Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail
Transcription
Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail
An Assessment of the Infrastructure and Service Requirements of Homeless Individuals in the Baccalieu Trail Region, 2009-10 Prepared For: Mariner Resource Opportunities Network Inc P.O. Box 520 Carbonear A1Y 1B9 Phone: (709)596-6217 Fax: (709)596-4473 Website: www.aroundthebay.ca Prepared By: Heather Tite, BA, MWS P.O. Box 1664 Bay Roberts, NL A0A 1G0 Phone: (709)786-3346 Email: [email protected] Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Acknowledgments I would like to take this opportunity to thank all of the groups and individuals who contributed their time and expertise to the development of this Community Plan for Housing and Homelessness in the Baccalieu Trail Region. In particular, I would like to that the members of the Baccalieu Advisory Board Community Resource Sub-Committee. These individuals are extraordinarily committed to ensuring that all residents of the region have access to safe, affordable and appropriate housing, and worked tirelessly to ensure that the resulting Community Plan would address the wide range of housing and homelessness issues in the region. These individuals are as follows: Sheila Handrigan, Tracy Oates, Wendy Cranford, Kim Crane, Mary Cleary, Karen Davis, Dana Combden, Gladys Mercer, Megan Forward, Marie Ryan, and Cindy Clarke. 2 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table of Contents 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 5 1.1 Statement of Purpose: ......................................................................................................................... 5 1.2 Project Objectives: .............................................................................................................................. 5 2. Project Background ................................................................................................................................... 6 3. Methodology ............................................................................................................................................. 7 3.1 Community Resource Committee ....................................................................................................... 7 3.2 Overview of Methodology .................................................................................................................. 8 3.2.1 Assessment of Regionally Available Housing and Support Services and Infrastructure ............. 8 3.2.2 Town Hall Meetings/Focus Groups ............................................................................................. 9 3.2.3 Strategic Planning Day............................................................................................................... 10 4. Findings .................................................................................................................................................. 12 4.1 Demographic Profile of the Baccalieu Trail Region ......................................................................... 13 4.1.1 Bay Roberts Local Area ............................................................................................................. 22 4.1.2 Harbour Grace Area ................................................................................................................... 26 4.1.3 Carbonear Area .......................................................................................................................... 30 4.1.4 North Shore Conception Bay ..................................................................................................... 34 4.1.5 Heart’s Delight Area .................................................................................................................. 38 4.1.6 New Perlican – Winterton Area ................................................................................................. 42 4.2 Housing and Homelessness Issues in the Baccalieu Trail Region .................................................... 47 4.2.1 Focus Group - Old Perlican ....................................................................................................... 50 4.2.2 Focus Group - Whiteway ........................................................................................................... 51 4.3 Strategic Planning Session ................................................................................................................ 51 4.3.1 Issues Related to Housing and Homelessness in the Baccalieu Trail Region ............................ 52 4.3.2 Local Assets Related to Housing and Homelessness ................................................................. 54 3 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 5. Strategic Directions ................................................................................................................................. 57 6. Contact Information ................................................................................................................................ 72 4 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 1. Introduction This report is in fulfillment of a contract between Heather Tite (consultant) and Mariner Resource Opportunities Network Inc. 1.1 Statement of Purpose: The intention of this project is to develop a comprehensive Community Plan which will aim to address the needs and challenges facing individuals who are homeless or at risk of homelessness in the Baccalieu Trail region, NL, and in doing so, improve the region’s ability to ensure that all residents have access to safe, affordable and appropriate housing. 1.2 Project Objectives: This project has four main objectives, namely: 1. Establish a Resource Committee who will provide project direction and monitor progress on an ongoing basis. The committee will oversee the development of the project and assist in focusing the resulting Community Plan. 2. Develop and implement a research methodology designed to identify the needs of and challenges facing individuals in the Baccalieu Trail region with regard to homelessness and the risk of homelessness. 3. Identify the services and other supports which are needed to reduce the rates of homelessness or vulnerability to homelessness among individuals in the Baccalieu Trail region. 4. Develop a comprehensive Community Plan based upon the findings of this research and provide a comprehensive set of recommendations based upon the research and the consensus of the Resource Committee. 5 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 2. Project Background This document describes the development of a Community Plan for addressing issues associated with housing and homelessness in the Baccalieu Trail region of Newfoundland and Labrador. This Community Plan represents the culmination of a five month study sponsored by Mariner Resource Opportunities Network Inc (M-RON Inc) in association with the Baccalieu Advisory Board on Housing and Homelessness, and is intended to support the development of a collaborative approach to addressing the region’s unique housing needs. In recent years there has been a growing awareness among service providers and community organizations in the Baccalieu Trail region that, despite that lack of a visible presence of homeless individuals in the region, many residents are experiencing difficulties with regard to attaining safe, affordable and appropriate housing. While initially established as a vehicle with which to explore local issues and to develop collective strategies to address these concerns, the Baccalieu Advisory Board on Housing and Homelessness has become particularly active with regard to addressing issues of housing and homelessness in the region. Comprised of representatives from community groups, government departments, health care institutions, faith organizations and community development agencies, the Baccalieu Advisory Board has functioned as a forum in which to share information and develop collective strategies to address the wide range of issues related to housing and homelessness in the Baccalieu Trail region. This process of facilitating increased cooperation amongst community organizations, service providers, and other stakeholders is mirrored at the provincial level. In September 2009, the St. John’s Housing Network hosted a Strategic Planning Day focused on defining the scope and direction of a Provincial Housing Network. The Provincial Housing Network, once it attains its potential, will facilitate collaboration on housing projects throughout the province. In addition, Regional Coordinators have been employed to act as resource persons to community groups and service providers who are interested in developing local housing initiatives. The Community Plan outlined in this document should be viewed as an expansion to this initial collaboration and is intended primarily as a means of coordinating the various housing initiatives underway in the region in such a way as to make the most effective use of the available financial and human resources. This report is organized into five sections. The first section provides an introduction and outlines the context of the project and the overall goals of the community plan. The second section provides an overview of the methodology employed in the development of the community plan. Section three details the findings of the study, including a discussion of the demographic composition of the various local areas housed within the region. The document concludes with an overview of the strategic directions which form the core tasks of the Community Plan. 6 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 3. Methodology Throughout the development of the project methodology, the primary concern was to ensure that the resulting Community Plan would be both feasible and reflective of the region’s unique needs. To this end, three broad goals were outlined and used to inform the development of the methodology. First, the Community Plan should be reflective of the unique geographic and demographic composition of the Baccalieu Trail region. Unlike other areas, the Baccalieu Trail region is comprised of both urban and rural populations. Services and related programmes are almost entirely located within the Carbonear, Harbour Grace or Bay Roberts areas all of which have fairly direct access to St. John’s (< 1 hour drive). Conversely, communities located in the Trinity Bay and North Shore areas of the region have access to substantially fewer services and share fewer social and economic ties with the St. John’s Metropolitan area. Second, the Community Plan should be evidenced-based, i.e., developed in direct response to information which is as accurate, inclusive and as current as possible.1 Third, the Community Plan will need to be feasible. In other words, this plan will need to be consistent with the resources (both human and financial) that can be reasonably accessed in the region. While it is likely that there are a multitude of housing and homelessness issues that should be addressed in the region, it is unlikely that there is currently a large enough resource base to address all of these issues simultaneously. Any attempt to do so, is likely to result in the over extension of scare resources. Instead, care will need to be taken to ensure that the ‘projects’ outlined in the community plan are realistic. Finally, the Community Plan should provide concise and measurable goals and objectives. 3.1 Community Resource Committee The planning process associated with this project was developed in consultation with the Baccalieu Advisory Board Community Resource Sub-Committee. This committee was established as a sub-committee of the Baccalieu Advisory Board on Housing and Homelessness and was comprised of individuals from Eastern Health, Human Resources Labour and Employment, Baccalieu Trail Youth Employment Centre, Regional Economic Development Board (M-RON Inc), CBDC-TC, the Town of Carbonear and the Department of Justice. Throughout the study, the Resource Committee held regular bi-weekly meetings during which the process, findings and recommendations were discussed. It should be noted, that unlike the St. John’s Area, the Baccalieu Trail region does not have an easily accessible source for community data, outside of what is available through the Community Accounts website (www.communityaccounts.ca). Thus, the data collected for this region, particularly with regard to specific target populations, will not be as precise as those available in larger urban centres. 1 7 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 3.2 Overview of Methodology While the Baccalieu Trail region has established an advisory board to address housing and homelessness issues, this collaboration is in its infancy. The Community Plan for Housing and Homelessness outlined in this document is the first such plan to be developed in the region. From a planning perspective, this lack of an integrated approach to providing housing and support services means that there is little in the way of readily accessible data regarding individuals who are currently or potentially homeless. Furthermore, the current gaps in regionally available services and supports means that the range of ‘essential’ programmes, services and infrastructure that could be included in the resulting Community Plan will far outweigh the human and financial resources that are available in the region. Subsequently, the primary task of this study and planning process will be to identify a small number of ‘foundational’ projects that can be completed without overextending the current resources and which will increase the capacity of the region to address housing and homelessness issues. The process outlined in this report was intended to provide a systematic approach to identifying these needs. This methodology is comprised of three distinct components, namely: an assessment of the current housing and support services and infrastructure that is available within the region; ‘Town Hall’ meetings/focus groups; and identification of priority issues to be incorporated into the Community Plan 3.2.1 Assessment of Regionally Available Housing and Support Services and Infrastructure The intention of this component of the research was to provide a clear depiction of the types of housing and support services and infrastructure which are currently available within the Baccalieu Trail region. The concern here was to ensure that the initiatives that will be incorporated into the Community Plan are not simply replicating existing services. In this phase of the research, data regarding the availability of services, programming, housing and related supports was collected through consultations with community leaders, and service providers, as well as through existing sources of data such as the Community Accounts (www.communityaccounts.ca). As this region encompasses a large number of small communities, the data was clustered into Local Areas. During this phase of the research, consultations have been held with local clergy, mental health/addictions practitioners, youth workers, Community Support Programme social workers, Regional Probations Officers, and representatives from Human Resources Labour and Employment. These individuals were chosen as informants due to their professional work in addressing housing and homelessness issues experienced by residents of the region. It should be noted that there are currently no organizations in the region which are mandated solely to address housing and homelessness issues. Instead, housing and homelessness issues are currently only 8 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region addressed as a component of other professional services. These consultations were conducted between October and December 2009, and consisted of in-depth open-ended interviews. During these consultations, participants were asked to outline their involvement with regard to addressing housing and homelessness issues in the region, to describe some of the challenges that they had experienced with regard to this work, and to discuss their ideas regarding the types of infrastructure and support services which would improve their ability to address the housing needs of their clients. 3.2.2 Town Hall Meetings/Focus Groups The second component of this study and planning process were ‘town hall’ meetings/focus groups. These sessions were aimed primarily at identifying the housing needs particular to the Local Areas within the region. As stated, the Baccalieu Trail region encompasses a wide range of communities all of which have fairly unique needs. While the majority of services are housed within the Carbonear, Harbour Grace and Bay Roberts areas, there are a number of different ‘service hubs’ all of which provide a fairly inclusive repertoire of services to the surrounding area. The intention of the focus groups was to ensure that the resulting community plan was reflective of the needs of all areas of the region. It should be noted that the Community Resource Committee is comprised of individuals from the Carbonear, Harbour Grace, Bay Roberts areas, thereby ensuring that the housing and homelessness issues present within these areas will be well represented through the course of this study and planning process. Initially, three ‘town hall’ meetings or focus groups were scheduled. These sessions were to be held between October 26th and November 3rd and were to be located in three areas of the region, namely: i. ii. iii. Old Perlican-Bay de Verde; Hearts Content/Delight- Whiteway Dildo-Blaketown. Due to the small number of responses to the invitations and difficulties with finding suitable venues, only two sessions were held; one being in Whiteway and encompassing the ‘Trinity Shore’ and the other in Old Perlican and encompassing the ‘North Shore.’ During these sessions, participants were asked to identify and discuss what they see as the primary issues related to housing and homelessness in their area (please note that a similar process was employed with the Community Resource Committee, resulting in the generation of a list of concerns and questions). In addition, participants were asked to outline the types of services and supports that they currently offer as well as identify the types of initiatives that they feel would benefit their community and/or clients. Finally, participants were asked to identify 9 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region the types of resources their organization or department would be willing and able to contribute to the implementation of the resulting Community Plan.2 3.2.3 Strategic Planning Day The final phase of the research was a day long strategic planning session which brought together stakeholders from around the region. The intention of this session was to discuss the findings of the initial consultations and focus groups and to use this data to inform the development of collective strategy to address the identified issues. The Strategic Planning Session was hosted on November 18th at the Avalon Wolverines Search and Rescue Building, Bay Roberts. This planning session employed an ‘Opportunities Management’ approach to identifying the priority issues and initiatives. An Opportunities Management approach entails a ‘stage-gate’ approach to planning, in which the a wide range of initiatives are examined in relation to a predefined range of criteria with only those initiatives which best meet the identified criteria being incorporated into the resulting plan. The intention of this process is to ensure that resources are not wasted on projects or initiatives which have little chance of success or do not meet the expressed goals of the group(s) or organization(s). Within the framework of this project, the housing initiatives that were to be incorporated into the Community Plan would need to meet the following criteria: a. Will improve the overall ability of residents to access safe, affordable and appropriate housing b. Does not replicate existing infrastructure or services c. Is feasible given the current financial and human resources d. Does not require legislative or programming changes at a provincial or federal level e. Has a local ‘champion’ or proponent to oversee the implementation of the initiative The Strategic Planning Session was divided into three components. First, a group discussion was held in order to compile an exhaustive list of the various housing and homelessness issues that are present within the region. Following this discussion, a second group discussion was held in 2 It should be noted that neither focus group was well attended despite the recruitment efforts. This lack of attendance was likely the product of a variety of factors including the ‘newness’ of the topic, the prevailing perception that homelessness is not an issue in this region. It should also be noted that these focus groups were held during the H1N1 outbreak. The focus group in Old Perlican was attended solely by local clergy, while the focus group in Whiteway was a bit more diverse and included representatives from the local development agency. 10 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region order to compile a similar list of the regions assets that are either currently working on addressing housing or homelessness issues or which could provide a supportive role during the implementation of the resulting community plan. Employing a nominal group method, participants were then asked to define which housing and homelessness issues they felt were priorities. Finally, the participants were divided into groups in order to outline the goals, objectives, tasks and proponent(s) for each of the initiatives that had been defined as priorities. Again, the small groups were asked to ensure that their ‘project outlines’ met the predefined criteria. The resulting project outlines then became the core components of the eventual Community Plan. Start Date Completed Remaining Work Plan Resource Committee … Lit Review Consultations Focus Groups Analysis Working Document 11 1/12/2010 12/23/2009 12/3/2009 11/13/2009 10/24/2009 10/4/2009 9/14/2009 8/25/2009 FIGURE 1- PROJECT TIMELINES Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 4. Findings As part this study and community planning process, a limited review of available Community Plans has been completed. These community plans vary greatly in scope; with the St. John’s Community Plan representing perhaps the most comprehensive assessment of housing and homelessness issues. The clarity of the St. John’s Community Plan is likely a function of a variety of factors, including the availability and variety of services and infrastructure and the accessibility of data regarding client populations and target groups. In other regions, the housing support services and related infrastructure are not as well established and do not cover the same range of housing issues as those available in the St. John’s area. It should be noted that the majority of community plans are largely focused on one or two municipalities (i.e., hubs) within a region. Unlike other areas, the Community Plan for the Baccalieu Trail region encompasses a large number of communities; many of which vary greatly with regard to size, infrastructure, and economic status and so on. In addition, the Community Plan outlined in this document is one of the first attempts in this region to develop and implement a collective and collaborative approach to addressing housing and homelessness issues in the region. As such, there is a paucity of regional statistics related to the specific experience of housing and homelessness in the region. It is hoped that the implementation of this Community Plan will result in an increased capacity to collaborate at the regional level and in doing so improve the overall accessibility of local data. As part of the initial literature review, the provincial social housing plan (A Social Housing Plan for Newfoundland and Labrador) was also examined. It should be noted that for this region’s Community Plan to be successfully implemented it will need to be compatible with the goals outlined in the provincial strategy. With this in mind, there are a number of key features which should be highlighted. First, the Provincial Strategy, in keeping with national guidelines defines a ‘core housing need’ as adequacy, suitability and affordability of housing. This strategy also outlines three key directions, namely: Developing partnerships between community organization and government departments to ensure that housing assistance is part of an integrated approach to community development and individual well-being; Ensuring that resources are allocated in such a way as to ensure that those with the greatest need receive the greatest amount of support; and Providing responsive housing assistance to ensure that the types of housing supports are reflective of the needs of current and potential clients. 12 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 4.1 Demographic Profile of the Baccalieu Trail Region As stated the Baccalieu Trail region encompasses a wide range of communities many of which vary greatly in terms of size, infrastructure and economic wellbeing. The intention of this section is to provide an overview of the demographic profile of the region as a whole, as well as to highlight the characteristics unique to Local Areas within the region. Again, the concern here is to ensure that the variations among Local Areas are reflected in the Community Plan and the projects and initiatives which are housed within it. The Baccalieu Trail region has an overall population of approximately 40,000 (see Table 4.2). Within the region the largest centres are Carbonear (population 7,780; see Table 4.12), Bay Roberts (population 5,705; see Table 4.6), and Harbour Grace (population 5,375; see Table 4.9). These areas are also home to the largest concentrations of public infrastructure and support services in the region. As illustrated in Figure 2, while the largest concentration of services and related infrastructure is housed within the most well populated areas, there are a variety of facilities and services present throughout the region. For instance, personal care homes are located in Dildo, Whiteway, Winterton, Old Perlican, Lower Island Cove, Victoria, Carbonear, Bishop’s Cove, Spaniards Bay, Bay Roberts, Shearstown, Clarke’s Beach and Brigus. Similarly, there are public schools, libraries and internet access sites dispersed amongst the region’s various communities. In addition, many towns within the region possess community centres, town halls and church buildings; all of which contribute to the public infrastructure. Finally, both Eastern Health and Human Resources Labour and Employment maintain a number of satellite offices outside of the region’s central hub, thereby improving the accessibility of support services in the more rural areas of the region. From an economic perspective, the Baccalieu Trail remains below the provincial average with respect to a number of the key indicators of economic wellbeing. Within the region, the economic self-reliance ratio as of 2004 was 68.8% compared to the provincial average of 78.1%. Similarly, the regional percentages of the labour force who have received employment insurance for at least one week per year, is also significant higher than the provincial average (see Table 4.1). While both personal income per capita and real disposable income per capita (in 1992 dollars) have shown a steady increase since 1996, both remain below the provincial average (see Table 4.1). Overall the region has exhibited a decline in the total number and incidence of low income families since 2003, with a total of 3,100 low income families as of 2005 (see Table 4.3). By far the highest rates of incidence of low income census families is in the lone-parent categories (45.00%) the majority of which are headed by a female member of the family. 13 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Figure 2 - Infrastructure Economic Zone 17 14 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.1 Economic Zone 17 - Economic Indicators Derived from the Community Accounts (2008) Economic Self Reliance Ratio Year 1996 2004 Year 1996 Zone 17 Province 63.6% 68.8% 78.1% Percentage of Labour Force Receiving Employment Insurance Minimum 1 Week/Year Zone 17 Province Difference 48.1% - 2001 46.4% 36.2% -10.2% 2002 46.6% 36.2% -10.4% 2003 48.0% 36.5% -11.5% 2004 48.4% 36.6% -11.8% Year 1996 1999 2002 2004 Personal Income Per Capita Province Difference ($) Difference (%) $14,300.00 -$2,200.00 -15.4% $16,000.00 -$2,500.00 -15.6% $18,800.00 -$2,900.00 -15.4% $20,600.00 -$3,300.00 -16.0% Year 1996 1999 2002 2004 Zone 17 $12,100.00 $13,500.00 $15,900.00 $17,300.00 Zone 17 $ 9,500.00 $10,100.00 $11,300.00 $11,700.00 Change (%) n/a -0.2% +0.2% -0.6% Real Disposable Income Per Capita (in 1992 Dollars) Province Difference ($) Difference (%) Change (%) $10,800.00 -$1,300.00 -12.0% n/a $11,600.00 -$1,500.00 -12.9% -0.9% $12,900.00 -$1,600.00 -12.4% +0.5% $13,400.00 -$1,700.00 -12.7% -0.2% 15 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.2 - Census 1986-2006: Population by Age and Gender Economic Zone 17 - Baccalieu Trail Region Male Female Total 19,330 20,510 39,850 Total Age Groups 0-4 875 835 1,710 5-9 1,025 950 1,970 10 - 14 1,130 1,125 2,255 15-19 1,305 1,260 2,560 20-24 1,085 1,045 2,135 25-29 890 930 1,815 30-34 1,010 1,200 2,210 35-39 1,290 1,400 2,695 40-44 1,535 1,585 3,120 45-49 1,560 1,680 3,240 50-54 1,650 1,815 3,465 55-59 1,700 1,770 3,475 60-64 1,395 1,415 2,810 65-69 1,050 990 2,040 70-74 740 840 1,585 75-79 520 620 1,145 80-84 335 500 840 85-89 175 385 555 90+ 70 150 220 Notes: Figures may not add to total due to random rounding. Census data contained in this table is from the 100% sample unless otherwise noted. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on information provided from the Census of Population 1986, 1991, 1996, 2001, and 2006 Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 16 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.3 - Economic Zone 17 - Baccalieu Trail Region Number and Incidence of Low Income Census Families 2003 2004 2005 Counts of Low Income Families Total Family Types 3,520 3,220 3,100 Couple Families 1,450 1,240 1,070 Lone-Parent Families 930 920 910 Male Lone-Parents 175 180 175 Female Lone-Parents 750 740 735 Non Family Persons 1,140 1,070 1,130 Male Non Family Persons 560 530 560 Female Non Family Persons 580 540 560 Incidence Total Family Types 20.30% 18.50% 17.70% Couple Families 13.20% 11.30% 9.90% Lone-Parent Families 47.90% 46.40% 45.00% Male Lone-Parents 45.60% 43.80% 43.00% Female Lone-Parents 48.40% 47.00% 45.50% Non Family Persons 25.80% 23.60% 23.70% Male Non Family Persons 31.10% 28.40% 28.70% Female Non Family Persons 22.10% 20.20% 20.20% Notes: a Using Census definitions of family types (includes couple families, lone-parent families and nonfamily persons). Please note, beginning in 2000, Statistics Canada began using the term Couple Families for Husband-Wife Families. Couple Families include same sex common law families. b A couple family consists of a couple living together (married or common-law, including same-sex couples) living at the same address with or without children. Beginning in 2000, same-sex couples reporting as couples are counted as couple families. c A lone-parent family is a family with only one parent, male or female, with at least one child living with the parent. d A non-family person is an individual who is not part of a census family, couple family or lone-parent family. Non-family persons may live with their married children or with their children who have children of their own. They may be living with a family to whom they are related or unrelated. They may also be living alone or with other non-family persons. e Incidence of low income, also known as a head count, measures the proportion of families with income below the low income threshold. Figures may not add to total due to rounding. Source: Newfoundland and Labrador Market Basket Measure of Low Income, Newfoundland and Labrador Statistics Agency. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 17 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region As of 2006, there were approximately 15,540 total dwellings in the Baccalieu Trail region, with an average of seven rooms per dwelling. As of 2001 (the most recently available data) the average value of dwellings in the region was $61,855. Of these dwellings, 14,425 (~93%) are detached houses, 360 are apartment buildings and 755 are classified as ‘Other’. With regard to the age of dwellings in the region, 9,285 were built after 1971, with 850 of these being build after 1996 (see Table 4.4). The vast majority of dwellings in the region are single family homes (11,970 total or 77% of the total housing stock) with only 3,260 (~21%) of dwellings classified as non-family households and 310 (~2%) as multiple family households. Over 87% of the dwellings in the region are owned by a member of the household. As of 2006, the average owner’s major payments were $509, up from $433 in 2001 (see table 4.5). During the same period, the average gross rent increased from $500 to $538. 18 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.4 - Economic Zone 17 - Baccalieu Trail Region Housing 1996, 2001, 2006 1996 2001 Total dwellings 14,750 14,840 Average value of dwellings $61,100 $61,855 Average number of rooms per dwelling 7 7 Type of Dwelling Total types of Dwelling Detached house Without Apartment With Apartment Apartment building Other 14,155 13,835 320 205 390 Period of Construction Before 1971 Before 1946 1946-1960 1961-1970 1971 or later 1971-1980 1981-1990 1991-1995 1996-2001 Household Type One-family households Multiple-family households Non-family households 19 2006 15,540 7 14,855 14,020 15,540 14,425 210 615 360 755 6900 2500 2240 2150 7850 3655 3030 1160 - 6,410 2,120 2,215 2,080 8,435 3,705 2,865 1,140 730 6245 2250 1970 2025 9285 3600 2945 1185 850 12215 210 2320 11,845 325 2,685 11970 310 3260 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Notes: a Figures for total dwellings exclude private farm and reserve dwellings. Figures for type of dwelling, period of construction and household type include all occupied dwellings. Figures for average number of rooms have been revised as of March 9, 2005. Based on Census 20% sample data. Figures may not add to total due to random rounding. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on custom tabulations from the Census of Population 2001, Statistics Canada Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 20 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Total dwellings Table 4.5 - Economic Zone 17 - Baccalieu Trail Region Owners and Renters 2001, 2006 2001 14,840 Dwellings owned by a member of the household Without mortgage With mortgage Average owner's major payments ($) Median owner's major payments ($) 2006 15,540 13,295 13,620 9,365 3,930 $433 $313 $509 - Dwellings rented by a member of the 1,545 1,915 household Average gross rent ($) $500 $538 Median gross rent ($) $485 Notes: a Figures for total dwellings 2001 are based on type of occupancy and exclude all private farm and reserve dwellings. These figures may be different from period of construction and household type which include all dwellings as per Housing table in the Household Spending Accounts for 2001. b Average and median owner's major payments includes mortgage, property taxes, condominium fees, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Also includes those dwellings for which the total regular monthly mortgage or loan payments is zero which may account for differences in average and median since many communities have a large portion of owner's without a mortgage. c Average and median gross rent includes rent, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Includes dwellings for which the monthly rent is zero which may account for differences between the average and median. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on custom tabulations from the Census of Population 2001, Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 21 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 4.1.1 Bay Roberts Local Area Between 2003 and 2005, the Bay Roberts area exhibited a steady decline in both the number and incidence of low income census families. In 2003, the Bay Roberts are had a total of 520 low income census families or an incidence of 22.30% (a rate which remains higher than the regional average). In 2005, the total number decreased to 470 (incidence of 19.60%). As with the regional profile, the highest rates of incidence of low income census families are among loneparent families (50.20%), the majority of which are headed by a female member of the household. Couple families exhibited the lowest incidence at 11.20% in 2005 a decrease from 2003. Non-family persons also exhibited a significant incidence at 25.50% combined with male non-family persons displaying a higher rate of incidence at 31.80% than did female non-family persons (21.20%) (see Table 4.7). In the Bay Roberts area, as of 2006, there were a total of 2,090 dwellings; up from 1,840 in 1996. These dwellings have on average eight rooms. As of 2001, the average value of dwellings was $73,885 down from $75,600 in 1996. Of these dwellings, 1,900 are detached houses, 40 are apartment buildings and 150 are classified as ‘Other’. 1,290 of these dwellings were built after 1971, with 175 of these being built after 1996. In the Bay Roberts area, as of 2006, 78% were single family homes; down from 81% in 1996. Between 2001 and 2006 there was a significant decrease in the number of multiple family households (from 40 total in 2001 to 25 total in 2006). During the same period, there was an increase in the number of non-family households (from 295 in 2001 to 420 in 2006) (see Table 4.9). As of 2006, 1,775 dwellings were owned by a member of the household. In this area, both average owner’s payments and average gross rents are above the regional average and have increased between 2001 and 2006. In 2006 the average owner’s major payments were $633 up from $572 in 2001. Likewise the average gross rent in the area increased from $482 in 2001 to $583 in 2006 (see Table 4.8). 22 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.6 - Bay Roberts Area Population by Age and Gender - 2006 Male Female 2,770 2,935 180 145 170 160 190 170 195 185 135 180 155 145 165 180 225 220 220 260 210 215 210 235 210 230 170 180 125 130 105 90 65 85 30 55 10 50 10 10 Total 5,705 320 335 360 385 320 300 345 445 475 425 445 440 355 250 190 145 85 60 15 Total Age Groups 0-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 80-84 85-89 90+ Notes: Figures may not add to total due to random rounding. Census data contained in this table is from the 100% sample unless otherwise noted. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on information provided from the Census of Population 1986, 1991, 1996, 2001, and 2006 Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 23 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.7 - Bay Roberts Area Number and Incidence of Low Income Census Families 2003 2004 2005 Counts of Low Income Families Total Family Types 520 510 470 Couple Families 210 190 170 Lone-Parent Families 150 160 150 Male Lone-Parents 30 30 30 Female Lone-Parents 125 130 125 Non Family Persons 160 160 150 Male Non Family Persons 70 70 80 Female Non Family Persons 90 80 80 Incidence Total Family Types 22.30% 21.60% 19.60% Couple Families 14.20% 13.00% 11.20% Lone-Parent Families 48.70% 51.90% 50.20% Male Lone-Parents 45.90% 49.50% 48.90% Female Lone-Parents 49.40% 52.50% 50.50% Non Family Persons 29.80% 27.50% 25.50% Male Non Family Persons 35.80% 32.20% 31.80% Female Non Family Persons 26.10% 24.30% 21.20% Notes: a Using Census definitions of family types (includes couple families, lone-parent families and non-family persons). Please note, beginning in 2000, Statistics Canada began using the term Couple Families for Husband-Wife Families. Couple Families include same sex common law families. b A couple family consists of a couple living together (married or common-law, including same-sex couples) living at the same address with or without children. Beginning in 2000, same-sex couples reporting as couples are counted as couple families. c A lone-parent family is a family with only one parent, male or female, with at least one child living with the parent. d A non-family person is an individual who is not part of a census family, couple family or lone-parent family. Non-family persons may live with their married children or with their children who have children of their own. They may be living with a family to whom they are related or unrelated. They may also be living alone or with other non-family persons. e Incidence of low income, also known as a head count, measures the proportion of families with income below the low income threshold. Figures may not add to total due to rounding. Source: Newfoundland and Labrador Market Basket Measure of Low Income, Newfoundland and Labrador Statistics Agency. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 24 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.8 - Bay Roberts Area Housing: 1996, 2001, 2006 1996 1,840 Total number of dwellings Average value of dwellings $75,600 Average number of rooms per dwelling 7 2001 1,910 $73,885 7 2006 2,090 8 Type of Occupancy Owned Average owners' monthly payments Rented Average gross rent per month 1,510 $399 330 $519 1,635 $572 280 $482 1,775 $633 315 $583 Type of Dwelling Detached house % of total dwellings Without apartment With apartment Apartment building % of total dwellings Other % of total dwellings 1,755 95% 1,655 100 15 .. 70 .. 1,800 1,900 40 40 75 150 775 42% 305 165 300 1,060 58% 500 355 205 875 800 310 265 300 1035 335 210 255 1,290 470 275 150 140 420 410 160 175 Period of Construction Before 1971 % of total dwellings Before 1946 1946-1960 1961-1970 1971 or later % of total dwellings 1971-1980 1981-1990 1991-1996 1996-2000 25 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Household Type One-family households 1,495 1575 1,640 Multiple-family households .. 40 25 Non-family households 345 295 420 Notes: a Includes mortgage, property taxes, condominium fees, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Also includes those dwellings for which the total regular monthly mortgage or loan payments are zero. b Includes rent, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Includes dwellings for which the monthly rent is zero. Figures may not add to totals due to random rounding. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on custom tabulations from the Census of Population 1996, Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 4.1.2 Harbour Grace Area Similar to Bay Roberts, and in keeping with the regional trend, Harbour Grace has displayed a steady decrease in both numbers and incidence of low income census families. As of 2005, there were a total of 400 low income census families (an incidence of 16.90%). While the highest incidence of low income census families is in the lone-parent category (a feature which is both expected and shared amongst areas within the region) it should be noted that in all categories with the exception of female non-family persons the incidence of low income families is either the same or below the regional average (see Table 4.10). With regard to the housing stock in the Harbour Grace area there has been little change in the number of dwellings between 1996 (2,060 total) and 2006 (2,075 total). While the average value of dwellings in the area has exhibited a marginal increase between 1996 (average value of $57,900) and 2001 (average value of $59,190), the average value remains below the regional averages for the same period. In this area, the average owner’s major payments were $526 in 2006, while the average gross rent was $503. Approximately 95% of the dwellings in the Harbour Grace area are detached houses while only 2% are apartment buildings (see Table 4.11). 26 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.9 - Harbour Grace Area Population by Age and Gender: 2006 Male Female 2,635 2,740 120 120 140 110 150 145 190 180 170 145 105 130 145 165 190 185 205 215 230 230 225 265 240 220 180 190 140 150 95 125 75 65 35 60 15 40 .. 15 Total 5,375 240 245 300 370 315 235 305 370 415 460 490 455 370 290 220 140 90 55 20 Total Age Groups 0-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 80-84 85-89 90+ Notes: Figures may not add to total due to random rounding. Census data contained in this table is from the 100% sample unless otherwise noted. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on information provided from the Census of Population 1986, 1991, 1996, 2001, and 2006 Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 27 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.10 - Harbour Grace Area Number and Incidence of Low Income Census Families 2003 2004 2005 Counts of Low Income Families Total Family Types 450 430 400 Couple Families 190 170 130 Lone-Parent Families 120 120 120 Male Lone-Parents 20 25 20 Female Lone-Parents 100 95 100 Non Family Persons 140 130 140 Male Non Family Persons 80 70 70 Female Non Family Persons 60 60 70 Incidence Total Family Types 19.10% 18.10% 16.90% Couple Families 12.40% 11.50% 9.00% Lone-Parent Families 44.70% 44.90% 44.40% Male Lone-Parents 41.90% 42.00% 43.00% Female Lone-Parents 45.30% 45.80% 44.70% Non Family Persons 25.90% 23.20% 23.60% Male Non Family Persons 33.80% 29.30% 27.80% Female Non Family Persons 19.70% 18.60% 20.50% Notes: a Using Census definitions of family types (includes couple families, lone-parent families and non-family persons). Please note, beginning in 2000, Statistics Canada began using the term Couple Families for Husband-Wife Families. Couple Families include same sex common law families. b A couple family consists of a couple living together (married or common-law, including same-sex couples) living at the same address with or without children. Beginning in 2000, same-sex couples reporting as couples are counted as couple families. c A lone-parent family is a family with only one parent, male or female, with at least one child living with the parent. d A non-family person is an individual who is not part of a census family, couple family or lone-parent family. Non-family persons may live with their married children or with their children who have children of their own. They may be living with a family to whom they are related or unrelated. They may also be living alone or with other non-family persons. e Incidence of low income, also known as a head count, measures the proportion of families with income below the low income threshold. Figures may not add to total due to rounding. Source: Newfoundland and Labrador Market Basket Measure of Low Income, Newfoundland and Labrador Statistics Agency. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 28 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.11 - Harbour Grace Area Housing: 1996, 2001, 2006 1996 2001 2,060 2,005 Total number of dwellings Average value of dwellings $57,900 $59,190 Average number of rooms per dwelling 7 7 2006 2,075 7 Type of Occupancy Owned Average owners' monthly payments Rented Average gross rent per month 1,820 $387 245 $502 2,005 $434 145 $489 1,880 $526 200 $503 Type of Dwelling Detached house % of total dwellings Without apartment With apartment Apartment building % of total dwellings Other % of total dwellings 1,960 95% 1,925 30 40 .. 60 .. 1,900 1,935 35 85 75 60 1,060 325 405 330 1,000 475 380 145 895 225 375 285 1,110 500 430 125 60 920 310 310 300 1,155 490 375 110 90 Period of Construction Before 1971 Before 1946 1946-1960 1961-1970 1971 or later 1971-1980 1981-1990 1991-1996 1995-2001 29 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Household Type One-family households 1,745 1,605 1,525 Multiple-family households 30 45 100 Non-family households 290 350 450 Notes: a Includes mortgage, property taxes, condominium fees, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Also includes those dwellings for which the total regular monthly mortgage or loan payments is zero. b Includes rent, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Includes dwellings for which the monthly rent is zero. Figures may not add to totals due to random rounding. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on custom tabulations from the Census of Population 1996, Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 4.1.3 Carbonear Area While the incidence of low income census families has shown a steady decrease between 2003 and 2005, the incidence remains higher in the Carbonear area than the regional average. As of 2006, there were a total of 700 low income census families in the Carbonear area, an incidence of 19.60%. While the distribution of low income census families follows the expected pattern (the largest concentrations of low income families being within the lone-parent categories), all categories of families in the area display a higher incidence of low income census families (see Table 4.13). As of 2006, there were a total of 2,995 dwellings in the Carbonear area. On average these dwellings have seven rooms and are valued at $60,605 (as of 2001). Of these dwellings, 2,450 are owned by a member of the household while only 545 are rented (see Table 4.14). Almost 63% of the total dwellings in the Carbonear area were built after 1971, with only 4% being built after 1996. Almost 87% of the total dwellings in the area are detached houses, while only 4% are apartment buildings, and 9% are classified as other. As of 2006, the average owner’s monthly payments were $537 (up from $385 in 1996) and the average gross rent was $544 (up from $541 in 1996). In the Carbonear area, 2,285 households are single-family, 60 are multiple family households, and 645 are non-family households. 30 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.12 - Carbonear Area Population by Age and Gender Male Female 3,675 4,110 150 175 190 195 230 225 245 250 210 195 190 190 175 240 235 270 305 300 305 370 325 350 295 335 265 275 185 185 145 155 95 130 60 120 45 95 20 55 Total 7,780 325 385 455 495 405 385 415 510 610 670 675 635 540 370 300 225 180 140 70 Total Age Groups 0-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 80-84 85-89 90+ Notes: Figures may not add to total due to random rounding. For more information click here. Census data contained in this table is from the 100% sample unless otherwise noted. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on information provided from the Census of Population 1986, 1991, 1996, 2001, and 2006 Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 31 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.13 - Carbonear Area Number and Incidence of Low Income Census Families 2003 2004 2005 Counts of Low Income Families Total Family Types 750 700 700 Couple Families 280 240 200 Lone-Parent Families 200 200 200 Male Lone-Parents 30 40 35 Female Lone-Parents 165 170 170 Non Family Persons 270 260 290 Male Non Family Persons 120 110 130 Female Non Family Persons 150 150 160 Incidence Total Family Types 21.80% 20.10% 19.60% Couple Families 13.80% 11.70% 10.00% Lone-Parent Families 48.90% 50.10% 48.40% Male Lone-Parents 45.80% 46.20% 45.40% Female Lone-Parents 49.50% 51.10% 49.10% Non Family Persons 27.50% 25.30% 26.40% Male Non Family Persons 31.30% 29.90% 30.40% Female Non Family Persons 25.20% 22.60% 23.80% Notes: a Using Census definitions of family types (includes couple families, lone-parent families and non-family persons). Please note, beginning in 2000, Statistics Canada began using the term Couple Families for Husband-Wife Families. Couple Families include same sex common law families. b A couple family consists of a couple living together (married or common-law, including same-sex couples) living at the same address with or without children. Beginning in 2000, same-sex couples reporting as couples are counted as couple families. c A lone-parent family is a family with only one parent, male or female, with at least one child living with the parent. d A non-family person is an individual who is not part of a census family, couple family or lone-parent family. Non-family persons may live with their married children or with their children who have children of their own. They may be living with a family to whom they are related or unrelated. They may also be living alone or with other non-family persons. e Incidence of low income, also known as a head count, measures the proportion of families with income below the low income threshold. Figures may not add to total due to rounding. Source: Newfoundland and Labrador Market Basket Measure of Low Income, Newfoundland and Labrador Statistics Agency. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 32 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.14 - Carbonear Area Housing: 1996, 2001, 2006 1996 2,805 Total number of dwellings Average value of dwellings $58,400 Average number of rooms per dwelling 7 2001 2,880 $60,605 7 2006 2,995 7 Type of Occupancy Owned Average owners' monthly payments Rented Average gross rent per month 2,315 $385 485 $541 2,465 $442 420 $460 2,450 $537 545 $544 Type of Dwelling Detached house % of total dwellings Without apartment With apartment Apartment building % of total dwellings Other % of total dwellings 2,610 93% 2,510 100 90 .. 105 4% 2,590 2,600 65 135 230 260 1,295 46% 405 435 455 1,510 54% 670 655 175 1,265 1,110 435 415 410 1,620 380 355 375 1,880 700 585 230 110 745 585 260 130 Period of Construction Before 1971 % of total dwellings Before 1946 1946-1960 1961-1970 1971 or later % of total dwellings 1971-1980 1981-1990 1991-1996 1996-2001 33 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Household Type One-family households 2,295 2,205 2,285 Multiple-family households 50 95 60 Non-family households 455 590 645 Notes: a Includes mortgage, property taxes, condominium fees, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Also includes those dwellings for which the total regular monthly mortgage or loan payments is zero. b Includes rent, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Includes dwellings for which the monthly rent is zero. Figures may not add to totals due to random rounding Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on custom tabulations from the Census of Population 1996, Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 4.1.4 North Shore Conception Bay The North Shore area of the region, like many of the other local areas in the region, has exhibited a reduction in the incidence of low income families. In 2003, the incidence of low income families was 14.3%. In 2004, the incidence of low income families dropped to 12.9%, and was further reduced in 2005 to 12.4% (See Table 4.16). It should be noted that these rates are significantly below the regional average. Between 1996 and 2006 there has been a steady decline in the number of dwellings in the North Shore area of the region. In 1996, there were a total of 1,535 dwellings. This total dropped to 1,515 in 2001 and 1,490 in 2006. Similarly, the average value of dwellings in the area also declined. In 1996, the average value of dwellings was $60,800 while in 2001 the average value was only $45,970. While the value of dwellings has declined during this period, the average owner’s expenses and the average gross rent has increased. In 1996, the average owner’s expenses were $277. In 2001, this figure increased to $304, and in 2006 the average owner’s expenses rose to $382. Similarly, in 1996 the average gross rent in the area was $386. This figure increased in 2001 to $415, and in 2006 to $501. Only 51% of dwellings in this area were built after 1971, and only 3% were built after 1996. In the North Shore area, over 94% of the dwellings are owned by a member of the household. Over 97% of the dwellings are detached houses; slightly over 1% of the dwellings are apartment buildings and less than 1% are classified as ‘other.’ Similar to other areas of the region, the vast majority of households in the North Shore region are single family households, with less than 1% of households being multi-family and 2.5% being non-family households (See Table 4.17). 34 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.15 - Population by Age and Gender North Shore Conception Bay Area Male Female Total 1,860 1,865 3,725 Total Age Groups 0-4 55 55 115 5-9 75 65 135 10-14 90 100 190 15-19 120 110 230 20-24 120 120 240 25-29 80 55 135 30-34 105 110 215 35-39 100 105 210 40-44 155 145 305 45-49 160 180 340 50-54 170 175 345 55-59 170 160 330 60-64 145 125 270 65-69 100 80 180 70-74 70 90 165 75-79 65 65 130 80-84 45 65 110 85-89 25 35 60 90+ 10 20 30 Notes: Figures may not add to total due to random rounding. Census data contained in this table is from the 100% sample unless otherwise noted Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on information provided from the Census of Population 1986, 1991, 1996, 2001, and 2006 Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 35 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.16 - North Shore Conception Bay Area Number and Incidence of Low Income Census Families 2003 2004 2005 Counts of Low Income Families Total Family Types 240 220 210 Couple Families 80 70 60 Lone-Parent Families 70 70 60 Male Lone-Parents 20 15 15 Female Lone-Parents 45 50 40 Non Family Persons 90 90 100 Male Non Family Persons 60 50 60 Female Non Family Persons 40 30 40 Incidence Total Family Types 14.30% 12.90% 12.40% Couple Families 8.40% 6.90% 5.80% Lone-Parent Families 31.60% 31.70% 25.50% Male Lone-Parents 30.50% 31.00% .. Female Lone-Parents 32.00% 32.00% 25.60% Non Family Persons 19.00% 16.70% 18.90% Male Non Family Persons 25.10% 21.90% 25.20% Female Non Family Persons 13.90% 12.10% 13.50% Notes: a Using Census definitions of family types (includes couple families, lone-parent families and non-family persons). Please note, beginning in 2000, Statistics Canada began using the term Couple Families for Husband-Wife Families. Couple Families include same sex common law families. b A couple family consists of a couple living together (married or common-law, including same-sex couples) living at the same address with or without children. Beginning in 2000, same-sex couples reporting as couples are counted as couple families. c A lone-parent family is a family with only one parent, male or female, with at least one child living with the parent. d A non-family person is an individual who is not part of a census family, couple family or lone-parent family. Non-family persons may live with their married children or with their children who have children of their own. They may be living with a family to whom they are related or unrelated. They may also be living alone or with other non-family persons. e Incidence of low income, also known as a head count, measures the proportion of families with income below the low income threshold. Figures may not add to total due to rounding. Source: Newfoundland and Labrador Market Basket Measure of Low Income, Newfoundland and Labrador Statistics Agency. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 36 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.17 - North Shore Conception Bay Area Housing: 1996, 2001, 2006 1996 2001 1,535 1,515 Total number of dwellings Average value of dwellings $60,800 $45,970 Average number of rooms per dwelling 7 7 2006 1,490 7 Type of Occupancy Owned Average owners' monthly payments Rented Average gross rent per month 1,425 $277 110 $386 1,400 $304 120 $415 1,405 $382 90 $501 Type of Dwelling Detached house % of total dwellings Without apartment With apartment Apartment building % of total dwellings Other % of total dwellings 1,515 99% 1,510 .. .. .. 20 .. 1,475 1,460 15 20 35 10 855 56% 335 315 210 680 44% 325 275 90 745 735 285 250 210 780 270 315 150 760 345 265 100 75 305 285 90 50 Period of Construction Before 1971 % of total dwellings Before 1946 1946-1960 1961-1970 1971 or later % of total dwellings 1971-1980 1981-1990 1991-1996 1996-2001 37 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Household Type One-family households 1,200 1,170 1,105 Multiple-family households 30 15 10 Non-family households 310 340 375 Notes: a Includes mortgage, property taxes, condominium fees, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Also includes those dwellings for which the total regular monthly mortgage or loan payments is zero. b Includes rent, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Includes dwellings for which the monthly rent is zero. Figures may not add to totals due to random rounding. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on custom tabulations from the Census of Population 1996, Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 4.1.5 Heart’s Delight Area In the Heart’s Delight area of the region, the incidence of low income families is slightly lower than the regional average, with 16.2% of total families falling within the low income category (as compared to the regional average of 17.7%) in 2006. As with other areas in the region, the Heart’s Content area has exhibited a steady decline in the incidence of low income families since 1996. While the overall incidence of low income families is lower than the regional average, it is interesting to note that lone-parent and female lone parent families both have a higher incidence than the regional average (see Table 4.19). Between 1996 and 2006, the Heart’s Delight area has shown a small but significant increase in the number of dwellings, despite the decrease in average value of dwellings ($62,200 in 1996 versus $58,765 in 2001). As of 2006, there were a total of 1,605 dwellings in the area. Of the total dwellings in the area, 1,540 were detached houses, 35 were apartment buildings and 35 were classified as ‘other.’ Approximately 64% of the dwellings in this area were built after 1971, with 4% having been built after 1996. In 2006, over 90% of the dwellings in the area were owned by a member of the household. Since 1996, the average owner’s monthly payments have increased substantially; from $244 in 1996 to $406 in 2006. Similarly, the average gross rents in the area have also increased significantly during this time period; from $365 in 1996 to $490 in 2006. In keeping with the regional trend, the vast majority of households in the region are single-family. Of the total households in the area, 1300 are single family, 280 are non-family 38 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region households and 20 are multiple family households. It should be noted that the number of nonfamily households has shown a steady and significant increase since 1996 (see Table 4.20). Table 4.18 - Hearts Delight Area Population by Age and Gender Male Female 2,010 2,145 80 80 100 105 130 120 135 115 85 105 90 75 85 115 120 165 160 175 180 175 175 180 180 200 150 155 120 105 80 90 55 70 45 60 20 30 10 25 Total 4,155 160 210 250 250 195 165 205 285 335 360 355 380 305 225 170 120 100 55 25 Total Age Groups 0-4 5-9 10-14 15-19 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 80-84 85-89 90+ Notes: Figures may not add to total due to random rounding. Census data contained in this table is from the 100% sample unless otherwise noted. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on information provided from the Census of Population 1986, 1991, 1996, 2001, and 2006 Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 39 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.19 - Hearts Delight Area Number and Incidence of Low Income Census Families 2003 2004 2005 Counts of Low Income Families Total Family Types 340 300 290 Couple Families 150 130 120 Lone-Parent Families 90 80 80 Male Lone-Parents 20 .. .. Female Lone-Parents 75 70 70 Non Family Persons 100 90 90 Male Non Family Persons 40 30 40 Female Non Family Persons 60 50 50 Incidence Total Family Types 18.80% 16.50% 16.20% Couple Families 12.30% 10.50% 9.80% Lone-Parent Families 58.70% 48.20% 47.20% Male Lone-Parents 55.20% .. .. Female Lone-Parents 59.60% 49.10% 47.60% Non Family Persons 22.90% 21.40% 21.50% Male Non Family Persons 25.30% 21.60% 23.90% Female Non Family Persons 21.50% 21.30% 20.00% Notes: a Using Census definitions of family types (includes couple families, lone-parent families and nonfamily persons). Please note, beginning in 2000, Statistics Canada began using the term Couple Families for Husband-Wife Families. Couple Families include same sex common law families. b A couple family consists of a couple living together (married or common-law, including same-sex couples) living at the same address with or without children. Beginning in 2000, same-sex couples reporting as couples are counted as couple families. c A lone-parent family is a family with only one parent, male or female, with at least one child living with the parent. d A non-family person is an individual who is not part of a census family, couple family or lone-parent family. Non-family persons may live with their married children or with their children who have children of their own. They may be living with a family to whom they are related or unrelated. They may also be living alone or with other non-family persons. e Incidence of low income, also known as a head count, measures the proportion of families with income below the low income threshold. Figures may not add to total due to rounding. Source: Newfoundland and Labrador Market Basket Measure of Low Income, Newfoundland and Labrador Statistics Agency. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, ,Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 40 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.20 - Hearts Delight Area Housing: 1996, 2001, 2006 1996 2001 1,540 1,565 Total number of dwellings Average value of dwellings $62,200 $58,765 Average number of rooms per dwelling 7 7 2006 1,605 7 Type of Occupancy Owned Average owners' monthly payments Rented Average gross rent per month 1,415 $244 125 $365 1,565 $372 115 $459 1,455 $406 155 $490 Type of Dwelling Detached house % of total dwellings Without apartment With apartment Apartment building % of total dwellings Other % of total dwellings 1,530 .. 1,525 10 .. .. 10 .. 1,515 1,540 30 35 20 35 640 42% 265 190 190 905 59% 440 340 120 545 585 195 145 200 1,020 215 175 195 1,025 430 390 100 445 320 165 60 Period of Construction Before 1971 % of total dwellings Before 1946 1946-1960 1961-1970 1971 or later % of total dwellings 1971-1980 1981-1990 1991-1996 1996-2000 41 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Household Type One-family households 1,325 1,300 1,300 Multiple-family households 30 30 20 Non-family households 185 235 280 Notes: a Includes mortgage, property taxes, condominium fees, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Also includes those dwellings for which the total regular monthly mortgage or loan payments is zero. b Includes rent, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Includes dwellings for which the monthly rent is zero. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on custom tabulations from the Census of Population 1996, Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 4.1.6 New Perlican – Winterton Area The New Perlican-Winterton area of the region exhibits a significantly lower incidence of low income families than the regional average. In 2005, the regional incidence of low income families was 17.7%, while in the New Perlican-Winterton area the incidence was only 11.5%. As with other areas of the region, the incidence of low income families is highest in the loneparent category, although these rates are still significantly lower than the regional average. It should be noted that, in this area, there are no male lone-parent families (See Table 4.22). Between 1996 and 2006, there has been a small but steady decline in the number of dwellings in the area. In 1996 there were 915 total dwellings, while in 2006 there were only 865 dwellings. In this area, the average value of dwellings is significantly lower than the regional average and has decreased between 1996 and 2001. Despite the decrease in property values, both average owner’s monthly expenses and the average gross rent have increased during the same time period. In 1996, the average owner’s monthly payments were $271. In 2006, these payments averaged $396. It should be noted, that while the average gross rent has increased somewhat during this time period, in 2006 the average gross rent is below the average owner’s monthly payments. Over 98% of dwellings in this area detached houses. There are no apartment buildings, and less than 2% of the dwellings are classified as ‘other.’ Almost 96% of the dwellings are owned by a member of the household. Less than 40% of dwellings in the New Perlican-Winterton area were built after 1971, and only 5% were built after 1996. Approximately 74% of households in the area are single-family; 26% are non-family households and, as of 2006, there are no multiple-family households in the area (See Table 4.23). 42 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.21 - New Perlican - Winterton Area Population by Age and Gender Male Female Total 1,060 1,055 2,115 Total Age Groups 0-4 35 35 70 5-9 50 25 75 10-14 60 45 100 15-19 70 55 125 20-24 50 40 90 25-29 35 30 65 30-34 40 45 85 35-39 65 60 125 40-44 85 75 160 45-49 85 80 160 50-54 95 90 185 55-59 85 100 185 60-64 70 90 160 65-69 80 75 155 70-74 65 80 145 75-79 40 50 95 80-84 40 35 75 85-89 15 25 40 90+ 5 10 20 Notes: Figures may not add to total due to random rounding. Census data contained in this table is from the 100% sample unless otherwise noted. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on information provided from the Census of Population 1986, 1991, 1996, 2001, and 2006 Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 43 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.22 - New Perlican - Winterton Area Number and Incidence of Low Income Census Families 2003 2004 2005 Counts of Low Income Families Total Family Types 140 130 110 Couple Families 60 50 40 Lone-Parent Families 30 30 30 Male Lone-Parents .. .. .. Female Lone-Parents 25 25 15 Non Family Persons 50 50 50 Male Non Family Persons 30 30 30 Female Non Family Persons 20 20 20 Incidence Total Family Types 14.20% 12.70% 11.50% Couple Families 10.10% 8.10% 6.70% Lone-Parent Families 38.40% 29.70% 30.10% Male Lone-Parents .. .. .. Female Lone-Parents 38.00% 30.80% 30.20% Non Family Persons 16.20% 17.10% 16.30% Male Non Family Persons 26.40% 24.60% 28.30% Female Non Family Persons 9.60% 12.00% 9.30% Notes: a Using Census definitions of family types (includes couple families, lone-parent families and non-family persons). Please note, beginning in 2000, Statistics Canada began using the term Couple Families for Husband-Wife Families. Couple Families include same sex common law families. b A couple family consists of a couple living together (married or common-law, including same-sex couples) living at the same address with or without children. Beginning in 2000, same-sex couples reporting as couples are counted as couple families. c A lone-parent family is a family with only one parent, male or female, with at least one child living with the parent. d A non-family person is an individual who is not part of a census family, couple family or lone-parent family. Non-family persons may live with their married children or with their children who have children of their own. They may be living with a family to whom they are related or unrelated. They may also be living alone or with other non-family persons. e Incidence of low income, also known as a head count, measures the proportion of families with income below the low income threshold. Figures may not add to total due to rounding. Source: Newfoundland and Labrador Market Basket Measure of Low Income, Newfoundland and Labrador Statistics Agency. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 44 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Table 4.23 - New Perlican - Winterton Area Housing: 1996, 2001, 2006 1996 2001 915 900 Total number of dwellings Average value of dwellings $40,800 $38,610 Average number of rooms per dwelling 7 7 2006 865 7 Type of Occupancy Owned Average owners' monthly payments Rented Average gross rent per month 855 $271 65 $341 870 $315 30 $403 830 $396 35 $387 Type of Dwelling Detached house % of total dwellings Without apartment With apartment Apartment building % of total dwellings Other % of total dwellings 905 99% 905 .. 10 .. .. .. 865 850 10 - 25 15 560 61% 250 160 150 355 39% 160 130 70 500 525 195 155 150 395 210 140 175 345 185 130 75 10 130 90 60 45 Period of Construction Before 1971 % of total dwellings Before 1946 1946-1960 1961-1970 1971 or later % of total dwellings 1971-1980 1981-1990 1991-1996 1996-2001 45 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Household Type One-family households 775 735 640 Multiple-family households 10 15 Non-family households 130 150 225 Notes: a Includes mortgage, property taxes, condominium fees, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Also includes those dwellings for which the total regular monthly mortgage or loan payments are zero. b Includes rent, electricity, oil, gas, coal, or wood fuels, as well as water and other municipal services. Includes dwellings for which the monthly rent is zero. Figures may not add to totals due to random rounding. Source: Compiled by the Community Accounts Unit based on custom tabulations from the Census of Population 1996, Statistics Canada. Copyright: Newfoundland & Labrador Statistics Agency, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador 46 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 4.2 Housing and Homelessness Issues in the Baccalieu Trail Region Through the course of this study, it has become increasingly apparent that the region’s housing stock is not adequate to address the needs of many residents. Unfortunately, at the time of writing, there are no reliable statistics regarding the exact scope and magnitude of homelessness in the Baccalieu Trail region. That said through the course of the consultations with service providers in the region it has been reiterated repeatedly that lack of access to safe, affordable and appropriate housing is a common concern of many residents in the region. In addition, according to many service providers, individuals with acute housing needs, i.e., the need for immediate shelter, are becoming increasingly common. For instance, one service provider with Human Resources Labour and Employment stated that in the past two years, twenty-five clients out of a total caseload of thirty (or approximately 83%) have experienced acute housing issues. Similarly, one social worker with Eastern Health’s Community Support Program stated that, in the past year, she is aware of fourteen clients in their programme who have experienced significant difficulty in accessing safe, affordable and appropriate housing. Similar figures have been reported by other service providers through the course of the consultations; with reports of 70 to 80% of their clients having experienced acute housing needs. It should be noted that there are a significant number of organizations that do not normally address housing issues have reported an increase in the numbers of clients with housing and/or homelessness related concerns. For instance, the Baccalieu Trail Youth Employment Centre, a community organization which is mandated to assist young people in obtaining employment, has had seven clients who have either been homeless or housed in inadequate environments. Likewise the CBDC-TC Community Youth Coordinator has had approximately twenty-one clients with housing concerns. It should be noted that the reported housing issues are not limited solely to those individuals who are in need of rental accommodations. As has been reported through these consultations, many individuals who own their own home are experiencing distinct challenges with regard to maintaining their property or affording the cost of utilities. Thus while the individual may own a home, the property may not be adequate, safe or accessible. Moreover, the declining property values present within a number of areas in the region presents a distinct challenge to many home owners as lack of equity or low resale values may prevent them from financing necessary renovations or purchasing a more appropriate dwelling. While there is an acute lack of accessible and affordable rental units (particularly evident in regard to small apartments), this housing shortage appears to extend to all price points of rental units. As illustrated in the previous section, the majority of houses available in the region are medium to large size, detached single family dwellings. Few of these dwellings encompass rental units, and there are few apartment or multi-family units available. In addition, while there are some NL Housing 47 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Units in the region, these units are in high demand and there are frequently long wait list for potential tenants. The shortage of rental accommodations and small sized and/or accessible dwellings is further complicated by the geography of the region. As illustrated, outside of the Carbonear, Harbour Grace and Bay Roberts areas, the Baccalieu Trail region is comprised of a large number of small rural communities. There is currently no public transportation available in the region. While appropriate accommodations may be available in the region as a whole, they may not be available within the individual’s or family’s home community. As a result, many individuals are obliged to choose between maintaining their community ties and support networks, and living in a safe, affordable and appropriate home While the overall shortage of rental units has had a negative effect across income levels, the most acute effects are experienced by those who have additional issues with which to contend. Through the course of this study, it has become apparent that the most acute housing issues are being experienced by those who are struggling with a number of issues including: Complex Needs Compromised mental health Developmental delayed Addictions Criminal history Behavioural Issues Young people Seniors Survivors of domestic violence It should be noted that for those contending with the aforementioned issues, the financial limitations are only one of a myriad of barriers to accessing safe, affordable and appropriate housing. With the exception of seniors3, those with the aforementioned issues are often perceived as undesirable tenants. These perceptions, when combined with the shortage of rental accommodations, present a distinct barrier to accessing appropriate housing; as landlords have little difficulty in leasing available units to ‘more desirable’ tenants. The negative perceptions regarding the desirability of certain populations are particularly problematic when viewed in relation to the geographic and demographic composition of many areas of the region. The lack of anonymity in small rural towns ensures that individuals who have been identified or classified Seniors appear to be seen as ‘ideal tenants’ particularly in relation to other groups who require affordable rental accommodations. 3 48 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region as difficult or undesirable tenants are known to landlords; thereby decreasing their likeliness of obtaining accommodations in the area. For those who have managed to acquire a rental unit, the overall shortage of rental accommodations and the difficulties associated with obtaining appropriate housing have the potential to place the individual in a particularly vulnerable position. Through the course of the consultations a number of service providers related cases wherein their clients were forced to live in unsafe housing, and/or contend with inequitable treatment due to their fear of eviction. The fear of eviction and the lack of equitable treatment were particularly evident amongst individuals who had to contend with a variety of issues and whose circumstances ensured that they were limited in their housing options. In some cases, the fear of eviction was so acute that the individuals were disinclined to complain about severe problems with their rental unit. For instance, one service provider related a case in which one of her clients was obliged to live without appropriate electrical or sewer systems due to their fear of the consequences of making a complaint to the landlord. While in many instances seniors are viewed by landlords as ‘ideal’ tenants, it has become apparent that the shortage of small sized apartments or rental units, has presented a distinct challenge to many seniors in the region. For many seniors their ‘family home’ has become too large and costly to maintain, and few of the existing homes are accessible to individuals with mobility issues. In addition, the cost of maintenance, housing upgrades and utilities are often too high for individuals living on a fixed or marginal income. While there are a number of subsidy programmes available which address the cost of utilities and building maintenance, these programmes are not widely known and are frequently not ‘user-friendly.’ Unfortunately, in order to obtain adequate or appropriate housing, many seniors are required to leave their communities and relocate to the more urban areas of the region; a practice which not only separates them from their support network but also has a broader negative effect on the wider community. Another key issue that emerged through the course of this study was the reliance on familial or friendship ties to address immediate housing concerns. This reliance appears to be a function of cultural traditions, shortage of affordable and appropriate housing and gaps in the available services. In some cases, this reliance has resulted in a ‘homeless’ person being taken in by extended family, while in others it has resulted in a practice of ‘couch surfing’ or living in nonsuitable accommodations, i.e., sheds. In other cases, particularly those which include violence, addictions, mental health issues, and/or behavioural issues, the family members who have adopted the role of caretaker are themselves placed at risk of homelessness. 49 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Finally, it has become apparent that there is a lack of housing alternatives available in the region. In particular, there are currently no emergency shelters4 for youth or individuals with complex needs, and there are no semi-supervised housing arrangements. This lack of emergency shelters has compromised the ability of many service providers to address both emergency and long-term housing needs. With regard to emergency housing, in many cases, individuals are being housed temporarily in local motels (at the cost of Social Services). Similarly, the shortage of supervised or semi-supervised housing arrangements has resulted in a significant number of young individuals being placed in personal care homes or in ‘Alternate Living Arrangements’ and Independent Living Arrangements; arrangements which may not be entirely suitable for the individual and are very costly to maintain. 4.2.1 Focus Group - Old Perlican The primary concerns raised in the focus group in Old Perlican were in relation to seniors who were no longer able to afford to maintain or heat their family homes. In particular, it was noted that for many seniors in the area their current house is much larger than they require and there are no housing alternatives (aside from personal care homes) available in the local area. The shortage of home care was also identified as a significant barrier to maintaining appropriate housing. It was noted that while the individual may qualify for a certain amount of support, it was very difficult to find a reliable home care worker; in turn compromising the individual’s ability to stay in their home. Other concerns are as follows: Influx of ‘summer people’ and the decline of year-round residents Seniors forced to sell family home due to cost of utilities and maintenance and relocate to Carbonear Shorter working season due to changes in the local fishery – resulting in an increase in the numbers of ‘working poor’ Family members who are dependent upon their elderly parents’ income (CPP) resulting in the parent being unable to live independently or choose their living arrangement Available subsidy programmes (utilities and building maintenance) are frequently confusing and are often inaccessible to many seniors in the area Geography and cost of transportation During this session a number of local assets were identified by participants including community food banks, fundraising initiatives and the endeavours of local church women’s organizations. Despite the expressed difficulties associated with accessing formal public services, there are a wide range of informal outreach services currently being conducted by community groups and individual community members. It should be noted that Iris Kirby will be opening a women’s shelter in Carbonear in winter 2010. 50 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region In addition, it was noted that a number of parishes in the area were in the process of either selling or repurposing their real estate and that affordable or emergency housing initiatives may be seen as a viable use for these properties. Finally, a number of participants stated that they would experience difficulties in establishing housing shelters for individuals with mental health issues due to the prevalence of stereotypes regarding the inability of these individuals to become constructive members of the community. 4.2.2 Focus Group - Whiteway While seniors housing issues were raised by participants during this session, the discussion was more heavily focused on the recent increases in the cost of housing and the lack of locally available housing alternatives. These issues include: Increase of average rental costs from $350/month to $700+/month Lack of local employment opportunities Increase in drug use (mostly youth) Increase in property crime (not local residents) Lack of resources and supports to encourage young people to stay in the area Remaining young people frequently have mental health or developmental issues which have prevented them from obtaining employment Isolation of individuals with mental health or developmental issues and the reliance on family support Lack of support for caregivers, including emotional support Lack of information regarding services and supports (computer literacy is often needed in order to access information regarding services and supports) Small-town dynamics increase the difficulty in asking for help Despite these challenges there are a number of supportive programmes available through community organizations in the area. With some exceptions, these programmes are largely directed toward employment concerns. The one exception is the work that has been directed toward developing an affordable seniors’ complex in the region. 4.3 Strategic Planning Session As a follow-up on the regional focus groups, a community planning day was held on November 18th, 2009 at the Northern Avalon Wolverines Search and Rescue Building, Bay Roberts. This day long workshop was intended to provide a forum in which to identify the key projects that would be incorporated into the resulting Community Plan. Participants included representatives from: CBDC, the SPLASH Centre, Corrections and Community Services, Mental Heath and 51 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Addictions, Community Supports, Baccalieu Trail Youth Employment Centre, Human Resources, Labour and Employment, Seniors Resource Centre, CMHC and Iris Kirby House. This planning session was divided into two parts. During the first part of the session, participants were asked to outline the key issues and assets related to housing and homelessness in the Baccalieu Trail region. Following this discussion, a nominal group approach was used to identify which issues were seen as the priority areas. During the second part of the day, participants were divided into small groups to develop a clear direction for the initiative and to develop a loose action plan. The findings for the Community Planning day are outlined below. 4.3.1 Issues Related to Housing and Homelessness in the Baccalieu Trail Region Shortage of Land for Housing Development Seniors o Shortage of home support workers o Problems associated with family dynamics o Financial concerns o Knowledge of available programmes and housing supports o Literacy (written and computer) o Lack of ‘user-friendly’ services and/or support programmes o Over-housed unable to afford the cost of utilities and maintenance (compounded by the time required to access subsidy programmes) o Lack of information regarding housing programmes o Information on programme specifics is not readily accessible Hidden Groups who are Experiencing Issues Related to Housing and Homelessness o Young People Rarely covered by existing services Housing issues are normally addressed by family members Frequently availing of inadequate housing arrangements, i.e., living in sheds Often alienated from support programmes Disenfranchised Isolated Frequently contending with other (non-housing related) issues, such as breakdown in family support, abuse, addictions, and so on. Individuals Arriving from Outside of the Region or Province 52 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region o Response to the perceived availability of jobs, despite the fact that a little of the local affluence is related to local employment Availability and Cost of Rental Units o Lack of availability of rental units in local areas o Costs of rental units are higher than local wage rates can sustain o Rental subsidies are frequently inaccessible to those who are not receiving social assistance Few Incentives to Become Landlords o Many landlords are either not maintaining their units or simply selling o Perception that Seniors Housing is a more lucrative venture than other housing developments, i.e., developments which support individuals with mental health or developmental issues. Belief is that seniors’ housing projects are ‘easy’ and that seniors are ideal tenants. o A number of incentive programmes exist, but are not widely known o Need for the increased involvement of landlords in affordable housing strategies Need for community education o Related to each of the available programmes o Challenge prevailing beliefs regarding individuals contending with issues such as mental health, addictions, and developmental delays and so on. Need for a ‘vehicle’ to bring together the variety of stakeholders engaged with affordable housing and programme development Need for a ‘generic’ emergency shelter to address immediate housing concerns o This shelter should service a variety of populations including: Individuals with development mental delays Individuals with mental health issues Individuals with behavioral issues ‘hard-to-house’ Individuals with addictions Individuals with criminal history Individuals with complex needs o Need to address housing issues before other concerns can be addressed. o Should provide intensive discharge planning Need for both short- and long-term housing solutions Need for dedicated professional staff to address housing issues 53 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Need for related supports o Employment supports o Youth training programmes, i.e., ‘Train for Trades’ o Inclusion in broader community 4.3.2 Local Assets Related to Housing and Homelessness Homecare Agencies Strong Intersectoral Partnerships (Government, Community Groups, Faith Groups, Etc) o Pastoral Care Committee (Eastern Health and Local Clergy) o Baccalieu Advisory Board (Local Stakeholders involved in housing related projects) Local Clergy who are very active in Community Development and Social Programmes Large Amount of ‘community’ Real Estate which is Currently Lacking Purpose Availability of Crown Lands Youth Support Programmes such as the ‘Baccalieu Trail Youth Employment Centre’ and the SPLASH Centre Local Food Banks Access to Experts in Affordable Housing and Shelter Development o Iris Kirby o Stella Burry o Provincial Housing Network o Choices for Youth o Etc. Seniors’ Resource Centre o Local Satellite Office Trinity-Conception Family Resource Centres Poverty Reduction Strategy Youth Retention and Attraction Strategy Flexibility of local departments and community organizations Municipal Organizations (Joint Councils & Joint Mayors) Community Service Organizations (Lions Clubs, Kiwanis, Church Women’s Groups, etc) Community Gardens and Greenhouse Projects (St. Francis School) Breakfast Programmes 54 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Local Salvation Army Thrift Stores (‘no charge’ policy for individuals in need) Accessible Community Facilities Cadets Sporting Associations and Facilities Hospitals located in Carbonear, Old Perlican and Whitbourne Psychiatrist practicing in local area Personal Care Facilities 50+ Clubs in many communities Crafters Groups who engage in fundraising and community development activities Active Volunteer Firefighters (also engaged in fundraising and community development activities) Vibrant Voluntary/Non-Profit Sector Effective Regional Economic Development Board (M-RON) which hosts a variety of social initiatives such as: o Supported Employment Services o Youth Employment Centre o Capacity Building Active Regional Development Associations o Lower Trinity RDA o North Shore RDA Wide range of Social Development and/or Supportive Organizations o SPAN o CPA o WISE o CHMC o CBDC o RCMP o Self-Health Groups (AA and NA) Affordable Housing Developments Currently Underway (Seniors’ Housing) o Dildo o Harbour Grace (8 units currently being developed with an additional 8 units planned) o Bay Roberts 55 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Related Housing Programmes o Rental subsidies o Victim services o Mental health crisis line Drop in ‘free-lunch’ café in Clarkes Beach (11-2pm daily and Sunday Dinner) 56 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 5. Strategic Directions As illustrated, the Baccalieu Trail region is currently experiencing a housing shortage. An aging housing stock, combined with a lack of variety of housing types, changing demographic patterns, and an overall increase in the cost of housing and maintenance, have had a significant impact on the ability of many residents to attain and maintain safe, affordable and appropriate housing. While many of these concerns are shared among residents, the most acute housing issues are being experienced by the most vulnerable individuals in the region. Despite the growing awareness of the prevalence of housing and homelessness issues in the region, the process of developing collective and collaborative strategies to address these issues is in its infancy. The Community Plan outlined in the follow pages is intended to support and augment the development of regional partnerships and collaborations and, in doing so, establish the foundation from which future housing issues can be collectively identified and addressed. As such, the Community Plan outlined in this document should be viewed as only the first phase of a long-term regional housing project. To this end, this Community Plan has three distinct sections. The first section is focused on addressing the most immediate housing needs, through establishing emergency housing shelters in various communities in the region. These shelters have been envisioned as fairly small units, which are dispersed throughout the region, and which will be mandated to provide residents with emergency housing as well as the supports needed to obtain long-term, sustainable housing. Ideally, these shelters, while operating in concert with each other, would be locally managed and would operate with enough independence to ensure that each shelter was reflexive of the needs of the community in which it is housed. The second section of this community plan is focused on increasing the capacity of the Baccalieu Advisory Board (BAB) to facilitate effective collaboration amongst organizations, institutions and government departments who are engaged with housing and homelessness related programmes. Accordingly, this section of the Community Plan is focused on increasing the overall ability of BAB to identify emerging housing issues, develop collective responses to the identified issues, and to develop the institutional memory necessary for facilitating effective collaborative responses, and increasing the regional knowledge-base surrounding housing and homelessness. The final section of this Community Plan is aimed at addressing the long-term housing needs in the region through increasing both the quantity and variety of housing stock available within the region. This Community Plan is outlined below. 57 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region FIGURE 3 - STRATEGIC DIRECTIONS Increase Capacity of Baccalieu Advisory Board to Oversee Projects Related to Housing and Homelessness Develop Emergency Shelters Establish a Youth Task Force Develop Communication Strategy Establish a ‘Complex Needs’ Task Force External Communications Strategy 58 Public Build a Business Case for Social Housing Internal Communications Strategy Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Project Outline – Acute Housing Needs Project Title Issues to be Addressed Goals Development of Emergency Shelters to Address Immediate Short-term Housing Needs Need for an umbrella organization to address immediate/emergency housing needs Need to address geographic concerns present within the Baccalieu Trail region, i.e., rural and urban populations, concentration of services in Carbonear, Harbour Grace and Bay Roberts area, etc. Need for an organization to support the transition to long-term sustainable housing Need for an appropriate proponent to support shelter development To provide individuals with housing needs access to safe and appropriate emergency housing and the supports needed in order for these individuals to make the transition to long-term sustainable housing Objectives Lead Agency or Agencies: 1. To obtain appropriate real estate in which to house an emergency shelter 2. To obtain the financial commitments required to ensure the sustainability of the shelter 3. To develop and implement the range of programming needed to support the transition to long-term housing 4. To develop strong collaborative partnerships with service organizations, community groups, government departments and other stakeholders in the region BAB & Shelter Proponent Will need the support of HRLE, Eastern Health, and CHMC Will also need the expertise of those organizations currently involved in shelter development and management Resources Required Financial Amount/Type Required To Be Determined Human To Be Determined Other (i.e., community support) To Be Determined 59 Strategy Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Action Plan Task 1. Identify Proponent and Establish Board of Directors 2. Define scope of shelter, including rules and regulations Agency or Agencies Responsible BAB, Faith Organizations (note: the Anglican Parish in Clarkes Beach has expressed interest in becoming a proponent) Board of Directors in consultation with BAB Timeframe 1 month 2 months 3. Find location for shelter & begin necessary renovations Should draw on the expertise of those involved in the development and management of shelters Should include service providers and related professionals practicing in the region Board of Directors in consultation with BAB 6 months 4. Open shelter 5. Establish long-term supports Should involve government departments at all levels Board of Directors BAB, Board of Directors, Service Providers and other stakeholders 60 6 months 1 Year after the opening of the first shelter. Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Project Outline – Capacity Building Project Title Capacity Building – Baccalieu Advisory Board on Housing and Homelessness Goals To increase the capacity of the Baccalieu Advisory Board on Housing and Homelessness to facilitate the development of collaborative initiatives related to housing and homelessness in the region Objectives Lead Agency or Agencies: To develop the operational capacity to facilitate collaborative initiatives amongst member organizations To create the operational capacity to respond to emerging issues related to housing and homelessness in the region BAB with the support of its members Resources Required Financial Human Amount/Type Required Cost of meeting space and nutrition breaks Membership Facilitator Other 61 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Action Plan Task 1. Schedule day long planning session 2. Appoint facilitator for planning session 3. Host planning session This session should focus on two key issues, namely: what role should BAB take? What changes if any need to be made in order to best fulfill this role? 4. Implement changes identified through the planning session Agency or Agencies Responsible Baccalieu Advisory Board Baccalieu Advisory Board Baccalieu Advisory Board Timeframe 2 weeks 2 weeks 1 day Baccalieu Advisory Board 3 months 62 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Project Outline – Internal Communications Strategy Project Title Goals Objectives Internal Communications Strategy for the Baccalieu Advisory Board on Housing and Homelessness To increase the operation capacity of BAB through ensuring that information is easily shared among the various organizations and institutions who are involved with the Board and to increase the capacity of BAB to support collaborative approaches to identifying and addressing housing and homelessness issues in the region. Lead Agency or Agencies: To provide a forum in which members can share information, raise concerns To provide a vehicle with which to foster new collaborative approaches to emerging housing and homelessness issues in the region To ensure that initiatives undertaken by the various organizations are complementary rather than competitive To facilitate the efficient use of human and financial resources To provide a means of evaluating the effectiveness of completed projects BAB with the active support of its members Resources Required Financial Human Amount/Type Required Dependent upon the type of communications strategy employed Coordinator Other 63 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Action Plan Task 1. Identify the communication needs of the BAB and develop a means for sharing this information amongst members Agency or Agencies Responsible Baccalieu Advisory Board Timeframe 2 months This is likely to include: regular meetings, members listserv, database of housing initiatives and contact information and regular planning sessions 2. Implement the resulting operational changes 3. Evaluate the effectiveness of the communication strategy and make any required changes Baccalieu Advisory Board 2 months Baccalieu Advisory Board 1 month to conduct evaluation, should be conducted no more that six months after the implementation of the communications strategy 64 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Project Outline – External Communications Strategy Project Title Goals Objectives Lead Agency or Agencies: Public Awareness Strategy and Promotional Activity To remove the common misconceptions that many have regarding individuals with complex needs, particularly with regard to housing. The short-term goal is to develop a promotional strategy which capitalizes on existing resources such as local newsletters, municipal websites, and so on. Over the long-term, the goal is to create a ‘resource centre’ which can act as a ‘clearing house’ for information, resources and direction related to social housing. Develop a public awareness campaign Support networking opportunities Host special events Provide a communications vehicle for those involved in addressing housing and homelessness issues Baccalieu Advisory Board Financial Resources Required Amount/Type Required Dependent upon the type of communications strategy employed Human Other(i.e., community support) Coordinator Dependent upon the type of communications strategy employed Action Plan Task Agency or Agencies Responsible Timeframe 1. Develop a promotional strategy, Baccalieu Advisory Board 3 months including the development of a housing newsletter and engaging local media 2. Identify sources of funding to implement the promotional strategy Baccalieu Advisory Board 3. Implement the resulting strategy Baccalieu Advisory Board 65 3 months Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Project Outline – Building a Business Case for Social Housing Project Title Issues to be Addressed Building a Business Case for Social Housing Particularly as it Relates to Individuals with Complex Needs Access to Affordable and Suitable Housing Barriers to Housing Lack of awareness on the part of landlords and wider communities regarding mental illness and addictions Goals To improve the availability of affordable and suitable housing for individuals with complex needs. Objectives 1. Build partnerships between private enterprise, service providers, and clients 2. Build a ‘business case’ for affordable housing development 3. Remove the barriers to affordable and suitable housing (attitudinal and financial barriers) Lead Agency Baccalieu Advisory Board (BAB) or Agencies: Community Organizations Eastern Health NL Housing HRLE Resources Required Amount/Type Required Financial Funding for Coordinator’s Salary and Related Office Expenses Human Other Volunteer Directors Coordinator Community Support including the active support of private enterprise 66 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Task 1. Establish Housing and Homelessness Task Force Timeframe 6 months Focused on complex needs of individuals Related to BAB but with a formal presence 2. Conduct a feasibility study and market analysis of the viability of establishing dedicated affordable housing units in the Baccalieu Trail region. Action Plan Agency or Agencies Community Organizations, BAB, NL Housing, HRLE and Eastern Health Outline a ‘business case’ for social housing 3. Develop incentive programme directed toward current or prospective landlords Housing and Homelessness Task Force 4-6 months Other stakeholders including: Private Enterprise NL Housing Service Providers Etc Housing and Homelessness Task Force, related Development Agencies 4. Devolve programme to other agency Housing and Homelessness Task Force, related Development Agencies 67 1 Year 1 Year Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Project Outline – Youth Homelessness Project Title Goals Objectives Establish a Youth Task Force focused on Addressing Issues Related to Housing and Homelessness To provide a vehicle with which to develop a collective response to issues related to youth housing and homelessness issues in the region Lead Agency or Agencies: To identify housing and homelessness issues which are specific to youth in the region and which would benefit from a collective response To provide a means of coordinating a collective response to the identified issues To provide a means of evaluating the effectiveness of the resulting initiatives To provide a means of engaging young people in addressing issues related to housing and homelessness in the region BAB Youth Organizations and Agencies in the Region Municipalities Educational Institutions Related Government Departments Resources Required Financial Human Other Amount/Type Required Dependent upon type of initiatives identified by the task force Commitment from Youth Service Organizations and General Membership of BAB Dependent upon type of initiatives identified by the task force 68 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Action Plan Task 1. Establish Youth Task Force 2. Identify the individuals, groups and/or organizations that should be represented on the Task Force 3. Develop a regular schedule for meetings and reporting to BAB Agency or Agencies Responsible BAB BAB Youth Task Force 69 Timeframe 1 month 1 month Ongoing Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Project Outline – Complex Needs Project Title Goals Objectives Establish a ‘Complex Needs’ Task Force focused on Addressing Issues Related to Housing and Homelessness To provide a vehicle with which to develop a collective response to the housing and homelessness issues faced by individuals with complex needs Lead Agency or Agencies: To identify housing and homelessness issues which are specific to individuals with complex needs and which would benefit from a collective response To provide a means of coordinating a collective response to the identified issues To provide a means of evaluating the effectiveness of the resulting initiatives BAB Service Organizations Eastern Health Heath Care Providers Municipalities Educational Institutions Related Government Departments Resources Required Financial Human Other Amount/Type Required Dependent upon type of initiatives identified by the task force Commitment from Service Organizations and General Membership of BAB Dependent upon type of initiatives identified by the task force 70 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Action Plan Task 1. Establish ‘Complex Needs’ Task Force 2. Identify the individuals, groups and/or organizations that should be represented on the Task Force 3. Develop a regular schedule for meetings and reporting to BAB Agency or Agencies Responsible BAB Timeframe 1 month BAB 1 month Complex Needs Task Force Ongoing 71 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region 6. Contact Information Baccalieu Trail Housing and Homelessness Community Plan Contact Information Name Organization Email Phone Sheila Handrigan Tracy Oates HRLE [email protected] 945-3004 HRLE [email protected] 945-3223 Wendy Cranford Eastern Health [email protected] 945-6551 Kim Crane CBDC-TC [email protected] [email protected] 596-3450 596-3849 945-3020 596-6217 Mary Cleary Karen Davis M-RON, Inc [email protected] Dana Combden Eastern Health [email protected] Robin Harris YEC (M-RON, Inc) [email protected] 596-3700 Megan Forward YEC (M-RON, Inc) [email protected] 596-3700 Gladys Mercer Town of Carbonear [email protected] 596-5124 Cindy Clarke Eastern Health [email protected] 786-5219 Marie Ryan Shelley Grant Rev. Roscoe Cole Senior’s Resource Centre Senior’s Resource Centre United Church, Broad Cove, Blackhead, Western Bay and Ochre Pit Cove [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] 786-4630 786-4630 598-2943 72 Housing and Homelessness Community Plan – Baccalieu Trail Region Father Gerald Westcott Rev. Cathy Laskey Mildred Glynn Francis Glynn* Deceased Rev. Elsie Pottle Anglican Parish of the Resurrection Anglican Parish of Heart’s Content Lower Trinity Regional Development Association Lower Trinity Regional Development Association fathergerald@anglicanresurrection. com [email protected] 786-7808 United Church 588-2638 Joy Bishop Dobbie Stacey Harris Local Service District Cavendish CBDC SPLASH Centre Department of Corrections and Community Services Eastern Health 588-2596 583-2359 583-2016 583-2016 [email protected] 596-1284 [email protected] 945-3020 [email protected] 945-6505 Eastern Health [email protected] 227-3610 Glen Furlong CMHC [email protected] 772-4949 Gail Tobin Iris Kirby House [email protected] 722-9272 Lisa Clarke Mental Health Nurse, Case Manager Community Support Program Social Worker, Old Perlican. Old Perlican Pastoral Care [email protected] 945-6591 [email protected] 587-2332 Lynn Burke Wendy White Lilly Mulrooney Bramwell Pollett Rev. Yvonne Hopkins 587-2067 73