Read the PDF - HarnessRacingUpdate.com
Transcription
Read the PDF - HarnessRacingUpdate.com
Saturday, January 4, 2013 Will Harness Racing in Michigan Disappear? By Joe Scarpa They've been racing at Northville Downs since 1944, at Hazel Park since 1953. Michigan has a long and illustrious history in the sport but its days appear to be numbered. Northville and Hazel Park are attempting to convert to thoroughbred racing and the state's other track, Sports Creek, is believed to be interested in heading in the same direction. The tracks applied for 2014 thoroughbred dates after the thoroughbred horsemen's group agreed to a system whereby horses would pay f for the privilege o racing at the d state's tracks, an not just in stakes races but in all Harness racing at Hazel races. Park...something you might not be "W hat it looks seeing much more of like it has come down to is choosing the way we'll die," said trainer-driver Kelly Goodwin. "W e can die in three or four years or we can just go away now. It sounds really bad to say that, but that's the way it is." W hen Michigan voters turned down a proposal in 2004 that would have legalized racetrack casinos it seemed certain that the state's racing industries were headed for an uncertain future. Both breeds limped along over the next few years, but their situations only worsened. W ith both struggling to find ways to survive the thoroughbreds agreed to a "pay to play" concept, whereby they would have to pay to enter a race. The harness industry refused to agree to do the same. "The horsemen here were already starving," said Bonley Farms' Karen Greengard. "At a certain point there's only so much more you can give. W hy do it? It starts being a situation like you get when showing Morgans. You win a ribbon and $60, not even enough to pay for your gas. It might be fun but it's not a livelihood." The Michigan tracks originally submitted dates applications for 2014 similar to their 2013 schedules, but amended them in December with Hazel and Northville asking for just 10 harness dates each and Sports Creek putting in for 11. The plan was to convert the racing surfaces to thoroughbred racing after the harness meets end. With money so tight in Michigan racing circles, it is widely believed that once funds are outlaid to convert the racing surfaces they’ll never be switched back to harness tracks. "W e're confident that if they convert they would never go The Least Surprising Story of 2013: Hanover is the Sport’s Leading Breeder ...Page 2 back," said Brett Boyd, the president of the Michigan Harness Horsemen's Association. "It is cost prohibitive and really hard to see them reconverting back to harness racing." Boyd is among those who has issued a warning to horsemen throughout the country, that if the "pay to play" model sticks in Michigan that track managements in other states will try to do the same. "The tracks want to be paid, which the thoroughbreds have agreed to do," he said. "I think this could have a cascading affect on the entire industry; it's a potential cancer that all our harness horsemen should be very concerned about." The battle is far from over. Boyd said that yesterday the Michigan Gaming Control Board ruled that Northville would have to conduct 26 harness racing cards. But Northville is expected to sue the Gaming Board and the future of Michigan racing likely won't be settled until the courts get involved. Boyd argues that "pay to play" is illegal because it is actually a roundabout way for the tracks to get more than their legislated share of the state's simulcasting money. In the meantime, it's hard to imagine any scenarios for (continued on next page) HarnessRacingUpdate.com • 1/4/14 PAGE 2 of 7 Michigan's future that are rosy. So many of the state's top drivers and trainers have already lefty and the breeding industry has fallen apart. Greengard said it wasn't long ago that there were more than 300 horses on the Bonley property and now there are just 35. On the final night of racing in Michigan in 2013, at Sports Creek, the top purse on the card was $2,600. And there is no hope of getting slots at the tracks. "W hat people are having to do now is drive somewhere to race," Goodwin said. "W e're not in a horrible location. It's 4 ½ hours to Toronto, which is a long drive but it's not undoable. W e've bought Indiana sired yearlings for this year and the next. You can go for good money in Ohio and Indiana and, still, in Toronto, so you try to get in as many at those tracks as you can. That's how we'll try to stay alive." Greengard said it's become a matter of everyone trying to keep the state's industry alive for just one more year, but she believes that sooner or later their luck is going to run out. "W e are hoping they will force the tracks to abide by their original dates applications so we might get one more year out of them," she said. "But once the tracks make the changes to accommodate thoroughbred racing I can't see them ever changing back. The question becomes when do you go down the tubes, 2014, 2015, 2016?" STATS CORNER For the Umpteenth Time, Hanover Leads all Breeders Hanover Shoe Farms led all breeders in both earnings and wins in 2013. Since the USTA began keeping records, Hanover has been the sport’s leading breeder every year. Hanover topped the earnings list with $29,123,021. It also had 2659 wins. W inbak Farm was second in both categories with $18,216,455 in earnings and 2086 wins. (All stats courtesy of the USTA) Breeder Starters W ins Earnings Hanover Shoe Farms 1112 2659 $29,123,021 W inbak Farm 1029 2086 $18,216,455 W hite Birch Farm 152 420 $8,664,668 Perretti Farms 354 727 $8,263,775 Brittany Farms 241 606 $7,733,777 Kentuckiana Farms 243 548 $6,421,053 Blue Chip 165 427 $5,473,756 Arlene & Jules Siegel 160 380 $4,000,303 Fox Valley 201 376 $3,354,022 Diamond Creek 96 223 $3,204,572 (continued on next page) HarnessRacingUpdate.com Leading Pacing Sire Ponder SBSW Art Major American Ideal Well Said • 1/4/14 PAGE 3 of 7 Sires by Average Earnings (2-Year-Olds) Foals Starters Earnings Avg Earnings 16 9 $382,927 $23,933 118 95 $2,813,037 $23,839 106 71 $2,371,227 $22,370 92 67 $1,883,190 $20,469 102 68 $1,388,210 $19,283 Leading Pacing Sires by Average Earnings (3-Year-Olds) Sire Foals Starters Earnings Avg Earnings SBSW 124 104 $8,320,488 $67,101 Bettor’s Delight 126 106 $5,300,397 $42,067 Western Ideal 102 74 $3,825,243 $37,502 Roddy’s Bags Again 16 15 $575,607 $35,975 Art Major 109 86 $3,804,905 $34,907 Dejarmbro’s Book Full and Closed The Dejarmbro Syndicate is pleased to announce Dejarmbro's 2014 book is now is full and closed. The Dejarmbro Syndicate wishes to thank breeders for their continued support. Dejarmbro stands at Hickory Lane Farm In Ohio. Eighteen Years Later, Augustine Has Returned to the Sulky Trainer-driver turned blueberry magnate Bill Augustine has resumed his driving career more than 18 years after he hung up his colors. Augustine won three races in 1992 before driving sparingly over the next three years. His attention has turned to his growing and lucrative blueberry business, which took him away from the sport. But he never lost his itch. In 2012 he bought into eventual Hambletonian winner Market Share and spent big money at the 2012 and 2013 yearling sales. Late last year he got ack into driving, first as an amateur and later as a professional. The 57-year-old finished up 2013 with two winners. “W hen you are involved with a Hambletonian horse like Market Share and our socializing with great trainers like Jimmy Takter, Ron Burke and Linda Toscano and hanging out in the paddock with drivers like Pierce, Tetrick, Campbell, Gingras, how can you not get the driving bug back?” Augustine said. That was my background and I always regretted giving up my license all those years ago. 21 years ago. I got in a wreck and broke four ribs and got real involved in this multi-million dollar blueberry operation. But socializing with the cream of the harness racing crop got me Back in the bike. Bill Augustine winning fired up again. at Freehold (W orld Wide Racing Photos) “This is something I am serious about. I workout every day and have lost 35 pounds, I eat blueberries every day and am on a strict diet.” Tim Tetrick does not have to worry about losing the driving assignment with Market Share to Augustine but Augustine said he would like to drive many of his own horses in major races in 2014. He is not interested in catch driving. USTA’s Langley Names Wand, Carson as President's Awards Recipients Friday, Jan. 3, 2014 - from the U.S. Trotting Association Columbus, OH --- U.S. Trotting Association President Phil Langley announced Friday that USTA Director Gabe W and and award-winning writer and horse owner Bob Carson are the recipients of the 2013 USTA Presidents Awards. Langley will present the awards at the USTA Annual Meetings on Sunday, March 30 in Columbus, Ohio. Elected to the USTA Board of Directors from District 4 in 2010, W and is a packaging manager for Swiss Valley Farms, a regional dairy headquartered in Davenport, Iowa. He started jogging horses at age 11 and has been involved in the sport for nearly 20 years. President’s Award “This award is being presented winner Gabe Wand to recognize Gabe's relentless efforts to keep county fair racing alive in W isconsin,” said Langley. “Being familiar with Wisconsin Fairs since the 1940s, I can especially appreciate his efforts to keep the history of so many great horse people from that state alive." In 2012, W and set a state record with his fourth consecutive W isconsin Driver of the Year title and now ranks second all-time in top driver awards there. For the past nine years, he has been the president of the W isconsin Harness Horse Association, where he was the youngest person ever elected to the board of directors (age 20) and its youngest president (age 23). He is also a member of the Illinois Harness Horsemen’s Association and the Southwest W isconsin Wind-Up Circuit. In 2009 when W and was named W isconsin Driver of the (continued on next page) AnEl i t eTr ot t i ngSi r eSt andsi nOhi o Dej ar mbr o' sbooki snowf ul l andc l os edf or2014. TheDej ar mbr os y ndi c a t ewoul d l i ket ot hankal l of t hebr eeder sf or t hei rc ont i nueds uppor t . DEJARMBRO I nqui r i est oFar m ManagerBr adWal l ace 1 4346Towns hi pRoad205,Fi ndl ay,Ohi o45840 ( 41 9)4223004,Fax( 41 9)4252999 www. hi ckor yl anef ar m. com HarnessRacingUpdate.com • 1/4/14 PAGE 4 of 7 Year for the first time, he co-owned, trained and drove Wisconsin Pacer of the Year Mel’s Z Tam and Good Ride Cowboy, who shared Wisconsin Trotter of the Year honors. In 2010, he campaigned his third Pacer of the Year, Mr Shankopotamus. Carson's award-winning freelance writing has appeared in more than two dozen national publications. He has been a steady contributor to the USTA’s website www.ustrotting.com, Trot Magazine and Timeline Magazine. “Bob is one of the few writers that can be serious and funny at the same time,” commented Langley. “His frequent articles on the USTA website are always informative, usually a little far out and very readable. His stories on educating new owners to be patient about first year losses ring a bell with all of us. I once told him that I had a somewhat similar problem but in the reverse when trying to explain that successes with the first horse don't necessarily work the second time. He is very worthy of this award." In the fall of 2010, Carson conducted an experiment taking seven non-harness racing people along during a year-long trip into the world of harness horse ownership and documented it on the USTA’s website in a 25-part series. In the spring of 2012, he attracted eight new owners and did a follow-up series of 24 reports on the behind-the-scenes experiences of ownership. Each chapter had a simple title introducing the topic and a secondary one using a song title. After more than 200 magazine articles and stories, his first novel, The Voyage of Mess (humor) was released in 2009. In 2005 he produced the documentary film, Touching Home (Minor League Baseball). In 2006 he received the Hervey Award for Journalistic Excellence and Best of Ohio Fiction awards. He has published Minor Trips (Minor League Baseball) since 1991. Carson has owned harness horses for more than a decade, including a stint as a weekend trainer. Track Meadowlands Race Purse 6th, A-1/FFA $30,000 Mack Lobell at 30 Looking healthy and happy at age 30, this picture of Mack Lobell surfaced on Facebook yesterday. His home is in Sweden. pps Darin Zoccali reviews the full Meadowlands card here. Ken W arkentin reviews the full Meadowlands card here. HARNESS RACING UPDATE IS: Bill Finley, Publisher Dean Towers, Columnist Sue Finley, Advertising Director Dean Hoffman, Contributor Lucas Marquardt, Contributor Robert Williams, IT Bob Carson, Congratulations Dennis Rodman, North Korean Correspondent Lia Kusch, Graphic Design Brian Fuller, Results, Layout and Distribution Visit us on the web at www.harnessracingupdate.com. 'Trying to Win' Revisited A recent article in Harness Racing Update titled, "In Sports - Especially Gambling Sports - Integrity Matters" , the (primarily) harness racing phenomenon of not trying to win a race was examined. The example used was Market Share's effort in a prep for the TVG where he went to the back, at 2-5 odds, while the next week he went right to the lead, in a wire to wire effort. This prompted a couple of letters to the editor to Harness Racing Update. Gates Brunet wrote: "Dean Towers' article makes a point using the NFL on how differently the integrity issue is handled in other sports. W hile, there's obviously a case for enforcement which is sorely lacking in many parts of our game and in most cases impossible to defend, I feel he (continued on next page) HarnessRacingUpdate.com • 1/4/14 PAGE 5 of 7 used a very poor example with the Market Share race. I will go down the same path he did, using the NFL and this being playoff time, would like to ask this question. W hen a team has clinched its playoff berth and home field advantage with one or two games to play, would you think it unwise to bet the opposing team which is clearly inferior but needs the win for a playoff spot? " This prompted a rebuttal from David Perry: "Gates Brunet's comments sound like those of a naive person whom knows little about what racing patrons think. The Market Share debacle is a good example. To use an analogy of a sports team saving its best efforts for the final points this out. The difference? If the best players are sat and not used till the final, that information is published and bettor can factor this into his/her betting before the event. When a racehorse enters the betting pool, the assumption is that the team: owner/trainer/driver-jockey/horse will deliver to the best of their ability and the public makes that assumption and bets accordingly. Integrity is what has been called into question and I believe Mr. Towers article points this out. The quality of the information you publish reflects on your publication's quality and integrity, I would hope you publish a rebuttal from Mr. Towers." Since Mr. Perry asked, and with the NFL in high gear and harness racing on a mini-hiatus for the most part for the holidays, I figured I would take Mr. Perry up on his suggestion. As we mentioned in the original article, the NFL does take gambling very seriously, despite them not earning a dime of hard-revenue from people wagering on game outcomes. That was never more apparent in week 17 of the season; the part of the season Mr. Brunet and Mr. Perry are speaking of in their letters. It's the part where there may be some "no try" efforts. One such game happened this past Sunday. The Kansas City Chiefs, who were already locked into their playoff seeding no matter what happened, were taking on the San Diego Chargers, who needed to win to have a chance of entering the playoffs. W ould it be a no try effort? W e did not have to guess. Early in the week Chiefs Coach Andy Reid made it clear that bettors would see "quite a few" backups playing in the game. By the end of the week it was announced for all bettors to handicap forthwith: "W hen the Chiefs' inactive report came out, it read like a Pro Bowl roster - quarterback Alex Smith, running back Jamaal Charles, receiver Dwayne Bowe, linebacker Tamba Hali, linebacker Derrick Johnson, offensive tackle Branden Albert and defensive lineman Dontari Poe will all be on the sideline when the Chiefs and Chargers kick off." The spread, sitting at KC + 9.5, was solidified. There was no mystery. The Chiefs were not trying too hard to win this game, as a must win, but they would be fielding a team of hungry back-ups who would get to shine on National TV. As Mr. Perry, in my view correctly noted, that's what sets about the Market Share and other "to the back no try efforts" and the NFL. The NFL supplies perfect information to bettors so they can handicap and decision-make, based on a spread. In harness racing this does not occur. A "no try" or "try" effort does not occur with such perfect information. It simply occurs based on the connections view of the race, or a driver's decision making before, or right behind the gate. Did you know for sure Market Share was going to the back on a speed favoring track at 2-5? For sure? Of course you didn't. But you did know the Chiefs were sitting their best players. Industry insiders like to say "well, it’s buyer beware and that's why they call it gambling." That's nonsense. You're not running an industry where customers have to guess if a magician is pulling a rabbit out of a hat, or if a little spinning ball will land on six; it's a betting skill game with statistics, and impact values and past performances. More apt (and in the bigger picture), that's a reason why so many in the public think insiders are crooks, like extolled in this recent article in Vice.com titled "The Sport of Kings is Full of Scum, Horse Racing's long history of shady dealings" Have you ever heard of a story like that using example after example of an NFL player or coach secretly throwing a game to cash a ticket each week or month? Not likely. In addition, when (in a two part series early this year) HRU asked several thoroughbred bettors who had played harness racing what they don't like about it, one bettor spoke of the "control a driver has to simply not try this week" as a major turn-off. The Market Share race is not singular, or even remotely rare. It happens with some frequency and it is maddeningly unhandicappable. Fortunately some drivers get it. I saw an interview with Ron Pierce after he had a well bet horse from the outside and drove her aggressively for the win. He said (paraphrasing, as one must do with Ron Pierce in interview prose) "I wanted to give her an easy one, but she was hammered at the windows so I had to try." I have seen other drivers like John Campbell say the same thing. Some don't seem to prescribe to the same doctrine, and they throw you for a loop so often it's impossible to model effectively. "Is he going to the back or going to try?" W ho knows. This is sending the public, who bets $2 billion a year, a very conflicted, nebulous message; a message no gambling game should ever send. One might think this is a pretty simple fix. W hen bettors complained about something in the NFL, like which players were injured or not, the NFL created the injury report. In the 2000's they created the NFL Network, which has more betting news than the Daily Racing Form. It's clearly about the gamble. In racing it would seem to be fairly easy to fine or suspend trainers or drivers who don't put forth an effort in these situations, and that would have an immediate and effective impact. It's not like that's not being done in Hong Kong or Australia, because if you read the world racing news, you see these offences called and penalized often. It's nothing new. W hen something like that is even suggested here, it's like you're asking for a free share of Somebeachsomewhere. An airline executive recently said something I found apropos. "Customers don't expect you to be perfect, but they do expect you to fix things when they go wrong." Not trying with a horse when a customers' money has hammered them down to odds-on is wrong. There's no getting around that, there's no excuse for it, and its high-time someone fixed it. HarnessRacingUpdate.com • 1/4/14 PAGE 6 of 7 By Brett Sturman Race 7, N/W $75K Life Pace It's about time that MAGIC TRICKS gets some respect and all three of his tries here at this winter meet have been excellent. After shocking on opening night here in November, this one ran a decent third against Twilight Bonfire and then had sharp pace at both ends of a 1:50 mile last out. W atson barn off to a good start. TROON was a game first over last out as a big longshot; a possible breakout kind of mile. BURKENTINE HANOVER was collared last week against a very sharp foe; he still closed in :26 and change. BIG GAME HUNTER comes out of consecutive sub 1:49 miles, that's almost not fair. An obvious contender on the drop. MUSCLE BEACHBOY makes his second start for Capone; he was good last week. Race 8, C-1 Pace It's really hard to be particularly inspired by anyone in here, but BOLERO ANDREW has a solid enough history here and still should be good enough to win in this spot. Going third start for the new barn, this one closed strongly two back and then was up against it in his most recent, almost a month ago. Likely blasts, as Dave Miller's pick. STAND BY CAM had an impossible trip when last seen here on opening night; rates a shot. EAGLE JOLT drops for Ford; picks up the hot hands of Callahan. SONIC DANCER finds the rail again; this field is probably a touch softer than what he recently faced. ALEX BULLVILLE didn't miss by much last out; he raced well here throughout much of last year. DREAMZZZZ R FOR U was YG's somewhat surprising pick. Race 9, C-1 4YO Pace It looks about time to take a swing with TARPON HANOVER as the former 2-year-old champion came to life with an eventful trip last out in his third start for Surick. This one actually took an open length lead into the stretch despite a tough early part of the mile; moving in the right direction. HUMILITY was used early last out into a :26 and change opening quarter; his best would give him a shot. BIG ART closed in :26:2 last week coming from the Saunders barn; not without a prayer as a longshot. MANCHESTER was DM's pick; short priced contender making his second start back from the vet scratch. Race 10, C-1 Pace STOLEN CAR blasted from post 10 last out into a :26:1 opening quarter and did well to finish second. That race from 12/21 was more recent a race than anyone else in here; chance for Cat to break through with a rare M1 win these days. CAM B ZIPPER finished right behind the classy Silent Swing last out but that was nearly a month ago; tough finding spots for horses here these days. FREDDY DAY HANOVER moves all the way from post 10 to the pole; he fits with these when on his game. BLUERIDGE WESTERN drops and while making his second start back, but again the gap in races is tough to gauge. This looks like class relief for Burke's FITZ'S Z TAM. SAMANDER is primarily a smaller track horse but shouldn't be outclassed. The Plays: $24 ticket ($1 base): 2-6-8 / 4-9 / 4-6 / 3-4 $32 ticket ($1 base): 6-9 / 1-4-7-9 / 4 / 3-4-7-9 © Copyright Harness Racing Update. This newspaper may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without prior written permission of the copyright owner, MB Publishing Inc. Information as to the races, race results and earnings was obtained from results charts published by the United States Trotting Association and utilized here with the permission of the copyright owner. HarnessRacingUpdate.com • 1/4/14 PAGE 7 of 7 6, M, $30,000, T, A-2/A-1/FFA Handicap Post Positions Drawn According to Class, 27.0, 54.3, 1:22.4, 1:51.1, FT 1-Sweet Justice (g, 4, Justice Hall--Sugar, by Sir Taurus), $30,000 2011 IN-PREM O-M & M Harness Racing LLC. B-Midland Acres Inc. T-Bruce Saunders. D-John Campbell, $15,000, Lifetime Record: 45-17-7-4, $227,834 2-Quick Deal (g, 6, Revenue S--Photo Magic, by S J's Photo), $1,000 2009 BRDS-SEL O-Our Horse Cents Stables & Rossie L Smith. B-John P Hurtgen. T-Ron Burke. D-Yannick Gingras, $7,500 3-Not Afraid (g, 5, SJ's Caviar--Beverly Crusher, by Balanced Image) O-Christina Takter & John D Fielding, CA & Goran N Anderberg, SD. B-Steve D Organ, CA. T-Jimmy Takter. D-Corey Callahan, $3,600 Calls: 2H, 2H, 1Q, NS, T - Finish Order: Daylon Magician, Amigo Ranger, Appomattox, Blacktuxwhitesocks, Il Mago, E W Fisher, Dash For The Cash To view the replay click here Meadowlands (Race 6): After 14 months off and drawing the 10 post tonight, the only millionaire of the field, Daylon Magician (David Miller),rode out most of the mile in the middle of the field (finishing 4th). Quick Deal (John Campbell) set all the fractions but still couldn’t beat Sweet Justice (John Campbell) in 1:51.1. Sweet Justice is 5 for 5 since his purchase @ Harrisburg for $25,000 with earnings close to double that for his new connections ($46,000). 7, M, $30,000, P, Fillies & Mares - A-2/A-1/FFA Handicap Post Positions Drawn According to Class, 27.0, 54.4, 1:22.3, 1:50.3, FT 1-Lorrie Please (m, 7, Western Ideal--National Gallery, by Artsplace), $15,000 2008 SHS-HBG O-Allen H & Ira S Kaplan & David M Sheib. B-Gary S Machiz & Barry Rubenstein Farms LLC. T-Douglas Lewis. D-Corey Callahan, $15,000, Lifetime Record: 120-34-21-18, $481,985 2-Keepers Destiny (m, 8, Intrepid Seelster--Keeper Flying, by Nuclear Flash) O-Merlin Howse, CA. B-Merlin Howse, CA & Casie Coleman, CA. T-Andrew Harris. D-David Miller, $7,500 3-Blissfull Romance (m, 5, Blissfull Hall--Draconian Promise, by Rustler Hanover) O-Burke Racing Stable LLC & Weaver Bruscemi LLC. B-Cully J Mcginnis & Lawrence G Simon, CA. T-Ron Burke. D-Yannick Gingras, $3,600 Calls: 1Q, 1Q, 1, 1T, 1H - Finish Order: Ramalama, Big Mcdeal, Eighthunrdolarbill, Marty Party, Best Boss, Bullet Point To view the replay click here Meadowlands (Race 7): Lorrie Please (Corey Callahan) took a brief early lead, but fell back to 3rd before resuming that lead just in front of the ½ mile pole, finishing in 1:51.3, 1/5 slower than her career mark. Missed an Edition of the HRU? Check out our archive at w w w .harnessracingupdate.com