Basic Microphone Knowledge
Transcription
Basic Microphone Knowledge
Knowledge: Microphones 1 Knowledge Microphones (What Every Musician Needs to Know) The microphone is the first element in the audio chain, and in many respects it is the most important. Without a good quality microphone, you can't create an acceptable recording no matter how good the other elements are. The first advice you'll hear from any professional about purchasing sound or recording equipment is "invest in good microphones."(1) This chapter deals with some of the basic concepts all musicians need to know about microphones in order to select and use them effectively. It covers: Microphone construction Types of microphones Directionality and pickup patterns How characteristics are compared © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media 2 Digital Music Production Microphone Classification A microphone is a transducer (2), that means itʼs a device that converts one form of energy into another(3). A microphone converts mechanical energy (traveling waves of compression and rarefaction in a medium like air) into electrical energy (similar waves of high or low electrical pressure.(4) It doesn't measure pressure changes, it simply converts them. Therefore it's basically an Diaphragm analog device even if it's in an all digital audio system. 1 (5) Capsule Diaphragm All microphones have certain parts in common, a capsule containing a thin diaphragm that moves with the pressure changes of a soundwave and changes them into voltage changes, circuits and/or wiring that either boost or simply transfer the voltage changes to the cable port, and a housing that encloses everything in a form best suited to the requirements of the user.(6) These common parts allow for many variations in construction-- both in design and in quality. All of these varieties lend unique colorations to the sound they record and make specific mics better for certain uses than others. Capsule Housing Housing Wiring Wiring Circuits Dynamic mic Condenser mic In spite of their many varieties in construction, we can separate microphones into two broad classes: dynamic and condenser.(7) Each of these classes contains several different designs and numerous variations of those designs. Dynamic Mics Dynamic microphones work by vibrating metal in a magnetic field. In the classic moving coil design, a thin diaphragm is attached to a coil of wire surrounding-- or surrounded by-- a high powered permanent magnet. Any movement of the diaphragm in response to sound waves moves the coil in the magnetic field and this in turn generates small changes in electrical pressure--voltage. The physical principle behind this process is known as electromagnetic induction.(8) Diaphragm Wire coil Permanent Magnet Dynamic Mic Capsule 1 Well, o.k., a point of clarification: The recently developed USB mic (the kind that attaches directly to your computerʼs USB port) contains an analog to digital processor that converts the fluctuating voltage of the mic into numerical measurements. So what comes out of the cable port actually is digital. Nevertheless the working part of any USB mic is identical to a traditional mic, © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media Knowledge: Microphones 3 As you might imagine, there are many factors that can come into play in designing a moving coil mic. One example: The more windings in the coil, the more current will be generated and so the more sensitive the mic will be. But more windings also means more metal, which means more mass and inertia, which means slower response to initial sound transients (how quickly the sound reaches full volume) and less responsiveness to high frequency sounds. (9) Popular Dynamic Mics Shure SM57 Shure SM58 Electro-Voice RE-20 Overall, moving coil mics are good all-purpose microphones. They are simple, cheap, and rugged, which makes them particularly good for field work and for hand held applications.(10) They also make good voice mics and are great for sound reinforcement. They usually have smooth response curves and higher headroom which means they can be used for louder sound levels of drums and other loud instruments.(11) On the other hand they lack fast attack response and high frequency response. Moving coil mics are very popular-- probably the first ones a person will purchase for recording and general sound reinforcement. The most common microphone in use today is a moving coil mic, the Shure SM58 shown above.(12) Another design that works on the principle of electromagnetic induction is the ribbon microphone. Less common than the moving coil type, it relies on a very light ribbon of metal-- usually corrugated-- suspended in the powerful magnetic field. (13) Since ribbons have a lot less mass than a coil of wire, they usually have better transient response and are better able to reproduce high frequencies. However the thinness of the ribbon makes them fragile-definitely not for outdoor use or even for the high SPL of drums even if in a controlled environment. In a studio they can be very effective for voice and most instruments. They produce a sound very close to the original-- in other words not colored by the microphone design. This lack of sonic coloration is often called "transparent" or "open." (14) Magnet Metal Foil Ribbon Some Ribbon Mics Nady RSM-4 Beyer M160 Nady RSM-2 © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media RCA 44BX 4 Digital Music Production Condenser Mics Charged Diaphragm Condenser microphones work on a different principle from dynamics. Itʼs called electro-static induction. If two oppositely charged plates are moved closer or farther apart, they will output a change in voltage. Itʼs the same principle as that used in electronic capacitors. Condenser mics usually have a very thin diaphragm coated with vapor deposited metal film (sometimes "gold-sputtered"). This is held very close to an oppositely charged metal plate. The surfaces can be anywhere from 1/4" in “small diaphragm” condensers to well over an inch in diameter in so-called "large diaphragm" models.(16) Charged Plate Small Diaphragm Condenser Capsule Popular Condenser Mics Shure SM-81 (small diaphragm) Shure KSM27 (large diaphragm) Neumann KM 184 (small diaphragm) The electrical charge on most professional level condenser mics is supplied by Phantom Power, a direct current voltage that is applied through the same mic cable that carries the alternating current voltage of the audio signal. Phantom power's unvarying pressure is usually 48 volts.(17) Less expensive condenser mics may get their voltage from internal batteries. A few even have permanently charged plate and diaphragm. These are called electret mics. The audio signalʼs voltage fluctuations coming off a condenser mic's capsule are very weak-- about a millionth of a volt-- and thus have to be pre-amplified even before they reach the normal microphone preamplifier . In spite of the condenser's weaker original signal, this pre-pre-amplification usually yields a hotter signal than a dynamic mic out of the micʼs cable. Another attribute: the condenser's thin diaphragm without any attached metal coil allows the condenser mic to respond well to fast attacks and to high frequencies.(18) Condenser mics are becoming increasingly popular for general recording. The ones shown above are common examples of this type of mic.(19) © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media Knowledge: Microphones 5 An interesting variation of the condenser type is the boundary mic. Operating on the same electro-static principle, it features a small diaphragm/plate capsule held very close to a solid plate of metal or other heavy material. This proximity-- usually about an eighth of an inch-- effectively eliminates out-of-phase wave patterns and thus produces a hotter signal through simple acoustic principles.(20) Boundary mics are quite sensitive to signals from any direction in front of the plate and reproduce high frequency signals well.(21) They are often used as conference microphones because of their hemispherical pickup pattern. The original design of the boundary microphone was patented by Crown in the mid '70's. It is often referred to as PZM for Pressure Zone Microphone.(22) Other Mics There are a few other types of microphones that work on different electrical principles, but they are not used much in professional audio settings. They are the piezo-electric design in which the moving diaphragm twists a quartz crystal producing a small voltage change, and the carbon granule design that works on varying electrical resistance. Carbon granule mic capsules were common on early telephones.(23) Piezo-Electric Mic Carbon Granule Mic © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media 6 Digital Music Production Cables Microphone cables are important to the overall quality of a recording. Inexpensive "consumer level" mics often use an unbalanced line cable like the one shown at right. Electrically, this is the simplest 2 wire loop that is essential for any electrical transmission to occur. This type of line uses a 1/4" or 1/8" tip-ring Phone connector on the far end of the cord.(24) If the length of the cord is less than 20 feet, unbalanced cables usually work fine; however, longer lengths risk corrupting the audio signal with inducted noise interference from any number of sources such as radio stations, ac power lines, and florescent lights.(25) The solution to this inducted noise problem is the balanced line cable which is now common on all professional level microphones. This cable uses 3 wires. Two of these wires carry mirror image audio signals, one of which is flipped over at the end of the cable. If any interference is added through the cable's length, it becomes a mirror image of itself when one of the audio signals is flipped. Since mirror image signals cancel each other out the noise is eliminated.(26) These cables usually use a 3 prong XLR connector at their far ends (sometimes called a cannon connector). Balanced cables can exceed 200 feet without risking noticeable inducted noise.(27) Pickup Patterns Microphones come in a variety of pickup patterns. In other words their sensitivity varies depending on the direction of the sound source. Common patterns are Omnidirectional, Cardioid (sometimes mistakenly labeled unidirectional),and bidirectional or figure 8.(28) These patterns are controlled by the overall microphone design and sometimes by the addition of baffles or vents at the sides of the microphone housing. Pickup pattern often may be the most important characteristic for matching a mic to a job. The ElectroVoice RE20 shown at right is an excellent example of a mic that uses baffles in its housing to help reject off-axis sounds. This makes its pickup pattern more directional © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media Knowledge: Microphones Omnidirectional 7 Hypercardioid Cardioid BiPolar (figure 8) The most common pickup pattern is the Cardioid. (29) It is most sensitive when pointed directly at the sound source and less so when pointed off-axis. Sound coming from in back of the mic is rejected to a large extent. Most condenser and dynamic mics use cardioid patterns. More expensive condenser mics often feature a switch that allows the user to select among several different Cardioid pattern variations or an Omni pattern. The Omni pattern is useful in situations where the recording engineer wants to capture sounds from all directions--the ambience of the hall perhaps, or a large number of sound sources equally. Omni mics are also a good choice for close voice micing because they tend to eliminate the boomy, bassy proximity effect. that cardioid mics exhibit when used too close(30) The AKG C 414 B-XL II Condenser Microphone features five selectable polar patterns Hypercardioid designs feature more rejection of off-axis sounds, however this side rejection usually comes at the expense of a little more sensitivity to sounds originating from behind the mic. The pattern is a kind of an unequal figure 8 design. If the sensitivity of both front and back becomes equal, then the pattern is bi-directional of figure 8.. (31) The ribbon mic is a good example of a true figure-8 design because sound can enter the ribbon element equally whether it comes from in front or in back.(32) This pattern can be useful for recording dialog or instruments placed facing each other as in a duet. In addition to the cardioid, omni, and hypercardioid patterns, more extreme patterns exist for special purposes. Shotgun mic extensions reject a great deal of off axis sound through baffles, but they do so at the expense of frequency response and overall sensitivity.(33) © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media 8 Digital Music Production Other Characteristics 1. Although pickup pattern is probably the number one characteristic for matching a mic to an application, several other factors can also be useful in describing suitability. You should be aware that changing any single characteristic tends to affect the others, so be wary of over-emphasizing the importance of any single factor without considering the others. The characteristics include: 2. Sensitivity. For recording quiet sounds or sounds at a distance, a more sensitive mic is needed. In general a sensitivity rating of -50 dB would be more sensitive than a rating of -60 dB, but this rather simplistic comparison is confounded by the many different rating scales manufacturers use and by the fact that raising sensitivity also tends to raise the mic's electronic noise level. Large diaphragm condenser mics tend to be more sensitive than moving coil mics. PZM condensers add even more sensitivity because they reject interfering sound waves. But be realistic; not every application requires the most sensitive mic.(34) 3. Frequency response. Even the cheapest Radio Shack mic often boasts a frequency response of 20 - 20,000 Hz. However, though technically true, this kind of information is simplistic and very misleading. Truer data is shown by a frequency response graph which indicates how much deviation in sensitivity the mic exhibits at various frequencies. Supposedly, perfection would be indicated by a flat line from 20 to 20,000 Hz, but in reality this is unachievable and maybe not even desirable. The industry standard for acceptability allows + or - 3 dB from this theoretical flat line and even for high end microphones this occurs only between frequencies of 40 Hz and 17,000 Hz.(37) Often mics are chosen because of their deviation from flat line-- for example a more sensitive high end for capturing a sound's brilliance. The typical Frequency Response graph below is for a Shure SM58. 4. Self-noise. Mics-- especially condenser mics with active pre-amplifiers built into them-- generate their own electronic noise. This can be minimized by using high quality components and good design, but usually the more sensitive a mic is, the more noise it will produce. In comparing mics, lower dB numbers in this categorygenerally mean lower noise, but this like other numbers can be deceptive.(40) Since human ears are most sensitive to sounds of between 1000 and 5000 Hz, a mic's self-noise at other frequencies is not sonically as important. Because of this, the most accurate rating for a mic's self-noise is usually stated in dBA, a decibel scale weighted by how the human ear responds. Think of dBA's as similar to the "wind-chill" factor often given in weather reports. (41) © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media Knowledge: Microphones 9 5. Transient response. Sounds that have fast attacks can have their sound dulled by inappropriate mic choice. Small diaphragm condenser mics usually offer the best attack response to instruments like orchestra bells, triangles, and xylophones.(36) 6. 3. Maximum SPL. Drums and close miking techniques for loud instruments require a mic that doesn't distort when sound pressure levels approach 130 to 140 dB. A moving coil mic can distort at loud levels but often this sonic coloration is not unpleasant. Condenser mics are more prone to unpleasant clattering artifacts at loud SPL's, however better condenser mics often feature pad switches that give 10 to 20 dB of high SPL protection(35) 7. Low frequency response. It's important to be able to capture a full range of sonic vibrations-- a string bass's lowest note is around 40 Hz. Sure, you want good low end response in a mic. However mics tend to also pick up handling noises and stage rumble as low frequency sound. In addition cardioid pattern mics in particular are prone to "proximity effect" coloration in which close micing emphasizes these low frequencies too much. To allow the best of both sides of this conundrum, many mics include a bass roll-off switch that trims as much as 10 dB in a curve from around 100Hz down.(38) To eliminate rumble, better mics often include an elastic banded shock mount rather than the familiar simple clamp.(39) 8. Impedance. This is a measure of a microphone's resistance to electrical fluctuation. All modern, high quality mics-- the ones that use balanced line cables-- are classed as low-impedance output, usually around 200 ohms (varying from 600 ohms to a very low 40 ohms). Modern quality recording equipment expects this low impedance at its inputs. If it receives a high-impedance signal instead (between 10,000 and 30,000 ohms resistance) the mismatch will cause dullness and sound distortion. It is important to know the output/input impedance specs of your mics and your pre-amp, mixer or recorder. If you must mismatch them (for example using a good modern microphone with an old classic tape recorder), you can compensate through the use of an impedance-matching transformer.(42) It can be deceptive to make judgements based simply on the numbers that manufacturers give for the above factors. First, the rating scales are not standardized. Which is more sensitive, a rating of "-56 dB" or a rating of "25mV/Pa (8mV/Pa +/-1dB?" Second, a recording may not require the highest level of a particular rating. For example a mic recording a string bass doesn't need the best high frequency response.(43) Any audio professional will have a good selection of different microphones to match different applications. A good starting setup would include a pair of rugged dynamics, a pair of small diaphragm condensers. and perhaps a pair of variable pattern, large diaphragm condensers. (44) All microphones add their own color and personality to the sound they record. In the long run it is best to rely on careful listening experience-- your own or that of other audio professionals you trust-- rather than just comparing numbers. The manufacturer's reputation is important too. Shure, AKG, Audio-Technica, Neumann, Sennheiser, BeyerDynamic, RODE, and Crown are all respected names.(45) Price can also be a guide: the sonic difference between a $20 mic and a $500 mic is pretty easy to hear if youʼre critical. Expect to pay $100 for even the most basic good professional mic (like a Shure SM58). Expect to pay $300 to $500 for mid-level quality.(46) If you want to set up a high quality recording facility, remember that the first recommendation of every professional involved with audio "invest in good microphones." © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media 10 Digital Music Production © 2008, Advanced Instructional Media