Steps Training Course – Stage 2
Transcription
Steps Training Course – Stage 2
Steps Training Course – Stage 2 by Ros Lugg The Learning Staircase Ltd P O Box 582 Rangiora 7440 Ph: 0800 701 107 Fax: 0800 000 703 [email protected] www.learningstaircase.co.nz The Big Five Dyslexic learners often exhibit difficulties (or signs of a residual difficulty) in each of these areas, which is why we refer to them as ‘The Big Five’. However, many other learners, including those in the ‘low-ability’ category have similar weaknesses. Therefore, any approach which addresses these difficulties is relevant to both dyslexics and other learners with processing weaknesses. Motor Development • Gross motor development • Laterality & midline crossing • Fine motor development • Kinaesthetic memory Sequencing • Visual sequencing • Auditory sequencing • General Visual Perception • Tracking • Visual discrimination • Perceptual organisation • Visual recognition • Irlen Syndrome Phonological Awareness • Auditory discrimination • Phonemic awareness • Rhyme & syllabification • Onset + rime • Word retrieval Memory • Visual memory • Auditory memory • Kinaesthetic memory • Working memory 2 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Motor Development Aspect Affects.. Useful exercises/activities Gross motor development Trunk stability Arrows Exercise Ability to sit still at a desk. Crawling Posture for writing tasks Perceptual Motor Programmes Indirectly affects ability to http://www.ot-mom-learning-activities.com/core-exercises-for-kids.html concentrate and listen. http://www.ot-mom-learning-activities.com/support-files/parent-info-gross-motor.pdf Laterality Hand dominance Midline crossing Writing fluency Sports Visual tracking when reading http://www.therapystreetforkids.com/CrossingMidline.html Lazy 8s exercises http://nspt4kids.com/parenting/help-your-child-develop-the-crossing-the-midline-skill/ Fine motor development Handwriting & pencil grip Writing fluency Written accuracy Letter formation & Writing fluency and accuracy Kinaesthetic memory Playdough. Jenga, Pick up sticks, jigsaws Teodorescu Perceptuo-Motor Programme (Write Start) Colouring activities Feed the face! – (tennis ball) Telephone book activity – scrunch paper and throw at target Larger triangular pencils for beginning writers. Pencil grips Dots on fingers to remind about grip! Gross motor letter tracing. Use Visual/Auditory/Kinaesthetic routes Teach cursive flick and joined writing at an early stage. Prompts – laminated strip on desk, letters at top of page Notes on Midline Crossing/Dominance Cross dominance This refers to a motor skill wherein the person favours one hand for some tasks and the other hand for other tasks but is not actually ambidextrous. Ambidextrous This is the term used to describe a person who is equally adept or able to use each hand and is very rare. Lateralisation or laterality This describes the development of lateral dominance, in other words one eye, hand, foot and ear becomes dominant. It also involves the development of specialised centres and functions in the left and right hemispheres of the brain. Thus, the right hemisphere sends messages to the left side of the body and the left hemisphere sends messages to right side. The ability to cross the midline is a prerequisite for appropriate lateralisation. Laterality also involves good balance and vestibular function. During a study at the Souther California College of Optometry, 73.8% of children already diagnosed with a learning disability failed tests used to assess laterality and directionality. Crossing the midline This is the ability of the one side of the body to cross over to the other side by moving across the centre line of the body, thus the right hand can cross over the midline and pick up an object from the left side of the body, for example. Signs that laterality has not yet developed: Non-dominant hand not used for support Switching hands so they don’t cross the midline Motor overflow Pointing with non-dominant hand These can be observed with all young children, but if confusion with laterality occurs after 8 years of age, it can potentially cause problems. Specific areas of difficulty if dominance is not established include: 1. Papers being read or written on are dramatically rotated 2. Difficulty perceiving left and right sides of objects and letters 3. Uncertainty about personal left and right body sides 4. Difficulty making decisions 5. Difficulty in accepting a change in rule or decision once it has been made 6. Delayed language acquisition 7. Difficulty comprehending instructions 8. Problems with word finding 9. Difficulty with organisational skills 10. Diminished concept of consequences 11. Poor gross and fine motor skills in general, in other words difficulties with kicking a ball, colouring in, cutting with scissors, drawing, etc. 12. Writing patterns that are inconsistent and untidy 13. Not crossing the midline 14. Possible difficulties with writing and reading activities The reason a child has a dominant hand, foot, ear and eye is because one of the two brain hemispheres has stepped forward as the dominant hemisphere, thus taking the lead in the process of making decisions as well as the way we perform tasks. This dominance should be established by the age of five and it should correlate or be on the same side of the body by the age of six years. This means that by six, the child should demonstrate dominance on the same side for his hand, foot, ear and eye. It is normal for a five-year-old child to sometimes use his non-dominant hand to perform a task that should be done with his dominant hand, but this should be the rare occasion. Laterality eventually evolves into directionality. A person needs to understand laterality on their own body before they can apply it in space. We always learn to judge where things are by first learning how to relate them to ourselves. When you start applying left and right concepts to your external visual space, you are beginning to learn directionality. . 5 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Directionality Directionality includes the concepts of ‘up, down, ahead, behind, right, left’ and any other concepts to do with space or direction. Directionality is very important in decoding letters. If you don’t understand this concept, learning to read can be very confusing. For example, the letters ‘b’, ‘d’, ‘p’ and ‘q’ all look like the same symbol if you don’t understand the concept of orientation. Consider the following: Are these objects the same? If the spoons are the same, regardless of which way they are, why aren’t these the same? b d Research has shown that children who still have reversal problems after the age of 8 are likely to have problems developing good reading skills. Bilateral integration The communication between the right and left cerebral hemispheres, which allows the two sides of the body to move together in coordination with each other. In order to function efficiently, we need to integrate information from various specialised areas of the brain in order to coordinate a planned response. Most people develop what is known as unilateral cerebral dominance, which means that their dominant eye, ear, hand and leg are on the same side of their body. However, research has indicated that approximately 20% of the population has mixed dominance, which can cause perceptual, organisational and performance problems in various areas of a person’s life. 6 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Motor Development The main thing aspect of motor development which affects literacy is, of course, fine motor control. Fine motor control is needed for handwriting and for mouse control or keyboarding. How does Steps develop Motor Development? Steps is not specifically designed to develop motor control as such, although there are plans for a touch typing course. However, there a few features which develop this aspect, including kinaesthetic memory (memory for movement). The workbook courses include a strong emphasis on handwriting and letter formation and the teaching method for high frequency/irregular words develops kinaesthetic memory. Blocks (game) – spatial awareness, quick thinking, fine motor skills Clear the Skies (game) – spatial awareness, mouse skills Alphabet (reference) – kinaesthetic memory for letter formation, handwriting 7 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Why teach touch typing to children with literacy difficulties? There are many advantages. Firstly, touch typing is an increasingly important skill for all young people in this age of computers. Correct touch typing will enable all young people to word process quickly and accurately. This is particularly important for children with literacy difficulties, as they can then access features such as spell checkers, editing facilities and specialist programmes, such as TextHelp. Children with literacy difficulties often find it much easier and quicker to word process than to handwrite. They benefit from being allowed to use word processors in class or for homework and many benefit hugely from the ability to use laptops. Secondly, touch typing is a fine motor and motor planning activity. Many children with learning disabilities also have a degree of fine motor immaturity. Dyspraxic children have this, as well as a difficulty with motor planning. These children benefit particularly from touch typing since it develops these important neurological aspects. It is not unusual to find that a child who has completed a touch typing programme also has greatly improved handwriting! This is because fine motor control has improved so much. Thirdly, and possibly most importantly, children develop a kinaesthetic memory for spellings. Kinaesthetic means 'movement' and a child will develop a memory for the movement involved in typing a word, much as a pianist develops a memory for the movements involved in playing a piece of music. This 'by-passes' some of the key difficulties these children have with spelling and enables them to cope more quickly and confidently with written language. Many children have reported that they can spell when they type, but not when they write. Will any touch typing programme do? No, not usually. Most readily available programmes are too fast and not structured enough for learners with literacy difficulties and possibly fine motor weakness. They also do not take advantage of the fact that children can develop a kinaesthetic memory for words. The most effective programmes are specialist programmes which are designed for children with literacy or other learning difficulties. Type to Learn is one of the best of these programmes, incorporating a complete spelling programme (at 3 different vocabulary levels), as well as a structured touch typing course with plenty of reinforcement. Type to Learn also has full teacher facilities and is diagnostic, providing extra practice for children having difficulty with particular exercises. Type to Learn is currently forming the basis for literacy programmes in a number of High Schools and is suitable for parents wishing to help their child acquire literacy skills. 8 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Sequencing Sequencing is literally the process of putting things in order. This may include letters (in the alphabet or in spelling words), words, ideas, paragraphs, mathematical items or steps in a process. Difficulties experienced by someone with sequencing problems Spelling problems (sequencing sounds in a word or letters in a word) Maths difficulties Reading comprehension problems Inability to follow the plot of a book Difficulty planning written work Feeling overwhelmed when doing homework Unable to follow instructions Lack of awareness of how much time has passed Difficulty with rote sequences – days, months, times tables Lack of awareness of patterns in number Processing an sequencing the sounds or syllables in a word which has been heard Signs and symptoms Difficulty with any of the above! Reading - was/saw, of/for Spelling – nosie (noise), sotp (stop) Activities Counting, skip counting and counting backwards Sequence puzzles What comes next? 0 1 3 6 10 15 ___ ___ Pattern/shape sequences (logic) Sequencing words to make a sentence Sequencing sentences to make a passage Sequencing lines of poetry/limericks Resources Sequencing Stories (Curriculum Concepts) Thinksheet (software programme) – Learning Staircase Memory and sequencing activities on Steps www.lumosity.com When I went to market……. (also develops auditory sequential memory and visualization) 9 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Sequencing Sequencing is a specific difficulty for dyslexic learners. Sequencing difficulties can affect visual processing, which causes confusions with similar words (of/for, saw/was, etc). It also affects auditory processing, with sounds being mis-sequenced. It can also affect sentence construction and planning skills for essays and other written work. How does Steps develop Sequencing? Sentence Builder – sequencing words to make a sentence, syntactic awareness Word Search – visual discrimination, pattern recognition, tracking Spelling – phonemic awareness, phonic knowledge, visual memory, visual sequencing Spelling Test - phonemic awareness, phonic knowledge, visual memory, visual sequencing Drop – visual sequencing, visualization Fireworks (game) – visual discrimination, tracking, pattern recognition, visual sequencing Pop the Balloon – spatial awareness of the alphabet, sequencing, keyboard awareness Alphabet Order – tracking, visual discrimination, sequencing, working memory Word Grid – auditory sequential memory, working memory Hangman (game) – ability to sequence letters and predict word structure Letter Chunks (general section) – alphabet sequencing, including reverse sequencing Number Chunks (general section) – number sequencing, including reverse sequencing Number Grid (general section) – auditory sequential memory, working memory Days and Months (General Section) – sequencing days of the week and months using visual and auditory sequencing 10 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Visual Perception The term visual perception refers to how the brain makes sense of what the eyes see. It is therefore not a physical difficulty. However, the development of visual perception is dependent on physical aspects, such as vision and eye tracking, so it is always worth checking these aspects first. Remember, if it a child has difficulty copying from the board, it may just be that he is short-sighted! Physical aspects (things to check) Eyesight and eye tracking An optometrist will generally only check vision, but a behavioural optometrist will check eye tracking and visual perception. An important function that bridges laterality and directionality is our eyes. Efficient eye movement skills are essential in developing good directionality skills. If your eyes cannot move across a page smoothly and accurately, this could mean that you are at risk for reversals and coding problems, because how we scan a letter is important when coding it to the brain. You can do a simple eye tracking exercise yourself. Just get the child to focus on an object (end of the pen is very suitable). Tell them to keep following it with their eyes, but don’t move their heads. Then move the pen slowly from side to side a couple of times. Then go up and down and finish by moving it slowly in a circle. Look at the eye movements. You will notice if they have difficulty following the movements – look out for eyes flickering off the target as well. Obviously, you may not pick up difficulties which would be noticed by a behavioural optometrist. However, you will usually see if there are any particular difficulties. Also ask if the child feels discomfort when doing this exercise – this often indicates weak ocular motor muscles. Eye dominance You can check for eye dominance for close and distant vision. If dominance is different, i.e. left-eye dominant for close vision, but right-eye dominant for distant vision, this can cause visual perceptual difficulties – another reason to refer to a behavioural optometrist. 11 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Dominance for distant vision Present the child with a tube and tell them to ‘look through your telescope’. Note which eye the child brings the tube up to. Be careful to present the tube to the child in the middle of their body, i.e. not to the left or the right. Dominance for close vision Make a hole in a piece of paper or card. Stick a piece of blutack or another similar marker about eye height on a wall or door. Get the child to stand about 1 metre away. Give them the card and ask them to line it up so they can see the blutack through the hole. Then ask them to move the card right up to touch their face, but keep looking at the blutack. The eye they bring the hole towards is the dominant one for close vision. Visual Perception (how the brain makes sense of what the eyes see) Visual perceptual processing, or visual information processing, is a set of skills we use to gather visual information from the environment and integrate them with our other senses. This is done while incorporating all the integrated information with other things, such as past experiences, motivation and development, so that we can derive understanding and meaning from what we are experiencing. This process allows the development of schemes to derive meaning from what we see. Visual perceptual processing is very important, but especially so when learning. Without visual perceptual processing, you would not be able to accurately learn to read, give or get directions, copy from the board or from a book, visualize objects or past experiences, remember things visually, have good eye-and coordination, integrate visual information with our other senses to do things like ride a bike, play ball, or hear a sound and be able to visually recognize where it is coming from (like an ambulance), just to name a few. Visual perceptual processing can be broken into many components, but three key areas visual spatial skills, visual analysis skills and visual integration skills. Just like anything else that is broken into components, these skills work together or build upon each other to help you function. 12 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Visual Spatial Skills These are the skills we use to understand directional concepts to organize our visual space. This is how we visually project our body coordinates out into the world. For example: When you say, "It is over to the left," the "to the left" has no meaning unless it has a point of reference. So actually, you are really saying to the left of where YOU are. If you don't know where your body is, it is hard to know where things are in relation to you. Visual spatial skills require observing an object, then accurately reporting its relationship in space relative to your own self. Signs & Symptoms of Visual-Spatial Dysfunction Lack of coordination and balance (clumsy) Difficulty learning left and right Reverses letters or numbers when writing or copying Difficulty with activities involving rhythm Not good at sports Does not cross the midline when doing tasks (switches objects from hand to hand) Does not use nondominant hand for support when writing or copying Rotates body when writing or copying (again to not cross the midline) Visual Analysis Skills Visual analysis, or visual discrimination, is used to identify, sort, organize, store and recall visually presented information. It is the ability to take in visual information remember it and apply it later. Children with poor visual analysis skills often have trouble learning the A, B, C's and recognizing words or simple forms even when presented repeatedly; for example, they may correctly read the word "house" in one sentence and incorrectly read "horse" two lines later. These kids tend to mistake words with similar endings or beginnings, generalize when grouping objects. They also have a hard time understanding size and magnitude, (a cup of water in a tall glass and a cup of water in a shallow bowl are not seen as equal amounts). 13 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Signs & Symptoms of Visual-Analysis Dysfunction Trouble learning the alphabet Trouble recognizing words Mistakes words with similar beginnings Overgeneralizes - confuses minor likenesses and differences Does not recognize the same word if repeated again on a page Trouble with remembering and writing letters and numbers Distractible Short attention span Problems concentrating Traces or touches figures Difficulty with understanding instructions Hyper or hypo active The Subskills of Visual Analysis Visual Figure Ground The ability to perceive and locate a form or object within a busy field without getting confused by the background or surrounding images. This skill keeps children from getting lost in details. Children with poor figure-ground become easily confused with too much print on the page, affecting their concentration and attention. They may also have difficulty scanning text to locate specific information. Example: Looking for a specific piece of information when reading or searching for a specific tool in a toolbox full of tools. Activity: Where’s Wally?, Hidden Pictures 14 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Visual Discrimination The ability to process visual detail. It includes the ability to determine exact characteristics and distinctive features among similar objects or forms. In reading, this skill helps children distinguish between similarly spelled words, such as was/saw, then/when, on/one, or run/ran. Activity: Letter tracking, jigsaws, Where’s Wally? Visual Form Constancy The ability to mentally manipulate forms and visualize the resulting outcomes. Recognition that visual information in a form is consistent in spite of the object, size, or location. This skill helps children distinguish differences in size, shape, and orientation. Children with poor form-constancy may frequently reverse letters and numbers. Example: DOG = dog = Dog, or that a cup of water is a cup of water whether in a tall glass or shallow bowl. Resources: Tetris, Blokus, Jigzone Visual Memory The ability to remember the characteristics of a given object or form. This skill helps children remember what they read and see by adequately processing information through their short-term memory, from where it is filtered out into the long-term memory. Children with poor visual memory may struggle with comprehension. They often subvocalize, or softly whisper to themselves, as they read in order to help compensate auditorily. They may have difficulty remembering what a word looks like or fail to recognize the same word on another page. They may also take longer copying assignments because they must frequently review the text. Visualization Ability to recall a previously viewed image or object and mentally manipulate the image from various aspects. Linked with visual memory. 15 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Example: Seeing a flattened box and being able to mentally reconstruct it and picture the dimensions to decide if the object you want to put in the box will fit. Visual Sequential Memory The ability to remember forms or characters in correct order. This skill is particularly important in spelling and also plays a role in comprehension. Letter omissions, additions, or transpositions within words are common for children who struggle with this skill. They often subvocalize (whisper or talk aloud) as they write. Recognizing and remembering patterns may also be a problem. Example: Recall a phone number 205-9786 vs. 205-9687, or in spelling "their" vs. "thier" Visual Closure The ability to visualize a complete whole when given incomplete information or a partial picture. This skill helps children read and comprehend quickly; their eyes don't have to individually process every letter in every word for them to quickly recognize the word by sight. This skill can also help children recognize inferences and predict outcomes. Children with poor visual closure may have difficulty completing a thought. They may also confuse similar objects or words, especially words with close beginning or endings. Visual Spatial Relations The ability to distinguish differences among similar objects or forms. This skill helps children in understanding relationships and recognizing underlying concepts. This area is closely related to the problem solving and conceptual skills required for higher level science and math. Visual Spatial Orientation is involved with letter reversals. Many parents and educators considered letter reversals after age seven to be a symptom of dyslexia. While this can be true, the most common cause of reversals in older children is a lack of visual spatial development--consistently knowing left from right, either in relationship to their own bodies or in the world around them. Activities: Blokus, Tetris, Jigzone 16 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Visual Speed & Span of Perception The rate and amount at which information is being handled in visual processing. This is also linked to visual retention span (the number of letters which can be retained in each ‘glance’ when copying. Example: Quickly and efficiently copying an assignment off the chalkboard with only a few glances vs. needing to glance at the chalkboard after every one to two words or bits of information is copied. Activity: Speed Stackers Visual integration skills All of the above usually involve visual integration, since one skill is rarely used purely in isolation. However, there are specific aspects which are particularly relevant academically. Visual-motor integration This is basically linked with hand-eye coordination and it is required for tasks such as copying from the board. The student may have difficulties just with the visual aspect or the motor aspect, or integrating/coordinating the two together. Children with visual motor integration difficulties are often slow at writing tasks and can have extreme difficulty copying from the board. Automaticity Once all of these skills are developed, it is important for them to become automatic so they take up less brain power to use. Just like learning to drive a car with a manual transmission. At first, it takes a lot of brain power to get your feet to move the right way and for you to time it with what your hand does with the stick shift. Not only are you learning a new skill, but you also have to make sure you pay attention to the road and steer accordingly. Once you get the hang of it, the ability to shift gears became automatic and you can devote that brain power to eating a Big Mac and talking on the cell phone along with everything else (not recommended, by the way). In order to have efficient visual information processing skills, you have to learn the skills well to the point where they become easy. Automaticity is essential to efficient learning. 17 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 How does Steps develop Visual Perception? All of the activities which develop phonological awareness have some impact on visual recognition of words, since instant visual recognition also requires an understanding of phonic patterns/phonological awareness. However, there are a number of activities on Steps which specifically develop Visual Perception: Find the word – visual recognition, decoding Word Flash – visual recognition, development of occipito-temporal Sentence Builder – reading in context, visual recognition Word Search – visual discrimination, pattern recognition, tracking Spelling – phonemic awareness, phonic knowledge, visual memory, visual sequencing Spelling Test - phonemic awareness, phonic knowledge, visual memory, visual sequencing Drop – visual sequencing, visualization Visual memory – visual and spatial memory, word recognition Fireworks (game) – visual discrimination, tracking, pattern recognition Snap (game) – perceptual organisation, visual discrimination Blocks (game) – spatial awareness, hand-eye coordination, directionality, fine motor coordination Pop the Balloon – spatial awareness of the alphabet, sequencing, keyboard awareness Reversals (letters and numbers) – visual discrimination, directionality Alphabet Order – tracking, visual discrimination, sequencing, working memory Directions – directionality, spatial concepts Perception – spatial awareness, perceptual organisation Spelling (General) – visual discrimination, pattern recognition 18 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Irlen Syndrome What is Irlen Syndrome? Irlen Syndrome is a perceptual dysfunction which mainly affects reading and processing other visual information. People with Irlen Syndrome see printed text differently, sometimes seeing quite major distortions, such as text becoming compressed, blurred or even moving. Sample distortions can be seen at: http://www.irlenatlantique.ca/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=10&Itemid=15&l ang=en Possible Symptoms Visual and Physical Difficulties Light sensitivity Restricted visual retention span Difficulty with sustained attention Reading Problems Poor comprehension Misreads words Problems tracking from line to line Reads in dim light Skips words or lines Reads slowly or hesitantly Takes breaks Loses place Avoids reading Discomfort Strain and fatigue Tired or sleepy Headaches or nausea Fidgety or restless Eyes that hurt or become watery 19 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Attention and Concentration Problems Problems with concentration when reading and doing academic tasks Often people can appear to have other conditions, such as attention deficit disorder, and are given medication unnecessarily. Writing Problems: Trouble copying Unequal spacing Unequal letter size Writing up or downhill Inconsistent spelling Other Characteristics: Strain or fatigue from computer use Difficulty reading music Sloppy, careless math errors Misaligned numbers in columns Ineffective use of study time Lack of motivation Grades do not reflect the amount of effort Depth Perception: Clumsiness Difficulty catching balls Difficulty judging distances Additional caution necessary while driving Distortions: Words on the page lack clarity or stability; i.e., may appear to be blurry, moving, or disappear. Contact Details: Irlen Diagnostic clinic – Pakuranga Suite 5, Pakuranga Professional Centre 267 Pakuranga Rd Pakuranga Manukau 09 576 5390 www.irlen.com 20 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Irlen Questionnaire Tick under the appropriate column for the following Often questions Do you lose your place when reading? Do you skip whole lines when reading? Do you accidentally skip words? Do you repeat lines when you read? Do you start off well, then slow down rapidly and get very hesitant? Do you confuse little words of similar shape? (was/saw, dog/boy, of/for? Do words go blurry or fuzzy? Do words move when you look at them? (shimmer, wave, jump up and down, vibrate?) Do words look squashed together or ‘run together’ as you read? Do you avoid reading whenever possible? Do you read a page and then find you can’t remember what you’ve read? Do bright lights (particularly fluorescent lights) irritate you, hurt your eyes or cause headaches? Does print on glossy white paper irritate you? Do you prefer to read in a dim light? Is print on coloured paper easier to read or see? Do you frequently lose your place when you’re copying from a board in class? Do you get headaches when you/ve been reading a lot? Do your eyes hurt when you read? Do you rub your eyes a lot? Do you blink or squint a lot or feel as if you want to open your eyes really wide when you’re reading? Do you get dizzy or feel sick when you read black print on white paper? Do you get car sickness a lot? 21 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Sometim es Never Don’t know Auditory Perception Physical aspects (to check and eliminate) As with vision/visual perceptual skills, there are aspects which are affected by physical difficulties and it is important to check these first. The main one is auditory discrimination, which can be caused by a hearing difficulty, such as glue ear (otitis media). Glue ear is much more common with dyslexics, but is relatively common with young children anyway. Unless it is identified and resolved (usually with grommets), it can have a devastating effect on the development of phonological skills. Auditory Discrimination This is the ability to identify the difference between similar sounding letters/words, i.e. vine/fine, go/grow. Auditory discrimination needs to be checked when starting to work with a learner with literacy difficulties. A quick and easy auditory discrimination test is included in this set of notes. Phonological Awareness There is considerable research from all over the world into the importance of different aspects of phonological awareness. Phonological awareness is often a major weakness in learners with dyslexia or similar processing difficulties. Phonological awareness is often referred to as phonemic awareness, but there is a crucial difference between these terms. The term ‘phonemic awareness’ comes from the word ‘phoneme’, which is a single sound in language. This includes the following individual skills: Identification of initial, final and medial sounds in word Segmentation (breaking words into individual sounds Blending (blending individual sounds to make words) Phoneme transposition (ability to ‘swap’ sounds) 22 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 The term ‘phonological awareness’ comes from the word ‘phonology’, which is the sounds and sound patterns of language. Phonological awareness is therefore a broader term than phonemic awareness and encompasses the following: All of the above aspects of phonemic awareness PLUS Onset + rime Rhyme Analogical transfer Syllabification Word Retrieval Auditory discrimination Phonological awareness is purely processing the sounds and sound patterns in language, not understanding how those sounds map onto text, which is referred to as phonic or orthographic knowledge. However, it is an essential precursor to phonic knowledge. There is no point trying to learn what letters represent what sounds if you are unable to process those sounds in language in the first place. How does Steps develop Phonological Awareness? The following activities are specifically designed to develop phonological awareness. Some of these activities only involve processing the sounds or sound patterns themselves (phonological awareness) and some make the link with the written word (phonological awareness + phonic knowledge). Chunks – onset + rime awareness Word Building – onset + rime awareness Initial Sounds – onset + rime awareness, phoneme transposition Sound Tiles – phonemic awareness + phonic knowledge Sound Boxes – phonemic awareness + phonic knowledge Vowel Sounds (game) – phonemic awareness, auditory discrimination and phonic knowledge Clear the Skies (game) - phonemic awareness, auditory discrimination and phonic knowledge Vowel Ladder (game) – phonemic awareness, auditory discrimination, phonic knowledge, blending, decoding/encoding skills Alphabet (General Section) – phonic knowledge, phonemic awareness Spelling (General Section) – auditory discrimination, phonemic awareness, decoding/encoding skills 23 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Phonemic/Phonological Awareness Research “The majority of preschoolers can segment words into syllables. Very few can readily segment them into phonemes. The more sophisticated stage of phoneme segmentation is not reached until the child has received formal instruction in letter-sound knowledge.” Predicting reading and spelling difficulties (Snowling & Backhouse 1996) "The best predictor of reading difficulty in kindergarten or first grade is the inability to segment words and syllables into constituent sound units (phonemic awareness)" Lyon, G. R. (1995). Toward a definition of dyslexia. Annals of Dyslexia, 45, 3-27. “The ability to hear and manipulate phonemes plays a causal role in the acquisition of beginning reading skills”. Smith, Simmons, & Kame'enui, 1998 The effects of training phonological awareness and learning to read are mutually supportive. "Reading and phonemic awareness are mutually reinforcing: Phonemic awareness is necessary for reading, and reading, in turn, improves phonemic awareness still further." Shaywitz. S. (2003). Overcoming dyslexia: A new and complete science-based program for reading problems at any level. New York: Knopf. 24 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Memory Memory is obviously a huge topic, with many different aspects. Most learners with literacy difficulties have some memory difficulties at least. Visual memory Weaknesses in visual memory affect the development of sight vocabulary. Learners in this category need significantly more exposure to text to fix words in to their long-term memory. Research indicates that a non-dyslexic learner only needs 4 – 10 exposures to a word to fix it into long-term memory, whereas a dyslexic learner may need 500 – 1300 exposures. Auditory memory There are two key aspects to this. Auditory sequential memory is the ability to remember a sequence of items/pieces of information. Working memory is the ability to retain information and simultaneously process it (as is necessary for taking notes). Kinaesthetic memory This is generally very under-utilised for learning, but it can be very powerful. Touch typing and joined writing are particularly important for developing a kinaesthic memory for spellings. Using gross motor movements is a good way to develop a kinaesthetic memory for the formation of letters. Memory for information This is obviously linked with the above aspects, but specifically refers to the ability to remember information such as verbal instructions or reading/listening comprehension questions. Most of the activities on Steps develop memory in some way or other, since they are providing reinforcement of the words or spelling patterns. However, there are specific activities which prioritise memory skills. 25 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Literacy Skills and knowledge needed for spelling Skills Knowledge syllabification segmentation blending auditory discrimination visual discrimination visual memory working memory kinaesthetic memory fine motor skill analogical transfer sequencing spatial awareness phonic knowledge orthographic knowledge word structure morphology (forms of language) etymology (sources/derivation of language) letter formation What is spelling? “The ability to spell is a highly complex and active intellectual accomplishment and not, as has historically been viewed, a low-order memory task.” Hodges (1981) Terminology phonology phoneme grapheme consonant digraph blend vowel digraph ‘r’ modified vowel schwa The sounds and sound patterns of a language A single sound Letter or letters which represent a single sound Two letters making one sound (sh, th, ch) Two or three letters making separate sounds (br, tr, str) Two vowels making one sound (ou, ai, ea, ee) Vowel + r (ar, er, ir, or, ur) Indeterminate sound in a word (letter, about) 26 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Sounds (Phonemes) There are 44 sounds in the English language Vowel phonemes a (hat) e (net) i (fig) o (hot) u (sun) u (put) a (lay) e (mean) i (guy) o (own) oo (food) a (half) aw (awful) ur (purr) oi (coin) ea (ear) air (chair) ou (mouse) Consonant phonemes b (bit) p (push) t (test) d (drum) k (kid) qw (queen) g (good) sh (sugar) ch (chalk) j (jet) h (hit) f (fight) v (vast) th (think) th (there) s (sun) s (sing) z (zest) m (meat) n (nut) l (leg) r (red) y (yellow) w (watch) 27 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Development of Literacy Beginning readers in the USA Looked at predictors of reading success or failure Pre-readers aged 3-5 yrs Looked at variety of abilities IQ Speech and language abilities Attention span Motor skills Phonological processing Found that phonological processing is even more important than IQ. Bryant & Bradley (1983) 400 4-5 year old (non-readers) tested on a number of aspects of phonological awareness including ability to: Detect alliteration Detect rhyme Children’s reading and spelling tested again 4 yrs later (age 8-9) Found that rhyme detection ability at 4-5 years of age is the most effective predicator of later literacy success. Rhyme and syllabification the foundation stones for the development of other aspects of phonological awareness. Rhyme develops gradually from the earliest stages. Syllabification develops in distinct stages. Sentences to words Words to syllables Words to Onset + rime Syllables/words to sounds 28 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Why is the onset + rime approach so important? It utilizes an awareness of rhyme (sound pattern) to enable the child to recognise and use spelling patterns. It simplifies the task – word families instead of individual words. It develops analogical transfer – the ability to apply knowledge learned in one context to a different context. It teaches at a level of natural phonological development Suggested resources Wordbuilding activities in Steps Chunks 29 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Summary Rhyming skills at 3-5 years of age are the single most accurate predictor of later reading success. Therefore, developing rhyming skills (sound patterns!) is a high priority Rhyme awareness leads to the ability to use onset + rime. Therefore link the awareness of sound patterns with the later awareness of spelling patterns – teach word families. Onset + rime awareness is a natural stage of phonological development. Therefore use the onset + rime approach particularly in the early stages to simplify the task and aid memory. Phonemic awareness does not develop naturally, but as a result of literacy teaching. Therefore teach and develop phonemic awareness as part of your spelling programme, but be aware of the stage your learner is at – provide appropriate scaffolding as necessary. Poor early readers often have poor syllabification. Therefore develop the sound skills of syllabification. Check that your learner can divide sentences into words and clap rhythms first. Onset + rime awareness leads to analogical transfer – the most important reading/spelling skill. Use the word family approach (even with more advanced learners) to develop analogical transfer. Take every opportunity to teach your learner to draw analogies – spelling and reading. 30 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 The Learning Staircase Auditory Discrimination Test (Lugg 2010) Conditions of Use This test has been compiled by and is the property of The Learning Staircase Ltd. It may be freely photocopied and distributed or quoted in other literature, providing that it is correctly attributed and referenced. It may not be re-written or re-formatted. What is auditory discrimination? Auditory discrimination is the ability to distinguish between similar sounds. Weaknesses in auditory discrimination may be caused by physical hearing difficulties such as glue ear, by weaknesses in auditory perception or by a combination of factors. Auditory discrimination difficulties are likely to affect the development of phonological awareness and may also affect auditory processing of verbal information such as instructions. Test Guidelines Do this test if the child has phonological difficulties and/or you suspect for some other reason that the child is not able to tell the difference between sounds. You may notice the any or all of the following: Poor listening skills generally Mis-hearing words in isolation or in context Particular difficulty with verbal instructions Poor articulation of speech sounds and words Difficulty developing phonological awareness Instructions for administration Note: You will need a photocopied recording sheet for each child. Seat the child comfortably in a quiet room with no background noise or other distractions. Explain that you are going to tell the child two words together and the child needs to tell you if the words are the same or different. Give examples as follows: “I’m going to say two words. I want you to tell me if they are the same or different. Listen to these words” Then say the words: “table – table” Make sure you say them slowly and clearly. “Were those words the same or different?” Hopefully the child will say “same”. “That’s right. Now listen to these words: table – cable. Are they the same or different?” If the child has mis-understood the instructions, explain them in more detail and talk through the differences between the words if necessary. Then say: “Now I’m going to say some more word pairs. I just want you to say ‘same’ or ‘different’. But if you can see my mouth move, it’s too easy. So I’m going to get you to turn around so you can’t see me.” 31 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Ensure that the child is facing the other way completely, i.e. not sideways on. Then start the test. Say each pair of words slowly and clearly. Mark the child’s response on the recording sheet. It’s fine to repeat the pair if necessary, but mark the form by ticking the ‘R’ column. Numerous repetitions may indicate auditory processing or attentional difficulty. When you say the words, say them clearly with a neutral intonation. Make sure that your voice does not inadvertently change when you say the matching pairs. Do not give detailed feedback to the child while doing the test. If you need to give encouragement, keep it non-committal. “Great work – well done!” Evaluating results When the test is completed, count up the errors. Use the table below to determine appropriate action (see note below). If there are numerous errors, the child may need to be referred to an audiologist. If there are only a few errors, ensure that this aspect is included in the child’s tuition and re-test after one term. If no progress (or very limited progress) is apparent despite remediation, consider referring the child to an audiologist. Note: Bear in mind that the following table is only a guideline. Use your professional judgement and knowledge of the child to decide on appropriate action. In the case of a younger child (below 8 yrs), glue ear is a strong possibility. This needs to be diagnosed as soon as possible if the child’s phonological and other auditory processing skills are not to be affected. 4-5 Extra Tuition monitor 4 – 7 errors 6-7 3 – 6 errors 7+ errors 8-10 2 – 5 errors 6+ errors 10+ 2-4 errors 5+ errors Age and Refer to Audiologist 8+ errors Use the table at the bottom of the form to analyse specific difficulties. Count the number of errors in each category. This will identify if there are particular difficulties with initial, end or medial sounds, or with blends. General notes Not all sound combinations are included – this would take far too long. The samples provided will give a good indication of auditory discrimination problems. The teacher can add in further combinations if required. 32 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 The Learning Staircase Auditory Discrimination Test Name: _____________________________________ Age: _________________ Reason for test: ______________________________________________________________ Tester: _____________________________________ Date: ________________ I = initial sounds, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 car pin sell bug badge whistle win king lathe bag vine sleep go stain dig scream grow shoot sick pray Initial Sounds Final Sounds Medial Sounds Blends F – final sounds, M – medial vowel sounds, B - Blends √/X R tar I 21 card cart pin 22 sit set shell I 23 back bat bud F 24 rich rich badge 25 sack smack thistle I 26 thin thing wind F 27 cot cut king 28 pill pill laid F 29 dale gale bug M 30 thread shred fine I 31 scar star sleek F 32 ship chip grow Bl 33 din bin stain 34 bell ball dug M 35 leg leg stream Bl 36 bet but glow Bl 37 fat flat shot M 38 lack lake thick I 39 stick stick play Bl 40 back bag Items (cross through incorrect ones) c/t s/sh wh/th v/f s/th g/d n/d th/d p/k t/d a/u i/u oo/o i/e o/u g/gr scr/str gr/gl pr/pl s/sm √/X R F M F Bl F M I Bl Bl I I M M Bl M F Errors g/d d/b sh/ch /8 k/t n/ng k/g /8 e/a(ll) e/u a/a-e /8 thr/shr sc/st f/fl /8 33 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Phonological Screening Test Name: ___________________________ Date: ______________ Phonemic Awareness Initial Sounds “I’m going to say some words. Tell me the first sound you hear in each word.” Example: “dog” “Yes, the first sound is ‘d’” cat ______ egg ______ goat ______ sheep ______ chips ______ thing ______ octopus ______ eel ______ Final Sounds “I’m going to say some more words. This time, tell me the last sound you hear in each word.” Example: “top” “Yes, the last sound is ‘p’” rat ______ take _______ last _______ pink _______ fresh _______ discuss ________ graph ________ earth _______ Medial Sounds “I’m going to say some more words. This time, tell me the middle sound you hear in each word.” Example: “cake” “Yes, the middle sound is ‘a’” loan ________ file ________ take ________ seem ________ head _________ cup ________ lot __________ thick _______ Syllabification “Tap these words on the table and tell me how many beats you can hear in each word.” example: “Elephant” 3 beats hospital ______ automatic _______ table ________ hippopotamus ____ carry ______ Do antelope ______ white _______ Blending Onset + rime “Listen to these chunks. Put them together and tell me the word.” t – op _____ st – and ________ 3-phonemes “Now put these sounds together and tell me the word.” c – a – p ______ s – ou – p _______ r – ai – n _______ r – ip ________ 34 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 thr – ead _______ m – a – n ______ 4-phonemes “Now put these sounds together and tell me the word.” s – t – o – p _____ s – o – f – t ______ Rhyme “Listen to these words and tell me which two rhyme.” Check that the learner understands what ‘rhyme’ means. Give one or two examples. dog – sock – log ___________ bun – rug – run _____________ pet – tap – rap ___________ cat – fan – mat ______________ dust – rust – pest ___________ fate – late – made ___________ Generating rhyme “Tell me some words which rhyme with these ones.” hat, mat ____________________ l – i – s – t ______ t – r – ai – n ______ whip, rip __________________ 35 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Phonological Checklist Pupil Name: ____________________________ Aspect Problem detected Auditory Discrimination: Initial sounds Final sounds Medial sounds Blends Phonemic Awareness: Initial sounds Final sounds Medial sounds Syllabification Blending: Onset + rime 3-phonemes 4-phonemes Rhyme: Generating rhyme Recognising rhyme 36 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Sample Lesson Plan - Two learners. Three 50 minute sessions per week - Teacher-led activity Session 1 Mins Learner 1 Learner 2 10-15 Word Race Computer – Steps 10 Steps – practice own list Work with teacher 10 Rhyme Game, followed by initial, final and medial sound activity 10 Work with teacher 5-10 Memory game/activity Computer - Steps Session 2 Mins Learner 1 Learner 2 10-15 Computer - Steps Word Race 10 Work with teacher Steps – practice own list 10 Phonics or language game 10 Work with teacher 5-10 Perceptual game/activity Computer - Steps Session 3 Mins Learner 1 Learner 2 10-15 Computer - Steps Work with teacher 10 Work with teacher Computer - Steps 10 Phonics or language game 10 Group or individual work with teacher 5-10 Perceptual game/activity 37 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Sample Lesson Plan - Three learners. Four 60 minute sessions per week - Teacher-led activity Session 1 Mins Learner 1 Learner 2 Learner 3 10-15 Word Race Computer – Steps Computer – Steps 5-10 Steps/workbook activity Work with teacher Steps/workbook activity 10 Rhyme Game, followed by initial, final and medial sound activity 10-15 Steps/workbook activity 5-10 Memory game/activity (if time permits) Steps/workbook activity Work with teacher Session 2 Mins Learner 1 Learner 2 Learner 3 10-15 Computer – Steps Word Race Computer – Steps 5-10 Steps/workbook activity Steps/workbook activity Work with teacher 10 Vowel Ladder Game (sample game) followed by short memory activity 10-15 Work with teacher 5-10 Memory game/activity (if time permits) Steps/workbook activity Steps/workbook activity Session 3 Mins Learner 1 Learner 2 Learner 3 10-15 Computer – Steps Computer - Steps Word Race 5-10 10-15 Work with teacher Steps/workbook activity Steps/workbook activity Listening Skills activity, e.g. listening to story or passage, then discussing and answering questions – whole group activity. Steps/workbook activity Work with teacher Steps/workbook activity 5-10 Vocabulary/language game (if time permits) 10 Session 4 Mins Learner 1 Learner 2 Learner 3 10 Work with teacher Computer – Steps Computer – Steps 10 Steps/workbook activity Work with teacher Steps/workbook activity 20 Language activity or game 10 Steps/workbook activity Steps/workbook activity Work with teacher 10 Visual perception game/activity (if time permits) 38 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Organisational requirements Quiet room with no distractions Teaching table in centre – ideally round or oval (better for games Computer for each learner Headphones for each learner – ideally ‘earmuff’ type Plug-in microphone for recording new words – not often used Easy access to printer is ideal – can print off worksheets/homework Additional resources Essential for maximum effectiveness: Selection of hands-on game materials, including Stargame resources Very beneficial: Supporting software – maths, memory, listening skills, reading comprehension Record keeping suggestions Print off a record booklet/set of recording forms for each pupil or each group. Have a separate folder for each pupil or group, which contains all of their records 39 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Recording Forms Suggested composition of Teaching Record Book Front Section Single learner or group information Assessment information with pre-test dates Background information on that learner/s if relevant Photocopied Word Demons sheet (from Steps to Lit Teacher Manual) for each learner Divider – coloured sheet or card (so that it’s easy to turn to the teaching records easily) Teaching Records Section Recording forms printed back to back. Include as many as you wish, i.e. one or two terms’ worth of sheets. Options: 1. Bind a separate book for each learner using the individual learner sheets. 2. Bind a book for that group using one sheet or half a sheet per lesson, with each learner’s information in a separate box. This gives you a record of the whole session and is easier to use in a group situation. However, you may wish to keep each learner’s records separate even though they may be taught in a group. Notes: If using the form for two or three learners, you can replace the ‘Name: ____________’ bit by just the learner’s name. These recording forms are in Word format on the website and can be downloaded and copied freely. 40 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Teaching Record Session: ____ Date: ________________________ Lesson Feedback/Planning Name: _____________________ Name: _____________________ Name: ____________________ Session: ____ Date: ________________________ Lesson Name: _____________________ Name: _____________________ Name: ____________________ Feedback/Planning Session: ____ Date: ________________________ Lesson Feedback/Planning Name: _____________________ Name: _____________________ Session: ____ Date: ________________________ Lesson Feedback/Planning Name: _____________________ Name: _____________________ 42 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Teaching Record Lesson Session: ____ Date: ________________________ Feedback/Planning 43 © The Learning Staircase Ltd 2012 Notes