New Car Buyers` Guide

Transcription

New Car Buyers’ Guide
MOTORSHOW 2011
Motorshow 2011 New Car Guide
Motorshow’s new and used car guides for buyers are
compiled by specialists who have years of experience and
extensive research facilities. Uniquely and very importantly
they are in touch with the new and used car market,
searching out where car buyers are being disappointed
and where others are really getting satisfaction.
Taking account of the various car segments, where preferential requirements vary, we rate all cars that are available on the Irish car market.
We acknowledge, simply due to competitive market
forces, that there are no really poor new cars being
offered anymore. However, there are vast differences
in residual values, build quality, specification levels,
prices, performance and economy levels etc. These and
many other factors greatly influence the ratings of one
seemingly similar car over others.
No other guide tells you, which cars are the best and
the worst buys in plain English. We tell it as it really is,
and you can be assured that the advice that you get in
Motorshow 2011, our annual car buyers’ guide is
independent and consumer driven. Motorshow 2011
is written by Eddie Cunningham, Padraic Deane and
John Loughran with additional research by Catherine
Conboy.
Special Readers Notice
Because prices, etc., can change, we suggest that
once you have made a short-list of cars that you
are interested in, you should confirm prices and
specifications with dealers when shopping for your
new car.
In our guide “prices start at” refers to the lowest
price of the passenger version in that model range.
Whilst every care has been taken in compiling this
guide from information received from the distributors
at the time of writing, (January 2011) no responsibility
can be accepted by the publishers or staff of
Automotive Publications Ltd. for any errors or
omissions.
The Jargon
Most motorists don’t understand the jargon used by carmakers
or in car advertising, surveys over a number of years have concluded.
Just five per cent of 4,000 motorists surveyed understood the
abbreviation TNT, which stands for taxed and tested.
Only 10 per cent understood the abbreviation MFSW – multifunction steering wheel, while fewer than one in three (30 per
cent) understood the abbreviation EBD, which stands for
Electronic Brake Distribution.
The most recognisable of the eight abbreviations used, was
ABS (anti-lock braking system), which was correctly identified
by 76 per cent of the respondents.
Survey points to major consumer annoyance with “dealerspeak” and brands it the most frustrating part of buying a used
car.
Far from making the used-car buying process simpler, terms
like FSH, ESR and ICE confuse the average consumer. 95 per
cent of men and 98 percent of women don’t know what the
most common terms mean.
The research also reveals that 27 per cent of those polled
believe second-hand car dealers deliberately use car jargon to
confuse potential customers into a sale; and 39 per cent of
people are put off buying a used car due to dealer-speak.
The top 10 most confusing car terms are:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
68
18AW
FAR
ESR
ICE
EFW
EW
FSH
PAS
BHP
RCL
- 18 inch Alloy Wheels
- Front Arm Rest
- Electric Sun Roof
- In Car Entertainment
- Electric Front Windows
- Electric Windows
- Full Service History
- Power Assisted Steering
- Brake Horse Power
- Remote Central Locking
MOTORSHOW 2011
CITY / MINI Cars
Chevrolet Spark
Citroen C1
Ford Ka
Hyundai i10
Kia Picanto
Nissan Pixo
Opel Agila
Peugeot 107
Suzuki Alto
Toyota iQ
Toyota Aygo
Volkswagen Fox
SUPERMINI Cars
Audi A1
Citroen C3
Citroen DS3
Fiat Panda
Fiat Grande Punto / Evo
Fiat 500
Ford Fiesta
Honda Jazz
Hyundai i20
Mazda2
Mini
Mitsubishi Colt
Nissan Micra
Opel Corsa
Peugeot 207
Renault Clio
Seat Ibiza
Subaru Justy
Suzuki Splash
Suzuki Swift
Toyota Yaris
Volkswagen Polo
COMPACT FAMILY Cars
Alfa Romeo Mito
Alfa Romeo Giulietta
Audi A3
BMW 1 Series
Chevrolet Aveo
Citroen C4
Dodge Caliber
Fiat Bravo
Ford Fusion
Ford Focus
Honda Civic
Honda Insight Hybrid
Hyundai i30
Kia Rio
Kia Venga
Kia cee'd
Mazda2
Mazda3
Mercedes-Benz A-Class
Mercedes-Benz B-Class
Mitsubishi Lancer
Nissan Note
Nissan Tiida
Opel Meriva
Opel Astra
Peugeot 308
Renault Megane
Seat Leon
Skoda Fabia
Subaru Impreza
Suzuki SX4
Toyota Corolla
Toyota Auris
Toyota Urban Cruiser
Volkswagen Golf
Volkswagen Golf Plus
Volkswagen Jetta
Volvo C30
FAMILY / COMPACT
EXECUTIVE Cars
Alfa Romeo 159
Audi A3
Audi A4
Audi A5
BMW 3 Series
Chrysler Sebring
Chevrolet Cruze
Chevrolet Lacetti
Chevrolet Epica
Citroen C5
Ford Mondeo
Honda Accord
Kia Soul
Lexus CT200h
Lexus Is 200
Mazda5
Mazda6
Mercedes-Benz C-Class
Opel Insignia
Peugeot 407
Renault Fluence
Renault Laguna
Saab 9-3
Seat Exeo
Skoda Octavia
Subaru Legacy
Toyota Avensis
Volkswagen Passat
Volvo S40
EXECUTIVE Cars
Audi A6
BMW 5 Series
BMW 5 Series Gran Turismo
BMW 6 Series
Chrysler 300C
Jaguar XF
Mercedes-Benz E-Class
Mercedes-Benz CLS
Saab 9-5
Skoda Superb
Volvo S80
ELECTRIC & HYBRID Cars
Honda Civic ES Hybrid
Honda Insight
Lexus RX Hybrid
Mitsubishi iMiev
NIssan LEAF
Toyota Prius
ESTATE Cars
Alfa Romeo 159 Sportwagon
Audi A4 Avant
Audi Avant
Audi A6 Avant
Audi A6 Allroad
BMW 3-Series Touring
BMW 5-Series Touring
Chevrolet Lacetti Estate
Citroen C5 Tourer
Ford Focus Wagon
Ford Mondeo Wagon
Honda Accord Tourer
Hyundai i30 Estate
Jaguar X-Type Estate
Kia cee'd Sporty Wagon
Mazda6
Mercedes-Benz C-Class
Mercedes-Benz R-Class
Mini Clubman
Opel Astra
Opel Insignia ST
Peugeot 207 SW
Peugeot 308 SW
Renault Grand Clio
Renault Grand Megane
Renault Laguna ST
Saab 9-3
Saab 9-5
Seat Exeo ST
Skoda Fabia
Skoda Octavia
Subaru Legacy
Subaru Outback
Toyota Avensis Tourer
Volvo V50
Volvo V70
MPVs / PEOPLE CARRIERS
Citroen Berlingo Multispace (M)
Citroen C3 Picasso (M)
Citroen C4 Picasso (M)
Citroen Grand C4 Picasso (L)
Dodge Journey (M)
Fiat Qubo (S)
Fiat Doblo (M)
Ford C-Max (M)
Ford S-Max (M)
Ford Galaxy (L)
Hyundai iX20
Honda FR-V (M)
Hyundai Montana (L)
Kia Venga (S)
Mazda5 (L)
Mitsubishi Grandis (L)
Nissan Primastar Combi
Opel Meriva (S)
Peugeot 3008 (M)
Peugeot 5008 (M)
Renault Kangoo (M)
Renault Scenic(M)
Renault Grand Scenic(M)
Seat Altea / Altea XL (M)
Seat Alhambra (L)
Skoda Roomster (M)
Toyota Verso (M)
Volkswagen Golf Plus (M)
Volkswagen Touran (M)
Volkswagen Sharan (L)
(Size: S- Small / M - Medium /
L - Large)
CROSSOVERS
BMW X1 SAV
Kia Soul
69
Mercedes-Benz R-Class
Mitsubishi ASX
Nissan Juke
Nissan Qashqai
Peugeot 3008
Skoda Yeti
Volvo XC60
Opel Astra Twintop
Peugeot 207 CC
Peugeot 308 CC
Renault Laguna Coupe
Volkswagen Beetle
Volkswagen Scirocco
Volkswagen Passat CC
SUVs / 4x4s
Audi Q7
Audi Q5
BMW X1 SAV
BMW X3 SAV
BMW X5 SAV
Daihatsu Terios
Ford Kuga
Honda CR-V
Hyundai Sante-Fe
Jeep Compass
Jeep Patriot
Jeep Wrangler
Kia Sportage
Kia Sorento
Land Rover Freelander 2
Land Rover Discovery
Range Rover Defender
Range Rover Sport
Range Rover
Lexus RX
Mercedes-Benz ML Class
Mercedes-Benz GL Class
Mitsubishi Outlander
Mitsubishi Pajero
Nissan Qashqai & Qashqai +2
NIssan Murano
Nissan X-Trail
Opel Antara
Skoda Yeti
Subaru Forester
Toyota RAV4
Toyota Land Cruiser
Volkswagen Tiguan
Volkswagen Touareg
Volkswagen Caravelle
Volvo XC60
Volvo XC70
Volvo XC90
CONVERTIBLES /
ROADSTERS
Alfa Romeo Spider
Audi A3
Audi TT
BMW 1 Series
BMW 3 Series
BMW 6 Series
BMW Z4
Daihatsu Copen
Fiat 500C
Ford Focus CC
Jaguar XK
Lexus IS 250C
Mazda MX-5
Mercedes-Benz SLK
Mercedes-Benz CLK
Mercedes-Benz SL
MG-TF
Mini
Mitsubishi Colt
Nissan 370Z
Opel Tigra
Opel Astra Twintop
Renault Wind
Saab 9-3
Volkswagen Beetle
Volkswagen Eos
Volvo C70
COUPES
Alfa Romeo GT
Alfa Rome Brera
Audi TT
Audi A5
BMW 1 Series
BMW 3 Series
BMW M3
BMW 6 Series
BMW X6 SAC
Ford Focus CC
Honda C-RZ
Jaguar XK
Lexus IS 250C
Mazda-MX-5
Mercedes-Benz CLC
Mercedes-Benz CLK
Mercedes-Benz CLS
Mercedes-Benz CL
Opel Tigra
LUXURY Cars
Audi A8
BMW 7 Series
Jaguar XJ
Jaguar XFR
Jaguar XK Coupe / Cabrio
Range Rover
Mercedes-Benz S-Class
Mercedes-Benz SL
Mercedes-Benz CL
Also consider - the contenders by segment
PERFORMANCE Cars
Audi S6
Audi TT RS
Audi R8
Audi A4 S
Audi A5 S
BMW M3 (Coupe / Saloon)
BMW M5
Jaguar XFR
Lexus IS-F
Mercedes-Benz C-Class AMG
Mercedes-Benz SLK AMG
Mercedes-Benz S CLS AMG
Mercedes-Benz S AMG
Mercedes-Benz SL AMG
Mercedes-Benz CL AMG
Mitsubishi Evo
Renault Clio RS Sport
Subaru Impreza WRX
MOTORSHOW 2011
Brera
ALFA ROMEO
Overall Marque Rating:
Prices start at: €49,750
Engines: 2.2JTS,
Bodystyles: 2dr. Coupe.
Plus points: Goes well thanks to
fine engine and decent chassis.
Well equipped.
Minus points: Who is going to
buy one in the current climate? Trade-in values likely to be hit
hard too.
Best Buy: 2.2JTS
Final answer: NO. Trade-in values scratch it from our list
+++
Dealerships In the Republic of Ireland: 22
Local dealer listing / Brochure request: 1850 444 888
www.alfaromeo.com
Spider
PLUS: See our Used Car Guide at the back of this publication.
Prices and specifications correct as at 15.01.2011.
Engines: 2.2 JTS, 2.4 JTDM
Bodystyles: Cabrio
Plus points: Lovely cabin in a fine
little roadster. Diesel excellent.
Minus points: Bit too harsh over
rougher roads; seems to take the
roof an age to open and close.
Best Buy: 2.2JTS
Final Answer: NO, its best days are behind it.
MiTo
Engines: 1.4 16v, 1.3 JTDM,
1.4 TB, 1.6 JTDM
Bodystyles: 3dr
Plus points: Crackling
performer with style and dash
all of its own.
Minus points: Tiny and
cramped; a real concern over how quickly it will lose value.
Best Buy: 1.6 JTDM
Final answer : YES, heart says yes but pocket should say no.
AUDI
Guilietta
Engines: 1.4TB, 1.8 TBI, 1.6
JDTM, 2.0JDTM
Bodystyles: 5dr Hatchback
Plus points: Replaces old 147,
which shone bright and briefly.
This is all curves and shortburst performance. Tries hard to
be an alternative hatch. Handling and engines excellent.
Minus points: Bluntly put, it presses right buttons but overarching
concern about reliability and trade-in values.
Best Buy: 1.6 JDTM
Final answer: YES, but for more than those who love an Alfa.
++++
Dealers In the Republic of Ireland: 16
Dealers listing/ Brochure request: 01 8989 700
www.audi.ie
A1
Engines: 1.2 TFSI, 1.4 TFSI,
1.6TDI
Bodystyles: 3dr hatch
Plus points: Price, engineering,
smart petrol engine, excellent
cabin. Prestige brand for low cost.
Minus points: Looks are quite
downbeat, lacks driving pep and zest; cabin really cramped.
Best Buy: 1.6TDI
Final answer: YES, but only because you can boast you own an
Audi.
159
Engines: 1.8 TBI, 2.0JDTM
Bodystyle: Saloon &
Sportwagon
Plus point: Good, stylish roomy
motor positioned to give you a
choice over more conventional
compact executives. Excellent
diesels.
Minus points: Poor handling lets it down badly. Alfa name hits
residual prospects.
Best Buy: 2.0JDTM
Final answer: NO, it has disappointing handling and residuals.
A3
ALWAYS DRIVE RESPONSIBLY
70
Engines: 1.2 TFSi, 1.4 TFSi, 1.8
TFSI, 2.0 TFSI, 1.6 TDi, 2.0 TDi.
Bodystyles: 3dr, 5dr /Sportback/
Cabriolet
Plus points: Solid, strong, compact hatch; always in keen
demand on secondhand market.
Good residuals as a result. Sportback 5dr roomier; 1.4TFSi engine
excellent.
Minus points: Still bit pricey despite reductions. Dull cabin but
that does not militate against its residuals.
Best Buy: 5dr. 1.4TFSi.
Final answer: YES, but new model on the horizon.
MOTORSHOW 2011
A4
Audi A7
Engines: 1.8TFSI, 2.0 TFSI,
3.0 TFSI, 2.0 TDI, 2.7 TDI,
3.0 TDI.
Bodystyles: Saloon, estate
Plus points: Looks much better than old one; noticeable
amount of extra room. First-class engines. One of better compact
executive saloons to hold its value.
Minus points: Still suffers from perception that BMW 3 handles
better and that it yields to ‘snob value’ of Mercedes C-Class.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDI
Final answer: YES, a rock solid buy.
3.0TDI
Bodystyles: Sportback
Plus points: Sweeping lines of
this large coupe-like sporty executive that slots in between A6 and
A8. Great styling, engines. Will make its mark because it has the
class
Minus points: Too early to say.
Best Buy: 3.0 TFSI
Final answer: YES, this has a real bit of drive to it.
Q5
A4 Allroad Quattro
TT Coupe / Roadster
Engines: 2.0 TFSI, 2.0 TDI,
3.0 TDI
Bodystyles: 5dr SUV
Plus points: Underrated compact
SUV with a lot going for it –
handling, quattro grip, cabin,
engines. Think giant Q7 in manageable proportions. And the quattro is a big plus for our icier
winters.
Minus points: Lacks a bit of cachet, expensive to upgrade equipment.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDi.
Final answer: YES, a really solid and smart all rounder.
A5
Engines: 3.0 TDi, 4.2 TDi,
6.0 TDi
Bodystyles: 5dr. SUV
Plus points: Gargantuan SUV
that blends agility with a big
frame and powerhouse
engines. Plenty of room here for passengers and their luggage.
Minus points: Really is excessive in current climate. Too many
options that should be standard, which means the price shoots
up.
Best Buy: 3.0 TDi.
Final answer: YES, but you need a thick skin.
3.0 TDI
Bodystyles: Big, tall estate
that tries to be an SUV
Plus points: Unusual, niche
vehicle, great roadholding.
Minus points: Now out of
date and favour.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDi.
Final answer: NO, too many better options.
Prices start at: €41,330 /
€46,330
2.5 TFSI., 2.0TDI.
Bodystyles: Coupe/ Roadster
Plus points: Most readily
identifiable Audi on the road.
Much better than old one, lovely cabin, great handling, excellent
engines, petrol and diesel.
Minus points: Still costs too much to add optional equipment
that many feel should be standard.
Best Buy: 2.0 TFSi
Final answer: YES, it is an icon in itself.
Q7
Prices start at: € 39,880
Engines: 2.0 TFSI, 3.0 TFSI, 4.2
FSI, 2.0TDI, 2.7 TDI, 3.0 TDI V6.
Bodystyles: Coupe, Cabriolet,
Sportback.
Plus points: Has slowly ingrained
itself especially with its looks.
Brings youthful brio to the marquee; drives well.
Minus points: Unimpressive amount of cabin space.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDI (Multitronic)
Final answer: YES, we reckon it will win more people over.
A8
A6
2.7 TDI, 3.0TDI
Bodystyles: Saloon/ Avant
(estate)
Plus points: Has looked better
since being revamped and
updated. Always had a fine cabin, excellent engines. Real alternative in medium executive sector.
Minus points: New BMW 5-series, Mercedes E-Class and Lexus
GS price cuts really put this where it belongs – in the past. New
one later this year.
Best Buy: 2.0Tdi.
Final answer: YES – but wait for the new model in the spring.
72
Engines: 3.0TDI, 4.2 TDI,
3.0TFSI, 4.2 FSI
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Probably most
technically advanced large luxury motor around. Handling
significantly improved.
Wonderful diesels, lots of room and a decent drive. Huge boot.
Minus points: It’s a close call but we have to give BMW 7-series
the nudge on handling and Mercedes S-Class the nod on prestige – but this closes the gap to millimeters.
Best Buy: 3.0 TDi.
Final answer: Yes, this is a great car.
MOTORSHOW 2011
Engines: 4.2 FSi, 5.2 FSi
Bodystyles: Coupe
Plus points: Super-car with
racing handling, superb performance, ride and looks – in
other words a Celtic Tiger
dream machine.
Minus points: As we say, a
Celtic Tiger dream machine.
Best Buy: R-Tronic (but it
costs 10k more)
Final answer: YES, if you can live with the ‘guilty looks’.
BMW
++++
Local dealer listing / Brochure request: 1890 719 421
www.bmw.ie
1 Series
Engines: 1.6i, 2.0i, 3.0i, 2.0d.
+ 3.0 Twin Turbo (Coupe only)
Bodystyles: 3dr./ 5dr
Hatchback, Coupe, Cabriolet.
Plus points: Transformed
from weakling into sparkling little car. Latest manifestations
(new coupe and cabrio got here in January) underline improvement. Diesels by far the best; great handling. Price reductions.
Minus points: Still that bit cramped at the rear. Price.
Best Buy: 2.0d
Final answer: YES, but wait for Coupe/Cabrio update in March.
3 Series
Engines: 1.6. 2.0i (318 & 320),
2.5i, 3.0i, 2.0d, 2.5d, 3.0d.
Bodystyle: Saloon & Touring.
Plus points: Still compact
executive they all like to beat if they can. Better priced, better
equipped, entry level model
excellent value. Diesels.
Minus points: Doesn’t stand out as much now thanks to huge
competition from Audi A4 and Mercedes C-Class.
Best buy: Base 1.6 model, for ease of re-sale and high residuals.
Final answer: YES. You can’t ignore this.
3 Series Coupe/
Convertible
€51,350
Engines: New Coupe: 2.0,
2.5, 3.0 (330 & 350) 4.0 (M3),
3.0d. 2.5d, 3.0d (330d & 350d).
Bodystyles: Coupe/ Cabriolet
Plus points: Understated styling means you can have a new one
and no-one will complain about you being extravagant.
Minus points: Why spend all that money without getting a bit of
recognition?
Best Buy: 325d Coupe
Final answer: YES, still a benchmark coupe for many.
5 Series
Engines: 3.0 (204hp, 258hp,
306 hp), 4.5 (407hp), 3.0
Diesel (204hp, 245hp)
Bodystyles: Saloon/Touring
Plus points: More compact
looking, beats old one hands
down – and pricing is much keener. Again the
chassis sets it apart and 520d diesel is exceptional.
No need for bigger engine. Lots of 7-series handme-down technology. Beautiful styling.
Minus points: The cabin feels a bit smaller.
Best Buy: 520d
Final answer: YES, has to be seriously considered.
Continental
Irish Executive /
Luxury Car
of the Year
Gran Turismo
Engines: 3.0, 4.4, 3.0 diesel
Bodystyles: 5 door saloon
Plus points: Hugely accommodating, superb engines and
lots of luxury touches.
Minus points: It just does not
work at all. It’s too much to take in.
Best Buy: 3.0 diesel
Final answer: NO. You don’t need this.
6 Series Convertible
Engines: 3.0i, 4.8 (550), 5.0
(M6), 3.0d.
Bodystyles: Convertible
Plus points: Great big car with
all the power and push you’d
want. Great diesel.
Minus points: It’s kinda lost in
the middle of nowhere; convertible way behind Coupe; too costly.
Best Buy: 3.0i Convertible
Final answer: NO, pricey and new model coming.
In our guide, ‘Prices start at:’ refers to the lowest price of the
passenger versions in that model range.
R8
MOTORSHOW 2011
7 Series
Engines: 3.0, 4.0, 4.8, 6.0,
3.0d
Bodystyles: Saloon (incl.
LWB versions).
Plus points: Handles like a
smaller car and leaves rivals
in shade. Got its act together on looks and banishing old stupid
iDrive input system. Diesel is best.
Minus points: Boy, does a 7-series lose value quickly? Let’s wait
and see how this fares but don’t hold your breath.
Best Buy: 730D.
Final answer: YES. Remarkable for handling ability.
Z4 Roadster
Engines: 2.0, 2.5, 3.0, 3.2 (M)
Bodystyles: Coupe/ Roadster.
Plus points: Has power to
back its looks and the handling’s great.
M versions really turn it on.
Minus points: Cabin dull and cramped despite improvements.
Price. Victim of recession buying.
Best Buy: 2.5SE.
Final answer: YES. It’s a big improvement.
CHEVROLET
X1 SAV
Engines: 2.0d
Bodystyles: Sports Activity
Vehicle
Plus points: Now here is
something quite unusual, a
baby Beemer sports activity
vehicle. Don’t be put off by the
‘baby’ bit. There’s a decent bit of room in this and it drives well.
Minus points: Price for a small BMW.
Best Buy: 2.0d
Final answer: YES, it is quite accomplished.
www.chevrolet.ie
X3
Engines: 2.5, 3.0, 2.0d, 3.0d
Bodystyles: Compact SUV.
Plus points: Made big effort to
get this new arrival right with a
much roomier and better
equipped cabin for around
€4,000 less. First-class handling, ride and grip thanks to xDrive.
Minus points: Still battling image problem of ‘expensive small X5’.
Best Buy: 2.0d SE
Final answer: YES, new arrival will change perceptions.
Spark
Engines: 1.2 petrol
Bodystyles: 5 door hatchback
Plus points: It’s new and fresh
Minus points: Too soon to say
Best Buy: 1.2
Final answer: Yes, it’s worth a
test drive
Aveo
Engines: 1.2, 1.4.
Bodystyles: 3dr /5dr and
saloon / hatchback
Plus points: Nice tidy little
number with a decent cabin.
Hatchbacks look better.
Decent price.
Minus points: Lacks a diesel and recognition factor. Poor resale
value likely.
Best Buy: 1.4.
Final answer: Yes, but only just.
X5 SAV
Engines: 3.0, 4.8, 3.0d
Bodystyles: 4x4 SAV
Plus points: Almost passé to
remark on just how well this
runs and drives. Seven seats,
3-litre diesel, grip, handling and
a better smattering of equipment.
Minus points: Might have over-stretched with its 7-seat dimensions and it doesn’t drive as tautly as old 5-seater. Price still stiff.
Best Buy: 3.0D
Final answer: YES, have a drive in this.
Lacetti
Engines: 1.6
Bodystyles: 4 Dr. Saloon,
Plus points: Unobtrusive,
roomy and well priced.
Minus points: Glaring lack of
diesel and there are concerns
over residual values.
Best Buy: 1.6 SX
Final answer: NO, can’t discount lack of diesel.
X6
Engines: 3.0d, 3.5, 5.0i
Bodystyles: 5dr SUV/Large
Coupe
Plus points: A crossover
based on X5 that scores better
with its engines and handling
than it does with design.
Minus points: This is really horrible looking now. Why would you
buy it?
Best Buy: X6x Drive 35i SE
Final answer: NO, lacks a lot of what you’d look for in a car
costing so much.
+++
74
MOTORSHOW 2011
Cruze
Sebring
Engines: 2.0 diesel
Bodystyles: 4 Door saloon/
5 Door hatchback
Plus points: Looks stylish
and drives well
Minus points: No track
record
Best Buy: 2 Litre diesel
Final Answer: Yes, worth a test drive, but check out the
competition
Engines: 2.0, 2.0CRD
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: The 2-litre diesel
gives it a chance in a crowded
market. Room and equipment
do too.
Minus points: Lacks refinement and appeal; up against likes of
VW Jetta and Mitsubishi Lancer.
Best Buy: 2.0 Diesel
Final answer: NO, really out of the game in tough market.
Epica
CITROËN
Engines: 2.0, 2.0D
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Big car for
money and the diesel isn’t
bad.
Minus points: Trade-in values a concern. Mondeo,
Avensis, new Passat all better bets surely?
Best Buy: 2.0LS
Final answer: NO, just not in the running.
Brochure request: 01 8851780
www.citroen.ie
CHRYSLER
+++
++
C1
Engine: 1.0i
Bodystyle: 3-dr., 5-dr.
Hatchback.
Plus points: Unusual looking
little city car that has appeal in
green era of austerity.
Minus points: Tiny, not great to drive, really. Bit of boom and tyre
noise in cabin; miniscule boot. Poor residuals.
Best Buy: 5dr Hatchback
Final answer: YES, but just about..
Dealers listing/Brochure request: 01 4698 700
www.chrysler.ie
300C
C3
Engines: 3.0 V6 CRD
Bodystyle: Saloon
Plus points: Big impact player
this. Popular for its room,
engines and value for money.
Minus points: Waddles a bit
when pushed into corners and
a bit too big for some tastes.
Best buy: 3.0 V6 CRD
Final answer: YES, value and diesel keep it in the frame.
Engines: 1.1, 1.4, 1.6, 1.4HDi
Bodystyles: 5dr. Hatch.
Plus points: Bit of flair, nice
diesels, several clever touches
aid its 2010 new-car introduction. User-friendly hatch.
Minus points: New distributor
has made huge effort but residual values are a big concern.
Best Buy: 1.4HDi
Final answer: YES. But only just.
76
MOTORSHOW 2011
Engines: 1.4 Vti, 1.6 HDI
Bodystyles: 2 Door,
Plus points: Rival to the
MINI or any other small performance hatch. Based on
C3, it combines looks, brio
and an excellent chassis. They’ve found a bit of magic here.
Minus points: Only thing against it is fear over residual values.
Best Buy: 1.6 HDI
Final answer: YES, this is a cracking little performer worthy of a
test drive.
Berlingo Multispace
Engines: 1.6HDi
Bodystyles: MPV 5-Seater.
Plus points: Impressive practical motor for times like these.
Really frugal diesel and there
is a nice spread of room. Less
of a ‘van’ feel to it now.
Minus points: But van feel not totally banished so it suffers
because of that and residual values.
Best Buy: 1.6HDi
Final answer: YES, a practical, frugal buy.
C5
Engines: 1.6 HDi 2.0 HDi
Bodystyle: 5dr. Hatchback
and Estate.
Plus points: Has gained some
credence from being an award
winner, having excellent handling,
first-class diesels and good equipment levels. 2010 revamp helped
Minus points: Doesn’t have heritage, poise or economic comeon appeal of Mondeo or Passat. Less said about its award winning the better.
Best Buy: 1.6HDi
Final answer: NO, nice car but poor residuals mean there are
better options.
DAIHATSU
www.daihatsu.ie
C3 Picasso
Engines: 1.6HDI
Bodystyles: MPV 5/7 seater.
Plus points: We like the
choice of five/seven seats and
the way room is worked
around cabin. Again the 1.6litre diesel impresses on consumption and performance.
Minus points: Dash overly plasticky, little room in back when
third-row of seats occupied.
Best Buy: 1.6HDi
Final answer: YES, put it on your shopping list.
New C4
Engines: 1.4 Vti,1.6HDi.
Bodystyle: 5 dr. Hatchback.
Plus points: New, fresh and
looking better. If you like a bit
of Gallic flair and something
different to drive, this might
suit. Lovely cabin and good
diesels.
Minus points: Still under cloud of historic discounted pricing and
low sales as well as trade-in value concerns.
Best buy: 1.6 HDi
Final answer: YES, just about nudges in.
C4 Picasso/
Grand C4 Picasso
Prices start at:
€26,190/€28,490
Engines: 1.6 HDi
Bodystyle: Compact MPV
Plus points: Popular mid-size
people carrier with first-rate
diesel. Nice roominess about it and the equipment levels are
high. Fairly recent revamp.
Minus points: Despite its good points there are concerns about
residual values.
Best buy: 1.6 HDi
Final answer: Yes, but only by the width of a number plate.
++
Sirion
Engines: 1.0, 1.3.
Bodystyle: Five-door hatch.
Plus points: Practical, bargainbasement pricing means it will
come on radar for those looking
for inexpensive transport.
Minus points: Really a strange looking piece of work with little
appeal to most.
Best buy: 1.0 GX
Final answer: No. Poor residuals override reasonable price.
Terios
DS3
Engines: 1.5
Bodystyles: 5dr small SUV
Plus points: Real option if
you’re looking for compact
SUV with good room and handling to bolster it. First cousin
of Toyota RAV4.
Minus points: Different proposition altogether as a diesel.
Best buy: 1.5 4WD Manual
Final answer: YES, even with petrol it’s a shopping list entrant.
Copen
Engines: 1.3.
Bodystyle: 2 Dr. Cabrio
Plus points: Fun little motor
that puts glitzier rivals in
shade.
Minus points: Has never
been given any marketing and doesn’t register on anyone’s shopping list.
Best buy: 1.3 GX
Final answer: YES, keen price keeps it in but time is limited.
77
MOTORSHOW 2011
DODGE
500/500C
Prices start at: €12,695/
€16,195
Engines: 1.2, 1.4
Bodystyles: 3dr
Hatchback/Coupe
Plus points: Fun all round–
and that’s welcome this year.
Bit of a fashion icon already.
Minus points: Nothing lasts forever and today’s fashion ‘must
have’ can be quickly forgotten.
Best Buy: 1.2
Final answer: YES, keep a smile on your face.
+
www.dodge.ie
Grande Punto
Engines: 1.2
Bodystyles: 3dr. & 5dr.
Hatchback
Plus points: Easily Fiat’s best
car and the one punters trust
most. Fine cabin and good
engines.
Minus points: Suffers a bit from rubbery gearshift and getting a
bit dated.
Best buy: 1.2
Final answer: YES, by all means but make sure it’s the new
model.
Caliber
Engines: 2.0 CRD.
Bodystyle: 5-door Hatch.
Plus points: Big blunt instrument with strange appeal.
Well-priced, once-off that has
a decent diesel engine.
Minus points: Can’t see too
many opting for this. Residual value concerns.
Best buy: 2.0 SE CRD, 6 speed.
Final answer: NO, has outlived its appeal.
Punto Evo
Journey
Engines: 1.2, 1.3, 1.4
Bodystyles: 3dr. & 5dr.
Plus points: All new look,
inside and out
Minus points: Questions over
residuals
Best buy: 1.4
Final answer: YES, it’s test drive material
Engines: 2.0 SXT CRD
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Nice people carrier that brings a bit of style
with it.
Minus points: Seat configuration means it’s not quite as versatile as other MPVs.
Best buy: 2.0SXT CRd
Final answer: NO, because brand is on the way out.
FIAT
Qubo
Engines: 1.3, 1.4
Bodystyles: 5dr small SUV
Plus points: Practical for passengers, unusual for onlookers, well priced.
Minus points: Based on
Fiorino van and betimes that
becomes obvious.
Best Buy: 1.3
Final answer: YES, multi-task motoring for a decent price.
+++
www.fiat.ie
Readers Notice
Whilst every care has been taken in compiling this guide from
information received from distributors, no responsibility can be
accepted by the publishers or staff of Automotive Publications
Limited for any errors or omissions. Because prices etc. can
change, we suggest that once you have made a short-list of
cars that you are interested in, you should confirm prices and
exact specifications with the dealer when shopping for your
new car.
Panda
Engines: 1.1, 1.2,
Bodystyles: 3dr. / 5dr.
Hatchbacks
Plus points: City car that has
the advantage of price and a
new Multijet engine.
Minus points: Cabin suffers
from tyre/road noise. Fiat residuals always a problem.
Best buy: 1.2
Final answer: YES, worth a slot on your shopping list.
78
MOTORSHOW 2011
Engines: 1.4 (16V) Petrol,
1.6(16V) Multijet Diesel
Bodystyles: 5 dr hatchback.
Plus points: Decent smallfamily motor. Good price,
room and diesels and price;
not a bad driver.
Minus points: Hasn’t done well at all and residuals will suffer badly.
Final answer: NO, far too many better options.
New Doblo
Engines: 1.6 Multijet
Bodystyles: MPV, 5 Seats.
Plus points: Less van-like
than it used to be thanks to
major overhaul. Drives okay.
Minus points: Plain styling
inside, par for the course in this segment.
Best buy: 1.6 Multijet
Final answer: YES, new model is a big step up.
FORD
+++++
www.ford.ie
Ka
Engines: 1.2, 1.3 TDCi
Bodystyles: 3dr. hatchback
Plus points: Never seems to
go out of fashion. Latest
model is easily best so far.
Fine little 1.3-litre diesel.
Minus points: Not many
apart from a soft-ish gearchange.
Best buy: 1.2
Final answer: YES, fun and frugality in a city car.
Fiesta
Engines: 1.25, 1.4, 1.4TDCi.
Bodystyles: 3dr./ 5dr.
Hatchback
Plus points: The more we
drive it the better this
becomes. Handles well, looks
smart and has a decent range
of engines. Has been snubbed by those deciding on awards.
Minus points: Bit short of room in the cabin.
Best buy: 5dr 1.4-litre diesel
Final answer: YES, one of the top three around.
Fusion
Engines: 1.4 M5
Bodystyles: 5dr.
Plus points: Little bit more
room than previous Fiesta (on
which it is based).
Minus points: Forget it, this
makes no sense any more.
Best buy: 1.4. Entry level model
Final answer: NO, bye bye.
Focus
Engines: 1.6 TDCI
Bodystyles: 3dr. and 5dr.
Hatchback / Saloon/ Wagon
(estate)
Plus points: Unrivalled for
driving with some seriously
good diesels. New global car arrives this spring. It is significantly
better so you have a choice. Wait or get a great deal on the outgoing model – can’t lose.
Minus points: New model will outstrip old one big time.
Best buy: 1.6 5-dr.
Final answer: YES, buy new or buy ‘old’. The Focus is that sort
of car.
Focus Coupe
Cabriolet
Bravo
Engines: 1.6, 2.0 and 2.0 TD
Bodystyle: Coupe Cabriolet
Plus points: Great chassis
makes it fun, rather than
compelling, to drive.
Minus points: Looks shocking and there’s a paucity of performance.
Best buy: 1.6
Final answer: NO, this is not worth the bother.
C-Max
Engines: 1.6 TDCi, 2.0 TDCi.
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: New versions of
this – 5-seater and bigger
Grand version – have changed
perceptions. Exceptional
pieces of work with excellent
diesels. Drives well and there’s plenty of equipment.
Minus points: Not too many at this point. Pity ordinary model
doesn’t have sliding rear door.
Best buy: 1.6 TDCi
Final answer: YES, not many better MPVs on the road.
Mondeo
Engines: 2.0TDCi
Bodystyles: Saloon/ 5 door
Hatchback/Wagon (estate)
Plus points: Recently
revamped, level of refinement
has gone up appreciably.
Better engines, good cabin,
fine boot. Still holds the accolade of best handling car in its class.
Minus points: It’s revised while closest rival, the VW Passat, is new.
Even with revamp, dare we ask: is it starting to look a tad dated?
Best buy: 2.0 TDCi
Final answer: YES, easily a top-three shopping list candidate.
79
MOTORSHOW 2011
S-Max
HONDA
Engines: 2.0 TDCI
Bodystyle: MPV (7 seats)
Plus points: Sleek and
deceptively roomy MPV that
slots in between Grand C-Max
and Galaxy. Well regarded by
families. Easy to drive, good diesels and residuals hold up well.
Recent revision has helped a lot.
Minus points: The larger Galaxy poses a buying option
headache – for a few euro more.
Best buy: 2.0 TDCi
Final answer: YES, it takes the middle ground like a good
politician.
++++
www.honda.ie www.greenhonda.ie
Galaxy
Jazz
Engines: 2.0 TDCI
Bodystyles: MPV, (7 seats)
Plus points: Daddy of large
MPVs; has loads of room; still
a great drive for a large vehicle. Diesel engines do really
well. Revised and revamped in the last year, it is a huge
favourite.
Minus points: As a fully-occupied seven-seater it leaves little
room for luggage.
Best buy: 2.0 TDCI
Final answer: YES, has to be tested as benchmark motor.
Engines: 1.2, 1.4.
Bodystyles: 5dr. hatchback
Plus points: Solid, roomy and
well-thought of as a secondhand, therefore good residuals.
Fine cabin, good engines.
Minus points: Badly needs a
diesel for wider appeal.
Best buy: 1.2
Final answer: YES, but wait for new version.
Insight
Kuga
Engines: 1.4 i-VTEC SE
Plus points: Hybrid technology, price, economy.
Minus points: We’re not
impressed. Lacks room and
poise of Prius; poor rear visibility.
Best buy: 1.4i-VTEC SE
Final answer: NO. This disappointed us.
Engines: 2.0 TDCi
Bodystyles: 5dr SUV
Plus points: Best looking
‘crossover’ SUV on the road?
Possibly, though Nissan would
have something to say about
their Qashqai. Much better
priced now. Well balanced package with decent cabin, sharp and
precise handling and good 2-litre diesel.
Minus points: We’d have liked a little more room in the cabin.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDCi
Final answer: YES, surprisingly good piece of work.
Civic
Engines: 1.4 i-VTEC,1.8
i-VTEC
Bodystyles: 3 dr. and 5-dr.
Hatchback, Saloon (incl. Hybrid
version)
Plus points: Nice cabin, plenty
of equipment, excellent
engines; diesel transforms it. Choice between snazzy 5dr and
more conservative saloon. Fine hybrid version.
Minus points: Smaller diesel would be nice.
Best buy: 1.4 5dr DSi.
Final answer: YES, good choice for family or couple.
Readers Notice
new car.
CR-Z
Engines: 1.5i-VTEC
Bodystyles: Coupe
Plus points: A unique car - a
genuine pleasure to drive
Minus points: Too soon to say
Best Buy: 1.5i-VTEC
Final answer: Yes, really
worth a test drive
ALWAYS DRIVE
RESPONSIBLY
80
MOTORSHOW 2011
Engines: 2.2iDTEC
Bodystyles: Saloon, Estate.
Plus points: Big, roomy,
powerful and driven by a great
diesel. An alternative to
German prestige for good
price.
Minus points: Hard to distinguish it from previous model .
Looking a bit dated.
Best buy: 2.2 diesel
Final answer: YES, good pedigree and decent package.
CR-V
Engines: 2.0 i-VTEC,
2.2i-DTEC
Bodystyles: SUV 4WD 5dr
Plus points: Popular 'softroader' looking better with
age. Nice, clean driver, well
made, no fuss. Blessed with
diesel and straightforward cabin.
Minus points: Not as much demand for these any more.
Best buy: 2.2i-DTEC
Final answer: YES. It’s a cert for your shortlist.
HYUNDAI
++++
Dealers listing/Brochure request: 01 2405621
www.www.hyundai.ie Email: [email protected]
i10
Engines: 1.1
Bodystyle: 5-door hatchback
Plus points: Ideal city car for
extended scrappage deal.
Smart and well priced with
decent equipment
Minus points: Engine really
struggles when pressure comes on.
Best buy: 1.1
Final answer: YES. And it has a three-year warranty.
i20
Engines: 1.2
Bodystyles: 3 dr. and 5 dr.
Hatchback.
Plus points: Gives Hyundai a
decent supermini to compete
for scrappage deals.
Equipment levels and good
pricing.
Minus points: Lacks recognition factor; people confused by all
the numbers on Hyundais these days.
Best buy: 1.2 5-door.
Final answer: YES, some good deals out there.
ix20
Engines: 1.4 petrol, 1.4 diesel
Bodystyles: Small MPV
Plus points: Sporty, dynamic
Minus points: Questions over
residuals
Final answer: Yes, worthy of
consideration
i30
Engines: 1.6 diesel,
Bodystyles: 5 dr. Hatchback
(Estate on the way)
Plus points: One of more
competitive family hatch packages on market – what better
time to have one? Lots of
equipment, 3-yr warranty. Shares platform with Kia cee'd.
Minus points: Unfavourably compared with cee'd price and Kia’s
seven-year warranty.
Best Buy: 1.6 Diesel Classic
Final answer: YES, a top-class small-family car.
ix35
Engines: 1.7 diesel, 2.0 diesel
Plus points: Stylish crossover
gets in on the scrappage
roundabout with its 1.7-litre
diesel. Looks the part, drives
well; plenty of equipment.
Minus points: Confusion over all those letters.
Best buy: 1.7d 2WD
Final answer: YES, this has a lot going for it.
81
Accord
MOTORSHOW 2011
Santa Fe
XJ
Engines: 2.0 CRDi, 2.2 CRDi
Bodystyles: 5dr. 4x4, SUV.
Plus points: So much bigger
now. Lots of equipment; fine
engine. Option of 2WD and
4WD. Has a real presence on
the road.
Minus points: Extra size doesn’t do its handling any favours.
SUVs in general not in demand.
Best buy: 2.2 (2WD)
Final answer: YES, still a shortlister.
Engines: 3.0 Diesel, 5.0V8
Bodystyles: Large saloon
Plus points: Jaguar’s brave
new attempt for what used to
be an ultra-conservative motor.
Great looks, lovely cabin,
brilliant diesel and loads of equipment.
Minus points: Recession blues against it.
Best buy: 3.0 Diesel
Final answer: Yes, has to be on large-luxury list.
XK Coupe /Cabrio
Montana
€136,415
Engines: 5.0 V8.
Bodystyles: 2dr. Coupe /
Convertible
Plus points: Scorching performance, especially from R
version. Harks back to great
old days of excess.
Minus points: Cabrio by no means as good as the Coupe. Petrol
engines would rob you and there’s a concern over residuals.
Best buy: 5.0 V8
Final answer: YES, a special buy if you have the cash.
Engines: 2.5 Diesel
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Big people
carrier; good diesel. Plenty
of room
Minus points: Virtually
unknown and looks like a large van.
Final answer: No. Far better elsewhere.
JAGUAR
JEEP
+++
www.jaguar.ie
www.jeep.ie
XF
Engines: 3.0V6, 3.0D, 5.0 V8,
Bodystyles: 4 door Saloon
Plus points: Getting better by
the year. Best-looking mid-size
prestige motor on the road.
Wonderful cabin and plenty of
energy in the drive.
Minus points: Price is key here. Maybe a bit too revolutionary for
some buyers in conservative segment.
Best buy: 3.0D.
Final answer: YES, Shows what can be done at this level.
Compass
Engines: 2.0 CRD
Plus points: Diesel underpins
good levels of equipment and
car-like drive.
Minus points: Awful dashboard that looks far too blocky.
Far too close on price and size on Patriot (see next).
Best Buy: 2.0 CRD
Final answer: YES,but wait for new version in June.
XFR
Engines: 5.0V8
Bodystyles: 4 door saloon
Plus points: Stomping version
of XF is outrageously powerful
and has a thirsty 5-litre V8
petrol. Stunning performance
from supercharged engine.
Minus points: Buy a 5-litre gas guzzler? – didn’t know you won
two Lottos.
Best buy: 5.0V8
Final answer: NO, only for the rarefied wealthy.
++
Patriot
82
Engines: 2.0 CRD Manual
Bodystyles: 5dr SUV
Plus points: Well priced after
series of cuts. Six-speed gearbox and diesel engine give it an
edge.
Minus points: Poor looking
cabin and little life in the drive.
Best Buy: 2.0 CRD Manual
Final answer: No, there better options available.
MOTORSHOW 2011
Engines: 2.8 CRD
Bodystyles: 4dr.
Plus points: Fun and a bit of
history in versatile and capable package. Diesel good.
Minus points: Has made little
impact really.
Best Buy: 2.8 CRD, 4 Dr. Manual.
Final answer: YES, but it is something of an acquired taste.
KIA
++++
www.kiamotors.ie
Picanto
Engines: 1.0
Plus points: Ideal little car for
a scrappage deal. Easy to
drive and park. Equipment,
warranty.
Minus points: Not too many. Fairly basic.
Best buy: 1 litre
Final answer: YES, but wait for new model in June.
Rio
Engines: 1.4, 1.5 Diesel.
Bodystyles: Hatchback and
Saloon.
Plus points: 1.5-litre diesel
keeps it relevant and so does
the 7-year warranty.
Minus points: Really, really
dated now.
Best buy: 1.4TX Hatchback.
Final answer: NO, because new model in August.
Venga
cee'd
Engines: 1.6 diesel
Bodystyles: 3dr., 5dr.
Hatchback, Sporty Wagon.
Plus points: Fine practical
family car that mixes price,
drive appeal (estate especially), nice cabin, warranty, equipment.
Minus points: Few. Estate better than hatch.
Best Buy: 1.6 diesel in all cases
Final answer: YES, estate will show you how good a small car
can be.
Soul
Engines: 1.6 Diesel
Bodystyles: Hatch / Estate
Plus points: Bit of cheer
amidst the gloom. Innovative
but highly practical and fine
diesel keeps fuel bills low.
Seven-year warranty.
Minus points: Maybe too different for many.
Final answer: Yes, great value for money and it’s fun.
New Sportage
Engines: 1.7D, 2.0D
Bodystyle: SUV 4x4 (5dr.)
Plus points: Brand new and in
huge demand. Fine on main
roads. Seven-year warranty,
smashing engine, good cabin.
Price.
Minus points: Disappointing over poorer surfaces. Visibility only
moderate due to rear design and front pillars.
Best buy: 2.0D
Final answer: YES, brand new and fresh appeal.
2010 Sorento
Engines: 2.2 CRDi
Bodystyles: SUV 4x4 5dr.
Plus points: New one has built
a good reputatioin and twowheel drive option is a boon.
Diesel works well; plenty of
equipment. Price is key.
Minus points: Same old SUV story – not too many looking for
them.
Best buy: EX 2.2CRDi
Final answer: YES, a classy SUV that won’t disappoint.
Engines: 1.4LX Diesel
Bodystyles: MPV hatch
Plus points: Well equipped,
compact, spacious, extremely
frugal 1.4-litre diesel, double
level boot. Seven-year
warranty.
Minus points: Bit of disappointment overall; engine struggles
when all passengers aboard; small cabin.
Best buy: 1.4 LX Diesel
Final answer: Yes, worth a test drive.
Readers Notice
new car.
83
Wrangler
MOTORSHOW 2011
Range Rover
LAND ROVER
Engines: 4.4 TDV8, 5.0V8
Bodystyles: 4x4, SUV.
Plus points: Go-anywhere
luxury SUV still dominates the
landscape. Air suspension,
luxury cabin, first-rate diesel.
Oh! and its price has come down.
Minus points: Gulp! Huge amount of money these days. Higher
profile rivals.
Best buy: 4.4 TDV8
Final answer: YES, still has to be on your list.
++++
Dealers listing/Brochure request: 01 4893790
www.landrover.ie
Defender
Engines: Range of Turbo
Diesels
Bodystyles: 4x4, 3dr. and
5dr. SW, Double Cabs.
Plus points: A vehicle for the
hard times. Keeps coming
back for more. Sticks to
basics and does them well. Politicians please copy.
Minus points: Low on creature comforts and really harsh on the
road.
Best buy:110 Td5 County Station Wagon
Final answer: YES, for those who really need a tireless workhorse.
Freelander 2
Engines: 2.2D.
Bodystyles: 4x4 SUV (5 dr.)
Plus points: With new
stop/start technology for economy on road, it is excellent off
road. Diesel gives it everything.
Minus points: Still concerns over residual values and reliability.
Best buy: 2.2 TD4
Final answer: YES, good demonstration of 4x4 ability in comfort
zone.
LEXUS
Discovery
Prices start at: 60,900
Engines: 3.0 TD V6
Bodystyles: 4x4 SUV 5dr,
5/7seats
Plus points: Big, strong,
roomy, highly capable SUV.
Equipment and loads of offroad ability. Exceptional diesel
engine. Recent revisions make a big difference.
Cabin improved.
Minus points: Still under cloud of unreliability from earlier manifestation. Who needs a big SUV these days?
Best buy: 3.0 TD V6
Final answer: YES, it is still well worth a test drive.
+++
www.lexus.ie
CT 200h
Range Rover Sport
Engines: 1.8 WT-i
Bodystyles: 5 door
Plus points: World’s first
compact with a full hybrid.
Gets luxury hybrid in under
the €30,000 mark. Lots of
equipment. Real-deal hybrid
frugality and performance.
Minus points: Has yet to be tested on Irish roads, so we’ll wait
and see
Best Buy: 5 Door
Final answer: YES, a Lexus hybrid, especially a compact one,
is worth a test drive.
Engines: 3.0TDV6
Bodystyles: 4x4, SUV.
Plus points: High performance; plenty of cabin space,
well equipped. Diesel
makes a big difference. Price.
Minus points: Bit of an
excessive luxury in this day
and age – little demand.
Best buy: 3.0TD
Final answer: YES, just about – and mainly for its performance.
84
MOTORSHOW 2011
Engines: 2.5 V6, 2.2d
Bodystyles: Saloon,
Executive, Sport
Plus points: Benefits from
recent overhaul and tweakings. Much better driving car
than is perceived. Well
equipped. Lower prices make
it competitive against BMW 3-Series and Mercedes C-Class.
Minus points: Still hogged by sixth-gear ratio in the diesel model
that lets it down badly. Petrol thirsty.
Best buy: IS220d
Final answer: YES. Better car now despite diesel sixth-gear lag.
RX
Engines: 3.5. 3.3 Hybrid
Bodystyles: SUV 5dr.
Plus points: Hybrid is by far
best option. Lot of equipment
and comfort.
Minus points: Looking bit
dated now; lacks a diesel and
off-road ability of some rivals. Much better priced.
Best buy: RX 2WD 350 entry level.
Final answer: YES, its 2WD hybrid gets it in under the radar.
MAZDA
++++
www.mazda.ie
Mazda2
Engines: 1.3
Bodystyles: 3 door, 5 Door
Plus points: Fine little supermini gives little trouble and zips
around. Has benefitted from
upgrades.
Minus points: Cabin noticeably
smaller than many rivals; small
boot.
Best buy: 1.3
Final answer: YES, Practical option for the times that are in it.
Mazda3
Engines: 1.6 diesel, 2.0 petrol
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5 Door
Plus points: Lots of emphasis
on style, innovation with new 3.
Good diesels (new 1.6-litre).
Minus points: Disappoints in
drive and cabin lacks space of main rivals.
Best buy:1.6 diesel
Final answer: YES, still a good piece of engineering and style.
Mazda5
Engines: 1.6 diesel
Bodystyles: MPV (7 Seats)
Plus points: Brand new with a
lot more going for it than the old
one – which admittedly isn’t
saying that much. Well
equipped. Good diesel.
Minus points: As always seven seats squeeze things a bit.
Rivals really smart now and 5 didn’t have a big presence so
there’s work to do.
Best buy: 1.6
Final answer: YES, it’s a new generation.
Mazda6
Engines: 2.0 petrol, 2.2D
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5dr.
Hatchback, Estate.
Plus points: Big, stylish car
with new 2.2-litre diesel engine
that adds a lot. Well equipped,
nicely styled, huge boot. More
spec for this year.
Minus points: Still struggles to make impact against the Mondeo
(handling) and Passat (prestige) despite big strides.
Best buy: 2.0D Saloon Executive
Final answer: YES, it’s a really good package.
MX-5
Engines: 1.8
Bodystyles: Roadster.
Plus points: Updated not that
long ago
Minus points: Cabin and boot
isn’t that roomy
Best buy: 1.8 Roadster
Final answer: YES, still a contender.
85
IS
MOTORSHOW 2011
MERCEDES-BENZ
E-Class
Engines: 1.8, 2.5, 3.0, 3.5, 5.0,
6.2 (AMG), 2.2CDi, 3.0CDi,
Plus points: Big breakthrough
in terms of looks and handling.
Lovely cabin, excellent diesels.
Well priced. First-class package now. Set pace on price. Estate
huge.
Minus points: Not as sharp as BMW 5-series but not far off.
Best buy: 2.2Cdi
Final answer: YES, first-class buy that will age well.
++++
www.mercedes-benz.ie
E-Class Coupe/
Cabriolet
A Class
Engines: 1.5, 1.7, 2.0, 1.6
CDI, 2.0CDI
Bodystyles: 5dr. Hatchback &
3dr. Coupe.
Plus points: At that price you
will struggle to unearth a better value car – not to mention
a Merc. Loads of space and equipment..
Minus points: Falls between two stools – not perceived as family
car and not seen as compact executive. B-Class probably takes
from it.
Best buy: 1.6 CDi. Classic
Final answer: YES. Easy to overlook it as an option.
B Class
Engines: 1.5, 1.7, 2.0,
2.0CDI
Bodystyles: 5dr. Hatchback /
Compact MPV.
Plus points: Nicely roomy
and has lots of equipment.
Price competitive. Fine diesel.
Minus points: Not the most flexible MPV and a bit out of the
public view.
Best buy: 2.0 (109bhp) CDi.
Final answer: YES, substantial car at a good price.
€52,275
Engines: 2.5CDI, 3.5 CDI.
Plus points: Lovely motor that
engages you with its drive as
much as looks, comfort, equipment and . . . . price. Excellent
diesels. Coupe better.
Minus points: Handling is quite poor over rough roads.
Best buy: 2.5CDI
Final answer: YES, a nice package.
CL
Engines: 5.4, 5.5. 6.0 & 6.2
(AMG).
Plus points: Big, powerful
prestige coupe with price to
match. Luxurious in extreme.
Huge performer. Another to benefit from a facelift.
Minus points: Mad price and running costs.
Best buy: CL500
Final answer: YES, if you’re in the money.
S Class
C-Class
Engines: 1.8, 3.0, 3.5, 2.2CDi,
3.0 CDi
Plus points: Choice of looks traditional models
(Classic/Elegance) and modern
(Avantgarde/ Sport) is a great idea. Diesels excellent, well
equipped. Update has helped.
Minus points: Hard to believe, but showing signs of dating. Well
behind BMW 3-series on handling and ride.
Best Buy: 2.2 CDi Saloon
Final answer: YES, but wait for update in April.
Engines: 3.0, 3.5, 4.7, 5.5(388
& 517 bhp), 6.0 & 6.2(AMG),
3.0Cdi
Bodystyles: Saloon.
Plus points: Recently
revamped to keep its status as
one of great cars on the road.
Drives so well for such a large motor. Residuals better than most.
Minus points: Beaten by BMW 7-series on handling and ride.
Some awful interior colour combinations so beware.
Best buy: 3.2Cdi
Final answer: YES, Hard to pass this.
86
MOTORSHOW 2011
MINI
SL
Engines: 3.5, 5.5 (388 & 517
bhp), 6.0 (AMG).
Bodystyles: 2dr. Cabrio.
Plus points: Good-time
Charlie of luxury roadsters.
Powerhouse performer, stunning looks, wonderful handling.
Aaaah! for the great old days.
Minus points: Madly thirsty petrol engines take the magic out of
performance.
Best buy: 350
Final answer: YES, if you have the money, go on.
Engines: 4.7, 5.5, 3.0 CDi,
4.0 CDi.
Bodystyles: SUV
Plus points: Gargantuan
seven-seater will get you away
from it all – anywhere. 7GTronic transmission, oozing
technology, big, big diesels.
Minus points: Size, price and SUV tag all against it.
Best Buy: 3.0 CDi
Final answer: YES, big dream machine if you can afford it.
M
Engines: 3.5, 5.0, 6.2 (AMG),
3.0CDi, 4.0CDi.
Bodystyles: SUV 4x4 5dr.
Plus points: Off-roader with
growing reputation. Huge
motor with lots of equipment.
Comfortable on tarmac. First-class diesels.
Minus points: Big prestige SUVs in poor demad.
Best buy: 3.5CDi
Final answer: YES, but so many others offer as much.
MG
++
K&C Garages,
Braemor Road, Churchtown, Dublin 14
Brochure request: 01 296 4020
TF
Engines: 1.8
Bodystyles: Roadster
Plus points: Mid-engined
sports car that tries to be pretty and affordable.
Minus points: Poor driving
position and handling let it
down badly. Residuals.
Best buy: 1.8
Final answer: NO, because it is a runout model but see ‘worth
waiting for’ section..
++++
www.mini.ie
Hatchback
Engines: 1.6, 1.4D
Bodystyles: 2-dr, Cabrio.
Plus points: They’ve put more
pep in the diesel, smartened it
up and kept it well within what
buyers love – the touch of a
modern classic. Brilliant drive
and equipment now.
Minus points: Garish large central speedo. Tiny boot. In danger
of tinkering too much with it.
Best Buy: New Mini One
Final answer: YES, great residuals make it a no brainer.
Convertible
Engines: 1.6 16V
Bodystyles: Hatch
Plus points: Throbbing power
with a drop roof – what more
could you ask for?
Minus points: Pricey and rear
room is poor.
Best buy: Convertible
Final answer: Yes, has it own bit of magic.
Countryman
Engines: 1.6
Bodystyles: Compact SUV
style
Plus points: First four-door of
the genre, mixes MINI magic
with practicality and off-road
looks. Family car/crossover
has decent room, good price.
Minus points: Not too many but still a bit cramped in cabin.
Best Buy: 1.6
Final answer: YES, this is quite an attractive package.
Clubman
Engines: 1.6, 1.4D
Bodystyles: 3.5-dr Clubman
(estate).
Plus points: Roomier than
conventional hatch. You still
get the tight driving. Plenty of
pep.
Minus points: The road-side door at the rear is difficult to manage and detracts from the car.
Best Buy: Mini Cooper D Clubman
Final answer: YES, it is different and worth a test drive.
87
GL
MOTORSHOW 2011
MITSUBISHI
ASX
Bodystyles: Crossover
Plus points: Long-awaited
crossover, it has everything
you’d expect from a Mitsubishi.
Nice cabin, good looks. Diesel
by far the best engine.
Minus points: Cabin feels smaller than many rivals. Others have
a major head start on it.
Final answer: YES, it stands up to scrutiny.
++++
Dealers listing/ Brochure request: 1890 41 51 61
www.mitsubishi-motors.ie
Outlander
Engines: 2.2 DiD
Bodystyles: SUV (7 Seats)
Plus points: Price cuts have
alerted a new buying market.
Classy, good cabin and 2.2 litre
diesel.
Minus points: Lowered price
reflects lack of demand for this sort of motor.
Best Buy: 2.2 DiD
Final answer: YES, It is value for money.
i-MIEV
Prices start at: €28,995*
Engines: Electric
Bodystyles: 5 door hatchback
Plus points: Good in urban
areas
Minus points: Range fears
Best buy: 5 door hatchback
Final answer: Yes, worth a
test drive
*i-MiEV retail price includes €5,000 Government grant for Electric
Vehicles.
Grandis
Engines: 2.0 DI-D
Bodystyles: MPV (7 seats)
Plus points: Long, sleek and
practical, it has served many a
family well with its seven-seater
cabin. Diesel does the business.
Minus points: Not that roomy and it still looks a bit awkward.
Price.
Best buy: 2.0 DI-D.
Final answer: YES, despite not being as roomy as some rivals.
Colt
Engines: 1.1
Bodystyles: 5 door.
Plus points: Fine supermini
with lovely cabin and threeyear warranty.
Price reduced and there’s a
diesel.
Minus points: Not a good seller on second hand market so
residual values can be poor.
Best buy: 1.1 L 5-Dr Classic
Final answer: YES, well worth a test drive.
Pajero
Engines: 3.2 diesel
Bodystyles: 7 seater
Plus points: Goes forever
Minus points: Pricey
Best buy: 3.2 DiD
Final answer: Yes, still up
there with the best of them
Lancer / Sportback
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5Dr
hatchback.
Plus points: New diesel puts
this right back in contention.
Sportback hatch better looking.
Great longevity.
Minus points: Flat design means it doesn’t attract much attention so it has to appeal on build and price.
Best buy: Saloon manual.
Final answer: YES, now it has a diesel, it’s a runner.
88
MOTORSHOW 2011
++++
www.nissan.ie
Pixo
Engines: 1.0
Bodystyles: Hatch
Plus points: Bargain basement price city car. Does what
it says on the tin.
Manages rougher roads well.
Minus points: Hasn’t made
much of an impact. Some better-known rivals.
Best Buy: 1.0 litre
Final answer: Yes, practicality gets it on your list.
Micra (2011)
Engines: 1.2
Bodystyles: 5 dr Hatchback.
Plus points: Bigger and
roomier, appeals for same reasons it’s predecessors did:
Micras don’t give trouble, are
versatile and go forever.
Minus points: Too early to say.
Best Buy: 1.2 R Dr. SXE manual
Final answer: YES, this has a lot going for it.
ALWAYS DRIVE
RESPONSIBLY
Readers Notice
new car.
Juke
Bodystyles: 5 door SUV
Plus points: Unusual,
provocative, well-priced and
refreshing alternative to a family car. Cut-down version of
Qashqai is nothing if not distinctive.
Minus points: Those looks take a bit of getting
used to and not everyone’s cup of tea.
Best Buy: 1.5D
Final answer: YES, Nissan have cornered the market on this
sort of motor.
Note
Engines: 1.4, 1.6, 1.5 Diesel.
Bodystyles: SUV
Plus points: One of those
cars that gives unrelenting
service without fuss. Easy to
drive, nice roomy cabin, well
equipped and a fine diesel.
Minus points: Dash over endowed with plastic and the styling is
drab.
Best Buy: 1.5 D. SXE
Final answer: YES, good investment for small, growing family.
Tiida
Engines: 1.6, 1.5 Diesel.
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5 Dr.
Hatchback.
Plus points: Low key smallfamily car for those who want
something purely to get them
from A to B.
Minus points: Has become butt of jokes, it is so boring. Has lost
its way a bit.
Best Buy: 1.2 R Dr. SXE manual
Final answer: YES, but only because it is a Nissan.
Qashqai
Engines: 1.6, 2.0, 1.5 D, 2.0D
Bodystyles: Hatchback/SUV
5/7 seats
Plus points: There is a waiting list for this. Latest update
changed its looks a bit and
added equipment. Mix of
urban people carrier, hatchback/ coupe and slightly muscular
SUV. Cabin better, diesel fine and you get 4x2 and 4x4 options.
Minus points: Seven-seater poor compared with five-seater.
Best Buy: 1.5 D. SE
Final answer: YES, join the queue. Updated Qashqai +2 coming
in April.
Murano 2011
Engines: 2.5 diesel
Bodystyles: SUV
Plus points: Has an astonishing capacity for power and
pace. Lots of equipment and a
classy handler.
Minus points: Scant demand
for this sort of vehicle any more.
Final answer: YES, the new diesel deserves to be checked out.
89
NISSAN
MOTORSHOW 2011
OPEL
370Z
Engines: 3.7V6
Bodystyles: 2 door coupe
Plus points: Out-and-out performance from this new supercar. Straight-line speed and
cornering match the best.
Minus points: Cost of purchase and running it.
Best Buy: 3.7V6
Final answer: NO, there are better options.
www.opel.ie
X-Trail
Engines: 2.0D.
Bodystyles: SUV 4x4 5Dr.
Plus points: One of best onroad SUVs around. Not much
different looking from old one
but there’s more space and
technical ability. Top-drawer
diesel.
Minus points: Hard to distinguish from old one.
Best Buy: 2.0D
Final answer: YES, but buy updated model in March.
Agila
Engines: 1.0i, 1.2i, 1.3 CDTi
Bodystyles: 5dr Hatchback
Plus points: Lot of room in this
tall and roomy hatch. Good
diesel option.
Minus points: Design is a bit
off the wall.
Best Buy: 1.2 16v
Final answer: YES, there is room for four within its awkward
frame.
Nissan Leaf
Prices start at: €29,995*
Engines: Electric motor
Bodystyles: Hatchback
Plus points: First electric car
that proves you can accommodate a family in an ‘ordinary’
setting. Accomplished, clever,
roomy, massive public exposure.
Minus points: Range anxiety haunts it - they
reckon 150km on a charge.
Best Buy: Hatchback
Final answer: YES, it is a big sign of things to come.
* Leaf retail price includes €5,000 Government grant for Electric
Vehicles.
Tigra
Engines: 1.4
Bodystyles: 2 Dr. Coupe
Cabrio
Plus points: Grand little fun
car with nice degree of zip and
zest. Diesel a big help. Easy to
fold away the roof.
Minus points: Hasn’t had impact of former version – different
times. Run out model.
Best Buy: 1.4
Final answer: NO, this is a runout model.
Meriva 2011
Primastar Combi
Engines: 1.4i, 1.3 CDTi,
1.7CDTi.,
Plus points: Initial reaction to
this new arrival has been good.
Easier to access, it retains the
handling that set its predecessor apart. Flexible seating and luggage space.
Minus points: No one knows it’s on sale.
Best Buy: 1.3 CDTi
Final answer: YES, it’s a good buy.
Engines: 2.0 Diesel
Bodystyles: Combi
Plus points: Well appointed
and comfortable; all seats
have headrests and 3-point
seatbelts and there’s optional
extra heating for the rear compartment.
Minus points: Not that well known
Best Buy: 2.0
Final answer: Yes, it should be on the list
Readers Notice
Corsa
new car.
++++
90
Engines: 1.2i, 1.4i,1.3CDTi
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr hatchback.
Plus points: Latest version of
this supermini just went on sale
in 2011. Excellent job to build
on fine predecessor. It has
more room and equipment.
Minus points: Too soon to say.
Best Buy: 1.2. Life 5-dr.
Final answer: YES, has the makings of a really good buy.
MOTORSHOW 2011
PEUGEOT
Astra
Engines: 1.4, 1.6, 1.3CDTi,
1.7CDTi, 1.9CDTi, 2.0 CDTi
Bodystyles: 3/ 5dr.
Hatchback, Coupe/Cabrio &
Estate.
Plus points: Another Opel that
deserves better billing. Looks and handles well and has a fine
spread of diesels.
Minus points: Not too many except old Astra name haunts it.
Best Buy: 1.3 CDTi
Final answer: YES, well worth a test drive.
www.peugeot.ie
Zafira
Insignia
Engines: 1.6i 16v, 1.8i 16v,
2.0i 16v Turbo, 2.8i V6 Turbo,
2.0CDTi 16v (130PS) ,
2.0CDTi 16v (160PS
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5dr.
Hatchback + Estate.
Plus points: Strongly styled
with lot of space and comprehensive engine range.
Minus points: Hasn’t impacted. We never saw it as a European
Car of the Year. Talk about a poor choice. Residual concerns.
Best Buy: 1.8 Saloon.
Final answer: YES, because it’s big for the money.
Antara
Engines: 2.0CDTi
Bodystyles: SUV
Plus points: They made a
grand job of this: design, cabin,
equipment and a decent 2-litre
diesel engine. Handling is
sharp. Good overall feel to it.
Minus points: Desperately poor boot space, outgunned and outshone by rivals in shrinking market. Run out model
Best Buy: 2.0 CDTi Elegance
Final answer: NO, it is a runout model.
107
Engines: 1.0
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr.
Minicar/Citycar
Plus points: A brother of
Toyota Aygo and Citroen C1,
it should pick up on drive
towards smaller cars. Fun-to-drive city car.
Minus points: Like Citroen C1, road noise in the cabin and tiny boot.
Best Buy: 107S 5 Dr.
Final answer: YES, for today’s smaller ambitions.
207
Engines: 1.4 petrol, 1.6 petrol,
1.4HDI
Bodystyles: 3 Dr./ 5 Dr.
Hatchback; Coupe Cabrio,
Sky Wagon (SW)
Plus points: Remains a firm
favourite; one of the best to retain value. SW version good too.
Excellent diesel.
Minus points: A little dated and lacks three-year warranty of Far
Eastern rivals.
Best Buy: 1.4 HDI
Final answer: YES, on the crest of a wave with this.
308
Engines: 1.6, 1.8, 2.2,
1.7CDTI, 1.9 CDTI.
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Still clinging to
best mid-size seven-seater
MPV accolade despite severe
competition. Great interplay between seating and luggage – and
it is so easy.
Minus points: Hard to distinguish it from predecessor. Looking
awfully dull now.
Best Buy: 1.8 Life
Final answer: YES, still tops at what it does best.
++++
Engines: 1.6 HDi,
Bodystyles: 5 Door. Coupe
Cabriolet
Plus points: Smart, understated small-family hatch with
excellent diesel, sharp handling and decent cabin.
Minus points: Probably overshadowed by big hitters such as VW
Golf and Toyota Auris. Little bit too understated.
Best Buy: 1.6 HDi
Final answer: YES, Good option despite intense competition.
91
MOTORSHOW 2011
3008
RENAULT
Engines: 1.6HDI
Bodystyles: MPV Crossover
Plus points: Has taken the
place by storm with its clever
use of space and storage.
Imaginative, roomy, excellent
deployment of dials and
instruments. On the button in the crossover era; price.
Minus points: Not too many even at this stage.
Best Buy: 1.6HDI
Final answer: YES, fine mix of room and style.
++++
www.renault.ie or www.irishscrappage.ie
407 SW
Engines: 1.6HDI
Bodystyles: Station Wagon
Plus points: Big and roomy
Minus points: Not that many
Best Buy: 1.6HDi
Final answer: NO, wait for
super new 508 in April.
Wind
Engines: 1.2 16V
Bodystyles: Roadster
Plus points: It’s new and has
a quirky look
Minus points: Questions
about residuals
Best Buy: 1.2 16V
Final answer: Yes, give it a try
RCZ
Engines: 1.6 petrol, 2.0HDI
Bodystyles: 2dr coupe
Plus points: Extraordinary
pitched-forward looks, twincurve roof, sparkling engine,
equipment. Real departure for
Peugeot.
Minus points: Big price for competitor to Audi’s
Continental Irish
TT. Really need to relish harsh, sport suspension
Performance
on Irish roads.
Car of the Year
Best Buy: 2.0 HDI
Final answer: YES, but only because of the novelty.
Clio/Grand Clio
Prices start at: € 13,390 /
€15,700
Engines: 1.2, 1.5 DCi
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr.
Hatchback, Estate.
Plus points: Clio has always
been a good, taut driver.
Standing test of time well.
Minus points: Cabin bit too small compared with many rivals.
And we wouldn’t bother with the Grand Clio.
Best Buy: 1.2 Royale
Final Answer: YES, has to get a test drive.
5008
Engines: 1.6 HDi
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Like the 3008, it
cleverly blends space, engine,
price and looks. Really an outstanding mix. Probably outstanding example of a mid-size MPV.
Minus points: May suffer from lack of demand for such MPVs –
a pity as it deserves a wider audience.
Best Buy: 1.6HDi
Final answer: Yes, has to be on your shopping list.
Kangoo
Engines: 1.5 DCi
Plus points: Should be called
Kandoo because it is so practical on room and engine (1.5litre diesel). Use it as a car
and/or workhorse.
Minus points: It is a van and handles like one.
Best Buy: 1.5 DCi
Final answer: Yes, if you want a really practical buy.
92
MOTORSHOW 2011
€19,690
Engines: 1.6 16V, 1.5DCi
Bodystyles: 3/5dr. hatchback,
Saloon, Tourer (estate),
Coupe/ Cabrio.
Plus points: They are pushing this on Scrappage. Biggest selling
model of 2010 as a result. Price, diesels are excellent. Coupe looks
wonderful. High equipment levels. Roomier Grand version too.
Minus points: Basic model lacks cabin space of many rivals;
what will residuals be like in a few years?
Best Buy: 1.5 dCi
Final answer: YES, especially under the scrappage deals.
Trafic
Engines: 2.0dCi
Bodystyles: 9 seater minibus
Plus points: Plenty of room
and a good spec
Minus points: Derived from
the panel van
Best buy: 2.dCi
Final answer: No, better options out there..
SAAB
Megane Coupe Cabrio
Engines: 1.5DCi
Bodystyles: Coupe Cabriolet
Plus points: Easily best looking
in Renault range. Handles quite
well and lacks for little in equipment. Nice combination.
Minus points: Only major concern is future residual value for car
of this nature.
Best Buy: 1.5DCi
Final answer: YES, it is a grand drive and looks smart.
Renault Fluence
Engines: 1.6 16v, 1.5DCi
Bodystyles: 4 door
Plus points: Offers choice in
the slot between Megane and
Laguna. Looks stylish and is
particularly well equipped.
Electric version on its way.
Minus points: Neither fish nor fowl and has been overshadowed
by Megane success in scrappage deals
Best Buy: 1.5DCi
Final answer: YES, it is stylish and has a certain poise.
Scenic / Grand Scenic
€24,590
Engines: 1.6, 1.5 DCi,
Bodystyles: MPV (5 Dr.) 5/7
Seats
Plus points: Always a consideration for families. Nicely styled,
cracking diesel and decent room.
Minus points: Gave up a huge head start to be overtaken by
likes of Ford C-Max, Toyota Verso and Opel Zafira.
Best Buy: 1.5DCi
Final answer: YES, new models get it onto our shopping list.
Laguna
Engines: 1.5 DCi, 2.0 DCi,
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. Hatchback,
Tourer, Coupe
Plus points: They have done
everything to make this a
viable option: major recent
revamp, three-year-warranty,
good 2-litre diesel, room, equipment and price cuts.
Minus points: Smacks of desperation; reliability of previous
model still dogs it. Concerns about residuals.
Best Buy: 1.5CDi
Final answer: YES, but only because of recent revamp.
+++
www.saab.ie
9-3 Saloon
Engines: 1.8T BioPower,
1.9TTiD,
Bodystyles: Saloon / Estate.
Plus points: After a turbulent
year, Saab is back on track
here. This is still a decent
motor with good diesels, and
Biopowers.
Minus points: Way off pace set by BMW 3-series, Audi A4 or
Mercedes C-Class. New one in offing.
Best Buy: 1.9TTiD.
Final answer: YES, watch out for special editions in August.
9-3 Convertible
Engines: 1.9 TTiD, 1.8 turbo
biopower
Bodystyles: Convertible.
Plus points: Popular drophead
down the years, mainly
because it is a four-seater with
some charm.
Minus points: Poor boot space with roof down.
Best Buy: 1.9TTiD
Final answer: YES, still an option for you especially as residuals
hold up well.
Readers Notice
new car.
93
Megane/Grand
Megane
MOTORSHOW 2011
9-5 Saloon
Ibiza
Engines: 2.0T Biopower,
2.0TiD, 2.0TTiD
Bodystyles: Saloon/ Estate.
Plus points: New and much better without breaking any moulds.
Good equipment levels and Saab
safety to the fore. Saloon just for now. Diesel the pick of engines.
Minus points: Cabin is quite dull as is the handling.
Best Buy: 2.0 TiD
Final answer: YES, it’s new and a real option.
SEAT
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 TDi, 1.6 TDi
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr.
Hatchback.
Plus points: We rate this
supermini highly. It has the
engines, looks, roomy cabin
and is well priced.
Minus points: Has fallen from limelight over past year.
Best Buy: 1.2 5.Dr.
Final answer: YES, good style and good value.
Alhambra
Engines: 2.0TDi.
Plus points: New one carries
on tradition of beating VW
Sharan and Ford Galaxy on
price (closely related to both).
Great 2-litre diesels and loads
of room. More stylish looking.
Minus points: Not much really, except lack of demand for large
MPvs.
Best Buy: 2.0TDi
Final answer: YES, new model is highly competitive.
+++
www.seat.ie
SKODA
Leon
Engines: 1.2 Tsi, 1.6 Tdi, 2.0 Tsi
Bodystyles: 5 Door Hatchback
Plus points: A top, top driver
that has loads of pace and style
and is a bit of a hidden gem.
Minus points: Big drawback is
poor legroom at the back. No profile.
Best Buy: 1.6 Tdi
Final answer: YES, well priced and poised to shine.
www.skoda.ie
Exeo
Engines: 2.0TDI
Bodystyles: 4dr saloon
Plus points: Based on Audi
A4 but its prices are way, way
better. Plenty of room and
equipment.
Minus points: Who knows
anything about it? Residual
value reservations.
Best Buy: 2.0TDI
Final answer: NO. Too low a profile.
Fabia
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 tsi, 1.6 TDi
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr.
Hatchback/Estate.
Plus points: Has proved its
worth for years now; update
adds polish. Add in 1.4-litre
diesel engine and there isn’t
much to complain about. Combi (estate) has more room.
Minus points: Prices rise quickly if you want to adorn this with
extras.
Best Buy: 1.2 Classic.
Final answer: YES, sound, steady buy.
Altea / Altea XL
21,375
Engines: 1.6TDi
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. Hatchback/
MPV
Plus points: Mixes hatchback
and MPV and has loads of
space as well as clever touches. Good diesel engine, space
excellent.
Minus points: Design has worn thin. Looks like something from
another age. It is.
Best Buy: XL - 1.6 TDi
Final answer: YES, for a certain buyer.
++++
94
MOTORSHOW 2011
Octavia
SUBARU
Engines: 1.2 tsi, 1.4 tsi,
1.8 tsi, 1.6 TDi, 1.9TDi
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. Hatchback,
Touring (estate).
Plus points: One of the great
Skoda successes thanks to a
fine cabin, good driving, big
boot and plenty of equipment. Real value for money.
Minus points: Might be starting to date a little bit on looks.
Options can push up price severely.
Best Buy: 1.9TDi Classic.
Final answer: YES, simply must be on shopping lists.
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 tsi, 1.2 TDi
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Blessed with
flexible seating arrangements
and 1.2-litre diesel. This is
more practical than most and
benefits from update.
Minus points: Despite not
being a van, it looks like one. Off-beat: you love or hate it.
Best Buy: 1.2TDi.
Final answer: YES, but be sure you can live with quirkiness.
Superb
Engines: 1.4tsi, 1.8tsi, 1,6 TDi,
1.9TDi, 2.0TDi, 3.6 FSi
Bodystyles: Saloon, Combi
(estate)
Plus points: At a time when
value for money is de rigeur,
this has to be the pace setter.
It’s huge, luxurious, has a great range of engines and look at the
price. Combi (estate) is exceptional.
Minus points: Not many, it is good value.
Best Buy: 1.9TDi.
Final answer: YES, buy a diesel saloon or estate and you have
a car for 10 years.
Yeti
Engines: 1.2ts, 1.6 Tdi, 2.0TDi
Bodystyles: SUV/MPV
Plus points: Skoda are pitching this against the runaway
‘crossover’ leader, the Nissan
Qashqai. As a 4x2 it has
gained a lot of admirers. High
levels of equipment and solid build.
Minus points: Looks blocky and lacks Qashqai’s
svelte, smart looks.
Best Buy: 1.6 TDi
Final answer: YES, it is set up to do the business.
Continental Irish
Compact Family
Car of the Year
+++
Dealers listing/ Brochure request: 1850 58 58 58
www.subaru.ie
Justy
Engines: 1.0i
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. Hatchback
Plus points: Well built, well
priced.
Minus points: Not an option
for vast majority due to lack of
recognition.
Best Buy: 1.0
Final answer: NO, even Subaru name fails to get it on your
shopping list.
Impreza
Engines: 2.0 TD
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. Hatchback
Plus points: The diesel saved
this car from oblivion. And you
get All Wheel Drive (AWD) for
extra grip – a gift in bad
weather.
Minus points: Old-fashioned cabin, poor boot space.
Final answer: YES, AWD and diesel make it worth inclusion on
your list.
Forester
Prices start at: €34,995.
Engines: 2.0 Boxer diesel.
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. SUV AWD
Plus points: Classy
SUV/large estate is a real
proposition now thanks to that
diesel engine. And it has AWD,
something that will make it
attractive to those whose rear-wheel-drive left them stranded in
the snow and ice.
Minus points: Really needs a good overhaul of the cabin especially – it’s so old fashioned.
Best Buy: 2.0 diesel.
Final answer: YES, this is a right good ‘crossover’.
95
Roomster
MOTORSHOW 2011
Legacy / Outback
Swift
€41,995
Engines: 2.0 Boxer diesel
Bodystyles: Saloon/ Estate
and Outback Estate
Plus points: Its credentials as
a quality drive were never in
doubt but it needed the diesel
to make it relevant in the current market. AWD there as well.
Minus points: Price still a bit of a deterrent and small number of
outlets.
Final answer: YES, prepare to be impressed.
Engines: 1.3, 1.5, 1.6
Bodystyles: 3/5Dr. Hatchback
Plus points: Brand new with
more efficient and lower-emission engines. Doesn’t look
much different from award-winning predecessor but it is.
Minus points: Engine can be a bit uneven at idle. Would have
liked it to look much more different from old one.
Best Buy: 1.3GL 5-dr.
Final answer: YES, this is as good a supermini as there is.
SX4
Engines: 1.5. 1.6 diesel
Bodystyles: 5dr. Hatchback
and Saloon
Plus points: New model is
nicely roomy with a good price,
decent boot and a smooth
diesel.
Minus points: Hard to see much use or demand for it these
days.
Best Buy: 1.5 GL.
Final answer: YES, but only just.
SUZUKI
+++
www.suzuki.ie
TOYOTA
Alto
Engines: 1.0
Bodystyles: Hatch
Plus points: Nippy, well-engineered small car that manages
to eke out plenty of space.
Minus points: Engine a bit
uncultured, rivals are slashing
prices ever lower.
Best Buy: 1.0
Final answer: Yes, but only because of the Suzuki reputation.
+++++
www.toyota.ie
Splash
Aygo
Engines: 1.0, 1.2 GLS
Bodystyles: 3dr/5dr
Hatchback
Plus points: Tall and unusual;
closely related to Opel Agila.
Good room for a city car.
Minus points: Has an outrageous looking rev counter binnacle on the dash that would alienate potential buyers?
Best Buy: 1.2 GLS
Final answer: YES, a fine little car if you can avert your gaze
from that binnacle.
Engines: 1.0 VVT-i
Body style: 3/5dr. hatch.
Plus points: Three-year warranty gives it a distinct edge
over its Citroen C1 and
Peugeot 107 siblings.
Minus points: We have some
complaints about design and tiny boot.
Best buy: Terra 5-door
Final answer: YES, City car that will go for a long time.
96
MOTORSHOW 2011
Engines: 1.0 VVTi,
Body style: Small hatchback.
Plus points: Has earned a lot
of respect for practicality, frugality and design. Good one for a
scrappage deal.
Minus points: It is expensive for a city car.
Best buy: 1.0 VVTi
Final answer: Yes, residual values make it a sound buy.
Yaris
Engines: 1.0, 1.33 Dual VVT-i,
1.4 D4D
Bodystyles: 3dr./ 5dr. Hatch.
Plus Points: Rock solid supermini always on buyers’ shortlist.
Just does everything in a nonfussy way. Holds value well.
Minus points: Skimps a bit on cabin space.
Best buy: 1.0 5dr.
Final answer: YES, an easy choice.
Urban Cruiser
Engines: 1.33 Dual VVTi, 1.4
D4D
Body style: Hatch
Plus points: Toyota’s attempt
to meet so-called urban
demand. Roomy, handles well,
good diesel.
Minus points: Lacks focus of appeal – what and who is it for?
Best buy: 1.4D4D
Final answer: Yes. But only because it is a Toyota.
Auris
Engines: 1.33 VVT-i, 1.6 VVTi, 1.4 D4D
Bodystyles: 3dr/5dr hatchback
Plus points: Hatchback has
carved out a distinct slot for
itself. They’ve made the 1.4D even more frugal. Simple, straightforward car with a roomier cabin than you’d think. Priced keen
now.
Minus points: Quite bland to look at inside and out compared
with many rivals.
Best Buy: 1.4 D4D
Final answer: YES, it’s a ‘Corolla’ hatch so it warrants inclusion.
Corolla
Engines: 1.33 VVT-i, 1.4 D4D.
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Huge push on
price/scrappage deals has
made this the best value it
has been. Big and roomy
saloon it has the best 1.4-litre diesel engine you’ll drive for many
a day. Three-year warranty.
Minus points: Bland design and cabin.
Best buy: 1.4 D4D
Final answer: YES, value for money and reliability.
Verso s
Engines: 1.33 VVT-i
Bodystyle: MPV (5 Seater)
Plus Points: Just arriving in
February but with a good preproduction drive reports
Minus Points: To early to say.
Best Buy: 1.33 VVT-i.
Final answer: Yes, but because it is all-new, check it out in
greater detail.
Verso
Engines: 1.6VVT-i, 1.8VVTi,
2.0 D-4D
Bodystyles: MPV (5/7 seats)
Plus points: They hit on a
good combination with this and
at just the right time.
By far the easiest MPV to drive. Lovely cabin, gear change and
it’s easier to mix and match seating/luggage combinations.
Minus points: Just that bit short on space especially for the third row.
Best buy: 2.0 D4D
Final answer: YES, smooth operator in a discerning and
demanding market segment.
Avensis
iQ
Engines: 1.6 VVT-i, 1.8VVTi,
2.0VVT-I, 2.0 D4D, 2.2 D-CAT
Bodystyles: Saloon /
Hatchback and Tourer (estate)
Plus points: Big, big push on
price here again, relatively new
model with roomier cabin, better equipment and engines. Massive
boot. Reliability and re-sale big plus factors.
Minus points: Already looking a bit dated and VW (new Passat),
Ford (Mondeo update) are snapping at its heels.
Best buy: 2.0 D4D saloon.
Final answer: YES, always a safe bet for the family or commercial traveler.
Prius
Engines: 1.8 Hybrid
(Petrol/Battery)
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Now a big car,
with same cabin space as
Avensis. So much technology
and equipment. Impressive package. Frugality and price.
Minus points: Bit sloppy to drive and uses petrol engine nearly
all the time on longer drives.
Best buy: One model
Final answer: YES, it is quite an achievement and has the practicality to take the family.
RAV-4
Engines: 2.0 VVT-i, 2.2D-4D,
2.2 D-CAT
Plus points: One of the easiest to drive with an exceptional
driving position. Well equipped
and good diesel. Price.
Minus points: Cabin needs a bit of an overhaul because it is
looking a bit tired compared with several rivals.
Best buy: 2.2 D-4D Luna
Final answer: YES, it is a top-three entrant always.
97
MOTORSHOW 2011
Land Cruiser
Golf
Engines: 3.0 D4D,
Bodystyles: 4x4, 3/5dr
Plus points: New one is,
believe it or not, better than
the old one and that was in
our humble opinion the best
and had been for some time. Brilliant on and off road. Excellent
diesel.
Minus points: Bit soon to crib except to say large SUVs are not
in huge demand these days.
Best buy: 3.0D4D LWB GX 5dr
Final answer: YES, back at Number One where it belongs.
Engines: 1.2TSi, 1.4TSi,
2.0TSi, 1.6 TDI, 2.0 TDI,
Bodystyles: 3/5dr. Hatchback
- GTi, Cabrio.
Plus points: Best Golf to date
by some distance. Great mix of
petrol and diesel engines; cabin roomier
than you’d think. Residual values.
Always popular with Irish buyers.
Minus points: Not that much different from old one – it has
always been thus as design is evolutionary rather than revolutionary.
Best buy: 1.4 TSi 5 Dr
Final answer: YES, built to last and always a favourite.
VOLKSWAGEN
Golf Plus
Engines: 1.2 TSI, 1.6 TDI
Bodystyles: Hatchback/MPV
Plus points: Has more room,
some good engines and
decent boot room.
Minus points: Price not
justified by meager enough additional room.
Best buy: 1.6TDi
Final answer: NO, not in these cost conscious days.
+++++
Dealers listing/ Brochure request: 01 8989700
www.volkswagen.ie
Tiguan
Engines: 2.0 TDI.
Bodystyles: SUV 4WD/2WD
Plus points: Mid-size sports
utility that embraces ‘big brother’ Touareg technology. Good
drive and decent room as well
as a practical 4x2 version.
Minus Points: Hard to criticise but rivals have taken a lot of
ground and this hasn’t really caught on.
Best buy: 2.0TDI
Final answer: YES. Well worth a test drive. Better than some of
the trendier competitors.
Fox
Engines: 1.2
Bodystyle: 3-dr hatchback
Plus points: City car built to
last and last. Plenty of zest in
the drive, good cabin.
Minus points: We don’t hear
much about it; demand should
be higher.
Best buy: 1.2.
Final answer: YES. Good residuals mean it is a solid buy.
Touran
Engines: 1.6TDi, 2.0 TDI
Bodystyles: MPV 5/7 seats.
Plus points: Newly revised it
carries on as one of the best
but most understated people
carriers around. Improved all
round, plenty of space and the
diesel is excellent. Seating/accommodation changes now more
easily achieved.
Minus points: Same as Golf – not great show of design flair.
Best buy: 1.6 TDi
Final answer: YES, fresh new model offers quite a bit now.
Polo
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 TDi, 1.4 TSi,
1.6TDi
Bodystyles: 3/ 5dr.
Hatchback
Plus points: Bigger and better, it is built like a tank and
typically sturdy. Fine new-technology petrol engines but the
diesel appeals too. Pricing
attempts to sweep more buyers
into lower priced versions.
Minus points: Has perception of
being expensive and unexciting. Many rivals now have cuttingedge looks and massive scrappage backing to sell.
Best buy: 1.2 Comfortline 5dr
Final answer: YES, Residual values and reputation push it high
up the list.
Jetta
98
Engines: 1.4 TSi,1.6TDI
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Fine saloon;
should have done better but
Golf stole its thunder. New one
here this spring. It’s bigger and
better. Huge boot, roomy cabin.
Minus points: New one due. Overshadowed by the Golf.
Best buy: 1.4 TSi
Final answer: NO, wait for the latest manifestation in May.
MOTORSHOW 2011
Scirocco
VOLVO
Engines: 1.4 TSi, 2.0TSi,
2.0TDi
Bodystyles: 3dr/5dr
Hatchback
Plus points: Really looks the
part and turns heads. Cabin
measures up, so do the engines.
Minus points: Doesn’t stir the soul as much as we anticipated.
Just lacks something.
Best Buy: 2.0TDI
Final answer: YES, smart car to have in the drive.
+++
www.volvocars.ie
Passat
Engines: 1.4 TSi, 1.6 TDI,
2.0 TDi
Bodystyles: Saloon/ Estate/
Coupe Carbriolet
Plus points: New one sets
the pace. Don’t be deceived
by visual similarity with old
one, this has taken the game to a new level with room, poise,
technology and equipment.
Good range of diesels with 2-litre particularly impressive.
Minus points: So like the old one you have to look twice to discriminate. Mondeo still beats it on handling and ride.
Best buy: 2.0TDI
Final answer: YES, this is one of the best around.
Engines: 1.6. 2.0F, 1.6D. 2.0D
Bodystyles: Hatchback
Plus points: They have added
a lot of greener (lower emission
DRIVe) models across the
range and this model is no
exception. Strong on safety.
Minus points: Even with the increased frugality, it suffers from
cramped rear room and is a poor driver.
Best Buy: 2.0 Flexifuel
Final answer: YES, the new DRIVe version is worth looking at.
C70
Sharan
Engines: 2.4i, 2.0D
Bodystyles: Cabriolet.
Plus points: Fine engines in
this big, comfortable executive
coupe. Safety features
strongly.
Minus points: Hasn’t caught
on and big cabrios are not in demand.
Best buy: 2.4i
Final answer: NO, doesn’t really stand up to scrutiny.
Engines: 2.0 TDI.
Plus points: Heavily revised
new version on the road now.
They’ve spiced it up a bit;
good engines, loads of space,
seat/luggage combinations
easily worked now.
Minus points: Seat Allhambra beats it – and Galaxy – on sheer
value for money.
Best buy: 2.0 TDi.
Final answer: YES, one of the big three choices.
S40 / V50
C30 Sports Coupe
€27,345
Engines: 1.6, 2.0F, 1.6D, 2.0D
Bodystyles: Saloon / Sports
Estate
Plus points: Another range to
benefit from DRIVe. The V50 is
our pick. Good engines here. V50 handles better than S40
saloon.
Minus points: S40 has poor rear seat space and boot room. As
you can see we like the V50.
Best buy: 2.0 Flexifuel.
Final answer: YES, but only the estate (V50) stands out from the
crowd.
Touareg
Engines: 3.0 V6 TDI
BlueMotion
Bodystyle: SUV / 4WD
Plus Points: Just arriving this
month but with a good pre-production drive reports.
Minus Points: Too early to
say.
Best Buy: 3.0 TDI BlueMotion
Final answer: YES, but because it is all-new, check it out in
greater detail.
99
MOTORSHOW 2011
S60/V60
XC60
€34,000
Engines: 1.6, 2.0, 2.5, 3.0,
1.6D, 2.0D, 2.4D
Bodystyles: saloon, estate
Plus points: Both saloon and
estate are quite distinct.
Saloon has a coupe profile but is a roomy 4dr. The V60 estate is
excellent. Plenty of equipment and lovely to drive.
Minus points: V60 is far better than the saloon. Price.
Best Buy: 2.0D
Final answer: YES, these are fine cars.
V70 / XC70
€44,495
Engines: 2.0F, 1.6D, 2.0D,
2.4D5
Bodystyles: Estates/ XC-SUV
AWD
Plus points: Hard to beat
either of these estates for
driving comfort and room. So comfortable to sit in and so easy to
drive.
Minus points: XC70 something of an anachronism and the
petrols are mad thirsty, if impressive performers.
Best buy: 2.0F
Final answer: Yes, the V70 has to be on your list.
S80
Whilst every care has been taken in
compiling this guide from information
received from distributors, no responsibility can be accepted by the publishers or
staff of Automotive Publications Limited
XC90
Engines: 2.4D5
Bodystyles: SUV (SAV)
Plus points: Roominess and
safety are its big attractions.
Still a family favourite.
Minus points: Diesel lacks
refinement and the likes of the
BMW X5 and Audi Q7 leave it
straddling in their wakes.
Best buy: 2.4D5
Final answer: YES, but it is living on reputation and that won’t
last forever.
Readers Notice
Engines: 1.4.D, 2.0F,1.6 D,
2.0D, 2.4 D5
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Where else
would you get a car of this size
with a 1.4-litre diesel engine in
it that does not suffer from lack
of power? That is the combination that makes this so attractive.
Luxury levels of equipment.
Minus points: Really sloppy handler.
Best buy: 1.4
Final answer: YES, small engine in large car equals big value.
Readers Notice
Engines: 2.4 diesel
Bodystyles: 5dr
SUV/Crossover
Plus points: One of the
smartest lookers around and,
unusually, has the performance, comfort, equipment and chassis to go with it. This is a winner.
Minus points: Not too many except shortage of money for cars
like this.
Best Buy: 2.4 D SE
Final answer: YES, it has the looks and the performance.
new car.
for any errors or omissions. Because
prices etc. can change, we suggest that
once you have made a short-list of cars
that you are interested in, you should
confirm prices and exact specifications
with the dealer when shopping for your
new car.
In our guide, ‘Prices start at:’ refers to
the lowest price of the passenger versions in that model range.
100

New Car Buyers` Guide

Transcription

Similar documents

2013 Gullane (Thomas) Limited. - Fisher

technician training

Trakindo Internal Magazine Antarkita – Within Us

Turning Press Releases into Ticket Sales

2006 Country Coach 530 Intrigue

Douglas TBL200E – Electric Towbarless Tug

AZIMUT 43S - Yachts Invest

the Pixelmation White Paper Here