stentec bv

Transcription

stentec bv

Raadgevend Ingenieursbureau Stentec B.V.
Hollingerstraat 14
8621 CA Heeg
The Netherlands
Tel. 0515 - 443515
Fax. 0515 - 442824
Date of release: 03 January 2003
STENTEC B.V.
Load set calculation Dowec 6MW
R45.04/01.03/03
CD C45.04/01.03/03
H. Efdé
W. Kuik
This copy belongs to: Stentec B.V. / NEG Micon /ECN
Load set calculation DOWEC 6MW
H. Efdé
Quality
Internal control
Date
Report
Ing. H. Efdé
(HE)
3 January 2003
Authorisation
Ir. W. Kuik
(WK)
3 January 2003
Signature
This document is made for NEG Micon and ECN. Stentec will only present the results of the
calculation to NEG Micon and ECN.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 2
H. Efdé
Summary
This report contains a load set calculation and design variation calculations for the DOWEC 6 MW
wind turbine. The wind turbine is modelled in Phatas IV by ECN. The calculations of the “baseline”
wind turbine are performed with executable “phat6MW.exe” dated 020502. For the design variations
other executables were used. The load set is programmed by Stentec B.V. according ref. [2]
description.
The resulting fatigue and ultimate loads are presented in time response diagrams, extreme values
tables, statistics and VBC tables (1Hz equivalent signals), generated by Stentec B.V.’s post
processing program ADAP. All results are stored on CD C45.04/01.03/03. The results of the design
variation calculations are stored on CD C45.04/01.03/03 and are used to generate “cost of energy”
tables.
The decisive values can be used for optimalisation and design detailling.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 3
H. Efdé
Contents
Quality .....................................................................................................................................................2
Summary .................................................................................................................................................3
Contents ..................................................................................................................................................4
1
Introduction ......................................................................................................................................5
2
Wind turbine .....................................................................................................................................6
2.1
Wind turbine modelling ........................................................................................................... 6
3
Load set. ..........................................................................................................................................7
3.1
Introduction. ............................................................................................................................ 7
3.2
Definitions of the quantities..................................................................................................... 7
3.3
Forces, moments and deflections........................................................................................... 8
3.4
User defined parameters ........................................................................................................ 9
4
Results ...........................................................................................................................................11
4.1
Maximum tower foot bending moment ................................................................................. 11
4.2
Extreme tables...................................................................................................................... 12
4.3
1 Hz equivalent signals......................................................................................................... 13
5
Design variations. ...........................................................................................................................15
5.1
Cost of energy....................................................................................................................... 15
5.2
Structural pitch. ..................................................................................................................... 15
5.2.1
Cost of energy. .............................................................................................................. 16
5.3
Tower eigenfrequencies. ...................................................................................................... 17
5.3.1
Cost of energy. .............................................................................................................. 17
5.4
Turbine control. ..................................................................................................................... 18
5.4.1
Cost of energy. .............................................................................................................. 18
5.5
Tapered blade....................................................................................................................... 20
5.5.1
Cost of energy. .............................................................................................................. 20
5.6
Low Lambda control. ............................................................................................................ 21
5.6.1
Cost of energy. .............................................................................................................. 22
6
Conclusion. ....................................................................................................................................23
References. ...........................................................................................................................................24
Appendix A.
Phatas file listing ..........................................................................................................25
Appendix B.
Load cases listing.........................................................................................................26
Appendix C.
Plot of loadcase GrEog1Voc.........................................................................................31
Appendix D.
Tables structural pitch. .................................................................................................32
Appendix E.
Tables tower frequencies..............................................................................................41
Appendix F.
Tables pitch control. .....................................................................................................50
Appendix G.
Tables tapered blade....................................................................................................59
Appendix H.
Low Lambda control. ....................................................................................................68
Appendix I. Plots tower eigenfrequencies. ..........................................................................................69
Appendix J.
Base line control versus Peak Shave control. ...............................................................72
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 4
H. Efdé
1 Introduction
In order to calculate the strength of a wind turbine a set of loads and load combinations is prescribed
by the certification authority. This report describes the load set and results according to IEC2 class C
and DNV regulations for the DOWEC 6 MW wind turbine. It is the purpose that the fatigue and
ultimate strength of the wind turbine comply with this standard. The wind speeds and turbulence
intensities that are used for the load set are given by NEG Micon and ECN ref. [2].
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 5
H. Efdé
2 Wind turbine
The DOWEC MW6 wind turbine is a three-bladed off shore wind turbine with a rotor diameter of 129
m. and a rated power of 6 MW. The turbine start up wind speed is 4 m/s and has a nominal wind
speed of 12.1 m/s. Rated rotor speed is 11.84 rpm. The blades on this variable speed wind turbine
are controlled by an active pitch control system. Normal pitching speed is 5º /sec. while emergency
speed is 10º /sec.
The hub height of the DOWEC is 91.4 m. above sea level. Total height of the tower is 110.2 m. from
the sea bottom.
A description of the DOWEC wind turbine can be found in ref. [3] and ref. [14].
2.1
Wind turbine modelling
The DOWEC 6 MW wind turbine has been modelled with the dynamic response program Phatas IV
by ECN. An overview of the used program and input files can be found in Appendix A.
For the simulation the DOWEC wind turbine with 21 meter foundation was used without
hydrodynamic loading.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 6
H. Efdé
3 Load set.
3.1
Introduction.
A loadset has been defined by NEG Micon and ECN, ref. [2]. The load cases are based on IEC2
class C regulations and DNV regulations for off shore wind turbines. According this load set
description Stentec B.V. made two series of input files for Phatas IV, one for the fatigue calculations
and the other for ultimate loads calculations. Stochastic wind models were generated with Swifti2.
3.2
Definitions of the quantities.
The definition of the quantities is according to the blade, hub and tower co-ordinate system of the
Terms of Reference ref. [4]. A short description of the used quantities in Phatas is given below.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 7
3.3
H. Efdé
Forces, moments and deflections.
Phatas notation
Unit
Description
Table 1: Blade co-ordinate system
Mxb[i], Myb[i]
[kNm] Total moment of blade i around the blade foot in x and y-direction of
the rotating blade co-ordinate system, non-pitching.
Mxb[i]-p, Myb[i]-p [kNm] Total moment of blade i around the blade foot in x and y-direction of
the rotating blade co-ordinate system, pitching.
Tip disp. flap [i]
[mm]
Total displacement of tip of blade [i] in X-direction.
Tip disp. lag [i]
[mm]
Total displacement of tip of blade [i] in Y-direction.
Table 2: Hub co-ordinate system
Fxn, Fyn, Fzn
[kN]
Total force at a predefined location behind the rotor centre in x, y
and z-direction of the non rotating hub co-ordinate system.
Mxn, Myn, Mzn
[kNm]
Total moment around the x, y and z-direction at a predefined
location behind the rotor centre of the non rotating hub co-ordinate
system.
Fxn-r, Fyn-r, Fzn-r [kN]
Total force at a predefined location behind the rotor centre in x, y
and z-direction, rotating rotor co-ordinate system.
Mxn-r, Myn-r,
[kNm]
Total moment around the x, y and z-direction at a predefined
Mzn-r
location behind the rotor centre , rotating rotor co-ordinate system.
Torsional
[deg]
deformation rotor
shaft
Rotor angular
[deg/s2]
acceleration
Axial force, rotor
[kN]
Axial aerodynamic force on the rotor
Aero power, rotor [kW]
Aerodynamic power on the rotor
Pitch angle [i]
[deg]
Pitch angle of blade [i], angle blade tip with respect to the rotor
plane (θ).
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 8
H. Efdé
Table 3: Tower co-ordinate system
Phatas notation
Unit
Description
Mxt, Myt, Mzt
[kNm] Total moment around the (x,) y and z-direction of the tower coordinate system at the intersection between the horizontal axis at a
specified height above the tower base and the tower Z-axis.
X-defl, Y-defll
[mm], Displacement in the X, Y direction, at a specified height above the
[deg]
tower base.
Yaw angle
[deg]
Yaw angle with respect to tower top.
Yaw rate
[deg/s]
Wind-speed, hub
Wind direction
Gen. shaft power
Rotorspeed
Azimuth angle
3.4
[m/s]
[deg]
[kW]
[rpm]
[deg]
Wind speed at hub height
Actual wind direction at hub with respect to the rotor shaft
Power through the generator shaft.
Speed of rotation of the rotor (positive is clockwise) (Ω).
Rotational angle of blade 1 with respect to the Z-axis
User defined parameters
In Phatas it is possible to determine deflections, moments and stresses at specified locations in
tower, nacelle and blades.
Table 5: Tower parameters
Phatas notation
Unit
Mxt[1], Myt[1]
[kNm]
Location above
tower foot
0.0 m
Mxt[2], Myt[2]
[kNm]
110.2 m
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
Description
foundation base
(sea floor)
yaw bearing
page 9
H. Efdé
Table 6 : Nacelle parameters
Phatas notation
Unit
Mxn[1], Myn[1], Mzn[1],
[kNm],
Fxn[1], Fyn[1], Fzn[1]
[kN]
Mxn-r[1], Myn-r[1],
[kNm]
Mzn-r[1]
Table 7: Blade parameters
Phatas notation
Unit
Mxb[i], Myb[i]
Mxb[i]-p[01],
Myb[i]-p[01]
Mxb[i]-p[02],
Myb[i]-p[02]
tip displ. flap[i]
tip displ. lag[i]
R45.04/01.03/03
Location aft of hub
0.0 m
Description
rotor centre
0.0 m
rotor centre
[kNm]
[kNm]
Location from
blade foot
-1.80 m
0.20 m
[kNm]
28.20 m
blade cross section
[mm]
[mm]
62.69 m
62.69 m
blade tip
blade tip
Stentec, 3-1-03
Description
rotor centre
blade root
page 10
H. Efdé
4 Results
After the PhatasIV calculations the digital output files were converted in ASCI format with the Phatas
postprocessor PHPOST.exe. PHPOST can convert 128 variables maximum per postprocessing run.
Stentec B.V.’s post processor ADAP was used to generate extreme values tables, statistics and for
fatigue analysis 1Hz equivalent signals. The extreme values were extracted from all load cases of
the ulitmate and fatigue load set. For the fatigue analysis only load cases 12 a/b, 18a/b and 24a/b
were examined. These are considered to be the decisive load cases for optimalisation.
4.1
Maximum tower foot bending moment
According IEC 6.1 36 simulations are performed with the wind turbine idling at a windspeed
(stochastic model) of 41.5 m/s. Each load case is calculated with a different wind direction. To
improve the idling of the model, the pitch angle of the blades is set at 85º.
The maximum resulting tower foot bending moments are:
Table 8: Ultimate tower foot bending moments
Variable Extreme Ldcase
2
Ldcase
Mxt[01]
-177230 E50335
-158310 E50325
Myt[01]
79498 E50025
-79262 E50175
all values in kNm, load factor = 1.00
3
Ldcase
-155300 E50345
-76273 E50185
4
Ldcase
-139370 E50315
-74108 E50195
The load case E50335 generates the highest tower foot bending moment. This load case is repeated
8 times, but for each load case a different stochastic model is used. The maximum tower bending
moments are:
Table 9: Ultimate tower foot bending moments
Variable
1
2
3
4
Mxt[01]
-177230 -170690 -166180 -147640
Myt[01]
87609
85477
77240
73366
all values in kNm, load factor = 1.00
5
-146740
71669
6
-135330
67842
7
-133620
65646
8
-117230
53084
From these values it can be determined that the mean maximum tower foot bending moment
Mxt[01] is: 149333 kNm.
It has to be noted that this value is not the absolute highest value. When looking at the extreme
values tables load case GrEog1Voc generates the highest tower foot bending moment Myt[01],
which is -281560 kNm (with = 1.00) . For a plot of this loadcase see Appendix C.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 11
4.2
H. Efdé
Extreme tables
Of the most important design parameters the extreme values are:
Table 10: All parameters, absolute extreme values.
Variable
Mxt[01]
Myt[01]
Mxt[02]
Myt[02]
Mxn
Myn
Mzn
Mxn-r
Myn-r
Mzn-r
Fxn
Fyn
Fzn
Mxb[1]
Myb[1]
Mxb[2]
Myb[2]
Mxb[3]
Myb[3]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
Mxb[1]-p[02]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
Mxb[2]-p[02]
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
Myb[1]-p[01]
Myb[1]-p[02]
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
Myb[3]-p[01]
Myb[3]-p[02]
Tip displ. flap[1]
Tip displ. flap[2]
Tip displ. flap[3]
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
Tip displ. lag[3]
R45.04/01.03/03
Unit
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kN
kN
kN
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
with without
Extreme
Loadcase Extreme
Loadcase
-171210.02 E50335-3
-231133.53 E50335-3
-281560.00 GrEog1Voc
10778.00 PrloVe1k
11855.80 PrloVe1k
-22697.00 EcdVrb
-30640.95 EcdVrb
-10157.00 PrloVe1h
12053.34 EmShVr
-19807.00 EcdVrb
-26739.45 EcdVrb
13249.00 Sh2bVr
-15412.95 EcdVrb
-10157.00 PrloVe1h
12053.34 EmShVr
17780.00 EcdVrb
24003.00 EcdVrb
-19443.00 EcdVrb
-26248.05 EcdVrb
1262.00 Eog50Vr
1703.70 Eog50Vr
767.05 E50335-7
1035.52 E50335-7
-1068.40 E50165
-1442.34 E50165
13824.00 E50335-7
18662.40 E50335-7
-18723.00 EcdVrb
-25276.05 EcdVrb
13627.00 E50335-7
18396.45 E50335-7
-21537.00 EcdVrb
-29074.95 EcdVrb
14612.00 E50025
19726.20 E50025
17416.00 3BfinVr
22241.25 Eog50_12
11099.00 3BfinVo
14449.05 GrEog1Vrb
3994.50 E50275
5392.58 E50275
12371.00 EcdVrb
16700.85 EcdVrb
3228.20 EcdVrb
4358.07 EcdVrb
11389.00 GrEog1Voc
15375.15 GrEog1Voc
3196.60 GrEog1Voc
4315.41 GrEog1Voc
18006.00 Eog50_12
24308.10 Eog50_12
5508.70 Eog50_12
7436.75 Eog50_12
16864.00 3BfinVr
-22407.30 EcdVrb
-5599.80 EcdVrb
-7559.73 EcdVrb
17280.00 3BfinVr
21274.65 EcdVrb
5272.70 3BfinVr
6726.51 Eog50Vr
-11994.00 EcdVrb
-13519.00 EcdVrb
-10330.00 Eog50Vo
9567.10 E50335-6
8537.20 E50025
8731.10 E50335-8
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 12
4.3
H. Efdé
1 Hz equivalent signals
Of the fatigue load set the following load cases are selected for the optimalisation process: 012,
018, and 024. The most important design parameters are analysed by rain flow counting the signal
for damage assessment and the determination of a 1 Hz equivalent signal. This procedure will be
repeated for design variations. By comparing values conclusions can be made about the
improvement of the design.
The results of the calculations of the base line are presented in the following table:
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 13
H. Efdé
Table 11: 1 Hz equivalent signals.
Variable
Fxn
Fyn
Fzn
Mxn
Mxn-r
Myn
Myn-r
Mzn
Mzn-r
Mxb[1]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
Mxb[1]-p[02]
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
Mxb[2]-p[02]
Mxb[3]
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
Myb[1]
Myb[1]-p[01]
Myb[1]-p[02]
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
Myb[3]
Myb[3]-p[01]
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
Mzb[1]-p[01]
Mzb[1]-p[02]
Mzb[2]
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
Mzb[3]
Mzb[3]-p[01]
Mzb[3]-p[02]
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
Myt[02]
Myt[01]
Mzt[01]
Mzt[02]
unit
kN
kN
kN
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
R45.04/01.03/03
1Hz equivalent values
matl curve loadcase 012 loadcase 018 loadcase 024
M5
225.83
223.39
260.89
M5
97.53
132.44
189.97
M5
70.93
98.11
151.90
M5
996.69
1447.73
2057.89
M5
1000.47
1455.05
2068.66
M5
4033.16
4804.88
6259.18
M5
4536.22
5165.74
7007.78
M5
4043.47
4834.25
6055.53
M5
4440.72
5251.48
6767.94
M10
6889.11
7290.93
8241.70
M10
5862.38
5930.37
6529.26
M10
1250.12
1334.03
1607.36
M10
6847.18
7272.08
8290.28
M10
5813.91
5917.89
6772.97
M10
1241.85
1331.19
1698.10
M10
6889.11
7309.88
8110.97
M10
5789.97
5838.04
6410.21
M10
1244.32
1313.16
1618.92
M10
6598.19
6991.87
7700.14
M10
7053.24
7575.70
8339.45
M10
2086.02
2107.90
2418.81
M10
6373.89
6267.36
7828.75
M10
6855.52
7142.80
8464.95
M10
2012.14
1926.68
2442.97
M10
6330.85
6692.39
8278.08
M10
6983.19
7455.21
8935.60
M10
1974.70
2020.82
2593.93
M10
127.88
112.81
119.37
M10
127.65
112.35
119.31
M10
65.13
63.08
75.22
M10
123.86
107.82
134.46
M10
123.79
107.79
134.42
M10
64.47
62.35
80.20
M10
130.19
116.58
135.20
M10
130.16
116.54
135.16
M10
64.83
61.92
76.16
M5
8081.77
19713.50
34205.57
M5
1122.98
1534.06
2184.33
M5
4017.79
4894.07
6424.40
M5
28633.63
30868.45
39798.94
M5
4453.22
5459.90
6931.03
M5
4453.22
5459.90
6931.03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 14
H. Efdé
5 Design variations.
By altering Phatas IV input files and/or executables by ECN and Stentec, design variations are
created. These are compared with the baseline DOWEC turbine. Not the whole load set is used, but
just the load cases that have caused the highest loads. The following load cases are chosen to
calculate the design variations: 012, 018, 024, 1B-5Vo, E50025, E50335, EcdVrb, Eog50-12,
GrEog1Voc.
5.1
Cost of energy.
To clarify the results, the cost of energy per design is calculated according ref. [9], chapter 5.
The cost of a wind turbine can be broken down in cost per component. Important design (and cost)
drivers of a component are the extreme and fatigue loads it has to withstand. A further break down is
achieved by weighing the several loads. By comparing load changes with the baseline configuration
an estimation can be made about the change in cost of the wind turbine.
Table 12: Influence of parameters on wind turbine cost.
cost of
wind
turbine
component (%)
design driver load
parameter
blade
6
extreme flat moment
Myb[1]-p[01]
fatigue edge moment
1Hz-Mxb[2]-p[01]
gearbox
5
average torque
Mxn mean
tower
16
extreme tilt moment foot Myt[01]
fatigue tilt moment top 1Hz-Myt[02]
component
cost
contribution
(%)
contribution
to wind
turbine cost
(%)
25
25
1.5
1.5
75
3.75
30
20
4.8
3.2
If the change in annual yield is known as well, the cost of energy can be calculated by dividing the
wind turbine cost by the yield:
Influence of design variation on cost of energy =
(change in wind turbine cost)
(change in annual yield)
It must be noted that these variations are one dimensional and therefore very crude. For example a
tip speed variation would be more effective with a blade design adapted to that speed. But in this
case the only change is the tip speed.
The results should not be judged for their values, but used as a guideline to further develop the 6MW
DOWEC.
5.2
Structural pitch.
By changing the position and rotation of the girders in the blades, the stiffness properties are
changed. The changed behaviour of the blades should result in smaller tip deflection and a decrease
of fatigue and extreme loads. 4 redesigns (ref [10]) are calculated :
• tr+5-5, girders 0.5o rotated, at tip girder suction side 0.5m to aft and girder pressure side
0.5 m forward.
• tt+5, girders 0.5o rotated, at tip girder suction side and girder pressure side 0.5 m aft.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 15
H. Efdé
•
tt+5-5, girders 0.5o rotated, at root girder suction side 0.5m forward and girder pressure
side 0.5 m aft.
• tt-5+5, girders 0.5o rotated, at root girder suction side 0.5m to aft and girder pressure side
0.5 m forward.
The modified turbine models are tested with load cases 008, 012, 018 and 024, 231 and 234. Load
case 231 is a stochastic windspeed of 12 m/s with –20o yaw, 234 a stochastic windspeed of 25 m/s
with –20o yaw.
To prevent interference of the blades with the turbine, the dynamic behaviour of the tower has been
switched off. Also the baseline loadcases have been recalculated with tower dynamics off.
This explains the difference in baseline loads in the table below, compared to the other
variations.The results of the simulations are stored on CD C45.04/01.03/03 . The extreme and
fatigue tables can be found in Appendix D as well.
5.2.1 Cost of energy.
The calculation of the cost of energy can only be based on the fatigue and extreme loads of the
blades. Gearbox loads, tower loads and energy production are not taken into account because the
aerodynamics of the blades are not changed and the tower dynamics are off. Therefore it is
assumed that these parameters have not changed.
Based on the changed loads the results in relative turbine costs are as follows:
Table 13: Structural pitch, cost of energy.
relative
relative
relative
relative
turbine
turbine
turbine
turbine
blade parameter baseline tt-5+5 costs
tr+5-5 costs
tt+5
costs
tt+5-5 costs
kNm
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
Myb[1]-p[01]
15535.00
0.70
0.01
3.40
0.05
0.70
0.01
3.70
0.06
1Hz-Mxb[1]-p[01]
8327.10
1.05
0.02
-0.60
-0.01
0.90
0.01 -12.00
-0.18
total
0.03
total
0.04
total
0.02
total
-0.12
The influence of the design variations on the cost of energy is similar to the relative turbine costs.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 16
5.3
H. Efdé
Tower eigenfrequencies.
The influence of the tower eigenfrequencies on the turbine behaviour is investigated by creating 8
new tower models with the following eigenfrequencies: 0.150, 0.175, 0.200, 0.225, 0.250, 0.300,
0.350 and 0.400 Hz. The clamping stiffness and material properties of the baseline tower were
modified iteratively to alter the eigenfrequency. The frequencies were calculated with Phatas IV.
The results of the load case calculations can be found on CD C45.04/01.03/03. The extreme and
fatigue tables can be found in Appendix E as well.
Compared to the baseline gearbox loads and annual energy production have not changed. Only
blade and tower loads were used to determine the change in turbine costs. When comparing the
towers the following table can be made:
Table 14: Tower eigenfrequencies, cost of energy.
relative
relative
relative
relative
twrfreq turbine twrfreq turbine twrfreq turbine twrfreq turbine
parameter
baseline
0.150 costs
0.175 costs
0.200 costs
0.225 costs
blade
kNm
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
Myb[1]-p[01]
18006.00
-8.83
-0.13 -5.53
-0.08 -2.69
-0.04
-0.45
-0.01
1Hz-Mxb[2]-p[01]
6772.97
-6.11
-0.09 -4.27
-0.06 -3.37
-0.05
-1.07
-0.02
tower
Myt[01]
1Hz-Myt[02]
-281560.00
6424.40
-21.52
-3.53
total
-1.03 -12.35
-0.11 -0.61
-0.59
-0.02
-4.31
-3.71
-0.21
-0.12
-0.62
-0.81
-0.03
-0.03
total
-0.76
total
-0.42
total
-0.08
-1.37
relative
relative
relative
relative
twrfreq turbine twrfreq turbine twrfreq turbine twrfreq turbine
parameter
baseline
0.250 costs
0.300 costs
0.350 costs
0.400 costs
blade
kNm
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
Myb[1]-p[01]
18006.00
0.12
0.00 -0.16
0.00 -1.26
-0.02
-1.19
-0.02
1Hz-Mxb[2]-p[01]
6772.97
-0.36
-0.01 -0.12
0.00
0.00
0.00
-0.95
-0.01
tower
Myt[01]
1Hz-Myt[02]
-281560.00
6424.40
-1.14
-1.20
-0.05
-0.04
-6.89
0.00
-0.33 -28.50
0.00 -1.99
total
-0.10
total
-0.33
total
-1.37 -24.63
-0.06
-2.57
-1.18
-0.08
total
-1.30
-1.45
The influence of the design variations on the cost of energy is similar to the relative turbine costs.
What this table doesn’t show is a resonance of the tower with the 0.200 e.f. The 1P oscillation
happens at 0.200 * 60 = 12rpm. Since this is very close to the nominal rpm of 11.844rpm,
considerable fatigue damage is the result. The DOWEC wind turbine cuts out at 14rpm, so the
lowest possible tower e.f. should be above 14 / 60 = 0.233Hz.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 17
H. Efdé
Plots in Appendix I show the behaviour of several towers.
5.4
Turbine control.
Three alternative controls are modelled (ref. [11]) and calculated, a High Tip Speed (HTS), Low Tip
Speed (LTS) and a Peak Shave (PS) control. The HTS turbine runs with a nominal speed of 12.58
rpm at Vr=11.7 m/s. The LTS turbine runs with 10.36 rpm at Vr=12.3 m/s.
The first eigenfrequency of the tower of the HTS control turbine is increased from 0.242 to 0.257 Hz.
This will prevent undesired excitations due to the higher nominal speed.
The PS control does not change the rpm, but limits the maximum axial force on the hub in this case
by opening the blade pitch 2 degrees at Vr. The design of the PS control is based on ref. [15].
The results of the load case calculations can be found on CD C45.04/01.03/03. The extreme and
fatigue tables can be found in Appendix F as well.
For the cost of energy of the HTS and LTS control the average gearbox torque and the annual
production is calculated. The average gearbox torque is determined by calculating the average
torque of the generator power curve from the Phatas input file “DowecHTS.inp” and “DowecLTS.inp”.
Phatas IV is used to create a PV curve of the HTS and LTS control. Consequently with the Phatas
post processing program “Eprod” the annual production is calculated. The results are presented in
the table below.
Table 15: HTS and LTS control, cost of energy.
High Tip
relative
Low Tip relative
Speed
turbine
Speed
turbine
parameter
baseline control
costs
control costs
Blade
kNm
%
%
%
%
Myb[1]-p[01]
18006.00
2.15
0.03
-16.28
-0.24
1Hz-Mxb[2]-p[01]
6740.51
0.72
0.01
-8.45
-0.13
gearbox
Mxn mean
tower
Myt[01]
1Hz-Myt[02]
30400.28
-5.34
-0.20
3.45
0.13
-281560.00
6372.64
4.94
4.86
0.24
0.16
-17.98
-9.81
-0.86
-0.31
total
0.24
total
-1.42
annual production baseline
HTS
change (%) LTS
change (%)
Gwh
25.4014
25.5353
0.53
24.656
-2.93
HTS control, change in cost of energy (%)
LTS control, change in cost of energy (%)
R45.04/01.03/03
- 0.29
1.47
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 18
H. Efdé
For the PS control the generator torque table is not changed. Therefore only the blade- and tower
parameters and the annual production is taken into account for the calculation of the cost of energy.
The results are presented in the table below.
Table 16, PS control, cost of energy.
Peak
relative
Shave turbine
parameter
baseline control costs
Blade
kNm
%
%
Myb[1]-p[01]
18006
-4.69
-0.07
1Hz-Mxb[2]-p[01]
6740.51
-0.48
-0.01
Tower
Myt[01]
1Hz-Myt[02]
-281560
6372.64
-0.18
-0.20
total
annual production
Gwh
-0.01
-0.01
-0.09
change
baseline
PS
(%)
25.4014 25.0053
-1.56
PS control, change in cost of energy (%)
1.44
It was expected that the PS control would give greater benefits. Analysis of the load cases and the
results show that the axial force (Fxn) is only reduced with 6.10% at loadcase 12PS, compared to
the baseline loadcase 12. When running a simple test loadcase with a linear changing wind from 4 to
25 m/s, the Fxn at Vr is even higher than that of the base line as can be seen in Appendix J.
It must be concluded that the present peak shave control for the 6MW DOWEC does not work
properly. It must be revised and tested prior to drawing conclusions.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 19
5.5
H. Efdé
Tapered blade.
ECN has designed a blade with more taper than the baseline blade, ref [12]. The cone angle is
changed to –2.4o. The input file “DowecR6.inp” is revised to reflect the new blade design. The
turbine control is the same as the baseline. The results of the load case calculations can be found on
CD C45.04/01.03/03. The extreme and fatigue tables can be found in Appendix G as well.
The blade- and tower parameters and the annual production are taken into account for the
calculation of the cost of energy. The average gearbox torque is similar to the baseline. It does not
have an effect on the cost of energy. The results are presented in the table below.
Table 17, Tapered blade, cost of energy.
Tapered relative
parameter
baseline blade
turbine costs
blade
kNm
%
%
Myb[1]-p[01]
18006.00
-2.69
-0.04
1Hz-Mxb[2]-p[01]
6740.51
-0.24
0.00
tower
Myt[01]
1Hz-Myt[02]
-281560.00
6372.64
-2.21
-1.00
-0.11
-0.03
total
-0.18
Tapered
blade
change (%)
Gwh
25.4014
25.394
-0.03
Tapered blade, change in cost of energy
R45.04/01.03/03
- 0.15
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 20
5.6
H. Efdé
Low Lambda control.
With the Low Lambda control (LL) the rated (wished) rotorspeed changes with the magnitude of the
wind. At high wind the rotorspeed is lower than for example at Vr. This will decrease fatigue damage,
but also makes it possible to keep the wind turbine in operation at windspeeds higher than Vo
(baseline). An other option is to investigate the effects of an increased rated rotorspeed from Vi until
Vr.
For this design variation no new turbine control is programmed, but output from the turbine control
variations (par. 5.4) has been used to create new load sets.
The following load sets have been created:
Table 18: Load sets contents
baseline
loadcase
occurrence(%)
mean windspeed P mean [kW]
012
5.44
12
5623
018
1.44
18
5867
024
0.17
24
5899
027
0.05
27
5806
Low Lambda 1
loadcase
occurrence(%)
012
5.44
12
5623
018LTS
1.44
18
5732
024LTS
0.17
24
5740
027LL
0.05
27
5424
Low Lambda 2
loadcase
occurrence(%)
012
5.44
12
5623
018
1.44
18
5867
024LTS
0.17
24
5740
027LL
0.05
27
5424
Low Lambda 3
loadcase
occurrence(%)
012HTS
5.44
12
5410
018
1.44
18
5867
024
0.17
24
5899
027LL
0.05
27
5424
Low Lambda 4
loadcase
occurrence(%)
012HTS
5.44
12
5410
018HTS
1.44
18
5812
024
0.17
24
5899
027LL
0.05
27
5424
Low Lambda 5
loadcase
occurrence(%)
012HTS
5.44
12
5410
018
1.44
18
5867
024LTS
0.17
24
5740
027LL
0.05
27
5424
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 21
H. Efdé
The standard load cases apply to a rotorspeed of 11.84 rpm, the LTS (Low Tip Speed) load cases
10.36 rpm and the HTS (High Tip Speed) loadcases to 12.58 rpm. For this Low Lambda analysis
load case 027LL was generated to assess the fatigue damage of a LTS turbine at a stochastic
windspeed of 27 m/s (wished rotorspeed at 10.36 rpm).
The occurrence of the load case is based on a Rayleigh distribution with a Vm of 9.2 m/s. The Pmean
is the average generator power of the load case and is used to calculate the yearly production.
The results of the load case calculations can be found on CD C45.04/01.03/03. The 1Hz equivalent
fatigue tables can be found in Appendix H as well.
The blade- and tower parameters and the annual production are taken into account for the
calculation of the cost of energy. The annual production is calculated by ADAP using the occurance
and mean power from table 18. The average gearbox torque could not be used, since the
rotorspeed-shaft torque table differs per loadcase. Also extreme values are not available because
the loadsets consisted only of fatigue loadcases. The results are presented in the table below.
Table 19: Cost of energy Low Lambda control variations.
100% loadcase
kNm
blade
Myb[i]-p[01]
1Hz-Mxb[i]-p[01]
-18006.00 Eog50-12
4483.82 all
Low
Lambda 1
change
Low
Low
Low
change in Low Lambda change in Lambda 3 change in Lambda 4 change in Lambda 5 change in
cost
2 change
cost
change
cost
change
cost
change
cost
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
n.a.
n.a.
-1.72
-0.03
n.a.
-0.71
-0.01
n.a.
1.46
0.02
n.a.
1.79
0.03
0.89
0.01
gearbox
Mxn mean
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
tower
Myt[01]
1Hz-Myt[02]
2558.84 all
MWh
LL1 loadset,
LL2 loadset,
LL3 loadset,
LL4 loadset,
LL5 loadset,
LL1
3532.3
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
-0.14
-1.83
-0.06
0.73
0.02
3.95
0.13
0.32
0.01
total
-0.16
total
-0.07
total
0.05
total
0.15
total
0.02
change (%) LL2
3511.4
n.a.
-4.33
-0.59
influence on cost of energy
change (%) LL3
3528.4
-0.11
change (%) LL4
3429.4
-2.91
change (%) LL5
3422.4
-3.11
change (%)
3427
-2.98
0.42
0.04
2.76
3.17
2.92
Based on the simplified Low Lambda load sets and the cost of energy model, it can be concluded
that only LL1 has a reasonable decrease in fatigue damage. But because the annual production is
lower, the cost of energy increases. LL3 to LL5 even cause more fatigue damage than the baseline
while production is lower than the baseline.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 22
H. Efdé
6 Conclusion.
Based on the turbine description of ECN ref. [3] a PhatasIV load set has been generated. With the
results of this final load set the components of the turbine can be checked by NEG Micon or ECN for
ultimate and fatigue loads according to the IEC and DNV regulations.
From the results of the load cases it is shown that the turbine behaviour is conform the load set
description given by NEG Micon ref. [2]. But the extreme loads are not in accordance with the
expectations. When table 10 is compared with ref. [13] it can be concluded that the maximum tower
top tilt moment Myt[02] is 1.7 times higher than calculated statically. The highest tower bottom tilt
moment Myt[01] is 2.5 times higher than expected.
A possible cause for this large difference might be the ECN modelling that allows short generator
overshoots while originally the 6MW was considered to be an absolute highest value.
Key load cases are used to calculate DOWEC design variations. Of the most important parameters
tables with extreme values and 1Hz equivalent signals can be found on CD C45.04/01.03/03. To make
the large amount of data understandable, it has been used to calculate relative turbine costs and
changes in cost of energy.
It is shown that tower frequency and turbine control have the largest influence on the cost of energy.
An increase or decrease in tower frequency of more than 0.1Hz, a lower tipspeed or the use of peak
shaving will have a beneficial influence on the cost of energy of the 6MW DOWEC.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 23
H. Efdé
References.
[1]
Handbook Reporting Handbook Reporting and Communication
and Communication Engineering consultancy Stentec B.V., March 2002, Report nr.
R6.20/02..01/02, H.P. Haring, Stentec BV.
[2]
Load set description
DOWEC 6MW
Load set description DOWEC 6MW turbine
DOWEC-F1W2-JP-02-62/00-P, version 0, 120402, H.F. Veldkamp
(NEG Micon), J.M. Peeringa (ECN).
[3]
DOWEC 6 MW predesign
DOWEC 6 MW pre-design. Aero-elastic modelling of the DOWEC
6 MW pre-design in PHATAS.
DOWEC-F1W2-HJK-01-046/2, ECN-CX-135, april 2002, H.J.T.
Kooijman, C. Lindenburg, D. Winkelaar.
[4]
Terms of Reference
Terms of reference DOWEC, Pre-EET number 10008.doc, 176-FGR0300/V1, F. Goezinne
[5]
IEC 61400-1ed. 2.
IEC 61400-1, second edition, 1999-02
[6]
Phatas-IV users
manual
PHATAS-IV user’s manual, release “jul-2001”, draft, October 15,
2001, C. Lindenburg
[7]
ADAP manual
ADAP manual, R6.20/01.01/01, June 2002, B.F. Boersma, H. Efdé,
Stentec B.V.
[8]
Email B. Hendriks
Email DOWEC: load variations, 250602, B. Hendriks, ECN
[9]
NM3000-LMH46-5
blade design
Aerodynamic Parameter Sensitivity Study, ECN-C--00-077, May
2001, C. Lindenburg, E. Bot, H.B. Hendriks, ECN
[10]
Email H.J. Kooijman
Email DOWEC 6MW, sensitivity analysis structural pitch, 040702,
H.J. Kooijman, ECN
[11]
Email J.M. Peeringa
Email Alternatieve DOWEC regelingen, 160802, J.M. Peeringa,
ECN
[12]
Tapered LMH-64-5
blade
6MW Blade Variant With Increased Taper, ECN-Wind DOWECNote, August 2002, C. Lindenburg, ECN
[13]
Data6MWV2.doc
Estimated data for 6MWe turbine with 129 m rotor diameter,
291101, F. Goezinne, NEG Micon.
[14]
DOWEC 6MW
design overview
DOWEC 6MW design overview, 270602, H. Efdé, Stentec B.V.
[15]
Ultieme Bladhoek
Regeling
Eindverslag van het UPC project, Stentec rapport
R052.01/01.09.98, 011098, W. Kuik, R.C. Wegerif, Stentec BV
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 24
Appendix A.
H. Efdé
Phatas file listing
Overview used Phatas files
Phatas file name
file date
phat6mw.exe
phpost.exe
030602
070402
blade_6MW_R5.inp
DOWEC_6MW_R5.inp
dowecR6.inp
found_21m.inp
defphat
150302
150302
060502
070402
260901
cylin1
cylin2
DU21_A17
DU25_A17
DU30_A17
DU35_A17
DU40_A17
NA64_A17
141101
141101
141101
071201
071201
071201
071201
071201
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 25
Appendix C.
R45.04/01.03/03
H. Efdé
Plot of loadcase GrEog1Voc.
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 31
Appendix D.
H. Efdé
Tables structural pitch.
Structural pitch, absolute extreme values 25 m/s, 20 degr. yaw
Ldcase:
234 234-tt-5+5
234-tr+5-5
234-tt+5
234-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
Extreme Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
7905
7829.3
-1.0
7457.5
-5.7
8063.1
2.0
6645.2
-15.9
Mxb[1]-p[02]
7404.9
7347
-0.8
6993.5
-5.6
7542.1
1.9
6216.8
-16.0
Mxb[1]-p[03]
-1398.3
-1467.7
5.0
-1359.7
-2.8
-1433.8
2.5
-1082.7
-22.6
Mxb[2]-p[01]
8055.9
8891.4
10.4
8321.4
3.3
7632.1
-5.3
6509.1
-19.2
Mxb[2]-p[02]
7560
8333.2
10.2
7817
3.4
7157.9
-5.3
6070.8
-19.7
Mxb[2]-p[03]
-1402.4
-1479.2
5.5
-1467.5
4.6
-1417.8
1.1
-1242.6
-11.4
Mxb[3]-p[01]
7313.5
7444.5
1.8
7761.7
6.1
7439.1
1.7
6781.6
-7.3
Mxb[3]-p[02]
6836.8
6981.1
2.1
7272.6
6.4
6982.1
2.1
6326.2
-7.5
Mxb[3]-p[03]
-1339.2
-1442.1
7.7
-1415.7
5.7
-1489.8
11.2
-1230.2
-8.1
Myb[1]-p[01]
12511
12248
-2.1
12387
-1.0
12536
0.2
12552
0.3
Myb[1]-p[02]
11854
11607
-2.1
11748
-0.9
11871
0.1
11883
0.2
Myb[1]-p[03]
2982.4
3034.2
1.7
3023.4
1.4
3039.8
1.9
2958.6
-0.8
Myb[2]-p[01]
11433
11717
2.5
11577
1.3
11623
1.7
11317
-1.0
Myb[2]-p[02]
10743
11085
3.2
10968
2.1
10997
2.4
10661
-0.8
Myb[2]-p[03]
2669.1
2722.6
2.0
2796.8
4.8
2739.8
2.6
2652.6
-0.6
Myb[3]-p[01]
12280
12552
2.2
12398
1.0
12445
1.3
12259
-0.2
Myb[3]-p[02]
11633
11850
1.9
11710
0.7
11788
1.3
11559
-0.6
Myb[3]-p[03]
2860.6
2908
1.7
2869.4
0.3
2931.1
2.5
2782.8
-2.7
Mxb[1]
8908.3
9552.2
7.2
9172.1
3.0
9305.5
4.5
8542.1
-4.1
Mxb[2]
9757.9
10718
9.8
10142
3.9
9357.3
-4.1
8344.5
-14.5
Mxb[3]
9271.7
9415.5
1.6
9147.8
-1.3
9299.6
0.3
8471.7
-8.6
Myb[1]
11468
11357
-1.0
11783
2.7
11550
0.7
11461
-0.1
Myb[2]
10265
10518
2.5
10552
2.8
10488
2.2
10046
-2.1
Myb[3]
11250
11130
-1.1
11048
-1.8
11300
0.4
10913
-3.0
Tip displ. flap[1]
Tip disp. flap[2]
Tip disp. flap[3]
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
Tip displ. lag[3]
[mm]
-6160.3
-6935.7
-6661.1
3341.6
3481.1
3318
[mm]
-5373.7
-6186.9
-5854
3426.9
3555.9
3207.7
-12.8
-10.8
-12.1
2.6
2.1
-3.3
[mm]
-5512.3
-6174.8
-5876.7
3387.6
3630.8
3197.7
-10.5
-11.0
-11.8
1.4
4.3
-3.6
[mm]
-6042
-6537.1
-6261
3113.6
3233.3
3225.1
-1.9
-5.7
-6.0
-6.8
-7.1
-2.8
[mm]
-6245.2
-6736.1
-6597.8
2657.6
2968.2
2771.4
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 32
1.4
-2.9
-1.0
-20.5
-14.7
-16.5
H. Efdé
Structural pitch, absolute extreme values 12 m/s, 20 degr. yaw
Ldcase:
231 231-tt-5+5
231-tr+5-5
231-tt+5
231-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
-5362.8 -5276.2
-1.6 -5078.4
-5.3 -5391.3
0.5
-5839
8.9
Mxb[1]-p[02]
-4986.8 -4913.6
-1.5 -4728.5
-5.2 -5018.8
0.6 -5440.6
9.1
Mxb[1]-p[03]
-918.24 -927.21
1.0 -898.64
-2.1 -861.81
-6.1
926.54
0.9
Mxb[2]-p[01]
-5305.8
-5551
4.6
-5293
-0.2 -5282.2
-0.4 -5527.1
4.2
Mxb[2]-p[02]
-4932.2 -5173.8
4.9 -4925.5
-0.1 -4924.6
-0.2 -5153.4
4.5
Mxb[2]-p[03]
-953.12
968.63
1.6
878.78
-7.8 -847.63
-11.1
934.87
-1.9
Mxb[3]-p[01]
-5443.8 -5398.3
-0.8 -5119.8
-6.0 -5599.4
2.9 -5500.2
1.0
Mxb[3]-p[02]
-5074 -5033.6
-0.8 -4758.3
-6.2 -5214.7
2.8 -5118.5
0.9
Mxb[3]-p[03]
-889.79 -943.43
6.0 -845.68
-5.0
824.24
-7.4
940.31
5.7
Myb[1]-p[01]
15319
14976
-2.2
14824
-3.2
15635
2.1
15082
-1.5
Myb[1]-p[02]
14536
14221
-2.2
14081
-3.1
14857
2.2
14310
-1.6
Myb[1]-p[03]
4075.7
4104.1
0.7
4053.2
-0.6
4162.1
2.1
3970.4
-2.6
Myb[2]-p[01]
15711
15742
0.2
15980
1.7
16231
3.3
16143
2.7
Myb[2]-p[02]
14925
14965
0.3
15182
1.7
15416
3.3
15318
2.6
Myb[2]-p[03]
3903.5
4079.6
4.5
4113.5
5.4
4102.2
5.1
3896.3
-0.2
Myb[3]-p[01]
15829
15704
-0.8
15477
-2.2
16334
3.2
15990
1.0
Myb[3]-p[02]
15048
14936
-0.7
14714
-2.2
15527
3.2
15200
1.0
Myb[3]-p[03]
4113.6
4199.5
2.1
4184.5
1.7
4232.4
2.9
4115
0.0
Mxb[1]
6377.8
6580.6
3.2
6356.8
-0.3
6598
3.5
6592.7
3.4
Mxb[2]
6624.5
7264.4
9.7
6761.2
2.1
6627.2
0.0
7026.8
6.1
Mxb[3]
6845.2
6556.3
-4.2
6285.1
-8.2
6726.2
-1.7
6500.9
-5.0
Myb[1]
14480
14604
0.9
14537
0.4
15017
3.7
14422
-0.4
Myb[2]
15335
15110
-1.5
15379
0.3
15827
3.2
15278
-0.4
Myb[3]
15228
14982
-1.6
15183
-0.3
15748
3.4
15532
2.0
Tip displ. flap[1]
Tip disp. flap[2]
Tip disp. flap[3]
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
Tip displ. lag[3]
[mm]
8056.3
7654.8
8207.2
-1840.4
-1880.9
-1932.4
[mm]
6601.6
6598.2
6783.5
-2366.1
-2666.8
-2349.1
-18.1
-13.8
-17.3
28.6
41.8
21.6
[mm]
6948.4
6936.3
7187.3
-2270.8
-2483.9
-2224.5
-13.8
-9.4
-12.4
23.4
32.1
15.1
[mm]
7251
7101.9
7504.9
-1782.3
-1781.6
-1779.8
-10.0
-7.2
-8.6
-3.2
-5.3
-7.9
[mm]
7265.7
7247.5
7521.5
-1005.4
-1055.4
-990.88
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 33
-9.8
-5.3
-8.4
-45.4
-43.9
-48.7
H. Efdé
Structural pitch, absolute extreme values 24 m/s
Ldcase:
024
024-tt-5+5
024-tr+5-5
024-tt+5
024-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
6997.9
7212.7
3.1
7017.9
0.3
6915.7
-1.2
6647.6
-5.0
Mxb[1]-p[02]
6525.9
6747.2
3.4
6555.2
0.4
6431.5
-1.4
6222.2
-4.7
Mxb[1]-p[03]
-1616.5
-1647
1.9 -1922.3
18.9
-1699
5.1 -1239.2
-23.3
Mxb[2]-p[01]
7201
7956.7
10.5
7588
5.4
7921.9
10.0
6053.7
-15.9
Mxb[2]-p[02]
6746.8
7408.6
9.8
7061.1
4.7
7452.2
10.5
5638.3
-16.4
Mxb[2]-p[03]
-1416.8 -1611.5
13.7 -1513.9
6.9 -1345.2
-5.1 -1129.6
-20.3
Mxb[3]-p[01]
6908.8
7203.9
4.3
6943.7
0.5
6903.5
-0.1
6741.1
-2.4
Mxb[3]-p[02]
6460.8
6716.3
4.0
6468.3
0.1
6475.5
0.2
6297.7
-2.5
Mxb[3]-p[03]
-1482.5 -1548.3
4.4 -1360.9
-8.2
-1352
-8.8 -1125.4
-24.1
Myb[1]-p[01]
12224
12331
0.9
12199
-0.2
12574
2.9
12292
0.6
Myb[1]-p[02]
11555
11661
0.9
11542
-0.1
11877
2.8
11618
0.5
Myb[1]-p[03]
2791.3
2805.8
0.5
2836.8
1.6
2858.9
2.4
2805
0.5
Myb[2]-p[01]
10504
11031
5.0
10868
3.5
10525
0.2
10620
1.1
Myb[2]-p[02]
9963.4
10387
4.3
10240
2.8
9907.1
-0.6
9995.5
0.3
Myb[2]-p[03]
2452.4
2446.7
-0.2
2429.5
-0.9
2521.9
2.8
2442.8
-0.4
Myb[3]-p[01]
13315
13650
2.5
13550
1.8
13453
1.0
12993
-2.4
Myb[3]-p[02]
12614
12922
2.4
12842
1.8
12730
0.9
12302
-2.5
Myb[3]-p[03]
3206.1
3286.3
2.5
3273.9
2.1
3216.8
0.3
3087.2
-3.7
Mxb[1]
9196
9044.4
-1.6
9227.4
0.3
9044.6
-1.6
8427.9
-8.4
Mxb[2]
8502.2
8522.7
0.2
8393.3
-1.3
9011.9
6.0
7424.6
-12.7
Mxb[3]
8908.8
9455.5
6.1
9113.3
2.3
8827.7
-0.9
8416
-5.5
Myb[1]
10582
10714
1.2
10783
1.9
11061
4.5
10800
2.1
Myb[2]
10421
10142
-2.7
10771
3.4
9949
-4.5
10255
-1.6
Myb[3]
12338
12647
2.5
12666
2.7
12515
1.4
11713
-5.1
Tip displ. flap[1]
Tip disp. flap[2]
Tip disp. flap[3]
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
Tip displ. lag[3]
[mm]
-4693.9
-5316.8
5221.3
2920.3
2936.3
-2929.4
[mm]
-4113.1
-4915.5
4146
-3010.4
2969.6
-3208.2
-12.4
-7.5
-20.6
3.1
1.1
9.5
[mm]
-4199.2
-4776.2
4352.7
-2977.8
2935
-3114.9
-10.5
-10.2
-16.6
2.0
0.0
6.3
[mm]
-4510.4
-5266.9
-4623.7
2855.6
2844.2
-2818.2
-3.9
-0.9
-11.4
-2.2
-3.1
-3.8
[mm]
-4780
-5301.8
4742.6
2437.7
2498.8
2238
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 34
1.8
-0.3
-9.2
-16.5
-14.9
-23.6
H. Efdé
Ldcase:
018
018-tt-5+5
018-tr+5-5
018-tt+5
018-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
5701.6
5978.9
4.9
6094
6.9
5828.4
2.2
5503.8
-3.5
Mxb[1]-p[02]
5294.6
5557.3
5.0
5670.1
7.1
5428
2.5
5121.2
-3.3
Mxb[1]-p[03]
-1090.5 -1283.5
17.7 -1229.4
12.7 -1185.2
8.7
-1005.1
-7.8
Mxb[2]-p[01]
5614.8
5856.3
4.3
5665.4
0.9
5663.3
0.9
5292.1
-5.7
Mxb[2]-p[02]
5228.1
5463.5
4.5
5265.5
0.7
5270.9
0.8
4937
-5.6
Mxb[2]-p[03]
-1117 -1325.6
18.7 -1263.8
13.1 -1208.5
8.2
-970.26 -13.1
Mxb[3]-p[01]
5644.8
5802.1
2.8
5883.2
4.2
5866.6
3.9
5430.7
-3.8
Mxb[3]-p[02]
5253.9
5391.5
2.6
5491.2
4.5
5473.2
4.2
5057.2
-3.7
Mxb[3]-p[03]
-1187.8 -1284.7
8.2 -1194.6
0.6 -1216.4
2.4
-957.22 -19.4
Myb[1]-p[01]
12945
13780
6.5
13205
2.0
13092
1.1
13221
2.1
Myb[1]-p[02]
12268
13070
6.5
12520
2.1
12412
1.2
12537
2.2
Myb[1]-p[03]
3025.4
3334.6
10.2
3090
2.1
3078
1.7
3135.7
3.6
Myb[2]-p[01]
11921
12086
1.4
12251
2.8
11978
0.5
12262
2.9
Myb[2]-p[02]
11325
11480
1.4
11620
2.6
11320
0.0
11583
2.3
Myb[2]-p[03]
2806.7
2775.1
-1.1
2823.5
0.6
2816.4
0.3
2796.4
-0.4
Myb[3]-p[01]
14220
14712
3.5
14541
2.3
14340
0.8
14020
-1.4
Myb[3]-p[02]
13474
13972
3.7
13782
2.3
13621
1.1
13305
-1.3
Myb[3]-p[03]
3547.3
3612.7
1.8
3629.4
2.3
3600.5
1.5
3462.3
-2.4
Mxb[1]
7409.6
8071.7
8.9
7781.2
5.0
7499.1
1.2
7603
2.6
Mxb[2]
7753.8
7606.6
-1.9
7574.4
-2.3
7788.7
0.5
7294.7
-5.9
Mxb[3]
8447
8654.8
2.5
8730.9
3.4
8547.5
1.2
8040.7
-4.8
Myb[1]
11574
12281
6.1
11801
2.0
11692
1.0
11877
2.6
Myb[2]
11453
11685
2.0
11564
1.0
11548
0.8
11437
-0.1
Myb[3]
12939
13270
2.6
13214
2.1
12778
-1.2
12580
-2.8
[mm]
Tip displ. flap[1] 4956.8
Tip disp. flap[2] 4733.9
Tip displ. lag[1] -2424.9
[mm]
4310.1
3561
4945.3
-2988.8
-2512.9
-3320.6
-13.0
-24.8
-20.1
23.3
8.8
12.4
[mm]
4181
3815.2
5318.5
-2754.6
-2503
-3246.6
-15.7
-19.4
-14.0
13.6
8.4
9.9
[mm]
4413.9
4151.6
5533.5
-2266.6
-2196.4
-2797.2
-11.0
-12.3
-10.6
-6.5
-4.9
-5.4
[mm]
4867.6
4439.1
5574.9
-1585
-1313.4
-1819.3
-1.8
-6.2
-9.9
-34.6
-43.1
-38.4
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 35
H. Efdé
Ldcase:
012
012-tt-5+5
012-tr+5-5
012-tt+5
012-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
-5368.8
-5577.8
3.9
-5191.9
-3.3
-5389
0.4
-5519
2.8
Mxb[1]-p[02]
-5001.4
-5202.4
4.0
-4833.9
-3.3 -5030.2
0.6
-5128
2.5
Mxb[1]-p[03]
-963.21
-1004.3
4.3
-856.44
-11.1
871.03
-9.6
977.98
1.5
Mxb[2]-p[01]
-5234.2
-5378
2.7
-5087.7
-2.8 -5225.1
-0.2
-5631
7.6
Mxb[2]-p[02]
-4859
-5008.5
3.1
-4729.7
-2.7 -4862.8
0.1
-5242
7.9
Mxb[2]-p[03]
-875.11
-955.24
9.2
-944.76
8.0 -947.97
8.3
864.32
-1.2
Mxb[3]-p[01]
-5448.6
-5583.2
2.5
-5294.3
-2.8 -5666.8
4.0
-5769.5
5.9
Mxb[3]-p[02]
-5073.6
-5202.6
2.5
-4924.7
-2.9 -5283.7
4.1
-5375.6
6.0
Mxb[3]-p[03]
-975.92
-1029.7
5.5
-861.03
-11.8 -947.64
-2.9
1028.2
5.4
Myb[1]-p[01]
15535
15645
0.7
16064
3.4
15643
0.7
16104
3.7
Myb[1]-p[02]
14788
14883
0.6
15288
3.4
14890
0.7
15304
3.5
Myb[1]-p[03]
4081
4081
0.0
4192.6
2.7
4101.1
0.5
4111.3
0.7
Myb[2]-p[01]
15918
15964
0.3
15866
-0.3
16188
1.7
15043
-5.5
Myb[2]-p[02]
15132
15176
0.3
15082
-0.3
15382
1.7
14306
-5.5
Myb[2]-p[03]
4080
4150.1
1.7
4174.2
2.3
4124
1.1
3946.4
-3.3
Myb[3]-p[01]
16353
16726
2.3
16082
-1.7
16698
2.1
16221
-0.8
Myb[3]-p[02]
15541
15898
2.3
15292
-1.6
15875
2.1
15416
-0.8
Myb[3]-p[03]
4141.9
4290.7
3.6
4276.1
3.2
4283.5
3.4
4163.5
0.5
Mxb[1]
7067.3
6781.8
-4.0
6662
-5.7
6953
-1.6
7018.8
-0.7
Mxb[2]
6716.6
6641.4
-1.1
6596.9
-1.8
6778.8
0.9
6792.1
1.1
Mxb[3]
7026.3
6927.4
-1.4
6800.2
-3.2
6941.7
-1.2
6834
-2.7
Myb[1]
15002
15201
1.3
15147
1.0
15164
1.1
15173
1.1
Myb[2]
15151
15090
-0.4
14860
-1.9
15335
1.2
14357
-5.2
Myb[3]
15356
15701
2.2
15326
-0.2
15725
2.4
15163
-1.3
[mm]
Tip displ. flap[1] 8265.7
[mm]
6650.7
6746.7
7180.2
-2583.6
-2655.2
-2545.9
-19.5
-16.9
-13.7
27.8
34.8
22.4
[mm]
7244.1
7129.8
7418.9
-2530.1
-2512.8
-2475.7
-12.4
-12.2
-10.9
25.1
27.6
19.0
[mm]
7241.6
7238
7533.7
-1936.7
-1920.3
-1923.1
-12.4
-10.9
-9.5
-4.2
-2.5
-7.6
[mm]
7295.6
7005
7348.3
-1074.5
-1144.4
-1078.8
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 36
-11.7
-13.7
-11.7
-46.9
-41.9
-48.1
H. Efdé
Ldcase:
008
008-tt-5+5
008-tr+5-5
008-tt+5
008-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Extreme in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
-4943.8
-4917.3
-0.5 -4865.6
-1.6 -5005.8
1.3
-5679.2
14.9
Mxb[1]-p[02]
-4592
-4571.5
-0.4 -4525.2
-1.5 -4652.9
1.3
-5300.7
15.4
Mxb[1]-p[03]
-733.42
831.01
13.3
738.12
0.6 -714.13
-2.6
-912.45
24.4
Mxb[2]-p[01]
-4819.9
-5085.7
5.5 -4908.7
1.8
-4859
0.8
-5363.1
11.3
Mxb[2]-p[02]
-4481.6
-4726.2
5.5 -4559.7
1.7 -4515.8
0.8
-4994.7
11.4
Mxb[2]-p[03]
-737.57
-780.42
5.8 -746.51
1.2 -717.57
-2.7
-856.58
16.1
Mxb[3]-p[01]
-5015.9
-4986.4
-0.6 -4854.1
-3.2
-4846
-3.4
-5639.1
12.4
Mxb[3]-p[02]
-4667.3
-4638.5
-0.6 -4510.7
-3.4 -4499.1
-3.6
-5260.2
12.7
Mxb[3]-p[03]
713.45
-739.6
3.7 -698.14
-2.1 -709.31
-0.6
-899.04
26.0
Myb[1]-p[01]
11820
12200
3.2
12294
4.0
12229
3.5
11819
0.0
Myb[1]-p[02]
11236
11598
3.2
11690
4.0
11620
3.4
11229
-0.1
Myb[1]-p[03]
3095.2
3181
2.8
3208.6
3.7 3161.8
2.2
3083.1
-0.4
Myb[2]-p[01]
11803
11892
0.8
11839
0.3
11870
0.6
11792
-0.1
Myb[2]-p[02]
11224
11309
0.8
11263
0.3
11296
0.6
11216
-0.1
Myb[2]-p[03]
3137.7
3153
0.5
3154
0.5 3193.2
1.8
3130.5
-0.2
Myb[3]-p[01]
11709
11768
0.5
11817
0.9
11741
0.3
11738
0.2
Myb[3]-p[02]
11140
11197
0.5
11234
0.8
11164
0.2
11173
0.3
Myb[3]-p[03]
3158.3
3218.7
1.9
3231.9
2.3 3225.2
2.1
3179.6
0.7
Mxb[1]
5437.3
6151.4
13.1
5773
6.2 5406.1
-0.6
5901.9
8.5
Mxb[2]
5457.4
5819.4
6.6
5561.4
1.9 5435.7
-0.4
5688.1
4.2
Mxb[3]
5478.2
5615.9
2.5
5391.6
-1.6 5426.9
-0.9
5882.1
7.4
Myb[1]
10962
11339
3.4
11439
4.4
11395
4.0
10961
0.0
Myb[2]
10964
10893
-0.6
10845
-1.1
11024
0.5
10877
-0.8
Myb[3]
10845
11256
3.8
11411
5.2
11212
3.4
10736
-1.0
Tip displ. flap[1]
Tip disp. flap[2]
Tip disp. flap[3]
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
Tip displ. lag[3]
[mm]
5665.5
5707.8
5883.2
-1453
-1533.2
-1399.3
[mm]
4770.6
4686.8
4878.7
-2150.7
-2122.1
-2037.2
-15.8
-17.9
-17.1
48.0
38.4
45.6
[mm]
5054.7
4905.3
5041.8
-2025.8
-1997.3
-1907.2
[mm]
-10.8 5050.5
-14.1 5058.6
-14.3 5193.5
39.4 -1420.7
30.3 -1428.2
36.3 -1396.4
-10.9
-11.4
-11.7
-2.2
-6.8
-0.2
[mm]
5205.5
5063.5
5194.6
-703.18
-686.96
-689.7
-8.1
-11.3
-11.7
-51.6
-55.2
-50.7
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 37
H. Efdé
Structural pitch, 1 Hz equivalent values 24 m/s
Ldcase
024
024-tt-5+5
024-tr+5-5
024-tt+5
024-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
in %
in %
in %
in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01] 8327.1
8389.2
0.7
8278.1
-0.6
8401.7
0.9
7328.9 -12.0
Mxb[1]-p[02] 7763.9
7807.0
0.6
7700.1
-0.8
7828.8
0.8
6805.8 -12.3
Mxb[1]-p[03] 1586.5
1657.1
4.4
1650.3
4.0
1641.6
3.5
1371.1 -13.6
Mxb[2]-p[01] 8169.9
8414.3
3.0
8169.9
0.0
8253.8
1.0
7179.3 -12.1
Mxb[2]-p[02] 7616.7
7828.8
2.8
7585.9
-0.4
7721.3
1.4
6668.6 -12.4
Mxb[2]-p[03] 1501.0
1710.0
13.9
1611.5
7.4
1587.0
5.7
1297.7 -13.5
Mxb[3]-p[01] 7995.7
8217.6
2.8
8064.4
0.9
7984.3
-0.1
7197.6 -10.0
Mxb[3]-p[02] 7435.5
7647.8
2.9
7485.0
0.7
7445.3
0.1
6692.4 -10.0
Mxb[3]-p[03] 1500.2
1584.7
5.6
1519.6
1.3
1537.5
2.5
1286.7 -14.2
Myb[1]-p[01] 8426.9
8426.9
0.0
8452.2
0.3
8647.1
2.6
8414.3
-0.1
Myb[1]-p[02] 8007.0
8018.5
0.1
8052.9
0.6
8205.6
2.5
7973.0
-0.4
Myb[1]-p[03] 2206.3
2223.7
0.8
2227.3
1.0
2340.3
6.1
2250.4
2.0
Myb[2]-p[01] 8339.4
8439.5
1.2
8401.7
0.7
8529.1
2.3
8229.6
-1.3
Myb[2]-p[02] 7928.0
8052.9
1.6
8018.5
1.1
8041.4
1.4
7807.0
-1.5
Myb[2]-p[03] 2098.5
2207.2
5.2
2148.2
2.4
2208.0
5.2
2156.4
2.8
Myb[3]-p[01] 8823.5
8949.8
1.4
8851.2
0.3
8893.2
0.8
8782.1
-0.5
Myb[3]-p[02] 8414.3
8503.3
1.1
8439.5
0.3
8477.7
0.8
8376.7
-0.4
Myb[3]-p[03] 2303.0
2363.9
2.6
2360.9
2.5
2381.9
3.4
2254.0
-2.1
Mxb[1]
8837.3
8851.2
0.2
8837.3
0.0
8949.8
1.3
8029.9
-9.1
Mxb[2]
8660.4
8741.2
0.9
8529.1
-1.5
8660.4
0.0
7796.2 -10.0
Mxb[3]
8503.3
8782.1
3.3
8660.4
1.8
8529.1
0.3
7961.7
-6.4
Myb[1]
7894.7
7916.9
0.3
7807.0
-1.1
7950.5
0.7
7679.1
-2.7
Myb[2]
7872.6
7995.7
1.6
8052.9
2.3
8041.4
2.1
7928.0
0.7
Myb[3]
8426.9
8376.7
-0.6
8327.1
-1.2
8741.2
3.7
8217.6
-2.5
Material M10 K100
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 38
H. Efdé
Ldcase
018
018-tt-5+5
018-tr+5-5
018-tt+5
018-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
in %
in %
in %
in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01] 7097.7
7455.2
5.0
7179.3
1.1
7206.9
1.5
6708.4
-5.5
Mxb[1]-p[02] 6567.4
6931.5
5.5
6660.7
1.4
6652.8
1.3
6232.6
-5.1
Mxb[1]-p[03] 1235.6
1404.0
13.6
1267.6
2.6
1315.9
6.5
1129.6
-8.6
Mxb[2]-p[01] 7018.0
7396.4
5.4
7151.9
1.9
7062.1
0.6
6676.5
-4.9
Mxb[2]-p[02] 6499.1
6855.5
5.5
6652.8
2.4
6521.7
0.3
6198.3
-4.6
Mxb[2]-p[03] 1237.8
1384.3
11.8
1315.0
6.2
1274.8
3.0
1098.9 -11.2
Mxb[3]-p[01] 6974.5
7348.1
5.4
7097.7
1.8
7071.0
1.4
6582.8
-5.6
Mxb[3]-p[02] 6424.9
6822.3
6.2
6590.5
2.6
6552.1
2.0
6084.3
-5.3
Mxb[3]-p[03] 1204.9
1321.2
9.7
1251.8
3.9
1254.3
4.1
1085.4
-9.9
Myb[1]-p[01] 7035.6
7357.7
4.6
7197.6
2.3
7000.6
-0.5
7044.4
0.1
Myb[1]-p[02] 6676.5
7009.3
5.0
6855.5
2.7
6668.6
-0.1
6629.3
-0.7
Myb[1]-p[03] 1735.3
1820.7
4.9
1787.1
3.0
1802.0
3.8
1752.6
1.0
Myb[2]-p[01] 6847.2
6830.5
-0.2
6855.5
0.1
6897.6
0.7
6789.3
-0.8
Myb[2]-p[02] 6499.1
6506.6
0.1
6499.1
0.0
6552.1
0.8
6388.4
-1.7
Myb[2]-p[03] 1740.7
1698.1
-2.4
1749.9
0.5
1773.6
1.9
1735.8
-0.3
Myb[3]-p[01] 7319.4
7504.9
2.5
7357.7
0.5
7328.9
0.1
7234.7
-1.2
Myb[3]-p[02] 6983.2
7161.0
2.5
7009.3
0.4
6983.2
0.0
6880.7
-1.5
Myb[3]-p[03] 1801.4
1877.2
4.2
1871.6
3.9
1883.5
4.6
1800.3
-0.1
Mxb[1]
7494.9
7839.7
4.6
7596.2
1.4
7585.9
1.2
7290.9
-2.7
Mxb[2]
7406.1
7721.3
4.3
7545.2
1.9
7465.1
0.8
7133.7
-3.7
Mxb[3]
7485.0
7817.9
4.4
7575.7
1.2
7637.4
2.0
7124.7
-4.8
Myb[1]
6476.6
6847.2
5.7
6575.0
1.5
6582.8
1.6
6446.9
-0.5
Myb[2]
6309.5
6439.6
2.1
6446.9
2.2
6316.6
0.1
6395.6
1.4
Myb[3]
6692.4
6740.5
0.7
6863.9
2.6
6732.4
0.6
6469.2
-3.3
Material M10 K100
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 39
H. Efdé
Ldcase
012
012-tt-5+5
012-tr+5-5
012-tt+5
012-tt+5-5
Change
Change
Change
Change
in %
in %
in %
in %
Variable
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
[kNm]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
6590.5
6740.5
2.3
6499.1
-1.4 6521.7
-1.0
6684.4
1.4
Mxb[1]-p[02]
6097.5
6239.5
2.3
6000.0
-1.6 6025.7
-1.2
6177.9
1.3
Mxb[1]-p[03]
1109.6
1119.1
0.9
1067.9
-3.8 1096.4
-1.2
1149.0
3.6
Mxb[2]-p[01]
6514.1
6708.4
3.0
6529.3
0.2 6514.1
0.0
6660.7
2.2
Mxb[2]-p[02]
6025.7
6198.3
2.9
6006.4
-0.3 6000.0
-0.4
6171.1
2.4
Mxb[2]-p[03]
1082.2
1114.2
3.0
1061.4
-1.9 1084.5
0.2
1121.1
3.6
Mxb[3]-p[01]
6559.7
6740.5
2.8
6491.6
-1.0 6575.0
0.2
6684.4
1.9
Mxb[3]-p[02]
6064.6
6218.9
2.5
5987.2
-1.3 6071.2
0.1
6184.7
2.0
Mxb[3]-p[03]
1109.6
1130.8
1.9
1069.7
-3.6 1099.4
-0.9
1165.4
5.0
Myb[1]-p[01]
7079.9
7445.3
5.2
7475.0
5.6 6914.5
-2.3
7071.0
-0.1
Myb[1]-p[02]
6748.6
7026.8
4.1
7124.7
5.6 6590.5
-2.3
6740.5
-0.1
Myb[1]-p[03]
1758.6
1852.4
5.3
1910.3
8.6 1809.5
2.9
1757.0
-0.1
Myb[2]-p[01]
7097.7
7253.3
2.2
7151.9
0.8 7124.7
0.4
6645.0
-6.4
Myb[2]-p[02]
6748.6
6880.7
2.0
6797.5
0.7 6797.5
0.7
6302.5
-6.6
Myb[2]-p[03]
1810.1
1839.7
1.6
1809.0
-0.1 1843.9
1.9
1743.4
-3.7
Myb[3]-p[01]
6637.1
7044.4
6.1
7197.6
8.4 6897.6
3.9
6830.5
2.9
Myb[3]-p[02]
6302.5
6700.4
6.3
6781.1
7.6 6575.0
4.3
6499.1
3.1
Myb[3]-p[03]
1692.0
1807.2
6.8
1831.3
8.2 1732.1
2.4
1708.9
1.0
Mxb[1]
6906.0
7088.8
2.6
6872.3
-0.5 6906.0
0.0
7044.4
2.0
Mxb[2]
6897.6
7079.9
2.6
6948.7
0.7 6872.3
-0.4
7018.0
1.7
Mxb[3]
6940.1
7097.7
2.3
6872.3
-1.0 6906.0
-0.5
7035.6
1.4
Myb[1]
6373.9
6708.4
5.2
6567.4
3.0 6446.9
1.1
6432.2
0.9
Myb[2]
6432.2
6506.6
1.2
6424.9
-0.1 6484.1
0.8
6090.9
-5.3
Myb[3]
6084.3
6281.4
3.2
6373.9
4.8 6191.5
1.8
6218.9
2.2
Material M10 K100
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 40
Appendix E.
H. Efdé
Tables tower frequencies
Tower frequencies, absolute extreme values 1B-5Vo
Variable
unit
Fxn
kN
baseline
754.16
_150
715.38
%
-5.14
_175
678.37
-10.05
682.74
-9.47
743.98
-1.35
740.90
-1.76
701.44
-6.99
692.38
-8.19
687.82
-8.80
Fyn
kN
226.72
223.38
-1.47
188.32
-16.94
436.98
92.74
263.39 16.17
197.56
-12.86
211.77
-6.59
197.62
-12.84
217.80
-3.93
Fzn
kN
-972.67
-980.39
0.79
-959.43
-1.36
-973.42
0.08
-984.76
1.24
-973.42
0.08
-1006.50
3.48
-1038.10
6.73
-1034.30
6.34
Mxn
kNm
7399.00
7138.90
-3.52
7427.00
0.38
7352.90
-0.62
7327.40
-0.97
7337.40
-0.83
7436.60
0.51
7343.40
-0.75
7312.60
-1.17
Mxn-r
kNm
7411.90
7153.10
-3.49
7442.90
0.42
7367.60
-0.60
7341.70
-0.95
7349.90
-0.84
7449.70
0.51
7354.10
-0.78
7322.90
-1.20
Myn
kNm
-10044.00
-10407.00
3.61
-10337.00
2.92
-9656.60
-3.86
-10097.00
0.53
-10181.00
1.36
-10692.00
6.45
-11246.00
11.97
-10992.00
9.44
Myn-r
kNm
-10694.00
-10271.00
-3.96
-9869.70
-7.71
-10354.00
-3.18
-10862.00
1.57
-10779.00
0.79
-10607.00
-0.81
-10403.00
-2.72
-10458.00
-2.21
Mzn
kNm
-10830.00
11759.00
8.58
11422.00
5.47
11969.00
10.52
11242.00
3.80
-10831.00
0.01
11144.00
2.90
11036.00
1.90
11043.00
1.97
Mzn-r
kNm
-11132.00
-12245.00
10.00
-12469.00
12.01
-12945.00
16.29
-11609.00
4.28
-10953.00
-1.61
-10998.00
-1.20
-11128.00
-0.04
-11389.00
2.31
Mxb[1]
kNm
8565.80
7775.00
-9.23
8209.50
-4.16
8186.30
-4.43
8518.60
-0.55
8459.90
-1.24
8136.10
-5.02
7340.30
-14.31
7388.20
-13.75
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-5831.90
-5508.60
-5.54
-5224.90
-10.41
-5251.50
-9.95
5776.40
-0.95
-5841.80
0.17
-5823.90
-0.14
-5653.20
-3.06
-5718.60
-1.94
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1655.80
1342.00
-18.95
1470.50
-11.19
1505.30
-9.09
1692.30
2.20
1658.10
0.14
1645.60
-0.62
1543.60
-6.78
1594.50
-3.70
Mxb[2]
kNm
9271.40
10001.00
7.87
9599.40
3.54
8864.00
-4.39
9077.10
-2.10
9206.70
-0.70
9385.10
1.23
9491.60
2.38
9423.10
1.64
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
-5266.30
-5678.80
7.83
-5604.40
6.42
-5426.50
3.04
-5183.60
-1.57
-5312.40
0.88
-5607.90
6.49
-5574.30
5.85
-5565.80
5.69
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-1134.90
-1316.00
15.96
-1318.20
16.15
-1315.00
15.87
-1209.90
6.61
-1134.60
-0.03
-1234.10
8.74
-1289.60
13.63
-1264.60
11.43
Mxb[3]
kNm
6321.20
5988.90
-5.26
6064.90
-4.05
6099.00
-3.52
6058.00
-4.16
6384.50
1.00
6444.80
1.96
6369.80
0.77
6412.20
1.44
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-6438.30
-5143.60
-20.11
-5088.60
-20.96
-5987.40
-7.00
-6442.90
0.07
-6459.50
0.33
-6622.50
2.86
-6185.40
-3.93
-6236.90
-3.13
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-1569.00
1181.00
-24.73
-1209.80
-22.89
-1449.90
-7.59
-1569.90
0.06
-1564.00
-0.32
-1597.50
1.82
-1582.00
0.83
-1585.30
1.04
Myb[1]
kNm
7783.60
7472.70
-3.99
7132.60
-8.36
8002.60
2.81
7633.50
-1.93
7831.80
0.62
7700.80
-1.06
8174.40
5.02
8207.20
5.44
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
9875.40
8747.30
-11.42
9107.00
-7.78
9146.90
-7.38
9784.00
-0.93
9808.80
-0.67
9495.90
-3.84
8918.50
-9.69
8839.90
-10.49
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1858.10
-1844.6
-0.73
-1806
-2.80
1792.20
-3.55
1897.90
2.14
1853.50
-0.25
1798.80
-3.19
1583.60
-14.77
1595.50
-14.13
Myb[2]
kNm
13858.00
13011.00
-6.11
12895.00
-6.95
12989.00
-6.27
14015.00
1.13
13747.00
-0.80
13488.00
-2.67
13235.00
-4.50
13234.00
-4.50
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
15152.00
14240.00
-6.02
14457.00
-4.59
14548.00
-3.99
15166.00
0.09
14994.00
-1.04
14865.00
-1.89
14752.00
-2.64
14711.00
-2.91
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
4004.70
3772.20
-5.81
3764.60
-6.00
3950.70
-1.35
3997.80
-0.17
3990.70
-0.35
3905.30
-2.48
3995.60
-0.23
3970.80
-0.85
Myb[3]
kNm
8487.10
8577.80
1.07
8948.90
5.44
8925.30
5.16
8496.30
0.11
8380.80
-1.25
8065.30
-4.97
7992.40
-5.83
8079.90
-4.80
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
8286.80
8309.10
0.27
8394.20
1.30
8224.40
-0.75
8237.10
-0.60
8347.90
0.74
8245.20
-0.50
8324.50
0.45
8339.50
0.64
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
2065.60
1909.20
-7.57
2003.50
-3.01
1997.90
-3.28
2092.50
1.30
2084.80
0.93
2007.80
-2.80
2014.10
-2.49
2020.60
-2.18
Mzb[1]
kNm
-200.46
-178.76
-10.83
-206.11
2.82
-193.68
-3.38
-198.13
-1.16
-199.48
-0.49
-198.99
-0.73
-203.78
1.66
-202.49
1.01
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-200.50
-178.80
-10.82
-206.16
2.82
-193.73
-3.38
-198.17
-1.16
-199.52
-0.49
-199.04
-0.73
-203.81
1.65
-202.53
1.01
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-122.62
-118.85
-3.07
-128.79
5.03
-124.19
1.28
-121.77
-0.69
-123.42
0.65
-123.65
0.84
-127.88
4.29
-126.74
3.36
Mzb[2]
kNm
106.43
109.61
2.99
117.50
10.40
120.99
13.68
107.38
0.89
105.76
-0.63
103.69
-2.57
101.05
-5.05
99.66
-6.36
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
106.26
109.49
3.04
117.34
10.43
120.83
13.71
107.20
0.88
105.60
-0.62
103.52
-2.58
100.93
-5.02
99.51
-6.35
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-78.21
-74.74
-4.44
-79.65
1.84
-87.22
11.52
-77.38
-1.06
-75.76
-3.13
-74.64
-4.56
-72.32
-7.53
-71.43
-8.67
Mzb[3]
kNm
-193.56
-149.21
-22.91
-153.14
-20.88
-177.91
-8.09
-186.62
-3.59
-196.89
1.72
-200.48
3.58
-202.63
4.69
-197.86
2.22
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-193.60
-149.25
-22.91
-153.17
-20.88
-177.94
-8.09
-186.65
-3.59
-196.93
1.72
-200.51
3.57
-202.67
4.68
-197.91
2.23
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-126.19
-113.98
-9.68
-116.55
-7.64
-125.60
-0.47
-123.40
-2.21
-121.46
-3.75
-120.83
-4.25
-124.85
-1.06
-121.78
-3.49
Mxt[01]
kNm
65292.00
67397.00
3.22
51518.00
73534.00 12.62
56468.00
-13.51
54254.00
-16.91
45858.00
-29.76
52650.00
-19.36
Mxt[02]
kNm
7840.50
8070.60
2.93
7769.00
-0.91
9177.60
17.05
7696.60
-1.84
7550.70
-3.70
7440.50
-5.10
7604.10
-3.02
7673.00
-2.14
Myt[02]
kNm
-10690.00
-11453.00
7.14
-11188.00
4.66
-10710.00
0.19
-10970.00
2.62
-10985.00
2.76
-11473.00
7.32
-12573.00
17.61
-12207.00
14.19
Myt[01]
kNm
132960.00 112660.01
-15.27 107310.01
-19.29
99828.01
-4.39 107120.01
-19.43
81547.00
-38.67
85959.01
-35.35
Mzt[01]
kNm
-12024.00
11476.00
-4.56
11000.00
-8.52
11943.00
-0.67
-12076.00
0.43
-12216.00
1.60
-11847.00
-1.47
-11456.00
-4.72
-11412.00
-5.09
Mzt[02]
kNm
-12024.00
11476.00
-4.56
11000.00
-8.52
11943.00
-0.67
-12076.00
0.43
-12216.00
1.60
-11847.00
-1.47
-11456.00
-4.72
-11412.00
-5.09
Tip displ. flap[1]
mm
-4645.10
-5139.10
10.63
-5059.70
8.93
-4525.30
-2.58
-4445.30
-4.30
-4596.10
-1.05
-4663.70
0.40
-4767.70
2.64
-4897.10
5.43
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
6194.50
5754.60
-7.10
5584.70
-9.84
5930.10
-4.27
6132.60
-1.00
6201.40
0.11
6018.90
-2.83
6078.20
-1.88
6030.10
-2.65
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-5266.10
-4530.00
-13.98
-4441.30
-15.66
-4996.90
-5.11
-5258.10
-0.15
-5184.30
-1.55
-5075.60
-3.62
-4935.30
-6.28
-4953.70
-5.93
Tip displ. lag[1]
mm
2729.60
3390.20
24.20
3390.50
24.21
2974.70
8.98
2814.00
3.09
2680.50
-1.80
2399.00
-12.11
2537.30
-7.04
2490.30
-8.77
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
-3111.70
-3229.80
3.80
-3191.00
2.55
-3162.40
1.63
-3102.30
-0.30
-3129.00
0.56
-3068.00
-1.40
-3080.20
-1.01
-3052.70
-1.90
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
2500.40
2536.20
1.43
1980.30
-20.80
2176.30
-12.96
2445.10
-2.21
2479.70
-0.83
2629.60
5.17
2692.70
7.69
2696.70
7.85
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
1288.40
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
-722.62
2606.90 102.34
0.00
-1646.60 127.87
%
_200
46.94
1380.80
_250
7.17
-2599.60 259.75
%
-3.40 127120.01
0.00
0.00
36.36
%
-24.92 128440.01
0.00
0.00
-985.35
_225
-21.10 178530.02 173.43
0.00
1893.20
%
1442.50 11.96
0.00
-900.77 24.65
_300
0.00
1148.10
_350
0.00
-10.89
0.00
-584.96
%
735.00
-347.12
_400
0.00
-42.95
0.00
-19.05
%
276.92
0.00
-78.51
0.00
-51.96
-210.68
%
321.29
-70.84
-256.03
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
-75.06
0.00
page 41
-64.57
H. Efdé
Tower frequencies, absolute extreme values EcdVrb
Variable
unit
Fxn
kN
baseline
1083.70
_150
1059.60
%
-2.22
_175
1073.70
-0.92
1055.20
-2.63
1082.50
-0.11
1083.70
0.00
1082.40
-0.12
1078.50
-0.48
1078.70
-0.46
Fyn
kN
345.01
316.22
-8.34
311.03
-9.85
330.86
-4.10
297.51
-13.77
318.21
-7.77
346.30
0.37
254.83
-26.14
261.81
-24.12
Fzn
kN
-972.91
-921.30
-5.30
-916.47
-5.80
-919.89
-5.45
-931.19
-4.29
-924.70
-4.96
-919.82
-5.46
-910.72
-6.39
-910.59
-6.41
Mxn
kNm
6606.60
6608.30
0.03
6597.00
-0.15
6585.10
-0.33
6617.70
0.17
6598.40
-0.12
6647.90
0.63
6627.30
0.31
6631.90
0.38
Mxn-r
kNm
6611.40
6612.80
0.02
6601.50
-0.15
6589.40
-0.33
6622.50
0.17
6603.00
-0.13
6653.00
0.63
6632.50
0.32
6636.90
0.39
Myn
kNm
-19807.00
-17094.00
-13.70
-16932.00
-14.52
-15711.00
-20.68
-15883.00
-19.81
-16133.00
-18.55
-16024.00
-19.10
-16268.00
-17.87
-16317.00
-17.62
Myn-r
kNm
17780.00
16574.00
-6.78
17085.00
-3.91
15044.00
-15.39
15070.00
-15.24
15286.00
-14.03
15273.00
-14.10
15372.00
-13.54
15321.00
-13.83
Mzn
kNm
-11417.00
-12350.00
8.17
-12305.00
7.78
-12025.00
5.33
-12064.00
5.67
-12095.00
5.94
-11859.00
3.87
-11915.00
4.36
-11785.00
3.22
Mzn-r
kNm
-19443.00
-16518.00
-15.04
-16943.00
-12.86
-17637.00
-9.29
-17678.00
-9.08
-17746.00
-8.73
-17633.00
-9.31
-17758.00
-8.67
-17840.00
-8.24
Mxb[1]
kNm
5973.50
7010.30
17.36
6252.10
4.66
5910.80
-1.05
6189.70
3.62
6045.10
1.20
5701.10
-4.56
6014.50
0.69
5996.20
0.38
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
8724.70
9795.80
12.28
9585.70
9.87
8957.60
2.67
9707.50
11.26
9317.00
6.79
8789.00
0.74
8976.50
2.89
8953.80
2.63
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
2316.70
2492.70
7.60
2461.90
6.27
2271.50
-1.95
2490.10
7.48
2365.10
2.09
2337.60
0.90
2374.80
2.51
2361.60
1.94
Mxb[2]
kNm
7662.00
6491.30
-15.28
6569.40
-14.26
6554.30
-14.46
6630.60
-13.46
6634.80
-13.41
6639.30
-13.35
6615.10
-13.66
6617.00
-13.64
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
12371.00
9177.80
-25.81
9868.50
-20.23
9748.90
-21.20
9997.90
-19.18
10215.00
-17.43
10324.00
-16.55
10264.00
-17.03
10284.00
-16.87
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
3228.20
2496.80
-22.66
2676.40
-17.09
2592.90
-19.68
2635.60
-18.36
2640.80
-18.20
2832.80
-12.25
2760.80
-14.48
2755.50
-14.64
Mxb[3]
kNm
-6290.20
6588.50
4.74
6067.50
-3.54
6109.20
-2.88
6118.80
-2.72
6132.90
-2.50
6152.90
-2.18
6179.40
-1.76
6178.60
-1.77
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
8187.70
9547.10
16.60
9509.30
16.14
-6808.90
-16.84
8304.00
1.42
7843.90
-4.20
8004.20
-2.24
-6998.90
-14.52
-7049.70
-13.90
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
2209.80
2613.40
18.26
2519.80
14.03
1832.80
-17.06
2341.40
5.96
2192.30
-0.79
2166.20
-1.97
-1898.40
-14.09
-1893.50
-14.31
Myb[1]
kNm
-18723.00
-18136.00
-3.14
-18586.00
-0.73
-17702.00
-5.45
-18807.00
0.45
-18761.00
0.20
-18213.00
-2.72
-17498.00
-6.54
-17612.00
-5.93
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-16048
14281.00
-11.01
-14890
-7.22
-14521
-9.52
-15171
-5.46
-15163
-5.51
-15063
-6.14
-14500
-9.65
-14609
-8.97
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-5259.4
-4815.8
-8.43
-4994
-5.05
-4821.9
-8.32
-5057.2
-3.84
-5031.8
-4.33
-4917.3
-6.50
-4791.8
-8.89
-4829.5
-8.17
Myb[2]
kNm
-21537.00
-15329.00
-28.82
-16431.00
-23.71
-16012.00
-25.65
-16419.00
-23.76
-16722.00
-22.36
-16732.00
-22.31
-17087.00
-20.66
-17057.00
-20.80
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
-16598
14846.00
-10.56
15039.00
-9.39
14410.00
-13.18
15164.00
-8.64
15118.00
-8.92
15061.00
-9.26
14932.00
-10.04
14943.00
-9.97
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-5599.8
4576.70
-18.27
4650.80
-16.95
4483.90
-19.93
4721.20
-15.69
4715.40
-15.79
4708.60
-15.91
4682.20
-16.39
4682.80
-16.38
Myb[3]
kNm
15600.00
-16422.00
5.27
-15707.00
0.69
15123.00
-3.06
15564.00
-0.23
15609.00
0.06
15675.00
0.48
15665.00
0.42
15667.00
0.43
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
15759.00
15502.00
-1.63
15569.00
-1.21
15324.00
-2.76
15719.00
-0.25
15766.00
0.04
15829.00
0.44
15829.00
0.44
15830.00
0.45
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
4852.80
4778.30
-1.54
4794.60
-1.20
4710.80
-2.93
4842.80
-0.21
4855.00
0.05
4876.00
0.48
4881.80
0.60
4881.90
0.60
Mzb[1]
kNm
490.22
435.10
-11.24
431.54
-11.97
386.89
-21.08
420.94
-14.13
422.82
-13.75
381.32
-22.21
387.35
-20.98
388.35
-20.78
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
489.89
434.76
-11.25
431.21
-11.98
386.64
-21.08
420.59
-14.15
422.54
-13.75
381.01
-22.23
387.11
-20.98
388.11
-20.78
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
170.65
-192.17
12.61
-183.71
7.65
-168.36
-1.34
-175.74
2.98
-173.92
1.92
-178.42
4.55
-171.88
0.72
-171.21
0.33
Mzb[2]
kNm
735.27
346.50
-52.87
385.95
-47.51
408.11
-44.50
363.80
-50.52
407.02
-44.64
452.37
-38.48
419.84
-42.90
420.30
-42.84
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
734.82
346.26
-52.88
385.68
-47.51
407.86
-44.50
363.50
-50.53
406.73
-44.65
452.06
-38.48
419.52
-42.91
419.98
-42.85
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
264.44
-211.94
-19.85
-207.25
-21.63
-198.66
-24.88
-211.71
-19.94
-211.31
-20.09
-205.66
-22.23
-209.54
-20.76
-209.82
-20.65
Mzb[3]
kNm
-261.79
429.78
64.17
371.26
41.82
-253.01
-3.35
-258.23
-1.36
-234.51
-10.42
-241.04
-7.93
-247.23
-5.56
-247.82
-5.34
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-261.83
429.52
64.05
371.02
41.70
-253.05
-3.35
-258.25
-1.37
-234.54
-10.42
-241.08
-7.92
-247.28
-5.56
-247.87
-5.33
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-182.14
-175.49
-3.65
-186.67
2.49
-165.77
-8.99
-168.10
-7.71
-158.11
-13.19
-161.23
-11.48
-165.43
-9.17
-165.40
-9.19
Mxt[01]
kNm
-54353.00
-50924.00
-6.31
-50512.00
-7.07
-68351.00
25.75
-42791.00
-21.27
-49086.00
-9.69
-50864.00
-6.42
-52335.00
-3.71
-53593.00
-1.40
Mxt[02]
kNm
6752.50
6725.00
-0.41
6693.50
-0.87
6633.50
-1.76
6761.00
0.13
6731.10
-0.32
6759.80
0.11
6693.40
-0.88
6710.10
-0.63
Myt[02]
kNm
-22697.00
-19706.00
-13.18
-19117.00
-15.77
-18663.00
-17.77
-18917.00
-16.65
-18974.00
-16.40
-18509.00
-18.45
-18380.00
-19.02
-18461.00
-18.66
Myt[01]
kNm
-184930.02
-198430.02
7.30
-175200.02
-5.26
-150490.00
-18.62
-153040.00
-17.24
-143860.00
-22.21
-127270.01
-35.41 119620.01
-35.32
Mzt[01]
kNm
-12445.00
-13768.00
10.63
-13488.00
8.38
-13198.00
6.05
-13192.00
6.00
-13082.00
5.12
-13050.00
4.86
-13068.00
5.01
-13116.00
5.39
Mzt[02]
kNm
-12445.00
-13768.00
10.63
-13488.00
8.38
-13198.00
6.05
-13192.00
6.00
-13082.00
5.12
-13050.00
4.86
-13068.00
5.01
-13116.00
5.39
Tip displ. flap[1]
mm
-11994.00
-12127.00
1.11
-12467.00
3.94
-12115.00
1.01
-12561.00
4.73
-12506.00
4.27
-12312.00
2.65
-11967.00
-0.23
-12049.00
0.46
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-13519.00
-10919.00
-19.23
-11560.00
-14.49
-11201.00
-17.15
-11339.00
-16.13
-11507.00
-14.88
-11625.00
-14.01
-11752.00
-13.07
-11734.00
-13.20
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
8701.10
-11364.00
30.60
-11154.00
28.19
-8892.90
2.20
-9974.00
14.63
-9548.60
9.74
-9339.50
7.34
-8857.60
1.80
-8816.80
1.33
Tip displ. lag[1]
mm
7354.10
4435.70
-39.68
4636.60
-36.95
4428.20
-39.79
4655.30
-36.70
4686.90
-36.27
4566.30
-37.91
4498.00
-38.84
4527.90
-38.43
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
6087.10
4161.10
-31.64
4277.40
-29.73
3634.60
-40.29
3741.90
-38.53
3726.60
-38.78
3777.90
-37.94
3898.80
-35.95
3891.20
-36.07
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
5859.00
4097.20
-30.07
4055.50
-30.78
3140.40
-46.40
3840.90
-34.44
3695.60
-36.92
3331.10
-43.15
3181.10
-45.71
3179.30
-45.74
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2049.80
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
546.94
-4880.60 138.10
0.00
1227.10 124.36
%
_200
0.00
-3393.40
_225
0.00
65.55
0.00
887.04
%
-2316.40
950.93
_250
0.00
13.01
0.00
62.18
%
-1898.50
481.90
_300
0.00
-7.38
0.00
73.86
%
-1508.50
425.37
_350
-26.41
-993.22
341.10
_400
0.00
-51.55
0.00
-22.23
%
-31.18 119450.01
0.00
0.00
-11.89
%
-466.19
0.00
-77.26
-516.17
0.00
-37.63
190.32
Stentec, 3-1-03
-74.82
0.00
-65.20
219.51
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
%
page 42
-59.87
H. Efdé
Tower frequencies, absolute extreme values Eog50_12
Variable
unit
Fxn
kN
baseline
1260.50
_150
1170.40
%
-7.15
1225.30
-2.79
1261.00
0.04
1265.90
0.43
1257.70
-0.22
1236.60
-1.90
-1231.30
-2.32
-1233.80
-2.12
Fyn
kN
65.24
-32.56
-50.09
28.15
-56.85
80.02
22.65
63.18
-3.16
68.30
4.69
49.62
-23.94
81.73
25.28
80.41
23.25
Fzn
kN
-849.91
-847.23
-0.32
-822.85
-3.18
-853.82
0.46
-846.38
-0.42
-849.03
-0.10
-861.30
1.34
-842.18
-0.91
-841.91
-0.94
Mxn
kNm
6788.90
6643.50
-2.14
6732.60
-0.83
6819.70
0.45
6813.10
0.36
6772.80
-0.24
6797.70
0.13
6803.50
0.22
6812.10
0.34
Mxn-r
kNm
6796.80
6649.00
-2.17
6739.30
-0.85
6827.80
0.46
6821.20
0.36
6780.70
-0.24
6805.70
0.13
6811.70
0.22
6820.40
0.35
Myn
kNm
-5587.50
2548.80
-54.38
1950.60
-65.09
-5021.20
-10.14
-5275.50
-5.58
-5653.00
1.17
-5895.80
5.52
-4660.50
-16.59
-4929.70
-11.77
Myn-r
kNm
-4434.80
2404.70
-45.78
2296.20
-48.22
-4531.50
2.18
-4591.30
3.53
-4296.40
-3.12
4093.40
-7.70
-3750.00
-15.44
-3833.90
-13.55
Mzn
kNm
-4047.20
2376.10
-41.29
2397.40
-40.76
-4398.10
8.67
-4213.40
4.11
-3989.70
-1.42
3626.70
-10.39
-2584.80
-36.13
-2737.30
-32.37
Mzn-r
kNm
-6403.70
3255.00
-49.17
2683.70
-58.09
-6111.60
-4.56
-6085.90
-4.96
-6378.40
-0.40
-6237.50
-2.60
-4718.20
-26.32
-5013.30
-21.71
Mxb[1]
kNm
6471.50
6085.30
-5.97
6204.20
-4.13
6327.20
-2.23
6435.90
-0.55
6486.70
0.23
6521.70
0.78
6479.40
0.12
6486.40
0.23
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
8743.80
-4754.50
-45.62
-4919.70
-43.73
9584.90
9.62
9225.70
5.51
8599.10
-1.65
9342.00
6.84
8422.80
-3.67
8620.50
-1.41
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
2395.20
944.01
-60.59
958.40
-59.99
2583.40
7.86
2491.80
4.03
2386.00
-0.38
2588.20
8.06
2391.10
-0.17
2450.30
2.30
Mxb[2]
kNm
5695.30
5692.10
-0.06
5696.20
0.02
5688.90
-0.11
5681.50
-0.24
5704.40
0.16
5777.10
1.44
5806.00
1.94
5795.90
1.77
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
11520.00
5086.00
-55.85
-5284.80
-54.13
11257.00
-2.28
11109.00
-3.57
11754.00
2.03
11795.00
2.39
11597.00
0.67
11674.00
1.34
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
3036.60
1149.00
-62.16
1125.70
-62.93
3026.50
-0.33
2921.90
-3.78
3121.40
2.79
3099.00
2.05
3062.50
0.85
3039.10
0.08
Mxb[3]
kNm
5347.60
5871.00
9.79
6045.30
13.05
5309.30
-0.72
5338.40
-0.17
5346.40
-0.02
5346.90
-0.01
5351.30
0.07
5349.40
0.03
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
6807.80
-4913.60
-27.82
-4777.30
-29.83
5240.30
-23.03
5819.70
-14.51
6912.00
1.53
6791.50
-0.24
7171.50
5.34
7177.80
5.43
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
2182.50
-760.58
-65.15
-820.19
-62.42
1663.30
-23.79
1956.40
-10.36
2148.70
-1.55
2156.60
-1.19
2163.50
-0.87
2173.10
-0.43
Myb[1]
kNm
18110.00
16413.00
-9.37
17023.00
-6.00
17566.00
-3.00
18024.00
-0.47
18134.00
0.13
18094.00
-0.09
17919.00
-1.05
17930.00
-0.99
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
18006.00
16416.00
-8.83
17010.00
-5.53
17521.00
-2.69
17925.00
-0.45
18027.00
0.12
17978.00
-0.16
17779.00
-1.26
17791.00
-1.19
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
5508.70
4987.80
-9.46
5157.20
-6.38
5297.30
-3.84
5469.70
-0.71
5522.30
0.25
5546.50
0.69
5499.70
-0.16
5500.30
-0.15
Myb[2]
kNm
15815.00
15097.00
-4.54
15283.00
-3.36
15556.00
-1.64
15783.00
-0.20
15837.00
0.14
-16037.00
1.40
-16126.00
1.97
-16141.00
2.06
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
15647.00
15030.00
-3.94
15184.00
-2.96
15407.00
-1.53
15608.00
-0.25
15675.00
0.18
15745.00
0.63
15725.00
0.50
15725.00
0.50
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
4775.80
4600.50
-3.67
4641.10
-2.82
4704.40
-1.50
4762.00
-0.29
4783.80
0.17
4818.70
0.90
4821.80
0.96
4820.70
0.94
Myb[3]
kNm
16475.00
14529.00
-11.81
15467.00
-6.12
16051.00
-2.57
16441.00
-0.21
16455.00
-0.12
16257.00
-1.32
15997.00
-2.90
16011.00
-2.82
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
15337.00
13700.00
-10.67
14547.00
-5.15
15073.00
-1.72
15337.00
0.00
15303.00
-0.22
15037.00
-1.96
14717.00
-4.04
14744.00
-3.87
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
4833.20
4338.70
-10.23
4505.00
-6.79
4679.90
-3.17
4810.70
-0.47
4833.90
0.01
4797.50
-0.74
4718.60
-2.37
4722.60
-2.29
Mzb[1]
kNm
339.46
139.77
-58.83
135.28
-60.15
364.76
7.45
351.67
3.60
332.80
-1.96
422.18
24.37
406.46
19.74
417.19
22.90
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
339.25
139.58
-58.86
135.14
-60.17
364.57
7.46
351.47
3.60
332.58
-1.97
421.95
24.38
406.22
19.74
416.94
22.90
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-131.22
-68.92
-47.48
-61.78
-52.92
-136.83
4.28
-132.67
1.11
-130.39
-0.63
160.42
22.25
155.76
18.70
160.07
21.99
Mzb[2]
kNm
485.38
122.43
-74.78
134.14
-72.36
428.89
-11.64
411.77
-15.17
506.41
4.33
447.87
-7.73
446.82
-7.94
442.62
-8.81
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
485.14
122.28
-74.79
133.98
-72.38
428.66
-11.64
411.56
-15.17
506.17
4.33
447.65
-7.73
446.54
-7.96
442.35
-8.82
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
191.49
-64.68
-66.22
-62.18
-67.53
141.98
-25.86
162.79
-14.99
201.05
4.99
178.66
-6.70
173.72
-9.28
178.67
-6.69
Mzb[3]
kNm
251.46
164.36
-34.64
170.98
-32.01
189.10
-24.80
239.12
-4.91
245.42
-2.40
296.28
17.82
292.60
16.36
290.62
15.57
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
251.25
164.19
-34.65
170.77
-32.03
188.92
-24.81
238.91
-4.91
245.20
-2.41
296.05
17.83
292.36
16.36
290.39
15.58
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-98.61
-67.75
-31.30
-69.79
-29.23
-93.74
-4.94
-97.14
-1.49
-99.02
0.42
-102.69
4.14
-101.18
2.61
-102.02
3.46
Mxt[01]
kNm
-53142.00
38587.00
-27.39
40820.00
-23.19
58505.00
10.09
-55207.00
3.89
-51975.00
-2.20
-45452.00
-14.47
44286.00
-16.66
42765.00
-19.53
Mxt[02]
kNm
7484.70
7202.10
-3.78
7421.90
-0.84
7778.80
3.93
7526.50
0.56
7463.50
-0.28
7457.80
-0.36
7406.10
-1.05
7420.80
-0.85
Myt[02]
kNm
-8710.20
-3766.60
-56.76
-2750.10
-68.43
-8022.70
-7.89
-8222.70
-5.60
-8737.10
0.31
-8552.70
-1.81
-6574.60
-24.52
-6920.90
-20.54
Myt[01]
kNm
-21.30 178390.02
-30.33
-260830.02
1.87
-254090.02
-0.77
-254880.02
-0.46
-244400.02
-4.55
-201160.02
-21.44
-208590.02
-18.54
Mzt[01]
kNm
-4078.80
-2298.10
-43.66
-1838.70
-54.92
-4512.60
10.64
-4226.50
3.62
-4022.70
-1.38
3765.80
-7.67
-2618.70
-35.80
-2767.30
-32.15
Mzt[02]
kNm
-4078.80
-2298.10
-43.66
-1838.70
-54.92
-4512.60
10.64
-4226.50
3.62
-4022.70
-1.38
3765.80
-7.67
-2618.70
-35.80
-2767.30
-32.15
Tip displ. flap[1]
mm
10095.00
8954.60
-11.30
9322.50
-7.65
9627.80
-4.63
10006.00
-0.88
10124.00
0.29
10182.00
0.86
10079.00
-0.16
10079.00
-0.16
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-9710.40
8182.20
-15.74
8273.70
-14.80
-9393.00
-3.27
-9564.30
-1.50
-9783.00
0.75
-9833.70
1.27
-10033.00
3.32
-10035.00
3.34
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-9231.10
7658.10
-17.04
7871.20
-14.73
-8761.10
-5.09
-9102.40
-1.39
-9273.00
0.45
-9405.60
1.89
-9393.70
1.76
-9406.70
1.90
Tip displ. lag[1]
mm
4678.60
-2231.40
-52.31
-2268.50
-51.51
4423.50
-5.45
4536.30
-3.04
4726.60
1.03
4784.40
2.26
4850.60
3.68
4840.80
3.47
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
4297.30
-1819.30
-57.66
-1822.10
-57.60
4473.80
4.11
4403.90
2.48
4376.40
1.84
4526.30
5.33
4526.80
5.34
4531.10
5.44
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
5028.80
-1995.40
-60.32
-2112.60
-57.99
4937.40
-1.82
5047.40
0.37
5041.80
0.26
4822.90
-4.09
4711.30
-6.31
4732.70
-5.89
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2663.00
4876.20
83.11
3318.10
24.60
-3827.80
43.74
-2994.40
12.44
-2516.00
-5.52
-1753.00
-34.17
-768.49
-71.14
-872.38
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
541.48
-981.64
-256050.02 201510.02
_175
%
_200
0.00
-812.41
_225
0.00
0.00
81.29
%
-910.28
_250
0.00
0.00
50.04
%
621.54
_300
0.00
0.00
68.11
%
503.49
_350
0.00
0.00
14.79
%
325.75
_400
0.00
0.00
-7.02
%
0.00
0.00
-39.84
-157.97
%
-70.83
-169.25
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
-67.24
0.00
page 43
-68.74
H. Efdé
Tower frequencies, absolute extreme values GrEog1Voc
Variable
unit
Fxn
kN
baseline
1021.80
_150
789.80
%
-22.71
_175
844.56
%
-17.35
_200
905.23
-11.41
991.11
-3.00
1020.60
-0.12
1066.90
4.41
-1060.90
3.83
-1061.70
3.90
Fyn
kN
-169.41
-148.65
-12.25
-139.93
-17.40
-196.00
15.70
-175.49
3.59
-161.49
-4.68
-154.45
-8.83
-138.49
-18.25
-134.19
-20.79
Fzn
kN
-832.81
-829.03
-0.45
-834.32
0.18
-838.82
0.72
-837.41
0.55
-840.73
0.95
-844.75
1.43
-875.49
5.12
-875.62
5.14
Mxn
kNm
7125.50
6892.80
-3.27
7015.80
-1.54
6971.10
-2.17
6969.90
-2.18
6991.60
-1.88
7033.10
-1.30
6919.80
-2.89
6910.80
-3.01
Mxn-r
kNm
7132.30
6904.50
-3.19
7021.80
-1.55
6983.20
-2.09
6982.50
-2.10
7005.40
-1.78
7048.40
-1.18
6934.90
-2.77
6925.80
-2.90
Myn
kNm
8918.30
7672.40
-13.97
8194.20
-8.12
8473.70
-4.99
8768.60
-1.68
9148.20
2.58
8899.20
-0.21
8882.90
-0.40
8968.00
0.56
Myn-r
kNm
-7610.50
-6604.40
-13.22
-6794.30
-10.72
-7243.00
-4.83
-7725.00
1.50
-7300.30
-4.08
-7063.40
-7.19
7035.20
-7.56
6838.80
-10.14
Mzn
kNm
-6638.60
-7891.10
18.87
-7933.40
19.50
-7378.80
11.15
-6753.80
1.74
-6709.10
1.06
-5664.10
-14.68
-4770.90
-28.13
-5099.00
-23.19
Mzn-r
kNm
-8863.60
-7735.50
-12.73
-8203.40
-7.45
-8446.80
-4.70
-8706.30
-1.77
-9089.70
2.55
-8995.90
1.49
-8886.10
0.25
-8969.30
1.19
Mxb[1]
kNm
-6555.60
-6048.90
-7.73
-6404.70
-2.30
-6826.70
4.14
-6606.00
0.77
-6574.00
0.28
-6445.00
-1.69
-6989.20
6.61
-7087.00
8.11
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
5917.30
7316.50
23.65
6889.30
16.43
6020.10
1.74
6045.30
2.16
5748.30
-2.86
5799.00
-2.00
8390.30
41.79
8325.60
40.70
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1860.60
2468.90
32.69
2370.10
27.38
2146.80
15.38
1921.50
3.27
1890.80
1.62
2013.60
8.22
2637.00
41.73
2595.80
39.51
Mxb[2]
kNm
5374.40
5581.50
3.85
5567.10
3.59
5539.40
3.07
5354.40
-0.37
5383.20
0.16
5459.70
1.59
5510.00
2.52
5559.60
3.45
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
9879.60
6784.40
-31.33
7324.90
-25.86
7816.00
-20.89
9230.20
-6.57
9992.30
1.14
11345.00
14.83
9723.20
-1.58
9768.80
-1.12
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
2653.60
1843.70
-30.52
1938.20
-26.96
2034.30
-23.34
2456.70
-7.42
2702.80
1.85
3077.30
15.97
2794.60
5.31
2775.40
4.59
Mxb[3]
kNm
5821.50
6000.80
3.08
5861.30
0.68
5791.60
-0.51
5784.40
-0.64
5821.40
0.00
5895.30
1.27
5910.90
1.54
5881.40
1.03
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
11389.00
9248.80
-18.79
9812.10
-13.85
10246.00
-10.04
10975.00
-3.64
11549.00
1.40
11849.00
4.04
11594.00
1.80
11691.00
2.65
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
3196.60
2687.80
-15.92
2829.30
-11.49
2908.70
-9.01
3111.60
-2.66
3253.30
1.77
3227.50
0.97
3096.90
-3.12
3136.40
-1.88
Myb[1]
kNm
-12621.00
-13427.00
6.39
-13108.00
3.86
-12677.00
0.44
-12390.00
-1.83
-12853.00
1.84
-13288.00
5.28
-16133.00
27.83
-16089.00
27.48
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-12395
11460.00
-7.54
11581.00
-6.57
-11806
-4.75
-12066
-2.65
-12511
0.94
-12691
2.39
-13853
11.76
-13952
12.56
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-4493.2
-4302.8
-4.24
-4334.9
-3.52
-4379.8
-2.52
-4413
-1.78
-4546.1
1.18
-4517
0.53
-4824.5
7.37
-4838.7
7.69
Myb[2]
kNm
-10652.00
7816.30
-26.62
-7921.90
-25.63
-8684.80
-18.47
-10110.00
-5.09
-10806.00
1.45
-12064.00
13.26
-11088.00
4.09
-11031.00
3.56
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
7048.90
8063.30
14.39
7894.10
11.99
7474.90
6.04
7087.10
0.54
7056.10
0.10
7082.30
0.47
8429.30
19.58
8410.00
19.31
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-2139.5
-2776.5
29.77
-2527
18.11
-2206.9
3.15
-2123.8
-0.73
-2114.3
-1.18
-2228
4.14
-2856.5
33.51
-2788.9
30.35
Myb[3]
kNm
-15365.00
-11368.00
-26.01
-12371.00
-19.49
-13328.00
-13.26
-14850.00
-3.35
-15346.00
-0.12
-16146.00
5.08
-14159.00
-7.85
-14381.00
-6.40
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
11051.00
8669.30
-21.55
9155.80
-17.15
9562.40
-13.47
10702.00
-3.16
10977.00
-0.67
11899.00
7.67
10984.00
-0.61
11118.00
0.61
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-3818.1
-2874.1
-24.72
-3092.6
-19.00
-3315.9
-13.15
-3730
-2.31
-3782.3
-0.94
-4074.5
6.72
-3341
-12.50
-3378.5
-11.51
Mzb[1]
kNm
-222.96
324.63
45.60
301.18
35.08
267.58
20.01
-221.45
-0.68
-216.69
-2.81
270.55
21.34
404.81
81.56
409.27
83.56
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-223.00
324.38
45.46
300.93
34.95
267.33
19.88
-221.50
-0.67
-216.73
-2.81
270.27
21.20
404.46
81.37
408.93
83.38
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-165.80
-154.96
-6.54
-157.47
-5.02
-159.82
-3.61
-163.70
-1.27
-165.74
-0.04
-174.40
5.19
-161.75
-2.44
-163.47
-1.41
Mzb[2]
kNm
209.39
-198.28
-5.31
-199.40
-4.77
-200.74
-4.13
-192.61
-8.01
216.92
3.60
264.40
26.27
280.26
33.85
269.82
28.86
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
209.33
-198.36
-5.24
-199.48
-4.71
-200.82
-4.07
-192.70
-7.94
216.86
3.60
264.33
26.27
280.13
33.82
269.71
28.84
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-148.62
-154.98
4.28
-153.63
3.37
-151.83
2.16
-146.17
-1.65
-151.72
2.09
-149.80
0.79
-176.87
19.01
-173.86
16.98
Mzb[3]
kNm
442.32
242.20
-45.24
290.48
-34.33
336.35
-23.96
420.33
-4.97
432.45
-2.23
431.23
-2.51
369.91
-16.37
378.02
-14.54
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
442.08
242.09
-45.24
290.33
-34.33
336.18
-23.95
420.12
-4.97
432.21
-2.23
430.98
-2.51
369.74
-16.36
377.85
-14.53
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
154.28
-108.25
-29.84
-112.54
-27.05
-115.68
-25.02
149.87
-2.86
150.59
-2.39
157.97
2.39
135.38
-12.25
136.80
-11.33
Mxt[01]
kNm
68493.00
43959.00
-35.82
49844.00
-27.23
53874.00
-21.34
66530.00
-2.87
67780.00
-1.04
67823.00
-0.98
52802.00
-22.91
46492.00
-32.12
Mxt[02]
kNm
6400.40
6231.00
-2.65
6078.40
-5.03
6115.40
-4.45
6344.10
-0.88
6203.20
-3.08
6345.10
-0.86
5983.70
-6.51
5846.60
-8.65
Myt[02]
kNm
9533.90
8005.30
-16.03
8673.50
-9.02
9091.50
-4.64
9423.30
-1.16
9611.80
0.82
9585.70
0.54
8406.80
-11.82
8409.90
-11.79
Myt[01]
kNm
-281560.00 220980.02
-21.52
-246800.02
-12.35
-269420.00
-4.31
-279810.00
-0.62
-278360.00
-1.14
-262150.00
-6.89
-201310.02
-28.50
-212210.02
-24.63
Mzt[01]
kNm
-6251.20
-7472.90
19.54
-7583.30
21.31
-6980.40
11.66
-6327.40
1.22
-6366.30
1.84
-5360.90
-14.24
-4800.60
-23.21
-5142.30
-17.74
Mzt[02]
kNm
-6251.20
-7472.90
19.54
-7583.30
21.31
-6980.40
11.66
-6327.40
1.22
-6366.30
1.84
-5360.90
-14.24
-4800.60
-23.21
-5142.30
-17.74
Tip displ. flap[1]
mm
-9901.80
-9731.00
-1.72
-9770.20
-1.33
-9839.30
-0.63
-9819.30
-0.83
-9973.40
0.72
-10046.00
1.46
-10673.00
7.79
-10727.00
8.33
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-5518.60
-6843.20
24.00
-6368.10
15.39
-5803.30
5.16
-5307.10
-3.83
-5536.80
0.33
-6192.70
12.22
-7135.00
29.29
-7021.00
27.22
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-9006.10
-7203.80
-20.01
-7607.80
-15.53
-8028.60
-10.85
-8849.90
-1.73
-8890.50
-1.28
-9387.20
4.23
-8311.10
-7.72
-8402.20
-6.71
Tip displ. lag[1]
mm
7315.10
7103.60
-2.89
7140.20
-2.39
7217.20
-1.34
7234.20
-1.11
7391.90
1.05
7166.30
-2.03
7740.60
5.82
7747.60
5.91
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
4735.30
4841.20
2.24
4589.90
-3.07
4437.50
-6.29
4767.20
0.67
4687.40
-1.01
4460.30
-5.81
4963.40
4.82
4868.10
2.80
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
6469.00
5356.50
-17.20
5631.30
-12.95
5898.80
-8.81
6350.60
-1.83
6421.40
-0.74
6627.70
2.45
5516.40
-14.73
5583.80
-13.68
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2923.00
5312.70
81.76
-4547.70
55.58
-3957.70
-3315.50 13.43
-2730.90
-6.57
-1835.40
-37.21
-764.02
-73.86
-878.92
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
-701.86
-1062.10
0.00
-908.41
_225
0.00
0.00
51.33
%
-784.73
_250
0.00
35.40
0.00
29.43
%
0.00
11.81
-776.17 10.59
%
_300
0.00
_350
0.00
0.00
-657.53
%
-475.09
_400
0.00
0.00
-6.32
%
0.00
0.00
-32.31
-175.60
%
-74.98
-169.34
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
-69.93
0.00
page 44
-75.87
H. Efdé
Tower frequencies, absolute extreme values E50025
Variable
unit
Fxn
kN
baseline
219.25
_150
199.86
%
-8.84
224.53
2.41
219.59
0.16
207.02
-5.58
222.47
1.47
230.93
5.33
236.47
7.85
300.88
37.23
Fyn
kN
-754.32
-689.80
-8.55
-659.58
-12.56
-795.34
5.44
-694.17
-7.97
-682.97
-9.46
-745.07
-1.23
-775.37
2.79
-800.89
6.17
Fzn
kN
-1061.40
-1029.50
-3.01
-1025.20
-3.41
-1053.80
-0.72
-1054.90
-0.61
-1057.50
-0.37
-1033.50
-2.63
-1079.10
1.67
-1066.30
0.46
Mxn
kNm
-1811.20
1458.90
-19.45
-1450.30
-19.93
1424.70
-21.34
-1354.80
-25.20
1473.10
-18.67
-1682.00
-7.13
-1507.60
-16.76
-1491.30
-17.66
Mxn-r
kNm
-1832.90
1476.40
-19.45
-1467.70
-19.92
1441.80
-21.34
-1371.10
-25.20
1490.80
-18.66
-1702.20
-7.13
-1525.60
-16.77
-1509.20
-17.66
Myn
kNm
-5803.00
-5522.60
-4.83
-5281.80
-8.98
-5506.80
-5.10
-5608.70
-3.35
-7020.50
20.98
-6220.00
7.19
-5304.70
-8.59
-6437.70
10.94
Myn-r
kNm
-7841.90
-6650.70
-15.19
-6031.50
-23.09
6096.60
-22.26
-6393.60
-18.47
6973.20
-11.08
7987.60
1.86
-6822.90
-12.99
6793.00
-13.38
Mzn
kNm
-6118.30
6511.10
6.42
6248.00
2.12
-6393.10
4.49
-6024.00
-1.54
-6677.70
9.14
6697.30
9.46
-6855.10
12.04
6480.70
5.92
Mzn-r
kNm
6751.50
5799.10
-14.11
-5382.30
-20.28
5745.50
-14.90
6214.10
-7.96
-7359.20
9.00
-6189.60
-8.32
5978.20
-11.45
6258.70
-7.30
Mxb[1]
kNm
13230.00
11690.00
-11.64
-12254.00
-7.38
12077.00
-8.72
12189.00
-7.87
12820.00
-3.10
13334.00
0.79
13729.00
3.77
12411.00
-6.19
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
6088.80
4696.80
-22.86
4937.10
-18.92
6325.70
3.89
6532.10
7.28
7236.20
18.84
6982.90
14.68
5819.30
-4.43
5941.40
-2.42
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1848.00
1337.10
-27.65
1434.70
-22.36
1926.50
4.25
2019.20
9.26
2295.70
24.23
2035.10
10.12
1542.90
-16.51
1752.90
-5.15
Mxb[2]
kNm
13596.00
14369.00
5.69
13649.00
0.39
13894.00
2.19
13957.00
2.66
14063.00
3.43
14596.00
7.36
14756.00
8.53
15360.00
12.97
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
5961.90
5724.40
-3.98
5693.30
-4.51
5709.90
-4.23
5386.10
-9.66
5757.70
-3.43
5415.20
-9.17
6053.30
1.53
5650.00
-5.23
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
1642.20
1478.60
-9.96
1453.30
-11.50
1548.60
-5.70
1507.70
-8.19
1579.10
-3.84
1530.60
-6.80
1629.10
-0.80
1576.40
-4.01
Mxb[3]
kNm
14612.00
14880.00
1.83
14401.00
-1.44
13419.00
-8.16
13999.00
-4.20
13625.00
-6.75
14325.00
-1.96
14546.00
-0.45
14893.00
1.92
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
4560.10
3899.20
-14.49
3989.10
-12.52
-4315.30
-5.37
-4389.20
-3.75
-5241.40
14.94
-4699.90
3.07
4461.10
-2.17
4455.70
-2.29
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
1405.30
1107.90
-21.16
1180.50
-16.00
1230.30
-12.45
1220.30
-13.16
1389.80
-1.10
1353.80
-3.66
1358.00
-3.37
1487.00
5.81
Myb[1]
kNm
-5097.40
-4078.90
-19.98
-3904.70
-23.40
-5375.80
5.46
-5692.30
11.67
-6354.90
24.67
-5864.30
15.04
-4585.10
-10.05
-4903.70
-3.80
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
12488.00
11184.00
-10.44
10988.00
-12.01
11745.00
-5.95
11359.00
-9.04
12272.00
-1.73
12815.00
2.62
12977.00
3.92
12003.00
-3.88
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
3305.00
3007.70
-9.00
2965.50
-10.27
2994.70
-9.39
3066.40
-7.22
3240.50
-1.95
3213.50
-2.77
3200.90
-3.15
3329.30
0.74
Myb[2]
kNm
-5093.10
-4951.20
-2.79
-4589.20
-9.89
-5887.20
15.59
-5820.80
14.29
-5356.90
5.18
-5974.60
17.31
-5391.00
5.85
-4996.20
-1.90
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
12820.00
13579.00
5.92
13168.00
2.71
13294.00
3.70
13126.00
2.39
13467.00
5.05
13664.00
6.58
14231.00
11.01
14426.00
12.53
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
4009.50
3689.70
-7.98
4041.80
0.81
3711.00
-7.44
3784.10
-5.62
3764.60
-6.11
3878.60
-3.26
4114.50
2.62
4045.10
0.89
Myb[3]
kNm
-5115.30
-3945.60
-22.87
-4348.90
-14.98
-4508.10
-11.87
-4877.70
-4.64
-4306.40
-15.81
-4818.60
-5.80
-5233.50
2.31
-5831.50
14.00
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
14260.00
14109.00
-1.06
13892.00
-2.58
12662.00
-11.21
13388.00
-6.12
13061.00
-8.41
13883.00
-2.64
14013.00
-1.73
13913.00
-2.43
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
4107.50
3970.90
-3.33
4046.00
-1.50
3414.00
-16.88
3552.20
-13.52
3391.60
-17.43
3678.60
-10.44
4035.10
-1.76
3658.90
-10.92
Mzb[1]
kNm
239.20
188.75
-21.09
185.59
-22.41
275.68
15.25
254.11
6.23
277.66
16.08
243.84
1.94
250.80
4.85
289.15
20.88
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
239.09
188.66
-21.09
185.50
-22.41
275.57
15.26
254.01
6.24
277.52
16.07
243.72
1.94
250.71
4.86
289.05
20.90
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
99.40
-88.54
-10.93
-84.67
-14.82
104.63
5.26
95.09
-4.34
-106.33
6.97
99.40
0.00
94.15
-5.28
119.97
20.69
Mzb[2]
kNm
-202.11
-189.28
-6.35
-187.03
-7.46
238.05
17.78
224.40
11.03
201.62
-0.24
-180.66
-10.61
-199.14
-1.47
-182.63
-9.64
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
-202.11
-189.28
-6.35
-187.04
-7.46
237.96
17.74
224.32
10.99
201.54
-0.28
-180.66
-10.61
-199.14
-1.47
-182.64
-9.63
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-92.81
-88.09
-5.09
-87.87
-5.32
92.76
-0.05
88.64
-4.49
-83.48
-10.05
-77.24
-16.78
-94.24
1.54
-80.66
-13.09
Mzb[3]
kNm
-166.83
-166.22
-0.37
-167.00
0.10
-175.53
5.21
177.41
6.34
-206.52
23.79
-204.64
22.66
-179.51
7.60
-190.85
14.40
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-166.79
-166.19
-0.36
-166.94
0.09
-175.48
5.21
177.37
6.34
-206.45
23.78
-204.58
22.66
-179.47
7.60
-190.81
14.40
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-82.80
-79.13
-4.43
-86.37
4.31
-81.13
-2.02
-81.90
-1.09
-93.89
13.39
-95.78
15.68
-86.46
4.42
-81.61
-1.44
Mxt[01]
kNm
Mxt[02]
kNm
Myt[02]
kNm
-6882.50
-6838.10
Myt[01]
kNm
73903.00
61585.00
Mzt[01]
kNm
9314.30
10254.00
Mzt[02]
kNm
9314.30
Tip displ. flap[1]
mm
Tip disp. flap[2]
164060.00 136730.00
3774.50
3055.30
_175
%
-16.66 151610.00
-19.05
_200
%
-7.59 172780.02
3037.30
-19.53
-0.65
-6300.30
-8.46
-6493.60
-16.67
75732.00
2.47
66338.00
10.09
9767.40
4.86
8976.90
10254.00
10.09
9767.40
4.86
-1030.60
-1033.10
0.24
-987.95
mm
-1113.80
-1251.70
12.38
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-1340.20
-1051.40
Tip displ. lag[1]
mm
8234.50
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
8537.20
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
X-defl[01]
mm
X-defl[02]
Y-defl[01]
Y-defl[02]
%
5.32 136170.00
-5.65
-6321.80
-10.24
70771.00
-3.62
8976.90
-4.14
-1078.20
-21.55
-1084.40
8266.80
0.39
7788.50
-8.77
7464.10
7570.80
1.43
0.00
0.00
mm
677.65
1327.90
mm
0.00
0.00
mm
-1655.90
-3313.80 100.12
%
-17.00 159330.00
-28.22
95.96
_300
-20.44
-8.15
-7190.20
-4.24
78329.00
9004.70
-3.32
-3.62
9004.70
-1095.10
6.26
-3.20
-1258.80
-19.09
-1088.80
8134.70
-1.21
7522.00
-11.89
7305.60
-2.12
89.32
-2784.50
4.47
-6869.10
5.99
69692.00
9721.70
4.37
-3.32
9721.70
-1162.70
12.82
13.02
-1252.80
-18.76
-1181.70
8689.70
5.53
8001.90
-6.27
7399.50
-0.87
883.88
-2513.80
%
-4.75 165820.02
1.07
-10.81
3473.10
-7.99
-0.19
-6183.40
-10.16
-8030.60
16.68
-5.70
79876.00
8.08 108190.01
46.39
9461.00
1.57
10031.00
7.69
9464.40
1.61
4.37
9461.00
1.57
10031.00
7.69
9464.40
1.61
-1318.80
27.96
-1155.30
12.10
-1017.80
-1.24
-1086.40
5.41
12.48
-1310.20
17.63
-1323.40
18.82
-1288.00
15.64
-1175.90
5.58
-11.83
-1126.80
-15.92
-1197.10
-10.68
-1182.20
-11.79
-1335.60
-0.34
8599.00
4.43
8636.10
4.88
8562.20
3.98
8579.50
4.19
8508.50
3.33
7980.30
-6.52
7556.70
-11.49
7694.30
-9.87
8067.90
-5.50
8273.80
-3.09
7650.30
2.49
7701.50
3.18
7749.50
3.82
7932.60
6.28
7779.90
4.23
754.45
0.00
11.33
0.00
51.81
_400
3366.50
0.00
30.43
%
-7.07 156260.00
-15.00
0.00
68.16
_350
3208.50
0.00
0.00
%
-2.88 152460.00
3003.10
1282.90
-8.21
_250
2709.50
0.00
3464.50
_225
-1596.40
678.05
0.00
0.06
0.00
-3.59
-1514.60
419.42
0.00
-38.11
0.00
-8.53
-1034.40
-282.23
0.00
-58.35
0.00
-37.53
-553.52
403.63
-40.44
0.00
-66.57
-655.69
-60.40
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 45
H. Efdé
Tower frequencies, absolute extreme values E50335
Variable
unit
Fxn
kN
baseline
208.05
_150
188.58
%
-9.36
_175
192.77
-7.34
196.69
-5.46
212.74
2.25
202.26
-2.78
200.56
-3.60
213.50
2.62
210.56
Fyn
kN
700.90
689.11
-1.68
762.42
8.78
711.61
1.53
721.88
2.99
711.31
1.49
687.57
-1.90
678.08
-3.26
712.39
1.64
Fzn
kN
-969.49
-943.83
-2.65
-954.16
-1.58
-969.47
0.00
-946.52
-2.37
-964.40
-0.53
-964.99
-0.46
-954.16
-1.58
-947.35
-2.28
Mxn
kNm
1411.40
-1505.50
6.67
1544.50
9.43
-1494.10
5.86
1482.00
5.00
1423.30
0.84
1528.20
8.28
1474.50
4.47
1412.90
0.11
Mxn-r
kNm
1428.30
-1523.50
6.67
1563.00
9.43
-1512.00
5.86
1499.80
5.01
1440.40
0.85
1546.50
8.28
1492.10
4.47
1429.80
0.11
Myn
kNm
4403.20
4305.00
-2.23
4478.10
1.70
4813.80
9.33
5163.00
17.26
4779.20
8.54
5246.80
19.16
6075.30
37.97
5976.40
35.73
Myn-r
kNm
5077.70
-4313.50
-15.05
4729.80
-6.85
-4816.70
-5.14
-5028.30
-0.97
5390.80
6.17
5202.00
2.45
5909.60
16.38
5949.50
17.17
Mzn
kNm
-5639.70
-5952.00
5.54
-5682.30
0.76
-5523.90
-2.05
-5486.10
-2.72
-5663.30
0.42
-6475.20
14.81
-5826.20
3.31
-6417.80
13.80
Mzn-r
kNm
5612.50
5009.00
-10.75
4980.40
-11.26
5775.30
2.90
5894.30
5.02
5677.70
1.16
5701.20
1.58
5282.90
-5.87
5485.30
-2.27
Mxb[1]
kNm
-12138.00
-12032.00
-0.87
-11576.00
-4.63
-11747.00
-3.22
-12090.00
-0.40
-12272.00
1.10
-12079.00
-0.49
-11395.00
-6.12
-12141.00
0.02
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
4783.40
3967.00
-17.07
4420.20
-7.59
4681.40
-2.13
4898.20
2.40
4826.50
0.90
4349.80
-9.06
4586.60
-4.11
5553.90
16.11
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1443.70
1215.90
-15.78
1260.50
-12.69
1402.70
-2.84
1423.50
-1.40
1412.20
-2.18
1289.40
-10.69
-1154.20
-20.05
1519.70
5.26
Mxb[2]
kNm
13234.00
13130.00
-0.79
12994.00
-1.81
13452.00
1.65
13637.00
3.05
13109.00
-0.94
12715.00
-3.92
12843.00
-2.95
13118.00
-0.88
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
4617.90
4541.70
-1.65
4477.50
-3.04
4648.30
0.66
4615.70
-0.05
4726.10
2.34
4813.50
4.24
4931.20
6.78
4850.90
5.05
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
1437.80
1301.30
-9.49
1369.30
-4.76
1351.60
-6.00
1405.60
-2.24
1490.40
3.66
1685.40
17.22
1433.20
-0.32
1522.70
5.90
Mxb[3]
kNm
12028.00
12294.00
2.21
12948.00
7.65
12234.00
1.71
12050.00
0.18
12111.00
0.69
12581.00
4.60
12939.00
7.57
13523.00
12.43
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-3822.50
5635.80
47.44
5704.50
49.23
5168.30
35.21
5566.00
45.61
-4174.10
9.20
5313.90
39.02
4147.10
8.49
3835.00
0.33
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
1173.40
1510.70
28.75
1574.30
34.17
1523.40
29.83
1699.60
44.84
1291.50 10.06
1449.40
23.52
1204.90
2.68
1186.00
1.07
Myb[1]
kNm
-3928.40
-3552.20
-9.58
-3768.70
-4.07
-3832.80
-2.43
-4088.60
4.08
-4076.40
3.77
-3586.70
-8.70
4059.10
3.33
-4123.50
4.97
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-10783
-11139
3.30
-10858
0.70
-11106
3.00
-11275
4.56
-11325
5.03
-11082
2.77
-10386
-3.68
-10688
-0.88
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-2745.7
-2848.6
3.75
-2818.3
2.64
-2805
2.16
-2878.3
4.83
-2860.6
4.18
-2948.3
7.38
-2766.3
0.75
-2933.9
6.85
Myb[2]
kNm
-4269.60
-4120.70
-3.49
-4092.30
-4.15
-4146.70
-2.88
-4445.50
4.12
-4358.80
2.09
-5203.10
21.86
-4519.20
5.85
-4498.60
5.36
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
12662.00
12315.00
-2.74
12270.00
-3.10
12752.00
0.71
12988.00
2.57
12332.00
-2.61
11948.00
-5.64
12034.00
-4.96
12741.00
0.62
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
3483.80
3199.20
-8.17
3020.70
-13.29
3314.60
-4.86
3385.10
-2.83
3414.30
-1.99
2959.20
-15.06
3008.60
-13.64
3443.00
-1.17
Myb[3]
kNm
-4631.40
-4574.80
-1.22
-4691.10
1.29
-4819.60
4.06
-5173.30
11.70
-5033.70
8.69
-4235.40
-8.55
-4425.30
-4.45
-4318.10
-6.76
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
11504.00
11726.00
1.93
12358.00
7.42
11610.00
0.92
11337.00
-1.45
11571.00
0.58
11906.00
3.49
12082.00
5.02
12941.00
12.49
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
3195.70
3098.70
-3.04
3319.40
3.87
3311.20
3.61
3190.10
-0.18
3201.10
0.17
3233.60
1.19
3228.50
1.03
3393.20
6.18
Mzb[1]
kNm
200.06
161.33
-19.36
174.23
-12.91
179.43
-10.31
164.74
-17.65
189.45
-5.30
170.76
-14.65
165.14
-17.45
227.85
13.89
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
200.00
161.24
-19.38
174.14
-12.93
179.34
-10.33
164.63
-17.69
189.36
-5.32
170.72
-14.64
165.09
-17.46
227.74
13.87
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
85.34
-71.27
-16.49
-75.59
-11.42
-75.29
-11.78
-77.07
-9.69
-79.16
-7.24
-78.32
-8.23
-74.65
-12.53
87.67
2.73
Mzb[2]
kNm
-180.79
-181.52
0.40
-176.99
-2.10
-176.84
-2.18
183.95
1.75
-187.63
3.78
-175.00
-3.20
-168.18
-6.97
-169.96
-5.99
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
-180.75
-181.48
0.40
-176.94
-2.11
-176.79
-2.19
183.86
1.72
-187.58
3.78
-174.95
-3.21
-168.12
-6.99
-169.91
-6.00
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-78.89
-80.26
1.74
-80.43
1.95
-77.29
-2.03
-80.18
1.64
-82.56
4.65
-77.60
-1.64
-89.50
13.45
-85.26
8.07
Mzb[3]
kNm
-129.73
190.87
47.13
163.02
25.66
184.63
42.32
225.84
74.08
140.77
8.51
191.41
47.54
148.14
14.19
123.98
-4.43
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-129.70
190.78
47.09
162.94
25.63
184.55
42.29
225.77
74.07
140.68
8.47
191.31
47.50
148.06
14.16
123.89
-4.48
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-68.69
-87.54
27.44
-82.33
19.86
-83.01
20.85
89.38
30.12
-79.70 16.03
-79.72
16.06
-66.85
-2.68
-56.11
-18.31
Mxt[01]
kNm
-150320.00
-146620.00
-2.46
-148740.00
-1.05
-141320.00
-5.99
-152870.00
1.70
-149830.00
-0.33
-156570.00
4.16
-133530.00
-11.17
-169550.02
12.79
Mxt[02]
kNm
-3213.00
-3187.80
-0.78
-2808.60
-12.59
-3179.80
-1.03
-3173.60
-1.23
-3337.70
3.88
-2962.20
-7.81
-3139.30
-2.29
-3733.60
16.20
Myt[02]
kNm
4799.60
-4780.50
-0.40
5111.30
6.49
5748.40
19.77
-5162.80
7.57
5181.10
7.95
5198.00
8.30
-6021.10
25.45
-5973.30
24.45
Myt[01]
kNm
61869.00
59467.00
-3.88
49309.00
-20.30
70198.00
13.46
78489.00
26.86
60153.00
-2.77
58354.00
-5.68
66664.00
7.75
62974.00
1.79
Mzt[01]
kNm
-8397.10
-8285.50
-1.33
-8109.20
-3.43
-8263.20
-1.59
-8269.60
-1.52
-8372.70
-0.29
-9072.00
8.04
-8581.70
2.20
-8856.80
5.47
Mzt[02]
kNm
-8397.10
-8285.50
-1.33
-8109.20
-3.43
-8263.20
-1.59
-8269.60
-1.52
-8372.70
-0.29
-9072.00
8.04
-8581.70
2.20
-8856.80
5.47
Tip displ. flap[1]
mm
-805.24
-839.33
4.23
-851.13
5.70
-811.37
0.76
-834.87
3.68
-805.72
0.06
-809.29
0.50
-700.59
-13.00
-870.78
8.14
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-977.70
-1044.20
6.80
-1076.90
10.15
-1011.80
3.49
-1036.20
5.98
-972.84
-0.50
-1237.80
26.60
-877.56
-10.24
-1119.10
14.46
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-1057.80
-1054.10
-0.35
-1068.30
0.99
-1128.50
6.68
-1193.30
12.81
-1134.20
7.22
-1037.60
-1.91
-1104.30
4.40
-1086.70
2.73
Tip displ. lag[1]
mm
8292.80
8477.00
2.22
8427.70
1.63
8375.90
1.00
8561.70
3.24
8528.70
2.84
8771.80
5.78
8316.90
0.29
8738.10
5.37
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
8024.70
7873.40
-1.89
8208.60
2.29
8342.70
3.96
8375.90
4.38
8099.20
0.93
8053.30
0.36
8018.50
-0.08
8129.20
1.30
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
7565.20
7506.10
-0.78
7679.90
1.52
7750.40
2.45
7767.20
2.67
7627.50
0.82
7612.90
0.63
7769.80
2.70
7708.10
1.89
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
539.15
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
1542.20
1350.80 150.54
0.00
3563.20 131.05
%
_200
0.00
858.92
_225
0.00
59.31
0.00
2740.40
%
943.57
2062.00
_250
0.00
75.01
0.00
77.69
%
871.29
1760.20
_300
0.00
61.60
0.00
33.71
%
530.43
1429.50
_350
0.00
-1.62
0.00
14.14
%
373.99
1068.20
_400
%
0.00
-30.63
0.00
-7.31
%
205.21
0.00
-61.94
195.00
0.00
-30.74
474.11
Stentec, 3-1-03
-63.83
0.00
-69.26
661.89
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
1.21
page 46
-57.08
H. Efdé
Tower frequencies, 1Hz equivalent values 24 m/s
Variable
unit
mat.
curve
Fxn
kN
M5
260.89
269.67
3.37
260.03
-0.33
264.60
1.42
262.89
0.77
254.55
-2.43
254.43
Fyn
kN
M5
189.97
178.22
-6.19
179.78
-5.36
226.78
19.38
181.75
-4.33
185.57
-2.32
Fzn
kN
M5
151.90
139.73
-8.01
142.73
-6.04
145.68
-4.09
147.13
-3.14
151.21
-0.45
Mxn
kNm
M5
2057.89
2201.05
6.96
2111.45
2.60
2140.01
3.99
2090.52
1.59
2080.90
Mxn-r
kNm
M5
2068.66
2211.82
6.92
2119.94
2.48
2148.73
3.87
2098.84
1.46
Myn
kNm
M5
6259.18
6020.96
-3.81
6197.87
-0.98
6090.50
-2.69
6185.75
Myn-r
kNm
M5
7007.78
6946.24
-0.88
7150.31
2.03
6915.88
-1.31
Mzn
kNm
M5
6055.53
6067.14
0.19
6009.52
-0.76
6078.80
Mzn-r
kNm
M5
6767.94
6739.11
-0.43
6739.11
-0.43
6855.94
Mxb[1]
kNm
M10
8241.70
8193.68
-0.58
8122.68
-1.44
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
6529.26
6388.37
-2.16
6323.73
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
M10
1607.36
1600.50
-0.43
Mxb[2]
kNm
M10
8290.28
8007.05
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
M10
6772.97
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
M10
Mxb[3]
kNm
M10
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
Mxb[3]-p[02]
bline
024-150
%
024-175
%
024-200
%
024-225
%
024-250
%
024-300
%
024-350
%
024-400
%
-2.48
249.77
-4.26
251.10
-3.75
190.37
0.21
183.33
-3.50
189.01
-0.51
148.27
-2.39
147.05
-3.19
147.35
-3.00
1.12
2176.82
5.78
2157.52
4.84
2207.19
7.25
2086.39
0.86
2190.38
5.88
2167.87
4.80
2221.14
7.37
-1.17
6210.04
-0.79
6173.69
-1.37
6321.70
1.00
6259.18
0.00
6976.88
-0.44
6976.88
-0.44
6931.03
-1.10
6992.30
-0.22
6976.88
-0.44
0.38
6090.50
0.58
6043.96
-0.19
6185.75
2.15
6173.69
1.95
6259.18
3.36
1.30
6767.94
0.00
6696.33
-1.06
6782.45
0.21
6811.66
0.65
6797.02
0.43
8087.64
-1.87
8134.43
-1.30
8278.08
0.44
8302.52
0.74
8327.10
1.04
8290.28
0.59
-3.15
6544.45
0.23
6484.10
-0.69
6605.94
1.17
6582.75
0.82
6621.49
1.41
6567.38
0.58
1557.51
-3.10
1622.19
0.92
1609.66
0.14
1619.39
0.75
1633.50
1.63
1663.45
3.49
1634.44
1.68
-3.42
8007.05
-3.42
8169.87
-1.45
8205.63
-1.02
8351.83
0.74
8278.08
-0.15
8290.28
0.00
8302.52
0.15
6359.48
-6.11
6484.10
-4.27
6536.84
-3.49
6700.37
-1.07
6748.60
-0.36
6764.83
-0.12
6772.97
0.00
6708.36
-0.95
1698.10
1587.85
-6.49
1602.78
-5.61
1633.97
-3.78
1700.66
0.15
1701.18
0.18
1688.92
-0.54
1681.85
-0.96
1668.87
-1.72
8110.97
7928.05
-2.26
8099.29
-0.14
8241.70
1.61
8041.40
-0.86
8099.29
-0.14
8007.05
-1.28
8076.03
-0.43
8029.91
-1.00
M10
6410.21
6137.43
-4.26
6184.67
-3.52
6446.94
0.57
6359.48
-0.79
6484.10
1.15
6274.35
-2.12
6359.48
-0.79
6417.52
0.11
kNm
M10
1618.92
1507.83
-6.86
1480.83
-8.53
1616.60
-0.14
1563.57
-3.42
1582.04
-2.28
1529.56
-5.52
1579.37
-2.44
1589.19
-1.84
Myb[1]
kNm
M10
7700.14
8146.21
5.79
7828.75
1.67
8052.91
4.58
7575.70
-1.62
7525.02
-2.27
7817.87
1.53
7796.20
1.25
7606.43
-1.22
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
8339.45
8542.08
2.43
8452.23
1.35
8795.87
5.47
8364.25
0.30
8490.50
1.81
8782.13
5.31
8620.62
3.37
8529.12
2.27
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
M10
2418.81
2428.21
0.39
2445.10
1.09
2441.91
0.96
2391.05
-1.15
2425.07
0.26
2408.45
-0.43
2479.59
2.51
2491.67
3.01
Myb[2]
kNm
M10
7828.75
7710.70
-1.51
7637.41
-2.44
7894.67
0.84
7839.66
0.14
7774.64
-0.69
8064.45
3.01
7916.90
1.13
7807.02
-0.28
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
M10
8464.95
8660.44
2.31
8452.23
-0.15
8452.23
-0.15
8302.52
-1.92
8265.92
-2.35
8503.34
0.45
8229.64
-2.78
8217.62
-2.92
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
M10
2442.97
2418.81
-0.99
2445.10
0.09
2534.33
3.74
2405.36
-1.54
2393.09
-2.04
2398.19
-1.83
2371.89
-2.91
2381.94
-2.50
Myb[3]
kNm
M10
8278.08
8018.47
-3.14
8087.64
-2.30
7796.20
-5.82
8122.68
-1.88
8278.08
0.00
7774.64
-6.08
7961.72
-3.82
8290.28
0.15
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
M10
8935.60
8673.80
-2.93
8823.46
-1.25
8700.63
-2.63
8741.19
-2.18
8879.17
-0.63
8529.12
-4.55
8687.19
-2.78
8700.63
-2.63
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
M10
2593.93
2499.42
-3.64
2570.23
-0.91
2490.57
-3.98
2640.20
1.78
2631.55
1.45
2526.36
-2.60
2518.44
-2.91
2642.68
1.88
Mzb[1]
kNm
M10
119.37
128.18
7.38
125.86
5.44
129.83
8.76
120.72
1.13
124.25
4.09
132.95 11.38
128.40
7.56
125.73
5.33
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
119.31
128.11
7.38
125.80
5.44
129.76
8.76
120.61
1.09
124.18
4.08
132.88 11.37
128.21
7.46
125.68
5.34
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
M10
75.22
74.34
-1.17
71.90
-4.41
76.60
1.83
75.01
-0.28
76.38
1.54
78.89
4.88
76.49
1.69
77.39
2.88
Mzb[2]
kNm
M10
134.46
130.97
-2.60
138.29
2.85
124.76
-7.21
132.71
-1.30
134.25
-0.16
126.08
-6.23
132.41
-1.52
134.15
-0.23
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
M10
134.42
130.93
-2.60
138.25
2.85
124.69
-7.24
132.67
-1.30
134.18
-0.18
126.04
-6.23
132.37
-1.53
134.11
-0.23
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
M10
80.20
79.93
-0.34
82.37
2.71
77.75
-3.05
81.29
1.36
81.89
2.11
76.25
-4.93
82.36
2.69
83.06
3.57
Mzb[3]
kNm
M10
135.20
130.55
-3.44
122.15
-9.65
118.06
-12.68
133.07
-1.58
133.70
-1.11
122.07
-9.71
127.43
-5.75
127.56
-5.65
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
M10
135.16
130.51
-3.44
122.11
-9.66
118.02
-12.68
132.99
-1.61
133.55
-1.19
122.03
-9.71
127.38
-5.76
127.52
-5.65
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
M10
76.16
82.67
8.55
75.52
-0.84
70.95
-6.84
73.93
-2.93
77.26
1.44
72.60
-4.67
73.49
-3.51
73.37
-3.66
Mxt[01]
kNm
M5
34205.57
31799.15
-7.04
30277.67
-11.48
60266.96
76.19
28376.83
-17.04
33131.05
-3.14
Mxt[02]
kNm
M5
2184.33
2330.76
6.70
2251.16
3.06
2427.32
11.12
2219.58
1.61
2233.68
2.26
2341.11
7.18
2365.61
8.30
Myt[02]
kNm
M5
6424.40
6197.87
-3.53
6385.50
-0.61
6185.75
-3.71
6372.64
-0.81
6347.07
-1.20
6424.40
0.00
6296.54
-1.99
Myt[01]
kNm
M5
39798.94
43641.59
9.66
41359.68
3.92
42470.00
6.71
40305.93
1.27
39304.54
-1.24
39798.94
0.00
Mzt[01]
kNm
M5
6931.03
6885.78
-0.65
6931.03
0.00
6976.88
0.66
6885.78
-0.65
6900.80
-0.44
7007.78
1.11
7007.78
1.11
7086.26
2.24
Mzt[02]
kNm
M5
6931.03
6885.78
-0.65
6931.03
0.00
6976.88
0.66
6885.78
-0.65
6900.80
-0.44
7007.78
1.11
7007.78
1.11
7086.26
2.24
38351.70 12.12
38822.27 13.50
49827.01 25.20
39798.94 16.35
2451.77 12.24
6259.18
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
-2.57
45525.40 14.39
page 47
H. Efdé
Variable
unit
matl
curve
Fxn
kN
M5
223.39
241.83
8.25
235.88
Fyn
kN
M5
132.44
131.00
-1.09
Fzn
kN
M5
98.11
95.69
-2.47
Mxn
kNm
M5
1447.73
1608.13
Mxn-r
kNm
M5
1455.05
Myn
kNm
M5
Myn-r
kNm
Mzn
bline
018-150
%
018-175
%
018-200
%
018-225
5.59
239.16
7.06
226.38
132.97
0.40
229.05
72.95
96.66
-1.48
100.08
2.01
11.08
1546.81
6.84
1572.96
1612.23
10.80
1555.18
6.88
4804.88
4841.64
0.77
4812.19
M5
5165.74
5208.25
0.82
kNm
M5
4834.25
4834.25
Mzn-r
kNm
M5
5251.48
Mxb[1]
kNm
M10
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
Mxb[2]
kNm
Mxb[2]-p[01]
%
018-250
1.34
222.51
132.89
0.34
97.60
-0.52
8.65
1494.22
1577.66
8.43
0.15
4768.67
5132.22
-0.65
0.00
4775.87
5295.42
0.84
7290.93
7179.27
5930.37
6019.21
M10
1334.03
M10
7272.08
kNm
M10
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
Mxb[3]
%
018-300
%
018-350
%
018-400
%
-0.39
217.30
-2.73
210.01
-5.99
210.87
133.19
0.57
131.40
-0.79
131.20
-0.94
146.41 10.55
97.68
-0.44
97.63
-0.49
97.74
-0.38
99.61
1.53
3.21
1427.48
-1.40
1534.06
5.96
1511.35
4.39
1531.09
5.76
1502.73
3.28
1433.30
-1.49
1539.29
5.79
1516.42
4.22
1534.81
5.48
-0.75
4841.64
0.77
4790.33
-0.30
4761.50
-0.90
4834.25
0.61
4841.64
0.77
5140.56
-0.49
5182.66
0.33
5107.37
-1.13
5123.91
-0.81
5174.18
0.16
5182.66
0.33
-1.21
4932.21
2.03
4834.25
0.00
4704.85
-2.68
4733.00
-2.09
4856.50
0.46
4849.06
0.31
5268.96
0.33
5385.56
2.55
5295.42
0.84
5268.96
0.33
5295.42
0.84
5242.77
-0.17
5242.77
-0.17
-1.53
7225.38
-0.90
7225.38
-0.90
7272.08
-0.26
7243.99
-0.64
7272.08
-0.26
7281.50
-0.13
7309.88
0.26
1.50
6064.64
2.26
6025.66
1.61
5936.63
0.11
5899.27
-0.52
5868.50
-1.04
5886.92
-0.73
5880.77
-0.84
1358.52
1.84
1360.16
1.96
1344.87
0.81
1329.30
-0.35
1320.87
-0.99
1322.43
-0.87
1313.78
-1.52
1308.89
-1.88
7225.38
-0.64
7319.40
0.65
7216.11
-0.77
7272.08
0.00
7300.40
0.39
7225.38
-0.64
7253.33
-0.26
7262.69
-0.13
5917.89
5874.63
-0.73
5930.37
0.21
5850.19
-1.14
5917.89
0.00
5917.89
0.00
5974.46
0.96
5917.89
0.00
5961.80
0.74
M10
1331.19
1318.40
-0.96
1324.29
-0.52
1298.91
-2.42
1334.98
0.28
1341.03
0.74
1369.43
2.87
1353.61
1.68
1365.11
2.55
kNm
M10
7309.88
7160.99
-2.04
7234.67
-1.03
7348.08
0.52
7243.99
-0.90
7281.50
-0.39
7319.40
0.13
7225.38
-1.16
7253.33
-0.77
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
M10
5838.04
5831.99
-0.10
5831.99
-0.10
5917.89
1.37
5850.19
0.21
5819.92
-0.31
5862.38
0.42
5807.90
-0.52
5862.38
0.42
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
M10
1313.16
1311.02
-0.16
1301.01
-0.93
1348.74
2.71
1313.16
0.00
1292.94
-1.54
1319.94
0.52
1310.11
-0.23
1323.36
0.78
Myb[1]
kNm
M10
6991.87
6756.70
-3.36
6724.40
-3.83
6983.19
-0.12
6889.11
-1.47
6797.53
-2.78
6764.83
-3.25
6469.19
-7.48
6544.45
-6.40
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
7575.70
7700.14
1.64
7319.40
-3.38
7647.80
0.95
7596.16
0.27
7262.69
-4.13
7272.08
-4.01
7525.02
-0.67
7616.73
0.54
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
M10
2107.90
2076.01
-1.51
2095.34
-0.60
2120.62
0.60
2153.09
2.14
2078.31
-1.40
2079.85
-1.33
2099.25
-0.41
2076.77
-1.48
Myb[2]
kNm
M10
6267.36
6484.10
3.46
6253.43
-0.22
6323.73
0.90
6352.30
1.36
6171.10
-1.54
6090.91
-2.82
6295.42
0.45
6302.47
0.56
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
M10
7142.80
7475.02
4.65
7188.44
0.64
7243.99
1.42
7206.86
0.90
7216.11
1.03
7044.41
-1.38
7106.70
-0.51
7225.38
1.16
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
M10
1926.68
2032.50
5.49
1923.39
-0.17
1945.34
0.97
1931.31
0.24
1914.22
-0.65
1903.86
-1.18
1905.79
-1.08
2004.26
4.03
Myb[3]
kNm
M10
6692.39
6906.02
3.19
6567.38
-1.87
6575.05
-1.75
6637.12
-0.83
6847.18
2.31
6637.12
-0.83
6150.85
-8.09
6454.34
-3.56
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
M10
7455.21
7142.80
-4.19
7062.10
-5.27
7170.12
-3.82
7445.34
-0.13
7504.94
0.67
7627.06
2.31
7044.41
-5.51
7070.97
-5.15
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
M10
2020.82
1907.73
-5.60
1891.06
-6.42
1912.92
-5.34
1935.96
-4.20
2021.54
0.04
2020.09
-0.04
1870.93
-7.42
1887.88
-6.58
Mzb[1]
kNm
M10
112.81
112.49
-0.28
111.38
-1.27
117.76
4.39
113.68
0.77
109.89
-2.59
110.50
-2.05
112.42
-0.35
112.23
-0.51
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
112.35
112.37
0.02
111.32
-0.92
118.11
5.13
113.60
1.11
109.84
-2.23
111.55
-0.71
112.36
0.01
112.23
-0.11
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
M10
63.08
63.39
0.49
63.28
0.32
63.95
1.38
63.92
1.33
62.17
-1.44
62.07
-1.60
62.95
-0.21
62.87
-0.33
Mzb[2]
kNm
M10
107.82
107.61
-0.19
107.02
-0.74
110.41
2.40
106.15
-1.55
107.80
-0.02
109.14
1.22
106.21
-1.49
107.25
-0.53
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
M10
107.79
107.70
-0.08
106.99
-0.74
110.38
2.40
106.12
-1.55
107.77
-0.02
109.17
1.28
106.18
-1.49
107.22
-0.53
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
M10
62.35
62.46
0.18
59.36
-4.80
63.65
2.09
60.95
-2.25
58.17
-6.70
60.86
-2.39
61.89
-0.74
62.52
0.27
Mzb[3]
kNm
M10
116.58
114.38
-1.89
115.96
-0.53
115.18
-1.20
114.80
-1.53
114.58
-1.72
115.07
-1.30
111.95
-3.97
115.58
-0.86
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
M10
116.54
114.34
-1.89
115.92
-0.53
115.10
-1.24
114.83
-1.47
114.54
-1.72
115.00
-1.32
111.92
-3.96
115.54
-0.86
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
M10
61.92
64.96
4.91
62.60
1.10
61.89
-0.05
62.29
0.60
64.14
3.59
62.65
1.18
61.46
-0.74
64.45
4.09
Mxt[01]
kNm
M5
19713.50
14349.28
-27.21
19470.87
-1.23
74447.44 277.65
17149.14
-13.01
19234.14
-2.43
19117.93
-3.02
Mxt[02]
kNm
M5
1534.06
1736.08
13.17
1663.08
8.41
2074.08
35.20
1572.96
2.54
1468.56
-4.27
1605.69
4.67
1631.35
6.34
Myt[02]
kNm
M5
4894.07
4947.64
1.09
4916.88
0.47
4863.97
-0.62
4878.97
-0.31
4863.97
-0.62
4841.64
-1.07
4797.59
-1.97
Myt[01]
kNm
M5
30868.45
35751.58
15.82
33131.05
7.33
36160.17
17.14
30570.20
-0.97
30868.45
0.00
29709.08
-3.76
Mzt[01]
kNm
M5
5459.90
5413.20
-0.86
5358.20
-1.86
5507.42
0.87
5441.12
-0.34
5394.74
-1.19
5358.20
-1.86
5469.34
0.17
5450.50
-0.17
Mzt[02]
kNm
M5
5459.90
5413.20
-0.86
5358.20
-1.86
5507.42
0.87
5441.12
-0.34
5394.74
-1.19
5358.20
-1.86
5469.34
0.17
5450.50
-0.17
25011.98 26.88
41359.68 33.99
34579.41 75.41
1703.37 11.04
4797.59
Stentec, 3-1-03
-1.97
37443.97 21.30
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
-5.60
page 48
H. Efdé
Variable
unit
matl
curve
Fxn
kN
M5
225.83
Fyn
kN
M5
Fzn
kN
M5
Mxn
kNm
M5
Mxn-r
kNm
Myn
bline
012-150
%
012-175
%
012-200
%
012-225
%
258.04 14.26
246.14
8.99
256.45
13.56
237.58
97.53
105.23
7.90
103.01
5.62
176.43
80.90
101.97
70.93
74.28
4.72
71.85
1.30
68.9
-2.86
68.6
996.69
1133.44 13.72
1079.31
8.29
1118.61
12.23
1043.02
M5
1000.47
1138.33 13.78
1081.16
8.07
1122.19
12.17
kNm
M5
4033.16
4017.791
-0.38
4144.088
2.75
3982.39
Myn-r
kNm
M5
4536.22
4503.93
-0.71
4497.53
-0.85
Mzn
kNm
M5
4043.47
4106.439
1.56
4043.47
Mzn-r
kNm
M5
4440.72
4459.498
0.42
4478.43
Mxb[1]
kNm
M10
6889.11
6822.259
-0.97
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
5862.38
5850.188
-0.21
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
M10
1250.12
1238.02
Mxb[2]
kNm
M10
6847.18
6855.52
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
M10
5813.91
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
M10
Mxb[3]
kNm
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
Mxb[3]-p[02]
012-250
%
012-300
%
224.62
-0.54
216.98
-3.92
4.55
99.1
1.61
99.29
1.80
-3.28
72.02
1.54
72.01
1.52
4.65
1003.65
0.70
1053.79
5.73
1048.2
4.77
1006.84
0.64
1059.43
-1.26
4117.129
2.08
4111.779
1.95
4446.959
-1.97
4491.149
-0.99
4516.789
0.00
4002.551
-1.01
4064.24
0.51
0.85
4459.498
0.42
4440.72
0.00
6847.178
-0.61
6940.1
0.74
6889.11
5838.039
-0.42
5917.889
0.95
-0.97
1235.84
-1.14
1271.03
0.12
6872.278
0.37
6830.549
5825.95
0.21
5813.911
0.00
5868.5
1241.85
1239.66
-0.18
1225.61
-1.31
M10
6889.11
6838.85
-0.73
6805.75
M10
5789.97
5844.11
0.94
5844.11
kNm
M10
1244.32
1254.87
0.85
Myb[1]
kNm
M10
6598.19
6965.889
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
7053.24
7585.911
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
M10
2086.02
Myb[2]
kNm
M10
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
Myb[2]-p[02]
012-350
%
%
212.2
-6.04
99.8
2.33
97.35
-0.18
70.86
-0.10
72.71
2.51
1027.11
3.05
1042.68
4.61
5.89
1031.12
3.06
1046.47
4.60
4017.791
-0.38
4085.23
1.29
4059.03
0.64
-0.43
4497.53
-0.85
4510.349
-0.57
4503.93
-0.71
4048.641
0.13
3987.41
-1.39
4101.12
1.43
4043.47
0.00
4453.22
0.28
4472.1
0.71
4484.779
0.99
4484.779
0.99
0.00
6880.679
-0.12
6863.889
-0.37
6863.889
-0.37
6897.559
0.12
5813.911
-0.83
5856.278
-0.10
5844.11
-0.31
5844.11
-0.31
5850.188
-0.21
1.67
1228.82
-1.70
1261.05
0.87
1235.84
-1.14
1231.78
-1.47
1230.97
-1.53
-0.24
6847.178
0.00
6847.178
0.00
6838.85
-0.12
6847.178
0.00
6838.85
-0.12
0.94
5825.95
0.21
5819.92
0.10
5807.901
-0.10
5813.911
0.00
5813.911
0.00
1228.82
-1.05
1238.29
-0.29
1245.7
0.31
1226.68
-1.22
1226.95
-1.20
1229.09
-1.03
-1.21
6855.52
-0.49
6830.549
-0.85
6863.889
-0.37
6897.559
0.12
6838.85
-0.73
6838.85
-0.73
0.94
5778.078
-0.21
5772.149
-0.31
5819.92
0.52
5819.92
0.52
5825.95
0.62
5831.989
0.73
1237.2
-0.57
1235.3
-0.72
1227.21
-1.38
1249.29
0.40
1243.77
-0.04
1243.49
-0.07
1238.56
-0.46
5.57
6940.1
5.18
6863.889
4.03
6756.701
2.40
6575.049
-0.35
6330.85
-4.05
6410.21
-2.85
6484.1
-1.73
7.55
7710.701
9.32
7415.889
5.14
7357.688
4.32
7253.33
2.84
6838.85
-3.04
6889.11
-2.33
6897.559
-2.21
2149.801
3.06
2239.681
7.37
2127.04
1.97
2089.891
0.19
2112.651
1.28
2021.54
-3.09
2045.81
-1.93
2038.39
-2.28
6373.89
6439.559
1.03
6388.369
0.23
7179.269
12.64
6410.21
0.57
6506.601
2.08
6211.989
-2.54
6366.669
-0.11
6260.388
-1.78
M10
6855.52
6914.51
0.86
7097.74
3.53
7606.43
10.95
7133.74
4.06
6983.188
1.86
6660.698
-2.84
6948.679
1.36
6822.259
-0.49
kNm
M10
2012.14
2051.781
1.97
2060.801
2.42
2275
13.06
2093
4.02
2031.77
0.98
2024.45
0.61
2072.951
3.02
2037.65
1.27
Myb[3]
kNm
M10
6330.85
6830.549
7.89
6830.549
7.89
6552.078
3.49
6295.42
-0.56
6388.369
0.91
6316.63
-0.22
6097.51
-3.69
5936.63
-6.23
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
M10
6983.19
7106.701
1.77
7300.4
4.54
6974.53
-0.12
6676.5
-4.39
6814
-2.42
6872.278
-1.59
6491.579
-7.04
6506.601
-6.82
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
M10
1974.70
2094.561
6.07
2139.981
8.37
2037.65
3.19
1935.3
-2.00
1957.52
-0.87
1920.1
-2.76
1864.11
-5.60
1834.32
-7.11
Mzb[1]
kNm
M10
127.88
133.84
4.66
131.2
2.60
134.05
4.82
128.52
0.50
129.23
1.06
127.13
-0.59
127.49
-0.30
127.58
-0.23
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
M10
127.65
133.96
4.94
130.95
2.59
133.93
4.92
127.49
-0.13
129.18
1.20
126.89
-0.60
127.43
-0.17
127.5
-0.12
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
M10
65.13
66.92
2.75
66.44
2.01
67.32
3.36
65.63
0.77
65.31
0.28
63.91
-1.87
63.87
-1.93
64.51
-0.95
Mzb[2]
kNm
M10
123.86
130.27
5.18
126.62
2.23
126.7
2.29
126.15
1.85
123.62
-0.19
123.15
-0.57
124.21
0.28
124
0.11
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
M10
123.79
130.23
5.20
126.58
2.25
126.66
2.32
126.11
1.87
123.38
-0.33
123.11
-0.55
124
0.17
123.93
0.11
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
M10
64.47
66.51
3.16
65.22
1.16
65.22
1.16
63.68
-1.23
64.52
0.08
62.63
-2.85
63.38
-1.69
62.44
-3.15
Mzb[3]
kNm
M10
130.19
138.57
6.44
136.48
4.83
131.05
0.66
133.31
2.40
130.87
0.52
133.04
2.19
132.2
1.54
132.19
1.54
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
M10
130.16
138.52
6.42
136.43
4.82
130.95
0.61
133.06
2.23
130.83
0.51
133
2.18
132.16
1.54
132.17
1.54
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
M10
64.83
68.15
5.12
66.93
3.24
64.5
-0.51
65.44
0.94
64.65
-0.28
64.48
-0.54
63.11
-2.65
64.65
-0.28
Mxt[01]
kNm
M5
8081.77
12287.428 52.04
Mxt[02]
kNm
M5
1122.98
1283.83 14.32
Myt[02]
kNm
M5
4017.79
Myt[01]
kNm
M5
28633.63
Mzt[01]
kNm
M5
4453.22
4582.21
2.90
4497.53
1.00
Mzt[02]
kNm
M5
4453.22
4582.21
2.90
4497.53
1.00
4349.159
4012.701
-0.13
37006.023 29.24
61437.203 660.19
10743.676 32.94
10671.209 32.04
13786.557 70.59
216.54
012-400
-4.11
14750.646 82.52
5.20
15030.945 85.99
12383.617 53.23
1227.55
9.31
1499.17
33.50
1135.07
1.08
1116.25
-0.60
1175.99
4.72
1156.64
3.00
1146.17
2.07
4133.259
2.87
4028.02
0.25
4095.811
1.94
4069.47
1.29
3977.39
-1.01
3918.28
-2.48
3923.14
-2.36
34961.5
22.10
29990.676
4.74
28895.129
0.91
28124.586
-1.78
4349.159
-2.34
4497.53
1.00
4459.498
0.14
4491.149
0.85
4453.22
0.00
4472.1
0.42
-2.34
4497.53
1.00
4459.498
0.14
4491.149
0.85
4453.22
0.00
4472.1
0.42
34205.566 19.46
33481.645 16.93
31799.148 11.06
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 49
Appendix F.
H. Efdé
Tables pitch control.
Pitch control, absolute extreme values 1B-5Vo
Variable
Unit baseline
Fxn
Fyn
kN
kN
Fzn
kN
-972.67
-976.24
Mxn
kNm
7399.00
6562.80
Mxn-r
kNm
7411.90
6571.00
Myn
Myn-r
kNm
kNm
-10044.00
-10694.00
Mzn
kNm
Mzn-r
kNm
Mxb[1]
754.16
226.72
1B-5VoHTS
742.10
-277.43
%
-1.60
22.37
1B-5VoLTS
%
660.90
201.27
-12.37
-11.23
0.37
-969.69
-11.30
7014.70
-11.35
-10535.00
-11879.00
-10830.00
-11132.00
kNm
Mxb[1]-p[01]
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
Mxb[2]
kNm
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
Mxb[3]
Mxb[3]-p[01]
1b5vo_PS
%
753.58
224.89
-0.08
-0.81
-0.31
-967.03
-0.58
-5.19
7010.30
-5.25
7026.40
-5.20
7022.20
-5.26
4.89
11.08
-9333.80
-10147.00
-7.07
-5.12
-10082.00
-10642.00
0.38
-0.49
-11818.00
9.12
-9917.40
-8.43
10763.00
-0.62
-11954.00
7.38
-9305.30
-16.41
-11141.00
0.08
8565.80
6957.00
-18.78
7422.50
-13.35
8531.40
-0.40
-5831.90
1655.80
-5692.80
-1422.30
-2.39
-14.10
5387.10
1447.20
-7.63
-12.60
-5863.70
1651.50
0.55
-0.26
9271.40
8826.80
-4.80
9017.50
-2.74
9205.70
-0.71
-5266.30
-5332.90
1.26
-4815.30
-8.56
-5176.20
-1.71
-1134.90
-1223.70
7.82
-1090.90
-3.88
-1129.00
-0.52
kNm
kNm
6321.20
-6438.30
5627.70
-6062.40
-10.97
-5.84
6054.90
-4498.40
-4.21
-30.13
6358.30
-6502.00
0.59
0.99
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-1569.00
-1495.30
-4.70
1022.90
-34.81
1580.50
0.73
Myb[1]
kNm
7783.60
8248.70
5.98
7169.00
-7.90
7773.60
-0.13
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
9875.40
9954.90
0.81
8440.60
-14.53
9866.60
-0.09
Myb[1]-p[02]
Myb[2]
kNm
kNm
1858.10
13858.00
1869.90
14711.00
0.64
6.16
1677.80
11256.00
-9.70
-18.78
1858.30
13831.00
0.01
-0.19
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
15152.00
16015.00
5.70
13110.00
-13.48
15077.00
-0.49
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
4004.70
4145.20
3.51
3318.10
-17.14
3997.20
-0.19
Myb[3]
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
8487.10
8286.80
8453.90
6869.70
-0.39
-17.10
7603.90
8115.60
-10.41
-2.07
8438.00
8291.70
-0.58
0.06
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
2065.60
1665.00
-19.39
1823.90
-11.70
2035.10
-1.48
Mzb[1]
kNm
-200.46
-186.11
-7.16
-122.30
-38.99
-200.72
0.13
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-200.50
-186.17
-7.15
-122.34
-38.98
-200.76
0.13
Mzb[1]-p[02]
Mzb[2]
kNm
kNm
-122.62
106.43
-135.57
108.32
10.56
1.78
-93.55
84.59
-23.71
-20.52
-122.37
105.49
-0.20
-0.88
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
106.26
108.16
1.79
84.47
-20.51
105.33
-0.88
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-78.21
-80.53
2.97
-67.14
-14.15
-83.31
6.52
Mzb[3]
kNm
-193.56
-196.47
1.50
-150.14
-22.43
-194.17
0.32
Mzb[3]-p[01]
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
-193.60
-126.19
-196.52
-135.91
1.51
7.70
-150.18
-105.71
-22.43
-16.23
-194.21
-124.07
0.32
-1.68
Mxt[01]
kNm
65292.00
68094.00
4.29
44767.00
-31.44
63662.00
-2.50
Mxt[02]
kNm
7840.50
7896.00
0.71
8152.90
3.98
7888.10
0.61
Myt[02]
kNm
-10690.00
-11312.00
5.82
-10228.00
-4.32
-10744.00
0.51
Myt[01]
Mzt[01]
kNm
kNm
132960.00
-12024.00
91754.01
-13114.00
-30.99
9.07
84133.01
-11170.00
-36.72
-7.10
132330.00
-12024.00
-0.47
0.00
Mzt[02]
kNm
-12024.00
-13114.00
9.07
-11170.00
-7.10
-12024.00
0.00
Tip displ. flap[1]
mm
-4645.10
-4712.10
1.44
-4250.10
-8.50
-4643.60
-0.03
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
6194.50
6441.60
3.99
4675.10
-24.53
6210.00
0.25
Tip disp. flap[3]
Tip displ. lag[1]
mm
mm
-5266.10
2729.60
-5119.50
2205.40
-2.78
-19.20
-5427.90
2420.60
3.07
-11.32
-5258.60
2789.10
-0.14
2.18
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
-3111.70
-3210.60
3.18
-2613.50
-16.01
-3131.70
0.64
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
2500.40
2592.50
3.68
3298.10
31.90
2633.90
5.34
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
Y-defl[01]
mm
mm
1288.40
0.00
873.95
0.00
-32.17
817.70
0.00
-36.53
1276.20
0.00
-0.95
Y-defl[02]
mm
-722.62
-673.13
-6.85
-512.08
-29.14
-711.56
-1.53
0.00
0.00
NOTE: gamma = 1
NOTE: 1B-5VoLTS brake_overspeed on 14.0 rpm to prevent early shut down
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 50
H. Efdé
Pitch control, absolute extreme values E50025
Variable
Unit baseline E50025HTS
%
Fxn
Fyn
kN
kN
219.25
-754.32
275.63
-828.58
25.71
9.84
E50025LTS % E50025_PS %
219.24
-754.44
0.00
0.02
219.25 0.00
-754.32 0.00
Fzn
kN
-1061.40
-1044.80
-1.56
-1061.40
0.00
-1061.40 0.00
Mxn
kNm
-1811.20
1356.00 -25.13
-1811.20
0.00
-1811.20 0.00
Mxn-r
kNm
-1832.90
1372.20 -25.14
-1832.90
0.00
-1832.90 0.00
Myn
Myn-r
kNm
kNm
-5803.00
-7841.90
-6007.30
3.52
6502.10 -17.09
-5794.60 -0.14
-7836.40 -0.07
-5803.00 0.00
-7841.90 0.00
Mzn
kNm
-6118.30
-6006.60
-1.83
-6113.20 -0.08
-6118.30 0.00
Mzn-r
kNm
6751.50
-6389.70
-5.36
6748.20 -0.05
6751.50 0.00
Mxb[1]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
13230.00
6088.80
12258.00
6951.30
-7.35
14.17
13231.00 0.01
6085.50 -0.05
13230.00 0.00
6088.80 0.00
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1848.00
2184.30
18.20
Mxb[2]
kNm
13596.00
15138.00
11.34
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
5961.90
5457.70
Mxb[2]-p[02]
Mxb[3]
kNm
kNm
1642.20
14612.00
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
4560.10
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
1405.30
Myb[1]
kNm
-5097.40
-5867.80
Myb[1]-p[01]
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
12488.00
3305.00
11453.00
3317.10
Myb[2]
kNm
-5093.10
-5149.60
1.11
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
12820.00
14450.00
12.71
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
4009.50
3811.40
-4.94
4009.00 -0.01
4009.50 0.00
Myb[3]
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
-5115.30
14260.00
-4874.60
14314.00
-4.71
0.38
-5113.20 -0.04
14258.00 -0.01
-5115.30 0.00
14260.00 0.00
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
4107.50
0.02
4107.50 0.00
Mzb[1]
kNm
239.20
300.03
25.43
239.15 -0.02
239.20 0.00
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
239.09
299.91
25.44
239.04 -0.02
239.09 0.00
Mzb[1]-p[02]
Mzb[2]
kNm
kNm
99.40
-202.11
112.76 13.44
-170.68 -15.55
99.36 -0.04
-202.05 -0.03
99.40 0.00
-202.11 0.00
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
-202.11
-170.69 -15.55
-202.05 -0.03
-202.11 0.00
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-92.81
-81.00 -12.72
-92.78 -0.03
Mzb[3]
kNm
-166.83
-191.71
14.91
-166.88
0.03
-166.83 0.00
Mzb[3]-p[01]
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
-166.79
-82.80
-191.66
-80.45
14.91
-2.84
-166.83
-82.82
0.02
0.02
-166.79 0.00
-82.80 0.00
Mxt[01]
kNm
164060.00
194350.02
18.46
164110.00
0.03
164060.00 0.00
Mxt[02]
kNm
3774.50
3595.70
-4.74
3775.00
0.01
3774.50 0.00
Myt[02]
Myt[01]
kNm
kNm
-6882.50
73903.00
-7122.60
102270.01
3.49
38.38
-6890.30
73907.00
0.11
0.01
-6882.50 0.00
73903.00 0.00
Mzt[01]
kNm
9314.30
9228.40
-0.92
9317.80
0.04
9314.30 0.00
Mzt[02]
kNm
9314.30
9228.40
-0.92
9317.80
0.04
9314.30 0.00
Tip displ. flap[1] mm
-1030.60
-1207.20
17.14
-1029.20 -0.14
-1030.60 0.00
Tip disp. flap[2] mm
-1113.80
-1340.20
-1241.90 11.50
-1102.00 -17.77
-1111.10 -0.24
-1339.50 -0.05
-1113.80 0.00
-1340.20 0.00
Tip displ. lag[1] mm
8234.50
8888.50
7.94
8233.40 -0.01
8234.50 0.00
8537.20
7952.70
-6.85
8538.00
0.01
8537.20 0.00
7464.10
7866.40
5.39
7464.40
0.00
7464.10 0.00
0.00
677.65
0.00
865.69
27.75
0.00
678.04
0.06
0.00
677.65 0.00
8.31
-1656.40
0.03
-1655.90 0.00
1846.00 -0.11
1848.00 0.00
0.00
13596.00 0.00
-8.46
5961.40 -0.01
5961.90 0.00
1477.90 -10.00
15018.00
2.78
1641.60 -0.04
14609.00 -0.02
1642.20 0.00
14612.00 0.00
2.68
4558.60 -0.03
4560.10 0.00
1198.60 -14.71
1403.00 -0.16
1405.30 0.00
15.11
-5092.60 -0.09
-5097.40 0.00
-8.29
0.37
12488.00
3305.00
12488.00 0.00
3305.00 0.00
-4682.30
3580.70 -12.83
X-defl[01]
X-defl[02]
mm
mm
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
-1655.90
-1793.50
13596.00
0.00
0.00
-5078.50 -0.29
-5093.10 0.00
12820.00
12820.00 0.00
4108.30
0.00
0.00
-92.81 0.00
0.00
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 51
H. Efdé
Pitch control, absolute extreme values E50335
Variable
Unit baseline
Fxn
kN
208.05
E50335HTS
230.82
10.94
%
E50335LTS % E50335_PS %
207.83 -0.11
Fyn
kN
700.90
824.24
17.60
702.00
Fzn
kN
-969.49
-970.23
0.08
Mxn
Mxn-r
kNm
kNm
1411.40
1428.30
1339.60
1355.70
-5.09
-5.08
Myn
kNm
4403.20
4675.70
Myn-r
kNm
5077.70
5330.90
Mzn
kNm
-5639.70
-6007.50
Mzn-r
Mxb[1]
kNm
kNm
5612.50
-12138.00
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
Mxb[3]
kNm
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
Mxb[3]-p[02]
Myb[1]
kNm
kNm
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
Myb[2]
kNm
-4269.60
-4308.10
0.90
-4266.20 -0.08
-4269.60 0.00
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
12662.00
3483.80
12631.00
3151.40
-0.24
-9.54
12668.00 0.05
3482.50 -0.04
12662.00 0.00
3483.80 0.00
Myb[3]
kNm
-4631.40
-4698.90
1.46
-4626.60 -0.10
-4631.40 0.00
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
11504.00
11631.00
1.10
11502.00 -0.02
11504.00 0.00
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
3195.70
3213.20
0.55
3195.20 -0.02
3195.70 0.00
Mzb[1]
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
200.06
200.00
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
85.34
-81.09
-4.98
Mzb[2]
kNm
-180.79
-183.75
1.64
-180.93
0.08
-180.79 0.00
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
-180.75
-183.70
1.63
-180.88
0.07
-180.75 0.00
Mzb[2]-p[02]
Mzb[3]
kNm
kNm
-78.89
-129.73
87.79
176.44
11.28
36.01
-78.94
-129.79
0.06
0.05
-78.89 0.00
-129.73 0.00
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-129.70
176.35
35.97
-129.77
0.05
-129.70 0.00
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-68.69
74.23
8.07
-68.71
0.03
-68.69 0.00
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
-150320.00
-3213.00
-159940.00
-3609.30
6.40
12.33
-150670.00
-3213.70
0.23
0.02
-150320.00 0.00
-3213.00 0.00
Myt[02]
kNm
4799.60
5477.60
14.13
4789.10 -0.22
4799.60 0.00
Myt[01]
kNm
61869.00
79146.00
27.93
61748.00 -0.20
61869.00 0.00
Mzt[01]
kNm
-8397.10
-8401.70
0.05
-8407.20
0.12
-8397.10 0.00
Mzt[02]
kNm
-8397.10
-805.24
-8401.70
-831.82
0.05
3.30
-8407.20 0.12
-805.16 -0.01
-8397.10 0.00
-805.24 0.00
-977.70
-1057.50
8.16
-976.73 -0.10
-977.70 0.00
-1057.80
-1073.30
1.47
-1057.70 -0.01
-1057.80 0.00
8292.80
8976.60
8.25
8293.00
0.00
8292.80 0.00
8024.70
7565.20
8137.40
7927.00
1.40
4.78
8038.10
7565.00
0.17
0.00
8024.70 0.00
7565.20 0.00
538.09 -0.20
539.15 0.00
208.05 0.00
0.16
700.90 0.00
-969.18 -0.03
-969.49 0.00
1412.00
1428.90
0.04
0.04
1411.40 0.00
1428.30 0.00
6.19
4393.50 -0.22
4403.20 0.00
4.99
5080.70
0.06
5077.70 0.00
6.52
-5628.40 -0.20
-5639.70 0.00
5840.50
-13362.00
4.06
10.08
5611.00 -0.03
-12140.00 0.02
5612.50 0.00
-12138.00 0.00
4783.40
4636.30
-3.08
4774.80 -0.18
4783.40 0.00
1443.70
1432.10
-0.80
1440.80 -0.20
13234.00
4617.90
13277.00
4829.60
0.32
4.58
1437.80
1455.40
1.22
1436.60 -0.08
1437.80 0.00
12028.00
12212.00
1.53
12027.00 -0.01
12028.00 0.00
-3822.50
4912.70
28.52
-3824.60
0.05
-3822.50 0.00
1173.40
-3928.40
1291.60
-3927.10
10.07
-0.03
1173.50
-3928.30
0.01
0.00
1173.40 0.00
-3928.40 0.00
-10783
-12201
13.15
-10785
0.02
-10783 0.00
-2745.7
-3057.7
11.36
-2745 -0.03
-2745.7 0.00
173.73 -13.16
173.64 -13.18
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
539.15
671.28
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
1542.20
1463.40
13235.00
4618.00
200.06
200.00
0.01
0.00
0.00
0.00
85.32 -0.02
0.00
24.51
1546.40
200.06 0.00
200.00 0.00
85.34 0.00
0.00
0.00
-5.11
1443.70 0.00
13234.00 0.00
4617.90 0.00
0.00
0.27
1542.20 0.00
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 52
H. Efdé
Pitch control, absolute extreme values EcdVrb
Variable
Unit baseline
EcdVrbHTS
Fxn
kN
1083.70
1168.00
7.78
1093.70
0.92
Fyn
kN
345.01
343.95
-0.31
336.96
-2.33
337.96
-2.04
Fzn
Mxn
kN
kNm
-972.91
6606.60
-966.62
5986.70
-0.65
-9.38
-945.73
6884.80
-2.79
4.21
-980.85
6244.00
0.82
-5.49
Mxn-r
kNm
6611.40
5991.90
-9.37
6889.90
4.21
6249.50
-5.47
Myn
kNm
-19807.00
-19316.00
-2.48
-19439.00
-1.86
-19908.00
0.51
Myn-r
kNm
17780.00
18508.00
4.09
18609.00
4.66
18047.00
1.50
Mzn
Mzn-r
kNm
kNm
-11417.00
-19443.00
-9913.60
17089.00
-13.17
-12.11
-9999.30 -12.42
15895.00 -18.25
-11236.00
-19489.00
-1.59
0.24
Mxb[1]
kNm
5973.50
-6343.30
6.19
-6393.60
7.03
6132.70
2.67
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
8724.70
8824.10
1.14
-7066.90 -19.00
9024.60
3.44
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
2316.70
2441.80
5.40
-1866.00 -19.45
2388.10
3.08
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
7662.00
12371.00
5921.50
9228.60
-22.72
-25.40
6035.80 -21.22
8581.40 -30.63
8108.90
12652.00
5.83
2.27
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
3228.20
2442.10
-24.35
2273.30 -29.58
3261.00
1.02
Mxb[3]
kNm
-6290.20
7774.00
23.59
7929.20
26.06
6164.50
-2.00
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
8187.70
2209.80
11649.00
2956.90
42.27
33.81
11213.00
2934.10
36.95
32.78
8018.40
2132.40
-2.07
-3.50
Myb[1]
kNm
-18723.00
16627.00
-11.19
12862.00 -31.30
-19045.00
1.72
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-16048
16677.00
3.92
13177.00 -17.89
-16215
1.04
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-5259.4
5170.30
-1.69
4093.90 -22.16
-5285.9
0.50
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
-21537.00
-16598
-18884.00
-15747
-12.32
-5.13
-18062.00 -16.14
-15431
-7.03
-21946.00
-16803
1.90
1.24
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-5599.8
-5173.5
-7.61
-5045.9
-9.89
-5685.2
1.53
Myb[3]
kNm
15600.00
-20595.00
32.02
-19027.00
21.97
15742.00
0.91
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
15759.00
15958.00
1.26
15574.00
-1.17
15896.00
0.87
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
kNm
kNm
4852.80
490.22
-5367.6
279.88
10.61
-42.91
-5066.4
4.40
-230.27 -53.03
4894.60
460.35
0.86
-6.09
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
489.89
279.67
-42.91
-230.30 -52.99
460.02
-6.10
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
170.65
-184.86
8.33
-155.21
153.33 -10.15
Mzb[2]
kNm
735.27
464.44
-36.83
437.08 -40.56
738.61
0.45
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
734.82
264.44
464.12
151.82
-36.84
-42.59
436.78 -40.56
143.45 -45.75
738.15
262.80
0.45
-0.62
Mzb[3]
kNm
-261.79
631.35 141.17
572.95 118.86
-274.89
5.00
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-261.83
630.97 140.98
572.58 118.68
-274.93
5.00
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-182.14
232.07
27.41
200.51
10.09
-186.42
2.35
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
-54353.00
6752.50
-54851.00
6159.40
0.92
-8.78
-56518.00
7198.70
3.98
6.61
-57951.00
6399.60
6.62
-5.23
Myt[02]
kNm
-22697.00
-21954.00
-3.27
-22017.00
-3.00
-22749.00
0.23
Myt[01]
kNm
-184930.02
-158710.00
-14.18
-158660.00 -14.21
-187630.02
1.46
Mzt[01]
kNm
-12445.00
-11343.00
-8.85
-11041.00 -11.28
-12335.00
-0.88
Mzt[02]
kNm
-12445.00
-11994.00
-11343.00
9443.20
-8.85
-21.27
-11041.00 -11.28
-7486.90 -37.58
-12335.00
-11985.00
-0.88
-0.08
-13519.00
-11834.00
-12.46
-11475.00 -15.12
8701.10
-13115.00
50.73
7354.10
6087.10
6006.10
7327.10
-18.33
20.37
-5.06
5859.00
5562.60
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2049.80
-1630.10
Y-defl[01]
Y-defl[02]
mm
mm
0.00
546.94
0.00
489.39
%
EcdVrbLTS
%
964.94 -10.96
-9.05
-10.52
%
-13645.00
0.93
43.11
-8813.30
1.29
5752.10 -21.78
7263.70 19.33
7380.90
6132.60
0.36
0.75
5426.00
5869.00
0.17
-12452.00
-7.39
0.00
-20.48
EcdVrb_PS
0.00
-1773.20 -13.49
0.00
558.73
2.16
-2083.30
1.63
0.00
574.29
5.00
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 53
H. Efdé
Pitch control, absolute extreme values Eog50_12
Variable
Unit baseline
Fxn
kN
1260.50
Fyn
kN
65.24
Fzn
Mxn
kN
kNm
Mxn-r
kNm
6796.80
Myn
kNm
-5587.50
Myn-r
kNm
-4434.80
Mzn
Mzn-r
kNm
kNm
Mxb[1]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
-849.91
6788.90
Eog50_12HTS
1346.40
%
Eog50_12LTS
%
6.81
1026.80 -18.54
58.05 -11.02
35.77 -45.17
-857.22
6351.00
0.86
-6.45
-810.47
7096.20
-4.64
4.53
6360.40
-6.42
7101.60
4.48
-4867.80 -12.88
5654.50
2024.60 -63.77
Eog50_12_PS %
1218.60 -3.32
60.34 -7.51
-850.17 0.03
6484.50 -4.48
6491.00 -4.50
-5650.20
1.12
27.50
-2687.60 -39.40
-4346.10 -2.00
-4047.20
-6403.70
-4354.40
7.59
-4938.70 -22.88
1995.60 -50.69
-2054.40 -67.92
-3966.00 -2.01
-6246.70 -2.45
kNm
6471.50
5347.10 -17.37
5731.40 -11.44
6218.40 -3.91
kNm
8743.80
5206.00 -40.46
-4304.70 -50.77
8624.70 -1.36
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
2395.20
1778.90 -25.73
903.97 -62.26
2368.10 -1.13
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
5695.30
11520.00
6132.40
11151.00
7.67
-3.20
6509.40 14.29
-4157.00 -63.91
5624.60 -1.24
11201.00 -2.77
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
3036.60
2956.40
-2.64
-799.37 -73.68
2910.30 -4.16
Mxb[3]
kNm
5347.60
5589.40
4.52
5907.00
10.46
5313.30 -0.64
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
6807.80
2182.50
11190.00
2879.20
64.37
31.92
-4535.20 -33.38
950.19 -56.46
6740.90 -0.98
2152.70 -1.37
Myb[1]
kNm
18110.00
17462.00
-3.58
13247.00 -26.85
17200.00 -5.02
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
18006.00
16307.00
-9.44
12449.00 -30.86
17162.00 -4.69
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
5508.70
5066.80
-8.02
4145.00 -24.76
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
15815.00
15647.00
18510.00
18393.00
17.04
17.55
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
4775.80
5577.90
16.80
Myb[3]
kNm
16475.00
16575.00
0.61
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
15337.00
16135.00
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
kNm
kNm
4833.20
339.46
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
Mzb[2]
kNm
485.38
484.58
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
485.14
191.49
484.31
175.27
Mzb[3]
kNm
251.46
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
251.25
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
Myt[02]
kNm
Myt[01]
kNm
Mzt[01]
5208.20 -5.46
15005.00
15075.00
-5.12
-3.66
15097.00 -4.54
14953.00 -4.44
4875.20
2.08
4525.80 -5.23
13613.00 -17.37
15877.00 -3.63
5.20
13719.00 -10.55
14724.00 -4.00
4954.20
2.50
224.39 -33.90
4294.80 -11.14
132.76 -60.89
4624.80 -4.31
341.63 0.64
339.25
224.01 -33.97
132.60 -60.91
-131.22
-110.73 -15.61
49.39 -62.36
-122.91 -6.33
-0.16
114.66 -76.38
459.80 -5.27
-0.17
-8.47
114.55 -76.39
-58.11 -69.65
459.59 -5.27
182.18 -4.86
477.98
90.08
105.30 -58.12
264.69
5.26
477.72
90.14
105.16 -58.15
264.47
5.26
-98.61
179.46
81.99
-43.58 -55.81
-95.84 -2.81
-53142.00
7484.70
-57218.00
6981.60
7.67
-6.72
32217.00 -39.38
7632.50
1.97
-52623.00 -0.98
7144.70 -4.54
-8710.20
-7962.50
-8.58
-2339.10 -73.15
-8629.40 -0.93
-256050.02
-272180.00
6.30
127870.01 -50.06
-250910.02 -2.01
341.42
0.64
kNm
-4078.80
-4528.70
11.03
1288.60 -68.41
-3943.50 -3.32
Mzt[02]
kNm
-4078.80
10095.00
-4528.70
-9467.70
11.03
-6.21
1288.60 -68.41
7136.20 -29.31
-3943.50 -3.32
9404.90 -6.84
-9710.40
10268.00
5.74
8740.30
-9.99
-9576.10 -1.38
-9231.10
-10145.00
9.90
7560.90 -18.09
-9194.60 -0.40
4678.60
4297.30
5007.10
4903.70
7.02
14.11
-1822.80 -61.04
-2239.90 -47.88
4637.30 -0.88
4288.90 -0.20
5028.80
4485.20 -10.81
-1610.40 -67.98
5045.50
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2663.00
-2554.90
Y-defl[01]
Y-defl[02]
mm
mm
0.00
541.48
0.00
533.34
0.00
0.33
0.00
-4.06
1333.10 -49.94
-2610.00 -1.99
-1.50
0.00
-389.73 -28.03
0.00
532.27 -1.70
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 54
H. Efdé
Pitch control, absolute extreme values GrEog1Voc
Variable
Unit baseline GrEog1VocHTS
Fxn
kN
1021.8
1062.20
3.95
900.47
-11.87
1019.10 -0.26
Fyn
kN
-169.41
-168.47
-0.55
-180.93
6.80
-165.57 -2.27
Fzn
Mxn
kN
kNm
-832.81
7125.5
-881.72
6646.00
5.87
-6.73
-860.47
6867.20
3.32
-3.63
-833.17 0.04
6970.70 -2.17
Mxn-r
kNm
7132.3
6661.30
-6.60
6879.40
-3.55
6977.30 -2.17
Myn
kNm
8918.3
10324.00
15.76
9465.00
6.13
Myn-r
kNm
-7610.5
9773.20
28.42
9103.30
19.62
Mzn
Mzn-r
kNm
kNm
-6638.6
-8863.6
-8273.20 24.62
7624.70 -13.98
-7624.60
-7048.50
14.85
-20.48
-6863.00
-9081.60
3.38
2.46
Mxb[1]
kNm
-6555.6
5833.30 -11.02
5879.50
-10.31
-6616.30
0.93
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
5917.3
12066.00 103.91
10015.00
69.25
5815.90 -1.71
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1860.6
76.44
2803.80
50.69
1937.80
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
5374.4
9879.6
-7194.90 33.87
8810.90 -10.82
-6322.90
7657.00
17.65
-22.50
5389.60 0.28
9749.50 -1.32
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
2653.6
2586.90
-2.51
2320.20
-12.56
2610.80 -1.61
Mxb[3]
kNm
5821.5
6046.90
3.87
6074.40
4.34
5822.20
0.01
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
11389
3196.6
8335.80 -26.81
2256.30 -29.42
6637.10
-1841.70
-41.72
-42.39
11448.00
3210.70
0.52
0.44
Myb[1]
kNm
-12621
16.77
-11525.00
-8.68
-12914.00
2.32
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-12395
8617.40 -30.48
7961.10
-35.77
-12518
0.99
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-4493.2
-3404 -24.24
-2641.3
-41.22
-4544.2
1.14
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
-10652
7048.9
-16909.00 58.74
-14377 103.96
-14056.00
-12050
31.96
70.95
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-2139.5
-5069.6 136.95
Myb[3]
kNm
-15365
11255.00 -26.75
8287.70
-46.06
-15252.00 -0.74
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
11051
11195.00
1.30
7864.20
-28.84
10915.00 -1.23
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
kNm
kNm
-3818.1
-222.96
-2660.2 -30.33
375.85 68.57
-2154.3
244.95
-43.58
9.86
-3739.7 -2.05
-219.38 -1.61
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-223
68.46
244.86
9.80
-219.41 -1.61
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-165.8
-130.85 -21.08
-97.85
-40.98
-164.82 -0.59
Mzb[2]
kNm
209.39
422.73 101.89
335.87
60.40
206.28 -1.49
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
209.33
-148.62
422.36 101.77
-169.51 14.06
335.60
-135.65
60.32
-8.73
206.22 -1.49
-151.37 1.85
Mzb[3]
kNm
442.32
-225.72 -48.97
-169.84
-61.60
428.95 -3.02
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
442.08
-225.82 -48.92
-169.91
-61.57
428.71 -3.02
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
154.28
-171.80
11.36
-128.93
-16.43
149.36 -3.19
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
68493
6400.4
65642.00
6214.30
-4.16
-2.91
54625.00
6468.60
-20.25
1.07
66738.00 -2.56
6197.30 -3.17
Myt[02]
kNm
9533.9
10256.00
7.57
9462.30
-0.75
Myt[01]
kNm
-281560
-295470.00
4.94
-230930.02
-17.98
Mzt[01]
3282.80
-14738.00
375.67
%
GrEog1VocLTS
%
-4447.5 107.88
GrEog1Voc_PS %
9095.60
1.99
-7433.20 -2.33
4.15
-10600.00 -0.49
7112.10 0.90
-2120.2 -0.90
9627.40
0.98
-281050.00 -0.18
kNm
-6251.2
-8380.30
34.06
-7612.00
21.77
-6509.50
4.13
Mzt[02]
kNm
-6251.2
-9901.8
-8380.30 34.06
-8181.00 -17.38
-7612.00
-6609.80
21.77
-33.25
-6509.50
-9989.40
4.13
0.88
-5518.6
98.73
-9514.10
72.40
-5451.90 -1.21
-9006.1
-6839.40 -24.06
-5694.00
-36.78
-8864.10 -1.58
7315.1
4735.3
5841.20 -20.15
8012.10 69.20
5144.60
7615.30
-29.67
60.82
7382.50 0.92
4710.10 -0.53
6469
4557.50 -29.55
4222.60
-34.73
6397.70 -1.10
-10967.00
X-defl[01]
mm
0
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2923
-2720.40
Y-defl[01]
Y-defl[02]
mm
mm
0
-701.86
0.00
0.00
-6.93
-2382.70
-18.48
-2916.80 -0.21
0.00
-592.68 -15.56
0.00
-561.16
-20.05
0.00
-683.87 -2.56
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 55
H. Efdé
Pitch control, 24 m/s 1Hz equivalent values
Variable
Fxn
Fyn
Fzn
Mxn
Mxn-r
Myn
Myn-r
Mzn
Mzn-r
Mxb[1]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
Mxb[1]-p[02]
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
Mxb[2]-p[02]
Mxb[3]
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
Myb[1]
Myb[1]-p[01]
Myb[1]-p[02]
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
Myb[3]
Myb[3]-p[01]
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
Mzb[1]-p[01]
Mzb[1]-p[02]
Mzb[2]
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
Mzb[3]
Mzb[3]-p[01]
Mzb[3]-p[02]
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
Myt[02]
Myt[01]
Mzt[01]
Mzt[02]
unit
kN
kN
kN
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
mat.curve baseline 024HTS
M5
262.38
279.17
M5
192.75
192.56
M5
152.25
152.95
M5
2053.88 2030.16
M5
2064.61 2036.70
M5
6246.82 6543.98
M5
7054.66 7054.66
M5
6043.96 6321.70
M5
6724.79 7349.63
M10
8217.62 8278.08
M10
6536.84 6789.33
M10
1601.41 1677.33
M10
8339.45 8339.45
M10
6740.51 6781.14
M10
1698.61 1694.52
M10
8181.75 8327.10
M10
6432.20 6582.75
M10
1600.50 1626.41
M10
7679.12 8401.73
M10
8376.71 8907.30
M10
2409.49 2549.26
M10
8052.91 7995.67
M10
8439.55 8477.70
M10
2455.77 2379.92
M10
8146.21 8253.79
M10
8949.81 8978.38
M10
2640.20 2632.79
M10
123.53
133.60
M10
123.48
133.56
M10
76.04
85.84
M10
137.27
141.50
M10
137.22
141.44
M10
79.77
82.48
M10
135.58
139.02
M10
135.53
138.96
M10
78.00
77.50
M5
34205.57 31799.15
M5
2160.47 2169.36
M5
6372.64 6682.19
M5
39798.94 43047.84
M5
6946.24 7349.63
M5
6946.24 7349.63
% 024LTS
6.40
225.83
-0.10
163.49
0.46
132.48
-1.15 2334.20
-1.35 2344.58
4.76 5634.93
0.00 6197.87
4.60 5394.74
9.29 6296.54
0.74 7861.57
3.86 5893.09
4.74 1430.01
0.00 7950.47
0.60 6171.10
-0.24 1516.77
1.78 7995.67
2.34 5886.92
1.62 1458.56
9.41 7689.62
6.33 8401.73
5.80 2358.96
-0.71 7465.10
0.45 8278.08
-3.09 2382.95
1.32 6940.10
0.32 8029.91
-0.28 2380.93
8.15
114.40
8.16
114.35
12.89
68.10
3.08
107.70
3.08
107.66
3.40
67.65
2.54
116.84
2.53
117.03
-0.64
70.39
-7.04 28895.13
0.41 2431.05
4.86 5747.53
8.16 34961.50
5.81 6222.25
5.81 6222.25
%
024PS
%
-13.93
261.02 -0.52
-15.18
189.68 -1.59
-12.99
150.55 -1.12
13.65 2060.57 0.33
13.56 2065.95 0.06
-9.80 6210.04 -0.59
-12.15 7038.96 -0.22
-10.74 6020.96 -0.38
-6.37 6739.11 0.21
-4.33 8193.68 -0.29
-9.85 6567.38 0.47
-10.70 1604.61 0.20
-4.66 8290.28 -0.59
-8.45 6708.36 -0.48
-10.71 1685.88 -0.75
-2.27 8146.21 -0.43
-8.48 6439.56 0.11
-8.87 1614.27 0.86
0.14 7905.77 2.95
0.30 8351.83 -0.30
-2.10 2478.50 2.86
-7.30 8099.29 0.58
-1.91 8452.23 0.15
-2.97 2440.85 -0.61
-14.81 8134.43 -0.14
-10.28 8921.42 -0.32
-9.82 2656.41 0.61
-7.39
121.20 -1.89
-7.39
121.15 -1.89
-10.44
74.83 -1.59
-21.54
132.69 -3.34
-21.54
132.64 -3.34
-15.19
79.49 -0.35
-13.82
141.34 4.25
-13.65
141.28 4.24
-9.76
78.00 0.00
-15.53 33839.73 -1.07
12.52 2194.94 1.60
-9.81 6359.83 -0.20
-12.15 39798.94 0.00
-10.42 6885.78 -0.87
-10.42 6885.78 -0.87
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 56
H. Efdé
Variable
Fxn
Fyn
Fzn
Mxn
Mxn-r
Myn
Myn-r
Mzn
Mzn-r
Mxb[1]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
Mxb[1]-p[02]
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
Mxb[2]-p[02]
Mxb[3]
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
Myb[1]
Myb[1]-p[01]
Myb[1]-p[02]
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
Myb[3]
Myb[3]-p[01]
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
Mzb[1]-p[01]
Mzb[1]-p[02]
Mzb[2]
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
Mzb[3]
Mzb[3]-p[01]
Mzb[3]-p[02]
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
Myt[02]
Myt[01]
Mzt[01]
Mzt[02]
unit
kN
kN
kN
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
% 018LTS
%
018PS
M5
225.70
232.34
2.94
203.27 -9.94
225.20
M5
134.10
143.45
6.97
114.76 -14.42
140.16
M5
98.38
102.33
4.02
89.31 -9.22
96.70
M5
1430.71 1478.85
3.36 1619.66 13.21 1442.45
M5
1438.51 1485.10
3.24 1615.52 12.31 1449.72
M5
4863.97 5099.14
4.83 4497.53 -7.53 4841.64
M5
5182.66 5497.85
6.08 4761.50 -8.13 5099.14
M5
4826.87 4932.21
2.18 4367.17 -9.52 4718.89
M5
5216.84 5349.14
2.54 4826.87 -7.48 5331.11
M10
7262.69 7319.40
0.78 7053.24 -2.88 7272.08
M10
5880.77 5999.95
2.03 5605.34 -4.68 5942.90
M10
1338.47 1349.72
0.84 1262.75 -5.66 1333.71
M10
7357.69 7406.13
0.66 7053.24 -4.14 7253.33
M10
5936.63 6130.74
3.27 5561.00 -6.33 5949.19
M10
1357.53 1370.43
0.95 1227.48 -9.58 1326.48
M10
7319.40 7338.49
0.26 7160.99 -2.16 7281.50
M10
5874.63 5993.56
2.02 5511.96 -6.17 5795.93
M10
1307.06 1347.77
3.11 1228.55 -6.01 1293.24
M10
7035.60 6469.19 -8.05 5993.56 -14.81 6814.00
M10
7700.14 7565.51 -1.75 6454.34 -16.18 7585.91
M10
2187.42 2060.80 -5.79 1900.00 -13.14 2137.54
M10
6239.55 6948.68 11.37 5795.93 -7.11 6461.75
M10
7079.87 7170.12
1.27 6847.18 -3.29 7367.33
M10
1909.67 1877.80 -1.67 1914.87
0.27 2088.34
M10
6652.82 7097.74
6.69 6246.48 -6.11 6402.91
M10
7455.21 7627.06
2.31 6764.83 -9.26 7000.57
M10
2014.30 2148.98
6.69 1999.27 -0.75 1875.92
M10
112.49
115.25
2.45
99.73 -11.34
112.19
M10
112.50
115.21
2.41
99.70 -11.38
112.36
M10
63.80
63.67 -0.20
56.66 -11.19
64.22
M10
111.63
115.23
3.22
103.99 -6.84
114.54
M10
111.54
115.18
3.26
103.46 -7.24
114.49
M10
61.75
67.06
8.60
60.11 -2.66
62.57
M10
119.40
119.15 -0.21
101.78 -14.76
115.59
M10
118.64
119.10
0.39
101.74 -14.24
115.55
M10
63.97
66.73
4.31
56.26 -12.05
63.53
M5
20612.49 17529.18 -14.96 19003.10 -7.81 26700.56
M5
1567.50 1566.73 -0.05 1677.18
7.00 1542.29
M5
4901.65 5260.20
7.31 4440.72 -9.40 4894.07
M5
30868.45 32121.98
4.06 28124.59 -8.89 31482.75
M5
5497.85 5565.55
1.23 4901.65 -10.84 5268.96
M5
5497.85 5565.55
1.23 4901.65 -10.84 5268.96
%
-0.22
4.52
-1.71
0.82
0.78
-0.46
-1.61
-2.24
2.19
0.13
1.06
-0.36
-1.42
0.21
-2.29
-0.52
-1.34
-1.06
-3.15
-1.48
-2.28
3.56
4.06
9.36
-3.76
-6.10
-6.87
-0.27
-0.12
0.66
2.61
2.64
1.33
-3.19
-2.60
-0.69
29.54
-1.61
-0.15
1.99
-4.16
-4.16
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 57
H. Efdé
Variable
Fxn
Fyn
Fzn
Mxn
Mxn-r
Myn
Myn-r
Mzn
Mzn-r
Mxb[1]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
Mxb[1]-p[02]
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
Mxb[2]-p[02]
Mxb[3]
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
Myb[1]
Myb[1]-p[01]
Myb[1]-p[02]
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
Myb[3]
Myb[3]-p[01]
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
Mzb[1]-p[01]
Mzb[1]-p[02]
Mzb[2]
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
Mzb[3]
Mzb[3]-p[01]
Mzb[3]-p[02]
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
Myt[02]
Myt[01]
Mzt[01]
Mzt[02]
unit
kN
kN
kN
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
kNm
M5
226.47
244.46
M5
101.86
110.42
M5
71.95
80.79
M5
993.87 1052.39
M5
997.32 1057.66
M5
4095.81 4278.58
M5
4510.35 4649.54
M5
4048.64 4165.91
M5
4497.53 4704.85
M10
6923.02 7062.10
M10
5886.92 6012.78
M10
1252.63 1280.58
M10
6863.89 6983.19
M10
5807.90 5949.19
M10
1247.35 1252.63
M10
6889.11 6948.68
M10
5825.95 5999.95
M10
1247.63 1287.32
M10
6567.38 6582.75
M10
7035.60 6940.10
M10
2097.69 1999.98
M10
6267.36 6724.40
M10
6732.44 7328.93
M10
2004.97 2170.54
M10
6295.42 6469.19
M10
6814.00 6668.59
M10
2007.83 1971.24
M10
128.47
140.94
M10
128.35
140.88
M10
64.47
69.73
M10
125.66
137.34
M10
126.90
137.12
M10
64.84
66.76
M10
132.38
144.60
M10
132.31
144.55
M10
65.72
69.01
M5
8494.00 10390.86
M5
1141.62 1159.19
M5
4111.78 4272.80
M5
29709.08 30868.45
M5
4453.22 4608.90
M5
4453.22 4608.90
% 012LTS
7.94
239.19
8.40
88.13
12.29
63.06
5.89 1512.79
6.05 1518.60
4.46 3422.40
3.09 3903.78
2.90 3441.01
4.61 3846.82
2.01 6855.52
2.14 5801.91
2.23 1279.41
1.74 6923.02
2.43 5784.02
0.42 1257.39
0.86 6830.55
2.99 5742.68
3.18 1268.16
0.23 6772.97
-1.36 7179.27
-4.66 2125.43
7.29 6772.97
8.86 7000.57
8.26 2208.03
2.76 6872.28
-2.13 7700.14
-1.82 2383.96
9.71
126.43
9.76
126.33
8.16
62.67
9.29
117.41
8.05
117.15
2.96
60.39
9.23
119.49
9.25
119.40
5.01
61.66
22.33 7726.53
1.54 1570.62
3.92 3545.11
3.90 30570.20
3.50 3846.82
3.50 3846.82
%
012PS
%
5.62
209.11 -7.67
-13.48
101.25 -0.60
-12.36
68.65 -4.59
52.21 1042.33
4.88
52.27 1025.77
2.85
-16.44 4095.81
0.00
-13.45 4453.22 -1.27
-15.01 4053.83
0.13
-14.47 4491.15 -0.14
-0.98 6906.02 -0.25
-1.44 5795.93 -1.55
2.14 1235.57 -1.36
0.86 6872.28
0.12
-0.41 5813.91
0.10
0.80 1218.18 -2.34
-0.85 6822.26 -0.97
-1.43 5778.08 -0.82
1.65 1209.01 -3.10
3.13 6012.78 -8.44
2.04 6521.69 -7.30
1.32 1825.98 -12.95
8.07 5772.15 -7.90
3.98 6316.63 -6.18
10.13 1771.91 -11.62
9.16 5880.77 -6.59
13.00 6559.72 -3.73
18.73 1778.08 -11.44
-1.59
124.23 -3.30
-1.57
124.16 -3.26
-2.79
62.77 -2.64
-6.57
118.28 -5.87
-7.68
118.21 -6.85
-6.86
60.48 -6.72
-9.74
125.81 -4.96
-9.76
125.51 -5.14
-6.18
61.89 -5.83
-9.04 10743.68 26.49
37.58 1188.80
4.13
-13.78 4085.23 -0.65
2.90 25011.98 -15.81
-13.62 4459.50
0.14
-13.62 4459.50
0.14
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 58
Appendix G.
H. Efdé
Tables tapered blade.
Tapered blade, absolute extreme values 1B-5Vo
Variable
Unit baseline 1B-5VoB
Fxn
kN
754.16
749.52
%
-0.62
Fyn
kN
226.72
253.45
11.79
Fzn
kN
-972.67
-975.28
0.27
Mxn
Mxn-r
kNm
kNm
7399.00
7411.90
7319.90
7332.10
-1.07
-1.08
Myn
kNm
-10044.00
-9405.00
-6.36
Myn-r
kNm
-10694.00
-10383.00
-2.91
Mzn
kNm
-10830.00
-10507.00
-2.98
Mzn-r
Mxb[1]
kNm
kNm
-11132.00
8565.80
-10539.00
8601.60
-5.33
0.42
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-5831.90
5791.20
-0.70
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1655.80
1620.90
-2.11
Mxb[2]
kNm
9271.40
9031.20
-2.59
Mxb[2]-p[01]
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
-5266.30
-1134.90
-5261.60
-1119.10
-0.09
-1.39
Mxb[3]
kNm
6321.20
6212.70
-1.72
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-6438.30
-6055.90
-5.94
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-1569.00
-1452.50
-7.43
Myb[1]
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
7783.60
-9875.40
7790.70
-10059.00
0.09
1.86
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-1858.10
-1798.90
-3.19
Myb[2]
kNm
13858.00
13317.00
-3.90
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
-15152.00
-4004.70
-14577.00
-3691.90
-3.79
-7.81
Myb[3]
kNm
8487.10
8148.00
-4.00
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-8286.80
-8247.00
-0.48
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-2065.60
-1961.50
-5.04
Mzb[1]
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
-200.46
-200.50
-179.97 -10.22
-180.01 -10.22
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-122.62
-114.01
-7.02
Mzb[2]
kNm
106.43
103.69
-2.57
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
106.26
103.53
-2.57
Mzb[2]-p[02]
Mzb[3]
kNm
kNm
-78.21
-193.56
-68.76 -12.08
-188.15 -2.79
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-193.60
-188.19
-2.79
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-126.19
-114.82
-9.01
Mxt[01]
kNm
65292.00
63571.00
-2.64
Mxt[02]
Myt[02]
kNm
kNm
7840.50
-10690.00
7701.50
-10091.00
-1.77
-5.60
Myt[01]
kNm
132960.00 128250.01
-3.54
Mzt[01]
kNm
-12024.00
-11630.00
-3.28
Mzt[02]
kNm
-12024.00
-11630.00
-3.28
-4645.10
6194.50
-4658.00
0.28
5482.40 -11.50
-5266.10
-5124.50
2729.60
2752.90
0.85
-3111.70
-2841.00
-8.70
X-defl[01]
mm
2500.40
0.00
2431.10
0.00
-2.77
X-defl[02]
mm
1288.40
1259.60
-2.24
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
-722.62
-708.81
-2.69
-1.91
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 59
H. Efdé
Tapered blade, absolute extreme values E50025
Variable
Unit baseline E50025B
%
Fxn
kN
219.25
-4.47
Fyn
kN
-754.32
-664.51 -11.91
Fzn
Mxn
kN
kNm
-1061.40
-1811.20
-1002.60 -5.54
1429.80 -21.06
Mxn-r
kNm
-1832.90
1447.00 -21.05
Myn
kNm
-5803.00
-5131.30 -11.58
Myn-r
kNm
-7841.90
-5275.00 -32.73
Mzn
Mzn-r
kNm
kNm
-6118.30
6751.50
6513.90
6.47
5215.20 -22.75
Mxb[1]
kNm
13230.00
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
6088.80
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1848.00
1309.30 -29.15
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
13596.00
5961.90
14632.00
7.62
4667.70 -21.71
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
1642.20
1350.40 -17.77
Mxb[3]
kNm
14612.00
12269.00 -16.03
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
4560.10
1405.30
Myb[1]
kNm
-5097.40
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-12488.00
-12755.00
2.14
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-3305.00
-3493.40
5.70
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
-5093.10
-12820.00
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-4009.50
-3751.00
Myb[3]
kNm
-5115.30
-4552.00 -11.01
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-14260.00
-11435.00 -19.81
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
kNm
kNm
-4107.50
239.20
-3138.00 -23.60
178.34 -25.44
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
239.09
178.23 -25.45
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
99.40
Mzb[2]
kNm
-202.11
-224.25
10.95
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
-202.11
-92.81
-224.20
-99.59
10.93
7.31
Mzb[3]
kNm
-166.83
159.99
-4.10
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-166.79
159.94
-4.11
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-82.80
-81.69
-1.34
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
Myt[02]
kNm
-6882.50
-6351.60
Myt[01]
kNm
73903.00
63379.00 -14.24
Mzt[01]
kNm
9314.30
9715.00
4.30
Mzt[02]
Tip displ. flap[1]
kNm
mm
9314.30
-1030.60
9715.00
-933.28
4.30
-9.44
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-1113.80
-981.78 -11.85
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-1340.20
-1066.70 -20.41
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
mm
8234.50
8537.20
7772.00
8051.80
-5.62
-5.69
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
7464.10
7761.70
3.99
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
677.65
584.34 -13.77
Y-defl[01]
Y-defl[02]
mm
mm
0.00
-1655.90
0.00
-1352.90 -18.30
209.45
13375.00
1.10
4706.20 -22.71
4625.00
1306.50
1.42
-7.03
4221.00 -17.19
4049.70 -20.49
-13944.00
8.77
-6.45
-80.12 -19.40
164060.00 131830.00 -19.65
3774.50
2539.50 -32.72
-7.71
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 60
H. Efdé
Tapered blade, absolute extreme values E50335
Variable
Unit baseline
Fxn
kN
Fyn
kN
Fzn
Mxn
kN
kNm
-969.49
1411.40
-956.65
-1477.30
Mxn-r
kNm
1428.30
-1494.90
4.66
Myn
kNm
4403.20
4227.00
-4.00
Myn-r
kNm
5077.70
-5315.10
4.68
Mzn
Mzn-r
kNm
kNm
-5639.70
5612.50
-5504.60
-5799.80
-2.40
3.34
Mxb[1]
kNm
-12138.00
-11512.00
-5.16
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
4783.40
4431.20
-7.36
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1443.70
1414.10
-2.05
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
13234.00
4617.90
12897.00
4373.50
-2.55
-5.29
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
1437.80
Mxb[3]
kNm
12028.00
11102.00
-7.70
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
-3822.50
1173.40
4786.60
1390.50
25.22
18.50
Myb[1]
kNm
-3928.40
-4090.90
4.14
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-10783.00
-10540.00
-2.25
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-2745.70
2812.30
2.43
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
4269.60
12662.00
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
3483.80
3210.10
-7.86
Myb[3]
kNm
-4631.40
-4248.50
-8.27
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
11504.00
10622.00
-7.67
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
kNm
kNm
3195.70
200.06
2804.90 -12.23
174.67 -12.69
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
200.00
174.59 -12.71
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
85.34
-81.08
-4.99
Mzb[2]
kNm
-180.79
180.68
-0.06
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
-180.75
-78.89
180.60
-86.66
-0.08
9.85
Mzb[3]
kNm
-129.73
187.28
44.36
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-129.70
187.21
44.34
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-68.69
-105.48
53.56
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
Myt[02]
kNm
4799.60
-4574.30
-4.69
Myt[01]
kNm
61869.00
57091.00
-7.72
Mzt[01]
kNm
-8397.10
-8353.00
-0.53
Mzt[02]
Tip displ. flap[1]
kNm
mm
-8397.10
-805.24
-8353.00
-951.43
-0.53
18.15
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-977.70
-880.65
-9.93
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-1057.80
-969.88
-8.31
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
mm
8292.80
8024.70
7941.70
7651.90
-4.23
-4.65
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
7565.20
7827.00
3.46
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
539.15
479.43 -11.08
Y-defl[01]
Y-defl[02]
mm
mm
0.00
1542.20
0.00
1310.60 -15.02
208.05
700.90
E50335B
%
183.71 -11.70
606.16 -13.52
-1.32
4.67
1197.70 -16.70
3610.50 -15.44
12282.00 -3.00
-150320.00 -130520.01 -13.17
-3213.00
-2997.20 -6.72
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 61
H. Efdé
Tapered blade, absolute extreme values EcdVrb
Variable
Unit baseline
Fxn
kN
1083.70
EcdVrbB
1080.50
%
-0.30
Fyn
kN
345.01
341.06
-1.14
Fzn
Mxn
kN
kNm
-972.91
6606.60
-983.29
6603.30
1.07
-0.05
Mxn-r
kNm
6611.40
6608.00
-0.05
Myn
kNm
-19807.00
-20074.00
1.35
Myn-r
kNm
17780.00
17288.00
-2.77
Mzn
Mzn-r
kNm
kNm
-11417.00
-19443.00
-11479.00
-19625.00
0.54
0.94
Mxb[1]
kNm
5973.50
5611.20
-6.07
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
8724.70
8563.90
-1.84
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
2316.70
2123.20
-8.35
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
7662.00
12371.00
8126.90
12032.00
6.07
-2.74
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
3228.20
2961.00
-8.28
Mxb[3]
kNm
-6290.20
-6278.40
-0.19
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
8187.70
2209.80
7457.20
1996.40
-8.92
-9.66
Myb[1]
kNm
-18723.00
-18870.00
0.79
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-16048
-16333
1.78
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-5259.4
-5267.7
0.16
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
-21537.00
-16598
-20875.00
-15944
-3.07
-3.94
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-5599.8
-5435
-2.94
Myb[3]
kNm
15600.00
15303.00
-1.90
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
15759.00
15437.00
-2.04
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
kNm
kNm
4852.80
490.22
4630.10
494.51
-4.59
0.88
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
489.89
494.17
0.87
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
170.65
164.97
-3.33
Mzb[2]
kNm
735.27
671.90
-8.62
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
734.82
264.44
671.49 -8.62
229.40 -13.25
Mzb[3]
kNm
-261.79
-232.40 -11.23
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
-261.83
-232.44 -11.22
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-182.14
-164.13
-9.89
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
-54353.00
6752.50
-51429.00
6783.10
-5.38
0.45
Myt[02]
kNm
-22697.00
-23145.00
1.97
Myt[01]
kNm
-184930.02 -177690.02
-3.91
Mzt[01]
kNm
-12445.00
-12497.00
0.42
Mzt[02]
Tip displ. flap[1]
kNm
mm
-12445.00
-11994.00
-12497.00
-12066.00
0.42
0.60
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-13519.00
-13101.00
-3.09
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
8701.10
8202.90
-5.73
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
mm
7354.10
6087.10
7042.80
5642.80
-4.23
-7.30
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
5859.00
5845.50
-0.23
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2049.80
-1969.50
-3.92
Y-defl[01]
Y-defl[02]
mm
mm
0.00
546.94
0.00
513.06
-6.19
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 62
H. Efdé
Tapered blade, absolute extreme values Eog50_12
Variable
Unit baseline
Fxn
kN
1260.50
Eog50_12B
Fyn
kN
65.24
Fzn
kN
-849.91
-821.69
-3.32
Mxn
Mxn-r
kNm
kNm
6788.90
6796.80
6741.90
6749.10
-0.69
-0.70
Myn
kNm
-5587.50
2046.30 -63.38
Myn-r
kNm
-4434.80
2566.50 -42.13
Mzn
kNm
-4047.20
2478.40 -38.76
Mzn-r
Mxb[1]
kNm
kNm
-6403.70
6471.50
3121.10 -51.26
6493.90
0.35
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
8743.80
-4584.50 -47.57
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
2395.20
841.50 -64.87
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
5695.30
11520.00
5697.50
0.04
5341.00 -53.64
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
3036.60
1192.00 -60.75
Mxb[3]
kNm
5347.60
Mxb[3]-p[01]
kNm
6807.80
-4483.00 -34.15
Mxb[3]-p[02]
Myb[1]
kNm
kNm
2182.50
18110.00
728.90 -66.60
17622.00 -2.69
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
18006.00
17521.00
-2.69
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
5508.70
5250.40
-4.69
Myb[2]
kNm
15815.00
15321.00
-3.12
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
15647.00
4775.80
15222.00
4528.30
-2.72
-5.18
Myb[3]
kNm
16475.00
16067.00
-2.48
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
15337.00
15119.00
-1.42
Myb[3]-p[02]
kNm
4833.20
4663.30
-3.52
Mzb[1]
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
339.46
339.25
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-131.22
-62.54 -52.34
Mzb[2]
kNm
485.38
132.21 -72.76
Mzb[2]-p[01]
kNm
485.14
132.05 -72.78
Mzb[2]-p[02]
Mzb[3]
kNm
kNm
191.49
251.46
-61.86 -67.70
170.42 -32.23
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
251.25
170.11 -32.29
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
-98.61
-63.89 -35.21
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
-53142.00
7484.70
35405.00 -33.38
7472.70 -0.16
Myt[02]
kNm
-8710.20
2424.20 -72.17
Myt[01]
kNm
-256050.02
154620.00 -39.61
Mzt[01]
kNm
-4078.80
1702.50 -58.26
Mzt[02]
Tip displ. flap[1]
kNm
mm
-4078.80
10095.00
1702.50 -58.26
9527.90 -5.62
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-9710.40
8024.20 -17.36
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-9231.10
8171.10 -11.48
Tip displ. lag[1]
mm
4678.60
-2157.40 -53.89
Tip displ. lag[2]
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
mm
4297.30
5028.80
-1658.50 -61.41
-1965.90 -60.91
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2663.00
Y-defl[01]
mm
0.00
Y-defl[02]
mm
541.48
1223.20
%
-2.96
-32.15 -50.72
6071.70
13.54
129.97 -61.71
129.83 -61.73
0.00
1614.50 -39.37
0.00
-418.09 -22.79
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 63
H. Efdé
Tapered blade, absolute extreme values GrEog1Voc
Variable
Unit baseline
Fxn
kN
1021.80
GrEog1VocB
996.64
%
-2.46
Fyn
kN
-169.41
-166.65
-1.63
Fzn
Mxn
kN
kNm
-832.81
7125.50
-837.24
6970.00
0.53
-2.18
Mxn-r
kNm
7132.30
6982.60
-2.10
Myn
kNm
8918.30
9285.50
4.12
Myn-r
kNm
-7610.50
-6561.80 -13.78
Mzn
Mzn-r
kNm
kNm
-6638.60
-8863.60
-8216.70
-9266.00
23.77
4.54
Mxb[1]
kNm
-6555.60
-6732.30
2.70
Mxb[1]-p[01]
kNm
5917.30
6401.70
8.19
Mxb[1]-p[02]
kNm
1860.60
2063.90
10.93
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
5374.40
9879.60
5491.50
9127.30
2.18
-7.61
Mxb[2]-p[02]
kNm
2653.60
2378.10 -10.38
Mxb[3]
kNm
5821.50
5787.80
-0.58
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
11389.00
3196.60
11476.00
3165.40
0.76
-0.98
Myb[1]
kNm
-12621.00
-13668.00
8.30
Myb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-12395
-12640
1.98
Myb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-4493.2
-4581.3
1.96
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
kNm
kNm
-10652.00
7048.90
-10381.00
7927.10
-2.54
12.46
Myb[2]-p[02]
kNm
-2139.5
-2153.7
0.66
Myb[3]
kNm
-15365.00
-14646.00
-4.68
Myb[3]-p[01]
kNm
11051.00
10055.00
-9.01
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
kNm
kNm
-3818.1
-222.96
-3481.7
252.36
-8.81
13.19
Mzb[1]-p[01]
kNm
-223.00
252.10
13.05
Mzb[1]-p[02]
kNm
-165.80
-150.63
-9.15
Mzb[2]
kNm
209.39
197.05
-5.89
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
kNm
kNm
209.33
-148.62
196.98
-146.09
-5.90
-1.70
Mzb[3]
kNm
442.32
391.77 -11.43
Mzb[3]-p[01]
kNm
442.08
391.58 -11.42
Mzb[3]-p[02]
kNm
154.28
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
kNm
kNm
68493.00
6400.40
Myt[02]
kNm
Myt[01]
kNm
Mzt[01]
kNm
Mzt[02]
Tip displ. flap[1]
129.95 -15.77
70826.00
6130.30
3.41
-4.22
9533.90
9525.10
-0.09
-281560.00
-275330.00
-2.21
-6251.20
-8173.80
30.76
kNm
mm
-6251.20
-9901.80
-8173.80
-10010.00
30.76
1.09
Tip disp. flap[2]
mm
-5518.60
-5792.80
4.97
Tip disp. flap[3]
mm
-9006.10
-8318.70
-7.63
Tip displ. lag[1]
Tip displ. lag[2]
mm
mm
7315.10
4735.30
7285.40
4579.60
-0.41
-3.29
Tip displ. lag[3]
mm
6469.00
5845.00
-9.65
X-defl[01]
mm
0.00
0.00
X-defl[02]
mm
-2923.00
-2862.90
-2.06
Y-defl[01]
Y-defl[02]
mm
mm
0.00
-701.86
0.00
-726.11
3.46
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 64
H. Efdé
Tapered blade, 24 m/s 1Hz equivalent values
Variable
unit
mat.curve baseline 024B
Fxn
kN
M5
262.38 258.74
Fyn
kN
M5
192.75 185.36
Fzn
kN
M5
152.25 147.12
Mxn
kNm
M5
2053.88 2017.22
Mxn-r
kNm
M5
2064.61 2019.79
Myn
kNm
M5
6246.82 6102.24
Myn-r
kNm
M5
7054.66 6885.78
Mzn
kNm
M5
6043.96 5908.52
Mzn-r
kNm
M5
6724.79 6626.21
Mxb[1]
kNm
M10
8217.62 8278.08
Mxb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
6536.84 6514.14
Mxb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
1601.41 1607.82
Mxb[2]
kNm
M10
8339.45 8217.62
Mxb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
6740.51 6724.40
Mxb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
1698.61 1678.84
Mxb[3]
kNm
M10
8181.75 7995.67
Mxb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
6432.20 6352.30
Mxb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
1600.50 1578.04
Myb[1]
kNm
M10
7679.12 7504.94
Myb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
8376.71 8439.55
Myb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
2409.49 2348.13
Myb[2]
kNm
M10
8052.91 7905.77
Myb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
8439.55 8290.28
Myb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
2455.77 2331.58
Myb[3]
kNm
M10
8146.21 7883.61
Myb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
8949.81 8714.11
Myb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
2640.20 2485.07
Mzb[1]
kNm
M10
123.53 116.51
Mzb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
123.48 116.55
Mzb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
76.04
69.78
Mzb[2]
kNm
M10
137.27 124.07
Mzb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
137.22 123.91
Mzb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
79.77
73.68
Mzb[3]
kNm
M10
135.58 124.07
Mzb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
135.53 124.04
Mzb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
78.00
71.30
Mxt[01]
kNm
M5
34205.57 34205.57
Mxt[02]
kNm
M5
2160.47 2134.24
Myt[02]
kNm
M5
6372.64 6309.10
Myt[01]
kNm
M5
39798.94 39798.94
Mzt[01]
kNm
M5
6946.24 6826.35
Mzt[02]
kNm
M5
6946.24 6826.35
%
-1.39
-3.83
-3.37
-1.78
-2.17
-2.31
-2.39
-2.24
-1.47
0.74
-0.35
0.40
-1.46
-0.24
-1.16
-2.27
-1.24
-1.40
-2.27
0.75
-2.55
-1.83
-1.77
-5.06
-3.22
-2.63
-5.88
-5.68
-5.61
-8.23
-9.62
-9.70
-7.63
-8.49
-8.48
-8.59
0.00
-1.21
-1.00
0.00
-1.73
-1.73
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 65
H. Efdé
Variable
unit
Fxn
kN
M5
225.70
220.09
Fyn
kN
M5
134.10
129.80
Fzn
kN
M5
98.38
97.82
Mxn
kNm
M5
1430.71 1444.42
Mxn-r
kNm
M5
1438.51 1452.38
Myn
kNm
M5
4863.97 4733.00
Myn-r
kNm
M5
5182.66 5050.30
Mzn
kNm
M5
4826.87 4670.13
Mzn-r
kNm
M5
5216.84 5165.74
Mxb[1]
kNm
M10
7262.69 7262.69
Mxb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
5880.77 5862.38
Mxb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
1338.47 1305.24
Mxb[2]
kNm
M10
7357.69 7272.08
Mxb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
5936.63 5930.37
Mxb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
1357.53 1331.19
Mxb[3]
kNm
M10
7319.40 7253.33
Mxb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
5874.63 5813.91
Mxb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
1307.06 1302.52
Myb[1]
kNm
M10
7035.60 6668.59
Myb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
7700.14 7300.40
Myb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
2187.42 2098.47
Myb[2]
kNm
M10
6239.55 6295.42
Myb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
7079.87 7234.67
Myb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
1909.67 1855.50
Myb[3]
kNm
M10
6652.82 6529.26
Myb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
7455.21 7151.89
Myb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
2014.30 1915.53
Mzb[1]
kNm
M10
112.49
106.89
Mzb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
112.50
106.85
Mzb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
63.80
59.61
Mzb[2]
kNm
M10
111.63
99.39
Mzb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
111.54
99.35
Mzb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
61.75
57.52
Mzb[3]
kNm
M10
119.40
107.68
Mzb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
118.64
107.65
Mzb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
63.97
59.41
Mxt[01]
kNm
M5
20612.49 20217.36
Mxt[02]
kNm
M5
1567.50 1529.61
Myt[02]
kNm
M5
4901.65 4761.50
Myt[01]
kNm
M5
30868.45 31172.57
Mzt[01]
kNm
M5
5497.85 5304.30
Mzt[02]
kNm
M5
5497.85 5304.30
%
-2.49
-3.21
-0.57
0.96
0.96
-2.69
-2.55
-3.25
-0.98
0.00
-0.31
-2.48
-1.16
-0.11
-1.94
-0.90
-1.03
-0.35
-5.22
-5.19
-4.07
0.90
2.19
-2.84
-1.86
-4.07
-4.90
-4.98
-5.02
-6.57
-10.96
-10.93
-6.85
-9.82
-9.26
-7.13
-1.92
-2.42
-2.86
0.99
-3.52
-3.52
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 66
H. Efdé
Variable
unit
Fxn
kN
M5
226.47
221.84
Fyn
kN
M5
101.86
99.44
Fzn
kN
M5
71.95
71.76
Mxn
kNm
M5
993.87
991.38
Mxn-r
kNm
M5
997.32
993.25
Myn
kNm
M5
4095.81 3908.60
Myn-r
kNm
M5
4510.35 4361.15
Mzn
kNm
M5
4048.64 3870.35
Mzn-r
kNm
M5
4497.53 4379.26
Mxb[1]
kNm
M10
6923.02 6914.51
Mxb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
5886.92 5924.13
Mxb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
1252.63 1292.05
Mxb[2]
kNm
M10
6863.89 6872.28
Mxb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
5807.90 5911.67
Mxb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
1247.35 1272.47
Mxb[3]
kNm
M10
6889.11 6897.56
Mxb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
5825.95 5856.28
Mxb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
1247.63 1282.04
Myb[1]
kNm
M10
6567.38 6469.19
Myb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
7035.60 6872.28
Myb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
2097.69 2010.70
Myb[2]
kNm
M10
6267.36 6084.32
Myb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
6732.44 6559.72
Myb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
2004.97 1937.30
Myb[3]
kNm
M10
6295.42 6330.85
Myb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
6814.00 6629.30
Myb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
2007.83 1913.57
Mzb[1]
kNm
M10
128.47
124.36
Mzb[1]-p[01] kNm
M10
128.35
123.61
Mzb[1]-p[02] kNm
M10
64.47
60.36
Mzb[2]
kNm
M10
125.66
120.97
Mzb[2]-p[01] kNm
M10
126.90
120.92
Mzb[2]-p[02] kNm
M10
64.84
61.31
Mzb[3]
kNm
M10
132.38
125.56
Mzb[3]-p[01] kNm
M10
132.31
125.49
Mzb[3]-p[02] kNm
M10
65.72
61.88
Mxt[01]
kNm
M5
8494.00 9750.43
Mxt[02]
kNm
M5
1141.62 1102.25
Myt[02]
kNm
M5
4111.78 3865.62
Myt[01]
kNm
M5
29709.08 27633.33
Mzt[01]
kNm
M5
4453.22 4238.46
Mzt[02]
kNm
M5
4453.22 4238.46
%
-2.04
-2.38
-0.26
-0.25
-0.41
-4.57
-3.31
-4.40
-2.63
-0.12
0.63
3.15
0.12
1.79
2.01
0.12
0.52
2.76
-1.50
-2.32
-4.15
-2.92
-2.57
-3.38
0.56
-2.71
-4.69
-3.20
-3.69
-6.38
-3.73
-4.71
-5.44
-5.15
-5.15
-5.84
14.79
-3.45
-5.99
-6.99
-4.82
-4.82
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 67
Appendix H.
H. Efdé
Low Lambda control.
Low Lambda control, 1Hz equivalent values
baseline
Variable
Fxn
Fyn
Fzn
Mxn
Mxn-r
Myn
Myn-r
Mzn
Mzn-r
Mxb[1]
Mxb[1]-p[01]
Mxb[1]-p[02]
Mxb[2]
Mxb[2]-p[01]
Mxb[2]-p[02]
Mxb[3]
Mxb[3]-p[01]
Mxb[3]-p[02]
Myb[1]
Myb[1]-p[01]
Myb[1]-p[02]
Myb[2]
Myb[2]-p[01]
Myb[2]-p[02]
Myb[3]
Myb[3]-p[01]
Myb[3]-p[02]
Mzb[1]
Mzb[1]-p[01]
Mzb[1]-p[02]
Mzb[2]
Mzb[2]-p[01]
Mzb[2]-p[02]
Mzb[3]
Mzb[3]-p[01]
Mzb[3]-p[02]
Mxt[01]
Mxt[02]
Myt[02]
Myt[01]
Mzt[01]
Mzt[02]
Low Lambda
132.56
65.54
50.48
734.02
736.76
2538.32
2823.751
2548.541
2808.711
5400.82
4498.159
991.44
5369.889
4483.82
1000.61
5390.469
4448.359
983.12
5139.288
5539.1
1617.99
4936.339
5375.02
1577.16
5111.269
5539.1
1578.04
94.11
94.07
48.57
92.07
92.02
48.72
96.99
96.96
49.33
11443.088
789.13
2558.841
17529.178
2823.751
2823.751
129.53
58.32
46.79
814.1
815.99
2429.18
2707.751
2429.18
2703.13
5309.068
4427.349
953.46
5324.139
4406.549
955.24
5349.459
4379.1
944.49
5006.63
5375.02
1579.82
4876.42
5284.129
1567.05
4863.779
5274.22
1537.08
93.37
93.33
46.84
91.03
91
46.93
96.16
96.1
47.84
10028.566
855.71
2447.981
16965.238
2677.961
2677.961
% Low Lambda 2
-2.29
-11.02
-7.31
10.91
10.75
-4.30
-4.11
-4.68
-3.76
-1.70
-1.57
-3.83
-0.85
-1.72
-4.53
-0.76
-1.56
-3.93
-2.58
-2.96
-2.36
-1.21
-1.69
-0.64
-4.84
-4.78
-2.60
-0.79
-0.79
-3.56
-1.13
-1.11
-3.67
-0.86
-0.89
-3.02
-12.36
8.44
-4.33
-3.22
-5.16
-5.16
131.83
61.71
47.95
779.21
781.52
2488.41
2762.12
2494.29
2764.541
5344.378
4466.02
966.4
5349.459
4462.479
970.9
5380.159
4420.4
959.8
5120.579
5572.02
1608.27
4919.068
5329.188
1569.68
4919.068
5385.31
1534.56
93.85
93.81
47.5
91.34
91.3
47.43
96.84
96.78
48.34
10356.836
829.03
2512.12
17242.598
2769.37
2769.37
% Low Lambda 3
-0.55
-5.84
-5.01
6.16
6.08
-1.97
-2.18
-2.13
-1.57
-1.05
-0.71
-2.53
-0.38
-0.48
-2.97
-0.19
-0.63
-2.37
-0.36
0.59
-0.60
-0.35
-0.85
-0.47
-3.76
-2.78
-2.76
-0.28
-0.28
-2.20
-0.79
-0.78
-2.65
-0.15
-0.19
-2.01
-9.49
5.06
-1.83
-1.63
-1.93
-1.93
139.49
65.86
51.60
760.67
763.24
2569.23
2831.33
2565.07
2859.48
5442.63
4563.86
996.53
5421.64
4549.10
999.37
5406.01
4527.13
998.83
5065.25
5511.96
1560.10
5162.88
5594.19
1609.19
5065.25
5506.56
1574.51
101.33
101.28
49.57
100.53
100.48
50.85
103.06
103.02
49.76
11082.36
816.83
2577.60
17825.45
2877.68
2877.68
% Low Lambda 4
5.23
0.49
2.22
3.63
3.59
1.22
0.27
0.65
1.81
0.77
1.46
0.51
0.96
1.46
-0.12
0.29
1.77
1.60
-1.44
-0.49
-3.58
4.59
4.08
2.03
-0.90
-0.59
-0.22
7.67
7.66
2.06
9.19
9.19
4.37
6.26
6.25
0.87
-3.15
3.51
0.73
1.69
1.91
1.91
139.67
66.90
52.42
767.49
770.48
2637.77
2888.19
2592.39
2867.25
5458.47
4578.72
999.90
5437.37
4563.86
1009.59
5400.82
4545.42
1006.16
4971.24
5517.37
1564.00
5201.07
5610.93
1610.58
5139.29
5599.76
1574.95
101.33
101.28
49.50
100.73
100.68
50.69
103.18
103.14
50.28
10780.29
814.94
2659.95
17926.44
2896.12
2896.12
% Low Lambda 5
5.36
2.08
3.84
4.56
4.58
3.92
2.28
1.72
2.08
1.07
1.79
0.85
1.26
1.79
0.90
0.19
2.18
2.34
-3.27
-0.39
-3.34
5.36
4.39
2.12
0.55
1.10
-0.20
7.67
7.66
1.91
9.41
9.41
4.04
6.38
6.37
1.93
-5.79
3.27
3.95
2.27
2.56
2.56
NOTE: gamma = 1
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 68
138.96
63.88
50.13
785.40
787.95
2548.54
2803.73
2536.28
2838.95
5421.64
4538.09
984.15
5395.64
4523.49
979.87
5390.47
4523.49
987.96
5060.69
5501.18
1555.79
5129.92
5572.02
1610.58
4993.30
5421.64
1539.60
101.27
101.22
49.72
100.35
100.30
50.01
103.16
103.11
49.12
10425.09
837.15
2567.15
17725.59
2833.87
2833.87
%
4.83
-2.53
-0.69
7.00
6.95
0.40
-0.71
-0.48
1.08
0.39
0.89
-0.74
0.48
0.88
-2.07
0.00
1.69
0.49
-1.53
-0.68
-3.84
3.92
3.67
2.12
-2.31
-2.12
-2.44
7.61
7.60
2.37
8.99
9.00
2.65
6.36
6.34
-0.43
-8.90
6.09
0.32
1.12
0.36
0.36
Appendix I.
H. Efdé
Plots tower eigenfrequencies.
Tower eigenfrequency 0.175Hz, production loadcase 12 m/s stochastic.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 69
H. Efdé
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 70
H. Efdé
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 71
Appendix J.
H. Efdé
Base line control versus Peak Shave control.
Base line pitch control.
Peak Shave pitch control.
R45.04/01.03/03
Stentec, 3-1-03
page 72

stentec bv

Transcription

Similar documents