Untitled
Transcription
Untitled
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The preparation of this document was financed through a Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) from the Department of Housing and Urban Development under the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, as amended, by the Alabama Department of Economic and Community Affairs and with matching funds provided by the City of Brundidge. CDBG Project No. SM-PF-PL-08-05 For additional copies of the plan contact: Brundidge City Hall 146 South Main Street P.O. Box 638 Brundidge, AL 36010 Phone: 334-735-2321 Fax: 334-735-5180 www.brundidge.org Mayor Honorable James T. Ramage, III City Council Hon. Lawrence Bowden, District 1 Hon. Arthur Griffin, District 2 Hon. Vernon Jackson, District 3 Hon. Cynthia Pearson, District 4 Hon. Steven “Nuco” Coleman, District 5 City Manager Mr. Britt Thomas Planning Commission Robert Fleming Delatha Mobley Annette Bryan Haisten Harris Dorothyrine Munningham Isabell Boyd Herbert Reynolds Ann Baker Brundidge Comprehensive Plan Prepared By South Central Alabama Development Commission 5900 Carmichael Place Montgomery, Alabama 36117 334-244-6903 www.scadc.net Skipper Consulting, Inc. 3644 Vann Road Suite 100 Birmingham, Alabama 35235 205-655-8855 www.skipperinc.com TABLE OF CONTENTS City of Brundidge Comprehensive Plan Summary 2010 Chapter 1: Introduction ..................................................................................................... 1 Authority to Plan Purpose of a Comprehensive Plan Brundidge Planning Process Planning Context Study Area Chapter 2: Resource Inventory and Evaluation............................................................. 17 Demographics Physical Resources Evaluation - Assets and Liabilities Chapter 3: Community Studies ..................................................................................... 23 Economic Development Housing Community Facilities Utilities and Infrastructure Transportation and Circulation Land Use Chapter 4: Development Strategy.................................................................................. 51 Vision and Goal Framework Development Priorities Major Street Plan Future Land Use Future Development Strategy Actions and Implementation Schedule Chapter 5: Appendices..................................................................................................... 71 A. Access Management Criteria B. Off Street Truck Parking Facility Design and Construction Guidelines 1. INTRODUCTION The City of Brundidge began a comprehensive planning process in response to the need to address a number of development issues that had arisen in the city, but with the realization that there are vital elements in the city that need to be protected. While Brundidge citizens are eager to promote continued economic development, they are not willing to promote unbridled growth at the cost of the unique features that make the city a special place to live, work, play and raise families. Therefore, local leaders and citizens sought the development of a comprehensive plan that maximizes economic opportunities while protecting the City’s natural and cultural resources, and most notably its famous antique center. The citizens of Brundidge entered into the planning process with the understanding that there would be hard decisions to make; and, that not all of those decisions would make everyone happy. In order to be fully-informed while making those hard decisions, the City of Brundidge utilized a planning process that encouraged an open forum for the exchange of ideas and concerns among citizens. Known issues to be resolved included residential development and population growth, redevelopment projects, tourism, and traffic conflicts. Local leaders envisioned an opportunity to address these issues, coordinate local problem resolution and meet potential prospects in an organized and cohesive effort. The result of the City’s planning efforts is a coordinated plan for growth and development that promotes new commercial and industrial development yet does not detract from the City’s strong downtown retail center nor does it detract from the City’s natural environment. The Brundidge Comprehensive Plan includes detailed study elements on economic development, housing, community facilities, utilities and infrastructure, transportation / circulation, and land use. Emphasis was placed on the community facilities, housing, and transportation elements as they were identified as the most urgent issues in meeting the immediate needs of citizens. A separate transportation study was conducted concurrently with the comprehensive plan, the results of which are included in the transportation element and implementation strategy. The Brundidge Comprehensive Plan concludes with a future development concept and an implementation strategy which outlines actions over a short and long-term time line. Authority to Plan Community planning is a process in which consensus is built among citizens, local officials, businesses, industries, land owners and land developers regarding the future growth and direction of a community, town or city. The cities of Alabama find their authority for planning, zoning and the regulation of subdivisions in powers granted to municipalities by the State Legislature. Title 11, Chapter 52 of the Code of Alabama, 1975, as amended, outlines the powers, duties and responsibilities of municipalities in the regulation of land in and around the corporate limits. Section 11-52-2(a) of the Code states: “Any municipality is hereby authorized and empowered to make, adopt, amend, extend, add to, or carry out a municipal plan as provided in this article and to create by ordinance a planning commission with the powers and duties herein set forth.” 1 Section 11-52-8 of the Code states that it shall be the function and duty of a municipal planning commission to make and adopt a master plan for the physical development of the municipality. The word “shall” in this section of Alabama’s administrative code provides not only the authority, but also the responsibility, of municipalities to plan for the long-range growth and development of lands within their jurisdiction. In the preparation of the Brundidge Comprehensive Plan, the City of Brundidge has availed itself of these powers and duties granted by the state legislature. In doing so, the City has taken a very positive step forward in charting its own destiny. Purpose of a Comprehensive Plan Section 11-52-9 of the Code of Alabama states that the general purpose of a municipal comprehensive plan is to “guide and accomplish the coordinated, adjusted and harmonious development of the municipality and its environs which will, in accordance with present and future needs, best promote health, safety, morals, order, convenience, prosperity and general welfare as well as efficiency and economy in the process of development, including, among other things: adequate provision for traffic; the promotion of safety from fire and other dangers; adequate provision for light and air; the promotion of the healthful and convenient distribution of population; the promotion of good civic design and arrangement, wise and efficient expenditure of public funds; and the adequate provision of public utilities and other public requirements.” The development of the Brundidge Comprehensive Plan and its subsequent implementation provides the foundation for making long-term decisions regarding capital improvements, the provision of services and attaining the vision held by citizens of what they want their community to become. It is clearly recognized, however, that this comprehensive plan may contain some ideas or recommendations that may or may not come to fruition. As with any long-range plans, personal or for a community, events may take place that change the course of plans. It is intended that the citizens of Brundidge utilize the comprehensive plan as a guide for making decisions. Should events occur that alter the long-range plans of the City, then it will be necessary to update the plan based on the impact of those events and new directions set forth for the City. The Brundidge Comprehensive Plan was prepared with the purpose of attracting and managing growth and development in and around the city. The plan provides local officials and citizens with a vision and five missions for the future of Brundidge and guidelines for actions to attain that vision. Vision: Brundidge, Alabama….forerunners and leaders in a dynamic environment where progress embraces tradition. Mission: Brundidge will retain its character and ensure a unique quality of life through: • Progressive Economic Development; • Providing Adequate Utilities and Infrastructure; • Maximizing Land Use; • Implementation of Recreation Facilities; and • Periodic Needs Assessments and Utilization. 2 Brundidge Planning Process Sound community planning typically involves a cyclical three-part process of policy, planning and management. In the policy portion of the process, an inventory and evaluation of the existing conditions and features is conducted, community issues are identified, including both problems and possibilities, and public policies are established through goals and objectives. The planning portion of the process involves the development of an overall strategy for growth and development by proposing solutions and selecting actions that lead to the attainment of the public policy. These actions are then compiled into an overall strategy for growth and development with a time frame and responsible party generally assigned to each action. The management portion of the process is the implementation of the actions as they are outlined in the overall development strategy. Management includes monitoring the results of the actions as they are implemented and making adjustments, as necessary, and as conditions change. Working with professional planners from the South Central Alabama Development Commission (SCADC), the City of Brundidge followed this three-step process in the preparation of the Brundidge Comprehensive Plan. Over a period of six months, three planning workshops were conducted and attended by members of a comprehensive plan steering committee. The public workshops were approximately 2.5 hours in length and included presentations of data, community surveys, completion of individual and group exercises, and consensus-building. City Council, Planning Commission and Steering Committee members were notified of the meeting dates and times by letter. Although committee members were notified by mail, the workshop meetings were open to everyone. The general public was notified by a meeting schedule and reminders that were included in the City’s water bill and flyers that were posted throughout Brundidge. 3 4 Topics for discussion at the first planning workshop included a long-range visioning, inventory and analysis of existing conditions, identification of assets and liabilities, and preliminary goals and concepts. The second planning workshop addressed the community elements of economic development, utilities and infrastructure, transportation, housing and community facilities. A goal framework was presented and expanded. In the third and final planning workshop, the land use element was addressed and attendees participated in the development of a draft development concept. Meeting notices for a planning workshop and open-house meeting. Following the planning workshops, the City conducted two open-house meetings in a comeand-go format that allowed citizens to visit, ask one-on-one questions, make comments and suggestions, and follow the progress of the comprehensive plan. The first open house was held on Thursday, April 15, 2010 from 3:00 PM to 7:00 PM. The focus of the workshop was to review a communitywide vision and mission, a development concept and a goal framework for the various elements of the comprehensive plan. Citizen comments from the open house were used to refine the development concept into a full development strategy. The development strategy and a detailed transportation study were presented to the city council, planning commission, industrial development board and the comprehensive plan steering committee prior to a final public presentation and review at a second open house meeting on June 3, 2010. Comments and suggestions were again used to refine the final action strategy. After the planning workshops and open-house meetings with the comprehensive plan steering committee, a public hearing was held to present and discuss the final draft of the Brundidge Comprehensive Plan on February 15, 2011. The plan was adopted by both the Brundidge Planning Commission and the Brundidge City Council on December 20, 2011. Although the final tangible product of the planning process is a comprehensive plan, the greater result is the on-going process for anticipating and managing the future of Brundidge and staying in a position to maximize opportunities as they arise. The community planning process enables a community to nurture and protect those features that are positive; to address and change those things that are negative; and to seek and attain the possible. Community planning is a dynamic process that must be continually molded to fit the growing needs of a community. Page 4: Pictures from Planning Workshops held on January 14, February 11, and March 11, 2010. Page 5: Pictures from Open House Meetings held on April 15 and June 3, 2010. 5 Planning Context Brundidge was originally known as Collier’s Store and was founded in 1851 when George C. Collier moved to the area and opened a general store. In the 1921 book, History of Alabama and dictionary of Alabama biography by Thomas McAdory Owen and Marie Bankhead Owen, Mr. Owen wrote that Brundidge was a ‘post office and incorporated town in the southeastern part of Pike County, located on the Atlantic Coast Line Railroad 12 miles southeast of Troy.’ He also stated that ‘Brundidge was located on the old stagecoach road from Troy to Dale County, and was long known as Collier's Store, but changed to Brundidge, in honor of an early settler.’ That settler was James McGinnis Brundidge (1812-1901) who founded the local Masonic Lodge. According to Mr. Owen, the population of Brundidge almost tripled over 40 years, from 300 persons in 1870 to 815 persons in 1910. By this time, Brundidge was home to the Bank of Brundidge (State), the Brundidge News which was a weekly Democratic newspaper established in 1898, a cottonseed oil mill, a sawmill, a grist mill, cotton ginneries, cotton warehouses, several stores, several churches, the Pike County High School and public grammar schools. Mr. Owen noted that of the early settlers in Brundidge, many of them were ‘well-to-do and of a high order of intelligence and culture.’ Early settlers included physicians, ministers, educators and plantation owners. He described the area as having large plantations that raised cotton, sugar-cane, corn, peanuts, melons and fruit, and cattle and hogs. The area was known for its cane syrup and peanut crops which were sold to manufacturers of oil. The agricultural – industrial character of Brundidge has not changed much over the last 100 years. Today, the corporate boundaries of Brundidge encompass 9.74 square miles, the majority of which is either undeveloped or in agricultural land uses giving the city appear an agrarian appearance. In comparison to its small size and population, however, Brundidge has a high proportion of local industry and attracts workers from around the region. Brundidge’s recent history of mixing agriculture and industry clearly dates back to 1928, when native J.D. Johnston started the Johnston Peanut Butter Mill in the upstairs of a downtown building in Brundidge. One of the first peanut butter mills in the southeast, Johnston Peanut Butter Mill responded to the growth in popularity of peanut butter as an inexpensive source of protein. The Mill was an integral factor in the livelihood of Brundidge families in the 1930s as jobs became scarce during the Great Depression. The competition from larger processing companies eventually drove smaller mills out of business in the late 1940s and 1950s. Local industries in Brundidge currently employ between 750 and 1,000 workers, although the majority of the industries are no longer agriculturally based. 6 Brundidge is better known today as “Alabama’s Antique City” and has a substantial downtown retail district due, in part, to antique shops. The city’s location on U.S. Highway 231 between Troy and Dothan draws a significant amount of ‘beach-bound’ through traffic to support the downtown area and provides regional access to 17 major cities. Brundidge is bisected by Alabama Highway 93, which runs north-south, and Alabama Highway 10, which runs east-west. Downtown Brundidge is located around the intersection of these routes, just one mile east of U.S. Highway 231. Major cities located within a 60-mile radius of Brundidge include Troy, Dothan, Enterprise, Montgomery and Auburn. Brundidge is also accessed by a rail line operated by CSX Transportation and which has a gross traffic density between 5 million tons and 20 million tons as of 2008. Railroad interchanges are located just north and south of Brundidge in Troy and Waterford/Dothan. Regional Location Study Area Section 11-52-8 of the Code of Alabama states that a municipal comprehensive plan may include plans for the physical development of areas outside of its boundaries which, in the judgment of the planning commission, bear relation to the planning of such municipality. And, Section 11-52-9 further states that in preparing a comprehensive plan, the municipal planning commission shall make careful and comprehensive surveys and studies of present conditions and future growth of the municipality and with due regard to its relation to neighboring territory. 7 Together, these two sections of the Code mandate, through use of the word shall, that a municipality considers its surrounding area in making future plans for growth and development. The reason for this is two-fold: one, so a municipality does not unduly impact its neighbors; and, two, so a municipality can effectively plan for its long-range growth by helping guide the development of area adjacent to its boundaries that has the potential to come within the corporate limits at a future date. In planning for lands outside the corporate limits, a municipality has the opportunity to determine how the surrounding area could affect its future plans; and likewise, the municipality has the responsibility to ensure that its future plans do not have an adverse effect on the surrounding area. Although the Code does not state a specific distance or territory to be covered under the planning jurisdiction, the police jurisdiction is generally accepted as the planning jurisdiction. Therefore, the primary study area for the Brundidge Comprehensive Plan includes the land within the corporate boundaries of the city and the secondary study area extends one-and-one-half miles beyond the corporate boundaries of the city, which is equivalent to the City of Brundidge police jurisdiction. Brundidge Comprehensive Plan Primary Study Area 8 2. RESOURCE INVENTORY AND EVALUATION The inventory and evaluation of existing resources provides an in-depth framework for making future planning decisions based on the presence of, or lack of, physical and structural features. The investigation, mapping, description and analysis of these conditions provide a starting point in the identification of issues that face the City of Brundidge. An inventory of the available resources was conducted by the staff of the South Central Alabama Development Commission and entered into a Geographic Information System (GIS) database, which was then used to help determine the general suitability of the land in Brundidge for future development. The inventory of existing conditions and resources was divided into two categories: demographics and physical resources. After information regarding the existing conditions and available resources was compiled, it was possible to perform an analysis to determine the assets and liabilities (or strengths and weaknesses) of Brundidge in regards to opportunities for future growth and to identify limitations to additional development. Demographics According to U.S. Census estimates, Brundidge has a 2010 population of 2,076 persons which is a 11.3 percent decrease from the 2000 population of 2,341 persons. Even so, Brundidge is the second largest municipality in Pike County following the City of Troy, which is the county seat. Brundidge has a population density of 213 persons per square mile, with most of the population located east of U.S. Highway 231 and concentrated along city’s main transportation arteries: Alabama Highways 10 and 93, Veterans Boulevard, and Galloway Road. The U.S. Bureau of Census, 2010 Census and the American Community Survey, 2005-2009 are the sources of all data provided in the demographic analysis, unless otherwise noted. Over the last 100 years, population growth in Brundidge has been somewhat erratic, with significant growth between 1920 and 1950, followed by more modest growth until 1980. Since 1980, the City of Brundidge has been experiencing decline in population. The most dramatic population loss occurred between 1980 and 1990, with a decrease of 23.1 percent. Population: 1900 to 2010 3,500 3,213 3,000 2,709 2,500 2,605 2,523 2,472 2,000 2,341 2,076 1,909 1,500 1,434 1,000 941 815 500 537 0 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 Source: U.S. Bureau of Census; U.S. Statistical Abstract 2011; University of Alabama Center for Business and Economic Research 9 2010 In the first half of the 20th Century, the City of Brundidge exhibited stronger growth patterns than the United States, the State of Alabama, Pike County, and the City of Troy. The exception to this is the United States growth rate between 1900 and 1910, which was the height of the European immigration movement to America. Between 1950 and 1960, however, Brundidge began losing population, as did Pike County. Although Troy and the State had positive growth rates during this decade, their corresponding growth rates were lower than they had been in previous decades. Between 1960 and 1980, Brundidge again experienced strong growth, with a 7.4 percent population increase between 1960 and 1970 and an 18.6 percent increase from 1970 to 1980. Likewise, Troy, the state and the nation also enjoyed population growth during this same time period. Textile industry closings in the 1980s, however, led to a drastic population loss of 23.1 percent in Brundidge and a 1.6 percent decrease in Pike County. In comparison, Troy, Alabama and the nation continued stable population growth. In the last 20 years, between 1990 and 20010, the population of Brundidge has continued to decline, at a much slower rate, however, while the populations of Troy, Pike County, Alabama and the United States have continued to increase. Population Growth Rate Comparison, 1900 to 2010 Location US Alabama Pike Co. 19001910 1110.1% 19101920 15.0% 19201930 16.2% 19301940 7.3% 19401950 14.5% 19501960 18.5% 19601970 13.3% 19701980 11.5% 19801990 9.8% 19902000 13.2% 20002010 9.7% 16.9% 9.8% 12.7% 7.1% 8.1% 6.7% 5.4% 13.1% 3.8% 10.1% 7.5% 5.6% 2.6% 1.9% 0.8% -5.8% -15.1% -3.7% 12.0% -1.6% 7.3% 11.1% Troy 21.1% 14.8% 2.1% 21.3% 21.3% 19.6% 12.2% 12.7% 0.8% 6.8% 29.4% Brundidge 51.8% 15.5% 52.4% 33.1% 36.5% -3.1% 7.4% 18.6% -23.1% -5.3% -11.3% Source: U.S. Bureau of Census; U.S. Statistical Abstract 2011; University of Alabama Center for Business and Economic Research Brundidge has a majority minority population, with 62.9 percent of the population being African American. Of the remaining population, 34.1 percent are white, 1.7 percent are persons on another race, and 1.3 percent are persons of two or more races. As shown in the table below, the racial distribution of the Brundidge population does not mirror that of Pike County or the State of Alabama. The majority of the Pike County and State populations are white, at 58.2 percent and 68.5 percent, respectively. The African American population of Pike County is 36.6 percent and of Alabama is 26.2 percent. Of the total population of Brundidge, it is estimated that 3.0 percent is of Hispanic origin, in comparison to 2.2 percent in Pike County, 3.9 percent in Alabama and 16.3 percent in the United States. Only 2.2 percent of the Brundidge population is foreign-born, which is similar to the State, at 2.9 percent, and Pike County, at 2.5 percent and in contrast to the US population, of which 12.4 percent is foreign-born. Of the Brundidge population that is foreign-born, all were born in a Latin American country. Population by Race, 2010 Race Total Population White Black or African American American Indian and Alaskan Native Asian Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander Some Other Race Two or More Races Hispanic Origin Source: U.S. Bureau of Census; 2010 Census United States 308,745,538 72.4% 12.6% 0.9% 4.8% 0.2% 6.2% 2.9% 16.3% 10 Alabama 4,779,736 68.5% 26.2% 0.6% 1.1% 0.1% 2.0% 1.5% 3.9% Pike County 32,899 58.2% 36.6% 0.6% 2.0% 0.1% 1.0% 1.5% 2.2% Brundidge 2,076 34.1% 62.9% 0.5% 0.6% 0.0% 0.6% 1.3% 3.0% The population of Brundidge has a higher percentage of females than males. While the same is true in Pike County, the state and the nation, the gap between the two population groups is more significant in Brundidge, at 53.5 percent female, than in the other locations at 52.6 percent in Pike County, 51.6 percent in Alabama, and 50.7 percent in the nation. In addition, the median age is higher in Brundidge, at 44.6 years of age, than in other locations as compared to Pike County, at 32.5 years, the State of Alabama, at 37.2 years, and the nation, at 36.5 years. The median age of females in Brundidge, at Population by Gender 2009 45.5 years, is higher than 53.5% that of their male 52.6% 54.0% 51.6% counterparts, at 43.3 years. 50.7% 52.0% The same is true in Pike 49.3% 48.4% 50.0% 47.4% County, Alabama and the 46.5% 48.0% United States. The 46.0% difference between male 44.0% and female median ages 42.0% ranges from 2.2 years in US Alabama Pike County Brundidge Brundidge and Pike County Male: Female: to 3.2 years for the State. Age Distribution, 2010 33.6% 35.0% 13.0% 12.8% 13.8% 21.0% 20.3% 19.8% 26.8% 27.0% 10.0% 16.2% 15.0% 26.7% 20.0% 22.1% 25.0% 26.9% 30.0% 39.7% 40.0% 39.8% 40.7% 45.0% 5.0% 0.0% 0 to 19 Years Brundidge 20 to 34 Years 35 to 64 Years Pike County Alabama 65 Years and Older United States The age distribution in Brundidge is not surprising, given the older median age of the population. As expected, the city has a higher proportion of persons age 65 and older, at 20.9 percent, than does Pike County, at 12.50 percent, the State of Alabama, at 13.5 percent, or the United States at 12.6 percent. What is surprising is the age bracket that is missing from the Brundidge population, which is the young working population at 18 to 34 years of age. This age bracket makes up only 17.8 percent of the Brundidge population, as compared to 30.0 percent of the Pike County population, and 22.9 percent and 23.3 percent of the state and national populations. The disabled population in Brundidge, at 32.2 percent of the total population age 5 and older, is much than in Pike County, at 24.3 percent, or in the state, at 14.2 percent. Of the persons, age 5 to 20 in Brundidge, 12.0 percent have a disability, as compared to 8.8 percent in Pike County and 11 9.0 percent in Alabama. Likewise, in the 21 to 64 age group, 32.1 percent in Brundidge have a disability, while 24.4 percent in Pike County and 23.2 percent in the state have a disability. The same trend continues in the elderly population of Brundidge, with 53.8 percent of the persons 65 years old and older having a disability, as compared to 54.4 percent of the elderly population of Pike County, and 49.5 percent of the state’s older population. Disability information was not included in the 2005-2009 American Community Survey, therefore data was obtained from the U.S. Bureau of Census, 2000 Census. Percentage of Population with a Disability by Age Group, 2000 53.8 Age 65 and Over 54.4 49.5 32.1 Age 21 to 64 24.4 23.2 12.0 8.8 Age 5 to 20 9.0 0.0 10.0 Alabama 20.0 30.0 Pike County 40.0 50.0 60.0 Brundidge As of 2009, there are an estimated 1,134 households in Brundidge, of which 54.1 percent are family households and 45.9 percent are non-family households. The percentage of family households in Brundidge is lower than that of Pike County, at 62.0 percent, the state, at 67.9 percent, and the nation, at 66.7 percent. Of the family households in Brundidge, 51.1 percent are married couples and 42.3 percent have a female head of household with no husband present. Of the non-family households in Brundidge, 93.3 percent are a householder living alone, which equates to approximately 485 households. The average household size of all households is 2.30 persons and the average family size 2.93 persons. Household income in Brundidge is reflective of the high proportion of elderly population and the high percentage of the population with disabilities. Of the 1,134 households, 45.1 percent have no earnings, as compared to 23.0 percent in Pike County, 24.2 percent in the state, and 19.9 percent in the nation. There are 591 households that have a wage or salary income, equal to 52.1 percent of the total households. Of these, 8.6 percent are from self-employment. Self-employment income is lower in Brundidge than in Pike County, at 11.8 percent, the state, at 13.7 percent, and the nation, at 15.4 percent. With the lack of wage-earning households, there is a high reliance upon some form of financial assistance among Brundidge households resulting a high proportion of households with a fixed income. Of the city’s total households, 51.8 percent receive Social Security income; 16.9 percent receive Supplemental Security income (SSI), and 3.0 percent receive public assistance income. These percentages are all higher than the corresponding percentages for Pike County, the State of Alabama and the United States. The percentage of households with retirement income in Brundidge, at 14.5 percent, however, is slightly lower than Pike County, at 14.9 percent, and considerably lower than the state, at 19.5 percent, and the nation, at 17.4 percent. 12 As would be expected, median income levels are low in Brundidge while poverty levels are high. In Brundidge in 2009, the median household income was $19,409; the median family income was $27,941; and the per capita income was $14,968. While these median incomes are lower than in Pike County, they are drastically lower than the median income levels of the state and nation – sometimes, less than half of the state and national levels, as shown in the table below. Poverty levels are also high in Brundidge with 36.2 percent of the population living below poverty level, as compared to 29.1 percent in Pike County, 16.8 percent in Alabama, and 13.5 percent in the United States. Poverty levels are especially high among the elderly population in Brundidge, with 13.7 percent of the persons age 65 and older living in poverty. Type of Household Income, 2009 United States Type of Income Total Households # of HH Alabama % # of HH 112,611,029 Pike County % 1,819,441 # of HH % 12,862 Brundidge # of HH % 1,134 With Earnings 90,209,008 80.1% 1,378,653 75.8% 9,910 77.0% 622 54.9% With No Earnings 22,402,021 19.9% 440,788 24.2% 2,952 23.0% 512 45.1% With Wage or Salary Income 86,671,258 77.0% 1,327,077 72.9% 9,547 74.2% 591 52.1% 13,347,071 15.4% 181,920 13.7% 1,131 11.8% 51 8.6% With Self-Employment Income With Social Security Income 30,470,729 27.1% 573,932 31.5% 4,026 31.3% 587 51.8% With Supplemental Security Income 4,283,276 3.8% 97,133 5.3% 743 5.8% 192 16.9% With Public Assistance Income 2,690,559 2.4% 26,548 1.5% 220 1.7% 34 3.0% With Retirement Income 19,599,672 17.4% With Other Types of Income 15,380,773 13.7% Median Incomes (In 2009 Inflation-Adjusted Dollars) 355,442 271,826 19.5% 14.9% 1,918 2,318 14.9% 18.0% 164 151 14.5% 13.3% Median Household Income $51,425 $41,216 $28,065 $19,409 Median Family Income $62,363 $51,989 $39,319 $27,941 Per Capita Income $27,041 $22,732 $19,085 $14,968 Persons Living Below Poverty Level, 2009 United States Persons With Income Below Poverty Level Alabama 13.5% 16.8% Pike County Brundidge 29.1% 36.2% Male 44.0% 41.9% 41.1% 43.0% Female 56.0% 58.1% 58.9% 57.0% Under 17 Years 34.3% 34.6% 30.9% 29.5% 18 to 64 Years 56.7% 55.6% 62.1% 56.8% 9.0% 9.8% 7.0% 13.7% 65 Years and Over It is estimated that there are 1,647 persons in Brundidge that are age 25 and older. Of these, 2 percent have had no education of any kind, 34 percent do not have a high school diploma, 39 percent have graduated from high school or have an alternate high school diploma, 14 percent have attended college but do not have a degree, 2 percent have an associate’s degree, and 9 percent have earned a bachelor’s or Educational Attainment in Brundidge, 2009 No High School Diploma 34% High School Diploma, GED 39% No Schooling 2% Bachelor's Degree or Higher 9% 13 Associate's Degree 2% Some College, No Degree 14% higher degree. In comparison to the nation, state and Pike County, Brundidge has low levels of educational attainment. While the percentage of the population with a high school degree in Brundidge is higher than the corresponding population in Pike County, at 34.2 percent, the state, at 31.8 percent, and the nation, at 29.3 percent, the portion of the population that has less than a high school diploma is also higher than the comparison areas and the portion of the population that has post-secondary education is lower. This is especially true for the portion of the population that has a bachelor’s degree of higher, which is 8.6 percent in Brundidge as compared to 22.2 percent in Pike County, 21.5 percent in the state, and 27.5 percent in the nation. Educational Attainment Comparison, 2009 United States Population, Age 25 and Older No Schooling No High School Diploma High School Diploma, GED Some College, No Degree Associate's Degree Bachelor's Degree or Higher 197,440,772 2,115,918 28,329,259 57,861,698 40,105,283 14,663,437 54,365,177 Alabama 3,049,663 28,049 556,159 971,298 631,854 205,605 656,698 1.1% 14.3% 29.3% 20.3% 7.4% 27.5% 0.9% 18.2% 31.8% 20.7% 6.7% 21.5% Pike County 17,363 134 3,874 5,945 3,012 551 3,847 0.8% 22.3% 34.2% 17.3% 3.2% 22.2% Brundidge 1,647 30 560 659 224 32 142 1.8% 34.0% 40.0% 13.6% 1.9% 8.6% Physical Resources Physical resources are those conditions that are inherent to the land. As such, they cannot be easily changed. Changing the physical conditions as they currently exist for development is often costly and may present new problems in other areas. The inventory of physical resources includes climate, topography, vegetation, hydrology, geology, and soils. Understanding both the opportunities and the limitations presented by these resources is essential to cost-effective and responsible development and land uses for the future. Brundidge has rather mild seasons Mean Temperature Degrees Fahrenheit where the average summer temperature is 80˚ Fahrenheit and the average winter temperature is 40˚ Fahrenheit. July and August are the warmest months with mean maximum temperatures of 90.4˚ Fahrenheit and 90.0˚ Fahrenheit, respectively. December and January are the coldest months, with December having a mean minimum temperature of 38.6˚ Fahrenheit and January at 36.2˚ Fahrenheit. Temperature variations between night and day tend to be moderate during summer with a difference that can reach 20˚ Fahrenheit, and moderate during winter with an average difference of 22˚ Fahrenheit. Average precipitation in Brundidge is 53.5 inches per year and rainfall is fairly evenly distributed throughout the year. The wettest month of the year is March, with an average rainfall of 6.3 inches, followed by July, with an average rainfall of 5.9 inches. The driest months are October and November, with average rainfall of 2.5 and 3.2 inches. 14 Brundidge is characterized by gently rolling hills with an elevation generally between 350 feet and 500 feet above sea level. The city’s higher elevations, at 500 feet and higher, are found in the northern part of the city between Galloway Road and Alabama Highway 93. Elevations between 460 and 500 feet are found mostly in the northwest quadrant, north of S. A. Graham Boulevard and west of Alabama Highway 93. There are also some areas with these higher elevations located in the city’s northeast quadrant, east of Alabama Highway 93 and north of Alabama Highway 10. Lower elevations, around 350 feet above sea level, are generally located near the corporate limits of the city in all directions along streams. Forest vegetation in Brundidge is primarily loblolly-shortleaf pine, which is one of the most commercially important forest species in the southern United States, making up over half of the standing pine volume. Pike County is a state leader in production of pine and hardwood pulpwood, saw timber hardwood, and private non-farm timber. Benefits of loblolly pine forests include the provision of animal habitats, wind and noise breaks, timber production and biomass for energy. Dense forested areas are generally located in lower elevations along streams and floodplains. Topography, Elevation and Vegetation Source: U.S. Geological Survey Quadrangle Map; and South Central Alabama Development Commission 15 Hydrology and Hillshade Source: U.S. Geological Survey; U.S .Environmental Protection Agency; U.S. Department of Agriculture, Natural Resource Conservation Service Brundidge is located in the Pea River Watershed of the Choctawhatchee-Pea-Yellow River Basin, which covers a large portion of southeast Alabama. The Pea River is the largest tributary of the Choctawhatchee River and flows generally southwest about 128 miles from Bullock County to join the Choctawhatchee near Geneva just above the Alabama-Florida state line. The Pea River Watershed encompasses about 1,542 square miles. Brundidge is primarily developed along a northsouth ridgeline that underlies the route of Alabama Highway 93. From this central ridgeline, water flows into one of five streams located in four subwatersheds and eventually drains into the Pea River. The northeast and north central part of the city is drained Sandy Run Creek and Bear Creek located in the Richland Creek subwatershed. The southeast part of the city is drained by Bowden Mill Creek located in the Bowden Mill Creek subwatershed. The southwest and south central part of Brundidge drains to Mims Creek located in the subwatershed of the same name. Mims Creek is the most significant of the streams in Brundidge. In the northwest part of the city, water drains to Whitewater Creek located in the Beaver Pond Branch subwatershed. 16 Due to the topography of the city, floodplains in Brundidge are generally constrained to linear areas that follow the course of the major streams and tributaries in the city. Floodplains in the southern part of the city tend to be slightly more expansive than those in the north, particularly along Mims Creek. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s National Wetlands Inventory has identified linear wetlands around Whitewater Creek, Sandy Run Creek, Bear Creek, Bowden Mill Creek and Mims Creek. Most of these floodplains and wetlands are not in the developed portions of Brundidge and do not present additional limitations to future development beyond those limitations already present because of topographical conditions. There exist two areas that are exceptions, both of which are adjacent to highly developed areas in the southwest quadrant of the city. The first area is the southwest corner of the intersection of U.S. Highway 231 and Alabama Highway10/ County Road 3316, which has potential for commercial or industrial development. The second location lies between two neighborhoods north of Johnson Street and south of Andrews Corner, however, it appears that some development that has occurred within the floodplain/wetland area. Hydrology and Floodplains Source: USGS; U.S .Environmental Protection Agency; U.S. Department of Agriculture, Natural Resource Conservation Service. Note: The Zone A Flood Areas depicted on this map are an approximation of the three official DFIRM maps. See http://msc.fema.gov to order official flood maps. 17 There are five major physiographic sections in Alabama: the Highland Rim, the Cumberland Plateau, the Valley and Ridge, the Piedmont Plateau, and the East Gulf Coastal Plain. Pike County is located in the Chunnenuggee Hills and Southern Red Hills districts of the East Gulf Coastal Plain, which extends from the northwest to the east central part of the state. The East Gulf Coastal Plain is Alabama’s largest physiographic region and encompasses about 60 percent of the state. The Chunnenuggee Hills district, which includes the Sand Fork, Enon, Lapine, High Ridge and Ripley cuestas, formed on sands and sandstones. (A cuesta is a ridge that slopes gently down one side and sharply down the other.) Along the 175-foot-high Lapine cuesta, in the central region, the hills reach elevations of more than 570 feet above sea level. In the western regions, the Chunnenuggee Hills are very narrow and are bounded by the Ripley and Troy cuestas. The Southern Red Hills district formed on sands, limestone, marls, clay, and silt, and elevations in these hills commonly reach more than 400 feet above sea level with local relief of as much as 200 feet. The northern boundary is the Troy cuesta (between 80 and 140 feet high), which developed on sand. The southern boundary occurs where the hills give way to the flatlands of the Dougherty Plain district in the east and central areas. (Source: www.encyclopediaofalabama.org) The major geological Geology formations in Brundidge are the Nanafalia formation and the Clayton formation. The extreme southwest tip of Brundidge is located in the Qalt-Alluvial formation. The majority of Brundidge is underlain by the Nanafalia formation which includes the Nanafalia Aquifer. An aquifer is a geological formation that is a wet underground layer of water-bearing permeable rock, gravel, sand, silt, or clay from which groundwater can be extracted. The Nanafalia Aquifer is a primary source of groundwater in southeast Alabama. The Nanafalia formation, part of the Wilcox Group, is made up of clay, claystone, sand and gravel characterized by medium-gray and white clay, carbonaceous clay, white and grayish-yellow fine to coarse sand and lenses of bauxite and bauxitic clay. Sand beds commonly are cross-bedded, gravelly, and contain numerous clay pebbles. The sequence of beds is often obscured by weathering and the collapse of beds into sinkholes in the underlying Clayton Formation. The Clayton formation, part of the Midway Group, is characterized by a gravelly medium to coarse sand containing clay pebbles. The formation is generally deeply weathered and fresh exposures are rare. (Source: USGS, Mineral Resources On-line Spatial Data. http://mrdata.usgs.gov/sgmc/al.html) 18 Brundidge lies in the Southern Coastal Plain Major Land Resource Area (MLRA 133A). The dominant soil orders in this area are ultisols, entisols, and inceptisols. These soils are generally very deep, somewhat excessively drained to poorly drained, and loamy. Typical land uses include timber production, cash-grain crops, and forage production. Major crops grown in these soils include soybeans, cotton, corn, and wheat and pastures are primarily grazed by beef cattle, but some dairy cattle and hogs are raised in the area. Major concerns with soils in this area are water erosion, maintenance of the content of organic matter and productivity of the soils, control of surface water, artificial drainage, and management of surface compaction and soil moisture. There are 25 different soils units within the corporate boundaries of Brundidge as shown in the map below. The Fuquay-Urban Land complex is the primary soil unit in the most heavily developed portions of Brundidge. These soils are generally very deep and well-drained. Permeability in the Fuquay soils is rapid in the surface and subsurface layers, but slow in the subsoil layer. These soils have low shrink-swell potential and no flooding. Soils 19 In the northern part of Brundidge, the undeveloped areas are primarily comprised of soils in the Luverne-Springhill complex; and in the southern part of the city, soils in undeveloped areas are primarily in the Arundel-Luverne-Troup complex. The Luverne-Springhill soils are also generally very deep and well-drained, but are found on the side slopes of highly dissected uplands. They have moderate to moderately slow permeability, low to moderate shrink-swell potential and no flooding. Arundel-Luverne-Troup soils are dominantly gently sloping to steep, well-drained to excessively drained, and have a loamy or sandy surface layer and a clayey or loamy subsoil. Permeability in these soils is slow and shrink-swell potential is high. Soil characteristics present some limitations to development due to wetness, steep slopes, permeability, and/or shrink-swell potential. The map below shows general limitations to development or construction of dwellings and small commercial buildings. Those areas with severe limitations are generally found along streams and steep slopes, although the soil limitation areas are more expansive than the existing floodplain areas. In addition, there are some areas with moderate limitations to development in the southeast part of the city. Limitations in this area are generally due to shrink-swell potential. Soil Limitations for Dwellings and Small Commercial Buildings Source: USDA, Natural Resource and Conservation Service, Web Soil Survey. http://websoilsurvey.nrcs.usda.gov 20 Evaluation – Assets and Liabilities – Infrastructure and Services Brundidge citizens were able to identify their strong and weak points as a community in terms of how they are able to attract, maintain and serve the city's population and how they are able to grow and develop. Further, citizens identified limitations to future development in terms of issues that must be resolved. Below is a list of identified assets, liabilities and issues. They are in no particular order in terms of importance; however, each will be considered in the community studies in the next chapter. Assets Liabilities Water system Animal Control Library Local drug problem Electric system Lack of recognition People Pollution, litter Volunteer fire department Trucks through town, street deterioration Knowledgeable, caring leaders Dilapidated housing Local restaurants Trailer parks Good access to local government Vacant commercial buildings Local doctor Police department – a good size for city the size of Brundidge Downtown parking, limited visibility (large vehicles in historic downtown) Abandoned vehicles Good elder services Highway 231 “entrance” School system Sanitary sewer services and wastewater treatment plant Issues Trucks turning into downtown Theater Industrial/residential compatibility Football, sports championships “Locked in” by surrounding land owners Local NFL players Recruitment team Climate Churches Another grocery store – “Retail competitiveness” City services Access to the post office Post office – no long lines Anti-littering enforcement High school dropout rate 21 22 3. COMMUNITY STUDIES Community elements describe those facets of Brundidge that make up the community lifestyle of residents. Beyond the resources and services that were inventoried in the previous chapter, community elements provide information on factors of Brundidge that can be improved, strengthened and maintained. Community elements discussed in this chapter include economic development, housing, community facilities, utilities and infrastructure, transportation and circulation, and land use patterns. Economic Development The 2009 windshield survey of Brundidge indicates that there are approximately 136 parcels of land that are utilized for commercial or industrial purposes. Combined the commercial and industrial land uses occupy about 13.0 percent of the developed land area in Brundidge, or 6.7 percent of the total land area. Commercial land uses vary from retail commercial to personal services, while industrial land uses include small manufacturing companies to large-scale distribution operations. Most of the businesses, however, are small locally-owned establishments that employ a small number of people or are home-based businesses. Of commercial and industrial properties, it is estimated that 84.5 percent of the parcels are commercial properties, but only 22.1 percent of the land area is commercial while the 78.0 percent of the land area remaining land area is used for industrial purposes. Some of the larger employers in Brundidge are listed in the table below. Employer Brundidge Electronics Corporation Carter Brothers Manufacturing Company, Inc. Pike County Elementary School Pike County High School Southern Classic Food Group, LLC Supreme Oil South Wal-Mart Distribution Center Number of Employees 26 to 50 101 to 150 50 to 99 50 to 99 100 to 249 50 to 99 500 to 999 The 2009 American Community Survey estimates that there are 787 workers, age 16 and older, living in Brundidge. Of these, the majority, at 34.4 percent, are employed in production, transportation and material moving occupations, which is a considerably higher percentage than those employed in these occupations in Pike County, at 18.9 percent, or in the State, at 16.4 percent. Following the production occupations, sales and office occupations and service occupations are the second and third largest occupational sectors, with each having just under 20 percent of the total workers. As compared to other locations, Brundidge has fewer workers employed in the sales and office sector, but is comparable in both the service occupations and construction occupations. In Brundidge, 19.3 percent of the workers are employed in sales and office occupations, as compared to 25.1 percent in Pike County and 25.6 percent in Alabama. An estimated 17.9 percent of Brundidge workers are employed in services occupations while 19.0 percent of Pike County workers and 15.5 percent of Alabama workers are employed in service jobs. Likewise, 13.9 percent of Brundidge workers are employed in construction, extraction, maintenance and repair occupations as compared to 9.5 percent of workers in Pike County and 11.0 percent of Alabama workers. The largest occupational sector in both Pike County and the State is management, professional and 23 related occupations, at 26.4 percent and 30.9 percent, respectively. Only 12.8 percent of Brundidge workers, however, are employed in management or related occupations. The smallest occupational sector statewide is farming, fishing and forestry occupations, with only 1.7 percent of the workers in Brundidge, 1.1 percent in Pike County, and 0.7 percent in the State. Employment by Occupation, 2009 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% Alabama Pike County Brundidge Management, Professional Service Sales, Office Farming, Fishing, Forestry Construction, Extraction, Maintenance, Repair Production, Transportation, Material Moving Source: U.S. Census, American Community Survey, 2005-2009 Employment by Industry, 2009 Industry Alabama Pike County Brundidge Agriculture, forestry, fishing, hunting, and mining 1.8% 2.4% 1.7% Mining, quarrying, oil and gas extraction 0.5% 0.1% 0.0% Construction Manufacturing Wholesale trade Retail trade 7.8% 6.8% 9.9% 14.8% 16.8% 25.8% 3.3% 2.7% 3.0% 12.1% 13.0% 14.1% Transportation, warehousing, utilities 5.3% 6.5% 7.2% Information 1.9% 0.5% 0.3% Finance, insurance, real estate, rental/leasing 5.8% 4.4% 2.7% Professional, scientific, mgmt, admin, waste mgmt services 8.4% 3.9% 5.1% Educational, health care, social services 20.5% 26.1% 15.2% Arts, entertainment, recreation, accommodation, food svc 7.4% 8.5% 6.6% Other services, except public administration 5.1% 3.7% 5.2% Public administration 5.3% 4.6% 3.2% Source: U.S. Census, American Community Survey, 2005-2009 The three major industrial sectors for employment in Brundidge are manufacturing, which employs 25.8 percent of the city's workers; educational, health care and social services, at 15.2 percent; and retail trade, at 14.1 percent. These are also the three largest industrial sectors for both Pike County and the State of Alabama. In Pike County and the State, however, education, health care and social services employs the largest percentage of workers, at 26.1 percent and 20.5 percent respectively, followed by retail trade and then manufacturing. 24 More than half of the Brundidge workers, at 61.9 percent, lived within close proximity to their employment and had a commute time of less than 20 minutes, according to the American Community Survey in 2009. In fact, 28.6 percent of Brundidge workers have a commute time of less than 10 minutes and 13.6 percent have a commute between 10 and 14 minutes. Of those that travel further distances, most still commute times of less than 34 minutes. Brundidge has a much smaller percentage of workers that travel long distances with a commute in excess of 35 minutes, at 10.0 percent, than does Pike County, at 16.1 percent, the State, at 18.3 percent or the nation, at 21.8 percent. The majority of the city's workers, at 77.7 percent, commuted to work by driving alone. Of the remaining workers, 15.0 percent carpooled, 3.4 percent walked or rode a bicycle, 1.6 percent worked at home, and 1.6 percent used other means. Although public transit is available in Brundidge and Pike County, it is not often used as a means of transportation to and from local places of employment. As a result, only 0.7 percent of Brundidge workers used public transportation as a means of transportation to and from work. Reliable and current unemployment data is not available for the City of Brundidge, however, data is available for Pike County. While unemployment in Pike County has increased in the last decade, it has not increased nearly as much as the State or other counties in the region. The 2010 average annual unemployment rate for Pike County was 7.8 percent, down from 8.4 percent in 2009. Comparatively, the 2010 average annual unemployment rate in the surrounding counties was 9.3 percent in Montgomery County, 14.7 percent in Bullock County, 12.1 percent in Barbour County, 8.5 percent in Dale County, 7.3 percent in Coffee County, and 8.7 percent in Crenshaw County. The 2010 average annual unemployment rate for the state was 9.5 percent and for the nation was 9.6 percent. Pike County Annual Average Unemployment Rate, 2000 to 2010 Year Annual Average Civilian Labor Force Annual Average Employment 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 14,184 13,646 13,716 14,291 14,929 14,934 15,210 15,634 15,772 15,892 15,635 13,491 12,985 12,971 13,536 14,213 14,417 14,685 15,088 15,093 14,561 14,422 Annual Average Unemployment Annual Average Unemployment Rate 693 661 745 755 716 517 525 546 679 1,331 1,213 4.9 4.8 5.4 5.3 4.8 3.5 3.5 3.5 4.3 8.4 7.8 Source: Alabama Department of Industrial Relations in cooperation with the Bureau of Labor Statistics In most cases, economic development is not just a local event, but instead, is reliant upon the regional economic climate. This is especially true for smaller municipalities such as Brundidge in which area residents often travel to other areas for basic necessities such as groceries and clothing due to a lack of choice in the local retail market. The opening of the Wal Mart Distribution Center in Brundidge is a prime example of a major industry location being dependent upon the regional labor force -- not just the Brundidge labor force. As a result of the distribution center, Brundidge now has more jobs within the corporate limits than resident workers. At the beginning of this 25 section, it was estimated that there are between 875 and 1,750 jobs in Brundidge provided just by the major employers in comparison to a local labor force of 787 workers. Brundidge is fortunate to have an excellent regional location on U.S. Highway 231 between two metropolitan areas and to have the available land and necessary infrastructure to attract such industry. The economic characteristics from a regional perspective are favorable for additional growth in Brundidge. As shown in the table below, a regional outlook increases the available labor force from less than 1,000 workers in Brundidge to just over 15,000 in Pike County to almost one-half million workers within a 60-mile radius of Pike County. The region within the 30-mile and 60-mile radius areas has seen tremendous population growth during the last 30 years, even though Brundidge continues to suffer a population decline. And, the per capita personal income is similar in Pike County and the extended region as that of the State of Alabama, at $33,413. Regional Economic Characteristics Pike County 30-Mile Radius 60-Mile Radius 2009 Estimated Population 30,704 768,469 1,089,955 30-Year Population Change 18.2% 25.4% 34.5 44.1 70.2 69.9 15,635 337,236 489,770 7.8% 9.7% 9.5% $33,413 $33,218 $32,125 Population Density, 2009 Labor Force, 2009 Unemployment Rate, 2009 Per Capital Personal Income, 2008 Source: Stats America, www.statsamerica.org Due to the regional nature and impact of economic development, the State of Alabama has established ten workforce development regions to provide a direct link to the workforce needs of business and industry at the local level. Each region is led by a workforce development council that works with member counties to develop regional strategic plans and a comprehensive workforce development system. Pike County is in Alabama's Workforce Development Region 10, which also includes Barbour, Coffee, Covington, Dale, Geneva, Henry and Houston Counties. The Alabama Workforce Development Program provides a number of studies that are relevant to local economic development efforts, target markets and labor force education and training. Alabama Workforce Development Region 10 26 The State of the Workforce Report V: Region 10, produced in June 2011 by the Center for Business and Economic Research as part of the Alabama Workforce Development Program, analyzes workforce supply and demand issues for Region 10 and presents implications and recommendations. Some of the findings outlined in the summary of the report, listed below, have a direct impact on future economic development efforts in Brundidge: Region 10 had an 8.9 percent unemployment rate in January 2011 and an underemployment rate of 26.6 percent for 2010 meaning that the region has a 47,483strong available labor pool that includes 34,764 underemployed workers who are looking for better jobs and are willing to commute farther and longer for such jobs. The region’s commute time and distance are down in 2010 implying that congestion has eased; however, the number of commuters has risen over the recent years. The significant within-region commuting indicates that continuous maintenance and development of regional transportation infrastructure and systems is important to ensure that congestion doesn’t slow economic development. By sector, the top five employers in the region are manufacturing; health care and social assistance; retail trade; educational services; and accommodation and food services. The top five high-demand occupations are truck drivers, heavy and tractor-trailer; registered nurses; customer service representatives; aircraft mechanics and service technicians; and elementary school teachers, except special education. The top five fast-growing occupations are forging machine setters, operators, and tenders, metal and plastic; computer software engineers, systems software; computer software engineers, applications; network systems and data communications analysts; and skin care specialists. The top 50 high-earning occupations are mainly in management, health, engineering, and computer fields and have a minimum salary $68,256. Seven of the top ten are health occupations. Skill and education requirements for jobs keep rising. Educational and training requirements of high-demand, fast-growing, and high-earning occupations demonstrate the importance of education in developing the future workforce. In the future, more jobs will require postsecondary education and training at a minimum. The importance of basic skills generally and for high-demand, high-growth, and highearning jobs indicates a strong need for training in these skills. For Region 10 the pace of training needs to increase for technical, social, and science skills while the scale of training is raised for basic and social skills. Ideally, high school graduates should possess basic skills so that postsecondary and higher education can focus on more complex skills. Employers should be an integral part of planning for training as they can help identify future skill needs and any existing gaps. From a 2008 base, worker surpluses of 9,604 and 1,395 for 2018 and 2025 respectively are expected. A focus on worker skills must be of high priority through 2025. Worker shortfalls for critical occupations will need to be continuously addressed. Higher incomes that come with improved educational attainment and work skills will help to increase personal income for the region as well as raise additional local (county and city) tax revenues. This is important, especially for a region that has fairly low population and labor force growth rates as well as low per capita income. 27 The State of the Workforce report supports many of the assumptions made by Brundidge residents during the comprehensive planning public meetings. Brundidge residents expressed the desire to simplify while continuing to encourage truck transportation routes to serve local industries. With the top high-demand occupation being truck drivers, Brundidge has an opportunity to create a niche for truck services, from resting locations to engine services. Brundidge residents also targeted the integration of the local public schools into economic development efforts through community business partnerships as a primary strategic action that would benefit both the educational system and local businesses. The workforce development program reinforces that assumption and provides guidance on educational skills and training that are (1) needed regionally, and (2) are directly related to the existing food industries in Brundidge. Improving education is important because (i) a highly educated and productive workforce is a critical economic development asset, (ii) productivity rises with education, (iii) educated people are more likely to work, and (iv) it yields high private and social rates of return on investment. The State of the Workforce report also cited an increased willingness to commute by both unemployed and underemployed workers while cautioning how that new industry is developed and roads are maintained to ensure that the transportation system continues to facilitate regional commuting. This is directly applicable to the City of Brundidge and its desire for a larger commercial presence on U.S. Highway 231. Community discussions, field observations and the review of existing data enabled Brundidge residents to outline the following economic development issues and opportunities. Economic Development Issues and Opportunities Issues Opportunities Good regional location to draw from to support retail and industrial growth Lack of presence on U.S. Highway 231 Lack of promotional materials to attract industrial prospects Ample room, available infrastructure and capacity to accommodate additional industrial growth Lack of competition among major retail resources Build upon existing historic resources in downtown area for unique shopping experience Small population base to support desired retail Lack of overnight accommodations for travelers Maximize regional location between two metropolitan areas, Montgomery and Dothan, to expand industrial development Lack of retail choice, particularly beyond basic necessities Integrate existing education system into regional workforce development programs Housing Housing data available from the 2010 Census is limited to the number of units, occupancy, tenure and race of the householder. Other housing information was obtained from the 2005-2009 American Community Survey. As of 2010, there are 1,086 housing units in Brundidge, of which 86.6 percent are occupied and 13.4 percent are vacant. Of the occupied housing units, 62.3 percent are owner occupied and 37.7 percent are renter occupied. Of the owner-occupied housing in Brundidge, over half of the homes, at 52.0 percent, are owned free and clear while the remaining 48.0 percent of the housing units are under ownership with a mortgage or loan. 28 The number of persons living in owner-occupied housing is slightly higher, at 64.3 percent of the total population, than the percentage of ownership. As a result, the average household size in owner-occupied units is 2.28 persons per unit while the average household size in renter-occupied units is 2.10 persons per unit. According to the 2005-2009 American Community Survey, the majority of the owneroccupied housing units, at 65.5 percent, are family households, of which 42.2 percent have a householder between the ages of 15 and 64 and 23.4 percent have a householder that is 65 years old or older. Also, the majority of the family households, at 42.8 percent, have both husband and wife present, while 5.8 percent have a male householder with no wife present and 16.9 percent have a female householder with no husband present. Almost half of the vacant housing units in Brundidge, at 49.3 percent, are not available for use. It is unclear if these houses have been abandoned or not. Of the total vacant units, 19.2 percent are for rent, 17.1 percent are for sale, and 8.9 percent are used for seasonal, recreational or occasional use, while 9.6 percent have been either sold or rented but are not yet occupied. Vacant and abandoned properties are an issue throughout the city, although the City of Brundidge has undertaken several housing rehabilitation projects in the last two decades in an effort to resolve this issue. Absentee ownership continues to be a problem in addressing the vacancy issue. In addition to the privately-owned homes and rental housing in Brundidge, publiclysubsidized housing is also available through the Brundidge Housing Authority. Some of the public housing is only available to age- and income-qualified residents, while other public housing qualifications are based solely on income. The Brundidge Housing Authority has used various funding programs to subsidize the existing housing; however, most of what is available has been funded through USDA Rural Development programs. Publicly Subsidized Housing on S.A. Graham Boulevard A windshield survey was conducted by the South Central Alabama Development Commission as a part of the planning process to determine concentrations of substandard housing. While no particular part of the city could be characterized by totally blighted conditions, varying degrees of substandard units were found in most all parts of the city. Those units that were in the worst conditions were manufactured housing units that were located throughout the city. Although there are a couple of areas dedicated to the placement of manufactured housing, many of the units have been placed on lots as an affordable replacement for a dilapidated site-built structure. 29 Residents of Brundidge recognize the viability of manufactured housing as a cost-effective means of housing; however, many residents express concern over proper location and safety regulations to ensure that the units remain as safe and sound housing resources and are a quality part of the Brundidge housing stock. Suggestions were made to develop manufactured housing subdivisions with either rental or owner-occupied lots. The intent of this suggestions was provide an organized and attractive development that one, is complementary to existing site-built housing units in Brundidge and two, ensures a safe and secure location for manufactured housing with proper spacing and parking facilities. Existing concentrations of manufactured housing units suggest that this has not been the case in most instances in Brundidge. Often, as many units as possible are located on one large lot or crowded together on several small lots. Concentration of Manufactured Housing on Main Street Historic Housing Near Downtown Brundidge The windshield survey also revealed concentrations of housing units that may qualify for status as a historic residential district. A historic district is an area or neighborhood that has a concentration of buildings and associated landscape and streetscape features that retain a high degree of historic character and integrity, and represent an important aspect of an area’s history. For the Alabama Register, eligible properties must be at least 40 years old or older. In Brundidge, 30 these housing units vary in style and size and are in varying stages of repair and disrepair; however they are collectively an important component of the city's character and sense of place. They trace the built history of the city and assist in defining the city's unique quality and spirit. As such, they should not be overlooked as an asset in attracting a stable population to Brundidge. Residents noted that there is a need for non-subsidized rental opportunities and newer starter homes. Further, residents recognized the need for both short and long term executive rental opportunities. Community discussions led to the opportunity to attract older students with available housing and new housing from the student populations to the north at Troy University and to the south at Enterprise-Ozark Community College. Community discussions, field observations and the review of existing data enabled Brundidge residents to outline the following housing issues and opportunities. Housing Issues and Opportunities Issues Opportunities Potential to attract residential growth from nearby markets in Troy, Ozark, and Dothan Absentee ownership Lack of property maintenance Potential for infill development to solidify and maintain internal neighborhoods while also providing increased housing choice Need dedicated space for manufactured housing Need starter housing opportunities and programs Provide housing opportunities for short-term executive rental Pursue student housing catering to older students at Troy University and Enterprise-Ozark Community College Establish and market a historic residential district that relates to the historic downtown area Community Facilities Brundidge is fortunate to have a wealth of community resources, facilities and attractions to serve area residents. Community facilities include those features that are beyond the basic necessities of utility services and that help define the quality of life within an area. These features may include historic resources, libraries, cultural amenities, education system, communications, recreational facilities, and safety and emergency services. Brundidge has a number of historic commercial, industrial and residential structures that help define the character of the city. The majority of these are located in the downtown area, however, the residential structures extend along S. A. Graham Boulevard and Alabama Highway 93. Unfortunately, only two of the historic structures in Brundidge are listed on the Alabama Register of Landmarks and Heritage and none are listed on the National Register. The two structures listed on the Alabama Register are the Johnston Mill, located at 201 Church Street, and the Lightfoot House, located on South Main Street. Johnston Mill was built between 1928 and 1930 and was listed on August 25, 2011. One of the first peanut butter mills in the southeast, the Johnston Peanut Butter Mill structure now houses a museum with artifacts from the area that include labels, photos and equipment, along with memorabilia from the city's annual Peanut Butter Festival. The Lightfoot House, located at 164 South Main Street, was constructed in 1897 and listed on the Alabama 31 Register on August 6, 1993. The Lightfoot House is now home to the Tupper Lightfoot Memorial Library, which is covered in more detail later in this section. In addition to the historic structures, four cemeteries in Brundidge were designated as historic cemeteries in 2009 and 2010, as listed below: Pleasant Hill Church Cemetery, 2009 McLaney Family Cemetery, 2009 Beulah Primitive Baptist Church Cemetery, 2010 and Conner Family Cemetery, 2010 There are also three historic markers in Brundidge: (1) Lest We Forget, (2) Philadelphia Presbyterian Church, and (3) Salem Baptist Church. The Lest We Forget marker is to honor the memory and valor of soldiers who served in the Civil War, World Wars I and II, the Korean and Vietnam Wars and Operation Desert Storm. The Philadelphia Presbyterian Church marker commemorates the location of a Presbyterian church that was organized largely by members of Beaver Creek Presbyterian Church near Camden, South Carolina. The Salem Baptist Church marker recognizes the church as Pike County's oldest church, organized by Dr. C.T. Mahoney in 1824. The marker states that the church was first a log structure, then occupied four wooden buildings before the present brick structure. Two of the Three Historic Markers in Brundidge Brundidge has made a name for itself with the We Piddle Around Theater that is housed in a 1940 historic Works Project Administration (WPA) building and is home to Alabama's Official Folk Life Play, Come Home, It's Suppertime, which is presented during the first two weeks of November and the last two weeks of May. The Brundidge Historical Society hosts several other events throughout the year such as an annual peanut butter festival and storytelling events. Additionally, the City of Brundidge conducts annual parades and community events. We Piddle Around Theater Annual 4th of July Parade 32 Mural for Annual Peanut Butter Festival Brundidge is home to the Tupper Lightfoot Memorial Library located in an historic structure next door to City Hall on Main Street. The library provides a focal point in the downtown area and is a great asset to the city. The library is open six days a week (closed on Sundays) and has preschool reading and story programs. The Tupper Lightfoot Memorial Library serves a population of 2,341 residents, including Brundidge residents and residents in the surrounding rural area. The library has a collection of 13,650 books including 1,250 large print books, and 270 audio books and periodicals. In addition to the reading materials, the library also has a collection of 790 video items, including DVDs, VHS tapes and compact discs. The library also offers five Internet terminals for use by the general public and provides two computers that are available for use by children. Beyond the Tupper Lightfoot Memorial Library, Brundidge residents have access to communications through a variety of nearby sources. There are no local newspaper, television stations or radio stations in the city. Brundidge events, however, are well covered by the Troy Messenger. Additionally, the Montgomery Advertiser and the Dothan Eagle have limited coverage of the Brundidge area and provide delivery service. There are eight television broadcast stations available in Brundidge, of which three stations are located in Montgomery and one station each is located in Dothan, Ozark and Troy. Additionally, there are two educational stations located in Dozier and Louisville. Of the 15 strongest FM radio broadcast stations available in Brundidge, four are located in Troy, three each are located in Dothan and Ozark, and one each are located in Brantley, Elba, Enterprise, Luverne and Montgomery. Brundidge residents have access to cable and Internet services through Troy Cablevision, located in Troy and serving the surrounding area. Public education in Brundidge is provided by the Pike County Board of Education and two of the county's schools are located in Brundidge. These include Pike County Elementary School, located on Hillcrest Drive in the northern part of the city, and Pike County High School, located on Alabama Highway 93, south of downtown. Pike County Elementary School is one of three elementary schools in the Pike County School System and serves approximately 525 students in kindergarten through sixth grade. Pike County Elementary School had its beginning as Rosenwald Elementary School with four classrooms and four teachers. As time passed, the County Board of Education assumed the financial and administrative responsibilities for the school. The original structure was destroyed by fire, but was replaced with a five room structure which became known as Brundidge Junior High School. Several years later, the second building was also destroyed by fire. In 1934, a six room building was erected. The school then became known as the Pike County Training School. The staff was comprised of eight teachers and the student population reached 300. With the increased enrollment, it became necessary to initiate double sessions of school. In 1954, the Board of Education recognized the need for expansion and purchased fifteen acres of land near the Training School campus. A modernized, fire-proof building was constructed. The new facility housed the elementary department and the old plant continued to house the junior and senior high school departments. The enrollment had climbed to 600 with 21 teachers. 33 Along with the period of consolidation came swift transition. White Water Junior High and Tarentum Elementary Schools consolidated with Pike County Training School. In order to accommodate the students from the newly combined schools, additional buses were put into service. Twenty-five teachers served the school which now had an enrollment of 750. With this kind of student-teacher ratio, all departments were challenged with an overcrowded situation. Realizing this kind of condition existed, in 1961 the School Board decided to build a new high school on the same campus as the elementary school. The new school was named Hillcrest High School and housed grades nine through twelve. On January 3, 1962, the Josie Junior High School consolidated with Hillcrest High creating a combined enrollment of 900, an all time high for the campus. The staff of the teachers increased to 30. In 1975, the school's name was changed to Pike County Elementary School and was reconfigured to house grades kindergarten through sixth which is its current configuration. Pike County High School has a student population of approximately 550, serving students in grades seven through twelve. During the late 1800's a two story wooden structure would house Pike County High School. Enrollment rose to the point that in the early 1900's additions were made to the building. At this time changes were also made to the curriculum and the school became a fully accredited high school. A new law was passed in 1907 requiring each county to have a high school. Brundidge was the location for Pike County's High School. In 1948, a two story building was built that would eventually house a lunchroom/kitchen complex, the library, science lab, classrooms, and the guidance and administrative offices. Several more buildings were added expanded or remodeled during the 1960's and 1970's. Pike County High School offers a wide range of activities and clubs are provided for the students. Clubs include: Science Club, Future Business Leaders of America, Family and Consumer Sciences Club, Future Farmers of America, Latin Club, Art Club, Drama, and Nutritional Advisory Council. Honor Societies include: National Honor Society, National Junior Honor Society, Art Honor Society, and Latin Honor Society. Pike County High School The City of Brundidge owns and maintains four parks: Brundidge Lake Park, Gilmore Park, Galloway Park, and Brundidge Recreation Park. The largest of these is Brundidge Lake Park, at 21.8 acres, followed by Brundidge Recreation Park, at 15 acres. The other two parks are much smaller facilities, at less than four acres each. The park facilities are operated and maintained by the City. The City oversees all recreational activities and facilities and sponsors summer T-ball, Dixie Youth League, Dixie Minor League, youth softball, and basketball (at the Pike County Elementary School). 34 Together, the parks consist of the provide tennis courts, baseball and softball fields, outdoor open space, playgrounds and indoor restrooms. In addition to the park facilities, the City owns and maintains a public meeting space, Brundidge Station, which is also used as a nutritional site for seniors. All recreational facilities are equally accessible to residents of the City regardless of age or residential location. In addition to the existing parks and recreational facilities, Brundidge citizens expressed a desire for additional recreation facilities, emphasizing the need for a community center, increased senior activities and more walking trails. There exists the potential for an outdoor gathering place and/or amphitheater at an existing vacant site near Brundidge Station. The remains of a historic structure and a windmill provide visual interest that would make the location unique to Brundidge. Walking trails could be developed using land along streams and creeks that is often located within flood plains and are not conducive to structural development. Development of walking trails in these areas could be mutually beneficial to the protection and conservation of these natural resources while making the resources available for public enjoyment. Brundidge Recreation Park Potential Amphitheater Site Public safety and emergency services are provided by the City of Brundidge Police Department and the Brundidge Volunteer Fire Department. As of 2010, the Brundidge Police Department employs a staff of 14 persons, of which nine are sworn police officers. The officer to population ratio is 3.96 officers per 1,000 residents, which is considerably higher than the average for the State of Alabama, at 2.36 officers per 1,000 residents. Over the last ten years according to www.city-data.com, Brundidge has experienced a decrease in the local crime index, which is the number of crimes reported per 100,000 population. The city-data.com crime index counts serious crimes and violent crime more heavily; and adjusts the crime index number for the number of visitors and daily workers commuting into cities. In 2010, the crime index was 230.5, as compared to 406.8 in 2009 and 396.0 in 2001. While the 2010 crime index in Brundidge was the lowest in the last five years, it was still higher than the national average of 302.8 crime index. An average crime index is considered to be between 200 and 449. A low crime index is between 50 and 199 and a very low crime index is less than 50. A high crime index is between 450 and 1,000 and a very high crime index is 1,001 or higher. Comparatively, Brundidge and most surrounding communities have an average crime index with Elba at 337.1; Ozark at 265.7; New Brockton at 335.5; and Troy at 440.7. Surrounding communities with a very low to low crime index include Ariton at 124.9; Clayton at 76.6; Clio at 3.3; and Louisville at 92.5. None of the surrounding communities had a high crime index in 2010. In recent 35 years Brundidge has experienced a significant decrease in the number of thefts and assaults while the number of burglaries increased since 2005. Brundidge had no reported arson, murder, or rape in 2010 and only had one robbery and two auto thefts. While the number of thefts and assaults was down from previous years, Brundidge still had eight assaults and 34 thefts. The number of burglaries in 2010, at 23, was only a slight increase from 22 burglaries in 2009, but a more significant increase from 2007, at 13 burglaries, and 2005, at 17 burglaries. Number of Crimes in Brundidge By Year (Odd Years Reported) Type of Crime 2001 2003 2005 2007 Arson N/A N/A N/A N/A Theft 69 67 46 80 Burglary 18 24 17 13 Assault 10 5 5 16 Auto Theft 4 1 1 4 Robberies 2 3 2 4 Rapes 0 0 0 1 Murders 1 0 0 0 City-Data.com Crime Index 396.0 286.4 210.4 434.9 Source: http://www.city-data.com/crime/crime-Brundidge-Alabama.html#ixzz1evyhT8eN 2009 N/A 52 22 8 4 3 3 0 406.5 2010 N/A 34 23 8 2 1 0 0 230.5 The City of Brundidge maintains a 6-bay fire station located just east of downtown on East Troy Street. Fire protection services are provided by volunteer fire fighters led by one fire chief. Annually, the City spends around $72,000 for contractual services with firemen, insurance, vehicle expenses, building maintenance, equipment and utilities, and travel and training. Community discussions, field observations and the review of existing data enabled Brundidge residents to outline the following community facilities issues and opportunities. Citizens stated that there is potential to establish a more solid cultural center in Brundidge due to the historic attractions and the attractions provided by a number of local artists and artisans. Community Facilities Issues and Opportunities Issues Opportunities Need a community center Potential to build on existing resources to become a regional arts and cultural center Need more activities for seniors Opportunities for trail development for recreational, transportation and economic benefits Pike County school system needs to build awareness of its positive assets Potential to involve the Pike County school system in more community development projects Create an amphitheater and outdoor gathering place at vacant windmill site near Brundidge Station Utilities and Infrastructure The City of Brundidge provides water, sanitary sewer, electricity, solid waste disposal, storm water drainage and street maintenance services to residents within the City's corporate boundaries. In the City's 2011 budget, total utility revenues were estimated at just over $6.4 million and total 36 utility expenses were estimated at just over $6.3 million, leaving an excess of approximately $103,000 in revenues over expenditures. The majority of the utility revenues are generated by the electric department, at more than $5.2 million, as compared to revenue from sewer services, at $725,000, and water services, at $473,000. Comparatively, the City's utility departments operate at almost a breakeven level with electric expenditures around $5 million, sewer expenditures of approximately $730,000 and water expenditures of approximately $580,000. The City of Brundidge provides water service to approximately 960 residential customers, more than 100 commercial customers and between 10 and 15 industries. Brundidge obtains source water from wells, one of which is located at the corner of College Street and Railroad Avenue and the other located on Elm Street. The College Street Well was first operational in 1948 and is approximately 750 feet deep. The Elm Street Well was put into service in 1969 and is approximately 660 feet deep. A new 400 gallon per minute water well was installed in 2007 and is now available on Sara G. Lott Boulevard. Each well draws water from the Ripley Formation. Together, the three wells have a combined permitted pumping capacity of 1,200 gallons per minute. Storage for the system is handled by four storage tanks totaling 875,000 gallons (75,000 gallon standpipe built in 1907; 250,000 gallon elevated tank built in 1954; a 250,000 gallon elevated storage tank built in 1969; and, a 300,000 gallon tank built in 2003. The system is in compliance with Environmental Protection Agency and Alabama Department of Environmental Management standards. No complaints regarding water services were stated during the 2010 comprehensive planning process. The Brundidge sanitary sewer system was constructed and began operation in 1930. Today, the sewer system serves approximately 1,020 residential customers, 102 commercial customers and five industrial users. In all, about 97 percent of all residences and 84 percent of all commercial establishments are served by the sewer system. The limited number of remaining residences and commercial enterprises that are unserved by sewer are scattered in the outlying areas of the city and have septic tanks that are currently functioning adequately. From a cost of service standpoint, it is not economically feasible to serve these structures until such time as additional development occurs in these areas. The sanitary sewer collection system consists of approximate 65 miles of sewer main and collection pipes. As with most older sanitary sewer systems, vitrified clay pipe and brick and cast iron manholes were used almost exclusively prior to 1980. Brundidge is no exception. However, even with the City's excellent maintenance record, a major problem exists in the system that serves the northwest section of Brundidge. Treatment of collected sewage is handled by a 600,000 gallonper-day capacity extended aeration activated sludge treatment facility. This facility was completed and permitted in 1987 and currently operates at between 50 and 55 percent of its design capacity. Brundidge Wastewater Treatment Plant 37 The City of Brundidge is located on a relatively level-crested plateau. The topography of Brundidge is a mix of gently rolling hills and flat areas. As a plateau, the area slopes gradually in all directions towards the five creeks that surround Brundidge. The creeks are: Sandy Run Creek to the northeast, Bear Creek to the east, Bowden Mill Creek to the southeast, Mims Creek to the southwest, and White Water Creek to the northwest. There are several unnamed, small tributaries and ponds in the City. Lake Foreen, in the northern portion of the city, is the only substantial, standing body of water. Each of the streams has some degree of surrounding flood plain; however, the flood plains in the area are primarily narrow and linear following the stream paths. The storm drainage system in Brundidge consists of a combination of curb and gutter and piped drainage to outfall in natural ditches and ravines. The drainage patterns within the City cause a few problems as stormwater runoff travels through populated areas to drain into the creeks and their tributaries. There are only a few housing units and other structures located adjacent to the flood-prone areas. Brundidge is a participating community in the National Flood Insurance Program. Brundidge is one of a few cities that operate its own electric system. The City provides both residential and commercial electrical service to residents. Additionally, the City of Brundidge owns and operates a landfill for solid waste disposal. The landfill is located in the southwest part of the city near the wastewater treatment plant. Natural gas services is available to Brundidge residents through Southeast Alabama Gas District. Utilities and Infrastructure Issues and Opportunities Issues Opportunities Commercial electric rates are high for young businesses to afford Opportunities and available land to address future storm drainage through the utilization of natural resources to construct retention areas and rain gardens. Sporadic areas with standing water due to storm drainage issues Potential to provide incubator electric rates for new and small businesses to attract economic growth Transportation and Circulation Brundidge is located on and served by three major regional roadways: U. S. Highway 231, Alabama Highway 10, and Alabama Highway 93. While Brundidge has not experienced population growth in the last decade, the City has seen an increase in industrial uses, most notably the Wal Mart distribution center. Like in most American cities, traffic volumes throughout the area have continued to increase more rapidly than the population, making greater demands on the City’s roadway network and increasing traffic congestion. This trend of increased traffic volumes on city streets is a combination of increased driving by area residents and transient traffic on the major roads in the area. Regionally the Brundidge area is served by a principal north/south arterial highway, a minor east/west arterial and a north/south minor arterial, offering strong north‐south and east‐west regional access as well as access within the Brundidge area. U.S. Highway 231 is a principal arterial roadway that bisects the City of Brundidge in a north‐south direction. A four-lane median divided roadway throughout the Brundidge area, U.S. Highway 231 provides regional connectivity for Brundidge to Montgomery and destinations north. Additionally, U.S. Highway 231 provides regional access to the south to Ozark, Dothan, the 38 panhandle of Florida and Interstate 10. Alabama Highway 10 is an east‐west minor arterial roadway that extends from U.S. Highway 231 eastward through Brundidge. Alabama Highway 10 provides access to areas east of Brundidge as well as the western portion of southern Georgia. From U.S. Highway 231 eastward to Alabama Highway 93 the roadway varies in width between four and two lanes of travel. Alabama Highway 10 is known locally as S.A. Graham Boulevard between U.S. Highway 231 and Alabama Highway 93 and then east of Alabama Highway 93, it is known as East Troy Avenue. Alabama Highway 93 (Main Street) is a north‐south minor arterial roadway and serves as the main street of Brundidge and contains the most intense development in the area. This route extends from U.S. Highway 231 on the southern portion of the city northerly to the city limits and provides a connection to U.S. Highway 29. The southern portion of Alabama Highway 93 from U.S. Highway 231 to the downtown area (south of Alabama Highway 10) is three lanes in cross‐section. The roadway narrows to two lanes in width through the downtown area from the vicinity of the Brundidge City Hall north to College Street. From College Street north the roadway is again three lanes wide north to Veterans Boulevard, when it again becomes a two lane facility. All transportation networks have some form of classification of its streets to categorize the hierarchy of movement in the system. The roadway network developed for the Brundidge study area was based on the functional classification system prepared by the Alabama Department of Transportation. The components of this network are arterials, collectors and local streets. Each type roadway provides separate and distinct traffic service functions and is best suited for accommodating particular demands. Their designs also vary in accordance with the characteristics of traffic to be served by the roadway. The following is a brief description of each roadway type. Arterials are important components of the total transportation system. They serve as feeders to regional destinations as well as major travel ways between land use concentrations within an area. Arterials are typically roadways with relatively high traffic volumes and traffic signals at major intersections. The primary function of arterials is moving traffic. Collectors provide both land service and traffic movement functions. Collectors serve as feeders between arterials as well as provide access to the local streets. Collectors are typically lower volume roadways that accommodate short distance trips. Local Streets provide access to the land uses that are immediately adjacent to the roadways as their sole function. The current classified roadways in the Brundidge area are as follows (all roadways not listed are considered as local streets): Roadway U.S Highway 231 Alabama Highway 10 (U.S. Highway 231 east) Alabama Highway 93 County Road 73 County Road 6 (west of U.S. Highway 231) Veterans Boulevard (Main Street) Galloway Street 39 Classification Principal Arterial Minor Arterial Minor Arterial Major Collector Major Collector Minor Collector Minor Collector Daily traffic volumes, as indicated by traffic counts at various locations on the roadway network, reflect current travel patterns and how well the network is serving the travel demand. Traffic count information was collected from the Alabama Department of Transportation for the primary roadways in the Brundidge area. The current daily traffic volumes on area roadways, as of 2008, in Brundidge are shown on the map below. The traffic count data reflects that the vast majority of travel in the Brundidge area takes place on the city's major arterial and collector routes. In addition to daily traffic volumes, the map also shows the portion of the daily traffic volume that is attributed to truck traffic. Roadways which have significant portions of their daily traffic attributed to truck traffic include U.S. Highway 231, at more than 20 percent, Alabama Highway 10, at more than 10 percent, and Alabama Highway 93 north of downtown, at 12 percent. Daily Traffic Volume with Truck Percentages Roadway networks are evaluated by comparing the current or forecast daily traffic volumes along each facility to the facility’s daily capacity. Roadway capacity is defined as the ability of the facility to accommodate traffic. Service flow volume is defined as the level of traffic flow (vehicles per day) that can be accommodated at various levels of service. The current level of service scale, as 40 developed by the Transportation Research Board in the Highway Capacity Manual, Seventh Edition, ranges from a level of service "A" to a level of service "F". Abbreviated definitions of each level of service are as follows: Level of Service A Level of Service B Level of Service C Level of Service D Level of Service E Level of Service F Free traffic flow (0 percent –35 percent of capacity) Stable traffic flow (35 percent –50 percent of capacity) Stable traffic flow (50 percent –62 percent of capacity) High‐density stable traffic flow (62 percent –75 percent of capacity) Capacity level traffic flow (75 percent –100 percent of capacity) Forced or breakdown traffic flow (>100 percent of capacity) As a general rule, the desired operation of a roadway should be no lower than Level of Service C. Additionally, the design level of service associated with new or improved roadways should also be a Level of Service C. A Level of Service D may be acceptable at intersections under certain circumstances for peak hours of operation. A Level of service E or F is considered unacceptable in all circumstances. The methodology used to evaluate roadway segment capacity in this project was a tabular analysis relating roadway classification, number of lanes, levels of service and daily service volumes. The estimated 24‐hour capacities of roadway facilities were derived from information provided by the Alabama Department of Transportation. The roadway capacity information combined with the information obtained form the Highway Capacity Manual provides a means of evaluating the need for improved roadways within the Brundidge study area. The daily traffic volumes were compared with the service volumes for each of the major roadways in the Brundidge study area as summarized in the table below. This comparison of existing daily traffic volumes with the associated service volumes produced an assessment of roadways that were within desired limits and those that were felt to be deficient. The results of this comparison of existing daily traffic volumes on the major roadways in the Brundidge area with established standards for operation found that all roadways currently operation at acceptable levels. No major roadway was found to be deficient in daily travel capacity and sufficient capacity exists for future growth. City of Brundidge Roadway Capacities FACILITY TYPE LOS A LOS B LOS C LOS D LOS E LOS F Two Lane 5,005 7,150 8,866 10,725 14,300 >14,300 Three Lane 5,705 8,150 10,106 12,225 16,300 >16,300 Four Lane 6,860 9,800 12,152 14,700 19,600 >19,600 Four Lane Divided 9,170 13,100 16,244 19,650 Source: Alabama Department of Transportation and Highway Capacity Manual 26,200 >26,200 Throughout the public involvement activities undertaken as part of the development of the Brundidge Comprehensive Plan, truck traffic was continuously brought forward as an area of concern by area residents. In particular the following concerns were voiced repeatedly: 1. The number of trucks currently using Alabama Highway 10 from U.S. Highway 231 east was considered unsafe, impacted retail and event activities along the corridor east of Alabama Highway 93 and contributed to congestion in the downtown area; 2. The number of trucks currently using Alabama Highway 93 north of Alabama Highway 10 north was considered unsafe for motorist and pedestrians and contributed to congestion in the downtown area; 41 3. 4. Turning trucks at the intersection of Alabama Highway 10 and Alabama Highway 93 contributed to congestions based on the limited width of the roadways and impacted pedestrian safety; and Trucks frequently stand in areas along approach routes to Brundidge and deteriorate the adjacent area as well as provide unsightly areas for visitors. Truck Storage Along U.S. Highway 231 Truck Traffic on East Troy Avenue As a follow‐up to comments presented at public involvement meetings related to truck traffic, field observations were conducted to determine the validity of such comments. The observations conducted in the field on the current truck routes by the study team are summarized as follows: Truck traffic observed in the downtown Brundidge area does cause congestion based on the size and number of trucks coupled with the narrow width of the streets (intersection of Alabama Highway 10 and 93); 42 Turning trucks at the intersection of Alabama Highway 10 and Alabama Highway 93 frequently require stopped vehicles to backup form the intersection to provide sufficient distance for turning movements; Pedestrians are frequently intimidated in the downtown area by the presence of large vehicles; and Extensive truck traffic is not compatible with activities in the downtown area. Current Truck Routes Through a combination of comments received at public involvement meetings, field observations conducted by the study team and a review of accident histories at intersections in Brundidge, areas of operational and safety concerns were identified. A brief discussion of the areas of operational and safety concern follows: South Main Street (AL Highway 93) from Troy Street (Al Highway 10) south to Oak Street – Accident history for this section of Main Street is higher than was expected based on the daily traffic volumes present. Observations conducted in the field suggest the accident history is the result of numerous activities occurring in a relatively short space. In other words, the drivers on Main Street as well as those attempting to enter Main Street from side streets or driveways have significant competition for their attention. Also noted, the presence of trucks seems to intimidate drivers and pedestrians. 43 U.S. Highway 231 at Alabama Highway 10 – Accident histories for this intersection, although numerous over a one year period, were not unexpected for an intersection located on a principal arterial that exhibits higher volumes traveling at higher speeds. Field observations did not reveal any significant deficiencies; however, the location of numerous access points to abutting developments could be a source of conflict and a safety concern. Accident History and Areas of Safety Concern Brundidge is also accessed by a rail line operated by CSX Transportation and which has a gross traffic density between 5 million tons and 20 million tons as of 2008. Railroad interchanges are located just north and south of Brundidge in Troy and Waterford/Dothan. The rail line runs in a north-south direction through Brundidge and is roughly parallel to Alabama Highway 93. The rail line veers to the southeast in the southern part of the city as Alabama Highway 93 curves southwest to intersect with U.S. Highway 231. 44 Through comments received at public involvement meetings, field observations conducted by the study team and a review of traffic volumes on major roadways in Brundidge, areas where traffic circulation concerns and issues are located were identified. A brief discussion of those locations where traffic circulation concerns were identified and the nature of those concerns are briefly described. Transportation and Circulation Issues Opportunities Alabama Highway 10 that includes its intersection with U.S. Highway 231 and for approximately ¼ miles east were identified both by the public and through observations as an area of circulation concern due to truck turning traffic, lack of access management guidelines for future development and lack of designated truck storage lots; Utilize a clarified circulation system and truck facilities to encourage additional industrial development in an orderly and efficient manner. Graham Street (Alabama Highway 10) from ¼ mile east of U.S. Highway 231 to Main Street (Alabama Highway 93) was identified as an area of circulation concern based on the lack of access management guidelines for future development and the irregular alignment of lanes from the varying number of lanes; Develop municipal airport into an air park that opens the door to attract a new demographic sector. Increase access to potential residents through ridership on and partnerships with the Pike County Transit System. Veterans Boulevard from U.S. Highway 231 east to Alabama Highway 93 is a concern based on the importance of the route as a gateway into the Brundidge area and the lack of access controls to guide future development; East Troy Avenue (Alabama Highway 10) from Church Street east to the railroad was identified at public involvement meetings as an area of concern for pedestrian traffic associated with events in the downtown area of Brundidge; and Main Street (Alabama Highway 93) between East Troy Avenue and Oak Street was identified by field observations, through accident records review and by the public of concern for pedestrians. The primary concern centered on the mix of pedestrians and large vehicles at the intersection of East Troy Avenue and in the vicinity of the Brundidge city hall. Land Use Land Use is the study of what has been built upon the land and the patterns formed by that development. Land uses and land forms help us locate where we are, or orient ourselves, within the built environment by providing visual clues and landmarks. Clusters of similar land uses form districts and/or neighborhoods, as well as providing a sense of entering or exiting a district, such as a downtown area. Together, a community's varying land uses form a pattern of development that is usually reflective of the underlying topography, natural resources and structural circulation routes. 45 Early in the Brundidge comprehensive planning process, citizens were asked to complete a survey that included questions about the city's special features, landmarks, and directions to various localities. Citizens were also asked to draw a map of Brundidge and include as many landmarks as possible. The graphic map below is a composite of the citizen survey responses. It is clear from the responses that Alabama Highway 93 is the spine of the City of Brundidge for both circulation and commercial and institutional development. Circulation arteries include U.S. Highway 231, S.A. Graham Boulevard - East Troy Street, Veterans Boulevard, Galloway Road, Lee Street and Hardshell Road. The north-south railroad is also a major circulation feature and landmark in the city, along with traffic signals at U.S. Highway 231 and S.A. Graham Boulevard and at Alabama Highway 93 and S.A. Graham Boulevard - East Troy Street. Clusters of commercial and institutional development form districts around the intersection of Alabama Highway 93 and S.A. Graham Boulevard (central business district) and around the intersection of Alabama Highway 93, Veterans Boulevard and Galloway Road. Citizen responses also indicate the formation of a loosely formed highway commercial district at the intersection of U.S. Highway 231 and S.A. Graham Boulevard. Major landmarks and attractions that were highlighted by Brundidge citizens included the Brundidge City Hall (Bass House), Pike County High School, Tupper Lightfoot Memorial Library, Salem Baptist Church, the We Piddle Around Theater, Brundidge United Methodist Church, the Wal Mart Distribution Center, Brundidge Station, Piggly Wiggly, Hardee's, Pike County Little School (Hillcrest Elementary), the City Park and the National Guard Armory. Brundidge Citizen Survey Map, 2010 46 The South Central Alabama Development Commission conducted a windshield survey of existing land uses in January 2010. The resulting existing land use map is provided on the following page. The inventory of existing land uses supports the citizen survey that Alabama Highway 93 functions as the spine of the city. Commercial and institutional development is clustered around the intersection of Alabama Highway 93 and Alabama Highway 10 to form the city's central business district. North of the downtown area, a local business district is created by commercial development around the intersection of Alabama Highway 93, Veterans Boulevard and Galloway Road. Limited commercial development has occurred along U.S. Highway 231 near its intersections with Alabama Highway 93, S.A. Graham Boulevard, and Veterans Boulevard marking the primary entrances to Brundidge. Although commercial development has occurred along the highway corridor, it has been sporadic in nature and neither highway commercial districts nor true gateways to Brundidge have been formed. In total, commercial development comprises 1.5 percent of the total land area of the City of Brundidge or 2.9 percent of the developed area. Just over half of the land area of Brundidge, at 51.6 percent, has been developed; however, agricultural land uses occupy the largest percentage of the area, at 48.0 percent of the developed land and 24.8 percent of the total land area. Residential land uses distantly follow, at 16.9 percent of the developed land or 8.8 percent of the total land area. Of the three categories of residential land uses, single unit structures occupy the highest percentage, at 13.4 percent of the city's developed land; followed by multi-unit residential development, at 2.6 percent, and small multi-family development (two to four units), at 0.9 percent of the developed land area. Residential land uses are primarily clustered around commercial land uses in the central part of the city, on both the east and west sides of Alabama Highway 93; in the northern part of the city between Alabama Highway 93 and Veterans Boulevard and along Galloway Road and in the southern part of the city between Alabama Highway 93 and U.S. Highway 231 south of Mims Creek. The residential land use patterns are clearly reflective of the underlying topography of the city with a noticeable lack of development along in the southwest between Mims Creek and S.A. Graham Boulevard, and in the northwest between Veterans Boulevard and S.A. Graham Boulevard east of Pine Valley Drive. Streams and deep ravines have prevented development in these areas. The same is true in the eastern half of the city with tributaries associated with Bowden Mill Creek, Bear Creek and Sandy Run Creek. Sporadic residential development, however, has occurred in the occasional high areas east of Hardshell Road and south of the Brundidge Recreation Park. Existing Land Use, 2010 Land Use Category Number of Parcels Single Unit Residential 886 2 to 4 Unit Residential 40 Multi-Unit Residential 11 Commercial 115 Industrial 21 Utility/Infrastructure 13 Institutional 43 Institutional/Recreational 1 Recreational 7 Agricultural 38 Total Developed Land 1,175 Undeveloped or Vacant n/a Source: SCADC Windshield Survey, January 2010 Acres 429.9 29.5 85.0 92.1 325.5 489.7 84.3 6.1 131.5 1,544.6 3,218.2 3,012.8 47 Percent of Developed Land 13.4% 0.9% 2.6% 2.9% 10.1% 15.2% 2.6% 0.2% 4.1% 48.0% 100.0% n/a Percent of Total Land Area 6.9% 0.5% 1.4% 1.5% 5.2% 7.9% 1.4% 0.1% 2.1% 24.8% 51.6% 48.4% Brundidge Existing Land Use, 2010 NORTH LEGEND 48 Utility and infrastructural land uses occupy 489.7 acres in Brundidge, which is 15.2 percent of the developed area. Of the 13 parcels designated as utility or infrastructure, five parcels comprise the largest amount of this land use. These five parcels include the city's landfill and wastewater treatment plan located in the southwest part of the city and the airport located in the northeast part of the city. Smaller utility and infrastructure land uses are located throughout the city and are used for water tanks, electrical substations, and similar facilities. Similarly, only 21 parcels are designated as industrial land uses but occupy 325.5 acres. Industrial land uses comprise 10.1 percent of the developed land area. The largest of the industrial land uses is the Wal Mart Distribution Center, located west of U.S. Highway 231 and south of County Road 6. The Wal Mart facility is followed by Southern Classic Food Group, Supreme Oil South, and wood products companies, all of which are located in the northern part of the city on either side of Alabama Highway 93. There is also a small cluster of industrial land uses just north of the central business district and adjacent to residential neighborhoods. The attraction for industry in these locations is access to the railroad. The remaining land use categories of institutional and recreational land uses combined only occupy 221.9 acres and comprise 6.9 percent of the developed land area. Institutional land uses include public buildings and facilities such as government buildings, schools, churches, and cemeteries. Recreational land uses include both passive and active recreational facilities and both indoor and outdoor facilities, such as parks, public open spaces, trails, and community centers. Institutional and recreational facilities are most often sited to best serve residents most efficiently, and therefore, are located throughout the city generally on smaller parcels of land. The exceptions are large parks, school campuses and cemeteries which occupy larger parcels of land. In the citizen survey conducted during the Brundidge comprehensive planning process, citizens were specifically asked about land use conflicts and difficulty in accessing land uses. The majority of the responses, 80 percent or more, stated that citizens did not experience any conflicts or nuisances due to neighboring land uses and did not have access issues to most areas. Some citizens, however, responded that there was insufficient buffering between industrial and residential land uses. Further, citizens stated that a primary land use issue is the lack of land for sale for future development. Land Use Issues and Opportunities Issues Opportunities Solidify highway commercial districts and gateways on U.S. Highway 231 at entrances to Brundidge to invite travelers into the city. Lack of available land for sale for development Lack of gateway development on U.S. Highway 231 to direct travelers into Brundidge Insufficient buffering between conflicting land uses Further define and enhance central business district; integrate mixed land uses harmoniously Existing terrain in some areas is not suitable for structural development Potential for infill residential development Ample land available to accommodate additional industrial growth Need additional and more formal delineation of central business district Build upon existing historic resources in downtown area for unique shopping experience Lack of walkable access to recreational facilities in many neighborhoods Develop trail system around city to connect neighborhoods with recreational and shopping resources 49 50 4. DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY The Brundidge Development Strategy is composed of three interrelated parts that build upon one another in the form of a pyramid. And, like a pyramid, if one of the parts is missing or not functioning, the other two parts will begin to disintegrate as well. The first part is the vision for the long-term growth and development of the community. The second part is a graphic representation of the physical development strategy. The third part is the implementation of both the mental vision and the physical development plan through coordinated actions of local leaders, citizens, industry, businesses, and civic and religious organizations. Each person and entity in Brundidge has a responsibility to assist in the future growth and development of their community. Vision and Goal Framework A vision outlines what a person, company, or community wants to be. It concentrates on future and is a source of inspiration. In terms of comprehensive planning, the vision statement provides guidance for all other policies and plans that are developed. If they are not instrumental in attaining the vision, then either those policies and plans are not in alignment with the vision, are not necessary to attain the vision, or the vision needs to be revised to reflect the desired policies and plans. Citizens of Brundidge began working on a vision statement through communications with friends and neighbors, written exercise and lengthy public discussion. As they discussed their current strengths and weaknesses and transformed those into ideas for what they want to become in the future, the citizens of Brundidge continued to focus on two concepts. First, Brundidge is very progressive for a city of its size in terms of infrastructure and community facilities. And second, Brundidge has a unique character and personality that has been preserved through the years and citizens want to continue to preserve that "Brundidge Hometown" character. Further, citizens wanted to ensure that their vision for the future included continued provision of basic services and facilities to residents while improving the economic climate of the city. As a result of their discussions, citizens developed the following vision statement along with a mission statement that addresses various components of the quality of life in Brundidge: Vision: Brundidge, Alabama….forerunners and leaders in a dynamic environment where progress embraces tradition. Mission: Brundidge will retain its character and ensure a unique quality of life through: • Progressive Economic Development; • Providing Adequate Utilities and Infrastructure; • Maximizing Land Use; • Implementation of Recreation Facilities; and • Periodic Needs Assessments and Utilization. As stated in the Community Studies portion of this plan, citizens were able to extend the vision and mission statements to the process of identifying succinct and solid goals for each element of the comprehensive plan. Together, these goals form a goal framework that was utilized in outlining the proposed development strategy and implementation schedule. The goal framework 51 establishes a the broad outcomes that are expected to be attained through implementation strategy. The purpose of the goal framework is to enable local stakeholders to envision how each of the plan's individual elements impacts the other element and to minimize duplication of efforts by differing groups, and even more importantly, to minimize the risk of stakeholders unknowingly working at odds with one another. Brundidge Comprehensive Plan Goal Framework Economic Development Attract industry Increase retail resources and opportunities Travel accommodations Community Facilities Utilities and Infrastructure Provide housing opportunities to attract long-term residents Establish Brundidge as a cultural arts center Improve stormwater drainage system Provide sufficient locations for manufactured housing Improve recreation resources: recreation center, parks and trails Housing Ensure availability of short-term and starter housing opportunities Improve perception and delivery of educational resources Transportation Minimize truck traffic conflicts Utilization of Pike County Area Maintain progressive utility Transit System system Utilization of implementation Brundidge airport Ensure adequate off-street parking Development Priorities In addition to the vision and mission statements and the goal framework, Brundidge citizens identified a number of development priorities. Many of these projects cross the borders of the comprehensive plan elements and should be looked at from a larger perspective -- or the big picture. As shown in the graphic on the following page, these development priorities include the following : Gateways Image Corridors Improved Circulation Multi-Use Trails Highway Commercial Expanded Downtown Mixed Use Area Expanded Industrial Area Infill Residential Development Conservation Residential Development Natural Resource Conservation Stormwater Management 52 Brundidge Development Priorities Major Street Plan The Major Street Plan for Brundidge will serve as a city wide guide to transportation needs (new and improved streets), give the City the ability to require right‐of‐way reservation in undeveloped areas, identify streets that will be used to move primary traffic, and establish a street classification system. The Major Street Plan was developed to be consistent with both the Short and Long Term Transportation Strategies for Brundidge. The typical design period for a major street plan is twenty‐five years with annual reviews and complete updates every five years. If a major street plan does not exist for an area, then the traveling public determines which streets will be major by using the most convenient streets to meet their daily travel needs. A major street plan identifies the streets that can safely accommodate larger volumes of traffic and identifies where future streets should be construct and which existing streets should be improved. Unplanned street development results in costly redevelopment projects that burden the public not only in taxes but also in construction inconvenience and in the alteration of existing neighborhoods. The Major Street Plan for Brundidge is shown on the following page and is followed by eight recommendations for changes in the city's circulation system. In the plan, Alabama Highway 93 from 53 U.S. Highway 231 north to Veterans Boulevard and Alabama Highway 10 from U.S. Highway 231 to the Brundidge Bypass have been reclassified as Urban Collectors. As such truck traffic has been recommended for removal on these routes and rerouting to U.S. Highway 231, Veterans Boulevard and the Brundidge Bypass. All other major roadways in Brundidge will maintain their current classification. Brundidge Major Street Plan Major Street Plan Recommendations: 1. Prohibit truck traffic on S.A. Graham Boulevard. Reroute truck traffic to Veterans Boulevard and eventually to proposed northeast bypass. 2. Reconfigure intersection of Alabama Highway 93, Veterans Boulevard, and Galloway Street, included truck turns and realignment of Galloway Street. 3. Implement access management recommendations with revisions to pedestrian crossings on East Troy Street. 54 4. Evaluate angle parking (with a possible angle change), revised pedestrian plan and access management on Alabama Highway 93 (South Main Street). 5. Designate Veterans Boulevard as an east-west truck route. Development access management guidelines for future development. Reclassify Veterans Boulevard as a minor arterial route. 6. Reclassify S. A. Graham Street as an urban collector street and develop access management guidelines. Construct a median from U.S. Highway 231 east to approximately one-half mile west of intersection with Main Street (Alabama Highway 93). Develop guidelines for offstreet parking lots. 7. Construct a 2-lane road as a downtown truck bypass connected Alabama Highway 93 (north of downtown) with Alabama Highway 10 (East Troy Street) with an overpass at railroad tracks. 8. Reclassify Alabama Highway 93 as an urban collector route from U.S. Highway 231 to Veterans Boulevard. It is recommended that the City of Brundidge proceed with two immediate projects, pending funding and approval of the Alabama Department of Transportation. First, in the downtown area, is the installation of a mid‐block crosswalk immediately in front of the Brundidge city hall building. This improvement would provide a means of crossing Alabama Highway 93 in addition to the pedestrian crossing at the intersection of E. Troy Avenue. Second, roadway modifications are recommended to improve pedestrian safety at the intersection of Main Street and East Troy Avenue. This improvement will reduce distances pedestrians will be required to cross each street, provide pedestrian signalization and enhance pedestrian safety. Several intersections in the Brundidge area will require modification beyond those as previously identified as portions of the transportation strategies for the area. A brief description of these recommended improvements are presented for inclusion in the overall transportation strategy for Brundidge. U.S. Highway 231 at Alabama Highway 93 – this intersection is designed for higher speed travel for all directions. As part of any change in the character and classification of Alabama Highway 93 in Brundidge, the operation of this intersection should be modified. To change the character of the traffic traveling northbound and entering Brundidge from the south, the ramp for northbound traffic should be removed and replaced with a traditional deceleration right turn lane at the intersection. This action will slow the northbound traffic on Alabama Highway 93 as it enters a congested area with 30 mph regulator speed limits. U.S. Highway 231 at Veterans Boulevard – by rerouting truck traffic onto Veterans Boulevard, a modification to this intersection will be required to ensure truck traffic can adequately and safely travel through the intersection. As an additional improvement measure, traffic signalization for the intersection should be considered as part of the planning for the rerouting of truck traffic. The success of the Major Street Plan for Brundidge relies on the City’s ability to protect current and future capacities of the roadway network. Access management can benefit roadside properties throughout the City of Brundidge by promoting safety and improving roadway capacities. If approached properly, access management can enhance property values while safeguarding past and 55 future public investments in the infrastructure. Access management techniques were developed for three specific corridors in Brundidge as follows: U.S. Highway 231 within the corporate limits of Brundidge; Alabama Highway 10 from U.S. Highway 231 east to the intersection of the proposed Brundidge Bypass and Veterans Boulevard from U.S. Highway 231 east to Alabama Highway 93. Unofficial off street truck parking facilities has been an issue in the Brundidge area for quite some time. Trucks awaiting delivery times at local businesses have created a demand for off street facilities to adequately accommodate this function. Currently waiting trucks are parking along the major routes in Brundidge and creating areas that are unsightly and can create traffic operational conflicts. It is recommended the City consider the adoption of design and construction guidelines for application to this issue. Future Land Use The Future Land Use Map, shown on the following page, is an approximate allocation of the land located inside the Brundidge corporate limits into ten different land uses. Three of the land use categories are residential to provide distinction between low density residential development, medium density residential development and multi-unit developments. Two of the land use categories are economic -- commercial and industrial. The remaining five land use categories can be described as 'specialty' land uses, in the sense that their locations are not necessarily based on the clustering of similar uses. Instead, these land uses tend to serve the surrounding residential or commercial areas. These land use categories include institutional, recreational, utilities and infrastructure, and agricultural land uses and conservation development. The allocation of the land into these ten categories forms a cohesive pattern for future development. Still, it should be noted that the future land use map is a guide for the physical growth and development of Brundidge and provides a solid basis for future land use decisions -- by both private land owners and the City of Brundidge. As such, the Future Land Use Map does not prohibit commercial development within an area designated for industrial land uses, or vice versa. If such alterations are made, however, the impacts of those decisions should be taken into account and the Future Land Use Map should be revised accordingly. As presented, commercial development is concentrated in the downtown area, around the intersection of Veterans Boulevard and Alabama Highway 93, and in well-planned clusters along U.S. Highway 231 between the intersections with Veterans Boulevard to the north and Alabama Highway 93 to the south. Existing industrial land uses are proposed to remain intact, however, additional vegetative buffering and screening should be undertaken to enhance the area aesthetics and establish distinct boundaries around these land uses. Industrial parking lots, etc. should not be open for the casual vehicle or pedestrian traffic due to liability issues. Expanded industrial development is proposed in the southwest part of Brundidge, south of County Road 6 and west of U.S. Highway 231, and near the existing industrial development at the intersection of U.S. Highway 231 and Veterans Boulevard. These locations provide good access for truck traffic and can be developed so that potential industrial traffic does not adversely impact planned commercial or residential areas. As with the existing areas, industrial expansion plans should include the necessary access and vegetative buffering and screening to ensure efficiency for the industry and protection of nearby land uses from industrial noise and unsightly conditions. Low density residential development, primarily single-family detached housing, is proposed for the interior parts of Brundidge, both east and west of Alabama Highway 93, on either side of 56 Galloway Street, and north and south of Alabama Highway 10. Concentrating residential development in these assist in promoting clustered service areas, such as recreation, infrastructural or institutional land uses. Consideration should be given to infill residential development in all existing residential area prior to residential expansion. Additionally, consideration should be given to planned development of higher density residential land uses in close proximity to the low density residential development to maximize access to community services, facilities and shopping. Brundidge Future Land Use Conservation Development 57 In addition to access to services and facilities, higher density residential development should be planned for those areas that are not as suitable for development in order to achieve an adequate return on investment. Rather than build several low density residential units on land that is expensive to build upon, concentrate higher densities in these areas to spread the higher construction costs. If done correctly, the concentration of higher density development in those areas that may have environmental or aesthetic values can help preserve these unique features and make them available for enjoyment by more residents. Agricultural development is planned primarily for the southeast and east central parts of the city due to the existing physical resources and large lot property ownership patterns. The nearby agricultural land uses will help to preserve the small town quality of life desired by residents. As stated previously, institutional, recreational and infrastructural land uses are interspersed among other land uses as necessary to adequately and efficiently provide services to area residents. The final land use category, conservation development, designates those areas that have a unique characteristic that should receive extra consideration in future development plans. These features may include scenic views, streams or other water features, wetlands, steep slopes, etc. Land designated for conservation development might be used for any number of different purposes; however, regardless of the land use, the unique characteristic to be preserved should be the focal point of the development plan. Brundidge Development Strategy The Brundidge Development Strategy, shown on the following page, is a merger of the considerations presented in the city's development priorities, major street plan, and future land use map. It presents the future land use and major street plan as the foundation with development priorities overlaid. Together, these components result in a vibrant development strategy as opposed to a stagnant future land use plan. Because precise locations for exact types of development cannot be accurately predicted, the development strategy provides a basis for development decisions based on the character of development. In contrast, a future land use map provides a guide for the types of land uses to be developed in fairly specific locations. The components of the development strategy reinforce the development priorities that were outlined earlier, but now have concrete foundations in the future land use map. The Development Strategy also maximizes opportunities for (1) increased connections between in and around Brundidge, (2) enhanced vehicular circulation, (3) promotion of commercial resources to travelers and (4) offers protection to the city's special features and resources. Further, the long-term physical development proposed in the Development Strategy will assist the City of Brundidge in addressing its vision to be progressive while embracing tradition. Each of the components of the Brundidge Development Strategy is described below and on the following pages. Gateways: A gateway is more than an entrance to the Brundidge, more than an intersection along Highway 231, and more than pretty landscaping. A gateway is both an announcement and an invitation. A well-developed gateway announces to the traveler that he has arrived at a 'place' and it tells the resident that he is 'home'. A truly well-developed gateway will not only announce arrival, but will also invite the traveler or resident into that place. A gateway uses a combination of structural and natural clues to designate itself as a place, whether that place is the entrance to the City of Brundidge or an activity center or district within the city. 58 59 60 Gateways convey a lasting image to residents, business and industry, and passersby. They should be safe, legible, inviting and interesting. Attractive gateways are not simply a matter of aesthetics; the economy of the city is tightly linked to its physical character, and its image must be enhanced and maintained to remain competitive. Major gateways are proposed at the five locations marking the entrances to Brundidge from different directions: (1) intersection of U.S. Highway 231 and Veterans Boulevard; (2) intersection of U.S. Highway 231 and S. A. Graham Street; (3) intersection of U.S. Highway 231 and Alabama Highway 93; (4) intersection of Alabama Highway 93 with the northern corporate boundary line; and (5) intersection of Alabama Highway 10 with the eastern corporate boundary line. Additionally, minor gateways should be developed upon the arrival to smaller districts within the City of Brundidge, particularly the Central Business District. Image Corridors The Brundidge Development Strategy designates Alabama Highway 93, between Veterans Boulevard and U.S. Highway 231, and S. A. Graham Boulevard as image corridors. These corridors are intended to protect the small-town character that is vital to preserving the identity of Brundidge. Those land uses that front the major thoroughfares should retain the character of the town with slower travel patterns and with significant visual interest. These transportation corridors convey a lasting image -- good or bad -- to residents, business and industry, and passersby. As such, they should be treated as viable community assets, not just infrastructure. Development components of the image corridors may include an overlay zoning district, construction of a median boulevard along S. A. Graham, a master street tree plan, screening and landscaping. Improved Circulation As part of a comprehensive transportation strategy for the Brundidge area both short term and long term programs were developed to allow the City the ability to address current deficiencies immediately and program longer term higher cost improvements at sometime in the future. The short term transportation strategy for Brundidge provides a guide for local and state officials to utilize in addressing existing traffic congestion, improve mobility within the city and address safety concerns. The transportation strategies are summarized in the graphics on the following page and contains the following specific actions: 1. Revise the truck routes in Brundidge to eliminate trucks on Alabama Highway 93 from U.S. Highway 231 north to Veterans Boulevard. The truck route would be carried along U.S. Highway 231 and along Veterans Boulevard. By rerouting trucks from Alabama Highway 93 to U.S. Highway 231, truck turning movements at the intersection of Alabama Highway 93 and Alabama Highway 10 can be eliminated; 2. Reconfigure the intersection of Alabama Highway 93 and Veterans Boulevard/Galloway to accommodate increase truck turning traffic; 3. Implement improvements at the intersection of E. Troy Avenue and Alabama Highway 93 to reduce walking distances for pedestrian traffic in the downtown area; 4. Main Street immediately south of E. Troy Avenue evaluate the possibility of converting the current angle parking to 45 degree parking, revise the pedestrian paths for Main Street and practice access management; 5. Veterans Boulevard should adopt access management principals to guide future development; and 6. Graham Street should have access management principals to guide future development, restripe for consistency of lanes and develop criteria for developing truck storage lots near U.S. Highway 231. 61 Short-Term Circulation Improvements Long-Term Circulation Improvements 62 Throughout the public involvement process associated with the development of the comprehensive plan for Brundidge, one item that the public was consistent in voicing was the need to remove all large vehicles (trucks) from the downtown area of Brundidge. Elements of the short term transportation strategy were specifically identified in an effort to provide immediate relief from such vehicles in the downtown area. It was felt that the removal of trucks from Alabama Highway 93 and rerouting to U.S. Highway 231 and Veterans Boulevard was an action that could be accomplished in a relatively short period of time in coordination with the Alabama Department of Transportation. The ability to remove all large vehicles (trucks) from downtown Brundidge will require construction activities to provide an alternative to Alabama Highway 10. The Transportation Strategy for Long Term conditions for Brundidge presents such an alternative in the extension of Veterans Boulevard (two lanes) eastward to intersect Alabama Highway 10 east of downtown with an overpass of the railroad. This construction of a northern bypass would allow the removal of all trucks from the downtown area, provide improved mobility for traffic in Brundidge and improve emergency vehicle accessibility for areas east of the railroad. Multi-Use Trails The City of Brundidge has valuable physical resources that lend themselves to trail development. Trails provide recreational, transportation and economic value while protecting nearby unique features. Using these unique features as the pathways, the Development Strategy proposes a system of interconnecting multi-use trails that provide circulation all the way around Brundidge, as well as access to and from the central part of the city. Additionally, opportunities are available to connect the local trail system with other regional trail systems. Although trails are often viewed as a recreational asset, trail planning and construction should include connection points to increase functionality for transportation and economic development. Suggested trail connections, or hubs, in Brundidge include downtown, school campuses, parks, major employers, and neighborhood centers. In this way, the trail system becomes a viable part of the local transportation system which decreases traffic congestion. Further, trail crossings require forethought and often innovative approaches. Not all trail crossings have to be at grade with the road system. Crossings can include both underpasses and overpasses when consideration is given to trail planning in conjunction with Trail path under County Road 52 transportation planning. In in Shelby County, Alabama particular, Brundidge must Photo courtesy of Amy Smith, KPS Group consider how trail crossings can occur across U.S. Highway 231 to connect residents with existing and future industrial locations. Trail development must also take buffering of the trails into consideration to ensure that local industries are not threatened with pedestrian liability. 63 Highway Commercial Development To date, Brundidge has a very limited presence along U.S. Highway 231. The proposed highway commercial development will help rectify that issue with carefully planned commercial development that caters to both local residents and travelers. In the past, the nearby access to Brundidge has not been promoted to travelers along Highway 231, although the city's antique and downtown retail resources were. It is believed that Brundidge is losing many potential shoppers because they do not realize how close they actually are to the downtown area as they travel along U.S. Highway 231; nor do traveling shoppers realize that there is additional return access to U.S. Highway 231 via Veterans Boulevard and Alabama Highway 93. Well-planned commercial development along U.S. Highway 231 will accomplish several needed tasks. First, it will bring a presence of Brundidge to the traveler, letting them know that they have arrived in a "place". Hand in hand with developing that sense of arrival is the development of a welcoming gateway that leads both visitors and residents into the city. Second, the proposed development along Highway 231 encourages larger retail development that is not aesthetically appropriate for the downtown area. Access to these shopping area, however, should not be from Highway 231, but instead from planned service roads that parallel the highway. And third, commercial development along U.S. Highway 231 presents an opportunity further create a service niche for transportation needs, with catering to heavy truck traffic as a priority. Expanded Downtown Mixed Use Area The downtown area of Brundidge is, quite possibly, the city's valuable feature and most viable economic resource as it exists today. At all costs, the downtown area should remain the central hub of the City of Brundidge. There are opportunities, however, to expand the downtown character slightly to nearby streets and residential areas forming a more distinct downtown district. In doing so, consideration should be given to including residential resources in the downtown area to increase activity levels in the evening, which would in turn, encourage even more retail development in the area. Special retail amenities should be provided to shoppers such as downtown meeting and gathering spaces, seating areas, waste disposal, and shading. Care should be also be taken to ensure pedestrian safety with the parking and crosswalk recommendations provided in the improved circulation strategy. The downtown area should not be restricted to only retail uses. Instead, a variety of uses can exist harmoniously if the focus is how the use interacts with the street and neighboring properties rather than just on the use of the land. A printer is often thought of as an industrial use due to the machinery involved; however, a local print shop can be a true asset to nearby offices and businesses. All businesses should have appealing street frontages that cater to the pedestrian. It is recommended that guidelines be developed for an overlay zone to be incorporated into the city's zoning ordinance. Images of Downtown Brundidge 64 Expanded Industrial Area The Brundidge Development Strategy proposes to maintain and provide additional buffering of industrial land uses in the northern part of the city along Alabama Highway 93 while expanding industrial lands in the southwest part of the city for future industrial growth. Considerations for industrial expansion include protection and integration of existing floodplains and natural resource areas into the overall development plan. Minor industrial development is also proposed in the northwest part of the city around the intersection of U.S. Highway 231 and Veterans Boulevard near existing industry and the National Guard Armory. Access to future industrial areas should be coordinated with existing intersections on U.S. Highway 231 with Alabama 93, S. A. Graham Boulevard and Veterans Boulevard. In all cases, the need for both aesthetic and sound screening and buffering will be a major consideration in order to preserve the quaint character of the city, to continue to promote increased commercial development, and to protect established residential neighborhoods. Infill Residential Development Existing residential patterns are fairly close-knit with a connection to two major internal intersections: Alabama 10 and Alabama 93 (S.A. Graham Boulevard and Main Street) and Alabama Highway 93 and Veterans Boulevard. Infill residential development in these existing communities should be encouraged so that, one, the neighborhoods remain safe, healthy and intact; two, a burden is not placed on the city's infrastructure to provide services; and three, the city's natural resources are not unnecessarily used for sprawling residential development. These neighborhoods are walkable and provide both a vehicular and pedestrian connection to existing commercial and institutional land uses. Care should be taken to preserve and enhance these connections. Conservation Residential Development Unlike traditional residential development, conservation residential development clusters homesites closely together, leaving as much open and green space as possible available for resident enjoyment. Conservation developments may or may not include pedestrian and neighborhoodoriented retail development to serve the surrounding households. These developments, however, should include neighborhood amenities such as parks, trails, community centers and meeting/ gathering spaces. Conservation developments help protect the surrounding countryside while providing ample opportunity for new housing. Moreover, these types of development can be even more cost effective for the developer and include a variety of A Typical Plan for a housing types from townhomes to Conservation Residential garden homes to larger and higherDevelopment end homes in one package. 65 Natural Resource Conservation The character of Brundidge is defined as much by its "unbuilt" resources as it is by its built resources. It is equally important to protect and enhance the natural surroundings in maintaining the city's ambiance as it is to encourage development. Many of these natural resources were reviewed in the inventory portion of the plan; however, special consideration should be given to maintaining and protecting scenic viewsheds, wetlands, and floodplain areas. Stormwater Management As development occurs in Brundidge, consideration should be given to increased stormwater management from additional runoff from impervious surfaces, such as rooftops, sidewalks, and streets. This is particularly important in Brundidge due to the elevation changes and steep slopes and ravines that are present throughout the city. Brundidge has the opportunity and available land to guide runoff through a natural filtration system so that local streams are not impacted with sedimentation and pollutants. This recommendation is a safeguard for development due to the potential to have a negative impact on local water quality, which could hinder issuance of future discharge permits which are often necessary to promote industrial development. Actions and Implementation Schedule The last part in compiling the Brundidge Development Strategy is identifying the actions and policies necessary to support the mission statements and goals to fulfill the city's long-term vision. The coordinated actions of local leaders, organizations and agencies and residents will fuse the mental vision with the planned physical development for Brundidge. By establishing goals and action steps, an outline for implementation of the Brundidge Comprehensive Plan is developed. A goal is a desired outcome. The actions associated with a goal are the steps that must be taken to make the goal a reality. Goals and action steps were developed to address and/or support each of the goals that were identified by citizens and local leaders in the goal framework. The implementation portion of the strategy outlines whether the action is the responsibility of the public sector, the private sector or will require a coordinated partnership between the two sectors. While the public sector includes the City of Brundidge, it may also the State of Alabama (particularly in regards to transportation), development authorities, educational institutions, federal agencies, or other public bodies. The private sector will most certainly include individuals and/or private businesses, but it also includes non-profits, civic organizations, faith-based groups, and neighborhood groups or organizations. Finally, the implementation schedule has also assigned a priority ranking to each action. The rankings are simplified into three categories -- first, second or third. Priority 1 actions should be addressed immediately and completed within two to five years. Priority 2 actions should begin being considered for implementation in the next three years and should be implemented in the next five to ten years. Priority 3 actions are those that are not considered urgent or that may be dependent upon the implementation of a higher priority 66 action before it can be implemented. Priority 3 actions should be reviewed and implemented in the next ten to 15 years. Besides the Priority 1, 2, or 3 actions, there are a few actions that will be dependent upon the results of other priority actions and/or changing conditions in the future. These long-range actions are designated with a "U" for Undetermined in the priority column of the implementation schedule because their time frame for implementation cannot yet be designated. Nevertheless, these long-range should remain in the implementation schedule as future actions when the timing is appropriate. If they are not included, simply because funds are not yet available or because the city has not yet reached that growth stage, the risk is high of losing the opportunity to implement the action at a later date. Brundidge Comprehensive Plan Implementation Schedule Economic Development Goals Attract Industry Increase Retail Resources and Opportunities Actions 1. Further develop industrial locations with adequate infrastructure to ensure that Brundidge is able to accommodate industrial prospects. 2. Promote the existing infrastructure as part of the City's industrial and commercial recruitment efforts. 3. Develop a spec building to entice industrial prospects. 4. Actively coordinate industrial and commercial recruitment efforts with the Pike County Economic Development Corporation to increase coverage. 1. Continually develop and diligently maintain retail locations to increase shopping by residents and visitors and to attract new retail resources. 2. Actively recruit new and expanding businesses to locate in Brundidge to expand retail choices and competition. 3. Actively encourage local entrepreneurship and establish start-up program to assist local entrepreneurial efforts. 1. Pursue construction of a local hotel. Develop Travel Accommodations 2. Encourage use of Brundidge historic housing resources for bed and breakfast businesses. 3. Pursue private development of accommodations for recreational vehicles. 67 Pub Pvt X X 2 X X X 1 2 X 1 X 1&2 X X Priority 1 X 1 X 2 X 1 X 1&2 Housing Goals Provide Housing Opportunities to Attract Long-Term Residents Provide Sufficient Locations for Manufactured Housing Ensure Availability of Short-term and Starter Housing Opportunities Actions 1. Increase opportunities for home ownership through local financing programs and community partnerships. 2. Develop higher-end housing to provide housing choice to established homeowners and to attract new residents, particularly retirees. 1. Develop quality manufactured housing subdivisions to provide a viable, safe and attractive housing choice. 2. Stringently enforce existing land use regulations and building codes to ensure an ongoing supply safe and sound housing stock. 3. Utilize building and zoning codes to phase out older manufactured homes that are no longer structurally sound. 1. Ensure that adequate rental property and/or apartments are available to meet needs of transient residents and nonhomeowners. 2. Develop quality starter housing that is attractive to first-time home buyers. 3. Develop and market student-oriented housing that is attractive both Troy University and Enterprise-Ozark Community College students, with particular emphasis on older and family students. Pub Actions 1. Establish a cultural arts council as a lead organization in hosting and attracting increased arts and cultural venues. 2. Develop a promotional campaign to increase statewide awareness of existing cultural arts resources in Brundidge. 3. Build upon existing cultural arts resources to develop new cultural arts avenues. 1. Increase opportunities for social gatherings and senior activities. 2. Utilize existing natural resources to develop a multi-use trail system than connects residents to activity centers. 3. Construct a community center as a central location for recreational activities. X Pvt Priority X 1 X 2 X 2 X X 1 X 1&2 X 3 X 1 X X 2 Pub Pvt Priority X 1 X X 1 X X 1&2 X X 1 X X 1&2 Community Facilities Goals Establish Brundidge as a cultural arts center Improve Recreation Resources: Recreation Center; Parks and Trails 68 X 2 Improve Perception and Delivery of Educational Resources 1. Extend educational programs into community. 2. Establish a Partners in Education Program to increase local awareness of quality schools and to increase local resources in the school system. 3. Increase vocational opportunities through partnerships with industry and businesses. X 1 X X 1 X X 1 Actions 1. Upgrade storm drainage system to eliminate existing private property flooding and to accommodate future development. 2. Determine location and cause of odors and correct problems. 3. Investigate “green” drainage systems as a means to increase stormwater drainage capacity and minimize impact on property owners. 1. Install underground utilities on Main Street to enhance the attractiveness of the downtown area. 2. Promote existing utility systems to business and industry. Pub Pvt Priority Actions 1. Revise truck routes through Brundidge to eliminate turns on AL Highway 10 to and from AL Highway 93. 2. Reconfigure the intersection at Galloway Street and Veterans Boulevard. 3. Develop and implement proposed access management plans for US Highway 231, Graham Boulevard, and Veterans Boulevard. 4. As needed, construct a 2-lane road from AL Highway 93 (north) to AL Highway 10 (east) as downtown truck bypass route. 1. Increase awareness of transit system and routes through advertisements and public announcements. 2. Utilize availability of Pike County Transit System to attract residential growth and development, with emphasis on student housing market. 3. Explore concept of rail trolley system between Troy and Brundidge. Pub Utilities and Infrastructure Goals Improve Storm Water Drainage System Maintain Progressive Utility System Implementation X 1 X 1 X X 2 X X 2 X 1 Transportation Goals Minimize Truck Traffic Conflicts Utilization of Pike County Area Transit System 69 Pvt Priority X 1 X 2 X X 1 U X X X X 1 1 X U Utilization of Brundidge Airport Ensure Adequate OffStreet Parking 1. Upgrade and make improvements to bring airport up to standards. 2. Investigate repair and renovation of the Brundidge airport. 3. Research necessary facilities to attract private air travel and use. 1. Evaluate angle parking in downtown. 2. Develop truck parking areas to new guidelines. 3. Recruit travel center facility / truck stop. 4. Include new guidelines in zoning ordinance and subdivision regulations, as appropriate. 70 X X X X 2 2 X X U 1 X X 1 X X 1 X 1 5. APPENDICES Appendix A. Access Management Criteria Appendix B. Off Street Truck Parking Facility Design and Construction Guidelines 71 72 APPENDIX A. BRUNDIDGE ACCESS MANAGEMENT GUIDELINES Introduction The document describes access management strategies and presents guidelines that can be used to plan development on land abutting arterials in Brundidge. The strategies outlined in this document are intended to apply to: • • • U. S. Highway 231 within the corporate limits of Brundidge; Alabama Highway 10 from U.S. Highway 231 east to the location of the proposed Brundidge bypass; and Veterans Boulevard from U.S. Highway 231 east to Alabama Highway 93. Specific strategies are illustrated to show how they work and why they are important. Encouraging substantial spacing between driveways is the single most important step that Brundidge can take to ensure safety and maintain the traffic carrying capacity of its arterials. When local officials review a development proposal that is adjacent to an arterial, a primary consideration should be for the safety of people traveling on the arterial, and a secondary consideration should be for people entering and leaving the proposed development. The following strategies are aimed at encouraging safe conditions. They have the added benefit of preserving traffic carrying capacity. These concepts should be considered for inclusion in the City’s zoning ordinance, site plan review, traffic standards and subdivision regulations. General Access Provisions: In general, all properties abutting public streets are permitted at least one safe access to the public street system. On properties with multiple public street frontages, the City reserves the right to restrict vehicular access solely to the public street having the lower roadway classification, and/or to the safest access location. Development proponents requesting more than one driveway access to a public street will be required to justify the second driveway on the basis of development generated trips. Where the driveway location does not meet minimum City separation criteria, or where a safe driveway location can’t be found, the City requires appropriate mitigation measures to provide for as safe a driveway as is feasible. Driveway Location and Design Driveway spacing standards establish the minimum distance between access points along major thoroughfares. These standards help to reduce the potential for collisions, as travelers enter or exit the roadway. They also encourage the sharing of access for smaller parcels, and can improve community character by reducing the number of driveways and providing more area for pedestrians and landscaping. The location of driveways affects the ability of drivers to safely enter and exit a site. 73 If driveways do not provide adequate sight distance, exiting vehicles may be unable to see oncoming traffic. In turn, motorists on the roadway may not have adequate time to avoid a crash. Driveway design standards assure driveways have an adequate design so vehicles can easily turn onto the site. Standards should also address the depth of the driveway area. Where driveways are too shallow, vehicles are sometimes obstructed from entering the site causing others behind them to wait in through lanes. This blocks traffic and increases the potential for rear‐end collisions. Considerations in establishing separation standards include street function and classification, driving speeds, location of adjacent streets and driveways, volume of trucks, driver expectancy, and the separation and reduction of motorist, bicyclist and pedestrian conflicts. Guidelines for a minimum turn radius, driveway width, and driveway slope are important because they help slower, turning traffic move off the arterial more quickly, and help the traffic leaving a driveway turn and enter the stream of traffic more efficiently. Requirements for turn radius, driveway width, and driveway slope are generally applied to non‐residential developments and subdivisions. Turn Radius The turn radius (or return radius) refers to the extent that the edge of the commercial driveway is “rounded” to permit easier entry and exit by turning vehicles. As shown in the diagram, a larger radius results in an “easier” entrance or exit movement for vehicles. The driveway movement can be performed at a greater speed and with less encroachment into oncoming through traffic. The preferred turn radii will depend on the type of vehicles to be accommodated, the number of pedestrians and cyclist crossing the driveway, and the operating speeds of the accessed roadway. Driveway Width It is important to regulate the maximum width of non‐residential driveways. If the driveway is too wide, as is often the case, there is virtually unrestricted access. The result may be a wide driveway, which is unsafe to drivers, who may have a hard time deciding where to position themselves, and to pedestrians, who will have a greater distance of pavement to cross. In the worst case, uncontrolled access across the entire frontage leads to a severe deterioration in the level of service of the arterial and to costly road improvements. On the other hand, if the driveway is too narrow, the access speed to and from the driveway will be slow, impinging on through traffic. 74 General Driveway Design Standards: Construction of driveways along acceleration or deceleration lanes, left turn storage lanes and tapers should be avoided, unless no other reasonable access to the property is available. Driveways on undivided roadways shall be aligned directly opposite driveways on the opposite side of the road, or offset from each other in accordance with applicable City or State Standards, due to the potential for conflicting left turns or jog maneuvers and resulting safety or operational problems. Driveway width and return radius or flare is adequate to serve the volume of traffic and provide for efficient movement of vehicles onto and off of the major thoroughfare. However, the width of driveways not so excessive as to pose safety hazards for pedestrians and bicycles. Driveways with more than two lanes should incorporate channelization features. Restrict the number of curb cuts to one entrance and exit drive. Where excessive access exists, install curbing to limit access to one location upon applications for expansions, redevelopments or change of use. Require shared driveways between two parcels at the property line, where practical. Minimum Distance between Driveways Maintaining a minimum distance between driveways along an arterial minimizes the number of access points that a driver must keep an eye on. This simplifies driving and reduces the opportunities for conflicts and crashes. Shorter access spacing can be permitted on lower classification roadways. Longer spacing is desirable on roadways in areas where speeds are higher. These guidelines can be used for both residential and nonresidential development. Driveway Spacing Standards: U.S. Highway 231 Veterans Boulevard Alabama Highway 10 (Graham Street) 600 feet measured center to center 500 feet measured center to center 350 feet measured center to center Mitigation measures for developments that cannot meet the minimum driveway spacing criteria: Move the proposed driveway as far from the closest driveway, or intersection, as possible. This is the minimum mitigation measure that will be accepted by the City, and in some instances is not an adequate mitigation by itself. Acquire a cross‐easement for ingress and egress from an adjoining property, and use an existing driveway for the new development. Acquire a binding agreement from an adjoining property to remove an existing adjacent driveway in order to meet the minimum driveway to driveway separation criteria; and remove that extra driveway. Depending upon the trip generation characteristics of the subject development and the traffic volumes on the subject street, removal of an existing driveway may be considered adequate mitigation even when the full driveway‐to‐driveway separation distance does not fully meet the minimum driveway separation criteria. 75 Median and Signalized Intersection Spacing Wide non‐traversable medians provide shelter for vehicles making left turns to and from the street. They also provide refuge for pedestrians attempting to cross wide streets. Consequently, collision rates on major streets with wide non‐traversable medians have been found to be substantially lower than undivided streets or streets having a continuous two way left turn lane. Medians can also be landscaped as part of a corridor beautification program. As with driveways, the spacing and design of median openings is important to the safe and efficient operation of the street. Safety benefits are reduced when median openings have inadequate storage for left turns, or when the openings are too close together. Narrow non‐traversable medians provide shelter for vehicles making left turns to and from the street and prevent unsafe left turns onto the street. Narrow non‐traversable medians do not provide all of the benefits of wide non‐traversable medians, but require only very minor physical changes in the street to accommodate their construction. Narrow non‐traversable medians also require less right‐of‐way and may be used more often where rights‐of‐way are limited. Long uniform intersection spacing on arterial streets facilitate the use of traffic signal timing plans to respond to peak and off‐peak traffic flow conditions. Long and uniform spacing improves traffic flow and increases the number of vehicles that may flow through the traffic signal on a given green cycle. Capacity of the intersection and the arterial street is thereby increased, fuel consumption and traffic emissions are decreased and traffic safety is improved. Median and Intersection Spacing Standards: U.S. Highway 231 within Brundidge corporate limits There should be at least 1,300 feet between each median opening There should be at least 2,600 feet between signalized intersections Veterans Boulevard from U.S. 231 to Alabama Highway 93 There should be at least 750 feet between each median opening There should be at least 1,000 feet to 1,200 feet between each signalized intersection Alabama Highway 10 (Graham Street) from U.S. Highway 231 and the proposed northeast bypass There should be at least 600 feet between each median opening There should be at least 1,000 feet to 1,200 feet between each signalized intersection Left and Right Turn Lanes Left‐turn and right‐turn lanes minimize the conflict between turning vehicles and vehicles attempting to continue in through‐traffic lanes. They also provide storage space where vehicles can safely wait to perform the turn maneuver. This results in smoother traffic flow, increased capacity and greatly increased safety. The construction of a left turn lane on a heavily traveled arterial can reduce the conflict and delay that occur when through vehicles turn left across traffic. A left turn lane can also reduce conflicts that occur when cars behind the turning vehicle have to slow down, stop or pass on the right of the turning vehicle. The left turn lane separates the turning vehicle from through traffic and 76 provides a storage area where a number of left turning vehicles can wait to make a turn. Left turns can also be controlled through median strips that allow left turns only at certain controlled points. Left turn lanes should be provided at all median openings on arterial roadways and meet City and/or Alabama Department of Transportation (ALDOT) standards. When medians extend the full length of a road, the spacing of intersections and median breaks are crucial to providing access to properties on both sides of the road. The median prevents vehicles from crossing the arterial and making left turns from side streets onto the arterial. Median breaks should generally only be provided at public road intersections or at driveways shared by several businesses. They should generally not be provided for access to individual businesses or residences. The number of median breaks should be kept to a minimum since they add conflict points and detract from safety. Raised medians fully separate opposing traffic, define where turns and crossings are allowed, and provide a safe refuge for pedestrians. Raised medians are most desirable at major activity centers where relatively few high volume driveways provide access to adjacent properties. Right Turn Deceleration Lane Right turn lanes and tapers help to get turning vehicles out of the through traffic lanes. Right turn lanes or tapers reduce traffic delays that would otherwise occur as through traffic slows to permit turning traffic to exit the arterial. A deceleration lane should be used when a specific Threshold of turning traffic is reached or when a traffic impact study indicates that a right turn lane is needed. Level‐of‐service criteria, volume warrants, crash experience, existing traffic operations, or engineering judgment that indicates a safety concern to right turning vehicles can justify the need for right turn deceleration lanes. The length of the deceleration lane will also vary according to the speed of traffic on the arterial. However, the turn lane should be sufficient length to allow the turning vehicle to leave the through lane at the posted speed limit, decelerate, and negotiate the turn. Right turn lanes should be required at any access point to an arterial roadway. Turn Lane Standards for Arterial Roadways: Left turn lanes shall be required at all median openings. Deceleration lanes shall be required at all access points. Corner Clearance Corner clearance is the distance from an intersection of a public or private street to the nearest access connection or driveway. Providing adequate corner clearance can decrease the likelihood of crashes and minimize the interruptions to the flow of traffic. Inadequate clearance 77 between driveways and intersections creates many conflict points within too small an area. Corner clearance guidelines preserve good traffic operations at intersections, as well as the safety and convenience of access to corner properties. Setting driveways and connections back from intersections reduces the number of conflicts and provides more time and space for vehicles to turn or merge safely across lanes. Adequate corner clearance is assured by establishing a larger minimum lot size for corner lots. Conditional use limitations may be imposed where adequate corner clearance cannot be obtained. This helps assure that corner properties do not experience access problems as traffic volumes grow. Factors affecting safe corner clearances include the posted speed limit, whether the driveway is “upstream” or “downstream” from the intersection, and whether or not the intersection is signalized. Corner Clearance Standards for Arterial Roadways: Locate new driveways outside the functional area of an intersection. No driveway shall be allowed onto an arterial roadway within 600 feet of an intersection. Mitigation measures for developments that cannot meet the minimum corner clearance criteria: If no other reasonable access to the property is available, including joint and cross access with adjacent properties; The connection does not create a safety or operational problem, upon review of a site‐specific study of the proposed connection prepared by a qualified professional, AND The proposed driveway location meets AASHTO standards and accepted engineering practice; then Provided appropriate sight distance standards are met, a driveway within the functional area of the intersection may be constructed. It shall be located as close to the property line and as far from the intersection as site conditions allow. Joint and Cross Access Joint and cross access requirements consolidate driveways serving more than one parcel and provide circulation between adjacent parcels. This allows vehicles to circulate between adjacent businesses without having to reentering public streets. Joint access requirements are used to connect major developments and to reduce the number of driveways that would otherwise be required to serve abutting parcels. Joint driveways are also used to improve driveway spacing or separation, and sometimes permit more than one driveway to serve a single parcel where separation standards would not otherwise permit more than one driveway. This may allow intensive development along a corridor while maintaining traffic operations and safe and convenient access to businesses. Property owners unable to meet minimum driveway separation standards are typically required to provide for 78 joint and cross access easements whenever feasible. Abutting properties under different ownership are encouraged to comply, but are generally not required to comply until they develop or redevelop property. Joint and Cross Access Standards Shared driveways and cross access easements shall be required when possible and to meet driveway spacing criteria. Properties located on arterial or collector roadways should provide a cross access drive and pedestrian access to allow circulation between adjacent sites. Such connection is generally required in retail commercial use adjacent to other commercial, office, industrial or multi‐family development. Required cross‐access corridors shall be shown on any subdivision or site plan. A system of joint use driveways and cross access easements shall be required to provide unified access and circulation among parcels and assist in local traffic movement. In such cases, the building site shall incorporate the following: 1. A continuous cross‐access or service drive with sufficient width to accommodate two‐way travel aisles for automobiles, service vehicles and loading vehicles. 2. Stub‐outs and other design features to make it visually obvious that abutting vacant properties shall be interconnected to provide cross access at the time they are developed. 3. Building sites shall be designed to ensure parking, access and circulation may be easily interconnected to future adjacent development. Where joint‐ and cross‐access is provided pursuant to this section, property owners shall: 1. Record an easement allowing cross access to and from other properties served by the joint use driveways or service drive, which shall be a covenant running with the land; 2. Record an agreement that any pre‐existing curb cuts providing for access in the interim shall be closed and eliminated after construction of the joint‐use driveway, which shall be a covenant running with the land; and 3. Record a joint maintenance agreement defining maintenance responsibilities of property owners that share the joint use driveway and cross access system, which shall be a covenant running with the land. Where abutting properties are in different ownership and not part of an overall development plan, cooperation between the various owners to create a unified access and circulation system shall be strongly encouraged. Abutting properties shall provide unified access and circulation at the time they are developed or redeveloped. Maximum Number of Driveways Every driveway or intersecting street along an arterial has the potential to reduce the ability of the arterial to move traffic. While it is essential to allow access to property, the City can limit the number of driveways permitted on any lot. Regulating the maximum number of driveways per property frontage limits the number of conflict points and provides drivers more time and distance to execute their maneuvers. A basic requirement should be established that limits the number of driveways to one per parcel, with special conditions for additional driveways. Commercial 79 properties should be limited to a single driveway unless they have larger frontages or they can demonstrate that their development generates more than 4,000 vehicles per day. Driveway Number Standards: The maximum number of direct access driveways allowed per parcel is one when no alternative for cross or joint access is possible. Shared driveways and cross access easements shall be required when possible and to meet driveway spacing criteria. When a parcel has frontages on two (or more) public streets with different street classifications and function, then the parcel should be limited to access on the lower classification of street. Outparcel Requirements (Internal Access) Shopping center developments often include separate lots or “outparcels” fronting on the major roadway. The outparcels are leased or sold to businesses looking for highly valued corridor locations. Access to these outparcels should be incorporated into the access and circulation system of the principal development and should not be allowed direct vehicular access to the arterial street. This approach reduces the need for separate driveways on the major road, while maintaining overall accessibility. To accomplish this, development sites under the same ownership or those consolidated for development will be treated as one site for the purposes of access management. A unified traffic circulation and access plan for the overall development site shall be required. Outparcel Standards: Outparcels shall be accessed via the shared circulation system of the principal development or retail center. Access to outparcels shall be designed to avoid excessive movement across parking aisles and queuing across surrounding parking and driving aisles. Frontage, Reverse Frontage and Alternative Access When land is subdivided for small commercial or residential uses, the lots abutting arterial streets should not be allowed direct vehicular access to the arterial street. Instead, an interior street, which provides access to the arterial street, should be required. The interior street may be a common service or minor road. This eliminates the conflicts between high‐speed traffic and traffic entering and exiting at closely spaced driveways. Access to the arterial street should be provided at a location able to meet separation and corner clearance standards, and designed to safely handle the traffic generated by the development. The diagrams below reflect the application of frontage roads for access to properties on arterial roadways. 80 When a parcel has frontage on more than one public street, and one of those streets has a higher street classification and function than the other street, then the property should be required to obtain access solely from the street having the lower (or lowest) classification and function, where possible. If there is more than one developer, or if development proceeds piecemeal over time, the City shall allow smaller sites to be served by an individual entrance only until such time as adjacent lots are developed. When a service road or interior street is constructed, the temporary commercial driveways shall be closed or consolidated. Frontage, Reverse Frontage and Alternative Access Standards: Frontage, Reverse Frontage and Alternative Access drives shall be required as an alternative to joint and cross access drives in larger developments when possible. Properties located on arterial or collector roadways shall provide a frontage or reverse frontage roads and pedestrian access to allow circulation between adjacent sites. Such connection is generally required in retail commercial use adjacent to other commercial, office, industrial or multi‐family development. Required roads shall be shown on any subdivision or site plan. Throat Length / Minimum Stacking The depth of the formal entranceway is referred to as the “throat length”. In designing driveways, adequate driveway queue length must be provided on commercial sites to prevent entering vehicles from having to stop in the public streets, and to prevent exiting vehicles from blocking internal circulation aisles. This problem is most evident with drive‐in service developments that generate high traffic volumes and require motorists to wait in their vehicles while being served, or until service begins. Such developments shall be carefully analyzed to assure that the site plan provides adequate storage. Specific storage areas shall be determined on an individual basis; however minimum storage lengths are required to be provided before any crossing or turning conflicts can be permitted. Driveways should be long enough to allow adequate space for vehicles pulling off the road and stacking to enter the road. Throat Length Standards: The minimum driveway throat length at major intersections and/or median openings shall be 250 feet. The minimum driveway throat length at minor access points, including right‐in, right‐out is 150 feet. 81 Residential Access Through Neighborhood Streets Residential driveways on major roadways result in dangerous conflicts between high‐speed traffic and residents entering and exiting their driveway. As the number of driveways increase, the roadway is gradually transformed into a high speed version of a local residential street. Subdivisions should always be designed so that lots fronting on major roadways have internal access from a residential street or lane (also known as “reverse frontage”). Minor land division activity can be managed by establishing a restriction on new access points and allowing land to be further subdivided, provided all new lots obtain access via the permitted access point. Another step is to prohibit “flag lots” along major thoroughfares. Some property owners subdivide their land into lots shaped like flags to avoid the cost of platting and providing a road. Instead, the flag lots are stacked on top of each other, with the “flag poles” serving as driveways to major roads. This results in closely spaced driveways that undermine the safety and efficiency of the highway. Although it might be easier and cheaper for a land developer to subdivide the frontage rather than construct interior roads, the public loses when the result is unsafe conditions, congestion, lower speed limits, and eventually a need for costly road improvements. It is better to construct interior roads that provide access to lots. This reduces the number of access points and preserves the capacity of the arterial to carry large volumes of traffic. Residential Access Standards: When a residential subdivision is proposed that abuts an arterial or major collector roadway, it shall be designed to provide lots abutting the roadway with access only from an interior local road or frontage road. Direct driveway access to individual one and two family dwellings on arterial and collector roadways is prohibited unless the City determines there is no acceptable access alternative. 82 Interconnected Street Systems Requiring developers to provide interior roads on property they subdivide along arterials is an important step in maintaining safety and preserving capacity, but it may not be sufficient. When subdivisions are built adjacent to one another, each with its own access to the arterial, drivers may use the arterial to travel from one subdivision to another, thus contributing to highway congestion. A simple remedy is to require that a subdivision contain connecting points to adjacent, undeveloped land, where feasible, and that adjacent subdivisions inter‐connect. This can reduce traffic on the arterial and help create a sense of community continuity, rather than isolation. As communities grow and land is subdivided for development, it is essential to assure continuation and extension of the existing local street system. Requiring internal vehicle connections will limit the number of times a driver has to enter the arterial when traveling between adjacent businesses. Dead end streets, cul‐de‐sacs and gated communities force more traffic onto collectors and arterials. Fragmented street systems also impede emergency access and increase the number and length of automobile trips. A connected road network advances the following objectives: Fewer vehicle miles traveled Decreased congestion Alternative routes for short, local trips Improved accessibility of developed areas Facilitation of walking, bicycling, and use of transit Reduced demand on major thoroughfares More environmentally sensitive layout of streets and lots Interconnected neighborhoods foster a sense of community Safer and less costly school bus routes Connectivity can be enhanced by a) allowing shorter blocks and excluding cul‐de‐sacs from the definition of intersection; b) requiring stub streets to serve adjacent undeveloped properties; c) requiring street connections to nearby activity centers; d) requiring connections to or continuation of existing or approved public streets; and e) requiring bicycle/pedestrian access‐ways at the end of 83 cul‐de‐sacs or between residential areas and parks, schools, shopping areas or other activity centers. It is also important to allow for a greater variety of street types. Interconnected Street System Standards: Developments shall be interconnected when possible; a variance may be granted only in extreme physical or environmental circumstances. All streets shall not exceed 1500’ in length without intersecting along each side at least one through street. Coordination with Alabama Department of Transportation The Alabama Department of Transportation is responsible for access permits along state and federal routes. The City of Brundidge oversees land use, subdivision and site design decisions that affect access needs. Therefore, State and local coordination is essential to effective access management. Lack of coordination can undermine the effectiveness of regulatory programs and cause unnecessary frustration for permit applicants. Timely communication is key to an effective review procedure, and that begins with a coordinated process for review of access permits along state routes. Applicants should send copies of the complete permit application to the designated local reviewing official and the state permitting official. Prior to any decision or recommendation, the local reviewing official and the state permitting official should discuss the application. Property owners will be required to submit the necessary certificates of approval from other affected regulatory agencies, before a building permit is issued. An effective method of coordinating review and approval between developers and various government agencies is through a tiered process. The first stage is an informal meeting and “concept review” period, which allows officials to advise the developer about information needed to process a development application. This includes information on required state and local permits, and any special considerations for the development site. The concept review provides the developer with early feedback on a proposal, before the preliminary plat or site plan has been drafted. Once the preliminary plan is drafted, it can be checked to determine if additional conditions are required for approval. The final plan that is formally submitted should then require only an administrative review. The City of Brundidge should also request a response from the ALDOT prior to approval of plats on the state highway system. Applicants should be required to send a copy of the subdivision application to the state access permitting official. This shall occur early in the plat review process, preferably during conceptual review. Early monitoring of platting activity would allow the Department of Transportation an opportunity to identify problems and work on acceptable alternatives. Intergovernmental agreements or resolutions can facilitate coordination between the state and local governments on access management. These tools can be used to clarify the purpose and intent of managing access along major thoroughfares, roadways that will receive special attention, and state and local responsibilities for advancing access management objectives. 84 APPENDIX B. OFF STREET TRUCK PARKING FACILITY DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION GUIDELINES The City of Brundidge, in an effort to ensure safe traffic operations for parking facilities developed for off street truck parking, is developing design and construction guidelines. The subsequent sections outline minimum criteria for the design and construction of such facilities. Access Access to any off street parking facility shall be submitted for permitting to the governmental agency responsible for maintaining the roadway where such access is proposed. On any state or federal aid facility, permits shall be obtained from the Alabama Department of Transportation and adhere to their guidelines. Additionally, any access management guidelines adopted by the City of Brundidge for application on their roadways shall also be followed. Parking Facility Layout The layout of a parking lot shall be undertaken by a registered professional engineer, registered in the State of Alabama. The parking facility layout shall be designed in such a manner that it allows adequate dimensions for circulation of design vehicles to occur on the parking facility site. This would include adequate turning radii, driveway aisles, parking stall dimensions, backing distances (if required) and other elements required to ensure all maneuvers associated with truck movements occur on the site of the parking facility. Layouts of proposed parking facilities for trucks will be submitted to the City of Brundidge for review and permitting. Additionally, any zoning requirements of the City for such facilities must be followed. Parking Facility Design The proper construction of off street truck parking facilities is essential to ensure the foundation is correct to handle intended loads presented by truck traffic. To this end any proposed off street parking facility shall be design by a registered professional engineer in the State of Alabama. The following guiding principals shall be followed as a minimum: 1. Subsurface materials used in constructing such facilities shall be of suitable strength and mix to provide adequate support for the design loads as defined by the design vehicle (specified by the design engineer); 2. The parking facility shall be graded in such a manner to avoid storm water runoff on adjacent properties or onto the public roadway in such a manner to cause a hazard. In those circumstances where such grading can not be provided, curb and gutter or other approved methods of detaining storm water on site will be considered; 85 3. An all weather surface will be required on all facilities (such surface shall include asphalt or concrete); and 4. All parking facilities shall be marked in such a manner to reflect parking stalls, access locations and parking aisles (all parking maneuvers required to access and circulate within the off street truck parking facility shall occur off the public right of way). Construction plans for any proposed off street truck parking facility shall be submitted to the City of Brundidge and/or the Alabama Department of Transportation for a permit for construction. Such drawings shall be stamped by a registered professional engineer in the State of Alabama. 86