exhibit 6 - Tony Webster
Transcription
exhibit 6 - Tony Webster
CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 1 of 46 EXHIBIT 6 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 2 of 46 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA Harvey Duranseau, Plaintiff, PRELIMINARY EXPERT REPORT OF STEVEN GRAYBOW,JD v. Portfolio Recovery Associates, LLC Defendant 1. COURT FILE NO.: 13-CV-00955-PJS-LIB Introduction I have been retained by Gll,BERT LAW OFFICE PLLC and THOMPSON, HALL SANTI, CERNY, & DOOLEY (hereinafter "Counsel") acting on behalf of and for the benefit of Plaintiff Harvey Duranseau (''Plaintiff'), in the above entitled matter. I have been asked by Counsel to review Defendant debt collector Portfolio Recovery Associates, LLC ("Defendant'')'s discovery responses, all pleadings, declarations, and affidavits filed in this matter. My credentials are attached in the form of curriculum vitae. EXHIBIT A. Exhibit 2 provides a listing of the files I have relied upon to form my opinion(s). EXHIBIT B. I reserve the right to amend or supplement this report upon the receipt and review of any additional documentation or information that has not been produced as of the date of this report. I may be called to testify at trial regarding documents produced and testimony taken after the date of this report. I may also be called to testify in rebuttal to any matters or issues offered by the Defendant in this matter. In testimony at trial, I may utilize, as exhibits, certain documents produced in this suit and/ or described in Appendix B to this report I may also rely upon documents produced 1 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 3 of 46 and testimony taken after the date of this report. In addition, I may utilize appropriate exhibits in response to matters or issues presented by Plaintiff in this action. Due to the unique nature of my expertise, I have not testified as an expert in a court action. 2. Overview of Engagement: My assignment was to evaluate both parties' claims and the production of documents relating to the number and content of phone calls between Defendant and Plaintiff. The damages suffered by Plaintiff stem from violations of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, as alleged in Plaintiffs Verified Second Amended Complaint. 3. Expert Qualifications and Compensation Steven Graybow is the Principal of Graybow Network Solutions I.LC. He has been in the telecommunications industry for over twenty (20) years. He has assisted hundreds of businesses, specifically including law firms and debt collection agencies, with the installation/ management of telecommunication systems as well as providing other telecorrununications solutions to these businesses. He offers his clients over twenty different telecommunication carriers which includes but is not limited to Sprint, Verizon, Level 3 Communications, Global Crossing (a subsidiary of Level 3), Comcast, Integra, CenturyLink, Cox, AT&T, and Integra. Mr. Graybow's compensation is not contingent on any action or event resulting from the analyses,opinions or conclusions in, or the use of, this report. Mr. Graybow's work on this matter is billed at an hourly rate of $225 per hour. Rates for personnel assisting him range from $110 to $150 per hour. 4. Parties and Background Plaintiff Harvey Duranseau is a consumer from Big Falls, Minnesota. Mr. Duranseau received between 25 to 50 phone calls to his home landline telephone from Defendant debt collector. Plaintiff suffered severe emotional distress as a result of the communications to him by Defendant which included the use of profanity and insults, as asserted in the Second Amended Complaint. Defendant Portfolio Recovery, LLC is a debt collection company based in Norfolk, Virginia. Defendant is a publically traded company with a market capitalization of approximately $3,000,000,000. 5. Fair Debt Collection Practices Act 2 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 4 of 46 The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act prohibits debt ~ollectors from engaging in abusive, deceptive, and unfair debt collection practices. Congress has acknowledged that "[a]busive debt collection practices contribute to the number of personal bankruptcies, to marital instability, to the loss of jobs, and to invasions of individual privacy." 15 U.S.C. 1692(a). 6. Summary of Plaintiff's Claims The Verified Second Amended Complaint identifies that Plaintiff .received approximately fifty (50) phone calls to his phone number ending in 2048 from October 2012 to February 2013. The Verified Second Amended Complaint also asserts that Defendant called Plaintiff on or about December 28, 2014 and called him a "nigger" and told him to suck their clicks. In support of his claims, Plaintiff has offered Affidavits from Art Trickey and Denise Maurer who, according to their affidavits, heard the phone conversation asserted in Plaintiff's verified Complaint on or about December 28, 2012. 7. Summary of Defendant's Claims Defendant claims that it only called Plaintiffs phone number ending in 2048 twenty-five (25) times. Defendant denies the occurrence of the phone call that took place on or about December 28, 2012. In support ·of its claim, Defendant has offered a Declaration of Tara Privette, an employee of Defendant, and its own fotemal call logs. Defendant has not offered or otherwise produced call logs from its phone carrier(s) or an otherwise independent third party. 8. Addressing the Conflicting Accounts I have reviewed Plaintiff's Frontier landline telephone records ending in 2048. HD00001442. The records detail only outgoing phone calls and not incoming phone calls. I understand Frontier communications does not keep information relating to non-billable incoming phone calls on its residential landline service. Without this information, there is no way to clispositively identify the number of phone calls placed by Defendant to Plaintiffs phone ending in 2048 and resolve Defendant's claim regarding the phone call that took place on or about December 28, 2012. Defendant has produced internal call logs and internal phone recordings from phone numbers in which it claims it used to call Plaintiff. Even with this information, there is no 3 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 5 of 46 way to dispositively identify that the phone numbers Defendant claims it used to call Plaintiff were only the phone numbers identified by Defendant.1 Based upon the available information, any of the following could explain the parties, differing accounts of the phone call that took place on or about December 28, 2012 and the number of phone calls placed by Defendant to Plaintiff: 1) Defendant has the phone recording of the communication that took place on or about December 28, 2012, and/ or other communications, and has failed to produce records of the communications, whether intentionally or by administrative oversight. 2) Defendant may have failed to link one or more of Defendant's phone numbers to one the three accounts associated with Thomas Duranseau,s account See e.g., Declaration of Tara Privette dated March 5, 2014 at ,I18. 3) Defendant deleted or otherwise destroyed the phone recording of the communication that took place on or about December 28, 2012 as well as other communications between the parties. 4) Due to technical error, which includes but is not limited to a software error, closing PRA.net software, or a computer crash, or an act of one of Defendant's employees or agents, Defendant never recorded the phone call on or about December 28, 2012 See,e.g.,Declaration of Tara Privette dated March 5, 2014 at 1117. 5) One of Defendant's employees used a personal cell phone or "burner phone" to make the phone call to Plaintiff on or about December 28, 2012 and Defendant does not otherwise have documentation of the phone call. 6) According to Defendant's purported theory, Plaintiff fa~ricated the contents of one phone call, the phone call on or about December 28, 2012. 9. Incorporation of Affidavit dated August 7m I Assuming the phone call that took place on or about December 28, 2012 came from one of Defendant's phone numbers, and not a personal phone number of Defendant, it is conceivable that the production of all of Defendant's invoices from Defendant's telecommunication carriers for each of Defendant's phone numbers could be dispositive on this issue. However, Defendant has more than 4,000 employees and call centers in Alabama, Kansas, Nevada, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia. EXHIBIT C. Defendant has represented that it has seven (T) different phone carriers throughout the course of its international operations. Stipulation re: Discovery dated April 4, 2014 at 5. Defendant places approximately 3 million calls per day 5 days a week and about 1.5 million calls the other two days. Id. Even if subpoenas are submitted to all of Defendant's telephone carriers, the telephone carriers may only be able to produce documents relating to the spe.cificphone numbers used by Defendant, which numbers could easily be in the hundreds to thousands. See HD000204-HD000239. 4 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 6 of 46 I also incorporate my J\ffidavit dated August 7, 2014 as a part of this Report. EXHIBIT D. 10. Provisional Findings and Conclusions As of the date of this repot:t, I have not received sufficient informadon identify the accuracy of Plaintiff and Defendant's to dispositively claims as they relate to the number of phone calls and the phone call that took place on or about December 28, 2012. Since Frontier has no record of incoming phone calls to Plaintiff and it would be financially unfeasible to obrain phone records from everyone of Defendant's phone numbers (which number in the hundreds, if nor rhousamJs), resolving the issue may be best left to the personal knowledge of Plain riff, J\rt Trickey, Denise Maurer, and Tara Privette. Yours Truly, ~~r Gravbow Network Solutions , 5 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 7 of 46 EXHIBIT A CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 8 of 46 Steven Graybow [email protected] 952-905-3105 CEO Graybow Network Solutions InformationTechnology and Servicesindustry President Graybow Telecommunications, LLC InformationTechnology and Services industry March 2004 - October 2007 (3 years 8 months) TelecommunicationsNetwork Servicesanalysis, consultingand agent for multiple service providersto deliver cost savings, solutions,expertise, and on-going support to businesses. coo Advanced Communication Technologies June 1991-May 1995 (4 years) _ Ran operationsfor company specializingin aggregatingAT&T long distance services for businesseson a national basis CFO & Head of Builders Division Graybow Daniels Co. InformationTechnology and Services industry August 1982-April 1991 (8 years 9 months} Assi~nt County Attorney Hennepin County Attorney's Office October 1977-April 1981 (3 years 7 months) EDUCATION Universityof MinnesotaLaw School Universityof Minnesota-TwinCities Universityof Colorado Boulder CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 9 of 46 EXHIBITB CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 10 of 46 Documents reviewed and relied upon in this report: > PRAHDOOOOOl-316; ).,, HD00001-HD000207; ).,, Verified Complaint; > Verified Amended Complaint; ).,, Verified Second Amended Complaint; ).,, Affidavit of Harvey Duranseau dated September 9, 2013; ).,, Affidavit of Denise Maurer dated September 9, 2013; ).,, Affidavit of Art Trickey dated September 13, 2013; ).,, All pleadings filed in this matter; ).,, Defendant's Supplemental Answers to Plaintiffs Discovery Responses dated May 28, 2014; . ).,, Stipulation re: Discovery dated April 4, 2014; ).,, Verification of Tara Privette dated March 5, 2014; and ).,, Supplemental Verification of Tara Privette dated March 12, 2014. CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 11 of 46 EXHIBITC CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 12 of 46 PRA Group ~~~ A World Leaderin AcquiringNon-PerformingConsumerDebt Offering comprehensive multinational solutions to global banks and credit issuers The only debt buyer with true U.S.,Canadian and European coverage across a wide variety of defaulted and insolvent customer account segments ~ Returning capital to lenders, strengthening their ability to more attractively price credit to consumers ~ ~ Headquarters: Norfolk.Virginia -> Employees: Morethan 4,000 Committed to continued, growing acquisitions in North America and Europe -} Significantaccess to capital """fIndustry-leading analytics that ensure best long-term pricing based on highly accurate underwriting and efficient collection operations -{, U.S.Call Centers: Birmingham,Alabama Hutchinson,l<ansas LasVegas,Nevada Jackson,Tennessee North RichlandHills,Texas Hampton,Virginia Norfolk.Virginia A 20-Year Recordof GlobalConsumerProtectionlaw Compliance A patient focus on customers most likely to pay bacl<their debt ~ Proprietary valuation and scoring models based on data from more than 43 million customer accounts over the past 20 years Guides a global network of best-in -class account representatives -t No offshore management of U.S.accounts or data, with seven owned-and-operated U.S.call centers ...+Deep servicing experience with nine in-house servicing centers plus access to more than 50 servicing partners across Canada and Europe - ----·..--· ... ·-----·----·- ...... .....·,,·--··- -· ~ .... ·-- -·- -·-· -.-- ---. ·····--· -····-- ...--.... - --}-In-HouseServicing Centers: Austria,Canada,England, Finland,Germany,Norway, Scotland,Spain and Sweden ·-l> Shareholder Value: Revenueand net income CAGRof 24% since 2003 Largestpubliclyowned debt buyer,with more than $2.SBmarket cap ~ ,u111'UNV. · ·100 - Our Business ~ Core Acquisitionsand Collections: Acquisitionand servicing of defaulted customer accounts from major credit grantors and other consumer debt owners in the U.S.and Canada. -+ Insolvency Investment Services: Acquisitionand servicing of secured and unsecured insolvent customer accounts from leading banking institutions, retail banks and other specialty finance providers in the U.S..Canada and the U.1<. ~ "1} ~ ~ PRAGroup Europe:Acquisitionand servicing of non-performing consumer loans from leading banks and financial institutions throughout Europe. Also offers contingent collection services in the U.1<. MuniServicesand RDS:Business tax revenue administration, audit, discovery and recovery services for state and local governments in the U.S. -> PRALocation Services: Forwarding,skip tracing.transportation, license plate recognition and FASTEST collateral recovery for auto lenders, insurance companies, law enforcement and other clients ·------ . ---· g:9~f~ ~,·--' --..--~ -·· "'? in the U.S. and Canada. Claims Compensation Bureau: Securities and antitrust class action claims filingand purchasing on behalf of institutional investors and corporate clients in the U.S.and Europe. CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 13 of 46 EXHIBITD CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 14 of 46 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA Harvey Duranseau, AFFIDAVIT OF STEVEN GRAYBOW, JD Plaintif~ v. Portfolio Recovery Associates, LLC Defendant. COURT FILE NO.: 13-CV-00955-PJS-LIB STATE OF MINNESOTA ) COUN1Y OF HENNEPIN ) ) ss. Steven Graybow, being duly sworn under oath, deposes and states as follows: 1. I have been retained by Plaintiff as a expert in telecommunications above entitled matter. in the 2. I offer this affidavit in support of Plaintiffs motion to enforce the terms of · the Stipulation re: discovery dated April 4, 2014 and to otherwise compel discovery. 3. I have been in the telecommunications industry for over twenty (20) years. My curriculum vitae is attached as EXHIBIT A I have assisted hundreds of businesses, specifically including law finns and debt . collection agencies, with the installation/management of telecommunication systems as well as provide other telecommunications solutions to these businesses. 4. I offer my clients over twenty different telecommunication providers which include but are not limited to Sprint, Verizon, Level 3 Communications, Global Crossing (a subsidi.ary of Level 3), Comcast, Integra, Century Link, AT&T, Cox, and Integra. 5. I have reviewed the following documents produced by Defendant, Portfolio Recovery Associates, LLC: Stipulation re: Discovery dated April 4, 2014; and Defendant's Supplemental Answer to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories dated May 28, 2014; PRAHD0000016-59,68, 85. 1 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 15 of 46 6. Typically, large companies that make numerous outgoing phone calls, specificallyincluding debt collection companies, are charged for every phone call made by their telecommunication provider. A typical invoice from the telecommunication provider will detail, the time, date, length of the phone call, the phone number which was called, the amount owed for each phone call, as well as other information. Consistent with my experience,Defendant unequivocallystated the following: Because PM is not charged for non-connected calls, it has no way of determining what carrier it used for those calls. Stipulation re: Discovery dated April 4, 2014 at 5. I understand Defendant has refused to provide Plaintiff with the invoices which detail the phone calls made from Defendant to Plaintiff. See Plaintiff's Second Set of Document Production Requests at Request No. 1. These invoices should be clispositiveon information relating to the calls made from Defendant to Plaintiff from the phone numbers identified by Defendant 7. I have also reviewed Defendant's supplemental answer to Plaintiff's Interrogatory No. 6 dated May 28, 2014. EXHIBIT B. Defendant's answer to this interrogatory includes that Defendant used Sprint, Verizon, and Cox Communications as its telecommunication providers. The "ANI USED" on the right hand column purportedly references the phone numbers used by Defendant to call Plaintiff. After reviewing the chart, I discovered numerous errors, specificallyincluding the fact that the second and third entries list the phone number "678-265-1576" as belonging to both Sprint and ~nd Cox Communications when the carrier for the phone number is actually Level 3 Communications: TRN_ DATE 12/13/2012 436 78 Carrier ANIUSED AGENT TALK OFFNA¥E TIME TO HANG Verizon 4844892841 12182762048PRH823 64 86 12/15/2012 869 78 12182762048 PRTl22 20 50 Sprint 6782651576 12/16/2012 266 54 12182762048PRA296 14 38 Cox 6782651576 TELELINE COMPCODE PHONE NUM 8. I have reviewed Defendant's sworn representations and created a chart documenting the errors in Defendant's sworn interrogatory answer. EXHIBIT C. For all twenty-five (25) phone calls purportedly made by Defendant to Plaintiff, Defendant failed to correctly identify a single phone carrier that corresponds to the purported phone numbers used by Defendant to call Plaintiff. As reflected in Exhibit A, if the phone numbers represented by Defendant are even correct, the phone carriers corresponding to the phone numbers provided by Defendant are Level 3 Communications (Global Crossing), Pac-West, and Cox, not Sprint, Verizon, and Cox as represented by Defendant. Based upon Defendant's false representations, I understand Plaintiff has spent 2 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 16 of 46 substantial time in trying to snbpocna Communications. this infomrntion from Verizon, Sprint, and Cox l have reviewed the call logs producc<l by Defe ndant. The call logs appear to 9. be produced by Defendant in variot1s software packages, suc h as Microsoft: Exce l. None of the call logs produced are from a telephone carrier or otherwise independent third party . l state under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed On: 7-+------ ' 2014 E,~---JIJ Steven Graybcy-,JD _,,~,c;_..,,/ __ Subscribed and sworn to before me this~ day of August , 20 14 A4 /_-CP~ / CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 17 of 46 EXHIBIT A CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 18 of 46 StevenGraybow [email protected] 952-905-3105 CEO Graybow Network Solutions Currentlyholds this position President Graybow Telecommunications, LLC March 2004 - October 2007 (3 years 8 months) TelecommunicationsNetwork Servicesanalysis, consultingand agent for multiple serviceproviders to deliver cost savings, solutions, expertise,and on-going support to businesses. coo Advanced Communication Technologies June 1991-May 1995 (4 years) Ran operationsfor company specializingin aggregatingAT&T long distance services for businesseson a national basis CFO & Head of Builders Division Graybow Daniels Co. PrivatelyHeld; 11-50 employees; lnfonnation Technologyand Services industry August 1982- April 1991 (8 years 9 months) Assistant County Attorney Hennepin County Attorney's Office October 1977- April 1981 (3 years 7 months) EDUCATION UniversityofMi _nnesota Law School Universityof Minnesota-TwinCities Universityof Colorado Boulder CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 19 of 46 EXHIBITB CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 20 of 46 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRlCT OF MINNESOTA Harvey Duranseau, Case No.: 0:13-cv-00955 Plaintiff, Jury Trial Demanded vs. PortfolioRecovery Associates,LLC, Defendant. DEFENDANT'S SUPPLEMENT AL ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST ~ET OF INTERROGATORIES Defendant Portfolio Recovery Associates,LLC ("PRA"), pursuant to.Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 33, hereby submits the following supplemental answer to Plaintiff Harvey Duranseau' s First Set of Interrogatories("First Set") to PRA. PRA incorporates by reference its general objections to Plaintiff's First Set and provides the following supplementalanswer: . ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES INTERROGATORY NO. 6: Provide the name, address, and telephonenumber for the company(ies)[sic] that providedtelephone services to Defendant for every communicationwith Pla~tiff. ANSWER: PRA incorporatesits general objections. PRA objects to the phrase "telephone services,,as vague and ambiguous.PRA also objects to this Interrogatoryto the extent it seeks proprietary or confidentialbusiness information. PRA further objects to this Interr.ogatoryto the extent it seeks informationnot relevant or reasonablycalculated to CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 21 of 46 lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.(SeeDocumentNo. 43.) SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWER: This SupplementalAnswer supplementsand does not supplant, displace or replace PRA's prior answer to InterrogatoryNo. 6 as set forth in its Answers to Plaintiffs First Set. Moreover, :PRA's prior answer to InterrogatoryNo. 6 is incorporatedby reference into th.is SupplementalAnswer. Subjectto and without waiving PRA'~ gener~land specif1cobjections,PRA states: TRN DATE TELELINE 12/13/2012 12/15/2012 12/16/2012 12/18/2012 12/26/2012 12/26/20.12 12/26/2012 12/28/2012 1213 .0/2012 1/3/2013 115/2013 1/7/2013 1n12013 1/9/2013 1117/201.3 1/19/2013 1121/2013 1129/2013 1/29/2013 1/29/2013 1/31/2013 2/2/2013 2/4/2013 2/6/2013 2/6/2013 436 869 266 508 I 799 812 929 838 659 140 477 138 693 719 930 652 779 5.16 681 915 778 123 318 622 COMPCODE AGENT NAME PHONE 78 78 54 52 13 54 54 78 13 78 54 15 78 52 78 '78 52 15 13 54 54 78 54 54 62 NUM 12182762048 PRH823 12182162048 PRT122 1218276204'8'PRA296 12182762048 PRB047 12182762048 12182762048 . PRAI25 l.2182762048 PRK721 12182762048 PRT191 12182762048 12182762048 PRH186 12.182,762048 .P.RA087 12182762048 · 12182762 '048 PRT024 12182762048 PRH008 12182762048 PE.H343 12182762048 PRK735 12182762048 PRK022 12182762048 12182762048 12182762048 · PRI<.075 12182762048 PRB155 12182762048 PRA625 12182762048 PRKOl9 12182762048 PRA028 )2182762048 PRA339 2 TALK TIME 64 20 14 55 0 19 16 45 0 6 46 0 .50 211 80 42 134 O' 0 28 41 63 57 94 II OFF_ TO HANG Carrier 86 Verizon so 38 77 30 47 39 67 27 26 70 34 81 230 104 62 152 32 31 42 66 90 74 107 28 Sorint Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Verizon Cox Sorint Cox Snrint Verizon Sorint Snrint Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox ANIUSED 4844892841 6782651576 6782651576 4122821423 4433131382 4122821423 4122821423 4844892841 678265L576 4433131382 6262092244 7578640020 7024107497 4122821423 4433131382 6262092244 7024107497 4i22821423 7024107497 7024107497 4844892841 6262092244 7024107497 4433131382 4122821423 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 22 of 46 DATED: May 28, 2014 ROBINS, KAPLAN, MILLER & CIRESI L.L.P. 800 LaSalleAvenue 2800 LaSallePlaza Minneapolis,MN 55402-2015 6f2-349-8500 [email protected] [email protected] ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOCIATES, LLC 3 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 23 of 46 VERIFICATION I am Tara Privette, Senior Vice President of Operations at Portfolio Recovery Associates, LLC, a party to this action. I have read the foregoing ANSWERSTO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORlESTO DEFENDANTand am authorizedto sign this Verification. I am informedthat no single officer of Portfolio. RecoveryAssociates, LLC has personal knowledgeof all matters stated in the foregoing responses,that authorized employees,agents, have assembled the facts stated in such responsesand/or legal representativesof PortfolioRecovery Associates, LLC. I am further informedand believe and on that ground allege that the facts stated in such responsesare true and correct, based on the records of Portfolio Recovery Associates, LLC and informationreasonably availableto its employees,agents, and/or legal representatives. Executed on May 27th, 2014, in Norfolk, Virginia. I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Virginia that the foregoingis true and correct. By~~ Tara Privette 8482SSl3.2 4 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 24 of 46 EXHIBITC CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 25 of 46 TRN DATE TELELJNE PHONE NUM TALK Defendant's TIME irepresentation iregarding Carrier 12/13/2012 12/15t2012 12/16/2012 12/18/2012 436 869 266 508 12182762048 12182762048 12182762048 12/26'201 2 I 12182762048 12/26/2012 12/26/2012 12/28/2012 12/30/2012 113/2013 115/2013 117/2013 799 812 9 29 121 82762048 64 20 14 55 0 19 16 45 0 6 Verizon Sprint Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Verizon Cox Sprint Cox Sprint Verizon Sprint Sprint Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox Cox 838 659 140 477 12 l 8Z762048 12182762048 12182762048 12182762008 1218Z762008 12182762048 12182762048 138 693 12182762048 12182762048 211 12182762048 l 2182762048 80 42 1/21/2013 1/29/2013 1!29!2013 1 /29/2013 719 930 652 779 516 68 1 12182762048 12182762048 12182762048 12182762048 1/31/2013 212/2013 915 778 1218 2762048 12182762048 13 4 0 0 28 41 63 2/412013 2/6/2013 12 3 3 18 121 82762048 12182762048 57 2/6,2013 622 12182762048 11 Cox 117/2013 1/9/2013 1/1712)13 1/ 19/2013 46 0 50 94 Actual Ca rr ier ANI USED Level 3 Level3 4844892841 6782651576 6782651576 4122821423 4433131382 Level3 Level3 Level3 Level 3 Level 3 Level 3 Level3 Level 3 Level 3 Cox Pac-Wes t Level 3 Level 3 Level3 P ac-West Level3 Pa c-West Pnc-West 4122821423 4122821423 4844892841 6782651576 4433131382 6262092244 7578640020 70241(J74'}7 4 122821 423 4433131382 6262092244 7024107497 4122821 423 7024107497 7024107497 Level3 Level3 Pac-West Level3 4844892841 6262092244 Level 3 4122821423 7024 10 7497 4433131382 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 26 of 46 1-484-489-2841/ 4844892&11 is a landline PhooeI VV11i tePages 7/10/2014 Level3 Landline in Philadelphia, PA 1-484-489-2841 Get a foll report about the ow.ner. Sponsored by l'coplcSmarL.com (484) 489-28 ,p Narne Available View Owner 's Name View Owner's Address Sponsored Special: 7-Dny Unlimited Search Trial Sponsored by l'copleSmart.c oni J\U\IVII ~ \V, ·t,N!l 1U~~{; · Penn Wynne lo .., , Havertown ~ " G'... · lvhllbo urnc . Eas1Lansdowne ·; Lansdowne 2j. :,t} . i CHN , -?P.-,,.,, c,."'l' ,ringfield . ,; · ,,<~ ,,.;, .,,-" ,,,, 71 \,. ...... Upper Darby ' Drexel Hill I> .'I. .:· ' -~ ; ... ' ,~;~: : ··:·--· !::' ..... '";i i IV '"t:, '911A,·<' . ci <:...IS ( r ,nJ: ...~ ',\ :l,c "' ~ ·"~"'~,~~~ ,· .. 1(1., Y. ,~;.v .:. ~ Cu~-. ;- ,,. .. - t;. '!: J 3 Pennsauken • .r . . 'f~ ~ Maple Sh. Merchantville .y· f..r, "'""~ Yeadon ; - ~ Golden . Triangle Cherry Hill Mal EOP f•l . .-·.·t l,•t,·.;,.• Clirton Heights Ji.....\ : , ,. f :.0.•I' , 1o; Cherry Hil! c, ..,..,,, .• ,., • ·., 1,••:. '!,/ ••; .. .:, .., 627 Darby Aldan Collingswood Collingdale Colwyn f.u. :<.c.1·: , £ ::·..i~J,: ·:i:'~ ::· :: ·J:-:· t ; :·, !.; •. J Area Code:484 Carricr:Lc.vcl:>, full Nurnher : 1-484-489-2841 City/State: Philadelphia , PA Sec a map of all United Stat es Arca Codc.s» Report this number Select CallType Default Debt Collector Fax Machine Political Call Non-Profil Survey Telemarketer 1-langUp Prank Call Legitimale Business Legitimate lnclividual Other !Default T j hllp:/M\wt.vAlitepages.com'phone/1-484-489-2841 1/3 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 27 of 46 1·484-489-2841 / 4844892841 is a landllnePhoneI 'MlltePages 7110/2014 Caller's Name lca11er's!"~me Your Name iyourName !,c ave a c omment ab ou t. t he c all e e here Leave a comment about the caller here * Your name and comments will be visible on WhitePages . "' ISubmit ! Thanks, your comment has been submitted. Recent Comments An Android User3/11/2013 Bottom feeding third party debt collector. T ry to call and scare or harass you into paying debt that is not real . All it takes is 1 letter and I'll stop calling you forever An Android User3/7 / 2013 portfolio recovery An Android Users/2/2013 bill collector An Android User3/2/2013 bill collector An Android User2/22/2013 Debt collector Jessie2/ 22/2013 Got a callfrom them. Dont know who they are so I dont answer but jf its a debt collector then idk how they got my number cuz this is a new number thru a different company and the account for the phone isnt in my name so no idea how they would know my new number or why they would even be calling me . Super fricken annoying An iPhone User2/21/2013 I don't know who it is. They didn't leave a message. An Android User2/21/2013 I really wish they would remove my number from their call listl!II http:/!wNN .'Mlitepages.com'phone/1-484-489-2841 213 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 28 of 46 7110/2014 1-484-489-2841 / 4844892841 ls a landlinePhoneJ WhitePages An AndroidUser2/8/2013 Portfolio recovery Numbers Similar to 1-484-489-2841 1-484-489-2840 1-484-489-0922 1-484-489-2731 1-484-489-0539 1-484-489-0286 1-484-489-0089 1-484-489-2730 1-484-489-2845 1-484-489-5514 1-484-489-0463 1-484-489-0375 1-484-4 89-0594 1-484-489-0088 1-484-489 -2811 1-484-489-2814 1-484-489-2941 1-484-489-1664 1-484-489-8454 1-484-489-0420 1-484-489 -0924 1-484-489-0519 1-484-489-0986 1-484-489-0449 1-484-489-0277 Phone number directory 1-484-489-0000 1-484-489-0137 1-484-489-0214 1-484-489-0362 1-484-489-0454 1-484-489-0569 1-484 -489-0591 1-484-489-0686 1-484-489-0705 1-484-489-0707 1-484-489-0710 1-484-489-0723 1-484-489-0749 1-484-489-0848 1-484-489-0856 1-484-489-0953 1-484-489-0991 1-484-489-1006 1-484-489-1092 1-484-489-1160 1-484-489-1359 1-484-489-1366 1-484-489-1700 1-484-489 -2421 Browse all similar numbers © 2014 WhitePages Inc. - Privacy Policy and Terms of Use http:/lv,w.v.Yd'tltepages.corr/pha,e/1-484-489-2841 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 29 of 46 1-676-265-1576I 6782651576ls a landllnePhone I WhltePages 7/100.014 Level3 Land.line in Atlanta, GA 1-678-265-1576 Get a fullreport about the owner. Sponsored by WhitePages PRO 1-678 -265-1576 Name is available View owner's name for free » Try WhitePages PRO, no credit card required » Sponsored by WhitePages PRO l,S7 . Scotfdale _, // @:r=: -iI~ . -~VO'!~ale Decatui. · · · ·Estates ~'..< ,,.~-/" ~~,==~\.. . ~(~# - . ~__ ,A, ~RUT \...._ f!tDGtCAlST ~ \ AD:;st~lU .· /1./. .... •. KIMBlllLY . If OOl!TS i %'. - .· !'@ {f/~ L., .\ ·@I) ···· AN. H t~l . ~ (Asc.\Df @ii • !. ) ) b-bing . ·: ,. r... ....... .. . 1 AAOUY l!OAO Hl!GHTS .. \ ' GlfflwcoclRd ~ -i. ,; ·,· ~~~:::::::a:. . :· ..~ c~:~~ - ~"' t:rorh:am P:aw' Area Code:678 Carrier:Levels Full Number:1-678-265-1576 City /State:Atlanta, GA See a map of an United States Area Codes » Report this number Select CallType Default Debt Collector Fax Machine PoliticaJ Call Non-Profit Survey Telemarketer Hang Up Prank Call Legitimate Business Legitimate Individual Other !Default ..-j Caller's Name l calle(s Nam? http://wMY.v.hltepages.com'phone/1 -678-265-1576 1/3 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 30 of 46 1-67~265-1576 / 6782651576 ls a landline Phone I WhitePages 7/10/2014 Your Name !Your Name Lea ve a c onunen: ab out hei:e th e caller Leave a comment about the caller here • Your name and comments will be visible on WhitePages. /, ISubmit I Thanks, your comment has been submitted. Recent Comments RebeccaS/17/2013 Annoying An Android User3/11/2013 Excessive calling is not the word. lfyou can't leave a message and I guess it's not important. An Android User3/11/2013 zombie bill coUector An Android User3/3/2013 Collection Anonymousg/3/2013 Ticked again :(2/2/2013 They never give up, these old debts are 1 o+ yrs and the money they spend on phone calls could cover the national debt! An Android Useri/20/2013 spam An Android Useri/20/2013 Ga: it a couple times so I blocked it An Android Usen/19/2013 Portfolio recovery Numbers Similar to 1-678-265-1576 http'JMWW .v.hitepages.can'phone/1-~265-1576 213 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 31 of 46 7/10/2014 1-678-265-1576/ 6782651576ls a landllnePhone I WhltePages 1-678-265-1568 1-678-265-7097 1-678-265 -0161 1-678-265-0705 1-678-265-7505 1-678-265-7777 1-678-265-SSSo 1-678-265-0717 1-678-265-7273 1-678-265-88oo 1-678-265-0826 1-678-265-1598 1-678-265-0205 1-678- 265-0772 1-678-265-8382 1-678-265-0877 1-678- 265-1566 1-678-265-7952 1-678- 265-7894 1-678-265-7615 1-678-265-7703 1-678-265 -7084 1-678-265-0762 1-678-265-3834 Phone number directory 1-678-265-0003 1-678-265-0017 1-678-265-0021 1-678-265-0040 1-678-265-0043 1-678-265-0059 1-678-265-0107 1-678-265- 0108 1-678-265-0131 1-678-265-0160 1-678-265-0165 1-678-265-0171 1-678-265-0172 1-678-26s-0197 1-678-26s-0242 1-678-265-0243 1-678-26s -0245 1-678-265-0246 1-678-265-0273 1-678-265 -0293 1-678-265-0294 1-678-265-0315 1-678-265-0462 1-678-265-0468 Browse all similar numbers © 2014 WhitePages Inc . - Privacy Policy and Terms of Use htlp://w.wf.v.hltepages.com'phooe/1-678-265-1576 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 32 of 46 1·412·282·1423/ 4122821423 is a landllnePhoneI WhitePages 7/10/2014 Level3 Land.line in Pittsburgh , PA 1-412-282-1423 Get a full report about the owner. Sponsored by WhitePages PRO 1-412-282-1423 Name is available View owner's name for free » Try WhitePages PRO, no credit card required » Sponsored by WhitePages PRO · SandyCteek Churc: v.u• ..,~ .. ' ~ biia~.ile Cai:najie ! -'~n..i . 1 / (~ Area Code:412 carrier:Level3 Full Number:1-412-282-1423 City/State:Pittsburgh, PA See a map of all United States Area Codes » Report this number Select CallType Default Debt Collector Fax Machine Political call Non-Profit Survey Telemarketer Hang Up Prank Call Legitimate Business LegitiJnatelndividual Other !Default caner 's Name ,. , iCalle(s Name htlp"J/www.v.tlltepages .com'pha,e/1-412-282-1423 1/3 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 33 of 46 1-412-282·1423/ 4122821423ls a landllnePhone I WlitePages 7/10/2014 Your Name iYourNam! Leave a comment about t he c al ~er here Leave a comment about the caller here "Your name and comments will be visible on WhitePages. /, ISubmit! Thanks, your comment basbeen submitted. Recent Comments AnAndroid User3/10/2013 PortfolioRecovery An Android User3/4/2013 Portfolio Recovery. An Android User2/19/2013 Billcollector An Android User2/13/2013 Capital one An Android User2/12/2013 Collection An Android Usen/30/2013 bill collector An Android Usen/30/2013 PortfolioRecovery Associates An Android Usen/29/2013 Billcollectors An Android Useri/16/2013 sbc portfolioscollectionagencies A Web Usen/14/2013 htlp://www:,,hltepages.coov'phone/1-412-282-1423 213 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 34 of 46 1-412·282·1423/ 4122821423is a landllne Phone I WhilePages 7/10/2014 COLLECTIONCALLSFOR ANTHONYPOINDEXTER Numbers Similar to 1-412-282-1423 1-412-282-1421 1-412-282 ...1422 1-412-282-1420 1-412-282-1000 1-412-282-8114 1-412-282-1321 1-412-282-1424 1-412:-282-4210 1-412-282-0026 1-412-282-8685 1-412-282-5316 1-412-282-5249 1-412:-282-52:78 1-412-282-4123 1-412-282-1481 1-412-282-1009 1-412-282-5364 1-412-282-8255 1-412-282-1412 1-412-282-2141 1-412-282-1428 1-412:-282-1292: 1-412-282-2222 1-412-282-8456 Phone number directory 1-412-282-0065 1-412:-282-0409 1-412-282-0466 1-412 -282-0500 1-412-282-0802 1-412-282-0822 1-412:-282-0896 1-412-282-1001 1-412-282 - 1025 1- 412:-282-12:2:3 1-412:-2:82-1241 1-412-282-1322 1-412:-2:82:-1400 1-412:-282-1402 1-412-282-1426 1-412-282-1427 1-412-282-1452 1-412-282-1680 1-412-282-1723 1-412-282-1918 1-412-282-1996 1-412-282-2142 1-412-282 -2:2:16 1-412-282-2:229 Browse all similar numbers © 2014 WhitePages Inc. - Privacy Policy and Terms of Use http://WMv.v.hitepages.com'phale/1-412· 282-1423 313 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 35 of 46 1-443-313-1382/ 4433131382 ls a landllnePhone1WhitePages 7/10/2014 1-443-313-1382 Level3 Landline in Fork, MD Get a full report about the owner. Sponsored by WhitePages PRO 1-443-313-1382 Name is available View owner's name for free » Try WhitePages PRO, no credit card required» Sponsored by WhitePages PRO ·. Camlii t,,. · ~ '·....:5\~· .i;~_. _:{ . · I !J ? Knoebtl Blenheim .., .· .. . " .... t:t J:i· i:: ~M~~,: &~;~ Long Green ·~ I i [ .. 'if:.,·;'A·\ l ·T, I · l ,.,<..'' \ ,/···. ~~~'.·':· \~J·; aJJ,1'461·: / a ~bi~ · · ..-. . ~ .M O R ~ ./~ ·' ·; E C O UpP,erFalls ;:.. Area Code:443 Carrier:Level:3 Full Number :1-443-313-1382 City/State:Fork, MD See a map of all United States Area Codes» Report this number Select Call Type Default Debt Collector Fax Machine Political Call Non-Profit Survey Telemarketer Hang Up Prank Call Legitimate Business Legitimate Individual Other J Default T 1 .. - ! -- · Caller's Name :Caller'sName ttttp://wNN .witepages.can'phone/1-443-313-1382 1/3 7/10/2014 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 36 of 46 Your Name~ 1-443-313-1382 / 4433131382 is a landllnePhooeI WhltePages ~N~~e Leave a comment about the callee here Leave a conunent about the caller here * Your name and .comments will be visible on WhitePages . h. ISubmit l Thanks, your comment has been subm itted. Recent Comments AnAndroid Usery/8/2013 Sunrocket/portfdio An Android Usery /6/2013 OneCallFromThisNumber ...From A PersonThat Has Been Signing UpForDifferentNumbers For ThePurpose Of Harassment An Android User3/28/2013 Portfolio recovery An Android User3/6/2013 Portfolio AnAndroid User2/27/2013 All the time thy calln.. An Android User2/27 I 2013 stop calling me .. SandraLy1U1e1/31/2013 I just LOVEmr.number. anyway, I am a little more than tiredofp .r. calling me and my relatives, trying to intimidate. I am puzzled as to how they got the phone numbers of my family. I don't give those numbers out. Just sayin ' Ema1/27/2013 This person is extremely alUloying. I really hate my phone going off during classes. An Android Usen/24/2013 Unknown Number http://vN,w.YAlitepages.com'phone/1-443-313-1382 213 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 37 of 46 7/10/2014 1-443-313-1382 / 4433131382ls a landlinePhaie I WlitePages Numbers Similar to 1-443-313-1382 1-443-313-1381 1-443-313-1380 1-443-313-3500 1-443-313-0056 1-443-313-9761 1-443-313-5969 1-443-313-2310 1-443-313-1302 1-443-313-6519 1-443-313 -5733 1-443-313-9793 1-443-313-2003 1-443-313-3066 1-443-313-3695 1-443-313-5480 1-443-313-4020 1-443-313-7517 1-443-313-8420 1-443-313-1121 1-443-313-5211 1-443-313-0774 1-443-313-2703 1-443-313-1332 1-443-313-1328 Phone number directory 1-443-313-0335 1-443-313-0481 1-443-313-1033 1-443-313-1353 1-443-313-1387 1-443-313-7044 1-443-313-8414 1-443-313-8861 1-443-313-9162 Browse all similar numbers © 2014 WhitePages Inc. - Privacy Policy and Terms of Use http:/!w,,w.v.hltepages.com'phone/1-443-313-1382 313 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 38 of 46 1-626-209-2244 / 6262092244 is a landlinePhoneJ VVhitePages 81612014 1-626-209-2244 Level3 Land.line in Covina, CA Get a full report about the owner. Sponsored by Spokeo.com (626) 209-2244 Name Available View Owner's Name View Owner's Address Owner's Hidden Profiles & Background Report Sponsored by Spokeo.com hltpJ/www.v.hitepages.com-'phone/1 -626-209-2244 1/3 Bl6'2014 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Documentls101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 39 of 46 1-62&209-2244/ 6262092244 a landllne Pr.oneI WhltePages Caller's Name jcalle(s Name YourName !vour Neme Leave a co mme nt a bc 1:t th~ ,~illlel · he re Leavea oommentabout the caller here /, * Your name and oommentswillbe visibleon WhitePages. lffi,!ilimft rJ Thanks, your commentbasbeen submitted. Recent Comments An AndroidUser3/10/2013 collector An AndroidUsers/8/2013 bill collector An AndroidUsers/8/2013 Just another longlist of numbers used by portfoliorecovery. An AndroidUser3/8/2013 portfoliorecoverycollectionsagency An iPhoneUser2/23/2013 I don't knowwho it is. They don't leave a message. An AndroidUsen/19/2013 portfoliorecovery An AndroidUseri/11/2013 PortfolioRecoveryis Spam!. An AndroidUsen/5/2013 do n0t answer - portfoliorecovery company An AndroidUsen/4/2013 portfoliorecovery http:J/wNN.v.hlt~es.com'phooe,'1-626-209-2244 2/3 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 40 of 46 8'&'2014 1·626-209-2244 / 6262092244ls a landllnePhone I 'MlitePages An Android User12/ 29/2012 Portfolio Recovery Associates Numbers Similarto 1-626-209-2244 1-626-209-2241 1-626-209-6670 1-626-209-3171 1-626-209-5757 1-626-209-3793 1-626-209-757 0 1- 626-209-3094 1-626-209-3383 1- 626-209-3786 1-626-209-52 15 1-626-209-3119 1-626-209-3864 1-626-209-98o7 1-626-209-5661 1-626-209-9397 1-626-209-7966 1-626-209 -3140 1-626-209-5837 1-626-209-6700 1-626-209-3o86 1-626-209-5904 1-626-209-3385 1-626-209-65 07 1-626-209-3511 Phone nUIIJberdirectory 1-626-209-0045 1-626-209-0129 1-626-209-0229 1-626-209-0290 1-626-209 - 0872 1-626-209-1000 1-626-209-1194 1-626-209-1198 1-626-209-1277 1-626-209-1282 1-626-209 -1330 1-626-209-1353 1-626-209-1406 1-626-209-1423 1-626-209-1780 1-626-209-1951 1-626-209 -2105 1-626-209-2109 1-626-209-2179 1-626-209-2201 1-626-209-2202 1-626-209-2203 1-62 6-209-2205 1-626-209-2206 Browse allsimilar numbers -- - --···-·- - ·-·-- - -- ·-.- .. - ···- ··· ··- .....-© 2014 WhitePages Inc. - Privacy Policy and Terms of Use http:l/wtm .v.hitepages.com'phone/1-626-209-2244 ---- - ···-- ·-··-·- · ·- ..---- ···..·-- - 3/3 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 41 of 46 1·757-864-0020/7578640020 is a laooline PhoneI WhltePages 8/&2014 1-757-864-0020 News, VA Cox Communication s Landline in Newport Get a full report about the owner. Sponsored by Spokeo.com (757) 864-0020 Name Available View Owner's Name View Owner's Address Records Instant &Accurate Sponsored hy Spokeo.com Area Code:757 carrier:Cox Communications Full Numher:1-757-864-0020 City/State:Newport News, VA See a mnp of all United States Area Codes Report this number » Select CallType Default Debt Collector Fax Machine Political Call Non-Profit Survey Telemarketer Hang Up Prank Call Legitimate Business Legitimate Individual http://wm1.v.Mepages .com'phone/1757-864-0020 1/3 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 42 of 46 1-757-864-0020 / 7578640020 ls a landline PhoneI VVhltePages 8/6/2014 Other 10efau1t Caller's Name !caller'sName Your Name ~ r Name __ _ Le a vf: a commen t. ab c,ut the c al le t he t f: Leave a comment about the caller here "' • Your name and comments willbe visible on WhitePages. li@ibrnl.!,J Thanks, your comment has been submitted. Recent Comments An AndroidUser3/23/2013 Dont recognizenumber An Android User3/14/2013 portfoliorecovery An Android User3/11/2013 portfo1iorecovery An AndroidUser3/3/2013 Spam An AndroidUser2/25/2013 PortfolioRecovery An Android User2/17/2013 PortfolioRecovery An iPhone User2/17/2013 Some Mrs. Jones calledI don't know who this is. An Android User2/4/2013 Portfioliorecovery collections http:/f\wNI .W1ltepages.com'phone/1· 757-864-0020 213 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 43 of 46 8/6t2014 1-757-864-0020 / 7578640020 Is a landllnePhone I 'MlltePages AnAndroid Usen/21/2013 port recovery An Android Usen/20/2013 Portfoliorecovery.. Numbers Similarto 1-757-864-0020 1-757-864-0634 1-757-864-0550 1-757-864-0150 1-757-864- 0230 1-757-864-5757 1-757-864-5578 1-757-864-2663 1-757-864-9892 1-757-864-1219 1-757-864-4102 1-757-864-8656 1-757-864-0778 1-757-864 -4909 1-757-864-3781 1-757-864-0749 1-757-864-0105 1-757-864-7164 1-757-864-4064 1-757-864-0902 1-757-864-0416 1-757-864-0454 1-757-864-4964 1-757-864-8581 1-757-864-4527 Phone number directory 1-757-864-0029 1-757-864-0060 1-757-864-0061 1-757-864-0063 1-757-864-0064 1-757-864-0065 1-757-864-0066 1-757-864-0067 1-757-864-0068 1-757-864-0071 1-757-864-0072 1-757-864-0074 1-757-864-0076 1-757-864-0077 1-757-864-0078 1-757-864-0079 1-757-864-0082 1-757-864-0083 1-757-864-oo84 1-757-864-0085 1-757-864-0088 1-757-864-0089 1-757-864-0092 1-757-864-0094 Browseall similar numbers ·---·-··-------- - ------ - - © 2014 WhitePages Inc. - Privacy Policy and Terms of Use http-J/wNN.v.tutepages.corrlphone/1-757-864-0020 313 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 44 of 46 1-702-410-749717024107497 ls a landlinePhoneI WhitePages 816/2014 1-702-410-7497 Pac-West Telecomm Landline in Las Vegas , NV Get a full report about the owner. Sponsored by Spokeo.com (702) 410-7497 Name Available View Owner's Name View Owner's Address Records Instant & Accurate Sponsored by Spok en.com Select CallType Default Debt Collect or Fax Machine Political Call Non-Profit Survey T,elemarketer Hang Up Prank Call Legitimate Business Legitimate Individual http:/lwww.Wlitepages.com'phonel1702-410-7497 113 8/6/2014 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 45 of 46 1-702-410-7497 / 7024107497ls a landllne PhoneI VvttltePages Other I0efaul1 Caller'sName ,Caller's Name Your Name Your Name Lea ve a co mment al:>oi:t the c a ll i!r her e Leave a commentabout the caller here * Your name and commentswill be visibleon WhitePages. & h~YRID! !;! Thanks, yoor commenthas been submitted. RecentComments An AndroidUser3/11/2013 Bottomfeedingthird party debt collector.If you do talk to these people do not acknowledgeany debt with them. They buy bogusdebt that's many years old or bas been paid offand try to harass you into paying again.These people ares*** bags they are the worst of the worst and 1-letter can stop them forever from callingor harassing you againyou need to tell them to cease and desist all further communicationwith you or you will sue them for harassment end ofstory these peoplesuck! An AndroidUser3/11/2013 PortfolioRecovery An AndroidUseT3/5/2013 portfoliorecovery An AndroidUser3/5/2013 'PortfolioRecovery'. Callsme about twice a week from a different number each time. An AndroidUseT3/4/ 2013 Billcollector..unknown An AndroidUser2/27/2013 Do not knowanyonefrom this area code. must be billcollector An AndroidUser2/26/2013 Portfoliorecovery!I swear they have a milliondifferent numbers but I hang up as soonas I know its them http://wMv.v.hitepages.com'phonel1· 702-410-7497 213 8/6/2014 CASE 0:13-cv-00955-PJS-LIB Document 101-6 Filed 10/20/14 Page 46 of 46 1-702-410-7497 / 7024107497 ls a landllne PhoneI WhltePages An Android User2/25/2013 Debt collector An Android User2/5/2013 don't no An Android User2/5/2013 portfolio recovery Numbers Similarto 1-702-410-7497 1-702-410-7894 1-702-410-7069 1-702-410-7930 1-702-410-7489 1-702.-410- 4130 1-702.-410-0197 1-702-410-3387 1-702-410-4055 1-702-410-0396 1-702-410-4256 1-702-410-7076 1-702-410-0031 1-702-410-4268 1-702-410-4182 1-702-410 -7899 1-702-410-8086 1-702-410-4005 1-702-410-0283 1-702-410-3574 1-702-410-3254 1-702-410-0028 1-702-410-0407 1-702-410-8565 1-702-410-3915 Phone number directory 1-702-410-0001 1-702-410-0005 1-702.-410-0009 1-702-410-0014 1-702-410-0024 1-702-410-0044 1-702-410-0045 1-702-410-0047 1-702-410-0049 1-702-410-0051 1-702-410-0052 1-702-410-0058 1-702-410-0059 1-702-410-0061 1-702-410-0077 1-702 -410-0081 1-702-410-0090 1-702-410-0093 1-702-410-0095 1-702-410-0111 1-702-410-0130 1-702-410-0135 1-702-410-0145 1-702-410-0169 Browse all similar munbers - -- ·--·- ------- -----··-· -- -- ·-- ---·- ----- ..·-·- .. - ·- ·-· ·-· -·-- ·-- · ·- . . © 2014 WbitePages Inc. - Privacy Policy and Terms of Use hl!p:/tw,w.,.v.hitepages.OOlffphone/1-702-410-7497 313