morven 2025 - UVA Foundation
Transcription
morven 2025 - UVA Foundation
M O RV E N 2025 OPPORTUNITY ASSESSMENT © 2010 Hart Howerton John and Maria Kluge, Donor Teresa A. Sullivan, President Tim Rose, Chief Executive Officer John Simon, Executive Vice President and Provost Jeff Legro, Vice Provost for Global Affairs This assessment builds upon research in previously completed studies and reports: MORVEN Event Handbook MORVEN Potential Platform for Collaborative Problem-Solving: An Overview of the Marketplace MORVEN 2 Grounds EXPERIMENTAL MORVEN BARN STUDY SMBW and University of Virginia Update June 2013 Highland Monticello Montpelier Morven College of William & Mary University of Virginia TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction Summary Context & History Site Analysis Concept Plan Operational & Capital Requirements Next Steps 3 PREFACE October 2014 MORVEN 2025 is designed to think about the future. Launched in the fall of 2013, it is a process specifically intended: To BUILD upon the first five years of program experience detailed in the Morven @ Five report. To explore programs that enhance multi-disciplinary initiatives; take advantage of Morven-based faculty and student research; examine architectural concepts provided by professional consultants and utilize benchmarks of competitive properties. This Opportunity Assessment is the result of a 90-day study. It builds on all the previously completed studies for Morven combined with an analysis of existing programs, operations, and facilities. It adds new input from stakeholder and user groups - including the UVA Foundation, the UVA Office of the Executive Vice President and Provost, Office of the Architect, the U.S. State Department, and the Virginia Center for the Creative Arts - on the best ways to move ahead. To ENGAGE those at the University, in the community, and in the nation’s capital who have used the property to understand their experience. To ask these participants what is unique, remarkable, essential and missing at Morven. The 10 Essential Recommendations of the Assessment comprise an overall strategy for carrying out an interrelated set of development and operational opportunities envisioned for Morven. To CREATE a vision for Morven aligned with the strategic priorities of the University that reinforces the goals of the Cornerstone Plan. To ask how Morven might strengthen UVA’s residential and research culture, bringing the world to UVA and UVA to the world. To undertake a mission of this size and scope Morven needed a professional partner with the expertise to design and execute a complex planning process. The HART HOWERTON team, under the direction of UVA alumni David Howerton, Stuart Siegel and Nicole Emmons, provided the leadership and talent essential to the assignment. In a remarkable example of corporate responsibility and service to the University, the HART HOWERTON team provided on a pro bono basis the professional commitment and staff capacity needed to launch and realize the full potential of MORVEN 2025. This report presents a collective vision of what MORVEN could become and provokes the essential questions necessary to reach that future. To more than 100 university, community and national experts who participated in this process, please accept our deep gratitude. I hope you will read the results of their work and let us know what you think about MORVEN 2025. Stewart Gamage Director Morven Programs 4 - In the near term, it endorses an initial plan to build on existing programs, and lays out concepts for new facilities and associated capital and operating budgets; - For the longer term, it shows the potential of the overall landholding and spells out an objective set of evaluation criteria to add new programs and facilities over time that can directly contribute to Morven’s continued vitality. Taken as a whole, the Opportunity Assessment shows how to increase and sustain the impact and influence of Morven on a global audience and how to do that in a financially sound way. As such, it is designed as a tool to help convey the value and strong potential of the Morven property, and to help realize the shared vision and objectives of John Kluge and the University of Virginia. David P. Howerton Chairman Hart Howerton INTRODUCTION The primary objectives of the Hart Howerton process are to provide UVA and the UVA Foundation with recommendations regarding existing land and facility use at Morven and to identify strategies that will facilitate the growth and support of long-term programmatic initiatives at the property. I. The Opportunity Assessment evolved from: II. The Opportunity Assessment addresses: III. The Opportunity Assessment proposes that: tɨFDMFBSBMJHONFOUPGUIF6OJWFSTJUZTDPSF values and goals with the vision of the Donor; tɨFVONBUDIFEHFPHSBQIJDMPDBUJPODPNCJOFE with the extraordinary asset of the University, distinguishing Morven among its peers; tɨFCSPBEQPUFOUJBMPGUIFMBOEUPNFFU programmatic needs while identifying development and financial requirements; t"OBMZTJTPGFYJTUJOHQSPHSBNTBOEPQFSBUJPOT establishing proof of concept and a demonstrated track record; tɨFHSPXUIPG.PSWFOUPCFOFëUBMM stakeholders – the University, the Donor, program participants and their sponsors – adding to existing University resources. t%FQMPZJOHUIJTBTTFUXJMMTUSFOHUIFOUIF competitive position of the University in the global arena as a destination for addressing large ideas in a persuasive and supportive environment; t'VUVSFVTFQBUUFSOTXJMMCFBTTFTTFEUISPVHIB non-political, objective and easily replicated evaluation process. t$PNQSFIFOTJWFSFTFBSDIJODMVEJOHQSFWJPVTMZ completed studies, planning and stakeholder interviews, targeting future opportunities. “Morven is the place for experiential and experimental learning - where the real world and the academy meet.” - Jeff Legro, Vice Provost for Global Affairs 5 SUMMARY 10 ESSENTIAL RECOMMENDATIONS: 1. Morven is a farm without silos that offers a unique environment for the analysis of complex questions and integrated decision-making through multidisciplinary collaboration. On-site interaction among participant groups is a primary motivation for faculty, students, and outside visitors to convene at Morven and should drive development considerations. 2. Morven requires a robust in-residence experience to facilitate educational goals. The majority of Morven users are in agreement: “To truly optimize the Morven experience, we would need to stay here.” We estimate that by developing 30 doubleoccupancy rooms, Morven would reasonably accommodate a variety of programs and benefit from revenue and market share. The operations model required to support this transition should support an immersive in-residence experience. In the interim, existing accommodations can be minimally expanded and upgraded while the broader initiative is studied and funded. “Morven represents an opportunity for the University of Virginia to build and extend upon the legacy and ideas of Thomas Jefferson in ways not previously possible.” - Manuel Lerdau, Professor of Environmental Sciences 6 3. Morven and UVA need an objective evaluation tool to assess the degree to which prospective programs correlate to the vision established for the property. Based on stakeholder feedback, we have provided a tool that could be used by the University to identify which programs belong at Morven, directly contributing to the QSPQFSUZTWJTJPOBOEWJUBMJUZ 4. Morven has the opportunity to be a broad-shouldered brand that can effectively accommodate a wide range of programmatic users. Establishing a hierarchy of programs based on the evaluation tool will identify who uses Morven, for how long, and in XIBUDBQBDJUZ.PSWFOTTUSPOHDPOOFDUJPOUPUIF 6OJWFSTJUZTJOUFMMFDUVBMDBQJUBMBOESFTPVSDFTPO Grounds are fundamental assets of the Morven brand that should be leveraged and protected. 5. Morven will need a new operations and financial model that supports in- residence programming and growth initiatives. A traditional hospitality model will not work BT.PSWFOTDPSFVTFSTBSF67"OPOQSPëUT BOE64(/(0TUIBUBSFOPUJOBQPTJUJPOUP sustain a market driven model. User analysis should balance the capacity of core users, new program participants, and market-driven revenue opportunities. 6. Key Performance Indicators should be developed and managed along with benchmarking of competitive properties to ensure .PSWFOTQSFFNJOFOUQPTJUJPOBNPOHJUTQFFS group. Morven must remain nimble in order to anticipate and exceed the needs of its intended participants. 7. Meaningful capital investment in Morven 2025 will be required in advance of revenue and will present a significant challenge for the University – a challenge faced by all investors. While we have not undertaken a comprehensive calculation, it is reasonable to assume that hard and soft costs for the construction of 30 double-occupancy rooms should be in the range of $4-6 million. 8. Morven Sources of Capital should come from a variety of funding sources including asset sales – timber or 9. To launch Morven 2025, funding priorities and financial requirements should be identified and tied to a Phasing Plan for Implementation. 10. All initiatives must embrace and promote an ethos of environmental responsibility and awareness. There should be a creative synthesis between programmatic opportunities that require ‘bricks BOENPSUBSBOEUIPTFQSPHSBNTUIBUTFFLUP maximize agricultural uses. conservation driven land sales; recruitment of individual donor support; co-development strategies and corporate support. If development costs can be raised in this fashion, program revenue, tuition dollars, and annual fundraising can support operational expenses. A financially independent operating model that does not impact existing resources should be crafted. “Morven is an inspiring venue for discourse concerning issues of national and global importance, and a haven for intellectual thought and discovery. As we plan Morven’s future, we will do so with respect and gratitude for this wonderful property, and in ways that are consistent with the University’s mission and values.” - Teresa A. Sullivan, President 7 “Morven is an environment suited to contemplation and discussion, to ‘unplugging’ and elevated inquiry . . . the historical backdrop is a lesson of our earliest experiences as a democracy. The transformation of the landscape over time is powerful and inspiring.” - Tomicah Tillemann, Senior Advisor for Civil Society and Emerging Democracies, US Department of State 8 4 4 5 4 5 5 2 3 5 1 3 7 6 LEGEND 1 Program Arrival 2 Main House 3 In-Residence Programs (Core) 4 In-Residence Programs (Satellite) 5 Event Barns & Programs 6 Meeting Barn 7 Entry Drive 5 5 min. Walk 0 1" = 600' 600 7 7 1200' Morven 2025 9 CONTEXT Charlottesville Morven’s location less than ten miles from UVA and 120 miles from Washington, D.C. is a strategic asset. It is close enough to be easily accessible to Washington or UVA and yet provides the distance needed to facilitate discussions free from distractions. It is a venue where distinguished international guests and UVA faculty and students can engage outside of the hierarchical setting of a classroom or lecture hall. The potential academic offerings on-site are a key EJêFSFOUJBUPSGPS67"XIJMFUIF6OJWFSTJUZTJOUFMMFDUVBM capital and resources distinguish Morven programs. UVA Morven is a partner in the Presidential Precinct, along with Monticello and Highland, Montpelier, the University of Virginia, and the College of William & Mary. The partnership is committed to advancing democracy, critical thinking, international dialogue, and collaborative problem solving both on-site and as a virtual resource. Proximity to the historic properties is unique and attracts programs and guests. Morven Site Location Diagram - Jeff Herlitz, Experimental Grounds “People will come here from around the world – bring their ideas, their culture. The University needs to decide why they will come; what they will do while they’re here.” - John W. Kluge Morven’s Main House 10 The Rotunda Charlottesville IN Ragged Mountain Natural Area M O U N T A 9. 9 21 mi m les in ut es A E D Monticello 64 IN R G G A 53 T 9. 9 21 mile s mi nu te s om as Je f fe r so nP kw Ri nn y y Th 53 aR iv ro on M Ja Conservation m es D Morven R C A L kw ER S M Y E DU Highland er 20 U va O U M O eP N T A I N T N Ha r ve rdw Thomas Jefferson Foundation a re Ri (approx. 2,500 acres) University of Virginia Foundation (approx. 2,800 acres) College of William and Mary (approx. 600 acres) Conservation Area Map 0 1" = 8000' 8000 16000' 11 CONTEXT PROGRAMS & INITIATIVES Morven was reopened in 2008 with a focus on university programs designed to support UVA leadership development, provide a platform for faculty and student research initiatives, and connect Morven to the local neighborhood. Morven Programs include more than 200 event days per year (producing an estimated $85 - $100K in revenue). The predominantly UVA programs include: collaboratively-taught courses focused on the history, culture, and ecological significance of Morven resulting in the creation of the Morven Summer Institute; student-led Morven Kitchen Garden and establishment PGBMPDBM$4"UIBUOPXTFMMTQSPEVDFUPUIF#PBST)FBE *OOBOEUIFBENJOJTUSBUJPOTIFBERVBSUFSTGPS67"T Leadership in Academic Matters (LAM) program to provide leadership training for mid and senior-level faculty and administrators. 'BDVMUZIBWFSFDFOUMZQSPQPTFEQSPKFDUTGPSSFHFOFSBUJWF BHSJDVMUVSFUIBUXPVMESFDMBJN.PSWFOTGBSNMBOEBOE SFJOGPSDF67"TTJHOJëDBOUTVTUBJOBCJMJUZJOJUJBUJWF 'JOBMMZUIFFTUBCMJTINFOUPGUIF1SFTJEFOUJBM1SFDJODU has successfully hosted 200 emerging leaders from 80 nations, the US-China Legal Dialogue, and a policy retreat for 44 US Senators at Morven. This spring, the Presidential Precinct was selected by the White House to host the Young African Leaders Initiative to bring Young African Leaders for a six-week intensive leadership development program. 12 Morven Kitchen Garden Morven Summer Institute 13 HISTORY MORVEN Morven was purchased by Thomas Jefferson on behalf of his protégé, William Short, in 1795. The property known as “Indian Camp” was for centuries a seasonal hunting ground for Native Americans who occupied the region. Archaeological research has uncovered evidence of human habitation dating back to the Later Archaic Period (40001200 BCE). Jefferson and Short undertook a number of agricultural experiments, ranging from extensive crop rotation to the division of the land into 100-acre tenant farms. Short was particularly interested in the economic viability of a non-slave based property. He petitioned Jefferson consistently with regard to the issue of slavery and advanced the prospect these tenant farms might ultimately serve as a “way-station” for emancipation. The experiment ended in 1813 with the sale of the property to David Higginbotham, the leading merchant in Milton, who would rename the farm “Morven” – a Scottish word meaning “ridge of hills”. The Stone family purchased Morven in 1926 and converted Morven into a successful stud farm. During the Stone era the formal gardens, designed by the leading New York landscape architect Annette Hoyt 'MBOEFSTXFSFBEEFE John Kluge purchased Morven in 1988 and supervised the building of a remarkable four-acre Japanese garden designed by Japanese architect, Koji Tsunoda, and aided locally by Charlottesville landscape architect, Will Reilly. John Kluge donated 7,379 acres of Albemarle County property to the University of Virginia 'PVOEBUJPOJOJODMVEJOH.PSWFO'BSN ɨF67"'PVOEBUJPOTPMEBQQSPYJNBUFMZIBMGPG the acreage, returning the land to active farming and creating an endowment that today totals more than $40 million. Annual proceeds currently support both property maintenance and university programming at Morven. As Morven looks to the future, this endowment support provides a significant advantage. "Indian Camp" map of Morven, ca. 1795 - Huntington Library Collection 14 2 l ce ar To Charlottesville/ Richmond tP es W 795 57 acres 1,102 acres Ja m es M on ro e Pk wy 1,680 acres el st Ea To Scottsville 795 rc Pa Total: 2,839 ac Site Map 15 SITE ANALYSIS 4m Monticello il e s 64 53 SITE ACCESS 20 3m om 2m as il e s Highland il e s 'SPNQPJOUTOPSUI8BTIJOHUPO%$ WJTJUPSTGPMMPX the rise and fall of the landscape along US Route 29, QBTU.POUQFMJFS+BNFT.BEJTPOTIPNF BOETPVUI UP$IBSMPUUFTWJMMF'SPNQPJOUTFBTU3JDINPOE BOE west (Staunton), Morven is easily accessed via US Route 250 and Interstate 64. Th 795 Je f fe rs on Pk w y 53 1 il y kw eP ro m es M on Morven Ja Morven currently has two entries from James Monroe Parkway, a gated entry to a switchback entry drive that leads to the Main House and a commercial entry with a gatehouse controlling access to the property. m e The five miles to Morven from Monticello via the Thomas Jefferson Parkway and the James Monroe Parkway are a physical connection to Jefferson and .POSPFɨFESJWFJTQBSUPGHVFTUTiUSBOTJUJPOBMw arrival experience. 20 A new entry sequence within the property will allow all visitors to arrive at Morven via a tree-lined drive that leads to the Main House. 795 Site Location Map James Monroe Parkway 16 Along James Monroe Parkway Aerial View 17 SITE ANALYSIS SITE ORGANIZATION "TQBSUPG)BSU)PXFSUPOTQSPDFTTUIFUFBN gathered GIS data available from Albemarle County to map physical conditions on the property including hydrology, vegetation, sun exposure, and topographic data. Based upon review of Morven maps and recent studies, together with site visits and an analysis of current programs, the Hart Howerton team drew conclusions regarding site planning and future use patterns. SLOPE HYDROLOGY Watershed 0%-10% 10%-25% > 25% Stream Pond Water Protection Ordinance Buffer 100 - Year Floodplain Wetland Slope Analysis Hydrology VEGETATION Deciduous Tree Cover Evergreen Tree Cover North Northeast Water East Impervious Southeast Pine Plantation South Forest Harvest Southwest Orchard/Vineyard West Bare Earth Northwest Vegetation Study 18 ASPECT Open Land Aspect Analysis Th f fe r so nP kw y 53 ns hi t es W Je Highland e rc a P uc s l as Ho Ca r r te M ou nt n ai om Cre e k 795 Bishop Hill 57 acres 1,680 acres Massey 1500 - 1592 M e ro on ee es k M Cr 1100 - 1200 s Dr ne n 1,102 acres Jo 1200 - 1300 ve e or Le M 1300 - 1400 or Dr Pk w 1400 - 1500 n ve e ek y ELEVATION Cr m 1000 - 1100 Ja 900 - 1000 800 - 900 700 - 800 600 - 700 el 500 - 600 st Ea 400 - 500 300 - 400 Q ua 50 ac 0 1" = 2000' 2000 rr y rc Pa Cre e k Elevation Study 4000' 5 ac 19 SITE ANALYSIS The core of the property is organized around natural landforms. There are three ridges that run parallel to Carters Mountain and gradually step the land down to James Monroe Parkway. On these ridges, the estate, its formal gardens, and its supporting structures have been built and organized in a manner that takes advantage of the views. The primary ridge is dominated by the formal buildings and gardens organized around the Main House. The two secondary ridges create a visual buffer, shielding the Main House from views of the working layers of the farm without obstructing the longer vistas and mountain views. The barns and service roads are located on the west ridge. Th Highland h in s 795 Bishop Hill M a s se Main House w Pk e ro es m Ja 1 Visible 2 Visible 3 Visible 4 Visible 5 Visible Qua Viewshed Study rr y Cre ek ek e Not Visible Cr VIEWSHED s Dr M n ne ve Jo or Dr e Barn #3 M M en Le Meeting Barn v or y Equipment Barn on Foaling Barn r so n 53 Cre e k The 1,102 acre “East Parcel” is topographically distinct and not visible to the core Morven property. It is at a much lower elevation, and its vegetation is largely a managed pine forest. As such, its continued association with the core property is not essential. 20 f fe wy M Je Pk s n ai uc er as Ho C t ar ou nt om yC re ek Th f fe r so nP kw y t es W Je Highland e rc a P 53 hhiin ucc s l as Ho Ca r r te M ou nt n ai om nss CCrreeeek k 795 Bishop Hill LOWLAND 57 acres LINE 1,680 acres E Massey DG ro E e LI NE GE RID y ee Ja m es k M Cr RI s Dr 1,102 acres ne n e ek Jo ve e or or Le M M Cr Dr Pk w UPLAND n ve on E LI N RI DG LANDFORMS Upland Lowland el Steep Slope (>25%) st Ea Gentle Slope (10%-25%) Fault Q ua 50 ac 0 1" = 2000' 2000 rr y rc Pa Cre e k Landforms 4000' 5 ac 21 SITE ANALYSIS OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS LEGEND Views The Main House atop the primary ridge has the advantage of distinctive views in each direction. Protecting the varied character of these views reveals opportunities to locate new facilities at the core. Building locations will optimize access to views without disrupting the existing pattern of development on the land and situated to limit the need for new infrastructure. Conversely, the pattern of protected views informs an open space structure for the site, building upon ideas that have been realized by past owners. Potential Development Sites Main House I W L O N G A I N V E T V N I U E E Y V I E W M O W N L L L O G V Hand Sketch of Thomas Jefferson Historic District - Eleanor Gould, Experimental Grounds 22 V A I E W Primary Views VI EW Main House IE W A V VI EW A VI EW Opportunity Framework Diagram Section AA 23 CONCEPT PLAN MORVEN 2025 With a robust in-residence experience, Morven becomes a destination where big ideas are addressed in an open and supportive environment. The breadth of the land should accommodate a wide range of programmatic users and encourages onsite interaction among participant groups, faculty, students, and outside visitors. New construction should be sensitively integrated within the site where it is subordinate to the existing buildings and gardens and landscapes – preserving the authenticity and character of Morven. The illustrative plans and diagrams depicted within this study employ a combination of repurposed existing structures and new construction organized BSPVOEUIFDPSFBOEUIFTJUFTSJEHFTBOEWBMMFZT An open space network of gardens, paths, and trails provides connectivity between facilities and encourages informal gatherings or moments of solitude and reflection for its visitors. The concept plan allows multiple user groups to function on-site simultaneously. Programs that require dedicated facilities are accommodated as a future satellite to the core with the potential for an autonomous presence. Satellite sites should limit the size and scale of new construction to preserve the views and the character of Morven. Morven 2025 Aerial View 24 4 4 5 4 5 5 2 3 5 1 3 7 6 LEGEND 1 Program Arrival 2 Main House 3 In-Residence Programs (Core) 4 In-Residence Programs (Satellite) 5 Event Barns & Programs 6 Meeting Barn 7 Entry Drive 5 5 min. Walk 0 1" = 600' 600 7 7 1200' Morven 2025 25 FUTURE PHASE FRAMEWORK PLAN AND PHASING FUTURE PHASE FUTURE PHASE PHASE 1 FUTURE PHASE ɨFSFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFO.PSWFOTFYJTUJOH components creates the framework for planning future development: the formal organization of buildings and gardens in the Main House core and the informal landscape of farm buildings and fields create a perfect location for the new In-Residence accommodations. Situated at the intersection between the existing formal and informal areas, the new In-Residence accommodations will be easily accessible from all facilities. al rm o f THE FARM AGRICULTURE FIELD LEGEND Core Program Support In-Residence Core Parcels FIELD In-Residence Satellite Parcels Views Primary Entrance Secondary Entrance Secondary Roads 26 THE MAIN HOUSE CORE Phasing Diagram The preservation of views and minimization of new infrastructure are primary factors considered in the development of the site. Environmental constraints including potential cultural resource sites and/or archeological sites must be considered in the development of Morven. Primary Road al rm o F In CONCEPT PLAN Framework Plan 0 1" = 800' 800 1600' ARRIVAL The preservation and reuse of the formal entry drive on axis with the Main House is a key element of the illustrative plan. The proposed entry drive will reveal Morven slowly to visitors. The new arrival experience takes visitors to the formal entry drive by way of the former Scottsville Road bridle path. LEGEND Primary Entrance ARRIVAL Secondary Entrance In-Residence Entry Road Secondary Roads Limited Access Roads Bus Route GATE Access & Parking 0 1" = 800' 800 1600' Limited Entry Road Parking - existing Parking - proposed 27 CONCEPT PLAN IN-RESIDENCE PROGRAM OPPORTUNITIES In-residence program accommodations at the Core TIPVMECFQSPWJEFEJOUIFëSTUQIBTF'PSGVUVSF phases, multiple satellite sites have been located for potential in-residence programs. Phase I: 30 In-Residence accommodations: t-PDBUFEBUUIF$PSF t"DDFTTUPBWBSJFUZPGGBDJMJUJFT t0QQPSUVOJUJFTGPSJOGPSNBMBOEGPSNBM interaction with other programs and participants. 4 2 4 ULT UR E 2.'VUVSF1IBTF*O3FTJEFODFBDDPNNPEBUJPOT t4BUFMMJUFMPDBUJPO t1PUFOUJBMGPSEFEJDBUFEGBDJMJUJFT t0QQPSUVOJUJFTGPSGPSNBMJOUFSBDUJPO with other programs and participants; t-JNJUFEPQQPSUVOJUJFTGPSJOGPSNBM interaction. LEGEND Core In-Residence Accommodation (Includes new structures) Existing Buildings New Buildings Arrival 28 4.'VUVSF1IBTF*O3FTJEFODFBDDPNNPEBUJPOT t4BUFMMJUFMPDBUJPO t1PUFOUJBMGPSEFEJDBUFEGBDJMJUJFT t0QQPSUVOJUJFTGPSGPSNBMJOUFSBDUJPO with other programs and participants; t-JNJUFEPQQPSUVOJUJFTGPSJOGPSNBMJOUFSBDUJPO F OR E ST / WATE 3 AGRIC 1. 3.'VUVSF1IBTF*O3FTJEFODFBDDPNNPEBUJPOT t4BUFMMJUFMPDBUJPO t0QQPSUVOJUJFTGPSJOGPSNBMBOEGPSNBM interaction with other programs and participants; t"DDFTTUPQSJNBSZSFDSFBUJPOBSFBQPPMMBLF trails, etc.). Primary Program Elements 0 1" = 800' 800 1600' 1 R THE MAIN HOUSE CORE Programs most closely linked to the Morven core values are located at the physical core of the site. This central location is comprised of a combination of 30 new residential accommodations and existing facilities including: the Main House, the Meeting Barn, the Stone House, the Old Kitchen, nearby barns, and the formal gardens. 9 9 6 9 10 8 7 6 3 6 6 10 6 9 5 10 2 Main House 2 4 1 3 6 4 5 3 LEGEND 6 7 Area of Plan Detail Core Facilities Plan 0 1" = 300' 300 600' Existing Building 1 Program Arrival 2 Residential Suites 3 Dining Rooms 4 Residential Guest Rooms 5 Meeting Hall 6 Event Garden 7 (BSEFO8BMM'FODF 8 Classrooms 9 Studio / Labs / Indoor Events 10 Morven Staff 29 CONCEPT PLAN EXPERIENCING THE SITE Community is a primary component of the immersive learning experience of Morven program participants and is fostered by access to formal and informal common spaces where unscripted and impromptu conversations happen. The walks and gardens at Morven provide a structure for participants to engage in discussions out-of-doors in a safe and inspiring environment. In-residence programs will be supplemented by a variety of recreational activities and unique entertainment and dining experiences to encourage a wide range of conversations and varied interactions. Many of the activities will be customizable for JOEJWJEVBMTBOEHSPVQTBOENBLFVTFPG.PSWFOT open space. Kitchen Garden Running / Jogging 8BUFS'FBUVSF Picnic Cook / Prepare Bar-be-que Tea House 'JSF1JU Celebrate Explore Ceremonies Read Gather / Meet Reflect Learning Preserve / Conserve Meditating Create Studying Eat Viewshed Walk Admire Play Jogging Path Conference Chess Music Lawn Sports Theater / Plays Racquet Sports Event Gardens Movies / Cinema 4PDDFS'PPUCBMM Working Gardens & Playfields Walks / Hiking Swimming LEGEND Garden Walk Hedge 'FODF-JOF Walks & Gardens 0 1" = 500' 30 500 1000' The following is a initial list of activities envisioned to help enrich the experience at Morven: 8BUFS'FBUVSFT Morven Activity Program Canoeing & Water Sports Recreation Outdoor Kitchen Rose Garden Outdoor Theater Formal Garden Event Barns Japanese Garden Kitchen Garden & CSA Sculpture Garden Outdoor Classroom Supporting Program Elements Main House Great Lawn 31 OPERATIONAL AND CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS Morven is fundamentally an immersion-based learning center. As such, in the more traditionallydefined hospitality sector the property would be viewed more as a conference center than a hotel. The property caters specifically to small groups of less than 60 participants with education-driven programs that are: t UVA-sponsored; t UVA-related; t Morven-sponsored; t Third party-hosted or sponsored: - U. S. State Department; - Not-for-profit organizations; - NGOs. 30 rooms for overnight accommodations at double occupancy would adequately serve these groups, provide the most immersive experience, and maintain the character of Morven. Day-use conferences and programs may still be considered on a selective basis, though priority should generally be given to groups requiring overnight accommodations. While Morven does not purposefully target social events – dinners, weddings, reunions, etc. – the property should immediately develop a policy and operating model about accepting day-use events. A comprehensive analysis of similar MPDBMWFOVFTFH,FTXJDL)BMM'BSNJOHUPO$PVOUSZ Club, Clifton Inn) will provide confirmation of market pricing and operational standards. The immediate revenue impact could be meaningful and not adversely impacted by incremental operating expenses since all associated event expenses are covered by fees. 32 Facilities Existing Morven facilities, with particular focus on the Meeting Barn, should be used for program activities. The Main House, the Old Kitchen, the Stone House, the two Gardens, as well as the barns and grounds, should also continue to be used for programs. Phase I required new facilities for overnight accommodations include: t Expanded arrival/reception area t Guest rooms – approximately 30 new rooms (“keys”) with 2 beds per room (minimum double queens): - 350-450 square feet including individual bathrooms; - Appropriate scale – “cottage-like” – not a dormitory but more equivalent to select service hotel room standards; - Rooms include a desk, appropriate lighting and ergonomic chairs; - Wireless internet access and cell service; t Program Arrival – Basic check-in/check-out function approximately 2,000 sf with small lounge, offices, work stations, and limited backof-house facilities; t 'JUOFTTDFOUFS t Swimming (lap) pool and other recreational amenities. Phase II facilities would then include: t Gathering area, bar (could be honor bar or “hosted bar” service); t Work stations (“business center”) where participants can use space other than their guest room (particularly important if two conferees per room and one desk); t Back-of-house area including laundry, housekeeping and staff break area; t Basic work facilities (could be in one of the barns). Phase III and other possible future facilities include: t Learning-friendly meeting space (tables, chairs, lighting, AV equipment, etc.). Design & Brand Standards In keeping with the overall character of Morven, new facilities should consider the site, landscape, and existing architectural qualities of the property as well as modern facilities standards, including: t Green/sustainable systems and design; t Architectural finish and specifications equivalent to new, full-service commercial hotels; t Construction standards and specifications (fire and life safety, etc.) per UVA standards. Even though Morven will operate “independent” accommodations, the design of the facilities would incorporate guest service, back-of-house, and other requirements necessary for operating quality levels equivalent to Starwood, Hyatt, or other national brands. As such, the property should consider Brand Standards with these hotel operating brands in mind. Main House 8 In-Residence Accommodations Program Arrival 22 In-Residence Accommodations Meeting Barn Phase 1 new construction: 30 “In-Residence” rooms with double occupancy 2,000 sf Program Arrival Phase 1 potential buildings for renovation To be used for classrooms, studios, work spaces, food and beverage, etc. Morven 2025: Phase I 33 OPERATIONAL AND CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS Investment The estimated budget below is conceptual and requires considerable additional design, development and scoping. Actual budgets could vary materially and could be further affected by entitlement and UVA requirements not considered within the current study. The Phase I conceptual budget is estimated between $4 - $6 million, including infrastructure JNQSPWFNFOUTPVUMJOFECFMPX'VUVSFQIBTFTNBZ include renovation of existing buildings for In-Residence Program work spaces (studios, classrooms, etc.). The Phase I conceptual budget includes items such as: t Construction of new buildings (site work directly related to building construction only); t 'VSOJUVSF'JYUVSFT&RVJQNFOU''& t Operating supplies and equipment; t Professional fees – architecture, engineering and specialty consultants; t Zoning Review; t Permitting, Legal & Insurance; t Project Management; t Limited renovation or modification of existing facilities in service of Phase I. A Phase I conceptual infrastructure budget may include: t Major site work or new infrastructure e.g. roads, parking, lighting, grounds, etc; t Utilities: water, sewer, electric, natural gas, telecom. 34 Meeting Barn OPERATING PERFORMANCE In order to successfully provide overnight accommodations, the Morven policies should provide for: Overnight Rates t Revenue and profit-loss models need to be developed based on government and University rates in the range of $125 - $150/night; t All UVA users to pay university rates for use of the facilities and guest rooms. dates is a desirable goal (mixing of artists and young, future world leaders) then the number of new rooms and facilities to be added would need to be larger; t Programs sponsored by the Presidential Precinct could provide multi-year commitments. Day Rates t Daily use facility fees including special pricing for government and university related use; t Meeting barn currently $1,500 - $2,250 per day. Hospitality Standards t 'PPETFSWJDFDPNQFUJUJWFMZQSJDFEXJUIBSFB hotels; t Service standards equivalent for a brand-operated hotel or small international conference center. Anticipated Occupancy t Target occupancy levels of 40-45% annually; t Lower occupancy due to limited ability to take simultaneous and overlapping groups. Users t Predominant use by UVA and government groups; t Market-based use (by policy) for social events (weddings, reunions, leisure unaffiliated individual reservations); t Morven-sponsored signature events; t A long-term user who could partner with Morven and provide regular occupancy at certain times during the year e.g. the U.S. State Department, Morven Summer Institute, Darden-sponsored executive learning programs; t A financially stable user for an “in-residence” program that would provide a base level of annual funding to support operations; t If accommodating multiple users on the same 35 OPERATIONAL AND CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS OPERATING PERFORMANCE (continued) Revenue, Expenses, & Subsidies t Business model assumptions of gross revenues of $650-$750,000 per year; t Minimal incremental operating expenses added to service in-house groups and daily use; t No reduction in Morven current operating subsidies from the endowment i.e. management, accounting, security, farm and grounds maintenance, utilities and the like continue to be provided through the endowment subsidy; t Develop zero-based expenses budget to support minimum services within the pad of the cottages, aggressively pursuing outsourcing for laundry, housekeeping, and other service providers. t Other revenue resources could include: - Corporate sponsor; - Major annual program commitments such as the U.S. State Department; - Corporate programs; - Successful UVA or Morven sponsored programs – “Morven Institute”; - Partnership with a Not-for-profit “content” or “program” provider e.g. Aspen Institute-Wye River Conference Center, the Brookings Institution; - More open use for social events and leisure individual travelers; - Outside management contract (e.g. Wye River Conference Center - Marriott Conference Centers). 36 The Claim House, 1796 t Land Divestment: The 1,102 acre “East Parcel” is topographically distinct and not visible to the core Morven property. In addition to its lower elevation, its vegetation is largely a managed pine forest. As such, its continued association with the core property is not essential. el c r a tP es W There are several potential scenarios for realizing the value of the land on the east side of James Monroe Parkway should be analyzed. However, the future use of the “East Parcel” should not dilute or compromise the core values of Morven. Options for the “East Parcel” may include: - Outright sale with a conservation easement strategy in place whose benefits can be realized by the purchaser(s); Co-development with an experienced and sympathetic fee developer or builder; Structural or phased parcel sales to the neighboring estates. 1,102 acres el arc P st Ea Parcel Location Map 37 NEXT STEPS DECISION MAKING PROCESS & EVALUATION TOOL The University should employ an objective evaluation tool to assess future uses for Morven. 'VOEBNFOUBMRVFTUJPOTBSFUJFEUPUIFFTTFOUJBM ingredients including: Role & Mission: Does the proposal enhance the role and mission of UVA and reinforce the goals of the strategic plan? Kluge Gift: Is the proposal congruent with the gift agreement and donor expectations? Champions: Does the proposal build on current UVA academic strengths? Are faculty leaders and students engaged? Comparables: Does the project enhance the relative position of Morven with regard to a peer group? Site & Space: What are the facility requirements and are they consistent with the character of Morven? Does the program require exclusive use of Morven for the QSPHSBNTEVSBUJPOPSBMMPXGPSNVMUJQMFVTFST The University would then develop a hierarchy of uses for Morven driven by the values assigned to the results of the evaluation tool. Morven Farm 38 OVATIVE MINDS N N I -I ER TT ESIDENCE | AFFORDABLE | INTEGRATED | A DEAS A CCE M N -R ESSENTIAL INGREDIENTS CO LL AB ROLE & MISSION E IV T RA O TH AT CH AR A CT KLUGE GIFT ER W O |S IM Y IT IC PL IS S SSIB LE | RK U E T NABLE | I A H USTAI T |S S CHAMPIONS COMPARABLES Single Structure Multiple LandStructures Based Use Existing Facilities Scale of New Infrastructure or Improvements to Existing Infrastructure FUNDING REQUIREMENTS & SOURCES PHYSICAL NEEDS SITE & SPACE DEDICATED FUNDING SPONSOR PROFILE status, fundraising capacity, access to new donors and/or sponsor base? “The Decision Tree” 39 NEXT STEPS ESTABLISHING A PEER GROUP Majority Academic 6OEFSTUBOEJOH.PSWFOTQFFSHSPVQBOEJUTQPTJUJPO in the competitive landscape is an essential business metric that will enable the: t Creation of consistent programming and pricing models; t Development of key marketing messages and brand value statements; t Identification of core target users. In 2010 Morven Programs conducted a comprehensive review of potentially competitive sites followed by a more detailed examination of four destinations #FMMBHJPPQFSBUFECZUIF3PDLFGFMMFS'PVOEBUJPOJO Lake Como, Italy, Salzburg Global Seminar in Austria, ɨF"TQFO*OTUJUVUFT8ZF3JWFSDBNQVTJO.BSZMBOE and Airlie in Warrenton, Virginia) to better understand .PSWFOTQPUFOUJBMDPNQFUJUJWFOFTTXJUIJOUIF marketplace. A detailed report summary can be found in the Appendix to this document. BREAD LOAF MORVEN BELLAGIO SALZBURG Rural Urban MACDOWELL AIRLIE GREENTREE WYE RIVER ARDEN Majority Professional 40 HOOVER INSTITUTION BELLAGIO CENTER Lake Como, Italy This comparative study indicates that Morven has the essential elements for successful development as a retreat destination with the exception of residential capacity. Residential capability is critical to offering competitive program options and critical to building a community among participants. .PSWFOTQSPYJNJUZUP8BTIJOHUPO%$BOEJUT location within the Presidential Precinct are powerful market advantages. Academic resources from UVA also set Morven apart from the other destinations while several have collaborated with universities on an ad hoc basis, none can boast the intellectual QPXFSBWBJMBCMFUP.PSWFOTQSPHSBNTCZWJSUVFPGJUT relationship to the University. Programs more closely linked to a University, such as Bread Loaf and the Hoover Institution, should be included in ongoing assessments. WYERIVER RIVERPLANTATION PLANTATION WYE Queenstown, MD Queenstown, MD AIRLIE AIRLIECENTER CENTER Terrace view of theWarrenton, Bellagio Center VA Warrenton, VA HISTORY Property traces its history to Romanization of Como region in the first A.D. Relationship with the Rockefeller Foundation began in 1959 when Ella Holbrook Walker offered her Italian estate, Villa Serbelloni, “for purposes connected with the promotion of international understanding.” Dean Rusk was Overhead view of the Wye River Houghton House Chair of Rockefellar Foundation when the agreement was negotiated. SALZBURG GLOBAL SEMINAR HISTORY Austria to Morven, the site has a richonhistory – Salzburg, owned initially by William Paca, signer of the Declaration of The Bellagio Center sitsSimilar on 53 acres in the town of Bellagio Lake Como. Independence. Aspen received the property in 1979 from the Houghton family, a wealthy NY philanthropist who founded Corning Glass Works. MISSION To promote the well-being of humanity through technological, social and economic growth devoted to MISSION creative thinking, problem solving, and artistic endeavors. As a subsidiary of the Aspen Institute, Wye River provides accommodations for conferences and retreats, as Natural views of Airlie’s 1,200-acre campus well as a place for the Aspen Institute to engage in long-range planning. PROGRAM LEADERSHIP HISTORY Pilar Palacia, Managing Director at Bellagio; Rob Garris, Managing Director, Bellagio in New York. Founded by Dr. Murdock Head in 1956, Airlie has served as a retreat destination for more than five PROGRAM LEADERSHIP decades. The property is also home for Airlie Productions, a film company producing documentaries on a CORE INITIATIVESCindy Buniski, Vice President, Administration and Executive Director wide range of issues. Conferences: Programs traditionally run for five days housed in a small conference center/hotel PROGRAMS with 23 guests. Applications submitted by organizations to Foundation; those accepted receive significant MISSION Aspen Institute Executive Seminars – Approx. leadersinfrom a variety come together financial support. US universities are frequent applicants. Pres. Sullivantwenty participated a program onof fields Lakefront view ofto thelearn ‘Schloss’ “A center where individuals and organizations can meet in a distraction-free and neutral environment to from each other variety of topics. Recent include: financing higher education organized by on theaUniversity of Chicago in issues August, 2011. corporate responsibility, ethical leadership, exchange ideas on issues,HISTORY ignite thought, and inspire collective action around shared interests, purpose and Asian cultures, and the policy impact of the digital age. value.” The Salzburg Global Seminar is headquatered in a rococo palace commissioned in 1736 for the Residences: Limited to 15 participants; residents include scholars, creative artists, and practitioners. Spouses Archbishop of Salzburg. The ‘Schloss’ was purchased and restored by Max Reinhardt in 1918. In 1947 it Faculty and Deans’ Seminar Series –28Provosts may accompany the resident. Residential stays are typically days. and academic deans may apply to Wye Seminars that focus on CENTER LEADERSHIP became home to the first Salzburg Global Seminar. The Schloss was also the birthplace of Salzburg Music a range of higher-ed topics. Kevin Carter, General Manager Festival and film location for “The Sound of Music”. PROGRAM THEMES Institute Custom Seminars – Targeted seminars that address specific business growth and leadership • Basic Survival Aspen Safeguards CONFERENCE ANDMISSION SEMINAR FACILITIES • Global Healthdevelopment issues designed for 12-24 people. With 150 guest rooms and cottages on aSeminar 1,200-acre Airlie can accommodate upwhich to Theeight Salzburg Global is a campus, non-profi t, independent institution brings together policy • Climate and Environment 200 people for a multi-day conference. Airliefrom hostsaround approximately 600 year.issues Airlieof accepts leaders and scholars the world to groups addressper critical global concern. Over 26,000 • Urbanization Aspen Institute Sponsored Conferences – Subject-specific conferences for 25 people or more on important weddings on a selective basis. participants from over 150 countries have taken part in Salzburg programs. subjectsSecurity where business and policy issues intersect. • Social and Economic PRESIDENT AND CEO FINANCE ALUMNI NETWORK Stephen L. Salyer goal isconference essentiallyparticipants to break even; notresident viewed as a profiPost-conference t center. Since 1957, Bellagio hasFinancial hosted 30,000 andWye 4,500 scholars. follow-up is recent area of interest. Bellagio competes with other Rockefeller Foundation initiative for PROGRAM THEMES CONFERENCE AND SEMINAR FACILITIES support. • ArtsPrograms & Culture The Wye River has been in business approximately 30 years. are developed through the Aspen Innovation and Sustainability Institute, thru policy staff located in Morven DC. Programs |•Benchmarking Report 2012 • Media & Citizenship Peace, Justice & Security Wye River caters to a wide range of audiences and price• points. Wye Woods is the most rustic facility, while • World experience: Stability & Wye Development the other two facilities are more expensive and offer a high-end hosted the Palestian-Israeli Peace talks during the Clinton Administration. CONFERENCE AND SEMINAR FACILITIES Eight seminarMorven rooms,Programs accommodating 10-150 participants | Benchmarking Report 2012 with state of the art technology EVENTS AND WEDDINGS Historic chapel available for weddings on select weekends; in-house catering RESIDENTIAL CAPACITY The Main House at Airlie Twelve suites in the Schloss (Main House). Adjacent historic Meierhof has fifty-five rooms, including Morven Programs | Benchmarking Reportand 2012 some suites with a kitchenette. Additional facilities: Max Reinhardt Library Whitman Fitness Center FINANCE, BUDGET, GOVERNANCE ‘09 revenue $7.7M; $7.6M in expenses. High-level board with administrative offices in Vienna and Washington, DC Morven Programs | Benchmarking Report 2012 41 42 POSTSCRIPT Morven 2025 was designed as a planning process to think collectively about the future of Morven. And that was exactly what happened. In May 2014 Hart Howerton presented its recommendations to the Provost of the University. The following week John Simon convened 26 senior faculty to discuss the draft report, solicit comment and recruit additional suggestions. 'PMMPXJOH$PNNFODFNFOUUIF1SPWPTUBOE1SFTJEFOU met to discuss the report. As a result of these deliberations, there is basic agreement that Morven: t Represents a significant strategic asset of the University; t Provides a multi-disciplinary platform for an “immersion experience” difficult to duplicate on Grounds; t Needs residential capacity to serve faculty, students and other program participants and requires a business model to provide a financial framework for successful operation; and t Requires a University-led process for evaluating proposals that have a significant impact upon the use of property. In early June the Provost appointed a University committee to evaluate major program proposals, chaired by Vice Provost Jeff Legro, and a Committee on Residential Use of Morven, chaired by Morven Programs Director Stewart Gamage. Both committees are organized and have begun work. During this planning process the work of Morven has continued. In conjunction with the Presidential Precinct, Morven Programs most recently hosted the 4UBUF%FQBSUNFOUT:PVOH"GSJDBO-FBEFST*OJUJBUJWF (YALI) bringing 25 remarkable emerging leaders from 18 nations to Virginia for an intensive leadership development program. UVA faculty and students have been deeply involved in the development and execution of the YALI program. This program suggests the potential that Morven Programs and the property offer the University and those who study here. 'JOBMMZUIFGBDVMUZTUBêTUVEFOUTBOEBDBEFNJD leadership of UVA are deeply grateful to Hart Howerton - especially to David Howerton, Stuart Siegel, and Nicole Emmons - who have provided the PQQPSUVOJUZUPPSHBOJ[FUIF6OJWFSTJUZTCFTUUIJOLJOH in planning for future of Morven. As the University prepares for its next century of leadership, Morven has the opportunity to make a significant contribution as a global destination for critical thinking and complex problem-solving. This report lays the foundation for that proposition. 43 CONTRIBUTORS Hart Howerton and the University would like to thank the following individuals for their generous contributions to the discussion: Milton Adams Sara Lee Barnes Sara Bon-Harper Antoinette Brewster Benjamin Brewster Bill Cromwell Dean Dass Rebecca Dillingham Emma Dinapoli 'SBOL%VLFT Terry Dunmire (SFH'BJSDIJME 'SBODFTDB'JPSBOJ %PSPUIZ'POUBJOF 1BVM'SFFENBO Neal Halvorson-Taylor Harry Harding Sharon Hostler Robert Hull Gregoris Kalai Jody Keilbasa Jane Kelly Maria Kluge Jeff Legro Manuel Lerdau Garrick Louis Maurie McInnis Dick Minturn 'SFE.JTTFM Julia Monteith With a special thanks to the leadership and staff at Morven: The Hart Howerton team, Stewart Gamage Rebecca Deeds 8IJUOFZ'BSNFS Elton Oliver .FH'BJTPO Photography provided by: Dan Addison David Howerton Stuart Siegel Paul Milana Michel Dionne Nicole Emmons Christina Calabrese Xuemei Luo Jim Murray Louis Nelson David Newkirk 4FBO0#SJFO Laura Pence Neal Piper Shelia Pleasants Drew Precious Tim Rose Marie Schacht Will Scribner Bill Sherman Hank Shugart John Simon Tom Skalak “What little difference you can make, you should make.” - John W. Kluge 44 Greg Smith Margo Smith Teresa Sullivan Emily Sydnor Diane Szaflarski Sam Taggart Ann Taylor Russell Taylor Chris Tilghman Tomicah Tillemann Tamara Van Meter Richard Will Emily Willey Bill Wylie 45 © 2010 Hart Howerton /&8:03,4"/'3"/$*4$0