Dodgy grading puts public at risk
Transcription
Dodgy grading puts public at risk
★★ Building watchdog on shaky ground FIRE IN THE HOLE Dodgy grading puts public at risk GRAEME HOSKEN A PRESIDENTIAL proclamation allowing the Special Investigating Unit to probe a construction industry watchdog could open a can of worms. The proclamation grants the SIU power to investigate government contracts awarded to ineligible companies. Industry insiders say such corruption would affect municipal service delivery and lead to potholed roads and shoddily constructed housing. The SIU has been instructed to look into a variety of practices at the Construction Industry Development Board, including the awarding of gradings. The board’s grading system governs how private and government construction contracts are awarded. The grading a contractor receives determines the maximum value of the projects for which it can tender. Grade 9 contractors qualify for work worth more than R130-million. The SIU has also been asked to investigate the appointment of “a panel of service providers to conduct investigations for the board”. The unit is to determine whether that appointment process violated Treasury regulations. This panel, said board spokesman Kolti Molise, includes specialist forensic investigators. Spanish soldiers of the 7th Airborne Light Infantry Brigade ‘Galicia’ perform manoeuvres in preparation for Nato’s Very High Readiness Joint Task Force in Zargoza, Spain. It will be used as a ‘spearhead force’ that can be deployed at short notice to counter threats against Nato sovereignty Picture: JAVIER CEBOLLADA/EPA It was established to investigate complaints about violations of the board’s code of conduct, such as fraud and corruption in awarding contracts, and to ensure that procurement systems are fair and transparent. Molise refused to comment on other questions from The Times about the SIU investigation. SIU spokesman Sefura Mongalo failed to respond to detailed questions on the investigation. ‘ Corrupt contractors are getting gradings higher than they should According to the presidential proclamation, the SIU should investigate the “validity of construction work contracts awarded by state institutions to contractors, where these institutions relied on the unlawful or invalid registration as contractors in the register of contractors, and contractor grading designations awarded by the board to those contractors”. ý Continued on Page 2 2 The Times Thursday April 21 | 2016 NEWS Order in the court: Judges go to school Schools system hacks the hackers LEONIE WAGNER and BIANCA CAPAZORIO KATHARINE CHILD THE Office of the Chief Justice wants to almost double its training budget in the next two years — pushing the amount spent from R34-million to R60-million by 2018. Yesterday Justice Minister Michael Masutha announced that the office would be working with a budget of R1.785-billion in this financial year — with R920-million allocated to remuneration and benefits for judges and the remaining R864-million for operational costs. A portion of the R864-million will go towards training and recruiting judicial officers. The Office of the Chief Justice’s 2016-2017 annual performance plan aims to conduct 225 training courses for judicial officers over the next three years. The training will include courses on the Domestic Violence Act, the Maintenance Act and the Immigration Act. Experts have welcomed the department’s move, saying there was a need for standardised training, especially in legal matters involving children. Shaheda Omar of the Teddy Bear Clinic for abused children in Johannesburg said there were “huge gaps” in the areas of domestic violence and maintenance. “This is a sore point. Some judicial officials lack sensitivity in communicating with victims of domestic violence, including children. There is a huge gap there and this needs to be addressed in the training,” Omar said. Office of the Chief Justice spokesman Nathi Mncube said the courses were developed after a broad consultative process with the judges and magistrates. He added that the acts mentioned in the report were examples and did not necessarily denote priority. Researcher and gender activist Lisa Vetten of the Wits Institute for ‘ There are too many who suggest rape is not always serious Social and Economic Development welcomed the promotion of standardised training. Vetten said training on sexual offences was especially necessary as there were still “too many cases where judges suggest [rape] is not serious if the victim has recovered”. The report also highlights the ripple effect of the increase in crime, which has increased the workload of judicial officers. The Office of the Chief Justice identified the need for more judicial officers and infrastructure — but did not say how many magistrates and judges needed to be hired. Masutha yesterday told parliament that there would not be enough funding to get the Mpumalanga High Court fully functional once its construction has been completed. POWER TO THE PEOPLE Probe of building industry watchdog ý From Page 1 The unit will also investigate whether board officials irregularly disseminated confidential information and the board’s alleged failure to properly safeguard confidential information. The investigation goes back to 2006. Yesterday the Construction Industry Development Board welcomed the investigation, saying it had asked for it as a counter to allegations of fraud and corruption. “The board simply cannot afford to ignore the potential risks associated with any fraud allegations related to its register of contractors. Fraud and corruption not only undermine the country’s economy and transformation efforts, they also potentially put the lives and safety of ordinary citizens in danger as a result of poor quality infrastructure,” the board’s CEO, Hlengiwe Khumalo, said. Charles Wright, Stefanutti Stocks’ enterprise development director, who has assisted the board in gradings, welcomed the investigation. “The board is incredibly strict in granting grading applications but allegations of corruption must be investigated.” He said the most serious con- 02 A community leader addresses thousands of residents of Zandspruit, northwest of Johannesburg, who marched yesterday to demand electricity in their area Picture: ALON SKUY sequence of such corruption was the collapse of municipalities’ service delivery capabilities. “Contractors are receiving gradings they should not be getting. The collapse of service delivery can be seen in every town, from roads falling apart to other vital infrastructure either not working or projects lying incomplete for years.” Wright said that in considering a 04 06 13 17 grading the board took into consideration the contractor’s turnover, available capital, projects executed and details of the largest project executed. “The big problem is that the board does not take into account the quality of work of contractors or their safety record.” Tinus Maritz, a member of the board’s advisory forum and head of Pre- 23 HOW TO CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION COPYRIGHT e-mail: [email protected] Subscription and delivery problems: 0860 946946 The copyright on all material in this newspaper and its supplements is expressly reserved. The Times subscribes to the South African Press Code that prescribes news that is truthful, accurate, fair and balanced. Complaints about or unresolved disputes relating to editorial content may be lodged with the South African Press Ombudsman’s office at PO Box 47221, Parklands, 2121, telephone 011-484-3618, fax 011-484-3619. Published by Times Media Group Pty Ltd. HELP US GET IT RIGHT The Times is committed to bringing you news you can trust. If you spot mistakes in our stories, point them out to us. Please phone 011-280-5245 or fax 011-280-5070/1 or e-mail [email protected]. or write to us at PO Box 1742, Saxonwold, 2132 38 toria University’s construction economics department, said the board raised the topic of corruption at a stakeholders meeting in Pretoria three weeks ago. “They acknowledged that [grading of contractors] is difficult to manage, especially because of fronting and fraudulent representations by contractors. “The corruption, which is as bad now as it was pre-1994, is with 09 11 15 30 THIRTEEN professional hackers tried to hack the Gauteng education department’s online school application system. But the system “hacked the hackers back”. So said Gauteng education MEC Panyaza Lesufi. The applications site went live on Monday after a six-hour delay because of technical problems. Lesufi said more than 188 000 parents had applied for places for Grade 1 or Grade 8 children. It received 37 500 hits a second on Monday afternoon. Lesufi said: “These statistics give us confidence that people have heeded our call to register online.” Half a million applications were expected, he said. The online system would stop fraud, such as that documented by NGO Corruption Watch in which parents and officials at schools allowed some people to jump the application queue, he said. The Federation of School Governing Bodies of SA said yesterday that it had decided not to litigate against the department because two important changes to the online system had been made on Monday. The CEO of the federation, Paul Colditz, said: “The site was changed so that parents could indicate their school of choice and the online applications will be sent to the schools for the compilation of the so-called A and B lists. This means a school’s language and admissions policies are taken into account. “In its previous format, the site allocated a school based on the parents’ address and it was not possible for applicants to indicate their language preference.” Some problems persisted. Foreigners had difficulty accessing the site because it did not allow people to enter ID numbers that included letters. The department’s Oupa Bodipe said this was a “technical problem” that had been rectified. contractors trying to secure the higher gradings needed to secure [the most valuable] tenders.” He said tough economic times made it hard for emerging contractors to maintain their grading and a down-gradings had serious adverse consequences for them. “The board experiences huge difficulties in monitoring the country’s thousands of contractors.” 40 48 25 Sourced from: South African Astronomical Observatory 17/31 15/26 07:13 18:15 17/26 18/32 12/24 06:18 17:30 15/26 06:26 17:46 11/23 Pietermaritzburg 10/22 21/28 Wind: 6km SSW e-mail Editorial: [email protected] Telephone 011-280-5245 Advertising: [email protected] Website: www.timeslive.co.za Cape Town office 021-488-1700 Durban office 031-250-8500 WARNING Readers are advised to carefully scrutinise advertisements offering investment opportunities. The Times cannot vouch for the claims made by advertisers. 13/24 16/19 Wind: 21km NNW 16/23 15/23 Wind: 24km NNE Wind: 19km NNW GET IN TOUCH WITH US: News desk 011-280-5245 email: [email protected]. Website: www.timeslive.co.za NEWS Thursday April 21 | 2016 The curse of the copycats Gavin Rajah has been accused of stealing US designer’s creations SUTHENTIRA GOVENDER FASHION designers to the stars say it’s impossible to protect their creations from being “knocked off” by copycats who “lack creativity”. They were speaking amid another Gavin Rajah copycat scandal, in which US fashion designer Chelsea Liu has accused him of stealing her designs and threatening to have her deported because of her allegedly defamatory comments in social media rants on Thursday last week. Liu posted images of her own designs as well as screenshots from an international magazine feature on Rajah showing the same designs. Rajah has denied the copycat allegations, threatening Liu with legal action. Top designer David Tlale refused to be “dragged into” the Rajah issue but conceded that protecting his work from copycats was near impossible. “When you get your inspiration from somewhere you have to put your personal touch or signature to it. Having to protect yourself is impossible. My take is that there has to be originality and something special about a design.” He said designers could patent a brand or a print. JJ Schoeman, who has designed for personalities such as Edith Venter, Abigail Kubeka, Khanyi Mbau, Yvonne Chaka Chaka and Bonang Matheba, said: “An ‘ There has to be originality and something special about the design identical kind of copy, where everything is one million percent the same, at a big event on a famous personality, because of a lack of creativity on the part of the designer — I think that would be a huge problem.” Fashion lawyer Sumaiya De’Mar said South African copyright law set out a range of creative works that were protected. “The courts are yet to establish the application of such protection for the design of a dress. But it could be argued that the dress is a ‘work of craftsmanship’, which falls under the act, in which case the copyright would apply.” IN HARMONY: DJ Maphorisa, Theo Kgosinkwe, Nhlanhla Nciza and Diamond Platnumz at yesterday’s launch at Silverstar Casino in Krugersdorp of their collaborative number, ‘Colors of Africa’ Picture: TSHEKO KABASIA.fash The Times 3 Is this the best festival lineup ever? IT IS a festival lineup that could put all others to shame. The organisers of Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival are planning a second event in October with a lineup that’s a who’s who of rock music. The three-night event, which will take place between October 7 and 9 at the Empire Polo Field in Indio and is being organised by an offshoot of AEG Live, could boast the following line-up: ý Paul McCartney ý Bob Dylan ý Roger Waters ý The Rolling Stones ý Neil Young ý The Who The Los Angeles Times claims an announcement will be made in the next two weeks. However, a source close to the project revealed: “It will be their [the bands’] full stage productions, with full sets.” Elliot Roberts, Neil Young’s manager, said: “It’s so special in so many ways. You won’t get a chance to see a bill like this, perhaps ever again. It’s a show I look forward to more than any show in a long time.” — © The Daily Telegraph Sea change in reality TV Maf ikizolo in colourful African collaboration AZIZZAR MOSUPI A NEW single and a video by South African duo Mafikizolo, DJ Maphorisa and Tanzania’s Diamond Platnumz is more than a musical collaboration, it’s a spectacle of African cultures. Titled Colors of Africa, the song celebrates the diversity of music from different parts of the continent. The Swahili lyrics by Diamond Platnumz are mixed with Mafikizolo’s signature Zulu and Sotho lingo over a catchy, Afro-beat inspired tune by DJ Maphorisa. Maphorisa from Soshanguve is a DJ and producer who recently co-produced Canadian rapper Drake’s latest single, One Dance, featuring Nigeria’s Wizkid. He has worked before with Mafikizolo — Nhlanhla Nciza and Theo Kgosinkwe — on their smash-hit, Khona. “We felt it was important to celebrate Africa and black excellence,” said Kgosinkwe. #$%& #'%& #()& #*)&+ airport transfers %##& '# # ()*+,)- . $ /# 012,3 Nciza said various local fashion designers were used in the styling of the video to further celebrate home-grown talent. “We made sure we used our very own African designers [for the video], which included Laduma Ngxokolo of Maxhosa by Laduma, Skorzch by Zano Sithetho and Trevor Stuurman,” she said. The Rolls-Royce musician, as Platnumz is also known, said working with Mafikizolo was “very nice” and he was a staunch fan of the pair. What makes Fedhealth different? ´ Unique beneft #1 Post-hospitalisation treatment for up to 30 days Unique beneft #2 ! and CT scans Unique beneft #3 Trauma treatment at a casualty ward Unique beneft #4 " , , - . " # # # "# "#" $ FEDH3038TT2 The Cheese Has Moved ! " # $ Mafikizolo, whose last studio album was Reunited in 2013, said their next album was “coming soon” and would see them continuing to experiment with an Afro-centric sound. “Over the years we’ve featured other musicians, but with this project we’re going to feature more African producers,” said Kgosinkwe. Colors of Africa will be launched tomorrow at the Taboo club in Sandton and the artists will perform live. STRESSED out by a fast-paced daily life and binge-watching the latest hit TV shows? Norway may have the answer with its latest “slow TV” instalment: watching the ebb and flow of the sea, for 12 hours, without interruption. Since 2009 Norwegian public broadcaster NRK has been experimenting with live, slowpaced programmes, variously broadcasting a seven-hour train journey across Norway, a six-day trip by cruise ship from south to north or how to knit, starting with shearing a sheep. The shows have been hits with viewers in Norway, so its latest idea is to live broadcast the world’s strongest tidal current, called Saltstraumen, near the city of Bodoe, some 80km north of the Arctic Circle. Lights, camera — not much action. — Reuters Fedhealth and Sanlam Reality: the picture-perfect modern family. Fedhealth and Sanlam Reality have joined forces ´ ´ one of the best medical aids in the business. Call ,1-,4(+2+5, SMS 6%*7890 to (+)::; # #$$< Scheme rules apply Sanlam Reality Ts&Cs apply *Standard SMS rates apply 4 The Times Thursday April 21 | 2016 NEWS Double rental costs R9m Gauteng department has to cough up after lease bungle OLEBOGENG MOLATLHWA ALMOST R9-million will be missing from the next budget of the Gauteng department of economic development following a building lease bungle created by the department’s entities. The Standing Committee on Public Accounts refused to grant funding approval yesterday for R8 993 000 arising from payments on several leased buildings around Johannesburg on behalf of the department’s five enterprise entities. Scopa pointed out that the department had a 20 818m2 building in the Johannesburg city centre meant to accommodate them under a single roof that is unoccupied. The bodies include the Gauteng Growth and Development Agency, Gauteng Enterprise Propeller, Gauteng Gambling Board, Gauteng Tourism Authority and Gauteng Fashion Council. Written responses from the department to Scopa reveal that the provincial department was forced to make double payments on the various buildings occupied Business boost for Ekurhuleni UNEMPLOYED people in the City of Ekurhuleni could have bright futures as entrepreneurs, executive mayor Mondli Gungubele has said. Delivering his state of the city address yesterday, Gungubele said the township economy revitalisation programme would change the face of local communities. “Nothing would be more fulfilling than seeing a small township business growing to do business globally as a result of our intervention,” said Gungubele. In five years the revitalisation programme had produced more than 200 000 jobs, he said. Gungubele said R10-million had been set aside for the Khumalo Street tourism node in Thokoza, which is designed to stimulate township tourism, economic development and job creation. The node will have a food market, heritage interpretation centre, flea market, cycle-tour route, an arts and crafts market, indigenous games, and live traditional music performances. — Neo Goba by the entities after they refused to move to the new premises. “At the time of concluding the lease (January 4 2010), agencies were still located in different office accommodation and continued with such accommodation even ‘ Their reluctance to move led to double payments for their accommodation UNLIMIT EARNIN ED G POTEN TIAL Times Media is looking for self-motivated, people-orientated team players to join their Telesales Division. Forward applications/CVs to Helen Mncube [email protected] FREE MEN: Advocate George Bizos, centre, and Sello, son of Andrew Mlangeni, second from right, with Frans Sheleng, protocol officer, right, as they receive The Freedom of the City from Johannesburg mayor Parks Tau Picture: ANTONIO MUCHAVE Bizos accepts award, says that SA will survive SIBONGILE MASHABA and SHAUN SMILLIE Sales and/or telesales experience a pre-requisite, as well as a knowledge of MS Word and Admin programmes. You can basically write your own salary cheque! after the lease had been concluded and had effectively started. “Their expressed reluctance to move led to double payments for their accommodation as rentals continued in their old premises while new lease payments simultaneously kicked in,” the department said in a written response. Scopa chairman Mbongeni Radebe said: “The money will be taken from [the department] to pay for that wastage.” The department’s website shows that all but one of its entities — the gambling board — occupies the building. In 2011, gambling board staff and its board rejected instructions from then MEC Qedani Mahlangu to move to the building at 124 Main Street. According to the written responses, the department was forced to pay R6.1-million towards rental on the new building as well as R2.893-million for security, municipal costs and furniture removal. The department said it could not hold any official accountable and no investigation was instituted. PRESIDENT Jacob Zuma and the Mayor of Johannesburg, Parks Tau, have honoured struggle icons and other people who have contributed to the country. At an event held yesterday in Randburg, Johannesburg ANC stalwart Andrew Mlangeni and Rivonia trial lawyer Advocate George Bizos were among those lionised. Andrew Mlangeni was too ill to attend an event at which he was honoured with the Freedom of the City of Johannesburg award, so Tau and his delegation visited him in hospital where they handed over the award. Mlangeni, who is also the chairman of the ANC integrity committee, was admitted to Netcare Sunninghill Hospital in Johannesburg on Sunday last week. His son, Sello, delivered his acceptance speech. Said Sello: “[My father] thanked the mayor for the award and for taking the time to come and see him in hospital. “He really appreciated that. My father is recovering very well. He is a strong man.” Sello could not say when his father would be discharged. In his acceptance speech, Bizos said: “Thank you for the great honour you have bestowed upon me.” Asked about the state of politics in the country, Bizos said: “We are going through a difficult period but I am confident that solutions will be found sooner or later. “I have confidence in our constitution, our judiciary and that the majority of South Africans want peace and tranquillity.” On April 28 Zuma will bestow the 2016 National Orders on both South Africans and foreigners. Former spin doctor Mac Maharaj will receive the Order of Luthuli in silver for his contribution to the fight against apartheid. Others who have been singled out for their activism during the struggle, like Maqashu Leonard Mdingi, and Peter Sello Motau, will receive posthumous awards. Helen Rees will receive an award for her achievements in the field of medical science and research. Marguerite Poland will be honoured for her contribution in the studies of indigenous languages, literature and anthropology. During the ceremony Zuma will hand out the Order of Mendi for Bravery, the Order of Ikhamanga, the Order of the Baobab, the Order of Luthuli, and the Order of the Companions of OR Tambo. Economy in safe hands, says Nene FOR a man who has been at the centre of the country’s fiscal storms after he was unceremoniously fired, former finance minister Nhlanhla Nene appeared upbeat about the country’s financial future at the Mangosuthu University of Technology in Umlazi, KwaZuluNatal, yesterday. Nene was honoured by the university for his expertise and contribution to the finance industry in both the public and private sector. Asked if he was totally lost to the public service, Nene chuckled and said his going to the private sector was now “private capture”, in reference to his announcement on Monday that he had joined investment giant Allan Gray as a non-executive director. “Not lost at all,” he said. “I miss working at Treasury and any other place I have been a part of.” Nene said he had full confidence in the country’s ability to maintain a strong financial path. “We shouldn’t lose sight of the resilience of our economy. Resilience has been the key,” he said, adding that there were proper plans in place at the Treasury. “And we have the most capable men and women to maintain prudence and fiscal path,” he said. When asked about his relationship with President Jacob Zuma, Nene said: “I have deep respect for the president. “He remains my president, the president of the country and that of the ANC.” Nene’s sacking by Zuma on December 9 last year triggered an economic crisis in South Africa that haemorrhaged an estimated half a trillion rand in foreign and local investment. He emphasised the importance of morality in business. — Nathi Olifant NEWS Teenager streamed friend’s rape live A TEENAGER accused of livestreaming the rape of her 17-year-old friend got caught up in collecting “likes” on social media, prosecutors said. Marina Lonina, 18, was charged with kidnapping, rape, sexual battery and breaking child pornography laws, the same charges facing Raymond Gates, 29, who allegedly committed the assault. Both have pleaded not guilty. Sam Shamansky, Lonina’s lawyer, said the pair met Gates the day before the attack, when he bought them vodka and encouraged them to meet him. They had been drinking at his home when Gates allegedly began to assault the victim. Lonina used her phone to broadcast a video live on the Periscope app. Shamansky said Lonina had tried “at various times” to stop the attack. Ron O’Brien, a county prosecutor, said in court Lonina started filming in the hope of putting a stop to the crime, but continued as more users began to tune in. “I have never seen a case ‘ Thursday April 21 | 2016 The Times 5 Sweet and sour of dreaded sugar tax KATHARINE CHILD THERE will be 200 000 more obese young South Africans by next year — mostly young people — if a sugar tax on soft drinks is not introduced, according to dietary researchers at Wits University. The Priceless unit at the Wits Centre of Public Health has investigated the effects of raising the price of soft drinks to deter excessive consumption. The unit’s research shows that failure to institute a tax would mean an increase in sales of soft drinks by 2.4% a year. Unit director Karen Hofman said the beverage industry had admitted it was targeting the youngest and poorest consumers. She said a 20% increase in the price of soft drinks would reduce the number of obese people by 220 000 in three years. In February Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan announced drinks with high sugar levels would be taxed. These include fruit juice, fizzy drinks, energy drinks, iced teas and vitamin waters. Beverage industry officials are expected to meet Treasury officials today to discuss their concerns about the tax. Spokesman for industry body BevSA, Mapule Ncanywa, said: “The industry is a valuable contributor to the growth of our economy and we are willing to pay our fair share of taxes. What we are against is a discriminatory tax and that is why we welcome engagement with the Treasury.” The industry has questioned why producers of sweet snacks, chocolates and sugary breakfast cereals ‘ A can of Coke a day increases the risk of diabetes by 26% are not facing higher taxes. Hofman said “liquid sugar” was the biggest risk for diabetes as soda was quickly absorbed and spiked the body’s blood sugar fast, overworking the pancreas and liver. Coke has eight teaspoons of sugar, Fanta Grape has 11 and energy drinks have about nine. “A can of Coke a day increases the risk of diabetes by 26% and being overweight by 27%,” said Hofman. Children who drink a can of Coke a day have a 55% higher chance of being overweight. A tax on sugar-sweetened beverages in Mexico introduced in 2014 led to a 12% reduction in purchases of the drinks a year later. LOVE IN FULL BLOOM It didn’t appear as if she was attempting to help the victim such as this where you would actually livestream a sexual assault,” he said. “It didn’t appear she was attempting to help the victim. “She got caught up in the likes,” he added. He said the victim can be heard screaming “no” and “stop”. A friend of Lonina’s saw the recording and contacted police. Shamansky described his client as a victim. He said at one point she asked followers: “What should I do now?” “She’s a good kid,” said Shamansky. “She’s the furthest thing from a rapist … The rapist was in court and it was not my client. Technology has moved us into an area that is sometimes beyond belief,” he said. — © The Daily Telegraph Newlyweds pose in a flowerfield near De Keukenhof, also known as the Garden of Europe, in the Netherlands. This year's planting theme of the floral park in Lisse is The Golden Age Picture: REMKO DE WAAL/AFP PHOTO Women back boss after ‘bitch switch’ remark What’s your gender, sonny? POPPY LOUW PARENTS of children as young as four enrolling at school in the southern English town of Brighton are being asked to choose the gender “they most identify with”, the local council said yesterday. “Parents and carers are asked to state their child’s gender as male or female,” said Brighton & Hove City Council’s lead member for equalities, Emma Daniel. “For the vast majority of families, this is very straightforward. We have inserted the additional text THE women in top management at Cell C have come out in full support of CEO Jose Dos Santos following a public outcry over comments he made about women having a “bitch switch”. Dos Santos, during an interview on Cliff Central on Tuesday, said women had a high tolerance for dealing with workplace issues. He added that he hoped a woman would become his successor when he stepped down from Cell C. “They have a different way of managing; they have a different way of engaging in meetings. It creates a different dynamic. “If I can use the term on your radio station, you know women do have a bitch switch, and boy if you see two women fighting, it is worse than two men,” said Dos Santos. Though they agreed that their CEO’s choice of words was “not appropriate”, the women yesterday said what he had done for every Cell C employee, particularly women, “far outweighed” his comments. “We believe in ourselves collectively as a team of highly skilled and highly capable women and we are rightly recognised as such in this company. “What we know is that we have all had far more opportunities to shine and be our best under his leadership. If this was not the case, we would not be here,” the women said. about gender identity in response to calls to show an inclusive approach,” she added. The pupil registration form, which is required for all children entering a new school, can be left blank if a child has “another gender identity”. Conservative MP Andrew Bridgen called the form “ridiculous”, telling The Sun newspaper “Schools should be teaching kids to read and write, not prompting them to consider gender swaps.” — AFP 8 The Times Thursday April 21 | 2016 NEWS SA’s climate-change ‘hot air’ NIVASHNI NAIR Committed to saving planet and building power stations SOUTH Africa, which is among the worst 20 greenhouse-gas emitters globally, will be merely blowing hot air when it joins 140 other countries to sign a landmark agreement to limit climate change on Earth Day tomorrow. That’s according to local environmentalists who yesterday added their voices to widespread criticism of the signing of the UN’s landmark Paris Agreement, drafted in the French capital last year. The agreement is meant to limit the increase in global temperatures attributable to climate-change to below 2C. Environmentalists believe the signing would bring governments one step closer to ratifying a “meaningless” agreement. “Environmental justice” organisation groundWork said the agreement — which requires its signatories to keep inventories of their greenhouse-gas emissions, and submit climate action plans and update them every five years — was a sham. Critics warn that emission targets are too low, that the rate of implementation of corrective measures is too slow, that there are no specific penalties for non-compliance and there is no start date. Bobby Peek, a groundWork director, said the South African government planned to sign the agreement while pushing ahead with the development of coal-based energy generation, fracking, offshore gas exploitation and building nuclear power stations. “This is completely incompatible with trying to stop climate change.” Centre for Environmental Rights attorney Nicole Löser said government decisions on energy and mining, and its international commitments and national climate-change policy, were largely incompatible. She said that although the Paris agreement failed to provide strict or enforceable obligations for countering global warming, South Africa’s accession to the Paris Agreement could lead to the stricter regulation of greenhouse- ‘ It could set us on a downward spiral of poverty, unemployment and inequality gas emissions and other climate change factors in this country. In response to the criticism, Environmental Affairs Department spokesman Albi Modise said the agreement was important for South Africa. “If not addressed, long-term climate change will not only undermine the development gains South Africa has made but will, potentially set us on a downward spiral of increasing poverty, unemployment and inequality,” he said. “Over 75% of South Africa’s [greenhouse gas] emissions come from the energy sector, primarily electricity generation and the combustion of fuels in the transport and industrial sectors.” Wealthy seek out SA dorps SHAUN SMILLIE VOICES UNHEARD: Daisy Goldstein, 90, who fled Europe before the Holocaust, outside the Cape Town High Court, where her daughter, Sarah, and other parties are challenging the SA Jewish Board of Deputies for prohibiting women from singing at a memorial ceremony Picture: ESA ALEXANDER Women singers not kosher at memorial KAREN GWEE IT WILL be progressives versus the orthodox in the Cape Town Equality Court in a row over Jewish women singing at an annual Holocaust memorial service. Two Jews and a progressive Jewish organisation are taking the Cape Council of the SA Jewish Board of Deputies to court in an attempt to overturn the decadeold ban. “In a secular ceremony commemorating the victims of the Holocaust — the victims of discrimination — it’s repugnant to pander to people who believe that women are an unequal or lesser NEWS publishers have such a fraught relationship with the people who comment on their articles that many websites have been removing the comments section altogether. Michael Robertson thinks he has a better idea: Start charging the people who hang out there. species,” plaintiff Gilad Stern told The Times yesterday. The Board of Deputies is said to have begun excluding female singers from the Holocaust ceremony and other communal events in 2005 when an Orthodox chief rabbi walked off a stage in protest at a schoolgirl performing a memorial song. “They favour rabbis who find women’s voices obscene,” said Stern, referring to Orthodox Jews who follow the Talmudic dictum kol isha, which means “a woman’s voice is lewdness”. Stern, his sister-in-law Sarah Goldstein, and the SA Centre for Religious Equality and Diversity applied to the Equality Court on April 1 for an order that would prohibit the Board of Deputies from barring women singers. “It’s about basic human rights … the basic value of women — they are equal,” said Stern’s sister-in-law and fellow plaintiff, ‘ It is repugnant to pander to people who see women as inferior Sarah Goldstein, whose mother Daisy, 90, fled Europe before the Holocaust. They hope the case will be heard ahead of the Holocaust ceremony at Pinelands Cemetery on May 5. The Board of Deputies will defend the action, it said yesterday. “We are faced with difficulty in upholding gender equity and also providing a forum where the needs of the Orthodox are met,” Cape board executive director Daniel Levitt said. The Board of Deputies said it planned to hold a colloquium to “air diverse points of view that will guide the board in terms of future ceremonies”. Readers must put money where mouths are Robertson, an entrepreneur in San Diego best known for founding MP3.com and fighting a long legal battle with the record industry, argues that the prospect of a new revenue stream will convince a struggling industry to reconsider the value of comments. A self-proclaimed libertarian, he believes his company, SolidOpinion.com, can provide a market solution to trolling. “If we can turn this into a revenue producer, then all of a sudden publishers will want it; they can invest time in it; and we can improve comments,” he said. One big news company is already THEY have become the hangouts of South Africa’s rich — the small towns that are collecting dollar millionaires faster than anywhere else in the country. Paarl, Stellenbosch, Franschhoek and towns along the Cape Garden Route have seen phenomenal growth in the number of dollar millionaires living there. The number of millionaires in Paarl, Franschhoek and Stellenbosch grew by 38% from 2007 to 2015, according to a survey by New Wealth Management, which tracks the movement of high-networth individuals. While these small towns have seen spikes in the number of wealthy residents, Johannesburg and Cape Town have experienced declines. Interestingly, Pretoria has seen an increase because of its growing number of residential estates. “What you are seeing in these small towns are retirees, and people from other countries,” explained the research head of the study, Andrew Amoils. Most of them are from Europe and Asia, he added. The number of South African millionaires has declined since the 2008 financial crisis, the research also found. However, the study did discover that an increasing number of African millionaires had bought property and moved to South Africa. Amoils estimated that more than 1 500 millionaires from countries such as Nigeria, Angola and Ghana had moved here since 2007. Over the next decade, 10 000 more African millionaires will make South Africa their home, he said. on board. Tribune Publishing, which owns the Chicago Tribune and the Los Angeles Times, turned on SolidOpinion’s software over the weekend. Readers can earn points that allow them to make comments, but the newspaper also sells 800 points for $10 (R142). — Bloomberg Call NOW! Open 7 days a week 0877 40 50 07 Local Airfares from Durban 1370 R * from 1790* Cape Town R Port Elizabeth R 1850* Keep your wallet happy with our randfriendly deals Worldwide Airfares from London 8470 R * from 7590*< Bangkok R Dubai R Mauritius R New York 5910*< 10470* R R Paris Phuket 6560* 7950*< R R Rome Sydney 6240* 6690* 9930 R *< Umhlanga Airfare + 3 nights 4-star from 3490 R * from Stay at the Urban Park Hotel & Spa with 3 days car hire° & unlimited mileage & BONUS R2000 Added Value plus The Entertainer discount voucher booklet. Cape Town Premium Economy Airfares Airfare + 3 nights 4-star 16360 * Stay at the Cape Town Lodge with breakfast daily & 3 days car hire° with unlimited mileage & * BONUS use of roof-top pool and gym. from R3890 London R 23890 * Durban to Cape Town New York R 24380 * Includes meals and entertainment on MSC Sinfonia departing Durban & BONUS 2 kids U/18 cruise FREE# * R when sharing with 2 adults. from 4780 from Hong Kong R Blue Lagoons Mauritius 8-day tour Airfare + 5 nights 5690 R * from * St ay at Be Cosy Apart Hotel & Includes a Topdeck tour with 7 nights accom & some meals including breakfast & dinner daily & SAVE R1010. Itinerary: Fethiye – Tarzan Bay – Kas & more. BONUS R1000 Resort Credit to be used towards food and drinks. Cruise The Med 8-day tour Phuket Airfare + 7 nights Includes an On The Go tour with 7 nights accom & some meals including breakfast & dinner daily. Itinerary: Marmais – Turtle Beach – Tersane Island & * R Sunken Bath Bay – Fethiye & more. from 7480 St ay at Sunset Beach Resort with breakfast daily & FREE Wi-Fi. Zanzibar Airfare + 5 nights 4-star Stay at Uroa Bay Beach Resort with breakfast daily. 3-night cruise 11690 R R from 8180* 12190* R Phuket Airfare + 8 nights 4-star Pay for 5 nights & get 3 nights FREE at Old Phuket Resort with breakfast daily & BONUS R1000 Resort Credit per room * R to be used on selected items. from 12690 Bali Airfare + 7 nights 4-star Bangkok Airfare + 3 nights Stay at Ibis Bangkok Sathorn with breakfast daily. from from 11090* R St ay at Mercure Bali Nusa Dua with breakfast daily. from 13470* R Airfares are return and include all taxes. Mall of Africa GRAND OPENING next week Thursday! Shop 2076A Magwa Cresent, Waterfall City Midrand. Last Minute Touring Magaliesburg Midlands 1 night 4-star Airfare + 1 night 4-star Limited Availability from from 2780 R Airfare + 2 nights 4-star * from 3690 R * Stay at the River Place Country Estate with breakfast . Stay at the Granny Mouse Country House & Spa with breakfast & 1 day car hire° with unlimited mileage. Stay at the Boardwalk Hotel with breakfast daily & 2 days car hire° with unlimited mileage. Stellenbosch Hermanus Cape Town Airfare + 1 night 4-star Airfare + 1 night 5-star Airfare + 2 nights 5-star from Give the gift of travel this Mother's Day 720 R * Port Elizabeth 2830 R * from Stay at the Kleine Zalze Lodge with breakfast & 1 day car hire° with unlimited mileage. 3620 R * Stay at the Arabella Hotel & Spa with breakfast & 1 day car hire° with unlimited mileage. from 4430 R * Stay at the Pepper Club with breakfast daily & 2 days car hire° with unlimited mileage & BONUS R2000 Added Value plus The Entertainer discount voucher booklet. All advertised prices are per person sharing. 0877 40 50 07 flightcentre.co.za *Package, cruise, tour, rail & hotel prices are per person, based on double occupancy for total length of stay unless otherwise stated. Prices are subject to availability for select departure dates and subject to fluctuations. Prices are correct at advertising deadline and can change without prior notification. Errors and omissions can occur. Prices quoted are on sale for a limited period unless otherwise specified or sold out prior. Some prices are based on payment by cash in store only. Group rates may differ and are available on request. All fights, where included, are per person return from Johannesburg in economy class unless otherwise specified. Resort Credit/Added Value inclusions may vary per resort. Various tours may be age specific, depending on supplier. All savings are already included in advertised price. Please refer to flightcentre.co.za for more details. The Entertainer holiday offers are only redeemable in JNB, DUR and CPT. <Airfares valid until 25 Apr '16. ° Credit card required for car hire. 21/4/2016. 10 The Times Thursday April 21 | 2016 BUSINESS/WORLD The smart money is on junk, say economists SOUTH Africa’s sovereign credit rating will probably be cut to junk status this year‚ at least by Standard & Poor’s‚ amid concerns the government could fail to reach its budget targets‚ a poll found yesterday. All but one of the 16 economists surveyed by Reuters expect SA to lose its investment grade status this year‚ further hitting markets that have already reacted to expectations of a downgrade. “A downgrade has been somewhat priced in. Government bond yields are in line with junk status already‚” said Rajiev Rajkumar‚ analyst at 4CAST in London. “Nevertheless‚ a downgrade would trigger some forced selling by institutional investors as many have a mandate to only hold investment-grade bonds.” Ten economists said a cut to junk‚ which would put South Africa on a par with peer Brazil‚ would be negative for markets‚ and six said it would be very negative. Economists accurately predicted Brazil’s downgrades in two similar Reuters polls last year. The majority of analysts agreed S&P‚ which, like fellow agency Fitch Ratings, rates SA just one notch above junk‚ was most likely to cut. Moody’s has it two notches above junk but on review for a downgrade. Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan has pledged to narrow the budget deficit to 2.4% of gross domestic product by 2018-2019. Political concerns and policy uncertainty are constraining growth‚ which is putting budget targets under threat‚ Rand Merchant Bank economist Carmen Nel said. South African growth has slowed due to lower prices for its commodity exports and powergenerating constraints. The economy is expected to grow 0.7% this year. Economists said a credit rating downgrade would hurt the poor, who depended on social welfare the most‚ with about a quarter of the labour force out of work. “A downgrade to junk will increase the country’s interest burden on servicing debt‚ taking money away from where it is needed — the social and welfare dependency scheme‚” said Colen Garrow‚ economist at Lefika ‘ A credit rating downgrade would hurt the poor Securities. However‚ emerging market risk sentiment has improved‚ taking the rand with it. A Reuters poll of global foreign exchange strategists conducted this month showed that currencies were not likely to sink to new lows‚ mainly because expectations for US interest rate hikes have been scaled back. Still‚ Rand Merchant Bank’s Nel said there was likely to be renewed downward pressure on the rand and asset prices leading up to or around the event‚ particularly given the recent appreciation in asset prices that has partly priced out some of the ratings-related risk. The rand has recovered from massive selling pressure caused by President Jacob Zuma’s decision to sack finance minister Nhlanhla Nene in December‚ replacing him with little-known Desmond van Rooyen. — Reuters Trump 2.0: How Donald got his mojo back NOT SO very long ago, things were going so badly for Donald Trump that a new theory started doing the rounds: Could he be sabotaging his own run for the White House? He spoke out in defence of his campaign manager when he was charged with assault. He stumbled over abortion, showing a woeful ignorance of the debate on reproductive rights and Republican values. And he managed to muddle the date of the worst terrorist attacks on US soil with the chain of 7-11 convenience stores. Perhaps he was working on an exit strategy, hastening a return to his day job of being a billionaire? How different it looks now. That he would win the Republican primary in his home state was never in doubt. New York City is well used to big egos and loud mouths. It’s where Ted Cruz sabotaged his own chances by using the term “New York values” as a term of abuse. But Trump’s dramatic margin of victory in the state — by almost 35 percentage points — will go some way to restoring momentum to a faltering campaign and shoring up his lead in the delegate count. But momentum is generally overrated in politics. Few voters mark their X based on a perception of motion. This is not a turning point or a decisive moment. Barring a miracle, Trump will not be able to settle things before INFLATION slowed for the first time in seven months in March and the measure stripping out fuel and food costs rose less than forecast, giving the Reserve Bank room to pause its interest-rate hiking cycle. Inflation fell to 6.3% from 7% a month earlier, Statistics SA said yesterday. The median of 22 economists’ estimates compiled by Bloomberg was 6.4%. Prices rose 0.8% in the month. Core inflation, which excludes food, non-alcoholic beverages, gasoline and electricity costs, slowed to 5.4% in March, the lowest rate since December and less than the 5.8% projected. The worst drought in more than a century has driven up food costs and added to pressure on consumer prices caused by the rand’s 25% fall against the dollar last year. While the Reserve Bank’s monetary policy committee hiked its benchmark repurchase rate four times since July to 7% and has said inflation will only return to its 3%-6% target range in the last quarter of 2017, slower price growth could allow it to pause its hiking cycle. “They have done a whole percentage point in three meetings and that is quite significant given the dismal state of the economy,” Elize Kruger, an economist at KADD Capital, said yesterday. “I think there could be enough reasons for them to just pause.” — Bloomberg Mitsubishi adds fuel to Volkswagen fire COMBING OUT FIGHTING: US Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump with his wife Melania at the New York presidential primary night rally in Manhattan Picture: SHANNON STAPLETON/REUTERS the Republican National Convention in July. He will have the most delegates but not enough for a majority before the horse trading begins. Instead it signals that he has got his mojo back. A shake-up behind the scenes is starting to deliver. Things are getting serious. First there are the hirings. Last month Trump brought in Paul Manafort, a famously discreet Republican operative, to lead the effort to wrangle delegates at the convention. That remains the biggest weakness in Trump’s game against rivals who have a longer history in the party and who are better acquainted with the arcane rules of the nomination process. Manafort knows the dark arts. He is credited with helping Vladimir Putin’s ally, Viktor Yanukovych, win the Ukrainian election in 2010, reportedly advising his client to ditch the bouffant hairstyle that brought to mind Soviet apparatchiks and helping soften the pro-Russian speeches that had proved a handicap in the past. At the same time, a grown-up has taken over Trump’s phone. His Twitter feed — once filled with abuse for assorted targets — has turned vanilla. It is now a list of thank-yous, forthcoming media appearances and campaign videos. In Tuesday’s victory speech, Trump referred not to Lyin’ Ted but to Senator Cruz. A big step up in civility. Trump 2.0 might not be enough to clinch the nomination without a long, hot summer of bitter politicking. But it does suggest that Trump might now know what he is doing. He has identified his weaknesses and brought people in to get the job done — perhaps the first presidential thing he has done. — © The Daily Telegraph HILLARY TAKES IT AWAY FROM BERNIE FORMER secretary of state Hillary Clinton won a sweeping victory in the New York primary yesterday, bolstering her bid for the Democratic nomination for the White House. It was the most decisive New York primary in decades and leaves self-styled democratic socialist Bernie Sanders with a tough decision on how to proceed as Clinton extends her Inf lation falls faster than expected overwhelming lead. Both Clinton and Donald Trump will now look to replicate their wins in Connecticut, Delaware, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Rhode Island, which hold primaries on April 26, as they edge closer towards a general election in November. Clinton relished the victory to stall momentum generated by Sanders, who won seven of the eight previous nominating contests. “Thank you, New York,” she said to chants of “Hillary, Hillary, Hillary” from jubilant supporters in a Manhattan hotel, where she walked on stage with husband Bill and pregnant daughter Chelsea. “Today you proved once again there’s no place like home,” said Clinton, 68, looking to make history as the first woman president of the US. “The race for the Democratic nomination is in the home stretch and victory is in sight.” The former first lady and New York senator won 57.9% of the vote to 42.1 for Sanders, CNN said. Clinton now leads with 1 930 delegates compared to 1 223 for Sanders, according to CNN. — AFP MITSUBISHI has admitted to manipulating test data in 625 000 vehicles to improve fuel-economy claims. The affected models include those supplied to Nissan, which discovered the manipulation. Mitsubishi Motors’ shares fell the most in more than a decade in Tokyo trading, plunging 15% after it said it improperly handled fuel economy tests. The admission will intensify scrutiny of the car-making industry after Volkswagen’s admission last year that it rigged diesel models with software to meet US emissions standards. Volkswagen investigators are struggling to make headway through data secured from more than 1 500 laptops and other devices and probably won’t have a complete report on the emissions cheating by the due date at the end of the month. — Bloomberg Gupta employees plead with banks AN OPEN letter by employees of the Gupta family’s Oakbay company yesterday appealed to the country’s big four banks to restore ties with the firm‚ for fear of job losses. The letter‚ titled “Please save our jobs”‚ is marked for the attention of CEOs Maria Ramos of Absa‚ Jacques Celliers of FNB‚ Ben Kruger of Standard Bank and Michael Brown of Nedbank. The letter states that the employees do not care if the allegations that the Guptas have unduly influenced government policy are true, stating: “We have not captured the state.” It added: “All we care about is providing for our families. If you do not open Oakbay’s bank accounts we cannot be paid.” — TMG Digital YOUR WORLD IN 5 MINUTES Thursday April 21 | 2016 URBAN INFERNO: Heat haze on a highway in Chandigarh, India. The government says the heat wave has caused 130 deaths Picture: AJAY VERMA/REUTERS 11 Picture: EPA DYE HARDS: Workers preparing fabrics they have dyed for sale in Old Cairo. Fabric dying in Egypt dates back millennia HIGH JINKS: Salthill beach, in Galway, Ireland. The diving tower at Blackrock is a magnet for brave souls who want to test their mettle against the Atlantic Picture: CLODAGH KILCOYNE/REUTERS The Times FLOATING NOTES: A Kashmiri folk dancer performing during the Shikara boats festival in Srinagar, the summer capital of Indianadministered Kashmir Picture: GETTY IMAGES PORCELAIN BABY: A man veils his daughter from the sun on a hot day in a popular park in Beijing, China Picture: HOW HWEE YOUNG/EPA LIBYA ITALY NORWAY BRAZIL EGYPT UN fears 500 dead in Med shipwreck France’s ‘fish soup’ pizza is best in world Mass killer Breivik’s human rights violated Rousseff heads to UN over impeachment ‘Adulterous’ comments: man’s sentence cut THE UN refugee agency said yesterday it feared about 500 migrants from Africa had drowned in the Mediterranean, in what could be one of the worst tragedies since the migrant crisis started. Survivors, who were spotted drifting at sea before being picked up by a passing merchant ship on April 16, told the UNHCR many migrants drowned when human traffickers tried to transfer people to an overcrowded vessel somewhere between Libya and Italy. The latest reported deaths come as Europe struggles to find a way of stemming the flow of people fleeing war, poverty and persecution in what has become the continent’s worst migrant crisis since World War 2. — AFP WOULD you eat a fish soup pizza? A Frenchman has been crowned the best pizza-maker in the world after his bouillabaisse pizza won the World Pizza Championships in Parma. The unusual dish beat the Italians in an unprecedented turn of events. Ludovic Bicchierai, who works at the Pizzeria La Gusto near Marseilles, won the award late last week after judges were impressed by his unconventional seafood pizza. What toppings would you find on a fish soup pizza? The winning chef decided to put tomatoes, bream carpaccio, mozzarella, courgette flowers, prawns and Tabasco sauce on top of his dish. — © The Daily Telegraph MASS killer Anders Behring Breivik’s human rights were violated when he was kept in isolation in prison after being sentenced for killing 77 people in twin attacks in 2011, a Norwegian court ruled yesterday. Breivik took Norwegian authorities to court in March, accusing them of exposing him to inhuman, degrading treatment or punishment in breach of the European Convention on Human Rights. “The prohibition of inhuman and degrading treatment represents a fundamental value in a democratic society. This applies no matter what — also in the treatment of terrorists and killers,” Judge Helen Andenaes Sekulic said in her ruling. — Reuters BELEAGUERED Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff has changed her plans and will attend a UN event tomorrow in New York to make her case against an impeachment process that could remove her from office within weeks, her office said. Rousseff lost a crucial vote in the lower house of Congress on Sunday and faces impeachment by the Senate on charges of breaking budget laws. She maintains the charges are groundless and trumped up to oust her and end 13 years of rule by her leftist Workers’ Party. Two presidential aides said she would use her visit to defend herself against an impeachment that she has called a “coup d’état without weapons”. — Reuters A CAIRO court yesterday reduced to three months a three-year sentence for a man imprisoned for saying many women in Egypt are adulterous, a judicial official said. The court decision came a month after Taimour Subki was sent to jail for making the claim in a television interview, which sparked an uproar on social media. A misdemeanour court had convicted him of spreading “false news that disturbs the public peace”. “Many women cheat on their husbands … I can say that 30% of women are ready to be deviant,” Subki said on television, pointing to the southern cities of “Asyut, Minya, Sohag, Qena, Luxor and Aswan”. He said his remarks had been taken out of context. — AFP 12 The Times Thursday April 21 | 2016 OPINIONANDLETTERS Mining Charter blunder drives us closer to ‘junk’ T HE rating agencies and economists have made it plain that, in order to avoid a potentially devastating downgrade of its sovereign credit rating within months, South Africa urgently needs to do several things. The government must demonstrate that it is capable of meeting the Budget targets outlined by Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan. It must show real progress in overhauling and turning around cash-guzzling state-owned enterprises, including South African Airways. Crucially, it must create policy certainty to encourage investment and kick-start economic growth, which has slowed to just over 0.5%. This means redrafting the anti-business Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Amendment Bill, slashing red tape stifling business, creating incentives for Draw in new investment and carrying out labour investment reforms. In addition, the before government needs to dividing up demonstrate that the current political turmoil the pie around President Jacob Zuma is not distracting it from carrying out these urgent reforms, This is a tall order, particularly when one considers that Standard & Poor’s, which takes the dimmest view of South Africa’s prospects and rates the country’s debt at one notch above sub-investment grade, or “junk”, is expected to deliver its assessment in June. Given the pressure on Pretoria, it defies belief that Mineral Resources Minister Mosebenzi Zwane has unilaterally released a revised draft of the Mining Charter containing several unexpected changes. His department is also sticking to a rigid interpretation of the provision that 26% of ownership of mining firms must remain in black hands, even when the beneficiaries sell their stake, that has been fiercely contested by the Chamber of Mines. Zwane has defended his actions, saying the release of the charter is merely aimed at encouraging “robust debate”. BEE is essential in mining, and the economy generally, but surely in the current climate the aim should be first to attract investment before attempting to keep dividing the diminishing pie. WHAT’S TRENDING AT http://timeslive.co.za NEWS: Protesting Rhodes University students held At least three protesters have been arrested at Rhodes University for public violence. They were protesting over a list of alleged rapists that was circulated on social media. CELEBS: Actress flaunts her booty in saucy video Actress Phindile Gwala has decided to return to dance lessons. And the sexy video she posted is filled with enough bum to last you the whole of today. BUSINESS: SA’s credit rating may be cut to junk The credit rating may be cut to junk status this year, at least by Standard & Poor’s, amid concerns that government could fail to reach its budget targets. Shark DDT claims beyond plausibility I REFER to the sensational headline “DDT found in great whites” by Tanya Farber in The Times. It is pure sensationalism at its best to suggest that the DDT applied in South Africa’s anti-malaria programme is responsible for the DDT found in great white sharks. If Tanya understood how the DDT is applied in the Department of Health’s malaria control programme, she would realise that it is almost impossible for any of that DDT to reach the sea. In addition, there is no indication of what “high levels of DDT” are. It has not been proved to be carcinogenic in humans. It was banned because of being persistent and it accumulates. There is no record of it being responsible for a human death when used as recommended. The fact that DDT has been found in this species illustrates the stability of DDT. The source in this shark is other than the programme. — Dr Jim Findlay, Parklands All grown up, nowhere to go THE picture that emerges from the statistician-general’s report (“Deadly youth cocktail”, April 19) is deeply disturbing for a number of reasons. One of the main problems is that we will miss out on the so-called youth dividend, when young adults move into the labour market and gradually take over from the older generation. It usually leads to accelerated economic growth. Unfortunately, in our society many youths remain undereducated, underskilled and unemployed. As a result, many youths are frustrated and angry. Some turn to crime. That dire picture is one that we at Girls and Boys Town can attest to. Previously residential care to a few youths in need was the bulk of our focus. Now it is to take services and support into families and communities because not every youth in need can be accommodated in a residential facility. We are also aware that strengthening families and communities will have a broader and more sustained benefit. Our ongoing research of youth leaving care speaks of their fear and reluctance to try to make it on their own — and fears of unemployment and poor access to post-school education top the list of concerns. It is necessary to reexamine strategies and use of resources. We must find means of reducing duplication and stop agencies from routinely passing the buck. Let us work together with unified intent. Our children will be grateful. — Lee Loynes, CEO, Girls & Boys Town Our children must be safe at university AS PARENTS we all want the best for our children. We would like them to get the best possible education to secure rewarding jobs. We show this by sending them to universities and colleges, but have we ever asked ourselves how safe these institutions are? I’m asking this in the light of the rape accusations and allegations at Rhodes University. Institutions of higher learning should be a home for students away from their families and safety should be the primary priority for management. This is not the first university from which such reports have emerged and parents have reason to worry. The punishment must be harsh for those guilty of sex crimes at universities. Universities should not make parents regret they sent their children to study there. We pay huge amounts for tuition and accommodation, and want our sisters and brothers and children to be safe. To all the university officials, please give our students education and safety, that’s all we request. — Melato Mphahlele, Zebediela SMS COMMENTS On ‘The body politic’: ý NO MERCY must be shown to rapists on campuses. Female students need to be protected. — Baba Saloojee On ‘East London dries up’: ý THE water shutdown in Buffalo City is the fault of the ANC city council, who prefer dancing, luxury cars and overseas trips to running a metro efficiently. — Nathan Cheiman On ‘‘SA is not all doom, gloom’’: ý WE HAVE a good story to tell? The post office is bankrupt. SAA is a never-ending money pit, education is poor, we can’t complain about service delivery because there isn’t any, the country is run by criminals, and then there is Prasa, Eskom, the shocking state of healthcare facilities, the murder rate, rape out of control, the government doing nothing to protect our food source (farmers), violent protests and strikes, fraud and corruption, our president’s dismal performance, and the list goes on. — Sue Potgieter On ‘Dumb and dumber’: ý GAUTENG education MEC Panyaza Lesufi — another arrogant taxpayers’ nightmare being paid far more than he is worth. Using the Gauteng Education Department as a guinea pig, how stupid can you be? Then, of course, the inevitable escape card — racism. — Tony Is a downgrade to ‘junk’ inevitable?: ý I DON'T know why we are surprised that a downgrade is imminent. Zupta, EFF, student vandalism, riots, free education marches, our president squandering taxpayers’ money, BEE, crime, mines closing and our president can't read simple numbers written on paper. I wouldn't want to invest either. — Kannie Glonie Each SMS costs R1.50 HOW TO CONTACT US: WRITE TO: PO BOX 1742, SAXONWOLD 2132 SMS: 33971 EMAIL: [email protected] FAX: 011-280-5150/1 The editor reserves the right to edit and reject letters. Pseudonyms may be used, but must be clearly marked as such. BIG READS Thursday April 21 | 2016 The Times 13 Damned by the maths The statistician-general’s report says our youth are doomed. There’s only one way to fix this . . . P ALI Lehohla is not a man given to exaggeration. The nation’s statisticiangeneral lives in a subterranean world where smart people churn out large volumes of data, emerging from time to time with a report on every conceivable subject, from housing to unemployment to education, before disappearing again into the vast underworld of officially collected numbers. Except when Mr Lehohla emerged from the depths this week and the humble, soft-spoken statistician-general released a “Social Profile of Youth” report that must have sent chills down the spines of the most optimistic of citizens. Parents, he said, commenting on the development of youth between 2009 and 2014, are “better equipped” than their children. In that simple statement he devastated the South African narrative of consistent progress. Since 1994 politicians have sold us the lie that education and training were continually improving. More children go to school, more pupils pass Grade 12, more young people go to university, and more graduates get jobs. This policy narrative is seductive … after all, Rome was not built in one day; given more time, South Africa gets better as we move away from apartheid because of well-meaning policies and well-intended politicians. That is why we pounce on pundits who claim things were better under apartheid; things were not better in the past, of course, but the post-apartheid redemption narrative was at stake. No more. Black youth, in particular, are less equipped with education and skills to get jobs than a previous generation and, even when they have formal qualifications, are less likely to find productive employment than lighter-skinned graduates. There are all kinds of problems here. More young people without education or jobs. Sustained racial inequality among black and white youth when it comes to degrees and work. Growing numbers of CAREY OPPENHEIM AS PARENTS we try not to row in front of our children. Instinctively, we know they find it hard to cope when we’re at odds with one another, and they’re disturbed if our arguments become persistent or hostile. This is plain common sense. But there’s some important new information that all parents need to be aware of. It was published in a new report by the Early Intervention Foundation, where I am CE, along with the University of Sussex. Its findings? Simply: that unresolved conflict between parents has a potent influence on children’s early development. This is true whether the parents are together or apart. Having disagreements is normal, of course. What does the harm is the “unresolved” part. Children need to know that arguments can be settled, BACK TO BASICS: To avoid disaster, the entire schooling system must be reformed and the primary school system must be rebuilt so that pupils gain real competence in literacy and numeracy Picture: ALON SKUY black African and coloured youth not finishing school and not completing university. It is time to roll out familiar South African clichés such as “ticking time-bombs”. But what lies behind these scary numbers? First, that going to school is not enough. A quality education matters and completing a degree matters more. You are much more likely to get a job and earn good money if you have a degree compared to a matric certificate, and heaven help you if you don’t even have that. Certification matters, but so does colour. Graduates from the same university are more likely to get jobs depending on their race, the only possible conclusion being institutionalised discrimination. Where does this leave the country? The statistician-general puts it best: “a cocktail of disasters”, a very bleak future for black youth. Remember those disturbing pictures seen regularly in the media of black men captured by police and spread face-down across the ground with hands cuffed behind their backs? Now you know how we got into this sad position. Now you should know also where all this enormous frustration comes from among youth in communities and on campuses. It is the accumulation of social deficits (education, training, skills, and jobs) that pushes the horizon way beyond black African and coloured youth, in particular, that devastates hope for this demographic. “We used to absorb these hardships during the struggle,” said a seasoned activist as he wondered why today’s youth turns violent so easily. It’s simple actually — the previous generation fought for an end to apartheid and, in consequence, a new country that was expected to end our misery. On the other hand, this current generation came into the new South Africa on a promise that is maddeningly elusive. So what’s the solution? The statistician-general’s recommendation is surprisingly flat, unoriginal and grammatically clumsy: “Create an enabling ‘ Black youth are less equipped with education and skills to get jobs than a previous generation Here’s how to mess your kids up allowing life to move on. Ongoing conflict between parents can affect children’s mental health, the development of their social and emotional skills, academic attainment — and can affect their ability to form relationships. It can also damage their physical health, lasting through their adult lives and into the next generation. And it starts early. Babies as young as six months show higher physiological symptoms of distress, such as an elevated heart rate, in response to overt exchanges between parents. But children of all ages can be affected by destructive interparental conflict outwardly through high levels of aggression, hostility and violence, and inwardly through low self-esteem, anxiety, depression and, in extreme cases, suicidal feelings. Much of the focus of early intervention has been on the relationship between the parents — usually the mother and child. But this report suggests that it’s actually the quality of the interparental relationship that has a ‘ Children need to know that arguments can be settled significant influence on children’s long-term psychological outcomes and the quality of parenting they receive. It’s a critical missing piece of the jigsaw. We may kid ourselves that our children don’t notice rows, but the reality is they’re highly perceptive and attuned to how their parents relate to each other. How children perceive their parents’ level of conflict determines how they expect their parents to behave towards them and this, in turn, can lead to psychological distress. What’s fascinating is that conflict between parents has more of an impact on the relationship between a father and child than a mother. As a dad, if you’re having frequent difficulties in your relationship, this is more likely to filter into how you relate to and parent your offspring. Mums seem to be better at insulating their children from this spill-over effect. This dynamic is important for thinking about the best ways of supporting families and children environment that will propel young people to consider education as the best tool to poverty alleviation.” Yawn. We know that. But the answer is not reopening teacher education colleges, for example, for that will simply warehouse young black students while hoping for a jobgenerating economy. No, the way out of this precarious future is to comprehensively fund quality preschool education, rebuild the primary school system so that pupils gain real competence in literacy and numeracy, retain especially boys in a high-quality high school education, and then ensure that quality passes bring students into universities and technical colleges so that they get degrees and diplomas that land them real jobs in a growing economy. If this chain is weak at any point along the line, good night South Africa. to address these issues. Policy and services need to consider the couple relationship — together or apart — as well as the parent-child relationship. It also needs to address fathers as well as mothers. Policy makers and commissioners should consider support for both the couple and the parenting relationship. Just targeting the parent-child relationship in the context of ongoing parental conflict does not lead to sustained positive outcomes for children. We need more emphasis on teaching children and young people ways of managing conflict to better prepare them for life ahead. Most parents desperately want the best for their kids. We must put families at the heart of how we organise services and give parents the confidence to seek help if they need it. — © The Daily Telegraph 14 The Times Thursday April 21 | 2016 STYLIN’ IT TREVOR STUURMAN Home is where the hat is Making hats that really fit involves putting different heads together, writes Rea Khoabane FROM being a blogger, to a photographer and a stylist, one of South Africa’s most prominent digital trendsetters Trevor Stuurman is now a hat designer. He said he started this venture because every time his fans would see him in the streets, they would ask him when he was going to start designing hats. “Design has always been in me and it was just a matter of listening to my followers and giving them something designed by me,” he said. As a creative, Stuurman said he wants his work to live everywhere and that comes with him exploring the industry. His personal style, which is heavily influenced by prints, is usually finished off by one of his signature Simon and Mary hats. The local hat producers also manufacture his new hat range. “I chose to work with them because of the quality of the brand,” he says. The designer’s personal hat style has evolved over the years. He has been seen rocking 1950s-style military hats reminiscent of the Russian military, as well as the Muslim topi-inspired style. In collaboration with artist Nelson Makamo, the collection is titled “Home Is Where the Art Is” and consists of 10 hats that come in fedora and bowler styles. Makamo’s first collaboration with a fashion designer was in 2014 with Ole Ledimo of House of Ole on his Autumn/Winter15 collection. There he explored acrylic paint on suit fabrics. Known for painting children’s faces, Makamo’s art work is made of a number of ‘ Design has always been in me and it was just a matter of listening to my followers and giving them something techniques such as media-watercolour, pen and ink, monotype, silkscreen, charcoal drawing and painting (oil). On the “Home Is Where the Art Is” hat collection with Stuurman, Makamo has painted his hand-print, his signature and his iconic trademark face paintings. “I have been following Nelson’s work for three years and being fond of it, I was inspired and knew I had to work with him,” said Stuurman. Inspired by his home province, the Northern Cape, the young designer says he was on his way home and took a picture of a landscape and realised how dry the province is — hence the colours are earth tones. STYLEWISE HUMAN KALEIDOSCOPE: Blogger, photographer, stylist and hat designer Trevor Stuurman TOP NOTCH: Stuurman’s ‘Home Is Where the Art Is’ collection of hats “As a storyteller I decided to do earth-tone colours such as browns, green and blue which resemble my home province. “The collection comes in two-toned colours designed for an understated and bold look at the same time.” In the past Stuurman has worked with world renowned designers including Laduma Ngxokolo of Maxhosa by Laduma and international actor and producer Terry Pheto. Stuurman believes collaboration is the future, stating: “Collaboration allows similar minded creatives to find strength in one another. Collaboration moves the industry forward allowing each and everyone to expand their network and, as we all know, two minds work better than one.” TV and radio host Bridget Masinga on not being left flat-footed Describe your style in a sentence? Best wrinkle cure? Classic sophistication with a whimsical twist. Clean, uncluttered lines that can transition seasonally. If someone introduced me to a method that works, I would pay them handsomely. Favourite jeans? Favourite Instagrammer for style inspiration? Fashion editor Asanda Sizani’s posts reflect what’s beautiful and creative (@asansasizani). My style inspiration isn’t literal. Art, music, street culture, home deco, food, textures and travel influence how I experience the world, dictating how I assemble an outfit that reflects who I am and what I am feeling. Best item in your closet? A knee-length, round-neck black coat I bought in New York is my current favourite. It goes from casual to formal, from winter to summer and day to night. I like a tight, dark, stretch denim with a bit of a fade to give it character. Like everything in your closet, denim should be versatile and transitional. If you can only wear it with a T-shirt then it’s pointless. #JustSaying Every home should have… Reflections of your character. My home smells like vanilla. I love feminine scents and vanilla reminds me of all things soft, pink and fluffy. So every home should have some form of perfume whether by way of diffusers, room spritzers or perfumes. What makes a shoe chic? The sleek elegance of the design. As long as a shoe is sexy, daring and damn high… I’m good. I am not a flat-shoe kind of girl. right vintage pieces. With that said there’s something special about pieces that have lived a thousand lives: they bring a certain character to your wardrobe and demand a respect that newer fashion is yet to master. Best underwear? For insanely unaffordable, yet ridiculously sexy lingerie it has to be Agent Provocateur and La Perla. Fave shop? BCBG MAX AZRIA Spotted any talent lately? Many young emerging designers. I particularly like Tuelo Nguyuza’s aesthetic. There’s something soft and dreamy about his work that leads me to believe that once he’s perfected his craft he’ll be a talent to be noted. Vintage or brand new? I don’t have the patience for finding the Your style inspiration? My friend David Tlale knows how to design clothes that flatter and complement a woman’s form and personality. Most stylish person on earth? Victoria Beckham is put together with effortless ease. She wears easy, practical, accessible fashion that’s always appropriate for the occasion and the stage in her life. O&M CAPE TOWN 89895/E COME ON PROTEAS KEEP IT FABULOUS 16 The Times Thursday April 21 | 2016 HOROSCOPES, FOOD & FASHION BAG IT Keep that purse pristine WHEN IN USE ý Keep make-up and creams in a separate bag to avoid spillage on the lining. ý Always put pens in a penholder. Marks generally don’t come out. ý In the car ensure that it is in a secure place. You don’t want it to roll around. ý Avoid placing handbags on the floor. They may be stood on or kicked over. ý Ensure that your hands are clean when holding your bag. Sweat, cream and natural oils can cause the handles to darken. ý Dark jeans sometimes give off dye. Be careful with lightcoloured bags because dye stains permanently. STORAGE ý Keep your handbags in the dust bags they originally come in. This protects them from light that may cause discolouring over time. This also protects the bags from rubbing colour off on each other, which is often the case, especially with patent leather. ý Keep bags stuffed so they keep their shape. Bags can change shape when empty. Use tissue paper. ý Keep bags on a dedicated bag shelf. This should be common practice. It ensures that bags are not squashed on top of each other, getting scuffed or losing shape. When hanging bags on a hook, gradual wear and tear is caused on the handles, and may even stretch them over time. WHAT TO DO WHEN YOUR HANDBAG GETS WET A downpour may catch you off guard, forcing you to find shelter under your ever faithful leather handbag. If you’re left with a dry hairdo but a wet leather handbag, follow these steps: ý Don’t panic! Some bags may go darker due to the water — it should revert to its original colour in most cases. ý Empty the contents of your bag and stuff it with paper in order to keep the shape. ý Put your bag in a dry place away from sunlight and leave it to dry. Depending on how wet your bag is, this may take a few days ý DO NOT put your bag in the sun or expose it to heat such as hairdryers, sunlight, ovens or microwaves. — Marissa Ravenscroft CARPETBAG STEAK INGREDIENTS Oyster stuffing 1 x 85g can smoked oysters, drained 45ml (3 tbsp) softened butter Zest and juice of 1 small lemon 5ml (1 tsp) dried chilli flakes (optional) 10ml (2 tsp) Asian fish sauce (or Worcestershire sauce) Freshly ground black pepper, to taste 2 sirloin steaks, cut 3-4cm thick Olive oil Salt and pepper, to taste METHOD For the stuffing, mash the oysters with a fork and mix with the butter, lemon zest and juice, chilli flakes and fish sauce. Season with black pepper and chill until firm. Using a sharp knife, make a deep, lengthways incision into the middle of each steak from the fat side, without cutting right through, to form a pocket. Divide the stuffing between the pockets in the steaks, securing with toothpicks. Rub steaks with olive oil and season. Cook over high heat for 6-8 minutes per side, depending on preference. Serve with chips and salad. Serves 2. ý Recipe from STARS scientists think there’s a fair statistical chance of another planet like Earth existing somewhere. But they’ve yet to find one. So it’s fair to say we’re amazingly lucky to be here. Why, on top of all that, would we even want to be lucky enough to win the lottery, too? Recognise the luck you already have today. This may yet help you to get the luck you need. The growing light of the full moon brings you fresh opportunity. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. Jonathan Cainer CAPRICORN (December 22 - January 20) ARIES (March 21 - April 20) People like to think of themselves as full of light and love. Rarely do we hear folk openly championing forces of darkness and hatred. Even when we encounter folk who seemingly espouse such causes, shouldn’t we be charitable and say: “They’re not really so bad; they’re just lacking insight and compassion.” Or should we denounce them? And if we do, won’t that take us into the shadowy world of moral judgment? Let the light of humility guide you away from a sense of false superiority today. Now, as the moon grows full, I have a spookily accurate forecast for you. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. TAURUS (April 21 - May 21) Thank you for coming to this page. I recognise you have a choice of service provider to meet your needs. But before I can meet those needs, I must assess them. I can’t just make an outlook sound better than it actually is in the hope that this will encourage loyalty. Nor, today, can you tell someone what they want to hear just because you suspect you know what that is. A full moon in your opposite sign suggests, for the sake of a better long-term relationship, you may have to be brave in the short term. As the moon grows full, much can be revealed and changed. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. GEMINI (May 22 - June 22) Who wins when we give up? Someone else, who hasn’t given up yet. It is, though, wise to remember that, sometimes, the only way to win is to stop trying so hard to be a winner. Some games aren’t worth playing, some challenges aren’t worth rising to, some victories are purely pyrrhic. We don’t really see the right way to proceed until we stop trying to convince ourselves that the wrong thing is the right thing. Something may need to be “given up” now. But only so something better can be taken up. The growing light of the full moon brings you fresh opportunity. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. CANCER (June 23 - July 23) If guardian angels don’t get paid, what keeps their minds on their jobs? Imagine if they let their attention wander like you and I tend to. What if they’re dreaming of their holidays just when we need rescuing from disaster? Perhaps we could get more help if only we could work out how to incentivise them? Some mystics say that’s possible. They say angels only ever want appreciation and for us to make some YOUR It’s full moon time. Or, at least, it will be soon. To an astrologer, it is always the phase just prior to the full moon that matters most. Once the angle of opposition between the two luminaries has become exact, we expect less tension, drama or change. The moon will still look full tomorrow and, indeed, all the weekend. Vampires and werewolves can still officially cite this as a licence to get out and about. But if you’re worried about any aspect of your own life resembling a scary story, by this time tomorrow, you should be seeing solutions. effort to hear and heed their suggestions. Try the latter today. Full moon magic will happen. Now, as the moon grows full, I have a spookily accurate forecast for you. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. LEO (July 24 - August 23) When do we ever wake up and wonder what today we should feel afraid of? We may cast around for new things to do, ideas to excite us or opportunities to inspire us but we rarely require fresh reasons to worry. In the unlikely event that we find ourselves short of these, fears automatically sense the vacancy and start jostling with one another for pole position in our personal list of top 10 terrors. Sing happier songs to yourself today till they become so catchy you can’t remember how any other tune goes. As the moon grows full, much can be revealed and changed. Call MTN 083900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. VIRGO (August 24 - September 23) Far more often than things go wrong, we worry about things going wrong. Far more often than there is trouble, we fear trouble. Far more often than we need to, we get anxious about whether there is something we need to do. Unless, perhaps, there’s some purpose to the way in which we give ourselves such a hard time or succumb to so much stress? Is it good for us? Do we gain from it? Of course not. Like a hurdle on a racecourse, it only exists so that it can be risen above. Rise high today. The growing light of the full moon brings you fresh opportunity. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. LIBRA (September 24 - October 23) Would you like a reason to worry? Aha! I thought not. Well, that’s good, isn’t it. I won’t give you one. The fact that you can supply such an unequivocal answer to our opening question tells us something encouraging. Why don’t you want a reason to worry? Partly, of course, for the same reason nobody does. But it is also because you feel you’ve already got too many of those. But you need not worry about getting any more and, despite a full moon, you may soon have fewer. Now, as the moon grows full, I have a spookily accurate forecast for you. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. SCORPIO (October 24 - November 22) “What the eye don’t see, the heart won’t grieve.” I remember, as a child, hearing this ghastly maxim being quoted in all seriousness by adults. Well, I say adults. It’s a childish idea. An adult understands consequences. An adult has integrity. An adult doesn’t think: “Can I get away with this if nobody sees it happening?” Only a person with an immature mindset makes that kind of a calculation. The question under this full moon in Scorpio is not, “What will make the best impression?” but, “What will be best?” As the moon grows full, much can be revealed and changed. Call MTN 083-9008535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. SAGITTARIUS (November 23 - December 21) Against all odds, a rock spins in space. Against all odds, it keeps at just the right distance from the star that it orbits. Against all odds, it supports life. Many There’s so much that we don’t know. With that, we’re all in the same boat. Whether we’re hungry for discovery or have no interest in broadening our minds, we’re only human. There are just too many subjects that deserve in-depth study yet we’re not here for long enough to scratch the surface of even a few. That may be why some decide not to try. Yet those who cultivate an open mind soon find they have a precious asset. Ask questions today. You’ll like what you learn. Now, as the moon grows full, I have a spookily accurate forecast for you. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. AQUARIUS (January 21 - February 19) We can be too quick at times to close doors. While we may need to get better at saying “no”, there’s a reason why we are reluctant to say it. Negativity brings more negativity. It is contagious. If we add to the overall amount of refusal floating around, we increase the likelihood that more will make its way back to us. Positivity may render us vulnerable but only if we don’t apply enough of it. Venus now conjoins your ruler. To get what you're hoping for, do less moping and more hoping. As the moon grows full, much can be revealed and changed. Call MTN 083900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. PISCES (February 20 - March 20) “T’ain't What You Do (It’s the Way That You Do It).” If you’ve been following your forecast lately, you’re hopefully humming the tune to this by now. I’ve made it our theme of the week because those words are so true to all you’re going through. You’ve got the power to transform a situation and to make it wonderful. You can solve a problem, heal a wound, make a great impression and fix a difficulty. Just be the person you become when you are at your best and all will happen naturally. The growing light of the full moon brings you fresh opportunity. Call MTN 083-900-8535 or Vodacom 079-008-4033. Calls cost R10 per minute at all times. Only on network calls are accepted. PUZZLES SPOT THE DIFFERENCE | Find five differences in these pictures of Karlie Kloss Thursday April 21 | 2016 The Times THE TIMES CROSSWORD 17 © The Times, London Pictures: GC IMAGES seen in New York on Monday SOLUTIONS 1 4 7 8 5 9 2 6 3 3 6 4 7 8 2 3 9 9 5 8 1 2 3 6 4 6 4 7 2 1 7 5 8 4 1 9 3 7 8 2 5 5 9 1 6 5 6 2 9 1 3 8 4 7 ACROSS DOWN 1 Borne back by fabled beast, mad 1 What’s made by celebrity getting out of here ahead of time? (6,5) 2 Parry departs leaving bill (5) 3 Top container for Spooner’s lowgrade fuel (5,4) 4 Looking embarrassed about tale vagrant told (7) 5 Overturned set about to malfunction (3,2) 6 Record-holder has spell on board (9) 7 Short performance raised a small amount (3) 12 Permission to leave troops in key setting (11) 14 Elaborate bromide rattled queen (9) 15 Region broadcast great communist features (9) 19 Republican in second surprise withdrawal (7) 21 Old sinner? There’s one, they say, in every church (5) 23 God’s name an irritant (5) 25 With leader absent, muddle remains (3) King George’s dumbstruck (13) 8 Extra cover for ruminants, primarily (4) 9 Put an end to bizarre rite described by monastic (10) 10 Gut reaction of fashionable society cold in tone (8) 11 Deposits by church rising (6) 13 Idolaters frantically penning article relating to Eros, etc (10) 16 Hot air bed (4) 17 Reporter’s become stuck upright in doorway (4) 18 Big city backer fails to get housing (3,7) 20 Active, like endangered species in historic flood? (2,4) 22 Bank holding large volume back by any chance? (8) 24 Amid badinage, detective’s keeping mum — he knows the score (10) 26 Male’s left warning about unknown livestock (4) 27 Source of timber from the southern Caucasus, extremely versatile (5,8) SUDOKU | 2 7 3 1 8 6 5 9 4 8 1 6 5 9 4 7 3 2 Fill in all the squares in the grid so that each row, column and each of the 3x3 squares contains all the digits from 1 to 9. © Puzzles by Pappocom 9 5 4 7 3 2 6 1 8 MEDIUM THE PAJAMA DIARIES VIOLA DAVIS AND ELLEN BURSTYN Solution, tips and computer program at www.sudoku.com 18 The Times Thursday April 21 | 2016 CRICKET Classified: 011 280 3147 [email protected] Legals: 011 280 5553 [email protected] Legal Services 2290 www. LAWYER.co.za 2230 Personal BIRTHRIGHT Pregnant? We care Jhb: 079 ± 742 ± 8861 Dbn: 031 ± 201 -5471 ADDICTION RECOVERY HOMES & HALFWAY HOUSE www. healingchoices.co.za peter@ healingchoices.co.za AL-ANON & ALATEEN For families & friends of problem drinkers. 0861 ± 252 ± 666 FREE SERVICE GAMBLERS ANONYMOUS Is your gambling problem making your life unmanageable? You are not alone Please call Gamblers Anonymous for help 071 377 2746 / 060 624 7140 Website: https://gasouthafrica.word press.com/ Town Planning 11150 NOTICE IN TERMS OF SECTION 18(3) OF THE RUSTENBURG LOCAL MUNICIPALITY SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BYLAW,2015 FOR CONSENT USE Direla Planning Solutions (PTY) LTD ( 2012/200772/07), being the authorized agent of the owner of Erf 4947 Geelhout park Extension 9, give notice in terms of Section 18 (3) (c) and section 18 (3) of the Rustenburg Spatial Planning and Land use Management By-law,2015 that we intend to apply to the Rustenburg Local Municipality for Special consent on Erf 4947 Geelhout Park extension 9, for the purpose of a Tuck Shop restricted to 40m2. The concerned property is curUHQWO\ ]RQHG k5HVLGHQWLDO y The property is 247 in extent. Particular of the applicant will lie for inspection during normal office hours at office of Director Planning and Development, Room 312, Missionary Mpheni House, c/o Beyers Naude and Nelson Mandela Drive, Rustenburg for the period of 30 days from 21 April 2016. Objections to or representations in respect of the application must be lodged with or made in writing to the Municipal Manager at the above address or at P.O. Box 16, Rustenburg, 0300 within a period of 30 days from 21 April 2016. Address of the authorized agent: 259 Beyers Naude Drive, Rustenburg, 0300 Cell of the authorized agent 0718869152 029E0E Town Planning 11150 NOTICE IN TERMS OF SECTION 18(3) OF THE RUSTENBURG LOCAL MUNICIPALITY SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BYLAW,2015 FOR CONSENT USE Direla Planning Solutions (PTY) LTD ( 2012/200772/07), being the authorized agent of the owner of Remaining Extent of Erf 1289 ( Section 2), give notice in terms of Section 18 (3) (c) and section 18 (3) of the Rustenburg Spatial Planning and Land use Management By-law,2015 that we intend to apply to the Rustenburg Local Municipality for Special consent on Remaining Extent of Erf 1289 ( Section 2), for the purpose of a Guest house. The concerned property is currently ]RQHG k5HVLGHQWLDO y 7KH property is 247 in extent. Particular of the applicant will lie for inspection during normal office hours at office of Director Planning and Development, Room 312, Missionary Mpheni House, c/o Beyers Naude and Nelson Mandela Drive, Rustenburg for the period of 30 days from 21 April 2016. Objections to or representations in respect of the application must be lodged with or made in writing to the Municipal Manager at the above address or at P.O. Box 16, Rustenburg, 0300 within a period of 30 days from 21 April 2016. Address of the authorized agent: 259 Beyers Naude Drive, Rustenburg, 0300 Cell of the authorized agent 0718869152 029E1V Sun won’t set on day-night debate TELFORD VICE THE lights will stay off for the third Test between Australia and South Africa in Adelaide in November — for now. Cricket Australia released their fixtures for 2016-2017 yesterday and the only day-night Test scheduled is against Pakistan in Brisbane in December. But the Aussies remain hopeful that the Saffers will wake up to what they consider the future. “We are working with Cricket SA with a view to ensuring that the Adelaide test is a day-night Test,” Cricket Australia CE James Sutherland said. “With more than 123 000 people attending and 2 million watching on television last season (when Australia and New Zealand played the inaugural day-night Test), there is enormous expectation that we deliver another pink-ball Test match this summer in Adelaide.” South Africa’s senior players pulled the plug on the idea based on the feedback they received from the Australians when they toured in March — that the ball is difficult to pick up visually in fading and artificial light, and that a pitch left unusually grassy to help preserve the condition of the ball was key to the Australia-New Zealand game ending inside three days. “ The players’ strong desire to play this as a normal Test match is testament to how much they care about the series,” SA Cricketers’ Association CE Tony Irish said. “There is understanding for what CA is trying to achieve and of the commercial advantages, but this is still very experimental and there is also a strong cricket imperative.” ‘ The pink ball is difficult to pick up in fading and artificial light Which would seem to be the kernel of the debate. After all, Sutherland’s view is that “day-night Test cricket is all about the fans”. The players? They’re in there somewhere ... “[South Africa’s players] are well aware of the views of the New Zealand and Australian players expressed after the first day-night Test,” Irish said. “It has been clear from all of this that the Australian players are also reluctant to play the match as a daynighter and that they want to play a normal Test match.” The discussion took an interesting turn yesterday,when AB de Villiers and Dale Steyn raised the same concerns Irish expressed. But Steyn, perhaps feeling his bowler’s blood surge, also told CA’s website: “I don’t want to go through my whole career without playing a day-night game. How cool are they? “I’m leaving it to CSA for them to make a decision, but to be honest with you, I’d love to play one.” SA in Australia: 1st Test: Perth, November 3-7. 2nd Test: Hobart, November 12-16. 3rd Test: Adelaide, November 24-28 Thai Café Franchising (Pty) Ltd seeks to employ: THAI CHEFS x 10 ATTENTION READERS ARE ADVISED TO CAREFULLY SCRUTINISE ALL ADVERTISEMENTS PLACED IN THE PAPER. IT REMAINS THE CONSUMER’S RESPONSIBILITY TO VERIFY THE ADVERTISERS CREDENTIALS PRIOR TO MAKING PAYMENTS FOR ANY GOODS OR SERVICES RECEIVED. TIMES MEDIA WILL NOT BE HELD LIABLE FOR ANY TRANSACTIONS MADE. Minimum Requirements: • At least 3 years of experience as a Thai Chef • Ability to converse in Thai and English • Must have ability to train South African kitchen staff with standard kitchen operational procedures, menu design, product selection and co-ordination. Duties will include: • The preparation of authentic Thai dishes • Training South African staff members and assisting the Head Chef/ Owner with Menu design, operational planning, kitchen management, production selection & procurement and coordinating the restaurant’s day-to-day activities. Remuneration & Benefits: To be assessed depending on the experience of successful candidate. Closing date for this application is 28 April 2016 Please send comprehensive CV in strictest confidence to: [email protected] NIGHT-WATCHMEN: A total of 123 000 people attended the Adelaide Oval for the three days of the inaugural day-night cricket Test between Australia and New Zealand last year Picture: QUINN ROONEY/GETTY IMAGES Think outside the box and embrace the pink Sunita Parbhoo on 011 280 3147 Email: [email protected] ESPNCricinfo’s Daniel Brettig believes the Proteas should drop their conservatism and take the long view: Ever since South Africa rejoined international cricket in 1992, their Australian counterparts have felt themselves to be in possession of a small but vital advantage. Put simply, when Australian teams are in a difficult position they attack, while South Africa’s combinations are often expected to take the conservative option. This idea has applied not only to Australian Test encounters with South Africa, but also to ICC events, in which the teams of AB de Villiers & Co have fallen short. With that in mind, it is not particularly surprising that South Africa’s cricketers have raised their hands in protest at the idea of playing a day-night Test as the potential decider to next summer’s series in Australia. South Africa, we are told, lack experience playing first-class cricket under lights. They have not tried the pink ball in domestic competitions, nor have the Test players given it a practice run at nocturnal training sessions. In a series in which the No 1 Test ranking may be on the line, SA’s players think the ‘ It is not surprising that SA cricketers have raised their hands in protest stakes are too high for such an experimental concept. A day-night warm-up match is not enough practice. As Rod Marsh argued in his Cowdrey Lecture at Lord’s last year, after Australia’s 2014 tour to South Africa: “How can the Test match crowds in South Africa be so poor? They have a magnificent team, with arguably the best fast bowler in the world and possibly the best batsman in the world. Yet no one goes to watch them play at home.” By consenting to play a day-night Test, SA’s players would make a statement of openness that would be felt far beyond the context of a single match in Adelaide. They would open up the possibility of such matches being played in South Africa in front of far larger Test crowds than the nation has ever seen. They should consider that last year’s Adelaide Test drew the biggest attendance ever for a match between Australia and New Zealand. Equally, a willingness to try something new would run contrary to the conservatism South African cricket is known for, and which player would not leap at the chance to overturn that stereotype? SPORT Thursday April 21 | 2016 The Times 19 Mzwakali wants out of Ajax Cape Town CONOR TAPS OUT AJAX Cape Town midfielder Bantu Mzwakali has told the club he wants out. Urban Warriors coach Roger de Sa says Mzwakali wants to make a move to one of Johannesburg’s big clubs. Ajax could part with as many as 12 players at the end of the season if management accepts the offers made by various clubs. — Tiyani wa ka Mabasa UFC featherweight champ Conor McGregor kicks Nate Diaz during their UFC 196 welterweight bout last month. The rematch — UFC 200’s headline bout — will not happen as McGregor has announced his retirement Picture: BRANDON MAGNUS/ GETTY IMAGES ‘Women bad drivers but good CEOs’ WOMEN drivers were not physically able to drive quickly enough in Formula 1, the sport’s supremo Bernie Ecclestone suggested at a conference in London. But he predicted a rise in female chief executives, saying: “Women are more competent and they don’t have massive egos.” — AFP Maties’ R37m civil case lurches into gear As keen as Mostert THE showdown in the civil case between the University of Stellenbosch and SA Rugby CEO Jurie Roux took a small step forward yesterday after months in limbo. The university finally supplied Roux’s lawyer with documents requested in December. It took a court application for the university to eventually comply. — Craig Ray Lions lock is hungry for Springbok glory SBU MJIKELISO LAST year Lions lock Franco Mostert caught a whiff of what it feels like to be a Springbok when he was called up to the Rugby Championship squad. But this time he is hungry for the full course. The industrious second-rower didn’t earn his debut cap despite an injury to Victor Matfield early in Brisbane that kept the veteran out for a couple of games. But Mostert dusted himself off after that disappointment and has formed the backbone of a Lions team hell-bent on making the Super rugby play-offs for the first time. He has faced some fearsome competitors at the lineout, such as Boks Pieter-Steph du Toit and Lood de Jager, plus All Blacks Sam Whitelock and Brodie Retallick. For the most part he’s come out on top. “I feel very good about my performances this season and I think I’ve had a few good seasons behind me,” said Mostert. “The big thing is to just be grateful and to enjoy every minute. If you do that everything will fall into place. “It’s every guy’s dream to play for the Springboks and just to be in that group of national team players. It’s recognition for the hard work you’ve put in and an affirmation that you’ve been playing well.” The former Blue Bulls and University of Pretoria (Tuks) lock was particularly satisfied with the Lions’ 29-22 win over the Stormers at Ellis Park on Saturday — even though the visitors were without the injured Bok enforcer Eben Etzebeth. Mostert will be going up against another emerging lock, who could be on Bok coach Allister Coetzee’s radar, John-Charles Astle, when the Lions face the Southern Kings in Port Elizabeth on Saturday. ‘ The big thing is to just be grateful and to enjoy every minute Astle, in concert with the experienced Steven Sykes, has kept the Kings lineout functioning smoothly. They have even had the cheek to disrupt a lot of their opponents’ throw-ins. Mostert said: “JC Astle is a good player. He played for the Shimlas in the Varsity Cup [in 2012 and 2013] and was a strong contender for the player-of-the-year award. “I’m looking forward to going up against him and I know I have to bring my best to compete against him. ” Single point in it for Baroka TSHEPANG MAILWANE WITH five games left in the National First Division, Lucky Mhlathe looks at who will win automatic promotion to the Absa Premiership. He predicts Baroka FC will sneak in ahead of Highlands Park, who are a point behind. Baroka’s remaining fixtures: April 30 v Royal Eagles (A) “Baroka have been good on the road, but slipped up at Vasco in Cape Town.” Prediction: Draw. May 4 v Thanda Royal Zulu (H) “Thanda have not had a good season.” Prediction: Baroka win. May 7 v Witbank Spurs (H) “Both teams play attacking football, so it should be an interesting one.” Prediction: Draw. May 15 v African Warriors (A) “Warriors are destined for relegation.” Prediction: Baroka win. May 22 v Milano United (H) “Milano will run out of steam.” Prediction: Baroka win. Predicted season total: 61 points Highlands Park’s remaining fixtures: April 23 v Milano United (H) “Milano will struggle.” Prediction: Highlands win. May 1 v FC Cape Town (A) “Highlands will be too strong for them.” Prediction: Highlands win. May 7 v Black Leopards (H) “Leopards’ new coach, Sello Chokoe, can get players to play for him.” Prediction: Draw. May 15 v Mthatha Bucks (A) “They are difficult to play against, but I think Highlands will be stronger.” Prediction: Highlands win. May 22 v AmaZulu (H) “AmaZulu’s players want to impress whoever is going to come in as new coach.” Prediction: Draw. Predicted season total: 60 IN CINEMAS 22 APRIL 9 771996 551005 07616 AS Vita shoot down sloppy Brazilians Downs left to rue lost chances MARK GLEESON MAMELODI Sundowns ran out of time in their bid to qualify for the African Champions League as they were eliminated from the competition on the away goals rule after beating AS Vita Club of the Democratic Republic of Congo 2-1 last night in the second leg of the third round. Sundowns now wait for the draw today of the African Confederation Cup into which they drop, left to chase Africa’s secondary competition rather than the glamorous top prize. Sundowns fans tried to invade the pitch after the referee played a scandalous four minutes of stoppage time when the Congolese were blatantly wasting time. But Sundowns have only themselves to blame. Down 1-0 from the first leg, the Brazilians had enough chances to easily win the return match but failed with their poor finishing against a crafty opponent, who used every trick to eat up time. “Anxiety crept in and our decision-making let us down,” a bitterly disappointed Pitso Mosimane said afterwards. Ordinarily Sundowns would have buried the chances they got in the 12th, 14th, 18th and 20th minutes but seemed to freeze at the vital moment in front of goal. It meant the early goal they craved did not come. WASTED CHANCES: AS Vita Club’s Bafola Dido is challenged by Khama Billiat of Mamelodi Sundowns during a CAF Champions League match at Lucas Moripe Stadium in Atteridgeville last night Picture: BACKPAGEPIX Vita Club got a chance in 28th minute when Mayimona Ikanga’s shot deflected for Kule Mbombo to get a touch, which Wayne Sandilands saved. But 11 minutes later, Mbombo got a touch from Bernard Morrison and the ball squeezed into the net. Suddenly Sundowns went from THE ALLISTER COETZEE BREAKFAST! llister Coetzee is the new South African coach for the next four years and CorporateSport has secured the former Stormers coach for a Mimecast business breakfast in Johannesburg. With the Irish arriving early in June, Coetzee has had to hit the ground running and will be chatting to us about the challenges which lie ahead. Enjoy a morning in the company of Coetzee with your key clients as we look ahead to a new era for South African rugby. Matthew Pearce will be the MC. A BREAKFAST DETAILS Date: Wednesday 4 May 2016 Venue: Wanderers Club (Ball Room) Time: 07h00 - 09h30 MC: Matthew Pearce BREAKFAST COSTS Per table of 10: R4950.00 (excl. VAT) Per person: R515.00 (excl. VAT) * Includes parking and autograph cards For more information, or to book, please contact Sally-Ann or Teresa at CorporateSport on (011) 803-0165 or via return e-mail at [email protected] • www.corpsport.co.za needing one goal to now suddenly needing three to win the tie. But they began their attempted comeback within 120 seconds as Castro won a penalty after being challenged by Vita goalkeeper Nelson Lukong and Thabo Nthethe converted the resultant penalty. In the 75th minute Sundowns went ahead as Nthethe put Tebogo Langerman through — but try as they may for a decisive third goal, it did not come. ý Golden Arrows were held to a 1-1 draw by Maritzburg United in an Absa Premiership match at Princess Magogo Stadium last night. Francois Pienaar bats for Proteas TELFORD VICE WHEN Francois Pienaar talks, people listen. Even when he says: “It’s not that we are the fount of all knowledge, definitely not.” The Rugby World Cup-winning Springbok captain spoke yesterday on his new role — as a member of a Cricket SA review panel that will try to get to the bottom of why the Proteas have yet to win a World Cup. “Passion. I love this country.” That was Pienaar’s reply when asked why someone who, in 1995, held the William Webb Ellis Cup aloft in triumph beside a beaming Nelson Mandela would bother with a bunch who are the best team in the game but not the tournament. “It’s not about the sport, it’s about the processes in place,” Pienaar said. “There are four or five things you need to get right, one is a bit of luck. “People think if you have that it’s a guarantee. It’s not. If you do those four or five things really well, you will have a good chance of winning. When you get to the final, it’s a 50-50 call and it’s the smart guys who work out the margins.” Pienaar said he was not unfamiliar with cricket. “They asked me to come and do a session on margins and big games and how you close games down.” Would the results of the panel’s work be made public? “They have to be. Otherwise I wouldn’t be involved.” Inspired Man United close in on the Gunners the top four spots yielding MATTEO Darmian inspired passage to the Champions Manchester United to victory League. over Crystal Palace and United trail Arsenal by a Liverpool crushed derby rivals point and third-place Everton 4-0 as both teams Manchester City by two, enhanced their chances of although the north London securing European football club have a game in hand. last night. Everton will Italian rightgo into their back Darmian M a r t i n ez ’s men Wembley date scored his first with United on Premier League have gone the back of a goal for United Merseyside and created an seven games derby hiding at own-goal for without victory Anfield that Damien Delaney means Roberto as fifth-place Martinez’s men have now gone United beat Palace 2-0. seven games without victory. Divock Origi scored but was After a one-sided first half, then stretchered off as Liverpool struck twice in four Liverpool outclassed Everton minutes shortly before halfto remain within two points of time as James Milner crossed sixth-place West Ham United. for first Origi and then centreThe teams finishing fifth and back Mamadou Sakho to head sixth stand to qualify for next home. — AFP season’s Europa League, with ‘