11. Consent Agenda (Leo Drozdoff, Chair) (All Items for Possible
Transcription
11. Consent Agenda (Leo Drozdoff, Chair) (All Items for Possible
11. 11. Consent Agenda (Leo Drozdoff, Chair) (All Items for Possible Action) Consent items will be considered together and acted on in one motion unless an item is removed to be considered separately by the Board. 11.1. Approval of the Action Minutes from the June 17, 2016 PEBP Board Meeting. 11.2. Receipt of quarterly staff reports for the period ending March 31, 2016: 11.2.1. PEBP Chief Financial Officer Reports 11.2.1.1. Budget Report 11.2.1.2. Utilization Report 11.2.2 PEBP Operations Officer Report 11.1. 11. Consent Agenda (Leo Drozdoff, Chair) (All Items for Possible Action) Consent items will be considered together and acted on in one motion unless an item is removed to be considered separately by the Board. 11.1. Approval of the Action Minutes from the June 17, 2016 PEBP Board Meeting. STATE OF NEVADA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES’ BENEFITS PROGRAM BOARD MEETING AND PUBLIC HEARING The Richard H. Bryan Building 901 South Stewart Street Suite 1002 Carson City, Nevada 89701 Video conferenced to: University of Nevada Las Vegas Systems Computing Services Building 4505 South Maryland Parkway Room 102 Las Vegas, Nevada 89154 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ACTION MINUTES (Subject to Board Approval) June 17, 2016 MEMBERS PRESENT IN CARSON CITY: MEMBERS PRESENT IN LAS VEGAS: Mr. Leo Drozdoff, Board Chair (joined at 9:17 a.m.) Ms. Jacque Ewing-Taylor, Vice-Chair Ms. Ana Andrews, Member Mr. Don Bailey, Member Mr. Tom Verducci, Member Mr. James Wells, Member (joined at 9:31 a.m.) Mr. Chris Cochran, Member (joined at 9:26 a.m.) Ms. Rosalie Garcia, Member Ms. Christine Zack, Member MEMBERS EXCUSED: Ms. Judy Saiz, Member FOR THE BOARD: Mr. Dennis Belcourt, Deputy Attorney General FOR STAFF: Mr. Damon Haycock, Executive Officer Ms. Laura Rich, Operations Officer Ms. Celestena Glover, Chief Financial Officer Ms. Nancy Spinelli, Public Information Officer Ms. Kari Pedroza, Executive Assistant 1. Open Meeting; Roll Call Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor opened the meeting at 9:01 a.m. Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor outlined that Public Comment would be taken as indicated in the Agenda and another opportunity for Public Comment would also be taken specifically about the HMO RFP, Agenda Item 5 under that item. 2. Public Comment Public Comment in Carson City: Peggy Lear Bowen- Retiree Participant (see attached for comments) Marlene Lockard- Retired Public Employees of Nevada (RPEN) Public Employees’ Benefits Program Board Friday, June 17, 2016 Minutes – Page 2 Public Comment in Las Vegas: Conrad Wilson- Past chair of the classified staff counsel in LV 3. Action ItemPublic Hearing to receive comment and take possible action on the proposed adoption, amendment, and repeal of regulation (LCB File No. R028-16), including but not limited to, revising the date that certain participants are eligible to participate in the Program. Executive Officer Damon Haycock went over the proposed adoption, amendment and repeal of regulation LCB File No. R028-16. Public Comment in Carson City: Peggy Lear Bowen- Retiree Participant (see attached for comments) Public Comment in Las Vegas: There were none. Board ActionMOTION: BY: SECOND: VOTE: Move to approve the motion for the R028-16 to be approved by the Board. Member Bailey Member Verducci Unanimous; the motion carried. 4. Action ItemConsent Agenda Consent items will be considered together and acted on in one motion unless an item is removed to be considered separately by the Board. 4.1. Approval of the Action Minutes from the May 19, 2016 PEBP Board Meeting. 4.2. Approval of changes discussed at the May 19, 2016 PEBP Board Meeting to the PEBP Plan Year 2017 Master Plan Documents. 4.3. Receipt of quarterly vendor reports for the period ending March 31, 2016. 4.3.1. HealthSCOPE Benefits – Obesity Care Management Program 4.3.2. Hometown Health Providers – Utilization and Large Case Management 4.3.3. Carson Tahoe Health – Diabetes Care Management Program 4.3.4. The Standard Insurance – Basic Life and Long Term Disability Insurance 4.3.5. Towers Watson’s One Exchange – Medicare Exchange Board Action on Items 4.1, 4.3.4 & 4.3.5.MOTION: Move to approve Items 4.1, with the one-word change (board members absent be changed to excused), 4.3.4 and 4.3.5. BY: Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor SECOND: Member Bailey VOTE: Unanimous; the motion carried. Board Action on Item 4.2.MOTION: Move to approve Item 4.2., with inclusion of the Center for Disease Control guidelines in the definition for Reasonable and/or Reasonableness as another entity that the plan administrator will consider. Public Employees’ Benefits Program Board Friday, June 17, 2016 BY: SECOND: VOTE: Minutes – Page 3 Member Andrews Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor Unanimous; the motion carried. Board Action on Item 4.3.1.MOTION: Move to approve Item 4.3.1., with one change on plan year 2016 on page 7. BY: Member Andrews SECOND: Member Garcia VOTE: Unanimous; the motion carried. Board Action on Item 4.3.2.MOTION: Move to approve the report as provided with additional information pending. BY: Member Cochran SECOND: Member Zack VOTE: Unanimous; the motion carried. Board Action on Item 4.3.3.MOTION: Move to approve Item 4.3.3. BY: Member Andrews SECOND: Member Bailey VOTE: Unanimous; the motion carried. BOARD DIRECTION: The Board asked Pam Puckett of Carson Tahoe Health (CTH) to provide an A1C progress break-down for each of the nine individuals who had an average reduction of their A1C. The Board would like A1C information for each individual showing where they were when they began the program and where they are currently. CTH will provide the information to PEBP staff and PEBP staff will share this information with the Board. 5. Action ItemHealth Claim Auditors, Inc. quarterly audit of HealthSCOPE Benefits (HSB) for the timeframe January 1, 2016 – March 31, 2016. 5.1. 5.2. 5.3. Report from Health Claim Auditors. (Robert Carr III, Health Claim Auditors) HealthSCOPE Benefits response to audit report. (Mary Catherine Person, HSB) Accept audit report findings and assess penalties, if applicable, in accordance with the performance guarantees included in the contract pursuant to the recommendation of Health Claim Auditors. Board ActionMOTION: BY: SECOND: VOTE: Move to accept the audit report and access the penalties as outlined in Health Claim Auditors’ report. Member Wells Member Verducci Unanimous; the motion carried. 6. Action ItemDiscussion and possible action regarding the following opportunities for Plan Year 2017 beginning July 1, 2016 Public Employees’ Benefits Program Board Friday, June 17, 2016 Minutes – Page 4 6.1. New reduced cost CDHP national network access for members living outside of Nevada; 6.2 Utilizing existing Third Party Administrator (HealthSCOPE Benefits), contract with a telemedicine vendor for virtual visits. Board Action on Item 6.1.MOTION: Move to allow Mary Catherine Person with HealthSCOPE Benefits to make a selection relative to a network administrator for participants residing outside of Nevada and allow her to make that decision based on her analysis and taking into consideration Board concerns about the sharing of protected information. BY: Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor SECOND: Member Bailey VOTE: Unanimous; the motion carried. Board Action on Item 6.2.MOTION: Move that the Board authorize the third party administrator, HealthSCOPE Benefits to contract with the telemedicine vendor for virtual visits effective July 1, 2016. BY: Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor SECOND: Member Andrews VOTE: Unanimous; the motion carried. As Member Wells was not present at the meeting during the time that Item 3 was discussed, he requested that the Board revisit the Item briefly. 3. Action ItemPublic Hearing to receive comment and take possible action on the proposed adoption, amendment, and repeal of regulation (LCB File No. R028-16), including but not limited to, revising the date that certain participants are eligible to participate in the Program. Member Wells shared his concern that the proposed regulation language in Section 1, subsection 3 (Page 2) in regards to when an employee who got approved leave without pay, elected not to pay premium and then returns to work is eligible for coverage, is not consistent with the other language in this regulation outlining eligible dates of coverage. Executive Officer Haycock agreed with Member Wells that the language is not consistent and stated that the language would be changed to provide consistency. Board ActionMOTION: BY: SECOND: VOTE: Move that we amend Regulation R028-16 to incorporate language in to Section 1, subsection 3, regarding coverage being effective of the 1st of the month on or after the date that they come back from leave without pay. Member Wells Member Andrews The motion carried with Member Garcia opposed. 7. Action ItemDiscussion and possible action regarding Board approval of a PEBP sponsored Statewide Survey to participants about Plan Year 2018 benefits. Public Employees’ Benefits Program Board Friday, June 17, 2016 Board ActionMOTION: BY: SECOND: VOTE: Minutes – Page 5 Move to proceed with the survey as presented with suggested inclusions from the Board (identify what the enhanced benefits are, add two questions regarding current plan and premium and acceptable premium increase range, add general health questions, and general demographic questions). Member Verducci Member Garcia Unanimous; the motion carried 8. Information/Discussion ItemDiscussion regarding the results of the PEBP Board survey provided to PEBP staff. Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor presented the PEBP Staff survey results to the Board. She explained that it had been her intention to analyze all of the qualitative data that was collected in the written comments so that the results would reflect general themes as opposed to verbatim responses but she ran out of time. The Board discussed the option of Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor bringing the results of the written comments after they were analyzed and summarized back to the Board. She stated that she could do that but would have to bring back the results in August or September. Board Chair Drozdoff offered to meet with any PEBP staff who wanted to provide feedback or expand on their comments to the survey one-on-one. 9. Action ItemDiscussion and possible action including approval of the Draft Overview of the Scope of Work and Scoring Criteria for Request for Proposals. 9.1. Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) services; and/or 9.2. Exclusive Provider Organization (EPO) services. Board ActionMOTION: BY: SECOND: VOTE: Move that we accept the HMO RFP overview as outlined on slide ten, the scope of work as outlined on slide 11, and the criteria as outlined on slide 14 with the preferences for the meeting exceeding statewide, open access, out of area services and that we continue to evaluate the feasibility of an EPO option for some future date. Member Wells Member Verducci Unanimous; the motion carried. 10. Action ItemDiscussion and possible action for contracts terminating on June 30, 2017. 10.1. Ratification of a four year contract extension for Self-funded PPO Dental Network to Diversified Dental Services Inc.; 10.2. Ratification of a five year contract extension for health plan auditing services to Health Claim Auditors, Inc.; and 10.3. Ratification of a two year contract extension for voluntary home, auto, and property insurance to Liberty Mutual Insurance. Public Employees’ Benefits Program Board Friday, June 17, 2016 Minutes – Page 6 Board Action on Items 10.1., 10.2. & 10.3.MOTION: Motion that the state have the authority to go forward extending the current contracts and the dental service, Liberty Mutual and Health Claim Auditors for the time frames specified. BY: Member Bailey SECOND: Member Andrews VOTE: The motion carried with Member Cochran abstained. 11. Action ItemDiscussion and possible action regarding the portability of Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA) Account authority from the Consumer Driven Health Plan to the Medicare Exchange HRA. Board ActionMOTION: Move that the Board reject the Staff recommendation and move forward with allowing portability of the HRAs for retiring people and have HealthSCOPE work with Towers Watson to make that happen. BY: Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor SECOND: Member Garcia Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor and Member Garcia withdrew the motion. MOTION: BY: SECOND: VOTE: Move that the Board ask staff to conduct financial analysis to include OPEB liability, rates, the Medicare Exchange cost that is currently absorbed by the CDHP and HMO participants and a formal position from RPEN and bring this back to the next Board meeting. Vice-Chair Ewing-Taylor Member Bailey Unanimous; the motion carried. 13. Information/Discussion ItemExecutive Officer Report. Damon Haycock presented his report to the Board regarding the overall activities of PEBP. 12. Action ItemDiscussion and possible action regarding Towers Watson’s OneExchange’s Service Improvement Plan. Board ActionThere was no action taken on this Item. This Item will be added to the next Board meeting agenda. 14. Public Comment Public Comment in Carson City: Marlene Lockard- Retired Public Employees of Nevada (RPEN) Peggy Lear Bowen- Retiree Participant (see attached for comments) Public Comment in Las Vegas: There were none. 15. Adjournment Chair Drozdoff adjourned the meeting at 3:29 p.m. Public Comment under Item 2: Peggy Lear Bowen: Good morning. My name and words for the record, P-e-g-g-y, space, L-e-ar, space, Bowen, space, B-o-w-e-n, Lear is L-e-a-r. I want to thank you very much for all the work you're doing and how hard you are to protect the state insurance program for the present day workers and for those who have retired and their spouses and significant others. I want to thank you very much. I also want to thank you for the work you've done regarding those who I nicknamed the orphans a few years ago during the legislative sessions who came from other entities to become part of PEBP at that juncture. And when we were brought forward, we were brought forward with the idea that if you have the retirees from other agencies within the state government and things like that, such as teachers, that you would maybe someday have your actives also in making a stronger program simply by the numbers. Well, at the end of last meeting -- I've learned a few lessons in the years that I've been around. And the lesson that I've learned most recently is never make assumptions. Find out why people have the passion they have and the direction they're going because it's based on their background and never take anything personally. Well, in the conversation with Mr. Wells after the last meeting, it was done in a public setting with other people hearing, I understood why we worked so hard regarding those who were not part of the state workers and such and related to the state workers as such, that Mr. Wells said very clearly, and he has substantiated this year after year by his actions, that he never wanted the retirees that were brought about in to the program because he felt, I'm going to say, and now I'm making an assumption, it would harm the program, that it would take the program's financial background down. I want to suggest to you in the last motion that was passed for what you would be discussing and working on maybe at this meeting, probably at this meeting, of the idea of bringing back that legislative packet that failed in the legislature last legislature about sending the workers back to where they came from, regardless of what that impact would be on those workers who joined the state after being enticed to join the state who were not state workers. He felt it was -- it harms the program, from his point of view, it makes other people in the program pay for people that didn't pay in to the system when they were working as such as teachers in Clark County, teachers across the state, and other entities that were brought in. I'm going to suggest to you that this program as a whole made some commitments that I would hope that you would not put in your RFP. The idea of bringing back the concepts of sending people away and making the system stronger by, in fact, weakening it because you didn't keep the promises that brought people in in the first place. And it is very important that the privatization of your insurance company gets the State of the Nevada out of the retiree system. All of those people who work for the State of Nevada, the A and B folk that were sent across the lines to Utah, we heard were sold. And I made a comment last time of they were sold to a company. And I made a comment last time, well, what about are the role that is going to be there. Mr. Wells' response to me quite some time ago was it depends on who the insurance company is, which makes me believe that the monies that the State of Nevada through their PEBP program provides to those people who work for the State of Nevada and earn this insurance as state employees that that money has been convoluted or transferred and that you are only the conduit of the money regarding your A and B Medicare folk. And you have other entities paying for their insurance in terms of handling what their benefits are, who they can do, what they can see, and how it's done. And it didn't come to light until we started looking at maybe not having Hometown Health being your carrier. You must, must realize that if you indeed fact quoting Senior Care Plus in talking about their insurees with the state sold A and B Medicare folk, and that's beyond Hometown Health. I believe you have other entities that are covered by those people, sold those people to a company, and all you're doing is being a conduit. And the fact that the state provides other monies to help assist, those people are dying in the Medicare hold because the state is unable to -After you've sold something I guess you can't affect the contract or maybe you can through whatever you negotiate or do. But it's only fair to those thousands of people that you have on A and B Medicare that the state has some responsibility for their insurance, for what their coverage is, what their benefits are. And you don't have people dying because they can't afford their medication, they can't afford -- And diabetic medication is the one that has hit the level. As soon as something becomes very expensive, they cut the insurance coverage, but they get more payback from the Medicare, from Medicare for how sick their people are. You cut their medication, ability to pay for their medication, they get sicker, the insurance companies get more money. And so I need you to maybe look at it in a little different perspective about what your responsibilities are for your A and B folk who other jobs are paying for their insurance basically by virtue of their Medicare coverage which with you -- the state does not offer. And I got a little wrapped up. But it is so important that you take back your folk either financially, fiscally, covering the doughnut hole, however possible, that you -- you may have sold them but you didn't sell the fact they worked for you for 27, 29, 35, 40 years. You didn't sell that. That commitment was to the State of Nevada and that responsibility still stands. If you want to have coverage for them through the A and B and the people you sold them to, fine. But you can't as an entity work on a benefit for them from the State of Nevada for their service that covers what is killing them right now. Public Comment under Item 3: Peggy Lear Bowen: My name and words for the record, P-e-g-g-y Lear, L-e-a-r, Bowen, B-o-we-n. And it's only that included under repeal sections under section four on page four, because it was included as a person or critical labor shortage, are we -- do we have an addressed critical labor shortage person coming back in after being retired and receiving both? Are we eliminating whether a person with critical labor shortage needs to be defined, or is the fact that they're still retired and receiving the other retirement. In other words, if I go back to work and in a critical labor shortage area, will I still be able to be covered by insurance? Executive Officer Haycock answered Ms. Bowen’s question. Public Comment under Item 14: Peggy Lear Bowen: My name and words for the record Peggy, P-e-g-g-y, Lear, L-e-a-r, Bowen, B-o-w-e-n. A few things that came up today. The discussion you had about people who are coming back from work after they were off work without pay. Much discussion in the lunch room, the concern is that if they start up on the 14th of the month, they haven't paid the premium from one to 13 of that month, and therefore they would be getting a gift, so to speak. I would hope and pray that you would reconsider having an option available for them if they want to pay the premium beginning that month of when they were brought back to work or when they went back to work that they'd have the option for paying the premium that would have been due had they been a working person at that time instead of out of work without pay, that sort of thing. At least give them an option so that they have their insurance. That's number one. Your telemed, I'm concerned that it is only for face time through technology with a doctor with telemed. For those of us who are not going to get sick between eight to five on a weekday and who are not -- who are not connected that they don't get a bonus for using telemed because that would be a fine for others who don't telephonically or computer wise electronically connected, that it's kept as an equal basis. It's just another option for people to get help with their doctors. For a lot of people this is the situation. We call the nurse. The nurse says you got to go to urgent care. You go to urgent care and they tell you have to go to the hospital. And you get to the hospital and the hospital says, we don't have any reason to admit you. There are lots of bills that have been incurred because you followed direction. And I don't want them ever to be deemed as not payable and covered by our insurance because it wasn't determined as being urgent or an emergency by when you finally got to the hospital. And so we need to word craft and work with that situation so that nobody is penalized for utilizing the options that they have available for them to use and not to assume that everybody is going to get the smart phone and all of that other stuff. Okay. Cancel that one. And I've heard a lot of things about the reserves being used up. But I remember Ms. Marlene's comment a few meetings ago about, well, what about the new reserves. It's like the piggy bank is empty but in fact from what I'm hearing that money is being built up in the accounts as we speak. And you're saying no. If that's not the case, then we need to put it by this board on the record what's happening with potential new reserves or any other reserves, not just the old ones. Then the survey, again, pertaining to the technical part, I would hope that everyone would receive a survey. And I want it in writing, in print, and electronically so that people can do them. But I want – I would hope and pray -- God, that was rude. I apologize. I would hope and pray that you would consider your survey so valuable that every single person receives it in a capacity that they can fill it out and return it to you and have it set up so that if, oh, if you're on the HMO, answer this part of the survey, and what if you're considering going to the high deductible. Well, what would your answers be over there and vice versa. So that you get a whole picture of a person who has options and that it is in writing and not just electronically done. Do both. Do a blend. Because you truly want your survey back and not necessarily the means by which it was sent. And I love you all and I hope all is well. And I don't want anybody left behind. Everything is done and thank you for all your hard work. 11.2.1. 11. Consent Agenda (Leo Drozdoff, Chair) (All Items for Possible Action) Consent items will be considered together and acted on in one motion unless an item is removed to be considered separately by the Board. 11.2. Receipt of quarterly staff reports for the period ending March 31, 2016: 11.2.1. PEBP Chief Financial Officer Reports 11.2.1.1. Budget Report 11.2.1.2. Utilization Report 11.2.1.1. 11. Consent Agenda (Leo Drozdoff, Chair) (All Items for Possible Action) Consent items will be considered together and acted on in one motion unless an item is removed to be considered separately by the Board. 11.2. Receipt of quarterly staff reports for the period ending March 31, 2016: 11.2.1. PEBP Chief Financial Officer Reports 11.2.1.1. Budget Report STATE OF NEVADA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES’ BENEFITS PROGRAM 901 S. Stewart Street, Suite 1001 Carson City, Nevada 89701 Telephone (775) 684-7000 · (800) 326-5496 BRIAN SANDOVAL Governor Fax (775) 684-7028 www.pebp.state.nv.us DAMON HAYCOCK LEO M. DROZDOFF, P.E. Executive Officer Board Chairman AGENDA ITEM X Action Item Information Only Date: June 17, 2016 Item Number: 11.2.1.1 Title: Chief Financial Officer Report Summary This report addresses the Operational Budget as of March 31, 2016 to include: 1. Budget Status 2. Budget Projections 3. Claims Summary Budget Account 1338 – Operational Budget – Shown below is a summary of the operational budget account status as of March 31, 2016 with comparisons to the same period in FY 2015. The budget status is reported on a cash basis and does not include incurred expenses and income owed to the fund. The budget status report reflects actual income of $238.1 million as of March 31, 2016 compared to $231.8 million as of March 31, 2015 or an increase of 2.7%. Total expenses for the period have increased $14.4 million or 5.9% for the same period. The budget status report shows Realized Funding Available (cash) at $122.1 million. This compares to $155.5 million for last year. After subtracting $31.1 million for reserves for Incurred but not Reported (IBNR) claims, $23.7 million for the Catastrophic Reserve and $31.3 million for the HRA Reserve, the remaining balance is $36.0 million in Excess reserves. The table below reflects the actual revenue and expenditures for the period. Although 75% of the fiscal year has elapsed total income is at 72% of budgeted, total expenses are at 70% of budgeted and realized funding (Excess Reserves) is at 116% of budgeted. Chief Financial Officer Report June 17, 2016 Page 2 Operational Budget 1338 Beginning Cash FISCAL YEAR 2016 Actual as of 3/31/2016 Work Program 143,516,188 143,516,188 Premium Income All Other Income Total Income 236,684,386 1,416,556 238,100,942 328,625,786 1,413,838 330,039,624 72% 100% 72% 230,967,886 844,716 231,812,602 311,515,729 1,211,219 312,726,948 74% 70% 74% Personnel Services Operating - Other than Personnel Insurance Program Expenses All Other Expenses Total Expenses 1,577,750 3,113,908 254,040,437 830,174 259,562,268 2,311,555 5,088,364 359,657,508 1,349,245 368,406,672 68% 61% 71% 62% 70% 1,513,615 4,674,229 238,257,623 701,770 245,147,238 2,096,382 5,306,381 329,625,600 1,010,542 338,038,904 72% 88% 72% 69% 73% (21,461,327) (38,367,048) (13,334,635) (25,311,956) REALIZED FUNDING AVAILABLE 122,054,861 105,149,140 155,493,509 143,516,188 Incurred But Not Reported Liability Catastrophic Reserve HRA Reserve (31,087,000) (23,700,000) (31,298,890) (31,087,000) (23,700,000) (31,298,890) (44,000,000) (30,300,000) (17,011,515) (44,000,000) (30,300,000) (17,011,515) NET REALIZED FUNDING AVAILABLE 35,968,971 19,063,250 64,181,994 52,204,673 Change in Cash Percent 100% 116% FISCAL YEAR 2015 Actual as of Fiscal Year 3/31/2015 2015 Close Percent 168,828,144 168,828,144 100% 108% Current Budget Projections The following table represents projections for FY16 based on data available as of March 31, 2016. The projection reflects total income to be more than budgeted by 3.1%, total expenditures are more than budgeted by 3.8%, offset by total reserves that are also more than budgeted by 27.3% (an increase in reserves is depicted by a negative number) when adjusted for the work program (budget amendment) which reduced the budgeted excess reserves by approximately $9.5 million. This reduction was a result of transferring those funds to the IBNR reserve category and the HRA Contributions category. Chief Financial Officer Report June 17, 2016 Page 3 Budgeted and Projected Income (Budget Account 1338) Description Carryforward State Subsidies Contributions All Other Total Budget 143,516,188 235,638,100 92,987,686 1,413,838 473,555,812 Actual 3/31/16 143,516,188 166,589,189 70,095,197 1,416,556 381,617,130 Projected 143,516,188 249,657,278 93,179,209 1,861,997 488,214,672 Difference 0 14,019,178 191,523 448,159 14,658,860 0.0% 5.9% 0.2% 31.7% 3.1% Budgeted and Projected Expenses (Budget Account 1338) Description Operating Self-Funded Admin Self-Funded Claims HSA/HRA Contributions Fully Insured Products Total Expenses Restricted Reserves Excess Reserves for Benefit Enhancements Total Reserves Total of Expenses and Reserves Budget 8,749,164 9,008,385 171,289,083 59,566,411 119,793,629 368,406,672 Actual 3/31/16 5,521,832 6,615,682 119,782,650 44,494,523 83,147,581 259,562,268 Projected 8,800,763 8,828,372 171,289,083 53,873,903 111,599,001 354,391,123 Difference (51,600) 180,013 0 5,692,508 8,194,628 14,015,549 -0.6% 2.0% 0.0% 9.6% 6.8% 3.8% 86,085,890 86,085,890 86,920,618 (834,728) -1.0% 19,063,250 35,968,971 46,902,931 (27,839,681) -146.0% 105,149,140 122,054,861 133,823,550 (28,674,410) -27.3% 473,555,812 381,617,130 488,214,672 (14,658,861) -3.1% State subsidies are projected to be more than the budgeted amount by $14.0 million (5.9%). Contributions are also projected to be higher than budgeted by $0.2 million (0.2%). This is due to an increase in actual enrollment compared to the budgeted enrollment (1.6%). When comparing actual enrollment as of March 1, 2016 to budgeted enrollment the mix of participants reflect the following changes: 2.0% more state actives, 1.8% more state non-Medicare retirees, 0.3% fewer state Medicare retirees, 25.0% fewer non-state actives, 8.4% more non-state, non-Medicare retirees, and 1.0% fewer non-state Medicare retirees. The HSA/HRA contributions are projected to be $5.7 million (9.6%) less than budgeted when adjusted for the work program (budget amendment) which increased the HSA/HRA funding availability from $25.3 million to $31.5 million. Fully Insured Products which includes payments to the northern and southern HMOs as well as life insurance premiums are projected to be $8.2 million (6.8%) less than budgeted. Excess reserves will be adjusted to reflect shortfalls or surpluses in both the expenditure and revenue categories. In addition, the PEBP Board approved utilizing approximately $52 million for plan design enhancements in PY 2016 and 2017 at its meeting in March 2015. Chief Financial Officer Report June 17, 2016 Page 4 Claims Summary Total self-funded paid medical claim dollars increased by $7.3 million or 9.2% from the period ending March 31, 2015 to the period ending March 31, 2016. On a per participant basis, medical claims paid increased 2.4%, dental increased 0.6% and prescription costs decreased 2.5%. Prescription costs do not include rebates from Catamaran RX or the Retiree Drug Subsidy Program. Prescription rebates are received by PEBP approximately nine to twelve months after they are earned. Self-Funded Net Paid Claims - Total Jul 2014 - Mar 2015 Jul 2015 - Mar 2016 Medical Inpatient Outpatient Total Medical Dental Prescription Total $ $ $ $ $ $ 30,366,479 49,190,053 79,556,532 16,773,323 17,279,508 113,609,363 $ $ $ $ $ $ 31,159,066 55,705,485 86,864,551 17,413,103 17,967,564 122,245,218 % Change 2.6% 13.2% 9.2% 3.8% 4.0% 7.6% Self-Funded Net Paid Claims - Per Participant Per Month Jul 2014 - Mar 2015 Jul 2015 - Mar 2016 Medical Dental Prescription Total $ $ $ $ 435.90 50.47 94.68 581.04 $ $ $ $ 446.23 50.75 92.30 589.29 % Change 2.4% 0.6% -2.5% 1.4% Information obtained from HealthSCOPE Benefits and Catamaran quarterly reports. Chief Financial Officer Report June 17, 2016 Page 5 Contract Payments The table below represents contract payments through March 31, 2016. State of Nevada - Public Employees' Benefits Program Payments for Contracts as of March 31, 2016 FY 2015 Total Amount % of Total Expenses FY 2016 through March 31, 2016 (75.00%) Amount % of Total Expenses % of Est'd % of Est'd FY16 FY16 Contract Budget Contract Term Date Consulting / Auditing Services AON Consulting Casey, Neilon & Associates Inc. Health Claim Auditors, Inc. Sub-total 482,551 36,829 137,700 657,080 5.59% 0.43% 1.60% 7.61% 478,275 8.54% 8.54% 672,043 2.57% 11.85% 14.42% 232,174 0.00% 6.56% 45.36% 51.93% 440,878 34,457 125,800 638,532 6.08% 0.44% 1.60% 8.11% 49.26% 31.01% 25.91% 19.22% 59.64% 55.78% 64.38% 60.29% 6/30/2016 12/31/2015 9/30/2017 8.54% 8.54% 60.69% 60.69% 62.51% 62.51% 12/31/2021 2.95% 9.27% 12.22% 57.10% 61.29% 60.22% 78.68% 76.01% 76.64% 6/30/2017 6/30/2019 5.60% 5.86% 51.25% 62.70% 12.91% 113.97% 17.33% 19.26% 60.03% 95.08% 80.49% 79.22% 6/30/2016 6/30/2020 6/30/2020 112.25% 0.00% 112.25% 88.85% 0.00% 88.85% 6/30/2019 6/12/2015 Enrollment / Eligibility System Morneau Shepell Sub-total 737,394 737,394 672,043 PPO Network Fees Diversified Dental Services 222,131 Hometown Health Partners 1,022,627 Sub-total 1,244,758 729,729 961,903 Third Party Administrator Services Catamaran (Admin Only) Extend Health HealthSCOPE Benefits Sub-total 566,622 3,916,088 4,482,710 461,119 4,034,494 4,936,490 Utilization Management / Wellness Hometown Health Partners 989,241 US Preventive Medicine 521,399 663,623 1,510,639 11.46% 6.04% 17.50% 663,623 8.43% 0.00% 8.43% 8,632,581 100.00% 7,872,591 100.00% 24.42% 75.93% Hometown Health Partners 44,305,659 27,721,709 57.23% 35.81% 93.04% 48,484,838 Health Plan of Nevada 58.31% 33.69% 92.00% 21.74% 27.31% 23.50% 63.98% 65.45% 64.51% 6/30/2016 6/30/2016 6.96% 6.96% 6,648,406 6,648,406 8.00% 8.00% 124.65% 124.65% 121.94% 121.94% 6/30/2018 5,387,572 77,414,940 100.00% 83,147,581 100.00% 25.13% 67.03% 15,995,974 16,800,278 16,170,018 11.71% 0.13% 11.83% 11.58% 0.00% 11.58% 12.91% 0.00% 12.77% 99.93% 0.00% 91.51% 120,488,483 120,488,483 88.17% 88.17% 102,982,373 16,742,735 6,982,886 17,447,502 41,173,123 12.25% 5.11% 12.77% 30.13% 17,900,698 44,494,523 12.34% 5.07% 13.26% 30.68% 136,658,501 100.00% 145,043,208 100.00% Sub-total Total Administrative Contracts - Health Maintenance Organizations Sub-total 72,027,368 28,014,337 76,499,175 Life & LTD Insurance The Standard Insurance Sub-total Total Fully Insured Products 5,387,572 Contracted Claims Expense Catamaran US Preventive Medicine Sub-total 174,044 16,800,278 Non-Contracted Claims Expense Medical Claims Sub-total 102,982,373 71.00% 71.00% HSA/HRA Expense PPO HDHP HSA PPO HDHP HRA Medicare Exchange HRA Sub-total Total Claims 7,359,859 19,233,966 84.68% 6/30/2016 6/12/2015 Chief Financial Officer Report June 17, 2016 Page 6 Recommendations None. 11.2.1.2. 11. Consent Agenda (Leo Drozdoff, Chair) (All Items for Possible Action) Consent items will be considered together and acted on in one motion unless an item is removed to be considered separately by the Board. 11.2. Receipt of quarterly staff reports for the period ending March 31, 2016: 11.2.1. PEBP Chief Financial Officer Reports 11.2.1.2. Utilization Report STATE OF NEVADA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES’ BENEFITS PROGRAM 901 S. Stewart Street, Suite 1001 Carson City, Nevada 89701 Telephone (775) 684-7000 · (800) 326-5496 BRIAN SANDOVAL Governor Fax (775) 684-7028 www.pebp.state.nv.us DAMON HAYCOCK LEO M. DROZDOFF, P.E. Executive Officer Board Chairman AGENDA ITEM X Action Item Information Only Date: July 21, 2016 Item Number: 11.2.1.2 Title: Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 This report addresses medical, dental, prescription drug and HSA/HRA utilization for the period ending March 31, 2016. Included are: Executive Summary – provides a utilization overview. HealthSCOPE Utilization Report – provides graphical supporting details for the information included in the Executive Summary. Catamaran Utilization Report – provides details supporting the prescription drug information included in the Executive Summary. Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 2 Executive Summary Key Observations During the period ending March 31, 2016: Total medical spend was $86.9 million (9.2% more than in PY15 at $79.6 million), of which 68.7% was spent by the State Active population. The average plan cost was $446 PPPM, 2.4% more than the period ending March 31, 2015 at an average cost of $436 (see appendix page 9). The PY16 plan cost was $5,355 per member, up 2.4% from $5,231 for PY15 (see appendix page 9). Inpatient claims of $144 PPPM (1,610 admits * $17,386 ÷ 21,629 employees ÷ 9 months) were 2.0% lower than the $147 for PY15 (1,469 * $18,238 ÷ 20,279 ÷ 9) (See appendix page 15, for number of admits and cost per admit, and page 4, for average number of employees.) The plan had more large cost claimants in PY16 with 122 claimants in excess of $100,000 compared to 115 claimants in PY15. Although representing 0.3% (122/38,758 members = 0.003) of the total membership, this segment accounted for 27.8% ($197,812 * 122 ÷ $86,864,551 = 27.8%) of dollars spent by the plan (see appendix page 9). Below is a chart showing the high cost claimant amounts for the last five plan years. PY 6/30/2011 6/30/2012 6/30/2013 6/30/2014 6/30/2015 3/31/2016 6/30/2016 Number of High cost Claimaints 55 157 167 139 157 122 163 Cost Notes $11,306,900 $36,772,529 $37,388,461 $31,345,612 $36,046,415 $24,133,064 Q3 PY16 $32,177,419 PY16 Annualized The non-state retiree members of the CDHP are reflecting an increase in claims cost. For this group, inpatient claims decreased by $0.4 million (12.5%) and outpatient claims increased by $0.9 million (22.5%) when comparing PY16 to PY15. On a PMPM basis the cost increased from $556 in PY15 compared to $644 for PY16 (15.9%). Overall medical claims for non-state retirees continue to demonstrate the volatility caused by the size of the non-state pool. (See appendix page 11 - 13). Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 3 Medical–Cost Distribution During the period ending March 31, 2016 the largest group (89.6%) of members had claims paid in the amount of less than $2,500. A little less than a period of all CDHP participants (22.4%) had no claims filed for the period. (See appendix page 14.) Q3 PY16 Member Distribution 0.30% 22.4% 10.3% 16.2% The average medical claim for this period was $305 which is virtually the same as the period ending March 31, 2015 ($305). ($86,864,551 ÷ 284,738 claims = $305.07 vs $79,556,532 ÷ 260,713 claims = $305.15). (See appendix page 4) 51.0% $100k + >$2.5k < $2.5k 0 Paid No Claim The average payment per claimant for a catastrophic claim was $197,812 (see appendix page 9). For a summary of the high-cost claim categories, see appendix page 14. Major Diagnostic Musculoskeletal, Diseases of the Circulatory System and Neoplasms are the three most expensive diagnostic categories, together accounting for 36.0% of total costs by the plan (see appendix page 18). The costs associated with these three categories are: Neoplasms at $11.5 million (See appendix page 19) Musculoskeletal at $11.5 million (See appendix page 20) Diseases of the Circulatory System at $8.3 million (See appendix page 21) Dental The average dental claim for the period ending March 31, 2016, was $162. This represents a 5.86% decrease from the $172 average dental claim for the period ending March 31, 2015. ($17,413,103 ÷ 107,373 claims = $162.17 vs. $16,773,323 ÷ 97,372 claims = $172.26) (See appendix page 24) % of Dollars Paid by Category 7% 23% 40% 30% Preventative Basic Major Periodontics Of the $17.4 million in paid dental claims during the period ending March 31, 2016, $7.2 million (41.1%) was for preventive services. (See appendix page 24) Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 4 Drug Utilization (See appendix pages 26-27) Drug utilization (number of members utilizing the PEBP pharmacy benefit as a percentage of all CDHP self-funded members) has decreased from 28.1% to 26.6% from the period ending March 31, 2015 to period ending March 31, 2016. Percent of total prescription costs paid by participants during the ten quarters ending March 31, 2016. Total prescription drug costs increased by $1.3 million (5.2%) from the period ending March 31, 2015, to the period ending March 31, 2016. Both the participant and the plan cost increased when comparing the period ending March 31, 2015 with the period ending March 31, 2016. The participant share increased by $0.6 million (7.6%) and the plan cost increased by $0.7 million (4.0%). Generic drug utilization (generic scripts filled as a percent of all scripts) reflects an increase of approximately 1.8% from 81.6% for the period ending March 31, 2015, compared to 83.4% for the period ending March 31, 2016. The generic effective rate increased by 1.4% (97.5% in March 2015 versus 98.9% in March 2016). Mail order claims remained the same at 1.6% of total claims when comparing the period ending March 31, 2015, to the period ending March 31, 2016. Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 5 Enrollment As of March 31, 2016, there were 42,188 participants enrolled in PEBP. This is 886 more than the average budgeted enrollment for FY 2016 of 41,302, due primarily to an increase in State Active Employees enrolled in the CDHP. Average enrollment in the self-funded plan increased 5.8% from 20,182 in FY 2015 to 21,431 in FY 2016. Average enrollment in the HMO plans decreased 7.8% from 10,285 to 9,545 during the same period. Average enrollment in the Medicare Exchange decreased 0.6% from 11,042 in FY 2015 to 10,972 in FY 2016. Below is a graphical representation of PEBP enrollment since July 2008. Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 6 CDHP HSA/HRA Account Balances HealthSCOPE Benefits administers approximately 9,747 CDHP Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA) accounts with approximately $11.4 million in PEBP contributions for the period ending March 31, 2016 compared to $12.9 million for the period ending March 31, 2015. The average contribution per account for the period ending March 31, 2016 is $1,165. PEBP paid approximately $7.0 million in HRA claims. Assuming PEBP continues to pay HRA claims at the current rate, it is expected that PEBP will pay approximately $9.4 million in HRA claims during fiscal year 2016 leaving a liability of $13.9 million in unused HRA funds (which includes rollover of $11.6 million from fiscal year 2015), or $1,423 per account. Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 7 HealthSCOPE Benefits administers approximately 14,743 CDHP HSA accounts. PEBP contributed approximately $18.4 million while employees contributed approximately $5.5 million for the period ending March 31, 2016. This compares to $17.1 million and $5.0 million for the same period in PY15 when there were 14,633 accounts. The average employee contribution increased from an average of $345 for the period ended March 31, 2015 to an average of $376 for the period ended March 31, 2016. For the period ending March 31, 2016, HealthSCOPE Benefits distributed approximately $17.9 million from participant accounts compared to approximately $16.7 million for the same period in PY15. Since inception, HealthSCOPE Benefits has distributed approximately $83.5 million from participant accounts. As of March 31, 2016, participants have cumulatively saved approximately $28.2 million in their accounts, an average of $1,916 per account. Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 8 Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 9 Exchange HRA Account Balances Towers Watson administers approximately 10,959 Medicare Exchange HRA accounts, with contributions of $22.3 million for the period ending March 31, 2016. These contributions include a one-time contribution of $2 per month per year of service due to the Board actions in March 2015 to reduce excess reserves. For the period ending March 31, 2016, PEBP paid $12.0 million in Medicare Exchange HRA claims ($1,092 per retiree). Assuming PEBP continues to pay Medicare Exchange HRA claims at the current rate, it is expected that PEBP will pay approximately $16.0 million in HRA claims during fiscal year 2016 leaving a liability of $18.0 million in unused Medicare Exchange HRA funds, or $1,641 per account, at the end of the period. (The following charts are based on Plan Year 2016 contributions and payments made during the period ending March 31, 2016.) Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 10 Recommendations None. Self-Funded Plan Utilization Report for the period ending March 31, 2016 July 21, 2016 Page 11 Appendix Index of Tables HealthSCOPE – Utilization Review for PEBP July 1, 2015 – March 31, 2016 HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS OVERVIEW.........................................................................3 MONTHLY COST SUMMARY ............................................................................................4 MEDICAL Claims by Plan/Relationship ..........................................................................................6 Paid Claims by Age Group ............................................................................................7 Financial Summary ........................................................................................................9 Paid Claims by Claim Type .........................................................................................11 Cost Distribution – Medical Claims ............................................................................14 Utilization Summary ....................................................................................................15 Provider Network Summary ........................................................................................17 Agency for Healthcare Research (AHRQ) Summary ..................................................18 Neoplasms ....................................................................................................................19 Disorders of Musculoskeletal System ..........................................................................20 Disease of the Circulatory System ...............................................................................21 Emergency Room Summary ........................................................................................22 Savings Summary ........................................................................................................23 Dental Claims Analysis ...........................................................................................................24 Savings Summary ........................................................................................................25 CATAMARAN RX UTILIZATION TABLES ...................................................................26 H S B D ATA S C O P E T M 1 Utilization Review for Nevada Public Employees’ Benefits Program PEBP July 1, 2015 – March 31, 2015 Jul 15 - Mar 16 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 2 Overview Total Medical Spend for 3Q PY16 was $86,864,551 of which 68.7% was spent in the State Active population. When compared to 3Q PY15, there was a 9.2% increase in plan spending overall. When compared to 3Q PY14, 3Q PY16 reflected an increase of 23.7% in plan spend, with State Actives having an increase of 31.9%. On a PEPY basis, the plan showed a slight increase of 2.4% when compared to 3Q PY15. The largest group, State Actives, increased 2.0%. When compared to 3Q PY14, 3Q PY16 reflected a 11.1% increase in plan spend, with State Actives having an increase of 6.0%. Jul 15 - Mar 16 89.6% of the Average Membership had paid Medical claims less than $2,500, with 22.4% of those having no claims filed at all during the reporting period. This is on track with 3QPY15. There are 122 High Cost Claimants (HCC’s) over $100K, that account for 27.8% of the total spend. HCC’s accounted for 28.2% of total spend during 3Q PY15, with 115 members hitting the $100K threshold. The largest claimant had total paid claims in the amount of $835,790 diagnosed with ESRD. IP Paid per Admit for the whole plan was $17,386, which is 4.7% lower than the 3Q PY15 IP Paid per Admit of $18,238. ER Paid per Visit is $1,886, which is 5.0% higher than 3Q PY15 ER Paid per Visit of $1,797. 95.9% of all Medical spend dollars were to In Network providers. The average In Network discount is 61.5%, which is a 1.9% increase over the 3Q PY15 average of 59.6%. TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 3 M o n t h l y C o s t S u m m a r y – Ye a r o v e r Ye a r C o m p a r i s o n PY16 Employees - Medical Members - Medical Employees - Dental Members - Dental Avg Member Age - Medical Medical Claims Processed Medical Claims Amount Dental Claims Amount All Claims Amount PEPM - Medical PEPM - Dental Jul 21,096 37,694 37,522 62,395 37.5 30,832 $10,981,720 $2,290,415 $13,272,135 $521 $61 Aug 21,238 37,935 37,725 62,694 37.4 34,053 $8,333,254 $1,991,370 $10,324,624 $392 $53 Sep 21,540 38,455 38,082 63,285 37.4 34,234 $9,599,605 $1,830,220 $11,429,825 $446 $48 Oct 21,715 38,864 37,923 63,784 37.2 29,052 $7,355,382 $2,003,876 $9,359,258 $339 $53 Nov 21,786 39,028 38,324 63,945 37.1 28,586 $7,076,789 $1,721,922 $8,798,712 $325 $45 Dec 21,834 39,160 38,379 64,090 37.1 32,878 $9,592,579 $1,890,767 $11,483,347 $439 $49 Jan 21,772 39,164 38,322 64,059 37.1 28,873 $10,146,702 $1,791,801 $11,938,503 $466 $47 Feb 21,849 39,254 38,421 64,162 37.1 29,935 $11,396,840 $1,806,177 $13,203,017 $522 $47 Mar 21,828 39,267 38,398 64,234 37.1 36,295 $12,381,679 $2,086,553 $14,468,232 $567 $54 Avg/Total 21,629 38,758 38,122 63,628 37.22 284,738 $86,864,551 $17,413,103 $104,277,654 $446 $51 PY15 Employees - Medical Members - Medical Employees - Dental Members - Dental Avg Member Age - Medical Medical Claims Processed Medical Claims Amount Dental Claims Amount All Claims Amount PEPM - Medical PEPM - Dental Jul 19,970 35,499 36,493 60,780 37.88 29,204 $9,725,546 $2,086,422 $11,811,968 $487 $57 Aug 20,156 35,779 36,749 61,131 37.81 28,439 $8,721,217 $2,000,244 $10,721,461 $433 $54 Sep 20,173 35,777 36,757 61,096 37.87 31,365 $7,972,088 $1,878,244 $9,850,332 $395 $51 Oct 20,216 35,885 36,847 61,259 37.94 30,687 $9,425,645 $1,986,922 $11,412,567 $466 $54 Nov 20,305 36,047 36,971 61,473 37.87 26,395 $7,486,810 $1,668,554 $9,155,364 $369 $45 Dec 20,436 36,231 37,114 61,684 37.77 22,844 $7,446,538 $1,630,849 $9,077,387 $364 $44 Jan 20,390 36,175 37,097 61,655 38.62 31,525 $10,034,003 $1,893,607 $11,927,610 $492 $51 Feb 20,437 36,250 37,181 61,757 38.53 28,445 $8,719,157 $1,704,157 $10,423,314 $427 $46 Mar 20,427 36,217 37,161 61,659 38.50 31,809 $10,025,529 $1,924,325 $11,949,854 $491 $52 Avg/Total 20,279 35,984 36,930 61,388 38.09 260,713 $79,556,533 $16,773,324 $96,329,856 $436 $50 Variance Employees - Medical Members - Medical Employees - Dental Members - Dental Avg Member Age - Medical Medical Claims Processed Medical Claims Amount Dental Claims Amount All Claims Amount PEPM - Medical PEPM - Dental Jul 5.6% 6.2% 2.8% 2.7% -1.0% 5.6% 12.9% 9.8% 12.4% 6.9% 6.8% Aug 5.4% 6.0% 2.7% 2.6% -1.1% 19.7% -4.4% -0.4% -3.7% -9.3% -3.0% Sep 6.8% 7.5% 3.6% 3.6% -1.2% 9.1% 20.4% -2.6% 16.0% 12.8% -5.9% Oct 7.4% 8.3% 2.9% 4.1% -2.0% -5.3% -22.0% 0.9% -18.0% -27.4% -2.0% Nov 7.3% 8.3% 3.7% 4.0% -2.0% 8.3% -5.5% 3.2% -3.9% -11.9% -0.4% Dec 6.8% 8.1% 3.4% 3.9% -1.9% 43.9% 28.8% 15.9% 26.5% 20.6% 12.1% Jan 6.8% 8.3% 3.3% 3.9% -3.9% -8.4% 1.1% -5.4% 0.1% -5.3% -8.4% Feb 6.9% 8.3% 3.3% 3.9% -3.7% 5.2% 30.7% 6.0% 26.7% 22.3% 2.6% Mar 6.9% 8.4% 3.3% 4.2% -3.6% 14.1% 23.5% 8.4% 21.1% 15.6% 4.9% Avg/Total 6.7% 7.7% 3.2% 3.6% -2.3% 9.2% 9.2% 3.8% 8.3% 2.4% 0.6% Jul 15 - Mar 16 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 4 P E P Y – Ye a r o v e r Ye a r Tr e n d $6,500 $6,000 $5,709 $5,829 $5,535 $5,500 $5,355 $5,287 $5,000 $4,500 $4,000 $3,500 $3,000 PY16* PY15 PY14 PY13 PY12 * Annualized Jul 15 - Mar 16 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 5 Medical Claims by Plan / Relationship Medical Claims by Plan - PY15 Total Costs PMPM (Per Member per Month) HRA $42,073,998 $364 HSA $44,790,553 $192 Medical Claims by Plan Total $86,864,551 $249 Total Medical Claims Paid / Relationship 1Q 2Q 3Q Insured $20,229,494 $16,773,111 $23,262,918 Spouse $4,790,462 $4,126,003 $5,233,288 Child $3,894,623 $3,125,637 $5,429,016 Total $28,914,579 $24,024,750 $33,925,222 YTD $60,265,523 $14,149,753 $12,449,276 $86,864,551 PMPM $310 $322 $113 $249 Medical Claims by Relationship Child 14% HSA 52% Jul 15 - Mar 16 HRA 48% Spouse 16% Insured 70% TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 6 Paid Claims by Age Group (p. 1 of 2) Paid Claims by Age Group Age Range <1 1 2-4 5-9 10 - 14 15 - 19 20 - 24 25 - 29 30 - 34 35 - 39 40 - 44 45 - 49 50 - 54 55 - 59 60 - 64 65+ Total Jul 15 - Mar 16 Med Net Pay $ 3,011,034 $ 358,282 $ 701,693 $ 1,212,539 $ 1,687,291 $ 2,646,296 $ 2,883,877 $ 2,563,190 $ 2,762,128 $ 3,323,898 $ 4,323,508 $ 6,463,152 $ 8,496,254 $ 14,553,156 $ 23,612,625 $ 8,265,627 $ 86,864,551 Med PMPM $ 1,394 $ 123 $ 65 $ 58 $ 74 $ 104 $ 107 $ 126 $ 124 $ 143 $ 173 $ 243 $ 289 $ 438 $ 596 $ 476 $ 249 Rx Net Pay $ 38,906 $ 5,399 $ 20,471 $ 116,228 $ 188,693 $ 343,663 $ 418,679 $ 288,541 $ 419,202 $ 604,567 $ 1,384,428 $ 1,403,362 $ 1,522,147 $ 2,678,840 $ 5,470,975 $ 3,078,463 $ 17,982,566 3Q PY16 Rx Dental Net PMPM Pay $ 18 $ 905 $ 2 $ 25,314 $ 2 $ 269,171 $ 6 $ 842,185 $ 8 $ 839,436 $ 14 $ 1,082,388 $ 16 $ 714,455 $ 14 $ 666,852 $ 19 $ 791,219 $ 26 $ 855,908 $ 56 $ 991,877 $ 53 $ 1,192,863 $ 52 $ 1,420,826 $ 81 $ 1,748,856 $ 138 $ 2,171,301 $ 177 $ 3,799,195 $ 52 $ 17,412,751 Dental PMPM $ 0 $ 6 $ 19 $ 28 $ 26 $ 29 $ 19 $ 24 $ 27 $ 26 $ 29 $ 30 $ 33 $ 35 $ 37 $ 38 $ 30 Net Pay $ 3,050,845 $ 388,995 $ 991,335 $ 2,170,952 $ 2,715,420 $ 4,072,347 $ 4,017,011 $ 3,518,583 $ 3,972,550 $ 4,784,373 $ 6,699,813 $ 9,059,377 $ 11,439,227 $ 18,980,853 $ 31,254,901 $ 15,143,285 $ 122,259,867 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS PMPM $ 1,412 $ 131 $ 85 $ 91 $ 109 $ 147 $ 141 $ 165 $ 169 $ 196 $ 257 $ 326 $ 374 $ 553 $ 771 $ 692 $ 331 7 Paid Claims by Age Group (p. 2 of 2) Paid Claims by Age Group Age Range <1 1 2-4 5-9 10 - 14 15 - 19 20 - 24 25 - 29 30 - 34 35 - 39 40 - 44 45 - 49 50 - 54 55 - 59 60 - 64 65+ Total Jul 15 - Mar 16 Med Net Pay $ 1,830,903 $ 282,299 $ 806,977 $ 1,916,122 $ 1,189,713 $ 2,032,231 $ 2,394,561 $ 2,607,780 $ 2,598,876 $ 3,355,934 $ 4,323,738 $ 4,433,944 $ 10,483,349 $ 11,439,027 $ 21,168,926 $ 8,692,153 $ 79,556,532 Med PMPM $ 1,190 $ 122 $ 84 $ 100 $ 56 $ 85 $ 96 $ 155 $ 131 $ 164 $ 186 $ 177 $ 373 $ 348 $ 548 $ 530 $ 246 Rx Net Pay $ 14,987 $ 48,982 $ 22,892 $ 99,252 $ 132,309 $ 400,409 $ 371,196 $ 305,036 $ 313,098 $ 562,901 $ 1,099,008 $ 1,101,136 $ 1,846,483 $ 2,949,172 $ 5,726,106 $ 2,086,957 $ 17,079,923 3Q PY15 Rx Dental Net PMPM Pay $ 10 $ 2,910 $ 21 $ 16,445 $ 2 $ 253,665 $ 5 $ 820,319 $ 6 $ 817,718 $ 17 $ 1,026,331 $ 15 $ 697,406 $ 18 $ 593,907 $ 16 $ 772,457 $ 27 $ 796,905 $ 47 $ 967,320 $ 44 $ 1,078,730 $ 66 $ 1,405,060 $ 90 $ 1,814,124 $ 148 $ 2,210,854 $ 127 $ 3,499,171 $ 53 $ 16,773,323 % Change Dental PMPM $ 2 $ 6 $ 18 $ 29 $ 26 $ 28 $ 19 $ 25 $ 28 $ 27 $ 28 $ 28 $ 33 $ 36 $ 36 $ 39 $ 30 Net Pay $ 1,848,800 $ 347,726 $ 1,083,534 $ 2,835,694 $ 2,139,740 $ 3,458,971 $ 3,463,163 $ 3,506,722 $ 3,684,432 $ 4,715,740 $ 6,390,065 $ 6,613,810 $ 13,734,892 $ 16,202,323 $ 29,105,886 $ 14,278,281 $ 113,409,778 PMPM $ 1,201 $ 148 $ 104 $ 134 $ 88 $ 130 $ 130 $ 198 $ 175 $ 218 $ 261 $ 249 $ 472 $ 474 $ 732 $ 696 $ 329 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS Net Pay 65.0% 11.9% -8.5% -23.4% 26.9% 17.7% 16.0% 0.3% 7.8% 1.5% 4.8% 37.0% -16.7% 17.1% 7.4% 6.1% 7.8% PMPM 17.6% -11.6% -17.8% -32.0% 22.9% 13.1% 8.4% -16.7% -3.6% -10.1% -1.5% 31.1% -20.6% 16.7% 5.3% -0.5% 0.7% 8 Cost DistributionPMPY High Cost Claimants Financial Summary Financial Summary (p. 1 of 2) Avg # Participants Avg # Members Mem / Part Ratio Gross Cost Plan Paid Employee Paid Client Paid-PEPY Client Paid-PMPY Client Paid-PEPM Client Paid-PMPM # of HCC's (>$100K) HCC's / 1,000 Avg HCC Paid HCC's % of Plan Paid Facility Inpatient Facility Outpatient Physician Other Total Jul 15 - Mar 16 All Combined Groups All Combined Groups All Combined Groups PY16 to PY15 State Active State Active State Active PY16 to PY15 Non-State Active Non-State Active Non-State Active PY16 to PY15 3Q PY16 21,629 38,758 1.79 $115,541,131 $86,864,551 $28,676,579 $5,355 $2,988 $446 $249 3Q PY15 20,279 35,985 1.77 $107,383,079 $79,556,532 $27,826,547 $5,231 $2,948 $436 $246 3Q PY14 19,420 33,927 1.75 $98,647,401 $70,204,066 $28,443,335 $4,820 $2,759 $402 $230 Variance 6.7 % 7.7 % 1.0 % 7.6 % 9.2 % 3.1 % 2.4 % 1.4 % 2.3 % 1.4 % 3Q PY16 17,389 33,064 1.90 $82,040,709 $59,632,795 $22,407,914 $4,573 $2,405 $381 $200 3Q PY15 16,089 30,428 1.89 $75,570,449 $54,102,853 $21,467,596 $4,484 $2,371 $374 $198 3Q PY14 14,949 28,059 1.88 $66,339,058 $45,209,352 $21,129,706 $4,032 $2,148 $336 $179 Variance 8.1 % 8.7 % 0.6 % 8.6 % 10.2 % 4.4 % 2.0 % 1.4 % 2.0 % 1.2 % 3Q PY16 5 7 1.36 $30,810 $22,019 $8,791 $5,872 $4,332 $489 $361 3Q PY15 5 8 1.56 $5,275 $1,525 $3,750 $407 $261 $34 $22 3Q PY14 6 12 2.00 $104,986 $94,365 $10,621 $20,970 $10,485 $1,748 $874 Variance 0.0 % (12.9)% (12.9)% 484.1 % 1,343.9 % 134.4 % 1,342.8 % 1,557.5 % 1,343.0 % 1,557.5 % 122 3.2 $197,812 27.8% 115 3.2 $207,728 28.2% 90 2.7 $205,564 26.4% 6.1 % (1.4)% (4.8)% (1.4)% 77 2.3 $178,533 23.1% 67 2.2 $206,710 25.6% 49 1.7 $190,063 20.6% 14.9 % 5.9 % (13.6)% (9.8)% 0 0.0 $0 0.0% 0 0.0 $0 0.0% 0 0.0 $0 0.0% $892 $971 $1,015 $110 $2,988 $966 $873 $1,002 $106 $2,948 $846 $816 $985 $111 $2,759 (7.7)% 11.2 % 1.3 % 3.8 % 1.4 % $688 $733 $899 $85 $2,405 $720 $698 $861 $92 $2,371 $637 $611 $814 $87 $2,149 (4.4)% 5.0 % 4.4 % (7.6)% 1.4 % $0 $2,432 $1,740 $160 $4,332 $0 $35 $224 $3 $262 $8,407 $936 $1,200 $40 $10,583 annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 % % % % 0.0 % 0.0 % 676.8 % 0.0 % 1,553.4 % 9 Cost DistributionPMPY High Cost Claimants Financial Summary Financial Summary (p. 2 of 2) Jul 15 - Mar 16 Avg # Participants Avg # Members Mem / Part Ratio Gross Cost Plan Paid Employee Paid Client Paid-PEPY Client Paid-PMPY Client Paid-PEPM Client Paid-PMPM # of HCC's (>$100K) HCC's / 1,000 Avg HCC Paid HCC's % of Plan Paid Facility Inpatient Facility Outpatient Physician Other Total State Retirees State Retirees State Retirees PY16 to PY15 Non-State Retirees Non-State Retirees Non-State Retirees PY16 to PY15 3Q PY16 3,066 4,417 1.44 $24,622,702 $19,860,635 $4,762,067 $8,637 $5,995 $720 $500 3Q PY15 2,925 4,184 1.43 $23,184,716 $18,623,745 $4,560,971 $8,491 $5,935 $707 $495 3Q PY14 2,856 4,045 1.42 $21,346,877 $16,593,864 $4,753,013 $7,747 $5,470 $646 $456 Variance 4.8 % 5.6 % 0.7 % 6.2 % 6.6 % 4.4 % 1.7 % 1.0 % 1.8 % 1.1 % 3Q PY16 1,169 1,271 1.09 $8,846,909 $7,349,102 $1,497,807 $8,382 $7,710 $699 $612 3Q PY15 1,260 1,365 1.08 $5,934,319 $6,828,409 $1,794,230 $7,226 $6,670 $602 $556 3Q PY14 1,609 1,811 1.13 $7,518,095 $8,306,485 $2,549,995 $6,883 $6,116 $574 $510 Variance (7.2)% (6.9)% 0.7 % 49.1 % 7.6 % (16.5)% 16.0 % 15.6 % 16.1 % 10.1 % 39 8.8 $186,704 36.7% 38 9.1 $175,886 35.9% 25 6.2 $258,655 39.0% 2.6 % (3.0)% 6.2 % 2.2 % 14 11.0 $221,754 42.2% 10 7.3 $190,140 27.8% 16 8.8 $162,761 31.4% $2,022 $2,164 $1,534 $275 $5,995 $2,280 $1,854 $1,614 $188 $5,935 $1,689 $1,853 $1,700 $227 $5,470 (11.3)% 16.7 % (5.0)% 46.3 % 1.0 % $2,294 $3,004 $2,228 $184 $7,710 $2,440 $1,786 $2,280 $167 $6,670 $2,164 $1,681 $2,035 $231 $6,116 annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 40.0 50.8 16.6 51.8 HSB HSB 2010 Peer Index $6,382 $3,436 $532 $286 % % % % (6.0)% 68.2 % (2.3)% 10.2 % 15.6 % $1,050 $1,122 $1,158 $106 $3,436 10 P a i d C l a i m s b y C l a i m Ty p e – S t a t e P a r t i c i p a n t s Net Paid Claims - Total State Participants Actives 3Q PY16 Pre-Medicare Medicare Retirees Retirees Total Actives 3Q PY15 Pre-Medicare Medicare Retirees Retirees Medical Inpatient Outpatient Total - Medical Dental Total $ $ $ $ $ Medical Dental Net Paid Claims - Per Participant per Month 3Q PY16 3Q PY15 Pre-Medicare Medicare Pre-Medicare Medicare Actives Retirees Retirees Total Actives Retirees Retirees $ 380 $ 802 $ 468 $ 432 $ 374 $ 754 $ 502 $ $ 53 $ 47 $ 50 $ 52 $ 53 $ 48 $ 48 $ Jul 15 - Mar 16 21,208,214 $ 6,397,654 $ 38,424,581 $ 10,909,813 $ 59,632,795 $ 17,307,467 $ 12,040,384 $ 1,431,608 $ 71,673,179 $ 18,739,075 $ 1,066,403 $ 1,486,766 $ 2,553,169 $ 1,946,562 $ 4,499,731 $ 28,672,271 $19,560,822 50,821,159 $34,542,031 79,493,430 $ 54,102,853 $ 15,418,554 $11,551,215 94,911,984 $ 65,654,068 $ $6,519,122 $9,668,975 16,188,097 $ $1,427,797 17,615,894 $ % Change Total Total $1,444,535 $ 27,524,479 $991,114 $45,202,119 2,435,649 $ 72,726,599 $1,692,832 $14,671,845 4,128,481 $ 87,398,444 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 4.2% 12.4% 9.3% 5.1% 8.6% % Change Total 425 52 Total 1.6% 0.6% 11 P a i d C l a i m s b y C l a i m Ty p e – N o n - S t a t e P a r t i c i p a n t s Net Paid Claims - Total Non-State Participants Actives 3Q PY16 Pre-Medicare Medicare Retirees Retirees Total Actives 3Q PY15 Pre-Medicare Medicare Retirees Retirees % Change Total Medical Inpatient Outpatient Total - Medical Dental Total $ $ $ $ $ Medical Dental Net Paid Claims - Per Participant per Month 3Q PY16 3Q PY15 Pre-Medicare Medicare Pre-Medicare Medicare Actives Retirees Retirees Total Actives Retirees Retirees $ 489 $ 756 $ 449 $ 698 $ 34 $ 629 $ 463 $ $ 42 $ 39 $ 42 $ 41 $ 29 $ 38 $ 44 $ Jul 15 - Mar 16 22,019 22,019 3,429 25,448 $ $ $ $ $ 1,941,993 4,518,317 6,460,310 613,707 7,074,017 $ $ $ $ $ 544,802 343,990 888,792 1,377,412 2,266,204 $ $ $ $ $ 2,486,795 4,884,326 7,371,121 1,994,549 9,365,670 $ $ $ $ $ 1,525 1,525 3,176 4,701 $ $ $ $ $ 2,252,393 3,733,994 5,986,387 729,673 6,716,060 $ $ $ $ $ 589,607 252,415 842,022 1,368,630 2,210,652 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS $ $ $ $ $ Total 2,842,000 3,987,934 6,829,934 2,101,479 8,931,413 -12.5% 22.5% 7.9% -5.1% 4.9% % Change Total 600 42 Total 16.3% -1.9% 12 P a i d C l a i m s b y C l a i m Ty p e – To t a l Net Paid Claims - Total Total Participants Actives 3Q PY16 Pre-Medicare Medicare Retirees Retirees 21,208,214 38,446,599 59,654,814 12,043,813 71,698,627 $ 8,339,647 $ $ 15,428,130 $ $ 23,767,776 $ $ 2,045,316 $ $ 25,813,092 $ Total Actives 3Q PY15 Pre-Medicare Medicare Retirees Retirees Total 19,560,822 34,543,556 54,104,378 11,554,391 65,658,769 $ $ $ $ $ 30,366,479 49,190,053 79,556,534 16,773,322 96,329,856 Medical Inpatient Outpatient Total - Medical Dental Total $ $ $ $ $ Medical Dental Net Paid Claims - Per Participant per Month 3Q PY16 3Q PY15 Pre-Medicare Medicare Pre-Medicare Medicare Actives Retirees Retirees Total Actives Retirees Retirees $ 380 $ 789 $ 463 $ 446 $ 374 $ 715 $ 491 $ $ 53 $ 44 $ 46 $ 51 $ 53 $ 44 $ 46 $ 1,611,205 $ 31,159,066 1,830,756 $ 55,705,485 3,441,961 $ 86,864,551 3,323,974 $ 17,413,103 6,765,935 $ 104,277,654 3Q PY15 $30,366,479 3Q PY16 $31,159,066 $ $ $ $ $ $49,190,053 $55,705,485 Inpatient Jul 15 - Mar 16 Outpatient 8,771,515 13,402,969 22,174,484 2,157,470 24,331,953 $ $ $ $ $ 2,034,142 $ 1,243,529 $ 3,277,672 $ 3,061,462 $ 6,339,133 $ % Change Total 2.6% 13.2% 9.2% 3.8% 8.3% % Change Total 436 50 2.4% 0.5% $16,773,322 $17,413,103 Dental TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 13 Cost Distribution – Medical Claims 3Q PY16 Cost Distribution Avg # of % of % of Total Paid EE Paid Members Members Paid % EE Paid Paid Claims Category 3Q PY15 Cost Distribution Avg # of % of % of Total Paid EE Paid Members Members Paid % EE Paid 110 0.3% $24,133,091 27.8% $730,741 2.5% $100,000.01 Plus 97 0.3% $22,434,621 28.2% $687,410 2.5% 178 0.5% $13,297,052 15.3% $1,057,421 3.7% $50,000.01-$100,000.00 166 0.5% $12,885,477 16.2% $985,012 3.5% 309 0.8% $11,970,901 13.8% $1,750,908 6.1% $25,000.01-$50,000.00 290 0.8% $10,900,522 13.7% $1,727,332 6.2% 811 2.1% $13,247,247 15.3% $3,644,247 12.7% $10,000.01-$25,000.00 724 2.0% $11,677,275 14.7% $3,581,374 12.9% 1,156 3.0% $8,685,689 10.0% $3,959,247 13.8% $5,000.01-$10,000.00 1,020 2.8% $7,502,089 9.4% $3,587,078 12.9% 1,507 3.9% $5,771,720 6.6% $3,443,398 12.0% $2,500.01-$5,000.00 1,410 3.9% $5,428,070 6.8% $3,353,970 12.1% 19,753 51.0% $9,758,851 11.2% $11,566,531 40.4% $0.01-$2,500.00 18,108 50.3% $8,728,478 11.0% $11,296,457 40.6% 6,260 16.2% $0 0.0% $2,524,086 8.8% $0.00 6,113 17.0% $0 0.0% $2,607,910 9.4% No Claims 8,674 22.4% $0 0.0% $0 0.0% 38,758 100.0% $86,864,551 100.0% $28,676,580 100.0% 8,056 22.4% $0 0.0% $0 0.0% 35,984 100.0% $79,556,532 100.0% $27,826,547 100.0% HCC's by AHRQ Clinical Classifications Chapter Distribution of HCC Medical Claims Paid HCC 27.8% Non-HCC 72.2% HCC – High Cost Claimant over $100K AHRQ Chapter % Paid Neoplasms 56 $5,920,579 24.5% Diseases Of The Circulatory System 84 $2,526,626 10.5% Injury And Poisoning 75 $2,140,466 8.9% Diseases Of The Nervous System And Sense Organs 91 $1,781,274 7.4% Diseases Of The Musculoskeletal System And Connective Tissue 79 $1,734,636 7.2% Diseases Of The Genitourinary System 61 $1,629,054 6.8% Certain Conditions Originating In The Perinatal Period 7 $1,489,263 6.2% Endocrine; Nutritional; And Metabolic Diseases And Immunity Disorders 75 $1,165,204 4.8% Infectious And Parasitic Diseases 63 $1,153,666 4.8% Diseases Of The Respiratory System 98 $885,396 3.7% 120 $882,336 3.7% Diseases Of The Digestive System 69 $832,776 3.5% Diseases Of The Skin And Subcutaneous Tissue 49 $811,338 3.4% Mental Illness 34 $382,419 1.6% Residual Codes; Unclassified; All E Codes [259. And 260.] 77 $306,105 1.3% Diseases Of The Blood And Blood-Forming Organs 42 $248,106 1.0% Complications Of Pregnancy; Childbirth; And The Puerperium 3 $138,708 0.6% Congenital Anomalies 9 $105,137 0.4% 122 $24,133,091 100.0% Symptoms; Signs; & Ill-Defined Conditions & Factors Inf Health Status Total Jul 15 - Mar 16 # Total Paid Members TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 14 Inpatient Facility # of Admits # of Patient Days Paid per Admit Paid per Day Admits / 1,000 Days / 1,000 Average LOS Physician Utilization Summary (p. 1 of 2) Office Visit Utilization Office Visit Paid / Visit Office Visit Paid / Member DX&L Utilization DX&L Paid / Visit DX&L Paid / Member All Combined All Combined All Combined Groups Groups Groups 3Q PY16 3Q PY15 3Q PY14 1,610 1,469 1,410 7,773 7,060 6,628 $17,386 $18,238 $13,169 $3,601 $3,795 $2,802 55 54 55 267 262 260 4.8 4.8 4.7 3.1 $34 $105 7.5 $62 $462 3.1 $31 $98 7.5 $59 $443 3.3 $28 $91 7.9 $53 $419 4,591 747 0.16 158 $1,886 0.16 4,008 656 0.15 149 $1,797 0.16 3,876 656 0.15 152 $1,479 0.17 annualized annualized annualized PY16 to PY15 Variance 9.6 % 10.1 % (4.7)% (5.1)% 1.9 % 1.9 % 0.5 % 0.0 9.7 7.1 0.0 5.1 4.3 % % % % % % State Active 3Q PY16 1,192 5,059 $15,597 $3,675 48 204 4.2 State Active 3Q PY15 1,039 4,617 $16,072 $3,617 46 202 4.4 State Active 3Q PY14 991 4,047 $11,724 $2,874 47 192 4.1 PY16 to PY15 Variance 14.7 % 9.6 % (3.0)% 1.6 % 4.3 % 1.0 % (4.5)% Non-State Active 3Q PY16 0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0.0 Non-State Active 3Q PY15 0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0.0 Non-State Active 3Q PY14 1 2 $74,966 $37,483 112 224 2.0 PY16 to PY15 Variance 0.0 % 0.0 % 0.0 % 0.0 % 0.0 % 0.0 % 0.0 % 2.8 $32 $88 6.8 $56 $381 2.8 $29 $82 6.7 $55 $369 2.9 $26 $74 6.8 $49 $334 0.0 % 10.3 % 7.3 % 1.5 % 1.8 % 3.3 % 4.5 $34 $156 12.2 $71 $867 2.9 $13 $39 0.0 $0 $0 5.4 $32 $171 4.8 $49 $235 55.2 % 161.5 % 300.0 % 0.0 % 0.0 % 0.0 % 3,709 516 0.15 150 $1,802 0.14 3,117 404 0.14 137 $1,794 0.13 2,903 424 0.14 138 $1,405 0.15 19.0 % 27.7 % 7.1 % 9.5 % 0.4 % 7.7 % 2 0 0.39 393 $2,140 0.00 0 0 0.00 0 $0 0.00 0 0 0.00 0 $0 0.00 annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized Emergency Room *DX&L=Diagnostic, Xray, & Lab Number of Visits Number of Admits Visits/Member Visits / 1,000 Avg Paid per Visit Admits per Visit Jul 15 - Mar 16 14.5 % 13.9 % 6.7 % 6.0 % 5.0 % 1.7 % TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 % % % % % % 15 Inpatient Facility # of Admits # of Patient Days Paid per Admit Paid per Day Admits / 1,000 Days / 1,000 Average LOS Physician Utilization Summary (p. 2 of 2) Office Visit Utilization Office Visit Paid / Visit Office Visit Paid / Member DX&L Utilization DX&L Paid / Visit DX&L Paid / Member State Retirees 3Q PY16 302 1,895 $23,364 $3,723 91 572 6.3 State Retirees 3Q PY15 320 1,802 $23,360 $4,148 102 574 5.6 State Retirees 3Q PY14 264 1,549 $16,372 $2,790 87 511 5.9 PY16 to PY15 Variance (5.6)% 5.2 % 0.0 % (10.2)% (10.8)% (0.3)% 12.5 % Non-State Retirees 3Q PY16 116 819 $20,208 $2,862 122 859 7.1 Non-State Retirees 3Q PY15 110 641 $23,804 $4,085 107 626 5.8 Non-State Retirees 3Q PY14 154 1,030 $16,578 $2,479 113 758 6.7 PY16 to PY15 Variance 5.5 % 27.8 % (15.1)% (29.9)% 14.0 % 37.2 % 22.4 % 4.7 $42 $198 10.9 $79 $859 4.5 $39 $178 10.8 $73 $791 4.8 $34 $164 11.7 $64 $755 4.4 % 7.7 % 11.2 % 0.9 % 8.2 % 8.6 % 5.8 $34 $199 14.1 $83 $1,171 5.8 $34 $198 14.6 $71 $1,035 6.0 $30 $181 16.5 $59 $967 0.0 % 0.0 % 0.5 % (3.4)% 16.9 % 13.1 % 3.4 $52 $177 8.6 $66 $568 681 180 0.21 206 $2,418 0.26 658 193 0.21 210 $1,804 0.29 665 155 0.22 219 $1,560 0.23 3.5 % (6.7)% 0.0 % (1.9)% 34.0 % (10.3)% 199 51 0.21 209 $1,646 0.26 233 59 0.23 228 $1,820 0.25 308 77 0.23 227 $2,001 0.25 (14.6)% (13.6)% (8.7)% (8.3)% (9.6)% 4.0 % 0.18 181 $1,514 0.16 annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized annualized HSB Peer Index $17,993 $3,960 60 273 4.5 Emergency Room *DX&L=Diagnostic, Xray, & Lab Number of Visits Number of Admits Visits/Member Visits / 1,000 Avg Paid per Visit Admits per Visit Jul 15 - Mar 16 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 16 Provider Network Summary In Network Discounts 61.5% •Average in Network Discount 3Q PY16 67.0% 66.7% 3Q PY15 3Q PY14 62.7% •In Network Utilization 61.5% 60.8% 95.9% 59.1% 59.0% 61.3% 59.6% 59.2% 57.4% 56.8% Network Utilization 100% 4.1% 6.2% 7.4% 95.9% 93.8% 92.6% Inpatient Facility Outpatient Facility Physician Combined 80% 60% 40% PEBP PY16 Additional Savings Total Savings Description 20% Non-Network Negotiations Subrogation 0% 3Q PY16 3Q PY15 In Network Jul 15 - Mar 16 OON 3Q PY14 Transplant Savings Total Savings 1Q 2Q 3Q PY16 $1,038,054 $638,577 $926,568 $2,603,198 $95,509 $124,174 $114,860 $334,542 $548,032 $1,681,595 $13,367 $776,118 TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS $4,337 $565,737 $1,045,765 $3,503,478 17 AHRQ* Clinical Classifications Summary AHRQ Clinical Classifications Chapter *Developed at the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), the Clinical Classifications Software (CCS) is a tool for clustering patient diagnoses and procedures into a manageable number of clinically meaningful categories. Total Paid % Paid Neoplasms $11,542,255 Diseases Of The Musculoskeletal System And Connective Tissue $11,462,254 Diseases Of The Circulatory System $8,260,269 Injury And Poisoning $8,053,330 Symptoms; Signs; And Ill-Defined Conditions And Factors Influencing Health Status $7,935,045 Diseases Of The Nervous System And Sense Organs $6,915,183 Diseases Of The Digestive System $5,193,772 Diseases Of The Genitourinary System $5,172,557 Diseases Of The Respiratory System $3,976,448 Endocrine; Nutritional; And Metabolic Diseases And Immunity Disorders $3,594,180 Infectious And Parasitic Diseases $2,914,127 Mental Illness $2,900,742 Complications Of Pregnancy; Childbirth; And The Puerperium $2,660,004 Certain Conditions Originating In The Perinatal Period $2,197,805 Diseases Of The Skin And Subcutaneous Tissue $1,526,711 Residual Codes; Unclassified; All E Codes [259. And 260.] $1,355,795 Diseases Of The Blood And Blood-Forming Organs $661,905 Congenital Anomalies $542,169 Total $86,864,551 13.3% 13.2% 9.5% 9.3% 9.1% 8.0% 6.0% 6.0% 4.6% 4.1% 3.4% 3.3% 3.1% 2.5% 1.8% 1.6% 0.8% 0.6% 100.0% Insured Spouse Child $9,555,081 $1,528,349 $458,826 $8,306,683 $2,494,066 $661,506 $6,852,471 $1,274,241 $133,558 $5,622,919 $1,278,190 $1,152,221 $5,304,074 $1,195,139 $1,435,831 $4,461,153 $969,716 $1,484,314 $3,675,158 $761,998 $756,616 $3,976,156 $822,993 $373,407 $2,734,075 $506,651 $735,722 $2,775,661 $542,249 $276,269 $1,655,563 $383,800 $874,764 $1,404,406 $408,640 $1,087,696 $1,407,953 $1,077,890 $174,161 $3,369 $2,808 $2,191,627 $1,140,084 $288,349 $98,278 $909,931 $376,592 $69,272 $396,979 $124,747 $140,179 $83,807 $113,333 $345,029 $60,265,523 $14,149,752 $12,449,276 Male Female $4,424,660 $7,117,595 $3,976,863 $7,485,392 $5,537,244 $2,723,026 $3,378,252 $4,675,078 $2,855,851 $5,079,194 $2,865,206 $4,049,976 $2,421,039 $2,772,733 $2,905,268 $2,267,289 $1,812,847 $2,163,602 $1,875,670 $1,718,510 $1,538,222 $1,375,905 $1,471,229 $1,429,513 $24,130 $2,635,875 $811,519 $1,386,285 $457,825 $1,068,886 $800,900 $554,896 $241,126 $420,779 $354,199 $187,969 $37,752,048 $49,112,503 Top 10 Categories by Claim Type Endocrine; Nutritional; And Metabolic Diseases And Immunity Disorders 18.80% Diseases Of The Respiratory System Diseases Of The Genitourinary System 34.80% 17.30% 12.10% Diseases Of The Circulatory System 39.90% Diseases Of The Musculoskeletal System And Connective Tissue Jul 15 - Mar 16 40.90% 17.30% OP as % of CCS Physician as % of CCS 13.50% 33.10% 34.60% 34.50% 4.30% 10.40% 36.20% 41.40% IP as % of CCS 4.00% 7.70% 3.80% 2.30% 34.80% Injury And Poisoning Neoplasms 5.00% 62.50% 31.30% Diseases Of The Nervous System And Sense Organs 6.80% 27.60% 13.30% Diseases Of The Digestive System Symptoms; Signs; And Ill-Defined Conditions And Factors Influencing Health Status 20.50% 27.50% 42.10% 4.80% 3.20% 3.40% 1.40% 7.80% 5.90% 4.50% 14.00% 15.60% 1.80% 0.80% Other as % of CCS TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 18 AHRQ Category – Neoplasms Diagnosis Category Maintenance Chemotherapy; Radiotherapy Cancer Of Breast Benign Neoplasms Secondary Malignancies Cancer; Other Primary Other Gastrointestinal Cancer Colorectal Cancer Cancer Of Bronchus; Lung Cancer Of Lymphatic And Hematopoietic Tissue Cancer Of Skin Cancer Of Male Genital Organs Neoplasms Of Unspecified Nature Or Uncertain Behavior Cancer Of Urinary Organs Cancer Of Uterus And Cervix Malignant Neoplasm Without Specification Of Site Cancer Of Ovary And Other Female Genital Organs Overall Patients 85 285 1,980 79 180 42 74 41 101 552 154 1,548 65 256 29 43 5,514 % of Patients 1.54% 5.17% 35.91% 1.43% 3.26% 0.76% 1.34% 0.74% 1.83% 10.01% 2.79% 28.07% 1.18% 4.64% 0.53% 0.78% ---- Claims % Claims Total Paid % Paid 481 2,996 4,064 581 1,173 743 1,023 705 1,162 1,702 1,145 2,956 506 777 149 305 20,468 17.9% 16.9% 9.4% 7.1% 6.6% 6.0% 5.7% 5.7% 5.7% 5.4% 5.4% 2.8% 2.1% 1.5% 1.0% 0.8% 100.0% Relationship Insured 0-17 2.9% 18-26 4.6% 75.5% 50-59 14.4% 27.9% 6.1% 60+ Jul 15 - Mar 16 11.4% 18.4% 40-49 Child $2,066,873 $1,954,986 $1,080,303 $814,089 $766,447 $695,878 $659,131 $655,372 $652,743 $624,946 $619,955 $325,930 $241,375 $174,184 $112,444 $97,600 $11,542,255 Age Range 27-39 Spouse 2.35% 14.64% 19.86% 2.84% 5.73% 3.63% 5.00% 3.44% 5.68% 8.32% 5.59% 14.44% 2.47% 3.80% 0.73% 1.49% ---- 38.9% TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 19 AHRQ Category – Disease of the Musculoskeletal System/Connective Tissue Diagnosis Category Spondylosis; Intervertebral Disc Disorders; Other Back Problems Non-Traumatic Joint Disorders Osteoarthritis Other Connective Tissue Disease Other Back Problems Intervertebral Disc Disorders Other Bone Disease And Musculoskeletal Deformities Other Non-Traumatic Joint Disorders Spondylosis And Allied Disorders Infective Arthritis & Osteomyelitis (Except That Caused By Tb Or Std) Acquired Deformities Other Acquired Deformities Systemic Lupus Erythematosus And Connective Tissue Disorders Rheumatoid Arthritis And Related Disease Acquired Foot Deformities Pathological Fracture Osteoporosis Overall Patients 2,274 2,169 646 3,424 1,905 652 1,985 1,799 350 49 328 109 99 136 173 53 225 16,376 % of Patients 13.89% 13.24% 3.94% 20.91% 11.63% 3.98% 12.12% 10.99% 2.14% 0.30% 2.00% 0.67% 0.60% 0.83% 1.06% 0.32% 1.37% ---- Relationship Insured 69.0% 17.6% 0-17 27-39 40-49 Child 13.4% 50-59 60+ Jul 15 - Mar 16 % Paid 10,705 9,639 1,983 10,866 8,099 2,094 9,301 7,873 1,005 442 764 272 405 393 400 128 439 64,808 19.5% 18.1% 12.8% 11.3% 9.2% 7.9% 5.8% 3.6% 3.1% 2.5% 2.0% 1.2% 0.8% 0.7% 0.7% 0.5% 0.3% 100.0% 16.52% 14.87% 3.06% 16.77% 12.50% 3.23% 14.35% 12.15% 1.55% 0.68% 1.18% 0.42% 0.62% 0.61% 0.62% 0.20% 0.68% ---- $2,239,841 $2,076,723 $1,465,575 $1,291,931 $1,059,679 $901,921 $660,849 $410,523 $355,368 $284,132 $231,109 $140,010 $97,251 $75,929 $75,140 $59,714 $36,557 $11,462,254 Age Range 18-26 Spouse Claims % Claims Total Paid 8.1% 6.9% 12.9% 16.8% 24.8% 30.6% TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 20 AHRQ Category – Diseases of the Circulatory System Diagnosis Category Diseases Of The Heart Cardiac Dysrhythmias Coronary Atherosclerosis And Other Heart Disease Nonspecific Chest Pain Aortic; Peripheral; And Visceral Artery Aneurysms Acute Myocardial Infarction Cerebrovascular Disease Congestive Heart Failure; Nonhypertensive Hypertension Diseases Of Arteries; Arterioles; And Capillaries Diseases Of Veins And Lymphatics Acute Cerebrovascular Disease Heart Valve Disorders Peri-; Endo-; And Myocarditis; Cardiomyopathy (Except Caused By Tb/Std) Pulmonary Heart Disease Peripheral And Visceral Atherosclerosis Essential Hypertension Other Circulatory Disease Conduction Disorders Other Diseases Of Veins And Lymphatics Other And Ill-Defined Cerebrovascular Disease Varicose Veins Of Lower Extremity Hypertension With Complications And Secondary Hypertension Occlusion Or Stenosis Of Precerebral Arteries Phlebitis; Thrombophlebitis And Thromboembolism Hemorrhoids Cardiac Arrest And Ventricular Fibrillation Transient Cerebral Ischemia Other And Ill-Defined Heart Disease Late Effects Of Cerebrovascular Disease Aortic And Peripheral Arterial Embolism Or Thrombosis Overall Jul 15 - Mar 16 Patients 1,866 563 293 740 40 28 205 75 2,130 386 321 80 305 67 72 76 1,766 360 112 63 32 64 92 82 102 82 16 42 103 26 9 10,198 % of Patients 18.30% 5.52% 2.87% 7.26% 0.39% 0.27% 2.01% 0.74% 20.89% 3.79% 3.15% 0.78% 2.99% 0.66% 0.71% 0.75% 17.32% 3.53% 1.10% 0.62% 0.31% 0.63% 0.90% 0.80% 1.00% 0.80% 0.16% 0.41% 1.01% 0.25% 0.09% ---- Claims % Claims Total Paid % Paid 6,653 1,778 834 1,760 106 138 630 310 3,819 695 842 382 554 166 386 179 3,168 606 223 155 67 168 214 139 371 134 45 85 133 73 26 24,839 26.78% 7.16% 3.36% 7.09% 0.43% 0.56% 2.54% 1.25% 15.38% 2.80% 3.39% 1.54% 2.23% 0.67% 1.55% 0.72% 12.75% 2.44% 0.90% 0.62% 0.27% 0.68% 0.86% 0.56% 1.49% 0.54% 0.18% 0.34% 0.54% 0.29% 0.10% ---- $2,719,235 $874,258 $739,045 $574,558 $457,309 $448,031 $276,009 $268,059 $226,425 $183,379 $159,087 $157,826 $151,601 $147,771 $143,382 $112,404 $104,683 $89,609 $77,336 $48,979 $47,028 $46,660 $37,787 $35,547 $31,059 $25,047 $21,534 $21,378 $20,744 $11,242 $3,258 $8,260,269 32.9% 10.6% 8.9% 7.0% 5.5% 5.4% 3.3% 3.2% 2.7% 2.2% 1.9% 1.9% 1.8% 1.8% 1.7% 1.4% 1.3% 1.1% 0.9% 0.6% 0.6% 0.6% 0.5% 0.4% 0.4% 0.3% 0.3% 0.3% 0.3% 0.1% 0.0% 100.0% Relationship Insured Spouse Child 75.1% 19.2% 5.7% Age Range 0-17 3.1% 18-26 3.6% 27-39 8.2% 40-49 50-59 14.4% 27.2% 60+ TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 43.6% 21 Emergency Room / Urgent Care Summary 2Q PY16 2Q PY15 HSB Peer Index ER/Hospital ER/Hospital ER/Hospital Physician UC Physician UC Physician UC UC UC UC ER/Urgent Care Number of Visits 4,591 7,377 4,008 5,836 Number of Admits 747 0 656 0 Visits Per Member 0.16 0.25 0.15 0.22 Visits/1000 Members Avg Paid Per Visit 0.18 0.20 158 254 149 216 181 200 $1,886 $44 $1,796 $29 $1,514 $73 0.16 0.00 Admits per Visit 0.16 0.00 0.16 0.00 Total Plan Paid $8,658,685 $327,209 $7,197,365 $167,989 annualized annualized annualized annualized ER / UC Visits by Relationship ER / Hospital Urgent Care Per 1,000 Physician Urgent Care Per 1,000 Total Per 1,000 Insured 2,602 120 4,261 197 6,863 317 Spouse 680 139 902 185 1,582 324 1,309 4,591 107 118 2,214 7,377 181 190 3,523 11,968 288 309 Relationship % of Paid Insured, 61.0% Spouse, Child, 18.5% 20.5% Child Total Visits by Day of Week 1290 1400 1131 1200 1000 800 1084 1063 1032 929 848 680 721 Sunday Monday 625 672 607 614 672 600 400 200 0 Tuesday Wednesday ER / Hospital UC Jul 15 - Mar 16 Thursday Friday Saturday Physician UC TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 22 Savings Summary – Medical Claims Dollars PPPM % of Eligible $309,818,366 $1,592 100.0% COB $7,299,211 $37 2.4% Medicare $17,512,985 $90 5.7% Excess/Maximums $3,795,589 $19 1.2% $165,669,451 $851 53.5% $19,609,437 $101 6.3% Description Eligible Charges PPO Discount Deductible Coinsurance $9,067,143 $47 2.9% Total Participant Paid $28,676,579 $147 9.3% Total Plan Paid $86,864,551 $446 28.0% Total Participant Paid - PY15 Total Plan Paid - PY15 2.4% $154 $476 5.7% 1.2% 28.0% 2.9% 6.3% COB Excess/Maximums Deductible Total Plan Paid Jul 15 - Mar 16 24.8% 53.5% Medicare PPO Discount Coinsurance 75.2% Total Participant Paid Total Plan Paid TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 23 Dental Claims Analysis Cost Distribution Paid Claims Category Avg # of Members % of Members Total Paid % of Paid Total EE Paid % of EE Paid $1,000.01 Plus 4,587 7.2% $6,787,216 39.0% $4,367,946 51.6% $750.01-$1,000.00 2,058 3.2% $1,834,134 10.5% $1,025,911 12.1% $500.01-$750.00 3,410 5.4% $2,153,998 12.4% $1,158,281 13.7% $250.01-$500.00 9,900 15.6% $3,447,862 19.8% $1,022,452 12.1% $0.01-$250.00 20,900 32.8% $3,189,894 18.3% $869,119 10.3% $0.00 452 0.7% $0 0.0% $28,104 0.3% No Claims 22,323 35.1% $0 0.0% $0 0.0% TOTAL 63,629 100.0% $17,413,103 100.0% $8,471,813 100.0% Total Paid $7,154,675 $5,186,585 $3,840,689 $1,231,154 $17,413,103 % of Paid 41.1% 29.8% 22.1% 7.1% 100.0% Category Preventive Basic Major Periodontal Total Network Performance 100% 80% 6.0% 6.3% 22.9% 7.1% 20.5% 19.0% 60% 40% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 94.0% 93.7% 92.9% 20% 10.0% 5.0% 0% 29.8% 41.1% 22.1% 7.1% 0.0% 3Q PY16 3Q PY15 In Network OON 3Q PY14 Avg Discount Total Number of Claims = 107,373 Jul 15 - Mar 16 % of Paid 0% 20% Preventive 40% Basic 60% Major TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 80% 100% Periodontal 24 Savings Summary – Dental Claims Dollars PPPM % of Eligible $36,207,640 $63 100.0% $115,896 $0 0.3% Excess/Maximums $2,843,532 $5 7.9% PPO Discount $7,363,296 $13 20.3% Deductible $2,322,983 $4 6.4% Coinsurance $6,148,830 $11 17.0% Total Participant Paid $8,471,813 $15 23.4% Total Plan Paid $17,413,103 $30 48.1% Description Eligible Charges COB Total Participant Paid - PY15 Total Plan Paid - PY15 0.3% $22 $44 7.9% 20.3% 32.7% 48.1% 67.3% 6.4% 17.0% COB PPO Discount Coinsurance Jul 15 - Mar 16 Excess/Maximums Deductible Total Plan Paid Total Participant Paid Total Plan Paid TOTAL HEALTH MANAGEMENT by HEALTHSCOPE BENEFITS 25 Prescription Drug Utilization PY 2016 Compared to PY2015 PY 2016 PY 2015 7/1/2015 - 3/1/2016 7/1/2014 - 3/1/2015 Membership Summary Member Count 46,418 43,221 Utilizing Member Count 12,326 12,137 Percent Utilizing 26.6% 28.1% 265,848 255,583 0.64 0.66 4,611 4,639 221,807 208,542 2,539 5,288 83.4% 98.87% 81.6% 97.53% Mail Order Claims 4,127 4,018 Mail Order % of Total Claims 1.6% 1.6% Claims Cost Summary Total Prescription Cost $27,134,407.56 $25,802,839.86 Total Ingredient Cost $26,735,482.66 $25,375,391.66 Total Dispensing Fee $301,165.80 $322,102.12 Total Other (e.g. tax) $4,304.35 $2,781.29 Total Incentive Fee $86,275.98 $102,564.79 Avg Total Cost per Claim $102.07 $100.96 Avg Total Cost for Brand $486.36 $461.00 Avg Total Cost for Generic $29.93 $31.00 Claim Summary Net Claims (Mail/Retail) Claims per Elig Member per Month Total Claims for Brand Total Claims for Generic Total Claims for Brand w/Gen Equiv Generic % of Total Claims Generic Effective Rate 26 26 Prescription Drug Utilization PY 2016 Compared to PY2015 PY 2016 PY 2015 7/1/2015 - 3/1/2016 7/1/2014 - 3/1/2015 Member Cost Summary Total Copay Avg Copay per Claim $9,166,843.86 $8,523,332.15 $34.48 $33.35 Avg Copay for Brand $132.31 $112.00 Avg Copay for Generic $16.97 $18.00 Avg Copay for Brand w/Gen Equiv $34.33 $72.00 Copay % of Total Prescription Cost 33.8% 33.0% $17,967,563.60 $17,279,507.59 $9,908,955.41 $9,437,592.31 $8,058,608.19 $7,841,915.28 Avg Plan Cost per Claim $67.59 $67.61 Avg Plan Cost for Brand $354.05 $349.00 Avg Plan Cost for Generic $12.96 $13.00 Net PMPM PMPM for Specialty Only $43.01 $44.42 $23.72 $24.26 PMPM without Specialty $19.29 $20.16 Plan Cost Summary Total Plan Cost Total Specialty Drug Cost Total Non-Speciality Cost 27 26 11.2.2. 11. Consent Agenda (Leo Drozdoff, Chair) (All Items for Possible Action) Consent items will be considered together and acted on in one motion unless an item is removed to be considered separately by the Board. 11.2. Receipt of quarterly staff reports for the period ending March 31, 2016: 11.2.2. PEBP Operations Officer Report STATE OF NEVADA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES’ BENEFITS PROGRAM 901 S. Stewart Street, Suite 1001 Carson City, Nevada 89701 Telephone (775) 684-7000 · (800) 326-5496 BRIAN SANDOVAL Governor Fax (775) 684-7028 www.pebp.state.nv.us DAMON HAYCOCK LEO M. DROZDOFF, P.E. Executive Officer Board Chairman AGENDA ITEM X Action Item Information Only Date: July 21, 2016 Item Number: 11.2.2. Title: Operations Report for period ending March 31, 2016 SUMMARY This report provides a summary of PEBP operations through the period ending March 31, 2016. REPORT PROGRAM UPDATES Towers Watson OneExchange: Due to the disproportionate percentage of participant issues and complaints, PEBP took a more active role in the complaint and resolution process with our Medicare Exchange participants. Traditionally, participants who called PEBP were immediately referred to Towers Watson and only escalated issues were assigned to and researched by PEBP staff. This led to a rather high amount of issues on the Issue Log. In an effort to mitigate some of these issues, the Member Services Unit (MSU) began assisting participants at the front end by providing those with known issues an additional level of customer service by coordinating with the participant and Towers Watson to ensure swift resolution. The added time spent by PEBP MSU staff did affect the overall call statistics, however, the added value in customer service resulted in a fewer number of issues that had to be researched by other staff, therefore reducing the resolution time for the participant. In March, Board Chair, Leo Drozdoff, Executive Officer, Damon Haycock and Operations Officer, Laura Rich traveled to Sandy, Utah and met with Towers Watson One Exchange staff to discuss and develop possible strategies for improvement. Towers Watson agreed to develop a plan of action and present this plan to the Board. Operations Officer Report July 21, 2016 Page 2 Wellness: PEBP reached out to both the UNR and UNLV Schools of Medicine to propose a pilot program where we can leverage resources and provide an opportunity to push a no cost wellness incentive surrounding the registered dietician programs and nutrition counseling. The program is still in the early planning stages, and we have had very successful discussions with UNR. UNR is eager to explore these opportunities and will be coming back to PEBP with initial findings so we can proceed. Additionally, we have assigned a staff member to enhance our wellness program as a whole. With the launch of our new website, he will be adding a robust wellness piece. He will be augmenting the calendar to include wellness events and coordinating with other agencies and organizations to ensure we can bring a focus back to current wellness benefits and opportunities with PEBP. ELIGIBILITY In February, PEBP implemented an upgrade to the eligibility system and successfully transitioned onto a new platform. All PEBP staff received extensive training over a 3-day period. As is common in all IT projects, there were some bumps along the way which did temporarily affect operations in both Eligibility and MSU, however the majority of the issues were able to be resolved timely. The Eligibility Unit was the most affected by these changes, therefore the staff in that unit endured the additional burden of the issues and process changes resulting from the new system. The staff coordinated heavily with the vendor to ensure most fixes were in place prior to the beginning of open enrollment. MEMBER SERVICES UNIT (MSU) MSU experienced significant turnover at the end of 2015. Three of the nine staff were promoted within or to other agencies, which left MSU short staffed for several months until MSU was able to hire and train staff. By the time MSU was again fully staffed and properly trained, PEBP transitioned to an upgraded eligibility system which required all staff to re-learn the end-user interface. As mentioned above, the volume of complaints and issues stemming from our Medicare Exchange participants prompted PEBP to re-evaluate how MSU addressed customer service for Exchange participants. In general, PEBP has received positive feedback from participants on the advocacy provided by both MSU and Complaints and Appeals staff. MSU has also experienced a surge of email and walk-ins. Typically MSU staff has been able to accommodate walk-ins and respond to emails in a timely matter, however, given the rise in both, PEBP has pulled staff from other units to provide additional support. If these trends continue, MSU will have to reassess staffing, processes and scheduling to ensure the needs of participants are being appropriately met. The table below reflects PY 15 and PY 16 MSU call center activities: Operations Officer Report July 21, 2016 Page 3 PLAN YEAR 15 PLAN YEAR 16 JulSep 2014 OctDec 2014 JanMar 2015 AprJun 2015 JulSep 2015 OctDec 2015 JanMar 2016 AprJun 2016 62 85 396 74 179 422 398 81 71 64 18 99 21 69 52 72 9,967 8,506 12,193 11,062 9,790 9,253 10,038 11,155 1,322 N/A N/A 4,983 1,421 N/A N/A 3,139 11,422 8,655 12,607 16,218 11,411 9,744 10,488 14,447 PEBP Average # of Calls Answered Per Day 112 96 140 125 111 108 117 126 PEBP Abandonment Rate 0.61% 0.98% 3.14% 0.66% 1.79% 4.33% 3.79% 0.72% PEBP Average Call Duration (minutes) 0:04:38 0:05:12 0:04:33 0:04:56 0:04:24 0:04:10 0:04:20 0:04:27 PEBP Abandoned Calls PEBP Voice Mail Calls PEBP Answered Calls Morneau Total Rollover Calls PEBP Total Incoming Calls PEBP Average Speed to Answer (seconds) PEBP Total Walk-ins PEBP Average # of Walk-ins Per Day PEBP Total Emails 0:00:13 0:00:16 0:00:30 0:00:12 0:00:20 0:00:43 0:00:39 0:00:13 404 383 124 146 164 419 427 467 4.5 N/A 4.3 N/A 1.4 985 1.6 1,144 1.8 871 4.7 2,027 4.7 2,057 5.2 3,521 CONCLUSION PEBP is constantly assessing the operational component of programs, eligibility, enrollment, and customer service. As participants utilize different methods to seek help, we adjust as timely and appropriately as possible to provide the highest level of service. Challenges exist with our Medicare Exchange vendor, a new system upgrade, and periodic turnover, however PEBP will continue to meet these challenges head on and create dynamic solutions moving forward.