Individual Blade Control
Transcription
Individual Blade Control
Die Flugsteuerung des Hubschraubers von den Grundlagen bis zur Einzelblattsteuerung Dr. Oliver Oliver Kunze Kunze Dr. Produktentwicklung LX LX-E Produktentwicklung -E ZF Luftfahrttechnik Luftfahrttechnik GmbH GmbH ZF Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Praxis -Seminar Luftfahrt Fachhochschule Hamburg Hamburg Fachhochschule Hamburg, d. d. 28.10.2004 28.10.2004 Hamburg, Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 1 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Flight Control – from primary to individual blade control z Overview z History / Configuration and Performance of a Helicopter z Main Rotor / Main Rotor Control Design z Problems of the Main Rotor z z z Aerodynamics Vibrations Noise z Individual Blade Control (IBC) z z z Principle of Operation Effects in Wind Tunnel and Flight Tests IBC System Design z Conclusion and Outlook Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 2 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Flight Control – from primary to individual blade control z Overview z History / Configuration and Performance of a Helicopter z Main Rotor / Main Rotor Control Design z Problems of the Main Rotor z z z Aerodynamics Vibrations Noise z Individual Blade Control (IBC) z z z Principle of Operation Effects in Wind Tunnel and Flight Tests IBC System Design z Conclusion and Outlook Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 3 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Comparison of 1930 Aircraft Maturity, Helicopter vs. Fixed Wing Do X giant seaplane: MTOW: 48to Distance: 2800km Endurance: 14h Helicopter by C. d’Ascanio: Altitude: 18m Distance: 1078m Endurance: 8:45min Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 4 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Standard Configuration Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 5 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Lockheed AH-56A Cheyenne Compound Aircraft Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 6 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Tiltrotor Aircraft Bell/Boeing V-22 Osprey Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 7 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Relative Power Required vs. Forward Speed 400 Helicopter Compound P/m [kW/to] 300 Tilt-Rotor Airplane 200 100 0 0 50 100 150 200 V [m/s] Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 8 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Velocity Distribution over Rotor Disk (Advanced Ratio µ = ΩR / V) Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 9 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Flight Control – from primary to individual blade control z Overview z History / Configuration and Performance of a Helicopter z Main Rotor / Main Rotor Control Design z Problems of the Main Rotor z z z Aerodynamics Vibrations Noise z Individual Blade Control (IBC) z z z Principle of Operation Effects in Wind Tunnel and Flight Tests IBC System Design z Conclusion and Outlook Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 10 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Rotor Blade Lift and Flap Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 11 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Blade Control System Using a Conventional Swashplate Arrangement +ϑ -ϑ Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 12 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Angle-of-Attack Distribution in Forward Flight Level Flight Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 13 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Main Rotor Control System Eurocopter (MBB) BO105 Pitch Horn Taumelscheibe Steuerstange Primärsteuer, stehend Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 14 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Conventional Mechanical Primary Control System Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 15 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Main Rotor Sikorsky CH-53G Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 16 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Main Rotor Sikorsky CH-53G Pitch Horn Taumelscheibe Steuerstange (hier IBC-Aktuator) Primärsteuer Booster stehende Schere Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 17 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Main Rotor Control with Spider Westland Sea Lynx MK88 Hub Pitch Control Rod Spider Arm Gimbal Joint Spindle Roller Bearings Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 18 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH NHI NH-90 Î Erstflug: 18. Dezember 1995 Î Quadruplex fly-by-wire Steuerung Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 19 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Main Rotor Design – 1950/60s AEROSPATIALE AS 341 Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 20 Sikorsky S-58 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Main Rotor Design – Bell 412 Virtual Flap Hinge Lag Hinge Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 21 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Damper and Feather Bearing Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Flight Control – from primary to individual blade control z Overview z History / Configuration and Performance of a Helicopter z Main Rotor / Main Rotor Control Design z Problems of the Main Rotor z z z Aerodynamics Vibrations Noise z Individual Blade Control (IBC) z z z Principle of Operation Effects in Wind Tunnel and Flight Tests IBC System Design z Conclusion and Outlook Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 22 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Limiting Phenomena Encountered by a Helicopter Rotor in Forward Flight Rotor Wake Interferences Dynamic Stall Due to Blade Vortex Interaction Mach Number Effects Yawed Flow High Angles of Attack Reversed Flow Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 23 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Vibrations: Source ⇒ Flexible Structure ⇒ Reaction Periodic and Impulsive Blade Loads Flexible Blade Coupled Eigenmodes Flexible Rotor/ Body Load Paths Structural Modes Rigid Body Motions Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 24 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Vibration Levels of 6 Different Helicopter Types (BO-105 4- and 5-Bladed, CH-53G Aluminium and IRB Blades, Tiger, UH-60) nBl/rev Vibration at Pilot Seat [g] 0.5 0.4 0.3 MIL-H-8501A (1962) 0.2 0.1 0.0 0.00 NASA Recommendation 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 Advance Ratio Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 25 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Passive Vibration Absorber and Isolation Systems Cabin Structure Flapping Mass Flexible Leaf Pendulum Absorber Cabin Absorber Bifilar Absorber Antiresonance Isolation System Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 26 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Nodal Beam Isolation System Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH BVI-Noise Generating Mechanism Air Flow Modified Vortex Strength ψ = 90° Reduced Pitch during BVI ψ = 0° Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 27 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Example of Helicopter Rotor Sound Spectrum (l.h.s.) and Average Time History (r.h.s.) Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 28 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Flight Control – from primary to individual blade control z Overview z History / Configuration and Performance of a Helicopter z Main Rotor / Main Rotor Control Design z Problems of the Main Rotor z z z Aerodynamics Vibrations Noise z Individual Blade Control (IBC) z z z Principle of Operation Effects in Wind Tunnel and Flight Tests IBC System Design z Conclusion and Outlook Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 29 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Individual Blade Control through Blade Root or Trailing Edge Flap Actuation Blade Root Actuator Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 30 Electrically Driven Trailing Edge (Servo) Flap Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Individual Blade Control through Blade Twist or Trailing Edge Flap Actuation Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 31 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH IBC Blade Pitch Control with higher harmonic blade pitch movements IBC Blade Pitch Movement characterization: 12 10 with IBC • frequency (2 .. 7 ΩRotor) B la d e P itc h [°] 8 •amplitude (0..3..6°) 6 • phase (0..360°) 4 primary control 2 0 0 45 90 135 180 225 270 315 360 Rotor Head Azimuth Angle [°] Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 32 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Resultant Angle of Attack αres at Blade Radial Station r/R = 0.7 [Deg.] Modification of Local Angle of Attack through IBC 15 x Ω with IBC - Baseline r ψ 10 ++ y + 5 + - 0 0 90 180 270 360 Rotor Azimut Angle ψ [Deg.] Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 33 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Principle Layout of IBC System BLADE-ROOT IBC PITCH ACTUATORS HYDRAULIC DISTRIBUTION CONVENTIONAL FLIGHT CONTROL SYSTEM FEEDBACK SIGNALS CONTROL PANEL HYDRAULIC POWER PICK-UP DIGITAL COMPUTER A HYDRAULIC MANIFOLD, MONITORING AND SHUT-OFF B ELEC. & HYDRAUL. ROTARY TRANSMISSION Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 34 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt IBC POSITION COMMANDS Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH IBC Actuator Mounted between Swashplate and Blade Pitch Horn Replacing the Rigid Pitch Rod Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 35 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Full Scale UH-60 Rotor Wind Tunnel Tests conducted at NASA Ames Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 36 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH IBC Inputs and Test Conditions Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 37 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Large Wind Tunnel at NASA Ames Research Center Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 38 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Testbed BO-105 S1 with IBC System Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 39 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH IBC Testbed CH-53G 84+02 Operated by WTD 61 Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 40 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Dynamic Components with IBC Mock-Up Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 41 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH IBC Data Processing and Control Computer (ZFL) and Data Gathering System (WTD 61) Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 42 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Effect of 0.15deg 5/rev IBC on 6/rev Accelerations at Main Gear Box and Pilot Seat @120kts y x z MGB x y z Pilot Seat Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 43 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Effect of 0.15deg 5/rev IBC on z-Vibration Spectrum at Pilot Seat @120kts without IBC with IBC Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 44 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH C.L. Test Sequence @70kts, Single Mode 5/rev IBC Controlled Variable: 6/rev AccPilz CL ref OL Phase Sweep ref ref ref 90% Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 45 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Predicted Multi Harmonic Vibration Reduction at Main Gear Box Based on Single Harmonic Flight Test Data (0.15deg IBC at 90kts) G(AccHGx,AccHGy,AccHGz) Vibration Reduction [%] 100 Numerically Predicted 6/rev Vibration Reduction at Main Gear Box (All Three Axes) Due to Different IBC Frequency Combinations 80 60 40 20 0 6/rev 4, 6/rev 4, 6, 7/rev 4, 5, 6, 7/rev Required Amplitudes [deg] 0.35 0.30 Corresponding Amplitudes Required 0.25 0.20 0.15 0.10 0.05 0.00 6/rev Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 46 4, 6/rev 4, 6, 7/rev 4, 5, 6, 7/rev Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Non-corrected Sound Pressure Level [dB] Noise Reduction Due to 2/rev 0.66deg IBC at Three Microphones (65kts, -6deg, Optimum IBC Phase) 103 100 97 94 91 88 85 103 100 97 94 91 88 85 VIAS = 65kts, γ = -6° Mic #1 (Center) Mic #2 (Retr. Side) 103 100 Mic #3 (Adv. Side) 97 94 91 88 85 -10 -8 -6 -4 Reference, no IBC A2 = 0.67°, ϕ2 = 30° -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 Time [sec] (t=0 at moment of highest sound pressure level) Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 47 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Flight Performance Relevant Parameters During 2/rev IBC Phase Sweep Altitude [ft] VIAS [kts] Power Q·Ω [kW] Level Flight VIAS = 125kts, A2 = 0.67° 2600 w/o IBC ϕ2 = 0° = 60° = 120° = 180° = 240° = 300° = 359° 2500 2400 2300 135 130 125 120 4500 16 Revs ≈ 5 sec 4000 3500 #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 #7 #8 Data Points Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 48 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Effect of 2/rev 0.66deg IBC on Power Required (125kts, Net Effect, Corrected by Speed, Accel. and Heave Effects) 15.00 ∆ P [%] (corrected) More Power Required 10.00 5.00 0.00 -5.00 -10.00 Less Power Required -15.00 0 60 120 180 240 300 360 IBC Phase Angle ϕ 2 [°] Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 49 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Reduction of Pitch Link / Actuator Load by Application of Optimum Phase 2/rev IBC (A2 = 0.66° ϕ2 = 270°) Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 50 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Flight Control – from primary to individual blade control z Overview z History / Configuration and Performance of a Helicopter z Main Rotor / Main Rotor Control Design z Problems of the Main Rotor z z z Aerodynamics Vibrations Noise z Individual Blade Control (IBC) z z z Principle of Operation Effects in Wind Tunnel and Flight Tests IBC System Design z Conclusion and Outlook Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 51 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Integration of IBC-System into CH-53G Testbed Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 52 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH ZFL´s IBC Actuator Evolution BO 105 WT/T BO 105 F/T TSS CH-53G F/T UH-60A WT/T Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 53 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH CH-53G IBC Experimental System Actuator Design Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 54 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH IDS IBC DC test bench with reversed kinematics non rotating ↔ rotating hydraulic manifold 4 IBC actuators IBC DC pump pump control unit in drive cage torque/speed sensor 11 kW electrical drive electrical slip ring Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 55 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Adaptation of Existing IDS to Lynx Rotor Hub Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 56 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH InHuS: Innovative Integrated Primary and Individual Blade Control System for Helicopters IDS: Integration of Both Primary Control and IBC into Gearbox/Rotorhub InHuS: Control System in the Rotating Frame at Blade Root, Combining Both Primary Control and IBC Using One Actuation System IBC: Hydraulic and Electrical Individual Blade Control Systems with High Bandwidth but Low Authority Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 57 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH InHuS: Innovative Integrated Primary and Individual Blade Control System for Helicopters (preliminary design) Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 58 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Helicopter Flight Control – from primary to individual blade control z Overview z History / Configuration and Performance of a Helicopter z Main Rotor / Main Rotor Control Design z Problems of the Main Rotor z z z Aerodynamics Vibrations Noise z Individual Blade Control (IBC) z z z Principle of Operation Effects in Wind Tunnel and Flight Tests IBC System Design z Conclusion and Outlook Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 59 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH Conclusion z Helicopter versatile aircraft z Complex aerodynamics of main rotor in forward flight causes performance restrictions z advanced main rotor blade control can reduce vibation & noise and extend flight envelope z extensive research work on IBC effects has been done z world-wide development activites of the helicopter industry in the field of application to production helicopters Ku LX-E 28.10.04 Slide 60 Praxis-Seminar Luftfahrt Proprietary Information ZFLuftfahrtechnik GmbH