Motorshow 2012 New Car Guide The Jargon

Transcription

New Car Buyers’ Guide
MOTORSHOW 2012
Motorshow 2012 New Car Guide
Motorshow’s new and used car guides for buyers are
compiled by specialists who have years of experience and
extensive research facilities. Uniquely and very importantly
they are in touch with the new and used car market,
searching out where car buyers are being disappointed
and where others are really getting satisfaction.
Taking account of the various car segments, where preferential requirements vary, we rate all cars that are available on the Irish car market.
We acknowledge, simply due to competitive market
forces, that there are no really poor new cars being
offered anymore. However, there are vast differences
in residual values, build quality, specification levels,
prices, performance and economy levels etc. These and
many other factors greatly influence the ratings of one
seemingly similar car over others.
No other guide tells you, which cars are the best and
the worst buys in plain English. We tell it as it really is,
and you can be assured that the advice that you get in
Motorshow 2012, our annual car buyers’ guide is
independent and consumer driven. Motorshow 2012
is written by Eddie Cunningham, Padraic Deane and
John Loughran with additional research by Catherine
Conboy.
Special Readers Notice
Because prices, etc., can change, we suggest that
once you have made a short-list of cars that you
are interested in, you should confirm prices and
specifications with dealers when shopping for your
new car.
In our guide “prices start at” refers to the lowest
price of the passenger version in that model range.
Whilst every care has been taken in compiling this
guide from information received from the distributors
at the time of writing, (January 2012) no responsibility
can be accepted by the publishers or staff of
Automotive Publications Ltd. for any errors or
omissions.
The Jargon
Most motorists don’t understand the jargon used by carmakers
or in car advertising, surveys over a number of years have concluded.
Just five per cent of 4,000 motorists surveyed understood the
abbreviation TNT, which stands for taxed and tested.
Only 10 per cent understood the abbreviation MFSW – multifunction steering wheel, while fewer than one in three (30 per
cent) understood the abbreviation EBD, which stands for
Electronic Brake Distribution.
The most recognisable of the eight abbreviations used, was
ABS (anti-lock braking system), which was correctly identified
by 76 per cent of the respondents.
Survey points to major consumer annoyance with “dealerspeak” and brands it the most frustrating part of buying a used
car.
Far from making the used-car buying process simpler, terms
like FSH, ESR and ICE confuse the average consumer. 95 per
cent of men and 98 percent of women don’t know what the
most common terms mean.
The research also reveals that 27 per cent of those polled
believe second-hand car dealers deliberately use car jargon to
confuse potential customers into a sale; and 39 per cent of
people are put off buying a used car due to dealer-speak.
The top 10 most confusing car terms are:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
68
18AW
FAR
ESR
ICE
EFW
EW
FSH
PAS
BHP
RCL
- 18 inch Alloy Wheels
- Front Arm Rest
- Electric Sun Roof
- In Car Entertainment
- Electric Front Windows
- Electric Windows
- Full Service History
- Power Assisted Steering
- Brake Horse Power
- Remote Central Locking
MOTORSHOW 2012
Also consider - the contenders by segment
SUPERMINI Cars
Audi A1
Citroen C3
Citroen DS3
Fiat Panda
Fiat Punto Evo
Fiat 500
Ford Fiesta
Honda Jazz
Hyundai i20
Mazda2
Mini
Mitsubishi Colt
Nissan Micra
Opel Corsa
Peugeot 207
Renault Clio
Seat Ibiza
Suzuki Splash
Suzuki Swift
Toyota Yaris
Volkswagen Polo
COMPACT FAMILY Cars
Alfa Romeo Mito
Alfa Romeo Giulietta
Audi A3
BMW 1 Series
Chrysler Delta
Citroen C4
Fiat Bravo
Ford Focus
Honda Civic
Honda Insight
Hyundai i30
Kia Rio
Kia Venga
Kia cee'd
Mazda2
Mazda3
Mercedes-Benz A-Class
Mercedes-Benz B-Class
Mitsubishi Lancer
Nissan Note
Opel Meriva
Opel Astra
Peugeot 308
Renault Megane
Seat Leon
Skoda Fabia
Suzuki SX4
Toyota Corolla
Toyota Auris
Toyota Urban Cruiser
Volkswagen Golf
Volkswagen Golf Plus
Volkswagen Jetta
Volvo C30
FAMILY / COMPACT
EXECUTIVE Cars
Audi A3
Audi A4
Audi A5
BMW 3 Series
Chevrolet Cruze
Citroen C5
Ford Mondeo
Honda Accord
Hyundai i40
Kia Soul
Lexus CT200h
Mazda5
Mazda6
Mercedes-Benz C-Class
Opel Insignia
Peugeot 508
Renault Fluence
Renault Laguna
Saab 9-3
Seat Exeo
Skoda Octavia
Subaru XV
Subaru Legacy
Toyota Auris
Toyota Avensis
Volkswagen Passat
Volvo S40
EXECUTIVE Cars
Audi A6
BMW 5 Series
BMW 5 Series Gran Turismo
BMW 6 Series
Jaguar XF
Mercedes-Benz E-Class
Mercedes-Benz CLS
Saab 9-5
Skoda Superb
Volvo S80
ELECTRIC & HYBRID Cars
Citroen C-Zero
Honda Civic ES Hybrid
Honda Insight
Lexus RX Hybrid
Mitsubishi iMiev
Nissan LEAF
Toyota Prius
ESTATE Cars
Audi A4 Avant
Audi Avant
Audi A6 Avant
Audi A6 Allroad
BMW 3-Series Touring
BMW 5-Series Touring
Citroen C5 Tourer
Ford Focus Wagon
Ford Mondeo Wagon
Honda Accord Tourer
Hyundai i30 Estate
Kia cee'd Sporty Wagon
Mazda6
Mercedes-Benz C-Class
Mercedes-Benz R-Class
Mini Clubman
Opel Astra
Opel Insignia ST
Peugeot 207 SW
Peugeot 308 SW
Peugeot 508 SW
Renault Grand Clio
Renault Grand Megane
Renault Laguna ST
Saab 9-3
Saab 9-5
Seat Exeo ST
Skoda Fabia
Skoda Octavia
Subaru Legacy
Subaru Outback
Toyota Avensis Tourer
Volvo V50
Volvo V70
MPVs / PEOPLE CARRIERS
Chrysler Grand Voyager
Citroen Berlingo Multispace (M)
Citroen C3 Picasso (M)
Citroen C4 Picasso (M)
Citroen Grand C4 Picasso (L)
Fiat Qubo (S)
Fiat Doblo (M)
Ford C-Max (M)
Ford S-Max (M)
Ford Galaxy (L)
Hyundai iX20
Kia Venga (S)
Mazda5 (L)
Nissan Note
Opel Meriva (S)
Opel Zafira
Peugeot 3008 (M)
Peugeot 5008 (M)
Renault Scenic(M)
Renault Grand Scenic(M)
Renault Espace
Seat Altea / Altea XL (M)
Seat Alhambra (L)
Škoda Roomster (M)
Toyota Verso (M)
Volkswagen Golf Plus (M)
Volkswagen Caddy Life
Volkswagen Sharan (L)
Volkswagen Shuttle
(Size: S- Small / M - Medium /
L - Large)
CROSSOVERS
BMW X1 SAV
69
Kia Soul
Mercedes-Benz R-Class
Mitsubishi ASX
Nissan Juke
Nissan Qashqai
Peugeot 3008
Skoda Yeti
Volvo XC60
Compact SUV
Audi Q3
BMW X1 SAV
Ford Kuga
Honda CR-V
Kia Sportage
Nissan Qashqai & Qashqai +2
Nissan X-Trail
Range Rover Evoque
Skoda Yeti
Toyota Urban Cruiser
Volkswagen Tiguan
SUVs / 4x4s
Audi Q5
Audi Q7
BMW X3 SAV
BMW X5 SAV
Hyundai Sante-Fe
Hyundai ix35
Jeep Compass
Jeep Wrangler
Jeep Grand Cherokee
Kia Sorento
Land Rover Freelander 2
Land Rover Discovery 4
Lexus RX
Mercedes-Benz ML Class
Mercedes-Benz GL Class
Mitsubishi Outlander
Mitsubishi Pajero
Nissan Murano
Range Rover Sport
Range Rover
Subaru Forester
Subaru Grand Vitara
Toyota RAV4
Toyota Land Cruiser
Volkswagen Touareg
Volkswagen Caravelle
Volvo XC60
Volvo XC70
Volvo XC90
COUPES
Audi TT
Audi A5
Audi A7
BMW 1 Series
BMW 3 Series
BMW M3
BMW 6 Series
BMW X6 SAC
Ford Focus CC
Honda C-RZ
Hyundai Veloster
Jaguar XK
Lexus IS
Mercedes-Benz C-Class Coupe
Mercedes-Benz CLC
Mercedes-Benz CLK
Mercedes-Benz CLS
Mercedes-Benz CL
Mini Coupe
Nissan 370Z
Peugeot 207 CC
Peugeot 308 CC
Renault Laguna Coupe
Volkswagen Scirocco
Volkswagen Passat CC
CONVERTIBLES /
ROADSTERS
Audi A3
Audi TT
BMW 1 Series
BMW 3 Series
BMW 6 Series
BMW Z4
Fiat 500C
Jaguar XK
Lexus IS 250C
Mercedes-Benz SLK
Mercedes-Benz CLK
Mercedes-Benz SL
Mini Roadster
Mitsubishi Colt
Nissan 370Z
Opel Astra Twintop
Saab 9-3
LUXURY Cars
Audi A8
BMW 7 Series
Jaguar XJ
Jaguar XK Coupe / Cabrio
Lexus 460
Lexus 600
Mercedes-Benz S-Class
Mercedes-Benz SL
Mercedes-Benz CL
Range Rover
CITY / MINI Cars
Chevrolet Spark
Citroen C1
Ford Ka
Hyundai i10
Kia Picanto
Nissan Pixo
Opel Agila
Peugeot 107
Suzuki Alto
Toyota iQ
Toyota Aygo
PERFORMANCE Cars
Audi S6
Audi TT RS
Audi R8
Audi A4 S
Audi A5 S
BMW M3 (Coupe / Saloon)
BMW M5
Lexus IS-F
Mercedes-Benz C-Class AMG
Mercedes-Benz SLK AMG
Mercedes-Benz S CLS AMG
Mercedes-Benz S AMG
Mercedes-Benz SL AMG
Mercedes-Benz CL AMG
Mitsubishi Evo
Renault Clio RS Sport
MOTORSHOW 2012
AUDI
ALFA ROMEO
Dealers In the Republic of Ireland: 15
Dealerships In the Republic of Ireland: 5
Brochure Request: www.audi.ie
Brochure Request Hotline: 1800 2532 00 (1800 ALFA 00)
www.audi.ie
www.alfaromeo.ie
Prices and specifications correct as at 06.01.2012.
MiTo
A1
Guilietta
A3
Prices start at: €17,995
Engines: 0.9, 1.4 16v, 1.3
JTDM, 1.4 TB.
Bodystyles: 3dr
Plus points: Sparkling little
performer with a nicelyjudged sprinkling of style
and dash.
Minus points: It is cramped. Real concern over loss of value
at trade-in time.
Best Buy: 1.3 JTDM
Final answer: YES, if you are an Alfa fan and love the
styling.
Engines: 1.2 TFSI, 1.4
TFSI, 1.6TDI, 2.0 TDI
Bodystyles: 3dr hatch
Plus points: Big engineering in small Audi. Fine cabin.
Affordable snob badge.
Minus points: Understated,
pricy, downbeat looks. Short on driving pep and zest;
cramped cabin.
Best Buy: 1.6TDI
Final answer: NO, checkout the A1 Sportback in March
instead. Better options available.
Engines: 1.4TB, 1.6JTDM,
2.0 JTDM, 1750 TBi
Bodystyles: 5dr Hatch
Plus points: Lovely looks
mask a decent driver. Fine
diesel engines and firstclass handling. Can be an alternative hatch.
Minus points: Stunning looks can not hide from deep-seated
concerns about reliability and trade-in values.
Best Buy: 1.6 JTDM
Final answer: YES, but you have got to be prepared to take
a hit on trade-in.
Engines: 1.2 TFSi, 1.4 TFSi,
1.8 TFSI, 2.0 TFSI, 1.6 TDi,
2.0 TDi.
Bodystyles: 3dr, 5dr
/Sportback/ Cabriolet
Plus points: Been-theredone-that motor built on strong, compact hatch foundations.
Huge secondhand demand so excellent residuals. Roomier
Sportback 5dr. 1.4TFSi engine pick of the bunch.
Minus points: New one in September. Perception of being
expensive.
Best Buy: 5dr. 1.4TFSi.
Final answer: YES, despite all-new A3 arrival in September,
its trade-in value alone earns it a place on your list.
70
MOTORSHOW 2012
A4
A6
A4 Allroad Quattro
Audi A7
TDI, 3.0 TDI
Bodystyles: Big, tall estate
that tries to be an SUV
Plus points: Good traction
and grip.
Minus points: Ridiculously out of date.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDi.
Final answer: NO, it’s well gone now.
Engines: 2.8 TFSI, 3.0 TFSI,
3.0TDI, 3.0 Bi-TDI
Bodystyles: Sportback
Plus points: Great looks,
plenty of room. Has carved
out a niche for itself between
A6 and A8. Super engines.
Really classy large coupe. Expect good residuals.
Minus points: Not too many except price.
Best Buy: 3.0 TFSI
Final answer: YES, this has a special feel to it.
TT Coupe /
Roadster
A8
Prices start at: €42,000 /
€47,000
TFSI, 2.5 TFSI., 2.0TDI.
Bodystyles: Coupe/
Roadster
Plus points: Modern icon that holds its position as one of the
most desirable on the market. Fine cabin, excellent handling.
Minus points: Lacks standard equipment levels to avert fastrising optional trim costs.
Best Buy: 2.0 TFSi
Final answer: YES, It’s an icon.
Prices start at: € 95,150
FSI, 6.3 W12, 3.0 TDI, 4.2
TDI
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Not many
can compete for the sheer
technical advancements on
this. They’ve improved the handling a lot. Great diesels, lots
of room; big, big boot.
Minus points: Trails BMW 7-series on driving and handling
verve.
Best Buy: 3.0 TDi.
Final answer: Yes, this is a great car in several senses of the
word.
A5
Q3
Prices start at: € 39,970,
3.0 TFSI, 2.0TDI, 3.0 TDI V6.
Bodystyles: Sportback,
Coupe, Cabriolet.
Plus points: Bit of an
upgrade/revision has helped.
By no means a knockout, but it has grown on us. Fine driver;
good engines
Minus points: Poor cabin space. Lacks real drive appeal.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDI (Multitronic)
Final answer: YES, it is still an above average piece of work.
Engines: 2.0 TDi, 2.0 TFSi
Bodystyles: Compact SUV
Plus Points: Cleverly aimed
at smaller crossover market.
Does the business on looks,
cabin, equipment and drive.
Quite eye-cathcing.
Minus points: Cabin room is tight. Price.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDI
Final answer: Yes, this has what it takes.
71
2.0 TDI, 3.0TDI
Bodystyles: Saloon/ Estate
Plus points: New model a
major boost. Excellent cabin.
Lovely engines, well equipped,
great room. Brilliant estate.
Minus points: Not too many except they could have made it
far better looking.
Best Buy: 2.0TDI.
Final answer: YES, this is an early entry on your list.
Engines: 1.8TFSI, 2.0
TFSI, 3.0 TFSI, 2.0 TDI,
3.0 TDI.
Bodystyles: Saloon,
Estate
Plus points: Bigger, better.
Excellent cabin now noticeably roomier. Some remarkable
engines. A top compact executive saloon. Residual values.
Minus points: Not many now. Big fleet discounting may hurt
residuals.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDI
Final answer: YES, an excellent buy.
MOTORSHOW 2012
BMW
Q5
Engines: 2.0 TFSI, 2.0 TDI,
3.0 TDI
Bodystyles: 5dr SUV
Plus points: Smart compact
SUV bang in tune with
‘crossover’ era. Super handler, great quattro grip for wintry roads; engines.
Minus points: SUV market not exactly busting with demand.
Equipment upgrade costly.
Best Buy: 2.0 TDi.
Final answer: YES, a smart and solid buy with lots of engineering.
Brochure Hotline: 1890 719 421
www.bmw.ie
Q7
1 Series
R8
3 Series
Engines: 3.0 TDi, 4.2 TDI,
6.0 TDI
Bodystyles: 5dr. SUV
Plus points: Hugely competent SUV that has the
agility and the power. Acres
of room and lots of technology at your
disposal.
Minus points: Too big for current environment. Big criticism is
cost of ‘topping up’ to what is standard on rivals.
Best Buy: 3.0 TDi.
Final answer: YES, because it is a fine motor in its own right.
Engines: 1.6i, 2.0i, 3.0i,
2.0d. + 3.0 Twin Turbo
(Coupe only)
Bodystyles: 3dr./ 5dr
Hatchback, Coupe,
Cabriolet.
Plus points: New one makes huge stride. It’s beefier,
smarter, roomier and a big advance on the old one. Diesels
the best. Price.
Minus points: Too soon to say.
Best Buy: 2.0d
Final answer: YES, now a real contender.
€177,410
Engines: 4.2 FSI, 5.2 FSI
Bodystyles: Coupe/Cabrio
Plus points: Among the
most eye-catching cars on
the road. Race-car
handling, out and out
performance.
Minus points: It was a Celtic Tiger dream machine. The
dream has died.
Best Buy: R-Tronic (but it costs 10k more)
Final answer: YES, if you want to live the dream within the
nightmare.
Engines: 1.6. 2.0i (318 &
320), 2.5i, 3.0i, 2.0d, 2.5d,
3.0d.
Bodystyle: Saloon &
Touring.
Plus points: Brand new
one makes it the one they
have to beat all over again. Price; equipment, excellent handling and ride. As usual diesel engines excel.
Minus points: Too early to say but recession doesn’t encourage this sort of purchase.
Best buy: 2.0d
Final answer: YES. Wait for this new one. It’s fresh and fit.
Can’t be overlooked.
3 Series Coupe/
Convertible
Readers Notice
€52,410
Engines: New Coupe: 2.0,
2.5, 3.0 (330 & 350) 4.0
(M3), 3.0d. 2.5d, 3.0d
(330d & 350d).
Bodystyles: Coupe/ Cabriolet
Plus points: Timeless looks are understated and yet stylish.
Minus points: Is ‘behind’ new 3-series because BMW doesn’t
replace the rest of the 3-series line-up when it brings in new
saloon.
Best Buy: 325d Coupe
Final answer: YES, still a classy purchase.
Whilst every care has been taken in compiling this guide
from information received from distributors, no responsibility can be accepted by the publishers or staff of
Automotive Publications Limited for any errors or
omissions. Because prices etc. can change, we suggest
that once you have made a short-list of cars that you
are interested in, you should confirm prices and exact
specifications with the dealer when shopping for your
new car.
In our guide, ‘Prices start at:’ refers to the lowest price
of the passenger versions in that model range.
72
MOTORSHOW 2012
5 Series
X1 SAV
Gran Turismo
X3
6 Series Coupe /
Convertible
X5 SAV
Prices start at: €95,180,
€104,610
Engines: 3.0i, 4.8 (550),
5.0 (M6), 3.0d.
Bodystyles: Coupe /
Convertible
Plus points: Huge car, lashings of technology and comfort,
tremendous diesel gives it real zip and grunt. Much better
now.
Minus points: Still far too extravagant and costly at a time
like this.
Best Buy: 3.0i Convertible.
Final answer: YES, if it works for you and your chequebook.
Engines: 3.0, 4.8, 3.0d
Bodystyles: 4x4 SAV
Plus points: King of the
road for many. Handles
and holds the road with
such ease. The mix of
seven seats, 3-litre diesel,
better equipment levels makes it a potent contender for your
money.
Minus points: Doesn’t drive altogether as well as a sevenseater as it did as a five-seater. Price still stiff.
Best Buy: 3.0D
Final answer: YES, you need to give this a drive.
7 Series
X6
Engines: 3.0, 4.4, 3.0
diesel
Bodystyles: 5 door saloon
Plus points: Big, comfortable spacious executive.
Excellent engines; packed
with luxury.
Minus points: Doesn’t nearly add up to sum of its parts.
Best Buy: 3.0 diesel
Final answer: NO. wait for the more practical 6 Series
Coupe.
Engines: 2.5, 3.0, 2.0d, 3.0d
Bodystyles: Compact SUV.
Plus points: Much better
proposition now. Cabin a lot
roomier. Price more competitive too. Admirable handling
and ride.
Minus points: Hard to attract attention after initial version got
deserved tag of being too small and too expensive.
Best Buy: 2.0d SE
Final answer: YES, on its own merits well worth a try.
Engines: 3.0, 4.0, 4.8, 6.0,
3.0d
Bodystyles: Saloon (incl.
LWB versions).
Plus points: Probably the
sharpest driving large executive on the market. Diesel tops.
Minus points: Loses value like a Government election
promise.
Best Buy: 730D.
Final answer: YES. If you have deep pockets and love a big
driver. Note that a new model will arrive within 12 months.
Engines: 3.0d, 3.5, 5.0i
Bodystyles: 5dr SUV/Large
Coupe
Plus points: X5-based
crossover that has far more
drive to it than its looks would
suggest.
Minus points: Looks awful and would put off all but the real
devotee. No need for it.
Best Buy: X6x Drive 35i SE
Final answer: NO, you can get the dynamics in several other
far better looking Beemers.
73
Engines: 2.0d
Bodystyles: Sports Activity
Vehicle
Plus points: Despite the
modest dimensions there’s
good room in this. And it
drives really well.
Minus points: Still a lot of money for a small motor BMW.
Best Buy: 2.0d
Final answer: YES, a decent buy.
Engines: 3.0 (204hp,
258hp, 306 hp), 4.5
(407hp), 3.0 Diesel (204hp,
245hp)
Bodystyles:
Saloon/Touring
Plus points: Pricing, handling, looks, equipment and cachet
make it one of the most sought-after cars on the market.
Excellent chassis, diesels, 7-series technology.
Minus points: Has lost its sense of exclusivity. Cabin feels
smaller.
Best Buy: 520d
Final answer: YES, has to be top of your test-drive list.
MOTORSHOW 2012
Z4 Roadster
CHRYSLER
Engines: 2.0, 2.5, 3.0,
3.2 (M)
Bodystyles: Coupe/
Roadster.
Plus points: Have really
spiced this up as a power
pack. M versions especially potent.
Minus points: Dull enough cabin which is quite cramped.
Price. Bit irrelevant in these gloomy times.
Best Buy: 2.5SE.
Final answer: YES. A lovely drive if you can stand the stares.
Brochure Request Hotline: 1 800 363 463
www.chrysler.ie
CHEVROLET
Ypsilon
Engines: 0.9, 1.2, 1.3 JTDM
Bodystyle: 5dr. Hatch.
Plus points: New supermini
with frugal TwinAir engine a
big attraction. Well equipped –
including air con.
Minus points: It’s a re-badged Lancia and reliability as well
as residual values will be a concern.
Best buy: 1.2
Final Answer: YES, because it is a good 21st. century
Lancia.
Brochure Request Hotline: 01 4139 200
www.chevrolet.ie
Spark
Delta:
Cruze
Grand Voyager:
Engines: 1.2 petrol
Bodystyles: 5 dr hatch
Plus points: It’s new and
fresh
Minus points: Too soon to
say
Best Buy: Only one model available
Final answer: Yes, it’s worth a test drive
Engines: 1.4, 1.6 JTDM,
2.0 JTDM
Bodystyle: 5dr. Hatch.
Plus points: Absolutely
crammed with equipment.
What an unusual design.
You like it or you don’t. We
do. Good choice of engines.
Minus points: Customer doubts about trade-in value. Looks.
Best buy: 1.6 JTDM
Final Answer: YES, certainly worth a test drive.
Engines: 2.0 diesel
Bodystyles: 4 Door saloon/
5 Door hatchback
Plus points: Looks stylish
and drives well
Minus points: It is about to
be replace by a new model. Residuals.
Final Answer: No, check out the competition
Engines: 2.8 D
Bodystyle: Large MPV
Plus points: They’re giving it
a new makeover this spring.
Fine 2.8-litre diesel. This is a
great large people carrier.
Minus points: Long time around now, even allowing for
newer version.
Trade-in values.
Best buy: Only one model available
Final answer: YES, it is one of the great survivors.
74
MOTORSHOW 2012
CITROËN
Berlingo Multispace
Engines: 1.6HDi
Bodystyles: MPV 5-Seater.
Plus points: One of those
practical all-rounders. Diesel
engine sips the juice and there
is less van feel to the cabin.
Minus points: You pay your money and you still get a bit
of a van feel. Residual values.
Final answer: YES, a ‘car’ for the times in which we live.
Brochure Request: www.citroen.ie
www.citroen.ie
C1
C3 Picasso
C3
New C4
DS3
New DS4
Engine: 1.0i
Bodystyle: 3-dr., 5-dr.
Hatchback.
Plus points: Quirky city
car that makes an ideal city
runabout.
Minus points: Poor driver, really small cabin. Poor residuals.
Micro boot.
Final answer: YES, but make sure its the new 2012 version.
Engines: 1.6HDI
Bodystyles: MPV 5/7 seater.
Plus points: Flexibility makes
it ideal for families with choice
of five/seven seats. Impressive
1.6-litre diesel.
Minus points: Let down by a lot of plastic throughout the
cabin. Third row really tight.
Final answer: YES, a genuinely practical option these days.
Engines: 1.1, 1.4, 1.4HDi
Bodystyles: 5dr. Hatch.
Plus points: Has some
flair, good diesels and
many well-thought-out
touches. One of
the more user-friendly hatches on the market.
Minus points: Residual values – which now represents
biggest challenge to Citroen for a long time.
Best Buy: 1.4HDi
Final answer: YES. Good engines and user friendly.
Engines: 1.4 Vti,1.6HDi.
Bodystyle: 5 dr. Hatch
Plus points: Fresh and
user-friendly with a lovely
cabin
and a lot of standard
equipment. Again the
diesel excels.
Minus points: Overshadowed
by rivals and undermined by residual values.
Best buy: 1.6 HDi
Final answer: YES, but only just, because of so many great
rivals.
Engines: 1.4 Vti, 1.6 HDI
Bodystyles: 3 Door,
Plus points: Now here’s a
C3 with a difference. This
MINI rival has real fizz and a
fine chassis. Looks great.
Minus points: Major drawback is fear over residual values.
Best Buy: 1.6 HDI
Final answer: YES, a refreshing piece of work that’s worth a
test.
Engines: 1.6 VTi, 1.6 THP,
1.6 HDi, 1.6 EHDi, 2.0 HDi
Bodystyle: 3 Door
Plus points: It is everything
the C4 is not. Has the looks,
equipment, handling and performance to make it one of the great niche buys.
Minus points: Bit expensive and flashy. Residual values
again a concern.
Best buy: 1.6 HDi
Final answer: Yes, for those who love proper Gallic flair.
75
MOTORSHOW 2012
C4 Picasso/
Grand C4 Picasso
FIAT
Prices start at: €26,890/
€29,190
Engines: 1.6 HDI, 1.6 eHDI
Bodystyle: Compact MPV
Plus points: Popular with
families for its blend of room and equipment. What a great
1.6-litre diesel.
Minus points: Despite everything it runs the risk of losing
more than average value as a trade-in.
Best buy: 1.6 HDi
Final answer: Yes, but only by a whisker.
Brochure Request Hotline: 1800 3428 00 (1800 FIAT 00)
www.fiat.ie
C5
Panda
C-Zero
500/500C
Engines: 1.6 HDi 2.0 HDi
Bodystyle: 5dr. Hatchback
and Estate.
Plus points: Big car, lots
of room, plenty of equipment, brilliant diesels.
Minus points: It still lacks real presence and is overshadowed on so many fronts by rivals such as the Mondeo or
Passat. Concerns over residuals.
Best Buy: 1.6HDi
Final answer: NO, it is just not on our shortlist.
Engines: 1.2.
Bodystyles: 3dr. / 5dr.
Hatchbacks
Plus points: Brand new city
car is much bigger and better.
As ever, Fiat have the equipment packed in. This has space and excellent petrol and
diesel engines. Good package.
Minus points: Too soon to say. Biggest obstacle is residual
value concern in long term but small Fiats do reasonably well.
Final answer: YES, it’s new, fresh and well worth a drive.
Prices start at: €35,900*
Engines: Electric
Bodystyles: 5 door hatchback
Plus points: Ideal for short
urban journeys as electricity cuts running costs significantly.
Minus points: Pricy but otherwise too early to say
Best Buy: Just one model.
Final answer: The jury is out!
* C-Zero price excludes Government tax rebate for Electric
Vehicles.
16,495
Engines: 1.2, TwinAir
Bodystyles: 3dr
Hatchback/Coupe
Plus points: Great fun,
loads of appeal. The little
500 and 500C have made
a real fashion statement, especially with the little two-cylinder
TwinAir engine.
Minus points: In danger of slipping a little in the fashion
stakes – that is the nature of things.
Best Buy: 1.2
Final answer: YES, it’s still a fun and fashionable buy.
Punto Evo
Readers Notice
Engines: 1.2, 1.3 JTDM, 1.4.
Bodystyles: 3dr. & 5dr. Hatch
Plus points: Evergreen Fiat,
regardless of attendant name
changes. Revision in March to
keep the the flag flying.
Combines room with looks and good engines. Good pricing.
Minus points: It’s moving on a bit now regardless of revamp;
slightly notchy gear shift. New model coming soon.
Best buy: 1.2
Final answer: NO, wait for the replacement model in a few
months.
new car.
76
MOTORSHOW 2012
FORD
Qubo
Engines: 1.3 JTDM.
Bodystyles: 5dr small
SUV
Plus points: It may be
unusual to look at but it is
highly practical. And well
priced
Minus points: Betrays its Fiorino van base; looks not to
everyone’s liking.
Final answer: YES, good price and practicality get it on
board.
Brochure Request: www.ford.ie
www.ford.ie
Bravo
Ka
Dobló
Fiesta
Engines: 1.6 JTDM.
Bodystyles: 5 dr Hatch
Plus points: Price, cabin,
fine diesel engines especially. Drives well.
Minus points: Buyers
have turned their backs on this. Huge residual fears.
Final answer: NO, totally outclassed by too many rivals.
Engines: 1.2, 1.3 TDCi.
Bodystyles: 3dr. hatchback
Plus points: Others come
and go; this keeps on trucking.
Big-hearted small car. Good
engines. Residuals.
Minus points: Soft gear change lets it down a bit.
Best buy: 1.2
Final answer: YES, frugal and fun car ideal for city motoring.
Engines: 1.6 Multijet
Bodystyles: MPV, 5 Seats.
Plus points: They’ve done
a good job toning down the
van look and it is comfortable enough. Drives well,
considering.
Minus points: Quite ordinary inside and functional.
Final answer: YES, still a big improvement on previous
version.
Engines: 1.25, 1.4,
1.4TDCi.
Bodystyles: 3dr./ 5dr.
Hatchback
Plus points: Best car in its
class on most fronts.
Under-rated by the socalled expert European judges. Looks smart, drives/handles
really well. Good engines.
Minus points: Cabin room a bit scarce; some of the plastics
in cabin let it down.
Best buy: 5dr 1.4-litre diesel
Final answer: YES, absolutely has to be at, or near, the top
of your shopping list.
Focus
ALWAYS DRIVE
RESPONSIBLY
77
Engines: 1.6, 1.6 TD, 2.0 TD.
Bodystyles: 3dr. and 5dr.
Hatchback / Saloon/ Wagon
(estate)
Plus points: New global car is
by far the best family hatch
they’ve made. Has the top chassis in its class. Lot of technology you don’t notice. Excellent diesels. Saloon and estate
measure up too.
Minus points: Maybe it doesn’t stand out the way the first one
did.
Best buy: 1.6 5-dr.
Final answer: YES, this is a must-look car for anyone thinking of buying.
MOTORSHOW 2012
Kuga
C-Max
Engines: 2.0 TDCi
Bodystyles: 5dr SUV
Plus points: Price reduction
last year made it far more
competitive. Certainly in top
three best looking ‘crossover’
SUVs on the road. Nicely judged package; good cabin and
extremely good handling. The 2-litre diesel is a cracker.
Minus points: It does lack real room in the cabin.
Final answer: NO, there will be a new model within 12
months.
Engines: 1.6 TDCi, 2.0
TDCi.
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Now a much
improved people carrier
with a good choice
between the Grand and five-seater versions. Surprisingly
good to drive, with lovely diesels and lashings of equipment.
Minus points: Grand is better than five-seater as latter lacks
sliding rear door.
Best buy: 1.6 TDCi
Final answer: YES, you’ll search a while to emulate this.
HONDA
Mondeo
Engines: 1.6 TDCi,
2.0TDCi
Bodystyles: Saloon/ 5
door Hatchback/Wagon
(estate)
Plus points: Still a class
act when it comes to handling and ride. The better of the
more recent upgrade. Engines appreciably better, good cabin,
big boot. Huge estate.
Minus points: Even with revision it is looking dated. New
global car in 2013.
Best buy: 2.0 TDCi
Final answer: YES, still makes your shortlist with plenty to
spare.
Dealerships In the Republic of Ireland: 20 Sales and
Service + 8 Authorised repairers (Service only contracts).
Brochure Hotline: 01 642 3100.
www.honda.ie
S-Max
Jazz
Galaxy
Civic
Engines: 1.6 TDCi, 2.0
TDCi
Bodystyle: MPV (7 seats)
Plus points: Has far more
room than you’d first think.
This wedges in between
Grand C-Max and Galaxy and is liked by families. Easy driver
with good diesels. Stylish with good residuals.
Minus points: Dilemma of buying a larger Galaxy for not that
much more.
Best buy: 2.0 TDCi
Final answer: YES, has a lot going for it.
Engines: 1.6 TDCi, 2.0 TDCi
Bodystyles: MPV, (7 seats)
Plus points: Big but agile,
roomy but versatile. This is
still one of the great people
carriers out there. Diesel
engines are excellent and complement a fine driving chassis.
Its last revision has helped it a lot.
Minus points: Suffers from same drawback as all sevenseaters – when they are fully occupied there is little room for
luggage.
Best buy: 2.0 TDCI
Final answer: YES, it is the one against which rivals test
themselves.
Engines: 1.2 iVTEC, 1.4
iVTEC
Bodystyles: 5dr. Hatch
Plus points: This just
keeps on going and going.
New and not so new versions retain a hugely loyal
following. Hence the excellent residuals. Good cabin.
Minus points: Diesel engine would make a big difference.
Note that a 1.2 Idie Start Band A version joins the range in the
spring.
Best buy: 1.2
Final answer: YES, this remains the real deal.
Engines: 1.4 i-VTEC,1.8 iVTEC, 2,2 iDTEC
Bodystyles: 3 dr. and 5-dr.
Hatchback, Saloon (incl.
Hybrid version)
Plus points: Brand new, fine
cabin, good equipment levels, fine engines including diesel.
Less dramatic design will appeal to more conservative buyers.
Minus points: It still needs a smaller diesel engine.
Best buy: 1.4 i-VTEC 5dr
Final answer: YES, a first-class option.
78
MOTORSHOW 2012
HYUNDAI
Insight
Prices start at: € 22,825*
Engines: 1.4 i-VTEC SE
Plus points: It has hybrid
technology, a good price,
and is of course economical.
Minus points: Hugely disappointing on looks, room and
performance. So far behind the likes of the Prius it is unreal;
poor rear visibility.
Best buy: Only one model available.
Final answer: NO, wait for updates in the spring.
*Price includes €1,500 refund from the Revenue Commissioners
Brochure Request: Email [email protected]
www.hyundai.ie
CR-Z
i10
Accord
i20
CR-V
ix20
Engines: 1.5i-VTEC
Bodystyles: 3 dr. Coupe
Plus points: One-off looks,
surprisingly good to drive
and plenty of pep.
Minus points: Cramped
and of limited interest.
Final answer: Yes, it has something different going for it.
Engines: 1.1, 1.2 petrol
Bodystyle: 5-door hatchback
Plus points: Handy little runaround, decent level of equipment and well priced. Fiveyear warranty/care package.
Minus points: Let down by under-powered engine.
Best buy: 1.1
Final answer: YES. Economical, and warranty is an important consideration.
Engines: 2.2 i-DTEC
Bodystyles: Saloon,
Estate.
Plus points: Revised version shows a marked
improvement. Lots of room,
fine diesel engine, great driver. Good non-German option for
families and fleets.
Minus points: Even with update it is dating a little considering rapid pace of change among rivals.
Final answer: YES, a refreshed package worth effort of test
drive.
Engines: 1.2
Bodystyles: 3 dr. and
5 dr. Hatch
Plus points: More than
decent supermini with lot
of equipment and it’s well
priced. Warranty
Minus points: Better-known rivals overshadow it.
Final answer: YES, but wait for the facelift model before the
summer.
Engines: 2.0 i-VTEC, 2.2iDTEC
Bodystyles: SUV 4WD 5dr
Plus points: Evergreen 'softroader' seems to get better
by the year. Clean driver, fine
engine and lovely cabin.
Minus points: Not the same level of demand for this sort of
car. Price. New model at the year-end.
Best buy: 2.2i-DTEC
Final answer: YES. Still an assured purchase.
Engines: 1.4 petrol, 1.6
petrol, 1.4 diesel
Bodystyles: Small MPV
Plus points: Handy micro
people carrier that drives particularly well and, of course,
has the five-year warranty. Good diesel.
Minus points: Cramped rear seat room.
Final answer: YES, this can do a job for you.
79
MOTORSHOW 2012
Santa Fe
i30
Engines: 2.0 CRDi, 2.2 CRDi
Bodystyles: 5dr. 4x4, SUV.
Plus points: Despite the antiSUV bias this remains a big,
well-equipped example of the
genre at its best. Good
diesels. Realistic 2WD and 4WD options.
Minus points: Handling suffers because of its size. Fall-off in
demand. Replacement model on the way.
Best buy: 2.2 (2WD)
Final answer: YES, you can’t ignore its claims for a test
drive, but replacement model due within a year.
Engines: 1.4 1.6 diesel,
Bodystyles: 5 dr.
Hatchback (Estate on the
way)
Plus points: Ticks most of
the small-family hatch
boxes. Really good diesel, lots of equipment.
Minus points: Hasn’t caught on here like it has in many other
countries, even though it shares platform with Kia cee'd. New
one on the way.
Best Buy: 1.6 Diesel Classic
Final answer: YES, wait for new model in March.
Veloster
JAGUAR
Engines: 1.6 GDI petrol
Bodystyles: Coupe.
Unusual 2+1 Door
Configuration
Plus points: Single rear
door a big help getting
smaller passengers into rear seats. Can carry four (two children in back). Design, cabin.
Minus points: Poor over rougher surfaces, engine lacks
real bite.
Final answer: Yes, it is a good value coupe.
www.jaguar.ie
i40 Saloon / Estate
XF
ix35
XJ
€26,495
Engines: 1.7 Diesel
Bodystyles: Saloon,
Estate
Plus points: Big car that
has moved Hyundai into
upmarket segment of family/fleet sector. Estate well worth a
try. Good diesel. Huge boot. Decent drive.
Minus points: Trails better handlers in class; no real pedigree in this market area.
Final answer: YES, this is in among the big boys now.
Engines: 2.2 D, 3.0 D,
5.0 V8,
Bodystyles: 4 dr Saloon
Plus points: Recent
update, addition of a
smaller diesel engine, great
performance and lower
price. Not a bad day’s work on an already outstanding car.
Minus points: Not too many, in fairness.
Best buy: 3.0D.
Final answer: YES, it has improved a lot – on what was a
pretty decent piece of work.
Engines: 1.7 D, 2.0 D
Plus points: Here’s a smart
crossover that does really
well on room and drive.
Smart diesel engine.
Minus points: Some key rivals look a good deal better.
Best buy: 1.7d 2WD
Final answer: YES, this should give you a decent return for
your money.
Engines: 3.0 Diesel, 5.0V8
Bodystyles: Large saloon
Plus points: Really eyecatching big executive saloon
in Jaguar’s brave new world of
design. Super cabin and the
diesel is excellent. Loads of equipment.
Minus points: Not many buying at this level unfortunately.
Best buy: 3.0 Diesel
Final answer: Yes, it is a front-runner for your money.
80
MOTORSHOW 2012
Grand Cherokee
XK Coupe /
Convertible
JEEP
KIA
Brochure Request Hotline: 1800 505 337 – (1800 50 JEEP)
Brochure Request: 01 4601288
www.jeep.ie
www.kiamotors.ie
Compass
Picanto
Engines: 2.2 CRD
Plus points: They’ve given
this a serious going-over so
it is a much better proposition now. High levels of
equipment. Price.
Minus points: Diesel not great. Lacks driving edge of any
sort to compete with key rivals. Doesn’t look great either.
Final answer: YES, Impressive despite serious competition
around.
Engines: 1.0
Plus points: New and
fresh, this is an attractive
little run-around.
Surprisingly roomy. Sevenyear warranty.
Minus points: Can be a bit of road/tyre boom in the cabin.
Final answer: YES, for city driving this is one of a handful to
look at.
Wrangler
Rio
Engines: 2.8 TD
Bodystyles: 4dr.
Plus points: Lots of heritage
keeps this going in the nostalgia stakes. Bit of fun.
Reasonable diesel.
Minus points: Little room for nostalgia these days.
Bit irrelevant.
Final answer: NO, it hasn’t enough going for it.
Engines: 1.25 petrol, 1.4 D
Bodystyles: Hatchback and
Saloon.
Plus points: Continental
Irish Car of the Year for
obvious reasons. It has executive car equipment, drives surprisingly well,
and has a seven-year warranty.
Minus points: Seriously colour sensitive –
can look dowdy in silver, much better in red.
Best buy: 1.4 EX Hatchback.
Final answer: YES, it earns the right for consideration.
81
Engines: 3.0 CRD
Plus Points: Impressive and
powerful on and off the road.
Lot of equipment and well
priced. Nice engine.
Minus Points: Has lost some profile in the market and few
want a big SUV these days.
Final answer: YES. It refuses to take a back seat to rivals
and deserves comparison.
€130,885
Engines: 5.0 V8.
Bodystyles: 2dr. Coupe /
Convertible
Plus points: Outstanding
performer – particularly from R version. Insight into what can be
done.
Minus points: Cabrio lags the Coupe for drive and handling.
Thirsty petrols would exhaust even a TD’s pension.
Final answer: NO, new model in development.
MOTORSHOW 2012
Sorento
Venga
Engines: 2.2 CRDi
Bodystyles: SUV 4x4 5dr.
Plus points: Has built good
reputation as one of the better
large SUVs. Two-wheel drive
option makes sense.
Equipment, warranty. Good diesel. Price key.
Minus points: These SUVs not in same demand any more.
Best buy: EX 2.2CRDi
Final answer: YES, it’s a really good package.
Engines: 1.4LX Diesel
Bodystyles: MPV hatch
Plus points: Compact and
tidy in everything. Lots of
equipment and mean 1.4litre diesel. Seven-year
warranty.
Minus points: It’s really quite cramped and the miserly
engine runs out of puff too soon.
Final answer: Yes, still worth a test drive.
cee'd
LAND ROVER
Engines: 1.6 diesel
Bodystyles: 3dr., 5dr.
Hatchback, Sporty Wagon.
Plus points: Understated
but highly practical family
car. Well priced, first-class
drive (especially the estate), cabin, seven-year warranty.
Minus points: Hatch not a patch on the estate. New model
on the way in the summer.
Best Buy: Only one model available.
Final answer: NO. Wait for the new model arriving this summer.
www.landrover.ie
Soul
Freelander 2
Sportage
Discovery 4
Engines: 1.6 Diesel
Bodystyles: Hatch / Estate
Plus points: Radical
crossover gets a makeover
to keep it fresh and will be
here later in year. A different take on motoring. Warranty.
Minus points: Initial enthusiasm has waned a little. There’s a
revision coming in February.
Final answer: Yes, value for money, fun – but wait for update.
Engines: 2.2D.
Bodystyles: 4x4 SUV 5 dr
Plus points: Excellent offroad; stop/start technology
helps on economy. Diesel
engine.
Minus points: Can’t shake
concerns over residual values and reliability.
Best buy: 2.2 TD4
Final answer: YES, it stays in the fold, as much for its 4x4
ability in winter months as anything else.
Engines: 1.7D, 2.0D
Bodystyle: SUV 4x4 (5dr.)
Plus points: This is an
example of what the modern
SUV can look like and do.
Good to drive, lovely cabin,
decent engine – and that warranty.
Price.
Minus points: Not that assured over poorer surfaces. Pillars
and design at rear impact on visibility.
Best buy: 2.0D
Final answer: YES, this is the real thing.
Prices start at: 65,280
Engines: 3.0 TD V6
Bodystyles: 4x4 SUV 5dr,
5/7seats
Plus points: Huge piece of
machinery with a lot of equipment and excellent off-road
credentials.
Great diesel engine. Cabin much improved.
Minus points: Ghosts of past unreliabilities still haunt it. And
big SUVs are not in much demand these days.
Final answer: YES, it is still worth a test drive.
82
MOTORSHOW 2012
Range Rover
Evoque
LEXUS
€43,240
Engines: TD4, SD4,
2.0 S1
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. / Coupe
Plus points: Courageous
new design sets the smallest Range Rover to date apart.
Driving dynamics up there with the best. Huge appeal and
fine diesel engine. Price. 2WD option.
Minus Points: Design is not to everyone’s liking.
Best buy: 4wd Pure SD4
Final answer: YES, this is one of those ‘musts’ to drive.
Brochure Request Hotline:1850 430 200
www.lexus.ie
Range Rover Sport
Engines: 1.8 WT-i
Bodystyles: 5 door
Plus points: Not alone is it
the first executive compact
with full hybrid, it is a smart
driver as well. Affordable (well
it is below the €30,000 mark), well equipped, hybrid frugality.
Wonderful seats!
Minus points: Rear is a bit cramped.
Final answer: YES, hybrid and pzazz go hand in hand here.
*Includes €1,500 refund from the Revenue Commissioners.
Range Rover
IS 200d/250
Engines: 4.4 TD V8,
5.0 V8
Bodystyles: 4x4, SUV.
Plus points: Luxury on
four wheels; air suspension, super cabin, excellent
diesel.
Minus points: Price. Perception of excess.
New model on the way within a year.
Best buy: 4.4 TDV8
Final answer: NO, Wait for the new model.
€44,110
Engines: 2.5 V6, 2.2d
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Price, hybrid
technology, better driver than
it is given credit for, Always a
rival for the BMW 3-Series, Audi A4 and Mercedes C-Class.
Minus points: Diesel let down by poor performance in sixth
gear. Bit overshadowed by German rivals.
Best buy: IS220d
Final answer: YES, Superbly reliable and understated.
IS-F
Readers Notice
Engines: 5.0 V8
Bodystyles: 4 Dr. Saloon
Plus points: Big performance.
Startling acceleration and
power.
Minus points: Only for Lotto
winners.
Best buy: Just one model.
Final answer: NO, great performance but not realistic.
new car.
83
CT 200h
Engines: 3.0TD V6, 5.0 V8
Bodystyles: 4x4, SUV
Plus points: Lashings of
performance; good cabin
room, equipment, fine
diesel.
Price. Very desirable.
Minus points: Amazingly hard to find fault with it.
Best buy: 3.0TD
Final answer: YES, a great favourite.
MOTORSHOW 2012
RX
MAZDA
Engines: 3.5. 3.3 Hybrid
Bodystyles: SUV 5dr.
Plus points: Quality of
hybrid technology often
overlooked. Plenty of
equipment.
Minus points: Dated looking now; lack of a diesel for Irish
market and poor off-road ability.
Best buy: RX 2WD 350 entry level.
Final answer: YES, on its hybrid merits.
www.mazda.ie
LS 460
Mazda2
Engines: 4.6 V8
Bodystyles: 4 Dr. Saloon
Plus points: Seamlessly
smooth large executive
saloon with so much equipment and technology.
Minus points: Price, trails key rivals on handling.
Final answer: YES, it is a testament to top-class engineering.
Engines: 1.3
Bodystyles: 3 door, 5 Door
Plus points: Effervescent little
supermini benefits from accumulated upgrades over the
years.
Minus points: Small cabin/boot, lack of overall impact.
Final answer: YES, Still a serious runner for your money.
LS 600h/ LS 600h L
Mazda3
€190,820
Engines: 5.0 Hybrid
Bodystyles: 4 Dr. saloon
Plus points: 600h - as
green as a big car can get
these days.
600h L - Limousine luxury and legroom
Best buy: Just one model in each.
Final answer: YES, if you can afford a cars like these.
Engines: 1.6, 1.6 D.
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5 dr
Plus points: Heavily
revised for this year with
more styling and equipment keeping it fresh. New
1.6-litre diesel.
Minus points: Lacks cabin space and handling can let it
down.
Best buy:1.6 diesel
Final answer: YES, it is better placed now to contend for a
place on your buying list.
Mazda5
Motor Tax Rates 2012
A
O – 120g:
€160
C
140g – 155g:
€330
B
D
E
F
G
120g – 140g:
155g – 170g:
170g – 190g:
190g – 225g:
>225g:
Engines: 1.6 diesel
Bodystyles: MPV (7 Seats)
Plus points: Makes a decent
attempt to accommodate a
family; good equipment levels,
fine diesel.
Minus points: Just hasn’t made breakthrough and so lacks
recognition factor – vital ingredients on the forecourts.
Final answer: YES, but mainly because it’s new.
€225
€481
€677
€1,129
€2,258
84
MOTORSHOW 2012
C-Class
Mazda6
Engines: 2.0 petrol, 2.2D
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5dr.
Hatchback, Estate.
Plus points: Excellent well
put together big-family
saloon with a classy cabin;
diesel engine; huge boot, fine styling. Impressive package.
Minus points: Somehow manages to come across as less
than the sum of its excellent parts. New model within a year.
Best buy: 2.0D Saloon Executive
Final answer: YES, a far better car than is generally recognised.
Engines: 1.8, petrol 3.0
petrol, 3.5 petrol, 6.2 petrol.
2.2 CDi, 2.5 CDi, 3.0 CDi, 6.3
(AMG).
Bodystyles: Saloon, Estate.
Plus points: Clever choice/
mix of traditional (Classic/Elegance) and modern (Avantgarde/
Sport) models. Recent update. Fine diesels; broad spread of
equipment.
Minus points: Definitely trails Audi A4 and BMW 3-series on
handling. Dating a bit despite revisions.
Best Buy: 2.2 CDi Saloon
Final answer: YES, it is an impressive overall package.
MERCEDES-BENZ
Engines: 1.8, 2.5, 3.5, 6.3
(AMG),2.2 CDi, 2.5 CDi
Plus points: It looks very
smart and not over aggressive, but elegantly sleek.
Carries with it the strong safety credentials of the C saloon.
Minus Points: Rear headroom a victim of roof line styling.
Best buy: 2.2 CDi
Final answer: YES.
www.mercedes-benz.ie
A Class
E-Class
B Class
E-Class Coupe/
Cabriolet
Engines: 1.5, 1.7, 2.0,
2.0CDI
Bodystyles: 5dr.
Hatchback & 3dr. Coupe.
Plus points: One of the
best value cars you’ll come
across. They’ve had a real go here with lots of space and
equipment.
Minus points: The larger B-Class steals some of its thunder.
Still not seen for what it is: a compact executive family car.
Best buy: 160 CDi.
Final answer: YES. Make a special note to test drive it.
Engines: 1.8, 2.5, 3.5, 5.5,
6.2 (AMG), 2.2CDi,
3.0CDi,
Bodystyles: Saloon,
Estate.
Plus points: Excellent
cabin and some grand
diesels. This is a big step forward. Luxury feel. Price. Huge
estate. One of the more impressive ranges.
Minus points: Just a bit behind the BMW 5-series on sporty
handling.
Best buy: 2.2Cdi
Final answer: YES, this is one of three or you have to drive
in this segment.
Engines: 1.6 petrol, 1.6 D,
1.8 D
Bodystyles: 5dr. Hatchback /
Compact MPV.
Plus points: Plenty of room
here and they didn’t spare the
equipment. Competitive price; excellent diesel.
Minus points: Lacks recognition factor; poorer than rivals on
interior/seating flexibility.
Best buy: 180 CDi.
Final answer: YES, This is a lot of car for the money.
€53,900
Engines: 2.0, 2.5, 3.5, 5.0,
2.2 CDi, 2.5 CDi, 3.5 CDi
Bodystyles: 2dr. Coupe.
Plus points: Both versions
look the part. Engines a big plus. Luxury fit out – at a good
price. Coupe beats the cabrio.
Minus points: Rougher roads and surfaces unearth suspension shortcomings.
Best buy: 2.5CDI
Final answer: YES, not too many large luxury motors compete as well at this level.
85
C-Class Coupe
MOTORSHOW 2012
CLS
SLK
CL
GL
S Class
M-Class
SL
Viano
Engines: 1.8
Bodystyles: Roadster /
Cabriolet
Plus points: Classic looks
and hugely improved performance. Good peppy engine. Lot
of technology.
Minus points: Handling could be a little better.
Best buy: For all its glitz and glamour, the cabin is a bit dull.
Final answer: YES, it is a classic of its kind.
Engines: 2.2CDI, 3.0CDI,
3.5, 4.7, 5.5 (AMG)
Bodystyles: 4 Door Coupe
Plus points: New car with
old graces mixed into a
fairly sumptuous executive
package. Grand diesels. Lotys of room.
Minus points: Not as ‘nostalgic’ to look at. Still have to duck
and dive to get into back seats.
Best buy: 3.0 CDi
Final answer: YES, it continues to set the pace as a 4dr
coupe.
Engines: 5.4, 5.5. 6.0 &
6.2 (AMG).
Bodystyles: 2dr. Coupe.
Plus points: Powerful
prestige coupe comes with
a good price tag. Real luxury this. High performance.
Minus points: Take a look at the price. Gulp!
Best buy: CL500
Final answer: YES, off with you Mr/Mrs Millionaire.
Engines: 3.0 petrol, 4.7CDI,
5.5 CDI
Bodystyles: SUV
Plus points: Massive sevenseater; off-road technology.
And it is good on the tarmac.
7-GTronic transmission, technology, diesels.
Minus points: Seriously over-the-top for recessionary times.
Best Buy: 3.0 CDi
Final answer: NO, new model by the year end.
Engines: 3.0, 3.5, 4.7,
5.5(388 & 517 bhp), 6.0 &
6.2(AMG), 3.0Cdi
Bodystyles: Saloon.
Plus points: Major revision
smartens it up a lot.
Remains one of great cars around. Manages to retain remarkable agility for such a large car. Good residuals.
Minus points: No doubt the BMW 7-series beats it on handling and ride. Watch out for interior colour combinations.
New model arriving in one year.
Best buy: 3.2Cdi
Final answer: YES, an example of motoring at the top of the
league.
Engines: 3.5, 2.2 CDI,
3.0CDI,
Bodystyles: SUV 4x4 5dr.
Plus points: Big SUV
combines well as an offroader and tarmac traveller.
Minus points: New one on way. Poor demand for this size of
SUV.
Best buy: 3.5CDi
Final answer: NO, hold on for new one this spring.
Engines: 3.5, 5.5 (388 & 517
bhp), 6.0 (AMG).
Bodystyles: 2dr. Cabrio.
Plus points: Fun and frolics
if money is no problem.
Lovely roadster with powerhouse performance to match. Looks great. Harks back to the
good times.
Minus points: Insanely thirsty petrols act as severe reality
check.
Best buy: 350
Final answer: YES, but must be the new model here in April.
Engines: 2.2 CDI, 3.0 CDI
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Very spacious.
Seating arrangement options.
Minus Points: Van based and
seat have to be removed to
maximise versatility.
Best buy: 2.2 CDi (or if carrying full compliment and driving a
lot - go for 3.0 CDi.
86
MOTORSHOW 2012
MINI
Countryman
Engines: 1.6
Bodystyles: Compact SUV
style
Plus points: A four-door MINI
family car/crossover with reasonable room and a bit of real
muscle in the looks. Well priced.
Minus points: It’s niche and maybe a tad cramped in cabin
for most families.
Best Buy: 1.6 Final answer: YES, has a lot going for it.
Final answer: YES, it is unique and practical.
www.mini.ie
Coupé
Engines: 1.6, 1.4D
Bodystyles: 3 and 5-dr
Clubman (estate).
Plus points: Buyers thankful
of extra room. Taut MINI drive
comes through in abundance.
Lots of energy in the engines and chassis.
Minus points: Roadside rear door – its key feature – can be
awkward to manage and does take from it.
Best Buy: Mini Cooper D Clubman
Final answer: YES, if you’re looking for something different.
Hatchback
Roadster
Engines: 1.6, 1.4D
Bodystyles: 2-dr, Cabrio.
Plus points: Big secret of
this small car is ceaseless
change and updating.
Really excellent drive;
loads of equipment. Super residuals.
Minus points: That large central speedo can be a real eyesore. Tiny boot.
Best Buy: New Mini One
Final answer: YES, there’s no arguing with the popularity and
residual values.
Engines: 1.6, 2.0D
Bodystyles: Convertible
Plus points: Better looking than convertible. More
sporty. A real roadster.
Minus points: Flat design
means it doesn’t attract
much attention so it has to appeal on build and price.
Best Buy: Mini Cooper Roadster (122bhp).
Final answer: Back in contention. Sportback hatch better
looking. Great longevity.
Convertible
Readers Notice
Engines: 1.6 16V
Bodystyles: Covertible
Plus points: Plenty of power
and you can drop the roof if
you like. Attractive mixture of
style and sizzle.
Minus points: Poor rear room - and good luck with the
weather.
Best buy: Convertible
Final answer: Yes, touch of real magic about this.
new car.
87
Clubman
Engines: 1.6 (in choice of
90, 135, or 155 kW) and
2.0 Litre SD
Bodystyles: 3-door coupe.
Plus Points: Another new
shape for the ever expanding range. Fairly daring looks, and as you’d expect, the taut
handling and excellent diesel of the core product.
Minus Points: You either love or hate that shape.
Best Buy: 1.6 Cooper Coupe (90 Kw) SD
Final Answer: YES, this is another ‘first’ worth a big test
drive.
MOTORSHOW 2012
ASX
MITSUBISHI
Engines: 1.6 petrol, 1.8 diesel
Bodystyles: Crossover
Plus points: Well-set up
crossover. Nice cabin and a
good driving feel. Looks well.
Diesel the top engine.
Minus points: Late arrival means it hasn’t got a real foothold
and rivals have cornered whatever market there is.
Final answer: YES, engineering and drive make it onto our
test list.
Brochure Request Hotline: 1890 41 51 61
www.mitsubishi-motors.ie
i-MIEV
Outlander
Colt
Pajero
Prices start at: €29,474*
Engines: Electric
Plus points: Ideal for short
urban journeys as electricity cuts running costs significantly. Good to drive.
Minus points: Limit of range you can drive it between
charges. Cost.
Final answer: The jury remains out on this one.
* Retail price includes Government tax rebate for Electric Vehicles.
Engines: 2.2 DiD
Bodystyles: SUV (7 Seats)
Plus points: Really decent
SUV with seven seats. Price.
Touch of class about this,
nicely laid out cabin and powerful 2.2 litre diesel.
Minus points: Not much demand for this sort of motor these
days.
Final answer: YES, It is good value for money now.
Engines: 1.1, 1.3
Bodystyles: 5 door.
Plus points: One of the
best superminis you’ll find
but it is underrated. Grand
cabin. Price.
Minus points: Strangely subdued demand for it on secondhand market. Residuals.
Best buy: 1.1 L 5-Dr Classic
Final answer: YES, here’s a bit of a hidden gem.
Engines: 3.2 diesel
Bodystyles: 7 seater
Plus points: They’ve
given it a fair old update
and upgrade. Longevity on
and off road.
Minus points: Who needs
one these days? Pricey
Final answer: Yes, this is still one of the best in contention for
your money.
Lancer
Engines: 1.8 diesel
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5Dr
hatchback.
Plus points: Different proposition now it has a diesel.
Lancers go forever. Price,
reliability.
Minus points: Saloon is rather dull to look at – a real no-no
in the age of sharp design.
Final answer: YES, a car for the long run in every sense.
ALWAYS DRIVE
RESPONSIBLY
88
MOTORSHOW 2012
Note
NISSAN
www.nissan.ie
Pixo
Qashqai / Qashqai + 2
Micra
X-Trail
Juke
Murano
Engines: 1.0
Bodystyles: Hatch
Plus points: Low-price city
car that drives quite well.
Not as basic as you might
expect.
Minus points: Hasn’t the ‘name’ of better-known rivals.
Final answer: Yes, practicality and price earn it a place on
your list.
€25,045
Engines: 1.6, 1.5 D, 1.6 D
Bodystyles: Hatchback/SUV
5/7 seats
Plus points: So popular there
was a waiting list for it. Looks
better now since update and has more equipment. Slick mix
of hatch/urban people carrier with some DNA of a SUV. Good
diesel; can have 4x2 and 4x4 options.
Minus points: For some reasons the seven-seater is not
nearly as good as the one with five.
Best Buy: 1.5 D. SE
Final answer: YES, get in line there and prepare for your test
drive.
Engines: 1.2
Plus points: This is much
roomier and well able for
rougher roads and longer
journeys. Retains the
quintessential Micra look. Versatile.
Minus points: Bit of cabin noise over rougher surfaces.
Final answer: YES, keeps on tradition of an all-time great.
Engines: 2.0D.
Bodystyles: SUV 4x4 5Dr.
Plus points: Super slick
operator with a lot of
punch in the kid glove.
Updated version marks a
significant improvement.
Lot of cabin space, excellent diesel, lashings of technology.
Minus points: Really looks far too much like its predecessor.
Final answer: YES, forget the looks – this is a first-class
machine.
Engines: 1.6, 1.5 D
Bodystyles: 5 door SUV
Plus points: Daring ‘sawnoff’ Qashqai looks, great interior, good pricing and what a
breath of fresh air.
Minus points: You want to look at that for the next three
years? Some do, some DON’T.
Best Buy: 1.5D
Final answer: YES, Sure you would have to see what it is
like.
Engines: 2.5 diesel
Bodystyles: SUV
Plus points: Goes like a
bomb and that diesel engine is
something. Laden with equipment; handles sharp and true.
Minus points: Few want this sort of car any more.
Final answer: NO, it is just too far away for most people.
89
Engines: 1.4, 1.6, 1.5 Diesel.
Bodystyles: SUV
Plus points: Most understated car that just keeps on
going. Everything about it is
straightforward: easy to drive,
clean lines in the cabin, decent equipment, good diesel.
Minus points: Too much plastic across the dash. Quite boring looks really.
Best Buy: 1.5 D. SXE
Final answer: YES, sound buy-in to a car that will go forever.
MOTORSHOW 2012
370Z Coupe/
Roadster
Meriva
Prices start at:
€57,995/61,195
Engines: 3.7V6
Bodystyles: 2 door coupe
Plus points: Supercar performance; Out of the blocks
like a rocket. Can match the best on acceleration and
cornering.
Minus points: Buying and running this could be prohibitive.
Final answer: NO, costs rule it out.
Engines: 1.4i, 1.3 CDTi,
1.7CDTi.,
Bodystyles: Small MPV
Plus points: Builds on previous car’s reputation as being
the best little driver in its niche
segment. Clever use of seating flexibility system.
Minus points: Opel have not exactly been proclaiming its
merits from the rooftops here.
Best Buy: 1.3 CDTi
Final answer: YES, a good buy for a family.
Nissan Leaf
Corsa
Engines: Electric motor
Bodystyles: Hatchback
Plus points: Proves that
families can be accommodated in an electric car. Is
roomy and ‘ordinary’ looking
and a realistic option. That’s
what made it a multi-award
winner last year.
Minus points: Relatively few have bought it despite a massive
amount of public exposure. Range anxiety no doubt a factor.
Best Buy: Hatchback
Final answer: YES, it does what it says.
*Price excludes Government tax rebate for Electric Vehicles.
Engines: 1.0i, 1.2i, 1.4i,
1.3 CDTi
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr Hatch
Plus points: Here’s a supermini that deserves more of the
limelight. Bigger and better than
what was a really good car. Roomier and smarter. Fine diesel.
Minus points: Outgunned by likes of Kia and Hyundai rivals
on warranty.
Best Buy: 1.2. Life 5-dr.
Final answer: YES, this is a supermini with something to
offer.
Astra
OPEL
Engines: 1.4, 1.6, 1.3CDTi,
1.7CDTi, 2.0 CDTi
Bodystyles: 3/ 5dr.
Hatchback, Coupe/Cabrio
& Estate.
Plus points: Much bigger
car than many rivals.
Handles really well and looks smart. Good choice of diesels.
Minus points: We feel it suffers from poor name of
predecessor.
Best Buy: 1.3 CDTi
Final answer: YES, this is a well put together alternative.
www.opel.ie
Agila
Zafira
Engines: 1.0i, 1.2i
Bodystyles: 5dr Hatchback
Plus points: Plenty of room
because it is tall and quite
comfortable.
Minus points: Not as outrageous looking as predecessor but it is still a bit of an acquired
taste.
Best Buy: 1.2i
Final answer: YES, it can carry four at a price.
90
Engines: 1.4i, 1.7 CDTi,
2.0 CDTI.
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: New one has a
bigger cabin and even more
seating flexibility. That keeps it
ahead of the family MPV pack. Not a bad driver either. Tried
and tested formula.
Minus points: Growing preference for more daring people
carriers/crossovers such as Nissan Qashqai. New version is
pricey.
Best Buy: 1.7 CDTi
Final answer: YES, but make sure it is the brand new one.
Old one really dated now.
MOTORSHOW 2012
308 / 308CC
Insignia
€34,665
Engines: 1.6 HDi
Bodystyles: 5 Door, Coupe
Cabriolet
Plus points: Sharp handling,
good diesel. Small family
hatch has, like a good wine, improved with age.
Minus points: Biggest criticism is its fairly drab looks. And it
is in tough company with the likes of the VW Golf and Toyota
Auris vying for buyers.
Final answer: YES, a decent compact family hatchback.
Engines: 1.4,1.4i, 2.8i,
2.0CDTI
Bodystyles: Saloon, 5dr.
Hatchback + Estate.
Plus points: It is a big car
for the money and they’ve
packed in the equipment. Lots of engine choice.
Minus points: Residual concerns. Doesn’t add up to the sum
of its parts. Updates on the way.
Best Buy: 2.0 CDTI
Final answer: YES, but wait for the updates.
PEUGEOT
Engines: 1.6HDI
Bodystyles: MPV Crossover
Plus points: Some cars feel
‘right’ from the start. This is
one of them. Innovative, easyto-use and drive. And a lovely
diesel. Price. Hybrid diesel version being added in April.
Minus points: Few minor quibbles but this is going well.
Final answer: YES, lots of reasons to take time out for a test
drive.
Brochure Request: www.peugeot.ie
www.peugeot.ie
107
508 / 508SW
Engines: 1.0
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr.
Minicar/Citycar
Plus points: Like the
Toyota Aygo and Citroen
C1, a little city car with a
Peugeot badge. And like the other two it is economical and
easy to drive around town.
Minus points: Noise in the cabin and tiny boot.
Final answer: YES, but wait for the 2012 facelift.
€29,365
Engines: 1.6 HDI, 1.6
eHDI, 2.0 HDI
Bodystyles: Saloon,
Station Wagon
Plus points: Fresh, bold
design, roomy and wellpriced. This amalgam of old 407 and 605 has immediately
impacted as a serious large-family saloon and estate. The latter is worth a special look.
Minus points: Not that many except the lustre wears off cars
in this segment terribly quickly.
Best Buy: 1.6HDi
Final answer: YES, this was worth waiting for.
207 / 207CC / 207SW
RCZ
€27,480 / €19,770
Engines: 1.4, 1.6, 1.4HDi,
1.6 HDi
Bodystyles: 3 Dr./ 5 Dr.
Hatchback; Coupe Cabrio,
Sky Wagon (SW)
Plus points: One of the top superminis. Well regarded on
secondhand market. Nice SW version and diesels are excellent.
Minus points: Going to be replaced in the summer. So many
rivals have three-year warranty.
Best Buy: 1.4 HDI
Final answer: NO, wait for the new 208 – or drive a phenomenal bargain on this.
Engines: 2.0HDI
Bodystyles: 2dr coupe
Plus points: In-your-face
looks. Dubbed world’s most
beautiful car. Twin-curve roof,
lively engines. Takes Peugeot
into new territory.
Minus points: Lacks the magic and low price (such as the
old Hyundai Coupe) needed to compete with likes of Audi’s
TT. Suspension too harsh on Irish roads.
Best Buy: 2.0 HDI
Final answer: YES, but we had to think long and hard about
it. Marginal call.
91
3008
MOTORSHOW 2012
Megane Coupe/
C abriol et
5008
Engines: 1.6 HDI
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Outstanding
mix of space, comfort,
equipment and design.
Easily the most attractive
all round package in the mid-size people carrier market.
Minus points: Not too many but there is muted demand for
this genre now. Pity.
Final answer: Yes, ideal buy for a family with a few euro to
spend.
32,400
Engines: 1.5DCi
Bodystyles: Coupe Cabriolet
Plus points: With stunning
looks and brilliant handling,
this tops the looks league in Renault.
Minus points: It may sound like carping but we have to highlight concerns over future trade-in values.
Best Buy: 1.5DCi
Final answer: YES, if you want to treat yourself without
breaking the bank.
Renault Fluence
RENAULT
Engines: 1.5DCi
Bodystyles: 4 door
Plus points: Slots in between
Megane and Laguna. Well
equipped. Electric version
adds diversity to range.
Minus points: Updated model within a year.
Final answer: YES, but it is in for a closer scrutiny over the
next year.
Brochure Request: www.renault.ie
www.renault.ie
Clio
Scenic / Grand
Scenic
Engines: 1.2 16 V, 1.5 DCi
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr.
Hatchback, Estate.
Plus points: Neat, perky
and standing the test of
time better than most.
Clean driver, good price.
Minus points: Cabin small compared with closest competitors. Bit dated. Residuals. New model within a year.
Best Buy: 1.2
Final Answer: YES, always popular.
€30,390
Engines: 1.5 DCi,
Bodystyles: MPV (5 Dr.)
5/7 Seats
Plus points: Can’t ever
disregard the Scenic, ordinary or Grand, with its spread of
room, price, equipment and a great diesel.
Minus points: Serious rivals like the Ford C-Max and Toyota
Verso. New model in late March.
Final answer: YES, but wait for updated model in March.
Megane/
Grand Megane
Laguna
Engines: 1.5 DCi, 2.0 DCi,
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. Hatchback,
Tourer.
Plus points: Few cars have
attracted such an effort from
Renault to produce a motor
with such high equipment levels, room, space and looks.
Diesels are really good. Price.
Minus points: Buying public has not been tempted in sufficient quantity. And that big spells trouble for residuals.
Best Buy: 1.5CDi
Final answer: YES, it is a big, comfortable car.
€20,690
Engines: 1.5DCi
Bodystyles: 3/5dr. Hatch,
Tourer (estate).
Plus points: Big seller, well
priced, crackling engines, sharp and taut suspension. Coupe
is a real stunner. Equipment.
Minus points: Some fears over residual values. Cramped
enough cabin.
Final answer: YES, it is priced and equipped to compete.
92
MOTORSHOW 2012
9-3 Convertible
Espace
Engines: 1.9 TtiD Linear
Bodystyles: Convertible.
Plus points: Popular drophead down the years, mainly
because it is a four-seater with
some charm.
Minus points: Poor boot space with roof down. Residuals.
Final answer: NO, because residual will be shot now.
Engines: 2.0 DCi,
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Spacious and
comfortable people carrier
with a lot of equipment and
a fine diesel. Still impressive.
Minus points: Little demand for such big motors; keen rivalry.
Final answer: Yes, you have to consider it.
SAAB
Engines: 2.0TtiD.
Bodystyles: Saloon.
Plus points: Good equipment
levels and Saab safety to the
fore. Decent diesel engine.
Minus points: Sadly, the last
of the Saab line. Cabin is a bit dull as is the handling.
www.saab.ie
SEAT
SPECIAL NOTE:
After a turbulent year, Saab is now discontinued,
though there are cars still in the system and with
dealers. Future unavailability of new Saab cars will
not affect the availability of parts or accessories
going forward.
Brochure Request: www.seat.ie
www.seat.ie
9-3 Saloon
Ibiza
Engines: 1.9TtiD.
Bodystyles: Saloon.
Plus points: 9-3 is still a
decent motor with a good
1.9 diesel engine and three
power options.
Minus points: Off the pace set by BMW 3-series, Audi A4 or
Mercedes C-Class.
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 TSI, 1.4 TSI
1.2 TDi, 1.6 TDi
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr. Hatch.
Plus points: Excellent supermini doesn’t get much of the
public limelight, yet sells well.
Engines, cabin room and looks as well as keen pricing. Lots
of Ibizas out there. Good secondhand demand.
Minus points: Like SEAT generally here, it needs a higher
profile.
Best Buy: 1.2 5.Dr.
Final answer: NO, new facelit in a few months.
93
9-5 Saloon
MOTORSHOW 2012
ŠKODA
Leon
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 TSI, 1.4,
1.6 TDi, 2.0 TDi
Bodystyles: 5 Door
Hatchback
Plus points: A different
sort of buy with lots of
drive, pace and style. Keeps its talents hidden. Advantage you.
Minus points: Poor legroom at the back is biggest letdown.
Needs far higher profile from distributors.
Best Buy: 1.6 Tdi
Final answer: YES, but all-new model in about a year.
www.skoda.ie
Fabia
Altea / Altea XL
20,840
Engines: 1.2 TSI, 1.6TDi
Bodystyles: 5 Dr.
Hatchback/ MPV
Plus points: Most unusual
cross between a hatchback
and people carrier. Acres of space; user-friendly touches all
over the place. Diesel engine.
Minus points: Design is a hate it or love it battle, with the former the more likely reaction. It is a ‘strong’ looking car that’s
not to everyone’s taste.
Best Buy: XL - 1.6 TDi
Final answer: NO, probably too extreme.
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 tsi, 1.6 TDi
Bodystyles: 3/5 Dr.
Hatchback/Estate.
Plus points: Highly capable
and likeable supermini with a
track record of consistent
performance in a cut-throat segment. Combi (estate) has
nearly as much room as a small-family car.
Minus points: Only real complaint is how quickly price rises
with a few extras that the likes of Kia is putting in as standard.
Best Buy: 1.2 Classic.
Final answer: YES, no hesitation in recommending this.
Exeo
Octavia
Engines: 2.0TDI
Bodystyles: 4dr saloon
Plus points: Great pricing
for something based on
Audi A4 platform. Room
and equipment are its big
selling points.
Minus points: All of which comes to nothing if no one knows
anything about it. Serious residual value reservations.
Final answer: NO. It is just too far off the buying public’s
radar.
Engines: 1.2 tsi, 1.4 tsi,
1.8 tsi, 1.6 TDi, 2.0TDi
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. Hatch,
Touring (estate).
Plus points: This isn’t a
top seller for nothing. It is
a really, really good car.
Big, big cabin gutsy engines, huge boot, decent price, equipment. 4x4 options.
Minus points: Price shoots up with addition of a few options.
Best Buy: 1.6 TDi
Final answer: YES, can’t afford to overlook this.
Alhambra
Roomster
Engines: 2.0TDi.
Plus points: Price compared
with its badge brothers, the
VW Sharan and Ford Galaxy,
puts it in pole position. Makes
a powerful argument. Spacious, big-family motor. 2-litre
diesels, loads of room.
Minus points: Hard to quibble with it – although demand is
really sluggish for this sort of motor now.
Final answer: YES, competes vigorously on price, space,
looks and engines.
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 tsi, 1.2 Tdi,
1.6 TDi
Bodystyles: MPV
Plus points: Cleverly packaged people carrier with flexible seating arrangements. Get
the 1.2-litre diesel – how frugal is that? Looks better since
update.
Minus points: It’s not a van but looks like one and that may
put some off.
Best Buy: 1.2TDi.
Final answer: YES, if you like it you love it.
94
MOTORSHOW 2012
Superb
Forester
Yeti
Legacy / Outback
Engines: 1.2ts, 1.6 TDi,
2.0TDi
Bodystyles: SUV/MPV
Plus points: Has grown
into a realistic option/rival
for likes of ‘crossover’
leader Nissan Qashqai. It has 4x2 and 4x4, good spread of
equipment and built like a small tank. Grows on you.
Minus points: Trails Kuga, Qashqai in the smart looks
department.
Best Buy: 1.6 TDi
Final answer: YES, this has an individual touch all of its own.
€42,495
Engines: 2.0 Boxer diesel
and Outback Estate
Plus points: Old Boxer transformed an already-fine driver
into an entity of real quality. Yes, there’s AWD there as well.
Minus points: Needs a price cut to make it really attractive to
broader audience.
Final answer: YES, no problem recommending this for a test.
SUBARU
SUZUKI
Brochure Request: www.subaru.ie
Brochure Request Hotline: [email protected]
www.suzuki.ie
www.subaru.ie
XV
Alto
Engines: 2.0 Boxer TD
Bodystyles: Compact
SUV/Crossover
Plus points: All-wheel drive.
Minus points: To early to
say.
Best buy: Just one model to start.
Final answer: YES, it is worth checking out.
Engines: 1.0
Bodystyles: 5 Door Hathback
Plus points: Smart little runabout-town, good levels of
equipment.
Minus points: Swamped by
better known rivals.
Final answer: YES, but wait for updated model in March.
95
Engines: 2.0 Boxer diesel.
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. SUV AWD
Plus points: Boxer saved the
Forester too. Now SUV/large
estate with AWD is a real
proposition. Understated
excellence.
Minus points: Dull, old-fashioned cabin. Exterior getting
dated.
Final answer: YES, still worth a look.
Engines: 1.4tsi, 1.8tsi, 1,6
TDi, 2.0TDi, 3.6 FSi
Bodystyles: Saloon,
Combi (estate)
Plus points: Few better
value cars. This is massive,
packed with safety and comfort equipment; fine engines.
Combi (estate) an exceptional piece of work. 4x4 options.
Minus points: Lacks bit of driving verve because it is so
solid.
Best Buy: 2.0TDi.
Final answer: YES, this will keep you going for years and
years.
MOTORSHOW 2012
Swift
TOYOTA
Engines: 1.2, 1.3
Bodystyles: 3/5Dr.
Hatchback
Plus points: Better than
before with lower-emission
engines, though it doesn’t
look that much different. Solid, sporty, good residuals.
Minus points: Engine uneven at idle sometimes. Too much
like old one.
Best Buy: 1.3GL 5-dr.
Final answer: YES, a fine example of what a supermini
should be.
Brochure Request: www.toyota.ie
www.toyota.ie
Splash
Aygo
Engines: 1.0 GL
Bodystyles: 5dr Hatch
Plus points: First cousin of
the Opel Agila, so it is tall
and roomy for a city car.
Minus points: Shocking
looking rev counter binnacle on dash a real put-off.
Final answer: YES, so long as you can live with that awful
binnacle.
Engines: 1.0 VVT-i
Bodystyle: 3/5dr. hatch.
Plus points: Because it has
a three-year warranty it has
an edge over its Citroen C1
and Peugeot 107 counterparts.
Minus points: Those looks are really gawky; tiny boot.
Best buy: Terra 5-door
Final answer: YES, but wait for 2012 facelift model.
SX4
iQ
Grand Vitara
Yaris
Engines: 1.5, 1.6, 2.0 D.
Bodystyles: 4 Dr. 5 Dr.
Hatchback and Saloon
Plus points: Big seller
here is the ability to go
from 2WD to 4WD at flick
of switch. That’s a major plus with our Big Freezes and
means you don’t have to buy a full-time, expensive 4x4.
Minus points: It is drab enough otherwise.
Best Buy: 1.5 GL.
Final answer: YES, all-wheel drive at a budget price.
Engines: 1.0 VVTi.
Bodystyle: Small hatchback.
Plus points: Impressive
small hatch that is frugal
and practical.
Minus points: Price for a
small car.
Final answer: Yes, Toyota credentials and practicality make
its case.
Engines: 1.9 GLX Diesel
Bodystyles: 5 Dr. SUV
Plus points: Stylish, neat,
reliable, comfortable and
always in demand. Excellent
piece of work and a fine
diesel.
Minus points: Cabin not as expansive as some rivals.
Getting on a bit now.
Final answer: YES, this is one of half-a-dozen you need to
look at.
Engines: 1.0, 1.33 Dual VVT-i,
1.4 D-4D
Bodystyles: 3dr./ 5dr. Hatch.
Plus Points: Latest model
ticks a lot of boxes. So many
people’s favourite, despite
latter day attacks on all fronts from rivals. Well finished,
smooth, roomier and high trade-in
values.
Minus points: Being beaten on three-year warranty by Kia
and Hyundai competitors.
Best buy: 1.0 5dr.
Final answer: YES, this is an obvious one.
96
MOTORSHOW 2012
Verso-S
Corolla
Urban Cruiser
Avensis
Auris Hybrid*
Prius
Engines: 1.33 Dual VVTi,
1.4 D-4D
Bodystyle: Hatch
Plus points: Good attempt
to meet urban driving
demand. Decent room,
nice diesel, handles well.
Minus points: Despite everything it lacks appeal.
Best buy: 1.4D4D
Final answer: YES. Purely on its Toyota credentials.
Engines: 1.6 VVT-i, 1.8VVTi,
2.0 D-4D, 2.2D-4D, 2.2 D-CAT
Bodystyles: Saloon /
Hatchback and Tourer (estate)
Plus points: Well priced;
they’ve really pushed up the
spec under latest revision, big cabin and boot, top engines
and a heritage of reliability gives it above average re-sale
status.
Minus points: The pace of change in its segment.
Best buy: 2.0 D4D saloon.
Final answer: YES, safe bet for the family or the fleet.
Engines: Hybrid
Bodystyles: Hatch
Plus points: First smallfamily hatch with hybrid
technology. Smooth, roomy
and efficient. Price for the
technology.
Minus points: Really lags – and moans - when you put the
foot down as CVT (Continuously Variable Transmission) tries
to meet accelerative demand.
Final answer: YES, this is an impressive piece of work.
Engines: 1.8 Hybrid
(Petrol/Battery)
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Hybrid side of
the story masks a lot about
this big car. For example it
has the same cabin space
as an Avensis. Technology and innovation. Price.
Minus points: Soft ride and unimpressive handling. Shines in
city but uses petrol engine most of time on longer drives.
Final answer: YES, but wait for updated models in the spring.
Auris
RAV-4
Engines: 1.33 VVT-i, 1.6
VVT-i, 1.4 D4D
Bodystyles: 3dr/5dr hatchback
Plus points: Well-built, solid
and deceptively roomy hatchback with that great 1.4D engine. Does the simple things well.
Residual values.
Minus points: Many rivals are far more attractive and less
dour to look at. And some beat the three-year warranty.
Best Buy: 1.4 D4D
Final answer: YES, how could you ignore what is effectively
a ‘Corolla’ hatch?
Engines: 2.0 VVT-i, 2.2D-4D,
2.2 D-CAT
Plus points: So easy to drive,
good room in cabin, excellent
diesel. Price.
Minus points: Rivals are beating it on cabin layout. Looking a
bit dated.
Best buy: 2.2 D-4D Luna
Final answer: YES, always one of the first on the shopping
list.
97
Engines: 1.33 VVT-i, 1.4 D4D.
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: It is easy to
overlook but this is a really big
saloon now. And it has one of
the best 1.4-litre diesel
engines you’ll find. Price.
Minus points: Just beginning to show its age a bit.
Best buy: 1.4 D4D
Final answer: YES, this is one of the most reliable smallfamily cars on the planet.
Engines: 1.33 VVT-i
Bodystyle: MPV 5 Seater
Plus Points: They’ve got it
right with plenty of room in
a relatively small frame.
Good range of equipment.
Minus Points: Looks mean a lot in this class and this lacks
that cutting edge design.
Final answer: YES, it is well thought out and unfussy.
MOTORSHOW 2012
Verso
Golf
Land Cruiser
Golf Plus
Engines: 1.2TSi, 1.4TSi,
2.0TSi, 1.6 TDI, 2.0 TDI,
Bodystyles: 3/5dr. Hatchback
- GTi, GTD, GolfR, and new
Cabrio.
Plus points: Buying this puts
you in the best Golf to date by a long way. Good spread of
petrol and diesel engines. Rock sold residual values - we Irish
love Golfs.
Minus points: Trails some key rivals on length of warranty – a
factor that is becoming increasingly important in the market place.
Best buy: 1.6 TDi 5 Dr.
Final answer: YES, you can’t buy a family hatch without running the rule over this. New model within a year.
Engines: 1.6, 2.0 D-4D
Bodystyle: MPV
Plus Points: One of the
easiest cars to drive, lovely
gear-change, good diesel,
plenty of room, quiet cabin.
Minus Points: Newer rivals have left the cabin and general
layout behind.
Best Buy: 2.0 D-4D
Final answer: YES, it is a Toyota people carrier after all.
Engines: 3.0 D4D, 4.5 D4D V8
Bodystyles: 4x4, 3/5dr
Plus points: This is so
competent you take it for
granted – until you drive
something else.
Excellent on and off road; diesel muscle power.
Minus points: We have a recession and big SUVs are not
much in demand.
Best buy: 3.0D-4D LWB GX 5dr
Final answer: YES, it’s the benchmark vehicle of its class.
Engines: 1.2 TSI, 1.6 TDI
Bodystyles: Hatchback/MPV
Plus points: Taller build gives
more cabin and boot room.
Engines.
Minus points: Not enough
additional space for the extra cost.
Best buy: 1.6TDi
Final answer: NO, it doesn’t add up any more.
Touran
VOLKSWAGEN
Engines: 1.6TDi, 2.0 TDI
Bodystyles: MPV 5/7
seats.
Plus points: This is the
one families buy for
longevity not current fashion. Excellent diesels and
there is plenty of space. Easier to work the seating/accommodation arrangements.
Minus points: It needed a bit of zest and freshness injected
but still looks a bit dated.
Best buy: 1.6 TDi
Final answer: YES, it carries on with the job.
Brochure Request: www.volkswagen.ie
www.volkswagen.ie
Polo
Jetta
Engines: 1.2, 1.2 TDi, 1.4
TSi, 1.6TDi
Bodystyles: 3/ 5dr. Hatch
Plus points: This is a commanding supermini with newtechnology petrol engines.
More sensible pricing at entry level.
Minus points: Critics view it as uninspiring to look at. But it
does the business even in the cutting-edge era.
Best buy: 1.2 Comfortline 5dr
Final answer: YES, They don’t come much sturdier than this.
Engines: 1.2 TSI, 1.4
TSI,1.6TDI, 2.0 TDI
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: New Jetta is a
big step forward with loads of
cabin space, excellent diesel
and a huge boot.
Minus points: Skimpy entry level model (lack of chrome).
Not nearly as good a handler as Ford Focus and one or two
others.
Best buy: 1.4 TSi
Final answer: YES, merits a late slot on your shortlist.
98
MOTORSHOW 2012
Tiguan
Engines: 1.4 TSi, 2.0TSi,
2.0TDi
Bodystyles: 3dr Hatchback
Plus points: Eye-catcher that
has the sort of looks to last a
while. Cabin spot on and
engines give it an edge.
Minus points: Has a lot going for it but just doesn’t engage
with driver as was expected.
Best buy: 2.0TDI
Final answer: YES, one of those smart cars that doesn’t cost
the earth.
Engines: 2.0 TDI.
Bodystyles: SUV 4WD/2WD
Plus points: Recently updated mid-size sports utility that
benefits from ‘big brother’
Touareg technology. Now
better to drive and has more equipment. 4x2 version.
Minus Points: It needed the facelift because there are some
major rivals out there.
Final answer: YES. It is well worth a test drive.
Passat
Touareg
CC
Caddy Life/Maxi
Life
Engines: 3.0 V6 TDI BMT
Bodystyle: SUV / 4WD
Plus Points: Massive size
and power.
Minus Points: Size does
matter in Recession Ireland.
Best Buy: 3.0 TDI BlueMotion
Final answer: YES, but not too many will be buying one.
Engines: 1.4 TSi, 1.6 TDI, 2.0
TDi
Plus points: Big striding motor
has taken a quantum leap really. Technologically it is on the
front grid. Accomplished in most facets. Good diesels – we like
the 2-litre.
Minus points: Lack of difference on looks from old one.
Mondeo and Peugeot 508 beat it on handling.
Best buy: 2.0TDI
Final answer: YES, sample what they can do with a big car
these days.
Engines: 2.0TDI
Bodystyles: Coupe
Plus points: Passat based
with Passat name dropped.
Plus Points: Super looking newly facelifted coupe
that is a pleasure to drive.
One of the best kept secrets out there.
Minus points: After a good initial innings, the recession
seems to have taken its toll.
Final answer: YES, new model here in March.
€27,640
Engines: 1.6 TDI, 2.0 TDI
Bodystyles: Van-like MPV
Plus points: Spacious and
functional. Price. Could be
ideal for many families in the tougher financial times we live.
Good fuel economy too.
Minus Points: Still can't shake van appearance fully despite
glass and other touches. Also, still a bit van-like in handling
and ride comfort.
Best buy: 1.6 TDi
Final answer: YES, on price and functionality.
Sharan
Carvelle / Shuttle /
California
Engines: 2.0 TDI.
Plus points: Has nearly
everything you’d want in a big
people carrier: loads of space,
fine engines, easily worked
seat/luggage combinations. Much better now.
Minus points: Trails Seat Allhambra on price/value for
money.
Best buy: 2.0 TDi.
Final answer: YES, you have plenty of choice between
Sharan and its ‘sisters’ the Galaxy and Allhambra.
€43,965 / €52,335
Engines: 2.0 TDI
Bodystyles: All van-like MPV
or camper (California)
Plus points: All perform very
well, are functional and give a great driving position. Caravelle
offers refinement.
Minus Points: Caravelle is expensive. All are van based as
opposed to specially developed passenger vehicles.
Best buy: Take your pick to suit requirements and budget.
Final answer: YES, if you have a specific vehicle requirement.
99
Scirocco
MOTORSHOW 2012
VOLVO
V70 / XC70
€45,537
Engines: 2.0F, 1.6D, 2.0D,
2.4D5
Bodystyles: Estates/ XC-SUV
AWD
Plus points: V70 is probably
the best overall estate around. Diesels.
Minus points: Thirsty petrols. XC70 meaningless in terms of
sales appeal.
Best buy: 2.0F
Final answer: Yes, put the V70 on your list; scratch the
XC70.
www.volvocars.ie
C30 Sports Coupe
S80
S40 / V50
XC60
Engines: 1.6. 2.0F, 1.6D,
2.0D
Bodystyles: Hatchback
Plus points: Lower emission
DRIVe models give this a
step up.
Minus points: Awfully cramped rear room. Poor driver.
Best Buy: 2.0 Flexifuel
Final answer: YES, just makes the grade with DRIVe version.
Engines: 1.4 D, 2.0F,1.6 D,
2.0D, 2.4 D5
Bodystyles: Saloon
Plus points: Imagine putting
a 1.4-litre diesel engine in a
saloon of this size. And it
works. Not a world beater on performance but it cuts the fuel
consumption. Luxury equipment levels.
Minus points: Awful handling militates against it heavily.
Best buy: 1.4 D
Final answer: YES, the small diesel engine makes this an
attractive proposition.
€28,101
Engines: 1.6, 2.0F, 1.6D,
2.0D
Bodystyles: Saloon / Sports
Estate
Plus points: DRIVe to the
rescue here. We much prefer the V50. Engines. V50 much
nicer all round.
Minus points: Old, dated and S40 cabin cramped. Will be
replaced this year.
Best buy: 2.0 Flexifuel.
Final answer: NO, new V40 arrives in July - worth waiting for.
Engines: 2.4 D
Bodystyles: 5dr
SUV/Crossover
Plus points: Shows how well
they can make and design a
large crossover. Knits performance, comfort, equipment and chassis into a decent package.
Minus points: Price is against it because there’s not much
money out there for cars like this.
Final answer: YES, it has to be on your shortlist.
S60/V60
XC90
Engines: 2.4D5
Bodystyles: SUV (SAV)
Plus points: Strong and big, it
managed to make it feel comfortable and easy-to-drive –
something that has eluded a
number of others.
Minus points: The diesel can be a bit raucous. Left behind
by likes of the BMW X5 and Audi Q7.
Final answer: YES, but it only nudges its way in - rivals have
advanced so much.
€34,764
Engines: 1.6, 2.0, 2.5, 3.0,
1.6D, 2.0D, 2.4D
Bodystyles: Saloon, estate
Plus points: Showcase for
how Volvo put in the equipment and make their cars comfortable. V60 estate excellent.
Minus points: S60 has lost its way. V60 better. Price.
Best Buy: 2.0D
Final answer: YES, the estate also has something about it.
100

Motorshow 2012 New Car Guide The Jargon

Transcription

Similar documents

2013 Gullane (Thomas) Limited. - Fisher

Trakindo Internal Magazine Antarkita – Within Us

technician training

Turning Press Releases into Ticket Sales

the Pixelmation White Paper Here

AZIMUT 43S - Yachts Invest

Poker Kortspel Poang - Wilde Country Rancho

Investor Update - Paris 2009 Defence Aerospace Axel - Rolls