abuser. Jpn J Forensic Toxicol 1990; 18: 68-69. Tanaka N, Kinoshita H, Takatsu M, Kuse A, Jamal M, Ohkubo E, Nagasaki Y, Yoshioka N, Asano M, Ueno Y, Ameno K. A fatal case of butane gas inhalation. Curr Study environ Med Sci 2010; 3: 15-16. Ago M, Ago K, Ogata M. A fatal case of n-butane poisoning after inhaling anti-perspiration aerosol deodorant. Legal Med 2002; 4: 133-118. Pfeiffer H, Al Khaddam M. Brinkmann B, Kohler H, Beike J. Sudden death after isobutene sniffing: a report of two forensic cases. Int J Legal Med 2006; 120: 168-173. Novosel I, Kovacic Z, Gusic S, Batelja L, Nestic M, Seiwerth S, Skavic J. Immunohistochemical detection of early myocardial damage in two sudden deaths due to intentianl butane inhalation: two case reports with review of literature. J Forensic Leg Med 2011; 18: 125-131. 119 Kimura-Kataoka K. et al. Fatal butane inhalation from gas cartridges: a case report and literature review 29. Rossi R, Suadoni F, Pieroni L, De-Giorgio F, Lancia M. Two cases of acute propane/butane poisoning in prison. J Forensic Sci 2012; 57: 832-834. 30. Ford JB, Sutter ME, Owen KP, Albertson TE. Volatile substance misuse: an updated review of toxicity and treatment. Clinic Rev Allerg Immunol 2014; 46: 19-33. 31. Johnston LD, O’Malley PM, Bachman JG, Schulenberg JE, Miech RA. Table 2-1: Trends in lifetime prevalence of use of various drugs for 8th, 10th, 12th graders, college students, and young adults (ages 19-28), in The Monitoring the Future: National survey results on drug use 1975-2013. Available at http://www.monitoringthefuture.org. Accessed February 9, 2015. 32. Hibell B, Guttormsson U, Ahlstrom S, Balakireva O, Bjarnasaon T, Kokkevi A, Kraus L. Summary table: selected key variables by country, in the 2011 ESPAD report: substance use among students in 36 European countries. Available at http://www.espad.org/Uploads/ESPAD_ reports/2011/Extended_EMCDDA_2011_ESPAD_Summary_EN.pdf. Accessed February 9, 2015. 33. White V, Bariola E. Inhalants, in Australian secondary school students’ use of tobacco, alcohol, an over-the-counter and illicit substances in 2011. http://www.nationaldrugstrategy.gov.au/internet/drugstrategy/Publishing.nsf/content/BCBF6B2C638E1202CA257ACD0020E35 C/$File/National%20Report_FINAL_ASSAD_7.12.pdf. Accessed February 10, 2015. 34. Spiller HA. Epidemiology of volatile substance abuse (VSA) cases reported to US poison center. Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse 2004; 30: 155165. 35. Wick R, Gilbert JD, Felgate P, Byard WR. Inhalant deaths in South Australia: a 20-year retrospective autopsy study. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 2007; 28: 319-322. 36. Garland EL, Howard MO. Adverse consequences of acute inhalant intoxication. Exp Clin Psychopharmacol 2011; 19: 134-144. 37. Butland BK, Field-Smith ME, Ramsey JD, Anderson HR. Twenty-five years of volatile substance abuse mortality: a national mortality surveillance programme. Addiction 2012; 108: 385-393. 38. Rohrig TP. Sudden death due to butane inhalation. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 1997; 18: 299-302. 120