MR imaging interpretation of the Palmer classification of triangular
Transcription
MR imaging interpretation of the Palmer classification of triangular
MR Imag#{252}g Interpre#{149}::::: tation ofthe Palmer au s::: . :: . Classification of Trian- gular Fibrocartilage Complex Lesions1 Susan R. Oneson, MD Lisa M Scales, MD Michael E. Timins, MD Scottj Erickson, MD Lewis Chamoy, MD The triangular fibrocartilage biomechanical nar I wrist TFCC The may TFCC are lesions This are sions. than contribute cause in its horizontal In the to the in determining arthrography accurately Traumatic of the extent structural pain. are U INTRODUCTION The distal radioulnar angular fibrocartilage this joint complex Index terms: RadloGraphics i I been GRE Wrist, 1996; detected joint is composed complex (TFCC). extensively movement Abbreviations: : have reliably while gradient 434.92 echo, #{149} Wrist, of the distal The complex explored preserving TFC = injuries, with over stability triangular 434.483, 434.77 MR the past transmitting #{149} Wrist, le- presence or ab- and is cases of imaging. radioulnar anatomy TFCC and may of TFCC classification only advanced and fibrocartilage, imaging abnormalities The sence of chondromalacia is a factor in the Palmer also considered in treatment planning. However, chondromalacia of injury (MR) evaluation the and degenera- mechanism in prospective instability injury; le- of degeneration. resonance demonstrate to ulnocarpal in its or degenerative. the Magnetic portion, classifIcation, to the and of ul- Palmer location according is helpful MR images that anatomic is a recognized injured according management. useful is a complex TFCC as traumatic subclassified clinical more be categorized classification directing (TFCC) to the or at its attachments. are subclassified tive be Injury portions, lesions sions : pain. peripheral complex structure. few = articulation and and biomechanics years. triangular This axial joint the triof permits load. fibrocartilage complex MR. 434.12141 16:97-106 I From 53226 entific the Department of Radiology’, Froedtert Memorial Lutheran Hospital, 9200 W Wisconsin Ave. Milwaukee, WI (S.R.O., L.M.S., MET., S.J.E.); and Hand Surgery Ltd. Milwaukee (L.C.). Recipient of a Cum Laude award for a sci exhibit at the 1994 RSNA scientific assembly. Received February’ 28, 1995; revision requested March 21 and re- ceived June c RSNA, 5: accepted June 6. Address reprint requests to S.R.O. 1996 97 Exclusion of the ulna from the carpal articulation by the addition of a ligamentous interposing structure-the TFCC-is one of the evolutionary factors that distinguish hominids from more primitive species. The articular disk is centrally fenestrated in all species except Homo has sapiens, been in whom postulated that the disk the isolation is intact. It of the ulna was necessary to create the rotational ability needed for tree swinging or brachiation (1). The TFCC can be thought of as a cushion between the carpus and the ulnar head. Injury to the TFCC is a common cause of ulnar wrist pain. Palmer (2) devised a classification system for TFCC lesions that is based on the cause, 1cation, and extent of the injury. This classification system has been weli received and has sig- nificant implications for treatment planning. In this article, we briefly review the anatomy and MR imaging appearance of the normal TFCC. We then describe the Palmer classification and illustrate the pertinent MR imaging findings jury. in surgically Finally, we of MR imaging TFCC proved discuss and cases the of TFCC relative arthrography the poorly defmed, loosely textured ulnar collateral ligament. The meniscal homologue has no independent histologic identity. Volarly, the TFC is attached to the lunotriquctral ligament, which is not considered part of the TFCC, and to the triquctrum via the ulnotriquetral ligament. There is weaker and inconstant attachment to the lunate via the ulnolunate ligament. The TFCC has three main functions: (a) The central fibrocartilaginous portion absorbs 20% of the axial or compressive load transmitted across the 80% (5,6). (b) radioulnar the dorsal wrist. in- absorbs radioulnar ligaments extend from the for the ulnocarpal joint. The ulnolunate palmar efficacies in diagnosis of lesions. U MR IMAGING APPEARANCE NORMAL TFCC In a normal TFCC, the OF articular disk THE (the TFC) TFCC articular disk (the triangular fibrocartilage [TFC] proper), the dorsal and palmar radioulnar ligaments, the meniscal homologue, the strong sheath of the ulnar cx- appears as a thick band of low signal intensity with all pulse sequences. The disk appears biconcave in the sagittal plane; the peripheral tensor has tendon, the ulnar collateral ligament, and the two ulnocarpal ligaments (the ulnolunate and ulnotriquetral ligaments) (Fig ia). The TFC attaches to the hyaline cartilage of the radius and inserts into the ulnar fovea. It attaches broadly to the ulna between the articular cartilage on the head and at the tip of the stybid process. The dorsal ligaments strengthen attaching uncalcified to the radius fibrocartilage ply TFC of the volar aspects. l0%-40% arises volar radial the penetrate TFCC, leaving are central zone. much thicker The a striated and ulnar stronger than attachment appearance on of the MR images the TFC (Fig ib). The meniscal homologue and the associated ulnar extensor tendon subsheath and ulnar collateral ligament are not consistently seen at MR imaging. However, the ulnotriquetral and ulnolunate (Fig ligaments can be clearly visualized ic). radioulnar attachment via zones of calcified (3). The vascular from Vessels of the and the margins ulnar, only the by and sup- dorsal, and the outer central and a PATHOLOGIC CONDITIONS OF THE TFCC . Clinical Experience During 1992 and 1993, the TFCC was evaluated with arthroscopy or arthrotomy in 59 adult patients at our institution. MR imaging of these radial portions avascular (4). This vascular distribution may play a role in degenerative lesions and has an effect on healing, as in tears of the knee menisci. The meniscal homologue is an ill-defined region of dense, irregular fibrous tissue. A continuation of the articular disk, it blends with the patients was performed with a 1 .5-T system (GE Medical Systems, Milwaukee, Wis) and a homemade single-turn solenoid coil 4 inches (10 cm) sheath 30#{176} flip of the ulnar extensor tendon and with in diameter density etition 70) and Exhibit 4 inches long. or T2-wcighted time and time gradient-echo two signals ness with = images with (rep- 2,200/16, (600/17, a 256 x field ofview, one or and a 3-mm section thick- an 8-cm averaged, a 0.5-mm obtained spin- images msec (GRE) were matrix, Coronal spin-echo msec/echo angle) 192-224 Scientific joint and ulnotriquetral ligaments prevent subluxation of the ulnar carpus. ANATOMY OF THE The TFCC consists of the U radiocarpal volar and dorsal rims of the sigmoid notch to the fovea and base of the ulnar styloid process. The major function of these ligaments is to prevent volar and dorsal subluxation at the distal radioulnar joint (6). (c) The TFCC provides stability U 98 The The TFCC is a major stabilizer of joint (6). The thick palmar and gap. Sagittal Volume Ti-weighted 16 Number 1 a. b. Figure 1. Normal TFCC. (a) Diagram shows the ligamentous supports of the ulnar aspect of the wrist (the TFCC) from a dorsal perspective. Not shown are the ulnar collateral liga- ment, the meniscal subsheath, and homologue, the volar spin-density MR of the ulnar lunotriquetral attachment ligament, tal Ti-weighted the image shows the normal shows ligaments extensor ligament. the tendon (b) Coronal striated of the TFC. ad mh = meniscal MR image ulnocarpal the ulnar radioulnar appearance articular homologue. disk, = normal it = Sagit- (C) appearance of (u). 0.5-mm gap for evaluation of the ulnocarpal ligaments. The MR images were retrospectively read by two musculoskeletal radiologists (M.E.T., Sj.E.) blinded to the surgical fmdings. This reading was C. Palmer of TFCC ClassifiCation I. Traumatic Lesions injury A. Central perforation B. Ulnar avulsion C. Distal D. Radial avulsion avulsion II. Degenerative A. TFC wear B. TFC wear performed . injury Palmer Injury nar and chondromalacia and E. TFC perforation, lunotri- lesions ulnocar- (class quetral ligament pal/radioulnar images perforation, arthritis luno- study and (500/20) were obtained with a 256 x matrix, an 8-cm field of view, two signals averaged, and a 3-mm section thickness with a 224 January 1996 of another imaging pro- clarify Classification to the wrist TFCC pain. tion system on a review C. TFC perforation and chondromalacia D. TFC perforation, chondromalacia, triquetral ligament perforation chondromalacia, as part ject (7). The surgical report, clinical information, and MR imaging appearance were used to categorize the TFCC according to the Palmer classification. MR images of arthroscopically proved TFCC injuries that show the characteristic findings in each category are presented later in this article. (2) as traumatic II) (Table). locus with wrist (class cause proposed for TFCC lesions, of the literature of patients the is a recognized Palmer of ul- a classi.fica- which was based and a retrospective pain. He classified D or degenerative Further subdivision of injury in traumatic serves to lesions and the cumulative derangement of the TFC in degenerative lesions. This classification is helpflu in determining the mechanism of injury and directing clinical management (8). Oneson et al U RadioGraphics U 99 a. b. Figure 2. Class IA lesion. the TFC. (b) Coronal GRE signal-intensity radial (a) Diagram MR image hyaline shows shows cartilage for a dorsal-palmar a class a slitlike slitlike IA tear (arrow). tear Care (arrow) must medial be taken to the radial not to mistake origin of the high- tear. a. b. Figure 3. Class lB lesion. (a) Diagram shows avulsion of the TFC at the peripheral ulnar attachment (arrow). (b) Coronal T2-weighted MR image shows a focus of high signal intensity that represents a tear at the ulnar fovea (arrow). Contrast this abnormal high signal intensity with the alternating bands of low and high signal intensity . that Class can be seen I Lesions Class IA lesions tions of the TFC sagittally oriented, are at the ulnar attachment of the (Traumatic) traumatic proper. slitlike tears These tears or perfora- 1 -2-mm-long, arc located ap- normal TFC (Fig ib). proximately 2-3 mm medial to the radial aspect of the TFC (Fig 2). Occasionally, there is a flap of redundant cartilage along the palmar aspect of the TFC. Because these tears occur in the avascular portion of the and are usually treated loose flap tissue (9). 100 U Scientific Exhibit TFC, with Volume they do not d#{233}bridement 16 heal of all Number 1 5a. 5b. Figures 4, 5. (4) Class IC lesion. Diagram shows disof the TFCC from its osseous insertions on and triquetrum (arrows). (5) Class ID lesion. Diagram shows avulsion of the TFCC from its radial tal avulsion the lunate (a) attachment (arrows). age shows ment and Class (b) Coronal abnormal signal in the radioulnar IC lesions spin-density MR are traumatic im- radial intensity at the joint (arrows). attach- avulsions of the peripheral volar attachments of the TFCC, specffically the ulnolunate or ulnotriquctral ligament (Fig 4). In our series of 59 wrists, no surgically proved These lesions stability with class IC lesions frequently palmar were result identified. in ulnocarpal translocation of the inlunate or triquetrum. Surgical repair is usually attempted in cases of acute or subacute lesions. An ulnar shortening osteotomy to tighten up the ulnocarpal ligaments is reserved for chronic lesions (9). 4. Class Class lB lesions are traumatic avulsions of the TFC from its attachment site on the ulnar fovea (Fig 3). Fracture through the base of the ulnar styloid process may accompany the TFC avulsion. These jury to the ments and instability. lesions palmar therefore Class well-vascularized and arc associated with in- dorsal radioulnar ligaoften result in radioulnar lB lesions periphery are and but some surgeons have begun tears using a modified meniscal located thus ID lesions are traumatic avulsions of the radial attachment of the TFC in the region of the sigmoid notch (Fig 5). They may be accompanied by distal radial fractures. The radial attachment is relatively avascular and therefore heals poorly. These lesions are less common than class IA and lB lesions and are currently treated with d#{233}bridement. in the may heal, repairing these repair system (9). January 1996 Oneson Ct al U RadioGraphics U 101 6a. 6b. 7a. Figures Th. 6, 7. shows wear (b) Coronal (6) Class hA lesion. of the central portion GRE MR image shows (a) Diagram of the TFC (arrow). an intact but subtly thinned TFC. (7) Class IIB lesion. (a) Diagram shows wear of the central portion of the TFC and lunate chondromalacia GRE (c) coronal ened C = lunate lunate (arrows). (b, c) Spin-density MR images show abnormally cartilage with an intact but thinned (b) and thick- TFC. chondromalacia. 7c. 102 U Scientific Exhibit Volume 16 Number 1 Figure 8. Class IIC lesion. (a) Diagram shows a large, central TFC perforation and abnormality of the lunate cartilage (arrows). (b, c) Spin-density (b) and GRE (c) coronal MR images show a central TFC perforation (large arrow). The thin line of low signal intensity represents abutment of ulnar cartilage against lunate cartilage, not a very thinned but intact TFC. Note the intact lunotriquetral ligament (small arrow). no perforation class IIB lesions is present in our Class H Lesions (Degenerative) (Fig 7). In the only advanced Class IIC lesions are IIC lesions arc usually spectrum of the and of degenerative change. Along with characterized by further degenerative change with frank perforation of the TFC (Fig 8). The perforation is located in the central, avascular portion of the TFC. These perforations tend to be oval rather than slitlike. Chondromalacia is not commonly appreciated on MR images, as shown in Figure 8. When visiblc, it typically appears as areas of abnormal Class hA lesions involve degenerative wear or thinning of the articular disk without perforation (Fig 6). As with all degenerative TFC lesions, class HA lesions are the result of chronic axial forces on the wrist and are more commonly seen with ulnar variance. Fraying of the proximal or distal aspect of the TFC may be seen at arthrography or arthroscopy. Class JIB lesions involve progression of the TFC study, cases of surgically proved chondromalacia were reliably detected prospectively with MR imaging. Class ILk and IIB lesions are managed conservatively, by d#{233}briding the worn areas, or with ulnar decompression (shortening) (9). Ulnar surgery is usually reserved for cases with chondromalacic change (9). C. . but signal intensity, TFC irregularity, ulnar and treated with decompression thinning. Class d#{233}bridement (9). thinning, chondromalacia of the lunate, triquetrum, or distal nina is present. The TFC wear is more advanced than in class hA lesions, January 1996 Oneson et al U RadioGraphics U 103 a. b. Class Figure 9. lunotriquetral lID lesion. ligament (a) Diagram disruption (large arrow). Note the tapered contrast to the square, straight normal U-shaped lunotriquetral Class IIC lesions quetral Such the a lesion a large (b) Coronal of the TFC appearance margins of a traumatic, ligament (small arrow). from class of lunotri- Class and comprise large chondromalacia, central ulnar lunotriquetral were ulnocararthritis result of of class with d#{233}brideis present, a be required study, MR imaging for detection and detected decreased had cx- of central radial-sided one of four was by the other. for detection degen- slitlike perfora- prospectively Many studies arthrography (9). three-phase However, of ulnar surgically proved accuracy avulsions: ulnar Only avulsions detected by each reader. have attempted to correlate performed compartment If suffi- is present, may on portion absent. can be treated If no ligament arthrodesis TFC impaction) the central completely ligament LID and lIE lesions ment and pinning. lunotriquetral cases, (ulnar and tions, with a high interobserver correlation. All 1 5 central degenerative perforations and all seven radial-sided slitlike perforations were detected by one reader; 1 4 of 1 5 and six of seven lunotriquetral loading chondromalacia, the TFC perforation DISCUSSION In our retrospective defects the wrist. In these the TFC is usually cient . erative TFC lunate shows at the edges of the perforation. This appearance is in slitlikc tear (class IA lesion). Also note the absence of the chondromalacia constellation of surgical fmdings. results in lunotriquetral instabil- lIE lesions axial perforation, MR image accuracy ligament disruption, and concomitant pal and occasionally distal radioulnar (Fig 10). Such a lesion is the end-stage chronic TFC spin-density cellent (Fig ity. perforations, central 9). A thinned, perforation perforated complete (arrows). lID lesions are distinguished by the additional presence ligament centrally shows with injection injection with technique single- or triple- arthroscopy. was The designed to minimize false-negative results in cases with flap tears or one-way valves. Using injection into the distal radioulnar found tears of the TFCC were not seen with joint, Belsole in 1 3 patients; radiocarpal et al (10) the tears injection in seven cases. Five of the 1 1 tears seen with radiocarpal injection were not seen with radioulnar joint injection. In 75 cases of complete TFCC 104 U Scientific Exhibit defects, Levinsohn et al (1 1) diagnosed Volume 16 Number 1 a. b. Figure Class lIE lesion. (a) Diagram shows a large central TFC perforation, chondromalacia and ulnar head, lunotriquetral ligament disruption, and osteophyte formation at the radioulnar nal GRE MR image shows absence of the central portion of the TFC (straight arrows), absence quetral ligament with separation of the lunate and triquetrum, irregularity of lunate and ulnar 10. osteophytes only at the two radioulnar additional joint defects joint injection. In a study TFCC perforations were mined with radiocarpal approaches with 75%, et al (i 1). studies have Fewer missed Note radioulnar on images alone. no oh- How- radiocarpal according attempted injec- to to correlate Zlatkin et al (13) found that tears of the TFCC were detected equally well with MR imaging and with arthrography performed with both radiocarpal and three-compartment injection. Cerofolini et al (14) found only one additional tear of the TFCC with arthrography that was not seen at MR imaging with MR imaging of 10 surgically In studies arthroscopy, arthrography (1 5) found that arthrography. compare the high that proved false-negative figures prominently. TFCC lesions were pletely diagnosed January 1996 tears. arthrography preoperatively the ulnar lunate (b) Coro- of the lunotri- cartilage, and variance. patients. (12), partial perforation of the abnormality, the rate of diagnosis tion alone Levinsohn with arrow). by Manaster injection ever, if one includes TFCC as a significant false-negative (curved of the joint. with rate of In a study by Roth and Haddad (16), of 37 confirmed TFCC lesions were identified with arthrography. The study of Vanden Eyndc et al (17) showed a 52% sensitivity and 50% specificity for TFCC lesions when arthrography was performed with radiocarpal injection. Their results yielded a positive predictive value of 92% and a negative predictive value of 8%. On the basis of these fmdings and the fact that several studies have shown poor correlation between the site of the arthrographic defeet and the patient’s symptoms, we believe that arthrography is useful only in confirming the clinical diagnosis. When arthrography is used for this purpose, arthroscopy is indicated whether or not the arthrogram is positive. We believe that MR imaging can supplant arthrogonly 70% raphy onstrates because it is noninvasive, perforation of the accurately TFCC, and dem- allows Koman et al incomin 62% of 53 Oneson et al U RadioGraphics U 105 assessment of other potential patient’s symptoms, perhaps copy in certain cases. . CONCLUSIONS The TFCC is a complex this ligamentous complex causes obviating of the planning. Linscheid 7. dioulnar Oneson structure, and injury is responsible for MR imaging 2. 3. 5. The distal of the wrist. Bednar MS, Arnoczky crovasculature of the J Anat 1990; 12. radioul- 14. mi- U Scientific Exhibit Arthroscopic . Chin treat- 1991 TL, Beatty ; 7:277ME, Rayhack JM. Digital subtraction arthrography of the wrist. J Bone Joint Surg [Am] 1990; 72: 846-851. Levinsohn EM, Rosen ID, Palmer AK. Wrist arthrography: value of the three-compartment injection method. Radiology i99i; 179:231239. Manastcr BJ. The clinical efficacy of triple-in- jection wrist arthrography. Radiology 1991; 178:267-270. Zlatkin MB, Chao PC, Osterman AL, et al. Chronic wrist pain: evaluation with high.rcsolution MR imaging. Radiology 1989; 173:723729. Cerofolini E, Luchetti R, Pederzini L, et al. 15. mogr 1990; 14:963-967. Koman LA, Poehling GG, Chronic throscopy. 16. 17. wrist pain: Toby indications Arthroscopy 1990; RothJH, Haddad RG. copy and arthrography MR EB, Kammire for wrist G. ar- 6:116-119. Radiocarpal arthrosin the diagnosis of ulnar wrist pain. Arthroscopy Vanden Eynde 5, DeSmet nostic of the 50-53. 106 RG. evaluation of triangular fibrocartilage complex tears in the wrist: comparison with arthrography and arthroscopy. J Comput Assist To- 172:59-67. SP, Weiland AJ. The triangular fibrocartilage complex: its clinical significance. J Hand Surg [Am] 1991; 16:iioi-iiO5. Palmer AK, Werner 1W, Glisson RR, Murphy DJ. Partial excision of the triangular fibrocartilage complex. J Hand Surg [Am] 1988; 13: 391-394. 11 AL, Terrill ment of TFCC lesions. Hand 281. Belsole RJ, Quinn SF, Greene is an excellent nar joint. Hand Clin 1992; 8:631-642. Palmer AK. Triangular fibrocartilage complex lesions: a classification. J Hand Surg [Am] i989; i4:594-605. Benjamin M, Evans EJ, Pemberton DJ. Histologic studies on the triangular fibrocartilage complex 4. MR. L, diagnosis of trianguwith arthroscopic Osterman 13. WS, Hausman MR imaging pathology ra- 275:46-55. SJ, Chamoy 9. U REFERENCES Drobner of the distal Orthop 1992; ME, Erickson 8. 10. . Biomechanics correlation (abstr). Radiology 1994; 193(P): 183. Mikic Z. The blood supply of the human distal radioulnar joint and the microvasculature of its articular disk. Clin Orthop 1992; 275:19-28. to tool for prospective evaluation of TFCC injuries, able to consistently and accurately demonstrate structural abnormalities that contribute to ulnocarpal instability and pain. The presence or absence of chondromalacia is a factor in the Palmer classification and is also considered in treatment planning. Unfortunately, in our experience, only advanced cases of chondromalacia are reliably detected with MR imaging. 1 RI. joint. Clin SR, Timins McAuliffe T. lar fibrocartilage many cases of ulnar wrist pain, once considered the “low back pain of the wrist” (2). The Palmer classification has proved useful to surgeons in determining conservative management or op- erative 6. arthros- 1986; 2:234-243. L, Fabry G. Diagvalue of arthrography and arthroscopy radiocarpal joint. Arthroscopy 1994; 10: Volume 16 Number 1