2016-01 January Specifics Newsletter
Transcription
2016-01 January Specifics Newsletter
San Francisco Chapter Specifics VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE RSVP: MONTHLY MEETING WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 13 6:00 – 8:00 PM SPECIAL LOCATION! Vivace Restaurant 1910 Ralston Ave, Belmont, CA Dinner and Program www.boiledarchitecture.com LEED V.4 & HPD (Health Product Declaration™) Are you up to speed with the current version of LEED? Leed v.4 has been out for a while now and its predecessors have been phased out, but many don’t fully understand the new version. LEED V.4 includes requirements for increased transparency including Health Product Declarations or HPDs. This presentation will explore the Health Product Declarations used in LEED v4 and how LEED v4 rewards product transparency and the Health Product Declarations (HPD). Understanding the differences among a range of product disclosure types will help building teams avoid confusion. Heather Gadonniex, LEED AP BD&C is the Director of Building and Construction for thinkstep. She is a seasoned strategist with over a decade of experience developing and leading international product marketing, business development, and product development initiatives focused on product sustainability and transparency for start-ups and large The Owners’ Guide to Starting Integrated multinational organizations. The Owners’ Guide to Starting Integrated IPD: An Updated Working Definition Learn how HPDs can help manufacturers get their products specified and how the design community can use them to better specify the products we use in our projects. That’s what SFCSI programs are all about --Professional development for design and construction professionals.© Please make your reservations no later than Sunday, January 10, 2016. Go to http://csiscvjan2016.brownpapertickets.com Cost is $40 for CSI SCV & SF Chapter Members, $50 for all others. RESERVATIONS REQUIRE PRE-PAYMENT. Place: Vivace RestaurantTime: 6:00 PM Social Hour 1910 Ralston Ave, Belmont, CA6:30 Dinner (650) 637-06117:30 PM Program Link to Vivace website & map: http://www.vivacerestaurant.com/contact2.htm Page 1 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE JANUARY 2016 Happy New Year everyone! Time to kick start our CSI engines after a holiday break. Our regular monthly meeting for January will be on our normal day, the second Wednesday, this month January 13, but at a different location! It is a joint meeting with the Santa Clara Valley Chapter and will be held at Vivace Ristorante, 1910 Ralston Ave., in Belmont. Social hour begins at 6:00 with a three course dinner starting at 6:30. Special thanks to the SCV Chapter for taking on the lion’s share of the planning for this event. Register at http:// csiscvjan2016.brownpapertickets.com/ President John Sellen Our speaker is Heather Gadonniex, Director of Building and Construction for thinkstep, https://www.thinkstep.com/ a global firm providing clients with strategies and operations for sustainability success through software and consulting services. Heather will be discussing LEED v. 4 including requirements for increased transparency including Health Product Declarations, of HPDs. In February we will be back at the Marriott Union Square on 02/10/2016 for a joint meeting with NAWIC for a discussion about why 32 percent of women graduates from design programs are not staying in the industry. Thanks goes out to Anne Whitacre, Programs Committee Chair, and Merideth Marschak, President Elect, for their planning efforts to schedule our programs well in advance. MARK YOUR CALENDAR! February 10 Monthly Meeting March 9Pro-Fair April 13 Monthly Meeting May 11 Monthly Meeting May 18-22 Bi-Region Conference, Lake Tahoe June 8 Awards Banquet Pro-Fair 2016 will be on March 9. This year’s event will be held at The Lodge of the Regency Center at Sutter and Van Ness in San Francisco. Our guest speaker will be the renown visual futurist and designer Syd Mead, the creative force behind so many of the futuristic images we’ve seen in movies and in architecture over the past 45 years. Visit his website at http://sydmead.com/v/12/ for a glimpse at the impressive resume and past projects of this visionary. Committee Chair and Board Director Edwin Essary is doing a terrific job with planning a memorable evening. Pro-Fair 2016 is sure to be an event not to be missed. Time to start planning to attend the 2016 West Region Conference, Continued on next page Page 2 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE Continued from previous page to be held May 18-22, 2016 at the Hyatt Regency Lake Tahoe Resort at Incline Village, NV. This year’s conference will be a biregion conference with the Northwest Region. The Sacramento Chapter CSI will host, and they are planning some amazing events and attractions. Go to http://csiwestregion.org/2016_Region_ Conference.html for sponsorship, registration, scheduling, and resort information. Silent auction items at the Holiday party PUBLISHED BY THE PUBLICATIONS COMMITTEE EDITOR Elizabeth Porter, AIA, CSI, CCS [email protected] PHOTOGRAPHER Elizabeth Porter, AIA, CSI, CCS [email protected] EDITORIAL POLICY In December we once again had a successful Holiday Party with our friends from the SCV and EBO CSI Chapters. Over 80 members and guests were in attendance. After last year’s rain storm on the night of the party, I specifically ordered a clear dry night, and presto! we got it! Thanks to the tri-chapter committee for putting this all together and to the SF CSI Foundation for sponsoring and organizing the Silent Auction to raise scholarship funds. So what do you think of our efforts for FY 2016 so far? Have you enjoyed the programs? What do you think of our venue? Does the new format tickle your fancy? Your Board of Directors has the difficult task of trying to please all of the people all of the time, in the tough San Francisco market; a feat not yet accomplished. Help us to keep SF CSI a meaningful and productive organization by putting your talents and skills to work for the benefit of the whole organization. Now is the time to start thinking about elections and the new Board for FY 2017. Please take a few minutes of your valuable time to read about everything that’s going on with SF CSI, right here in this month’s SPECIFICS! I look forward to seeing you at an upcoming event… and bring a friend. John Sellen President of San Francisco CSI 1. To inform members of the Chapter and Institute goals and activities directed toward these goals; 2. To inform members of the Chapter and Regional activities, Board actions; and 3. To provide a forum for all members. Page 3 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE PRO-FAIR IS COMING MARCH 9! By Edwin Essary Regency Center, venue for Pro-Fair Regency Center dining room The annual PRO-FAIR event embodies a San Francisco CSI Chapter tradition of facilitating the development of relationships that make buildings better. This tradition continues on March 9, 2016, at the historic Regency Center in San Francisco. Our PROFAIR 2015, with the highest professional attendance in several years, sold out quickly, encouraging us to enlarge the venue and streamline the experience for sponsors and their guests! While housed in one of the city’s landmark structures, this year’s format has also been re-oriented to focus on our vendor members, building personal relationships and forward thinking. Each sponsorship includes a small host station in a luxurious, relaxed setting; two hours of direct personal contact, in a targetrich environment of prominent members of the Bay Area’s design and construction community, with three hosted bars and a taste of the city’s most delicious hor douvres; and your choice of three masterfully prepared dinners in the breathtaking Lodge. Following dinner, our guest speaker, Mr. Syd Mead, will present some of his most famous works and share his thoughts on incorporating the design of structures in a broader and futuristic view of technological advances, societal change and sustainable urban lifestyles. It is certain to be an evening to remember for you and your guests! Aspiring guests who have not already been invited by a sponsor may register their interest and contact information on the website. Regency Center primary reception area For more detailed information: Speaker: https://vimeo.com/17376932 Venue: http://www.regencycentersf.com/the-lodge/ Other event questions: Edwin Essary [email protected] Secondary reception area The San Francisco Specifics is your award winning Chapter newsletter! Page 4 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE FROM THE SPECIFIER’S DESK By Anne Whitacre Holiday party salad course I’m working over the holidays because it provides me with the thing that “captured” specifiers seldom have – quiet. The office (no matter what office I work for) is typically about 50% strength; we never have deadlines, and those weeks usually consist of thoughtful contemplation of my specifier’s task, a sorting out of reference materials, and maybe a long lunch or two thrown into the mix. I’m looking back at what may have been the most demanding year of my career with the largest project of my career. That alone is satisfying but after the New Year, I’m looking at a string of 60 hour weeks in our planning calendar until the large project finally is sent to the contractor. So after this year, what industry changes am I seeing? 1) Delegated design: I’m starting to see a contractor backlash against this concept – which in some ways brings documentation to a full circle in my career lifetime. When I first started working, we designed everything (curtainwalls included) because everything was custom designed. As we started using more off-the-shelf systems, we started pitching delegated design because we had little control over who the contractor selected as a subcontractor. Now, contractors have caught on that all that engineering will Craig Mount with Jim and Jaymi Hill and cost them money, and I’m seeing some contractors refuse to Michael Chambers accept delegated design for systems on their projects. I think this is still to be resolved, but it’s an indication that costs are being tightened even more than before. 2) More exterior wall – not glazed; the energy code is not going to permit fully glass walls any longer – unless they are double skinned walls with a high insulating value. One project on my desk is precast concrete and double glazed windows – I did dozens of those 30 years ago. 3) Amenities, everywhere. Every health care organization is inviting the public in – for community meetings, farmer’s markets, and exercise classes. Every multi-building office complex has more sports courts than a junior college (bocce, basketball, Chris Rowe, Terri Sudbrook, and Tony Camp with Jerry and Diane Pozo Continued on next page Page 5 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE Continued from previous page parkour, yoga). It’s all about attracting people these days, and the current thinking is that amenities will do that, either as employees or clients. Silent auction items beckon 4) Sustainability labels: We’re all familiar with LEED (in various incantations) and CalGreen. Hold on, because we’re also getting WELL, DECLARE, JUST, Living Building “Petal” credits, Cradle to Cradle…. We’re getting tentative inquiries from clients about all of them. I personally hope that some of this sifts out in the next few years. Let’s just say that there is a learning curve and implementation cost to all of them. 5) Design-Build. I find this one rather amusing as an “innovation” because Washington State has used design-build as the primary method for procuring new State buildings for the past 25 years. I’m also seeing more instances of what we used to call “DesignAssist”, where the contractor team in on board at the very beginning of the project. In Washington State, we went through a period where every project was reduced in cost to the minimum; eventually, the Design-Build process started to spend more time on the actual “design” part with early contractor involvement. I will admit that I don’t like having a contractor tell me what sort of roofing and waterproofing we’re using on an institutional project. Let me just say that “assist” should actually mean “assist” and not “dictate”. Craig Mount and Paulette Salisbury Happy New Year everyone -- THE PACIFIC ENERGY CENTER At 851 Howard Street, San Francisco Presents its series of Programs Most are free of charge and carry CEU credits. Register at 415-973-7268 or www.pge.com/pec Silent auction items Page 6 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE Linda Stansen, Craig Mount and Paulette Salisbury The Piedmont Singers entertained us at the holiday party Randy Agno, CSI, ACT Architectural Consultant Mobile (925) 344-2665 E-mail: [email protected] http://www.behr.com/www.BehrPro.com | www.espanol.BehrPro.com www.KilzProX.com | www.Kilz.com Behr offers: Direct to Pro Delivery, Division 9 Specifications, Color Services, CEU AIA approved courses, Architectural Coatings, Industrial Coatings, Stains, Waterproofing Systems, Floor Coatings. We are CHPS approved, MPI rated & approved, ZERO VOC Products, and GreenGuard Certified. Page 7 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE TELL ME AGAIN – AND SHOW ME THE MONEY! By Sheldon Wolfe Minneapolis - St. Paul Chapter In the last few articles we looked at how redundancies needlessly increase the size of specifications. Another thing that affects the length of specifications is writing style. Even though CSI’s mantra, “Clear, concise, correct, complete”, suggests specifications Brenda Hunsinger and Bernadette Jurich should contain only the essence of requirements, commercial guide specifications and office master specifications alike tend to use words that aren’t necessary. In 1949, Ben John Small wrote an article titled “The Case for the Streamlined Specification.” In it, he uses anecdote and logic to explain why terse writing is superior to verbose. He also cites previous works to show that streamlined writing is nothing new, but has been advocated as far back as 1896. In his opening remarks, Small said, “Streamlining is not and never has been considered a panacea or short cut in the writing of good specifications. If one can write a thorough and competent specification using the long form one can streamline that same specification without the slightest adulteration, yet reduce its bulk by one-third or more.” Briefly, streamlining is the removal of all words that are not essential to understanding the specifications. Cathy and Nick Vadasz with Robert Hemphill Tim Maliepaard and Carl Falchetta Small used this quotation to show an impressive extreme of verbosity: “The Owner shall not nor shall any department or officer thereof be precluded or estopped by any return or certificate made or given by the Board, the Engineer or other officer, agent or appointee thereof under any provision of this contract from at any time either before or after the final completion and acceptance of the work and payment therefor pursuant to any such return or certificate, showing the true and correct classification; amount, quality and character of the work done and materials furnished by the Contractor or any other person under this contract or the reasonable value of work done under ITEM XXX of this contract or from showing at any time that any such return or certificate is untrue and incorrect or improperly made in any particular or that the work and materials or any part thereof do not in fact conform to the requirements of this contract; and the Owner Continued on next page Page 8 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE Continued from previous page shall not be precluded or estopped, notwithstanding any such return or certificate and payment in accordance therewith, from demanding and recovering from the Contractor such damages as it may sustain by reason of his failure to comply with this contract or the specifications.” Linda Stansen, John Sellen and Merideth Marschak That’s a single sentence with 196 words! Small goes on to say, “Opposition lawyers love obese specifications for there are bound to be many loopholes in the avoirdupois.” One of the first steps in streamlining is to use imperative mode, rather than indicative mode. While your English teacher might be impressed to hear you use those terms, they’re not in everyone’s vocabulary. In everyday language, this means use verbs to begin sentences, as if you’re talking to someone. If you were talking to a contractor, you wouldn’t say “The Contractor shall paint the bollard” and you wouldn’t say “You shall paint the bollard.” Instead, you would say, “Paint the bollard.” Next, eliminate articles, such as “a”, “all”, “an”, “any”, and “the”. Your Division 01 states that words such as “approved”, “directed”, and similar actions are assumed to be performed by the architect unless followed by some other entity, so they can be omitted. With these few rules, Small shows how specifications can be simplified without losing their intent (see diagram on next page). Continued on next page Patricia Smith The see nati The the pos to c sem the can and stru incl leav area Paulette Salisbury Guests enjoying the holiday celebration Page 9 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE Continued from previous page Linda Stansen, Mary Nowee, Merideth Marschak, Anne Whitacre and Paulette Salisbury He follows with this amusing summary of the changes. Chatterbox Hospital Specification Surgery Department Laboratory Report No. 11/8. Robert Hemphill and John Sellen 1. Patient: Case “X” 2. Weight (before operation): 485 words 3. Weight (after operation): 251 words 4. Net Loss: 234 words 5. List of diseased Excised Material: [followed by a list of text removed from each paragraph] At each step in the streamlining process, it’s common to hear, “So what? If the meaning is the same, what difference does it make how it’s stated?” As it happens, it makes a big difference. The obvious difference is one of length. Following the above rules, and, at the same time, correctly addressing the contractor rather than Christopher Tesser and Taryn Fischer Continued on next page Page 10 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE Continued from previous page a subcontractor, “The painter shall apply paint to the bollard” becomes “Paint the bollard”, reducing the length from eight words to three. Eric Patricio and Linda Stansen The shorter text means the specifications can be read more quickly, and the simpler sentences mean they will be easier to understand. I believe they also will be more likely to be read. I’m sure you’ve seen a variety of expressions when you ask someone to review a project manual: bewilderment, dread, disbelief, and hate come to mind. You probably have not seen joy, thankfulness, or excitement. You never will, but if the project manual is half an inch instead of two inches thick, it’s more likely you’ll get useful responses. The bottom line is the driving factor in virtually everything related to construction. We try to save money on materials, installation, storage, transportation, and more, but we seem to have no concern about the cost of poorly written or poorly drawn documents. A number of studies have shown that documents that are easy to understand do affect cost. An oft-cited Navy study showed that changing from bureaucratic style to plain language reduced reading time by about twenty percent, at the same time increasing comprehension. If only officers read documents in plain language, the savings were calculated to be about $30,000,000. If all Navy personnel used plain language documents, the savings were projected to be $300,000,000. Christopher Tesser Removing redundancies and streamlining not only make them easier to read, they make them easier to understand. The result? Fewer mistakes, fewer questions, more accurate bids, and lower cost. © 2015, Sheldon Wolfe, RA, FCSI, CCS, CCCA, CSC Agree? Disagree? Leave your swconstructivethoughts.blogspot.com/ comments at http:// Sources: John Sellen, Bill Nelson and Vivian Volz The Case for the Streamlined Specification, the Construction Specifier. Writing for Dollars, Writing to Please, www.impact-information.com/impactinfo/ dollars.htm Tell me again part 1 http://swconstructivethoughts.blogspot.com/2015/08/tell-meagain-part-1.html Tell me again part 2 http://swconstructivethoughts.blogspot.com/2015/09/tell-meagain-part-2.html Tell me again part 3 http://swconstructivethoughts.blogspot.com/2015/10/tell-meagain-part-3.html Haystacks: Do construction documents do what they’re supposed to do? http:// swconstructivethoughts.blogspot.com/2015/03/haystacks-do-constructiondocuments-do.html Page 11 San Francisco Chapter VOL. LII NO. 1 | JANUARY 2016 | NEWSLETTER OF THE SAN FRANCISCO CHAPTER | CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE Nick DeOcampo, Michael Morris, Edwin Essary and David Rausch Mary Nowee, Julie Barrett and Joseph Joslin Guest, Fred Deuschle and Anne Whitacre Speaker Odis Sudderfield and Eric Cole Vivian Volz has an appetite! Fred Deuschle and Odis Sudderfield, our speakers Page 12 San Francisco Chapter Construction Specifications Institute PO Box 2356 San Francisco, CA 94126-2356 415-294-3800 [email protected] http://sanfrancisco.csinet.org CSI membership is composed of a cross-section of the construction industry - architect, engineers, contractors, developers, manufacturers, suppliers and representatives from allied industries. Chapter activities reflect the unbiased concerns of the entire industry - not one section of it. Members through the Chapter, Region and Institute have the opportunity to contribute their views and experience to the improvement of specifications and other contract documents. Board Members 2014-2015 President John Sellen 415-430-8027 [email protected] President-Elect Merideth Marschak 510-649-8295 [email protected] Immediate Past President Tim Maliepaard 916-847-8447 [email protected] Secretary Michael Morris 415-956-5211 [email protected] Treasurer Ben Miller 619-248-1576 [email protected] Vice President Liesl Morell 650-207-5266 [email protected] Vice President Vivian Volz 415-244-6756 [email protected] Director Peg Collins 909-509-1402 [email protected] Director Edwin Essary 415-715-4678 [email protected] Director Jeffery Glick 415-595-1740 [email protected] Director Bill Nelson 415-836-4182 [email protected] Region Director Linda M. Stansen 650-570-6411 [email protected] Publications Elizabeth Porter 510-517-5360 [email protected] Pro-Fair Edwin Essary 415-715-4678 [email protected] Programs Anne Whitacre 415-356-8685 [email protected] Bill Nelson (415) 836-4182 [email protected] Directors Committee Chairs Page 13