AUBURN HILLS MEETING SCHEDULE

Transcription

AUBURN HILLS MEETING SCHEDULE
AUBURN HILLS MEETING SCHEDULE
248-370-9402
MARCH 2011
(3-17-11)
21 City Council, 7:00 p.m., Council Chamber
22 Library Board, 4:00 p.m., Library Conference Room
23 Beautification Advisory Commission, 6:00 p.m., Admin Conference Room
29 Planning Commission, 7:00 p.m., Council Chamber
APRIL 2011
04 City Council, 7:00 p.m., Council Chamber
05 Planning Commission, 7:00 p.m., Council Chamber
(Planning Study or Squirrel P.H)
11 Tax Abatement Review Committee, 5:00 p.m., Admin Conference Room
12 Tax Increment Finance Authority, 4:00 p.m., Admin Conference Room
14 Zoning Board of Appeals, 7:00 p.m., Council Chamber
CANCELED
18 City Council, 7:00 p.m., Council Chamber
20 Planning Commission, 7:00 or 6:00, Council Chamber
(Planning Study or Squirrel P.H)
26 Library Board, 4:00 p.m., Library Conference Room
26 Planning Commission, 7:00 p.m., Council Chamber
27 Beautification Advisory Commission, 6:00 p.m., Admin Conference Room
City Council Chamber – 1827 N. Squirrel Road
Administrative Conference Room – 1827 N. Squirrel Road
Public Safety Building – 1899 N. Squirrel Road
Community Center – 1827 N. Squirrel Road
Department of Public Services (DPS) – 1500 Brown Road
Fieldstone Golf Course - 1984 Taylor Road
Library - 3400 Seyburn Drive
Downtown City Offices – 3395 Auburn Road, Suite A
The City of Auburn Hills
Regular City Council Meeting
Monday, March 21, 2011 * 7:00 p.m.
AGENDA
Council Chamber ™ 1827 N. Squirrel Road ™ Auburn Hills MI
248-370-9402 ™ www.auburnhills.org
1.
2.
3.
4.
4a.
4b.
4c
4d
MEETING CALLED TO ORDER
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
ROLL CALL OF COUNCIL
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Regular Meeting – March 7, 2011
Executive Session – February 7, 2011
Executive Session – February 21, 2011
Executive Session – March 7, 2011
5.
5a.
5b.
6.
7.
APPOINTMENTS & PRESENTATIONS
Appointment – Stan Torres to Public Safety Advisory Committee
Presentation - Michigan Concrete Association's Michigan Awards of Excellence – Squirrel Road Rehab
PUBLIC COMMENT
CONSENT AGENDA
All items listed are considered to be routine by the City Council and will be enacted by one motion. There will be no separate discussion
of these items unless a Council member so requests, in which event the item will be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered
in its normal sequence on the agenda.
7a. Board & Commission Minutes
7a.1. Beautification Advisory Commission – February 23, 2011
7a.2. Planning Commission – March 1, 2011
7a.3. Tax Increment Finance Authority – March 8, 2011
7a.4. Planning Commission – March 15, 2011
8. OLD BUSINESS
8a. Public Hearing/Motion – Renewal of 2011 Liquor Licenses
8b. Public Hearing/Motion – Renewal of 2011 Public Recreation Hall Licenses
8c. Rescind Resolution 11.03.050 - Alternative Energy Personal Property Exemption/United Solar Ovonic, LLC
8d. Forester Square SAD
9. NEW BUSINESS
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
COMMENTS AND MOTIONS FROM COUNCIL
CITY ATTORNEY’S REPORT
CITY MANAGER’S REPORT
EXECUTIVE SESSION – City Attorney Opinion
ADJOURNMENT
City Council meeting minutes are on file in the City Clerk’s office.¾ NOTE: Anyone planning to attend the meeting who has
need of special assistance under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is asked to contact the City Clerk's Office at 370-9402 or the City
Manager's Office at 370-9440 48 hours prior to the meeting. Staff will be pleased to make the necessary arrangements.
The City of Auburn Hills
City Council Meeting
Minutes
CALL TO ORDER:
LOCATION:
Present:
Absent:
Also Present:
March 7, 2011
by Mayor McDonald at 7:00 p.m.
City Council Chamber, 1827 N. Squirrel Road, Auburn Hills, MI 48326
Mayor McDonald, Mayor Pro Tem Hammond, Council Members Doyle, Kittle,
Knight, McDaniel, Newkirk
None
City Manager Auger, Assistant City Manager Tanghe, Police Chief Olko, Fire
Chief Burmeister, City Assessors Bennett & Lohmeier, Community Development
Director Cohen, Police Lt. Manning, City Attorney Beckerleg, City Engineer
Stevens, Library Director McCoy, Planning Commissioner Mitchell, TIFA Chair
Bennett
156 Guests
Mayor McDonald stated he was amending the agenda; Public Comment would be heard first, 4. Approval of
Minutes next, followed by Item 5f. Historical Sign Presentation, and then proceed with the agenda.
6. PUBLIC COMMENT
Veronica Mitchell introduced the new Library Director Stephanie McCoy.
Numerous people spoke in opposition to the proposed Planned Parenthood facility in Auburn Hills.
Julianne Reyes read a letter from the Superintendent of Oakland Christian School opposing the proposed
Planned Parenthood facility.
Kay Sendegas noted the golf season is approaching and netting at the golf course on Opdyke Road is in
need of repair.
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4a. Regular City Council Minutes – February 21, 2011
Moved by Mr. McDaniel; Seconded by Mr. Newkirk.
RESOLVED: To approve the February 21, 2011 Regular City Council Meeting Minutes.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.037
5. APPOINTMENTS & PRESENTATIONS
5f. Presentation – Proposal for Historical Signage at Log Cabin in the Downtown
Wilson Garner, Historical Society Chair, presented a rendering of a proposed sign for the old log cabin
building downtown. It will be the third such sign for a heritage location in the City. The Historical Society
requests if Council makes any changes to the sign, that they be notified of the changes.
5a. Appointment – Keith Stonehouse to the Tax Increment Finance Authority
Moved by Mr. Newkirk; Seconded by Mr. McDaniel.
RESOLVED: To confirm the appointment of Keith Stonehouse to the Tax Increment Finance
Authority for a term ending February 28, 2015.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald
No: Newkirk
Motion carried (6-1)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.038
5b. Appointment – Reanna Douglas to the Tax Increment Finance Authority
Moved by Ms. Hammond; Seconded by Mr. Kittle.
RESOLVED: To confirm the appointment of Reanna Douglas to the Tax Increment Finance
Authority for a term ending February 28, 2015.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.039
City Council Minutes – March 7, 2011
Page 2 of 8
5c. Reappointment – Steve Goodhall to the Tax Increment Finance Authority
Moved by Mr. Knight; Seconded by Mr. McDaniel.
RESOLVED: To confirm the reappointment of Steven Goodhall to the Tax Increment Finance
Authority for a term ending February 28, 2015.
VOTE: Yes: Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: Doyle
Motion carried (6-1)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.040
5d. Reappointment – Charlotte Copple to the Tax Increment Finance Authority
Moved by Mr. McDaniel; Seconded by Ms. Hammond.
RESOLVED: To confirm the reappointment of Charlotte Copple to the Tax Increment Finance
Authority for a term ending February 28, 2012.
VOTE: Yes: Hammond, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald,
No: Doyle, Kittle, Newkirk
Motion carried (4-3)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.041
5e. Reappointment – Dave DeClerck to Local Officials Compensation Commission
Moved by Mr. Knight; Seconded by Mr. Kittle.
RESOLVED: To confirm the reappointment of Dave DeClerck to the Elected Officials
Compensation Committee for a term ending February 28, 2016.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.042
7. CONSENT AGENDA
Mr. Kittle requested Items 7c., 7d., 7e. and 7f. be removed from the Consent Agenda.
7a. Motion – Approve 2011 Public Recreation Hall License Renewals
RESOLVED: To accept the report and recommendation for renewal of Recreation Hall license
for the listed establishments who have passed City inspections, paid the appropriate licensing
fee and presented the necessary documents. Furthermore, to set a Public Hearing on March
21, 2011, for Duffy’s, Tobey Keith and The Post Bar to consider evidence in regards to nonrenewal of their license.
7b. Motion – Approve Purchase of Motorola Mobile Workstations for Police Department
RESOLVED: To approve the purchase of nine (9) Motorola MW810 Mobile Workstations by the
Auburn Hills Police Department under the Oakland County Cooperative bid price of $44,568.
Moved by Mr. Kittle; Seconded by Mr. McDaniel.
RESOLVED: To approve Consent Agenda items 7a. and 7b.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.043
7c. Motion – Approve Budget Amendment to the 2011 Police Budget
Moved by Mr. McDaniel; Seconded by Mr. Knight.
RESOLVED: To allocate $147,000.00 from the police fund balance to cover the cost of
equipping the patrol fleet with in-car video camera systems.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.044
7d. Motion – Approve request to transfer all stock interest in 2010 Resort B-Hotel licensed business
Moved by Mr. Kittle; Seconded by Mr. Knight.
RESOLVED: To adopt the resolution approving a request to transfer all stock interest in 2010
Resort B-Hotel licensed business issued under MCL 436.1531(4) located at 2300 Featherstone,
Auburn Hills, MI, Oakland County wherein co-licensee, AH Tenant Corporation, stockholder
CHH Auburn Partnership LP transferred 100 shares of stock to new stockholder, Ashford HHC
Partners, LP; wherein co-licensee, AH Hotel Partner, AH Hotel GP, LLC's member, CHH
City Council Minutes – March 7, 2011
Page 3 of 8
Auburn Partnership, LP transferred 100% membership interest to new member CNL HHC
Partners, LP, sometime in April 2007; wherein co-licensee, AH Tenant Corporation,
stockholder Ashford HHC Partners, LP transferred 100 shares of stock to new stockholder
Ashford TRS Corporation; and wherein co-licensee AH Hotel Partners, LP's general partner,
AH Hotel GP, LLC's member, CHH Auburn Partnership, LP transferred 100% membership
interest to new member Ashford HHC Partners, LP (f/k/a CNL HHC Partners, LP), sometime in
December 2008 and to authorize the City Clerk to forward said resolution to the Michigan
Liquor Control Commission.
VOTE: Yes: Hammond, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: Doyle, Kittle
Motion carried (5-2)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.045
7e. Motion – Approve request from AH Hotel Partners and LP AH Tenant Corporation to drop Hilton
Suites, Inc. as a co-licensee in a 2009 Resort B-Hotel license
Moved by Mr. Kittle; Seconded by Ms. Doyle.
RESOLVED: To adopt the resolution approving the request from AH Hotel Partners and LP AH
Tenant Corporation to drop Hilton Suites, Inc. as a co-licensee in a 2009 Resort B-Hotel license
with Official Permit (food), 3 bars, and 224 rooms located at 2300 Featherstone and to
authorize the City Clerk to forward said resolution to the Michigan Liquor Control
Commission.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.046
7f. Motion – Approve request from AHHS Acquisitions, LLC to transfer ownership of a 2010 Resort BHotel licensed business from AH Hotel Partners, LP & AH Tenant Corporation.
Moved by Mr. Kittle; Seconded by Mr. Newkirk.
RESOLVED: To adopt the resolution approving the request from AHHS Acquisitions, LLC to
transfer ownership of a 2010 Resort B-Hotel licensed business with minimum seating 100,
Official Permit (food), 3 bars & 224 rooms located at 2300 Featherstone in Auburn Hills from
AH Hotel Partners, LP & AH Tenant Corporation and to authorize the City Clerk to forward said
resolution to the Michigan Liquor Control Commission.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.047
8. OLD BUSINESS – none.
9. NEW BUSINESS
9a. Public Hearing and Motion – Michigan Next Energy Authority- Alternative Energy Personal Property
Exemption United Solar Ovonic, LLC
Mayor McDonald opened the public hearing at 9:04 p.m.
John Morgan, Vice President, explained in the past year the company has invested $20 million in the
Auburn Hills facility and will be investing an additional $15 million this year. The incremental tax relief is a
percentage based on the amount invested. Even though it was necessary to let 140 people go, it has
helped the company to consolidate, resulting in closing the Rochester Hills facility and bringing those 200
jobs to Auburn Hills. The Troy research facility will also be moved to Auburn Hills in the next year. The
company has also become more competitive by expanding beyond the roof systems they produce.
Mr. Morgan stated the company employees approximately 1,500 with 272 employees in Auburn Hills.
The current new equipment and the additional equipment this year will not generate any new jobs, but will
have saved jobs. In the long term however, expanding into other markets will generate more jobs.
Mr. Beckerleg confirmed the option presented before Council to either grant or deny the request is the
same option that the school board is given, the City does not speak on behalf of the school district.
Mr. Morgan explained the only avenue to receive an abatement on this equipment is through the federal
government. Mr. Bennett explained this abatement, through the federal government, is a 100%
abatement, the PA198 through the City is a 50% abatement.
Mr. Knight was in favor of the current request since the company hadn’t requested any abatements from
the City for this new equipment.
It was noted if the Council wishes to grant the abatement, then no action is necessary – no motion;
however, to determine a consensus of the Council a vote could be taken.
City Council Minutes – March 7, 2011
Page 4 of 8
The application for the abatement is based on the $20 million that was invested in 2010. Mr. Bennett
explained the State has approved $7.6 million maximum allowed for the abatement of the $20 million.
Council is being requested of 100% relief of the personal property tax on $7.6 million of the $20 million
invested, over the next three years. The State has certified the property as being eligible to receive this
exemption.
The amount the City would forgive over the next three years would be $87,637.
Mr. Morgan noted his company has never asked schools for the incentives.
With no further comments, the Mayor closed the public hearing at 9:29 p.m.
Moved by Mr. Knight; Seconded by Ms. Hammond.
RESOLVED: To adopt the attached Resolution to opt-out of the exemption for Alternate Energy
Personal Property from local taxes for United Solar Ovonic LLC as designated under MNEA
Resolution 2010-10.
VOTE: Yes: Hammond, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: Doyle, Kittle
Motion carried (5-2)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.048
Moved by Ms. Hammond; Seconded by Mr. Newkirk.
RESOLVED: To Reconsider the previous motion.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Kittle, McDonald, Newkirk
No: Hammond, Knight, McDaniel
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.049
Motion carried (4-3)
Moved by Mr. Knight; Seconded by Mr. McDaniel.
RESOLVED: To adopt the attached Resolution to opt-out of the exemption for Alternate Energy
Personal Property from local taxes for United Solar Ovonic LLC as designated under MNEA
Resolution 2010-10.
VOTE: Yes: Hammond, Knight, McDaniel, Newkirk
No: Doyle, Kittle, McDonald
Motion carried (4-3)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.050
9b. Motion – To recommend approval of the annual liquor licenses of those establishments that have met
the licensing requirements of the City; and that a public hearing be scheduled for Monday, March 21,
2011 to consider evidence regarding the recommendation of non-renewal of a liquor license to those
establishments who have not met the City’s requirements
Moved by Mr. McDaniel; Seconded by Ms. Doyle.
RESOLVED: To Move to recommend approval of the annual liquor licenses of those
establishments that have met the licensing requirements of the City; and that a public hearing
be scheduled for Monday, March 21, 2011 to consider evidence regarding the recommendation
of non-renewal of a liquor license to those establishments who have not met the City’s
requirements.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.051
9c. Motion – Approval of Special Land Use Permit / Dow Automotive Systems - Outside Storage
Moved by Mr. Knight; Seconded by Ms. Hammond.
RESOLVED: To accept the Planning Commission’s recommendation and approve the Special
Land Use Permit for Dow Automotive Systems to allow outside storage of vehicle bodies
subject to staff notes and conditions
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.052
10. COMMENTS AND MOTIONS FROM COUNCIL
Mr. Knight:
•
Being the representative of City Council, he presented a Proclamation to Dr. John Marine, Pastor
of North Auburn Hills Baptist Church in honor of his 70th birthday. Dr. Marine appreciated it very
much.
City Council Minutes – March 7, 2011
Page 5 of 8
•
Noted how dreary the downtown looks since the tree lights had been taken down, but appreciated
them being up the additional time.
•
Suggested investigating the possibilities of including electric or hybrid vehicles in the City’s
vehicle fleet.
Ms. Hammond:
•
Requested the landfill be advised of all the blown trash along the fence on M-24.
Mr. McDaniel:
•
Inquired about the downtown wi-fi system.
Mr. Auger stated he will be reporting on that under his comments.
•
Asked if the Fire Chief had looked into the parking situation on Oakmont.
Fire Chief Burmeister stated it was investigated and isn’t an issue.
Mr. Kittle:
•
Asked if it was possible to reconsider the action that was taken on the United Solar Ovonic
request of tax exemption, since it seemed quite confusing.
Mayor McDonald stated it could be reconsidered at the next meeting.
•
Questioned if the frequent power outages in the Heritage in the Hills neighborhood had been
investigated.
Mr. Auger stated Ms. Carroll has been in contact with a DTE representative who explained a fuse
had blown this last outage. There are two individuals who will not allow tree trimming on their
property. Consequently limbs have come down on the power lines that feed the Heritage in the
Hills neighborhood.
•
Hats off to all of the people that come out to support life, against the Planned Parenthood facility.
Appreciates that people feel this is a real detriment to the community and support Auburn Hills,
even though it is an issue that Council doesn’t have much authority over.
Ms. Doyle:
•
•
Noted she appreciated the opportunity to talk with Board and Commission applicants. She asked
that reappointments submit new applications and resumes and also come before Council. It
would be beneficial for those who don’t know the reappointed board members.
Mayor McDonald stated that would be possible.
Mr. Newkirk:
•
Congratulated Ms. Doyle on the publication of her book ‘Powering Up! How America’s Women
Achievers Become Leaders’.
11. CITY ATTORNEY’S REPORT – none.
12. CITY MANGER’S REPORT
•
Distributed his ‘Open Issues Log – February’ noting items that were a concern of Council. School
links on the web page has been completed; there are 366 Auburn Hills students that attend
Pontiac schools; Tim Melton/Tim Grimmel has been resolved on the web page; changed
‘investment’ to ‘cost’ on assessing document; regarding the downtown wi-fi, there will be two
meetings held downtown this month, with one in the morning and one in the afternoon.
Recommendations from staff will be available after the report from Netarx has been received and
reviewed.
Mr. McDaniel requested that those reports be forwarded to Council when received.
The cost of running the pension board is $109,000 per year. Annual expenses for attorney fees,
consultants costs and liability insurance is approximately $52,000 for the pension board and
$46,000 for the retiree health care board.
Mr. McDaniel asked if those costs fluctuate. Mr. Auger explained the meetings had previously
run four or five hours, but they have tried to keep them at two hours or less.
Mr. Knight asked Mr. Auger if he could supply a written report to him regarding these items. Mr.
Auger stated he would do so.
City Council Minutes – March 7, 2011
Page 6 of 8
Mr. Knight asked what the cost might be to replace the current consultants. Mr. Auger stated he
didn’t figure that in, and would look into it.
13. EXECUTIVE SESSION – Property Sale
Moved by Ms. Hammond; Seconded by Mr. Kittle.
RESOLVED: To adjourn to Executive Session
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.053
Moved by Mr. McDaniel; Seconded by Ms. Doyle.
RESOLVED: To approve the lease between the City of Auburn Hills and the Traffic
Improvement Association for approximately 1,143 square feet of space in the former
Community Development Building in accordance with the terms and conditions as set forth in
the proposed Commercial Gross Lease Agreement and authorize Assistant City Manager
Thomas Tanghe to execute the lease on behalf of the City.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Abstain: Kittle
Motion carried (6-0-1)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.054
Moved by Ms. Hammond; Seconded by Mr. McDaniel.
RESOLVED: To approve the sale of twenty-four single family residential lots in the Forester
Square Development to Trowbridge Homes Construction LLC, on behalf of an entity to be
formed, in accordance with the terms and conditions found in the purchase agreement.
Furthermore, authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the agreement on behalf of the
City and authorize Assistant City Manager Thomas Tanghe to attend and execute the
necessary documents at closing on behalf of the City of Auburn Hills.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.055
Moved by Mr. Knight; Seconded by Ms. Hammond.
RESOLVED: To approve the sale of twenty-four single family residential lots in the Forester
Square Development to Michele (pronounced Michael) P. Mattera, on behalf of an entity to be
formed, in accordance with the terms and conditions found in the purchase agreement.
Furthermore, authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the agreement on behalf of the
City and authorize Assistant City Manager Thomas Tanghe to attend and execute the
necessary documents at closing on behalf of the City of Auburn Hills.
VOTE: Yes: Doyle, Hammond, Kittle, Knight, McDaniel, McDonald, Newkirk
No: None
Motion carried (7-0)
RESOLUTION NO. 11.03.056
The Regular meeting adjourned at 9:55 p.m. and reconvened at 10:27 p.m.
13. ADJOURNMENT
Hearing no objections, the meeting was adjourned at 10:41 p.m.
_____________________________
Mayor James D. McDonald
___________________________
Linda F. Shannon, City Clerk
City Council Minutes – March 7, 2011
Page 7 of 8
Attachment A
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
RESOLUTION
TO NOT EXEMPT ALTERNATIVE ENERGY PERSONAL PROPERTY
UNITED SOLAR OVONIC, LLC
At a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Auburn Hills, Oakland County, Michigan
held in the Council Chambers at 1827 N. Squirrel Road, Auburn Hills, Mi 48326, on the 7th day of
March, 2011.
The following resolution was offered by Council Member Knight and supported by Council
Member McDaniel:
WHEREAS the Michigan NextEnergy Authority has notified the City that United Solar Ovonic
LLC has been certified as an Alternative Energy Technology Business under PA 593 of 2002, as
amended; and
WHEREAS the Michigan NextEnergy Authority has certified certain personal property owned
by United Solar Ovonic LLC, and located at 2705 Commerce Parkway, Auburn Hills, and 3800
Lapeer, Auburn Hills, as Alternative Energy Personal Property exempt from certain property taxes;
and
WHEREAS the maximum value of the exempted property is $7,691,059; and
WHEREAS the removal of this personal property from the personal property tax roll would
create an economic burden on the City of Auburn Hills and other local taxing units, and result in the
potential shifting of the tax burden to other residential and commercial properties within the City; and
WHEREAS, PA 593 of 2002, MCL 211.9i (4), allows the governing body of the local tax
collecting unit in which the alternative energy personal property is located to adopt a resolution to not
exempt that Alternative Energy Personal Property from taxes collected in that local tax collecting unit,
except taxes collected under sections 1211 and 1212 of the revised school code, 1976 PA 451 MCL
380.1211 and 380.1212 , a tax levied under the revised school code, 1976 PA 451, MCL 380.1 to
380.1852 to retire outstanding bonded indebtedness, or the tax levied by the state under the state
education act, 1993 PA 331, MCL 211.901 to 211.906; and
WHEREAS, before acting on said exemption, the City Council of Auburn Hills held a hearing
on the 7th day of March, 2011 at a regularly scheduled meeting, at which time United Solar Ovonic,
LLC, the City Assessor, and a representative of the affected taxing units were given written notice and
were afforded an opportunity to be heard on said exemption; and
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City Auburn Hills that
1.
The City Council herby determines to not exempt the alternative energy personal
property of United Solar Ovonic LLC as certified by the Michigan NextEnergy
Authority Certificate Resolution 2010-10 from the taxes collected in the City of
Auburn Hills as provided by PA 593 of 2002, MCL 211.9i(4); and
2.
The City Assessor is herby authorized and directed to file with the Michigan
Economic Development Corporation a certified copy of this resolution.
AYES:
NAYS:
ABSENT:
ABSTENTIONS:
Hammond, Knight, McDaniel, Newkirk
Doyle, Kittle, McDonald
None
None
RESOLUTION ADOPTED (4-3)
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
)SS
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
City Council Minutes – March 7, 2011
Page 8 of 8
I, the undersigned, the duly appointed City Clerk for the City of Auburn Hills, Oakland County,
Michigan do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and complete copy of a resolution adopted at a
regular meeting of the Auburn Hills City Council held on the 7th day of March, 2011.
IN WITNESS HEREOF, I have hereunto affixed my official signature of this 14th day of
March, 2011.
Linda F Shannon, City Clerk
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
AGENDA ITEM NOS. 4B, 4C, 4D.
4b. Executive Session Minutes – February 7, 2011
4c. Executive Session Minutes – February 21, 2011
4d. Executive Session Minutes – March 7, 2011
These minutes have been provided under separate - confidential cover.
O:\CITY
COUNCIL PACKET\MARCH 21\4b Executive Session Minutes.Doc
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
To:
City Council
From:
Mayor James McDonald
AGENDA ITEM NO. 5A.
MAYOR’S OFFICE
Submitted: March 17, 2011
Subject:
Motion – Confirming Appointment of Stan Torres to the Public Safety Advisory Committee for a
term ending November 30, 2011.
INTRODUCTION AND HISTORY
Please consider confirming the following appointment/reappointment:
Name
Board
Term Ending Date
Stan Torres
Public Safety Advisory Committee
November 30, 2011
MOTION
Move to confirm the appointment of Stan Torres to the Public Safety Advisory Committee to fulfill
the unexpired term of Phillip Castonia, ending November 30, 2011.
O:\CITY
COUNCIL PACKET\MARCH 21\Appointment.doc
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
To:
City Council
From:
Mayor James McDonald
AGENDA ITEM NO. 5A.
MAYOR’S OFFICE
Submitted: March 17, 2011
Subject:
Motion – Confirming Appointment of Stan Torres to the Public Safety Advisory Committee for a
term ending November 30, 2011.
INTRODUCTION AND HISTORY
Please consider confirming the following appointment/reappointment:
Name
Board
Term Ending Date
Stan Torres
Public Safety Advisory Committee
November 30, 2011
MOTION
Move to confirm the appointment of Stan Torres to the Public Safety Advisory Committee to fulfill
the unexpired term of Phillip Castonia, ending November 30, 2011.
O:\CITY
COUNCIL PACKET\MARCH 21\Appointment.doc
C I T Y O F A U B U R N H I LL S
C I T Y C O U N C I L A G E N DA
M A R C H 21, 2011
A G E N D A I T E M N O . 5B.
5b. Presentation – Michigan Concrete Association’s Michigan Awards of
Excellence – Squirrel Road Rehab
NO ELECTRONIC INFORMATION AVAILABLE
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
A G E N D A I T E M N O . 7 A .1.
NOT YET APPROVED
The City of Auburn Hills
Beautification Advisory Commission Meeting
1. CALL TO ORDER:
February 23, 2011
Chairperson Hamm called the meeting to order at 6:02 p.m.
2. ROLL CALL: Present:
Arendt, Foster, Hamm, Hendricks, Watson
Absent:
Doyle, Brockelbank
Also Present. Community Development Executive Assistant, Elizabeth Brennan
Location: Administration Meeting Room, 1827 N. Squirrel Rd., Auburn Hills MI 48326
3. PERSONS WISHING TO BE HEARD - none
4. CORRESPONDENCE – Ms. Brennan informed the commission of a quarterly meeting of the
Beautification Council of Southeast Michigan on March 17, 2011. In Gibraltar, MI. Mr. Foster expressed
interest if Mr. Brockelbank was attending.
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion made by Ms. Hamm to accept the minutes of January 26, 2011 as submitted.
Moved by Mr. Arendt, supported by Ms. Watson.
VOTE:
Yes: Arendt, Foster, Hamm, Hendricks, Watson
No: None
Motion carried (5-0)
6. OLD BUSINESS
2010 Budget
Ms. Brennan informed the committee that three additional invoices were submitted by Kevin Lent for the
2010 budget year. The invoices totaled $916.52 which did not exceed the budget for 2010.
2011 Monthly Budget Report
Ms. Brennan presented the monthly report to the Commission. Nothing to date has been billed or paid.
Beautification Council of Southeast Michigan Luncheon
Ms. Brennan informed the Commission that the best available date to host a BCSEM luncheon was March
2012 (as an alternative to hosting the luncheon this fall – in the same month as the Beautification Awards).
The Board decided that March 2012 was not good due to increased work load for planning the Perennial
Exchange. Ms. Brennan was asked to review other possible dates and submit options at the March
meeting.
Banner Replacement
The Committee agreed that the summer banners are the most in need of replacement. A few samples were
presented to the commission by Ms. Brennan for their review. Our City intern will be contacted to check his
availability to assist with the design of the new banners.
BAC ~ February 23, 2011
Page 2
7. NEW BUSINESS
Perennial Exchange
The Committee discussed the idea of ordering t-shirts or polo shirts with the BAC logo to be worn at the
Perennial Exchange and roadside clean-up dates. Ms. Brennan will present pricing at the March meeting.
Advertising
The Commission unanimously agreed to update the Perennial Exchange ad in the Auburn Hills
Review. A rough draft of the new format will be developed by Kevin Lent and forwarded to the
Committee for approval. Once approved, a similar design will be produced for use on the I-75 LED
billboard to promote the event.
Also, the Committee discussed adding a one-page flier to the water bills that go out before the
Perennial Exchange.
Beautification Awards
Ms. Brennan recommended that the August meeting, currently scheduled for August 24th at 6pm, move to
August 10th at 5pm for the purpose of reviewing beautification award nominations. This will provide more time
to plan the event. Committee members will check their calendars and decide at the March meeting.
To streamline planning, it was unanimously agreed upon by the Committee that response cards (mailed out
with the invitations) must be returned via US Mail to RSVP for the Awards Dinner. Seating this year will be
limited to immediate family only, with a maximum number still to be determined.
9. OPEN DISCUSSION
10. CONFIRM NEXT MEETING
The next meeting is confirmed for March 23, 2011.
11. ADJOURNMENT
Being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 7:34 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
Benita LaLone
Community Development
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
A G E N D A I T E M N O . 7 A .2.
Not Yet Approved
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
March 1, 2011
CALL TO ORDER: Chairperson Ouellette called the meeting to order at 7:01 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
Present.
Absent.
Also Present.
Guests.
Hitchcock, Kittle, Mitchell, Pierce, Ouellette, Salerno, Spurlin, Verbeke
Beidoun
Director of Community Development Cohen, DPS Deputy Director Grice, OHM
Civil Engineers Juidici, Loveland, Stevens
2
LOCATION: City Council Chamber, 1827 N. Squirrel, Auburn Hills, MI 48326
PERSONS WISHING TO BE HEARD - None
MINUTES
Ms. Verbeke moved to approve the minutes of February 1, 2011.
Supported by Ms. Salerno
VOTE: Yes: Hitchcock, Kittle, Mitchell, Pierce, Ouellette, Salerno, Spurlin, Verbeke
No: None
Motion Carried (8-0)
PETITIONERS
5a.
Public Hearing / Motion – Recommendation to City Council for Approval of Special Land Use
Permit / Dow Automotive Systems – Outside Storage (7:04 p.m.)
Mr. Ouellette and Mr. Cohen explained that the applicant has requested Special Land Use Permit approval to
allow the outside storage of up to eight (8) vehicle bodies utilized for product testing at 1250 Harmon Road. The
proposed storage area will be 1,320 sq. ft. in size. The property is zoned I-1, Light Industrial district.
Conny Lauzon, representing Dow Automotive Systems, explained that all vehicle testing will occur inside
the building. The company tests polyurethanes, elastomers, films, fluids, adhesives, emissions solutions, and
acoustic-management materials on the vehicles.
The Commission’s discussion covered the following:
• Mr. Lauzon expects to have one (1) to three (3) vehicles in the storage area at a time, but could have up to
eight (8) total during some testing cycles. The length of storage is variable because the company may test
the vehicle with multiple products at various stages of construction.
• The vehicle bodies will be covered during storage inside the enclosure.
• No leakage of chemicals will occur outside the building because the products used on the vehicles have to
cure inside before storage.
• The storage area will be screened from view within an eight (8) foot tall vinyl fence enclosure. All storage
will be at least one (1) foot shorter than the enclosure. The fence will be white in color so that it matches the
adjacent storage building.
Planning Commission – March 1, 2011
Page 2 of 4
•
After construction of the enclosure, staff may require additional landscaping along Harmon Road in two
small gaps in the existing vegetation. Staff would only require additional landscaping if the interior of the
storage area were deemed visible from the roadway due to its lower topographic elevation.
The public hearing was opened and closed at 7:12 p.m. No comments from the public were made.
Mr. Kittle disclosed that Dow Automotive Systems has been a customer of his business for many years and he
is familiar with the company. He stated that he is willing to abstain if the Commission felt there was a conflict of
interest. Mr. Ouellette and the Commission advised Mr. Kittle that they found no conflict and had no objection
to him voting on the request.
Ms. Verbeke moved to recommend to City Council approval of the Special Land Use Permit for Dow
Automotive Systems to allow outside storage of vehicle bodies subject to staff notes and conditions.
Supported by Ms. Mitchell
VOTE: Yes: Hitchcock, Kittle, Mitchell, Pierce, Ouellette, Salerno, Spurlin, Verbeke
No: None
Motion Carried (8-0)
OLD BUSINESS - None
NEW BUSINESS - None
7a.
Overview of the Draft Infrastructure Studies for North Squirrel Road and Taylor Road/Lapeer
Intersection (7:25 p.m.)
Mr. Stevens, Mr. Juidici, and Mr. Loveland presented findings from two (2) traffic and geometric studies. The
first study area is North Squirrel Road from Walton to Dutton, and the second involves the Taylor/Opdyke/
Lapeer intersection and the Taylor Road extension.
North Squirrel Study
The North Squirrel Road Study involved first completing a traffic study and analysis to examine the existing
conditions and future needs of the roadway corridor. Mr. Stevens explained that traffic volume counts and three
(3) years of crash data were obtained and reviewed. Based on the information collected, the intersections see
typical crash rates for the area but there appears to be a higher rate of rear-end crashes between the
intersections. This is likely caused when vehicles are stopped to make a left turn into properties. Adding a
center turn lane and improving the road profile to increase sight distance would likely reduce these crashes.
Existing traffic volume is approximately 17,000 vehicles per day. Study utilized a one percent (1%) growth
factor to project to 2035, which is in line with SEMCOG projections for the area. This results in a future volume
of 22,000 vehicles per day.
The existing road cross section is a single travel lane in each direction with occasional auxiliary turn lanes at
intersections and/or driveways. Mr. Loveland reviewed the existing intersection operations and showed the
traffic model with the existing volumes. Most of the current intersections operate at an acceptable level of
service, although eastbound Shimmons Road and westbound Tienken Road approaches have delays during the
peak hours. With no improvements, all intersections fall below acceptable levels of service based on the future
traffic volumes.
Options for each future intersection were presented. The options involved a traffic signal or roundabout at each
location. The signal options with expanded thru-lanes as well as the roundabout options operate well, with the
roundabouts having less overall delay. Based on future volumes, the roadway section would be five (5) lanes
between Walton Boulevard and Tienken Road and three (3) lanes between Tienken Road and Dutton Road.
The option of having a narrow boulevard in locations where the center turn lane was not needed was also
presented.
Based on the traffic analysis and recommendations, an alignment study along the roadway was completed. Mr.
Juidici reviewed the alignment study objectives and constraints, including right-of-way impacts, environmental
concerns, aesthetics, utility conflicts, and estimated costs. By widening the roadway, there will be impacts to
Planning Commission – March 1, 2011
Page 3 of 4
existing trees, property frontages, wetlands, etc. Most of the road footprint would fit within the existing right-ofway, but additional would be needed in some areas. The different intersection options also have different
impacts. The roundabout options would require more right-of-way than signals, but will reduce long-term costs.
Roadway profile corrections would also result in significant grading work up to, and in some cases beyond, the
right-of-way. The preliminary costs for each of the options were discussed as well as potential funding
opportunities.
The Commission, City staff, and OHM discussed the options and reviewed exhibit diagrams. It was discussed
that this is a long-term plan and not intended to be constructed in the immediate future. The long-term plan will
help guide road improvement projects, land use plans, and development projects along the corridor. Options for
“phasing” the project were discussed, such as constructing three (3) lanes with the future plan to widen to five
(5) lanes. A public open house meeting will be scheduled to present the plan and seek resident input. Mr.
Cohen advised the Commission that the anticipated date of that meeting is April 20th.
The Commission also recommended that staff meet with the most affected property owners again prior to the
April 20th public open house to further explain the City’s long term vision. It was suggested that City Manager
Auger participate in those meetings, if available.
Taylor Road Study
Mr. Stevens explained the main objective of the Taylor Road study is to evaluate options to improve the Taylor
Road intersection with Lapeer Road as a means to promote development along Taylor Road. The study
involved a traffic analysis to forecast anticipated traffic and examine the operation of different intersection types
and alignments.
Traffic volume counts and three (3) years of crash data were obtained and reviewed. Based on the information
collected, the intersection sees typical crash rates for the area. The highest number of crashes occurs on
Lapeer Road at the Taylor Road intersection and at the median cross-over south of Taylor Road. This is likely
caused by limited sight distance at these locations and the “weaving” being done by vehicles leaving Taylor
Road to use the cross-over. Existing traffic volumes were obtained for the road network and were projected in
the study to 2035 using a one percent (1%) growth factor. The undeveloped property along Taylor Road was
reviewed and anticipated traffic that could be generated based on the City’s existing zoning requirements. The
study projected future 2035 traffic based on full build-out of the undeveloped land to zoning requirements. Mr.
Loveland reviewed the existing intersection operations using the traffic model. The existing operation operates
well for Lapeer Road and Opdyke Road, but does not allow for complete connection/movement of Taylor Road.
This intersection involves other jurisdictions including the Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) and
the Road Commission for Oakland County (RCOC). A brainstorming session was previously held with
representatives from the City, MDOT, and OHM to look at intersection options that could be considered. Many
configurations were discussed and five (5) layouts were selected for further evaluation: a signalized intersection,
single roundabout, dual roundabout, signalized intersection with bridge bypass, and roundabout with bridge
bypass.
The various options were reviewed using the traffic model to illustrate the signalized options. Based on the
projected volumes, significant change to the intersection would be required to have an acceptable level of
service. It was noted that this future growth would not happen immediately, and the improvements may be
“phased” as the demand increases. The impacts of the various options and costs were presented.
The Commission, City staff, and OHM discussed the options and reviewed exhibit diagrams. Similar to the
Squirrel Road study, this analysis is meant to serve as a long-term plan to help guide future projects and
decisions. It was discussed that it would be ideal to have a joint workshop between Planning Commission and
City Council to discuss the traffic infrastructure options and vision for this area.
Ms. Verbeke moved to request a Joint Meeting with City Council to review the Taylor Road Traffic Study
and future land use plans for Taylor Road near Lapeer.
Supported by Mr. Kittle
VOTE: Yes: Hitchcock, Kittle, Mitchell, Pierce, Ouellette, Salerno, Spurlin, Verbeke
No: None
Planning Commission – March 1, 2011
Page 4 of 4
Motion Carried (8-0)
COMMUNICATIONS
Mr. Cohen announced the following items:
• It appears Kensington Church will locate their church in Orion Township and not in Auburn Hills as originally
planned. Church officials explained to staff that it is cheaper and faster to rehabilitate an existing industrial
building, than build a new church.
• A rezoning of the old Wal-Mart site at 300 North Opdyke Road is scheduled for March 29th. Legend Value is
requesting a rezoning from B-2, General Business District to I-1, Light Industrial District. Legend Valve has
been in business in Michigan for over 20 years, supplying plumbing valves and fittings to plumbing
wholesalers across the United States for use in residential and commercial construction. Their intent is to
utilize the site as their company headquarters and for warehousing and distribution.
• Staff will be presenting the Riverwalk Master Plan at the Oakland County Planner’s Gathering on March 4th.
ANNOUNCEMENT OF NEXT MEETING
The next scheduled meeting is March 15, 2011.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 9:14 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
Steven J. Cohen
Director of Community Development
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
A G E N D A I T E M N O . 7 A .3.
“Not Yet Approved"
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
TAX INCREMENT FINANCE AUTHORITY MEETING
March 8, 2011
CALL TO ORDER:
Chairman Bennett called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
Present:
Absent:
Also Present:
Guests:
Bennett, Creager, Douglas, Goodhall, Hassett, Landsberg,
Stonehouse, Thornton
Copple
Assistant City Manager/TIFA Executive Director Tom Tanghe,
Finance Director Gary Barnes, Coordinator of Community
Relations and Legislative Affairs Stephanie Carroll, Management
Assistant Matthew Rizzo, Gary Korleski, Executive Assistant
Karrie Marsh
None
LOCATION: Auburn Hills City Hall, Council Chambers, 1827 North Squirrel Road, Auburn Hills, Michigan
48326
PERSONS WISHING TO BE HEARD
Mr. Bennett asked Mr. Tanghe to introduce the new members to the Board. Mr. Tanghe made a brief
introduction and then invited the new Board members to further introduce themselves. Ms. Douglas and
Mr. Stonehouse spoke briefly and provided the Board with a little background about themselves.
Mr. Tanghe distributed a number of work samples from Marketing Coordinator Andrew Opalewski in order
to familiarize the Board with what he is accomplishing.
CORRESPONDENCE
Mr. Tanghe explained the memo from DPS Deputy Director Don Grice regarding the Opdyke Road
Maintenance Contract which included bids from four companies. Mr. Landsberg questioned the
discrepancy of the wide range of bid amounts submitted. Mr. Tanghe explained that overhead and labor
costs and other factors affect the bid amounts submitted and that the low bidder was deemed qualified.
Because the amount did not meet the threshold of formal approval, no action was required.
.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
For clarification, Mr. Tanghe asked Mr. Goodhall whether the new members could vote on previous
minutes. The answer was no.
Moved by Mr. Creager to approve the December 14, 2010 minutes as submitted.
Supported by Mr. Hassett.
Yes:
No:
Bennett, Creager, Goodhall, Hassett, Landsberg, Thornton
none
Motion carried
page 2 of 5
March 8, 2011 minutes
FINANCIAL REPORT
Mr. Barnes presented the financial report for December 31, 2010, reviewing the activities for this period,
including the most recent revenues and expenses. That report included the following Total Liabilities and
Fund Balances and Available Cash:
TIFA 85-A
TIFA 85-B
TIFA 86-D
$ 29,212,337
12,910,027
25,180,610
$ 67,311,974
Available Cash (TIF-A) $8,173,857
Available Cash (TIF-B) $8,228,006
Available Cash (TIF-D) $1,818,402
Moved by Mr. Creager to approve the Financial Report of December 31, 2010 as submitted.
Supported by Mr. Hassett.
Yes:
No:
Bennett, Creager, Douglas, Goodhall, Hassett, Landsberg, Stonehouse, Thornton
none
Motion carried
OLD BUSINESS
None
NEW BUSINESS
7.a.
Mr. Korleski was present to request a Site Improvement Grant. He has asked that we consider one of the other three contractors than the one that is in the original memo awarding his project. He believes that he will not be able to successfully complete the project with the company that was the original low bidder. Julion Construction has submitted a revised bid in the amount of $63,500. This satisfies our “lowest qualified bidder” requirement. Because the Julion Construction bid is not itemized, Mr. Tanghe deducted a lump sum of 5% of their total bid for permits, scaffolding, and clean up. Therefore, the request is based on $57,150. On a dollar‐for‐dollar matching basis, the recommendation is a grant in the amount of $28,575. Mr. Korleski shared a rendering of the new façade and described a timeline for expected completion. Moved by Mr. Goodhall to approve the request from Gary Korleski (3329 Auburn Road LLC) for a Village Center Site Improvement Grant in the amount of $28,575 for qualifying exterior façade improvement expenses, for the property located at 3329‐3341 Auburn Road. Furthermore, payment shall be made directly to the contractor, Julion Construction in the amount of $28,575.00, upon completion of the work being funded and approval by the Building Department that the work is acceptable by building code and local ordinances. Payment is subject to all outstanding taxes, assessments, and City utility bills being paid to the page 3 of 5
March 8, 2011 minutes City and/or County by the building owner. Funds are available in TIFA‐A, Account No. 27350/76815. Supported by Mr. Landsberg.
Yes:
No:
Bennett, Creager, Douglas, Goodhall, Hassett, Landsberg, Stonehouse, Thornton
none
Motion carried
7.b.
Coordinator of Community Relations and Legislative Affairs Stephanie Carroll informed the Board
that the Farmers’ Market did very well in 2010. The Market had between 20-25 vendors last year.
On average there were approximately 200 visitors each week. Six vendors have already signed
up for this year’s Market and we anticipate the same number of vendors for the 2011 season. As
outlined in the memo to the Board, Mrs. Carroll is requesting funding from the Board in the
amount of $15,000.00 and would like to rename the Marketing Subcommittee the Events &
Marketing Committee, since the number of events being held in the Downtown are increasing
each year. The funding will be used for advertising, marketing and to purchase items such as
picnic tables to create a more ambience for the market attendees. While the sponsors from last
year have declined, Mrs. Carroll was pleased to announce the partnership with Genisys Credit
Union who will be the presenting sponsor for the 2011 Market. Mr. Stonehouse asked if the
Farmers’ Market had potential to generate revenue. Mrs. Carroll said that was a goal, but
according to other local markets, the first few years the focus is on growing the Market and
attracting customers to the Downtown area in hopes of later being able to generate revenue and
make a profit. Ms. Douglas inquired as to how to improve attendance. Mrs. Carroll responded
that advertising is important. For example, the 2010 Market was advertised in the Michigan
Gardener for eight weeks at the cost of $50.00. Word of mouth also improves attendance as well
as working with other local Markets. Mrs. Carroll stated that a press release will be issued at the
beginning of April regarding the Farmer’s Market. She would like to call a meeting of a
subcommittee in a couple of weeks. That subcommittee will consist of Mrs. Thornton, Mr.
Landsberg, Ms. Douglas and Mrs. Copple if she wished to remain. Mrs. Carroll is looking forward
to the Farmers’ Market Grand Opening on May 19th.
Moved by Mrs. Thornton to approve Funding the 2011 Farmer’s Market Marketing Plan as
submitted. Supported by Mr. Creager.
Yes:
No:
Bennett, Creager, Douglas, Goodhall, Hassett, Landsberg, Stonehouse, Thornton
none
Motion carried
7.c.
Mr. Tanghe explained that there was no reason for a closed session to discuss the acquisition of
land that is on the agenda. This parcel is not something of interest to anyone else but the City and will be used for the construction of a pathway for our river walk. Additionally, there is no great urgency to acquire it but it is important for us to own it for our future plans. The property is approximately 1.25 acres in size and contains a good stretch of river frontage. It is adjacent to land the city currently owns that is part of River Woods Park. A purchase agreement has been forwarded to the owner. They have agreed to the price offered and a response is expected shortly from the individual who has authority to sign the purchase agreement on behalf of the ownership. The property has an assessed value of $20,250 and page 4 of 5
March 8, 2011 minutes therefore an assumed market value of $40,500 per our Assessor’s office. A purchase price of $15,000 has been agreed upon. The land has limited access and use. The land is actually not included in TIF District A, but is wedged between two parcels that are contained in Development District A. It is appropriate and permissible to acquire a parcel of this nature using TIFA funds when in fact it is a key component that links two district parcels together. Our City Attorney has reviewed this acquisition and has given his stamp of approval. Moved by Ms. Douglas to recommend approval to City Council, the purchase of a 1.25 acre parcel of land with property identification number 14‐25‐401‐003 in the amount of $15,000, and authorize TIFA Executive Director Tom Tanghe to execute the necessary documents on behalf of the Tax Increment Finance Authority. Supported by Mrs. Thornton.
Yes:
No:
Bennett, Creager, Douglas, Goodhall, Hassett, Landsberg, Stonehouse, Thornton
none
Motion carried
7.d.
Mr. Tanghe introduced Mr. Matt Rizzo, Management Assistant. Mr. Rizzo gave a presentation of the DTE overhead line relocation in the Downtown. His presentation showed where the current lines are and where they could be relocated along the north side of Primary Street. The lines to be relocated include those that are mid‐block from South Squirrel Road to Grey Road, and between Primary and Auburn Roads. The transformer would be located on the west side of South Squirrel Road. Mr. Rizzo presented cost estimates from DTE, AT&T, and Comcast. The costs did not include additional expenses to connect businesses along Auburn Road with new services, that which the TIFA would be expected to pay. The expected cost for each would be in the range of $3,000 to $4,000 and there will likely be a handful of businesses that will need to be converted to the new service. There will be some underground work that needs to be performed utilizing conduit. Mr. Rizzo will follow up with more details at an upcoming meeting after a final cost proposal is prepared by all of the utilities. 7.e.
Mr. Tanghe discussed establishing a Phase I implementation of the River Walk Master Plan. City staff has begun to meet about what the logical next steps might be for implementing the plan. The proposed amphitheater in Riverside Park was discussed and some conceptual drawings were shared. Price ranges for construction of an amphitheater vary based on needs which have not yet been finalized. The purpose of the discussion today was to prepare the Board for plans that will be forthcoming. The TIFA will be funding the improvements contained in the River Walk Master Plan. page 5 of 5
March 8, 2011 minutes
ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION ITEMS & ANNOUNCEMENTS Historical Society Signage – A Proposal for Historical Signage at the Log Cabin in the Downtown was
presented to City Council by Wilson Garner, and accepted. The TIFA will be paying for the sign and the
content of that sign is yet to be determined. A staff review in conjunction with the Historical Society will
produce a final product.
Mr. Tanghe reminded the Board of the Auburn Hills Chamber and TIFA Ribbon Cutting and Open House this Thursday, March 10th from 4:00 p.m. – 7:00 p.m. at 3395 Auburn Rd. Ste A. The ribbon cutting will take place promptly at 5:00 p.m. DPS Deputy Director Don Grice is moving forward on implementing LED Technology Lighting Downtown. An ad‐hoc committee was formed due to the fact that three different lighting solutions are being proposed. The following TIFA Board members volunteered to serve on an ad‐hoc committee. They are: Mr. Bennett, Mr. Hassett, Mr. Creager and Mr. Stonehouse. Mr. Tanghe distributed 2011 budgets for TIFA A, B and D, as well as the 2012 Amendments to the Development Plan & Tax Increment Financing Plan for Auburn Heights Development Area 85‐A, B and D. He asked that each Board member insert them into their three‐ring binders. ANNOUNCEMENT OF NEXT MEETING – The next regularly scheduled TIFA Board meeting is Tuesday,
April 12, 2011 at 4:00 p.m. in the Admin. Conference Room at City Hall.
ADJOURNMENT
Moved by Mr. Creager to adjourn the meeting at 5:42 p.m.
Supported by Mrs. Thornton.
Yes:
No:
Bennett, Creager, Douglas, Goodhall, Hassett, Landsberg, Stonehouse, Thornton
none
Motion carried
Respectfully submitted,
Charlotte Copple
Karrie L. Marsh
Thomas A. Tanghe
Secretary of the Board
Recording Secretary
Assistant City Manager
TIFA Executive Director
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
A G E N D A I T E M N O . 7 A .4.
Not Yet Approved
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
March 15, 2011
CALL TO ORDER: Chairperson Ouellette called the meeting to order at 6:37 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
Present.
Absent.
Also Present.
Guests.
Beidoun, Hitchcock, Kittle, Mitchell, Pierce, Ouellette, Salerno, Spurlin, Verbeke
None
Director of Community Development Cohen, OHM Civil Engineer Juidici, Water
Resources Coordinator Keenan
None
LOCATION: City Council Chamber, 1827 N. Squirrel, Auburn Hills, MI 48326
PERSONS WISHING TO BE HEARD - None
MINUTES - None
PLANNING WORKSHOP DISCUSSION – Auburn Road Corridor Planning Study
The Commission began brainstorming discussions on a vision for the property along Auburn Road at the
periphery of the Downtown core. The purpose of the workshop was for the group to become familiar with the
study areas (e.g., existing conditions, constraints, and potential land use options) prior to meeting with property
owners. The intent of the discussion was not to focus on the core, since the HyettPalma study had recently
been completed for that area.
Staff presented concepts for two (2) study areas in detail. The first area called “East Auburn Road” was from
Juniper east to Adams Road. The second area called “West Auburn Road” was from the Clinton River west to
I-75. All attending gathered around the maps and generally discussed the pros and cons of various land use
options and ideas for future development. No consensus was made in terms of land use policy direction for the
study areas; however all felt the discussions were fruitful.
The Commission plans to proceed with the following schedule:
• Conduct a walking tour of the study areas on Tuesday, April 5th (weather permitting)
• Visit various Downtowns in Michigan, with an intentional focus on observing what land uses are commonly
found at the edges or periphery of those areas. This will occur in the months of March and April.
Commission members will team-up in groups of two (2) and visit up to ten (10) Downtown areas and report
back with their findings.
• Hold visioning meetings with property owners in May and/or June
• Complete the study by August
COMMUNICATIONS - None
ANNOUNCEMENT OF NEXT MEETING
The next scheduled meeting is March 29, 2011.
Planning Commission – March 15, 2011
Page 2 of 2
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 8:32 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted,
Steven J. Cohen
Director of Community Development
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
AGENDA ITEM NO. FOR CLERK'S USE
POLICE DEPARTMENT
To:
Mayor and City Council
From:
Peter E. Auger, City Manager; Doreen E. Olko, Chief of Police
Submitted: March 17, 2011
Subject:
Public Hearing and Motions - Approving 2011 Liquor License Renewals for Establishments in
Compliance.
Public Hearings and Resolutions – Objecting to 2011 Liquor License Renewals for Establishments
Not in Compliance.
INTRODUCTION AND HISTORY
Establishments in Compliance: In addition to those liquor licenses recommended for approval on March 7,
2011, the following establishments have now met all the requirements for liquor license renewal for 2011:
Applebee’s # 5832
Applebee’s # 5860
Macaroni Grill
Hoops Sports and Spirits (Green Pastures)
The Palace of Auburn Hills
The Post Bar
Establishments Not in Compliance: The following establishments, as of March 17th, 2011, at 10:00 am, still
have an outstanding financial obligation to the City and, therefore, under section 6-11 of the City of Auburn
Hills Code of Ordinances do not meet the requirements for liquor license renewal:
LICENSES NOT MEETING ELIGIBILITY FOR RENEWAL
The following establishments have not met the requirements for license renewal due to non-payment of renewal fees,
water/sewer fees, and/or taxes.
Real Property Taxes as
of 03/01/11
Personal Property
Taxes as of 03/01/11
2010
Summer
2010
Winter
2010
Summer
2010
Winter
Total
Taxes
Due
Callahan Holdings
0.00
8,297.70
0.00
1,229.41
9,527.11
Duffy's Irish Pub
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
Fiero Lanes
15,412.40
12,758.68
2,637.76
2,111.13
Lelli's
33,115.41
10,359.12
2,392.37
1,133.41
The Post Bar*
32,393.53
10,133.31
Company Name
74.39
License
Renewal
Fees
261.27
9,788.38
250.00
2,503.82
2,753.82
32,919.97
250.00
0.00
33,169.97
47,000.31
0.00
1,276.98
48,277.29
42,601.23
0.00
0.00
42,601.23
*Note: Status as of 03/17/11
** Lelli's still owes 2009 taxes to Oakland County - $33,350.87 (Real)
** The Post Bar still owes 2009 taxes to Oakland County - $128,909.29 (Real)
0.00
Water & Sewer
Total
Amount
Due
Grand Total
Delinquencies
136,590.69
Page 2
*Post Bar made partial PP payment on 3-2-11, forwarded to County, leaving a balance of $74.39
Post Bar real property owned by landlord
Max & Erma's removed per Derk due to bankruptcy that is open
The Clerk’s office sent notices to each of these establishments advising that the City Council would be holding
a hearing on March 21, 2011, regarding the City’s potential objection to the renewal of their liquor licenses
based on outstanding financial obligations to the City. These notices were sent two ways:
•
•
•
By first class certified mail on March 8, 2011.
By letters hand delivered by the Auburn Hills Police Department on March 9 & 10, 2011
Licenses of Special Note
o Max and Erma’s is in bankruptcy
o Mountain Jack’s, Fiero Lanes, La-Shish, Taste of Thailand and Blue Water Bistro are in
Escrow
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
For those establishments which have now paid their outstanding financial obligation to the City staff
recommends the City Council recommend to the Michigan Liquor Control Commission renewal of their liquor
license.
After the public hearing for those establishments not in compliance, if City Council finds financial obligations
still outstanding by 5:00 P.M.,March 29, 2011, staff recommends that the City formally object to the renewal of
these liquor licenses.
MOTION
Move to recommend approval of the annual liquor licenses of those establishments who have now met
the licensing requirements of the City: Applebee’s #5832, Applebee’s #5860, Hoops Sports and Spirits
(Green Pastures), The Palace of Auburn Hills, The Post Bar and Macaroni Grill.
Move to adopt the attached resolution(s) directing the City Clerk to file objection on behalf of the City
Council to renewal of liquor licenses for Callahan Holdings, Duffy’s Irish Pub and Lelli’s due to
outstanding financial obligations to the City, which objection will be forwarded to Liquor Control
Commission unless such financial obligations are met by March 29, 2011 at 5:00 p.m.
I CONCUR:
PETER E. AUGER, CITY MANAGER
Resolution No.
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
RESOLUTION
OBJECTING TO RENEWAL OF LIQUOR LICENSE FOR
LELLI’S
At a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Auburn Hills, Oakland County, Michigan,
held in the Council Chambers at 1827 N. Squirrel Road, Auburn Hills MI 48326 at 7:00 p.m., on the 21st
day of March, 2011
The following resolution was offered by
and supported by
.
RESOLVED: To adopt the attached resolution(s) directing the City Clerk to file objection on behalf
of the City Council to renewal of liquor licenses for Lelli’s, Duffy’s Irish Pub, Callahan Holdings,
for the establishment Callahan’s, due to outstanding financial obligations to the City, which
objection will be forwarded to Liquor Control Commission unless such financial obligations are
met by March 29, 2011 at 5:00 p.m.
VOTE: Yes
No:
Motion carried (-)
RESOLUTION NO.
WHEREAS, Lelli’s is the holder of the liquor license for the establishment known as “Lelli’s”
located at 885 N. Opdyke, Auburn Hills, Michigan 48326; and
WHEREAS, the Lelli’s’ Liquor License for Lelli’s is currently under consideration for renewal in
2011; and
WHEREAS, Section 6-11 of Chapter 6 of the City of Auburn Hills Code provides that the City
Council shall review each licensee’s on-premise liquor license, annually, before March 30, to determine
whether or not to object to the Liquor Control Commission’s renewal of the license, and
WHEREAS, Section 6-11 of Chapter 6 of the City of Auburn Hills Code also provides that the City
Council may object to renewal of a liquor license,
•
If the licensed establishment has not complied with all standards, plans and conditions established
and approved at the time of the issuance of the license or at a time of later city approval.
•
If any personal property taxes, real property taxes and/or other obligations due and payable to the
city are not paid in a timely manner or are outstanding.
•
For any of the reasons set forth in section 6-12 of the Code, and
WHEREAS, Section 6-13 of Chapter 6 of the City of Auburn Hills Code provides that The City
Council shall hold a hearing on the proposed objection prior to filing such objection with the Liquor Control
Commission, written notice of which shall be served on the licensee by first-class mail at least ten days
prior to a hearing, and
WHEREAS, on March 21, 2011, the Auburn Hills City Council held a hearing on the proposed
objection to the renewal of liquor license currently held by Lelli’s for the establishment known as Lelli’s,
with the licensee having been timely and duly notified of the hearing and the right to attend the same as
required by Chapter 6 of the Auburn Hills City Code, and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Auburn Hills finds that the following obligations and
property taxes for the establishment known as Lelli’s have not been timely paid, are due, and are, at this
time, outstanding;
Lelli's
Real Property Taxes as
of 03/01/11
Personal Property
Taxes as of 03/01/11
33,115.41
2,392.37
10,359.12
1,133.41
47,000.31
0.00
1,276.98
48,277.29
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, due to Lelli’s’ failure to meet the aforementioned
outstanding obligations by the deadline established in the adopting resolution and pursuant to Chapter 6
of the City of Auburn Hills Code, the City Council hereby directs the City Clerk to file objection on behalf
of the Auburn Hills’ City Council to renewal of the 2011 Liquor License held by Lelli’s by forwarding the
following documents to the Michigan Liquor Control Commission in such a manner as to be received by
the Liquor Control Commission no later than March 31, 2011:
•
A certified copy of the Auburn Hills Liquor Licensing Ordinance, as currently contained in Chapter
6 of the Auburn Hills City Code, including the date of adoption of the Code and the date of
publication of the same.
•
A certified copy of the notice sent to the licensee advising the licensee of the March 21, 2011
hearing on the issue of renewal of the liquor license.
•
A Proof of Service and/or Affidavit indicating that the notice of the March 21, 2011 hearing was
sent to the licensee.
•
A certified copy of this Resolution objecting to the Liquor Control Commission’s renewal of the
subject liquor license.
AYES:
NAYS:
ABSENT:
ABSTENTIONS:
RESOLUTION ADOPTED (-)
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
)SS
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
I, the undersigned, the duly appointed City Clerk for the City of Auburn Hills, Oakland County,
Michigan do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and complete copy of a resolution adopted at a
regular meeting of the Auburn Hills City Council held on the 21st day of March, 2011.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto affixed my official signature on this 22nd day of March,
2011.
______________________________________
Linda F. Shannon, City Clerk
Resolution No.
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
RESOLUTION
OBJECTING TO RENEWAL OF LIQUOR LICENSE FOR
DUFFY’S IRISH PUB
At a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Auburn Hills, Oakland County, Michigan,
held in the Council Chambers at 1827 N. Squirrel Road, Auburn Hills MI 48326 at 7:00 p.m., on the 21st
day of March, 2011
The following resolution was offered by
and supported by
:
RESOLVED: To adopt the attached resolution(s) directing the City Clerk to file objection on behalf
of the City Council to renewal of liquor licenses for Lelli’s, Duffy’s Irish Pub and Callahan
Holdings, for the establishment Callahan’s, due to outstanding financial obligations to the City,
which objection will be forwarded to Liquor Control Commission unless such financial obligations
are met by March 29, 2010 at 5:00 p.m.
VOTE: Yes:
No:
RESOLUTION NO.
Motion carried (-)
WHEREAS, is the holder of the liquor license for the establishment known as “Duffy’s Irish Pub”
located at 3320 Auburn Road, Auburn Hills, Michigan 48326; and
WHEREAS, the liquor license for Duffy’s Irish Pub is currently under consideration for renewal for
2011; and
WHEREAS, Section 6-11 of Chapter 6 of the Auburn Hills City Code provides that the City
Council shall annually review before March 30 each licensee’s on-premise liquor license to determine
whether or not to object to the Liquor Control Commission’s renewal of the license, and also provides that
the City Council may object to renewal of a liquor license if all personal property taxes, real property taxes
and any other obligations due and payable to the City are not timely paid and are outstanding; and
WHEREAS, Section 6-13 of Chapter 6 of the Auburn Hills City Code provides that prior to the City
filing an objection with the Liquor Control Commission for the renewal of a liquor license, the City Council
shall hold a hearing on the issue of whether to object to the renewal of the liquor license and shall serve
the licensee by first-class mail at least ten days prior to a hearing with written notice of the hearing; and
WHEREAS, on March 21st, 2011, the Auburn Hills City Council held a hearing on the issue of
whether to object to the renewal of the liquor license currently held by Duffy’s Irish Pub with the licensee
having been timely and duly notified of the hearing and its right to attend the same as required by Chapter
6 of the Auburn Hills City Code, and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Auburn Hills finds that the following obligations and
property taxes for the establishment knows as Duffy’s Irish Pub have not been timely paid, are due, and
are, at this time, outstanding;
Real Property Taxes
March 2009
Company Name
Duffy’s Irish Pub
Personal Property Taxes
March 2009
2009 Taxes
2009 Taxes
Total Taxes
Due
0.00
0.00
0.00
License
Renewal
Fees
250.00
Water &
Sewer
2,503.82
TOTAL
AMOUNT
DUE
2,753.82
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, due to Duffy’s Irish Pub’s failure to meet the
aforementioned outstanding obligations by the deadline established in the adopting resolution and
pursuant to Chapter 6 of the City of Auburn Hills Code, the City Council hereby directs the City Clerk to
file objection on behalf of the Auburn Hills’ City Council to renewal of the 2011 Liquor License held by
Duffy’s Irish Pub by forwarding the following documents to the Michigan Liquor Control Commission in
such a manner as to be received by the Liquor Control Commission no later than March 31, 2011:
• A certified copy of the Auburn Hills Liquor Licensing Ordinance, as currently contained in Chapter 6
of the Auburn Hills City Code, including the date of adoption of the Code and the date of publication
of the same.
• A certified copy of the notice sent to the licensee advising the licensee of the March 21, 2011
hearing on the issue of renewal of the liquor license.
• A Proof of Service and/or Affidavit indicating that the notice of the March 21, 2011 hearing was sent
to the licensee.
• A certified copy of this Resolution objecting to the Liquor Control Commission’s renewal of the
subject liquor license.
AYES:
NAYS:
ABSENT:
ABSTENTIONS:
RESOLUTION ADOPTED (-)
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
)SS
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
I, the undersigned, the duly appointed City Clerk for the City of Auburn Hills, Oakland County,
Michigan do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and complete copy of a resolution adopted at a
regular meeting of the Auburn Hills City Council held on the 21st day of March, 2011.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto affixed my official signature on this 22nd day of March,
2011.
______________________________________
Linda F. Shannon, City Clerk
Resolution No.
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
RESOLUTION
OBJECTING TO RENEWAL OF LIQUOR LICENSE FOR
CALLAHAN HOLDINGS
At a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Auburn Hills, Oakland County, Michigan,
held in the Council Chambers at 1827 N. Squirrel Road, Auburn Hills MI 48326 at 7:00 p.m., on the 21st
day of March, 2011
The following resolution was offered by
and supported by
:
RESOLVED: To adopt the attached resolutions directing the City Clerk to file objection on behalf of
the City Council to renewal of liquor licenses for Lelli’s, Duffy’s Irish Pub and Callahan Holdings, for
the establishment Callahan’s, due to outstanding financial obligations to the City, which objection
will be forwarded to Liquor Control Commission unless such financial obligations are met by March
29, 2010 at 5:00 p.m.
VOTE: Yes:
No:
RESOLUTION NO.
Motion carried (-)
WHEREAS, Callahan Holdings is the holder of the liquor license for the establishment known
Callahan’s located at 2105 E. South Blvd., Auburn Hills, Michigan 48326; and
WHEREAS, the liquor license for Duffy’s Irish Pub is currently under consideration for renewal for
2011; and
WHEREAS, Section 6-11 of Chapter 6 of the Auburn Hills City Code provides that the City
Council shall annually review before March 30 each licensee’s on-premise liquor license to determine
whether or not to object to the Liquor Control Commission’s renewal of the license, and also provides that
the City Council may object to renewal of a liquor license if all personal property taxes, real property taxes
and any other obligations due and payable to the City are not timely paid and are outstanding; and
WHEREAS, Section 6-13 of Chapter 6 of the Auburn Hills City Code provides that prior to the City
filing an objection with the Liquor Control Commission for the renewal of a liquor license, the City Council
shall hold a hearing on the issue of whether to object to the renewal of the liquor license and shall serve
the licensee by first-class mail at least ten days prior to a hearing with written notice of the hearing; and
WHEREAS, on March 21st, 2011, the Auburn Hills City Council held a hearing on the issue of
whether to object to the renewal of the liquor license currently held by Callahan’s Holdings for the
establishment known as Callahan’s with the licensee having been timely and duly notified of the hearing
and its right to attend the same as required by Chapter 6 of the Auburn Hills City Code, and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Auburn Hills finds that the following obligations and property
taxes for the establishment knows as Callahan’s have not been timely paid, are due, and are, at this time,
outstanding;
Real Property Taxes as
of 03/01/11
Company Name
Callahan Holdings
Personal Property
Taxes as of 03/01/11
2010
Summer
2010
Winter
2010
Summer
2010
Winter
Total
Taxes
Due
0.00
8,297.70
0.00
1,229.41
9,527.11
License
Renewal
Fees
0.00
Water & Sewer
261.27
Total
Amount
Due
9,788.38
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, due to Callahan’s failure to meet the
aforementioned outstanding obligations by the deadline established in the adopting resolution and
pursuant to Chapter 6 of the City of Auburn Hills Code, the City Council hereby directs the City Clerk to
file objection on behalf of the Auburn Hills’ City Council to renewal of the 2011 Liquor License held by
Callahan Holdings, for the establishment Callahan’s, by forwarding the following documents to the
Michigan Liquor Control Commission in such a manner as to be received by the Liquor Control
Commission no later than March 31, 2011:
• A certified copy of the Auburn Hills Liquor Licensing Ordinance, as currently contained in Chapter 6
of the Auburn Hills City Code, including the date of adoption of the Code and the date of publication
of the same.
• A certified copy of the notice sent to the licensee advising the licensee of the March 21, 2011
hearing on the issue of renewal of the liquor license.
• A Proof of Service and/or Affidavit indicating that the notice of the March 21, 2011 hearing was sent
to the licensee.
• A certified copy of this Resolution objecting to the Liquor Control Commission’s renewal of the
subject liquor license.
AYES:
NAYS:
ABSENT:
ABSTENTIONS:
RESOLUTION ADOPTED (-)
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
)SS
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
I, the undersigned, the duly appointed City Clerk for the City of Auburn Hills, Oakland County,
Michigan do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and complete copy of a resolution adopted at a
regular meeting of the Auburn Hills City Council held on the 21st day of March, 2011.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto affixed my official signature on this 22nd day of March,
2011.
______________________________________
Linda F. Shannon, City Clerk
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
M A R C H 21, 2011
To:
Mayor and City Council
From:
Peter E. Auger, City Manager; Doreen E. Olko, Chief of Police
AGENDA ITEM NO. 8B
POLICE DEPARTMENT
Submitted: March 17, 2011
Subject:
Public Hearing and Motions - Approving the report and recommendation for issuance/renewal of
Recreation Hall Licenses
INTRODUCTION AND HISTORY
To insure appropriate oversight of Recreation Hall licenses, City Council enacted “Ordinance for Mechanical
Amusement Devices, Video Games and Pool Tables” under Chapter 10, Article III of the Code of
Ordinances. In addition to those Recreation Hall Licenses recommended for approval on March 7, 2011, the
following license holders have paid the required fee and posses the necessary certificates. Furthermore, the
Police, Fire, and Building Departments have conducted inspections at these establishments requesting
renewal of a Recreation Hall license. No major violations were found which would prohibit the renewal of these
licenses, and none of the businesses listed below had any violations relating to their recreation hall license in
2011:
The Post Bar
Establishments Not in Compliance: The following establishments, as of March 17th, 2011, at 1:00 pm, have
not applied for renewal for their Recreation Hall License. On March 31, 2011 these licenses will expire. The
license holders may apply to renew their license and the City Council may object to that renewal.
Duffy’s Irish Pub and Toby Keith’s I Love This Bar and Grill.
The Clerk’s office sent notices to each of these establishments advising that the City Council would be holding
a hearing on March 21, 2011, regarding the City’s potential objection to the renewal of their Recreation Hall
Licenses based on their failure to pay the renewal fee. These notices were sent two ways:
•
•
By first class certified mail on March 8, 2011.
By letters hand delivered by the Auburn Hills Police Department on March 9, 2011
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends the renewal of the Recreation Hall license for the businesses listed as having passed City
inspections, paid the appropriate fee, and possess the necessary certificates.
MOTION
Move to accept the report and recommendation for renewal of Recreation Hall license for the listed
establishments who have passed City inspections, paid the appropriate licensing fee and presented
the necessary documents.
I CONCUR:
PETER E. AUGER, CITY MANAGER
O:\CITY
COUNCIL PACKET\MARCH 21\Added\COVER MEMO Public Hearings And Motions - Approving The
Report And Recommendation For Issuance Renewal Of Recreation Hall Licenses.Docx
C
Ciittyy ooff A
Auubbuurrnn H
Hiillllss
City Council Agenda
March 21, 2011 Meeting
Agenda Item No. 8c.
CITY ASSESSOR
To:
Mayor and City Council
From:
Peter Auger, City Manager, and Victor Bennett, Assessor
Submitted:
March 17, 2011
Subject:
Rescind Resolution No. 11.03.50 opting out of the Alternate Energy Personal Property Exemption from local
taxes for United Solar Ovonic LLC
INTRODUCTION AND HISTORY
All material presented herein is identical to that presented to Council at the meeting of March 7, 2011.
Notification was received on January 19, 2011 that the Michigan Next Energy Authority (MNEA) has certified personal
property purchases in 2010 by United Solar Ovonic LLC as Alterative Energy Personal Property (AEPP) (MNEA
Resolution 2010-10), thereby exempting the property from local property taxes thru the year 2013, unless the local taxing
unit and or the local school district resolves to opt out of the exemption. The personal property in question is located at
3800 Lapeer and 2705 Commerce Parkway. City Council has 60 days from the receipt of the letter to exercise the opt-out
option.
This certificate is the 12th AEPP certificate issued by MNEA to United Solar Ovonic and its predecessors since 2003. City
Council resolved to opt out or not exempt local taxes from the first two certificates issued to United Solar by MNEA in
2003, and 2008. City Council did not opt out of certificates issued in 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2009.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
The personal property involved in this certification by MNEA was to be purchased in 2010 and the maximum value is
$7,691,059. If the City opts out of the tax exemption, the maximum amount of new city taxes realized on this equipment in
2011 would be $34,637. The total new taxes to the City over the three (3) years of the certificate would be $87,637. Total
potential savings to the company, if all local taxes are exempted would be $191,119.
Reasons for City Council to not take action or to not opt out would be that United Solar is a growing and expanding
company and is engaged in the development of alternative energy resources, and the City wishes to further encourage
the company to expand in Auburn Hills.
It is understood that upon further review and clarification, Council wishes to re-address this matter. Therefore, it
is required that Council rescind Resolution No. 11.03.50. If, by a majority vote of those present, Council votes in
favor of rescinding Resolution No. 11.03.50 and is in favor of granting the exemption, NO FURTHER ACTION IS
NECESSARY after the below stated motion.
MOTION
If Council wishes rescind Resolution No. 11.03.50, the following motion should be offered:
Move to rescind Resolution No. 11.03.50 as adopted March 7, 2011.
I CONCUR:
PETER AUGER, CITY MANAGER
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
ALTERNATE ENERGY PERSONAL PROPERTY LISTING
City of Auburn Hills
United Solar Ovonic
Michigan Next Energy Authority
Alternate Energy Personal Property ListingCertificate
#
Company
Name
Property
Address
$ Amount
Approved
$ Amount
Acquired
Year
of Acquisitions
Parcel
Opt
Out Resolution
Expires
Taxes
Paid
2010
2003-12
United Solar Ovonic Corp
3800 Lapeer
$
36,220.35
26,105.00
2003
95-03-100-012** Local Taxes
12/30/2012 $
2003-13
United Solar Ovonic LLC
3800 Lapeer
$
1,697,035.00
1,550,023.00
2003
95-03-100-013** Local Taxes
12/30/2012 $
2004-08
United Solar Ovonic LLC
3800 Lapeer
$
741,644.00
73,653.00
2004
95-04-100-008
None
12/30/2012
2004-09
United Solar Ovonic Corp
3800 Lapeer
$
130,934.00
94,455.00
2004
95-04-100-009
None
12/30/2012
2005-09
United Solar Ovonic Corp
3800 Lapeer
$
147,177.00
55,262.00
2005
95-05-100-009
None
12/30/2012
2005-10
United Solar Ovonic LLC
3800 Lapeer
2705 Commerce Pkwy
$
$
30,609,937.03
11,841,325.00
290,940.00
2005
2005
95-05-100-010
95-05-200-010
None
12/30/2012
12/30/2012
2006-08
United Solar Ovonic Corp
3800 Lapeer
$
237,076.35
2006
95-06-100-008
None
12/30/2012
2006-09
United Solar Ovonic LLC
3800 Lapeer
$
873,815.28
399,326.00
2006
95-06-100-009
None
12/30/2012
2705 Commerce Pkwy
$
67,029,844.00
62,870,020.00
2006
95-06-200-009
None
12/30/2012
2007-11
United Solar Ovonic LLC
3800 Lapeer
2705 Commerce Pkwy
$
$
1,231,813.00
2,705,674.00
918,204.00
2,138,220.00
2007
2007
95-07-100-011
95-07-200-011
None
12/30/2012
12/30/2012
2008-12
United Solar Ovonic LLC
2009-07
United Solar Ovonic LLC
3800 Lapeer
2705 Commerce Pkwy
3800 Lapeer
2705 Commerce Pkwy
$
$
$
$
4,111,693.00
325,110.00
10,254,805.00
164,263.00
1,353,741.00
238,932.00
148,447.00
171,048.00
2008
2008
2009
2009
95-08-100-012
95-08-200-012
98-09-100-007
98-09-200-007
Local Taxes
Local Taxes
None
12/30/2012 $
12/30/2012
12/30/2012
12/30/2012
Total to date
$ 132,138,366.01 $
70,328,376.00
7,513.93
10,579.98
CITY OF AUBURN HILLS
ALTERNATE ENERGY PERSONAL PROPERTY LISTING
Other Personal Property
Company
Name
United Solar Ovonic
LLC
Property
Address
Parcel
Year
Established
TRUE
Cash Value
2010
3800 Lapeer
99-00-002-014
2000
$ 21,540,060
United Solar Systems 3800 Lapeer
99-00-003-119
2000
$
134,780
Tax
Abatement?
Taxes
Paid
2010
no
7 year Act 198 abatement for
$50 million expired in 2007
no
$
250,510.79
$
1,567.42
Real Property
Leased by United
Solar
Owner
Name
3800 Lapeer Investo
Property
Address
3800 Lapeer
Parcel
14-02-401-031
Year
Leased
2000
TRUE
Cash Value
$
7,796,540
Tax
Abatement?
Taxes
no
$
Paid
2010
185,167.73
$
294,557.39
5 year Act 198 abatement for $2
million expired in 2006. .
Auburn Hills LLC et-al 2705 Commerce Pkwy
14-02-200-030
2006
$ 12,402,420
no
I year Act 198 abatement for $14
million expired in 2007
Total 2010 Tax $
Paid
$749,897.24
C I T Y O F A U B U R N H I LL S
C I T Y C O U N C I L A G E N DA
M A R C H 21, 2011
8d. Forester Square SAD
NO ELECTRONIC INFORMATION AVAILABLE
AGENDA ITEM NO. 8D.
Memo
To:
From:
Date:
Re:
Aerial
Auburn Hills Fire
Department
Auburn Hills Fire Department
Pete Auger, City Manager
John Burmeister, Fire Chief
March 17, 2011
Monthly Activity Report January 2011
During the month of January the department responded to 266 calls for service. This represents an increase of 52 incidents, or a 20% increase from the same month last year. There was 1 actual fire, and
265 non-fire related incidents.
Of the 265 non-fire related incidents 183 were calls for Emergency Medical Service and Injury Accidents
which represents an increase of 20% over the same month last year. Combined these two categories
represent 69% of our activity.
The busiest part of the day between 6:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m., experienced 170 alarms or 64% of all activity.
Incident responses:
6:00 A.M. to 6:00 P.M.
Station
Total NonPriority Calls
Total Priority
Calls
Non Priority Response Time
Priority Response
Time
1
42
21
7:43
5:50*
2
59
21
10:34
4:32
3
19
8
11:20
5:51*
SRU & mutual aid
6:00 P.M. to 6:00 A.M.
1
23
9
8:47
6:41*
2
42
9
6:58
6:02*
3
12
1
10:59
10:53*
SRU & mutual aid
Total
197
69
*An explanation of all priority calls over 5 minutes is attached.
cc:
All Staff
All Stations
PSAC
Priority Calls over 5 minutes
January‐11
Date
Location
Alarm Time Incident # Response
time
Nature of call
Explanation
1‐Jan
835 Nichols Drive
16:21
9
6:25
chest pain
1‐Jan
715 Provincetown
16:22
10
5:54
siezure
5‐Jan
800 Chrysler Drive
11:45
41
6:28
chest pain
8‐Jan
2100 Willot Road
1:28
61
7:14
Difficulty Breathing
Unit did not call on scene immediately
8‐Jan
Brown & Giddings
4:57
63
10:53
PI Accident
Distance to scene. PD on scene requested medical.
9‐Jan
2700 Shimmons #154
7:02
73
8:03
Difficulty Breathing
Second call wihin 10 minutes. Engine responded.
10‐Jan
978 Hunt Club
5:26
77
8:00
trouble breathing
Distance from Station 2
10‐Jan
683 Tall Oaks
9:41
79
6:45
Difficulty Breathing
First unit in had difficulty locating specific address
10‐Jan
700 Brown Road
15:34
83
5:25
stroke
Distance with traffic from station 3.
10‐Jan
Lapeer/Harmon
7:55
87
6:29
facial injuries
Distance with traffic.
11‐Jan
Baldwin and I75
9:29
88
5:55
PI accident
Distance
11‐Jan
2646 Patrick Henry
5:51
92
5:51
Difficulty Breathing
Fourth call within 90 minutes. Engine responded from Opdyke/University also snowing.
11‐Jan
1500 University Drive
14:11
93
6:04
passed out
road conditions from snow.
Distance from Station 2
second call within 1 minute. First unit in could not call on scene due to radio traffic from 3 different calls.
Third call within 90 minutes. Patient being cared for CTC medical staff. First unit in from station 1.
11‐Jan
3258 Countryside
16:02
95
6:34
sugar issues
second call within 15 minutes. Engine responded with poor road conditions from snow.
11‐Jan
2700 Shimmons #33
21:15
97
5:54
unconscious
Distance and road conditions from snow.
12‐Jan
3004 Henrydale
0:32
98
11:44
Congestive Heart Failure
Distance and road conditions due to snow
12‐Jan
2650 N. Opdyke
6:59
100
8:45
chest pain
Distance and road conditions from snow.
12‐Jan
2595 Auburn Road
18:07
108
7:57
chest pain
Second call within 20 minutes and distance from station 2
13‐Jan
2800 Waukegan
8:13
110
5:34
Difficulty Breathing
updated information prior to fd arrival
13‐Jan
800 Chrysler Drive
9:39
112
6:59
chest pain
second call wihin 90 minutes. Patient in care of CTC medical staff. Fire units followed CTC security.
13‐Jan
N I75 NO Auburn and E M59
16:15
121
6:57
PI Accident
Fifth call within 75 minutes. Limited access to scene.
14‐Jan
1370 Pacific
7:39
125
8:31
passed out
Distance to scene
15‐Jan
351 N. Squirrel Road #228
23:27
139
8:14
Difficulty Breathing
Distance from station 2 & location.
18‐Jan
885 West Entrance
2:46
152
7:59
possible stroke
Distance from Station 2
18‐Jan
800 Chrysler Drive
11:56
155
7:56
chest pain
Second call within 15 minutes. Engine responded from station 2. Patient being cared for by CTC staff.
19‐Jan
4444 Giddings Road
8:13
165
9:01
rapid heart rate
Distance to scene from station 2 with slick roads
19‐Jan
800 Chrysler Drive
15:50
170
5:07
cardiac arrest
Wrong address given to responding units, corrected while enroute.
19‐Jan
2555 South Blvd.
1:15
190
9:10
Difficulty Breathing
Distance from station 2
18:35
192
12:32
PI Accident
Snow event. Second call within 35 minutes. First unit in did not call on scene. Patients in care of AHPD.
19:43
194
5:55
unresponsive
Distance from station 2 snow event
10:28
198
7:52
chest pain
Distance from stations
15:55
203
7:06
PI Accident
Access to scene
12:03
213
5:18
Difficulty Breathing
Address near the rear of park entrance.
22‐Jan
22‐Jan
24‐Jan
24‐Jan
25‐Jan
N. Squirrel & N. Shimmons
165 S. Opdyke Road #151
3199 Lapeer Road
N. I75 ‐ South Blvd. & South
351 N. Squirrel Rd. #268
26‐Jan
N. I75 & Auburn Road
10:26
221
7:29
PI Accident
Access to scene
26‐Jan
800 Chrysler Drive
15:44
225
5:15
chest pain
Patient in care of CTC medical staff. First unit in came from station 1.
26‐Jan
3851 N. Briarvale
7:49
239
7:47
seizure
Distance from station 2.
29‐Jan
2700 Shimmons Road #45
18:49
243
6:04
Difficulty Breathing
Distance from station
29‐Jan
4144 Blue Heron
21:37
244
6:38
passed out
Distance from station
31‐Jan
800 Chrysler Drive
6:06
254
10:32
chest pain
units followed CTC security to remote site. Pt not in first aid
31‐Jan
800 Chrysler Drive
11:48
258
5:34
cardiac arrest
unit followed CTC security to first aid. Patient in care of on duty CTC medical staff
Calls of interest On January 28, 2011, at 9:03 a.m., we responded to a smoke investigation. Upon arrival of our Police department, they notified dispatch that this was a working structure fire with heavy smoke pouring out of the eaves. Upon Fire Department arrival an offensive attack was initiated. The first crew reported zero to low visibility. Ventilation was initiated and the seat of the fire was discovered between the many levels of sub‐flooring. The fire was extinguished with minimal amount of water. An investigation was completed by AHFD and Oakland County Sheriff Department fire investigation team where they found the fire to be accidental in nature. The only source of ignition that they could not rule out was electrical. This coincides with a call from Det. Martin who stated that he was advised by the resident of an on‐
going electrical problem. This incident is a prime example of teamwork within the city. The original caller hung up, and the dispatchers, who were very persistent, were able to call him back. They then determined this was a smoke investigation in the area of Adams and Auburn. Units were dispatched to the area, PD was first to arrive on scene and gave a specific address and upgraded the scene to a structure fire, and DPS responded to the incident and started spreading salt to help alleviate slip and falls. AUBURN HILLS FIRE DEPARTMENT
MONTHLY ACTIVITY REPORT
January, 2011
Personnel
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Staff
Station 1
Station 2
Station 3
16
15
12
15
16
14
15
12
11 - Structure Fire
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Structure Fire
Arson/Suspicious
Arson Percentage
Arson Dollar Loss
Total Dollar Loss
1
0
0
0
80000
4
0
0
0
5520
12- Outdoor Fire
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Outdoor Fires
Arson/Suspicious
Arson Percentage
Arson Dollar Loss
Total Dollar Loss
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
13 - Vehicle Fire
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Vehicle Fires
Arson/Suspicious
Arson Percentage
Arson Dollar Loss
Total Dollar Loss
0
0
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
6550
All Fires Combined
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
All Fires Combined
Arson/Suspicious
Arson Percentage
Arson Dollar Loss
Total Dollar Loss
1
0
0
0
80000
8
0
0
0
12070
Non Fire
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
30 - Emergeny Medical
35 - Injury Accident
40 - Hazardous Conditions
50 - Service Calls
60 - Good Intent
70 - Alarm Activation
172
11
3
19
33
27
134
13
4
15
21
19
Category
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Total Non-Fire Incidents
Total Fire Incidents
Total of All Incidents
265
1
266
206
8
214
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
Percent Change
from Prior Year
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
Percent Change
from Prior Year
1
0
0
0
80000
4
0
0
0
5520
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
0
0
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
6550
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
1
0
0
0
80000
8
0
0
0
12070
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
172
11
3
19
33
27
134
13
4
15
21
19
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
265
1
266
206
8
214
-75.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
1349.28%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
-100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
-100.00%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
-87.50%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
562.80%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
28.36%
-15.38%
-25.00%
26.67%
57.14%
42.11%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
28.64%
-87.50%
24.30%
EMS Transports
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
106
111
Percent Change
from Prior Year
Transports
106
111
Investigations
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Fires Investigated
1
0
Plan Review
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Site
Suppression
Detection
8
11
3
1
5
1
Inspections
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Annual
Final
Suppression/Detection
Follow-up
Home
Complaints
Smoke Detectors Installed
33
4
9
23
0
3
0
17
5
4
70
0
0
0
Injuries
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Employee Injuries
Employee Fatalities
Civilian Injuries
Civilian Fatalities
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Department Training
Current
Month
Same Month
Last Year
Administration
Fire Officer
Suppression
Hazmat
EMS
Technical Rescue
141.25
0
151.25
4.5
174.5
12
0
0
191.75
7.25
45
9
141.25
0
151.25
4.5
174.5
12
0
0
191.75
7.25
45
9
100.00%
0.00%
-21.12%
-37.93%
287.78%
33.33%
TOTAL TRAINING HOURS
483.5
253
483.5
253
91.11%
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
1
0
Current Year
Current
to Date
Year to Date
8
11
3
1
5
1
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
33
4
9
23
0
3
0
17
5
4
70
0
0
0
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Current Year Last Year to
to Date
Date
-4.50%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
100.00%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
700.00%
120.00%
200.00%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
94.12%
-20.00%
125.00%
-67.14%
0.00%
100.00%
0.00%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
Percent Change
from Prior Year
PUBLIC EDUCATION
Number of
Programs
Type of Program
Children in
Attendance
Adults in
Attendance
Pre-school
Elementary School
Middle School
High School
Tour of station
Community parade
Senior Citizen
Civic Organization
1
Business
30
Fire Prevention Week
Fire Extinguisher
Community Displays
1
C.P.R.
8
1
First Aid
14
Car Seat Checks
Counseling
Programs Year
to Date
Programs Last Year
Attendance
Year to Date
Attendance
Last Year to
Date
3
4
52
49
City of Auburn Hills
Parks & Recreation Dept.
January Update
Monthly Report Vol.8 No.53/2011
_________________________________________________
Field Reservations for 2011
We started taking reservations on Jan 3rd for 2011
fields (ball diamond and athletic field) in Civic
Center Park.
To date, we’ve reserved time on the ball diamond this
spring for: boys baseball practices and games (4
teams); girls softball practices and games (one team);
mixed with our t-ball, pre t-ball and adult softball
leagues this season.
Program
Category
participants
Comp
w/Jan.
10 (+/-)
Year
to
Date
‘11
Comp
w/ YTD
‘10
596
-14
596
-14
1106
-135
1106
-135
925
+49
925
+49
Na
Na
Na
Na
43
-4
43
-4
+47
178
Total:
9,986
+47
End
less!
Jan. 11
# of
Youth
Programs
Adult
Programs
All Ages
On the multi-sport athletic field, we’ve reserved time
this spring and fall for: Holy Family boys
lacrosse, OU Men’s Lacrosse games, Avondale
girls soccer practice and games (their field is
under renovation); MUSL men’s soccer games;
Oakland Christian football; and Makos football,
mixed with our youth soccer leagues, beginner’s
soccer and flag football leagues.
Thank You
Mike – (Mike Mansour, Naturalist) I just wanted to thank you for a great den meeting my
seven cub scout bears had at Hawk Woods several weeks
ago. My usually very rambunctious boys have never been
so well-behaved, because they were so engaged and
interested in your program. You have such a good rapport
with kids. I am sure you were a very respected, effective
teacher, and still are.
Yesterday, I dropped off two bags of sunflower seeds at
the Community Center. Thanks again. I look forward to
returning with my scouts for another great program.
Renée Prisciandaro
Respectfully submitted by:
Brian Marzolf & Staff
Recreation Director
248.370.9353
[email protected]
Park
Reservations
Comm Center
Room/Gym
Reservations
Community
Center Cards
Issued
Parks &
Recreation…
178- New
88-Renew
the
benefits
are