Hotels: The Terrorist Soft Target of the Future?

Hotels: The Terrorist Soft Target of the Future?

Hotels: The Terrorist Soft Target
of the Future?
Andy Williams : Temi Group
Hotel Attacks from 1999
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
1999/03, La Paz – Bolivia, Radisson Hotel, bombs (one defused);
1999/04, Athens – Greece, Intercontinental Hotel, bomb, 1 death – 1 injured;
1999/04, Moscow – Russia, Intourist Hotel, bomb, 11 injured;
2000/02, Puerto Asís - Colombia, Hotel Quirama, car bomb, 2 deaths - 4 injured;
2000/02, Irvinestown - Northern Ireland, Mahon's Hotel, explosive device, none injured;
2000/04, Rawalpindi - Pakistan, Hotel in Raja Bazaar area, bomb, 5 injured;
2000/06, Calì – Colombia, Intercontinental Hotel, car bomb (defused), none injured;
2000/11, Barcelona - Spain, Hilton Hotel, car bomb, 2 injured;
2001/05, Cali - Colombia, Hotel Torre de Cali, car bomb, 4 deaths – 32 injured;
2001/12, Jerusalem – Israel, Metzudat David Hotel, suicide bomber, 1 death – 5 injured;
2002/03, Samaria – Israel, Hotel in Ariel, suicide bomber, 15 injured;
2002/03, Netanya – Israel, Park Hotel, suicide bomber, 30 deaths - 140 injured;
2002/04, Kabul – Afghanistan, Intercontinental Hotel, bombing attempt;
2002/05, Karachi – Pakistan, Sheraton Hotel, car bomber,14 deaths – 23 injured;
2002/05, Istanbul – Turkey, Ritz-Carlton and Ceylan Intercontinental Hotel, bombs, none
injured;
2002/07, Tbilisi – Georgia, Marriott Hotel, explosive device (deactivated), none injured;
2002/11, Mombasa – Kenya, Paradise Hotel Mombasa, car bomber, 13 deaths - 80 injured;
2002/12, Bogota – Colombia, Intercontinental Tequendama Hotel, package bomb, 32 injured;
2003/01, Quito – Ecuador, Hilton Colon Hotel, bombs, 1 injured;
2003/05, Casablanca – Marocco, Farah Maghreb Hotel, suicide bomber, 2 deaths;
2003/08, Baghdad – Iraq, Canal Hotel / UN Headquarters, truck bomber, 23 deaths – 100 injured
2003/08, Jakarta – Indonesia, Marriot Hotel, car bomber, 12 deaths – 150 injured;
2004/03, Tessenei - Eritrea, Hashferai Hotel, explosive devices, 3 deaths – 12 injured;
2004/03, Baghdad – Iraq, Mount Lebanon Hotel, car bomb, 7 deaths – 35 injured;
2004/05, Riyhad – Saudi Arabia, Oasis Residential Resorts, armed attack, 9 deaths;
2004/05, Pahalgam – Kashmir, India, Purnima Hotel, grenade attack, 4 deaths – 28 injured;
2004/05, Baghdad – Iraq, Four Seasons Hotel, bomb, 6 injured;
2004/06, Ankara - Turkey, Hilton Hotel, explosive device, 2 injured;
2004/07, Baghdad – Iraq, Al-Sadeer Hotel, mortar attack, 1 killed - 3 injured;
2004/08, Taltala - Bangladesh, Hotel Gulshan, car bomb, 25 injured,
2004/08, Basra – Iraq, Buraq Hotel, car bomb, 2 killed – 2 injured;
2004/08, Yala – Thailand, My House Hotel / Japan Karaoke Restaurant, explosive device, 9
injured;
2004/09, He’rat province – Afghanistan, Bahar-e-Azadi Hotel, bomb, none injured;
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
2004/10, Taba - Egypt, Hilton Hotel, car bomb, 34 deaths – 159 injured;
2004/10, Islamabad – Pakistan, Marriott Hotel, explosive device, 9 injured;
2004/10, Baghdad – Iraq, Ishtar Sheraton Hotel, rockets attack, none injured;
2004/12, Guwahati – India, Hotel in Paltan Bazaar area, grenade attack, 1 death – 11 injured;
2005/02, Sungai Kolok – Thailand, Marina Hotel, car bomb, 7 deaths – 40 injured;
2005/04, Songkhla – Thailand, Green World Hotel, bomb, none injured;
2005/07 Sharm el-Sheikh – Egypt, Ghazala Gardens and Moevenpick Hotels, car bombs and
suitcase bomb, 62 deaths - 116 injured;
2005/08, Dhaka – Bangladesh, Sheraton Hotel, bomb, none injured;
2005/10, Baghdad – Iraq, Palestine and Ishtar Sheraton Hotels, car bombs, 20 deaths – 40
injured;
2005/11, Amman – Jordan, Grand Hyatt, Radisson SAS and Days Inn Hotels, suicide bombers, 60
deaths - 110 injured;
2007/01, Islamabad – Pakistan, Marriott Hotel, suicide bomber, 2 deaths;
2007/03, Trinidad-Tobago, Hilton Hotel, tear gas attack, 9 injured;
2007/08, Mogadishu - Somalia, Lafwen and Medina Hotels, hand grenade attacks, 3 injured;
2007/07, Nairobi – Kenya, Ambassador Hotel, bomb, 1 death - 37 injured;
2008/01, Kabul – Afghanistan, Serena Hotel, suicide attack, 6 deaths;
2008/05, Ngele Boran – Ethiopia, Kidane Mihret and Shuferoch Hotels, bombs, 3 deaths – 3
injured;
2008/08, Bouira – Algeria, Hotel Sophie, bomb, 12 deaths – 15 injured;
2008/09, Islamabad – Pakistan, Marriot Hotel, truck bomber, 60 deaths – 250 injured;
2008/10, Neiva – Colombia, Plaza and Sulicam Hotels, bombs, 1 death – 7 injured;
2008/11, Mumbai – India, Taj Mahl and Oberoi Trident Hotels, armed attack, 173 deaths – 308
injured (hotela + other attacked places).
•
2009/07 Jakarta Marriott Ritz Carlton
•
•
•
•
2010
2011
2012
2013
??????????????
??????????????
??????????????
??????????????
© 2012 Temi Group
Nuri Checks In
17 July 2009 at 7:45 am
Nuri walking towards the lounge
Device found in room #1808 - JW Marriott Hotel
Bomber walking toward Airlangga restaurant
OPTICS STRATEGY
•
•
•
•
•
•
Operational
Physical
Technical
Intelligence
Communication
Safety
Traditional Facility Security
Rings of Security
• Physical:
Construction/Barriers
• Technical /Procedural:
Guards & Guns
Procedures & Devices
© 2012 Temi Group
IP1
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
CARVER
• Criticality
• Vulnerability
Primary consideration of
strategic impact
Means and expertise to
expose weakness
• Accessibility
• Effect
How observe – remain
undetected – decamp
Desired damage
• Recuperability
How long target takes to
repair/replace
• Recognizability
How distinguishable –
iconic – critical damage
points
Carver Matrix-Strategic
Target
Strategic
C
A
R
V
E
R
Total
Air Transport
1
1
3
1
2
2
10
Ports and
waterways
1
1
3
1
1
1
8
Hotels
5
3
5
3
5
5
26*
Embassies
Gov Buildings
5
2
2
2
5
5
Fast Food
Chains
3
5
3
5
3
5
24
Carver Matrix-Operational
Target
Operational
C
A
R
V
E
R
Total
Oriental Hotel
4
3
5
3
4
5
24
Conrad Hotel
4
3
5
4
4
5
25
Nana Hotel
3
4
4
4
3
3
21
JW Marriott
4
3
5
3
5
5
26*
Carver Matrix-Tactical
Target
Tactical
C
A
R
V
E
R
Total
Conference
room
5
5
5
5
5
5
30*
Vehicle
check point
5
4
3
3
2
5
22
lobby
5
2
5
2
3
5
22
Footprint
area
5
5
5
5
5
5
30*
Water intake
3
1
1
1
5
4
12
Air intake
2
1
1
1
5
1
11
Fuel supply
3
1
4
3
5
4
20
Krungthai
Bank
KFC
Pleonchit Rd.
E
X
P
R
E
S
S
W
A
Y
D
U
A
N
G
P
I
T
A
K
R
D
.
Nana square
Sukhumvit Rd.
S
O
I
S
GasO
I
Station
Pleonchit
Center2
Hotel
Nana
Majestic
Hotel
N
A
N
Hotel
A
Landmark
Hotel
Raja Hotel
Tobacco
Factory
.
RAMA VI RD.
Queen Sirikit
Convention
Hall
Krungthai
Bank
KFC
Pleonchit Rd.
E
X
P
R
E
S
S
W
A
Y
D
U
A
N
G
P
I
T
A
K
R
D
.
Nana square
Sukhumvit Rd.
S
O
I
S
GasO
I
Station
Pleonchit
Center2
Hotel
Nana
Majestic
Hotel
N
A
N
Hotel
A
Landmark
Hotel
Raja Hotel
Tobacco
Factory
.
RAMA VI RD.
Queen Sirikit
Convention
Hall
Krungthai
Bank
KFC
Pleonchit Rd.
E
X
P
R
E
S
S
W
A
Y
D
U
A
N
G
P
I
T
A
K
R
D
.
Nana square
Sukhumvit Rd.
S
O
I
S
GasO
I
Station
Pleonchit
Center2
Hotel
Nana
Majestic
Hotel
N
A
N
Hotel
A
Landmark
Hotel
Raja Hotel
Tobacco
Factory
.
RAMA VI RD.
Queen Sirikit
Convention
Hall
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
© 2012 Temi Group
Thank You
[email protected]
© 2013 Temi Group