OT3bIB lpocTpaHcTBa rro3BoJrreT orrpeAenraTb ypoBeHb

OT3bIB
oQuqua.rrbHoro o[rroHeHTa, KaHAv.Aara Hcrop[qecKux HayK, AoIIeHTa
Ilyrlyraeso fi Can usr CafiryAAuHoBH br Ha Arrccepraur{rc Xtyproeoft AHxe"rru
Apnrconnu <<rlpoqecc Bxo?nAeHrrfl HapoAoB Ilenrpa"rrbHoro Kanrcasa B cocraB
PoccHu B oreqecrneHnofi rrcropuorpaQuu>>, [peAcraBJreHHyro Ha corrcKaHne
yuenofi crerrenrr KaHAnAara rrcropuqecKrrx HayK rro c[equaJrbHocrrr 07.00.09
IlcropnorpaQnn, rrcroqHrrKoBeAeHrre *r MeroAbr rrcropnqecKoro
[ccJreAoBa'nufl
,,{nccepmqzr A.A. Xypronofi uocs.sqeHa oAHoit. us cav,.blx aKTyzuIbHbIX
upo6neu
Ar{cKyccnoHHbrx
coBpeMeHHofo KaBK€l3oBeAeHIiIq. Anarus
r{cropr4orpaSz.recrux uanpauenufi
coBpeMeHHbrx reppr4Topz€LrrbHbrx
pea"Jrv3auJ.Iv
H
B
Lr3yqeHr.ru rrpoqecca SoprrazpoBaH:z.fl,
IpaHurI Pocczu Ha Cenepuou Kantca:e,
IlpzHrllrnoB Mr4pHoro cocyulecTBoBaHlrr
lpocTpaHcTBa rro3BoJrreT orrpeAenraTb ypoBeHb
B
paMKax oAHofo
KoHconrrAr{poBaHHocTn
rocyAapcrBa v o6qecrsa.
Ore.recrneHHas Hcropuorp aSut poccufi cxo-KaBKa3cKr{x B3arrMoorHoru elnuit
B
cpeAHeBeKoBbe
rrporr4BoperrarqprMrr
vr HoBoe BpeMrr uso6unyer
Apyr Apyry Kareropurr
p€r3rurrHbrMr4, HHorAa
v,Lr Lr 4efi unuq Lrflvtvr, Koropbre cny)Kar
ocnosofi rotrt ullu uuoit reopuu. B ux qncJre raKlre rrowtrvrn, KaK ((BXox(AeHI4e>),
/
(A OOpOBOJIbHO
e [pI4CO eALrHeHHe>, (BO eHHO -IIOIr{TLrqe CKLILT COrO3>
co3Aaror
ALr
cKyp cplBHo e rroJre,
rpe6yloqe e my6 oro ro
Hayr{H
n trP ., KOTOpbIe
oro anurur3a.
K 3arrllrre ,{r4cceprarlus orJrLrqaerc.f, KoMTIJIeKcHrIM
noAxo,qoM K upo6nerrae. B HcropLtorpa$uuecrou Krroqe u3yqeH rlpoqecc
llpaacraBreHHa-s
B cocraB PoccraH: poccuficroceBepoKaBK€r3cKlre B3alrMoorHorrreHnr s XVI-XIX an., rpaBoBoe oQopulenne
rrpucoeAuneHLrfl. peruroHa r Poccuficrofi LrMrrepuLt, Kanxascrca.s sofiHa z qp. B
BXoxAeHr4r HapoAoB I{eHrpanrHoro Kanraga
pa6ore qerKo o6osHa.reHu o6rerr kr rrpeAMer uccneAoBanvra, yKa3aHbI qenb
3AAAqI/',
B qlrCJre
14
KOTOpbTX BepHO [OArrepKHyTa HeOOXOAI4MOCTb LI3yqLITb
opraHlrcarlLloHHbre ocHoBbr HayrrHbrx l4ccneAoBa:rruit,
ux no:4eficraze
r{HTeHcrlBHocrb Lr coAepxaHue uccneAoBarenbcKoro rpoqecca
Ha
(c. 19). B pa6ore
AoBonbHo rroJrHo [peAcraBJreHa crerreHb rl3yrreHHocrz npo6JIeMbI B coBercKoit u
coBpeMeHHofi LrcropuqecKofi HayKe.,{nccepranr yMeno
ucronrcyer
MeroAbI
r4cropuolpaQuuecroro aHaJrlr3a, He nyraer rrcropvorpa$nuecrrae rIcrorIHr4KLr
r4cropuolpafi rvecrue
BuolHe
$arru.
oqeBr,rAHa
Hayquafl HoBlr3Ha .4rrccepra\w, Korop€u o[peAeJleHa
caMr{M rrpeAMeroM LrccJreAoBanyrfl, rrprlMeHeHnofi
A.A. Xypronofi uero4onotueft,
n .rbcrHocrra rrcrroJrb3oBaHlreM AlrcqulnlrHapHofi varpnqbl Llcropu.recrofi
fr. ProseHa. Bnepebre
anaJrvr3
vr
B oreqecrBennofi racropuolpa$uu rpoBeAeH
HayKLI
rounnercnrrfi
Lrcropl{orpa$nuecrux rrrcrorrHlrKoB AopeBonroqvoHHoro, coBercKoro
14
coBpeMeHHoro [epr4oAa, rrocBrrrleHHbrx npooneue Bxox{AeHI{t HapoAoB
I{enrpanrHoro Kasra3a
B
cocraB Poccnficroro rocyAapcrBa.
He sHsHBaer coMneHufi [paKTnqecKaq 3HaquMocrb
ALrccepraIILToHHoro
Anfl HayKLT vr o6ulecrna. PaccuarpvrBaeMafl, npo6levra HocI{T
ocTpononllTl4qecKrrfi xaparrep, rBJrf,eTcfl o6rerrciu p€BnurIHbIX ncraxennfi Lr
r{ccneAoBaHvrfl.
crreKynf,rlrafi,
roropue Heo6xoAlrMo
BoBpeMs BbrrBJrrrb
I{ HafrHo orlpoBeprarb.
flocro.sHHufi npoqecc rr3)nreHLrs, v anarrv3a Jrlrreparypbr, rrocBqIrleHnofi Ltcropl4l{
poccuftcrco-KaBKa3cKlrx B3aLrMoorHoruenutrt n
XVI-XIX ss. rIo3BoJrLIT peluurb grLI
upo6neuu. Pesynrrarbr AncceprarllroHHoro rrccneAoBartlzfr A.A. Xyproaofi rraoryr
6urr
14
AcrroJrb3oBaHbr rrplr co3Aanvkr
ucr opvrorpaQuu
C
o6o6qaroqnx pa6or, rrocBf,IqeHHbx vrcropnrr
enepnoro Kasra3a.
Oco6rrfi LrHTepec [peAcraBJrrer
TeopervqecKuM
BbrAeJreHbr
kT
rrepBzur rJraBa Ar4ccepraqvrvr, rrocBfltrleHHa-s
MeroAoJrorrrqecKuM acrreKTaM uccJre4oBa:avrfl npo6reurr.
u o6ocnoBaHbr ocHoBHbre grarrbr pa3Bnrvfl. rrccneAoBanufi no npo6neue
BXoxAeHLrf, HapoAon I{eHrpa;rbHoro Kasra3a B cocraB
Poccuficroro rocyAapcrBa;
rrpoaHurnr43r4poBaHhr ocHoBHbre KaTeropLlLI
v
Lrcropr4orpa$uu poccuficro-KaBK€BcKoro
LtcropuqecKoro
.{uccepraur u*q."i"py.t
Lr
B gefi
BHLIMaHue
geSunutlnu, ucnonb3yeMble B
Ha laarvr'rvu B
B3aLIMoAeitcrr,ufl,.
orerlecrBenuofi
croprlofp a$uu npo6nenau orpeAene HLIA xapaKTepa B3al4Moornourenuft Mexly
Pocczefi
v
HapoAaMv I{enrpanrHoro Kasxa3a Ha
roM vrilvr IaHoM gTane Lrx
r{cropuqecKoro B3avMoAeitctsus. flosrouy, KaK rroJlaraer aBTop, Hayvnufi [oLIcK
TepMuHa, clloco6Horo Har46oJree froJrHo oTp€t3rrTb Bce acrreKTbl AaHHofi npo6neMbl,
6y4er rrpoAonxarbcfl, r{ B A€rnbHefiruena (c. a5).
, A.A. Xyprona paccMorperra
KareropvurnbHyro Marplrqy
ee
ToqKLr 3peHlrs Bo3MoxHocrl{
[plrMeHeHurr
B
ilopna
ProseHa c
vccneAoBanavn npo6rervt
[anuar. reoperuqecKa{ KoHcrpyKrlur rlo3BoJrvra ALIccepraHTy
pacinaorperu LrcropuqecKyro HayKy oAHoBpeMeHHo KaK aKaAeMLIqecKyIo
KaBKa3oBeAeHLrr.
u cibepy KynbrypHofi nparrurn o6qecrBa,
Alrcqnrrnlrlry
pa3Bvrrvrfl oreqecrBenHofi
ucropvolpa$uu
rpoaH€rnv3upoBarb xoA
BXo)K,{eHVfl, Hapo4on l{enrpaJlbHoro
Kasra3a B cocraB Poccrau, MaKcLtM€rJrbHo ) {LrrbrBar rraHoroQaKTopHocrb gToro
rpoqecca.
Bo nropofi ruase ,qlrccepraHT
poccl{}rcKo -ceBepoKaBKzl3cK}rx
AopeBoJrroqlroHHylo LlcropuorpaSzro
B3aLIMO OTHOIIIeHLILI.
B
r.rAeonoruqecKlrx HarrpaBneHlnr
v
Lt3yrrprJr
rrccneAoBamuu
rpkl
ooo3HaquB
upo6neuu:
KoHcepBarI4BHoe,
K uucly ocHoBHbrx KpI4TepI{eB Bbl.qereHnfl,
AaHHbrx nanpaueHufi orHocrrrcf, rro3urr\v1fl,, Koropylo ror ulrvt uttotrt aBTop
rlptrHnMaer B Borrpoce poccuftcro-ceBepoKaBKa3cKoro rlporl4Bocroflravts., rIbI4
rrpaBa v LrHTepecbr, c efo TorrKr,I 3peHlrr, Aonx(HhI rrrlTblBaTbct B AaHHOM
m6epalrHoe
rcouQlurcre
peruoHa
AeMoKparr4qecKoe.
B [epByro
K Poccuu
oqepeAb, KaKVe MeroAbr vr cnoco6u [pvcoeAI{HeHLIt
A.A. Xyprona, HecMorpr
rroJrr{TLrKLr
B
Kar BepHo noAqepKuBaer
Ha p€BHoe noHLrMaHLre v orIeHI{BaHLIe uunepcroft
npaBoMepHo ktcrroJrb3oBarb.
pefkroHe, AopeBonroqrroHHble zccneAoBaTeJILI
eALIHO|JIaCHO
orrpeAensnr4 rrpoqecc poccuficro-raBKa3cKoro r{cropuqecKoro B3alaMoAeitcrr.ufl,
KaK coqeranne
4o6ponolbHoro
r4
B3ar{MoBbrroAHoro (rIoAAaHcrBD) HaHav.alrbHoM
gTarre B3aLrMoornoruenrafi 14 [pr4HyAlrremnofi ((KoJIoHlI3aurrD)
rroJroBlrHe
XVIII-XX
LrccneAoBaa*rfl KoHrIa
BB.
XVIU
(c.
-
nropofi
103-104). Anrop crpaBeAnllBo orMetlaer, qro
HaqaJra
XX ss. [ocnyxwlLl
4alrneft ruero pzl3BI4TrIt oreqecrBeHHoro
B rperuefi
Bo
Ba)KHofi ocnosoit
ltts
KaBKzl3oB e Aererafl .
IJIaBe AuccepTaHr vccneAoB€Ul coBercKylo Llcropl.,IolpaQnro
pocczficro-ceBepoKaBKa3cKkrx B3ar4Moourourennft. MeroAonoru.{ecrofi 6azoit
ur3yqeHnr nauponofi ur oreqecrseHHofi rlcropLrvr Bblcryrlan MapKcLI3M. OcHosHoe
BHLIMaHUe LICTOpLIKI{
yAelIflnu [pwIuHaM, MeTOAaM v
IIOCJIeACTBLITM
Poccuz. Anrop
rrpoAeMoHcTpI4poB€IJI KaK OTpaXaJILtCb I43MeHeHVs BHyrpI4- vr
IlpucoeAuHeHur ceBepoKaBKuBcKux Hapo.qoB
BHEIIIHCIIOJII{TI{AIECKOfi CUTYA\VU
K
B CCCP HA XAPAKTEPC OCBEIIIEHI4'
NPOqECCA
BxoxAeHlrr I{eHrpanrHoro Kasra3a B cocraB Poccuu. flo4po6Ho ocBeIIIeHbI
AoCTlIXeHufl
vI IIpeAenbI LICTOpltqecKoLI
MbICJILI COBeTCKOTo
Couacno BbrBoAaM ALTccepraHTa, B cosercrnfi [epl4oA
HecKoJrbKo rroAxoAoB K r.r3)n{eH}rro
AoMr,rHrapoBarra
cSoprraupoB€ulocb
[poqecca r{HTelpaqhr4 Hapo[on I{eHrp€LIIbHoro
Kasxa3a B cocraB Poccuficroro rocyAapcrBa.
x rr.
KABKA3OBCACHLI'I.
KoHrleflqur
B 1920-x - nepnofi
rIoJIoBI4He 1930-
o6 <<a6conrorHou 3Jre), conlacHo
Poccus 6rrla o6rssreHa (TropbMoft napo4oB)>, 14 Bce MaJrbIe HapoAbI
Koropofr
so[rrll s ee
cocraB B xoAe Kaexa3crofi sofiHH. Co nropofi nonoBuHbl 30-x
n. XX n., uo
reoput o
(HaI{MeHbIueM
Bepcr4lr
A.A. Xypronofi,
3Jre), corJracHo
,qaHnyrc KoHrlelrlr{rc cMenser
roropofi npoqecc BxoxAeHVr HapoAon I{entpanbHoro Kasra3a s
cocraB Poccura rpaKToB€lJlc.fl I4ccneAoBarelrflMn KaK (HalIMeHbIIree 3JIo)
KoHreKcre nepcueKruBbr
6rrm
3aBoeBaHHbIMrI
Typuuefi utru klpaHoM.
B
B 1950-x
Sopuyna ((HarrMeHbrrree 3Jro) 3aMerurercr roHqenquefi o <<,qo6poroJlbHoM
npl4coeArrHeHlru K Pocczu vr ero [porpeccrrBHblx nocneAcrBl4qx), corJlacHo
rr.
xoropofi
HapoAbr. I{enrpanrHoro Kanrasa go6pononrHo [pI{coeALIHt4JILIcb
PoccuficroMy rocyAapcrBy (c.
B
1
5
K
1-152).
uerneprofi rJraBe A.A. Xyprona rpoaHaJrlr3lrpoBana ocHoBHbIe
TeHAeHTII]I B
COBpeMeHHbD( KaBKa3OBeAqeCKIIX UCCneAOBaHIdflX
paccMarpusaeNrofi [po6reMe,
IIO
B qacrHocru MeroAonorz.{ecrufi [nIop€uII{3M
B
vrc1vlrenrlur SoprvrupoBanns, PoccrEftcxoro MHoroHaul4oH€ulbHoro rocyAapcrBa,
roropnft lpr{Ben K
Bo3H}rKHoBeHLrro rraHoroo6pa3vIs, LlHTepnpera\uft
lpncoeALrHeHr4r I{enrpanrHoro Kasxa3a
co
BpeM
eHHbrx
rr cc
Jr
eAo BaHr4nx
rr o Jr1..
run
r Poccnz. Bonruroe paclpocrpaHeHLle
t\vrBvrnvr3aqzo
Hnrrfi
(co
qno
rynrrypu ufi )
rroAXoA, rcoroprrfi paccMarpvBaer poccuftcro-ceBepoKaBK€l3cKoe
nporlrBocrotrHue KaK neuuHyeusrft
c
rrror
couplIKocHoBeHI4rI
oquoKynbrypHblx ctlcreM : rlMrlepcKo fi u p annerocyAapcreeHHofi
.
B
BoeHHoe
AByx
pa3HbIX
,{uccepraHr o6ocuosan
xapaKTepa poccuitcKo-KaBK€l3cKlrx orHorrreHuit
s
c
ocMbIcJIeHLILl
coBpeMeHHofi zcropuorpaQun.
OroH.rareJrbHoe BXox(AeHne .I{eurpaJrbHoro Kanra^sa
r4croplrKl4 cBr3brBaror
B
nplrHrlr4nn€LJrbHbre pa3nwrvrs.
B cocraB Poccuz
MHorLIe
<<xecrorofi KoJroHuaJlrHoft norururofi>> llMnepcKoro
rrpaBlrreJrbcrBa B [epuoA KasKa3crofi sofiHrr, qacrb r,rccJreAoBarerefi crpeMllTc.a
npo4err,roncTptrpoBaTb Mr4pHbrfi xaparrep poccuft cro-ropcKll
,ftr roro qro6rr yircu or rroJrr4TraKo-uAeoJrornqecKoro
x B3allMooTHoIuenufi
.
rrporrlBocrofHllfl B HayKe,
aBTop o6ogna.run Bo3Mox(Hbre rryrr,r p€l3Br{Tur oreqecrnennofi ucropllorpa$uu
aHaJwr3vrpyevrofi rpobnerrnu. Manougf{eHHbrM r4 BecbMa rlepcrleKTznHunl,
c
ed
TOqKH 3peHLrfl, HanpaBneHI{eM tBJIteTCt UICCJTeAOBaH}Ie KpbTMCKO-KaBK€I3CKO|O
ucropuqecKoro B3auMoAeitcrnvtn, Koropoe rro3BoJrrrr nyqrue ttoHtrb
B3alrMoorHorueHrar ceBepoKaBKa3cKr4x HapoAoB n PoccraIE s
XVI-XIX
ss.
CrerreHb AocroBepHocrrr p$yJrbraroB nicre4onannfl o6ecnequBaerc-f,
crporr{M or6opou
u
TeoperurqecKlrM o6ocnonaHlreM
I4ccreAonaHure
A.A. Xypronofi
IIcT0aIHLIKOBOM Marepu€rne,
noloxeHnfi,
BbrABLrraeMbIX
B
Al4ccepralllln.
ocHosaHa Ha cowrAHoM Lrcroprlorpa$nrecrou z
cocrotrlleM He roJIbKo I{3 po c cufi crl4x tIccJIe goaanui1
Ho u sapy6exHux uzganuit,
[epeBe.qeHHbIX Ha pyccr<ufi
rroJro)r(eHvfl, Avrccepraur{r.r orpax{eHbr
peKoMeHAoBaHHbrx
pa6or, uy6ot<ltv
Kpr{TraqecKr.rM aHarrlr3oM [puBneqeHHbIX
t3bIK.
OcHosHrre
u 29 rly6nuKarlr4sx aBTopa, 5 zs roropblx
B
BAK P(D uayrHbrx xypHaJlax.
B ra.recrBe 3aMe qatruir xoreJrocb 6rr oruerplTb cileAyroqee
Bo-uepnux, AuccepraHT ne o6osHaqaer
Lr
:
He o6ocnosrrsaer co6crBeHHyK)
TOqKy 3peHrrr oTHocr{TeJrbHo IIpnqLrH, xapaKTepa ]1 LrToroB BXox(AeHIIs, HapoAoB
{eurpamHoro Kasra3a B cocraB Poccuu.
Bo-nroprrx, aBTopoM HeAocrarorrHo rrerKo o6osHa.{eHrr
BbrAeneHr4-rr
B
KpI{TepuLI
conperurenHofi Lrcropuorpa$uu AByx HarlpaBneuuit: Lt3yuaroqux
npoqecc [pvcoe.quHeHrrr I{enrpanrHoro Kasrca3a x Poccuu, c oAHofi cropoHbl,
KoHTeKcre poccuficKoro ucropwrecKoro rrpoqecca
grarroB pen4oH€ulrnofi
llcropllu.
v, c
Apyroft
-
KaK oAI{H
B
I43
B-rperrux, B LrccneAoBannv Mrlno Bnnlr.all'vs. yAeJIeHo v3freHLIIo
pa3rrrrrHbrx apxeorpaSuuecrnx ucroqHrrKoB, c6opnuron AoKyMeHToB Ll
Marepu€uoB, I43AaHHbIx B XX . Haqzule
XXI s.
Brrcra3aHHbre 3aMeqaHr.rr Hocrr yroqHrrrollq.rzfi xapaKTep
u He BJII{tIor Ha
o6ulee 6laroupurrHoe BleqarreHne or AaHHofi pa6oru. ,{uccepraqnr Xypronofi
AHxenu
Apuronusr
'BJI'ETC.fl
IIOJIHOUEHHbIM
t4
cropuolpaSuuecrnra
uccneAoBaHneM, BbrrroJrHeHHbrM aBTopoM caMocTo-f,TeJlbHo Ha BbIcoKoM Har{HoM
ypoBHe. Pa6ora coorBercrByer ga.ssreHHofi HayrHoft cneqrlaJlbHocrl{ u
rpe6orauvIflM, ycraHoBneHHbIM <<fIoloxeHLIeM
creneuefi>>, rpex(Ae Bcero rIyHKraM
9-11
o
npucyxAenrzlzr )nreHbIX
<<floloxelnvfl>>.
AaropeSepar
cooTBeTcrByer coAepxaHrllo Au ccepralll4oHHoro I{c cJIeAoBaHnt.
Xyprona Anxela ApuronHa 3acnyx(LrBaer npvcy)KAeunfl yteuofr crerleHl4
KaHALrAara LrcropruecKr.rx HayK
rro cnerlr{ErJrbHocrrlr 07.00.09
-
l4c'topuorpasux,
r{croqHl4 KoBeAeHI{e I{ MerOAbI LICTOpI{qe CKOIO IICCJIeAOB AHUfl.
OSuquanrnrrfi ornoHeHT
cropl4q e cKI{x H ayK ( 0 7 . 0 0 . 0 9 - Vlcr opuorp aSux,
r{crorrHrlKoBeAeHlre r{ MeroAbI I{cropuqecKoro I{ccneAoB anut),
AorIeHr, san. ra$eApofi <<Vlcr opun ApeBHero MI{pa
KaHAvrAut
Lr
I{ CpeAHIztX B9KOB>, 3aMeCTLITeJIb AeKaHa
no Ha)rurHo-opraHr{3arl}toHHofi pa6ore
O|BOY BO <<rle.IeHcxufi
rocyAapcTBeHHbIrI yHI{BepcI4Ter>
C.C.UyqynaeBa
n$&nr{*b
eh-F ';
,i.1,
fi. ;( |
OfBOy B O <<Ile.rencruft rocyAapcrseHHrrfi yHLIBepcI4rer)
Agpec: 364907, rle.IeHcrat Pecny6luKa, I. fposnrrfi, yl. IIIepvrIoBa, A.32.
Ten. : +7 (57 12)29 - 48 -3 2; E-mai
I
:
mail @chesu. ru