- Gilwell.com!

Transcription

- Gilwell.com!
Journal
of the American Scouting Historical Society
Winter 1998 No. 6
N
U
R
T
B
e
h
ll
i
B
by
h
t
for
s
’
A
S
s
i
k
p
To
R
O
eB
o
t
s
i
H
f
f
e
J
•
!
R
DE
M
n
i
ry
y
e
l
r
Mo
o
c
i
ex
ne
a
u
•D
s
k
l
w
Fo
plus:
Jeff Feldman
Tom Gould
Bob Wagner
Bruce Shelley
Paul Myers
Members of the American
Scouting Historical Society
Thomas Ashton, Burnsville, MN
Conrad Auel, Monessen, PA
Ed Basar, Livonia, MI
Mike Bega, York, PA
Dr. Gene Berman, Jackson Heights, NY
Dwight Bischel, IL
Dana Bonstrom, Kettle Falls, WA
Gary Burdorf, Santa Monica, CA
Bob Connor, Nesconset, NY
Chris Deering, DeKalb, IL
Fred Deurch, Logan, UT
Kirk Doan, Kansas City, MO
Duane Fowlks, TX
Jeff Feldman, Woodland Hills, CA
Dr. James Flatt, Huntsville, AL
Jeff Godby, Columbia, SC
Dr. Ron Godby, Yorktown, VA *
Gary Gole, Cleveland, OH
Tom Gould, Los Angeles, CA
Destry Hoffard, Johnson City, IL
Randall Holden, Blairstown, NJ
Rick Horne, Greensboro, NC
Frank Kern, DuPont, WA
Rob Kutz, Carlisle, PA
Raymond Lee, Tuscola, IL
Dr. David Leubitz, Akron, OH
Wally Majors, Jackson, MS
Craig McDaniels, American Fork, UT
Roy More, Ann Arbor, MI
Dr. Jeff Morley, San Francisco, CA
Paul Myers, Goshen, IN
John Pannell, Burlington, NC
John Pleasants, Siler City, NC
Al Sakai, Honolulu, HI
Scott Shackleton, Hermosa Beach, CA
Bruce Shelley, Arlington Heights, IL
Dr. Roger Schustereit, Cisco, TX
John Snead, Baton Rouge, LA
Wayne Snyder, Northumberland, PA
Bill Topkis, Park City, UT
Bob Wagner, Kansas City, MO
Cliff Ward, Cary, NC
Roger Ward, Nokomis, FL
Roy Wetherbee, Shrewsbury, MA
Rusty Van Reeves, Madison, MS
John Conley Williams, Waco, TX
*deceased
ON THE COVER
Scouts de America
Some lodge issues, camp patches, and a
council strip of the BSA council Scouts de
America of Mexico City are pictured on
the cover. See the article on page 15.
2
Letters to the Editor
Dear [Editor]:
I received a copy of the Journal and
was spell bound — 1938 NOAC —
Irondale.
You see my home Lodge is 51,
tapped out in ’51 at camp Irondale. I
spent 3 summer camps their. So this
copy is really a treasure for me.
I enjoyed the Journal and would
like to continue receiving a copy.
I also attended Lions Den — NOAC
’52, ’54, ’92, and ’94.
Still Active Scouter
Charles Lahay
Fayette, AL
Hi Guys:
I certainly enjoyed reading the Journal. The articles are interesting. Glad I
can contribute.
WWW
Conley Williams
Waco, TX
Dear [Editor]:
I appreciate getting your Journal.
This issue was great.
The bad part is I didn’t get it until
Sat. May 18. A day after the auction
ended.
WWW
Nelson Clements
Levittown, PA
Dear [Editor]:
I really enjoy reading the Journal
and have already started a section for it
in my periodical collection. Keep up the
good work!!!
BTW, I’m Greg Galloway, Vigil
Honor member and Founders’ Award
(youth) recipient in Tsali Lodge #134,
WWW. I’m currently in graduate school
so my collecting (and Scouting in general) is temporarily limited. I’m
working on a complete Tsali set but
need about seven flaps. FYI, the
Arapaho II is far from complete (or accurate). Bro. Hoogeveen has sent me his
updated list based on my findings in the
Lodge, and I’ve also sent my list to
other collectors (e.g. Conley Williams,
John Pleasants, Doug Bearce and
Streamwood [Chris Jensen]). I’m hoping the new Blue Book will be complete
and accurate. Perhaps [I’ll] finish work
on the Lodge history and patches and
submit it.
I just looked in my folder and have
issues of the Journal for Jan. 93 (#1),
July ’93, Winter ’94 and Spring ’96.
Would it be possible to get “back issues” that I’m missing? (They could
have been lost in the mail after I left for
grad school).
WWW
Greg Galloway
Athens, GA
Dear [Editor]:
I missed the first copy of the Journal (Vol. 1 #1). If you have any left, can
you send me one?
Thanks
Joe Hupp
Dear [Editor]:
I recently received a copy of the
Spring 1996 Issue of the Journal of the
Journal
Number 6
Winter 1998
published by the
American Scouting Historical Society
c/o Bill Topkis
2580 Silver Cloud Court
Park City, UT 84060
© 1993–1998 All Rights Reserved
American Scouting Historical Society
Editors:
Tom Gould (310) 474-4647
[email protected]
Jeff Morley (415) 474-1555
[email protected]
John Snead (504) 346-8540
[email protected]
Bill Topkis (435) 655-8899
(801) 655-8899
[email protected]
Number 6 – Winter 1998
American Scouting Historical Society. I
noticed that it was Volume 4, Issue 1. Is
there a way to get back issues? If so,
how many and at what cost? Xerox copies available?
Please advise,
Silas Jue
San Jose, CA
Dear [Editor]:
Enjoyed your publication — Spring
96 — a wide variety of different articles.
I collect “Cherokee 50” — know
that is nuts. I understand that in a past
issue you dealt with the 50R - Felt - “Z”
- could I get a copy of that issue?
Keep up the excellent work.
WWW
John Johnson
Harvest, AL
EDITORS NOTE: MANY OF YOU HAVE ASKED
WE
HAVE A LIMITED NUMBER . P LEASE SEE THE
AD ON PAGE 18.
ABOUT BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL.
Dear [Editor]:
P.S. page 42 Lot #1016 I read all of
this you’re CRAZY!!!
HA
Kevin Howard
Boaz AL
HiWanted to drop you a quick note to
say how much I’ve enjoyed receiving
my issues of the Journal of the American Scouting Historical Society. I was
really impressed/surprised when I got
your fourth issues (V4#1) with the nice
slick paper cover. Too bad you lost the
3-holed punch, as I liked to put my issues in binders along with the rest of
my scouting historical mags like “Scout
Memorabilia” and the like.
I really liked the article in issue #2
or #3 on the Tribe of Gimogash. I never
knew that when National was ‘trying
out’ the OA, that they were also doing
so with some of the other major honor
scouting groups like Firecrafters &
Mic-O-Say.
Keep up the good work! I wish I
could contribute an article, but my main
interest in scouting history/memorabilia
is my local council, and it’s only be
around since 1967 or so. I would like to
do something on it’s predecessor from
the 20’s, but my fellow collectors have
yet to discover any memorabilia apart
from one camp patch. Oh, well.
In Scouting.
Michael Brown
Via the Internet
In This Issue
5
9
14
EDITORS NOTE: MEMBERSHIP
19
IS OPEN TO
SCOUTING’S HISTORY.
PLEASE SEE “GUIDELINES FOR AUTHORS /
MEMBER APPLICANTS ON PAGE 4. WE LOOK
FORWARD TO YOUR ARTICLE.
SINCERE INTEREST IN
Dear [Editor]:
As we discussed, I am researching
segregation in the Boy Scouts in the
Southeast. I think that I will be able to
prepare an article for your magazine
sometime soon. The article will particularly focus on camps (and badges) for
black camps in South Carolina.
Sincerely,
Matthew L. Delk
Columbia, SC
Dear [Editor]:
I greatly appreciate being placed on
your mailing list and sincerely hope that
I continue to receive the Journal in the
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
OA HISTORY
Lodge Neckerchiefs
A photo essay on OA neckerchefs from Westchester
County, New York
by Bill Topkis & Jeff Morley
Dear [Editor]:
I am very interested in becoming a
member of your “American Scouting
Historical Society.” What are the requirements for membership, is it by
invitation only? I hope this has found
you well.
In Brotherhood
Destry L. Hoffard
Johnston City, IL
P.S. I am going on a short patch expedition this weekend to St. Louis and I
will do my best to track down one of the
Camp Irondale staff bandannas to photograph for your next issue.
ANY AND ALL INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE A
Scouting’s Paper
“Every membership card
represents a boy in
scouting’s history…”
by Jeff Feldman &
Tom Gould
Hey, guys,
Got your catalogue and wish I had
the money to buy it all. So much for that
pipe dream.
Dave Miller
Via the Internet
COLLECTING
BLUE BOOK
Blue Book on the Net
“The Blue Book is now
available for downloading-free
on the World Wide Web.
Here’s how.
by Bob Wagner
15
BSA HISTORY
Run for the Border
The BSA’s history in Mexico is
told with the story of Scouts
de America
by Bill Topkis, Jeff Morley,
& Duane Fowlks
RESEARCH
Lodge Names
Tracking down the errors in
historic lodge listings and
investigating source
document authenticity
by Bruce Shelley
26
DOCUMENTATION
Burden of Proof
A tale of two newly
discovered “First Flaps”
by Bill Topkis & Jeff Morley
DEPARTMENTS
2 Letters
28 Overheard…
at the Trade O Ree
by Paul Myers
30 Rules of the Auction
32 The Auction & Sale
3
How to become a member
Membership in the American Scouting Historical Society is not necessary to receive the Journal. Membership is open to any and all individuals who
have a sincere interest in Scouting’s history. The only requirement is that each
prospective member submit and have accepted for publication in the Journal, a
comprehensive article of historical depth that follows the guidelines as set forth
below or participate in a significant manner to an American Scouting Historical
Society project (i.e. The Blue Book).
Guidelines for Authors,
Member Applicants
Each article should be type written, single spaced, and one to three pages in
length. The subject matter may be on any vintage scouting insignia or memorabilia topic prior to 1965. The article should be original in nature, (no restatement
of prior information), should be of suitable historical depth and contain the following additional items:
• Photographs. Each article should be accompanied by one to four high
quality black and white photographs that clearly portray the items
discussed in the article.
• Photograph of Author.
• Biography of Author. Not to exceed two paragraphs. The biography
should briefly explain pertinent information about the author, education, background, scouting activities and area of collecting.
• Computer Disk. A copy of the article and biography should be
submitted on computer disk.
Authors and prospective members agree that submission of an article to the
Journal of the American Scouting Historical Society carries express permission
for publication in whole or part, and use of the authors name and image by the
Society. Furthermore, authors and prospective members agree that the Journal
retains final editorial rights over any article that it accepts for publication, that
any article may be refused for publication and that membership in the society
may be refused to any applicant who, in the view of the editorial board of the
Journal, does not meet each requirement for membership as outlined above.
Authors should submit articles to:
American Scouting Historical Society
c/o Bill Topkis
2580 Silver Cloud Court
Park City, UT 84060
[email protected]
4
future. I recently put together a booklet
on the patches of my home Lodge #296.
I have enclosed a copy for your use as a
reference. This includes all issues and
varieties (even though they are listed as
issues) so hopefully you may identify
any questionable issues from my lodge.
As soon as it is available, I will send you
a copy of the neckerchiefs and an estimate of the years and number produced
of each issue. Once again thanks for
your support of our hobby.
In the Brotherhood,
Andrew Stevens
Wilson, NC
Hi.
I really enjoyed the Journal, It was
sent to my son! I picked it up and started
reading it. The information on Merit
Badges was a good job. I received it too
late for the Auction. You do a good job!
In Scouting
Glenn A. Meloon, Sr.
Terre Haute, IN
Dear [Editor]:
Thank you for sending me The
Journal Vol. 4 Issue 1. The photograph
of the delegates to the 1938 National
Order of the Arrow Convention is very
interesting. I am currently in the process
of researching my father’s scouting career. He became a member of The
Owasippe Tribe of The Order of the Arrow in July 1936. 1 have his
membership card and membership pin.
Enclosed is a photocopy of them for
your review. I would like to obtain a
photograph of The Owasippe Tribe circa
1936 and therefore would like you to
print my letter asking your readers for
assistance.
Request for Assistance.
Moqua Chapter, Owasippe Tribe,
Order of the Arrow, Circa 1936
Scouter David Clement would like
to obtain information and or copies of
any photographs of the Owasippe Tribe,
Order of the Arrow, circa July 1936. His
father, Eagle Scout Edwin Clement, was
among those inducted into the Moqua
Chapter, Owasippe Tribe, Order of the
Arrow in the summer of 1936. Any information would be appreciated. David
(continued on page 28)
Number 6 – Winter 1998
Collecting Scouting’s Paper
by Jeff Feldman & Tom Gould
Recently, there has been a surge in the
collecting of paper. Some examples of
more popular paper collectibles include
sports cards, stock certificates, cigar rings
or produce labels. Also of note, is the increase in theme specific ephemera
collections; such collections might focus
on the Golden Age of Hollywood, Disney,
fraternal organizations or the military.
Figure 1 – Collectible cigar ring from
the 1955 World Jamboree.
For many years collectors of Scouting memorabilia have virtually ignored
paper collectibles in favor of cloth. Ten
years ago, we asked ourselves why? Paper documents the history of the Scouting
movement as well, if not better than, cloth.
Paper collectibles can be as colorful, if not
more colorful than patches. Paper collectibles often include the date of issuance
and the number printed so no guessing.
How often does cloth?
How many of you have a box of Boy
Scout cards or paper in your closet? Why
haven’t you discarded or sold it? Probably
the reason is that you know they have some
collectible value, albeit not as financially
significant as other types of Scouting collectibles.
Our goal with this, and
future, articles is to share
with the collectorate what we
have learned over the years
about collecting Scouting
paper. We hope that other
collectors will share their
knowledge with us, so we
can bring this information to the hobby.
An added desire is that we can build enthusiasm toward this interesting area of
Scouting’s history.
Every membership card represents a
boy in Scouting’s history and every rank
card represents an achievement, what an
interesting way to think about paper. Another draw to paper collectibles is the
artwork and content.
The major distinction between different types of paper collectibles that we have
made is “cards” and other scouting “paper.” Cards, as a group, will refer to those
items of scouting paper that are typically
printed on card stock and smaller than a
seven inch square. Paper as a group would
include everything else printed on paper;
for example Certificates, Warrants, applications, Calendars, letterheads,
photographs, maps, decals, promotional
handouts, pamphlets and books.
In this first article we will discuss several types of Scouting cards–collecting
cards, membership cards, rank and merit
badge cards, jamboree cards and list other
types of collectible Scouting cards. Future
articles will focus on individual categories of cards, giving an in-depth analysis
of them.
Collecting cards
“Collecting cards” is an attractive area
to collect due to extensive artwork and the
familiarity that a Sports/Non-Sports card
collector would enjoy. The artwork generally depicts a scouting activity in a
classic setting. The reverse side of the card
typically conveys a story, carries the message of an advertiser or a checklist of the
cards in the series.
uted in 1933 under the label “Some Boy
chewing gum.” The cards were distributed,
a few wrapped in a waxed wrapper, with
a stick of gum; the same way baseball
cards were distributed.
Figure 2 – 1933 “Some Boy” card
by Goudey.
Other popular collecting cards include
numerous British and American advertising cards like the ones commonly
distributed with cigarettes around the turn
of the century. Recently Boys Life magazine distributed a large set of collecting
cards. During the National / World Jamborees and National OA Conferences
collecting cards are used during wide
games.
Membership Cards
The Boy Scouts of America started
issuing membership cards on October 1,
1913, due to the need to collect dues and
control membership.1 While membership
cards are the most common
scouting cards seen, they are
also a key piece in the history of the Boy Scout
movement and should be the
cornerstone of any scouting
card collection.
Often done by famous
artists, Leyendecker and
Rockwell to name a few, membership
cards contain some of the most recognizable Scouting artwork.
“Every membership card represents a
boy in scouting’s history and every rank
card represents an achievement”
The most popular card series is, without a doubt, the series printed by the
Goudey Gum Company of Boston; with
the permission of the Boy Scouts of
America. The set of 48 cards was distrib-
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
1. Scouting Magazine, Vol. 1 - No. 10, Sept.
1, 1913.
5
Early membership cards contained a
lot more information than the cards we
stick in our wallets today. The early membership cards contained some, or all, of
the following groups of information:
• Certificate page
• The Scout Oath/The Scout Law
• Morse Code and Semaphore
• Dues Record
• Scout History/Offices Held
• Personal Record of Achievement
• Personal Information (city, state,
troop, patrol, age, height, weight)
• Blank Pages
When membership cards were reduced in size to fit the wallet, the purpose
of the cards changed significantly. Pre1940’s cards were living documents of the
Scout’s experience. These cards were used
as a record, as well as proof of membership. From the late 1940’s onward the
cards were used exclusively to prove membership; simply containing the certificate
of membership.
The membership cards of the teens
had a celluloid cover and back held together with a rivet or rings. During the
twenties through the forties membership
cards were on card stock and folded in
thirds or in half. These cards were inserted
into a paper sleeve that typically had an
advertisement for Boy’s Life on the front.
In the late forties, membership cards were
changed to single cards a size to fit in a
wallet.
Special cards were issued for Senior
Scout Programs, Lone Scouts, Veteran
Scouts, Cub Scouts and Scouters. In the
absence of cards designed for the specific
lection. Special serial number sequencing
was used to identify different programs
Membership cards from 1914 through
the early fifties contained from four to
seven signatures. The signatures
were typically the
national officers
of the Boy
Scouts. Cards
from the fifties
forward had the
signature of the
Honorary President (President of
the United States)
and the Chief
Scout Executive.
Figure 3 – A 1914 riveted celluloid membership card.
program, national placed special markings
on the standard issue membership card.
Membership cards from the 20’s
through the mid 50’s were serial numbered. The serial numbering was reset, or
reconfigured, a number of times during
this period, but serial numbers represent
one of the best means of cataloging a col-
Figure 5 – a modern wallet-sized card.
Figure 4 – A tri-fold membership card from 1919.
6
Number 6 – Winter 1998
Jamboree Cards
Two types of cards
were used as part of the
World and National Jamborees. The first category
is attendance cards, and
the second is wide game
cards. These types of
cards were also issued for
other national events,
such as the National Order of the Arrow and
Explorer Conferences.
Figure 6 – An early-type rank card.
Figure 9 – A modern trading card
from the 1969 National
Jamboree.
Rank and
Merit Badge Cards
From the earliest days of Scouting
when a scout earned a rank advancement,
he not only received a patch, but also a
card. These cards are significant because
they are the official records of a scouts advancement.
Early advancement/merit badge cards
were rectangular in shape; approximately
3" by 5". This configuration was continued until the early 40’s, when the cards
were changed to the current configuration,
a smaller format that is more conducive
to fitting in a wallet. An exception to this
Figure 7 – An early Cub card.
format are early Cub Scout advancement
cards, which were diamond in shape (3"
by 3").
Many of the local Councils opted to
issue their own rank and merit badge cards
rather than using the nationally distributed
ones. Eagle Scout cards were, and still are,
only issued by the national office.
supposed to write their name and address
on the cards that they exchanged with boys
from different parts of of the country or
world. Some examples of the content of
Figure 8 – A Jamboree participant’s
card from 1964.
Attendance cards were issued to participants and the staff at World and
National Jamborees. There was a card issued for each National Jamboree,
including the cancelled 1935 jamboree.
Typically these cards indicated name and
city or council of the boy attending. Cards
were also issued to staff and dignitaries.
The cards bore the signatures of the national officers until 1964. Scouts attending
the early World Jamborees were issued
identification cards to indicate that they
were traveling representatives of the Boy
Scouts of America.
Trading cards were used during wide
games at the Jamborees. The wide games
were intended to foster intermingling of
the scouts. A scout would typically get an
envelope with a number of trading/collecting cards. They would walk around the
Jamboree to other sub-camps, trade cards,
and complete their set. The scouts were
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
Figure 9 – A modern rank card.
the cards include Astronauts and early
scouting pioneers.
Card Categories
We had intended to title this section
“Miscellaneous,” but realized that there
were too many cards to bulk into a generic
section. For this reason, we have compiled
a list of all of the card categories that we
have identified to date.
Our collection is limited to nationally
issued cards. Council issues are neat, but
the issues would total in the hundreds of
thousands, rather than just a few thousand.
7
We have listed a lot of card categories here, but it is logical to assume that
there are probably many more cards floating around than we have listed. This is
where we rely on the collectorate to help
fill-in the blanks. We will continue to publish updates, as long as new information
is coming in.
Other Paper Collectibles
We plan to discuss “other paper collectibles” in future issues of the Journal
after we cover each category of cards in
painful detail.
Below is a list of paper collectibles
that don’t fit in the card category:
• Charters
• Leader Warrants
• National Letterhead
• Certificates
• Post Cards
• Photographs
• Jamboree
• Decals
• Applications and forms
• Scorecards ❏
WANTED
1910–1969
Scout and Adult
Membership Cards
Rank Cards
Charters and Warrants
Rare BSA Publications
call:
Tom Gould
(310) 474-4647
or
Jeff Feldman
(818) 345-8873
8
Card Category Listing
Membership
Cub Scout
Boy Scout
Exploring
Explorer Scout
Sea Scout
Air Scout
Lone Scout
Adult
Woman’s Reserve
Order of the Arrow
NESA
Veteran
Rank
Cub
Arrow Point
Bobcat
Wolf
Bear
Lion
Webelos
Webelos Activity Badge
Arrow of Light
Den Chief
Scouting
Scout
Temporary Induction Certificate
Scout
Tenderfoot
2nd Class
1st Class
Life (Star)
Star (Life)
Eagle
Eagle With Bronze Palm
Eagle With Gold Palm
Eagle With Silver Palm
Merit Badge Cards
Senior Scouting
Exploring
Apprentice
Ordinary
Able
Bronze Award
Gold Award
Silver Award
Senior Scout Title
Explorer Rating
Sea Scouting/Sea Exploring
Apprentice
Ordinary
Able
Quartermaster
Air Scouting/Air Exploring
Apprentice
Observer
Craftsman
Ace
Varsity Scouting
Scouting Programs
Totin’ Chip
Firem’n Chit
Whittling Chip
Scout Axe License
Paul Bunyan Axman
Paul Bunyan Woodsman
Conservation Good Turn
Outdoor Code
Family Camping Code
Gold Quill Award
100% Uniform Inspection
Organizer Award
Receipt for Dues
Savings Record Card
Mile Swim
Scout Lifeguard
Safe Swim Defense
Safety Afloat
Snorkeling BSA
Emergency Service
Emergency Service Apprentice
Dispatch Bearer
Camp Staff
Project S.O.A.R.
World Crest
Vigil Honor
Sustaining Membership
Donation
Emergency Service Exploring
“Ready” Explorer
Religious Awards
Training
Cub Training Certificate
Scout Training Certificate
Explorer Training
Explorer Trained Officer
Woodbadge
National Camp School
Attendance Card
Administration
Activities
Camp Administration
Camp Management
Scoutcraft Activities
Program Director
Camp Director
Handicraft
Swimming
Lifesaving
Boating
Canoeing
Veteran
Junior Alumni
Veteran (blank year)
Veteran (Years listed 5 - 80)
Jamboree
Attendance
Wide Game
Number 6 – Winter 1998
The O.A. Neckerchiefs of Westchester County
A photo essay on Neckerchiefs
by Bill Topkis & Jeff Morley
Wimachtendienk WW started early in
Westchester County, New York, beginning
in 1923, the society’s eighth year. That is
when Chappegat became WWW’s fifteenth lodge located in New Rochelle. In
the following twenty years four other
lodges from within the county located
between the Hudson River to the west and
Long Island Sound to the east would apply for charter.
CONNECTICUT
H ud
WESTCHESTER
so
Bridgeport
n
Riv
Ossining
ROCKLAND
er
White
Plains
NEW
JERSEY
Yonkers
New Rochelle
g
Lon
Isla
nd
Sou
nd
Mount Vernon
TA
N
BRONX
AT
SUFFOLK
NH
MA
Newark
QUEENS
Lodge 15 Mide
(1957–1973)
Lodge 47 Hanigus
(1930–1957)
Lodge 32 Kitchawonk
(1927–1942)
Lodge 15 Ktemaque
(1973–present)
Lodge 32 Tahawus
(1942–1955)
Lodge 246 Horicon
(1955–1973)
Lodge 86 Wiccopee
(1936–1951)
PUTNUM
ORANGE
Lodge 15 Chappegat
(1923–1957)
NASSAU
New York City
BROOKLYN
Figure 1 – Map of Westchester County,
New York.
Those lodges were, Kitchawonk
Lodge 32 (later Tahawus ) of Yonkers
(1927), Hanigus Lodge 47 of Mt. Vernon
(1930), Wiccopee Lodge 86 of Ossining
(1936), and Wakoda Lodge 246 of White
Plains (1943) (see map – Fig. 1). By 1973
after a complex series of mergers and formations of new lodges all five original
lodges within the county would combine
into one brotherhood,
Ktemaque Lodge 15.
(Fig. 2)
To the knowledgeable OA name and
number collectors these
lodges of Westchester
County are legendary.
Many late night badgetrading sessions have been spent
discussing these lodges and their insignia.
It is where the Wakoda A1 felt is from and
five different badges from Hanigus 47, two
of them felt composition and two activity
felts (Fig. 3). It is also the home of the
Lodge 246 Wakoda
(1943–1951)
Lodge 246 Apachedotte
(1951–1955)
Figure 2 – Diagram of lodge mergers in Westchester County. Ktemaque Lodge
continues the heritage of nine superceeded lodges.
Tahawus neckerchief, the only issue of that now extinct lodge. It
is this neckerchief department
that the county has no peer.
Where and when the first OA
neckerchief was issued we do not
know. The earliest known neckerchiefs are three issued by
Anicus Lodge 67 of Wilkinsburgh, Pennslyvania in 1940.
These neckerchiefs were issued to
commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Order of the Arrow and
their hosting of the 25th anniversary National Meeting at Camp
Twin Echo (Fig 4 & 5). No doubt
the contingent of 20 from
Figure 3 – Early lodge patches from
Westchester County, New York.
Their first neckerchief
(and first official lodge
issue) was on orange
cotton with black
block printing (Fig. 6).
It is listed in The Blue
Book as N1. Their
other neckerchief issued that year was for hosting the 1941
Area “E” conference (among the oldest
sectional conclave items) (Fig. 7). It is also
orange cotton with black block printing.
Block printing along with stenciling
is among the earliest and most crude meth-
“Many silk-screened and direct embroidered
neckerchiefs, perhaps as many as two thirds,
were issued specifically as contingent items”
Chappegat Lodge (the seventh largest contingent of the 64 lodges that sent
representatives) took notice.
In the following year, 1941,
Chappegat Lodge issued a pair of extremely primitive full square neckerchiefs.
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
9
Figure 4 – 1940 contingent neckerchief
from Anicus Lodge 67.
Figure 6 – Block-printed neckerchief
from Chappegat Lodge (1941).
Figure 7 – The host lodge neckerchief
issued by Chappegat Lodge in
1941, one of the oldest OA
sectional conclave items.
10
Figure 5 – Early neckerchiefs from Anicus and Skanondo
Lodges..
ods of manufacturing neckerchiefs. In general these methods were for small quantity,
inexpensive “do it yourself” neckerchiefs.
A block print, often cut out of linoleum is
like a large rubber stamp where ink is applied to the block and then pressed onto
any available piece of cotton. A stencil is
where a pattern is cut into a single piece
of cardboard and then paint is applied
through the spaces where it is desired. The
telltale sign of stenciling is that gaps are
used inside of letters and other objects so
that the cardboard can remain a single
piece.
At the time of the printing of The Blue
Book only nine stenciled or block printed
standard OA issued neckerchiefs were
known (three more are now known and
will be added in the next edition of The
Blue Book). For an example of a stenciled
neckerchief, see the first known neckerchief from Skanondo Lodge 64 from
nearby Middletown, New York (Fig. 5).
Chappegat Lodge issued many more
neckerchiefs between 1942 and 1955.
These neckerchiefs were all of the same
design, featuring their totem, the beaver,
superimposed on a flint chip arrowhead
with the lodge name across the top. These
neckerchiefs were all on red cloth and
were made both as silk-screened neckerchiefs and as direct embroidered as well.
(Figs. 8, 9, & 10).
Silk-screening is a process that utilizes
an extremely fine screen made out of silk.
A negative pattern is placed upon the
screen and then ink is pressed through the
fine holes and onto the material. If more
than one color is used, then another screen
for each color is placed exactly on the
same portion of the material and the new
color of ink is applied. This is a relatively
inexpensive method, especially when
compared to the cost of manufacturing a
badge and sewing it onto a neckerchief.
Silk-screening also could be used for small
quantities, as few as a dozen, and the
screen could be maintained for future usage.
If a neckerchief has a design that is
loomed into the material of the neckerchief
then it is called a “direct embroidered”
neckerchief. This method could also be
done at a low cost and in small quantities.
This was especially true because the vast
majority of direct embroidered neckerchiefs were manufactured overseas. The
Chappegat embroidered neckerchiefs are
among the oldest examples of direct embroidery. They were not made abroad.
They were manufactured locally one at a
time.
In general, neckerchiefs were utilized
for two purposes. First they created a “uniform” look for all Arrowmen within the
same lodge. This was to help create an
esprit de corps. Generally they were required wear at all Order of the Arrow
functions, especially when traveling outside of the lodge to a Sectional or National
event. The second purpose was for easy
identification of the members of a contingent. This was especially useful for boy
and adult leaders trying to keep their lodge
together.
Many silk-screened and direct embroidered neckerchiefs, perhaps as many as
two thirds, were issued specifically as conNumber 6 – Winter 1998
Figure 8 – Chappegat Lodge neckerchiefs N2 and N3.
Figure 9 – Chappegat Lodge neckerchiefs N4 and N5.
tingent items. Unfortunately,
if
the
neckerchief lacks commemorative markings,
its use is often lost. Although The Blue Book
attempts to note all contingent neckerchiefs,
those lacking commemorative markings
generally were not
listed as such. Also it
was not uncommon for
the same neckerchief to
be used for years at multiple events before
being
retired.
Chappegat did, however, issue several
commemorative contingent neckerchiefs for
wear at a single function.
The first contingent
neckerchief issued by
Chappegat Lodge was a
block print neckerchief
for their contingent to
the 1949 Area 2A Fellowship hosted by
Man-A-Hattin Lodge
82 (Fig. 11). This neckerchief is white with red
printing. Even though
this neckerchief was issued for a section
conclave and features a
date, it will be listed in
the next edition of The
Blue Book because it
was issued as a contingent item not for
use by other lodges.
In 1952 Chappegat issued a neckerchief for their contingent to the National
Order of the Arrow Conference held at
Miami University, Oxford, Ohio (Fig. 12).
This NOAC neckerchief is one of the earliest examples of a neckerchief issued for
a NOAC contingent. It is a purple neckerchief with white silk-screening and a white
satin ribbon border. It was issued one per
contingent member.
In 1953 Chappegat issued a pair of
Neckerchiefs for the Area 2A fellowship
that they hosted (Fig. 13). The neckerchief
issued for all attendees of the conference
is on white cotton with blue silk-screening and a red braided ribbon inner border.
The neckerchief issued only to host lodge
members is orange with dark green silkscreening and will be listed as N7 in The
Blue Book, second edition.
The second to last neckerchief issued
by Chappegat prior to merging with
Hanigus Lodge 47 was the “‘Buzzy’ the
busy beaver” issue (Fig.12). This neckerchief was made on yellow cotton with red
satin border and red silk-screening.
The last neckerchief of the lodge was
made to observe the demise of the lodge.
It was issued at the final reunion held at
Camp Siwanoy in 1958 and also marked
the Lodge’s 35th anniversary. (Fig. 14)
The most extraordinary neckerchief
issued in Westchester County was the
Tahawus Lodge 32 neckerchief. The issue is special because it is the only piece
of insignia ever issued by the lodge. Because of this uniqueness, and its scarcity
Figure 10 – Chappegat Lodge neckerchiefs N5.1 and
N5.2
Figure 11 – Chappegat Lodge 1949
contingent neckerchief.
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
Figure 12 – Chappegat Lodge contingent neckerchiefs
from the 1950’s.
11
Figure 13 – Chappegat Lodge issued these Area 2A
Fellowship neckerchiefs in 1953.
Figure 15 – This rare neckerchief is the
only known issue from Tahawus
Lodge 32.
Figure 16– Early neckerchiefs from Hanigus Lodge 47.
(six known) name and number collectors
have sought out this black on pale yellow
silk-screened neckerchief to complete
their “name” collection. (Fig 15.) The
neckerchief is so rare that many name and
number collectors have either ignored it
or decided that they do not collect neckerchiefs within their name and number
collection.
Figure 17 – The Horicon Lodge 246
neckerchief.
12
Figure 14– The last neckerchief of
Lodge 15 Chappegat.
Hanigus Lodge 47 issued two neckerchiefs. Although overshadowed by the
rare badges of this lodge these two neckerchiefs have as few or fewer known
examples as the badges.
The first neckerchief is on white cotton with black piping. (Piping is the rolled
cotton tape edge appearing on most neckerchiefs issued after 1960.) The name of
the lodge is silk-screened in red and the
Native American hoop dancer is in black.
An interesting design element is that the
WWW’s are subtly formed within the
hoops, one of them made out of the feathers in the dancer’s headdress. (Fig 16.)
The second neckerchief issued by
Hanigus was issued to commemorate their
thirtieth anniversary. (Fig 16) It also presents us with two puzzles. The first puzzle
is relative to chronology, the second with
design.
Chronologically Hanigus chartered in
1930. We know that they knew that because their last round had the correct date
on it. (Fig. 3) (Have your heard the one
about the collector who refused to trade
for a 47R because “he knew it could not
be from 1930?”) However, Hanigus,
merged with Chappegat in 1957. That
means the lodge only existed for 27 years.
So how (or why) did they have a 30th anniversary neckerchief? The best answer
seems to be that they wanted to issue an
anniversary neckerchief marking the end
of their lodge. No doubt they wanted to
issue a last commemorative neckerchief
just like Chappegat Lodge, the lodge that
they merged with did for their 35th Anniversary.
Number 6 – Winter 1998
The second puzzle is a secret hidden
in the simple design to observe the demise
of Hanigus Lodge. On the neckerchief the
“O” and “A” are superimposed over each
other and have a double meaning. The letters can also be viewed as a sun setting
over a snow capped mountain representing the sunset of the lodge. The 30 th
anniversary neckerchief of Hanigus is gray
with black piping. It has the name, arrow
and “30 years of service” screened in
black.
Of the three lodges that bore the number 246, only the last, Horicon Lodge 246,
issued a neckerchief. It is silk-screened on
white cotton with blue piping. (Fig 17)
The design features a raccoon on an arrow with the name of the lodge in red.
Figure 19 – The Chappegat Chapter of
Mide Lodge 15 issued a
neckerchief that is greatly similar
to the old Chappegat Lodge 15.
the tradition of the Order of the Arrow and
are just as special as the badges issued
contemporaneously with them. Lack of
knowledge and failure in the past to have
accurate listings of neckerchiefs has contributed to the mistaken belief that they
were not issues worth collecting like their
badge counterparts. Perhaps the inverse is
closer to the truth. With The Blue Book
we now, for the first time, have a worthwhile listing of over 1,400 non-patch
neckerchiefs. The Blue Book, second edition, will have over 1,600 OA neckerchiefs
listed. ❏
EDITORS NOTE — FOR ISSUES NOT LISTED
I N The Blue Book (F I R S T E D I T I O N ),
DECIMAL
BLUE BOOK NUMBERS
CORRESPOND TO B LUE B OOK 2 ND E DITION
(IN PRESS).
Figure 18 – The Mide Lodge 15
silkscreened neckerchief.
Figure 20 – Ktemaque Lodge 15 neckerchiefs.
Mide Lodge, 15, the resultant lodge
of the merger of Chappegat and Hanigus
issued one lodge silk-screened issue and
one chapter neckerchief. The Lodge neckerchief is a peach colored neckerchief with
an orange shiny ribbon border. (See Fig
18.) It is the same design as their P1 and
like many neckerchiefs was issued because it was considerably less expensive
than a Swiss embroidered pie.
Chappegat Chapter of Mide issued a
chapter neckerchief. The neckerchief is
designed to look exactly like the arrowhead neckerchiefs issued by the original
lodge. (Fig. 19) It is white silk-screen on
red cotton and has a white piped border
unlike the Chappegat issues which had ribbon borders. Because of the design, this
neckerchief is easily mistaken for a
Chappegat neckerchief and could easily
be missed by an unaware collector.
Finally, Ktemaque Lodge 15, the
lodge that now represents all of
Westchester County issued neckerchiefs.
(See Fig. 20.) Their basic neckerchief is a
direct embroidered neckerchief on bright
blue cotton with white piping. Ktemaque
also issued a neckerchief for their 1976
training weekend. It is a white unbordered
cotton neckerchief with orange silkscreening.
From the OA neckerchiefs of
Westchester County we can see the true
diversity of neckerchiefs. They came stenciled; block printed, silk-screened and
direct embroidered. They could be issued
in extremely small quantities and at a dramatic saving. They were issued for
NOACs, Section Conclaves, and anniversaries and for esprit de corp. But perhaps
most significant is that these neckerchiefs
are important issues of the lodges for
which they stand. They are emblematic of
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
WANTED
Merit Badges
before 1950
Eisner BSA Coats
with Merit Badges
Merit Badge
Accumulations
White Merit
Badge Pamphlets
Call
John Pleasants
(800) 322-3918
13
How to view The Blue Book on Your PC
by Bob Wagner
Now that The Blue Book is available
on the Web, people are asking, “How do
I get it?” Here’s how.
Choose your favorite browser.
(Mine is Netscape.)
1. Open location http://
www.kirkdoan.com and Kirk
Doan’s first page (Home page)
will appear.
2. Click on “The BlueBook, OA
Patches . . .” this brings us to
http://www.kirkdoan.com/
download.htm
3. Click on bluebook.txt (this is the
smallest choice and it is a tab
delimited spreadsheet.) Then
wait about 7 minutes until it is
downloaded to you.
4. Then click File, Save As and
save the file as you wish or the
default, it is “bluebook.txt.” Wait
7 more minutes for the file to be
saved.
In Excel (95 or 97) do the
following:
1. File; Open bluebook.txt and the
Text Import Wizard step 1 of 3
shows.
2. Click Delimited Start import at
row 1, File Orig in Windows
(ANSI)
3. Click Next and the Text Import
Wizard Step 2 of 3 shows.
4. Click Delimiters Tab; leave the
rest blank; Text Qualifier: “
5. Click Next and the Text Import
Wizard Step 3 of 3 shows.
6. Click General column data
format for each column.
7. Click Finish to bring up the work
sheet. To find out how you did so
far depress the CTRL key and
the End key simultaneously. In
Excel97 the last entry will be row
19711. In Excel 95 you will get
a warning message “File not
Loaded Completely.” And the last
entry is 16384 showing lodge
458A patch F1c. In either case
the first line gives the name of
the fields.
8. Save As “Microsoft Workbook”
on “c:\Bluebook.xls” in Microsoft
Excel 5.0/95 and exit Excel97. If
you are using Excel 95, you will
have to repeat steps 1 through 8
again this time importing Delimited Start import at row 16385.
Step 7 will display line 3327 as
the last line showing lodge 618A
patch S4. Save As “Microsoft
Workbook” on “c:\Bluebk2.xls”
in Microsoft Excel 5.0/95. Exit
Excel 95.
Open Microsoft Access and Create
a New Database Using Blank
Database as follows:
1. File New Database where you
want it. e.g.; Filename: tstbb.mdb
Save in: your favorite folder
“create.”
2. Click table; File; Get External
Data; Import
3. Import Filetype *.xls; click
filename bluebook.xls Import and
wait.
Import Spreadsheet Wizard will
appear.
1. Click First Row Contains
Column Headings.
2. Click Next.
3. Click In a New Table.
4. Click Next.
5. Set All Field Names have
Indexed = NO except Field
Name “ipid” Indexed: Yes
(Duplicates OK).
6. Click Next.
7. Let Access add Primary Key.
8. Click Next.
9. Import to Table: bluebook.
10. Click Finish and bluebook will
appear as a Table.
Now do a similar thing with the
Lodges to create a Lodge Table;
i.e.;
1. Choose your favorite browser
again and download the
Lodges.txt file.
2. In Excel create a spreadsheet
and call it (c:\Lodges);
3. Open the Access Database you
created before tstbb.mdb and
import Lodges as another Table
so that you now have 2 tables in
Excel97 or 3 in Excel 95.
Good luck. Another article will follow
about what you are able to do with the
database you have created.
THE BLUE BOOK
The ASHS is continuing work on the preparation of a new edition of The Blue Book which will
be available in book form and on-line for the 1998
NOAC. Corrections and new issues will be added
with no number changes.
14
Number 6 – Winter 1998
Run for the Border:
The BSA’s History in Mexico
Scouts de America
by Bill Topkis, Jeff Morley, and Duane Fowlks
Of all the councils that have ever existed in the history of the Boy Scouts of
America, one of the most unusual, if not
the smallest, was the council located in
Mexico City, Mexico. The council was
created so those American citizens living
in Mexico City could participate in the
BSA. Although the council no longer exists today, it left behind a legacy of
distinctive and extremely scarce badges.
The name of the council, and insignia used
by the members, was Scouts de America
(as opposed to Scouts de Mexico). Later,
circa 1960, Scouts de America became
associated with Direct Service Council.
Eventually, in 1971, Scouts de America
and Cuauhtli Lodge became fully integrated with Direct Service Council and
were absorbed.
Figure 1 – Scouts De America’s first
council patch (CP).
Like many
BSA councils
based abroad, the
members
of
Scouts
de
America were
comprised of a
unique blend of
Scouts and Scouters. Members primarily fell into one of
several groups. Many were connected with
the American Embassy / Diplomatic corp.
Others were U.S. military personnel and
their dependents. Many were connected
with major American business interests Lodge have been traditionally associated
based in Mexico. As a group they were with Region 9.
affluent, mobile and big on Scouting. That
The Council badge for Scouts de
is why they had a presence at National America (Fig. 1) was constructed of red
events such as Jamborees and Arrow Con- felt on black felt and featured a red wolf’s
ferences and why their Order of the Arrow head and the words Scouts de America. It
Lodge, Cuauhtli 446, was allowed to ex- was issued in the early 1950’s. The badge
ist as long as it did. This National presence was for wear to National and International
gave the illusion that the Council was events attended by council members. Likelarger than it actually
was.
From its humble beginnings, the council
was always small. The
first American Scout
troop in Mexico,
“George Washington
Troop One”, was
founded in 1943 by Mr.
Phil “G” Groesbeck. Figure 2 – Scouts De America council strips (CSP).
From that time forward,
the Council never had more than three wise, in the same time period, four differtroops, Troops 1, 2 and 3 and one Explorer ent council shoulder badges (CSP’s) were
Post. Furthermore, the council only had used (Fig. 2). Each strip is of felt on felt
one sponsor for all of its troops, The construction and featured the name of the
American Society of Mexico. The Ameri- council and the word “Mexico”. One of
can Society was the provider of an the strips appears on gray felt with red let“American” accredited private education tering (upper left – Fig. 2). The color of
for US citizens’ abroad. It is not unusual lettering and the thickness of the letters
to find the Council referred to as the distinguish two of the other strips. One has
American Society or American Society of red thin lettering (upper right – figure 2)
Mexico, in reference to the sole sponsor’s and the other has dark red thick letters
(lower right – Fig.
2), both on black
felt. The fourth
CSP was issued
for Rover Scouts
for international
events and is dark
red lettering on
green felt.
Other badges were used by Scouting
name. The Council relied on Scouting societies in Mexico. Included is the
materials and direction from the Alamo Mexico, D.F. (District Federalis) shoulArea Council in San Antonio, Texas. That der strip. This strip is orange with red
is why Scouts de America and Cuauhtli screening on flocked canvas. It is believed
that this is a Boy Scouts of Mexico strip
“affluent, mobile, and big on Scouting, they had a
presence at national events which gave the illusion
that the council was larger than it actually was”
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
15
Figure 3 – Badges of Mexican
scouts and French scouts in
Mexico.
that some Americans used as their district
badge. The Scouts de Mexico strip was
worn by members of the Boy Scouts of
Mexico and is red on white. The Scouts
de France – Mexico strip is a red on cream
badge and was worn by the French equivalent to the Scouts de America; those
French nationals who were in the Boy
Scouts of France and residing in Mexico
(Fig. 3).
Camp Aztec
The Scout Camp for the Scouts de
America was unique in many respects.
Founded in 1949, Camp Aztec was only
open one week a year. The early guiding
force behind Camp Aztec was Dr. J. Pier
Freston (“Doc”) who served as Camp
Manager and Scoutmaster of Troop 3.
Camp Aztec was located on a lake in a
valley. The Valley was named Valle Del
Bravo (Valley of the Brave) and there were
no improved roads to reach it. The Scouts
would go to the “embarcadero” and rent
launches to travel the two miles to get to
the million square meter campsite. The
camp was built upon the ruins of an ancient Aztec pyramid. This explains the
later badges, issued for the camp that are
trapezoidal shaped to resemble the Aztec
pyramids.
In the early years, Scouts de America
had no one qualified to be a Camp Director. Jay Knowles of Alamo Area Council
traveled annually to Camp Aztec from San
Antonio, Texas, beginning in the early
1950’s to serve as their Camp Director.
He was as close to a professional as the
Figure 4 – Camp Aztec patches from the 1940’s and 1950’s.
council ever had. He had National Camp
School and Philmont training.
The daily events at the camp were
much the same as at any Scout summer
camp. Scouts worked on advancement of
rank, merit badges and their swimming
skills. Of note was the high praise given
for the food. Sr. Mario Palomo, head chef
at the prestigious Hotel Cortes in Mexico
City, was Camp Cook. Beginning with the
first year of Camp Aztec in 1949, Sr.
Palomo used his vacations and culinary
skills to “serve” the Scouts. His Mexican
fiestas were legendary and his salsa was
volcanic. In recognition of his efforts, he
was made a member of the Order of the
Arrow.
In later years the campsite where
Camp Aztec was held became known as
Camp Amarac. Camp Amarac was open
throughout the summer for “American
style” summer camp for girls and boys,
with “Camp Aztec” being held one week
each year. Sam Atkins, Scoutmaster for
Troop 3 from the 1962 – 1990 served as
Camp Director for Camp Aztec and Camp
Amarac.
The earliest Camp Aztec badges were
silk-screened on white felt (Fig. 4). The
first general issue features a dark red
American Indian chieftain. Two known
contemporaneous issues featured a canoe
on a lake and were for Warrior (red silkscreening) and Brave (dark green
Figure 5 – Camp Aztec patches from the 1950’s. and 1960’s.
16
Number 6 – Winter 1998
silk-screening). Presumably these were for
an early non-OA camp society and it is
believed other ranks existed. A red and
green screened badge was also issued for
“five year” campers.
In 1956 Camp Aztec issued a triangular badge with accompanying 1956
segment. Subsequent to the triangle Camp
Aztec began issuing trapezoidal (Aztec
pyramid) shaped badges. These trapezoids
were for wear both on hats and the Scout
shirts. The Trapezoid was issued on “no
twill” and twill right (Fig. 5), as well as
fully embroidered and stamped in leather
(Fig. 4).
was issued to Ordeal honor members and
the solid was issued to Brotherhood honor
members. These flaps were issued after
the lodge wasunder the Direct Service
umbrella and are therefore considered
chapter badges by many collectors.
The most mysterious badge issued by
the lodge was the flat chenille (C1) felt
round (Fig. 9). This badge is misspelled
(Cuautli) and was issued in the late 1950’s
and early 1960’s. The badge was used for
special recognition, such as for Vigil or
special service to the council and was pri-
Order of the Arrow
Before there was a Black Eagle
Lodge, before there was a Hinode Goya
Lodge there was Cuauhtli Lodge 446 in
Mexico, the first lodge outside of the
United States and it’s territories (territorial lodges did exist prior in Alaska and
the Canal Zone). Cuauhtli signified the
eagle in the Nahuatl Indian language.
Cuauhtli Lodge never had more than thirty
members. Tap outs and ceremonies started
simple in the 1950’s (Fig. 6), but later, in
Figure 7 – Cuauhtli Lodge used Aztec
themes for a ceremony at the 1969
National Jamboree.
years this badge was thought of as a fake,
perhaps because of the number of them
traded over the years by Jay Knowles,
sound evidence exists that the badge was
authentic. For a number of years the sateens were reissued within the lodge and
a number from 1-4 was placed on the back
to describe condition. Apparently when
the badge was retired because of condition or when the flap superceded it, Mr.
Knowles, a badge trader in the 1950’s and
Figure 9 – Official Cuauhtli Lodge
patches from the 1950’s; R1, C1,
and F1.
Figure 6 – Cuauhtli Lodge ceremony at
Camp Aztec in the mid-1950’s.
the 1960’s, took on a distinctive and most
impressive Aztec theme (Figs. 7 and 8).
The first badge of the lodge, the dark
yellow sateen round with green silkscreening was issued circa 1952 (Fig. 9).
The design incorporated the Mexican flag,
which features an eagle with a snake in
its beak except they replaced the snake
with an arrow sash. Although for many
Figure 8 – Cuauhtli Lodge ceremony at
the 1969 National Jamboree.
1960’s, ended up with the supply of the
badges.
In 1956 Cuauhtli Lodge issued its first
and only official flap (F1) (Fig. 9). Subsequent to the F1, rolled edge versions of
the first flap were made (Fig. 10). The twill
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
Figure 10 – Rolled-edge Cuauhtli
Lodge flaps from the 1960’s were
issued after the lodge’s official
disbandment and are usually
considered to be unofficial issues
or chapter flaps of Lodge 555
Gamenowiwink.
17
marily distributed by long time advisor
Sam Atkins.
The lodge also issued an extremely
scarce silk-screened neckerchief (circa
Figure 11 – The Cuauhtli Lodge
silkscreened neckerchief.
1962) that used the design of the sateen
(Fig. 11).
The End of an Era
Starting in 1960, National started to
bring pressure upon Scouts de America to
dissolve and become a part of Direct Service Council. American Scouting in
Mexico had changed significantly because
of changes in the government. Slowly the
council did become absorbed into Direct
Volume 1, No. 1 January, 1993,
Inaugural Journal. 12 pages. 155
R1 vs. 272 F1; The Case of the
Woapink Lodges; Fraudulent Lodge
50 felt. Extremely limited - $40
Service, however, the Cuauhtli Lodge continued for a number of years
independently. This was partially because
Lodge 555, Gamenowinink was slow to
organize. In 1962 Gamenowinink Lodge
was chartered, but it was not until about
1969 that it became a viable lodge. Largely
through the efforts of individual Scouters,
Cuauhtli Lodge continued despite pressure
from National to merge. The one individual who stands out most for continuing
the rich traditions of Cuauhtli Lodge and
Scouts de America was Sam Atkins, a long
time member, and the last Advisor of the
lodge and his wife, Annette. Together they
ran the council as volunteers putting thousands of dollars of their own money into
Scouting. In 1971, the lodge officially
merged with Lodge 555 and Mr. Atkins
accepted this merger in 1973. In 1990 the
last tap out for OA members in Mexico
was held, with Mr. Atkins advising, as always, and Camp Aztec ceased to exist.
While Scouts de America, Camp Aztec and Cuauhtli Lodge are gone, the
badges remain as reminders of a unique
chapter in the history of the Boy Scouts
of America in a far away place. ❏
Credits:
John Bibo
Mrs. Annette Atkins
John Conley Williams
Volume 1, No. 2 July, 1993, 36 pages.
The Sateens of California; Air Scout Merit
Badges of the 1940’s and 1950’s; Labels
of the Standard Pennant Company; 254 F1
Discussed. Extremely limited - $35
Volume 2, No. 1 Winter, 1994, 32
pages. Ay-Ashe Lodge No. 73,; A Timeline
History of the Order of the Arrow; Origin of
Karankawa Lodge F2; Merit Badge
Collecting, An Update. Limited - $25
Back Issues of
The Journal
Are Available!
contact:
Volume 3, No. 1 Summer, 1995,
52 pages. The Dwight W. Bischel
interview, Gimogash Lodge 214;
Tribe of Gimogash: The Silent Power;
OA Back Patches. Available - $10
18
ASHS
2580 Silver Cloud Ct.
Park City, UT 84060
(435) 655-8899
Volume 4, No. 1 Spring, 1996, 44
pages. 1938 National OA Meeting; Eriez
Lodge 46 Chenilles; Merit Badges;
Uwharrie Lodge 208; 1938 OA
collection; Solid Ones. Available - $10
ON THE INTERNET
To all who are interested:
I will be the first to admit when I am
wrong, and do so now. An Internet poll of
Arapaho vs. Bluebook preferences was
taken. The tally is in and the following is
the breakdown. I was very disappointed
that only 45 out of 253 replied. That’s
worse than National Elections, folks. I
made it so all you had to do was check a
box and send (about 20 seconds) and
only 45 returned. I was shocked. Anyway
the breakdown:
Strongly for Arapaho II
Arapaho II
Both
Didn’t care
The Blue Book
Strongly for The Blue Book
1
1
3
6
30
4
Well that’s it folks, however please note:
A. Several felt that the dealers should be
ready to give either if called upon.
B. About 20 of the Blue Book votes were
concerned that The Blue Book will not
have the follow-through that it needs.
C. 4 thought The Blue Book had bugs
and corrections that needed attention.
D. 2 were totally fed up with the entire
hobby and the $$$ turn that it is
making, and felt the dealers and
serious collectors have destroyed the
pureness, and fun that this hobby once
gave them.
E. Of the 45 answers I believe about 35
were serious collectors. Only 1 was
new to it and he felt that both should
be used to help the little guy.
In conclusion I will soon be switching to
The Blue Book on my sales lists.
Hopefully someone will do a crossreference, and at that time I might use it
too.
Along the same line, I love Dave Franck’s
book for CSP’s, with the exception of the
# changes every year. And the fact that he
refuses to sell me a disk version, which
may cause me to do something else.
When I buy a collection of 2000 CSP’s
time is very important to me. I understand
that he doesn’t want it in an easily copied
format, however there are some that I feel
warrants his trust, as the dealers that keep
his book of interest. I list and sell more
CSP’s than any other dealer (my
specialty) and I need you to help me
persuade him.
Sincerely
Ben Gomm
Number 6 – Winter 1998
Researching Lodge Names
by Bruce C. Shelley
One feature of The Blue Book was an
attempt to list by number and name all
historic Order of the Arrow lodges. The
compilation of this list proved to be difficult and not without controversy. A
number of names were newly discovered
or had been seen rarely before. Others
were accepted more or less in the past. The
list that appeared in The Blue Book was
the best that could be produced by the time
of publication.
The purpose of this discussion is to
describe the research that went into assembling the list and the standards of
authenticity that were applied to the evidence for names. A number of individual
cases are discussed in detail.
I agreed to take the post of lodge listing editor for The Blue Book at the request
of John Pleasants. When the task was first
described for me at the Pre-NOAC TOR
in 1994, it involved building a list of all
lodges for which patches exist. For each
lodge basic information concerning charter dates, totem, council affiliation,
location, and changes (names and mergers) was to be included.
I began with a list of lodges to be included in The Blue Book that had been
distributed to the editors. More information was obtained from the many local,
regional, and national OA references that
are available to collectors. To help narrow
the possibilities for dating name changes
and mergers that are not precisely known,
I began acquiring lists of lodges from national publications.
As I neared the
completion of the
basic listing to the
best of my ability
and information,
several of the senior Blue Book
editors requested
that I expand the
listings to include every lodge that ever
existed, including all names. The goal was
to provide as much information as possible within reasonable space and research
time constraints.
I discovered quickly that it would be
difficult, if not impossible, to ever build
an accurate list of all lodge names for several reasons. First, some information is
difficult to find and may be lost forever.
There are no men left today who can recall the early history of many lodges,
especially those who’s history goes back
very far or those that were always very
small. Second, the information that is
available is often contradictory. It can be
difficult to tell when different spellings on
national lodge lists are typographical errors, new spellings, or new names. Third,
the evidence that is available has varying
degrees of authenticity, ranging from
lodge charters, membership cards, lodge
publications, insignia, and national lists to
hearsay, recollections, and opinion.
The highest weight of authenticity was
given to official documents, beginning
with lodge charters, lodge membership
cards, and lodge documents. Lodge insignia were given a high weight also. The next
level of importance was placed on official
regional and national publications that list
lodge names. These include minutes of
National Meetings, OA Bulletins, minutes
from regional meetings, and lists of lodges
prepared by National. The next level was
newspaper accounts of meetings or events.
The least weight was given to recollections and other hearsay evidence that could
not be documented in some manner.
Where the evidence that exists remained
contradictory or unclear, other editors and
I made a judgment.
such lists, unfortunately, ranging from
1936 to 1991. The most important of these
dated to 1955 or before. In a separate table
I have included the names listed from the
pre-1955 lists for a sample of lodges.
These samples illustrate some of the problems encountered. Across the top of the
columns in the table are a series of dates.
Each date refers to one list of lodge names
in existence at that date. (The table does
not include a column for the 1952 list. I
obtained this much later and the list is
missing several pages. It also does not include lists from OA Bulletins from 1943
and 1944 that I acquired after The Blue
Book was published.) The corresponding
references are the following.
1936: An appendix to the minutes of
the National Meeting of the Order
of the Arrow in 1936 that listed
all lodges present as reported by
the Attendance, Credentials, and
Registration Committees.
1938: A roster of active lodges as of
9/1/38 included with the minutes
of the National Meeting of the
Order of the Arrow.
1940: An appendix to the minutes of
the National Meeting of the Order
of the Arrow in 1940 that lists all
OA lodges (even those dropped
or merged).
5/48: A list of OA lodges by Area
from the Bulletin of the OA for
May 1948.
9/48: A list of OA lodges by Area
from the Bulletin of the OA for
September 1948.
6/49: A list of OA
lodges by Area
from the Bulletin
of the OA for
June 1949.
1951: The list of
lodges included
in the Wabaningo Lodge Emblem
Handbook, which was based on a
National lodge list from 1951
(now lost).
“The evidence that is available has varying degrees
of authenticity, ranging from official documents
and insignia to hearsay, recollections, and opinion”
Because official documents are difficult to obtain in many cases, I relied
heavily on the second level of evidence—
lists of lodges prepared by National or its
equivalent. I had available only about ten
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
19
1952: The National Order of the
Arrow Organizational Pattern and
Local Lodge Listing of 1952.
1953: The National Order of the
Arrow Organizational Pattern and
Local Lodge Listing of 1953.
1955: The National Order of the
Arrow Organizational Pattern and
Local Lodge Listing of 1955.
It was apparent from the start that
spelling errors were common on all lists.
Lodge names that are known to have never
changed in the periods covered by this list
might appear at various times with different spellings. This was due in part to the
unconventional names of many lodges that
derive from Native American languages.
For example, the name for Lodge 214 is
shown as Gimogash through 1951 and
then Gimogasm thereafter. Also, the name
of Lodge 298 is shown consistently as
Gorgonia and San Gorgonia when it was
always Gorgonio or San Gorgonio.
There are several cases where the
listed lodge name can be proven to be an
error. For example, the name for Lodge
339 in 1949 is shown as Genesee. I own a
photocopy of this lodge’s charter from
1949 showing that the name had been
changed to Tana-Wis-Qua (Fig. 1).
I have assumed that lodges were given
names at the moment they were chartered
but this may not be the case. I own photocopies of the 1943 and 1945 charters of
Ney-A-Ti 240. The 1943 charter was their
first and shows no name. The 1945 charter shows the name Ney-A-Ti. A history
of Black Eagle 482 posted on the Internet
states their lodge was not given a name
when it was chartered. If lodges were not
always given names when first chartered,
this fact would help explain why many
lodges have no name on several of the
National lists, even though the lodge is
shown as being in existence. The lack of
an official name may also explain why
some lodges are listed under their camp
name. In the early days of the Order,
lodges were often referred to by their community or camp affiliation. For example,
Lodge 2 was originally named Trenton
Lodge according to the 1990 OA 75th
anniversary history and a lodge history
posted on the Internet.
No distinction is made between names
that are different only in punctuation. For
20
example, Lodge 231 is spelled on different lists as Mi Ka No, Mi-Ka-No, and
Mikano. Lodge 278 appears as Yosemite
and Yo-Se-Mite. This is treated as the same
name.
An additional concern is what Jeff
Morley has called the ‘Crazy Horse effect.’
Crazy Horse Lodge 171 changed its name
first to a Native American spelling of
Crazy Horse, then a revised version of this
name, and than back to Crazy Horse. Although this case is well documented, there
may be older examples of the Crazy Horse
effect that remain a source of confusion.
An examination of the name changes
shown in Table 1 has interesting implications when compared to other OA lodge
references, including Arapaho II, Second
Edition Supplement 1993. The Arapaho
II authors based their listings on charters
and lists that were examined at the offices
of the National Council. However, they
may have made errors and all charters
were not available. In addition, I have been
told that most of the information available
to them did not go back before 1948 when
the OA became a national program.
Figure 1 – The 1949 lodge charter from Tana-Wis-Qua 339.
Number 6 – Winter 1998
lodge member Sandy Tallman
of Lodge 38’s history is
wrote that the original name of
the following. Shaubena
the lodge was Ottowa. The name
Lodge 38 was chartered
Ottowa is obviously an authentic
in 1928. It may have gone
Native American name. The
through several periods of
names Ohowa and Chowa could
inactivity and charter
easily be typographical misspelllapse before absorbing
ings of Ottowa, but the only
Pokawachne 45 in 1938.
evidence for Ottowa is hearsay.
At the start of 1941,
Member Dave Wolverton has
Lodge 38 changed its
been actively researching the
name to Inali. The new
history of this lodge for many
name in 1941 may
years and we have exchanged all
represent a new start for
the information we have on
the OA within the council
names. He may someday obtain
after its previous on and
Figure 2 – Detail of the 1943 lodge charter from
better evidence for the names of
off history.
Lodge 240 (no name shown).
this lodge.
52: The name of this
96: The list of 1936 shows the lodge
lodge is consistently spelled Chan
not yet in existence; the 1938 list
Owapi on all lists consulted.
Included below are discussions of inshows the name as Tesomas, also
Arapaho II lists the name as
dividual lodge names by number that may
the name of the principal council
Chan-O-Wapi, as do all patches
be considered controversial or surprising.
camp; the 1940 list shows the
issued by the lodge.
5: A history of this lodge published in
68: The name is
1942 mentions that the original
Watchung in 1936
lodge name was Indiandale, the
and 1938 (the
name of their camp, and that their
lodge was
totem was the Bison. The name
associated with
was changed to Minsi sometime
Watchung Area
before 1936 when that name
Council) and
appears in the minutes of the
Minquin from 5/
National Meeting. The totem was
48 to 6/49. From
changed to the wolf head at least
1951 on, the name
as early as 1926, which would
is Miquin. I have
imply the name changed along
copies of
with it.
Watchung lodge
membership cards
38: Arapaho II shows six names in
from 1936 and
use by this lodge prior to the
1938 owned by
formation of the new lodge in
Gene Berman and Figure 3 – Detail of the 1945 lodge charter from
1994 with that number. I couldn’t
Lodge 240 (Ney-A-Ti).
Bill Topkis, and
find evidence for all of these
copies
of
other
names and I believe there may be
name as Tomkita Chara. A camp
lodge documents using that name.
errors among them. One name,
booklet of the era mentions the
Pokawachne, was also the name
71: Arapaho II shows the name as
OA but not the lodge name. I
of neighboring Lodge 45 that at a
Chowa from 1933 until 1945
have recently obtained a copy of
later date either merged into 38 or
when it is changed to Na-Tsi-Hi.
the original charter for 1936 and
was absorbed by 38. Another
The reference lists show the name
it shows the name as Tomkita
Arapaho II name for 38, Indian
as Ohowa from 1936 through
Chara. The charter is dated 11/3/
Creek, also has ties to the same
1940, no name is shown for either
36, too late to appear in the 1936
neighboring council, Kewanee
1948 list, the name is Chowa in
National Meeting list. The charter
Council. The Camp Book lists a
1949, the name is changed to Nasuggests that the name was
camp in Kewanee Council by the
Tasi-Hi in 1951, and finally to
always Tom Kita Chara or some
name Indian Creek Lodge,
Na-Tsi-Hi thereafter. There is a
variant, but without documentary
suggesting a source of potential
patch contemporary with 1951
evidence contradicting the name
confusion. The National lists
showing the name Na-Tasi-Hi.
Tesomas for the year 1938, we
show no lodge 38 existing in
All later patches from the lodge
can never be sure this wasn’t an
1936 or 1938 and a Shaubena
show the name Na-Tsi-Hi. In a
example of the Crazy Horse
Lodge 38 in 1940. My judgement
1970’s collecting newsletter,
effect.
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
21
22
Number 6 – Winter 1998
Chan Owapi
Watchung
Ohowa
No name
No listing
1938
Chan Owapi
Minquin
Ohowa
No name
No name
No name
Tsalagi
1940
Sept. 1948
June 1949
Chan Owapi
Chan Owapi
Chan Owapi
Minquin
Minquin
Minquin
No name
No name
Chowa
Broad-Winged Hawk (appears also 9/48 and 6/49)
No name
No name
Colonneh
Delevan
Leekwinai
Leekwinai
Tsalagi
Tsalagi
Tslagia
Ojibway
Ojibway
Ojibway
Chequa
Chequa
Chequa
King Philip
King Philip
King Philip
Wahin’Kto
Wahin’kto
Wahin’Kto
Stanford
Stanford
Stanford
Gimogash
Gimogash
Gimogash
Chawtaw
Chawtaw
Chawtaw
Mi-Ka-No
Mi-Ka-No
Mi-Ka-No
Unalee
Unalee
Unali’yi
Meshepeshe
Meshepeshe
Meshepeshe
No name
Suriarco
Suriarco
Wakoda
Wakoda
Wakoda
No name
Tsisqan
Tsisquan
Cornplanter
Cornplanter
Cornplanter
Mow-A-Tox
No listing
No listing
Thunder City
Thunder City
Thunder City
Akonequa
Akonequa
Akonequa
Wewanoma
Wewanoma
Wenona
Nonotuck
Nonotuck
Nonotuck
Cimaroon
No listing
No listing
Kit-Chee-Ke-Ma Sakawawin
Sakawawin
Gorgonia
Gorgonia
Gorgonia
Cayucos
Cayucos
Miwok
No listing
No name
No name
No listing
No listing
Unilachtego
May 1948
1953
1955
Chan Owapi
Chan Owapi
Chan Owapi
Miquin
Miquin
Miquin
Na-Tasi-Hi
Na-Tsi-Hi
Na-Tsi-Hi
Equa-Tawa-Dee Equa-Tawa-Dee
Equa-Tawa-Dee
Colonneh
Colonel
Colonel
Leekwinai
Leekwinai
Leekwinai
Tsalgia
Tslagia
Tslagia
Ojibway
Ojibwa
Ojibwa
Chequah
Chequah
Chequah
King Philip
King Philip
King Philip
Wahin’Kto
Wahintko
Wahintko
Stanford
Stanford
Stanford
Gimogash
Gimogasm
Gimogasm
Pilthlako
Pilthlako
Pilthlako
Mi-Ka-No
Mikano
Mikano
Unali’yi
Unal’yi
Unal’yi
Ketchikeniqua
Ketchikeniqua
Ketchikeniqua
Semialachee
Semialachee
Semialachee
Wakoda
Apachedotte
Apachedotte
Tsisquan
Tsisquan
Tsiquan
No listing
No listing
Chief Cornplanter
Mow-A-Toc
Mow-A-Toc
Mow-A-Toc
Thunder City
Thunder City
Thunder City
Me-She-Kin-No-Quah (appears also in 1953 and 1955)
Wenona
Wewanoma
Wewanoma
Apinakwi Pita
Apinakwi Pita
Apinakwi Pita
No listing
No listing
No listing
Sakawawin
Sakawawin
Sakawawin
San Gorgonio
San Gorgonia
San Gorgonia
No listing
No listing
Cayucas
No name
No listing
Mahoning
Unilachtego
Unilachtego
Unilachtego
1951
Table 1 – Comparisons of name changes of official lists from 1936 to 1955.
1: Patch illustrated in Wabaningo book shows the name as Egwa-Tawa-Dee as it is has appeared on all lodge patches.
2: Council used Camp Delevan from 1926? to 1989.
3: In 1951 Fenimore Cooper Council (Wakoda 246) merged with Hendrik Hudson Council (Wiccopee 86) to form Washington Irving Council (Apachedotte 246).
4: In 1953 council changed name from Warren County to Chief Cornplanter.
5: The 5/48 listing also shows the council name as Cimaroon Valley when it was Cimarron Valley. Lodge name may have actually been Cimarron.
No listing
Watchung
Ohowa
52
68
71
1291
137
1572
163
173
194
195
199
207
214
229
231
236
238
239
2463
253
2554
262
266
269
272
277
2835
287
298
304
396
411
NOTES:
1936
#
newspaper photograph
he has seen that shows a
youth wearing a 137f1.
The spelling Colonel in
1953 and 1955 could be
a misspelling of
Coloneh and possibly
consistent with Coloneh
appearing on flaps.
There is some belief
that an OA lodge was
established in Houston
much earlier than now
accepted. The man who
helped found Lodge 36
Figure 2 – Detail of the 1943 lodge charter from
transferred to the
Lodge 240 (no name shown).
Houston area in the
1920s. Lodge 36 was
129: Arapaho II shows the name as
instrumental for much of the
Broad-Winger Hawk until the
spread of the OA in Texas. There
name was changed at an unknown
is a troop document from 1928
date to Egwa Tawa Dee. There is
that mentions the Order of the
no listing in 1936 and no name
Arrow existing at summer camp.
for 1938 and 1940. In 1948 and
A 1971 lodge history, revised in
1949 the name is Broad-Winged
1978, mentions that an early
Hawk. From 1951 the name is
name used by the lodge was
shown as Equa-Tawa-Dee, which
Mitigwa and that the totem was a
is probably a spelling error. The
beaver. Lodge 36 had been named
patch illustrated for the lodge in
Mitigwa originally. Colonneh
the Wabaningo book shows the
Lodge actually issued a 40th
spelling Egwa Tawa Dee, as it is
anniversary patch in 1968.
spelled on all lodge patches.
A lodge document from 1945
137: Most references show the
shows
the name “Houston
spelling as Colonneh throughout
Lodge,”
but this could be just a
the lodge’s history. First Flaps
contraction
of the expression “the
says the lodge name was Coloneh
lodge
in
Houston.”
until the middle 1950’s, as shown
138: Name is listed as Yoqui in
on the lodge’s first two flaps. The
Arapaho II but Yaqui on the
lodge does not appear on the lists
National lists. Yaqui is a known
of 1936 and 1938, and is shown
Native American name. I recently
with no name from 1940 through
acquired a set of membership
1948. (Robert Frizzell has located
cards that span the history of this
lodge documents that discuss the
lodge through its three names and
reformation of the Order of the
these confirm the dates of name
Arrow in Houston in 1945.) In
changes that appear in The Blue
1949 the name is Colonneh, as it
Book. The membership cards also
is in 1951. The name is spelled
confirm the name Yaqui. The
Coloneh for the first and only
published dates were derived
time in 1952, and then Colonel in
from examination of the lists
1953 and 1955. If the name was
available at the time.
indeed Colonneh in 1949, the use
of the name Coloneh on two
157: The 5/48 list shows the name as
successive patches could be a
Delevan, which was the name of
misspelling and or another Crazy
the principal council camp.
Horse effect. The Wabaningo
Thereafter the lodge name is
book says there were no patches
Leekwinai. The OA Bulletin of
up to 1951 but Robert Frizzell is
11/43 lists the name as Delevan
attempting to locate a 1950
in a chart of new and changed
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
lodge names. The name is also
listed as Delevan in the list of
lodges in the OA Bulletin of 3/44.
Lodge members say the early
charters are lost and no members
recall the name Delevan.
163: Arapaho II shows the lodge
name as Tslagi until it changed to
Tsalagi in 1987. The lodge name
is shown as Tsalagi in 1940,
1943, 1944, and 1948, changing
to the misspelled Tslagia on
following lists. The implication is
that the lodge name was originally Tsalagi until a new spelling
came into general use after 1955.
173: The lists show the name as
Ojibway from 1944 through
1952, changing to Ojibwa
thereafter. Ojibway could have
been a misspelling that was
carried forward until corrected in
1952.
194: Arapaho II shows the name as
Chequah throughout, as does the
list of 1944. The lists of 1948 and
1949 show the name as Chequa.
A controversial OA patch exhibits
the name Chequan but there is no
evidence associating this patch
with Lodge 194 other than the
similarity of the name. Wisconsin
collectors believe it is a chapter
issue from another unknown
lodge entirely.
195: Arapaho II shows the original
name as Ma-Ta-Cam and implies
the name was changed to King
Philip in 1965 when it merged
with Lodge 370. A patch exists
with the name Ma-Ta-Cam but
some people believe this was the
name of a lodge program, not a
lodge name. Lodge 195 appears
in lists of lodges in OA Bulletins
of 3/44 and 5/48 with the name
King Philip. These lists may predate the Ma-Ta-Cam patch. MaTa-Cam is the Native American
name for the Chief known to
colonists as King Philip.
198: Arapaho II lists the only name
for this lodge as Ottawa from its
charter date on 6/27/41 until it
merged away in January of 1945.
In the OA Bulletin of 11/43, the
Area P Leader notes that “Ba-Ta-
23
Wa-Ga-Ma Lodge of Iron Range
Area Council of Stambaugh has
undergone a reorganization and is
now under way with a full head
of steam.” The original name was
Ba-Ta-Wa-Ga-Ma, but changed in
1943 or 1944 to Ottowa. The
name is listed as Ottowa in the
OA Bulletin of 3/44.
199: Lists of 1948 through 1951
show the name spelled
Wahin’kto.
207: The lists show the name as
Stanford from 1948 through
1955. Other documentation
including newspaper articles and
section meeting minutes also
show the lodge name as Stanford.
I have heard that the name was
just Stanford until the OA also
moved to Camp Oljato. Thereafter, the lodge name changed to
Stanford-Oljato, a combination of
the names of the two council
camps. At least one California
collector says he knows a Scouter
who was a member of the OA in
lodge 207 prior to 1955 but who
attended Camp Oljato only.
226: Arapaho II shows this lodge
chartering in 1942 as Potawatomi
but changing its name later that
year to Ka’ Katowi Meshe-Ka. It
then disbands in 1948 and
recharters in 1956 as
Maunugezet. It then changes its
name at an unknown date to
Manquzet before merging in 1965
to form Chemokemon 226. The
OA lists show the lodge name as
Ka’Katowimeshe-Ka in 1948 and
on 6/49. Confusion over this
lodge’s name concerns what it
was called between Ka’ Katowi
Meshe-Ka and Manquzet, if
anything. Some believe the name
during this period was really
Manquzet all along. There are
eight variations of the third name.
• Maunugezet Arapaho II
• Maungezet 1951 list
• Maunguzet Wabaningo book
• Manuguzet 1952 list
• Maunguezet 1953 and 1955 lists
• Maunquzet on patch tradition
ally cataloged as
24
226x1 Manquzet
• Manqueset Appears in book
on Sinnissippi
Council history
• Mangueset Appears in book
on Sinnissippi
Council history
The Wabaningo book shows
the name as Maunguzet in 1951
but Dwight Bischel says he
believes that the list of 1951
originally showed the name as
Maungezet. He had this written
down in his records and then he
changed the spelling to
Maunguzet. He believes he made
the change following correspondence with the lodge. The OA
Patch Guide by Roy More says
the spelling on the 226x1 was the
actual lodge name at the time but
he has no evidence other than the
patch itself.
I have been researching this
lodge when time permits for
several years, but with little
success. I have yet to locate a
single document showing the
lodge name. The charter chief
remembers the 1942 name change
but not the second name or its
meaning. The 1952 chief did not
recall the name of his lodge at all.
My personal belief is that the
name changed to Manquzet when
the council opened Camp Offield
in 1947, giving them a summer
camp of their own for the first
time. They has previously used
Camp Oh-Da-Ko-Ta, where the
charter members were inducted.
236: The lists show the name as
Unalee in 1944 and 1948,
Unali’yi in 1951, and Unal’yi in
1953 and 1955. All of these
spellings may be typos of the
correct spelling Un A Li’yi.
239: The lists of 3/44 and 5/48 show
no name. The lists of 9/48 and 6/
49 show the name as Suriarco,
changing to Semialachee thereafter. Rick Obermeyer’s history of
this lodge, How True the Arrow,
says the lodge was first chartered
as Suriarco (from the first two
letters of the words in the council
name Suwanee River Area
Council) but that the name was
changed in 1948.
246: The lists of 1952, 1953, and
1955 show the name as
Apachedotte. Fenimore Cooper
Council (Wakoda 246) merged
with Hendrik Hudson Council
(Wiccopee 86) in 1951 to form
Washington Irving Council,
which merged with Yonkers
Council in 1955. The merger of
Wakoda and Wiccopee formed
Apachedotte Lodge 246, which
merged with Lodge 32 to form
Horicon 246. Jeff Morley has
corresponded with the man who
derived the name Apachedotte by
combining the names of two
Native American tribes—the
Apaches and the Wyandottes.
255: Arapaho II shows the name as
Chief Cornplanter until merging
in 1960, though the lodge
disbanded from 1950 to 1954.
The lists show the name as
Cornplanter in 1948 and 1949,
with no listing for the lodge in
1951 and 1953. The lack of
listings in 1951 and 1953 is
consistent with the disbandment
mentioned in Arapaho II. We
know that in 1953 Warren County
Council changed its name to
Chief Cornplanter Council. The
lodge may have changed its name
to Chief Cornplanter as well
when it rechartered in 1954.
266: From 1948 through 1955 the
lodge name is shown on the lists
as Thunder City. Earlier editions
of Arapaho II also list the name
Thunder City which was changed
in 1959.
269: The lists of 1948 and 1949 show
the name as Akonequa, changing
to Me-She-Kin-No-Quah
thereafter.
272: The lists show the name as
Wenona in 1949 and 1951, with
the name being Wewanoma both
before and after. A copy of the
1944 charter was published in the
TeePee Trading Post in the 1970’s
that shows the original name was
Wewanoma. A letter from Tom
Ball accompanied the photocopy
and he wrote that the name was
Number 6 – Winter 1998
1953, implying disbandment or charter lapse. First
1945-48 Cayucos
Doesn’t exist
Flaps says that a flap
1949
Miwok
Doesn’t exist
exists for Cayucos 304,
1950
Disbands?
Charters as Miwok
while others believe it was
1951
Doesn’t exist
Miwok
Miwok flap. According to
1952-54 Doesn’t exist
Disbands; doesn’t exist
the Wabaningo book,
1955
Recharters as Cayucas (typo?)
Doesn’t exist
lodge 304 had no patches
1956-57 Cayucas or Cayucos
Doesn’t exist
in 1951, when its name
1957/58 Changes name back to Miwok
Doesn’t exist
was already Miwok
1959
Miwok
Doesn’t exist
according to the 1949 list.
1960-61 Doesn’t exist
Doesn’t exist
The 1955 list shows the
1962
Reforms as Chumash
Doesn’t exist
name as Cayucas. This is
1964
Chumash
Recharters as Miwok
one of the most confused
Table 2 – Chart of possible name changes in lodges
of the lodge names and
304 and 439.
merits a much longer
discussion. Jeff Morley
believes that the 304 discussion
incorrectly spelled Wenona on a
must include the history of
number of National lists. Tom
Miwok 439 that chartered in
Ball’s testimony must be consid1950, existed for two years,
ered hearsay, however. Without
disbanded, and rechartered in
the evidence of charters from
1964. A possible chart of the two
1949, 1950, or 1951, the possibillodge’s changes is shown on the
ity remains that the lodge used
table.
the name Wenona for several
A possible 304/439 scenario
years (the Crazy Horse effect).
outlined by Jeff Morley goes like
When Dwight Bischel correthis. An exec from 304 transfers
sponded with the lodge in 1951,
to Santa Clara Council in 1950.
they were apparently using the
He takes the name “Miwok” with
name Wenona because that is
him to new council and starts OA
how he addressed them and they
there. Old lodge in Santa Lucia
didn’t correct him, according to
Council goes defunct because the
his notes. During that corresponold exec was the one who
dence, Mr. Bischel was given one
supported it. The OA fizzles in
of their sateen flaps by the lodge
439 after 1951. In 1955 guys in
chief. That correspondence is
Santa Lucia want OA again and
lost, unfortunately.
pick original name when they
283: Arapaho II and The Warshield
start again—Cayucos 304. They
show the name as Cimeroon
decide, however, that Miwok was
during the lodge’s short existence
correct name around 1957 or
from 1945 to 1948. The list of 5/
1958. Then the OA fizzles again
48 shows the name as Cimaroon
in Santa Lucia. A new group
and the council name as
restarts OA in Santa Lucia in
Cimaroon Valley. The council
1962 with new name Chumash.
name was actually Cimarron
In 1964, OA restarts in Santa
Valley and the lodge name may
Clara Council. They see the name
have actually been Cimarron.
Miwok is available, so they take
it.
304: Arapaho II shows the name as
Cayucos from 1945 to 1947,
396: Arapaho II shows the original
Miwok from 1947 until 1960
name as Nea-To-Ka in 1948,
(disbanded from 1950 to 1954,
changed to an unknown name in
and again in 1960), and recharter1949. The lodge with the uning again in 1962 as Chumash.
known name disbanded in 1951,
The lists of 1948 show the name
rechartering in 1953 as Mahoning
as Cayucos. The list of 1949
Lodge. The lists are consistent
shows the name as Miwok. There
with this information. The list of
is no listing for 1951, 1952, or
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
Date
Lodge 304
Lodge 439
5/48 shows no lodge existing.
The lists of 9/48, 6/49, and 1951
show the lodge existing but with
no name known. The lodge is
again not listed in 1953, but
appears in 1955 as Mahoning.
411: Arapaho II shows the name as
Unilachtigo from its original
charter in 1949 until merging in
1967. The lists consistently spell
the name Unilachtego from 1949
through 1955. Early patches from
the lodge are spelled Unalachtigo.
First Flaps and the OA Patch
Guide by Roy More assert
Unalachtigo is a different spelling
of the name. Several people recall
being told by old members that
the lodge was required to change
its name because it was the same
as lodge 168. These comments,
however, are hearsay without
documentary evidence. Later
patches issued by the lodge from
1950 to 1955 spell the name
Unilachtego, as on the lists. Old
members state that the lodge and
National recognized different
spellings for the name until the
lodge caved in and finally
accepted National’s spelling.
While this is hearsay, it would
explain and reconcile the conflicting evidence of lists and patches.
The name shown in Arapaho II
does not appear on any list or
patch.
These lodge names are examples of
the difficulties encountered preparing a
listing of all historic OA lodges. This work
continues and is to be updated in future
editions. New lodges are added to the database as they come into existence. We
continue to seek hard documentary evidence in those cases that are not yet
satisfactorily resolved.
The heavy reliance on the National
lists as documentary evidence is a compromise. When stronger evidence is found,
it takes precedence. I encourage anyone
who can provide such evidence, or who
can provide other information where it is
missing in the listings, to contact me or to
publish elsewhere so we can discover and
share the true history of the Order of the
Arrow.
25
Burden of Proof:
A Tale of Two Flaps
By Bill Topkis & Jeff Morley
Whenever an old vintage badge is “uncovered” the inevitable questions must be
asked about the authenticity of the find.
While no published standards exist to determine when a badge ought to be accepted
it seems clear that the following minimum
standards must be met:
1. The item must come from a
verifiable first hand source. That
means the original owner.
Hearsay should never be accepted
as fact. The proverbial “Old
Scouter” who refuses to have his
name released is as old an excuse
to cover a fraud as “my dog ate
my homework”.
2. Documentation should be
obtained from the original owner.
That includes membership cards
and supporting badges that would
be associated with the correct era.
This would not include unsigned
and undated documents that may
look supportive, but could be
fraudulent.
3. A written verification from the
first hand source should accompany the item.
In 1996 a new discovery was thrust
upon the hobby: a ritual team flap from
Waukheon Lodge 55 (Fig. 1). During the
last year two major Scout memorabilia
dealers aggressively marketed
this flap, first as
being an authentic
badge and then being the first flap
from the lodge.
Based upon their
assertions several
unsuspecting collectors paid large sums of money to
purchase this flap. Additionally in a rush
to publish, a major collector’s magazine
boldly printed a story proclaiming and promoting the supposed legitimacy of this
vidual in the lodge.
Therefore only hearsay evidence was
provided by Ed to either of the two Scout
dealers to support
any of his contentions. Ed sold these
two dealers between
13 and 17 examples
Figure 1– The 55 ZF1 Waukheon Lodge Ritual Team
of the badge at two to
flap, proven to be bogus.
three hundred dollars
badge. Unfortunately the Waukheon a piece in cash and trade.
Lodge 55 ritual team flap met none of the
After diligent research by the Ameriabove standards of proof.
can Scouting Historical Society, Ed was
The scout memorabilia dealers pur- confronted with irrefutable evidence that
chased these badges from long time scout the badges must be fakes. Ed confessed
collector Ed Hillenberg. Ed told the story that he indeed had made up the badges.
that these Lodge 55 Ritual Team flaps (At time of publication there appears to
came from an “Old Scouter”. Ed stated be evidence that a real “Ritual Team” flap
that his source did
not want his name
known and therefore
refused to provide
the name of the
source of the badges.
Ed further stated
that the badges were
from 1947 and therefore were the
valuable first flap of
the lodge. Ed pro- Figure 2– 146 F1, the newly documented first flap of
Tichora Lodge.
exists from Waukheon Lodge 55.
Date of issuance
has not yet been
determined.)
In contrast to
the Waukheon
Lodge fake Ritual Team flap, the newly
discovered Tichora Lodge 146 (Fig. 2) first
flap meets the burden of proof necessary
to confirm a badge as an issue of the lodge.
The example photographed was obtained
Lodge 55 “Ritual Team” Flap Proven to be Fake
Lodge 146 “Camp Service Conference” Flap Meets
the Standard of Authenticity
26
vided a stencil for the badge and a typewritten set of instructions on how to make
the badge. These documents did not come
from a verifiable source and were not
dated or able to be attributed to an indi-
Number 6 – Winter 1998
from an original member of the lodge,
John Lorimer, who earned the badge himself as a boy. He has provided a written
first hand statement verifying the usage
and significance of the badge. Furthermore, it was obtained on a badge vest that
bears his name on the front and other
badges of the era, mostly from his council and the surrounding councils, on the
back (Figures 3-5). Membership cards
were also obtained from Mr. Lorimer further substantiating his membership in the
Figure 5– John Lorimer’s badge vest., lower back.
Figure 3– John Lorimer’s badge vest.,
upper back.
when making their buying decisions. By
merely offering an item for sale they lend
credibility to the issue. It is paramount that
dealers vigorously question the authenticity of previously unknown items by
demanding non-hearsay information before offering them to the hobby, even if it
means foregoing substantial profits. We
must all accept that a minimum burden of
proof is required. It must be required of
the magazines, books and newsletters of
the hobby as well. They too have the duty
to properly verify “true” facts and not rely
solely on hearsay or the word of a second
hand party. By publishing without hard
facts they give false legitimacy to unsubstantiated claims and aid those that are
doing the hobby harm.
Will the fakers ever learn? If you make
a fake, eventually it will be found out by
the hobby. You will be stripped from the
hobby and become unwelcome in scouting.
If you discover a previously unknown
badge you have a duty to satisfy the burden of proof necessary to confirm the
issue. ❏
Figure 4– John Lorimer’s badge vest.,
front.
right place at the right time (Figure 6). This
type of evidence is undeniable and firsthand.
Fraudulent badges are a part of this
hobby. When someone can make a few
badges in their basement and sell them for
hundreds, if not thousands of dollars there
exists an unfortunate incentive for unscrupulous Scouts or Scouters to forget their
Scout Oath and the Scout Law. Indeed,
Blue Book has documented over 400 of
these fakes in Order of the Arrow collectibles alone.
Dealers must recognize that the hobby
looks to them to obtain knowledge of what
is legitimate and what is not. They need
to accept that potential buyers depend
upon the information that they provide
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
Figure 6– John Lorimer’s Boy Scout and
Explorer BSA Membership cards.
27
Overheard…
at the Trade-O-Ree
by Paul Myers
The NEW Philadelphia (Reading,
PA.) TOR got off to a good if somewhat shaky start. After several mediocre
years at Wilmington, the new location
is desirable and accessible. Short notice and scheduled on a Jewish holiday
hurt attendance this year but everything
looks good for the future. About 100
table renters this year and more local
walk through than before.
Reports from the Jamboree TOR’s
were that most dealers were pleased
while traders were somewhat unhappy.
I’m hearing that there will be 2 TOR’s
at pre-NOAC (Chris Jensen & NSCS)
and don’t think it will be as big a deal as
last NOAC. Dealers need an outlet to
sell common material to casual collectors while others, myself in particular,
have no interest in having hundreds of
casual collectors rummage through better material. Our hobby has grown too
big for aggressive dealers to allow others to influence their business.
Roy More has been criticized for not
providing the 2nd Bernie Miller sale book
in a timely manner. At Pittsburgh, Roy
told me that when he realized the book
was going to be late for the auction that
he went into a rewrite mode to make it
more useful. I have been told (October
‘97) that its in the mail.
Did you get everything you wanted
from the Jamboree? I was surprised at
the lack of Jambo material available at
the Philly TOR. Hardly anyone had
dupes of JSP’s or staff junk. Sale lists
immediately after the Jambo carried lots
of items but I wonder if after Jambo anyone cares. This might be a new
phenomenon, the Yoda or Cat in the Hat
etc. JSP’s are only desirable to kids at
the Jamboree. The pocket patch and
neckerchief was all that I cared about.
28
Aggressive “diggers” have been
advertising in local papers for rare OA
badges for many years. With the advent of personal 800 numbers, ads
are increasing. Some dealers are
employing people to research and dig
up valuable items. If you know local
people who have valuable material,
advise them of the value and express
an interest. It’s too late after they’ve
sold the items by mail.
John Bibo, well-known national
trader and longtime collector is selling his massive collection through The
Scout Patch Auction. Paul Biggs disposed of his OA and memorabilia
collection in the spring. Nelson Engles
is selling due to health problems. Expensive OA material seems to be
leveling. Did you see the 219F (slight
use) on Brush Creek ’s sale for
$2800? I paid $4500 for mine in
1988. I’m told there were four 219’s
available at the Jambo TOR’s.
TOR etiquette— BUYERS: if you
acquire something at below market
value don’t go around bragging and
don’t put the item on your table for a
higher price, at the same event.
SELLERS: if you don’t know what
your stuff is worth, don’t put it on your
sale table. Contact a dealer or a price
realized guide, before the TOR. If you
absolutely must have top dollar, send
the item off for auction. ❏
OPINIONS EXPRESSED ARE THOSE OF THE
AUTHOR AND NOT NECESSARILY THOSE OF
THIS PUBLICATION .
(continued from page 4)
can be contacted at 11513 Sutters Mill
Cir., Gold River, CA 95670-7203-1 Telephone (916) 638-7314.
It would be interesting to know if a
photograph of the Moqua Chapter of the
Owasippe Tribe has survived the years. It
would also be interesting to learn if anyone knows about the Order of the Arrow
pins, which appear to have awarded to
Scouts who became Ordeal Members.
Thank you again for sending me a
copy of the Journal. I would like to eventually prepare an article for publication
on my fathers scouting career and become a member of the Historical Society.
Yours in Scouting
David Clement
Eagle Scout
Gold River, CA
Dear [Editor]:
Congratulations on the 1996 Spring
Issue of the Journal. The cover picture
and the accompaning article of the “Class
of 38” was outstanding. I could identify
several of the St. Louis area scouts and
scouters from the cover photo. I would
like to obtain a copy of the photos in the
article and any others that may be available from that event. Irondale was a
favorite long term camp from the early
twenties until it closed in the fifties.
Thanking you in advance,
John H. Remelius
Number 6 – Winter 1998
Dear [Editor]:
I enjoyed the article on Class of 38
in the Journal. You may or may not
know that in 1930 the two founders of
Suanhacky lodge were Joe Brinton and
Charles Heistand (brother of Robert). I
wrote a book on the history of Queens
Council and the order of the Arrow from
its founding in 1915. Unfortunately, its
still in manuscript. I am trying to get the
lodge and have been trying for 4 years to
publish it.
I actually met Charles Heistand in
1980 as he was our guest of honor at the
1980 50th Anniversary Banquet. I never
met Joe Brinton but did correspond and
speak with him several times.
The last time I spoke with him was
about 1992. He was well aware of all the
changes in the Order of the Arrow. He
always stayed informed so he really did
keep up with the OA at least until 1992.
I believe he passed away in 1994 or
thereabouts. Technically his letter is correct; but not in substance. i.e. In 1936
Queens Council broke up into 8 districts
and 8 district service divisions of the OA
were formed to service each district.
These district service divisions evolved
into chapters, as he states, in the 1940’s
but really didn’t have names until the
late 1950’s. So although they weren’t
officially chapters until the 1940’s they
were district service areas in the late
30’s. They were called Chapter Two of
Jackson Heights for example. In the late
50’s District Two adopted the name Ta
Wa Pa Ki. So too District One with
White Buffalo (Woapsu Sisilijia) and so
on. By 1960 there were 12 districts and
12 chapters. In 1964 all were merged
into North, East, South, West and
Rockaway. Then West was split in two,
North in two in the 70’s. In the 80’s
North was reformed as Dan Beard,
Rockaway was absorbed by South who
became Tomahawk. This year, 1996 a
new reorganization took place. There
will be only 3 districts as of June 1st.
Take care. WWW,
Dr. Eugene M. Berman
Jackson Heights, N.Y.
MANY OF YOU HAVE ASKED WHERE WE HAVE
BEEN FOR SO LONG , WELL PUBLISHING THIS
J OURNAL HAS BEEN MORE WORK THAN WE
EVER EXPECTED. S INCE THE LAST J OURNAL
WE HAVE HAD MANY DISTRACTIONS . The
Blue Book, MOVING HALF WAY ACROSS THE
COUNTRY (B ILL, J ODY , JAKE C OREY AND
ALEC ARE NOW LIVING IN PARK CITY , UT)
AND HAVING A BABY (T OM AND V ALERIE
HAD A BABY GIRL, EMMA ) HAVE ALL TAKEN
UP ALOT OF TIME . T HE PLAN IS TO PUBLISH
AT LEAST ONE J OURNAL A YEAR . ✯
Investors and Sellers
Services
If you have patches to sell
or need an honest appraisal
of your collection give us a
call. You can consign your
patches to appear on this
auction or we buy collections
outright at fair prices.
Furthermore, if you are an
investor looking to assemble
a quality portfolio of investment grade patches, let us
know. Whether you acquire
them from us or any other
dealer our advice on prices
and which pieces to buy will
be invaluable to your
success. Contact:
Bill Topkis
(435) 655-8899
Dr. Jeff Morley
(415) 474-1555
SEEKING
Civil War-related
Scout Memorabilia
Historic Trails • Pilgrimages
Commemoratives
buy – sell – trade
John Snead
3040 South Eugene St.
Baton Rouge, LA 70808
(504) 346-8540
[email protected]
Journal of The American Scouting Historical Society
29
The Auction in the Journal
Closes Friday, February 20, 1998
CALL (435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899 or Email topkis@ sisna.net
RULES OF THE AUCTION
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
This auction closes on Friday, February 20, 1998. All mail bids MUST be received by this day.
Telephone bids will be accepted anytime prior to the auction and on auction day February 20, 1998 from noon until
midnight Eastern Time (9:00 Pacific) or at any time after that there has been 15 minutes between calls
All telephone bids must be for at least 10% over the current high bid.
All bids are an offer to buy. Any errors in listing will be refunded.
We reserve the right to reject any or all bids.
The reserve amount is a true reserve. No bids will be accepted below the reserve. All patches with a bid at or above the
reserve will be sold.
If you have questions regarding the condition of any item, feel free to call anytime between the hours of 9:00 a.m. - 9:00
p.m. (Pacific Time). If we are not available, leave a message.
FREE CALL BACK SERVICE - Please note on your write in bids or indicate during the bidding that you desire a call
back. If your bid is no longer the high bid, we will call you back and offer you an opportunity to place a new bid until you
drop out. You will only be allowed to bid on those items which you requested call back on, or lots which did not receive a
reserve bid. Please take advantage of our free call back service. We suggest that you bid early to avoid
the congestion on the final auction night. With the free call back you can not lose a badge without
getting an opportunity to raise the bid.
RULES OF THE SET PRICE SALE
•
•
•
•
•
•
All items are priced as marked and will be sold on a first come, first served basis.
O/A items have been identified using the The Blue Book.
If you call in your order, you will find out immediately which items are available for purchase.
All items will be held 9 days for payment.
You may mail in a list of patches you would like. Please enclose a check for the total amount, including shipping (or
credit card number and expiration date), We will send a refund for any item already sold. Please list any alternate items
you would like if your first choice is not available.
Please include your address with all orders. If you request overnight delivery, please include a street address, not a P. O.
Box, UPS is unable to deliver to a P. O. Box.
Make all checks out to Bill Topkis.
Send all payments to:
Bill Topkis
2580 Silver Cloud Ct.
Park City, UT 84060
Credit Card, Cashiers Check and Money Order payments will be shipped in two working days. Badges will be held until
personal checks clear.
All Auction and Sale items will be shipped via UPS or U.S. Mail, your choice. Please indicate your preferred shipping
method. If no shipping option is selected, we will ship via UPS. The cost of shipping will be calculated using our 10-51 method, you have three choices:
UPS Second Day Delivery ............................... $10.00
First Class Insured Mail ..................................... $5.00
First Class Mail (you assume all liability) ....... $1.00
Mastercard and Visa accepted. A 3% surcharge will be added to all credit card payments.
Financing is available on purchases over $1,000.00. Please arrange financing by February 18th by calling Bill Topkis at
(801) 655-8899 or (435) 655-8899 or Email to [email protected].
Limited quantities of Green Book II are available for $10.00 and First Flaps for $12.00 per copy.
30
The Auction in the Journal
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Special Lodge 15 Sale
The American Scouting Historical Society recently acquired the
collection of one of the largest collectors from lodge 15 during
the1950’s. Included in the collection was his trading stock from
his own lodge. The American Scouting Historical Society is
making these rare, 40 year old patches available on a limited
first come-first served basis. We are able to offer these classic
and historic patches at a significant discount to allow all collectors
to take advantage of acquiring these special patches for their
own collections. No matter what your collecting interest, this is
a rare opportunity to put away a special keepsake at well below
retail value.
The Auction In the Journal
Part One:
The Dwight Bischel Auction
The American Scouting Historical Society is pleased to present
for auction the Dwight Bischel collection It is the most significant OA collection ever to be presented for sale. As we have
reported in prior issues of The Journal, Dwight was the father of
modern OA collecting with his seminal work, The Wabiningo
Lodge Emblem Handbook. Each badge sold from Dwight’s collection will be accompanied by a handsome certificate personally
signed by Mr. Bischel.
Package 1:
The First Flap Package Chappegat F1 and Mide F1
(Retail value $175)
Package 2:
Chappegat Issue Package Upside down flap and
Chappegat F2 (Retail Value
$175)
Package 3:
Fun Pak - Chappegat 35th
Ann. Neckerchief, Chappegat
hosted1953 2A Section
Conclave badge, Chappegat
1957 leather X-mas banquet
slide, Mide F2, Mide 1958
Christmas Banquet slide &
1950's Camp Siwanoy 3" c/e
R (Retail value $100)
Part Two:
Auction
A selection of fine scouting collectibles is offered for auction in
Part Two of the Auction in the Journal. Bids are due on 2/20/98.
Free call-backs are offered.
Special ASHS Sale Price:
Package 1 - $95
Package 2 - $95
Package 3 - $50
Part Three:
Set Price Sale
Discounts – Buy 2 packages - 10% discount
Buy all 3 package - 20% discount ($192)
Limit 3 sets of all three packages - special price $450
While supply lasts, quantities are limited.
A selection of scouting collectibles is offered for sale in Part
Three of the Auction in the Journal. This is a set-price sale on a
first-come, first-served basis. Call for availability.
First come first served.
Auction Closes: Friday – February 20, 1998
(435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
31
The Dwight Bischel Auction
Wabaningo
Lot
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
Item
1
5
6
7
12
15
22
29
33
38
40
43
50
50
54
57
65
67
71
77
79
81
91
104
110
118
119
125
134
142
162
168
180
184
197
197
212
227
229
232
237
254
257
282
292
296
302
307
309
317
326
349
353
360
376
386
388
395
401
426
431
R8
X3a
C2a
R2
X2
X3
X1b
X1
F1a
X2
R2
S1a
R1
X1
R1b
R4
R1
C6
X1
X2
X1
A1
X1a
R1
A1
R1a
X1
R1
R1a
R1a
R1
F1a
R1
R1
A1
A2
R1
R3a
A1
X1b
A1a
A1
R1
X2
X1a
R2
A1a
R4
A2a
R2a
R3
A1a
X1a
R1a
R1b
R1b
A2
R1
R2a
R2a
R1a
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C RED RED GRN
GRY GRY
YOR M/C
C LBR PGR RED
R RED WHT RED
C RED BLK YEL
RED WHT
C WHT RED YEL
DGR
C BRN WHT RED
C DYL WHT RED
C KHA KHA
C RED WHT RED
C WHT RED
C WHT RED WHT
WHT WHT
C DBL BLU DBL
BRN LBR
C YEL GRN YEL
C YEL WHT BLU
C RED DBL GRN
C WHT GRN WHT
C WHT BLK DGR
C RED GRN YEL
C WHT WHT RED
C LBR WHT RED
C RED ORG RED
C WHT RED
C GRN WHT RED
C DGR WHT DGR
C DYL RED LGR
C DGR WHT RED
C RED WHT BLU
C RED NBL WHT
C GRN WHT RED
C GRY RED WHT
C RED WHT RED
C DYL DBL RED
C DBR WHT RED
C BLK GRN WHT
C RED WHT GRN
C LBR YEL LBR
C GRN WHT RED
DYL DBL DBL
C RED WHT DBL
C WHT WHT BLK
C BLK RED WHT
R BLK WHT RED
C GRN WHT GRN
C GRN WHT RED
C RED WHT DBL
C BLK RED
C BRN ORG RED
C RED BLU BLK
C RED WHT BLK
C DBR WHT RED
C RED WHT DGR
C RED WHT BLK
C GRY BLK GRY
C BLK WHT BLK
C RED ORG BLU
Description
Reserve
twill VER head; (WAB)
$30
solid EMB wolfhead on felt w/o
$50
T-bird flat head; type 6b label
$30
WAB; EMB on felt
$50
Light box soil;TRI; DYL eagle;
$50
WAB; 75 mm beaver that looks like $100
type 5a label; WAB
$40
dots between OA and name; WAB; $30
WAB; arrow & deer on twill; FF; thin $500
twill; 4 mm wheels; (WAB)
$30
bird has ring neck & twill in tail;
$60
DBR cabin; RED stitch from cabin to $100
WAB
$60
EMB arrow goes behind R1 or R2;
$20
thk ltrs poorly defined arrows; WAB; $30
felt; VER EMB squirrel; WAB; (1947) $50
WAB
$30
DYL center stripe; OLV chipmunk;
$75
NA-TASI-HI; twill; OVAL; 58x93
$40
oval; bird has distinct claws; twill;
$30
HEX; WAB; 75x75 mm; DIAg stitch $40
DBN buffalo; WAB
$40
WAB; oval shape; thin letters;
$40
one arrow points to the "E" in "THE" $60
WAB; 13 mm tall RED arrowhead;
$30
WAB; TL; GRY/BRN used in design $50
BLU heron on tepee; (WAB)
$75
4x5 mm arrowhead; WHT arrowshaft $90
WAB; no GRN beaded bdr on inside $70
WAB; TRR; RED fletching ends to $30
WAB; no tab; LGR line (beads)
$30
head under "O"; FF; WAB; 3 mm
$40
WAB; light box soil
$30
WAB; TL
$50
WAB; RED Native American; GRN $30
WAB; GRY details; WHT band $30
WAB
$30
TLR
$30
no 229; WAB
$100
63x87 mm; TLS; WAB
$60
5 mm border; NT; WAB
$70
WAB; (possible MVE bkgd color)
$300
all HOR BLK bear w/ears together; $40
BSA; flocked on felt; "ORDER OF
$175
OCT; WAB; TRR
$30
light use; VER BLU circle; short last $90
WAB; lighter RED TRR; "pegs"
$75
76 mm; FR/E; (1951); WAB
$150
thin ltrs; 1st S&U link @ bottom;
$50
TRR; WAB
$40
75 mm; "WWW" inside state; WAB $80
WHT heron; WHT "WWW"; WAB; $60
8 mm council name & "353"; BRN
$75
10 mm BLK in left wing; WAB; HOR $40
TLS DBN beaver; WAB
$90
WAB
$30
RED WWW; solid RED feather; 24 $110
WAB; 73 mm RND; HOR YEL; TRR $50
HOR GRN center; TRR; WAB
$30
TRR; HOR RED fire 15 mm along
$40
9 mm ltrs-name; 75 mm twill; TR;
$30
Names and Numbers
Lot
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
32
Item
73
106
167
216
227
267
279
R5
F2
X1
S2a
S2a
F3
X2a
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C BLK
C GRN
C M/C
R BLK
R DBL
R RED
C RED
MAN BLK
WHT BLK
M/C BLK
M/C RED
WHT RED
WHT BLK
ORG GRN
Description
Reserve
$200
$125
BLK "WOLPENK" lodge; Ambraw
$100
"1" of "216" touches bottom left of
$25
YEL t-bird; square corners; tags from $75
LB
$90
GRN leaf smoothly EMB; 23 mm
$40
(1953)
The Auction in the Journal
The Dwight Bischel Auction
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
352
376
390
403
411
419
442
470
496
R1
F2
F1
F1a
A1
S1
F1
X1
F1
C GRN WHT BLK
C DGR WHT RED
C RED GRY RED
C RED LBL WHT
C RED WHT RED
R DYL M/C BLK
C BLK BLU RED
C DBL BLU RED
C WHT LBL RED
RED "WWW"
$60
straight top bdr; no eye
$450
FF
$450
FF; 122x60 mm; TLR; 105 mm BLK $125
w/ "411"; twill arrowhead; 100x80 mm $90
LB
$100
FF
$100
tooth shape; (1953)
$200
wave behind canoe; FF; TLS
$450
First Flaps
Lot
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
Item
4
6
7
16
17
18
26
33
41
42
51
55
58
63
64
66
77
82
93
94
95
100
104
108
113
114
128
129
139
146
147
149
150
156
162
167
170
171
172
173
175
184
190
191
194
197
201
211
225
228
230
232
236
239
244
248
249
254
268
271
282
284
286
F1
F1b
F1b
F1c
F1a
F1
X6
F2b
F1
F1a
F1a
F1
F1
S1d
F1a
W1
F1
F1
F1a
F1b
F1
F1
S1
F1a
F1b
S1a
F1
S1a
F1
S1b
F1
F1
F1
F1
F1b
F1b
F1b
F1
F1
F1
S1b
F1a
F1
S1a
S1b
S1b
F1
F1a
F1a
F1
S1
F1a
F1b
S1a
F1a
F1
F1b
S1a
F1
F1a
F1a
F1
F1
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R WHT LBL BLK
C BLK WHT RED
C BLK WHT BLK
C RED WHT BLK
C RED WHT BLK
C RED WHT BLK
C DBL RED DBL
KHA
C DYL WHT RED
C RED DGR RED
R WHT BLK RED
C DBL DYL RED RED
C RED WHT DBL
C M/C GRN WHT
C RED DGR RED
DBL LGY RED
C RED WHT DBL
R ORG WHT RED
C RED WHT RED
C RED LBL
C RED WHT BLU
C WHT WHT RED
C RED WHT RED
C RED DBL WHT
R RED WHT
C DBL WHT LOL
C WHT BLK WHT
R DBL YOR DBL
C RED WHT GRN
C RED WHT RED
R RED WHT RED
C WHT LBL WHT
C RED ORG BLK
C RED WHT RED
C DYL WHT DGR
C BRN WHT BLK
C M/C YOR BLK
C RED GRN YEL
C DYL BLK DYL
C RED ORG DBL
C RED LGY RED
C RED DBL LGY
C BLK ORG BLK
C WHT WHT DBL
C RED BLK DYL
C DBL YEL BLK
C DYL LBL RED
R RED LBR BLK
C YEL GRN RED
C GRN WHT RED
C RED WHT BLK
C BLK GRN WHT
C GRN WHT RED
R WHT M/C RED
C RED WHT BLK
C WHT BLU WHT
C DYL BLU DBL
C GRN BLK WHT
C RED WHT RED
C RED WHT GRN
C RED WHT DBL
C BRN LBR BRN
C BLK WHT RED
Description
Reserve
52x125 mm; MTZ; owl on stump; FF $10
thin letters
$10
thin bdr; thin BLK letters
$15
thick BLK outline around WWW;
$10
FF; arrow touches deer's tail
$20
FF
$40
70 mm high; straight sides; FF; twill $30
LBR deer; TLR
$400
no details in wings; FF
$200
closed eye; FF
$30
LGR/ St. Louis cncl; FF; FR/E; no
$15
has round head; BSA; FF
$20
FF; RED "DOTS" around bustle;
$50
GRN base material
$25
HOR EMB stag; FF; TRR
$70
"NEY"; FF; (1959)
$20
RED WWW; FF
$20
MTZ; FF
$20
FF; 5 mm fletching
$30
small eye
$30
FF
$30
without "100"; FF; (1957)
$100
FF
$20
FF; 122 mm; RBR head
$30
TLR; FF
$150
FF; WHT BMT
$30
RED WWW; FF
$30
no number; FF; (1957)
$60
VER; BRN deer
$40
RBR pine cone
$300
55x134 mm; flat R/E; owl; fletching $20
FF; WHT eyes; TLS; distinct WHT $40
(1955); MVE; FF
$40
FF; WHT buttonhole (uncut!)
$100
thin letters
$20
LGY possum; fur line runs across body $30
legs of "W's" same height as middle; $20
FF
$60
3.5-4.5 mm thick CE; arrowhead not $30
BRN house; FF
$30
both parts of arrowhead are barbed
$60
closed eye; TLR; FF
$30
arrowhead 8 mm wide; skinny HOR $300
WHT BMT; FF
$20
3 mm BLK eye
$40
VER; DBL BMT
$20
oversized flap; rounded bottom; FF; $150
8 mm letters; FF; arrowshaft stitched $10
FF; fat points that extend to edge of $100
FF
$95
BLK eye; (1956)
$60
117x60 mm; fletch touches "W";
$60
TLR; thin letters
$50
LBL sky; 135 mm; thin BLK outline; $40
DYL WWW; GRN turtle; TLR; BLK $90
pine tree has BRN trunk; FF
$50
RED arrowhead extends onto DYL
$30
thin border; BLK BMT; (FF) MVE
$30
A.R.; FF
$20
semi-circle shape; FF; YEL turtle and $200
FF
$50
FF
$50
RED WWW; FF; (1956)
$50
Auction Closes: Friday – February 20, 1998 (435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
33
The Dwight Bischel Auction
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
287
297
308
310
316
320
322
329
345
357
360
368
378
384
390
397
406
408
409
425
431
438
441
443
445
450
458
460
461
465
486
488
489
512
513
522
529
534
566
F1b
F1
F1a
F1b
S1
S1a
S1b
F1
F1
F1
F1
S1b
F1b
F1c
S1a
F1a
S2
F1a
F2
S1b
F1a
F1
F1
F1
F1b
F1b
F1c
X1
F1a
F1
F1b
F1
F1
F1
F1
F1
F1
S1
S1a
C DYL GRN BLK
C RED WHT BLK
C RED WHT BLK
C BRN WHT RED
R WHT BLK WHT
R RED BLU DBR
C WHT RED DYL
C BLK ORG RED
R RED BLK WHT
C DGR WHT RED
R DYL LBL RED
C M/C BLK RED DYL
C DBL ORG DBL
C DGR WHT RED
R RED M/C BLK
C YEL LBL RED
R DBL WHT RED RED
C DYL WHT RED
C DBR WHT BLK
C DYL BLU RED BLK
C RED ORG BLU
C BLK WHT RED
C RED LBL RED
C WHT ORG RED
C DGR RED WHT
C DGR WHT DGR
C LGY NBL LGY
C BLK WHT
RED
C LGY YEL RED
C DYL LBL RED
C YEL WHT BLU
C BLU WHT RED
C DBL ORG DBL
C DYL BLK DYL
C BLK WHT BLK
R GRY BLK ORG
R WHT RED WHT
R DBL WHT YEL
R WHT M/C WHT
3D cut in tree; 7mm thin tail; MVE $40
FF; 123 mm wide; no "76"
$2500
FF; "O" of "OA" has squared corners $30
$100
FF
$100
FF; LB; (1964); WHT throat bordered $50
left wing completely connected to
$50
FF
$50
FF
$250
FF
$40
MTZ; FF; FR/E; MVE -- bkgd shades $10
WHT BMT; RED outline of feathers $10
121x53 mm; 6 mm wide fletch; FF
$350
TRR (looks like NT)
$50
FF; HOR EMB sky; thick HOR BLK $60
FF; 3 mm bdr; 7 mm RED letters
$40
FF; B.S.A.
$10
6 mm ltrs; 91 mm arrow; MVE; FF
$25
LBL waterfall
$30
BRN council name; ORG BMT
$25
FF; BRN acorn
$30
FF
$125
FF
$150
GER; FF
$50
60x121 mm
$50
TLM; "G & E" of "LODGE" tag @
$50
56x120 mm
$20
BSA; Viking helmet shape w/ horns; $35
TLR; 51x95 mm; FF
$100
55x123 mm; 3-4 mm thick CE; no
$100
"L" has no tag; FF
$125
FF
$150
122x55 mm; FF; (1953)
$250
WAH-PI-KAW-ME-KUNK; FF
$400
FF
$50
FF
$15
FF; F R/E; WHT anteater
$70
A.R.; FF; MVE
$10
FF; PCH CORAL;
$15
Region 1 - New England
Lot
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
Item
83
83
124
164
195
217
220
234
245
261
271
274
277
313
319
329
329
369
369
389
393
393
414
451
487
491
507
509
S1
YA2
S1
R1a
A1b
r2b
R2
P1a
A1a
S2
F3a
R1
R2b
F2
X1
F2
S1
X2a
S1
S2
X2b
S3
R2
F2a
X1
A1
A2
S2b
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R DBL BLU DBL
C DGR RED
R BLK GRY BLK
C RED GRY RED
C YEL WHT RED
C RED WHT BLK
C RED WHT BLK
C BLK BLU RED
C RED WHT RED
R RED M/C BLK
R RED WHT GRN
C WHT LBL WHT
C BLK DYL BLK
R RED NBL WHT
C BLK WHT RED
R BLU YEL RED
R DBL YEL RED
C RED DGR YEL
R RED GRN YEL
R BLK M/C RED
C BRN WHT RED
R RED BLU WHT
C BLK WHT RED
R RED WHT GRN
C RED LBL BLK
C RED WHT RED
C RED WHT RED
R DYL M/C BLK
Description
Reserve
$15
EMB twill like YA1; confirmed camp $25
25th ANN
$20
BLK outline stump; MVE-twill shades $90
squarish O & D; 6 mm high thk ltrs in $25
separate top chest detail lines
$30
MVE
$30
thin letters; MVE
$35
thick letters; near round head; TRM $60
Minuteman has two feet; MVE--angle $10
"P" in Pine at an angle to the "I"; 104 $15
A.R.
$40
TRM; smooth EMB arrow; DYL twill $45
$10
OVAL
$40
$30
HOR bkgd
$20
Machine sewn; WHT feather
$20
53x119mm; LB
$15
VER Mts; no stitch in ribbon
$15
thin 7 mm ltrs; WWW has only 3
$25
lightly outlined eastern shore
$10
8 mm rnded ltrs; 50 mm inner CIR;
$35
GRN turtle
$10
WHT paddle handle
$20
twill; arrow behind Native American $60
7 tail feathers on eagle; detailed
$40
regular R/E; MVE
$20
New York & New Jersey
Lot
208 2
34
Item
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
F1a R RED DBL DYL
Description
TLR; FF; (1957)
Reserve
$15
The Auction in the Journal
The Dwight Bischel Auction
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
4
4
4
9
9
14
19
24
34
37
37
48
49
49
49
68
84
95
112
159
165
178
181
267
268
294
339
339
359
359
360
362
402
412
412
417
418
423
440
443
444
449
484
515
516
547
A2
S3
N3b
R2
S2a
R2
S3
A1b
A1b
X4
F2
A3
F3a
F3c
S2a
X1a
R4
R1
R1
F2b
X1
A1a
A1
X1a
F4a
R1
F3b
W1
R1a
R1b
S1
A1
R1
R1
F2
S1
S3b
R2c
R1
R1
R1
R1
A2
F7a
F1a
S1
C WHT LGR BLK
R GMY M/C BLK
WHT M/C
C RED WHT RED
R BLK M/C BLK
C RED GRY RED
C DGR DGR RED
C RED WHT DBL
C BLK GRN WHT
C BRN LBL YEL
R BRN TRQ DYL
C RED WHT WHT
R DYL LTQ RED
R DYL LTQ RED
R BLK RED YEL
C WHT BLU RED
R DBL ORG YEL
R RED WHT BLU
C RED WHT BLU
C BLK WHT GRN
C RED YOR LGR
C YOR BLK YOR
C GRN WHT RED
C BLK WHT RED
R DBL WHT RED
C DBL ORG RED
C RED WHT DYL
ROR GRY ROR
C BLK ORG GRN
C BLK YOR DGR
R DYL BLU RED
C DGR WHT BRN
C DYL WHT RED
C RED WHT GRN
C OLV BLK ORG
R DBR M/C BLU
R GRY M/C BLK
C RED DBL DYL
C GRN RED DYL
C WHT ORG BRN
C RED GRN RED
C DGR LBL RED
C ORG WHT RED
R WHT LBL WHT
R RED YEL BRN
R BLK WHT BLK
$10
$10
$15
$30
$10
$50
$40
$15
$30
$20
$25
$60
$10
$10
$5
$20
$15
$20
$30
GRY face; RBR longhouse; lighter
$30
83x78 mm DOME
$30
98x78 mm arrowhead twill; Robert
$30
115x78 mm including tab
$50
BLK/YEL bdr; pointed nose; square $50
TLR; 77 mm arrow; "ODGE" link @ $10
74 mm with protruding arrowhead
$35
RBR beaver; RED arrowhead 3 mm $25
$25
65 mm; MVE
$10
69 mm; MVE
$10
SQU corners; MVE--GRN shades
$5
5 mm ltrs; 76x66 mm; arrowhead;
$20
75 mm; TLS; arrowhead points into $30
$30
MTZ; 52x124 mm; 6-7 mm wide
$10
$5
LGY wolf outlined in BLK
$15
75 mm twill; WHT feet & BLK beak $25
78 mm twill
$25
63 mm RND with protruding arrow
$25
$25
79 mm twill; MVE
$20
twill 104x78 mm; feathers EMB;
$25
35 mm sides; MVE; LB; DGR frog; $10
5x5 mm arrowhead; TLR
$15
HOR EMB bkgd; 28x22 mm head
$25
95x76 mm; VER EMB owl; TAN
39 mm owl with tepees
EMB; owl 90 mm from bottom
BRN tree trunk; MVE; twill; 74 mm
GRN tree; thick FR/E; (1961)
twill; 76 mm
WWW staggered below buffalo
TRS
"open eye" -- BLK pupil in eye; G &
REC; twill; MVE; 50x75 mm
FR/E; MVE
like A2 but twill
MTZ; discontinuous arrow; 50 mm
continuous arrow; 48 mm name TLR
BRN stag; MVE
"68"; 6 mm; TLR
8 mm RND; (1966)
Pennsylvania
Lot
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
Item
1
1
1
5
11
11
18
22
30
30
33
39
43
43
43
43
43
44
44
46
46
76
103
103
103
130
R7b
R10
S1
S1
X2
X4
R2
R3
R2
S4a
ZS1
R2b
S2b
R3a
S8a
S9a
F1a
F2a
S1a
R2a
S1
F4
X1
X3b
S2
F3
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
BLK
C BLK
R BLK
C BLK
C DBL
C BLK
C RED
C RED
R RED
R RED
R RED
C RED
C DGR
C RED
C RED
C RED
C RED
R BLK
R BLK
C GRN
R GRN
R GRN
C NBL
C NBL
R YEL
R RED
RED GRN
RED GRN
GRY GRN
ORG RED
ORG
RED BLK
BLU RED
ORG RED
WHT GRN
GRY DBL
WHT BLK
ORG RED
DGR
WHT GRN
WHT GRN
WHT GRN
M/C DBL
WHT RED
WHT RED
WHT GRN
WHT GRN
WHT GRN
NBL YEL
BLK DYL
BLK YEL
ORG BLK
Description
Reserve
Machine sewn;MVE; 62 mm; DIAG
35th ANN; (1950)
MVE
HOR bkgd
BLK "II"; keystone shaped
w/ pupils in eye
wings beyond bdr
75 mm duck doesn't have foot
slight box soil
A.L.; VER bkgd; FR/E
"E" of LODGE directly under "E" of
RBR deer; back legs over "W" of
RED stitch from cabin to "W"; KHA
DBR cabin; thin letters
111mm; WHT BMT; DBR cabin
124 mm; DBR cabin; GRN ltrs
125 mm; thick ltrs
3 W's; thick letters; FF
GRN "W's" and "44"; CB
BRN branch; 28-30 mm arrows; TRR
BRN panther
MVE
Used; YEL 103; RED eye; TRI;
tags between lines; NT
rounded sides & bottom; 55x116; 4
$25
$10
$15
$10
$15
$10
$85
$15
$25
$20
$5
$20
$90
$20
$25
$30
$15
$15
$10
$15
$15
$20
$250
$30
$15
$35
Auction Closes: Friday – February 20, 1998 (435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
35
The Dwight Bischel Auction
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
223
242
242
255
256
275
316
343
343
343
347
347
384
384
455
455
455
519
R1
X2
F2
S4b
X1
S2
R2
R1
R3a
S4
X1a
S1
X2
S5b
A1
F2a
F4
S2
C RED DGR WHT
C DBL WHT BLU
R BLU LBL RED
R YEL M/C DBL
C BLK WHT RED
R BLU WHT RED
C RED LTQ RED
WHT DBL
C WHT DBL
R RED M/C RED RED
C RED BLK WHT
R RED M/C RED
C RED WHT GRN
R GRY M/C RED
C RED DBL WHT
C RED BLK WHT
R RED PBL DBR
R YEL DBL WHT
$30
$25
53x125 mm; MTZ
$35
LBR wolfhead; regular R/E
$10
diamond; has both names
$60
47 mm lake; VER WHT
$25
MVE; letters outlined in DGR
$30
Sewn; EMB on felt; 78 mm diameter $225
VER WHT deer; twill; thin BLK
$30
BSA
$10
BLK twill separates RED rays from $20
LB
$20
twill TRI w/rounded corners
$30
thick RED letters & arrow
$20
$30
A.L.; RBR face
$25
$20
arrow below turtle; LB
$20
78 mm; twill almost BLK
Virginia, Maryland & D.C.
Lot
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
Item
3
12
20
258
276
276
463
470
470
483
S3
S3b
S2
A2a
X1
S3
A1
S2
S4
X1
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C RED WHT GRN
R RED WHT RED DYL
R BLK M/C BLK
C WHT WHT WHT
C BRN WHT GRN
R LGY BLU DYL
C RED GRN RED
R LGY BLU NBL
R DYL BLU DYL
C YEL GRN YEL
Description
Reserve
$65
$5
$5
no border above WHT necklace;
$40
shape of camp
$35
LGY antlers; (25th ANN); (1969)
$40
solid BRN acorn
$40
HOR bkgd; 3 windows on each
$5
BLK "20th ANNIVERSARY"; (1972) $20
90 mm keyhole; glue spot
$30
BLU/WHT/RED; DYL "3"; (1959)
PB; (1977)
Region 4 - OH, KY & WV
Lot
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
Item
93
109
121
123
123
123
123
123
151
151
151
151
155
205
238
241
306
306
323
350
350
367
377
457
462
472
472
480
495
550
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R3 C RED WHT RED
S2 R BLK M/C BLK
R1 C RED YOR GRN
F1 C WHT BLK RED
R4 C BLK WHT RED
F3a C RED WHT BLK
S2b R RED WHT BLK
S7 R BLK M/C DYL
A3b C BLK DGY RED
A3c C BLK LGY RED
F2b R GRN LGY RED
S3a R BLK WHT RED
ZF1 C WHT GRN RED
ZF2 C DYL WHT GRN
R1 C GRN WHT RED
S1 R GRN WHT RED
Slide
X2 C YEL GRN WHT
F2b C RED DBL
A1 C DBL RED WHT
S1 R RED LBL BLK
S4 R BLK M/C BLK
S7b R BLK WHT DBL
S4 R YEL LBL BLK
R1 C RED M/C
A1 C DBL WHT RED
F1 C DBL WHT RED
X1c C GRN WHT RED
S2 R WHT M/C BLK
S4a R DYL M/C BLK
Description
Reserve
$25
$15
$40
FF
$200
fat bird
$25
52x124 mm; MVE; no tags from
$20
5 mm fletching; 2 mm thick tal
$20
"USA 200"; BIC
$20
TRS
$30
NT
$30
Native American has no chin
$10
RED rosette
$10
fake issued by lodge 550
$5
TL; 58x120 mm
$5
$40
$20
Metal slide
$10
12 segment RED turtle; WHT arrow $85
Used; 50x122 mm; 100 mm RED
$15
$25
BLK WWW
$15
A.L.
$15
RBR deer
$5
open "4"; slanted "457"; LB
$10
also Kunieh TRIBE from other
$75
feathers have short RED lines coming $25
FF
$40
TL; used
$25
61x125 mm
$10
BLK solid beard; CB; (1972)
$10
100 mm; DBL WWW in chest
RBR deer; MVE; DYL in sky
Region 5 - AL, AR, LA, MS & TN
Lot
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
36
Item
111
135
149
160
166
169
179
R3
R2
R2
S1c
S7
X1b
R4
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C WHT BLU WHT
C RED BLK RED
C BLK WHT RED
R BLK M/C BLK
R ORG M/C WHT
C RED NBL WHT
C GRN GRY RED
Description
Reserve
$40
DYL EMB center
$60
GRN WWW; 4 RED lines in quivver $30
110 mm; LBR bluff; DYL prairie
$10
$5
RBR tree trunk
$30
EMB eye; with RED dots between
$25
The Auction in the Journal
The Dwight Bischel Auction
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
179
185
193
224
235
260
260
264
293
397
399
404
413
481
R5b
X2
ZF1
R2
X1a
R1
S1
S5
S3
F3
S2b
S1d
X1
A1b
C GRN GRY RED
C BLK ORG RED
R RED BLU LGY
C YEL BLK WHT
C GRN WHT YEL
C RED NBL RED
R BRN WHT GRN
R WHT M/C BLK
R RED DYL RED
R YEL BLU RED
R YEL BLU DYL
C RED YOR RED
C GRN WHT BLK
C RED WHT RED
bottom of neck angles down to left
$25
3 arrows to right of Native American $25
TLR; square bottom breechcloth
$5
$40
diamond; 78 mm wide
$45
$30
HOR bkg; no 260; MVE
$10
no WWW
$10
"XX"; (20th ANN)
$20
$20
76 mm RED arrow; WHT shows
$15
3-4 mm thick bdr; 2 mm of YOR
$15
shield shape
$40
GRN cornstalk
$75
Region 6 - GA, FL & Carolinas
Lot
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
Item
70
87
104
116
117
163
188
200
200
204
204
221
229
236
237
237
237
243
265
265
270
318
324
326
326
331
333
340
353
358
385
385
459
552
R4a
R1a
R5a
S1
S2
A2
R1b
R1
S2
F1
S2
R2
S2a
A1c
A1b
A2
X5a
X1
F3
F4
X3a
A2b
S1
R4
F4
R2
X1a
X1d
S3
A1
S4b
S7
A1
S3b
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C NBL NBL NBL
C BRN ORG DGR
LBL WHT RED
C RED BLK RED
R GMY M/C RED
C BLK WHT RED
C YEL WHT DRD
C RED WHT DBL
C RED LBL RED
C RED WHT RED
C DYL LBL RED
C DYL WHT RED
R DYL LBL RED
C GRN WHT RED
C RED WHT GRN
C RED WHT DGR
C LBL GRN DYL
C RED ORG BLK
C DYL GRN DYL
R DYL GRN DYL
C WHT GRN WHT
C YEL WHT ORG
R YEL WHT DBL
C RED WHT DBL
R RED BLK RED
R DBL WHT WHT
C BLK WHT RED
C DYL WHT DBL
R NBL M/C RED
C RED GRN RED
C RBR PNK RED
R DYL DBL RED
C LGY WHT
R BLK M/C BLK
Description
Reserve
heron facing left; GRY heron & outer $40
$40
BPR face; BLK antenna; felt; YEL
$25
(1961); VER; near mint
$350
BRO; (1973)
$20
108 mm tall; GRN belt; BRN eye
$30
TRR
$30
$95
LBL BMT
$30
BRN outlined thunderbird
$40
t-bird
$30
76 mm
$30
BRN logs; LB; (1967)
$30
TL
$40
TRR
$60
3 mm border; straight sides
$50
shape of FL; VER DYL; TR; BRN
$30
HOR BLK bear poorly EMB
$40
59x136 mm; heron flies left; name & $475
Used; crude heron; heron flies left;
$85
two hair bands; DBR VER face; 74
$30
GRN thin trees that have WHT twill $75
LB; HOR field; (1959)
$20
75 mm; GRN state; one "W" inside $30
"TIPISA LODGE" above arrow
$20
"CHEERFUL SERVICE"
$30
ORG face; "E" of "LODGE" has flat $40
TRR
$30
123 mm; LBL sky; TRQ water; LB
$20
ECHECONNEE; bottom of deer's
$50
used
$55
VER sky; 119x47 mm; WHT crown $10
RED WWW; hornet's nest
$60
DIAG LBL between YEL ripples;
$40
Region 7 - IN, IL, MI & WI
Lot
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
Item
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
29
29
38
38
40
40
40
F5
S3a
S6
act
act
act
ch
ch
ch
ch
ch
ch
ch
S3
S4
X5
S3b
S5
P1
S19
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R DYL
R BLK
R BLK
C BLK
C RED
C GRN
C BLK
C BLU
C RED
C BLK
Description
Reserve
WHT DYL
Chicago area; 50x126 mm; VER BLK
M/C WHT
GMY 7
M/C WHT GMY GMY 7; SS
ORG BLK
1949 Midwinter fellowship
WHT RED
1950 fellowship
WHT RED
1951 spring fellowship
TUR RED
Checaugau Chapter 1950 Spring
WHT BLU
Checaugau Chapter 1953 Fellowship
WHT RED
Garrison Chapter
GRY RED
Garrison Chapter 1949 Fellowship
Garrison Chapter Metal Slide
C BLK WHT RED
Miami Chapter 1955 Spring
C RED WHT BLK
Wakay Chapter
R WHT RED DYL
52x115 mm; MVE
R BLK RED DYL
C YEL BLU RED
REC; random RED lines around sun
R BLK M/C BLK
PALE GRY rays; 8 mm "38"
R WHT TRQ BLK
3 mm mouth; BLK 40 below RED 40
R BLK BLU M/C
QC elk design; used, on N/C
R WHT M/C DYL DYL CD; PBL water
$10
$10
$5
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$10
$10
$15
$15
$10
$10
$20
$5
$10
$30
$5
Auction Closes: Friday – February 20, 1998 (435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
37
The Dwight Bischel Auction
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
61
65
73
75
81
88
89
92
92
94
94
96
96
107
110
110
115
126
132
136
136
140
140
143
152
152
156
162
182
189
189
191
203
206
206
212
215
218
222
231
231
233
240
248
248
248
248
248
248
269
280
280
280
308
315
332
334
337
337
339
373
373
381
381
401
422
422
425
452
469
R2
S3
ZS1
A2
S5
R1
S2b
R3
S1b
A2a
act
S1a
act
X2b
X1
S5
R2b
F4b
R1c
F2c
S4a
R2b
X1a
S2
X3
S1
S2b
F2a
F2
R3
F6a
R2
R3
A1
F1b
X2a
F2b
R2a
F2b
X1
N.5
R2
R2a
R1b
R4
P1
S1c
N3
R0
X1a
R1
R2
S2
S1
R1
S3
S1
S1
S6
X1
A1b
S2
R1
F2b
X2b
R1
S6
R1
X2
X1b
C RED BLU YEL
R RED DBL BLK
R BLK M/C RED
C DBL RED WHT
R RED LBL RED
C RED ORG NBL
R ORG M/C ORG
C RED GRN DYL
C RED GRN DYL
C RED WHT BLK
C RED WHT DBL
C RED DYL RED
C RED DKH DGR
C WHT TRQ RED
C GRN PYL RED
C GRN WHT RED
C RED WHT RED
C RED DYL RED
C RED BLK RED
C YEL DBL YEL
R BLK M/C RED
C RED WHT DGR
C BLK WHT BLK
R BLK M/C RED
C BLK WHT WHT
R DYL LBL BRN
R BLK DYL BLK
R WHT BLU RED
C BRN ORG RED
C DYL BLU DYL
C M/C DBL RED
C DYL RED DYL
R RED LYL WHT
C BLK RED WHT
R WHT BLK RED
C RED BLU RED
R RED WHT DYL
C RED WHT DBL
C RED ORG WHT
C BRN WHT GRN
R RED RED WHT
C RED WHT BLU
C GRN WHT RED
C WHT DBL WHT
R WHT DBL WHT
R WHT BLU WHT
R WHT M/C WHT
WHT RED
C MAR WHT
C PYL LYL RED
C RED M/C DBL
C BLK WHT BLK
R DBL WHT BLK
R BLK M/C BLK
R DYL BLU RED
R RED WHT RED
C WHT DBL WHT
R RED M/C RED
R RED M/C RED
C RED WHT DYL
C RED ORG RED
R DYL LBL RED DYL
C LGR DBL WHT
R RED BLU BLK
C RBR WHT RED
C RED WHT RED
R LGY M/C BLK
C YEL BLU RED
C YOR BLU GRN
C DBL DOR DBL
BRN face Native American
$40
BLK paw print
$15
82 mm; "SINAWA LODGE"; PBL sky $5
WHT circle
$10
BLK outline on nose; BLK bead
$15
$30
light BLU sky
$10
RBR face on Native American
$15
GRN BMT; MVE
$10
89 mm; DYL in bonnet; TRR
$20
1952 Reunion
$20
BRN deer; tops of W's are parallel to $50
1956 Fall Conference
$10
"N"s almost look like "H's"
$30
NOAC52;shield, on silk N/C
$30
VER bkgd
$20
BLU waves
$30
LBN face
$40
thin BLK arrow; TR; VER RED
$15
$15
WHT details in mound; YEL ground; $10
$20
twill bkgd; oval; RED feathers below $20
53x115 mm; BGR trees; LGR grass $15
RED "SCENIC TRAILS COUNCIL" $15
RED WWW
$20
light RBR snowshoes
$10
with "DETROIT"; BRN eagle
$10
MVE
$25
name "APOSA ACHOMAWI"
$40
HOR grass; no ear on otter
$50
name top 2/3 of patch
$25
$20
$20
NT
$10
shape of Indiana; BRN Native
$20
48x123 mm; 6 mm BRN acorn
$35
RED WWW; TRR
$20
GRN turtle
$45
RED "WWW 231"; GRN detail stitch $35
SSC
$40
79 mm; arrow fletching flat on bottom $35
smooth stitched beaver; TRM
$40
blob type BRNd uck; thick neck large $35
like R1b; FR/E
$80
RED arrow behind flying duck; QC; $50
HOR LBL sky
$20
SSC GRN w- duck- tree; RED
$20
Felt, Pre OA
$150
turtle shape
$25
BLK "WWW"; DYL "280"; solid
$30
box soil; RBR, BLK, & DYL fox
$30
MVE DBL council name
$10
$15
$25
BRO; BLK WWW
$30
$15
LBL sky; ORG middle; A.R.; no #
$35
DYL sky; LBL beak; RED "337"; 3
$10
semi-cir w/ arrow @ bottom; rat tail; $25
NT
$30
30 mm FDL; VER LBL
$10
RED WWW; council name
$50
TLS
$10
TRR
$30
thick letters; arrow diag. left; TAN
$30
(25th ANN)
$20
BRN WWW and council name
$30
no "WWW"; WHT clouds above top $30
$40
Regions 8 & 10
Lot
484 16
485 31
38
Item
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R1 C BLK WHT BLK
X1a C GRN YOR BLK
Description
RED WWW; no lodge no.; TVE
80x80 mm; TRR
Reserve
$30
$35
The Auction in the Journal
The Dwight Bischel Auction
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
51
52
69
74
80
97
108
108
147
147
176
176
183
321
371
372
383
383
387
387
429
433
434
453
458
458
464
464
467
473
492
536
541
R2
R1a
A1b
F3a
S1c
A1
R2b
S2
A1a
F3
S2a
S4c
S2a
X1b
S1b
S2a
R2
F3
A1
S1a
F5
S1
F3a
R1
R1
S3a
R1b
S4a
R1
A1
S1
S1d
S3a
C RED WHT RED
C RED WHT BLK
C RED WHT BLK
R BLK BBL BLK
R BLK M/C RED
C DGR WHT
C DBL WHT RED
R RED DBL WHT
C RED WHT
R RED WHT RED
C LGY LGY
R RED M/C RED
R DBL M/C RED
C DBL WHT ORG
R RED WHT DBL
R RED M/C BLK
C DYL BLU RED
C RED BLU LGY
C RED WHT BLK
R BRN BLU RED
R DYL LBL BLK
R BLK WHT DBL
R BLK LYL RED
R DYL WHT RED
R WHT NBL WHT
R WHT M/C RED
C BLK ORG BLK
R NBL BLU NBL
C BLK WHT BLK
C YEL WHT MAR
R RED BLU RED
R DYL M/C RED
R YEL BLU RED
$30
$30
$40
$10
$10
$30
NT
$30
(1964)
$20
110 mm high; LBL details
$40
51x117 mm; normal R/E; LB
$20
two RED drops and detailed rosette; $40
RBR tepee
$15
LBR ground; RBR & DYL details in $15
ROR WWW, 321 & arrow; 5 mm
$30
116x51 mm
$30
LBR ground
$15
110 mm; LBL lake; GRN trees on
$40
RED WWW 383; 10 mm wide "W"; $30
RBR mountain; LGY ram & snow;
$30
mostly WHT backing; (1972)
$10
55x124 mm
$5
RED 433
$40
Coronado area council; LPK inner
$40
FR/E
$125
Light use; FR/E;HOR EMB buffalo
$40
DYL WW 458; regular R/E; pointed $5
no tags from "464" to bdr
$30
135x58 mm; VER field; (possibly
$40
BLK WWW
$80
RED WWW; (1956)
$80
BLK WWW 492; HOR sun and sky; $5
"TUPWEE LODGE 536" on same
$10
BRN eye; 52 mm high; BRN bird;
$10
GRN VER w/ outline
skinny stars; thin barbed arrowhead
BRN face
MVE
TAN sand; PUR mountains; rounded
Region 9 - NM, OK & TX
Lot
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
Item
35
36
36
36
56
60
60
62
66
72
72
78
99
99
99
101
101
113
133
137
138
141
190
199
213
232
272
272
272
272
281
288
295
307
328
330
341
378
428
R2
A3
F2b
S1
S1
X1
F2c
S3b
R1
F2b
F4
X1a
A5a
A6
S2c
A2c
F5a
X2a
X1a
F4a
S2b
A3
S1
F2
S3
S2a
F3
F7a
F7b
S1a
S3b
S1
R1b
S4b
S2
F2
S1c
S5a
R1
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C BLK WHT BLK
C RED GRY RED
C YEL TRQ RED
R DYL BLU DBR
R RED M/C RED
C BLK WHT BLK
C YEL WHT BRN
R YEL M/C DGR
C RED WHT RED
C LBL ORG RED
C LBL ORG RED
C BLK RED WHT
C WHT RED
C WHT RED WHT
C WHT RED WHT
C YEL WHT
C YEL BLU RED
C BLK BLU
C RED ORG RED
R RED WHT BLK
C RED RED YEL
C WHT RED BLK
R BRN M/C BLK
C BLK WHT RED
R BLK M/C LYL
C BLK GRN WHT
R RED WHT RED
R RED WHT RED
R RED WHT RED
R WHT M/C WHT
R RED M/C RED
R RED BLU RED
C RED WHT BLU BLU
C BLK WHT RED
R RED WHT RED
C RED ORG BLK
R BLK M/C RED
R BLK M/C BLK
C RED WHT BLK
Description
Reserve
TRR; 71 mm; W's 5mm; Emb tab;
Dancer
TLS; boxsoil
MVE; (1967)
(1971)
114 mm; feathers; "I" in hutsi
bottom rt of BLU arrow rounded; thin
88 mm; (1953)
TLR
BLK outline of hands; 1st "W" above
shield; WHT eye; 11 mm; RED twill
RED TRR & W's; 3 mm bdr; 65x87
78x65 mm; (1954)
BLK; BLK feet have 3 distinct toes
MVE; no tags
120x60 mm; HOR GRN ground; RED
94 mm; hat shape; no name; shaft in
115 mm; shield; GRN circle has GRN
"COLONNEH"; small bird; F/RE;
fletching ends under "I"; 82 mm
tail looped; RED twill comes thru
solid YEL tepee above squirrel's
arrow points to left; "WAHINKTO"
A.L.; ORG"W"s; VER sky;
121x53 mm; 9 mm name; BLK BMT;
124x59 mm; FR/E; large; MVE; GRY
115x52 mm LB; nested W's below
LGY dove
118x63 mm; no beak; (1964); back of
LBR grnd.
MVE's--size
TRS
8 mm fletch is V'ed
LBL t-bird; MVE
BLK "330" in WHT buffalo; GER;
BRN face; tags name to bdr
ORG & BLK gila is defined; LBR
BLK 428; NO NAME; 76 mm; MVE;
$90
$90
$50
$40
$20
$30
$25
$30
$45
$30
$30
$30
$55
$50
$30
$40
$10
$40
$65
$20
$15
$30
$15
$25
$25
$30
$40
$20
$20
$15
$15
$15
$40
$10
$25
$30
$25
$20
$50
Auction Closes: Friday – February 20, 1998 (435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
39
The Dwight Bischel Auction
558 486 A2b C BLU WHT YEL
559 489 F2 R DBL ORG DBL
560 578 S5b R YEL M/C WHT
Used; 84 mm;9 closed to form 8;
BLU eye; claws; FR/E; MVE
GRN foilage
$50
$20
$10
Region 11- Pacific Northwest
Lot
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
Item
253
259
266
300
300
300
305
325
336
348
348
355
355
356
361
363
363
392
407
415
421
442
544
549
S8b
S2
S2
X1b
X3
F1
F2b
A1a
S2a
A2
S1b
P1
S2b
X2
S1b
S2a
S4
S4a
S3a
F2b
A1
R2a
S2
F2b
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R RED BLK WHT
R DYL GRN DYL
R RED M/C DBL
C BRN WHT DBL
C BRN ORG RED
R BLK BLU BLK
R WHT RED WHT
C DBL RED
R DYL M/C RED
C WHT BLU WHT
R YEL M/C RED
C RED WHT RED
R DBL BLU RED
C RED LBL RED
R DYL M/C RED
R RED DBL RED
R RED DBL RED
R DYL RED DYL
C RED BLU DYL
C BLK WHT BLK
C BLK RED BLK
C RED LBL RED
R YEL M/C RED
R RED NBL DYL
Description
Reserve
$10
$10
$10
$30
side border 3 mm wide; TRR; "E" of $30
$10
50x122 mm; very rounded lower
$15
twill circle in arrowhead; RED twill $90
three canoes; LBR ground & ram
$15
RED WWW; BRN & WHT mtn
$40
19 mm GRN tree on left partially
$25
Alaska Council; GRN & DGR
$150
$20
oval; WHT rear leg; deer w/antlers
$40
PUR mountains
$20
FR/E; 128 mm; MVE
$30
RED "TP"
$15
MVE
$15
GRY & LGY fish
$15
no WHT bdr around top of snow cap $10
feet under wings "a" above "L"
$50
HOR EMB WHT on tree; LBL on mtn $50
118x50 mm; 32 mm sides; VER grass $10
TLR; well defined DOR bars in neck $10
RBRdeer
with number; BLK detail lines on
cougar head; RED band in bonnet
AZ, HI, NV, UT & Reg. 13
Lot
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
Item
312
346
432
482
494
498
503
514
551
557
567
S1a
S4a
S2b
F3c
S2a
S15
R1
S2c
S2b
S3b
S1b
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R RED
R RED
R RED
R BLU
R DOR
R YEL
C GRN
R BLK
R RED
R RED
R RED
M/C BLK
GRY RED
BLU WHT
YEL BLU
M/C BLK
M/C BLK
RED BLK
M/C RED
M/C BLK
WHT BRN
WHT BLK
Description
PBR mountains
BRN antelope w/WHT throat
GRN stripe under mask
2 mm arrowshaft; YEL twill eye
GRN details on cactus; LB
53x124 mm; LTQ sky; LBL water
DBR beaver; PGR foreground; YEL
BLK dots connected in triplets
PUR wingtips; PBR body & head
FF; 62x128 mm; MVE
Reserve
$15
$10
$10
$30
$20
$20
$50
$20
$60
$25
$10
California
Lot
596
597
598
599
600
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
40
Item
90
98
102
127
127
207
225
228
249
252
252
263
263
278
291
298
303
342
354
354
354
375
375
379
395
430
436
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
S2 R BLK M/C BLK
S1b R WHT WHT RED
S3 C BLK LBL PUR
X1b C BLK WHT RED
S3a R GRY M/C BLK
F5b R DGR LBL BLK
S4a R YEL RED BLK
R1 R GRN WHT RED
A3a C WHT RED LBL
A4b C YEL LBL BLK RED
A
RED YOR DGR
A1 C DYL BLU RED
F1a C RED WHT BLK
S1 R BLK M/C RED
A2a C YEL WHT RED RED
X1b C DBL WHT DGR
F4b R WHT DPR TAN
S2 R PGR BLK GRN
R1 C DBL WHT RED
S1 R WHT M/C WHT
S3 R BLK M/C WHT
A2
RED BLK YEL
F3b C RED BLK YEL
F3b R RED WHT RED
S3 R GMY M/C RED
S12b R WHT M/C RED
S6a R LBL BRZ RED
Description
Reserve
HOR BLU sky; GRN water
$10
53x124 mm; round corners
$25
BLK BMT; thick arrow; TAN face
$30
NT; no dimple in upper lip
$30
VER OA ribbon; YEL sun; GRY arrow $25
LBL lake
$20
arrow points at "WWW"; no period
$20
90 mm; BRN line under arrow
$125
“WWW”; NT; WHT swirls
$40
BSA; tree does not touch top of shield $20
Felt; Mishe Mokwa Chapter
$65
narrow tail; VER right wing
$30
FF; DBR bird; beak outline short of $50
5 little trees left of bear
$20
BSA; TRQ arrowhead and headress; $125
DYL fire
$30
dull YEL moon; light boxsoil
$20
$20
NT
$50
F R/E; pointed bottom; BPR
$20
DBL water
$10
LBR eye; 7 water lines; felt
$150
BRN mtn; BGR trees; YEL bear
$60
TRS
$20
50th ANN of council
$20
BRN deer
$20
VER BRZ bkgd; WHT lockstitch in $15
The Auction in the Journal
The Dwight Bischel Auction
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
466
468
468
468
478
485
488
488
511
528
533
537
548
A1
F2b
F3
S2b
R1
S1b
R3b
F2
S2
S1
S2b
S1
S3
C BLK M/C BLK
C BLK WHT BLK
C BLK WHT BLK
C BLK WHT BLK
C LBL WHT RED
R YEL M/C DBL
C DBL WHT RED
C RED DBL RED
R DYL M/C RED
R RED WHT RED
R RED M/C RED
R WHT M/C WHT
R DYL M/C RED
$125
$30
$35
$10
$40
$10
$40
$40
$60
$20
$20
$30
$15
no number; YEL bird
DYL bar 5 mm wide
side view of eagle; WHT arrow
no BLK line
75 mm; NT; no bdr around LYL
BPR mountain
TLS; almost NT
GRN trees
52X120 mm; "OA" in front of arrow
small BRN eye
VER RED foreground
PUR mountains
Section Conclave
Lot
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
Item
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
1949 ??
1950 7A
1950 7F
1952 7B
1953 5E
1953 7A
1953 7B
1953 9B
1954 2F
1954 7B
1955 3A
1955 7B
1957 3A
1957 5A
Description
Reserve
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
$15
Fellowship Conference; Unknown
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Section Conclave badge
Jamboree
Lot
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
Item
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
1935 NJ
1937 NJ
1947 WJ
1950 NJ
1950 NJ
1950 NJ
1950 NJ
1953 NJ
1960 NJ
1960 NJ
1964 NJ
1964 NJ
1967 WJ
1967 WJ
Description
Reserve
Pocket Badge; slight use; sewn
Pocket Badge; used
American Contingent badge - Felt
Canvas Pocket Badge
Cloth Pocket Badge
LAAC Contingent shoulder badge
Rainbow Council Crusader Jamboree
Jacket Badge
Jacket Badge
Pocket Badge
Jacket Badge
Pocket Badge
Jacket Badge
Pocket Badge
$100
$100
$30
$20
$25
$25
$25
$100
$10
$20
$20
$10
$25
$10
NOAC
Lot
664
665
666
667
Item
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
1950
1952
1954
1956
Pocket
Pocket
Pocket
Pocket
Description
Badge
Badge
Badge
Badge
Reserve
$30
$30
$30
$30
Region Items
Lot
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
Item
1
1
1
2
2
2
3
3
4
5
5
6
6
7
7
7
7
R
R3b
slide
slide
slide
X2
R1b
slide
R2b
slide
X1
R3
slide
R
slide
slide
X1a
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
Description
BLK WHT RED RED Felt; Canoe Trails; BSA
BLK WHT RED
Felt
metal
Metal; REC; NY, NJ PR
metal - Round 1964 Jambo
C DYL RED WHT
New York New Jersey only
C BLU LRD BLU
Metal- Round
C DYL RED M/C WHT BSA
Metal- Shield
C DBR RWB DYL
Shield
C RED WHT GRN
Metal- Round
C DYL RED WHT WHT Explorer Canoe Base; BSA
Metal - shield
Metal - shield; Canoe base
C DYL RED DYL
Shield
Reserve
$30
$30
$10
$10
$10
$30
$25
$10
$20
$10
$30
$30
$10
$20
$10
$10
$25
Auction Closes: Friday – February 20, 1998 (435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
41
The Dwight Bischel Auction
685
686
687
688
689
690
691
692
693
694
695
696
8
8
8
9
9
9
9
10
10
11
11
12
R5b
slide
X2b
R2
slide
X1a
X1b
R3b
slide
slide
X2a
R6
C BLK LBR RED
R RED
C BLK
C RED
C RED
C BLK
C DYL
C BLK
$40
$10
$30
$40
$10
$30
$30
$30
$10
$10
$30
$30
Metal - tear drop
PYL RED
Tear drop
ORG BLK BLK BSA
Metal - shield
ORG LBR
ORG NBL
WHT BLK
Metal - Diamond
Metal - Dome
BLK WHT
Dome
WHT RED
BSA
Other
Lot
697
698
699
700
701
702
703
704
705
706
Item
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R BLK RED WHT
R BLK RED DYL
R DBL M/C DBL
R DYL WHT RED
Jap
1950
1951
1960
1964
Description
Reserve
Arrowhead Council Badge
Arrowhead Council Badge
Metal Slide; old jacket badge design
Owasippe Scout Reservation jacket
Troop 55 “25” Puerto Rico flap
Council Badge?
Wildcat Scouts; Evanston, ILL
Ambraw Wabash Area Council
Wildcat Scouts; Evanston, ILL
Wildcat Scouts; Evanston, ILL
$10
$10
$5
$10
$5
$40
$5
$5
$5
$5
WANTED
OA Lodge Neckerchiefs
Silk screened or embroidered
$ CASH PAID $
interested in singles or collections
CALL
Bill Topkis (435) 655-8899
42
The Auction in the Journal
TheDwight
AuctionBischel
in the Journal
The
Auction
800
801
802
803
804
805
806
807
808
809
810
811
812
813
814
815
816
817
818
819
820
821
822
823
824
825
826
827
828
829
830
831
832
833
834
835
836
837
838
839
840
841
842
843
844
845
846
847
848
849
850
851
852
853
854
855
856
857
858
859
860
861
862
863
864
865
866
867
868
869
870
871
872
873
874
1
4
7
9
11
14
19
19
26
35
37
38
41
47
47
47
48
61
72
76
77
89
89
90
96
110
123
124
137
138
139
141
143
153
166
168
169
176
177
188
193
200
220
220
227
242
247
251
251
256
256
258
266
267
267
271
296
300
303
303
305
309
313
313
314
318
345
345
346
351
358
359
361
363
364
R3a
A1b
AR
F1
X1b
R1
R1
R2
X5
F1a
X3
X1
A4
act1
act2
R3
A2
F1
F1
R2
X1
A1
F1
S1
F1
X2
R2b
R2
F1
S1b
X1
F1
F1
S1a
F1
A1
F1
S1
F1
F1
F1
F1
R1
X1
J1
A1
X1
X1
C4
X5
F1
F1a
F1
R1
R2
X2
R1
S1
F1
R1a
F1
S1
F1
F2
X2
A1
F2
F3
F1
R2
S1
F1
F1
S1
F1
BLK RED GRN
Used; Moth holes; flannel; "UNAMI $150
GRN BLK
Machine Sewn; 70x48 mm
$600
RED WHT
WHT SSC on RED felt; "SERVICE $250
C RED WHT GRN
Light box soil; event flap; 1953 POW $450
ORG ORG
Slight mothing; closed BLK eye; no $150
RED GRY RED
Machine sewn; flocked on felt; 88
$650
RED WHT RED
SSC felt; 40x32 mm arrowhead;
$1200
RED WHT RED
SSC; felt; 32x27 mm arrowhead;
$200
C WHT BLU
Sewn, washed; DBL felt w/ WHT
$650
R BLK WHT BLK
Slight use; Barbed arrowhead; FR/E. $650
WHT RED WHT WHT Light use; BSA; felt oval w/flocked $900
WHT RED
Paper on back; felt; EMB; WAB
$450
WHT
RED arrow EMB on felt
$325
RED WHT RED
SSC on felt. 1953 Lodge Convention $350
RED WHT RED
Light use; flocked on felt. 1954 Lodge $350
C BRN WHT BLK
Used, nice; 85 mm; fully EMB;
$1200
RED WHT WHT
EMB felt without tab; additional RED $600
C DYL BLU RED
Sewn; FF; TLS
$725
C RED BLU
Box soil; no name or #; only RED
$1000
C BLK RED
GRN WWW; tail touches WWW; 78 $450
RED WHT
Used; felt on felt on felt bird; WAB $250
DBL DBL RED
Excellent condition; EMB felt; WAB $800
R WHT DBL RED
21 mm; sides - FF; FR/E; MTZ
$700
R BLK LBL BLK
FF; VER LBL sky and water; (1960) $3200
C RED DGR RED
FF; "1954"
$750
DGR LBR
DGR felt base; EMB owl and arrow; $250
C BLK GRN RED
Light use; NT; black inner circle; 80 $1200
RED GRY RED
"NOQUOCHOKE LODGE 124
$375
C RED WHT BLK
Used; "COLONEH"; TRI bill; 121x54 $675
C RED RED YEL
Daw Zu 123 mm
$1000
DYL RED WHT
felt on felt; shield
$750
C WHT RED BLK
Light stain at bottom; VER buffalo w/ $1100
C BLK GRY DYL
Used; FF; RED bdr around arrowhead $900
C DYL LBL RED
Light box soil; BRN "153"; arrow
$1850
C RED MAN DBL
no number; FF
$875
RED WHT RED
Machine sewn; felt w/ felt turkey
$1250
C RED NBL WHT
55x102 mm; FF
$950
C GRY GRY
Light use; one RED drop and blob
$1100
R BLK WHT BLK
FF; BLU thin outlined mountains; 6 $1300
R YEL DBL RED
FF; RED feathers of bonnet stitched $900
R RED BLU WHT
threads connect "193' to bdr; FF;
$650
R BLK WHT RED
FF
$550
RED
Light sew marks; BLK bear EMB on $450
RED WHT
Used; WHT felt bear sewn on RED
$400
C BLL YEL RED
SMY 25; RED 1942 1967; ANN
$200
C RED LBL RED
Used
$125
C RED WHT GRN
Box soil, stuff on back; 100x114 mm $225
RED ORG DBL DBL Light use; BSA felt; type 6B; flat
$1100
RED M/C BLK
"1969"; (25th ANN)
$1500
DGR DGR
RED flocked deer on composition;
$1400
C BLK WHT BLK
wrong no. 257; FF
$700
C RED WHT BLK
with all segment; FF; 2 mm thin bdr; $2200
C RED WHT DYL
FF
$600
RED WHT RED
74 mm SSC on felt; feather
$750
RED WHT RED
74 mm SSC felt; feather separated
$650
RED WHT RED
67x99 mm oval; BSA; RED SSC on $1200
WHT WHT BLK
Used;SSC on felt
$400
R RED M/C RED
Used; threadbreak in council name; $900
C YEL GRN RED
FF; "KERN CO. COUNCIL"; MVE
$1500
C BLK WHT RED
Light glue shows from back; flared
$450
C WHT RED DBL
FF; light staple marks; looks mint
$900
C BLK GRN BLK
49x128 mm TRAPEZOID; FF
$700
C BRN MAN DBL
bison has BRN eye; FF
$900
C DBR LYL DBL
bison has LYL twill eye
$800
C WHT RED BLU
Native American is brave; HOR hair $1550
YEL M/C ORG
solid EMB on WHT felt; WAB (1946) $1000
C RED KHA
RED eye; 50x123 mm
$700
C RED BLK
$700
C RED GRY RED
Wiyaka; FF
$1000
C DYL DPR DYL
Used; EMB felt; MVE--minor shades $300
C LGR M/C WHT
no #358; DYL spear; FF
$1200
C RED WHT DBL
Light use; RED WWW; sq corners; $1800
C YEL WHT RED
FF; light use
$900
C RED DBL RED
FF
$1100
C GRN WHT RED
solid EMB neck & tail feathers; FF; $650
Auction Closes: Friday – February 20, 1998 (435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
43
The Auction in the Journal
875
876
877
878
879
880
881
882
883
884
885
886
887
888
889
890
891
892
893
894
895
896
897
898
899
900
901
902
903
904
905
906
907
908
909
910
911
912
913
365
367
369
370
370
373
374
375
383
388
390
406
414
421
424
425
430
441
448
453
468
470
476
476
482
498
506
521
525
526
528
530
530
535
536
541
546
547
548
F1
F1
X1
F1a
S1
S1
F1
A1
F1
A1
R1
R2
R4
S3
A1
P1
C3
X1c
F1
F1
R1
F1
X1
J1
F1
F2
F1a
F1
F1
F1
F1
F1b
F2
F1
F1
C1
S1
F1
R1
C RED LBL RED
C DGR YEL RED
RED DGR YEL
C LGR WHT RED LGR
R BLK DBL RED LGR
C YEL M/C RED
C RED LBL RED
DYL NBL
C RED TRQ LGY
C RED WHT DGR
C RED GRY RED
C BLU ORG BLK
R BLK WHT BLK
R LGY LBL RED
C RED WHT RED
C DYL WHT RED
C RED GRY RED
RED WHT RED
C RED GRY RED
C YEL WHT RED
C RED WHT BLK
C GRY LBL NBL
C GRN WHT BLK
C DBL BLU BLK
C DBL ORG DBL
C YEL TRQ BLK
C LBR LBR DBL
C BLK BLK RED
R RED BLU RED
C BLK YOR BLK
C RED WHT RED
R WHT BLU RED
R DBL WHT RED
R BLK WHT RED
C YOR RED WHT
R WHT RED
DBL
C DYL WHT RED
R BLK WHT BLK
R RED M/C RED
FF; VER EMB grass; TLR
$550
FF; DBR elk; used
$900
EMB felt
$400
FF; TLR; VER periods between B.S.A. $100
HOR bkgd; Swiss EMB with
$850
Excellent; BRN WWW and council $180
Velcro on back, box soil; VER GRN $140
Off N/C; WAB, sateen w/ DYL
$220
RED WWW 383; 14 mm wide "W"; $850
DGR WWW; BRN Native American $900
$700
"CHICKASAW"
$350
ORD; sateen; detailed flying squirrel $300
LGY thunderbird; (25th ANN); no
$150
button tab
$750
QC
$300
Used; BRN VER deer; flap shape
$800
small moth hole; outlined fletching, $600
FF; 50x116 mm; owl ears 2 mm
$150
FF; stuff on back
$135
wrong number: "467"
$600
FF
$500
Light use; twill; no "476"; FF; used $900
arrowhead shaped
$400
FF; no WWW
$120
TL sky; LBL HOR water
$300
FF
$120
RED handstitch in lower BDR; GER; $800
Used; FF
$140
Used; "NSC" on left; FF
$250
FF; arrow right
$850
Used; 123x50 mm; TLM; name
$600
$450
60x125 mm; FF; left & right "W"
$700
Slight use; YOR WWW; FF; GER
$850
108x195 mm; flap shape; SS; chenile $120
Used; FF; council name misspelled $800
FF; no apostrophe behind "GOH";
$700
F R/E; solid EMB
$600
WANTED
OA Chapter and Activity Patches
from Lodges 7, 24, 96, and 252
Lodge 96 Conference patches from 1940–1948
Camp Sun Dance patches from 1940’s and 50’s
CALL
Jeff Morley (41) 474-1555
44
The Auction in the Journal
The
in the
Journal
The Auction
Journal Set
Price
Sale
Names and Numbers
Lot
1000 59
1001 69
1002 106
1003 216
1004 227
1005 234
1006 302
1007 306
1008 320
1009 364
1010 411
1011 411
1012 411
1013 419
1014 442
1015 461
1016 461
1017 471
1018 491
1019 525
Item
F2
F1a
X4b
F2
S2b
S1
F1a
F1
F1
F3
F1a
F1b
F2
F1
F2
F2
F3
S1b
F2
A1
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R WHT LBL RED
R BLK DYL BRN
C GRN WHT RED
R ORG WHT RED
R DBL WHT RED
R BLK TRQ BLK
R RED WHT RED
C YEL GRN BLK
C RED ORG GRN
R LGR WHT RED
C RED WHT DBL
C RED WHT DBL
R RED WHT DBL
C WHT DBL DYL
R BLK BLU RED
R GRY BLK YEL
R LGY BLK YEL
C BLK RED WHT
R GRY YEL BLK
C RED M/C RED
price
Reserve
Description
$675
$675
$80
$170
no tags from "U" and "L" to arrow
$205
Minor handling; FF
$350
FF; FR/E; 53x123 mm
$350
WHT WWW; FF; TLR; BRN turtle $525
"OKLAHOMA LODGE NO. 320"; FF $450
loon looks like a duck; "394"
$200
Light use; TLM; "CH" of
$550
Light use; TLR; "CH" tag @ top
$475
(1966); used
$200
$325
$575
52x113 mm; 65 mm arrow; Rounded $250
52x118 mm; 71 mm arrow; LB; BLK $90
FF light RBR eagle neck; sewn
$450
GRY lockstitch in bdr; TLM
$275
MVE--river color
$300
I & E link at bottom; sparse trees;
RED OA & 69; BLK 1933; FF
RBR elk
First Flaps
Lot
1020 1
1021 5
1022 5
1023 7
1024 8
1025 8
1026 9
1027 10
1028 11
1029 12
1030 13
1031 14
1032 15
1033 15
1034 15
1035 23
1036 24
1037 25
1038 27
1039 29
1040 33
1041 34
1042 34
1043 36
1044 37
1045 38
1046 39
1047 40
1048 44
1049 46
1050 46
1051 48
1052 49
1053 50
1054 53
1055 53
1056 56
1057 57
1058 59
1059 60
1060 62
1061 66
1062 67
1063 68
1064 70
1065 71
1066 74
1067 75
Item
F1
F1
S1
F1a
S1a
S1b
S1
S1
S1a
F1
S1b
S1
F1
F1a
S1
S1
S1a
S1a
F1c
S1
F1c
S1
S1
F1a
S1a
F1
W1
S1a
S1a
F1
S1
F1
F1
F1
F1a
S1a
F1
S1
S1
F1
F1
W2
S1
S1b
S1a
F1b
F1
F1a
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
Description
Reserve
price
C BLK WHT DGR
VER center of turtle; HOR RED; FF
C WHT PYL BLK
FF
C BLK M/C BLK
FF
C BLK WHT BLK
thick bdr; thick BLK letters; BLK
R GRN DBL WHT GMY FDL; rounded corners; FF
R GRN DBL WHT GMY FDL; squared corners
R DYL DPK RED
Dark Pink sky; 5x63 mm name; FF;
R DBL YEL RED
FF
R WHT M/C DGR
eye; FF; LVI ground; PBL sky
C RED WHT RED
RED arrow points right; FF; (1959)
R WHT M/C RED
BRN COG
R WHT BLU BLK
FF; light use
R RED BLK YEL
long snouted beaver; FF; MTZ
R YEL BLK WHT
BLK lockstitch in outer bdr; MTZ;
R WHT M/C WHT
FF
R WHT M/C BLK
ORG bkgd for name; FF
C BLK BLK WHT
FF; 118 mm
R BLK M/C BLK
RED WWW "25" - FF; name on
R RED DTQ RED YEL PB double stitched GRY
C WHT RED DYL
FF; used
DGR
BRN deer;crimped & glued to
R BLU M/C ORG
BLU sky; BLK details in tree; FF
R DYL M/C RED DGR FDL; FF; BRN canoe; LB
C YEL DGR RED
"C" of name open; FF; (1958);
R DYL M/C WHT
5 trees on left; ; BRN bear; FF;
C RED ORG BLK
wagon; FF
BLU GRY RED
FF
C WHT M/C RED
RED/WHT field; WHT show thru
R RED M/C BLK
DGR grass; FF; LBL area in smooth
R GRN WHT GRN
FF
R WHT DBL DYL
FF
C WHT BLK GRN
135 mm; arrowhead points above
C BRN YOR RED
FF
R RED WHT RED
FF
R BLK ORG BRN
RED OA & 53; BLK WWW; FF;
R BLK M/C BLK
LBL sky; FF; VER stitch sky; single
C BLU WHT RED
103x33 mm; RED "SHERMAN
C RED GRY GRN
R WHT M/C BLK
FF; LB
C YEL WHT DBR
letter almost BLK; MVE: DBR; FF;
C WHT RED BLU
MVE; FF; (1954)
DBL LBL RED
"HEY"; FF; (1960); used
R DYL NBL DBR
FF
C DYL BLK RED LGY WHT BMT
R RED M/C RED
LBL sky; FF
R YEL GRN YEL
YEL lockstitch in bdr; FF
C RED GRN
FF; BLK "74"; light use
R YEL WHT RED
TLS; 6 mm arrowhead; FF
Auction
Closes:toFriday
February
Call or Email
reserve– sale
items 20, 1998
$125
$475
$50
$25
$25
$20
$15
$25
$35
$30
$10
$575
$90
$35
$65
$30
$45
$20
$15
$100
$600
$55
$65
$275
$10
$550
$40
$35
$25
$40
$35
$750
$125
$140
$25
$20
$475
$50
$35
$90
$175
$40
$110
$40
$120
$50
$550
$75
(435)655-8899 or (801) 655-8899
[email protected]
45
The Journal Set Price Sale
1068 78
1069 79
1070 80
1071 81
1072 83
1073 85
1074 89
1075 91
1076 92
1077 97
1078 98
1079 101
1080 101
1081 102
1082 106
1083 106
1084 106
1085 106
1086 107
1087 107
1088 107
1089 109
1090 111
1091 112
1092 114
1093 117
1094 119
1095 120
1096 124
1097 124
1098 125
1099 126
1100 127
1101 127
1102 130
1103 131
1104 133
1105 140
1106 142
1107 145
1108 145
1109 148
1110 159
1111 159
1112 160
1113 161
1114 164
1115 165
1116 168
1117 168
1118 170
1119 170
1120 172
1121 173
1122 178
1123 178
1124 180
1125 181
1126 182
1127 182
1128 183
1129 186
1130 189
1131 194
1132 195
1133 196
1134 199
1135 205
1136 212
1137 212
1138 212
1139 213
1140 217
1141 218
1142 220
46
F1b
S1
F1
S1
F1
S1b
S1
F1
F1
S1a
F1
F1a
F1b
F1b
F1a
S2a
S2b
S1
F1a
F1b
S1
F1
F1
F1
S1b
F1a
F1
F1
F1
S1
F1
F1
F1a
S1a
F1
F1b
F1b
F1
F1
F1b
S1
F1
F1a
S1a
F2
S1
F1
S1
F1d
F1
F1a
S1
F2
F1
F1b
S1
F1a
S1
F1a
F1b
F1
F1
F2
S1a
F2
F1
F1
F1
S1a
S1b
S1b
S1a
F1
F1
F1a
C BLK RED RED
C RED DBL GRN
C RED GRN RED
R RED M/C RED
C RED WHT DBL
C RED BLU BLK
R WHT M/C RED
C WHT BLK DGR
C RED GRN DYL
R RED WHT DBL
R BLK KHA RED
C YEL WHT GRN
C DYL WHT GRN
C BLK BLU PUR
C GRN WHT RED
R RED WHT BLK
R RED WHT BLK
R WHT M/C DBL
C DBL LBL RED
C DBL BLU RED
R WHT M/C BLK
C BLK RED DYL
C WHT BLU WHT
C RED WHT BLK
C DBL WHT LOL
C DBL YOR DBL
R GRN WHT DOR
C BLK LGY GRN
C YEL BLK WHT
R RED M/C BLK
C WHT RED DYL
C RED WHT RED
C RED WHT BLK
R BLK M/C BLK
C RED ORG BLK
R DYL RED DYL
C RED ORG RED
R BLK WHT RED
C RED BLU BLK
R BLK BLU DYL
R WHT LBL DYL DYL
R RED BLU BLK
C BLK WHT LGR
R BLK M/C DGR
C BLK YEL DBL
C BLU ORG BLK
R RED LBL RED
R WHT M/C BLK
C DGR WHT RED
R ORG PBL BLK
C RED DBL RED
R DYL M/C WHT
C DYL BLK DYL
C M/C WHT RED
C GRN WHT RED
R RED DYL DBL
C DYL BLK RED
R BLK M/C BLK
C BRN LBL RED
C BRN LBL RED
C DBL BLU RED
C GRY BLK BLK
C M/C DBL RED
C RED BLK DYL
C RED LBL WHT
C LBL WHT RED
C BLK WHT RED
C DYL WHT GRN
C WHT M/C BLK
C WHT M/C BLK
R BLK M/C BLK
R BLK M/C LYL
C RED WHT BLK
C RED WHT DBL
C BLK WHT BLK
Paper on back; TLM; 8 mm letters
FF; Used
FF
Threadbreak;PBL sky;FF;4 BLK lines
FF
BLU base material; Used
FF
FF; Used
FF
VER WHT below beaver; FF; PUR &
FF
Light boxsoil;121x48 mm;RED
124x48 mm; TLR; thin arrow
TLS
Used;FF; TLS; RBR elk
70x123 mm; 5 mm thin arms
Used;7 mm thick arms
HOR moon; 52x124 mm; FF; no RED
TLR; FF; MVE; (1957)
TRR
RED 107; MVE; (1964)
FF
FF
FF
BLU BMT
thin lettering and thin deer; FF; MVE
FF; LB; TL; VER GRN grass; HOR
RED WWW; BLU river
FF; MVE--backstitch
FF
A.R.; FF
BLK WWW; FF; (authenticity
FF; RED line between eyes
FF; ORG arrow; BLU face
FF
TLS; MVE
DBR buffalo
multicolored pipe; FF
DYL WWW; FF
BSA; FF; sharp corners; OLV in
wings have LBL EMB; MVE; (1957);
Light boxsoil;LGY face w/ zig-zag
FF; DPR mountains
Light use;FF;(may be issued before
course VER ORG bkgd; FF
FF; double rainbow
FF
Light use; 2 mm wide legs of RED
FF
BRN flying owl; FF; RED outline
MAR eagle with BLK details; FF
2.5 mm thick CE; arrowhead touches
FF; VIO mountains
TLM
FF; (1976)
FF; 3 mm thick bdr
Used;Native Americans w/
FF; RED tags from name to bdr; LBL
no tags from name to bdr; no tint to
WHT cow skull; FF
FF
VER grass; FF
RED "W"; FF; 1 mm BLK eye
7 mm gate sign; NT
52x126 mm; RED tongue on BLU ox;
arrow points right; WAHINKTO;
FF; 57x112 mm; TLR
Box soil;RED;tight small lacing in
3 mm wide lacing in tepee
LGR hills
"713"; (1969); FF; BLU sky
FF
FF
misspelled "PASACONAWAY"; FF;
$115
$425
$475
$125
$185
$325
$100
$75
$65
$30
$200
$200
$145
$125
$475
$85
$75
$50
$135
$90
$20
$75
$200
$90
$60
$200
$60
$175
$150
$90
$395
$350
$500
$45
$150
$20
$100
$30
$90
$45
$15
$125
$75
$15
$600
$650
$150
$45
$60
$40
$200
$60
$75
$40
$90
$25
$200
$90
$125
$100
$450
$150
$275
$125
$80
$125
$110
$315
$175
$75
$25
$650
$200
$85
$175
The Auction in the Journal
The Journal Set Price Sale
1143 221
1144 223
1145 224
1146 225
1147 226
1148 229
1149 232
1150 233
1151 237
1152 238
1153 242
1154 246
1155 247
1156 248
1157 251
1158 251
1159 252
1160 253
1161 255
1162 257
1163 261
1164 262
1165 267
1166 271
1167 274
1168 275
1169 276
1170 278
1171 279
1172 282
1173 287
1174 288
1175 289
1176 291
1177 292
1178 294
1179 295
1180 296
1181 298
1182 298
1183 300
1184 304
1185 307
1186 309
1187 312
1188 313
1189 313
1190 315
1191 319
1192 321
1193 326
1194 328
1195 332
1196 334
1197 340
1198 343
1199 348
1200 349
1201 350
1202 351
1203 353
1204 355
1205 356
1206 356
1207 369
1208 371
1209 375
1210 377
1211 379
1212 380
1213 381
1214 389
1215 391
1216 394
1217 396
F1a
F1
S1
F1b
F1a
F1
F1b
F1a
S1a
S1a
F1a
F1
F1a
F2
F1a
F1b
S1a
S1a
S1
F1
S1
S1
F1
F1b
S1a
S1b
F1
F1b
F1b
S1a
F1a
F1
F1b
F1
F1
F2a
F1a
S1
F1a
F1b
S1
S1
F1
F1
F1
F1b
F1
F1
F1a
F1
F1
S1
F1
F1
S1
F1
F1
S1
F1
S1
S1
F1a
F1a
F1b
F1
F1
F1a
F1
F1
F1
F1b
F1
F1a
S1a
F1a
C YOR WHT RED
C RED WHT BLK
C DYL BLK WHT
C YEL GRN RED
C BRN PYL BRN
R DYL DBL BLK
C BLK GRN WHT
C BLK GRY BLK
R GRN M/C BLK
C GRN DYL RED
C BLU PBL RED
R RED WHT RED
R BLK MAN YEL
C WHT LBL WHT
C RED BLU BLK
C RED BLU BLK
R PUR M/C RED
R RED M/C DYL
R DYL WHT BLK
R RED WHT RED
R RED M/C BLK
R BLK WHT DBL
C BLK WHT RED
C RED WHT GRN
R RED LGR RED
R WHT M/C BLK
C BRN BLU DYL
C BRN TRQ WHT
C LBL WHT LBL
R RED M/C YEL
C DYL GRN BLK
C RED LBL RED
C WHT BLK RED YEL
C RED WHT DBL
C RED WHT DYL
R GRN YEL DBR
C BLK WHT BLU
C RED BLK BLK
C M/C WHT DGR
C M/C WHT GRN
C RED M/C RED
R BLK M/C RED
R BLK WHT RED
R RED BLU BLK
C RED WHT DBL
C RED WHT DBL
R YEL NBL WHT
C YEL DBL YEL
C GRN LYL RED
C DBL WHT ORG
C RED BLU RED
C YEL WHT RED
C RED BLU RED
C WHT DBL WHT
R DYL WHT RED
R GRN MAN DBR DBR
C WHT LBL RED
R RED M/C RED
C DBR LBR BLK
R RED M/C RED
R NBL M/C RED
C RED WHT DBL
C RED BLU RED
C RED BLU RED
C RED DGR YEL
R RED WHT BLU
C RED NBL DYL
C BLK WHT RED
R RED WHT RED
C RED WHT RED
C RED BLU BLK
C BLK WHT RED
R GRN YEL NBL
R BLK WHT BLK
R DYL WHT BLK
FF; BRN fox
$275
FF
$225
FF
$375
thin points that do not extend
$225
Light glue stain;RED "WWW"; FF
$400
FF
$90
122x60 mm; fletch does not touch
$125
FF; Used
$450
no water area; "Needle nose"; FF; top $90
FF; WHT BMT
$90
ORG chest; FF;Used
$125
MTZ; "WWW" staggered at bottom; $250
FF; thin BLU, RED, BLK, YEL
$75
pine tree has no trunk;Used
$90
Light use;FF; "HOH-SQUA"; 5 mm $125
Used; 3 mm tall BLK ax head
$90
FF; BRN Native American; flat
$30
FF; FR/E; 117 mm
$275
FF; LB
$30
FF
$80
"Pegleg" issue; FF; LB
$30
FF
$150
BLK/YEL bdr; RED lips; FF
$450
Light handling; DYL turtle and inner $350
HOR EMB bkgd; FF
$90
LBL sky
$25
BRN antlers; FF
$225
FF; arrowhead is almost the same
$350
Mint w/staple marks;acorns do not
$325
FF; NBL sky; bear has nub tail
$90
notched in tree; 9 mm fat tail; FF
$140
125x51 mm; (1961); FF
$125
Light use;thick 2 mm LBL candles
$60
FF
$950
FF
$90
LB shape; 53x118 mm; thick arrow; 7 $85
Light use;DYL "WWW"; (1956); FF $110
tie together on right top of first "N"; $375
FF; thin letters; BLK and RED C/E $90
thick letters
$80
FF
$40
teddy bear; big ears; no teeth; FF
$250
Used; AR; 12 stripes; FF; MVE
$125
FF; LB
$40
FF; Box soil
$225
122x60 mm; Used
$90
charter mbr issue; FF
$75
FF
$125
panther has twill eye; FF
$125
FF
$350
FF; (1956)
$450
small YEL t-bird; DYL BMT; FF;
$110
WHT WWW; FF
$175
FF
$800
FF; LB; (1959)
$45
BSA; deer has horns; FF
$350
FF; Light use
$150
DGY heron; WHT "349"; BLU
$150
FF
$90
FF
$40
FF; flying owl; light use
$150
FF; council name on 92 mm arc; 44 $125
gauze backing; FF
$125
pellon backing; 122 mm
$50
MVE; FF
$125
28x29 mm t-bird; 46x120 mm; FF
$200
Lt use;dbl thick top bdr;tag connects # $150
FF; light boxsoil
$650
FF; bent wings; no number
$125
FF; DBL eagle
$150
light use;"381" tags @ middle
$125
FF
$375
FF; NBL lock between "PANA-MA" $250
118 mm wide; FF; CB
$60
Used;FF; MTZ; FR/E
$75
Call or Email to reserve sale items
(435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
47
The Journal Set Price Sale
1218 396
1219 398
1220 399
1221 400
1222 402
1223 404
1224 407
1225 408
1226 409
1227 410
1228 412
1229 413
1230 415
1231 416
1232 417
1233 420
1234 421
1235 422
1236 422
1237 423
1238 424
1239 428
1240 428
1241 429
1242 432
1243 433
1244 433
1245 434
1246 436
1247 436
1248 438
1249 440
1250 442
1251 444
1252 446
1253 449
1254 451
1255 452
1256 455
1257 456
1258 457
1259 458
1260 461
1261 462
1262 464
1263 466
1264 467
1265 473
1266 474
1267 477
1268 478
1269 478
1270 480
1271 481
1272 484
1273 484
1274 490
1275 490
1276 492
1277 494
1278 495
1279 497
1280 498
1281 499
1282 503
1283 506
1284 507
1285 510
1286 515
1287 523
1288 524
1289 527
1290 529
1291 533
1292 533
48
F1c
F1
F1b
F1
F1
S1b
F1
F1b
F1
F1b
F1
F1
F1a
F1
F1
F1a
S1
F1a
F1c
S1b
F1
F1a
F1c
F1a
F1
F1a
F1b
F1b
S1a
S1b
S1
S1
S1
F1
F1
F1a
F1
F1b
F1a
S1a
F1a
F1a
F1b
F1a
S1
F1
F1
F1
S1
S1
S1a
S1b
F1a
F1a
F1a
F1b
F1a
F1c
F1a
F1
F1a
F1
F1
F1
F1a
F1b
F1
F1b
F1a
F1b
S1
S1
F1
F1
F2a
R DYL WHT BLK
R DGR DBL RED
C YEL PBL YEL
C RED DGR BRN
R YEL BLU RED
C RED YOR RED
C GRY NBL GRY
C DYL WHT RED
C DBR WHT BLK
C RED LBL RED
C GRN BLK ORG
R DGR WHT BLK
C BLK WHT BLK
R DBL ORG BLK
R RED ORG GRN
C BLK GRY RED
R WHT LBL RED
C RED WHT RED
C RED WHT RED
C DYL M/C RED
R RED DGR RED
C BLK YEL BLK
C BLK YEL BLK
C BLK LBL BLK
C RED WHT BLK
C BLK WHT DBL
C BLK WHT DBL
C BLK LYL RED
C LBL LBR RED
C LBL LBR RED
R ORG M/C DYL
R GRN RED DYL
R DYL M/C ORG
C DBL DRD DBL
C GRN WHT RED
C RED WHT DBL
C RED WHT GRN
C RED WHT BLK
C RED BLK WHT
C DBL M/C RED
C LBL GRY LBL
C LGY NBL LGY
C LGY LYL RED
C DYL KHA WHT
C NBL DBL NBL
C RED RED BLK
C BLK WHT BLK
R DYL WHT BLK
C GRN DYL DBL
R DYL WHT DBL
C LBL BLK WHT
C LBL BLK WHT
C BLK ORG RED
C RED WHT RED
R ORG WHT RED
R YOR WHT RED
C BLK WHT ORG
C BLK WHT ORG
C RED LBL RED
C RED WHT BLK
R RED WHT RED
R RED BLU RED
R SMY GRN LGR
C DYL RED WHT DYL
R GRN ORG BLK
C LBR MAN DBL
R BLK BLU BLK
C WHT ORG RED
C RED WHT RED
R LBR KHA RED
C BLK WHT YEL
R RED LBL DYL
R WHT RED WHT
R RED GRY RED
R RED GRY RED
regular R/E; very DGY rock; 9 mm
FF
Light staining; 122x59 mm; TRR; 77
FF; elk does not have eye; lower half
FF
3-4 mm thick bdr; 2 mm YOR
FF
7 mm ltrs; 94 mm arrow
BLU waterfall; FF
Used; grass/water not EMB in HOR
48x130 mm nearly a REC; FF
A.R.; TLR; FF; 129x55 mm
FF; twill snow; no YEL between "H"
FF; (1957)
Light use;FF; A.R.
FF; RBR eagle
no number; name partly on land; FF
Used;light KHA acorn bottom; DBR
TAN acorn bottom; (almost LPK
LBL BMT
FF; (almost BLK twill)
HOR feathers; (1958); MVE
TLM; 3 mm bdr; DIAG feathers
Used;TLR; "DZ" tag @ bottom;
FF; tail touches right "W"; 22 mm
Glue stain;FF; PYL mouth
LYL mouth
MVE
FF; GRY BMT
ORG BMT
no arrow; WHT star; 10 mm ltrs; FF
52x124; HOR leaf; rd corners; MTZ;
MVE; FF
all 3 "4"s touch; GER; FF
TLR; 117x56 mm; (1956); FF; MVE
VER ground; rounded trees; TLM;
FF
LBR in duck
A.R.; DBR face; FF; solid VER WHT
WHT BMT; FF; (1957)
Used;FF; RED chipmunk has 2 tiny
60x126 mm
NT
FF
VER field; VER LGY arrowhead; FF;
FF
RED WWW; FF
Used; arrow right; 28 mm sides; FF;
GRN WWW; FF; DBR eagle; 3
FF; MVE--letter thickness
FF; BLU BMT; 67X137 mm
BLK BMT; solid DOR arrowhead
FF; rounded bottom; TLR
TLR; FF
Box soil;FR/E; MTZ; FF
TLR; zig-zag in ORG band left of
distinct ORG &YEL bands to left of
BLK WWW 492; 122x59 mm; FF;
FF;inked number shows from back
TLS; A.L.; FF; FR/E
FF
GMY WWW; FF
FF; FDL
FF; F R/E; BLK tags from name to
Light use
FF
thick ltrs
dipped point; TRR; FF; (1955)
TRM; 115 mm
FF; machine stitched
no lodge number; FF; (1958)
FF; F R/E; WHT anteater
FF; 52X116 mm
52X125 mm; F R/E
$40
$275
$100
$250
$140
$30
$225
$50
$175
$150
$95
$140
$450
$200
$175
$100
$100
$125
$90
$75
$250
$175
$90
$125
$350
$150
$140
$90
$275
$275
$20
$250
$50
$175
$375
$200
$140
$125
$100
$200
$325
$90
$175
$80
$125
$275
$350
$275
$510
$75
$225
$200
$90
$160
$110
$45
$95
$75
$60
$175
$90
$325
$125
$375
$195
$275
$220
$175
$250
$200
$550
$475
$200
$110
$100
The Auction in the Journal
The Journal Set Price Sale
1293 537
1294 539
1295 545
1296 548
1297 549
1298 552
1299 553
1300 554
1301 561
1302 564
1303 573
1304 578
F1b
F1
F1
S1
F1c
S1
F1
F1a
S1a
F1b
S1
S1a
R GRN LYL GRN
R RED WHT BLK
R RED DGR RED
C BLK M/C RED
R RED WHT RED
R BLK M/C BLK
R LGR WHT RED
R RED WHT BLK
R BLK M/C BLK
R RED YEL BLK
R ORG M/C LOR
C RED M/C WHT
7 of "537" does not touch bdr
round "O"s; MVE--widths; FF; LB
FF
FF
TLS; 123x50 mm
6 ripple lines on each side; 124x49
FF
FF; 52x115 mm VER face; TL;
LGY bkgd
TR; "sunglass"; all "O" have YEL
FF; BRONZE face; Native American
feathers; BLU BMT; (1970); FF
$125
$230
$200
$125
$100
$400
$175
$90
$40
$125
$30
$140
Region 1 - New England
Lot
1305 83
1306 131
1307 164
1308 195
1309 217
1310 220
1311 220
1312 220
1313 234
1314 234
1315 245
1316 261
1317 271
1318 274
1319 274
1320 297
1321 297
1322 309
1323 313
1324 319
1325 351
1326 388
1327 389
1328 398
1329 408
1330 408
1331 408
1332 414
1333 427
1334 487
1335 505
1336 507
1337 509
1338 518
1339 518
1340 518
1341 521
1342 521
1343 521
1344 521
1345 534
1346 539
Item
S2
S3
F3
R2
R2a
F3
F4a
S1
S3a
S4
F2
R1
S4a
R2
X1
F2a
S2
S2a
S1
S3
F2b
A3
S1
S1
A2
S1
S2
R7
S1
S1
F3
F2a
F1b
S2
S3c
P2
F3
S1
S2
S3
X1
ZF1
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
Description
Reserve
price
R RED M/C DBL
Native American facing forward;
$40
R DYL RED DYL DYL BSA; HOR bkgd; LB
$25
R DBL GRY RED
$60
C BLK WHT BLK
Paper on back;5 mm"O"inORDER; 8 $110
C RED WHT BLK
top chest detail line continuous
$100
R BLK WHT BLK
Used"AREA 1A"
$80
R BLK WHT BLK
Used; "AREA 1F"; plain back
$60
R RED M/C RED
MVE
$30
R NBL LBL WHT
Well used; even 6 mm ltrs; RED
$30
R WHT RED WHT
LB
$55
R BLK WHT RED
$225
R BLU WHT BLU
$40
R BLK M/C BLK WHT FDL; 103 mm VER sky; RED
$20
C WHT BLU WHT
A.L.
$125
R BLK M/C RED
TRI
$90
R RED WHT BLK
54x126 mm; FR/E; TLR; 12x15 mm $120
R BLK DYL RED
HOR bkgd; LB
$125
R RED LBL BLK
Light use; "AREA 1A"; LB
$95
R RED BBL WHT
5 mm "313"
$25
R GRN DYL BLK
"TOKA WIKAN"; LB
$90
R DYL NBL DYL
Used; TLS
$200
C RED WHT GRN
RED WWW; RED outline of feather; $150
R BLK M/C RED
HOR Mts; LGY stitch in ribbon
$40
R RED M/C RED
small bobcat tracks; 4x6 mm pads; LB $45
C DYL GRN RED
point down; depicts a panther
$125
R DYL LBL RED
thick WWW; DYL inside circle; LB $45
R DYL BLU RED
thin WWW; YEL inside circle; FR/E; $40
R BLK WHT RED
twill; flying squirrel
$75
R RED M/C BLK
LB
$35
R DYL M/C BLK
$70
R RED WHT RED
BRO; TLR
$45
C DYL PUR BLK
$80
R WHT BLU YEL
TLM
$80
R RED LPK BLK
HOR bkgd; LB
$175
R RED PN K BLK
FR/E lighter & duller than arrow
$110
R RED LPK BLK
75x135 mm TRI
$125
R RED WHT RED
no chin & no cheek/arrowhead detail; $60
R RED WHT RED
56x129 mm
$60
R RED LBL BLK
54x120 mm
$50
R RED BLU BLK
52x118 mm; LB; MVE--2 shades of $50
C RED WHT
14x27 mm arc; solid EMB thin YEL $40
R RED WHT BLK
tall "O"s; "O" in "PASSAQUO"
$15
New York & New Jersey
Lot
1347 2
1348 2
1349 2
1350 4
1351 4
1352 4
1353 4
1354 9
1355 9
1356 9
1357 9
1358 14
1359 14
1360 15
Item
S1
R3
S2a
A3
F2a
S1b
P1
R1
F2b
S1
S3
A1
F1a
F2d
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R DYL DBL DYL
R DYL DBL DYL
R DYL WHT RED
C WHT GRN BLK
R WHT BLU BLK
R WHT M/C BLK
R BLK WHT M/C
C RED WHT RED
C GRN GRY RED
R BLK M/C BLK
R DYL BPK RED
C BLU BLU RED
R BLK TRQ WHT
R YEL BLK WHT
Description
price
Reserve
1919-1969 in WHT; ANN; MVE
twill; 1969; 78 mm; 50th ANN
thick letters; (1970)
95x75 mm; HOR EMB owl; GRN
52x118 mm; LB; owl on stump; TLR
DOL grass
GRN/BLK ltrs; QC
small 1/4” rust mark;GRN tree trunk;
tree does not touch bdr; "W" under
Black tree; (1959)
bright PNK sky; 7x54 mm name
Used; 110x78 mm arrowhead; twill
TLR
TLS; FR/E
Call or Email to reserve sale items
$30
$40
$10
$40
$20
$20
$60
$75
$90
$20
$15
$225
$95
$40
(435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
49
The Journal Set Price Sale
1361 15
1362 19
1363 19
1364 19
1365 24
1366 24
1367 24
1368 24
1369 24
1370 24
1371 24
1372 24
1373 24
1374 34
1375 48
1376 48
1377 49
1378 49
1379 49
1380 49
1381 54
1382 54
1383 54
1384 64
1385 71
1386 71
1387 71
1388 76
1389 77
1390 77
1391 82
1392 82
1393 82
1394 95
1395 95
1396 95
1397 107
1398 159
1399 159
1400 159
1401 165
1402 165
1403 165
1404 172
1405 178
1406 178
1407 186
1408 186
1409 186
1410 246
1411 247
1412 247
1413 284
1414 284
1415 286
1416 286
1417 357
1418 357
1419 357
1420 359
1421 360
1422 360
1423 360
1424 362
1425 362
1426 409
1427 409
1428 410
1429 411
1430 412
1431 412
1432 417
1433 417
1434 418
1435 418
50
L
S2
F1
S4
A1a
X1b
F1
S2
S3
F3
S5
S7
S9
S4
F2
S2
R2b
F4
F6
S2b
F2
F3
S4
F3b
P1
F6
S1b
F5
F2
W1
A1b
S1
P2
F2
S1
S4a
X3
F4b
P2
S2a
P2
S2
P1
F3b
C1
F2
F2
P2b
S2a
F2b
S1
S2
F2
S1
X2
S3
X3b
F2a
P1
J1
P1
F2a
P3
C1
S1
F3
S2
S1
P2a
F3a
S2
X1
W1
S2
S4b
BLK DYL
C DGR DGR RED
C RED WHT RED
R BLK M/C RED
C RED WHT DBL
C LBR WHT DBL
C RED WHT WHT
R BLK ORG BLK
R BLK ORG BLK
R RED WHT WHT
R WHT WHT BLK
R WHT WHT BLK
C BLK M/C BLK RED
R YEL M/C RED LGR
C WHT BLK GRN
R WHT BLK GRN
C YEL GRN WHT
R DYL LTQ RED
R ORG BBL YEL
R BLK RED YEL
R YEL BLU WHT
R YEL BLU WHT
R YEL LBL WHT
R DGR LGR BLK
R DYL M/C RED RED
R GRN YEL GRN
R GRN DYL GRN
C LGY WHT GRN
C RED BLU YEL
RED GRY DYL
C MAR YOR BLU
R ORG WHT RED
R ORG WHT RED
R RED WHT BLU
R RED WHT RED
R RED M/C BLK
R RED YOR BLK
R BLK WHT GRN
R BLK M/C WHT
R BLK M/C DGR RED
R BLK M/C RED
R DYL M/C BLK
R DYL BLU BLK
R WHT BLK WHT
RED GRN
R GRN WHT RED
R GRY BLK BLK
R GRY BLK BLK
R BLK M/C BLK
R LBL WHT RED
R BLK ORG YEL
R BLU ORG YEL
R BRN LBR BRN
R RED GRY BLK
C WHT WHT RED
R GRY BLU GRY
C RED WHT LGR
R DYL GRY BLK
R DYL M/C BLK
R BLK WHT RED
R DYL LBL RED
R DYL BLU RED
R DYL BLU RED
C WHT WHT
R BLK M/C BLK
R DBR MAN BLK
R DBR WHT BLK
R BRN M/C WHT
R ROR M/C WHT
C GRN BLK ORG
R WHT M/C ORG
C DBR GRN RED
R RED ORG GRN
R GRY M/C BLK
R GRY M/C BLK
$20
$90
$250
$75
$35
$40
$40
$40
$45
$30
$20
$20
$15
$15
$475
$20
$30
$30
$10
$10
$45
$40
$25
$15
$125
$20
$15
$115
$70
$40
LBR log gate
$90
MVE
$20
103x175 mm solid EMB TRI; MVE $50
LB; light use
$40
GRY WWW; VER EMB bkgd
$30
3 mm gap between "OHNI" &
$15
REC; 50th ANN; NOAC65; 76x54
$60
TLS
$20
On N/C; 123x170 mm QC; 6
$80
FDL; LBL sky
$5
On N/C; 152x215 mm QC; DBL sky $150
$15
On N/C; 152x210 mm twill QC
$125
TLM; used
$10
RED WWW 178; no label; 101 mm $275
GRN WWW
$55
LB
$20
TLS
$75
58x120 mm; 88 mm name
$10
darker LBL R/E; DBL stitch in BDR $90
$20
$20
rounded bottom
$45
LB
$30
oval twill; (1952)
$75
VER bkgd; (25th ANN); (1969)
$125
TRM
$125
$60
95x135 mm; HOR sky/water; QC
$140
140 mm R; (1975); MVE--thin - thick $45
On silk N/C; 155x175 mm twill QC; $110
TLR; MVE
$20
150x60 mm solid EMB QC; same
$75
GRN tree; RED arrow; no label or
$275
$50
no number
$90
BLK bear; ONE gunwale canoe
$20
FF; detailed GRN/DGR trees;
$35
solid EMB QC; BLU water
$350
Used; 50x118 mm; 6-7 mm wide
$15
ears point up; MVE-ltr thickness
$15
90x64 mm fully EMB turtle
$225
$60
MTZ; LGY wolf without BLK outline $30
bright BLU sky
$30
1958 Christmas Banquet
WWW in straight line below buffalo
Box soil
WHT buffalo
TRR
Paper on back; WHT twill shows in
2 points on heron's breast; TLR; MVE
all DBL heron; BLK No. 24
"1915 1965"; OA 50th ANN; LBL/
"jailbird" issue
REC w/ rounded bottom corners
regular flap shape
FDL
FDL
Machine sewn; 114 mm; arrowhead
GRY squirrel with BLK details; LB
with X2 attached
LB; continuous arrow; 48 mm name;
FR/E
RBR stag; MVE
WHT/RED ribbon arrow down left;
WHT/RED ribbon arrow down left no
Used; arrow points up; "W" has BLK
BRN stag
BSA; 2 piece; 125x175 mm; BLU
62 mm arrow left; 10 mm wide
MED GRN thin trees; 62 mm arrow;
Used
RED WWW; MVE
The Auction in the Journal
The Journal Set Price Sale
1436 423
1437 423
1438 423
1439 423
1440 431
1441 431
1442 440
1443 443
1444 444
1445 444
1446 449
1447 465
1448 515
1449 515
1450 535
1451 535
1452 546
P1
F1
F2
J1
F2
S2
R2
P1
F3
S1
S1b
P2
F3
F4
F2a
S1
S2
R DYL BLU RED
R RED YEL BLK
R RED YEL BLK
C RED LBL ORG
R RED ORG BLU
R BRN M/C RED
R GRN RED DYL
R WHT ORG BRN
R WHT DRD WHT
R WHT RED WHT
R RED M/C RED
R DYL BLU RED
R RED WHT RED
R LYL BLU RED
R BLK WHT RED
R BLK ORG RED
R DYL WHT RED
On N/C; 154x210 mm; solid; QC;
WHT wing tips; TLR; LBL water;
BLK wing tips; TLR; LBL water;
148 mm; solid; 9 mm ltrs; (1975)
MVE--thk & thn ltrs
WWW in cloud; LB
80 mm solid
On N/C; BRN WWW; 75x145 mm
MTZ; FR/E
with WWW
Box soil; FR/E; BLU sky; LPR &
HOR EMB GRN; 104x139 mm fully
DGR frog outline; MTZ; (1960)
MTZ; light use
52x118 mm; TL; LB; "W's" inside
LB; council name spelled correctly
$175
$30
$30
$150
$55
$75
$95
$125
$25
$25
$20
$100
$80
$60
$25
$50
$50
Pennsylvania
Lot
1453 1
1454 1
1455 1
1456 1
1457 1
1458 1
1459 1
1460 1
1461 1
1462 1
1463 5
1464 5
1465 5
1466 5
1467 5
1468 5
1469 5
1470 5
1471 6
1472 6
1473 6
1474 11
1475 11
1476 11
1477 11
1478 18
1479 18
1480 22
1481 22
1482 22
1483 22
1484 22
1485 22
1486 22
1487 22
1488 30
1489 30
1490 33
1491 33
1492 33
1493 33
1494 39
1495 39
1496 39
1497 43
1498 43
1499 43
1500 43
1501 44
1502 44
1503 44
1504 46
1505 46
1506 67
1507 130
Item
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R7c
BLK DRD GRN
X7a
BLK DGR
X7c
BLK GRN
X13b BLK GRN
R14 R DYL LGY RED
R15 R BLK GRY RED
R16 R RED LGY RED
F5 R GRN RED BLK
S6 R SMY M/C DYL DYL
S12 R SMY M/C DYL DYL
F2 R GRY PYL BLK
S2 C BLK ORG RED
A2 C BLK DYL RED
S3 R DYL M/C BLK
P1 R BLK YEL BLK
S5a R DYL M/C BLK
S5c R DYL M/C BLK
X1
DGY GRY
R2 R RED WHT RED
C3a
ORG M/C
S4 R RED BLU RED
X3a C DBL ORG
X5 C BLK RED BLK
R2b R BLK ORG BLK
S1b R WHT M/C DGR
X1 R RED BLU BRN
F3 R RED LBL RED
X1c
RED WHT
R1a C RED ORG RED
S2 R GRN BLU WHT
X2a
RED WHT
S4 R RED ORG RED
S5 R RED ORG RED
R4 R RED ORG RED
S16 R PUR M/C RED BLK
S2 C RED GRY DBL
S3 C RED GRY DBL
X1 C DGR WHT
F8 C RBR DGR RED
X4a C DGR WHT RED
C2
DYL DBR
R2a C RED ORG RED
S1a R YEL M/C RED
S3 R YEL M/C RED
R3b C RED WHT GRN
S9b C RED WHT GRN
R7 R RED M/C NBL
S10b R RED M/C DBL
A1a C BLK WHT RED
S1b R BLK WHT RED
S2c R DYL M/C BLK
R2b C GRN WHT GRN
X2 R DBL M/C RED
C8
DBR PCH
S2 R ORG M/C BLK
Description
price
Reserve
$30
$125
$125
$40
$40
HOR field
$40
solid turtle left
$40
60th ANN; 1975
$20
FDL; BRN shoreline; LB
$15
FDL; LGY shoreline
$15
wolfhead in 15x33 mm "V"; FR/E
$50
VER bkgd
$30
used
$45
5 sun rays; wolf's nose in bdr; dip
$10
Used; BLK outline around sun
$75
5 sun rays; LBL sky; GRN foreground $10
BLU sky; BGR forground; very DGR $10
solid EMB wolfhead; PB; DGY felt $40
$55
Used; round head; YEL chest;
$60
53x117 mm; MVE; GRN eye; LB
$20
BLK "XI"; TRR; thick BLK waist and $55
w/o pupils in eye
$35
NT; no BRN ridge
$35
LBL sky
$30
diamond
$40
$15
type 5b label; WAB
$125
102 mm; WAB; thin letters
$75
53x117 mm; LB
$35
felt; EMB W's; 2 mm thin W's; WHT $85
Council name in quotes
$75
Council name no quotes
$40
78 mm; BLK nails
$30
FDL; DYL horseshoe; PB; VIG
$35
A.R.; 7 mm fletching; no crossbar
$50
A.L.
$50
77x111 mm; no lodge or council name $125
$85
76x115; TAN deer; TLR
$65
103x160 mm; BLK underline of WHT $100
BRN deer; back legs over "WA" of
$50
OLV hills
$25
BRN head outline
$20
very thick letters; DBR cabin
$50
light box soil; BRN cabin; lighter
$45
solid EMB; on N/C
$35
DBR cabin
$15
GRN "44" WWW
$100
BGR "W'" and "44"
$25
BGR grass
$30
TLR
$80
shield
$45
damaged; feet are same golden BRN $125
WHT headband
$140
62 mm; MVE; DIAG stitch GRN
95x148 mm felt on felt turtle; EMB
6 mm wide legs in W's; WHT tight
GRN details in shell; WHT cloth
Call or Email to reserve sale items
(435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
51
The Journal Set Price Sale
1508 139
1509 139
1510 168
1511 168
1512 168
1513 168
1514 223
1515 242
1516 251
1517 251
1518 251
1519 251
1520 251
1521 251
1522 251
1523 251
1524 251
1525 251
1526 251
1527 255
1528 256
1529 275
1530 343
1531 343
1532 343
1533 343
1534 343
1535 347
1536 384
1537 384
1538 386
1539 386
1540 419
1541 441
1542 441
1543 455
1544 455
1545 455
1546 455
1547 519
1548 519
X2
S5
A2
F3
S1a
S2
F5
C3a
C3c
C3d
S1
S2
S3
R3
Act
Act
Act
Act
Act
P2
S2a
S3
S2
S5
S6
S7
S3b
F2
R1a
F2b
R1a
S2a
A3
F2
F3b
P1b
F5
F7c
F8
S1d
P1
C RED ORG RED
TRI; light use
R RED WHT GRN
HOR WHT
C GRN WHT RED
twill
C YEL GRY
BLK 168 WWW
R GRN M/C
RED and BRN turkey head; 52x123
R DBL LBL BLK
R RED LBL BLK
DBL WHT
85x85 mm; DBL bird; type 8B;
RED DBL
used, faded; DBL sky; WHT
RED DBL
used; 1 DBL line @ top of cloud; 2
R RED BLU BLK
BLK W's; RED Native American
R RED M/C BLK
RED W's; DYL sun; DYL & RED
R RED BLU BLK
BLK W's; BRN Native American
R YEL TAN RED
"CEREMONIAL TEAM"
R DBL LBL BLK
1967 Ceremonial Conclave
R DBL LBL BLK
1968 Ceremonial Conclave
R BRN LBR BLK
1968 Field Day
R BRN YEL BRN
25 Years of Service 1969 Circle
R LGY LBL BLK
25yrs of Service 1972 3B
R WHT BLK WHT
TRI; LBL water; used
C RED DYL GRN
VER bkgd; washed, restored
R WHT M/C BLK RED BSA; BLK line in log; YEL W's;
R WHT DBL ORG WHT BSA; A.R.; LB
R WHT DBL RED WHT BSA; A.L.; ORD
R RED DBL RED WHT BSA; A.L.; BRO
R YEL DBL RED WHT BSA; A.L.; VIG
R ORG M/C RED RED GRY/WHT buffalo; LBL water
C RED BLU RED
A.L.
R RED LTQ BLK
103 mm; FR/E
R DGR WHT RED
left "W" 3 mm away from tree; 8 mm
C BRN WHT RED
R DBL M/C BLK
LBL water; ORG sun blends into
C GRN WHT GRN
solid EMB; off N/C
R RED DBL RED
DBR deer & outlines
R RED DBL RED
TLS
R RED LBL BLU
Used; LBR deer; BGR grass; TLR
R RED WHT RED
"1951 1961"; ANN
R RED BLU LBR
TLS
R LGY BLU BRN
R YEL DBL WHT
58x118 mm; distinct lettering; WHT
R YEL DBL WHT
TRI solid EMB
$125
$45
$175
$50
$35
$15
$30
$125
$210
$225
$40
$40
$40
$125
$15
$15
$15
$20
$20
$95
$60
$20
$35
$30
$60
$70
$10
$75
$75
$80
$40
$15
$175
$125
$90
$150
$60
$25
$35
$40
$325
Virginia, Maryland & D.C.
Lot
1549 3
1550 3
1551 3
1552 3
1553 12
1554 12
1555 12
1556 20
1557 20
1558 161
1559 161
1560 161
1561 258
1562 258
1563 276
1564 317
1565 349
1566 456
1567 463
1568 483
1569 540
Item
R2a
F1
S15
X
F2
S1
S5
X1b
S1b
R2
S2
S9
A3
S8a
S6
S7a
S3
A1
A4
S1
S1
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
Description
price
Reserve
C GRN WHT RED
GRY raccoon w 4 legs; flat top "3";
R RED YEL GRN
Used; BLU/WHT/RED feathers;
R RED WHT GRN RED DYL bow; 2 SS
R RED WHT
1981 Winter Banquet
C RED WHT RED
RED arrow points left; (1962)
R RED WHT RED
R RED M/C WHT WHT BSA; MVE; (1982)
R RED WHT BLK
RND R/E; thick "20"
R RED WHT BLK
5 mm letters; 65 mm council name;
R RED GRN BLK
6 mm high name; BRN wings
R DBL M/C RED
name in smoke; FF (error); issued
R RED M/C BLK DYL VER GRN grass; 10 mm FDL; BRO;
C M/C WHT WHT
WHT border around arrow; (1951)
R WHT M/C BLK BLK 76 mm name; MAN shore; two 8 mm
R BLK M/C BLK WHT 30 mm square sides; BSA; (1980)
R DYL M/C DYL DBL FDL; CB; LGY B.S.A.; (1975)
R RED M/C RED
DYL "349"; PUR shadow; WHT
C RED WHT DBL
oriented horizontal
R RED M/C BLK
On N/Csolid EMB for N/C; large A;
R DYL GRN DYL
(1962)
R RED M/C ROR
A.R.; OLV grass;; LOR details in
$300
$200
$15
$15
$45
$20
$10
$175
$5
$125
$60
$15
$125
$15
$15
$15
$250
$125
$100
$70
$60
Region 4 - OH, KY & WV
Lot
1570 17
1571 17
1572 17
1573 17
1574 93
1575 109
52
Item
X1
S2a
S2c
S6
R2
R3
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C RED
R BLK
R BLK
R RED
C RED
C BRN
WHT BLK
M/C BLK
M/C BLK
M/C BLK
WHT RED
GRN RED
Description
price
Reserve
Used; WWW only lettering; shape of
LBR sky; GRN trees; name stitched
KHA sky; ORG mountains
VIG large head; BLK antlers; VAR
75 mm
"Shawnee"
$125
$25
$25
$55
$60
$100
The Auction in the Journal
The Journal Set Price Sale
1576 114
1577 145
1578 151
1579 151
1580 151
1581 201
1582 201
1583 201
1584 201
1585 289
1586 323
1587 350
1588 367
1589 367
1590 377
1591 377
1592 377
1593 377
1594 377
1595 377
1596 382
1597 396
1598 416
1599 462
1600 472
1601 472
1602 472
1603 475
1604 480
1605 480
1606 495
1607 495
1608 499
1609 499
1610 513
1611 513
1612 513
1613 522
1614 527
1615 550
S2a
S1
W1
S4
S18
R2
S3a
S3b
S6
S1a
F2a
S3
F3a
F3b
S1
S2b
S4
P2a
S9
C2
X2
F2
S2
S1
F3
X1
S4
F2
F2b
S9a
F2
S1
F2b
S2
S4
A3
S7
P1
F1
S2
R DBL WHT LOL
Used; RED WWW; w/o periods; 8
R BLK BLU DYL
MVE
GRN GRY RED
R BLK WHT RED
WHT rosette
R DOR LGR BLK
woodland Native American
C WHT RED DBL
76 mm; NT
R YEL M/C RED
rounded bottom; LBL sky; ORD; VER
R YEL M/C RED
BLU sky; BRN hills
R YEL M/C RED
pointed bottom; ORD; HOR
R WHT BLK RED DYL FDL; CB; DYL flames/tent
C RED DBL
no name; WHT "323"; 50x126 mm;
R BRN GRN BLK
BLK WWW; 53x114 mm
C DGR WHT RED
BRN elk; small eye
C DGR WHT RED
DBR elk; large eye
C BLK WHT BLU
SIPP-O; DBL BMT
C BLK WHT BLU
coarse VER bkgd; BRN antlers
R BLK WHT DBL
SIPPO; LBR arrow, 377 & WWW
R BLK WHT DBL
On N/C, used; QC; deer has all WHT
R DYL WHT DBL
SIPP-O; BLK 377 & WWW; VIG
WHT M/C
PCH deer w/WHT in back half of ear
C RED ORG BLK
6 mm letters; 5 mm tall fletching &
R BRN LGR WHT
Used; restricted issue
R YEL M/C WHT WHT BSA; (1970)
R DYL BLU WHT
R DBL WHT RED
6 mm wide arrowhead; MVE
R BLK PGR RED
79x120 mm oval; On N/C
R BLK BTQ BLK RED BSA; BRN face; front view
C DYL WHT PUR
no "475"; arrow behind mountain
C BLK ORG RED
BLK beak on eagle
C GRN DYL BLK
LBL BMT; MVE
R RED WHT RED
A.R.
R WHT M/C BLK
51x114 mm
R DYL DRD WHT DYL 50x115 mm; FDL
R DYL RED WHT DYL home lodge nat. chief; FDL
R RED PBL BLK
HOR bkgd; BLK eyes; DBR hat &
C BLK WHT RED
hat brim not EMB; WHT face with
R GRN M/C RED
HOR bkgd; HOR apple
R GRY M/C ORG
TRI
R RED BLU DYL WHT 66 mm "BUCKONGEHANNON";
R DYL M/C BLK
beard made from VER BLK lines
$10
$20
$115
$10
$10
$150
$25
$25
$20
$15
$110
$30
$55
$50
$40
$45
$25
$90
$60
$125
$125
$45
$30
$40
$30
$45
$20
$60
$50
$25
$25
$10
$30
$45
$25
$85
$15
$110
$35
$30
Region 5 - AL, AR, LA, MS & TN
Lot
1616 149
1617 149
1618 169
1619 179
1620 184
1621 185
1622 193
1623 202
1624 202
1625 224
1626 230
1627 230
1628 230
1629 235
1630 235
1631 235
1632 235
1633 254
1634 254
1635 260
1636 260
1637 260
1638 260
1639 264
1640 264
1641 310
1642 345
1643 345
1644 345
1645 397
1646 397
1647 397
Item
S2
P1
X1a
R3
S1b
P1
S2
F2b
S2
QP1
S4b
S6a
S8
F2
P1
S5
S9a
A2
S1b
F2
F3
S3
S4a
S1
S3
S10
F4
S2b
S6b
A2
A3b
S4
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C WHT BLU WHT
R BLK M/C RED
C RED NBL WHT
C GRN GRY RED
C RED DBL LGY
R YEL YEL GRN
R GMY BLU WHT
R BLK PYL RED
R BLK M/C BLK
R YEL BLK WHT
R RED WHT BLK
R BLK M/C WHT
R BLK M/C WHT
R GRN WHT DYL DYL
C YEL WHT BLK
C GRN WHT BLK
C YEL M/C BRN
C BRN ORG BRN
C GRN BLK WHT
C DBR WHT GRN
R DBR WHT GRN
R DBR WHT GRN
R BRN WHT BGR
C BLK LGY BLK
R BLK GRY BLK
R ORG M/C ORG YEL
R BLK WHT RED
R RED DYL RED
R BLK YOR RED BLK
C BLU LBL RED
C YEL BLU RED
R YEL M/C BLK
Description
Reserve
$125
$175
$80
$50
$25
$225
$60
$145
$115
TRI; no "LODGE"; TLR
$95
LGY wolf
$30
HOR bkgd; 53x127 mm; GRY fox
$20
51x114 mm
$30
BSA; used
$195
150x210 mm; QC; off N/C
$325
$45
$45
$225
GRN BMT; MVE
$35
"SEBOONEY"
$50
MVE
$50
"260" below arrow; VER bkgd
$145
"260" on tree; 53x123 mm
$20
110x57 mm; thin C/E; squared lower $200
GER shape; 124x58 mm
$300
PB
$15
$175
123x60 mm
$45
$30
VER WHT in circle
$275
TRR; used
$95
HOR sky; HOR bird
$20
GER shape
gator and heron design; QC
BRN tree trunk
EMB eye; no dots between OA and
DYL sash
solid EMB QC; off N/C, used
PB; BRO
rounded corners
Call or Email to reserve sale items
(435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
53
The Journal Set Price Sale
1648 397
1649 404
1650 404
1651 413
1652 413
1653 413
1654 563
1655 563
S6
S2
S7
F2b
S3b
S7
P1
S2
R ORG M/C BLK
R RED DYL RED
R DYL M/C BLK
R GRN WHT BLK
R GRN M/C BLK
R GRN M/C BLK
R WHT YEL BLU
R RED M/C YEL
6 WHT feathers; BRO; silky EMB;
53x102 mm; 404 above fletching on
no apostrophe; VER DYL bkgd
6 mm trees; BLK tags from name to
thin HOR trees
VER trees; BRO bars flank arrow
TRI
130x61 mm; BLK outlines &
$20
$95
$25
$35
$30
$30
$100
$175
Region 6 - GA, FL & Carolinas
Lot
1656 87
1657 104
1658 104
1659 117
1660 118
1661 118
1662 118
1663 118
1664 118
1665 129
1666 129
1667 129
1668 134
1669 134
1670 163
1671 200
1672 200
1673 200
1674 204
1675 208
1676 229
1677 236
1678 236
1679 239
1680 239
1681 239
1682 239
1683 243
1684 243
1685 265
1686 270
1687 273
1688 324
1689 324
1690 324
1691 326
1692 331
1693 353
1694 385
1695 552
Item
S1
R6
S3
X1
P1
S5
S7a
Act
Act
R1
S2
P1
P1
S2
S5
S1
S4a
S8a
S12
X2
S1
P1
S7
X1b
P2
S7
ACT
S3
S4
S2
S2
F2
F2
F3
S2
F2
X1
X1c
S8
S2
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R BRN YEL WHT
LBL WHT RED
R RED WHT RED
R WHT LBL RED
R DOR DGR WHT
R BRN LGR YEL
R BRN LGR YEL
R RED M/C RED
R YEL BLK GMY
C LBR WHT BLK
R DBL DYL DBL
R DBL DYL DBL
R DYL WHT BLK
R RED M/C RED
R YEL BLK RED BRN
C WHT GRY RED
C RED M/C DBL
R RED M/C BLU DYL
R RED M/C BLK
C RED YOR BLK
R DYL DBL BLK
R GRN WHT RED
R WHT M/C RED
R WHT M/C RED
R WHT M/C RED
R WHT M/C RED
R BLK M/C BLK BLK
R BLK GRY BLK
R YEL M/C RED
R YEL M/C RED
C GRY PBL RED
R GRN WHT YEL YEL
C YEL WHT RED
R YEL WHT DBL
R DYL WHT DBL
R RED BLU RED
R DGR DYL WHT
C DBR YOR RED
R YEL LBL RED
R BLK M/C BLK
Description
Reserve
price
LB
$35
LPR face; BLU antenna; on felt
$40
LPR head; ORD
$15
75 mm dome shape
$50
twill pentagon
$125
RWB beads; (1969)
$55
ORG & BLU beads; VER bkgd; flat $15
Lodge 111 Fall Fellowship 1987
$15
Lodge 111 Fall Fellowship 75th ANN $15
A.R.; arrow points to “C”; TRR; WAB $145
BLK number
$15
On N/CTRI w/rounded corners
$125
twill QC
$350
Used; BRO; (1973)
$40
ORD; VER bkgd; HOR sky; (1973); $25
$100
LBR hands; YEL BMT; ORG on left $30
2 mm thick WWWs
$25
no #; no face; VER WHT foreground; $30
oval; GRN EMB eyes on turtle;
$125
$40
QC; (1966); On N/C
$125
(1974)
$30
crude outlining; FR/E
$115
crudely drawn Seminole; QC; solid
$160
127 mm; PCH face & feet
$30
FDL; 1985 Spring Pow Wow
$15
RED eye; 108 mm wide
$85
118 mm wide; ORD
$40
52x117 mm; LB; VER trees; MVE
$30
BLK inner bdr
$45
FR/E; (1964); BSA
$275
arrow to left; all RED arrow; (1958); $200
four chapter totems; (1969)
$45
FR/E; (1972)
$15
(1959)
$25
50x63 mm; oval; on N/C
$70
10 mm council name & "353"; DBR $125
HOR sky; 53x117 mm; LB; WHT
$25
7 ripple lines on each side 118x52
$50
Region 7 - IN, IL, MI & WI
Lot
1696 7
1697 7
1698 7
1699 7
1700 23
1701 29
1702 40
1703 40
1704 41
1705 41
1706 61
1707 61
1708 75
1709 75
1710 75
1711 79
1712 81
1713 81
1714 81
1715 81
54
Item
R5a
F4
F6b
S1
S2
X4
R1
R3a
R7
R8
S1b
P1
A1
S1
P3
X4b
A5b
P1
S3
S7
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C DYL WHT RED
R DYL WHT DYL
R DYL WHT DYL
R DYL BLK DYL
R RED M/C BLK
R WHT RED DYL
C LYL WHT RED
C YEL WHT RED
R BLK GRN
R BLK YEL
R YEL M/C RED
R DGR LGR DGR
C DBL RED WHT
R DYL M/C RED
R DYL BLU RED
C RED DBL DYL
C WHT BLK RED
C RED M/C BLK
R DOR M/C WHT
R DYL M/C BLK RED
Description
price
Reserve
YEL stitching around hand; TRR
DYL nails; Chicago council
TLM
50th ANN
WHT bkgd for name
edge & letters look like GMY; MVE
TRR; HOR body of bird
BLK 41; WWW; BRN bird
BLK 41; WWW; BRN bird
RBR and TAN stag; YEL behind
TRI; on N/C
DYL circle; WAB
twill QC
TRM
95 mm
flying egret; TRI; on N/C
standing egret
VER SS; PB
$35
$20
$20
$15
$15
$40
$125
$30
$45
$50
$40
$80
$30
$20
$125
$40
$40
$75
$10
$10
The Auction in the Journal
The Journal Set Price Sale
1716 88
1717 88
1718 92
1719 96
1720 106
1721 106
1722 110
1723 110
1724 115
1725 115
1726 126
1727 128
1728 132
1729 132
1730 132
1731 136
1732 140
1733 142
1734 152
1735 152
1736 152
1737 153
1738 156
1739 156
1740 162
1741 162
1742 162
1743 167
1744 167
1745 167
1746 173
1747 173
1748 175
1749 175
1750 175
1751 180
1752 180
1753 182
1754 182
1755 189
1756 191
1757 191
1758 191
1759 194
1760 197
1761 197
1762 197
1763 197
1764 203
1765 203
1766 206
1767 206
1768 212
1769 214
1770 218
1771 218
1772 218
1773 218
1774 222
1775 226
1776 231
1777 231
1778 269
1779 269
1780 290
1781 290
1782 290
1783 315
1784 332
1785 334
1786 334
1787 334
1788 337
1789 337
1790 337
S4b
S2
S1a
act
S4a
F1
X5
P1
R3
Act
R1
A2
R2
X1
A1
P3
S5
R1c
A2
X2
R1
S3
R1b
R3b
R4
S2
P2
F2
S2
S4
S1
F2a
R1
S2
S6a
R3
S2
F4
S1
R4
R1
S3
S4
R1
S2
X1
S3a
S5a
R4
S1
S5b
S8b
S5
ZX1
R1
F2b
S1
S5
X2
F2
F2b
S1b
S3b
S3c
R3
A1
R5
S2
F2
P1
P2
S3
S4
S5
S7
R WHT M/C WHT
DYL sun
R NBL M/C DBL
BSA; YEL WWW and inner bdr;
C RED GRN DYL
solid; 3/4 view Native American;
C GRY GRN PGR
1951 Fall Conference
R WHT M/C DBL
HOR moon; RED details; BLU water;
R WHT M/C DBL
large HOR moon
C GRN WHT RED
Light glue spot; BRN owl in Chief
R WHT M/C RED
QC; MVE
C BLK WHT RED
restored; BLK bird on DYL starburst;
C GRN LYL BLK
Conclave 1959
C BLK WHT RED
25 mm across base of WWW; 11 mm
C BLK WHT RED
BLK WWW 53x77 mm arrowhead
C RED BLK RED
cardinal has WHT eye; VER WHT
R RED WHT BLK
BLK arrowhead around circle; REC
C BLK WHT BLK
R BLK M/C RED
RED WWW on TAN mound
R BLK WHT RED
52x113 mm
C DGR WHT DGR
right leg of mid "W" lines up w/"E";
C BLK RED WHT
twill; threadbreak on border
C BLK PYL RED
77x89 mm
R RED PYL RED
LBL WWW; 1939-1971; ANN
R DYL BLU RED
MAN acorn; A.L.
C BLK BLU BLK
DGY land and eagle
R BLK TRQ BLK
TL; 74 mm
C DYL GRN RED
NOAC54
R DYL GRY GRN
Used; RED WWW; 110 mm; no
C BLK WHT RED
NOAC61; TRI
C BRN WHT BLK
HOR GRY possum; rippled fur
C LBL MAN BLK
RED WWW; shield design
C GRN MAN BLK
RED WWW; shield design
R LGY ORG DBL
C M/C WHT RED
PUR mountains; BBL sky
C GRN WHT DBL
RED WWW; BLU goose
R RED DGY RED
Used; 52x110 mm; both parts of
R ORG LBN ORG ORG DYL sun behind DBL flying duck;
C BLK RED DYL
CHICK AGAMI
R DYL BLK RED
C WHT ORG RED
R RED M/C RED
C YEL DBL YEL
Damaged; HOR DGR outer ring; TR
C DYL RED DYL
name top 1/2 of patch; (WAB)
R WHT DBL WHT
round corners; HOR bkgd
R YEL M/C PUR
Used; restricted; RED WWW arrows
C RED BLK DYL
one BLK "W"
C DBL YEL BLK
HOR; GER
C BLK WHT WHT
106x117 mm Tepee
R DBL YEL BLK
VER bkgd; YEL rosette; tight bkgd; 9
R DBL DYL BLK
HOR stitch; WHT rosette; 102 mm
R RED TAN WHT
Border repair
R BLU LBL RED
BLK WWW
R YEL LBL BLK
small face Native American
R YEL LBL GRY
R WHT M/C RED
RED/BLK lines on roach; small
WHT DBL
felt on felt TRI; no BLK SSC bdr
C RED ORG RED
GRN WWW; CUWE Lodge; WAB
R RED WHT DBL
TLS
R DBL WHT DBL
GRN tall pine; all WHT VER
R DBL WHT DBL
HOR inner WHT; VER outer WHT;
R RED MAN BLK
TRI
R LGY PGR RED
C BRN LYL GRN
small eye
R BRN DYL GRN
C RED M/C BLK
WHT BMT; TAN Native American
C RED M/C BLK
RED BMT
C DGR BLU RED
TRS; LBR ground
C DYL BLK DYL
RED "WWW"
C RED BLK RED
76 mm twill
R BRN DYL BLK
BRN 315
R RED BLU RED
WHT WWW; RED 332
R DBL DBL WHT
Off N/C; DBL inside WHT stitched
R DBL NBL WHT
On N/C; NBL inside WHT stitched
R WHT DBL WHT
RED arrow right; WHT 334 on trees
R RED M/C RED
DYL sky; no #; (GRY tail stitched
R RED M/C RED
DYL sky; RED "337"
R RED M/C RED
LYL sky; RED "337"
Call or Email to reserve sale items
$20
$15
$20
$25
$15
$20
$70
$45
$100
$35
$225
$95
$40
$35
$75
$110
$20
$30
$65
$35
$40
$125
$130
$45
$90
$10
$80
$70
$30
$30
$25
$10
$65
$30
$10
$25
$40
$40
$40
$40
$75
$15
$35
$125
$55
$40
$25
$20
$30
$40
$20
$15
$25
$250
$65
$45
$15
$15
$40
$50
$65
$20
$45
$45
$40
$40
$40
$35
$75
$40
$45
$15
$45
$30
$30
(435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
55
The Journal Set Price Sale
1791 337
1792 373
1793 373
1794 373
1795 373
1796 374
1797 374
1798 381
1799 425
1800 425
1801 425
1802 452
1803 452
1804 452
1805 452
1806 469
1807 469
1808 501
1809 512
1810 524
S8
X1
A1a
A3a
S5b
P1b
S2
F2a
X1
S2b
S2c
R1
S1a
R3
S2
P1
F4
F2
S4
S2
R DBL
C GRN
C RED
C DYL
R DYL
R RED
R GRY
R RED
C BLK
C DYL
C DYL
C YEL
R RED
R BLK
R DYL
R DYL
R BLU
R DBR
R DYL
R BLK
BLU DBL
RED YEL
Machine sewn; GRN WWW; REC;
ORG RED
WHT WWW 373; TRR
DBL RED
HOR state; TRM
LBL RED DYL PB
M/C RED
Used;pale PNK (almost WHT) face
M/C RED
BLK WWW 1948-1973; VER field;
BLU BLK
regular R/E; TLM
M/C RED
Native American bonnet
BLU RED
WHT BMT; no WHT between DBL
BLU RED
BLU BMT
LBL RED
RED upper body with BLK detail in
WHT BLK
DYL "WWW"; thin letters
M/C BLK
RED "WWW"; solid EMB
M/C RED
WHT DBL
On N/C; RED WWW 469; QC
YOR BLU
RED WWW; 469
WHT RED
Slight use; MVE
DBL DYL
WHT YEL
Damage at fletching; RED "524";
$10
$85
$75
$65
$10
$85
$20
$20
$40
$40
$40
$70
$50
$20
$40
$150
$75
$200
$45
$85
Regions 8 & 10
Lot
1811 31
1812 42
1813 42
1814 51
1815 51
1816 51
1817 51
1818 52
1819 74
1820 100
1821 100
1822 147
1823 147
1824 170
1825 171
1826 171
1827 176
1828 176
1829 183
1830 216
1831 216
1832 313
1833 321
1834 371
1835 372
1836 372
1837 383
1838 387
1839 434
1840 438
1841 453
1842 453
1843 460
1844 460
1845 464
1846 473
1847 492
1848 536
1849 541
1850 541
1851 541
Item
S2b
W1
F2
R1a
F2
S1a
P1a
S1b
S2
S2
R1
A2
S2a
W1
F3b
S1
S2b
S5
S2b
X2
J1b
F2
S3
S2
F2
S1a
S7c
S1b
F3b
S2
F2
S2
F1a
F2
S2
S1
N1
S3a
R1
F2a
S3c
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C LGY LGY RED
RED PNK BGN
R RED LBL BLK
C RED WHT RED
C WHT BLK RED
C BLK LBL RED
C BLK BLU RED
R RED M/C BLK
R RED GRN RED RED
R WHT M/C RED
C RED OLV YEL
C RED WHT
R WHT LGR BLK
R DYL M/C RED YEL
R DYL BLU RED
R DYL LBL RED
C LGY LGY
R RED M/C RED
R DBL M/C RED
R BLK M/C RED
R BLK BLU RED
R RED WHT DBL
R GRY GRY ORG
R ROR WHT DBL
C RED M/C GRN
C RED M/C BLK
R DYL M/C RED
R BRN BLU RED
R BLK DYL RED
R ORG M/C YEL
R YEL WHT RED
R YEL BLU BLK
R RED WHT NBL
R RED WHT NBL NBL
C NBL BLU NBL
R DYL WHT BLK
YOR BLK
R DBL M/C RED
R WHT BLU YEL
C WHT BLU YEL
R YEL BLU RED
Description
price
Reserve
$90
$75
MVE
$20
GRN HOR; WAB; (1952); TRR
$90
RED/51; GRN/MVE
$50
LBL BMT; MVE
$10
GRN/WWW; TRI
$20
BRN hills & hut; darker GRN
$25
MVE
$5
5 mm high "100"; F/RE; LBR & BRN $25
issued at a fellowship
$70
98mm high; RED/BLU details in
$45
HOR field; standing turkey ; number $10
log inner bdr; BRN eagle; FDL
$35
$85
Used
$125
YEL/ORG face; right edge of ax
$80
ORG tepee and face
$20
COP & DYL details in cliffs
$20
72x108 mm oval; RED at top of
$20
158x218 mm TRS; GRAYISH twill
$150
$40
(30th ANN); (1976)
$35
minor thread break on W
$15
BRN bison; 110 arrow
$60
LBL BMT
$65
no bdr around coney or rock
$30
mostly DBL backing
$25
Used; DPK inner eye
$40
with arrow; WHT star; 8 mm ltrs
$20
$115
$90
Pheasant council; TLM
$40
BSA; Pheasant council
$40
HOR field; VER LGY arrowhead;
$25
RED WWW; arrow left
$30
flat chenille; YOR sunburst & "492"; $50
CB; VIG; (1976)
$20
RED "526"; error in #
$85
LBR bird; TLR
$125
RBR eye; RBR bird
$10
Light use; very LGY; rounded VER
Region 9 - NM, OK & TX
Lot
1852 35
1853 35
1854 35
1855 35
1856 36
1857 60
1858 60
56
Item
R3
P2
P3b
C1
F2a
S2
S7
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
C BLK
C BLK
R BLK
RED
C YEL
C YEL
R BLK
WHT BLK
WHT BLK
WHT BLK
WHT BLK
TRQ RED
WHT BRN
M/C ORG
Description
price
Reserve
TRR; 71 mm; W's 7mm; Emb tab
TRI; 147x72; no BLK outline @ W's;
RED W's; thin letters
flap shape issued w/certf; (1987)
TLR; (1960)
103x51; small
YEL inner bdr; BRO; (1970)
$285
$395
$225
$30
$115
$20
$85
The Auction in the Journal
The Journal Set Price Sale
1859 60
1860 60
1861 60
1862 60
1863 60
1864 62
1865 72
1866 99
1867 99
1868 101
1869 101
1870 113
1871 113
1872 133
1873 133
1874 133
1875 137
1876 137
1877 137
1878 137
1879 137
1880 137
1881 141
1882 150
1883 199
1884 199
1885 199
1886 213
1887 232
1888 272
1889 281
1890 307
1891 307
1892 307
1893 307
1894 307
1895 307
1896 307
1897 307
1898 307
1899 327
1900 327
1901 327
1902 327
1903 327
1904 328
1905 330
1906 330
1907 341
1908 378
1909 378
1910 486
1911 486
1912 489
1913 489
1914 489
1915 489
1916 578
1917 578
1918 578
1919 578
S8 C WHT M/C YEL
bottom BLK bdr makes Texas shape; $75
P1 R WHT LBL RED
202 mm QC
$75
S10 R DYL WHT BRN DYL 2 FDL's; MVE--BLU; VER WHT bkgd $10
S11 R GMY WHT BRN GMY 2 FDL's; (50th); (1981)
$10
S15 R YEL WHT BRN YEL 2 FDL's; SWISS; PB; MVE
$10
R1 C WHT RED WHT
78 mm; (1948)
$135
P3 R RED LTQ RED
210 mm QC; "72" in shield; NT
$175
S3 R WHT RED WHT
7 BLK lines in wing; MVE: BMT;
$15
S6 R RED WHT RED
RED bars at end of arrow; BRO
$20
F2b C DYL WHT RED
Sewn; 55 mm RED arrow w/fat
$65
F4b C YEL BLU RED
letters of name connected at top and $20
X2b C BLK LBL
TLR
$135
F2 R RED WHT
no name; 116x52 mm; TLS; (1963) $160
X1b C RED ORG RED
Cloth on back; slt. staining;GRN
$75
S1a C BLK M/C BLK
VER bkgd; (1964); MVE; 3 WHT
$35
S2c C BLK M/C BLK
WHT BMT
$30
F4b R RED WHT BLK
"COLONNEH"; small bird; F/RE/
$25
F5 C RED WHT BLK
large bird; (1957)
$20
X2b C RED BLK WHT
RED BMT; CB
$35
S3 R RED WHT RED
sharp angle to "V NECK"; WHT fine $10
ZS1 C RED WHT RED
117x50 mm; fake of S; VER bkgd
$10
ZS2 C RED WHT RED
115x50 mm; fake of S1; crude EMB $10
ZA1 C WHT RED BLK
like A3; no stitched eye; TLR; tail
$20
S1a C RED M/C BLK
RED BMT; 15 mm BLU sky shaft
$50
S2d R RED M/C BLK
RED thick arrow; TAN deer; DPR
$10
P2 R WHT DRD BLK
203 mm QC; TRR; 4 BLK TRI's HOR $95
S2d R RED M/C BLK BLK PB; MVE; BSA
$5
S4 R BLK M/C YEL
LB; HOR sky; MVE
$60
S2b C BLK GRN WHT
7 mm name; BLK round end to
$25
F2 C RED WHT
124x52 mm; "RIO GRANDE
$225
S2a R DYL M/C RED
no BLK on top of mtns
$15
W1
DBL GRY BLK
(1958)
$200
S2b C BLK WHT RED
thick BLU outline; thin stripes
$25
P1 C BLK WHT RED
170x115 mm; 7 mm 307; DBL BMT; $75
S9b R GRN WHT BLK
square bottom
$10
S15 R DBL WHT BLK
(1970)
$10
S17 R BRN WHT BLK
(1971)
$10
S20a R RWB WHT BLK
(Bicentennial; 1976)
$15
S21 R GRY WHT BLK
(1973)
$10
S26 R BLK WHT BLK
125x63 mm large
$10
A1c C BLK WHT BLK
84x68 mm solid BLK feathers;
$65
L1
BLK WHT BLK
thin leather A; 92x64 mm; (1957)
$86
S4a C BLU LBL BLU
GER; shape; RED inner bdr; BLU
$10
S5 R RED M/C RED
"25"; LB; (1971); ANN
$80
F1 R RED BLU RED
LB; 117x52 mm; (1972)
$20
S2 R BLK M/C BLK PGR SS; LB; (1978); MVE
$20
P1 R RED ORG RED
197 mm VER TRI
$275
QS1 R RED DYL RED RED FDL; VER bkgd; VIG; 128x50 mm; $10
F4 C YEL LBL RED
BRO
$65
S3 C BLK M/C BLK
Used; VER bkgd; HOR st. yucca stalk $75
F5a R RED BLU RED
mountains have RBR & LBR details; $55
F2b C YEL WHT BLU
Used; MVE
$75
S3b R DYL TRQ BLK
regular R/E
$20
F2 R DBL ORG DBL
BLU eye; claws; FR/E; MVE
$35
F3 R DBL ORG DBL
WHT EMB eye; claws; FR/E
$30
F6a R DBL ORG DBL
step stitch bkgd; NT; (1962)
$20
S1a R DBL ORG DBL
VER; no eye; 5 mm high neck;
$10
S1b C RED M/C WHT
LBR BMT; RED eye
$20
S3 R RED M/C WHT
112x51 mm; sky LBL; water BLU
$15
P1 R RED BLU WHT
On N/C;215 mm QC; ORG region 9 $115
S5a R YEL M/C WHT
water & sky different shades of BLU; $10
Region 11- Pacific Northwest
Lot
1920 253
1921 253
1922 299
1923 300
1924 301
1925 305
1926 305
1927 311
1928 311
1929 311
1930 311
Item
S6
X1
S1
S3
P1
S1
P2
S1
S3
S6
S7
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
Description
C RED BLK WHT
C RED BLK WHT
TSISQAN SERVICE; REC
R RED DYL BRN
R RED M/C RED RED FDL
R GMY M/C RED
On N/C; QC; solid EMB
C WHT DBL WHT
Sewn
R RED RED DBL
On N/C; QC; fully EMB
R RED WHT BLK
coyote head
R RED M/C BLK WHT FDL; World Jamboree 1967
R RED M/C BLK WHT FDL; World Jamboree 1969
R RED M/C BLK WHT FDL; JAM73
Call or Email to reserve sale items
Reserve
price
$55
$85
$275
$15
$100
$35
$220
$45
$20
$20
$20
(435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
57
The Journal Set Price Sale
1931 325
1932 355
1933 356
1934 356
1935 361
1936 361
1937 363
1938 400
1939 400
1940 407
1941 415
1942 415
1943 437
1944 437
1945 437
1946 502
1947 502
1948 502
1949 544
1950 544
1951 549
1952 549
1953 549
S2
P2
X3
QF1
A1
ZF1
S5a
F4b
QF1
F2b
X3b
F3a
F3a
S1
P4
S1
F2
S6
S1a
S3
F2a
F2c
P2
R SMY M/C BLK
C RED WHT RED
C RED BLU RED
R RED LBL RED
C DYL LBL WHT
R DYL WHT RED
R RED DBL RED
R RED WHT BLK
C RED WHT BLK
R RED BLK WHT
C WHT WHT RED
R BLK WHT BLK
R DYL BLK RED
R DYL BLK RED
R DYL BLK RED
C BLU LYL RED
R RED BLU RED
R LBL DYL RED
R YEL M/C RED
R YEL M/C RED
R RED NBL DYL
R RED NBL DYL
R DYL PGR RED
WHT goat on BLK mountain; ORD $20
GRN northern lights; Alaska council; $85
oval; BRN rear leg
$30
6 points on antlers; rejected by lodge $20
DPR outline on goose
$70
like F2b; shiney
$10
DYL tepee; DYL eagle
$15
TLM
$60
"WAWOOKIS"; TLR
$25
115 mm; slt. use
$45
On N/C; coyote looks like a pig; TLM $30
HOR DYL behind name; TLM
$15
Slt. use; TLR; no tags from council
$95
Slight use
$95
On N/C; with number; HOR EMB
$65
no number; HOR EMB dot in name; $80
TRM; VER fletching
$20
no number; VER EMB DYL; & LBL; $50
113x50 mm; BRN mtns; 23 mm
$40
ORD; HOR EMB; grass; PB
$35
TLR; fuzzy DOR bars in neck
$25
TLS
$20
WHT mountains; RED & DYL
$300
AZ, HI, NV, UT & Reg. 13
Lot
1954 346
1955 346
1956 346
1957 391
1958 391
1959 432
1960 432
1961 482
1962 482
1963 482
1964 482
1965 494
1966 494
1967 498
1968 498
1969 503
1970 506
1971 508
1972 514
1973 514
1974 520
1975 520
1976 520
1977 520
1978 554
1979 567
Item
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
F2 R RED LGY RED
S3 C RED GRY RED
S5 R RED M/C RED
S1 C RED LBL RED
X2 R WHT LBL RED
F2 C RED WHT BLK
S3 C BLK M/C BLK
F2 C DBL ORG DBL
W2 R NBL LYL NBL
P1 R DBL DYL BLK
S2 R BLK YEL BLK
S5 R RED M/C BLK
S6 R GRY M/C BLK
S7b C BLK M/C BLK
S17a R DYL M/C BLK
F1b R GRN ORG BLK
F2 C DBR LYL DBL
S6 R RED PGR RED
F2c R WHT RED DBL
S1a R GRN M/C RED
S1a C BLK M/C RED
S2 C BLK M/C RED
R1 R BLK M/C RED
S5 R GRY M/C RED
F3b R RED WHT BLK
S3b R RED WHT BLK
Description
price
Reserve
$75
$75
$45
$75
square diamond
$50
28 mm sides; MVE; tail reaches over $125
VER WHT in VIG sash
$55
DBL WWW
$325
BSA written out; FR/E
$60
On N/C; BSA; BLK
$150
BSA with periods; 6 WHT bars in
$10
VER sky
$15
VIG
$35
council name; 100 mm wide; MVE
$95
52x115 mm; HOR sky; CB; LBL
$35
REGULAR R/E; no tags
$20
Used
$250
diagonal "508"; RED eye
$20
TLR
$50
Used; BRN beaver
$40
LYL radial stitch sun rays; BRN stag $30
VER DYL sun rays; stag w/VER neck $30
On N/C; BLK council name
$125
BLK council name; ORD
$20
NT
$70
52x123 mm; 98 mm arrow; MVE
$10
Used
asian EMB
E. URNER GOODMAN award
NBL
RED
BLK
RED
California
Lot
1980 13
1981 90
1982 90
1983 90
1984 98
1985 98
1986 98
1987 98
1988 98
1989 98
1990 102
1991 127
1992 127
1993 127
1994 127
1995 127
1996 207
1997 207
1998 207
58
Item
S9
A4a
A4b
QS1
R1
S2d
S2g
S5
S6
S9a
S6
X1c
S2
P1
S6b
S12
F3
S3
R5
Border Bkgd Name BSA/fdl
R BRN M/C RED
C M/C YEL GRN
C M/C YEL GRN
R BLK M/C BLK
R BLK LBR BTQ
R TRQ WHT DRD
R TRQ WHT RED
R BTQ M/C RED
R SMY M/C RED
R TRQ M/C TRQ
R GRY TRQ YEL
C BLK WHT RED
R RED M/C RED
R ORG M/C BLK
R RED M/C BLK
R GRN M/C BLK
C GRN YEL RED
R DGR M/C YEL
R DGR BLU BLK
Description
price
Reserve
RED FDL; 51x123 mm
TRR
NT
LBL FDL; GRY swordfish; lodge reject
Staple marks;No number,“OA”on left
KHA lockstitch; YEL details
LBL lockstitch
RED FDL
RED FDL
TRQ BSA; 52x124 mm; WHT lockstitch;
(25th ANN)
TR; arrow fletching touches "T"; no
no BRN line between grass and river
Off N/C; QC; rounded corners
GRN grass; round "Q"
LBR FDL on right; dark PNK and RED in
51x119 mm; 8 mm stars
GRY mountains
"VIGIL" in water; second hanging
$15
$20
$20
$20
$275
$15
$15
$20
$20
$20
$95
$80
$80
$215
$75
$10
$100
$25
$125
The Auction in the Journal
The Journal Set Price Sale
1999 207
2000 225
2001 225
2002 225
2003 225
2004 225
2005 228
2006 249
2007 249
2008 252
2009 252
2010 252
2011 252
2012 262
2013 263
2014 263
2015 263
2016 278
2017 278
2018 278
2019 278
2020 282
2021 282
2022 282
2023 291
2024 291
2025 291
2026 298
2027 298
2028 298
2029 303
2030 303
2031 354
2032 354
2033 354
2034 354
2035 354
2036 354
2037 354
2038 354
2039 379
2040 395
2041 430
2042 430
2043 430
2044 436
2045 436
2046 436
2047 436
2048 436
2049 439
2050 468
2051 468
2052 468
2053 468
2054 468
2055 468
2056 468
2057 468
2058 468
2059 468
2060 468
2061 468
2062 478
2063 478
2064 478
2065 478
2066 478
2067 478
2068 478
2069 478
2070 485
2071 485
2072 485
2073 488
S8b R DGR M/C YEL
S1 C YEL RED BLK
R6b R YEL ORG
S5a R YEL M/C BLK
S5b R YEL M/C BLK
A1 C M/C ORG RED
Act R WHT BLK WHT
F2b R DYL LBL DBL
S11 R DPR M/C WHT BLK
S3 R PUR M/C RED
A9b C YEL BLU BLK RED
S4a R PUR M/C RED
S7a R PUR M/C RED
S8b C YEL M/C RED
A2a C YEL BLU RED
F2a C RED WHT BLK
S3a R DYL BTQ BLK DYL
F2 R BLK BLU RED
P1a C M/C LGY RED
S3 R BLK M/C RED
S4c R BLK M/C RED
R1b C RED WHT DBL
X3 C M/C BLU YEL
R1 R WHT WHT RED
S2c R WHT M/C YEL
S5a R RED M/C ORG RED
S12 R GMY M/C BLK
X3a C DBL WHT DGR
S5 C BLK M/C RED
S8a R RED M/C YEL
F3 R WHT DPR TAN
R4b R BLK BLU RED
F2a C GRY NBL YEL
S2 R WHT M/C WHT
S5c R RED M/C WHT
S8a R SMY M/C ORG
S8b R SMY M/C ORG
S9 R SMY M/C ORG
C1
BLK RED BLK
S25 R YEL M/C RED GRN
A2 C RED WHT RED
S1b R RED LBL RED
F1 R RED GRY RED
S9 R WHT M/C RED
X2 R WHT LBL RED
S2a R LBL LBR RED
S2b R LBL LBR RED
S5a R LBL TAN RED
S6b R LBL BRZ RED
S11 R BLU KHA RED
S3b R WHT M/C RED
S8 R BLK WHT BLK
P1 R RED WHT BLK
S11 R YEL WHT BLK
S12 R BGR WHT BLK
S14 R RED WHT BLK
S15 R LTQ WHT BLK
S16 R WHT WHT BLK
S17 R YEL WHT BLK
S20 R RED WHT BLK
S24 R DGR WHT BLK
S25 R DOR WHT BLK
S27b R BLK WHT BLK
S2a C BLU BLK WHT
S3a C BLU BLK WHT
S4a R DBL BLK WHT
S5a R LBL BLK WHT
S6b R LTQ BLK WHT
S8 R LTQ BLK WHT
A1 C BLK YEL RED
ZR1 C LBL WHT RED
R1b C WHT DBL RED
F1b C YEL WHT DBL
F2a R YEL WHT DBL
R1 C DBL WHT RED
4 canoes; GRN left shore and trees
(1959)
ORG points
BRN tepees; (1965)
DBR tepees; PUR mountains
RED and WHT C/E
1970 Fellowship Conference
TLR; BRN coyote
BSA; RED TRIANGLE next to moon
pale BRN Native American; flat
thick letters
BPR mountains; DYL shield; round
LBL sky and water; pointed bottom;
cloud on left touches name; YEL
narrow tail; HOR right wing; YEL
NT; BLK tags from name to border
SS; 51x113 mm
DGR trees; LGY BMT; LBL water
BRN mountains; HOR sky
DGY mountains; LGR grass; RBR
NT
RED and WHT C/E; NT; HOR LBR
ONE IN BROTHERHOOD
GRN HOR grass; 64x127 mm
FDL; 61x125 mm; LBL and DBL sky;
(NOAC83)
VER bkgd; all W's in line; 40 mm
YEL fire
Used; wide FR/E
thin BLK outlines; slit eyes
DPK outline on fish
round bottom; DPR mountains
darker BLU mountains; GRY salmon
DGR trees; LGR grass
DGR trees; BGR grass
RED arrow w/BRO bars; GRY &
TRI; VIG
FDL; NOAC88
no number; NT; BLK lines do not
dot eyes
Used
HOR WHT arrowhead; LBR deer;
Thread break;OCT; 20th ANN; 1970
62X136 mm; wide FR/E; BLK strands
BLK strands have 2 LBL strands in
"4" between "E" & "L"; F R/E; WHT
BLU lockstitch in bdr
"4" under "L"
left most tree offset on trunk; trees
53X120 mm; eagle has point on back
On N/C; QC; bald eagle
RED "OA"
RED "OA"
RED "OA"
no "OA"; RED & DBL bars touch
no "OA"; RED & DBL bars touch
no "OA"; RED & DBL bars touch
no "OA"; RED & DBL bars touch
no "OA"; WHT separates RED &
no "OA"; WHT separates RED &
YEL eagle & color bar
60X126 mm 12 mm wide LOR
57 X 123 mm; 14 mm wide DOR
solid ORG arrowhead
57 X 132 mm; DOR arrowhead; legs
ORG ARROWHEAD
ROR arrowhead; HOR bkgd; LTQ
LPR mountain
TRR; no bdr around PYL arrowhead;
no tag; thin outline of mountain
DGR grass; 3 mm wide BLK smoke
DBL tags from lettering to bdr
"TA TANKA"; 4 legs
Call or Email to reserve sale items
$125
$85
$65
$30
$30
$75
$15
$20
$40
$35
$25
$15
$15
$20
$90
$95
$10
$90
$135
$15
$15
$150
$75
$80
$30
$15
$20
$25
$30
$25
$100
$45
$120
$40
$15
$30
$30
$35
$85
$10
$100
$25
$125
$15
$25
$75
$75
$15
$15
$15
$15
$25
$135
35
$35
$35
$25
$25
$25
$25
$25
$25
$15
$65
$65
$40
$35
$35
$35
$45
$20
$125
$75
$35
$90
(435)655-8899 or (801)655-8899
[email protected]
59
The Journal of the
American Scouting Historical Society
2580 Silver Cloud Ct.
Park City, UT 84060
Forwarding and
Address Correction Requested