recordingreviews - Early Music America
Transcription
recordingreviews - Early Music America
recordingreviews Edited by Tom Moore J. S. Bach Goldberg Variations Andreas Staier, harpsichord Harmonia Mundi HMC 902058 (CD and DVD) www.harmoniamundi.com The first time I heard Andreas Staier in a live concert was during an early music festival. I was tired and felt that a whole recital of solo harpsichord music was more than I could bear. But time went by fast, and Staier’s playing kept me nailed to the chair. The man had passion and intelligence, coupled with a riveting stage presence—the kind that makes you want to meet the artist and have tea with him. After that, I began to buy his CDs and was often moved, amazed, and entertained. So, there, it is out in the open: I cannot profess to be a dispassionate critic. According to Bach’s biographer, Johann Nikolaus Forkel, “Count Kaiserling was often ill and had sleepless nights. At such times, Goldberg, who lived in his house, had to spend the night in an antechamber, so as to play for him during his insomnia.… Once the Count mentioned in Bach’s presence that he would like to have some clavier pieces for Goldberg, which should be of such a smooth and somewhat lively character that he might be a little cheered up by them in his sleepless nights. Bach thought himself best able to fulfill this wish by means of Variations...” Whether true or false, this story helped to shape the posterity of the piece. While much praised, the Goldberg Variations was played less often in concert than many other keyboard works of J.S. Bach (16851750). Evidently this had to do with its length, which could take over a whole recital, and also with its intimate nature, intellectually challenging in its intricate twists and turns, rather than any soporific qualities! It has been a well-regarded gem and a favorite among keyboard players, 16 but perhaps not really a crowd pleaser. Notwithstanding the “lively character” that Forkel mentions as the Count’s wish, there is a shroud of melancholy that envelops the theme from the start and that remains undispelled even in the frizzier variations, or the noble ones. In its long-winded search for itself, the Goldberg Variations seem to require a small audience, in an intimate setting. Once recordings were available, they became the natural medium for the work, and there are countless examples of artists who made the Goldberg Variations a goal to reach in their maturity. For the listener, it represented a quiet pleasure to be had at home, late in the evening, in order to clear the mind of the petty worries of the day and set it into a more spiritual frame for the night. Most of the recordings I cherish tend to be delicate, pensive, and sad—journeys deep into the interpreter’s soul. Knowing Staier’s inclination towards the brilliant and the energetic, I hardly imagined that he would take a meek or brooding approach. A lively touch was only to be expected, but even I was surprised to be faced with such a vigorous, loud, and vibrant sound. Much of this can be credited to the instrument chosen for the recording, a sturdy and impressive harpsichord (made by Anthony Sidey, after Hass), with a huge tone and a wide palette; and some of it can be attributed to the miking—very close to the soundboard, making us feel at times as if we were inside the instrument. Make no mistake, however; these are all Staier’s personal choices and they perfectly match his vision. Is this bad? Well, it jolts the ear a bit in the beginning, especially if you are in the suave music mode. But after the initial shock, it captures another dimension of the work, one displayed with flair and conviction. I had the impression of hearing a completely different composition, the kind that sends sparks flying. It won’t replace my former image of the Variations, one of serenity and acceptance. But it is personal, interesting, and gripping in its own way. This is a full-blooded performance, Winter 2010 Early Music America one that most certainly will not lull you to sleep. On the other hand, it may make you re-shape your notions about sonority, intentions, and style in Bach. The accompanying bonus DVD (About Bach’s Goldberg Variations, a film by Christian Leblé) is as close as most of us will ever get to meeting Staier and having tea with him. It permits us to hear him talk about the music he loves with intelligence and affection and is a welcome addition to the package. —Laura Rónai J. S. Bach Die Kunst der Fuge Gavin Black, harpsichord; George Hazelrigg, harpsichord CD or download available from www.theartofthefugue.com Bach’s music is set apart from that of his contemporaries by both its extraordinary compositional skill and its uncanny empathy with the listener. The latter is most evident in the great sacred works such as the St. Matthew Passion, the Magnificat, the B Minor Mass, and all those astonishing cantatas. His compositional mastery of harmony, form, and above all counterpoint is best evidenced in the keyboard works and the collections Musikalisches Opfer and Die Kunst der Fuge (The Art of the Fugue). This excellent recording of Bach’s last and most intriguing work is delightful, insightful, and extremely well executed and recorded. As an art form, the fugue has become the terror of entering graduate music students and a Hollywood staple for meaningful drama. This recording reminds us that the fugue can also be fun; each subject entrance, permutation, or mutation, each harmonically winding episode, should fill us not only with profound respect for Bach’s craft but also impress us with his genius for drama. By using the same subject for every fugue in Die Kunst der Fuge, Bach offers a double serving; each new fugue demonstrates extraordinary skill, at the same time gratuitously playing with and gratifyingly delighting our intelligence. Much scholarly ink has flowed to explain how Bach meant this work to be performed instrumentally and what is to be done about the unfinished final fugue. The performers, George Hazelrigg and Gavin Black, director of the Princeton Early Keyboard Center, have made an excellent choice in dividing the contrapuntal voices between two largermodel German harpsichords. By doing so, they clearly bring out each voice through registration, color shifts, and a healthy dose of the lute stop. Even the complex mirror fugues and the famous unfinished final fugue on three subjects—here abruptly ended—have a pristine clarity. However, to credit the instruments alone is a disservice to Messrs. Black and Hazelrigg, who ably phrase and shape the individual voices and employ a transparent and accessible structural approach to each separate fugue and canon. The result is to give Die Kunst der Fuge a lightness of touch missing from many other recordings and to remind us that, for all his northern Teutonic sobriety, Bach can be a lot fun to listen to as well. —Lance Hulme Heinrich Ignaz Franz von Biber Mensa Sonora; Battalia Baroque Band, Garry Clarke, director Çedille Records CDR 900000 116 www.cedillerecords.org That Heinrich Ignaz Franz von Biber (1644-1704) has not remained a household name on the level of other Baroque luminaries is an injustice to one of the most talented and versatile composers of that era. It may be that his relative obscurity is due, like Corelli’s, to his belonging to the middle Baroque, a time before the full maturity of the compositional techniques that mark the period and remain its legacy. In any case, the Salzburg-based Bohemian was reportedly the greatest violinist of his time, particularly known for the many virtuoso violin works, such as the Mystery Sonatas and Harmonia artificiosa-ariosa, that employ Anna Bon La virtuosa di Venezia La Donna Musicale, Laury Gutierrez, director La Donna Musicale LA10104 www.ladm.org Anna Bon (c.1738-after 1770) was the daughter of highly successful figures in the world of opera: her Nobil Donna Music at the Barberini Palace Suzie LeBlanc Soprano La Nef Photo: Tara McMullen / ATMA mother was a singer and her father a scenographer. This gave her the opportunity, not open to many women in the 18th century, to receive a stellar professional music education at the Ospedale della Pietá (the same institution where Antonio Vivaldi taught for many years) and to pursue a vocation as harpsichordist and composer. It seems she spent her early years traveling as a harpsichordist with her parents to courts across Central and Eastern Europe. Although her exact itinerary remains unknown, she was certainly engaged at the court of Frederick the Great’s brother-in-law, the Margrave of BrandenburgBayreuth, and then at the Esterhazy court (within a year of Josef Haydn’s appointment there as Kapellmeister). The members of La Donna Musicale have devoted themselves to unearthing and performing music by early modern female composers, and they make a sympathetic case here for Bon’s music. Most of the chamber works on this recording, which Bon composed early in her life, have been explored on disc before, but here the group experiments with the instrumentation of all the works, with attractive results. Two of the three sonatas for flute instead feature the violin (which also substitutes for the flute in the Divertimento) and pardessus de viole, respectively, with the viola da gamba joining the fortepiano as continuo instrument. The decision to use members of the viol family—one as a melody instrument and one as bass accompaniment—is unusual for music composed so late in the 18th century, but it is fitting in light of the fact that even as the viol was abandoned south of the Alps, it enjoyed a final efflorescence in Germany well into the last quarter of the century. In this case, the caressing tones of the viol family suit the subdued galanterie of these works perfectly. The vocal works are all first recordings, with Julianne Baird lending her lovely soprano to two of the three sacred pieces. The attentiongrabbing heart of the disc is the offertory Ardete amore, an urgent exhortation to the faithful to “burn with love” in praise of God. Martial horns, a flurry of restless figurations on the strings, and continually shape-shifting tempi set a theatrical Giovanni-Felice Sances Giovanni Girolamo Kapsberger Stefano Landi Marco Marazzoli Giovanni Battista Vitali Benedetto Ferrari Bernardo Storace Girolamo Frescobaldi Luigi Rossi Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina Riccardo Rognoni ACD2 2605 scordatura (retuning the strings to allow greater harmonic and contrapuntal flexibility). His phenomenal output ranges from the profundity of the Missa Salisburgensis to the humor, flash, and panache of the Battalia heard on this CD. Andrew Manze’s 1995 Gramophone award-winning release, Biber, Violin Sonatas, helped to redress the gap in public awareness of Biber’s music. This CD from the Chicagobased Baroque Band adds to his justifiably growing reputation. The six Mensa sonora that comprise the first part of the CD are “sonorous table” partitas written for Biber’s patron the Archbishop of Salzburg and were intended to accompany formal dining. Unlike the more virtuosic solo sonatas, these partitas do not use scordatura, instead concentrating on melodic development and harmonic and formal ingenuity. The Baroque Band provides a truly musical and precise musical interpretation, making me regret I am not able to experience their Chicago concerts. The ensemble uses multiple performers on each part, which creates an impression of grandeur not heard in other recordings. Each Mensa sonara has its individual appeal. Collectively they are delightful for the connoisseur, but I do wonder whether they are a little too much the same to appeal as a set to the casual listener. In any case, the final selection is a perfect antidote. The well-known Battalia is a battle piece typical of the period but extraordinary in its use of extreme dissonances and scraps of folksong to represent the battle between the European West and Turkish East. I played Battalia for my first year music theory students. They were enthralled. I have heard a number of recordings of this raucous, splashy, and yes, perhaps a little trashy, work, but the Baroque Band’s performance has become my favorite. —Lance Hulme AT M AC L A S S I Q U E . C O M Early Music America Winter 2010 17 Lost in Time Press New works and arrangements for recorder ensemble Compositions by Frances Blaker Paul Ashford Hendrik de Regt Harold Owen and others Inquiries: Corlu Collier PMB 309 2226 N Coast Hwy Newport, Oregon 97365 www.lostintimepress.com [email protected] New from Plectra Music World Premiere Recording of the 1627 Ioannes Ruckers Harpsichord Complete Harpsichord Works Elizabeth Jacquet de La Guerre Available December 2010 www.plectra.org 18 Winter 2010 Early Music America RECORDINGreviews stage for the vocalists, who exploit the frequent dynamic changes in their parts to great dramatic effect. These are excellent performances of delightful music by an enigmatic composer. —Berna Can Dr. John Bull Complete Works for Keyboard, Volume I Mahan Esfahani, Peter Watchorn, harpsichords Musica Omnia MO0301 www.musicaomnia.org This excellent two-CD set is the first release in a projected series of the complete keyboard works of composer, virginalist, organ builder, and early-Baroque bad boy Dr. John Bull (c.15621628). There has been a long lag between the recording and release of this set. I hope that future releases will be more timely, since a comprehensive collection of this great composer’s works is long overdue. Bull’s colorful biography belies the seriousness of his compositional oeuvre. Very early on he enjoyed the patronage of Elizabeth I and later James I, but he was forced to flee England, having sired a child out of wedlock. His career and life ended at Antwerp Cathedral, where he claimed refuge as a rather dubious recusant Catholic. These colorful highlights, including a possible stint as spy, are contrasted with an Oxford doctoral degree, a professorship at Gresham College, and consistently erudite and musical production. Were one to judge Bull’s works by the examples in the Fitzwilliam Virginal and Parthenia, it might be tempting to regard him as a sort of Elizabethan Oscar Peterson—popular dance suites ornamented by running scales. But much of Bull’s output reflects far more complex compositional approaches, including inventive variations and grand contrapuntal works. These CDs include works from the more popular publications, and this reviewer happily awaits the more involved works in subsequent releases. Music Omnia owner Peter Watchorn is not only a performer and scholar but also an instrument builder. He trades off performances with Mahan Esfahani, presently artist-in-residence at New College, Oxford. Both interpreters provide excellent and particularly crisp interpretations, using three harpsichords, each modeled on a different instrument. It would take a far more nuanced ear than mine to differentiate between the three equally fine instruments or, for that matter, between these two talented keyboardists. Notable in the actual recording is the lack of action noise, a particular benefit from having a harpsichord builder as producer and performer. —Lance Hulme William Byrd Gradualia (1607) Ensemble Plus Ultra (Grace Davidson, Sally Dunkley, Clare Wilkinson, Warren Trevelyan-Jones, Thomas Hobbs, Matthew Brook, Jimmy Holliday, Michael Noone, director); Robert Quinney, organ; Musica Omnia MO0302 www.musicaomnia.org One of the joys in listening to new recordings of early music is coming across a group that understands one-on-a-part singing. Ensemble Plus Ultra is definitely a group that fits the bill, and for a variety of reasons. First of all, the seven singers featured on this disc blend exceptionally well together, creating a rich, mellow, and unified sound. Secondly, they sing with clarity, both in the imitative sections and in the more homophonic ones; the listener can clearly hear where each individual singer is in the mix, and that transparency is most welcome, especially when the music is as complex as that written by William Byrd (1540-1623). While the group could have chosen any of Byrd’s 109 pieces from the Gradualia, the ones selected here are those he wrote for the feasts of Saints Peter and Paul and for the Blessed Sacrament and Corpus Christi. A setting of the English poem “Why do I use my paper, ink and pen” is included, featuring the gorgeously warm voice of alto Clare Wilkinson, accompanied by Robert Quinney on organ. Byrd originally set the poem for five voices, but I have more frequently heard it performed as a solo with viol consort. The organ was an excellent choice, working exceptionally well with the timbre of Wilkinson’s voice, and since it is featured on a number of solo fantasias interspersed amongst the vocal numbers, it unifies the vocal and instrumental portions of the recording. Bookending these works are two more Latin motets, his Circumspice Hierusalem and Venite exultemus Domino, both highlights of the disc. In the liner notes, Michael Noone gives an amazingly detailed discussion of the cultural milieu in which these pieces were written— the tense years of the English Reformation, in which any hint of Catholicism was grounds for arrest and perhaps even execution. Despite the risks, Byrd continued to associate with Jesuits and publish Catholic compositions (or Catholic-lite, seeing as how at times the text was too provocative and only the incipits were given), often treading perilously close to treason by doing so. Noone urges that the listener hear the pieces within this context, as “virtuosic cries for justice and freedom.” While I would agree that the performance is beautifully virtuosic, I can’t quite say that it reminds me of a cry for freedom. For that, I’d need more edge, more bite, more dynamic contrast, more rage—but that might be asking for something a little too anachronistic. Instead, the recording is a glimpse of secret music in a hidden chapel. It is sensitive and nuanced, able to slip easily in and out of the different metrical moments that Byrd gives us, nicely bouncy in the joyous moments and gently grieving in the sad ones. It’s a most welcome contribution to the catalogue of Byrd recordings, both for its scholarship and its musicality. —Karen Cook Pierre Février Pièces de clavecin Charlotte Mattax Moersch, harpsichord Centaur CRC 3084/3085 (2 CDs) www.centaurrecords.com Unless you are a harpsichordist, the name of Parisian keyboard mas- ter Pierre Février (1696-1760) has probably never come to your attention. His 1734 volume of pieces was republished in facsmile as early as the mid-1970s; the second volume (probably from 1735) was long thought to be lost (Grove still lists it thus), but was rediscovered and republished about 10 years ago. In addition to these two books, there are three cantatas to his credit that survive. It is surprising, given the high quality of the music, that Charlotte Mattax Moersch is the first to release a collection devoted to Février. Although most of his contemporaries were moving in the direction of a simpler, more Italianate music, these works still retain a high level of seriousness (even if only one suite opens with the traditional allemande). Mattax brings this music across with style, the sort of panache that can make listeners think that only French Baroque music is the pinnacle of good taste and refinement. At times she pushes the music as far as it can go; for example, in La Delectable, marked très gracieusement, the motion is stretched to the uttermost. The sound and tuning of the 2009 instrument by John Philips, after an original by Dumont, are marvelous and beautifully captured. —Tom Moore Johann Jakob Froberger Suites Nos. 2, 7, 8, 9, 10, & 12 Christophe Rousset, harpsichord Naïve/Ambroisie AM 148 www.naive.fr Generally recognized as the first great German harpsichord composer, Johann Jakob Froberger (16161667) travelled extensively, facilitating the widespread dissemination of his works and making him a figure of enduring international repute. His influence extended well beyond his generation to composers such as Buxtehude, Pachelbel, Handel, and J.S. Bach; even Mozart and Beethoven copied his works. But it was through a contemporary that his voice established its most unadulterated stylistic legacy. Around 1652, Froberger traveled to Paris and captivated an impressionable Louis Couperin. In turn, the rising French composer infused his burgeoning national style with features of the German’s music. Early Music America Winter 2010 19 RECORDINGreviews Froberger did incorporate some codified French customs into his harpsichord suites; he particularly admired Chambonnières’s compositions. But thanks to the success of Couperin and his followers, Froberger’s own stylistic contributions sound as if they have a decidedly “French” dialect: the complex harmonic progressions in the Allemande of Suite X, the jarring chordal juxtapositions in the Courante of Suite IX, and the metrical ambiguity in the opening “Lament” of Suite XII, a technique that became the model for Couperin’s unmeasured preludes. Not surprisingly then, in this latest album of Froberger’s harpsichord suites, Christophe Rousset, who has recorded critically acclaimed performances of works by Couperin, Rameau, and Lully, makes a comfortable and elegant transition within the French Baroque tradition. The profound introspection of Froberger’s suites demands a skilled and sincere expression to illuminate their intensely personal character; the composer even stipulated that his manuscripts be destroyed upon his death, asserting that no other performer could correctly interpret them. Rousset’s poignant performance lends the pieces an air of sublime mystery. On the whole, he plays with a discerning sense of metrical freedom—tempered by somewhat livelier tempi than other recent recordings—which serves to enunciate delicate phrasal structures and prevent somber moments from becoming incoherent or dull. Rousset chose an appropriate instrument for this performance. Constructed in 1652 (roughly concurrent with Froberger’s Parisian journey), it is one of only six surviving harpsichords created by the celebrated Flemish builder Johannes Couchet, grandson of Hans Ruckers, patriarch of the famed dynasty of harpsichord builders. The instrument exhibits a rich and resonant tone evenly throughout its range, its magnificent timbre well-served by the excellent sound quality of this recording. Froberger exploited the 20 harpsichord’s full compass, and Couchet’s instrument responds well, from the melancholy of the low tessitura in the Allemanda of Suite II to the famous C major “ascent to heaven” that concludes the “Lament on the loss of Ferdinand IV” in Suite XII. This attractive collection is a tribute to both Froberger’s emotive and eloquent suites and Rousset’s vivid and learned artistry. —Jeffrey Palenik Joseph Haydn Orlando Paladino Marlis Petersen, Tom Randle, Pietro Spagnoli, Magnus Staveland; Freiburger Barockorchester, René Jacobs, director; Nigel Lowery and Amir Hosseinpour, stage directors: Oper Unter den Linden (Berlin) Euro Arts 2057788 (2 DVDs) www.euroarts.com Although this work lacks the inspired genius of Mozart, it is unfair to Haydn (1732-1809) to imply that his most performed opera is in any way inferior. The vocal and instrumental writing are masterful, and if the libretto falls short of Da Ponte, the hallmarks of Haydn’s personal style—sudden Neapolitan chord shifts, for example—make for a delightful work. Orlando Paladino is a dramma eroicomico, a satirical opera seria, which allows Haydn to employ the entire spectrum of operatic writing, from comic folksonglike melodies to dramatic bravura coloratura passages. René Jacobs’s direction is typically fresh and balanced, and the Freiburger Barockorchester performs with humor and lightness of touch. To say the cast is uniformly excellent is not to detract from each singer‘s individual appeal. All roles are wonderfully cast and performed with attractive voices and dramatic craft. As for the direction, this reviewer saw derivative Peter Sellars-influenced Regietheater overshadowing excellent performances. Eighteenth-century characters scurry about in 21st-century flea market costumes on a Tim Burton night- Winter 2010 Early Music America mare Christmas-tree market set. Why, during Pasquale’s Leporelloesque aria, must we be diverted from excellent singing by frenetic gesticulations? The irony of this sort of stage direction is unnecessary in an already genre-mocking work. The cinematography rightly varies close-ups and full-stage viewings. The DVDs have no supplemental biographies or commentaries. I would have liked a discussion with Jacobs on his use of pianoforte in the recitatives and some musicological musings about an excellent performance of an unjustly neglected opera. —Lance Hulme Josef Myslivecek Complete Wind Octets and Quintets L’Orfeo Bläserensemble Carin van Heerden, director CPO 777 377-2 www.cpo.de One of many musicians who left Bohemia in the 18th century to pursue musical careers in various European cities, Josef Myslivecek (17371781) ended up being the only one to gain renown in the birthplace of opera, a genre to which he contributed prolifically. Affectionately nicknamed “Il Boemo” by Italian music lovers, who were quick to embrace the composer’s fiery music but reluctant to master his exotic name, Myslivecek spent the greater part of his life in Italy, where his dramatic works enjoyed acclaim in illustrious opera houses in such cities as Naples and Venice. It was in Bologna that Myslivecek developed a warm friendship with the Mozarts, father and son, and it is from their correspondence that readers can glean, along with some of the more gossipy details of Myslivecek’s life, the high regard in which both held his music. The quintets, for pairs of oboes and horns with bassoon, are appealingly tuneful works, though their brevity allows for little thematic development. The oboes frequently carry the cantabile passages, while the bassoon, which in most movements plays a busy supporting role in the background, moves in for its jocular close-up in the Quintet in G Major, and the excitable horns muscle their way to prominence in the Quintets in D, F, and E-flat. The unadulterated happiness of these quintets is a chief source of their charm, and it gives one pause to consider that Myslivecek most likely composed them in the last months of his life, when he was disfigured by illness, facing public rejection of his latest works, and reduced to poverty. The octets are more substantial musically, and the instrumentalists are often asked to test their endurance and agility, which the members of the L’Orfeo Wind Ensemble handle with consummate skill and sense of ease, the horn players deserving special mention for their sharply robust intonation. The kaleidoscopic variety that Myslivecek imparts to texture in these octets stops short of extending to mood; all movements are resolutely cheery affairs in the major mode. Tantalizingly brief glimpses of deeper waters flicker at unexpected points in several movements, such as the last two of the first octet and first two of the third octet, but they are quickly abandoned in favor of a suaver brand of entertainment. —Berna Can Oswald von Wolkenstein Songs of Myself Andreas Scholl, countertenor, Kathleen Dineen, soprano; Shield Of Harmony, Crawford Young, director Harmonia Mundi HMC 902051 www.harmoniamundi.com Tyrolian poet and composer Oswald von Wolkenstein (c.13771445) is a key transitional figure in music history in more ways than one. Musically, his songs marked a transition from minnesanger (early lyric love songs and poetry) to meistersinger. And textually, he seemed to be moving from bardic verse to stream-of-consciousness poetry. Reading the texts of many of his songs feels a bit like reading the diary of a lusty, grumpy old man. We even know what he looks like; his portrait with one eye closed is almost the iconic image of a Medieval troubadour. He lost the eye when the merrymaking got out of hand at a carnival, which tells you a lot about him. Oswald came from a noble family and went out into the world at First complete recording of The Songs of Philip Rosseter TIMOTHY NEILL JOHNSON, Tenor TIMOTHY BURRIS, Lute Review of Part I: “The Maine-based duo of Timothy Neill Johnson and Timothy Burris brings a natural rapport and gentle delivery to these songs. Johnson's lines are silky and warm; Burris's accompaniment is placed simply and gracefully.” — Early Music America Magazine The Songs of Philip Rosseter, Part I The Songs of Philip Rosseter, Part II TIMOTHY NEILL JOHNSON, Tenor TIMOTHY BURRIS, Lute TIMOTHY NEILL JOHNSON, Tenor TIMOTHY BURRIS, Lute La Donna’s new release Anna Bon: La virtuosa di Venezia This CD includes a variety of unique instrumental combinations that bring out the vivid qualities of Anna Bon’s expressive, humorous, and virtuosic music. It also contains world-premiere recordings of three fascinating vocal pieces attributed to Bon, featuring extraordinary period ornamentation by internationally acclaimed soprano Julianne Baird. The enclosed booklet provides new biographical information about the composer. “Their best to date, it captures the sumptuous beauty inherent in Anna Bon’s music. Their performance is a high-caliber tour of a lesser-known, yet excellent composer from the early Classical Era.” – Bernard Gordillo, Harmonia Early Music podcast. For more information and to hear samples of the CD, please visit www.ladm.org 2CD set available for $20 at www.cdbaby.com/Artist/MusicsQuill Tickets are on sale now! Learn more at by Agostino Steffani (1654–1728) June 12–19 2011, Boston, MA June 24–25 2011, The Berkshires, MA Paul O’Dette & Stephen Stubbs, Musical Directors Gilbert Blin, Stage Director Anna Watkins, Costume Designer Caroline Copeland & Carlos Fittante, Choreographers Lenore Doxsee, Lighting Designer Philippe Jaroussky, Anfione Amanda Forsythe, Niobe WWW.BEMF.ORG JUNE 2011 FESTIVAL & EXHIBITION Join us in Boston for the most exciting Early Music experience in North America. Hear distinguished artists and ensembles in over 100 concerts, try out exquisitely crafted instruments at the world-famous Exhibition, shop at the one-of-a-kind BEMF CD Store, and more. DON’T MISS the North American premiere of this operatic masterpiece featuring breathtaking sets, elegant costumes, dazzling Baroque stage machinery, and showcasing some of the finest musicians and dancers in early music today. Early Music America Winter 2010 21 René Slotboom bowed instruments www.reneslotboom.nl think beyond the score HISTORICAL PERFORMANCE PRACTICE FACULTY Julie Andrijeski Baroque Violin, Baroque Dance Peter Bennett French Baroque Music, Organ & Harpsichord Francesca Brittan 19th-century Music, Fortepiano Ross W. Duffin Early Music Performance Practices Debra Nagy Historical Double Reeds & Collegium David Rothenberg Medieval & Renaissance Music DEGREES BA, MA, DMA, and PhD in Historical Performance Practice CONTACT 216.368.2400 [email protected] music.case.edu 2010-2011 Kulas Visiting Artists Ellen Hargis, Nina Hinson, Janet Youngdahl, René Schiffer, Marc Destrubé, and Shira Kammen think beyond the possible SM 22 Winter 2010 Early Music America RECORDINGreviews age 10. War service may have taken him as far as Asia. After his father’s death, he tried to extend his own lands but proved to be rather hamfisted at it. From 1415 on, he was in the service of the German Emperor Sigismund, who sent him on various diplomatic missions. He eventually became involved in a series of legal disputes with other landowners, and ended up spending some time in jail. Finally, he was forced to retire from politics. He then lived the life of a country squire, but, as his songs make clear, he hated it. (“I am caught in marriage, which makes me miserable very much against my will,” he opines in “Durch Barbarei, Arabia.”) Andreas Scholl is perhaps the perfect singer for such personal songs. Each song is a mini-monodrama, and Scholl totally immerses himself in each character. He sings with absolute conviction, embodying profoundly almost any emotion. He makes Oswald’s complaints seem like real blows to the heart, rather than merely blows to the ego. Most of the songs are single melodies, although Scholl does have one duet with the lovely soprano Kathleen Dineen. We also get to hear Scholl in both his voices— countertenor and baritone—as he creates a world of character and emotion. The quartet Shield Of Harmony accompanies him with sensitivity and gusto and really shines on the few instrumental tracks. This CD was recorded in St. Valentine’s Church in Kiedrich, where both Scholl and his father sang as a choirboys and where his sister also sang. —Beth Adelman Georg Phillipp Telemann Ouverture & Concerti Alexis Kossenko, traverso, recorder; Georges Barthel, traverso; Jane Gower, bassoon; Alfredo Bernadini, oboe; Lidewij van der Voort, violin; Judith Maria Olofsson, cello; Holland Baroque Society Channel Classics CCS SA 28409 www.channelclassics.com The Holland Baroque Society’s latest CD, their second on Channel Classics, explores Telemann’s changeable style via four concerti grossi and one ouverture. A flexible and energetic ensemble, the society appoints a new artistic leader for each project it presents. This time it is the accomplished Alexis Kossenko, who plays flute and recorder with a sweet sound and remarkable articulation. The disc’s liner notes, translated into four languages, offer a quick biography of Telemann (1681-1767) and a brief but useful description of each work and its context in this thoughtfully constructed program. The promise is that, although each concerto is in the traditional fourmovement form, each has its unique character—and the performance does not disappoint. The soloists are treated quite differently in each work, from virtuosic passagework to expressive melody to opposing instrumental groupings. Perhaps the most striking piece is the Concerto in G Major for two traversi and bassoon, TWV 54:G1, which opens with the wind concertino in both the first and second movements. The string ripieno is especially jarring the first time this happens. Jane Gower’s bassoon playing is agile and expressive in both this work and in the Concerto in F Major for recorder and bassoon, TWV 52:F4. Other works include the Concerto in D Major for two traversi, violin and cello, TWV 53:D6, and the Concerto in B-flat Major for two traversi, oboe, and violin, TWV 53:B2. The disc opens with the Ouverture in E Minor, TWV 55:e3. This work contains the only character piece, “Les Cyclopes,” which is particularly successful. The orchestral accompaniment is shapely and interesting, with snappy articulation and fabulous intonation throughout. The soloists are wellmatched and simpatico. Germanstyle French music presents interpretational challenges, and despite some rather heavy notes inégales, the Holland Baroque Society does an excellent job of making it dance. Indeed, what makes this CD a success is not its programmatic con- cept—one would expect a collection of concerti grossi with varying instruments to have a certain degree of compositional individuality—but that it is really good music performed by what is clearly a topnotch ensemble. —Heather Miller Lardin Double bassist and viol player Heather Miller Lardin is artistic director of NYS Baroque in Ithaca, New York. She recently received her DMA in Performance Practice from Cornell University. Tomás Luis de Victoria Lamentations of Jeremiah The Tallis Scholars Peter Phillips, director Gimell Records CDGIM 043 www.gimell.com The Tallis Scholars once more deliver in Tomás Luis de Victoria’s Lamentations of Jeremiah. This album commemorates the Scholars’ 50th recording with Gimell records and the recording label’s 30th anniversary. Praised as Music Web International’s “Recording of the Month,” the disc “can be said very fairly to be a celebration of the core virtues of both the label and of the Tallis Scholars.…” The group, founded in 1973 by Peter Phillips, is known for their pioneering work in promoting Renaissance vocal music, and their interpretation of Victoria’s Lamentations does not disappoint. The authorship of the Old Testament Book of Lamentations is disputed. Tradition, however, has credited the source of the lamentations to Jeremiah, a 6th-century prophet living in the Holy Land. Known as the “Weeping prophet,” Jeremiah was witness to Jerusalem’s destruction and Babylonian exile in 586 B.C.E. The “Lamentations is a description of a desolate Jerusalem after the armies of Babylon have plundered and destroyed it” (essortment.com). Jeremiah warned the people to repent their wicked ways, but his pleas fell upon deaf ears. After “God’s judgment,” Jeremiah grieved for the people and urged them to remain faithful to God, who would someday deliver them. The musical interpretation of such devotion to a wayward people and their loving, yet vengeful God requires a deft hand. Inspired by Spanish polypho- ny’s “fierceness” and “mysticism” and Palestrina’s intense restraint, Victoria (c.1548-1611) creates in the Lamentations an entreaty of desperation and resignation, using tight harmonies to create urgency and bleak acquiescence. The Tallis Scholars’ soaring sound and flawless intonation realize this perfectly. Three lamentations each are presented for Maundy Thursday, Good Friday, and Holy Saturday. Each begins with a Hebrew letter of the alphabet and concludes with the admonition: “Jerusalem, Jerusalem, turn to the Lord your God.” Through carefully controlled dissonances and effervescent harmonies, each lamentation speaks of despair and the hope for renewal. Also included on this album are the Lamentations for Maundy Thursday of Juan Gutiérrez de Padilla (c.1590-1664)—“The best-known representative of the Spanish school of composers in Mexico.” Gutiérrez’s Lamentations provide a worthy contrast to Victoria’s work. This six-voice setting explores avenues of augmented intervals and soaring moments of homophony. The only possible complaint is the Scholars’ sacrifice of consonants; often the text is lost within the lofty melodies. —Heather Strohschein Matthias Weckmann Wie liegt die Stadt so wüste Cantus Cölln Konrad Junghänel, director Harmonia Mundi HMC 902034 www.harmoniamundi.com Until recently, the musical legacy of Matthias Weckmann (c.16161674) has been absorbed into the history of 17th-century North German composers; many CDs feature his vocal music alongside works by Dieterich Buxtehude, Heinrich Scheidemann, and Georg Böhm. While these albums present a contextual perspective on the musical works by North German composers of the time, Konrad Junghänel and Cantus Cölln offer Baroque devotees a wonderful alternative. Their newest disc highlights Weckmann’s most poignant contributions to the sacred vocal concerto, a 17th-century genre known for its musical depictions of religious texts. The three sacred concertos included on this disc—Wie Continued on page 57 Early Music America Winter 2010 23 CARL PHILIPP EMANUEL BACH he omplete orks RECENTLY PUBLISHED VOLUMES “Kenner und Liebhaber” Collections I Edited by Christopher Hogwood ---- (xxxii, pp.) .* “Kenner und Liebhaber” Collections II Edited by Christopher Hogwood ---- (xxxii, pp.) .* Keyboard Concertos from Manuscript Sources I Edited by Peter Wollny ---- (xxviii, pp.) .* Keyboard Concertos from Manuscript Sources VIII Edited by Elias N. Kulukundis and David Schulenberg ---- (xxiv, pp.) .* Arias and Chamber Cantatas Edited by Bertil Van Boer ---- (xxxii, pp.) .* Please see website for a complete list of available and forthcoming volumes. All are cloth-bound and contain introductions and critical commentaries. The Wilhelm Friedemann Bach Collected Works Edition is also available through our website. Phone orders: () - Web orders: www.cpebach.org * These prices are for direct sales only RECORDINGreviews Continued from page 23 liegt die Stadt so wüste, Weine nicht, and Zion spricht—are highlights of North German music during the mid-17th century, and the performance given by Cantus Cölln is a testament to both the talents of the group as well as to Weckmann’s compositional mastery. The three works differ in orchestration and musical style. Wie liegt, the first track on the album, is a setting of the Lamentations of Jeremiah, and Weckmann’s approach to this piece emphasizes both personal and collective grief. Johanna Koslowsky’s performance as the soprano soloist is appropriately emotional: she treats her solo as a theatrical role, creating anticipation and drama through her use of ornaments and dynamics (her ornaments in her second solo are extraordinary). Wolf Matthias Friedrich, the bass soloist, provides a lovely counterpoint to the soprano; although each sings separately to express personal sorrow, they join together at the end of the lament in a compelling exaltation of God. In Weine nicht, the orchestra takes up expressions of grief; in contrast to Wie liegt, the orchestra cultivates contrasting themes of lament through intensely chromatic passages, suspensions and sequences, and varieties of orchestration (including an interlude of fanfares that connotes a battle). My favorite piece, the setting of Zion spricht, opens with an affective sinfonia full of dissonance and chromaticism. The singers are treated as one voice, singing together or presented in point of imitation as echoes. In each sacred concerto, the singers perform with a pious devotion to musical detail (especially regarding ornaments) and religious affect. As Peter Wollny’s liner notes tell us, these three sacred concertos, found in the Lüneburg autograph score, were composed just after Weckmann’s wife died of the plague in Hamburg in 1663; perhaps, as Wollny suggests, these laments are Weckmann’s own outpouring of sorrow. This disc also includes chamber vocal music and two canzonas featuring Bruce Dickey on cornett and Simen Van Mechelen on trombone. These pieces, generally shorter and with more focused affect, illustrate the variety of musical styles that Weckmann included in his sacred music, including imitation, dance forms, and virtuoso vocal writing. This disc is a wonderful addition to the catalogue of sacred music of the 17th century, especially because Weckmann’s work has been rather neglected. Overall, the balance on the CD is wonderful, something that is noticed especially during moments when the continuo organ (played by Carsten Lohff) cuts through the musical texture. There were a few moments, especially during bass solos, when the group drowned out the singer. Despite this minor flaw, Konrad Junghänel and Cantus Cölln have done a wonderful job putting together an album that showcases Weckmann’s expertise at composing affective and dramatic vocal music. —Alison DeSimone COLLECTIONS Bolivian Baroque, Vol. 3— Music from the Missions and La Plata Florilegium, Ashley Soloman, director; Arakaendar Bolivia Choir; James Johnstone, organ Channel Classics CCS SA 28009 www.channelclassics.com It’s been eight years since my “Music in the New World” story appeared in the Winter issue of this magazine. At that time the repertoire was dominated by the seminal recordings of Gabriel Garrido and his Ensemble Elyma on the French K617 label. Interest in the music has gained some momentum since then, and in recent recordings the repertoire has been championed by Jeffrey Skidmore and Ex Cathedra (Hyperion) and Ashley Solomon’s Florilegium (Channel Classics). Thanks to Father Piotr Nawrot’s exhaustive research in the archives of the Bolivian missions, Solomon and company present a program of villancicos, polychoral liturgical music, a trio sonata by an anonymous native composer, and key- board works by Domenico Zipoli (1688-1726). Villancicos by Juan de Araujo (1646-1712), Sebastián Durón (1660-1716), Roque Jacinto de Chavarria (1688-1719), and Diego de Casseda (fl.1673-94) are sprinkled throughout the program. All are performed with the right balance of rhythmic pop and tenderness. The liturgical works are the Missa Octavo Tono by Tomás de Torrejón y Velasco (16441728) and an anonymous Salve a 8. The Velasco is a nice find that showcases some delicate writing for the small vocal group and a richly sonorous massed choir sound for the full ensemble. Zipoli’s organ music is played by James Johnstone on the instrument at the Mission Church of Santa Ana, the sole surviving 18thcentury organ in the Chiquitania. The organ has a marvelously grainy and pungent sound. The native composer’s trio sonata (Nawrot refers to them as “Sonatas chiquitanas”) is a charmer and features a particularly galante-styled closing minuette. Much of the heavy lifting is done by the young voices of the Arakaendar Bolivia Choir, the ensemble founded by Solomon. As heard on earlier volumes, the choir’s bright youthful sound is very pleasing, despite an occasional bout of meandering pitch. Florilegium’s performances are terrific and do much to make this series a fine addition to the genre. —Craig Zeichner Music from the Court of Burgundy Ciaramella, Adam Knight Gilbert and Rotem Gilbert, directors Yarlung 05785 www.yarlungrecords.com When a group plays or records early music, there are two ways to go about it. One is to treat the music as a historical artifact to be preserved as accurately as possible, and the other is to interpret the music in the way we understand its contemporaries to have done. A group can definitely do both if it has the skill, and Ciaramella has it in spades. On this latest release, Ciaramella presents an exciting conglomeration of music from the 15th century. It might as well be a study in dichotomies—sacred vs. secular, soothing vs. raucous, vocal vs. instrumental, loud(s) vs. soft(s). But co-director Adam Knight Gilbert’s liner notes place the repertory squarely within the multifaceted milieu of the Burgundian court, in which these categories were flexible, if ever really present. So each piece is rendered as it might possibly have been done in the 15th century, when form, and every other determinant, followed function. Musically, the recording is excellent. The individual melodic line is so important in music of this era, and it is especially clear here in the recorder pieces, where the close miking described in the liner notes allows the listener to hear not only every single line equally distinctly, but even the tiniest of hasty breaths. Rhythmically, this music is quite challenging, but rather than feeling as if there are tapping toes and frantic counting, the performances come off sounding playful. “Una panthera” and the three settings of “Comme femme desconfortee” are my personal favorites; if Ciconia or Agricola were jazz, they’d be deep in the groove. Jazz isn’t too far removed from some of the music of this era—performers of that era would have been expected to improvise, often taking familiar tunes of the day and reworking them or embellishing them. In that vein, Gilbert treats the Early Music America magazine welcomes news of recent recordings. Please send CDs to be considered for review and pertinent information to Tom Moore, Recording Reviews Editor, c/o Early Music America, 2366 Eastlake Ave. E., #429, Seattle, WA 98102; [email protected]. Early Music America cannot guarantee the inclusion of every CD sent for review. All reviews reflect the personal opinions of the reviewer only. Label web sites are supplied with each review to assist readers who are unable to locate discs through Amazon.com, CDBaby.com, ArkivMusic.com, or other outlets. Early Music America Winter 2010 57 Vox Renaissance Consort RECORDINGreviews Valentin Radu, Artistic Director & Conductor Noël Renaissance Exceptional sound on a new Lyrichord CD! Christmas motets, carols, dances & Noëls by Monteverdi, Gabrieli, Praetorius, Victoria, Corelli, Purcell & others, for voices & period instruments Available at VoxAmaDeus.org (610) 688-2800 58 Winter 2010 Early Music America listener to his own sets of divisions on “La Spagna” and arrangements of other well-known songs. On the whole, this is some of the best early music you can find. From the standpoint of repertory, there’s a delightful mix of more- and lessfamiliar music, representing all the different musical traditions at court. And as for Ciaramella, their superb sense of motion, rhythm, and phrasing, combined with their rich sound, create a unified and exceptionally musical recording. —Karen Clark New New Nothing, or, English Country Dances of the Seventeenth Century Shulamit Kleinerman, violin; Jacob Breedlove, Lee Inman, viole da gamba; Charles Coldwell, recorder; Ruthie Dornfeld, Arcana Ferfche, violins; and Lisa Michele Lewis, harpsichord Jack Straw Productions www.shulamitk.net On this latest release from violinist Shulamit Kleinerman, she presents an eclectic group of country dance tunes, the majority of which are taken from John Playford’s 1651 The Dancing Master. The recording itself is quite decent—very clear and crisp, which makes it seem as though you’re in the front row at a performance, or better yet, at a dance lucky enough to feature such fine live music. Kleinerman is herself a dancer, which I think is evident in her choice of tempi for the tunes and the way that the rhythms inherent in each style of tune come forth in her playing. As a result, the music feels informal, spontaneous, welcoming, even familiar. I applaud, as always, the current trend in environmentally friendly packaging, although, of course, the problem with not providing liner notes is that one has to be connected to the Internet in order to access them at any given time. Kleinerman provides a page of liner notes on her website, but I wish these had been included with the CD for those listeners who may not always bother to look them up online. Not only are they short and succinct, but they provide valuable information about some of the changes and additions that she’s made to the dance tunes as they stand in the Playford book. For example, she has added her own harmony parts to several of them, which of course is probably not far off from the practice of the day in the 1600s. However, slightly more problematic to my ear are those tunes where she has altered a key in order to link it with another similar dance tune, or changed a few notes to heighten a sense of modality more common to much later American string music. While Playford purists would most likely be able to tell upon first listening that there were changes made, others may appreciate knowing this right off the bat. Her changes aren’t unmusical by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, some of them are quite imaginative, like the unusual choice of pizzicato on “An Old Man is a Bed Full of Bones,” and the very interesting reprise of “The New Hornpipe,” the only piece chosen from a different Playford book (The Division Violin). The result is a very earthy and enjoyable melange of dances. Almost all of the tunes presented here are done so as duets. To that end, Kleinerman has invited a large number of other musicians to sit in. Each of them adds something special to the disc; my personal favorites were the lovely recorder variations on “Scotch Cap/Hey Boys Up Go We/Green Stockings,” the violin duets on “Maiden Lane/PellMell/Europe’s Revels,” and of course the harpsichord on the most famous of the tunes, “Greensleeves.” If you like to country dance to pre-recorded music, this surely would be a very good recording to have on hand. The biggest problem with that, of course, is that if the performers are there in person, the dance can continue ad infinitum, while with a CD you’re limited to the recorded length of the piece. With that said, however, I think that for those active in English country dancing, this would be a fine recording to have. And outside of a dance context, it’s quite pleasant to listen to in its own right. —Karen Cook USC Thornton School of Music Early Music Program FACULTY Adam Knight Gilbert Program Director, Baroque Sinfonia and Collegium, Musicology Offering M.A. and D.M.A. degrees in Historical Performance and Ph.D. in Musicology and Early Modern Studies t1FSGPSNXJUIUIF64$ɩPSOUPO#BSPRVF4JOGPOJBBOEPUIFSFOTFNCMFT t4UVEZIJTUPSJDBMQFSGPSNBODFQSBDUJDFXJUIPVSPVUTUBOEJOHGBDVMUZ t1BSUJDJQBUFJONBTUFSDMBTTFTBOEXPSLTIPQTCZSFOPXOFETQFDJBMJTUT t3FDSFBUFIJTUPSJDBMJNQSPWJTBUJPO t$PMMBCPSBUFXJUIUIF64$)VOUJOHUPO&BSMZ.PEFSO4UVEJFT*OTUJUVUF Susan Feldman Baroque Violin, Vielle, Baroque Sinfonia Lucinda Carver Harpsichord and Continuo 'PSBQQMJDBUJPONBUFSJBMTBOEJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUBTTJTUBOUTIJQT BOENFSJUTDIPMBSTIJQTJODMVEJOH$PMCVSO'PVOEBUJPO4DIPMBSTIJQT GPS)JTUPSJDBM1FSGPSNBODFDPOUBDU 1+8PPMTUPO%JSFDUPSPG"ENJTTJPO VTDNVTJD!VTDFEV William Skeen Baroque Cello and Viola da gamba 'PSJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUPVSEFHSFFQSPHSBNTWJTJU XXXVTDFEVNVTJDQSPHSBNTFBSMZ "EBN,OJHIU(JMCFSUEJSFDUPS BEBNHJMCFSU!VTDFEV Shanon Zusman Violone and Viola da gamba Rachelle Fox Voice and Collegium Rotem Gilbert Recorder, Alta capella, Performance Practice Paul Sherman Baroque Oboe and Oboe Band Charles Koster Baroque Bassoon Scott Shubeck Lute and Theorbo Bruce A. Brown Musicology Stephen Stubbs, LUTE Ingrid Matthews, VIOLIN EARLY MUSIC AT Byron Schenkman, HARPSICHORD Margriet Tindemans, VIOLA CORNISH SEATTLE Janet See, BAROQUE DA GAMBA FLUTE Maxine Eilander, HARP Kris Kwapis, BAROQUE TRUMPET, CORNETTO Cyndia Sieden, VOICE Nancy Zylstra, VOICE Ross Hauck, VOICE commit to excellence Cornish College of the Arts offers a Bachelor of Music in Composition, Instrumental or Vocal Performance. apply online at www.cornish.edu/music or call 800 // 726 // ARTS Early Music America Winter 2010 59