2015 Community Assessment Report
Transcription
2015 Community Assessment Report
Columbia Opportunities, Inc. Community Assessment 540 Columbia Street Hudson, NY 12534 Telephone: (518) 828-4611 www.columbiaopportunities.org 2015 - 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW ........................................................................................... 3 GREATEST NEED & CONCERN AREAS ...................................................................................... 4 ABOUT COLUMBIA OPPORTUNITIES, INC. .............................................................................. 5 ABOUT COLUMBIA COUNTY, NEW YORK ................................................................................ 7 POPULATION PROFILE ........................................................................................................... 8 POVERTY ............................................................................................................................. 14 EMPLOYMENT ..................................................................................................................... 24 EDUCATION ......................................................................................................................... 30 HOUSING ............................................................................................................................ 34 INCOME .............................................................................................................................. 39 NUTRITION .......................................................................................................................... 44 HEALTH CARE ...................................................................................................................... 47 CRIME ................................................................................................................................. 52 COMMUNITY RESOURCES .................................................................................................... 53 NYS COMMUNITY ACTION ASSOCIATION 2015 POVERTY REPORT ........................................ 56 NYS COMMUNITY ACTION ASSOCIATION 2015 POVERTY GUIDELINES .................................. 58 2 Introduction and Overview Columbia Opportunities, Incorporated (COI) as the Community Services Block Grant (CSBG) funded Community Action Agency (CAA) and the Head Start grantee for Columbia County, NY is required to complete a comprehensive Community Assessment every three years. This report is COI’s full Community Assessment for 2015-2018. The Program Committee for the COI Board of Directors has overall responsibility for the Community Assessment. After determining the best way to proceed with the report, the Program Committee formed a Community Assessment Team that included committee members, a representative of the Head Start Policy Council, COI program staff and “Community Advisors” to assist in the collection and analysis of survey data. Community Assessment Team members included: COI Board of Directors Berne Bendel Carol Friedman Terri Mayhew (Head Start Policy Council Representative) Barbara Sagal Community Advisors Joyce Lapenn Barbara Heimroth Johnson Kelly Sackett COI Staff Cynthia Andrus, Head Start Director Sophia Becker, Hudson Family Literacy Director Annemarie Friebe, Weatherization Program Coordinator Tina Sharpe, COI Executive Director Juliette Tomlinson, Head Start Family Community Partnership Manager This report is a compilation of both qualitative and quantitative data. Qualitative data was derived from a series of community focus groups conducted during the months of August and September, 2015. A total of 5 focus groups were held with 77 attendees including COI customers, board members, staff, Head Start Policy Council members, and community members. Additional data included information derived from COI program reports including Community Services Block Grant Program Progress Reports and Head Start Program Information Reports. Quantitative data includes statistics and information obtained from a variety of sources, including: Berkshire Taconic Community Foundation – Early Childhood Development Mapping Report Child Care Connections of Columbia & Greene Counties - 2014 Community Assessment Columbia County Community Health Assessment & Improvement Plan 2014-2017 Columbia Greene Housing Coalition Continuum of Care 2015 Point In Time Study Dyson Foundation/Marist College 2012 “Many Voices, One Valley- Making Ends Meet Report.” Feeding America Website (Map the Gap) National Low Income Housing Coalition New York State Community Action Association Community Assessment Tool New York State Community Action Association 2015 Poverty Report New York State Department of Education New York State Department of Health New York State Office of Temporary & Disability Assistance New York State Statistical Yearbook The Self-Sufficiency Standard for New York State 2010 U.S. Census Bureau 3 The 2015 Community Assessment identifies and explores the opportunities and challenges facing Columbia County residents with limited or low income. The key study objectives include the following: Identify the current causes and conditions of poverty in our community including social, emotional, economic and educational Identify community resources Develop a report that will guide future decisions about COI program design, development, retention, evaluation, and expansion Issue a report that can be used by community partners, planners, and leaders to better understand the issue of poverty in Columbia County, NY Greatest Need & Concern Areas The 2015 Community Assessment found the greatest need and concern in the following areas (listed alphabetically not in rank order): Early childhood development opportunities & child care Employment and job training opportunities Health care services – especially dental and mental health services for children Housing Affordability Nutrition and hunger services Transportation 4 About Columbia Opportunities, Inc. Columbia Opportunities, Inc. (COI) is the private, not-for-profit Community Action Agency that has been serving the residents of Columbia County since 1978. With a mission to help solve poverty related problems in our community, COI’s goal is to enable families to attain the skills, knowledge, and opportunities they need to become self-reliant. COI offers training, education, counseling, housing services, healthcare, advocacy, emergency assistance and support to over 1300 local families each year. These programs have a measurable impact on the causes and conditions of poverty in our community. Asset Development The Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) program offers free tax help to people who generally make $54,000 per year or less, people with disabilities, senior citizens and limited English speaking taxpayers who need assistance in preparing their own tax returns. IRS-certified volunteers provide free basic income tax return preparation with electronic filing to qualified individuals. VITA ensures that customers receive all the tax credits they are eligible for. The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) is an earnings supplement available through the income tax system that offsets payroll taxes and supports low and moderate income workers raising children. It has grown to be the nation’s largest federal antipoverty program. The EITC has significant benefits for taxpayers and the community. These include encouragement of work, reduction of poverty, and boosting of local economic activity. Emergency Assistance The Community Services Program offers emergency interventions for food and shelter needs, problem solving for income and family issues, and advocacy to insure that individuals and families have access to all available and necessary services. COI offers financial assistance for a variety of emergency needs in partnership with the Berkshire Taconic Foundation Neighbor-to-Neighbor Fund and the Hudson River Bank & Trust Foundation Supplemental Energy Assistance Program. In addition COI is helping to close the “digital divide” between rich and poor. Community Services customers have access to a variety of information technology resources from basic telephone to internet access. This enables customers to search for housing and employment, apply for mainstream benefits, manage their income, and even file their own income tax returns. Housing & Energy Services COI is an alternate certifier for the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP). This program helps individuals and families with the high cost of heating their homes. According to the Campaign for Home Energy Assistance, LIHEAP has evolved into a widely supported program that delivers critical short-term aid to our most vulnerable neighbors. LIHEAP is an essential resource for the country’s most underserved populations, including the working poor, those making the difficult transition from welfare to work, disabled persons, elderly persons and families with young children. Unfortunately it only covers a fraction of the need. COI also serves as an intake site for emergency assistance offered by area utility companies in partnership with HeartShare NY. COI’s Housing Choice Voucher Program provides ongoing help with monthly rent payments. This federally funded program assists very low-income families, elderly people, and people with disabilities to afford decent, safe, and sanitary housing in the private market. Since housing assistance is provided on behalf of the family or individual, participants are able to find their own housing, including singlefamily homes and apartments. Vouchers are designed to bridge the difference between 30% of a tenant’s income and the fair market rental of an appropriate housing unit. However as rents in the area continue to rise; this voucher program cannot keep up. The program has a long waiting list and is currently serving individuals and families who applied in 2009. 5 The Weatherization Program provides energy audits to homeowners and renters, in order to find the best way to make their homes more energy efficient. Energy conservations measures such as refrigerator replacements, furnace repair or replacement, insulation, and air sealing are installed to make residences safe, comfortable and less expensive to heat. Individuals and families with low incomes typically spend well over 20% of their total annual income on energy costs. During the heating season these families frequently cut back on other necessities to cover this expense. Weatherization provides a long-term solution for customers, helping to protect them from rising energy costs. Preparing Individuals, Families, and Children for Success Head Start is an early childhood development program designed to meet the needs of preschool age children and their families. Services are provided in classroom and home based settings throughout Columbia County. Since its inception, Head Start has taken a comprehensive approach to providing high-quality early education. The program focuses on the whole child, recognizing the importance of social, emotional, physical and cognitive development. Head Start children receive medical and developmental screenings and subsequent treatment for identified concerns. Their families receive parenting education, health education and support services that connect them to education, jobs and other community resources. Current research tells us that this full array of services is what early education programs should offer to have a positive effect on vulnerable children. COI’s Head Start Program offers safe and free child development opportunities in high need communities throughout Columbia County. Through a partnership with the Hudson City School District, the Hudson Family Literacy Program offers a range of literacy services and supports to individuals and families. This program is designed to support and guide the adult and child learner in meeting their educational and vocational goals while helping to develop the home and community as a learning environment for everyone. The Family Literacy program is driven by a comprehensive, holistic approach to education where parents and children learn and grow together. Family Literacy programs address the literacy strengths and needs of the family while promoting adult involvement in children's education and recognizing adults as a powerful influence on their children's academic success. Community Partnerships COI maintains both formal and informal partnerships with different public and private organizations to achieve family, agency and community outcomes. The Columbia Greene Housing Coalition Continuum of Care Program is a significant community collaboration that was spearheaded by Columbia Opportunities, Inc. in 2002. This initiative has been responsible for the creation of several permanent supportive housing opportunities for residents of Columbia and Greene Counties who had been homeless. 6 About Columbia County, New York Geographic Summary Columbia County is located between the Capital District and the Hudson Valley, with the Hudson River to the west, the Massachusetts border to the east, Dutchess County to the south, and Rensselaer County to the north. Columbia County is a rural community and covers an area of 688 square miles. The county has eighteen towns (Ancram, Austerlitz, Canaan, Chatham, Claverack, Clermont, Copake, Gallatin, Germantown, Ghent, Greenport, Hillsdale, Kinderhook, Livingston, New Lebanon, Stockport, Stuyvesant, and Taghkanic) four villages (Chatham, Kinderhook, Philmont, and Valatie) and one small city, the City of Hudson. The County’s population is well dispersed with only a few population centers that exceed 10% of the total population. These areas include the Town of Kinderhook, City of Hudson, and Town of Claverack. Governing Structure Columbia County is governed by a County Board of Supervisors elected by respective towns and wards in the City of Hudson. Each supervisor receives a weighted vote which is based on the population of the town or ward represented. The City of Hudson, situated on the Hudson River, the western border of the county, is the only city in the county and is the county seat. Current Economic Conditions and Development Agriculture Columbia County has vast regions of open space that traditionally had been utilized for dairy, vegetable and fruit farms. The economic viability of farming had declined over the past half century due to the high cost of land and the shrinking opportunity to obtain credit. There is, however, a growing movement to attract young people back to farming. The current interest in local "farm-to-table" is a catalyst for the revitalization of farming. According to the Columbia Economic Development Council, agribusiness has been identified as a priority in the regional economy and continues to experience economic growth in Columbia County. From 2002 to 2007, there was an 11% increase in the number of farms, bringing the number to 557. The natural resources and infrastructure of Columbia County already exists to support new initiatives in this field. Service Industry Major providers of community services and employment include Columbia Memorial Hospital, Columbia-Greene Community College, Coarc, the state of New York, Columbia County government, local school districts and nursing homes. Together these are the major employers in Columbia County. Tourism Tourism remains one of Columbia County's and New York State’s growth industries. Local government and the private sector continue to explore ways to attract more tourists to the county. While there was a dip in the number of tourists in 2009 at the height of the recession, Columbia County’s decrease was still only half of the decline experienced in nearby counties. 7 Population Profile The population of Columbia County has been relatively stable for the past 20 years. The following table shows the population changes in Columbia County from 2000 to 2010. However there has been a downward shift in the number of working adults of childbearing years, a decline which began in the early 1990s. The closing of manufacturing plants, job loss and displacement by second home owners are contributing factors. This is a trend found throughout upstate New York. Table 1. Population Change 2000 - 2013 Census 2000 ACS 2009-2013 Population Change Population Population % Change Columbia 63,094 62,674 -420 -0.67 Statewide 18,976,457 19,487,052 510,595 2.69 Source: United States Census Bureau, Population Division, Census 2010. Release Date: February 2011 and United States Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. The City of Hudson is among the most populated municipalities, but had lost one third of its population between 1950 and 1980. Since 1990, when the population was 8,034, it has continued to decline, reaching 6,713 by 2010. The 2010 census revealed that Canaan, Claverack, New Lebanon and Stuyvesant also lost more than 5 percent of their residents since 2000. In contrast, Austerlitz, Clermont, Copake, Gallatin, Hillsdale and especially Taghkanic grew by more than 10 percent in the number of year-round residents. Age and Gender Demographics The ACS 2009-2013 5 year population estimates indicate the female population comprised 50.05% of Columbia County, while the male population represented 49.95%. The population by age in Columbia County is illustrated in the following graph. 8 Children under the age of 5 According to the 2010 Census, there were 2,902 children under age 5 in Columbia County, representing 4.6 percent of the population. This represents a substantial drop from the 2000 Census, when there were 3,357 young children or 5.3% of the population. Adults over the age of 65 Columbia County has a high percentage of people age 65 and older (18.2%, compared to the state percentage of 13.5%), and people age 85 and older (2.5% compared to the state percentage of 2.0%) The county’s median age of 45.3 is higher than the state’s median age of 38.0. Veterans, Age and Gender Demographics Table 2 shows the number of veterans living in Columbia County. 10.57 percent of the adult population in the county are veterans. This is higher than the statewide average of 6.01 percent and national average of 8.99%. Table 2. Age and Gender Demographics of Veterans, 2009 - 2013 Veterans Percent of Population over 18 by Gender Total Males Females Total Males Females Columbia 5,317 4,887 430 10.57 19.58 1.70 Statewide 912,499 861,084 51,415 6.01 11.92 0.65 21,263,780 19,709,452 1,554,327 8.99 17.21 1.27 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is an average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Race/Ethnicity Demographics Population by race and gender within Columbia County is shown in Table 3. According to the American Community Survey 5 year averages, the county population was 91.07% white, 4.26% black, and 1.80% other races combined. Persons identifying themselves as mixed race made up 2.87% of the population. The City of Hudson had the highest proportions of African-Americans, Hispanics and Asians. 9 Table 3. Population By Race, 2009 - 2013 Black American Asian Indian White M F M F M F M Native Hawaiian F M Mixed Race F M F Ancram 764 650 24 12 0 0 13 0 0 0 16 7 Austerlitz 629 747 19 5 0 0 11 12 0 0 0 0 Canaan 783 710 85 5 0 0 28 7 0 0 29 36 Chatham 1,943 2,020 16 12 0 0 37 1 0 0 55 20 Claverack 2,757 2,689 114 6 27 4 0 3 0 0 160 179 Clermont 905 921 9 0 0 0 11 24 0 0 26 31 Copake 1,761 1,700 18 0 0 0 11 0 0 0 11 3 Gallatin 799 951 5 0 0 0 0 8 0 0 18 26 Germantown 854 1,066 0 14 0 2 0 2 0 0 29 37 Ghent 2,706 2,327 89 87 0 0 54 37 0 0 17 13 Greenport 1,760 1,803 131 70 0 0 79 59 0 0 134 83 Hillsdale 907 795 91 81 0 0 8 4 0 0 5 20 Hudson-N 962 1,149 331 461 24 28 107 111 0 0 132 246 Hudson-S 1,206 1,058 398 146 9 0 8 58 38 0 84 42 Kinderhook - N 1,028 1,124 7 22 1 2 14 0 0 0 28 17 Kinderhook - S 2,890 3,001 66 47 0 0 45 59 0 0 37 29 Livingston 1,701 1,691 33 75 0 0 5 29 0 0 24 52 New Lebanon 1,075 1,085 24 45 0 0 44 69 0 0 29 24 Stockport 1,396 1,356 22 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 Stuyvesant 892 1,027 60 10 0 0 11 4 0 0 37 43 Taghkanic 606 566 1 0 0 0 6 6 0 0 2 4 Columbia 28,324 28,436 1,543 1,115 61 36 492 493 38 0 874 912 Statewide 6,244,223 6,535,103 1,404,656 1,637,496 36,280 36,460 711,026 768,300 3,512 3,853 250,960 259,469 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Data on public elementary school enrollment often more accurately reflects the current racial and ethnic composition of children in each part of the county. The general population census reflects all age groups and includes “group quarters,” such as nursing homes and correctional facilities. Based on the information in Table 4, there are higher proportions of African Americans, Hispanics and Asians in the schools than in the population as a whole. 10 Table 4. Race and Ethnic Composition Columbia County, NY Public Schools PreK-12 2014-15 School Year School District White Black 980 % 87% Germantown 489 Hudson Hispanic Asian, Pacific Islander 11 % 1% American Indian 0 28 % 2% 56 % 5% 88% 4 1% 39 7% 6 1% 821 47% 400 23% 231 11% 186 1719 92% 44 2% 59 3% 376 93% 10 2% 8 Taconic Hills 1172 85% 30 2% Total 5557 79% 516 7% Chatham Kinderhook New Lebanon % 0 Multiracial 48 % 4% 0 0 16 3% 11% 1 0% 121 7% 26 1% 0 0 11 1% 2% 5 1% 0 0 4 1% 109 8% 8 1% 4 0% 54 4% 502 7% 242 3% 5 <1% 254 4% Source: NYS Department of Education Report Card – 2014-15 Citizenship Status Table 5 shows the numbers and percent of population by citizenship status for Columbia County. The county has a total of 1,654 non-Citizens, or 2.64 percent of the total population of 62,674 persons, in contrast to the New York average of 10.49 percent of the population and the national average of 7.11 percent non-Citizens living in the United States. Table 5. Citizenship Status, 2009 – 2013 Population Count Native Born in a US Territory Born Abroad to US Citizens By Percent Naturalized Non-Citizen Columbia 58,389 198 527 1,906 Statewide 14,699,492 312,716 160,142 2,270,762 2,043,941 266,837,152 1,773,094 2,584,452 18,206,896 22,135,004 Nationwide Native 1,654 95.69 Born in a US Territory Born Abroad to US Citizens Naturalized 0.32 0.86 3.12 2.64 84.27 1.79 0.92 13.02 10.49 92.20 0.61 0.89 6.29 7.11 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. Communities with higher than average percentage of non-citizens include: Hillsdale, the City Hudson, Copake, Livingston, and Claverack. Communities with a higher than average numbers of non-citizens include: Hudson, Copake, Hillsdale, Livingston, and Claverack. 11 Non-Citizen Table 5a. Citizenship Status, 2009 - 2013 Population Count Native Born in a Born Naturalized US Abroad to Territory US Citizens NonCitizen Native By Percent Born in a US Territory Born Naturalized Non-Citizen Abroad to US Citizens Ancram 1,422 0 12 16 54 98.07 0.00 0.83 1.10 3.59 Austerlitz 1,333 2 20 41 27 95.49 0.14 1.43 2.94 1.90 Canaan 1,647 6 12 21 18 97.69 0.36 0.71 1.25 1.06 Chatham 3,865 10 21 141 67 95.74 0.25 0.52 3.49 1.63 Claverack 5,565 16 83 208 124 94.77 0.27 1.41 3.54 2.07 Clermont 1,825 0 6 74 28 95.80 0.00 0.31 3.88 1.45 Copake 3,295 0 35 57 195 97.28 0.00 1.03 1.68 5.44 Gallatin 1,713 0 3 81 10 95.33 0.00 0.17 4.51 0.55 Germantown 1,895 5 27 42 35 96.24 0.25 1.37 2.13 1.75 Ghent 4,947 0 105 210 90 94.01 0.00 2.00 3.99 1.68 Greenport 3,896 10 8 148 57 95.91 0.25 0.20 3.64 1.38 Hillsdale 1,648 0 12 76 177 94.93 0.00 0.69 4.38 9.25 Hudson-N 3,144 54 18 187 220 92.39 1.59 0.53 5.50 6.07 Hudson-S 2,770 57 11 103 122 94.19 1.94 0.37 3.50 3.98 Kinderhook - N 2,087 0 14 101 41 94.78 0.00 0.64 4.59 1.83 Kinderhook - S 5,973 36 23 108 69 97.28 0.59 0.37 1.76 1.11 Livingston 3,293 0 63 114 149 94.90 0.00 1.82 3.29 4.12 New Lebanon 2,198 0 3 117 84 94.82 0.00 0.13 5.05 3.50 Stockport 2,740 0 22 17 13 98.60 0.00 0.79 0.61 0.47 Stuyvesant 2,012 0 12 0 67 99.41 0.00 0.59 0.00 3.20 Taghkanic 1,121 2 17 44 7 94.68 0.17 1.44 3.72 0.59 Columbia 58,389 198 527 1,906 1,654 93.16 0.32 0.84 3.04 2.64 Statewide 14,699,492 312,716 160,142 2,270,762 2,043,9 41 84.27 1.79 0.92 13.02 10.49 266,837,152 1,773,094 2,584,452 18,206,896 22,135, 004 92.20 0.61 0.89 6.29 7.11 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Language According to the United States Census Bureau Quick Facts, 7% of the population in Columbia County speaks a language other than English in their home; this is in contrast to 30.2% in New York State, and 20.9% in the United States. According to NYS School Report Cards for area public schools, 4% or 249 enrolled students are identified as Limited English Proficient. The Hudson City School District has the 12 highest number and percentage of students (132/8%) followed by Ichabod Crane (74/4%) and then Germantown (11/2%). Chatham and Taconic Hills School Districts report that only 1% of their student enrollments are Limited English Proficient, New Lebanon reports none. COI Head Start enrollment data indicates that 86% of enrolled families speak English as their primary language. Eleven percent speak Spanish and 3% speak a Middle Eastern or Asian language. Households The change in number of households within Columbia County from 2000 - 2013 is shown in Table 6. The number of households increased by 484, or 1.95% as reported in the ACS 2013 estimates. This compares to a statewide increase of 2.52%. Table 6. Change in Number of Households, 2000 - 2013 Total Households, Total Households, Change in Households 2000 2008-2013 % Change in Households Columbia 24,796 25,280 484 1.95 Statewide 7,056,860 7,234,743 177,883 2.52 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2000 Census of Population and Housing, Summary File 1, 2000 and U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Families Between 2008 and 2013, Columbia County had 25,280 households or families according to the American Community Survey, with an average of 3.5 persons per household. Of these, an estimated 16,228 are families, 6,630 of which have children under 18 years old. Of that number 76% of the families with children under 18 are married couples, 17% are female headed with no spouse present, and 7% are headed by a man with no spouse present. Nearly 670 grandparents live with their own grandchildren under age 18. Forty percent of them are responsible for their grandchildren. More than three-quarters of the estimated 9,000 “non-family households” live alone. Of these, nearly two-fifths are single individuals over the age of 65. 13 Community Concern: The issue of poverty was raised as a concern at one or more community focus groups. It was also noted that poverty rates can be misleading, especially when looking at less populated communities. Poverty According to updated information provided by the NYS Community Action Association poverty estimates show a total of 7,155 persons living at or below the poverty line in the county. The county poverty rate is estimated at 11.8%. This is a 3% increase in the poverty rate since initial 2013 estimates. Table 7. Poverty, 2013 All Ages Age 0-17 Number of Persons Columbia Poverty Rate 7,155 Number of Persons 11.8 Age 5-17 Poverty Rate 2,032 17.9 Number of Persons Poverty Rate 1,395 16.2 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates (SAIPE), 2013. Estimates for 2013 were released in December2014. Poverty Rate (ACS) Table 6 shows the total 2013 population estimates for all persons living in poverty in Columbia County. According to the American Community Survey 5 year averages, an average of 9.79 percent of all persons lived in poverty during the 2013 calendar year. The poverty rate for all persons living in Columbia County is less than the statewide average of 15.3 percent. This rate is lower than reported in Table 8. Table 8. Poverty Rate (ACS), 2009 – 2013 Poverty Rate for All Persons Total Population In Poverty Poverty Rate Columbia 60,363 5,911 9.79 Statewide 18,975,362 2,903,982 15.30 303,692,064 46,663,432 15.37 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. The City of Hudson has both the highest poverty rate for all persons and the largest number of individual people living in poverty as compared to other municipalities in Columbia County. Other towns with higher than average poverty rates include: Taghkanic, Clermont, Ancram, Copake, and Livingston. Towns with a higher number of individuals living in poverty than average include: Claverack, Copake, Copake, Livingston, Ghent, Greenport, and Kinderhook. Table 8a reveals poverty rates by census tract. 14 Table 8a. Poverty Rate (ACS), 2009 - 2013 Poverty Rate for All Persons Total Population In Poverty Poverty Rate Ancram 1,493 198 13.26 Austerlitz 1,423 115 8.08 Canaan 1,504 106 7.05 Chatham 3,990 224 5.61 Claverack 5,691 494 8.68 Clermont 1,928 265 13.74 Copake 3,568 471 13.20 Gallatin 1,767 88 4.98 Germantown 1,997 96 4.81 Ghent 5,120 376 7.34 Greenport 4,006 364 9.09 Hillsdale 1,913 142 7.42 Hudson-N 3,533 947 26.80 Hudson-S 2,593 474 18.28 Kinderhook - N 2,230 35 1.57 Kinderhook - S 5,838 322 5.52 Livingston 3,363 416 12.37 New Lebanon 2,366 174 7.35 Stockport 2,772 238 8.59 Stuyvesant 2,091 184 8.80 Taghkanic 1,177 182 15.46 Columbia 60,363 5,911 9.79 Statewide 18,975,362 2,903,982 15.30 303,692,064 46,663,432 15.37 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. 15 Households in Poverty Table 9 shows the number and percentage of households in poverty in Columbia County. In 2013, it is estimated that there were 2,353 households, or 9.31 percent, living in poverty within the county, compared to a statewide average of 14.49 percent and national average of 14.20%. Table 9. Households in Poverty, 2009 - 2013 Total Households, Households in Poverty, 2009/2013 2009/2013 % Households in Poverty, 2009/2013 Columbia 25,280 2,353 9.31 Statewide 7,234,743 1,048,297 14.49 115,610,216 16,415,984 14.20 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. The City of Hudson has the highest percentage and number of households living at or below the poverty level. Other communities with higher than average poverty rates include the towns of: Stuyvesant, Taghkanic, Ghent, Austerlitiz, Greenport, Claverack, and Ancram. Other communities with higher than average number of households living in poverty include: Claverack, Ghent, and Greenport. Table 9a. Households in Poverty, 2009 - 2013 Total Households, Households in Poverty, % Households in Poverty, 2009/2013 2009/2013 2009/2013 Ancram 638 60 9.40 Austerlitz 594 60 10.10 Canaan 616 25 4.06 Chatham 1,790 99 5.53 Claverack 2,469 233 9.44 Clermont 712 60 8.43 Copake 1,343 105 7.82 Gallatin 737 34 4.61 Germantown 847 50 5.90 Ghent 2,010 207 10.30 Greenport 1,870 178 9.52 716 64 8.94 Hudson-N 1,528 421 27.55 Hudson-S 1,409 247 17.53 Kinderhook - N 1,004 20 1.99 Kinderhook - S 2,216 104 4.69 Livingston 1,285 86 6.69 New Lebanon 1,034 76 7.35 Hillsdale 16 Table 9a. Continued Total Households, 2009/2013 Stockport Households in Poverty, 2009/2013 % Households in Poverty, 2009/2013 1,147 78 6.80 Stuyvesant 837 95 11.35 Taghkanic 478 51 10.67 Columbia 25,280 2,353 9.31 Statewide 7,234,743 1,048,297 14.49 115,610,216 16,415,984 14.20 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Households in Poverty by Family Type In 2013, it is estimated that there were 2,353 Columbia County households living in poverty. Table 10 shows the number of households in poverty by household type. In 2013, it is estimated that 3.91 percent of all households were living in poverty within the county, compared to a statewide average of 7.52 percent and the national average of 7.5 percent. Table 10. Households in Poverty by Family Type, 2009 - 2013 Total Households in Poverty Households, Overall Married Couples Male 2009-2013 Householder Female Householder Columbia 16,228 2,353 989 273 108 Statewide 4,637,549 1,048,297 544,050 189,858 54,297 76,744,360 16,415,984 8,666,630 3,148,540 923,063 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Poverty Rate Change, 2000 – 2013 Poverty rate change in Columbia County from 2000 to 2013 is shown in Table 11. According to the U.S. Census, the poverty rate for the county increased by 2.1%, compared to a statewide increase of 2.8%. Table 11. Change in Poverty Rate, 2000 – 2013 Persons in Poverty Rate, Persons in Poverty Rate, Poverty, 2000 2000 Poverty, 2013 2013 Change in Poverty Rate, 2000 - 2013 Columbia 5,949 9.7 7,155 11.8 2.1 Statewide 2,466,704 13.2 3,068,227 16.0 2.8 31,581,086 11.3 48,810,868 15.8 4.5 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates (SAIPE), 2013. 17 Child (0-17) Poverty Rate Change, 2000 - 2013 The poverty rate change for all children in Columbia County from 2000 to 2013 is shown in Table 12. According to the U.S. Census, the child poverty rate for the area increased by 3.4%, compared to a statewide increase of 3.8%. Table 12. Change in Childhood (0-17) Poverty Rate, 2000 – 2013 Children in Poverty Rate, Children in Poverty Rate, Poverty, 2000 2000 Poverty, 2013 2013 Change in Poverty Rate, 2000 - 2013 Columbia 2,074 14.5 2,032 17.9 3.4 Statewide 873,085 19.1 956,127 22.9 3.8 11,587,118 16.2 16,086,960 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates (SAIPE), 2013. 22.2 6.0 Nationwide Child (0-17) Poverty Rate (ACS) Table 13 shows the total population estimates for all children and children living in poverty for Columbia County. According to the American Community Survey 5 year averages, an average of 12.71 percent of area children lived in a state of poverty during the 2013 calendar year. Despite this increase, the poverty rate for children living in Columbia County is less than the statewide average of 21.67 percent. Again, these rates are lower than reported above. Table 13. American Community Survey, Child (0-17) Poverty Rate, 2009 – 2013 Children, Ages 0 - 17 years Total Population In Poverty Poverty Rate Columbia 11,771 1,496 12.71 Statewide 4,224,746 915,655 21.67 72,748,616 15,701,799 21.58 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Based on these 5 year projections, communities with higher than average child poverty rates include: Taghkanic, the City of Hudson, Ancram, Stockport, Clermont, Copake, and Livingston. Communities with higher than average numbers of children living at or below the poverty level include: the City of Hudson, Stockport, Copake, Ghent, Claverack, Livingston, Taghkanic, Clermont, and Greenport. 18 Table 13a. American Community Survey, Child (0-17) Poverty Rate, 2009 - 2013 Children, Ages 0 - 17 years Total Population In Poverty Poverty Rate Ancram 213 69 32.39 Austerlitz 287 31 10.80 Canaan 287 23 8.01 Chatham 662 32 4.83 Claverack 994 83 8.35 Clermont 435 73 16.78 Copake 590 97 16.44 Gallatin 249 4 1.61 Germantown 418 15 3.59 1,039 90 8.66 Greenport 651 73 11.21 Hillsdale 355 39 10.99 Hudson-N 1,042 359 34.45 Hudson-S 441 113 25.62 Kinderhook - N 418 2 0.48 Kinderhook - S 1,492 59 3.95 Livingston 617 82 13.29 New Lebanon 509 41 8.06 Stockport 443 103 23.25 Stuyvesant 426 31 7.28 Taghkanic 203 77 37.93 Columbia 11,771 1,496 12.71 Statewide 4,224,746 915,655 21.67 72,748,616 15,701,799 21.58 Ghent Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. 19 Child (0-4) Poverty Rate Change, 2000 - 2013 The poverty rate change for children under five years of age in Columbia County from 2000 to 2013 is shown in Table 14. According to the U.S. Census, the poverty rate for children under age 5 increased by 4.9%, compared to a statewide increase of 3.7%. Table 14. Poverty Rate Change for Children under Five, 2000 - 2013 Children 0-4 in Poverty Rate, Children 0-4 in Poverty Rate, Poverty, 2000 2000 Poverty, 2013 2013 Change in Poverty Rate, 2000 - 2013 Columbia 628 18.3 637 23.2 4.9 Statewide 267,704 21.2 289,572 24.9 3.7 4,050,543 20.3 5,128,728 25.9 5.6 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates (SAIPE), 2013. Child (0-4) Poverty Rate (ACS) Table 15 shows the total population estimates for children and children in poverty for Columbia County. According to the American Community Survey 5 year averages, an average of 16.16 percent of children lived in a state of poverty during the 2013 calendar year. The poverty rate for children living in Columbia County is less than the statewide average of 24.04 percent. Again, these rates are lower than reported above. Table 15. American Community Survey, Child (0-4) Poverty Rate, 2009 - 2013 Children, Ages 0 - 4 years Total Population In Poverty Poverty Rate Columbia 2,717 439 16.16 Statewide 1,144,996 275,271 24.04 19,743,544 4,881,767 24.73 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Based on these estimates, communities with higher than average poverty rates for children under the age of 5 include: Greenport, Taghkanic, Hudson, Ancram, Stuyvesant, Hillsdale, and Stockport. Communities with higher than average number of young children (age 5 or younger) includes: the City of Hudson, Greenport, Claverack, Taghkanic, Stuyvesant, and Copake. 20 Table 15a. American Community Survey, Child (0-4) Poverty Rate, 2009 - 2013 Children, Ages 0 - 4 years Total Population In Poverty Poverty Rate Ancram 26 8 30.77 Austerlitz 69 10 14.49 Canaan 49 8 16.33 Chatham 107 5 4.67 Claverack 320 26 8.13 Clermont 119 12 10.08 Copake 149 22 14.77 Gallatin 72 0 0.00 Germantown 135 15 11.11 Ghent 190 7 3.68 Greenport 79 47 59.49 Hillsdale 56 12 21.43 Hudson-N 315 128 40.63 Hudson-S 227 51 22.47 Kinderhook - N 128 0 0.00 Kinderhook - S 257 4 1.56 Livingston 160 13 8.13 New Lebanon 41 6 14.63 Stockport 90 19 21.11 Stuyvesant 82 22 26.83 Taghkanic 46 24 52.17 Columbia 2,717 439 16.16 Statewide 1,144,996 275,271 24.04 19,743,544 4,881,767 24.73 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. 21 Seniors (age 65 or older) in Poverty (ACS) Poverty rates for senior citizens, including data from the American Community Survey for the 2009 to 2013 period, are shown in Table 14. In 2013, it was estimated that there were 571 seniors, or 5.22 percent, living in poverty within the county. According to updated information from the NYS Community Action Association’s Poverty Report, the number of Columbia County seniors living in poverty has increased by more than 67% in the last 3 years. Table 16. Seniors in Poverty, 2009 – 2013 Seniors, 2009/2013 Seniors in Poverty, 2009/2013 Senior Poverty Rate, 2009/2013 Columbia 10,930 571 5.22 Statewide 2,595,107 293,920 11.33 40,544,640 3,793,577 9.36 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is an average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Communities with higher than average poverty rates for seniors include: the City of Hudson, Ancram, Austerlitz, Copake, Clermont, Greenport, and Claverack. Communities with higher than average number of seniors living in poverty includes: the City of Hudson, Copake, Claverack, Greenport, Ancram, Kinderhook, and Ghent. Table 16a. Columbia County Seniors (age 65 or older) in Poverty, 2009 - 2013 Seniors, 2009/2013 Seniors in Poverty, Senior Poverty Rate, 2009/2013 2009/2013 Ancram 310 40 12.90 Austerlitz 224 24 10.71 Canaan 298 3 1.01 Chatham 755 16 2.12 Claverack 1,278 75 5.87 Clermont 201 17 8.46 Copake 878 75 8.54 Gallatin 332 13 3.92 Germantown 435 0 0.00 Ghent 949 29 3.06 Greenport 873 60 6.87 Hillsdale 365 3 0.82 Hudson-N 313 90 28.75 Hudson-S 425 51 12.00 Kinderhook - N 319 3 0.94 Kinderhook - S 916 36 3.93 22 Seniors, 2009/2013 Seniors in Poverty, 2009/2013 Senior Poverty Rate, 2009/2013 Livingston 525 14 2.67 New Lebanon 444 0 0.00 Stockport 519 6 1.16 Stuyvesant 264 9 3.41 Taghkanic 307 7 2.28 Columbia 10,930 571 5.22 Statewide 2,595,107 293,920 11.33 Nationwide 40,544,640 3,793,577 9.36 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is an average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. 23 Community Concern: Participants at all of the focus groups expressed concerns about limited employment opportunities and the lack of jobs that paid a living wage. They also noted that improvements in employment supports such as job training, transportation and child care are needed. Employment Current Unemployment Unemployment rates are among the most closely watched “vital signs” by analysts seeking clues to the health of the economy. Unfortunately, this important economic statistic is often misunderstood. Of particular interest are “underemployed” workers whose circumstances are not fully captured by labor market statistics published each month. Labor force, employment, and unemployment data for Columbia County is provided in Table 17. Overall, the county experienced an average 3.6% unemployment rate in August 2015, compared to a statewide rate of 5.0%. Table 17. Employment/Unemployment Information, August 2015 Labor Force Employment Unemployment Unemployment Rate Columbia 32,343 31,165 1,178 3.6 Statewide 9,696,742 9,212,040 484,702 5.0 158,517,517 150,215,269 8,302,248 5.2 Nationwide Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics, September 30, 2015. Five Year Unemployment Rate Unemployment change within Columbia County from August 2011 to August 2015 is shown in the table below. According to the U.S. Department of Labor, unemployment for this five year period fell from 6.7 percent to 3.6 percent, compared to a statewide decrease from 8.2 percent to 5.0 percent. Table 18. Five Year Unemployment Rate, August 2011 - August 2015 August 2011 August 2012 August 2013 August 2014 August 2015 Columbia 6.7 6.8 5.5 4.3 3.6 Statewide 8.2 8.5 7.6 6.1 5.0 Nationwide 9.1 8.2 7.4 6.3 5.2 Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics, September 30, 2015. Employment: Employment Wages Table 19 shows the private sector employment, payrolls, and average weekly wages of employees that are covered by Unemployment Insurance for the years 2002, 2007, and 2012. Table 19. Wages from Employment, 2002, 2007, and 2012 Average Employment Total Payroll ($millions) Average Weekly Wage ($) 2002 2007 2012 2002 2007 2012 Columbia 16,113 16,383 15,943 442 530 576 Statewide 6,848,949 7,118,523 7,181,910 322,110 437,467 459,688 2002 2007 $527.28 $621.89 $694.76 $904.43 $1,181.82 $1,230.89 Source: 2014 New York State Statistical Yearbook, Private Sector Employment, Payrolls, and Average Weekly Wages of Employees Covered by Unemployment Insurance, NYS by County: 2001, 2006, and 2011, Rockefeller Institute, University at 24 2012 Albany, State University of New York. Employment: High School Graduates Table 20 shows the number of public high school graduates in the county for the 2013/2014 academic year. Table 20. High School Graduates Graduates Graduate Rate (%) Total Male Female Total Male Female Columbia 524 283 241 82 79 86 Statewide 161,986 79,514 82,472 76 73 80 Source: Data supplied by The New York State Education Department's Public High School Graduation Rate for the 2013/2014 school year. Table 21. Employment: Regional Top Employers 10 Largest Private Sector Employers in the Capital Region (Albany, Columbia, Greene, Rensselaer, Saratoga, Schenectady, Warren, and Washington counties) Albany Medical Center Hospital Bechtel Marine Propulsion Corp. Ellis Hospital General Electric Co. Glens Falls Hospital Hannaford Supermarkets * Price Chopper* Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute St. Peter's Hospital Walmart* Employers with an * have work sites located in Columbia County. Table 22. Employment: Economic Development Agencies Agency Name Areas Served Center for Economic Growth Albany, Columbia, Fulton, Greene, Montgomery, Rensselaer, Saratoga, Schenectady, Schoharie, Warren, and Washington Counties Choose Columbia (Columbia Economic Development Corporation) Columbia County, NY Hillsdale Economic & Community Development Corporation Town of Hillsdale, NY Hudson Development Corporation City of Hudson, NY New Lebanon Economic Development Committee/Lebanon Valley Heritage Center Town of New Lebanon, NY VERA (Valatie Economic Development Association) Town of Valatie, NY Source: Columbia County Chamber of Commerce 25 Community Concern: Participants at each of the five community focus groups identified the lack of affordable, high quality child care as a concern. Employment: Child Care In their 2014 Community Assessment, Child Care Connections of Columbia and Greene Counties, the local child care resource and referral agency, reports that there are not enough child care slots, quality child care, or child care subsidies to meet the needs of working parents in Columbia County. The following table prepared by Child Care Connections shows the number of children in need of child care and the number of regulated slots available by town. Seven out of 18 communities have no licensed child care available at all. Towns Ancram Austerlitz Canaan Chatham Claverack Clermont Copake Gallatin Germantown Ghent Greenport (includes Hudson) Hillsdale Kinderhook Livingston New Lebanon Stockport Stuyvesant Taghkanic Total Table 23. Demand for Child Care # of Children in need 0-5 Child Care of Child Care Slots 126 0 112 0 156 0 387 47 574 24 204 24 276 0 128 0 189 24 514 36 819 378 169 24 800 151 297 6 228 0 314 0 235 40 85 0 5613 754 School Age Slots 0 0 0 96 2 8 0 0 93 10 408 6 148 2 45 0 4 0 822 % of Need Met 0% 0% 0% 37% 5% 16% 0% 0% 62% 9% 96% 16% 37% 3% 20% 0% 19% 0% 28% Sources: Family of Woodstock, Inc. 2011 Needs Assessment; Columbia Opportunities, Inc., Community Assessment (2013); Greater Hudson Promise Neighborhood Needs Assessment (2012); New York State Office of Children and Family Services. The Columbia County Department of Social Services does help income eligible families pay for child care. Families must have income at or below 200% of the federal poverty guidelines in order to be considered for assistance. In 2013 DSS provided subsidies for an average of 157 families with approximately 460 children, per month. There is a waiting list for families needing financial assistance with child care. Several local child care centers are unwilling to accept direct payment from Columbia County due to the delay in receiving payments. 26 Community Concern: Participants at each of the community focus groups expressed concerns about the lack of employment opportunities that paid a wage high enough to cover the cost of living in Columbia County. It was noted that many individuals have to work more than one job to make ends meet. Employment: Wages Average weekly wages for Columbia County during the 3rd quarter of 2014, are provided in table below. County Table 24. Weekly Wages, Third Quarter (July –September) 2014 Total Average Federal Average State/Local Average Private Average Employees Weekly Employees Federal Employees State/Local Employees Private Wage ($) Government Government Weekly Weekly Wage Weekly Wage ($) ($) Wage ($) Columbia 22,147 693 165 1,028 4,253 938.5 17,729 667 Statewide 8,902,062 1,145 113,596 1,512 1,249,761 1,102.0 7,538,705 1,152 Nationwide 137,724,117 949 2,731,870 1,541 18,428,727 961.0 116,563,520 940 Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages. Employment: Self-Sufficiency Standard - 2010 The Self-Sufficiency Standard for New York State 2010 provides a detailed measure of what it takes to make ends meet in Columbia County, NY without public or private assistance. The Self-Sufficiency Standard is based on the costs of six basic needs for working families: housing, child care, food, health care, transportation, and miscellaneous items as well as the cost of taxes and the impact of tax credits. Table 25. Self-Sufficiency Standard for Columbia County, NY 2010 Monthly Costs Adult Adult + Preschooler Housing 737 869 Child Care 0 843 Food 236 358 Transportation 270 277 Health Care 150 363 Miscellaneous 139 271 Taxes 322 582 Earned Income Credit 0 0 Dependent Care Credit 0 -55 Child Tax Credit 0 -83 Making Work Pay Credit -33 -33 COLUMBIA COUNTY, NY SELF SUFFICIENCY WAGE Hourly $10.35 $19.26 Monthly Annual $1,821 $21,857 $3,391 $40,486 Adult + Infant & Preschooler 869 1580 469 277 378 357 825 0 -100 -167 -33 $25.31 4,455 53,464 Adult + Preschooler & School-Age 869 1337 536 277 388 341 681 0 -100 -167 -33 $23.46 $4,129 $49,545 Source: The Self-Sufficiency Standard for New York State 2010 by Diana M. Pearce, PhD 27 2 Adults + Infant & Preschooler 869 1580 673 532 451 411 909 0 -100 -167 -67 2 Adults+ Preschooler, School-age 869 1337 737 532 461 394 760 0 -100 -167 -67 $14.46 $13.51 per adult per adult $5,091 $61,095 $4,756 $57,069 Community Concern: Participants at all of the community focus groups expressed concerns about the lack of public transportation to support employment, education, and vocational training opportunities. While many had managed to acquire a car; the cost of the vehicle was a real strain on their budget. Those without personal vehicles relied on family, friends, carpooling and limited public transportation services. Employment: Motor Vehicle Registrations Table 26 shows the number of registrations in 2010 by vehicle type for the county. County Table 26. Motor Vehicle Registrations, 2010 All Registered Passenger Commercial Motorcycles Vehicles Vehicles Vehicles Mopeds Columbia 58,618 45,698 6,322 2,675 107 Statewide 10,611,259 8,988,666 795,609 339,455 12,148 Source: 2013 New York State Statistical Yearbook, Motor Vehicle Registrations in Force by Type of Vehicle, NYS by County of Residence: 2010, Rockefeller Institute, University at Albany, State University of New York. Employment: Commuter Travel Patterns According to the Dyson Foundation Making Ends Meet Study, nearly three out of four Columbia County residents (72%), report the cost of gasoline puts a considerable strain on their household budget. This includes 38% of all residents who describe the cost of gasoline as a major stress on their finances and another 34% who report it places a good deal of difficulty on their household budget. According to their website, Bankrate.com is a leading aggregator of financial rate information. They analyzed the cost of gasoline, repairs and insurance in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. Labor and parts data were provided by CarMD.com, while gas spending was calculated with statistics from GasBuddy.com and the Bureau of Transportation Statistics. Insurance costs were compiled from National Association of Insurance Commissioners statistics. According to these estimates, it costs the average New Yorker $365 for repairs, $1196 for insurance, and $713 per year for gasoline, for a total annual cost of $2273. This average monthly cost of $189 would strain the budget of most individuals and families with low incomes and does not include the price of purchasing a car. Table 27 shows the method of transportation workers used to travel to work for Columbia County. Of the 29,253 workers in the county, 85.91 percent, or 25,132 workers used private automobiles to travel to work. Of these, 78.42 percent drove to work alone while 7.49 percent carpooled. 2.53 percent of all workers reported that they used some form of public transportation, while 4.29 percent (or 1,254 workers) used some other means including walking, bicycles, and taxicabs to travel to work. Table 27. Method of Transportation to Work, 2009 - 2013 Method of Transportation to Work (Percent) Workers 16 Drive Carpool Public Bicycle / Taxi / and Up Alone Transportation Walk Other Work at Home Columbia 29,253 78.42 7.49 2.53 3.60 0.68 7.27 Statewide 8,870,713 53.81 6.98 27.04 6.94 1.32 3.91 139,786,640 76.35 9.75 5.01 3.38 1.19 4.33 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. 28 Employment: Travel Time to Work Travel times for workers who do not work at home is shown in Table 28 for Columbia County. The median commute time for the county of 23.84 minutes is shorter than the statewide median commute time of 30.38 minutes. Table 28. Travel Time to Work, 2009 - 2013 Workers 16 Travel Time to Work in minutes (Percent of Workers) and Up Less than 10 10 to 30 30 to 60 More than 60 Average Commute Time (mins) Columbia 29,253 18.53 46.72 27.37 7.38 23.84 Statewide 8,870,713 10.54 41.26 31.99 16.20 30.38 139,786,640 13.48 50.76 27.64 8.12 24.42 Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Employment: Public Transportation Columbia County government offers limited public transportation through a contract with Johnston & Pulcher, Inc. Bus services include a daily shuttle bus that runs between the City of Hudson and the Town of Greenport, a Hudson/Albany Commuter Bus Service, and a Southern County Bus Schedule. The Hudson/ Greenport Shuttle service and the Hudson/Albany Commuter Bus do meet the transportation needs of some commuters. Amtrak provides train service both north and south of the Hudson, NY train station. The train schedule and fair structure enables some full and part time residents to commute to work on the northeast Adirondack train line. 29 Community Concern: Participants at all of the focus groups expressed concerns about the lack of high quality early childhood development and school readiness opportunities for their children. For many the eligibility restrictions, cost, location, hours and the lack of transportation make it difficult to utilize the available resources. Education Early Childhood Development Opportunities Early Childhood development programs in Columbia County are provided by a network of licensed day care centers, nursery schools, universal pre-kindergarten programs offered by local school districts, and COI Head Start. Local libraries, community centers and the Hudson Opera House offer special programming for preschoolers throughout the year. According to Child Care Connections of Columbia and Greene Counties there are thirteen “regulated” or licensed early childhood daycare centers throughout the county; nearly half are COI Head Start centers. COI Head Start serves the largest number of preschool children as compared to other day care and pre-kindergarten programs. Most opportunities are found in the Greater Hudson and Kinderhook areas. There are few organized programs for young children in the rest of the county. Seven out of eighteen towns have no regulated child care services at all. These same communities have few or no preschool or nursery school programs either. The following information regarding Early Childhood Development opportunities was derived from a mapping study conducted by the Berkshire Taconic Community Foundation and the 2015 COI Head Start Community Assessment update. Columbia Opportunities, Inc. provides center-based Head Start services at 5 locations and 7 classrooms in Columbia County with the capacity to serve 146 children. COI offers a full “school day” schedule five days per week and a combination home/center based option three days per week with monthly home visits. Head Start centers are strategically located in communities with the greatest needs. There are no tuition or fees for the Head Start program. The Chatham Central School District has a full day pre-kindergarten class with a 15 student capacity; the school provides transportation for these students who have “deficits in school readiness and/or family barriers that limit access to other preschool programs.” (CCSD website) The district receives no state pre-k funding for this program. COI Head Start established one of their first Head Start classrooms in the Mary E. Dardess Elementary School in 1994. The program serves 17 children in one classroom. No transportation services are provided. There is no charge for these programs. The Columbia Greene Community College Day Care Center offers a program designed to stimulate cognitive development, as well as social/ emotional growth. The center is available to children ranging in age from 3 to 5 years. While the center is available to all college and college related personnel, as well as the community when space is available, first priority is given to the children of CGCC students. The center accommodates the children while their parents are attending classes, pursuing a college related activity or working. The center charges a modest fee for this program. Family Resource Centers of Columbia County offers, parents, guardians, and those caring for young children support, parenting workshops, and supervised playgroups in Hudson, North Chatham, Chatham, and Germantown. Each Family Resource Center has trained childcare staff, snacks for adults 30 and kids, and peer support programs for adults. The centers and playgroups are open to all without charge and meet once or twice per week during the school year according to location. In 2015 the Germantown Central School District opened two Universal Pre-Kindergarten classrooms that are full day, with transportation provided. They have a capacity to serve 38 children. There is no charge for this program. Hawthorne Valley Waldorf School offers tuition based programs that include a Nursery program, a halfday Kindergarten, and extended day child care. They also offer parent/child and family support services and activities. As of 2015, the Hudson City School District has one Targeted Pre-K classroom serving 18 children in conjunction with QUESTAR III and one Universal Pre-K Classroom that enrolls 36 students in two half-day sessions. Three additional students are served in a COI Head Start classroom located in the primary building, for a total of 39 students. COI Head Start has 4 classrooms in the City of Hudson two serving 17 and two serving 18 children. Transportation is not available for the Head Start or Pre-K classrooms. The COI Hudson Family Literacy Program provides child care and Early Childhood enrichment activities to the children of enrolled families. The program serves infants, toddlers, and pre-school age children. As a result of funding limitations, these services are only provided once per week. With private foundation support, summer activities have been offered in the past. The Ichabod Crane School District offers a Targeted Pre-kindergarten program that serves six (6) children with disabilities in a shared QUESTAR III classroom that has a total enrollment of 30. The TPK children are full day and are bused to school while the UPK students attend half-day sessions and are transported by family. TPK students receive services through a contract with Advanced Therapy, P.L.L.C. Oversight and staffing is provided by Questar III. COI Head Start has a center in the Village of Valatie, providing 3 full days of early childhood programming and monthly home visits for 17 children. No transportation is provided for the Head Start children. There is no charge for these programs. New Lebanon Central School District had a Targeted Pre-K program serving 18 children, also in conjunction with QUESTAR III; however it closed in June of 2015 due to the lack of eligible children. These slots were transferred to the Hudson City School District as of September, 2015. The Taconic Hills Central School District offers a full day program and provides transportation to children that will be four by December 1st of the given year. There are three classrooms with 18 students each and four additional students in a Head Start classroom located in the elementary building, for a total of 58 students. COI Head Start has a full day classroom in the elementary school building serving 18 children (four are dually enrolled in the UPK program) and another full day classroom in the Village of Philmont serving 17 children. Transportation is not available to children enrolled in the Philmont Center. There is no charge for these programs. Education: School Enrollment Columbia County residents are largely served by 6 public schools and 5 private schools. Children living in the northern and southern most portions of Columbia County may also be enrolled in school districts located in neighboring counties. The following table shows the total public school enrollment in the county for the 2013/2014 school year. 31 Table 29. Public School Enrollment, 2013/2014 Total Enrollment Male Enrollment Percent Male Female Enrollment Percent Female Columbia 7,300 3,807 52.15 3,493 47.85 County 7,300 3,807 52.15 3,493 47.85 2,652,283 1,359,112 51.24 1,293,171 48.76 Statewide Source: Data supplied by The New York State Education Department's Public School Enrollment Data for the 2013/2014 school year. Education: High School Dropouts Table 30 shows the number of Public High School dropouts in the Columbia County for the 2013/2014 academic years. Table 30. High School Dropout Rates Dropouts Total Male Female Dropout Rate (%) Total Male Female Columbia 53 28 25 8 8 9 Statewide 15,207 8,565 6,642 7 8 6 Source: Data supplied by The New York State Education Department's Public High School Graduation Rate for the 2013/2014 school year. Education: High School Graduates Table 31 shows the number of Public High School Graduates in the county for the 2013/2014 academic years. Table 31. High School Graduates Number of Graduates Total Male Female Graduate Rate (%) Total Male Female Columbia 524 283 241 82% 79% 86% Statewide 161,986 79,514 82,472 76% 73% 80% Source: Data supplied by The New York State Education Department's Public High School Graduation Rate for the 2013/2014 school year. Education: Educational Attainment 32 Table 32 shows the distribution of educational attainment levels in the Columbia County. Educational attainment is calculated for persons over 25, and is an average for the period from 2009 to 2013. Table 32. Percent Attaining Educational Levels, 2009 – 2013 Over Age Education Level for Persons over 25 18 with No High High Some Associates Bachelors No High School School College School Diploma Only Diploma Graduate or Professional Columbia 13.73 12.82 30.20 17.41 11.38 14.60 13.59 Statewide 14.76 14.84 27.15 16.38 8.43 18.86 14.35 Nationwide 14.20 13.98 28.12 21.25 7.81 18.05 10.79 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Education: Veterans - Educational Attainment Table 33. contrasts the distribution of educational attainment levels between veterans and non-veterans in Columbia County. Educational attainment is calculated for persons over 25, and is an average for the period from 2009 to 2013. Table 33. Percent Attaining Educational Levels for Veterans and Non-Veterans, 2009 – 2013 Veterans Non-Veterans % No Diploma % High School Diploma % Some College % Bachelors or Higher % No Diploma % High School Diploma % Some College % Bachelors or Higher Columbia 9.10 34.75 33.05 23.10 13.31 29.60 28.23 28.85 Statewide 8.76 33.32 32.47 25.44 15.31 26.70 24.21 33.78 Nationwide 7.73 29.53 36.42 26.32 14.74 28.01 28.15 29.11 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Education: Adult Literacy The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) produces estimates for adult literacy based on educational attainment, poverty, and other factors in each county. Table 34. Persons Lacking Basic Prose Literacy Skills, 2003 Estimated Population over 16 Percent Lacking Literacy Skills Columbia 50,118 11% Statewide 15,058,111 22% Source: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, State and County Estimates of Low Literacy, 2003. 33 Community Concern: The lack of safe and affordable housing was a community concern identified by participants at each of the community focus groups. These concerns applied to rental units as well as those occupied by home owners. For many participants the cost of home ownership was simply out of reach. Housing According to the Dyson Foundation “Making Ends Meet Study”, 64% of Columbia County residents expressed concern about the strain utility costs place on their finances. Twenty-three percent report paying their heat and electric bills inflicts a great deal of stress on their household budget, and another 41% encounter a good deal of difficulty paying these bills. Also according to this report, a notable portion of Columbia County residents are financially challenged to meet their monthly rent or mortgage payment. Forty-three percent of residents say this expense poses a great deal or a good amount of strain on their family budget. Paying for property taxes is another major expense for more than seven in ten Columbia County homeowners. Seventy-one percent of homeowners in the county feel pressure to meet their property tax obligations. This includes 34% who say these expenses strain their monthly budgets a great deal. Housing Units The number of housing units within Columbia County in July of each year from 2004-2014 is shown in Table 35. According to the U.S. Census, there were a total of 32,838 housing units in the county in 2014, an increase of 1,438 or 4.58% since 2004 compared to a 3.81% increase statewide. July 2004 Columbia Statewide Nationwide 31,400 July 2005 31,755 July 2006 32,081 Table 35. 2004 - 2014 Housing Units July July July July 2007 2008 2009 2010 32,406 32,612 32,715 32,783 July 2011 32,764 July 2012 32,743 July 2013 July 2014 32,766 32,838 7,870,881 7,916,683 7,970,267 8,015,248 8,059,465 8,101,349 8,113,177 8,133,629 8,153,981 8,170,903 8,191,040 128,758,958 130,872,915 132,894,778 134,764,927 136,159,359 137,014,358 131,797,695 132,172,145 132,584,625 133,190,257 133,957,180 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Population Division, Housing Unit Estimates for Counties: April 1, 2004 to July 1, 2014, Release Date May, 2015. Housing Age Total housing units, median year built and median age in 2013 for Columbia County are shown in table below. The majority of Columbia County housing units were constructed before 1980, with nearly half build before 1960. Before 1970, aluminum wiring and lead paint were used in homes, posing serious safety and health risks to residents. In addition, the discovery of asbestos in these older homes also puts residents in danger. Older housing stock is more likely to be substandard and less affordable, due to high energy and home repair costs. Not only are they typically expensive to maintain, but homes built prior to 1970 are also more likely to pose health and safety risks for residents due to deteriorating, substandard conditions. 34 Table 36. Median Housing Unit Age, 2009 - 2013 by Census Tract Census Tract Housing Units Median Housing Units Built Percent Units Built Where Year Year Newer than Built 1980 Built 1960 Built pre Newer Built 1980 Built 1960 Built pre Built is built 2000 to 1999 to 1979 1960 than 2000 to 1999 to 1979 1960 Known Ancram 1,014 1971 134 241 267 372 13.21 23.77 26.33 36.69 Austerlitz 1,003 1974 130 240 270 363 12.96 23.93 26.92 36.19 Canaan 1,109 1957 115 243 177 574 10.37 21.91 15.96 51.76 Chatham 2,365 1951 205 498 406 1,256 8.67 21.06 17.17 53.11 Claverack 3,070 1954 212 465 756 1,637 6.91 15.15 24.63 53.32 Clermont 843 1976 196 187 155 305 23.25 22.18 18.39 36.18 Copake 2,368 1967 189 495 796 888 7.98 20.90 33.61 37.50 Gallatin 1,044 1968 122 206 305 411 11.69 19.73 29.21 39.37 Germantown 1,068 1953 86 224 147 611 8.05 20.97 13.76 57.21 Ghent 2,343 1958 162 588 384 1,209 6.91 25.10 16.39 51.60 Greenport 2,056 1972 49 716 538 753 2.38 34.82 26.17 36.62 Hillsdale 1,218 1958 95 299 181 643 7.80 24.55 14.86 52.79 Hudson-N 1,796 1939 144 144 247 1,261 8.02 8.02 13.75 70.21 Hudson-S 1,746 1939 9 38 300 1,399 0.52 2.18 17.18 80.13 Kinderhook - N 1,158 1964 77 232 317 532 6.65 20.03 27.37 45.94 Kinderhook - S 2,549 1972 264 523 954 808 10.36 20.52 37.43 31.70 Livingston 1,568 1977 317 425 277 549 20.22 27.10 17.67 35.01 New Lebanon 1,295 1957 104 191 324 676 8.03 14.75 25.02 52.20 Stockport 1,324 1951 22 218 347 737 1.66 16.47 26.21 55.66 960 1970 74 182 314 390 7.71 18.96 32.71 40.63 Taghkanic 811 1973 56 255 202 298 6.91 31.44 24.91 36.74 Columbia 32,708 1962 2,762 6,610 7,664 15,672 8.44 20.21 23.43 47.91 Statewide 8,113,270 1955 553,505 1,098,389 1,823,921 4,637,455 6.82 13.54 22.48 57.16 132,057,808 1976 20,157,260 36,735,368 35,676,692 39,488,480 15.26 27.82 27.02 29.90 Stuyvesant Nationwide Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Fair Market Rent Fair market monthly rent for 0-4 bedrooms for Columbia County is shown in Table 37. The average rent for 2-bedroom units in the county was $923 in the 2015 fiscal year, compared to a statewide average of $940. Table 37. Fair Market Rents, 2015 Fair Market Rent (Monthly $) for 0 Bedrooms 1 Bedroom 2 Bedrooms 3 Bedrooms Four Bedrooms Columbia 738 743 923 1,196 1,535 Statewide 684 761 940 1,227 1,368 Source: National Low Income Housing Coalition, Out of Reach 2014 Report. This report is based on Housing and Urban Development's (HUD) Annal Fair Market Rent Documentation System. Report published 2015. 35 Affordability The National Low Income Housing Coalition reports each year on the amount of money a household must earn in order to afford a rental unit based on Fair Market Rents in the area and an accepted limit of 30% of income for housing costs. Affordable housing units are not necessarily located where lowincome families need or want to live. Table 38. Hourly Wage Needed to Afford a Fair Market Rent, 2014 Average Hourly Wage ($) needed for Renter Hourly 0 Bedrooms 1 Bedroom 2 Bedrooms 3 Bedrooms Wage ($)* 4 Bedrooms Columbia 10.67 13.79 13.87 17.23 22.33 28.65 Statewide 21.81 19.23 20.71 24.87 32.02 35.89 Source: National Low Income Housing Coalition, Out of Reach 2014 Report. Vacancy Rates The U.S. Census Bureau provides vacancy data based on American Community Survey 5-year estimates (2009 - 2013). Vacancy rates for Columbia County are reported in Table 39. Vacant non-rental housing totals 767 units and includes those for sale only and sold but not occupied. For the county, there is a non-rental housing vacancy rate of 2.34 %, in comparison to the New York rate of 1.31 % and the national rate of 1.73 %. Vacant rental housing totals 558 units and includes those for rent and rented but not occupied. For the county, that is a rental housing vacancy rate of 1.71%, in comparison to the New York rate of 2.44% and the national rate of 2.9 %. Vacant other housing totals 6,103 units and includes those used for seasonal, recreational, or occasional use, as well as units used for migrant workers. For the county, there is an “other” housing vacancy rate of 18.66 %, in comparison to the New York rate of 7.08 % and the national rate of 7.82 %. County Table 39. Vacancies, 2009 – 2013 Total Housing Vacant Non- Vacant NonVacant Vacant Vacant Other Vacant Other Units Rental Rental Rate Rental Rental Rate Rate Columbia 32,708 767 2.34 558 1.71 6,103 18.66 Statewide 8,113,270 106,629 1.31 197,685 2.44 574,213 7.08 132,057,808 2,290,610 1.73 3,830,007 2.90 10,326,971 7.82 Nationwide Source: United States Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. 36 Homeowners The U.S. Census Bureau estimated there were 17,504 owner occupied homes in Columbia County in 2000, and 18,301 owner occupied homes in the county for the 5 year estimated period from 2009 2013. Table 40. Owner Occupied Homes, 2000 – 2013 Homes, 2000 County Homes, 2013 Columbia 17,504 18,301 Statewide 3,739,166 3,923,505 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2000 Census of Population and Housing, Summary File 1, 2000; U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Overcrowded Housing Occupied housing units, overcrowded housing units, and percent overcrowded for 2000 and 2013 are provided for Columbia County in Table 41. The average for the county is 1.33%. County Table 41. Overcrowded Housing Units Occupied Overcrowded Percent Occupied Overcrowded Housing Units, Housing Units, Overcrowded, Housing Units, Housing Units, 2000 2000 2000 2009/2013 2009/2013 Percent Overcrowded, 2009/2013 Columbia 24,796 24 0.10 23,835 318 1.33 Statewide 7,056,860 92,454 1.31 5,098,017 349,049 6.85 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2000 Census of Population and Housing, Summary File 3, 2000.;U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Unsafe, Unsanitary Homes The number and percentage of county occupied housing units without plumbing are shown in Table 42. U.S. Census data shows 74 housing units in the county were without plumbing in 2000 and ACS five year estimates show 61 housing units in the county were without plumbing in 2013. County Table 42. Housing Units without Plumbing, 2000 and 2009 - 2013 Occupied Housing Units Percent Occupied Housing Units Housing Units, without without Housing Units, without 2000 Plumbing, 2000 Plumbing, 2000 2009-2013 Plumbing, 2009-2013 Percent without Plumbing, 2009-2013 Columbia 24,796 74 0.24 25,280 61 0.24 Statewide 7,056,860 58,418 0.76 7,234,743 39,679 0.55 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2000 Census of Population and Housing, Summary File 3, 2000.;U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. 37 Community Concern: Homelessness was identified as a concern at one or more of the community focus groups. The lack of emergency shelters for individuals and families as well as lack of permanent supportive housing options were cited as areas needing improvement. Homelessness The Columbia Greene Housing Coalition is the Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Continuum of Care (CoC) Planning Group for Columbia and Greene Counties. Each year they conduct a Point In Time count to identify the number of individuals and families who are homeless. When completing this count, the CoC must use HUD’s definition of “literally” homeless that does not include people who are “doubled up” or go from place to another each night to stay off the streets. The following chart shows the results of the 2015 Point In Time Count. Table 43. Columbia Greene Continuum of Care Point In Time Count-2015 Sheltered Total Households and Persons Emergency Unsheltered Total Transitional Total Number of Households 56 2 2 60 Total Number of Persons 91 4 2 97 Number of Children (under age 18) 32 2 0 34 9 0 0 9 50 2 2 54 Number of Persons (18 to 24) Number of Persons (over age 24) In addition to estimating the number of individuals and families experiencing homelessness, the CoC completes an annual Housing Inventory Count. By comparing the numbers of people who are homeless with the available inventory of housing, the CoC is able to estimate the unmet needs for homeless housing as seen in the table below. Currently the only emergency shelter beds available are for victims of domestic violence. In both Columbia and Greene Counties area motels are used to provide emergency shelter to all others. This practice is considered both expensive and unresponsive to the needs of those being housed, especially families with children. Table 44. Unmet Need for Homeless Housing - 2015 Households with Adult Only Child Only Children Households Households Beds Emergency Shelter Transitional Housing Permanent Supportive Housing Units Beds Beds All Households Total Year Round Beds Units Overflow Beds 21 6 8 0 0 29 15 17 4 14 8 4 39 0 24 8 50 0 0 74 0 38 Income Income Levels Three common measures of income are Median Household Income, Per Capita Income, and Average Income based on U.S. Census Bureau estimates. All three measures are shown for Columbia County in Table 45. The average income for earners in this county is $44,339.26. The Census Bureau defines an earner as someone age 15 and older that receives any form of income, whether it is wages, salaries, benefits, or some other type of income. The average Columbia County median income per household is $57,336. Table 45. Income Levels by County, 2009 - 2013 Median Household Income, 2013 Per Capita Income, 2013 Average Income Per Earner, 2013 Columbia 57,336 33,613 44,339 Statewide 58,003 32,382 46,450 Nationwide 53,046 28,155 40,683 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Table 45a shows all three income measures for each town and city in Columbia County. Communities with the lowest median incomes include: the City of Hudson and the towns of Greenport, Claverack, Livingston, and New Lebanon. Communities with lower than average per capita income include: the City of Hudson and the towns of Stockport, Livingston, Taghkanic, Greenport, Gallatin, Stuyvesant, and Clermont. Communities with lower than average income per earner include: the City of Hudson and the towns of Stockport, Livingston, Greenport, Gallatin, Stuyvesant, Ancram, Taghkanic, New Lebanon, and Germantown. 39 Census Tract Table 45a. Income Levels by Municipality, 2009 - 2013 Median Household Income, Per Capita Income, 2013 2013 Average Income Per Earner, 2013 Ancram 62,045 32,716 39,302 Austerlitz 72,500 43,847 58,862 Canaan 74,167 34,631 47,399 Chatham 78,885 49,224 63,929 Claverack 51,329 35,500 46,083 Clermont 63,276 31,966 47,641 Copake 66,062 40,494 52,044 Gallatin 65,230 29,502 37,227 Germantown 60,917 32,412 43,769 Ghent 60,250 36,267 46,716 Greenport 44,401 28,820 36,549 Hillsdale 83,750 50,098 63,595 Hudson-N 31,184 18,942 27,506 Hudson-S 41,152 26,387 38,913 Kinderhook - N 72,500 38,116 48,881 Kinderhook - S 79,655 33,632 46,282 Livingston 52,429 26,505 33,775 New Lebanon 53,929 32,094 42,079 Stockport 54,406 26,491 32,828 Stuyvesant 64,358 29,820 38,091 Taghkanic 57,895 28,814 39,400 Columbia 57,336 33,613 44,339 Statewide 58,003 32,382 46,450 Nationwide 53,046 28,155 40,683 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Income: Personal Income Table 46 shows personal income by the major categories of earnings (wages, salaries, self employment), property income (rent &interest), and transfer payments (government payments including Social Security) in millions of dollars for the county in 2011. Persons in Columbia County received 21.69 percent of their income from transfer payments, compared to the state wide average of 18.37 percent. 40 Total Income Columbia Statewide Table 46. 2011 Personal Income by Type Income by Category (in $millions) 2,627.56 Earnings 1,487.05 Property Income 570.71 Transfer Payments Percent Income by Category Earnings Property Income Transfer Payments 569.81 56.59 21.72 21.69 995,184.70 651,168.20 161,173.60 182,842.90 65.43 16.20 18.37 Source: 2013 New York State Statistical Yearbook, Personal Income by Type and County of Residence, NYS: 2011, Rockefeller Institute, University at Albany, State University of New York. Income: Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) In NYS, the Family Assistance (FA) program provides cash assistance to eligible families that include a minor child living with a parent or a caretaker relative. FA operates under federal Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) guidelines. Eligible adults are limited to receiving benefits for a total of 60 months in their lifetime, including months of TANF-funded assistance granted in other states. Once this limit is reached, that adult and all members of his or her FA household are ineligible to receive any more FA benefits. The months need not be consecutive, but rather each individual month in which TANFfunded benefits are received is included in the lifetime count. Parents and other adult relatives receiving FA, and who are determined to be able to work must comply with federal work requirements to receive FA benefits. As a further condition of FA eligibility, each person who applies for or is receiving FA, is required to cooperate with state and local department of social services efforts to locate any absent parent and obtain support payments and other payments or property. Non-cooperation without good cause could result in lower FA benefits. The number of persons receiving Family Assistance in January 2015, within Columbia County is shown in Table 47. The NYS Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance reported that 1,035 persons were receiving TANF benefits at a cost of $309,944, or $299.46 per recipient. Fifty three and one half (53.5) percent of the recipients were children. These cash assistance benefits leave family income well below 50% of the federal poverty level. Table 47. Persons Receiving TANF, January 2015 Persons Receiving TANF, January 2015 Total Children Adults Columbia 1,035 554 481 Statewide 569,551 298,121 271,430 Cases, January 2015 546 Expenditures, January 2015 Total ($) Per Case ($) Per Person ($) 309,944 567.66 299.46 297,128 185,310,788 623.67 325.36 Source: NYS Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance, January 2015. Data issued April 1, 2015. Income: Safety Net Assistance Safety Net Assistance (SNA) is provided to individuals and families not eligible for Family Assistance. SNA is for: single adults, childless couples, children living apart from any adult relative, persons who have exceeded the 60-month limit on family assistance, aliens who are eligible for temporary assistance, but who are not eligible for federal reimbursement. Recipients of SNA, who are determined to be able to work must also comply with work requirements to receive benefits. Generally, an individual can receive cash SNA for a maximum of two years in a lifetime. After that, if they are still eligible for SNA, it is provided in non-cash form, such as a two party check or a voucher. 41 The number of persons receiving Safety Net Assistance in January 2015, within Columbia County is shown in Table 48. The NYS Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance reported that 430 persons were receiving Safety Net Assistance benefits at a cost of $160,657 or $373.62 per recipient, in the county during January 2015. Twenty six and one half (26.5) percent of the recipients were children. Safety Net Assistance benefits also leave household income well below 50% of the federal poverty level. Table 48. Safety Net Cases, January 2015 Safety Net Cases, December 2015 Cases, Expenditures, December 2015 December Total Children Adults Total Per Case Per Person 2015 Columbia 430 114 316 294 160,657 546.45 373.62 County 430 114 316 294 160,657 546.45 373.62 188,563 318,209 112,052 206,157 116,521,268 617.94 366.18 Statewide Source: NYS Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance, January 2015. Data issued April 1, 2015. Income: Supplemental Security Income The Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program pays benefits to disabled adults and children who have limited income and resources. SSI benefits also are payable to people 65 and older without disabilities who meet the financial limits. The number of Supplemental Security Income recipients and expenditures by the state and federal governments in the county are shown in Table 49. It is widely known that the application process for SSI and Social Security Disability Income (SSDI) is complicated and difficult to navigate. According to the SSI/SSDI Outreach Access, and Recovery website, only about 29% of individuals applying for these benefits are approved on initial application and appeals take an average of 1 year to complete. Table 49. Supplemental Security Income, January 2015 December December Expenditures ($) Recipients Total Federal State Expenditure per Recipient Columbia 1,739 1,022,047 831,006 191,041 587.72 Statewide 719,686 416,670,229 363,556,726 53,113,503 578.96 Source: New York Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance, January 2015. Data issued April 1, 2015. Income: Child Support Collections The child support program provides custodial parents with assistance in obtaining financial support and medical insurance coverage for their children by locating parents, establishing paternity, establishing support orders, and collecting and distributing child support payments. Child support collections for Columbia County are shown in Table 50. During January 2015, child support collections totaled $472,121.65. 42 Table 50. Child Support Collections, January 2015 Child Support Collections, February 2013 Total Current Assistance Former Assistance Never Assisted Columbia 472,121.65 17,347.44 245,449.38 209,324.83 Statewide 145,100,955.90 5,274,762.97 70,141,320.28 69,684,872.61 Source: New York Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance, January 2015. Data issued April 1, 2015. 43 Community Concern: Participants at each of the focus groups expressed concerns about their limited access to grocery stores and other sources of affordable and nutritious food. Nutrition Food Insecurity According to Feeding America, food insecurity refers to the United State Department of Agriculture’s measure of lack of access, at times, to enough food for an active, healthy life for all household members and limited or uncertain availability of nutritionally adequate foods. Food insecure households are not necessarily food insecure all the time. Food insecurity may reflect a household’s need to make trade-offs between important basic needs, such as housing or medical bills, and purchasing nutritionally adequate foods. Table 51. Food Insecurity Poverty Rate of Food Insecure People Food Insecure Food Insecure: Rate Number of people Below 200% Above 200% Columbia - all ages 11% 6860 63% 37% Children – 0-17 11% 2400 65% 35% Source: Feeding America - Map the Meal Gap The numbers of children and families in need are expected to increase, as SNAP-eligible families continue to cope with benefit cuts which took effect on November 1, 2013. According to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, this cut is “the equivalent of taking away 21 meals per month for a family of four, or 16 meals for a family of three, based on calculations using the $1.70 to $2 per meal provided for in the Thrifty Food Plan.” Nutrition: Free and Reduced Lunch Program The National School Lunch Program is a federally assisted meal program operating in public schools. It provides nutritionally balanced, low-cost or free lunches to children each school day. Table 52 shows the number of students eligible for the Free and Reduced Lunch Program during January, 2015. The figures below include all School Food Authority agencies. 50.39% of the students in the county were eligible for free or reduced lunches. Table 52. Students Participating in the Free and Reduced Lunch Program, 2015 School District Total Student # Eligible Students % Eligible Students Enrollment Chatham 1123 416 37.04 Germantown 564 204 36.17 Hudson 1760 1155 65.63 Ichabod Crane 1859 585 31.47 New Lebanon 403 142 35.24 Taconic Hills 1377 726 52.72 Columbia County 7086 3228 45.55 Source: New York State Education Department, Child Nutrition Management System, January, 2015. 44 Starting with the 2015/16 school year, the Hudson City School District began participation in the Community Eligibility Provision of the federally funded free/reduced lunch program. The Community Eligibility Provision allows local schools in high-poverty areas to offer school breakfast and lunch through the National School Lunch and Breakfast Programs to all students at no cost. The goal of the program is to help reduce hunger and streamline school meal programs. The Hudson City School District also offers the Summer Food Service Program (SFSP). This program helps to ensures that low-income children in the Hudson City School District continue to receive nutritious meals when school is not in session. This is the only Summer Food Service Program offered in Columbia County, NY. Nutrition: Hunger Prevention and Nutrition Assistance Program (HPNAP) The Hunger Prevention and Nutrition Assistance Program (HPNAP) is a food and nutrition program of the New York State Department of Health. HPNAP, in partnership with food banks and emergency food organizations, is dedicated to improving the health and nutrition status of people in need of food assistance in New York State. HPNAP grants are administered by the Regional Food Bank of Northeaster New York. The number of meals provided through Hunger Prevention and Nutrition Assistance Program (HPNAP) Supported Soup Kitchens, Food Pantries and Shelters is shown in Table 53. The statewide average number of meals served per day was 212 meals per site. Not all area food pantries receiving HPNAP funding. Table 53. Soup Kitchens, Food Pantries and Shelters, July 2010-June 2011 HPNAP Sites Sites per 10,000 Average Meals Served per Site per Day Meals per Person per Year Columbia 7 1.1 75 4 Statewide 2,522 1.3 212 6 Source: New York Department of Health, Services Provided by HPNAP Supported Groups Nutrition: Persons Served by Soup Kitchens, Food Pantries and Shelters The number of persons being served at Hunger Prevention and Nutrition Assistance Program (HPNAP) Supported Soup Kitchens, Food Pantries and Shelters is shown in Table 54. On average, the statewide number of people served per day was 82,507. Table 54. Persons Served through the Hunger Prevention and Nutrition Assistance Program (HPNAP), July 2010-June 2011 Total Persons Presenting Themselves Adjusted to an Average Daily Basis (Duplicated) All Columbia Statewide 44,482 Children 14,380 Adults (18-65) Elderly (>65) All Children Adults (18-65) Elderly (>65) 22,847 7,255 122 39 63 20 30,115,199 8,581,937 17,540,369 3,992,893 82,507 23,512 48,056 10,939 Source: New York Department of Health, Services Provided by HPNAP Supported Groups. Note: The number of persons served is based on counting individuals as they enter a facility. The totals columns count individuals more than once. 45 Nutrition: Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) issues monthly electronic benefits that can be used like cash to purchase food at authorized retail food stores. Eligibility and benefit levels are based on household size, income and other factors. The number of households and persons receiving SNAP benefits and the total SNAP dollars issued are shown for Columbia County in Table 55. According to the New York Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance, Columbia County had the average benefit per household during January of 2015 was $220.77 per household. Table 55. Households and Persons Receiving SNAP Benefits, January 2015 Households Receiving Persons Receiving Benefits Benefits Issued ($) Benefits Total Temporary Assistance Non Temporary Assistance 2,424 Columbia 3,801 1,377 Statewide 1,673,567 679,072 Temporary Assistance Total 6,613 Non Temporary Assistance 1,905 994,495 3,055,942 1,030,923 4,708 Total 839,134 Temporary Assistance Non Temporary Assistance 284,670 Benefits Per Household 554,464 220.77 2,025,019 424,847,862 156,319,408 268,528,454 253.86 Source: New York Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance, January 2015. Data issued April 1, 2015. Nutrition: Households Receiving SNAP by Poverty Status (ACS) Table 56 shows that 2,190 households (or 8.66 percent) received SNAP payments during 2013. During this same period there were 1,366 (or 5.40 percent) households with income levels below the poverty level that were not receiving SNAP payments. Columbia County had 8.66 percent of households receiving SNAP payments, which is less than the statewide average of 14.52 percent. Table 56. Households Receiving SNAP by Poverty Status, 2009 - 2013 Households Receiving SNAP Households Not Receiving SNAP Total Percent Income Below Poverty Income Above Poverty Total Percent Income Below Poverty Income Above Poverty Columbia 2,190 8.66 987 1,203 23,090 91.34 1,366 21,724 Statewide 1,050,669 14.52 541,633 509,036 6,184,074 85.48 506,664 5,677,410 87.60 8,917,586 92,353,292 Nationwide 14,339,330 12.40 7,498,398 6,840,932 101,270,878 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. SNAP numbers are for the last 12 months of the five-year average (2013). 46 Health Care The Dyson Foundation Making Ends Meet Study reports that 37% of Columbia County residents say the cost of health insurance places a burden on their family budgets. This includes 15% of residents who say these expenses cause a great deal of strain and 22% who say they cause a good amount. More than one in four residents in the county, 28%, say they experience at least a good deal of financial strain due to health care costs. This study was released in 2013, before the Affordable Care Act was implemented. Many individuals and families with low to moderate incomes have found more affordable health insurance through the NYS of Health Marketplace. Health Care: Medicare and Medicaid Providers The total number of institutional Medicare and Medicaid providers, including hospitals, nursing facilities, federally qualified health centers, rural health clinics and community mental health centers for Columbia County is shown in Table 57. According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, there were 9 active Medicare and Medicaid institutional service providers in the county in the second quarter of 2014. Table 57. Institutional Medicare and Medicaid Providers, 2014 Total Hospitals Nursing Federally Rural Health Community Institutional Facilities Qualified Clinics Mental Health Providers Health Centers Centers Columbia 9 1 4 1 0 0 Statewide 2,375 249 629 247 10 4 Source: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Provider of Services File, Second Quarter, 2014. Health Care: Federally Qualified Health Center Hudson River HealthCare (HRHCare), a not-for-profit, federally qualified health care system that offers a range of medical services at its facilities throughout New York State, opened an office in Hudson, NY in April, 2014. This is the only federally qualified health center located in Columbia County, NY. Health Care: Persons Receiving Medicare The total number of persons receiving Medicare is shown, broken down by number over 65 and number of disabled persons receiving Medicare for Columbia County in Table 58. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services reported that a total of 14,526 persons were receiving Medicare benefits in the county in 2012. A large number of individuals in our society are aware that persons over 65 years of age receive Medicare; however, many of them are unaware that disabled persons also receive Medicare benefits. A total of 2,760 disabled persons in the county received Medicare benefits in 2012. Table 58. Medicare Enrollment, 2012 Persons Over 65 Receiving Disabled Persons Receiving Medicare Medicare Total Persons Receiving Medicare Columbia 11,766 2,760 14,526 Statewide 2,768,866 626,516 3,395,382 Source: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Medicare County Enrollment Report, 2012. 47 Health Care: Persons Receiving Medicaid The average number of persons receiving Medicaid during 2014 is shown in Table 59 for Columbia County. The average rate of Medicaid recipients during 2014 was 157.49 per 1000 persons. The rate in Columbia County is lower than the overall state rate. Table 59. Monthly Average Number of Persons Receiving Medicaid, 2014 Monthly Average Number of Persons Receiving Medicaid, 4th Quarter Total Children Adults Elderly Disabled Family Health Per 1000 Other Columbia 3,609.33 3,505.75 574.50 1,871.58 392.75 88.5 9,870.67 157.49 Statewide 1,816,194.58 1,679,607.67 292,636.00 634,979.42 220,514.50 260,806.5 4,842,490.00 248.50 Source: New York Department of Health, Information for a Healthy New York, Medicaid Quarterly Reports of Beneficiaries and Expenditures by Category of Eligibility and Social Service District. Data is for calendar year 2014, released March 13, 2015. One of the major coverage provisions of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is the expansion of Medicaid eligibility to nearly all low-income individuals with incomes at or below 138% of the poverty level ($27,724 annual income for a family of 3 in 2015). New York State is one of 31 states that opted to expand their Medicaid Eligibility. Many hard working low income wage earners have gained access to affordable health care through this expansion. Health Care: Child Health Plus NYS offers Child Health Plus as a health insurance plan for children. Several options are available depending on family income. For some the program is free, for others a monthly premium may apply. Table 60 shows the total enrollment for the New York Child Health Plus program for September 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, and 2014. According to the New York Department of Health, there were 1,171 persons enrolled in the Child Health Plus Program during September 2014. Between September 2010 and September 2014, enrollment decreased in the county by 489 persons, or 29.5%. Table 60. Child Health Plus Total Enrollment Sept 2010 Sept 2011 Sept 2012 Sept 2013 Sept 2014 Columbia 1,660 1,703 1,509 1,309 1,171 Statewide 395,312 411,892 345,741 309,335 292,802 Source: New York Department of Health, Information for a Healthy New York, Child Health Plus Enrollment by Insurer Health Care: Uninsured Population The uninsured population is calculated by estimating the number of persons eligible for insurance (generally those under 65) minus the estimated number of insured persons. In 2013, the percentage of persons uninsured was 11 in Columbia County. The number of uninsured individuals is expected to drop substantially as a result of the Affordable Care Act. 48 Table 61. Uninsured Persons, 2013 Insurance Population Number Insured Number Uninsured (2013 Estimate) Columbia Nationwide Percent Uninsured 48,506 43,188 5,318 11% 264,843,216 220,365,245 44,477,968 17% Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Health Insurance Estimates, 2013 (January 2015 release). Health Care: Prenatal Care In 2011, a total of 3 women did not receive any prenatal care in the county. This figure indicates that less than one percent of pregnant women did not receive prenatal care during pregnancy. Table 62. Trimester When Prenatal Care Began, 2011 First Trimester Second Trimester Third Trimester No Prenatal Care Unknown Not Reported Total Births % No Prenatal or Third Trimester Care Columbia 358 114 19 3 49 1 544 4.45 Statewide 167,091 49,230 11,123 1,608 6,783 3,901 239,736 5.56 Source: 2014 New York State Statistical Yearbook, Resident Live Births by Month Prenatal Care Began, NYS by County: 2011, Rockefeller Institute, University at Albany, State University of New York. Health Care: Teen Births In 2013, births to teens in the area totaled 35, or 6.49 percent of all live births, in the county. Table 63. Births to Females Age 10 to 19, 2013 Age Under 15 Age 15 to 17 Age 18 to 19 Total Live Births Births to Teens Columbia 0 5 30 539 35 Statewide 125 2,972 8,119 235,274 11,216 Source: New York Department of Health, Vital Statistics of New York State 2013. Health Care: Deaths According to the information in Table 64, death rates in Columbia County and NYS have remained consistent in the last 6 years. In 2011, the death rate was 10.6 deaths per 1,000 persons in Columbia County. Table 64. Deaths and Death Rates 2007 2008 2009 2006 Total Columbia 649 Statewide 147,615 Rate /1000 10.3 Total 632 7.6 146,266 Rate /1000 10.1 Total Rate /1000 629 7.6 147,469 10.1 Total 607 7.6 144,874 2010 Rate /1000 9.8 Total 690 7.4 144,913 2011 Rate /1000 10.9 Total 667 10.6 7.5 147,105 7.6 Source: 2014 New York State Statistical Yearbook, Resident Deaths and Rates, NYS by County: 2008-2011, Rockefeller Institute, University at Albany, State University of New York. 49 Rate /1000 Health Care: Physicians Table 65 shows the number of Physicians, Physicians with 3-year licenses, Physician assistants and Specialist assistants for the county. There are 2.6 physicians per 1000 persons in the county, lower than the statewide average of 4.34 physicians per 1000 persons. Table 65. Physicians and Assistants, 2014 Physicians, MD Physicians, 3yr Physician Assistants Specialist Assistants Physicians/Assistants per 1,000 Persons Columbia 132 0 30 0 2.58 Statewide 73,386 37 11,065 84 4.34 Source: New York Office of the Professions, New York State Licensed Professions>; United States Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Community Concern: The lack of dentists that accept Medicaid was a concern raised at each of the community focus groups. In addition, parents with young children noted that there were no Pediatric Dentists in Columbia County. Health Care: Dentists Table 66 shows the number of Dentists, Dental Hygienists and Certified Dental Assistants for Columbia County. The statewide average is 1.36 dental professionals per 1000 persons. Dentists Table 66. Dental Professionals, 2014 Dental Specialists Dental Hygienists Dental Professionals per 1,000 Persons Columbia 27 30 5 0.99 Statewide 15,304 9,862 1,255 1.36 Source: New York Office of the Professions, New York State Licensed Professions>; United States Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Health Care: Nurses Table 67 shows the number of nurses, nurse practitioners, and midwives for Columbia County. The statewide average is 16.0 nursing professionals per 1000 persons. Nurse, RN Table 67. Nurses, 2014 Nurse, LPN Nurse Practitioners Midwives Nurses per 1,000 Persons Columbia 897 324 50 1 20.30 Statewide 227,017 66,365 17,353 976 16.00 Source: New York Office of the Professions, New York State Licensed Professions>; United States Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. 50 Community Concern: The lack of mental health services for young children was a concern raised at each of the community focus groups. Health Care: Mental Health Professionals Table 68 shows the number of mental health professionals for Columbia County. The statewide average is 0.42 mental health professionals per 1000 persons. Columbia County is well below that rate. Table 68. Mental Health Professionals, 2014 Psychoanalysts Mental Health Creative Arts Marriage and Mental Health Counselors Therapists Family Therapists Professionals per 1,000 Persons Columbia 3 9 3 1 0.26 Statewide 663 5,225 1,376 875 0.42 Source: New York Office of the Professions, New York State Licensed Professions; United States Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Health Care: Transportation States are required by federal regulations to assure necessary transportation to Medicaid beneficiaries to and from medical services. Since 2012, Medicaid transportation in Columbia County has been handled by Medical Answering Services, Inc. Transportation can be arranged by telephone, fax, or through their website. The Columbia County Healthcare Consortium also provides Medicaid transportation as well as non-emergency medical transportation to Columbia County residents who lack any other means of getting to and from a medical appointment. Both programs have improved access to medical services for area residents. Health Care: Therapists Table 69 shows the number of physical, occupational and massage therapists for Columbia County. The statewide average is 2.60 physical, occupational and massage therapists per 1000 persons. Table 69. Therapists, 2014 Physical Physical Therapist Occupational Occupational Massage Therapists/ Therapists Assistants Therapists Therapist Therapists Assistants per 1,000 Assistants Persons Columbia 40 16 24 13 78 2.73 Statewide 17,288 4,991 10,579 3,605 14,266 2.60 Source: New York Office of the Professions, New York State Licensed Professions>; United States Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Health Care: Special Health Professionals Table 70 shows the number of Optometrists, Audiologists, Speech Pathologists, Respiratory Therapists, and Respiratory Technicians for the county. The statewide average is 1.34 special health professionals per 1000 persons. County residents must frequently travel out of the county to receive care by these special Health Professionals. 51 Table 70. Special Health Professionals, 2014 Audiologists Speech Respiratory Respiratory Pathologists Therapists Technicians Optometrists Special Health Professionals per 1,000 Persons Columbia 3 3 28 19 4 0.91 Statewide 2,698 1,258 15,756 5,501 983 1.34 Source: New York Office of the Professions, New York State Licensed Professions>; United States Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 Data Release, December 2014. The 2013 American Community Survey 5-year data is a 5-year average of data collected from 2009 through 2013. Community Concern: At each of the community focus groups, participants expressed concerns about crime and safety in their communities. Some felt there was an increase in crime associated with drug abuse. Crime Violent Crime Occurrences of violent crime within Columbia County are shown in Table 71. According to the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services reporting system, a total of 51 assaults, 17 robberies and 8 rapes took place within the county in 2013. As reports for subsequent years become available, there will be an increase in the number of recorded homicides. Table 71. Homicide, Negligent Manslaughter, Assault, Robbery, Rape, 2013 Total Violent Homicide Assault Robbery Crime Rape Columbia 76 0 51 17 8 Statewide 76,451 644 46,029 27,171 2,607 Source: New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, Index Crimes Reported: 2009 - 2013. Property Crime Occurrences of property crime within Columbia County are shown in Table 72. According to the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services reporting system, a total of 207 burglaries, 828 incidents of larceny, and 14 automotive thefts were recorded in 2013 within the county. Table 72. Burglary, Larceny, and Auto Theft, 2013 Total Property Crime Burglary Larceny Auto Theft Columbia 1,049 207 828 14 Statewide 355,902 56,120 284,331 15,451 Source: New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, Index Crimes Reported: 2009 - 2013. 52 Community Resources During each of the community focus groups participants were asked to identify community resources that were available to assist with community concerns and needs. They were also asked to identify barriers to accessing these resources. The following chart summarizes what they had to say, however it may not include information about all available community resources. Community Concern Area Child Care Community Resources Available to Address Problems / Issues Barriers to Accessing Available Resources Child Care Providers Expensive and not enough child care opportunities Agribusiness Child Care Program Limited funding, restricted to farm workers, limited child care providers Little Wonders Early Childhood Learning Center, Hudson Day Care Long wait for infant care, expensive, not enough subsidies available. After School Programs Some are too expensive Columbia Greene Child Care Connections Limited funding for child care subsidies Limited number of child care slots Crime NYS Troopers Columbia County Sheriffs’ Department Education Head Start Promise Neighborhood Mentoring Programs Unable to patrol in all communities, response time can be slow No crime prevention activities Limited hours and locations Income & age guidelines may prevent some from being eligible Lack of transportation Need more volunteers & mentors need training Local Libraries Summer Programs Lack of awareness Elder Services Office for the Aging Lack of awareness Employment Workforce Investment Office (CGCC) Lack of awareness No transportation to the college Family Support School Social Workers have been a great resource for families and children Many schools have eliminated these positions Promise Neighborhood – arranging for Skype visitation for families with incarcerated member Columbia Opportunities, Inc. Must have access to technology Need close cooperation with prisons Lack of transportation & lack of awareness Parsons Northeast Parent & Child Berkshire Farm St. Catherine’s Health Care Urgent Care in Valatie & Copake Some Drs offering early urgent care w/o appointments 53 Not available in all communities Limited network of providers Community Concern Area Health Care continued Community Resources Available to Address Problems / Issues Barriers to Accessing Available Resources Medicaid transportation Long wait on the phone when arranging for transportation People don’t know about this resource Homelessness Columbia County Health Care Consortium Navigators – ability to meet people in the community at nontraditional business hours Continuum of Care Programs Housing Affordable Housing Complexes Family housing limited to greater Hudson area No community room available for Hudson Terrace Habitat for Humanity – new homes and ReStore New home applicants must have enough income to pay back mortgage Housing Choice Voucher Section 8 Rental Assistance Programs (Hudson Housing Authority and COI) Waiting lists very long When voucher is received, not enough time to find a unit that meets the guidelines Lack of rental opportunities Lack of awareness – no transportation to participate Galvan Housing Resources Income Supports SSI is a great resource for people with disability and limited incomes Opportunities limited Very narrow definition of homelessness Information Sources Local officials seen as a resource by some Local Libraries also source of information Eligibility guidelines make it hard for people to receive disability determination, income rules are biased against people who are married Some DSS staff do not treat people with respect Some are overworked & make mistakes (with devastating effects on consumers) Not transparent regarding how people qualify for benefits Benefits are not high enough to meet basic expenses Most of cash benefit is used for housing, nothing left over for other needs They may not know about all the resources that are available Mental Health Mental Health Association Lack of awareness – no transportation Private mental health therapists for children Not enough supply Community Food Pantries including Columbia Opportunities, Catholic Charities, and Salvation Army Some pantries run out of food People do not know where to go to receive food or how to support food pantries Long lines at some food pantries Needs to be expanded to the middle & high schools Regional Food Bank is so far away – limiting availability to bring food in to the area People don’t know about the program Too much milk, not enough flexibility to meet nutritional needs so people drop out of the program Department of Social Services Cash Assistance Food Stamps Emergency Assistance Nutrition School Backpack Programs (Hudson, Taconic Hills) WIC Program – Catholic Charities 54 Community Concern Area Nutrition - continued Community Resources Available to Address Problems / Issues Barriers to Accessing Available Resources Salvation Army Community Center Soup Kitchen – Food Pantry Lack of awareness – no transportation Local Farmer’s Markets Even though some accept food stamps and WIC checks, the items can be too expensive Some are crowded with not enough parking available (Hudson) Some are full – not accepting new gardeners Not available in all areas Community Gardens Cooperative Extension Programs Loss of Eat Smart NY limits available programming Safety Community Action of Greene County Columbia Greene Domestic Violence Program REACH Center Child Advocacy Center Special Needs COARC Substance Abuse Twin County Recovery Services Transportation Wheels for Work – Community Action of Greene County Youth Development Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts, Navigator Programs, 4-H Only provider – no choice about services Services based in Hudson, limits access for people in outlying areas Community opposition to establishing services in other areas 55 Hard to find a place to hold meetings Columbia County Columbia Opportunities, Inc. www.columbiaopportunities.org Race & Whites African Americans Hispanics/Latinos 10.0% (5,501) 25.8% (452) 28.1% (685) Poverty 540 Columbia Street Hudson, NY 12534 518.828.4611 Education & Poverty County Population: 62,445 Adult Population 25+ - 44,152 Population for whom poverty status is determined: Overall 60,330 Population Under 18 11,528 Population 25 & Over 44,152 Population over 65 11,402 Educational Attainment No Degree 11.2% (4,928) Total 23.0% (1,133) Living in Poverty Median Income Individuals 11.2% 6,744 Children (Under 18) 16.6% 1,913 Adults 25+ 8.8% 3,879 Senior Citizens 65+ 5.9% 675 Associate 30.0% (13,268) Total 10.4% (1,380) Living in Poverty & Poverty 28.5% (12,574) Total 3.1% (386) Living in Poverty Health & Poverty No Health Insurance Unemployment Rate December 2014 Median Income w/High School Diploma $37,182 $31,463 Living Wage for 1 Adult, 1 Child Household Hourly Wage for FMR, 2 BR Apartment $21.04 $17.23 Gender Employed 9.6% Unemployed 21.9% Free/Reduced Lunch Program 47% Of Those Families with Female Heads of Household and Children Present & Poverty High School Diploma Bachelors or Higher 30.3% (13,382) Total 7.3% (980) Living in Poverty Employment 4.5% Living In Poverty High School Median Income Median Income $35,478 $26,335 US Poverty Rate: 15.9% • NYS Poverty Rate: 15.9% 56 26.0% Live in Poverty Maps: On each county profile page, the map of NYS is included, with the county highlighted in red. The inset map shows the county map with the county seat noted. On city profile pages, the map of NYS is again included, with the county highlighted in grey and the cities noted in red. Inset map is the county, with cities noted. Data Key Please see census.gov for more specific definitions for any of the data sourced from USCB reports. Race & Poverty Data 88% 66% 44% 22% 0% Population Data: The population is the official count of people from the US Census Bureau’s (USCB) BO1003 report. The Population for Whom Status is Determined reflects the size of census samples and is provided in USCB report S1701. Poverty Data: The poverty rate includes all individuals living in poverty. The numbers are then broken down in three other categories: children under 18, adults over 25 and adults over 65. The percentage of each group living in poverty is followed by the number of individuals that percentage represents. Families in Poverty Data is from USCB Report S1702 and indicates the percentage of all families with a female head of household and at least one child under 18 that are living in poverty. ALL Census Reports cited are from the American Communities Survey three year estimates (2011 - 2013) when available. Otherwise, the American Communities Survey five year (2009 2013) estimates have been used. See next page for more details. Data on race is based on self-identification. There are a minimum of five categories from which to select, including White and Black/ African American. People are able to selfidentify as more than one race. People who identify their origin as Hispanic, Latino or Spanish may be of any race. The data is from USCB Report S1701 ). Education & Poverty Data The top numbers provided, next to the dark blue squares, indicate the total for each category, as a percentage of the entire population and number of individuals. The number below, next to the lighter square, shows the percentage of all people in that category living in poverty and total number of individuals that indicates. This data is from USCB Report S1701. Income & Poverty Data Median Income - Total income is the sum of the amounts reported for wage/salary income, self employment income,, interest, dividends, rental income, royalty income, income from estates or trusts, Social Security or Railroad Retirement income, Supplementary Social Security, public assistance or welfare payments, retirement/survivor/disability pensions and all other income. The data is from USCB Report S1501. Health & Poverty Unemployment Rate - Unemployment rate, by county, for the month of … from the NYS Department of Labor - Labor Statistics (www.labor.ny.gov/stats/ LSLAUS.shtm) Living Wage - The wage listed is the wage an individual would need to earn as the sole provider for a household consisting of themselves and one child based on the typical expenses in that county or city. This wage is a minimum estimate of the cost of living for a low wage family. Data from Massachusetts Institute of Technology Living Wage Calculator (www.livingwage.mit.edu) Hourly Wage - The hourly rate listed is that which one person would need to earn working year round, 40 hours per week in order to afford a 2 bedroom apartment at the fair market rate (FMR) for that county, assuming 30% of income is spent on housing. Data is provided by the National Low Income Housing Coalition ‘s report: Out of Reach 2014 . www.nlihc.org 57 Insurance Based on self reporting this includes people who have: insurance from a current/former employer, insurance purchased directly from an insurance company, Medicare, Medicaid, Medical Assistance, any government assistance plan for people with low income or disability, TRICARE or military health care, VA, Indian Health Service or any other type of health insurance or health coverage plan. Data from USCB Report S2701. Free/Reduced Lunch Program Of students who attend public schools where National School Lunch Program (NSLP) is offered, the percentage of enrollment that is eligible for free or reduced lunches. This does not represent those attending private schools or schools that do not administer NSLP. Data is provided by Hunger Solutions New York. Female Head of Household Data from USCB Report S1702 2015 Poverty Guidelines Sec on 673(2) of the Omnibus Budget Reconcilia on Act (OBRA) of 1981 (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)) requires the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services to update the poverty guidelines at least annually, adjus ng them on the basis of the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U). The poverty guidelines are used as an eligibility criterion by the Community Services Block Grant program and a number of other Federal programs. The poverty guidelines issued here are a simplified version of the poverty thresholds that the Census Bureau uses to prepare its es mates of the number of individuals and families in poverty. As required by law, this update is accomplished by increasing the latest published Census Bureau poverty thresholds by the relevant percentage change in the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U). The poverty guidelines are not derived from the Census Bureau's new Supplemental Poverty Measure (SPM). The figures represent annual income. These are the 2015 Poverty Guidelines for the 48 Con guous States and the District of Columbia. 50% 100% HS/EHS 110% 130% 150% LIHEAP 185% WIC 200% IDA & WAP 1 $5,885 $11,770 $12,947 $15,301 $17,655 $21,774.50 $23,540 2 $7,965 $15,930 $17,523 $20,709 $23,895 $29,470.50 $31,860 3 $10,045 $20,090 $22,099 $26,117 $30,135 $37,166.50 $40,180 4 $12,125 $24,250 $26,675 $31,525 $36,375 $44,862.50 $48,500 5 $14,205 $28,410 $31,251 $36,933 $42,615 $52,558.50 $56,820 6 $16,285 $32,570 $35,827 $42,341 $48,855 $60,254.50 $65,140 7 $18,365 $36,730 $40,043 $47,749 $55,095 $67,950.50 $73,460 8 $20,445 $40,890 $44,979 $53,157 $61,335 $75,646.50 $81,780 Number in Household HS/EHS - Head Start/Early Head Start LIHEAP - Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program WIC - Women, Infants & Children IDA - Individual Development Account WAP - Weatheriza on 58