Item 2 West Jordan Kingdom Hall of Jehovah`s Witnesses
Transcription
Item 2 West Jordan Kingdom Hall of Jehovah`s Witnesses
WEST JORDAN PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT ITEM 16 2008 January DATE SIDWELL 27 04 152 010 CUP20070011 PROJECT 2 SDMA20070008 SPC020070013 Kingdom Hall of Jehovah s Witnesses Preliminary Site Plan Preliminary Plat and West Jordan APPLICATION I Church Conditional Use Permit A APPLICANT West Jordan Jehovah B REQUEST s Utah Witnesses Site Preliminary English Terry Plan Congregation of Wilson Preliminary Plat and Conditional Use Permit C 8900 South 3200 West LOCATION 1 69 D ACREAGE BACKGROUND II Applicant is requesting Preliminary Site Plan Preliminary Plat and Conditional Use Permit approval for the West Jordan Kingdom Hall of Jehovah s Witnesses Church to be located at approximately 8900 South 3200 West on a vacant parcel of land containing 1 69 acres The proposed site is planned for Very Low Density Residential The and is zoned RR 1 D Rural Residential The property fronts South that is not directly yet dedicated to the onto 3200 West and built but subject City in the has access to a future road right of way does presently exist just beyond the This will need to be either acquired by the City or future before the existing dead end portion of 8870 South connected to 3200 West A table of the subject property Land Use s surrounding zoning Map Category Zoning and land uses are as Actual Land Use North Very Low Density Residential RR 1 D Church South Very Low Density Residential RR 1 D Church East Very Low Density Residential RR 1 D Residential West Medium Density 8870 some tract boundaries of the 1 Acre Lot Minimum Residential R 1 8D Residential follows III PRELIMINARY SITE PLAN ANALYSIS BUILDING The Applicant approximately is proposing to construct 5000 square feet of floor a single The stucco metal and brick materials shown does meet code for this building height requirements as one story church structure containing area on requirements S89 3 704 outlined within the material and color board submitted The building meets all setback and a PARKING SITE ACCESS required to provide 46 parking spaces per S89 6 603 b of the City of West Jordan Municipal Code The project is providing a total of 53 parking stalls 3 of which will be handicapped stalls located close to the primary entrance to the building Access to and from the project site will be from a single proposed 26 5 foot width driveway off of 3200 West with a second 29 foot driveway stub to the north for a future The project will be connection to 8870 South when it is constructed LANDSCAPING The Applicant has submitted a landscape plan which shows extensive landscaping and screening throughout the entire project site The project is providing a generous 48 site landscaping which exceeds code requirements required per S89 6 708 1 2 Municipal project provides street trees meeting this standard along both 3200 West and the future 8870 South The landscaping shall be maintained by a permanent irrigation system installed by the developer per S89 6 703 a 5 and shall be designed for the most efficient use of water per S89 6 704 a 4 Deciduous trees shall have a minimum 2 caliper and all evergreen trees a minimum 5 in height per SB9 6 705 b 1 of the Municipal Code Not less than 80 of the trees shall be water conserving species that can withstand dry conditions once established a1 The plant material shall recognize the climatic limitations of the per SB9 6 704 Salt Lake Valley and the need for water conserving per S89 6 704 a A minimum of one tree per 30 linear feet of of the West Jordan Code streetscape is The UTILITY SCREENING All above property ground utility lines shall be undergrounded across the frontage of the per Section 89 6 903 Section 89 6 803 requires all utility and mechanical equipment dumpsters loading areas and other utility areas commonly found outdoors shall be constructed below the natural grade and or completely screened with masonry fencing with solid metal gates and landscaping unless other materials of sufficient durability are determined by the Planning Commission to be more compatible with the associated development c 2 West Jordan Kingdom Hall Church Planning Commission Staff Report permitted above ground utility features must be screened from view with landscaping The dumpster enclosure materials and colors shall be consistent with per SB9 6 803 c the materials used on the primary structure All ENGINEERING COMMENTS The following review comments have been generated by the Review Engineer regarding the proposed Preliminary Site Plan For Final Site Plan submittal show driveway and dumpster location switched to provide the minimum required separation between the driveway and the intersection of 8870 South with 3200 West Improvements have South at the present access been determined time however a by the City to parking lot drive not be required to 8870 provided for stub shall be to the street in the future FIRE COMMENTS following review comments have been generated by the Fire Marshal regarding the proposed preliminary site plan A driveway stub on the north side of the project parking lot to the Future 8870 South Street is required to provide for a secondary access to the property at the time the street is actually built The IV SITE PLAN Criteria 1 Approval a The proposed development follows all provisions other applicable City ordinances and standards Discussion Church all submitted Finding uses are and landscaping parking City Ordinances and Standards Staff finds that the Title and all other of this Title and all Conditional Uses in the RR 1 D bulk accordance with Criteria 2 Criteria Per Section 89 5 104 zoning district As height requirements are met in proposed development follows applicable City ordinances and standards all provisions of this proposed development does not have any detrimental effect upon the general health welfare safety and convenience of persons residing or working in the neighborhood or is not detrimental or injurious to the neighborhood The proposed use is a conditionally permitted use within the RR anticipated to have any detrimental impacts on surrounding properties or the residents of the community based upon its location within a low density residential area with neighboring existing churches and primary access to Discussion The 1 D zone and is not 3200 West 3 West Jordan Planning Kingdom Hall Church Commission Staff Report Finding The proposed use will not have a detrimental effect upon the general proposed use and will not welfare of persons working in the neighborhood of the be detrimental or injurious to the neighborhood The Criteria 3 proposed development promotes structures to site and in one a desirable another open spaces and relationship of topography both on the surrounding neighborhoods Staff finds that the proposed use and structure will promote a compatible and desirable relationship with the surrounding area and uses A significant landscape and screening package will be provided to buffer the site from its neighbors and site grading should not be highly disruptive Discussion proposed development will promote a desirable relationship between adjoining structures open spaces and topography both on the site and in the surrounding area Finding The Criteria 4 The height area setbacks and overall structure buildings appropriate to the community walls and signs development mass as well as parts of any and lighting landscaping neighborhood and the are the The proposed site is large enough in size and shape to accommodate the proposed use and all bulk and setback requirements are being met The proposed building is adequate in height and meets the requirements for general design guidelines required in Section 89 5 308 of the Zoning Discussion Ordinance Staff has also reviewed the the Applicant has satisfied per Section 89 6 701 708 plan review by the Preliminary landscape plan and has determined that the minimum landscaping requirements as required of the Zoning Ordinance subject to final landscape City consultant Finding The height area setbacks and overall massing proposed structure and landscaping are appropriate to neighborhood and the community Criteria 5 as well the as parts of the development the proposed development considers and fully addresses traffic Ingress egress internal traffic circulation off street impacts parking facilities loading and service areas and pedestrian ways are so designated as to promote safety and convenience The parking and vehicle circulation is appropriate for the size of this site There is adequate off street parking with all of the handicapped parking stalls being placed with convenient access to the primary entrances to the church structure The development site has one immediate and Discussion Overall off street 4 West Jordan Planning Kingdom Hall Church Commission Stafl Report point of ingress and egress into the site The parking area will be completely asphalted and provides adequate fire access subject to the Fire Department comment provided within this report as a condition of approval one future The Finding circulation ways have Criteria 6 proposed development has adequate parking and traffic Ingress egress off street parking loading facilities and pedestrian been designed to promote safety and convenience to the site The architectural character of the proposed development is in harmony with and compatible to those structures in the neighboring environment and the architectural character adopted for any given area avoiding excessive variety or monotonous repetition The architectural design of the proposed building meets the The proposed building will Zoning Ordinance integrate the use of varying stucco materials and brick to break up the building mass and give the development a unique look and will incorporate a pitched roof with screened mechanical equipment A building materials and color board has been submitted by the Applicant for the Planning Commission hearing that is appropriate for the site and in compliance with the ordinance Discussion standards as outlined in the The proposed building will be in harmony with and compatible to structures in the neighboring environment with the architectural character of the proposed structure avoiding excessive variety and monotonous repetition Finding Criteria 7 The architectural character of the proposed development addresses the climate of this will withstand region by using exterior materials of a nature that prolonged exposure to the elements with only minimum maintenance required In order to ensure compliance with these criteria the Planning Commission may require additional information or reports regarding proposed building materials Discussion stucco siding Proposed building metal considers to meet the window materials consist of two different colors accents and brick general design requirement of which Staff wainscoting adequate buildings and for materials Finding The architectural character of the the climate of the prolonged painting to require area by using proposed development exterior materials of a addresses nature that will withstand exposure to the elements with only minimum maintenance required Staff does not believe it to be necessary for the Planning Commission additional reports or information materials 5 West Jordan Kingdom Hall Church Planning Commission Staff Report regarding the proposed building V CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT Approval Criteria Per Section 89 3 502 requires that churches located in the RR 1 D zoning district obtain a Conditional Use Permit CUP Prior to approving any application for a Conditional Use Permit the Planning Commission shall find that the use meets the following criteria listed within Section 89 Section 89 3 502 of the Rural Residential 5 404 Zoning Ordinance 1 Acre Lot Minimum e Criteria 1 The proposed use is consistent with the goals policies and Land Use map of the West Jordan General Plan and the purpose of the zone district in which the site is located Discussion Map as Very The low subject property is designated on Density Residential and is zoned the Future Land Use for Rural Residential uses proposed use of the property as a church will not result in a substantial impact to the area with 2 other churches already in the vicinity off of 3200 West Notably churches are historically located within entirely In this residential areas and are an important part of a neighborhood case there are few dwellings actually near the proposed site and all traffic impacts are being placed onto 3200 West and not local neighborhood The streets Finding The proposed use of the subject property will be consistent with the goals policies and Land Use Map of the West Jordan General Plan and the P O Criteria 2 Professional Office zone The proposed use will not be materially detrimental to the health safety or general welfare of persons residing or working in the neighborhood of the proposed use or have an adverse effect on the property adjacent properties the surrounding neighborhood or the City as a whole as a result of the type of use or hours of operation Discussion The site will not produce noise light vibration or traffic that objectionable surrounding land uses Church peak traffic times tend to vary greatly from that of nearby residential uses thereby also lessening impacts would be to The Finding land Criteria 3 proposed use will The proposed site is adequate in size and shape to accommodate the intended use and that all requirements for the zone district including but not limited to setbacks walls landscaping and buffer yards are 6 Planning surrounding uses met West Jordan not be detrimental to the Kingdom Hall Church Commission Staff Report Discussion The site is intended church use of the site still and 48 The Finding adequate in size and shape to accommodate the All required components are present on the plan remains for landscaping and buffering accommodate the intended Criteria 4 site proposed is adequate in size and to The proposed use will provide for adequate screening landscaping parking utilities and traffic circulation Discussion under These issues Preliminary previously analyzed in this Analysis and all code requirements were Site Plan all Finding The proposed use will provide for adequate landscaping parking utilities and traffic circulation Criteria 5 shape use The staff are report met screening proposed use will ensure compatibility with surrounding and will use building materials that are in harmony with the area Discussion The compatible with surrounding uses dwellings Building materials requirements and are compatible with surrounding proposed other churches including proposed meet code uses use and will be residential structures The Finding uses Criteria 6 proposed use will ensure compatibility with surrounding building materials that are in harmony with the area and will use Adequate conditions or stipulations have been incorporated into the approval of the Conditional Use Permit to ensure that any anticipated detrimental effects can be mitigated Discussion Conditions of section of this mitigate report approval are included in the recommendation These conditions of approval will be sufficient to any foreseeable detrimental effects Finding Adequate conditions or stipulations have been incorporated into the approval of the Conditional Use Permit to ensure that any anticipated detrimental effects can be mitigated VI A PRELIMINARY PLAT ANAYSIS plat was required from the Applicant to dedicate to the of way for 3200 West No other subdivision gap exists within the right of way for 8870 unresolved to date as to ownership of the 7 West Jordan Planning Kingdom Hall Church Commission Staff Report City an additional 9 feet of right or lot line changes are necessary A deed South undeveloped roadway stub that is Given the difficulty of resolving this gap issue on not owned property by the Applicant and the undeveloped stub nature of 8870 South across the north side of the property no street improvements or dedication of right of way are being required at the present time City Attorney s Office Planning Engineering and further significant Fire Department Staff have reviewed the Preliminary Plat and have no comments VII STAFF RECOMMENDATION Planning Commission grant Preliminary Site Plan Conditional Use Permit and Preliminary Plat approval for the new West Jordan Kingdom Hall of Jehovah s Witnesses Church to be located at approximately 8900 South 3200 West based on the positive findings of fact with the conditions of approval as listed below Planning Commission approvals do not include Public Safety Fire Building and Safety or Engineering approval Approval by these City divisions or departments may be required Staff recommends 1 Show that the driveway stub to future 8870 South at east end of parking lot and move dumpster to different location to provide minimum driveway separation distance from intersection with 3200 West 4 improvements to 8870 South are required however a fully improved driveway stub is required to access the street in the future All aboveground power and utility lines to be undergrounded The Conditional Use Permit is subject to review and or revocation as per Section 5 The 2 3 No 89 5 404 VIII applicant shall apply for and submit Final Site Plan and Final Plat drawings with the required fees Final approval may be granted administratively ATTACHMENTS Exhibit A Zoning Vicinity Map Exhibit B Aerial Photo Exhibit C Site Plan Exhibit D Landscape Plan Building Elevations Preliminary Plat Application Exhibit E Exhibit F Exhibit G IX and Floor Plan CLEARANCE 7 Chris Gilbert Associate Planner 8 West Jordan Hall Church Kingdom Planning Commission Staff Report jtr Hwang P E Review Engineer Chien 0ilfrL olash Greg City Planner 9 West Jordan Planning Kingdom Hall Church Commission Staff Report I co a oro I eg ro 0 roN 0 CO CO z 086l II O Z OE r 0 0 5 r N CC0 0 e O 0 0 0 0 J 0 0 0 0 CO OCJ JO IDa r o CIS CIS J a O CJ oo ED J 0 00 en e e CIS ea Q CIS 0 l o U tfj Q I II w Z C i ClO g W 0 L l i a 3 OJJJ J OJ CII L OOZE 0 E r z 8 K f z U IJ OJI I C I 0 II ClO 7 Zoo f f o E a or II 3 z 1 a I C U I l V I i311oi9V c d i I X W C ella 20 o ellN C Q ell J DC o ell 0 N z J J o ca J o En 0 Co en c c cu co C o e ra en tIl Q OJ c s W I t II r i ill i t I l i J u j C C i c l ii i I l C t C cc II 4 L JQ l i 11 o nuuu gi t j tf I 3 t oI i 7 t i T g f tJIL r J i 4 i L I i l I l Li i i Q fK I l I Ip I L l n Ii i i I i I J 1TI1 I II i II 1I l 15 I j fl ii j I 1 l II I ill 1 j 1 n i ii jt j i I II i j l i m4 ri 1 I i r tj iLl i i i Iii l l Ji n i j i c QJ J r il IIsl I I i t ii i I 1 Ill l h I 1 I I i jl j 1 Il gi i Ii Ii i L II il 1 1f ttH fln ACD6 I I I 1 1 r lit i leili L f L SITE K UTILITY 1 fil i I II t I J j r L l b iii II Ill 11 I o iJ Ii II II I lit II i i 111 ii IP lR i 11 I 1 I IUnl l1 I mmmml I uu u uu i I I Mm i ii mmml un l il zn nHI n I PIoN HAUorJCHQVA cS P RtiDliiE t pl I I s c T 81It f I i n 0 0 I oo ji tj o o u c C lo OJ II 1f0tl g F j 11 C C 5 j r I O t i L I H I I I i i I I I I i 1 i F I i g g @ 1il I@ 1il j il 1 jl B l U j 1 1 i1i l 11I 1I l lII 1 1 W i ti liP iij II LJ II H l g ih If i I II e I p Ii JIJ liJ I i I i lil j i d t i i J oa I l g Q S i j I il l l I r i III i jA 3 a III r 1 II 1I I l i i S F h hl i iJld1 l 1 11 j I ill 1 O a x iI 00 PJ Ii il illl l g i j 1 1 r i ut 0 I iE P Kingdom Hall ew0 South of J SGe ASSOCIATES flc ah s Witnesses 200 I ll M ielIt lJ l 110 l Jord4f f Cit V Jt II ifi f i l ll i I i l l 11 t l IU iA j tI P i I ia ld I I I illt lr l I lIQ hl r lh i M 1 i i q lll Im ij Ilofii Ill 3 0 i jet alP H h li l l Ir m li Iii I I hi lil 1 Ii1 1 i i i f l 01 E n jtll I jelj IltI h ii iic g U l i I I I I I ilia 1 1 J A f 1 II i i 1 I I il I Vli C eI l i i i lj i I s W IIIt 1 i fi IS l 11 i 1 i Ii II s i i 1 C iL I1 t Y ue I O 10 0 r C rO o O S ro 10 TO TOP 1 PLATE e o O n o e C o o o J O l 1 CO 0 I l II n r n 0 i n 0 fTl 0 0 z l Q l r r c c r I r c 0 l z in qrr1 o C r r Z g i r Z o z 0 z i P r r I n r Z i Z in c r i r Z p i i n c 0 c Iii 0 r r If J i SH j I IlLE t GJ NO EXTERIOR fTl ELEVATIONS OAT 3 07 BY VIS10N FlI WJC 5 TE PLAN SUBMITTAl o z g j J IO n p OJ cr 1ITl O o f I 0 0 L KINGDOM HALL 8900 SOUTH 3200 WEST WEST JORDAN CITY UTAH J E Q o c o 00 q 10 TO TOP 1 1 PLAT n o n Z z v c o c c g z 0 r Sir j f o z J r a r e r J 0 6r r 0 z o z ill x 2 z f z o Ill ro c Ln i EXTERIOR 8E r I A Z c 0 LN NO SHEer nilE E ELEVATIONS REvIS ON OATE 3 07 JC W SlTE PLAN OY SUBMITTAL 2 II PllOJ CrTIIlE KINGDOM HALL J l CJo 5900 SOUTH 3200 WEST UTAH WEST JOROAN CITY L J r B B e EU e ev 1 2 7J ooV ZZIN 00 N ZZ I I It 0 0 1 11 0 mo j lJl lI I J C rilz6 0 ClIZCl m U c O oQ I QFo Q N OIJJ mID g lriz 1 00 0 6 c I Z n mil tt gg Q ro u EJ I B 0 l I l n 0 c I 5 I I 0 ZN 0 l o ro z i c pn roo oli Qo m ro 0 19 rom O 0 g ld N W l1 m N 5 0 q o 5 g 0 Z 0 0 C l ro z l I o J 8 o 0 ze5 M o J n o l1 l 5 1 8 4 6 26 0 1 6 0 8 J 4 Z 0 S 5 0 l Z 8 Z m en e 0 CO o Q no Cro S ro 0 tJ c @ ro o Z x 1J JI R s z o 0 q z Vi @ R 0 0 S S E 50 0 NO TITLE PLAN DATE 3 07 REVISION JC W SITE PLAN SUBM TTAL K E l d l OJECT FI 11 I S8b mF FLOOR I J o Vl Ii 8Z PI I q I ill L m I z r tl z o b 8 J z II l 0 z i2 l TIH KINGDOM HALL 8900 SOUTH 3200 WEST WEST JORDAN CITY UTIJ J F r M 31 EXHf iiil 3200 I Ill EST STREET ii I I II It i sig e l H f H r zi c iT j J to c Ii HI 1 l 5 lL l i j1 I i j l m in i I il i I 1 i II Ill I 8 1 II I t ii ill J i I iH i f d 1 H i Ill 1I I I 19 Iii Ii I I c e q i I I g I f I i I U I H i I I I i Ii o i f E p 1 II n I q I Ji I Ii i I I i Ill I i I i I I It 11 I i Ii i II i IL i I h I I I I II ijji i 00 I a IUIl maJO 114 I 11 s Itl I f Iii rYIIII i I rf I I IH I I I i e I 1 i I i i f t I I fl It Irnl lt f ifihJi il1iMjII I I J UiiJ i g i h9jl I h Ii I it n11 Hil i 1 ll i I II v 5 I z III j I ilh 5 l I 1 I f Ill 1 II j J II l U m i i Ii f j I i I 1115 Ii f I j 1 I 1 i 1 il lif I jli to II jq I i r I il lfl IJl dillIIi I l Iii hi I I ih n tI ll iI I u d 111 IW51 lima h lll Ij i ll I iI li II l I Ili III i Jlj i dH t hIf mn t l 1 il fH11 ilI J I 1 I hiJ J tr I I r I I i i l f I ii h Ill il llI J i l I j i 8 VV C Jvnul l III I Ut V ILV II I IVI I Ir rL M I IIVI cXH B r r I 8000 South Redwood Road 801 r J 569 5180 lIDJ S1DWELL J7 b PROPERTY ACREAGE nlf IJ NAME OF PROJECT o ADDRESS fh rm il1 TYPE OF APPUCATION k rI 1rLfr iJ ifl fP hdJl Cl tue oJ S jIaltwulrs r7 9 llhUlLJ fZOCJW 1 ZONING p lrrruJJ c rml PROPERTY OWNER S ICWUJ jc Address lJ State J a O Zip Telephone APPUCANT S PrImary Contact Co tV Ue U any 1fiiIL Q Contact Name all correspondence will be sent to this Address address Stale 8400 ltl elePhone l e rr r r o OJ Llcn bul t 11 J T bI City fK J t Zip e mall offICe 0i k y l Company e ur reV lff lf J Contact Name A fA l J Li e mail U O 13 J Fax 8 Company 1 e1 f Telephone Architect e home J 1 130 ur S I ef jW Contact Name emall Address Fax Telephone Lanclscape Architect Company S s Contact Name Address 7 a zS e sS 0 C A f L lE p 0 1 te I 1J c s NJ iLL J emall 4 8 tjlll DATE I L r l1 0 J 12 34 Fax V 2 7 sj O f J i vIo Revised 1212006