Pdf

May 2016
100
THE
CityRealty is the website for NYC real
estate, providing high-quality listings
and tailored agent matching for prospective apartment buyers, as well as
in-depth analysis of the New York real
estate market.
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
Additions to The CityRealty 100
The CityRealty 100 is an index comprised of the top 100 condominium buildings in Manhattan. Several factors—including a
building’s sales history, prominence and CityRealty’s rating for the property—are used to determine which buildings are included
in the index. This report tracks the performance of those buildings through March 31, 2016.
Three buildings have been added to the index as of the first quarter of this year, reflecting the changing landscape of the city’s luxury
housing market. The additions are as follows:
432 Park Avenue
The 1,396-foot tower at 432 Park Avenue, developed by Macklowe Properties and the CIM Group, is
the tallest residential tower in the Western Hempisphere. Rafael Viñoly designed the 96-floor tower,
which is the newest luxury building on the stretch of Midtown West that has been dubbed Billionaire’s
Row. Aside from the impressive height and equally impressive prices, the building’s units are defined
by their 10-foot-by-10-foot windows, which afford panoramic Manhattan views.
https://www.cityrealty.com/nyc/midtown-east/432-park-avenue/54898
The Greenwich Lane, 140-160 West 12th Street, 139-155 West 11th Street
The Rudin Organization’s large new complex, the Greenwich Lane, consists of some 200 condominiums
in five buildings on the former site of St. Vincent’s Hospital. FXFowle was the architect of the
development, which is on the western end of the block bounded by 12th and 11th Streets, Seventh
and Sixth Avenues in Greenwich Village. All of the buildings are centered on a large, private garden
courtyard; amenities include a pool, fitness center, and a private screening room.
https://www.cityrealty.com/nyc/greenwich-village/the-greenwich-lane-155-west-11th-street/63455
10 Madison Square West
The development at 10 Madison Square West consists of the conversion and expansion of a prewar
commercial building into 125 condominiums. The Witkoff Group and the Vector Group redeveloped the
limestone-and-brick-clad property, and Goldstein, Hill & West were the architects for the conversion.
The building, which is on Broadway between 24th and 25th Street, overlooks Madison Square Park and
is across the street from Eataly, the popular Italian food emporium.
https://www.cityrealty.com/nyc/flatiron-union-square/10-madison-square-west-5-west-24th-street/50191
About CityRealty
Established in 1994, CityRealty offers the most comprehensive data, analysis, and content available for the New York City real estate market,
covering both sales and rentals. Additionally, CityRealty provides a free, personalized service for New York City apartment buyers and
sellers, matching each customer to an agent with the precise expertise needed to find his or her perfect home. Further information about
CityRealty is available at www.cityrealty.com.
2
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Summary
During the six-month period starting October 1, 2015 and ending March 31, 2016, 566 apartments were sold in buildings that
are part of The CityRealty 100, a marked increase from the 334 sold in the same period a year ago. The rise in closings is largely a
result of numerous sponsor sales in newer buildings, including the Greenwich Lane, 150 Charles Street and One Riverside Park.
The average price per square foot was $2,602, which represents a year-over-year price decrease of 8%. The median price per square foot
was $2,344, which was a 3% increase from the median a year ago. The relatively small changes in average and median prices indicate a
steady market for condominiums included in the index.
Average and Median Price Per Square Foot
$2,602
$2,344
$3,500
$3,000
avg price / ft 2
$2,500
$2,000
M e d ian price / ft 2
six months ending
March 31, 2016
$1,500
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q1
Q2
2014
key:
avg price
Q3
Q4
2015
Q1
2016
median price
Transaction Volume
566
350
300
250
200
150
total sales
six months en d ing
March 31, 2016
100
50
Q2
Q3
2014
Q4
Q1
Q2
Q3
2015
Q4
Q1
2016
3
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
Historical Investment Comparison
Since March 2006, the average price per square foot of properties in The CityRealty 100 has increased at a Compound Annual
Growth Rate (CAGR) of 7% per year (non-inflation adjusted). This is well above both the ten-year CAGR for the S&P 500 (+4.4%). It is also
much higher than the CAGR for oil (-5%), which has experienced significant volatility in the past year. The ten-year CAGR for gold (+7.8%)
is similar to the CAGR for the buildings covered in The CityRealty 100.
Ten Year Price Change of The CityRealty 100
$3,250
avg price / ft 2
$2,750
+7%
$2,250
10 year Compound Annual
Growth Rate (CAGR) (USD)
$1,750
$1,250
2006
key:
the cityrealty 100
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
all manhattan condos(1)
Other Markets and Measures of Wealth
S & P 500
Oil
Gold
+4.4%
-5.0%
+7.8%
10 year Compound
annual growth rate
'06
10 year Compound
annual growth rate
'16
'06
+6.0%
10 year Compound
annual growth rate
'16
'06
Data from March 1, 2006 through March 31, 2016. *Based on top 100 billionaires in the world included in Forbes’ annual ranking from 2006-2016.
4
Wealth of Forbes'
Top 100 Billionaires*
10 year Compound
annual growth rate
'16
'06
'16
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
Buildings in The CityRealty 100
BUILDING
15 Central Park West
Residences at the Mandarin Oriental
One57
Walker Tower
432 Park Avenue
Time Warner Center
Baccarat Hotel & Residences
The Plaza
One Beacon Court
Trump International
40 Bond
Millennium Tower
737 Park Avenue
18 Gramercy Park South
530 Park Avenue
135 East 79th Street
40 Mercer Street
279 Central Park West
The Greenwich Lane
150 Charles Street
Centurion
Park Millennium
Sky Lofts at 145 Hudson
One Madison
The Mayfair
535 West End Avenue
The Park Imperial
500 Park Tower
Trump Park Avenue
One Lincoln Square
One Kenmare Square
Olympic Tower
The Chatham
Caledonia
Essex House
299 West 12th Street
One Jackson Square
Liberty Lofts
50 United Nations Plaza
10 Madison Square West
The Park 900
Trump Tower
141 Fifth Avenue
One York Street
The Lucida
1 Morton Square
30 East 85th Street
Devonshire House
240 Park Avenue South
400 Fifth Avenue
12-MONTH
PRICE AVG
$6,039 (-4.7%)
$5,956 (n/a)
$5,175 (-13.1%)
$5,088 (32.8%)
$4,829 (n/a)
$4,385 (-20.0%)
$3,996 (12.4%)
$3,929 (-8.3%)
$3,716 (n/a)
$3,673 (-12.6%)
$3,637 (n/a)
$3,585 (n/a)
$3,469 (23.5%)
$3,453 (n/a)
$3,430 (22.5%)
$3,373 (n/a)
$3,224 (-3.5%)
$3,157 (n/a)
$3,061(n/a)
$2,934(n/a)
$2,885 (5.5%)
$2,885 (13.2%)
$2,864 (n/a)
$2,812 (-5.6%)
$2,788 (-9.1%)
$2,764 (n/a)
$2,738 (n/a)
$2,728 (n/a)
$2,693 (2.2%)
$2,688 (8.0%)
$2,634 (11.9%)
$2,556 (18.0%)
$2,543 (-9.1%)
$2,509 (0.7%)
$2,501 (-4.5%)
$2,500 (-18.9%)
$2,492 (8.5%)
$2,488 (n/a)
$2,475 (-15.0%)
$2,473 (n/a)
$2,435 (25.2%)
$2,415 (-11.5%)
$2,408 (n/a)
$2,401 (n/a)
$2,308 (0.5%)
$2,289 (5.5%)
$2,252 (-5.2%)
$2,250 (13.7%)
$2,248 (-7.0%)
$2,241 (-5.6%)
SALES / PAST
12 MONTHS
7
1
16
5
27
7
16
11
7
6
2
2
7
4
13
1
3
2
64
74
5
3
1
5
2
1
1
1
7
4
2
11
5
14
6
6
2
1
36
27
3
6
2
4
4
9
5
4
4
12
BUILDING
Bristol Plaza
The Olcott
101 Warren Street
The Aldyn
166 Perry Street
456 West 19th Street
The Century
200 East 79th Street
100 Eleventh Avenue
The Harrison
Laureate
SoHo Mews
The Grand Millennium
The Siena
The Laurel
Metropolitan Tower
W New York Downtown
Manhattan House
3 Lincoln Center
Place 57
Apple Bank Building
The Loft
Sheffield 57
The Heritage at Trump Place
The Park Laurel
The Apthorp
170 East End Avenue
The Park Belvedere
The Empire
250 West Street
520 West Chelsea
45 Park Avenue
The Galleria
One Riverside Park
The Ritz-Carlton, Battery Park City
Trump World Tower
Museum Tower
The Centria
The Rushmore
Central Park Place
The Greenwich Street Project
The Visionaire
Trump Palace
200 Eleventh Avenue
15 Union Square West
Linden 78
Superior Ink
HL23
The Porter House
Park Avenue Place
12-MONTH
PRICE AVG
$2,235 (14.3%)
$2,223 (23.6%)
$2,213 (-2.4%)
$2,209 (5.3%)
$2,207 (n/a)
$2,196 (9.2%)
$2,191 (-17.1%)
$2,185 (n/a)
$2,181 (-5.6%)
$2,112 (0.9%)
$2,099 (-30.1%)
$2,088 (-18.4%)
$2,088 (31.7%)
$2,087 (n/a)
$2,067 (8.9%)
$2,040 (22.2%)
$2,023 (0.4%)
$2,022 (-4.4%)
$1,999 (1.1%)
$1,999 (n/a)
$1,985 (10.1%)
$1,980 (2.9%)
$1,972 (5.8%)
$1,968 (45.4%)
$1,944 (n/a)
$1,923 (12.0%)
$1,920 (n/a)
$1,907 (0.6%)
$1,901 (-0.1%)
$1,874 (-22.1%)
$1,870 (-0.7%)
$1,832 (4.3%)
$1,830 (10.6%)
$1,798 (n/a)
$1,757 (-14.5%)
$1,754 (3.4%)
$1,748 (-0.3%)
$1,735 (-3.0%)
$1,722 (-11.6%)
$1,711 (-11.7%)
$1,594 (n/a)
$1,593 (6.1%)
$1,524 (-12.5%)
$1,421 (n/a)
$1,233 (n/a)
(n/a)
(n/a)
(n/a)
(n/a)
(n/a)
SALES / PAST
12 MONTHS
2
10
7
7
2
2
15
1
3
10
2
3
6
3
4
13
12
43
18
1
3
2
29
7
2
11
1
7
4
10
2
3
11
192
5
24
22
14
17
8
3
14
10
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
Percentage changes based on the current 12-month period, ending March 31, 2016, vs. previous 12-month period; must have at least 2 transactions in both periods.
5
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
New York's Most Expensive Condos
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
15 Central Park West
$6,039
avg price per ft 2
(Based on the 12-month perio d en d ing March 31, 2016)
+ 8.7%
(CAGR)
Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
2008
key:
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
avg price
One57
Walker Tower
157 West 57th Street
212 West 18th Street
25 Columbus Circle
$5,175
$5,088
$4,829 $4,385
avg price per ft 2
avg price per ft 2
+10.6%
'16
avg price per ft 2
avg price per ft 2
+5.5%
(cagr)
'06
'16
(cagr)
'06
Data from October 1, 2006 to March 31, 2016; for inclusion properties must have 3 or more transactions in the final time period.
6
Time Warner Center
+21.9%
(cagr)
'06
432 Park Avenue
'16
'06
'16
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Top Price Gainers
10 YEARS OF SALES
One Lincoln Square
150 Columbus Avenue
$2,688
avg price per ft 2
(Based on the 12-month perio d en d ing march 31, 2016)
+ 7.0%
(CAGR)
Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
2006
key:
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
avg price
Park Millennium
Olympic Tower
The Century
111 West 67th Street
150 Columbus Avenue
25 Central Park West
The Heritage at
Trump Place
250 Riverside Boulevard
$2,885 $2,556 $2,191 $1,968
avg price per ft 2
avg price per ft 2
+6.8%
+6.4%
(cagr)
'06
'16
avg price per ft 2
'16
+5.7%
+6.0%
(cagr)
'06
avg price per ft 2
(cagr)
(cagr)
'06
'16
'06
'16
Data from October 1, 2006 to March 31, 2016; for inclusion properties must have 3 or more transactions in the final time period.
7
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
Midtown West/CPW Highlights
H
D
E
G
B
F
C
A
key:
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016 Sales
A
The Plaza ($3,929/ft2)
D
One57 ($5,175/ft2)
G
Metropolitan Tower ($2,040/ft2)
B
The Baccarat ($3,996/ft2)
E
Time Warner Center ($4,385/ft2)
H
432 Park Avenue ($4,829/ft2)
C
15 Central Park West ($6,039/ft2)
F
Essex House ($2,501/ft2)
G
$1,000
$2,000
F
A
$3,000
B
E
$4,000
avg price per square feet
Average price/ft2 calculated using closings from the 12-month period ending March 31, 2016.
8
H
D
$5,000
C
$6,000
$7,000
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
SoHo - TriBeCa Highlights
A
C
B
D
E
key:
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016 Sales
A
Sky Lofts @ 145 Hudson Street ($2,864/ft2)
C
40 Mercer Street ($3,224/ft2)
B
SoHo Mews ($2088/ft2)
D
The Loft ($1,980/ft2)
D
$1,000
B
$2,000
E
E
One Kenmare Square ($2,634/ft2)
A
C
$3,000
avg price per square feet
Average price/ft2 calculated using closings from the 12-month period ending March 31, 2016.
9
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
Most Expensive Sales
By Sale Price
15 Central Park West, #1819B
5,610 ft2 (4 beds, 6+ baths)
$45.0M
8,021 / ft2
432 Park Avenue, #64A
$44.8M
4,019 ft2 (3 beds, 4.5 baths)
11,155 / ft2
15 Central Park West, #8A
$35.0M
4,565 ft2 (4 beds, 5.5 baths)
150 Charles Street, #9C/2DN
6,288 ft2 (6 beds, 6+ baths)
One57, #54B
5,475 ft2 (5 beds, 5.5 baths)
432 Park Avenue, #71B
4,019 ft (3 beds, 4.5 baths)
2
150 Charles Street, #9A
5,840 ft2 (6+ beds, 6+ baths)
432 Park Avenue, #67B
4,019 ft2 (3 beds, 4.5 baths)
140 West 12th Street, #PH8
4,027 ft2 (3 beds, 3.5 baths)
432 Park Avenue, #65B
4,019 ft2 (3 bed, 4.5 baths)
7,667 / ft2
$34.4M
5,476 / ft2
$34.4M
3 Beds, 4.5 baths
$44,833,409
6,278 / ft2
$31.0M
approx 4,019 ft2 | $11,155 / ft2
7,701 / ft
2
$29.1M
4,981 / ft2
$26.6M
6,623 / ft2
$26.0M
6,464 / ft2
$25.6M
6,370 / ft2
By Price per Square Foot
432 Park Avenue, #64A
4,019 ft2 (3 beds, 4.5 baths)
15 Central Park West, #1819B
5,610 ft2 (4 beds, 6+ baths)
432 Park Avenue, #71B
4,019 ft2 (3 beds, 4.5 baths)
15 Central Park West, #8A
4,565 ft (4 beds, 5.5 baths)
2
432 Park Avenue, #67B
$11,155 / ft2
$44.8M
$8,021 / ft2
$45M
$7,701 / ft
$31M
$7,667 / ft2
$35M
$6,623 / ft2
530 Park Avenue, #2F
$6,587 / ft2
4,027 ft (3 beds, 3.5 baths)
2
432 Park Avenue, #65B
4,019 ft (3 beds, 4.5 baths)
2
157 West 57th Street, #54B
5,4752 (5 beds, 5.5 baths)
432 Park Avenue, #63B
4,019 ft2 (3 bed, 4.5 baths)
$5.6M
$6,464 / ft2
$26m
$6,370 / ft2
$25.6m
View more sales from the CityRealty 100 at www.cityrealty.com
4 Beds, 5.5 baths
$6,278 / ft
2
$34.4m
$6,117 / ft2
$24.6m
The top 20 sales above are ranked based on prices for closings from the 6-month period ending March 31, 2016.
10
approx 4,027 ft2 | $5,464 / ft2
$26.6M
140 West 12th Street, #PH8
$26,030,476
2
4,019 ft2 (3 beds, 4.5 baths)
858 ft2 (1 bed, 1 bath)
3 Beds, 3.5 baths
$35,000,000
approx 4,565 ft2 | $7,667 / ft2
Q4 2015 - Q1 2016
THE CITYREALTY 100 REPORT
Methodology
The CityRealty 100 is an index of the top 100 residential condominiums in Manhattan. CityRealty follows a
strict set of criteria to determine which buildings are included in The CityRealty 100. All buildings must have a
minimum average price/ft2 of $1,000 for recorded sales during preceding 12 months. If the buildings have had
no recorded transactions in the past 12 months, then the last transaction value is used. For newly constructed
properties, a minimum of three months closing history is required.
The building's prominence, popularity and desirability among purchasers and brokers is also taken into
consideration, as is CityRealty’s rating for the building.
Please note that CityRealty does not rank buildings within the Index; rather, a default sort order is provided
(which is price/ft2 based on the each building's past 12 months sales history). Details for all listed apartments
that comprise The CityRealty 100 are available at www.cityrealty.com/indices. Additional transaction details
for The CityRealty 100 are available on the CityRealty website, as are other market indices that cover additional
areas of Manhattan and Brooklyn.
Gabby Warshawer, CityRealty Director of Research and Communications, welcomes any questions and
comments regarding the New York City real estate market. She can be reached at [email protected]
or by phone at 212-209-8809.
Visit www.cityrealty.com for more sales information.
(1) Pricing information for "All Manhattan Condos" on page 4 does not include buildings north of 96th Street on the East Side, above 110th
Street north of Central Park, and above 125th Street west of the Park.
All closed sales data has been provided by the New York City Department of Finance via the Automated City Register Information System
(ACRIS). No warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy of any data provided by ACRIS or any other sources. All dimensions are
approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer and for no property included in this report shall the
number of bedrooms listed be considered a legal conclusion.
11