the Doo Wop Guidebook
Transcription
the Doo Wop Guidebook
wop doo How to Y Wildwoods-by-the-Sea Handbook of Design Guidelines 1 2 3 doowop How to Wildwoods-by-the-Sea Handbook of Design Guidelines A project of The Doo Wop Preservation League PREPARED BY Michael Lorin Hirsch Richard Stokes AIA Anthony Bracali, RA EDITING & DESIGN Jack Wright BOARD OF TRUSTEES Dan MacElrevey, Jack Morey, R. Michael Zuckerman, PhD, Elan Zingman-Leith, Paul Russo, Charles Schumann, Clark Doran, PP Jay Ford, Mary Fox, MAI Thomas P. Byrne, AAI, Joseph Salerno, Dennis Anderson, Arlieen Franco, Randy Hentges, Lou Ferrara, Bill Huf, Richard Stokes, AIA, John Donio ADVISORY BOARD Michael Hirsch, Michael D’Angelo, Joanne Galloway, Joanne Duffy, Andrew Cripps, Alex Shear, Todd Kieninger, Kirk Hastings HONORARY MEMBERS Steven Izenour, AIA (1940-2001) Dan Vieyra, AIA, Dr. J. Salvatore, Dane Wells, CHA, Alan Hess Partially funded by The Byrne Fund for the Wildwoods, Inc., a philanthropic fund tasked to enhance art, culture and educational opportunities for residents of The Wildwoods. 4 5 Contents 1. Why Does Doo Wop Matter?...... P8 Introduction P10 Task List P14 Doo Wop District Map P16 2. The Doo Wop Vision ................P18 General Design Principles For All Projects P27 Design Standards For Rehabilitation P28 Design Standards For New Construction P28 General Standards For New Construction P28 3. A Brief Architectural History ....P30 4. Site Design ............................ P 34 Views P36 Site Planning P36 Parking P37 Site Lighting P40 Landscaping P40 5. Rehabilitation Of Contributing Structures In the Wildwoods .......P42 Appropriateness Of Use P44 Preservation Of Significant Historial Qualities P44 New Systems & Code Compliance In Historic Buildings P47 Types Of Work P49 Concept Of Character In The District P54 The Miami Experience P56 A Miami Case Study P60 A Concept For The Satellite Motel P62 7. How To Doo Wop ......................P64 Site Organization P66 Building Massing P70 Human Scale P72 Features Of The Facade P73 Doors & Windows P75 Railings P79 Roof Forms P80 Signage P80 Typrography P81 Materials & Colors P86 Pools & Landscaping P91 8. Condos With Attitude ..............P94 9. Doo Wop On The Cheap ............P104 10. The 10 Commandments For Creating A Doo Wop Motel ...........P106 11. Plants & Flowers ....................P108 12. Glossary ..............................P110 Resources .................................P114 6. New Construction In Historic Districts........................P52 Designing In Context P54 The LEFT: Wildwood’s boardwalk by night. Photo by Julie Marquart COVER: An imaginery Wildwoods coastline. Illustration by Anthony Bracali 6 7 PART one Why does Doo Wop matter? 8 9 T HE America of the 1950s and early 60s was an optmistic, confident, forward-looking society. After the Second World War, America had grown into an economic colossus, and its people, particularly the emerging middle class, were enjoying greater wealth and more leisure time than ever before. Television overtook radio as the biggest influence on the culture, and TV began broadcasting ads for a device that would transform society: the production line automobile. At the same time, the Garden State Parkway, a concept nearly 50 years in the making, was finally completed in 1955, linking South Jersey to the metropolises of Philadelphia and New York (from where vacationers had previously endured six-hour trips to the Shore). As a result, hundreds of thousands of new tourists, breathing in the smell of leather in their brandnew cars, and eager to broaden their horizons, made the trip to Cape May County and, in particular, the Wildwoods, where entrepreneurs like Will and Lou Morey had begun a building boom, constructing quirky motels, festooned with plastic palm trees and gaudy neon signs, inspired by their trips to the neon fantasyland of Miami Beach. “Forty years ago, the Wildwoods was the South Jersey mecca for bluecollar workers who had enough extra dollars from the Philadelphia industrial economy to vacation at the shore. The opening of the Garden State Parkway, the ever more casual American society and the rise of the automobile led to the motel revo10 lution that is the enduring artifact of present-day Wildwood,” wrote the architectural historian, George Thomas. The seashore architecture of this era reflected the spirit of the people: brash, bold and boastful. The motels, diners, gas stations, even offices, presented a varied and exaggerated spectacle of designs. Angular elements, space-age imagery, tropical themes and colors, with spectactular signage cranked up the volume even more. With leisure time and money in good supply, the masses wanted to be entertained – and Wildwood accommodated them, with a terrific boardwalk, amusement piers and a variety of nightclubs that became proving grounds for many of the biggest stars of the day. Bill Haley and the Comets first performed Rock Around the Clock here, in 1954; the first episode of Dick Clark’s American Bandstand was was broadcast from Wildwood; and the resort inspired Bobby Rydell’s 1963 Billboard hit, Wildwood Days. Not only that, but the Wildwoods enjoyed a wonderful location, with a beautiful seven-mile stretch of white sandy beaches. It was no wonder, then, that it soon became one of America’s premier family seaside resorts. PREVIOUS: The Motel Martinique – a bold and striking sign, by day or night. Photo by Brian McMahon RIGHT: Some of the Wildwoods’ gaudilyeffective neon signage. From the George G. Boyer Historical Museum 11 As Ocean Drive in South Beach, Miami, exemplifies the Art Deco style of the 1930s, Ocean Avenue in Wildwood celebrates the soaring designs and imaginative forms of ’50s architecture. It was a golden age in American history, one that is preserved today in the architecture of the Wildwoods, which, thanks to the continued existence of a magnificent beach and boardwalk, remains a premier family destination. However, strong efforts are needed to ensure that future development on the island does not compromise and ultimately destroy this rich legacy. This is the mission of this book and it publishers, the Doo Wop Preservation League. Our guiding principles are: T T T TO EXPAND public awareness of the Wildwoods’ time capsule of 1950s and 1960s culture. TO COLLABORATE with others to educate the public about the value of this unique resource. TO PROMOTE an environment for the preservation and the rehabiliation of mid-20th century cultural assets. In recent years the League has heped to capture the imagination of the national media, with in-depth articles in publications such as the Los Angeles Times, The New York Times, USA Today, Newsweek, Travel and Leisure and Coastal Living. The Wildwoods contains the biggest concentration of mid-century architecture in America. And like its southern cousin, Cape May, which boasts the greatest 12 collection of Victorian architecture in America, the Wildwoods needs a strong set of preservation principles. But the League also recognizes the need for development, and to incorporate that into the need for preservation. This is where the Wildwoods is unique. Here, preservation also means innovation. While the Doo Wop Preservation League is committed to promoting preservation and awareness of mid-century American architecture, it also actively promotes just the kind of spirit of adventure that helped to capture the imagination of the public half a century ago. Throughout this book are examples of new construction and rehabilitation that perfectly capture the spirit of Doo Wop and which add to the quality of life in the community. This book is aimed at everyone, from major developers of condominiums to small motel owners, homeowners and concerned citizens who care about the wonderful living, breathing museum that is the Wildwoods. The fact is that everyone can play a part, whether it be designing a high-rise condo inspired by the funky shapes and colors of the 50s, erecting a new neon sign on a restaurant, or painting the side of a motel a concoction of pastel colors. In each case, it would be adding to the rich architectural landscape of this wonderful island. We hope that this book is educational and entertaining and, ultimately, we hope it’s inspiring. 13 Y THERE are 275 buildings in the Wildwoods which in September 2003 were recognized by New Jersey’s review board to the state registry of historic places. We anticipate national recognition in the near future. Y THIS development shows that the state of New Jersey identifies the Wildwoods’ Doo Wop (mid-century) architecture as a cultural treasure. Y THE opportunity exists for our historic district to be an important contributor to our community. Y MIAMI Beach, Palm Springs, and Savannah have shown that heritage tourism is growing in popularity with Americans. Y THIS is why Doo Wop is much more than a matter of esthetics – rather, it has the potential to be a major economic catalyst. Illustrations by Anthony Bracali 14 15 The Proposed Doo Wop Historic District 16 THE district is primarily bounded by Atlanta Avenue to the south, Atlantic Avenue to the west, Morning Glory Road to the north and Beach Avenue to the east Illustration by Anthony Bracali 17 D3 D3 The Doo 3 D D Wop Vision 3 D 3 D part two 18 19 20 21 T HE Doo Wop Historic District presents the opportunity to establish a dynamic and exciting community within one of the most popular family resorts on the eastern seaboard. The Wildwoods’ location, proximity to Philadelphia, rich architectural legacy and ample residential base evokes a vision of a special place, full of vitality and imagination. This vision can be achieved through the redevelopment of the community by addressing site and architectural issues and through consistent and complimentary additions to existing buildings. New architecture in the proposed Doo Wop Historic District, and within the community, should be part of a unified composition of buildings and public spaces. New architecture should be based on design principles of form, scale and siting, and made responsive to their setting and environment. Many of the current new buildings are in a Victorian cookiecutter style, meaning that inappropriate designs are seen over and over again. The new image for this district should move towards the future, inspired by the boundless enthusiasm and innovation of postwar, Space Age America. This design framework will allow individual property owners freedom of expression within the personaliLEFT: The Star diner in North Wildwood is a new building with a refined retro look. Photo by Brian McMahon PREVIOUS: The Starlux is a renovation of an existing motel but represents a 21st-century interpretation of the ’50s. Photo by Julie Marquart 22 23 24 25 24 25 The Ebb Tide, Wildwood Crest’s first motel (1952-2003), was notable for walls that angled forward and back, making reference to the ebb and flow of the ocean. PREVIOUS: Restored Airstreams at the Starlux continue the tradition of roadside architecture. Photo by Maciej Nabrdalik ties of their buildings while establishing and maintaining an overall unifying character and image for the entire community. In addition, it is of paramount importance that developers address specific design considerations. These should be derived from the location and surrounding environment, such as respecting views, using state-of-the-art building materials, and reflecting the summer-resort architectural heritage developed in the 1950s. Designing in response to our Doo Wop/Jetsonian (mid-century modern) heritage, adhering to consistent architectural order, and enhancing the public experience will enable The Wildwoods’ Doo Wop Historic District to define its own identity – making it a distinct and special place not just within the context of the Jersey shore, but in coastal resort communities throughout the world. It is our objective to propose the adoption of this handbook to promote a desirable visual environment and to ensure the continued visual integrity of this district in the city/borough. Design guidelines assist architects, builders, real estate agents and those planning to build or purchase property on the island, as well as all residents who wish to maintain and renovate their houses or commercial structures in Eden Roc is unique for its brick face and the first bay of each wing which contains a room that appears to float over the parked cars, an element that could be seen by passing motorists The Oceanic, built in 1955, was one of the first motels to have parking underneath, individual room balconies and interior circulation 26 historic district to ensure continued visual integrity. In a community that contains the largest collection of mid-century modern architecture, we envision new developments that meet the needs of today’s homeowner while continuing to produce great design and signage to compliment a resort that combines natural and man-made pleasures. General Design Principals for All Projects The motels of The Wildwoods were originally designed to celebrate the automobile, allowing views of your car from your room. The buildings were usually situated perpendicu27 lar to the beach, allowing generous views of the Wildwoods’ greatest asset. Rooms were arranged around a central court, containing the pool, which was considered an essential element. While today’s planning principals generally require that the car be hidden, we have much to learn from the siting, scale and thematic decoration of the historic motels. Design Standards for Rehabilitation Many of the motels are in good repair, and it is our goal that many of the existing Doo Wop details – railings and novelty items such as thatched and stepped roofs – be maintained. Many of the historic railings do not meet current building code, but by adding or retrofitting the historic iron rails, it is possible to meet current code issues. The old jalousie or curtain wall systems are often rotting or in need of repair – but, again, there are sensitive ways to upgrade that are complimentary to historic details. Often the historic pools, lobbies, signage and colors are thematic and representative of the Doo Wop movement. This handbook offers solutions to the challenges faced by residents and property owners. Design Standards for New Construction Our vision is that new buildings within the historic district be compatible with the existing motels, in terms of both style and scale. Recent examples such as Wawa, Star Diner and Harley-Davidson show that designs in context make for good neighbors. General Standards for New Construction The architectural portion of these guidelines is intended to provide a unified, conceptual framework using historical Doo Wop references. In order to maintain a unique and inviting seaside resort, design should be generated by location, surrounding environment, building materials, and should reflect the seaside resort heritage. But within this framework, the architectural language of buildings should strive to reinterpret its heritage and look to the future, instead of simply mimicking the past. Classic postcards from postwar Wildwood, when Five Mile Beach really began to take off 28 The Shalimar promoted the kind of escapism Morris Lapidus described (see below) and was typical of the exotic lengths to which Wildwoods motel owners would aspire. In the fall of 2004, the Shalimar was set for an addition and renovation that would bring the motel up to 21stcentury standards, with conference facilities, exercise room, and twostory suites with private roof decks equipped with jacuzzis. Care would be taken to preserve the exotic vibe. “I WAS convinced that just as a store had to be designed to make people want to buy what the merchant had to sell, so a hotel had something to sell also. What was that something? A home away from home? Absolutely not! Who wants a homey feeling on a vacation? The guests want to find a new experience – forget the office, the kids, the bills. Anything but that good old homey feeling that the old hotels used to see with a comfortable bed, a nice rocker on the veranda, a good solid nourishing meal. Not on your life! We were coming out of the war and the postwar period. People wanted fun, excitement, and all of it against a background that was colorful, unexpected; in short, the visual excitement that made people want to buy – in this case, to buy the tropic luxury of a wonderful vacation of fun in the sun. A sense of freedom from the humdrum lives the guests had. A feeling of getting away from it all.” – Morris Lapidus (1902-2001), architect who defined the 1950s Miami Beach resort hotel style 29 ABOVE: The Bauhaus by Walter Gropius (1925) and, right, the Ministry of Education, by Costa and Niemeyer with LeCorbusier ( 1943), are examples of the “serious” architecture that held sway until Morris Lapidus and others introduced fantasy to modernism. A Brief Architectural History part three 30 W ORKING-class and middle-class families had rising expectations in the 1950s. The new motels of the Wildwoods were created by borrowing details from the high-style modern architecture seen by local builders and designers in magazines and often Miami Beach and incorporating them in local structures. The proposed Doo Wop District includes a significant concentration of mid-twentieth century architecture. It contains enough buildings of similar architecture in a concentrated 31 area to create a sense of place and to recall a specific time in American history. These buildings embody the technological/industrial history of the era in two ways. First, they are a new building type closely associated with the postwar boom in automobile ownership. Second, they illustrate the concept of “styling” in industrial design that was a central characteristic of mid-twentieth century marketing and design. The motels also capture the social history of the era by reflecting the upward mobility of working-class and lower middle-class Americans of the time. In order to preserve the historic, architectural and cultural resources that are contained in the Doo Wop District, the buildings should be preserved and restored. Changes to those buildings should be appropriate to their style and significance. Architectural changes to other buildings in the district should be designed not to detract from the sense of place and character of the district. Building design also participated in the shift from “serious” design to “styling”. Ranch houses, restaurants, and especially motels used modern elements to decorate essentially simple boxes. The difference between serious architecture of the period, for which the manipulation of space and light and structure were paramount considerations, and Doo Wop architecture, where modern decorative motifs were added to completely conventional structure – is not the difference between valuable and valueless architecture. It is the difference between the architecture of a stable class structure and the architecture 32 created out of a period of rising standards for a new middle class. There is a close parallel between the Doo Wop and Victorian eras. During the Victorian era, the new white collar workers became middleclass after the industrial revolution of the mid-nineteenth century. Their buildings combined conventional construction with a wide variety of surface ornament to lend style to the structure. Italianate, Gothic, French Second Empire, Eclectic, or Aesthetic Ornament might be added to a conventionally planned and built house to give it style. In the late 1950s and early ’60s, working-class and lower middleclass families wanted new and stylish products. To fill this demand, cars, appliances, split-level houses, and motels were created by grafting symbols of modernism on to conventional structures. Borrowed from art, science, and high-style architecture, the motifs of modernity added a superficial layer of decoration. This superficiality does not make Doo Wop architecture less important than high-style architecture of the period. The Gothic cottages of Cape May are not at all Gothic in plan or structure; the Renaissance cornices are not structural. This doesn’t make them any less valuable. It makes them an important part of the social history of a new class. The Doo Wop motels of Wildwood are not at all modern in plan or structure. The canted walls are not structural. Again, this does not make them any less valuable. It makes them an important part of the social history of a new class. The Marseilles by LeCorbusier, from 1952, exhibits the kind of architecture that was accepted as the standard. BELOW: The Casa Bahama (1962) displays a much more playful approach, but this legacy is every bit as valuable to our architectural heritage. 33 part four Doo Wop Site Design 34 35 U THE design principles in this section apply to all projects: rehabilitation, additions, and new buildings, within the proposed Doo Wop Historic District, adjacent to a building listed on National Registry document, or to anyone interested in building a compatible structure in the Wildwoods. Views DOO BE DO! DOO BE DON’T! These buildings interrupt the rhythm of open space by placing themselves on street edge OVERVIEW DOO BE DO! Historically, buildings in the proposed Doo Wop Historic District were oriented to maximize views of the beach. Taller portions of buildings were set back from the street to allow pedestrians a larger panoramic view of the ocean. Some motel room facades were even angled towards the ocean. DESIGN STANDARDS Planned projects should retain, and reinforce, view corridors to the beach. Buildings should be located perpendicular to the beach, so as to not block views for residents beyond. Parking lots/parking structure design should also be respective of view corridors. Site Planning to respond to the existing pattern of adjacent buildings. Consider building setbacks, orientation and open space, x Overview The general site planning of buildings in the proposed historic district should follow the existing pattern of buildings situated perpendicular to the ocean. DESIGN STANDARDS New construction should be situated 36 These new buildings respect the historic motel by shifting their massing to the rear of the site Historically, buildings were sited to encourage a view of the beach. These scenic views should be respected. DOO BE DON’T! x Respect historic motel siting. This tall building blocks ocean views and breezes. PREVIOUS: Plastic palms, the official tree of Wildwood. Photo by Maciej Nabrdalik all of which are addressed in more detail in the sections that follow. Abrupt changes in scale and character at the boundary edges should be avoided. Parking OVERVIEW Accommodating the automobile was a major consideration in the design of Doo Wop structures. By definition, a motel is a motor hotel. However, the planning of Doo Wop-era building carefully considered both the car and the pedestrian as equals. The balconies, pools, sun decks and hotel lobbies which faced the street provided pedestrians with a vibrant street edge with which to interact. The traditional Doo Wop motel provided parking spaces along the entire perimeter of the site that could be accessed directly from the street. This model is now unacceptable under current Wildwood zoning ordinances. DESIGN STANDARDS The experience of the pedestrian should be enhanced by promoting a walkable community and restoring a safe, pleasant walking environment. Streets lined with garage doors are anti-pedestrian. Ganged driveways to parking are encouraged rather than off-street parking spaces that back on to sidewalks. Provide screening if cars are parked in view of pedestrians. For at-grade parking lots, the following shall apply: *Landscaping shall meet or ex37 DOO BE DO! Carports often act as a screen of cars from prime ocean views x landscaping. *Parking lots associated with commercial uses are encouraged to be located on the side or rear of the main building when such properties are located on streets that have a strong pedestrian orientation. *Parking lots in the proposed Doo Wop Historic District are encouraged , where appropriate, to use the side street as a means of entrance and exit. This facade sends a message, “cars For parking garages and structures, rule”. Where is the front door? the following shall apply: *The ground floor of parking ceed the standards of the Wildwoods’ structures should contain commerMaster Plans, and the Land Use Or- cial uses, with store fronts and archidinance of the appropriate borough/ tectural detailing, so as not to appear city. Parking lots should be screened as a garage on elevations that face a from the street with decorative walls/ north-south avenue. The placement DOO BE DON’T! 38 Partially submerged parking minimizes height of the Pan American and creates a friendlier street feel DOO BE DON’T! x Pull-in parking is not legal under current zoning codes DOO BE DO! Ganged driveway to parking is encouraged – the visual impact of cars is minimized. 39 at night by multicolored and fanciful site and building lighting. Many motels have lighting which compliments their architectural features and makes them even more visible at night. Lighting can used to further a theme, complimenting the signage, or to provide a unique image for a building, such as the Caribbean’s multi-colored recessed lighting, or the Shalimar’s purple lighting. Multi-colored lighting bathes the fascia of the Caribbean and combines with the glowing office and game-room block, and the shimmering pool at the center of the motel of commercial uses depends on the location in the proposed historic district. *Multiple levels of parking structures should be parallel to grade on primary and waterfront elevations. *Stairways and elevators, which are the most commonly vandalized areas of garages, should be glass-enclosed or open and clearly visible to the street or other populated areas. *Ramps, stairwells and any other portion of a garage should be buffered with decorative grilles and screens. *Parking garages within the proposed historic district are encouraged to be located on sites which are nonhistoric and non-contributing. *Locating some space below grade (parking for example) is encouraged to minimize scale of new buildings. Site Lighting OVERVIEW The Wildwoods are transformed 40 DESIGN STANDARDS The style of the light and light standard should be consistent with the architectural style of the principal building. Decorative lighting of landscape features, pool decks and recreation areas is encouraged. Use shielded, indirect light sources for all exterior lighting, and avoid lighting that creates a hazard or nuisance to residential properties. Colored lighting that highlights the buildings’ architectural features, or creates a pattern or rhythm on the facade is encouraged. Exterior lighting proposals must be submitted according to requirements for the borough/city where the project is located. See Signage section – Pages 8089 – for information on neon. Cars are screened in a decorative manner from pedestrian view on a major intersection Historically, decorative screen block was sometimes used to block view of cars from the pool. rapidly, becoming the “official tree” of the area. Natural beach grasses and evergreens are indigenous to the island, require very little watering, and can be used for ornamental plantings, and screening for parking. DESIGN STANDARDS Use landscape schemes that emphasize native plant materials like beach shrubs, dune grasses, plastic palms. Consider evergreen planting to establish wind breaks in the winter. Likewise, deciduous trees will provide shade in summer but allow sun in winter months. Avoid damage to natural resources on the site, including established trees. See Page 108 for more information on plants and flowers. Landscaping OVERVIEW Landscaping can be used to create a resort atmosphere. The plastic palm tree was first introduced to the Wildwoods in the late 1950s, and has since spread The Caribbean is considered to be the first motel to erect plastic palm trees – in 1958 41 part five Rehabilitation of Contributing Structures in the Wildwoods 42 43 U THE design principles in this section apply to all projects: rehabilitation, additions, and new buildings, within the proposed Doo Wop Historic District, adjacent to a building listed on National Registry document, or to anyone interested in building a compatible structure in the Wildwoods. Appropriateness Of Use OVERVIEW Reasonable effort should be made to provide a compatible use for the building that will require minimal alteration to the building and its site. Building use similar to the original use is preferred. A compatible use can be accommodated without radical alteration to the original architecture. For example, a motel could easily become a condominium or dormitory. DESIGN STANDARDS Seek compatible uses for historic buildings. New uses that require minimal change to the existing structures are preferred. When a more radical change in use is necessary to keep the building in active service, then those uses that require the least alteration to significant elements are preferred. It may be that in order to adapt your building to the proposed new use such radical alteration to its significant elements would be PREVIOUS: Classic signage at the Caribbean motel. Photo by Brian McMahon 44 required that the entire concept is inappropriate. Experience has shown, however, that in most cases, designs can be developed that respect the historic integrity to the building while also accommodating new functions. Check the Wildwood or Wildwood Crest Master Plan and Land Use Ordinances to determine which uses are acceptable in the proposed historic district. Cara Mara was converted into a condo-motel with minimal alteration to the exterior. This would be considered a compatible use for an existing building in the Doo Wop Historic District. Preservation Of Significant Historical Qualities OVERVIEW Preserve the original materials and details, as well as distinctive form and scale, that contribute to the historic significance of the structure. Rehabilitation work should not destroy the distinguishing quality or character of the property or its environment. DESIGN STANDARDS Respect the historic design character of the building, whether it be contributing or non-contributing. Minimize intervention with his- Imperial 500 motel was altered but preserved significant original qualities. The building was expanded by adding a fourth floor and an elevator. Photos by Brian McMahon 45 DOO BE DO! should be treated with sensitivity. Refer to the Secretary of Interior’s Standards and Guidelines for Rehabilitation if you intend to rehabilitate a building listed on the National Registry. There are approximately 200 buildings in The Wildwoods that have been submitted. A set of guidelines must be observed in order for a building or property to be eligible for Federal and State tax incentives. New Systems & Code Compliance In Historic Buildings DOO BE DON’T! x Mechanical equipment should be suitably screened from view areas DOO BE DO! OVERVIEW Consider enclosing trash containers with a thematic screen, as shown at the Port Royal hotel toric elements, and preserve historically significant features. Preserve original ornament and detail of the facade. Architectural details add interest to motels and are a part of the unique identity of the buildings. Fascia trim and signage are part of the decorative elements that add to the theme. Where portions of these details have been removed, refer to photographic evidence of the earlier condition. Look for details that may have been removed and stored to use as patterns for new designs. Where exact reconstruction of 46 DOO BE DON’T! x details is not feasible, consider developing a simplified interpretation of the original, in which its major form and line is retained. Distinctive stylistic features or examples of skilled craftsmanship Integrate new mechanical systems into historic buildings with sensitivity by avoiding cutting new louvres into walls and locating mechanical equipment where it can be seen or heard. DESIGN STANDARD Minimize visual impacts of new systems. Especially avoid placing mechanical and electrical equipment on primary, character defining facades. Avoid damaging historic materials in order to insert new mechanical and electrical systems. Screen exterior roof-mounted equipment. Refer to the pertinent Master Plan, which advises to visually screen service equipment, including transformers, or locate them out of public view. Screen or enclose service equipment and trash containers. Integrate enclosures into the design of the building. Use a color scheme or the theme of the motel on screens or partitions to hide trash areas and mechanical equipment. Make the street elevations more attractive and safer for your guests and pedestrians. Mechanical and other equipment may be erected or stored outside of the principal building, but shall be suitably screened from view from parking areas, public rights-of-way and adjacent residential uses. Such equipment must be situated within the property line of the Principal Use. 47 Types of Work THERE are various approaches to rehabilitation, and a successful rehab project may involve a combination of these approaches. Adaptive re-use Converting a building to a new use, different from what it was originally designed to be. A good project retains the historic character, while adapting to the new functions. Preservation The act or process of applying measures to prevent further deterioration of materials on an historic property. It may include features of the site that are important in defining its overall historic character. Work, including preliminary measures to protect and stabilize the property, generally focuses upon the ongoing maintenance and repair of historic materials and features rather than extensive replacement and new construction. Rehabilitation Rehabilitation is the practical compromise of making possible a compatible use for a property through repair, alterations and additions, while preserving those portions or features which convey its historical, cultural, or architectural values. This process remains true to the spirit of the Maureen Restaurant and Martini Bar was previously a nightclub. Photo by Maciej Nabrdalik 48 past without sacrificing utility. The majority of preservation projects in the Doo Wop Historic District may be considered rehabilitation projects. Remodeling To reconstruct or make over a building without historical consciousness is to “remodel.” The appearance is changed by removing original detail and adding new features which are out of character from the original building. A remodeling project is unacceptable in the Doo Wop Historic District, and will be ineligible for Federal or State tax credits for historic preservation. Renovation To make new, or as if new again. The appearance of the building is enhanced. The basic character and significant details are respected and preserved, but sympathetic alterations may also occur. Restoration The act or process of accurately depicting the form, features, and character of a property as it appeared at a particular period of time by means of removing features from other periods in its history and reconstruction of missing features from the restoration period. A successful rehabilitation project in the Doo Wop Crest Historic District may involve a historic structure that includes a combination of preservation, restoration, and other treatments. Reconstruction The act or process of depicting, 49 by means of new construction, the form, features, and detailing of a non-surviving site, landscape, building, structure, or object for the purpose of replicating its appearance at a specific period of time. “It is better to preserve than to repair, better to repair than to restore, better to restore than to reconstruct.” A.N. Didron, Bulletin Archeologique, Vol. 1, 1839. General Rehabilitation Standards GRS are based on the Secretary of Interior’s Standards for Treatment of Historic Buildings. See www. doowopusa.org for more information. The guidelines apply to all rehabilitation projects, including additions, within the proposed Doo Wop Historic District. They apply to all buildings (primarily motels) that are designated as “contributing” as well as “non-contributing” buildings. These guidelines apply specifically to approximately 275 motels identified by the National Register of Historic Places within Five Mile Beach – the Wildwoods – in New Jersey. Contributing Structures that have been judged to add to the historic district’s sense of time, place, and historic development. Those listed on the National Register of Historic Places should be protected. If there is a choice between either restoring or losing an authentic detail it is our hope that a restoration will not lose or distort 50 the spirit, particularly on the exterior. See the Crest Savings Bank canopy (right). No building so deemed or any portion thereof will be approved for destruction unless it is judged to be a public hazard, in which case the building inspector or court must sign the order for demolition. Even then, all reasonable measures to save rather than raze will be the preferred course of action. Non-Contributing Buildings which do not add to a historic district’s sense of time, place and historic development may be called an intrusion. A structure is an intrusion because it lacks compatibility with its surrounding buildings in the historic district. It detracts rather than adds or merely conforms to the scene of which it is part. If a building is not contributing, design alterations should be compatible with neighboring contributing buildings. BEFORE... ...after RIGHT: Crest Savings Bank in downtown Wildwood recently incorporated an abandoned building into its 1908 classic revival building, listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2000. In Cape May, preservation is about a moment frozen in time. In Wildwood, one is able to preserve in the traditional manner, while also showing an appreciation for the dynamic Doo Wop period. A one-of-a-kind bank building for a one-of-a-kind resort. 51 part six New Construction in Historic Districts 52 53 U THESE guidelines apply to all new construction, including major additions, within the proposed Doo Wop Historic District, or adjacent to one of the buildings listed on the National Register of Historic Places document. The guidelines are also recommended for anyone interested in designing a compatible building in the Wildwoods. DESIGNING in CONTEXT New construction within the proposed Doo Wop Historic District should be compatible with the mid-century modern character of the buildings found there. New designs that respect the general characteristics of the historic buildings; including their basic scale, form, and materials are likely to be compatible. This means that an historic style need not be copied. Although historic styles may often be compatible, new design styles can also respect the basic characteristics of the district and be compatible while expressing current concepts. New construction should consider broad characteristics of the district that give it its overall sense of character and that convey the community’s history. The visual themes reinforced the importance of the individual motel proprietor and his/her personal expression. These features should be respected in all new construction. Designs that incorporate these basic characteristics but that do so in such a way as to be stylistically distinguishable from historic buildings are preferred. New construction should be distinguishable from historic build54 ings so that it does not confuse our ability to visually interpret the history of the community and how it has changed over time. The design of the Star Diner in North Wildwood is an example of a compatible style that gives visitors a sense of the character of our island. Where tall buildings are adjacent to residential neighbors, new buildings should be compatible in height and mass, so as not to overwhelm the scale of the smaller structure. Consider height setbacks, so the full building height is not perceived from the street. THE CONCEPT of CHARACTER in the DISTRICT The surviving historic buildings create the character of the district that we seek to protect. In some cases, newer buildings already exist that deviate from this established character, but in no way should these new buildings be considered the context with which further development should be compatible. Reinforcing the surviving historic character is the goal, not responding to a hybrid character that is influenced by existing incompatible buildings. The abrupt scale of new construction in the historic district overwhelm residential neighbors. PREVIOUS: Subway was a residence and has a new neon sign compatible with neighboring historic signage. Photo by Julie Marquart 55 The Miami Experience By Nancy Liebman, preservationist, former Miami Beach commissioner, president of the Urban Environment League M IAMI Beach’s development has been a series of successes, crashes, and rebirths. By the 1930s, as the country was recovering from the Great Depression, Miami Beach was well on the road to new speculation and the building of a 20th-Century tropical Deco resort area. Following the war, Miami Beach was the symbol of glitz and glamour for the tourist industry. A new hotel was built every year throughout the 1950s and early 1960s. A wave of condominium highrises replaced the elegant estates in an effort to bring retirees to the city for year-round housing. By the 1970s new resorts and jet service had diminished Miami Beach’s image as a tourist destination. As tourism waned, the city turned its attention to expanding its convention center. As the hotels lost business, they fell on hard times and neglect, especially in the older neighborhoods of South Beach. By the 1980s, the Mariel Boat Lift had brought a horde of new people to Miami Beach, some of whom were honest and hard-working and others who became part of the criminal element that gravitated to the troubled neighborhoods. Desperate property owners and a negligent administration allowed the city 56 to crash. While the city’s leaders worked to maximize zoning, condemn properties, thwart improvements to existing building stock, and schemed to disembody a neighborhood, the Miami Design Preservation League, founded in 1976, went to work to place the 1920s, 1930s and 1940s Tropical Deco architecture on to the National Register of Historic Places. In 1979, the Art Deco District was placed on the Register despite the city government’s objections. The collapse of the neighborhood took place as a result of a building moratorium which had been designed to drive residents out and lower the values of properties ripe for condemnation. The National Register designation of the neighborhood to the north of the Redevelopment Area was not recognized as an asset by the city, and the efforts to preserve, protect, and promote it became a 13-year battle. After the National Register Designation in 1979, the Preservation League created an Art Deco District Preservation Plan, a vision and a guide to preserving, protecting, marketing, promoting, and creating infill for the designated district. The plan was never adopted or recognized by the city leadership. The changes occurred one small step at a time, with the League following the model of the plan. Grassroots efforts included marketing and promoting, establishing an economic arm for development and restoration, learning grantsmanship, lobbying for preservation laws to both prevent demolition and establish a design TOP: The Royal Palm condo-hotel in North Beach, Miami, has a pattern expressed in the facade, horizontal fins and decorative signage. ABOVE: This 1930s Miami Beach property has horizontal fenestration with fins to shield the sun. 57 New condos in Florida show good use of color, horizontal fenestration, and, right, a signature roof. OPPOSITE: This dynamic window conceals a parking garage, and blends with historic structures. review process, and creating media relations to help win over an intransigent city government. It was a challenge to create the local legislation necessary to protect the integrity of the one-square-mile neighborhood. The city’s leadership rejected any historic preservation overlay legislation. A lawsuit by Dade County finally overturned the city’s resistance, but only with a change in political leadership in the early 90s did the battles turn to successes. While the Preservation League was steadfast in its vision to protect the National Register Art Deco District, the city feared preservation protection for the historic neighborhood because they wished to build a new hotel on the ocean near the Miami Beach Convention Center. The convention center had been expanded as a fix for the lagging tourist industry, but now the city needed a new hotel to serve it. With the Second Bust of the city in the 1970s and 1980s and a dead hotel market, the city had not had a new hotel in 20 years. The city leadership did not understand the growing phenomenon of a 58 re-energized Art Deco District and wished to build the new hotel by condemning property on the northern edge of the designated National Register District. The preservationists prevailed upon the city administration to hire an architectural consulting firm to demonstrate to the public that a new convention hotel could be designed that would incorporate historic buildings into a plan for new compatible construction. This construction would be in keeping with the existing scale of the neighborhood and sympathetic with the pedestrian quality of the Art Deco District. The study concluded with a plan that was accepted by the preservationists, developers, hoteliers, and the tourism convention industry. The Loews Miami Beach opened in 1998. It was a time of new acceptance for the preservation ethic in Miami Beach. The grand compromise limited the scale of the new construction but also allowed for certain portions of historic buildings to be demolished. The entire boundary of the National Register District was finally protected with local preservation legislation in 1992, two years after the compromise had been reached. Miami Beach has learned the value of protecting its architectural heritage, as this heritage has been the catalyst for the city’s latest boom. The world now recognizes Miami Beach’s signature statement, its thriving Art Deco District. But with success comes a new challenge. We must be ever-vigilant in protecting the atmosphere that has been created. We must reject the efforts of those who wish to overbuild and over-commercialize our popularity. Cities of quality preserve the past and use it as a guide to build the future. Historic Districts and Heritage Tourism are a phenomenon as well as an economic success. Cities must have an identity to distinguish them from the rest. 59 The facade of the original is polished, preserved and connected seamlessly to the addition at the new Cabana Beach in Miami. The addition incorporates fun details from original Mimo architecture like the Eden Roc, where you could sit at the bar and watch people swim past. A Miami Case Study T HE Allison Hotel, designed in 1951 in Miami’s new North Beach Historic District, will be re-born as Cabana, a 210-unit retreat. Architects are Sieger Suarez Architectural Partnership + BSG Development. The building is a staid box inter60 sected by a curving plane with windows arranged in horizontal bands. The eastern facade of the Allison was underutilized, so just the back of the building which faced the ocean was demolished. The new superstructure frames the view of the ocean, and is centered around an infinity pool, with glass walls and floors. An infinity pool has negative or vanishing edges, leaving the impression of an endless or infinite setting. Swimming in the pool you will be able to see fish swimming in an aquarium below. Sitting at a bar you can view people in the pool. The old hotel had lots of small spaces used for cold storage, dry storage, management offices, and laundry areas. This was all taken out and the space used to provide parking for 100 cars. Additional cars are parked with valet parking. Cities like Miami Beach give incentives to encourage adaptive reuse. This is a creative way to accommodate parking constraints that the Wildwoods don’t allow for. Variances are granted in order to protect the historic resources. As Americans, we don’t have a lot of history compared to Europe. We look at the recent past, and say, “Why keep it, it’s old?” Not so long ago, people said that about Miami’s Art Deco district. The City of Miami is fairly liberal in its historic preservation efforts in what you can do with the back or side of a building. The Allison is a case in point. What was once considered old can become tomorrow’s treasure. 61 A New Look for the Satellite The Satellite motel was significant for its space age imagery. Our vision for the Satellite condominium borrows from that – it preserves the existing office/owner’s quarters as a luxury residence, and keeps the boomerang roof, which sets the tone. The ground level contains hidden parking, accessed by a single entrace on the side street. The new structure surrounds the new pool terrace and steps up gradually to its highest point. The vision for the Satellite motel is conceptual in nature and was developed solely for the purpose of this book. Illustration by Anthony Bracali 62 63 PART seven How To DooWop Elements Of Architecture in the Wildwoods 64 65 U THE design principles in this section apply to all projects: rehabilitation, additions, and new buildings, within the historic district, adjacent to a building listed on National Registry document, or anyone interested in building a compatible structure on Five Mile Beach. THE L-SHAPED FORM THE RECTANGULAR FORM Site Organization OVERVIEW Doo Wop architecture employed a unique combination of site planning to accommodate the automobile with the pedestrian. The public areas of many Doo Wop motels were open to the street so that the activity around the pool area could always be seen from the streets around. Most Doo Wop structures in the district form one of three basic forms: 1. Rectangular 66 THE HIGH-RISE FORM (OCEANFRONT) 2. L-Shaped 3. High Rise (Oceanfront) DESIGN STANDARDS New construction should address the existing rhythm of setbacks and open space. Renovations to existing buildings should not compromise the existing character of the site. Building Massing OVERVIEW Historic buildings found in the dis67 SITE ORGANIZATION Smaller scale portions of historic motels (such as the lobbies shown in orange) were situated along Atlantic Avenue in Wildwood Crest to create a buffer zone between the residential neighborhood and the Doo Wop Historic District. New construction should respect this pattern of setbacks and open space. 68 TOP: The spectacular pagoda at the Singapore contains not only the lobby, but motel rooms. ABOVE: Chateau Bleu has a room supported by wishbone columns that act like a porte cochere, adding unique form to an otherwise common L-shape. Photo by Julie Marquart 69 The Tangiers motel has an exotic hut that serves as an office/game room to contrast with a three-storey rectangular motel, while the Starlux introduced a new dramatic element to offset the rectangular shape of the original trict are dominant forms that establish the perceived mass of the neighborhood. When viewing the district as a whole, the consistency of building height provides a sense of human scale on the east-west streets. The majority of Doo Wop structures in the historic district are organized with the taller portions of the building set back from major pedestrian streets. Large areas at the center or corners of the site were left as open space that could accommodate pools, sun decks, miniature golf courses or shuffleboard. Many historic Doo Wop motels had a signature lobby element with dramatic interior spaces, roof forms, and window configurations. These helped to reinforce the theme of many motels. They also helped to 70 enliven the pedestrian character of the street. There were also many structures with canted walls. These walls either angle inward toward the building or outward towards the street. These are one of the hallmarks of the Doo Wop style and suggest speed and modernity. Canted walls were usually not structural; they were added to the vertical, structural walls and created dead space behind them. They created the impression of daring structure, however, and announced the kinship of the modern motel to other modern buildings like airport terminals. DESIGN STANDARDS Design new buildings to be similar in proportion with the historic context. Glass canted windows and walls can be seen on the Rio, Caribbean, Eden Roc and Seawind New structures should not appear appreciably larger than these buildings. New buildings next to historic structures should not create a dramatic change in scale. New construction may be taller than the established norm if the change in scale is not perceived at the pedestrian access. Care- ful consideration must be paid to any side of the building connected to the public right of way. Locate taller portions (more than 18 feet) of structures to the back or center of a site to minimize the appearance of bulk and maintain pedestrian friendly scale on east-west streets. 71 DOO BE DON’T! x Rhythm and scale of neighborhood is disrupted by locating building without a setback. Garage doors at street level present an unfriendly face to the pedestrian. Existing historic structures should not be dramatically altered. Existing lobby elements and other features must be preserved. The lobby element can be a nice addition to a Doo Wop motel missing that amenity. Human Scale OVERVIEW In addition to creating visual continu- ity, the consistent small size of most historic buildings in the Doo Wop Historic District helps establish a sense of pedestrian scale that encourages walking and contributes to the sense of community that the island enjoys. This pedestrian-friendly character is a key to the well-being of the island’s residents and contributes to the economic health of the area; therefore, it should be emphasized in new buildings. DOO BE DO! Set back buildings from the street to maintain views and preserve open space. Locate the lobby element at the corner to soften the scale. Doo Wop motels paid careful attention to the corners of their sites. This was critical in establishing a pedestrian scale for the neighborhood. Sun decks or other smaller scale elements of the building were often placed at the corners to form a transition between the taller elements of the building beyond. DESIGN STANDARDS New buildings should reinforce the character of the Doo Wop Historic District by conveying a good pedestrian scale. Incorporate features that help establish a human scale in new construction. Using windows in shapes and sizes similar to those found historically helps establish a sense of scale. Features Of The Facade Windows, balconies and doorways can add human scale and help make a building inviting to both pedestrians and motorists 72 OVERVIEW The Doo Wop architecture of the Wildwoods used themes to imply modernity, a “jet set” lifestyle and resort atmosphere. There are a number of shapes that were applied as decorative motifs in the Doo Wop period. Many of these motifs borrowed on popular culture and arts in the 1950s era. The personal style of Catalan painter Joan Miro, or the moving statues called “mobiles” of Alexander Calder, even the bio-morphic shapes of Pablo Picasso – any of these sources suggested a new vocabulary of decorative devices unrelated to traditional designs. Amoeba shapes, artists’ palettes, boomerangs, parabolas, kidney shapes, random circular “cheese holes” all suggested modern “abstract” art. Often more figurative decorative motifs were suggestive of a wealthy “jet set” life; for example: champagne glasses, martini glasses, and musical notes, anything suggestive 73 DOO BE DON’T! x Gables and parking garages are inappropriate, and the facades are flat DOO BE DO! false supports contributed to the theme. Historically our mid-century modern builders treated an end wall with no function as another surface to express a theme. DESIGN STANDARDS Decorative features of the façade are an important asset of the historic district and their general character should be preserved where possible. Design overall facade proportions to be similar to those of the historic buildings. The overall proportion is Similar-sized balconies, when repeated along the building facade, help to establish a rhythm, or visual continuity in the district. Doors & Windows OVERVIEW The extensive use of glass on a Doo Wop building marks the greatest change from tradition. Prior to the modern movement, glass was costly and could not be made in large sheets. A themed facade and facets make for a vibrant, attractive frontage DOO BE DO! Driftwood on the Eden Roc, painted panels on Three Coins and decorative concrete screen block on the Windward. All are examples of how the founding fathers of Doo Wop – the Wildwoods’ mid-century builders – treated a blank wall as another opportunity to express a theme. Horizontal fenestration breaks up the facade, while the verticals express rhythm of tropical vacations – palm trees, pyramids, glass roofs, Tiki torches, Caribbean references, Hawaiian masks, airplanes, and especially jets. Another set of decorative motifs suggested modernism by referring 74 to new technologies (of the time) – satellites and space travel by rocket, and molecular models. On buildings whose theme was tropical islands, thatch roofs often contributed to the Tiki/Polynesian effect. Unpeeled saplings used as the ratio of the width to the height of the building, especially the primary facade. The amount of a facade devoted to a wall surface as compared to that devoted to openings should be compatible within the neighborhood and with the function of the building. The larger the window area, the more friendly the building becomes. Most Doo Wop buildings contained large areas of glass on the primary facades. In the 1950s, technology was developed to make glass relatively inexpensively and in much larger sizes than was possible previously. In modern buildings, when windows are used for entire walls, this is called a curtain wall. The windows in Doo Wop motels often avoid the standard American traditional window, the double-hung window. In the motel units, fixed 75 DOO BE DON’T! x DOO BE DO! This new project in Miami Beach expresses horizontality with its windows and the exaggerated overhang above, illustrating that mid-century details are still modern today Doors and windows that express modernity are encouraged. glass windows are most common. Windows are either made of wood or mill-finished aluminum. Several common window types used in Doo Wop structures are: 1. Awning windows 2. Jalousie windows 3. Fixed sash (decorative muntins) 4. Casement windows 5. Sliding glass doors on private The Pink Champagne’s decorative muntins express the long proportions of the motel’s fixed-sash windows WINDOW TYPES balconies. Larger windows that typically surround the pool can be shaded by the continuous balconies at the exterior. Casement 76 Awning Fixed-panel & awning Fixed-panel & louvres Fixed-panel & strip windows DESIGN STANDARDS The basic character-defining ele- ments of windows and glass curtain walls are; their proportions, the number of divisions, and the dimensions of the frames. This characteristic should be preserved wherever possible. Preserve the functional and decorative features of original fenestration. Such features can include frames, sills, heads, jambs, and glass curtain walls. Protect original wood with paint, varnish, or other protective finish. New windows could include aluminum or wood and large picturewindow glass. It is important that a new building have the spirit and sense of daring exhibited in historic mid-century modern buildings. Small punched windows are discouraged unless grouped or to give 77 toric wood windows with new insulated glass. Railings This rehabilitated bulge-type guardrail at the Imperial 500 was brought up to building code by adding a top rail at 42” height. The original distinctive design was retained. Another method would be to raise the existing guardrail to current required height with infill added at bottom. ABOVE: Examples of classic Doo Wop railing designs. BELOW: The Jolly Roger’s railings feature an elaborate geometric pattern. The Starlux has a rather simple handrail but it does not detract from the 21st-century feel with its cutting-edge corrugated aluminum siding. the effect of larger window feature. Fake muntins are discouraged. If replacement is necessary, replace in kind, to match the original. Maintain original window size and muntin spacing. Avoid fake muntins on double hung windows. Either replace existing windows with new insulated windows of the same size, or retrofit existing his- 78 OVERVIEW Balcony railings were typically employed as a major decorative element on the facade. These were always painted steel, fabricated locally. Some railings were simple curves, while some, as in the Jolly Roger, were more elaborate, utilizing geometric patterns and motifs popular at the time. These railings were whimsical in design, in order to better contrast with the simple geometric forms of the buildings. DESIGN STANDARDS Where possible, existing railings should be modified to meet current code standards. This can often be done by adding horizontal rails above the existing railing system. The design of new railings should be inspired by historic precedents. Railings which employ simple, vertical pickets are acceptable in some cases. More simple railings can be decorated with attached panels featuring more complicated shapes cut into them, such as curves, bulges and diamonds. Roof Forms OVERVIEW In keeping with the spirit of the island’s notable mid-century modern resort architecture the roof forms should generally give the 79 impression of modernity and daring engineering. In some of the best Doo Wop buildings, the dominant roof is unusual. A single slope-shed roof with deep cantilevers (see Fantasy Motel) or a round, pleated roof (see Surfside Diner) make the shape of the building itself proclaim its modernity. Typically the main roof of the motel was a built-up bituminousfelt roof. Historically the extended roof overhang was at least equal to the width of the balcony. Large glass areas, particularly with a southern exposure, provide solar heating in the winter, while a deep overhang casts a shadow in summer. DESIGN STANDARDS Preserve the original roof form. Preserve the original roof materials where feasible. Where replacement is necessary, use materials of similar color, texture, and finish to the original character-defining features. Asymmetrical roof shapes are encouraged. Avoid traditional shapes like gable, 80 gambrel, or mansard. Roof forms are often the most significant characterdefining elements for motels, their preservation is important. Typical roof forms seen in the proposed historic district include: blast-off, gull-winged, and terraced. Signage OVERVIEW The most important element of a Doo Wop Motel was its signage. Often, the motel owner would go directly to the signage fabricator with an idea for a theme or a name, and the fabricator would design the signage, incorporating appropriate colors, graphics and type faces. Thus the sign would set the theme of the motel. The colorful neon signs were considered crucial for attracting the eye of the passing motorist, with each sign trying to outdo the next. Signage would almost always incorporate neon, and be designed to be readable both day and night. Many of the script signs had no background, as they become easily readable at night, when silhouetted against the night sky. Signs were one part of a larger thematic expression and motel operators looked actively to themes as a way to publicize their businesses and evoke images of glam- CLOCKWISE, from left: Round, pleated roof at the Surfside diner, which is being rebuilt as the new Byrne Visitor Center; single slopeshed roof with deep cantilevers at the Fantasy motel; blast-off roof at the Ocean View; terraced style at The Attache; gull-winged at the Seagull; and the Starlux, which has a circular lounge with a projected cantilevered roof, punctured with cheese holes and supported by bean poles. our and exoticism. Typography OVERVIEW Doo Wop typography is self-consciously modern, rejecting both the serifed, classical tradition and the spiky, gothic Olde English style. Sans serif letter faces were standard. Italicized letters, especially with rounded corners as though drawn with a marker or brush, conveyed the ideas of speed and informality that were intrinsic parts of the Doo Wop style. Some motels, especially those named after a prestigious foreign vacation destination, might use a traditional serifed typeface to evoke the refined associations of the other destination. 81 Signage was considered crucial for attracting the attention of the passing motorist, especially in an age before the internet and credit card reservations, when vacationers would choose their accommodations by cruising the streets. 82 83 Laura’s Fudge Shop is historic Doo Wop, while Juan Pablo’s Margarita Bar and Cool Scoops are examples of new neon signage that reflect the unique history of the Wildwoods where “every day is a holiday and every night’s a Saturday night.” Ultimately the typography further enforced the theme of the motel, with the intent of allowing vacationers to forget the routine of their everyday lives. Doo Wop motels incorporate several categories of themes: 1. Geography (Nassau Inn, Biscayne, Catalina); 2. Exotic locations (Singapore, South Beach, Tahiti); 3. Tropical paradise (Ala Kai, Aqua Beach, Bali-hi); 4. Space age (Apollo, Astronaut, Starfire); 5. American heritage, patriotism (Cape Cod Inn, Frontier, Saratoga Inn). 84 DESIGN STANDARDS Preserve original signage and typography where feasible. New signage should be similar in scale and style to those used historically and should incorporate period typography, colors and shapes. Signs should be incorporated into the architecture of the building and should reinforce the theme. Signage should be designed with individual letters and as much neon as possible. Backlit plastic panels with fluorescent lighting are discouraged. Check local ordinances to determine any sign, canopy, or awning prohibitions. 85 PanAm hotel’s rotating starbust globe was inspired by the astronauts of the 50s. Center and right: the power of neon was used to seduce the motorist to pull over. Photo by Julie Marquart Materials & Colors OVERVIEW One of the most typical characteristics of Doo Wop “popular modernism” is the extensive use of materials and color; this characteristic separates this style from the high end International Style modernism of the 86 ’50s and ’60s. Typically, the Doo Wop buildings utilized color in inventive ways to enhance the theme. Use of color has been associated with the resort architecture of Miami; the original inspiration for Doo Wop architecture. Color can be used to suggest a resort atmosphere. The best Doo Wop motels used color to further the theme, and to create a festive atmosphere. The colors were usually mixed pink, beige and tan, or aqua blue/green, and was very horizontal in emphasis. Some examples of 1950s colors: Aqua, Pink, Pale yellow, Pale green, Powder blue. Some 1960s colors: bright orange, gold, purple, avocado green. A number of materials were used on Doo Wop facades to suggest either modernity or exotic locations. A unit masonry, used as veneer, was fabricated from Portland cement and made to resemble long, narrow, random, ashlar stone. This stone facing was used on bases of buildings, on entire facades, and on canted fins. 87 The sign on this recently-built “Doo Wop’d” Wawa is readable by day or by night. OPPOSITE: The pink and teal colors on the Harley-Davidson motorcycle dealership are compatible with the significant Fantasy motel next door. Photo by Brian McMahon DESIGN STANDARDS Preserve original materials and colors. The color relationship between adjacent buildings should be compatible (not identical). The bold use of color is strongly encouraged, and can be used to break up large wall surfaces. Pastel and primary colors are favored. Decorative patterns can also be used to break up large wall surfaces. Use of other materials also can break up the facade. Painting or plastering over ashlar stone walls is inappropriate. Consider new materials like cultured stone if they need to be replaced. Inappropriate materials would be aluminum or vinyl siding, polyurethane balustrades, fiber-crete cornices, T-111 siding. Sherwin Williams has a line 88 called Suburban Modern Exterior Color Preservation Palette (see colors, next page). and Interior Color Preservation Palette Some titles hint at The Wildwoods motel names. These are the official colors of Main Street Wildwood. Pools & Landscaping OVERVIEW The pool and terrace can further express the unique quality of the design. The pool and sun deck are NEXT PAGE: Doo Wop buildings exhibit many different types of decorative veneer masonry, such as, clockwise from top: tinted ashlar brick, rough ashlar brick, lava rock, and random dressed rubble stone. Photos: Julie Marquart 89 typically surrounded by wings of the motel, which provides a public space for socializing. The Caribbean has a number of distinctive features – the suspended curvilinear walkway, Cshaped pool, plastic palm trees, multi-colored lights embedded in the futuristic angled fascia, and a large neon sign. There is a choice of outdoor areas, covered and uncovered, and an open trellis at the top of the ramp. The shape and floor patterns of the terrace relate to the curves of the pool, not the straight lines of the building. DESIGN STANDARDS Swimming pool shape and layout should try and compliment the architecture of the building. The shape of a pool is very important, since it will be viewed from above. Possible shapes include boomerang, half-round, circular, bow tie, oval. Consider decorative features such as waterfalls or fountains, bridges and islands. Colored concrete paving or colored pavers around the pool area are encouraged, and patterns created from different colors can break up large expanses of paving. The use of extensive landscaping around the pool can suggest a tropical resort. Jacuzzis can be integrated into the pool design, with a waterfall feature. Consider painting a pattern on the bottom of the pool, to further enhance the theme. 90 91 The Caribbean and Chateu Bleu represent typical motels at the peak of the Doo Wop movement – L-shaped units with funky-shaped pools at the center 92 The Starlux and Pan American Hotel pools have the visual volume turned up for the post-millenial traveler 93 part eight Condos with Attitude W HAT would a Doo Wop high-rise look like? As the original Wildwood motel builders did, we can look to Miami Beach for inspiration. Not unlike Wildwood, Miami Beach was booming in the postwar period. Many large new hotels were built along the ocean, north of the smaller (and back then unfashionable) art deco hotels of South Beach. The pre-eminent designer of these new hotels was the architect Morris Lapidus. Lapidus created fantasy environments geared toward the newly affluent middle class. His buildings, while highly modernist in massing and fenestration, were often adorned with thematic elements such as birdcages with live birds, regency-style interiors, and highly decorative lobby stairs to nowhere. Lapidus was not above piling on more and more decoration, as confirmed in this qoute: “If you like ice cream, why stop with one scoop; have three scoops, too much is never enough. Enjoy, enjoy!” Many of the original Wildwood motel builders would winter in Miami, and come back with ideas based on what they saw. The Morey brothers, Will and Lou, were particulary active in Wildwood in the ’50s and ’60s. They designed and built numerous motels, including the Fantasy and the 94 Satellite. Their crowning achievement was the Pan American Hotel, which was inspired by the Americana Hotel in Bal Harbour (1956), by Lapidus. The Pan American provided a complete beachfront resort experience (similar to the new Miami Beach hotels) including indoor corridors, elevators, a circular swimming pool, a spectactular lobby, and an adjacent restaurant. Like the Americana, the Fontainbleu Hotel (1954) and the San Souci (1949), both by Lapidus, inspired the design of many Wildwood motels. “When the hotel opened it became instantly famous,” Lapidus said of the Fontainbleu, his most famous creation. Indeed, the Fontainebleu was visited by presidents, move stars and gangsters – Frank Sinatra and his cronies were said to have the run of the place. And it quickly became one of the most famous hotels in the world. Today’s high-rise hotel or condominium can take inspiration from not only the glamorous Lapidus hotels in Miami, but also from newer buildings, such as those designed by the architects Arquitectonica, whose stunning 1982 condomium, The Atlantis, featuring a 37-foot cube cut out of the center, was featured on the opening credits of Miami Vice. OPPOSITE: The Fontainbleu (top) and the Sans Souci, two of Morris Lapidus’s magnificent Miami Beach creations. ABOVE: The Atlantis condominium, in Miami. 95 Concept Condo #1 THE WAVE THIS project employs a “wave” motif to create interesting interior and exterior spaces for each of the condo units on the floors above. The base of the building has several three story condo units which have small yards that front the main street. All the parking for these units is behind them in a structured garage with a single entrance to the street. Concepts by Anthony Bracali 96 97 Concept Condo #2 THE POOL CONDOMINIUMS can be successfully integrated with Doo Wop architecture. This project encloses an indoor gym and health club in a “funky”, angular, glass enclosed lobby. The base of the building has a lower scale feeling since it is only two stories and steps back at the condo tower above. The parking is consolidated within a single lot with one entrance that is screened from the street. The stair and elevator tower is a strong vertical element used to organize signage. The horizontality of each floor is expressed along the floor edges. The roof has a deeper overhang to act as a cornice for the entire building. 98 99 Concept Condo #3 WATERWORLD THIS hotel in inspired by the swooping, dramatic sketches of Morris Lapidus. The main hotel tower is conical and forms an ellipse in plan. The lobby is on the main floor of the tower and is ringed by a series of gently sweeping walkways which allow guests to move around the building and form a carport at the entrance. The lower portion of the building is traditional motel rooms with balconies that front the streets. The interior courtyard is raised from the street and has a pool and bocce courts. 100 101 Concept Condo #4 MARQUEE THE “Marquee” employs major vertical lines and a classic post-modernist entrance element to create a large scale gesture to the street. The condo units in each floor above have living spaces with windows that open onto the marquee. Each unit has terraces at the rear which face the ocean views. The lower portion of the building (on the left) is a traditional motel with balconies that face the street. The main entrance has a large lobby, restaurant and night club to activate the corner of the block. Parking for all these units is consolidated behind the building in garage. 102 103 part nine Doo Wop On The Cheap T HE Doo Wop style does not have to be expensive or complicated. Most of the historic Doo Wop Motels were built very inexpensively. The original owners would winter in Miami, and would come back with ideas based on the modern hotels they saw there. They told their architects and builders to add these elements at little cost – one builder coined the term Wildwoodize. There are three elements can that easily provide Doo Wop style with little or moderate cost: Paint, Lighting, Signage Paint The DooWop motels used paint to highlight architectural features, decorate blank walls, and further the theme of the building. See DooWop resources for appropriate period paint colors, however the more color, the better. Doors and trim were typically painted bold colors, thus creating an overall pattern to the façade. Paint can be used on blank walls, with simple blocks of color. Painted stencil patterns are cheap, and can create a wallpa- I I I I I 104 per effect Lighting Lighting was very important to the original Doo wop motels, setting a nighttime tone and further enhancing the theme. Use colored lighting along balconies and walkways. While colored light bulbs are harder to find, color gels over modern compact fluorescent or halogen fixtures offer a wide variety of colors. Low lighting levels are important in public spaces, thus making it more comfortable to guests, and not overwhelming signage, as viewed from the street. Translucent vinyl can be applied to simple plastic compact fluorescent fixtures, thus making the lighting fixture an architectural feature, and furthering the theme. Simple colored floodlights on blank facades can turn the bland into something unique, creating a decorative wash of color. Provide uplighting for plastic palm trees, which creates a soft glow at night. Avoid pole mounted sodium lighting, which creates harsh shadows, and poor color rendition. I I I I I I I Three-dimensional back-lit sign with fun typeface conveys a theme inexpensively Signage A Doo Wop motel is not complete without a neon sign. Many have two signs, a primary, more decorative sign, and a secondary, more functional sign. The neon sign should be the primary element for conveying the theme of the motel, using typeface, color, and images. I I I I Signage theme and colors should also be used for informational signs – office, parking, etc. The room signs on doors are a good place to further the theme of the motel. Today’s technology allows for inexpensive custom plastic signs in a variety of colors. Graphics and photos can also be incorporated into the sign at little extra cost. The combination of warm colors on Beach Colony’s faceted wall provides an inexpensive built-in decoration on a blank wall 105 part ten The 10 Commandments For Creating A Doo Wop Motel Take a simple two- to three-story bar or L-shaped motel and add the following: 1 A name that evokes the ’50s – The Rock-N-Roll Motel; an exotic vacation spot – The Caribbean Motel; or space age – The Astro Motel. 2 pinks, baby blue, turquoise, sea greens, for rails, doors, trim and the drapes in the picture windows. 7 Create an interior color scheme using a similar but more subtle pallette and add Jetson decorations and furnishings from the ’50s. Create a wild and crazy high reader sign with shapes and typefaces that evoke the name, e.g., stars, planets, kidney shapes, and lots and lots of neon. 8 3 9 4 10 Create a motel office, lounge, etc. in the shape of some wonderful wacky image, i.e., a spaceship, a beach ball, a sailboat, etc. with lots of color, glass and a decorative paint job. Create a pool area with kidney shaped pool surrounded by bright green Astroturf, and wild and crazy beach umbrellas and landscape with plastic palm trees. 5 Create a colorful and distinctive profile for the balcony railings – S-curves, C-curves, the more curvy the better. 6 106 Create an exterior color scheme made up of ’50s colors, e.g., Create a wild and crazy neon roof sign in the style and typeface of the motel name and high reader sign. Create a decorative night lighting scheme, e.g. linear neon fascia or eave lights, floodlighting, and thematic, decorative fixtures in the pool and parking areas. And last, but not least, pull this all together in an idiosyncratic, original and crazy way that clashes, jumps and jives! From the Penn/Yale/Kent State Wildwood Study 1997-99. The Doo Wop Preservation League is indebted to the students, professors and critics who participated in the“Learning from the Wildwoods” research and design studios conducted by the University of Pennsylvania, Yale University and Kent State University, led by Steve Izenour, Daniel Vieyra and Susan Snyder. 107 part eleven Plants & Flowers THE name Wildwood was given by Philip Pontius Baker for the dense twisted forest of growth that covered the island. An early real estate brochure lists Wildwood Beach as, “A veritable forest by the sea.” This list is from the Borough of Wildwood Crest Land Development Ordinance, adopted 1992. It is to be used as a guideline only. SHADE TREES Acer pseudoplatanus Acer Rubrum Celtis occidentalis Quercus phellos Platanus acerfolia Bloodgood COMMON NAME Planetree Maple October Glory/Red Maple Common Hackberry Willow Oak London Planetree MINimum SIZE 12-14 ft 12-14 ft 12-14 ft 12-14 ft 12-14 ft 12-14 ft FLOWERING TREES Cornus Kousa Magnolia virginiana Amelanchier canadensis Viburnum prunifolium Malus floribunda Prunus yedoensis Kousa Dogwood Sweetbay Magnolia Shadblow Serviceberry Blackhaw Viburnum Japanese Crabapple Yoshino Cherry 6-8 ft 6-8 ft 6-8 ft 8-9 ft 8-9 ft 8-9 ft EVERGREEN TREES Ilex opaca Pinus strobus Pinus thunbergii Juniperus virginiana Thuja occidentalis American Holly White Pine Japanese Black Pine Eastern Red Cedar Dark American 7-8 ft 7-8 ft 7-8 ft 7-8 ft 7-8 ft SHRUBS Ilex glabra Myrica pensylvanica Prunus maritima Viburnum dentatum Pyracantha coccinea Rosa rugosa Rosa virginiana Vaccinium corymbosum Ilex crenada Berberis gladwynesis Inkberry Bayberry Beach Plum Arrowwood Viburnum Rutgers Firethorn Rugosa Rose Virginia Rose Highbush Blueberry Japanese Holly William Penn Barbery 18-24 in 18-24 in 18-24 in 18-24 in 18-24 in 18-24 in 18-24 in 18-24 in 18-24 in 18-24 in GROUND COVER Cotoneaster dammeri Juniperis chinensis sargenti Rosa wichuraiana Juniperus conferta Bearberry Cotoneaster Sargent Juniper Memorial Rose Shore Juniper 12-15 in 12-15 in 12-15 in 12-15 in 108 CLOCKWISE, from left: the Beach Plum, Red Maple, Crab Apple, Red Cedar, American Holly and Virginia Rose 109 Glossary Adaptive Re-use Converting a building to a new use, different from what it was originally designed to be. A good project retains its historic character, while retaining the new functions. A-frame A structural frame in the shape of the capital letter A. Bauhaus Progressive school of arts and architecture founded in 1919 Germany and birthplace of the European Modernist movement that emphasized bold experimental geometric visuals and typography. 3 Boomerang Popular parabolic or amoebashaped design motif “Building as sign” Building where the shape, size or color provides identification as much as signage does Bungalow Small house or cottage usually with a small front porch 110 Cantilevered Structure that projects or hovers in space seemingly without support from beneath Carport A covered automobile shelter. One or more sides are open to the weather. Clerestory Windows which are above normal ceiling height and project into roofline De Stijl Design style that uses asymmetry and rectangles, term derived from 1930s Netherlands school of decorative arts Doo Wop The seashore architecture of this era that reflects the spirit of the people: brassy, bold and boastful. The motels, diners, gas stations and other commercial buildings present a varied and exaggerated spectacle of designs. Signage was considered crucial for attracting the passing motorist and grabbing attention from one motel to another. Angular D elements, space-age imagery, tropical themes, and colors, with spectacular neon signage turning up the volume even more, combine to form a fantasyland atmosphere. The name pays homage to the great cultural force, a type of rock and roll music at the time. Facade The exterior face of a building which is the architectural front, often distinguished from the other faces by elaboration of architectural or ornamental details. False front A front wall that extends beyond the sidewalls of a building to create a more imposing facade. Faux False (Fake) Fins A thin flange projecting outward. Googie Coffee shop Modern architectural style characterized by space-age graphics, widely angled lines, fanciful motifs; term derived from Googie’s coffee shop, designed by John Lautner Glazed brick Brick having a ceramic glaze finish. Infill The use of vacant land and property within a built-up area for further construction or development, especially as part of a neighborhood preservation or limited growth program. Interior Lit Signage in the which solid letters are illuminated by obscured light fixtures. International Style characterized by clean, bold lines and geometric forms; lack of ornamentation or texture; and steel, glass or reinforced-concrete construction. Jalousie A shutter or blind with fixed or adjustible slats which exclude rain and provide ventilation, shade, and visual privacy. Jalousie Window A window consisting of a series of overlapping horizontal glass louvers which pivot simultaneously in a common frame and are actuated by one or more operating devices so that the bottom edge of each louver swings toward the exterior and the top edge swings toward the interior during opening. Jet age See space age. 111 Jetsonian Term used to describe futuristic fantastical architecture envisioned on the 1960s animated television show. Very similar to the built world of Wildwood, NJ. Kidney shaped Usually a swimming pool shape like the human organ or bean. Y Kinetic Refers to signage with motion Mid-century modern The term mid century modern refers to the work of the generation of young architects who emerged from American universities in the late 1940s. They were taught by the leading modernists of the 1920s Bauhaus: Walter Gropius, Josef Albers and Marcel Breuer. Characterized by the architecture of space, the unity of arts and architecture, the new vision of abstraction in the visual arts and the new technology of structural engineering and industrial design. Miesian Minimalist geometric shape, term is derived from the sparse style of architect and designer, Mies Van der Rohe Moderne vs. Modern Moderne refers to an Art Deco style which has a streamline look and pre-dates Modern; Modern refers to mid-century postwar style Mondrian 112 Broad flat areas of color reminiscent of the Modern painter, Piet Mondrian, who used color similarly Pagoda A multistoried shrine-like tower. Parabolic Curved in a way that is not symmetrical Populuxe Author Thomas Hine coined this term for the hopeful designs of the ’50s and ’60s fashion, furniture, architecture, and automobiles which were linked to mass-production, space-age, rock + roll, and a nation in love with car culture. Porte cochere Covered or shelter entryway for vehicles, from French means carriage porch Portico Exterior building element that is supported by columns Postwar Historic period after the end of World War II in 1945, usually extended to the 1960s. Roadside Structures, signage or other elements that are designed primarily to attract the passing motorist Space age Also called jet age, technology innovation in air travel, satellites and eventually moon travel translated into Modern motif. Sputnik Popular space age design embellishment that looks like a starburst with wheel spokes and balls on the ends; associated with progress and named after the Russian satellite launched in the late 1950s Sun Deck A roof area, balcony, open porch, etc. which is exposed to the sun. Tiki/Polynesia Design motif first popularized by GIs stationed in the South Seas during World War II; just before and immediately after Hawaii first became the 50th state in 1959, a Polynesian frenzy took place, often reflected in postwar architecture and motif Veneer A thin sheet of wood that has been sliced, rotary cut, or sawn from a log; one of several plies for added strength or as a facing material on less attractive wood. An exterior wall facing (brick, stone,etc.); provides a durable decorative surface but is not load bearing. 1 Tropical themed Motels with reference to locations with a proximity to the equator. Morris Lapidus a Florida architect designed many glamorous hotels in Miami Beach had a great influence on motel design. qAPPENDICES The following information will be on our website, www.doowopusa.org: RELOCATION OF HISTORIC BUILDINGS & BIBLIOGRAPHY 113 Resources Signage ABS Signs, 3008 Park Avenue, Wildwood, NJ 08260, (609) 522683 www.abssignco.com Ultra Neon, F.D. Musso, Wildwood, NJ 08260, (609) 5234255 Lighting Moonshine Shades (lampshades) (214) 827-2211 www.moonshineshades.com LavaWorld (lava lamps) (773) 237-5700 www.lavaworld.com City Sign, 424 Caredean Drive, Horsham, PA 19044, (215) 4421323 Clothes Daddy-o’s, 888-900-1950 www.daddyos.com Plastic Palm Trees Four Sons Custom Palm Trees Inc., 800-223-2051 Gift Items & Accessories Tropical Expressions Inc., (732) 889-1733 www.tropicalexpressions.com Fifties Fabric Melinamade (fifties reproductions) (415) 902.8460 www.melinamade.com Pillow Fiesta (pillows made from vintage fabrics) (941) 379-6377 www.pillowfiesta.com/ Retro Furniture Circa 50 (butterfly chairs) 800-247-2250 www.circa50.com Modernica (classic reproductions) (212) 219-1303 114 Chiasso (modern furniture, accessories) 800-654-3570 www.chiasso.com Umbra (modern furniture, accessories) www.umbra.com Do-wah-diddy (602) 957-3874 www.dowahdiddy.com Cruising USA (retro stuff) 800-444-1685 www.cuisinusa. com Vintage Vending (retro vending machines) 888-242-6633 www.vintagevending.com Doo Wop Shop at Moreys Pier, Schellenger Avenue, Wildwood. (unique retro gifts and accessories) (609) 884-5404, ext. 133 LEFT: Retro fittings at the lobby bar at the Starlux. Photo by Julie Marquart 115 doowop How to THE Wildwoods-by-the-Sea Handbook of LDesign Guidelines was produced and published by the Doo Wop Preservation League. It is intended to provide an educational resource to the community. L THE book celebrates the rich history of the Wildwoods, and seeks to promote an understanding of that history. Our team of architects, planners and Lpreservationists have compiled information and advice on how to manage an historic Photo by Julie Marquart 116 building, and how to construct new buildings that complement the character of the giddy collection of Doo Wop architecture that has earned this island international recognition. is our ultimate hope that these guidelines LwillITinspire residents to appreciate the great cultural treasures in our community.