Heritage Recommendation 602861 - Department of Environment

Transcription

Heritage Recommendation
602861
Queensland Heritage Act 1992
Under delegation from the Chief Executive, Department of Environment and Heritage Protection, and under the
provisions of s.44 of the Queensland Heritage Act 1992, I, Fiona Gardiner:
Recommend to enter this place in the Queensland Heritage Register as a State
Heritage Place
Recommendation Date: 27 July 2015
Delegate name/position: Fiona Gardiner, Director
Figure 1: 1933 Sectional School Building (Block A), viewed
from northeast (Source: EHP, 2015).
Figure 2: Proposed heritage register boundary (EHP, 2015)
Place name
Moorooka State School
Address
Sherley Street, Moorooka, 4105
LGA
Brisbane City Council
RPD
Lot 595 on SP118822; and 5 metres into the road reserve of Beaudesert
Road (1/ROAD0) and Sherley Street (1/ROAD0) (see attached proposed
heritage register boundary map).
Queensland Theme
9.01
Educating Queenslanders: providing primary schooling
Prepared by Heritage, Department of Environment and Heritage Protection | 27 July 2015
1
602861
Assessment of significance
Statement of Significance
criterion a
the place is important
in demonstrating the
evolution or pattern of
Queensland’s history
Moorooka State School (established in 1929) is important in
demonstrating the evolution of state education and its associated
architecture in Queensland. The place retains excellent, representative
examples of a standard government design that was an architectural
response to prevailing government educational philosophies, and a nonstandard design that reflects the specific needs of the school.
Three connected Sectional School buildings (1929, 1933 and 1946)
demonstrate the culmination of many years of experimental timber
school design by the Department of Public Works (DPW), providing
equally for educational and climatic needs.
A three-storey brick and concrete building (1956) demonstrates the postwar construction of larger and more permanent school buildings in areas
of established populations. The building reflects mid-20th century
architectural and educationalist movements through its modernist,
climatically responsive design and materials.
The grounds retain mature trees and landscaping features,
representative of suburban school sites, and demonstrate the
importance of play and aesthetics in the education of children.
criterion d
the place is important
in demonstrating the
principal
characteristics of a
particular class of
cultural places
Moorooka State School is important in demonstrating the principal
characteristics of a Queensland state school with later modifications.
The school is a good, intact example of a suburban school complex,
comprising: timber-framed teaching buildings constructed to standard
designs by the Queensland Government; a non-standard brick and
concrete building; and a landscaped site with mature shade trees,
retaining walls and assembly / play areas.
The three connected Sectional School buildings (1929, 1933 and 1946)
are fine, intact examples of their type, comprising: timber framed
structure; Dutch-gabled roofs; highset form with play space beneath
(1929 and 1946 buildings); blank end walls; northern verandahs, with
linkages between buildings; large banks of south-facing windows;
projecting teachers rooms (1929 and 1933 buildings); hat room
enclosures; single-skin verandah walls; coved ceilings with metal tierods and latticed vents; and early joinery and internal linings.
The brick and concrete building (1956) is an excellent, intact example of
an individually-designed state school building, typically constructed in
areas with large urban populations to meet the specific needs of the
school. Designed in a mid-20th century modernist style, the building
combines rectangular massing, walls with areas of contrasting textures
and climatically responsive design elements such as concrete fin sunshades. The efficiently planned and well composed building comprises
an elongated form, with facebrick and metal-framed glazing enclosing
stairwells at the east and west ends, north-facing concrete verandahs
along the first and second floors, and a glazed entrance and lobby to the
east.
2
602861
criterion g
the place has a strong
or special association
with a particular
community or cultural
group for social,
cultural or spiritual
reasons
Schools have always played an important part in Queensland
communities. They typically retain significant and enduring connections
with former pupils, parents, and teachers; provide a venue for social
interaction and volunteer work; and are a source of pride, symbolising
local progress and aspirations.
Moorooka State School has a strong and ongoing association with the
surrounding community. It was established in 1929 through the efforts of
the local community and generations of children have been taught there.
The place is important for its contribution to the educational development
of its suburban district and is a prominent community focal point and
gathering place for social and commemorative events with widespread
community support.
3
602861
History
Moorooka State School opened in January 1929 to accommodate the growing population of
a previously rural district on the southern outskirts of Brisbane. The first Sectional School
building was extended in 1933 and 1946 with further Sectional School buildings to its
northeast and northwest corners. In 1956 a three-storey brick and concrete classroom block
in a modernist style was added, as post-war housing construction in Moorooka continued to
increase the local population. The standard and purpose-built school buildings are set
amongst terraced, landscaped grounds with mature trees. Apart from a brief hiatus during
World War II (WWII), the school has been in continuous operation since establishment and
has been a focus for the local community as a place for important social and cultural activity.
Originally part of an area called ‘Boggo’, which ran from Dutton Park to Rocky Water Holes
(later Rocklea, c1884), and which was part of the traditional lands of the Turrbal people,
Moorooka’s development was spurred on by transport improvements. Predominantly an
agricultural area until the early 20th century, 1 the coming of the Logan railway in 1885
increased the attraction of the district for residential development. The Moorooka railway
station was established in 1887 and the Moorooka Railway Station Estate was advertised in
1889, 2 but flooding in 1893 deterred settlement of the area for some time. 3 By 1900
Moorooka was still primarily rural, with most residents living between Ipswich Road and
Beaudesert Road. 4 The house ‘Greenloaning’, built for Robert Bell in 1904, was on land
which later became the Moorooka State School’s Infant School, and his family lived there
until WWII.5
Residential development occurred to the west and north of the school site in the early 20th
century, assisted by the extension of the tramline to Yeronga Park in 1915. 6 In the 1920s the
area east of Ipswich Road, to the south of Yeronga Park, was used for war service housing. 7
The tram line was extended from Yeronga Park, down Beaudesert Road as far as Mayfield
Road, in 1937. 8 However, the area around Moorooka State School (east of Beaudesert
Road, between Mayfield and Evans Roads) remained largely undeveloped before WWII,
apart from some housing between Bracken Street and Sherley Street. 9
The establishment of schools was considered an essential step in the development of
growing communities and integral to their success. Locals often donated land and labour for
a school’s construction and the school community contributed to maintenance and
development. Schools became a community focus, a symbol of progress, and a source of
pride, with enduring connections formed with past pupils, parents, and teachers.
In 1911, the population of Moorooka was 350, rising to 791 by 1921. 10 Pressure for a state
school at Moorooka occurred from around 1912, when the Moorooka Progress Association
presented a petition to the Education Department. 11 Moorooka children either attended
Rocklea State School, or Yeronga State School (established 1867 as Boggo State School). 12
A site for a new school at Moorooka, consisting of 3 acres, 1 rood and 2 perches (1.3ha),
was purchased from Charles Robert Parish by the Department of Public Instruction in
December 1927. 13
The first building constructed for the school, during 1928, was a standard Public Works
design. To help ensure consistency and economy, the Queensland Government developed
standard plans for its school buildings. From the 1860s until the 1960s, Queensland school
buildings were predominantly timber-framed, an easy and cost-effective approach that also
enabled the government to provide facilities in remote areas. Standard designs were
continually refined in response to changing needs and educational philosophy and
Queensland school buildings were particularly innovative in climate control, lighting, and
ventilation. Standardisation produced distinctly similar schools across Queensland with
complexes of typical components.
4
602861
Attention to improving light and ventilation to achieve an optimum classroom environment
culminated in 1920 with the Sectional School (Type DT/1), a high-set timber structure. 14 This
fundamentally new design combined all the best features of previous types and implemented
theories of an ideal education environment. It proved very successful and was used
unaltered until 1950. This type was practical, economical, satisfied educational requirements
and climatic needs and allowed for the orderly expansion of schools over time.
Before the Sectional School, all school buildings were generally aligned with street and
property boundaries, regardless of aspect. By late 1914, after acceptance of the principles
and virtues of providing natural light into classrooms advocated by Dr Eleanor Bourne,
(appointed as the first Medical Inspector of Schools in 1911), buildings were being preferably
orientated to receive maximum indirect southern light. The Sectional School type was
designed to have an unobstructed wall of windows on its southern elevation and verandahs,
typically to the north but sometimes to the end elevations, allowing for linkages to other and
future buildings. Its blank end walls were also detailed to be removable, so that as the school
grew, the building could be easily extended in sections, hence the name. This led to the
construction of long narrow buildings of many classrooms – a distinctive feature of
Queensland schools. 15
The Sectional School building at Moorooka was aligned approximately east-west, being
lowset at the east end, and highset at the west end (due to sloping ground), and consisted of
five classrooms 21ft by 18ft (6.4m by 5.5m), with an 8ft (2.4m) northern verandah which
wrapped around the east and west sides. A teachers room projected off the northern
verandah, and the northeast and northwest verandah corners were enclosed. 16 The 1928
plan indicated possible future expansion through the addition of buildings off each corner of
the first building, linked by their verandahs; 17 an expansion approach that accommodated
the sloping site. The building (known as Block B in 2015) had a Dutch-gabled roof and was
set on concrete piers. About two thirds of the understorey play area, on the west side, was
floored with concrete. Three of the classrooms were linked by folding partitions, which could
be opened to create an assembly hall. The remaining partitions were fixed, with centred
doorways. 18 It was reported that there was room for 200 pupils, with ample light and
ventilation provided by large windows on the southern side. The completed cost was
£2,607. 19
Moorooka State School opened in January 1929 with 139 children and 6 teachers. By the
end of the year, enrolments had increased to 230. 20 At the school’s official opening on 16
March 1929, T Wilson, the Minister for Education, noted that the school, built on the elevated
part of the site, had a beautiful view to the west, and was positioned to allow for future
expansion. 21
Efforts were made to improve the school grounds and its facilities. The Ladies Committee
worked to provide a piano, a sewing machine and a library, and to install electric lights at the
school. In late 1929 a concert was held in the Ideal Picture Theatre in Yeronga to raise
funds. 22 The uneven parade ground between the school and Sherley Street was levelled by
government relief workers, and boys at the school helped remove tree stumps from the
grounds. 23 In 1931 two tennis courts were opened, southwest of the school building, with
money raised by the School Committee, the Ladies Committee, and teachers. 24
The continued increase in daily attendance (averaging 260 by 1933) also led to a new twoclassroom wing for 100 children (known as Block A in 2015) officially opened on 27 May
1933 by FA Cooper, the Minister for Public Instruction. 25 Connected to the northeast corner
of the 1929 block, the addition was another Sectional School building, with the same
proportions and features as the first. 26 The south wall had casement windows with fanlights,
while the northern windows were double-hung sashes. 27 There was a teachers room off the
north verandah, and semi-enclosed hat rooms at the northwest and southeast verandah
corners. Inside, the building had coved ceilings, with exposed metal tie rods.
5
602861
WWII affected the functioning of Moorooka State School. In 1942, a Staging Camp (Camp
Moorooka) was constructed for the US Army between Mayfield Road and Bracken Street,
extending south to the east of Medina Street, and west to the southeast corner of Moorooka
State School. 28 The Queensland Government closed all coastal state schools in late January
1942, 29 but while most state schools resumed on 2 March 1942, some, such as Moorooka,
remained closed for ‘special reasons’. 30 The US Army took over Moorooka State School
from 24 February 1942, 31 and as a result, most of Moorooka’s pupils went to Junction Park
State School. However, Moorooka’s students were allowed back to their own school on 13
July 1942. 32
Substantial housing development also occurred south of the school towards the end of
WWII. In 1944-45 the Moorooka War Workers Housing Estate was built between Scherger
Street and Evans Road, for married workers at the Rocklea Munitions Works. This
complemented the hostels built for single workers, located to the west of Beaudesert Road,
south of Hamilton Road, 33 and the hostels’ area was later used for housing ex-servicemen. 34
After the war, the business centre of Moorooka shifted to Moorvale, at the junction of
Beaudesert and Mayfield Roads. 35
Moorooka State School continued to expand after WWII, as a result of housing development
and an increased local population. In 1947 the combined population of Moorooka, Rocklea
and Salisbury was 8,364, and this rose to 12,163 in 1954, and 17,246 by 1971. 36 In late
1946 a new wing for infants (known as Block C in 2015) was added to the northwest corner
of the original building. 37 Another Sectional School design, this was highset (although lower
than the 1929 building) with the understorey floor concreted. Plans also show a concrete
retaining wall between the 1946 building and Sherley Street. 38 The roof was Dutch-gabled,
and the northern verandah wrapped around the east and west sides. The southern side was
lit by casement windows and the northern by double-hung sash windows. The two
classrooms were larger than in the previous blocks, being 26ft by 23ft (7.9 by 7m) and
divided by a folding partition. Ceilings were coved, with exposed metal tie-rods and latticed
vents. Hat rooms were located at the south end of the west verandah, and the northeast
corner of the verandah of the new building; while the connection to the 1929 building, by
steps rising up between the verandahs, required the relocation of an existing hatroom to the
south end of the latter’s western verandah. 39 It is claimed that the windows on the verandah
side of Block C improved ventilation, and that these rooms were popular. 40
The Department of Public Instruction was largely unprepared for the enormous demand for
state education that began in the late 1940s and continued well into the 1960s. This was a
nation-wide occurrence resulting from the unprecedented population growth now termed the
‘baby boom’. Queensland schools were overcrowded and, to cope, many new buildings were
constructed and existing buildings were extended. 41 At Moorooka State School, a former
Camp Moorooka store building to the south of the school was converted into four classrooms
in 1946. 42 Between 1946 and 1950 a new teachers room was attached to the east verandah
of the 1929 block, as well as a single-storey extension to the west of the existing northern
teachers room. Concrete stairs to the northwest of Block A, similar to those adjacent to Block
C, were also added around that time. Two temporary classrooms blocks (totalling five
classrooms), were built between 1948 and 1951, on 0.7ha of land added to the south side of
Moorooka State School in 1943. 43 Such temporary buildings were constructed in
Queensland schools between 1943 and 1951, and were introduced as an expedient,
temporary solution to the baby boom and post-war shortages of labour and materials. The
remainder of the school grounds, to the south, were added by 1950. 44
While the majority of school buildings were built to standard plans, as in other periods, some
buildings were also constructed to a purposed design. These were typically constructed in
areas of stable, suburban and urban populations and can be seen as an evolution of the
urban brick school buildings of the early 1900s and depression-era brick school buildings.
They were generally substantial structures of brick and concrete that introduced many
6
602861
innovative ideas that later found their way into standard plans. For example, brick was
progressively used more frequently in high schools as standard. 45
In 1953, new brick primary school buildings were planned for Moorooka, Townsville and
Walkervale (Bundaberg), as part of a school-building program at that time that was
reportedly a record for the state. 46 Moorooka State School’s new brick and concrete threestorey classroom block (known as Block D in 2015) was approved in 1953, at a cost of
£43,635, 47 and the building was opened in 1956. 48 The building was designed by Frederick
George Kirkegard, 49 a student architect with the Department of Public Works, in a modernist,
austere style popular at the time.
Modernist architecture developed in pre-World War I Europe and gained popularity in
Australia after WWII. It is notable for a rationalisation of planning, emphasising clarity and
simplicity of form and detailing. 50 Distinguished by their extensive use of steel, reinforced
concrete and glass, Australian buildings in the modern or ‘International’ style were heavily
influenced by American and European examples. Characteristics included rectangular
massing, plain smooth walls with areas of contrasting textures, and selective expression of
structural systems, such as concrete framework. In Queensland, architects sought to create
climatically responsive modernist buildings by combining careful building orientation, sunshading devices and natural ventilation methods. This design approach was consistent with
the requirements espoused by UK and NSW educationalists at the time, who advocated for
schools that were climatically responsive with diffused natural light, and constructed of
modern materials that were durable, washable and attractive. 51 Education in the 1950s was
embracing the modern, and media reports at the time espoused the virtues of bright and
attractive school buildings for encouraging student attendance, stating that ‘Brisbane’s
modern new State schools should make for happier, healthier learning’. 52
The new building at Moorooka was anticipated to ‘provide classrooms and other facilities of
the most modern character’. 53 Kirkegard’s design comprised an elongated form of
rectangular massing, with contrasting areas of facebrick (enclosing the east and west ends)
and painted concrete (verandah and shade elements). There were open verandahs on the
northern side, with large concrete fins that contributed to sun control, and a concrete
balustrade. The building had timber-framed hopper windows on the southern elevation with a
long flat concrete hood, and double-hung sash windows with fanlights on the northern
elevation. Constructed to the southwest of Block C, the new building contained an open play
area for most of the ground floor, with a health services room, glazed entry lobby and
stairwell at the east end, and a stairwell and boys lavatory at the west end. The first floor
included four classrooms, a store and cloakroom at the west end, and a head teachers
room, with associated lobby and bathroom, at the east end; while the second floor had four
classrooms, with a store and cloak room at the west end and a utility room at the east end. 54
A curved, Brisbane Tuff (commonly known as porphyry) retaining wall with incorporated
planter boxes, was also built to the north and east of Block D at this time 55 (with concrete
block extension in the late 1960s).
The school continued to expand from the 1950s onwards, with new buildings and some
changes to existing buildings. New tennis courts were built by 1955, further south on the
east side of the school, after Block D was built north of the original tennis courts. In 1958
Blocks J and K were built for an Infant’s School (opened 1959). In 1959 Block C’s western
verandah was enclosed as a store and hat room, new stairs were built at each end of Block
B (on the verandahs, leading down to the understorey), and a boys’ toilet was added inside
the Head Teacher’s room in Block D. 56
The 1960s was a period of growth at the school. Enrolments rose from 700 to 1000 between
1967 and 1970, although later fell back to 700 by 1976. 57 Further buildings were added to
the school during the 1960s and 1970s, along with a swimming pool in 1963. An east-west
retaining wall was built south of Block A in the late 1960s, and the retaining wall to the
northwest of Block A was extended to Sherley Street at the same time. 58 Staff toilets were
7
602861
added to the west end of the ground floor of Block D c1968, and a library (Block L) was built
south of the east end of Block D in 1977. Meanwhile, the converted army hut was removed
from the grounds c1958, and the temporary classrooms blocks between 1972-4. 59
The population of Moorooka in 1976 was 9,639, but the late 1970s saw a decline in student
numbers, due to an aging population. In 1983, the Junior and Primary Schools were
combined. 60 In December 2006, Blocks J and K were destroyed by an arson attack, 61 but
were replaced with a multi-purpose hall that opened in 2009. 62 Moorooka’s population was
8,609 in 2001, rising to 9,984 in 2011. 63 The arrival in the suburb of immigrant families from
culturally diverse backgrounds is reflected in the current student body at Moorooka State
School.
The school grounds now cover 5.1ha, and include mature plantings, some of which were
planted by students on Arbor Days. The provision of outdoor play space was a result of the
early and continuing commitment by the Department of Public Instruction to play-based
education, particularly in primary school. Trees and gardens were planted as part of
beautification of schools. In the 1870s, schools inspector William Boyd was critical of tropical
schools and among his recommendations stressed the importance of adding shade trees to
playgrounds. 64 In addition, Arbor Day celebrations began in Queensland in 1890. Landscape
elements were often constructed to standard designs and were intrinsic to Queensland
Government education philosophies. Educators believed gardening and Arbor Days instilled
in young minds the value of hard work and activity, improved classroom discipline and
developed aesthetic tastes. Aesthetically-designed gardens were encouraged by regional
inspectors. 65 Mature trees currently along the northwest boundary were evident in aerial
photographs from 1946. 66 Memorials commemorating ANZAC Day (2008) and the opening
of the Outdoor Learning Centre (2004) have been placed adjacent to one of two pencil pines
(Cupressus Sempervirens) to the northeast of Block C.
In 2015, the school continues to operate from its original site. It retains standard timber and
purpose-built brick buildings dating from 1929 to the 1950s, set in landscaped grounds. The
school is important as a focus for the surrounding community and generations of students
from the area have been taught there. Since establishment the school has been a key social
focus for the local community. The grounds and buildings have been the location of many
social and community events over time, including as a meeting place of the Moorooka
Branch of the Australian Red Cross during WWII, 67 and for fetes to raise funds for the
school. 68
8
602861
Description
Moorooka State School occupies a 5.1ha site (Lots 595 SP118822 and 594 SP118821)
bounded by Sherley Street to the north, Beaudesert Road to the west, Alexander Park to the
south, and residential properties that front Blomfield Street to the east. However, the
registered boundary encompasses the northern 1.3ha of the school (Lot 595 SP118822
only), consistent with the 1927 school reserve. The main entrance to the school is along
Sherley Street, where the timber school buildings (Blocks A, B and C) and mature trees
along the boundary contribute to the suburban streetscape. The site slopes downwards from
northeast to southwest. The school complex comprises a variety of educational buildings
and landscape features of varying eras of design and construction. Of these, significant
components are concentrated to the north and include:
•
•
•
•
•
Block B – Sectional School Building (1929);
Block A – Sectional School Building (1933);
Block C – Sectional School Building (1946);
Block D – Brick and Concrete Building (1956); and
Landscape features – Mature trees and retaining walls.
Elements within the registered boundary that are not considered to be of cultural significance
include: Blocks E, F, and I; the Library; various modern ancillary structures; modern
landscape features such as pathways and paved areas; and the swimming pool. Where the
register boundary extends into road reserve, the road and footpath fabric is not considered
to be of cultural significance.
Sectional School buildings – Blocks A, B and C
The three Sectional School buildings are timber-framed and weatherboard-clad structures on
concrete piers, with corrugated metal-clad Dutch-gable roofs and verandahs along the north,
east and west sides. The buildings are symmetrically arranged in a U-shaped plan, with
Block A and Block C connected to either end of the northern verandah of Block B. The
buildings range from lowset to highset, reflecting the slope of the site. From east to west:
Block A is lowset; Block B is highset; and Block C is highset, though set lower than Block B
and connected via verandah stairs.
The buildings retain extensive early timber joinery. Southern windows comprise large banks
of casements with horizontal centre-pivot fanlights. Windows to the northern verandah walls
vary, with banks of high-level horizontal centre-pivot windows to Block B, and double-hung
sash windows with horizontal centre-pivot fanlights to Blocks A and C. Windows and doors
retain early fittings and hardware. The interior walls and ceilings are lined with timber vjointed (VJ) tongue-and-groove (T&G) boards. The ceilings are coved, with exposed metal
tie rods and square lattice ceiling vents. Skirtings and architraves are timber of a simple
profile.
Verandah walls are single-skin, lined with VJ, T&G boards with exposed external framing.
Verandah floors are timber, and ceilings are raked and lined with VJ, T&G boards. Joinery to
the verandahs includes square timber posts and two-rail timber balustrades with battened
balusters. Classrooms are accessed from the northern verandahs via flush-panelled doors
with fanlights. Hat / bag hooks are attached to the verandah walls of Blocks B and C.
Teachers rooms are attached to the north and east sides of Block B, and to the north of
Block A; they are gable-roofed and weatherboard-clad, and feature skillion window hoods
with timber brackets. The north-facing teachers rooms have battened gable infills. The
interior walls and flat ceilings are lined with VJ, T&G boards.
9
602861
Elements of the Sectional School buildings not considered to be of cultural significance
include additions and alterations such as: modern extensions; carpet and linoleum floor
linings; sheeted and glazed partitions; ceiling fans and air conditioning units; understorey
enclosures; modern joinery, fixtures and fittings; and aluminium framed windows.
Block B (1929) - Centre
Block B contains an open plan classroom space (formerly five classrooms). The lintels and
bulkheads of the four original classroom partitions remain, with a modern concertina door
inserted into one opening.
An early hat room enclosure (1946) is retained on the southwestern corner of the verandah,
along with a connecting stair to the northwest. The northern verandah is accessed via two
sets of external stairs. Additional stairs (c1959) have been inserted into the east and west
verandahs, providing covered access to the understorey. The east verandah stairs are
enclosed with a combination of modern fixed glazing and louvres.
The eastern teachers room (c1946 - 1950) is lowset on timber stumps; and connected to the
1929 building via a small verandah extension. The door is panelled and the windows to the
north, east and south are narrow, double-row casements.
The northern teachers room is highset on concrete piers. floor. The window on the eastern
wall is an original casement, while the fixed northern window and verandah door are
modern. There is a lowset weatherboard-clad extension to the west (added c1946-50).
The understorey of Block B combines open areas for play, and enclosed areas for storage
and a workshop (former modern tuckshop). The southern side has been partly enclosed with
facebrick, which also formed the tuckshop counter area. Other areas are enclosed by either
concrete, corrugated metal or timber battens. The understorey of the northern teachers room
is enclosed with weatherboard cladding.
Block A (1933) - East
Block A contains two classrooms, separated by an original partition with part-glazed doubledoors. Part-height modern partitions form a small office space within the western classroom.
The east and west facing Dutch-gable ends feature battened infills. The lowset understorey
is also enclosed by timber battens.
The verandahs are partially enclosed with modern sheeted and glazed partitions on the
northern side between the teachers room and classrooms, and in the southeast corner for a
store room (former hat room). The original semi-enclosed hat room is retained in the
northwest corner.
Two sets of timber stairs access the northern verandah either side of the lowset teachers
room. The teachers room retains a casement window to the north, while the eastern window
has been replaced.
Block C (1946) - West
Block C is primarily highset, with a lowset eastern verandah that is supported by a concrete
retaining wall (1946). The building contains an open plan classroom space (formerly two
classrooms – larger than those in Block A). The former layout is discernable from partition
bulkheads that remain.
The original semi-enclosed hat rooms are retained in the northwest and northeast corners of
the verandah. The western verandah (now enclosed) is clad externally with weatherboard
and lined internally with flat sheeting, and has with timber-framed hopper windows. Timber
stairs provide external access to the north and east verandahs. The understorey is enclosed
with corrugated metal, timber battens and concrete panels, and used as a storage area.
10
602861
Brick and Concrete Building – Block D (1956)
Block D is a three-storey, brick and reinforced-concrete building with a low-profile hipped
roof. The building has rectangular massing and the elongated form comprises three distinct
sections: full height facebrick enclosing concrete stairwells and amenities at the east and
west ends; and first and second floor classrooms with north-facing verandahs to the centre.
The north elevation features vertical and horizontal concrete fins forming ten bays to each of
the upper floors. The verandahs are painted concrete and the end bays are enclosed with
fixed, metal-framed glazing. The south elevation features a continuous, flat reinforcedconcrete hood over the lower windows.
The building retains much of its original timber-framed joinery. Windows to the east-end
section are hoppers with rendered projecting jambs, and the west-end section has mostly
casement windows. Classrooms have banks of south-facing hopper windows with fixed
timber shelves to sill height. Windows to the verandah walls are double-hung sashes with
horizontal centre-pivot fanlights. Some verandah windows on the second floor have been
replaced with aluminium-framed sliders. Classroom doors are low-waisted timber with glazed
inserts. Classrooms at the western end have sliding doors.
There are three (formerly four) classrooms on both the first and second floors. The fixed
classroom partitions have timber doors at the southern end. Original folding partitions have
been removed; however, the fixed partition bulkheads and doorways remain. Walls and
ceilings are lined with flat sheeting.
The west end section has lavatories to ground floor, and open meeting spaces (former cloak
rooms) and toilets to the first and second floors. The east end section has a glazed entrance
lobby to ground floor, and a combination of offices, storage and toilets to the first and second
floors. The stairs in both end sections have metal balustrades with timber handrails. A ramp
at the eastern end of the first floor connects with the understorey of Block B to the east.
Much of the ground floor (formerly open play space supported by concrete piers) has been
enclosed with fibrous-cement sheeting to form modern office spaces. Open areas have been
retained adjacent to the east and west stairwells. These thoroughfares have fixed timber
bench seats.
Landscape Elements / Grounds
The established school grounds comprise mature trees and garden beds, as well as various
built landscape features.
The sloping site is terraced with embankments and retaining structures. The school is set
slightly below Sherley Street, with earth embankments along part of the northern boundary.
There is a flat parade ground to the north of Block B, surrounded by garden beds. A
concrete retaining wall (1946) with stairs aligns to the north of Block C, and a similar set of
concrete stairs (pre-1950) are located north of Block A. A curved retaining wall (c1955),
finished with Brisbane Tuff, extends from northwest of Block C around to southeast of Block
D. The wall is stepped and incorporates planter boxes.
Mature trees including figs (Ficus spp.) and camphor laurels (Cinnamomum camphora) are
concentrated along the northwest boundary of the school and contribute to the streetscape.
Further mature plantings of various Eucalypt species (Eucalyptus spp.) are concentrated
near the eastern boundary of the school.
Two mature pencil pines (Cupressus Sempervirens) are located adjacent to the entrance on
Sherley Street. Memorial plaques have been placed adjacent to one of the pencil pines. One
memorial is an ANZAC Day commemoration from 2008, the other is in commemoration of
the opening of the Outdoor Learning Centre in 2004.
11
602861
Illustrations
Figure 3: Northwest corner of Moorooka State School, view from Beaudesert Road, from northwest (EHP, 2 June 2015).
Figure 4: Sectional School Building (Block B) with projecting teachers room; north elevation, view from parade ground, from
northwest (EHP, 2 June 2015).
12
602861
Figure 5: Sectional School Building (Block A), with adjacent concrete stairs and western verandah connected to Block B
northern verandah; view from northwest (EHP, 2 June 2015).
Figure 6: Sectional School Building (Block A); view along west verandah from Block B, view to hat room, from south (EHP, 2
June 2015).
13
602861
Figure 7: Sectional School Building (Block C); north elevation, view from north (EHP, 2 June 2015).
Figure 8: Sectional School Building (Block B); classroom interior, view from east (EHP, 2 June 2015).
14
602861
Figure 9: Block D; north elevation, from Sherley Street entrance, from northwest (EHP, 2 June 2015).
Figure 10 (left): Block D; east stirwell from first floor landing, with glazed verandah bays, view from south (EHP, 2 June 2015).
Figure 11 (right): Block D; north elevation with verandahs and concrete fins, view from northwest (EHP, 2 June 2015).
15
602861
Site Plans
North
Figure 12: Moorooka State School, site plan with significant buildings shaded in grey and proposed register boundary in red
(EHP, 2015).
16
602861
Proposed heritage register boundary
The proposed heritage register boundary contains all of Lot 595 SP118822 and extends 5
metres into the road reserve (1/ROAD0) at the northwest corner to encompass the extent of
significant tree canopies.
17
602861
18
602861
Endnotes
1
Clarke, R and Thomason, P, 1979 (plus 1989 update volume by Thomason, P), Moorooka State School Jubilee
1929-1989: a history of the school and district. Moorooka State School Jubilee Committee, pp.14-5.
2
Clarke and Thomason, Moorooka State School Jubilee 1929-1989, p.17; ‘Moorooka Railway Station Estate’,
The Brisbane Courier, 11 May 1889, p.10.
3
Project Services, ‘Moorooka State School’, in Queensland Schools Heritage Study Part II Report, for Education
Queensland, January 2008, p.4; ‘Do you know your Brisbane? Moorooka and Rocklea – rich in historic interest’,
Sunday Mail, 7 July 1929, p.28.
4
Clarke and Thomason, Moorooka State School Jubilee 1929-1989, pp.20-1. Moorooka was part of the Shire of
Yeerongpilly, prior to its amalgamation into the City of Brisbane in 1925.
5
Clarke and Thomason, Moorooka State School Jubilee 1929-1989, p.24.
6
‘Do you know your Brisbane? Ipswich Road – a cluster of progressive suburbs.’ Sunday Mail, 14 April 1929,
p.23.
7
8
‘Suburban development of Brisbane: bright future of the Ipswich Road District’, Courier Mail, 19 February 1936,
p.18. The article claimed that Moorooka would become ‘another Annerley’, regarding residential development,
thanks to the tram line extension. The tramline was extended to Salisbury in 1940. (Mackenzie, A, 1992.
Memories along the Boggo Track, Boolarong, Brisbane, p.108.
9
Aerial photograph, 17 May 1944, RAAF3-4.
10
‘Moorooka’, www.queenslandplaces.com.au/moorooka (accessed 6 May 2015).
11
‘Progress Associations: Moorooka’, The Telegraph, 13 December 1912, p.4.
12
Queensland State Archives Agency ID5869, ‘Yeronga State School’.
13
Certificate of Title 11230205, DNRM. The land was originally part of Portion 198, purchased by John
Robertson in 1864.The site was transferred to the Crown in February 1943, with a Deed of Grant to the Secretary
for Public Instruction in Queensland, the next month. The school was originally intended to be sited west of
Beaudesert Road (then called the Southport Road), which would have put it in the Oxley electorate, rather than
the Logan electorate in which it ended up; despite 95% of the pupils coming from the Oxley electorate. ( ‘New
State School opening at Moorooka, Department’s record’, The Telegraph, 18 March 1929, p.7)
14
School types are detailed in the following study: Burmester, P., Pullar, M., and Kennedy, M., Queensland
Schools, A Heritage Conservation Study: Conservation Management, Report for the Department of Education,
November 1996, p.30.
15
Burmester, P., Pullar, M., and Kennedy, M., Queensland Schools A Heritage Conservation Study, a report for
the Department of Education, November 1996, pp.41-44.
16
‘Moorooka State School’ photo in DPW Annual Report, 1929; Plan 143-15-9_16113845, ‘Moorooka State
School Additions’, Department of Public Works, 1932.
17
Plan 143-15-9-2_16113856, ‘Moorooka State School’, Department of Public Works, 1928.
18
Plan 143-15-9_16113845, ‘Moorooka State School Additions’, Department of Public Works, 1932.
19
Report of the Department of Public Works for the year ended 30 June 1929, p.5.
20
21
‘Moorooka, new state school, splendid structure’, Sunday Mail, 17 March 1929, p.12; ‘Moorooka: opening of
the new school’, The Brisbane Courier, 18 March 1929, p.20.
22
‘School concert’, Brisbane Courier, 2 December 1929, p.23.
23
24
Clarke and Thomason, Moorooka State School Jubilee 1929-1989, p.43; ‘Tennis Courts opened’, Brisbane
Courier, 7 October 1931, p.18. These tennis courts were located south of Block D. See site plan 1637-4161_11048279, ‘Moorooka State School Block Plan’, Department of Public Works, 1950.
25
‘School wing opened’, Sunday Mail, 28 May 1933, p.20.
26
Plan 143-15-9_16113845, ‘Moorooka State School additions’, Department of Public Works, 1932.
27
Project Services, ‘Moorooka State School’, p.7.
28
National Archives of Australia, control symbol FOLDER M TO N FOLIO 69, ‘Moorooka Camp Site’, 1944.
29
‘All coastal schools shut until change seen in war’, Courier Mail, 28 January 1942, p.3.
30
‘Teaching pupils of shut schools’, Sunday Mail, 1 March 1942, p.3.
31
‘Moorooka State School commandeered by the military during WW2’,
http://www.ozatwar.com/locations/moorookastateschool.htm (accessed 6 May 2015)
32
‘Concern on school facilities’, The Telegraph, Monday 20 July 1942, p.2.
33
‘Moorooka War Workers Housing Estate’ http://www.ww2places.qld.gov.au/places/?id=959 (accessed 28 May
2015).
34
35
36
37
The new block is not extant on a 12 June 1946 aerial photograph of the school. (QAP82-35283, DNRM).
38
Plan 1637-282_16113900, Department of Public Works,1946.
39
40
19
602861
41
Project Services, Queensland Schools Heritage Study Part II Report, for Education Queensland, January
2008, pp.28-31.
42
‘Rest of news in brief: Moorooka School’, The Courier Mail, 31 May 1946, p.5; Plan 1637-289_16113889,
‘Moorooka State School, conversion of army hut to temporary classrooms’, Department of Public Works, 1946;
Site plan 1637-416-1_11048279, ‘Moorooka State School Block Plan’, Department of Public Works, 1950; and
NAA control symbol FOLDER M TO N FOLIO 69, ‘Moorooka Camp Site’, 1944.
43
Plan 1637-238_16113867, ‘Moorooka SS new temporary classroom’, Department of Public Works, 1948; aerial
photograph BCC5-39426, 1951. Survey Plan SL1673 indicates that a ‘State School Extension Reserve’ was
gazetted in 1943.
44
The current grounds were listed as school reserves by 1950 (site plan 1637-416-1_11048279, ‘Moorooka State
School Block Plan’, Department of Public Works, 1950). Lot 594 was surveyed in November 1948, and from
1981 this allotment included the 1943 school extension. (Survey plans SL1952, (1948); SL9570, (1981).
45
Burmester et al, Queensland Schools, A Heritage Conservation Study, p.77.
46
‘Record School Building’, Queensland Times, 28 December 1953, p.2.
47
‘New school’, Courier Mail, 20 February 1953, p.5.
48
Building was still underway in 1955 (Report of the Department of Public Works for the year ended 30 June,
1955’).
49
F.G. Kirkegard was later a founding partner of Kirkegard & Ellwood, a Brisbane based architecture firm.
50
Richard Apperley, Robert Irving and Peter Reynolds, A Pictorial Guide to Identifying Australian Architecture,
p.281.
51
Burmester et al, Queensland Schools, A Heritage Conservation Study. p.72.
52
‘Bright Schools May Be Magnet to Many Pupils’, The Courier Mail, 31 December 1952, p.3.
53
Report of the Department of Public Works for the year ended 30 June 1955, p.10.
54
Plan 1637A-8-4_16113988 ‘Moorooka new brick school, foundation plan, ground floor’, Department of Public
Works, 1953; Plan 1637A-8-5_16113977, ‘Moorooka, new brick school, first floor plan, second floor plan’,
Department of Public Works 1953.
55
Plan 1637A-8-2_16113614 ‘Plan showing setting out of building ground improvements and drainage’,
Department of Public Works, 1953.
56
57
Clarke and Thomason, Moorooka State School Jubilee 1929-1989, pp. 50-1.
58
Plan W1569-66_11676291, ‘Moorooka State School: groundworks and erosion control’, Department of Public
Works, 1968.
59
Building dates derived from: Project Services, ‘Moorooka State School’; aerial photographs (various dates) and
various plans of site, Department of Public Works.
60
61
‘School fires spark hunt’, Sunday Mail, 9 December 2006.
http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/queensland/school-fires-spark-hunt/story-e6freoof-1111112662038
(accessed 6 May 2015.)
62
‘Project: Moorooka State School’.
http://www.cordellconnect.com.au/public/project/ProjectDetails.aspx?uid=829966 (accessed 6 May 2015);
‘Moorooka State School: History’,
https://moorookass.eq.edu.au/Ourschool/History/Pages/History.aspx, (Accessed 25 May 2015).
63
64
Burmester et al, Queensland Schools, A Heritage Conservation Study, p.4.
65
Burmester et al, Queensland Schools, A Heritage Conservation Study, p. 49.
66
Aerial photograph 1946, QAP82-35282, sourced from DNRM.
67
‘Women’s War Work’, Courier Mail, 21 June 1940, p.12; ‘Moorooka Red Cross’, Courier Mail, 18 June 1941,
p.9.
68
Fetes were replaced with direct giving for fund-raising by 1976 (Clarke and Thomason, Moorooka State School
Jubilee 1929-1989, p.52.
20

Heritage Recommendation 602861 - Department of Environment

Transcription

Similar documents

Xero House

enREDo International Design Network

QuarterlyFall09.qxp:Quarterlywtr05 final layout

Sustainable management of the World Heritage Site, Bryggen.

Five Star Mechanical Cover

Heritage Committee Monday, November 16, 2015 7:00 p.m. Council

Ganaraska Region Conservation Authority Work on

From: Lee Sexsmith [mailto:hecubuspg@telus

family matters summer 2016 - Heritage Family Credit Union