Rotary Pendulum Clocks
Transcription
Rotary Pendulum Clocks
© 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. John C. Briggs and Rotary Pendulum Clocks by Chorles Terwilliger There are mor.e questions than hard the American rotary pendulum clock. One would suppose that John C. Briggs, who received the first United States patent for the "application of the conical pendulum to timekeepers," would be well known to horological historians, but on the contrary, references to Briggs and his patents are seldom found. In the nineteenth century, only Charles S. Crossman mentions .,the Fortunately, although research has facts about the beginnings of failed to uncover inJonylation about Briggs' Iife, some of his artivities during the decade ending in 1860 are docunented in the cfficial history of Coacord.a We learn from the Histot-g thzt "under the dir€ction of the Concord Railroad Company, about 1852-53, James A. Weston and John C. Briggs made surveys for a raih"oad from Con- Pittsfield...." (The projected line to Pittsfield, N.H., was never cold to Briggs Patent Flexible Pendulum Clock... which Mr. John C. Briggs built.) A few years later, on October had patented in 1855,"1 As Dr. Hugh Grant Rowell oncre "It is, as you know, very di.fficult to trace out these patentees and even some makers. These fellows were seldom of much loeal consequence aad are in local the main streets on Concord, t'then counter-marched in a.lternate lines in State House Park" in a defirons,tration of Republican strength. At the same time, Mrs. John C. Briggs was treasur"er of the Ladies' Kansas Aid Society, "established .[or procuring sup- histories. They failed to advertise much and left few traces."z In the case of Briggs, Dr, Rowell is partly right" Although John C. Briggs is shown as a resident of "Concord, in the county of Merrfunack, the Stat€ of New Hampshire," in the applications for his patents, no reference to him can plies of clothing arrd sther necessaries for the relitrf of Free State emigrants." When a new high schooi was needed Concord in 1858, John C. Briggs served on the building committee, In 1859, Briggs was president of the Common Council of Concord a.rd representative of Ward 4. The same year, 1859, the City Council authorized Briggs and four others to purchase land for a cernetery. fn 1860, the ground was surveyed. and in ibe found in New Hampshire vital records, nor in the various biogtaphical or genealogical materials in ttre New Itrampshire Historical Society. Two genealogi,es of the Briggs farnily list no John Briggs identifiable as the John C. Briggs who lived in the 1850s.3 in 23, 1856, John C. Briggs was chief marshal, witJr sixty marshals and assistants, in charge of the Concord portion of a procession tlat marched through said, rarely -nrentioned (NY) Concord oq © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. spending a large part of their time thinking about clocks. Is it too fancifu.l to imagine that one laid out by John C. Briggs, "whose eminent ability as a civil engineer," in the words ot the Cemetery Committee, r'was fully equalled by his skill and taste as a landscape gardener." The consecration of the cemetery was held in July 1860, and by vote of those day when surveyor Briggs was setting up his transit, as he had done hun- of times before, he was suddenly bemused by the rotation of the plumb dr.eds present was named Blossom Hill a pendubob, and saw a pendulum - an obserlum that rotated? Just such Cemetery. vation had inspired Galileo, as he watched a lamp swinging back and forth in the cathedral at Pisa, to envision the principle of the oscillating After the events of 1860, Briggs is not mentioned again in the Histo'rE. The Concord ciby directory, printed every four years, lists him in its 1856 edition as a "civil engineer, boarding at the Phmix Hotel," and as living at pendulum. A no best of all, it would be silent more noisy ticking. Submitting- only the simplest drawings and text, Briggs applied for and received a patent for the "application of the conical pendulum to timekeepers" on Aug'ust 21, 1855 ( Figure 1). Perhaps Briggs tried to build a model incorporating the ideas he had outlined in his patent application. If he did, he must have had difficulties, as a second patent, for a "mode of regrrlating the conical pendulum for tirnekeepers," was issued to him July 15, 1856 ( Figure 2). Long before Briggs made his appeararce in Concord, a now-famous affairs during his residence in Concord. No shred of evidence has appear"ed to link him with timepieces. However, clockmaking was in the air in New England in the ninet€enth cen- tury, and Concord itself hsd a rich tradition in the considerable output of the Chandlers and Levi and Abel Hutchins; it is obyious from developments in clockmaking in Connectieut during the century that hundreds of people in the New England states were J. C clock with a rotating pendulum would be new, different, eye-catching, an innovation in clockm,aking, and, Spring and Washington Streets in the 1860 edition, but has no listing for John C, Briggs in its 1864 edition. So we know that Briggs was a surveyor and civil engineer with a talent for landscape gardening, and that he was a,ctive irr polibical and community BRI6GS. Mode of ReguhlinB Clocks, l{o. 11451. &c, by Pemduluns Patarted Aug. Fig. I Drowing in John C. Briggs' August 21. 1855, Pdlent 100 A,|855. © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. J. C. BRIGGS. Regulaling Pendulum, No, 15,356. Prtent?d.luly l5s l85E J'49 2. E&'5' 'c Fig.2 Drowing in John C. Briggs'July 15, 1856, po'ent clockmaker, Major Timothy Chandler, had established his business in the town. An advertis€ment of Major Chandler's first appear.ed in the Concord. Herald, in 1791 : . . . warranted eight day Clocks, i'r'ith enamelled, moon, or plain Simiiar advertisements continued to appear from time to time for almost four decades. In 1829, his son, Abiel, joined Major Timothy briefly, and after his father's retirement, Abiel Chaa'dler continued for a few years as a clockrnaker, but the flood o-[ machine-made inexpensive Connecticut clocks made clockmaking in the old handcrafted way more and mo "e unprofitable. Major faces, time pieces of various kinds . . . Clocks and Watches clea,ned and repaired . . . and all kinds of Gold and Silver Smith work, done with regular dispatch. Timothy, as early zs 1792, ha.d adr"er- 101 © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. tised surveyors' compasses, and later quadrants, dividers, protraetors arrd parailel rulers were added; rn 1844, Abiel Ch,andler adv€rtised that he was a "Philosophical Instrument Maker,,, manufacturing "surveyor's compasses of all kinds surveyor's chains, plotting scales, protractors, etc.,' a,nd also that he repaired surveyor's instruments "at short notice and guaranteed to give satisfaction." Two surveyor's compasses made by Abiel Chandler are in the collection of the Ne.nr Hampshire flistorical Sociel,y. Abiel was alio interested in gardening ard horticul- ture and later fur life was a cosrespotldent for agricultural papers, including the agricultural deparknent of the Concord Monito'r. Considering Abiel Chandler's activities and interests, it is not surprising to find that John C. Briggs consulted hfun about the practical use of his pat- for the conical pendulum. Ctrandler was well-known in Concord as a clocbnaker and instrument makerl ents Briggs may have purchased surveyor's instruments from him or Abiel may - hstruments. have lepaired Briggs' During their dealiags, the landscape gardener and the horticulturist could also have discussed ga.rdening and plantings, even possibilities for Blossom Hill Cemetery. fn any event, two must have discussed clocks, as Crossrna,n says trhat Abiel Chandler th.e "developed the Briggs Clock in 1858 and 1859,"r No working models, d rawings, or papers have survived to shed light on the period of experimentation, but in the end, Chandler was unable to de- ROTARY. Fig. 3 Welch "Rotorf Adoms Aflo6 vise a rotary penduh'm clock that would function, Crossman says, ..In practice it was found that the clock stopped very easily if jarred, and Chandler gave up the idea of rnakimg them to 'any extent."6 So ends all that is known of the early development of Briggs' idea and, at the same time, any documentation about John C. Briggs. He fades from the picturre as quietly as he had entered it, leaving nothi'ng be,hind except the fact that he had obtajned two pat- ents concerning the application and regulation of the conical pendulum for timekeeners. L02 ' os shown in Asher © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. preceded by an earlier Welch production, Model I (Figure 4). Welch's The Welch "Rotary" Nothing furhher is heard about con- Model II, the "Rotary," is shown in tr'igure 5. For a comparison of the two models, see Figure 6. Welch, alone in ical pendulums in the United States until the early 1870's, when an alticle in an Asher & Adams Atlas on the products of Ure E. N. Welch Manufacturing Connpany illustrated the "Rotary," a clock using the pendulum (Figure 3). The article states that Welc.h makes "a specia.lty of 'Rotsxy the field, continued to produce clock for several years. There is no evidence to indicate that Briggs was in any way connected with the manufacture of the Welch clocks, although stamped on the top plate of Model I is "Pat. Aug. 1855, JuIy 1856," indicating that Welch knew of BrigEs' patents, or at least the dates they were issued. The patent dates do not appear on Model II. The 1855 and 1856 patents relate only to the conical pendulum as a means of "regulating Clocks' and . , . are the only American makers of a reliable clock having this escapement." Although the "Rotary" is the first American rotary pendulum clock that has been documented. the it was Fig.4o Welch Model l- 7" high {Unless otherwise noted, oll clocks illustroied ore presently or were previorrsly owned by the Fig..4b Welch Model outhor) 103 l, bock © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. Fig. 5o Welch Model ll t04 - 7 t/a" high © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. Fig. 5b Welch Model ll, side ("Americon Horologist & Jeweler" phorogrophl © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. MODET Position of pendulum regulathg nut MODEI I At top of bracket Directly over spindle Wheel and pinion train II Completely redesigned Not intelohangeable Same gear ratios Top plate attached with Top plate markings Pins Screws PAT AUG 1855 JULY 1856 None Die-stamped Turned Motion train wheels Solid Crossed out Motion train bddge Shaped Plain Several designs Several designs Terry-t11e SPade 3,5 mm 3.8 mm t2 6 Availa;ble Avairlable Pillars Pendulum ball Hands Key squa.re Number of key fingers Nickel-plated plates Slightly larger Legs Less deeply embossed Fig.6 Moior differences belween Welch Models 106 lond ll © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. Fig. 70 French conicol pendulum whose cdse design Welch copied clocks and timepieces 7" clock high Fig. 7b Bock view of clock shown in in the Asher & Adams article, ;" Welch de- Figure where an illustration and description of the Welch rrAlcove" cloek, "a French invention patented by E. tr'arcot of Paris," appears. signed a clock and movement to make use of the conical pendulum. How did Welch arrive at the design of the "Rotary," a design that was unusual in American clockmaking? The designer must have been familiar witrh In describing their clock, Welch did rrot use the words "Briggs" or "conical," but referred to it only as the "Rotary," As far as I know, the name "The Briggs Rotary" was first used by Jesse Coleman in his Augrrst 1946 a clock made in France, probably in the 1850's or 1860's, shown in Figure 7. I first saw this clock in 1968 in the science museum. Instituto e Museo di Storia della Scienza, in Florenoe, and article in The Amet"ican Horologist ond, Jetpeler. No later found it illustrated in a.n article on conica.l pendulums in Antiquarian manufacturer's nam€ appears on the Welch clocksl as a matter of fact. I know of no American rotary clock made before the 1970's that bears a manufacturer's lame. Hwologg.T Subsequent efforts to obtain information about the clock and its maker. by inserti,ng an adveltisernent asking for such inf,ormation in the May 19?5 issue of the bulletin published by the Association Nationale des CollectionneurB et Amateurs d'Horlogerie Ancienne, were fruitless. I finally obtained one of, the clocks from a:t American collector in 1976. Stamped on the bottom plate of the movement is a trademark with the initials AR (Figure 8), which suggests that the clock was made by Antoine Redier, a well-known alocknaker. who was arctive in Paris from 1849 to the 1870's. (For more irforrnation about Redier, see footnote 16.) Fig- B Tfddemork slomped on bottom o{ That Welch kept in touch with French clock production is indir.ated French conicol pendulum clock shown ures 7o ond 7b !07 in Fig- © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. his first patent? Could a few trial of a rotary pendulum clock BROWN'S B, O T A R, models Y. il Brown's factory when it was sold to E. N. Welch, to be found years later, redesigned, given a Welch have been E. N, Welch MoveEent. movement and called Rotary"? "Brown's There arre no records showing when E. N. Welch first produced a mtary pendulum elock, or when production ceased. One can approximate the years as being the decade between 18?0 and 1890. Nox does anyone kno-r how many clocks were made, let alone how many of each model. The extaDt illustrations, including those for "Brotvn's Rotary," illustrate Model II. Based on the many clocks of both models I have seen over the years, I would hazard a guess that the production of Model II (This Cut ts Querter the r size ol the Day. Time. Clock.) was ten times as great as that of Model I, but ttrrat there ar.e probably not more than 300 or 400 of both models in existence today. Spring. Brass or Nickel. Fig.9 "Brown's Rotory" illustroted in lhe Americon Clock Compony's cqiolog No. 166, Morch I878 On page 64 of the March 1878 catalog of the American Clock Company, clock wholesalers and distributors of E. N. Welch clocks, the same "Rotary" drawing shown in the Asher & Adams article appears again, but it is now titled "Brorm's Rotary E. N. Welch Movmrent" ( Figure 9).- The wholesale prices given were $2.50 for brass, $3.50 for nickel. This advertisement has given xise to the idea that another in the manufacture of the clock. Some authorities suggest that 'Brown" might have been a typographical error for person was involved "Briggs." One interesting speculation does arise. Jonathan Clark Brown, a clockmaker active in Bristol between 1831 and 1855 under various (Bartholomew, Brown firm names & Co., Forest- ville Mfg. Co., Hills, Brown & Co., J. C. Brown & Co., Forestville Clock Manufartory, Forestville Hardware & Clock Co.), failed ard sold out to E. N. Welch in 1855.s Could Briggs have had any contact with. J. C. Brown in the time preceding his application for Fig. 10 Kroeber Noiseless No. I known os the derrick or oil well clock. 20'1" high 108 © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. Other American Rotaries In the 1880's, another rotary was harketed by the F. Kroeber Clock Company of New York, en lepreneurs and distributors of clocks made by leading American and some foreign manufacturer-s. These clocks were available in six different models. The Noiscless Hotary No. J is known as the "derrick" or "oil well" clock because it resembles oil rvell derricks in use at the time. The other Nofseless Rota,ries, Models 2 through 6, have the same statue of a draped female figure from t'hose upheld hand the pendulum hangs, but the cases on which the figures stand differ.e Figures 10 through 12 iliustrate Kroeber Noiseless Rotaries. All Kroe-ber models have this same movement, patent€d by Gilbert H. Blakesley of Bristol, Connec,ticut on June 18, l8?8 (Figure 13). This is another mystery, as Blakesley never made a clock in his life, according to the late Edward Ingraha"m of Bristol, ',vho kn€w Blakesley and had discussed the matter wit*r two of Blakesley's friends and a rnan who had been em- ployed in Blekesley's plant for many years.lo On the contrary, he manufac- Fig. 12 Kroeber Noiseless No. 6 hrgh {Americon Clock & Wolch Museuml 21" lured a "hair crimper" and various small items, such as arm bands, at his Blakesley Novelty Company in Bristol. The patent is another indication, though, that hundreds of people in New England in the nineteenth cen- tury were thinking about clocks. It has been suggested that the Noiseless Rotaries were made for Kroeber by either the William L. Gil- bert Clock Company in Winstead, Connecticut, or by E. N. Welch. The latter would seem to be more logical, as Welch had had considerable experi- in manufacturing rotary pendulum clocks. ence Kroeber rotaxies a,re rare, In I have seen only a few: several derricks, a Noiseless Rotary No. 5, and the No. 6 in the twenty-five years, Fig. I I Kroeber Noiseless No. 5 high American Clock & Watch Museum in Bristol shown in Figure 12. Because of tle Kroeber firm's dealings with foreign manufacturers, Kroeber de- - signers were fa.miliar witft conical pendulum clocks being made in 2l Vr" 109 © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. o. ilo.2O5,O9t. l, ELAf,ESIET, 0lool. Pelcnlrd Iqnc lE. 1878. ffiffi Fig. 13 Drowing in Gilbert H. Blokesleys June 18, 1878, pdlenf 110 © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. scientists and clockmakers harl been making intermittent attempts to carry out the principle of such a pendulum for almost four hundred yeanrs, although he ref,ers to Foucault in the application for his second patent: ". . . circulating pendulums having the maintaining power applied at the top, as Foucault's. . In first .." 1587, Jost Boedecker "was the to conceive a coltinuously revolv- ing mectranical appliance oparated by weights for the measurement of time. He devised a rotating star as a regulator for the cathedraL clock in Osna- bruck."l1 This clock, which not sur- prisingly has disappeared, is described on page 304 of Alfred Ungerer's Zes in Paris Ho,rloges il'Edi.f ice, published in 1926. A line drawiag showing how the movement might have been constructed is shown in Figule 15. Almost a century later, Christiaan Huygens, following his application of the oscillating pendulum to a clock in 1656, devised Fig. l4 The Briggs Roidry Pendulum Clock, lhe idea o-[ a timepiece with a conical pendulum, probably about 16)9, and made furl,her experiments with clocks using the pendulum o Horolovor reproduclion boseC on the Welch Model ll Franee. The shape of a rctar"y or conical pendulum clock is prede.ternined by the necessity for an overhead sup- port fi:om w'hich to suspend the pendulum. Welch models used a simnle curved strip o-f metal originating at the back of the dial: almost alt of the larger French conical pendulum elocks use the woman's figur.e with raised arm, a.s do all Kroeber clocks excent the unique derrick*model. Again there is a lapse, and a rather lengthy one, until 19?5, when Clock Trade Enterprises of Bronxwille, Neu' York, introduced the Briggs Rotary Pendulum Clock, a reproduction of the Welch Dlodel II (Figure 14). The reproduction maintains the general appearance and operation of the 30hour oliginal, but is slightly larger because of its S-day movemeni. Notes on the Hi8tory of the Conical Pendulum Clock It is doubtful that John C. Briggs, when he was applying for patents Fig l5 Drowing of on the application of the conical pendulum to timekeep€rs, was a,ware that l587 movement o{ Boedecker Osnobruck clock (Deulsche lJhrmocher Zeilung) 111 © 1978 National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors, Inc. Reproduction prohibited without written permission. in the years 1666-1668.r, A drau'ing of Huygens' pendulum appears on page 144 of P'auI M. Chamberlain's The clock has a fascinating his- tory. It is named "Corfu" because the onyx used in its construction was mined on the Greek island of Corfu. (It has also been called the "Cor"nu" clock since its base was crafted by Eugene Cornu on the Boulevard des ltaliens 24, It's About Time; this is probably the same drawing preserved in Leidm, Holland, referred to in the description of a Kroeber derrick clock displayed in the Smithsonian Institution. In England, Dr. Robert Hooke ex- Paris.) perimented with all sorts of p€ndulums, "both vertical and conical"; the Minutes of the Royal Society contain The timepiece, which'stands the Paris Exposition of 1867. After the fair closed, the clock was shown throughout the great art capitals of Europe. In 1869, Mr. Alexander T. Stewart, fomer reports of several of these experiments in 1666 and 1667.13 There is litttre information about the use of the conical pendulum in the eighteenth century, but the idea had a recurring attraction for horologists and the second half of the ni,neteenfh century saw an upsurge of activity, particularly in France, where clockmakers and manufacturners prcduced a Iarge number of conical pendulum clocks, ranging from ela,borate exhibition pieces to miniature alarrn clocks. chaiman of the honorary comnis- sion sent the clock for He placed the one-andone-half ton instrument in the hallway of his New York City tion, in Baillie residence. when piece was acquired Powers as a of by Patrick Rochester, Ne,w York. Mr. Lambert [whose house in Paterson later became tlre Society's headquartersl obtained the Paris.r5 clock from the Powers estate. Even at a cursory glance, one is inclined to agree that t,l.e timepiece is a truly unique art object. Two ormolu dials are set in the clock's front; one gives the time iman, 1855" and "Comparateur chrona pendule conique par Rediert 1859."16 Later in the century, Louis Moinet, who worked with Breguet, illustrated two conical pendulum ometriquc and the other marks the day of the month and quarterly moon periods. The opposite side has two similar dials indicating baromet- in his book, Nouaeau Traite General d'Horlogenie, published in in in Stewart's possession.) At moved the clock to his department store, which was eventua-lly sold to John Wanamaker. Wanamaker placed this rare olock near tle front entrance on the main floor of his famous New York stole. Somel,ime a-fter"ward, the time- "Horloge a pendule conique par Ball- Pa-ris contemporary pho- an unknown date, Stewart re- There are two conical pendulum wall clocks on display in the Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers in Paris: clocks (A tograph reveals that the bronze goddess was brilliantly polished nineteenth oentury clockma,ker of great repute, was the first to exhibit a conical pendulum clock in purchased 910,000, conical pendulum clocks were made after 1850, the Manfrankisches Museum in Wurzburg has e, long case clock wiLh conical pendulum signed Caspar Bollerman, c. 1815. The c,lock is a quarter-hour repeater, with a "horizontal impulse rod that p€rmits Jean Wagner, listed by the United States Government to the Paris Exposi- European Conical Pendulum Clocks Although the majority of European tadial displacements."r+ 13 feet, 6 inchcs, was exhibited at ric changes and time in major cities actoss rhe globe. Tn addi- 1875. tion, the clock is fitted \Fith nhei t and Cmtigtade In this country, a clock exhibited by the Passaic County Historical Society at its hoadquarters and museum, Lambert Castle in Paterson, N,J., is shown in Figure 16. The guide to the museum gives the following information: F ah re therrnometers. On top of the base is a statue by the French sculptor, Alb€rt Ernest Carrier-Belleuse (L824- 7L2 Article continues here.