Velocity Measurements From Gliders
Transcription
Velocity Measurements From Gliders
www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference Ve l o c i t y M e a s u r e m e n t s F r o m Gliders Peter J. Rusello NortekUSA Boston, MA NortekUSA Glider Workshop Ocean Sciences 2012 Wednesday, April 18, 12 M ov i n g P l a t f o r m s www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Moving platforms include: Mooring lines Vertical profilers Towed arrays Gliders AUVs • Profilers are nominally fixed in (x,y) and profile in z. They are subject to mooring line motion (passive motion). • Autonomous underwater vehicles (AUVs) and gliders actively move in (x,y,z) 2 Wednesday, April 18, 12 W h y m ov i n g p l a t f o r m s ? www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Allow high vertical resolution in measurements. • Active motion allows adaptive sampling of regions of interest. • A single instrument can be used to measure along a transect line, act as a virtual mooring, or for Lagrangian tracking of a water mass. • Gliders and AUV’s can be deployed from small vessels and reduce total ship time for equivalent surveys. Nortek Glider ADCP mounted in iRobot 1KA Seaglider 3 Wednesday, April 18, 12 ADCPs Measure Relative Motion www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • A Doppler instrument measures motion relative to the instrument. • Platform motion is implicitly measured. umeasured = ucurrent Um Um uglider Ug Speed over ground A positive platform velocity will appear as a negative measured velocity and vice versa. 4 Wednesday, April 18, 12 M e a n f l ow v e r s u s Tu r b u l e n c e www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • To accurately estimate mean flows, the platform motion must be explicitly removed. • To estimate turbulent fluctuations, the platform motion can be implicitly removed. 5 Wednesday, April 18, 12 A quiescent 2D ocean www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference z x z0 z1 zi Um (zi ) = Ug (z0 ) Wm (zi ) = Wg (z0 ) Ug Wg z2 z3 z4 z5 6 Wednesday, April 18, 12 A 2D ocean with horizontal currents www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference z Um (zi ) = x Ug (z0 ) + Uc (zi ) Wm (zi ) = z0 z1 Ug Wg (z0 ) Uc Wg z2 z3 z4 z5 7 Wednesday, April 18, 12 A 2D ocean with horizontal currents www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference z x Speed over ground Assume the glider follows the water 0 Ug (z0 ) = Ug (z0 ) + Uc (z0 ) Where Ug' is the glider motion in a quiescent ocean z0 Ug Uc Wg Substitute this into the relative motion equation… Wednesday, April 18, 12 8 A 2D ocean with horizontal currents www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference The measured velocity becomes: z x 0 Um (zi ) = Ug (z0 ) typically U 0 (z0 ) g z0 z1 U g' + [Uc (zi ) Uc (z0 )] [Uc (zi ) Uc (z0 )] Uc Wg z2 z3 z4 z5 9 Wednesday, April 18, 12 We h a v e a “ q u i e s c e n t ” 2 D o c e a n www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference z y is into the page Um (zi ) ⇡ x Wm (zi ) ⇡ z0 z1 zi Ug (z0 ) Wg (z0 ) Ug Wg Vg is motion in or out of the page z2 z3 z4 z5 10 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Glider UVW velocities www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference Data from a Rutgers glider off of California 11 Wednesday, April 18, 12 F a c t o r s a f f e c t i n g U g' www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Roll is used to change heading, can easily be +/- 10º. • Pitch changes throughout a dive, leads to changes in forward velocity. • Different behavior when ascending and descending (some of this may be due to the system used). • Drag is dependent on glider Re (O(104-106)). • Drag also dependent on mounted instrumentation and glider orientation to the current. • Leeway is unknown. 12 Wednesday, April 18, 12 G l i d e r F l i g h t Pa t h www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference GPSend Expected end position GPSstart 13 Wednesday, April 18, 12 L e e wa y www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference Leeway 14 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Depth Averaged Currents www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference 159 m 185 m Actual Position - Dead Reckoned Position = Depth Averaged Current Δt 15 Wednesday, April 18, 12 M ov i n g f r o m U g ' t o U g www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Methods of measuring glider speed over ground (Ug): Underwater Positioning Systems Bottom tracking • Methods of estimating or compensating for Ug: Shear profiles Least squares solutions (global problem) Inertial navigation systems / optimal state estimation (local problem) • Each of these methods has advantages and drawbacks. 16 Wednesday, April 18, 12 U n d e r wa t e r P o s i t i o n i n g S y s t e m s www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference Drawbacks include: Increased power requirements, multiple platforms to support multiple transducers, increased material cost, viability for longterm deployments, etc. • Super Short, Short, and Long baseline navigation systems provide positional information by measuring distances between a target and an array of transducers. • Accuracy depends on the array characteristics. 17 Wednesday, April 18, 12 B o t t o m Tr a c k i n g www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Bottom tracking provides an independent measure of the platform velocity over the ground. • Typical glider ADCPs will have a range of 10-50 m, while dives will typically occur over 100-1000 m. • Bottom tracking utility is highly dependent on deployment location. Usually out of range 18 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Iner tial Navigation/Optimal State Estimation www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Inertial navigation systems are routinely used on aircraft and ground robots to estimate the current state (position, attitude, velocity) of a body. • INS is subject to integration errors, i.e. cumulative error since the last known position. • Optimal state estimation is the statistical treatment of data to forecast the future state of a system (e.g. Kalman filtering). • Kalman filtering is implemented already in most glider mission planning. It’s use here is one a finer scale and would incorporate more data. 19 Wednesday, April 18, 12 L ow e r e d A D C P M e t h o d s www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Shear Method Implicitly removes platform motion by differentiating velocity profiles. Platform motion during an individual measurement is assumed constant. • Least squares solutions (Inverse Method) Solve a set of linear equations representing the observations to determine the unknown platform and water velocities. To ensure non-trivial solutions, external constraints are needed. 20 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Shear Method www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • The platform motion is assumed constant during an individual velocity profile. • Individual velocity profiles are differentiated to produce a composite shear profile. • There is an unknown integration constant. • Two surface GPS fixes can be used to determine the integration constant. • This method is sensitive to integration errors. Firing, E., & Gordon, R. L. (1990). Deep ocean acoustic Doppler current profiling. In Proc. IEEE Fourth Working Conf. on Current Measurements (pp. 192–201). Fischer, J., & Visbeck, M. (1993). Deep velocity profiling with self-contained ADCP's. Journal Of Atmospheric And Oceanic Technology, 10(5), 764–773. 21 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Least Squares Solutions www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference umeasured = ucurrent uglider zi zg Measurements Desired uc(z) Profile • Describe the measurements as a system of equations. • This system will be over- or under-determined depending on how the measurements are treated. • The system is solved in a least squares sense for uc(z) and ug(z). Visbeck, M. (2002). Deep Velocity Profiling Using Lowered Acoustic Doppler Current Profilers: Bottom Track and Inverse Solutions*. Journal Of Atmospheric And Oceanic Technology. Wednesday, April 18, 12 22 www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference 23 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Glider Coordinates www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference z x Xg zg 24 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Glider XYZ velocities www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference X Y Z Glider Y velocity is near zero 25 Wednesday, April 18, 12 www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference 26 Wednesday, April 18, 12 www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference Acoustic Backscatter Wednesday, April 18, 12 A no cost data stream www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Many gliders incorporate an echo sounder for both range and backscatter measurements. • An ADCP provides similar data at no additional cost in power with velocity measurements. Echosounder ADCP 28 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Nor tek Glider ADCP www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • 1 Mhz transmit frequency • Small, power efficient design • 0.25-2 m range cells (typical) • 30 m maximum range With apologies to Pepsi… 29 Wednesday, April 18, 12 Acoustic scattering www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference • Maximum sensitivity occurs at ka = 1, where k is acoustic wavenumber and a is particle radius. • For 1 MHz this occurs at 2a = 475 μm • Many zooplankton will fall within a reasonable range of this peak value. • Suspended sediment will typically be smaller than this peak value. Wednesday, April 18, 12 30 Example Data from Antarctica cour tesy Rutgers University www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference 31 Wednesday, April 18, 12 www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference 32 Wednesday, April 18, 12 www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference 33 Wednesday, April 18, 12 www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference 34 Wednesday, April 18, 12 www.nortekusa.com True innovation makes a difference 35 Wednesday, April 18, 12