Transfigurations Exhibition
Transcription
Transfigurations Exhibition
Transfigurations.'Documentsand lmagesfrom ContemporaryFeministArt frorn NYFAIReflectionsExhibit, 1985 October14, 1996 to January16, 1gg7 SpecialCollectionsand UniversityArchivesGallery ArchibaldStevensAlexanderLibrary Introduction Transfigurations:Documentsantl Image.rfrom ContemporatyFeminisiArt is one of three exhibitions celebratingthe twenty-fifth anniversaryof the Mary H. Dana Women Ariists Series at tlre Mabel Smith DouglassLibrary. It is being held in conjunctionwith Twent,v-Jive Yearsof Feminism, TwenN-fiveYearsof lt/omen'sArt, a retrospectiveof works by the artists who have shown in the series,at the Mason Gross School of the Arts Galleries,and an exhibition of the arfists' portraits and statementsat the Mabel Smith DouglassLibrary. Contemporaryfeministart originatedin about1970,inspiredby the Women'sl,iberation N{ovementwhich was sweepingthe country at this time. Women artistsbeganto focus on the fact that so ferv women were representedin gallery and museum shows, not to mention the exclusionof rvomenartistsfrom the art history canon. Furthermore,very felv women taught on the facultiesof art schools,in spiteof the fact that the majority of art studentswere women. In the early 1970s,women artistsand acti,ristsaddressed theseissuesthroughdemonstrations at muserunsand exposingthe practicesof galleriesandart schools.Originallydcminatedby white women,the movementeventuallyencompassed the concernsof African-American,Hispanicand other minoriry rvomenartists, Feministartistssoughtmore,however,thanequalrepresentation. They believedthat their art could help bring aboutsocialand politicalchange.The porverof art to changethe self and societyis the tansfigurationto which the exhibition'stitle refers. Feministartistsintroduced both new subject matter and formats in their work, which, unlike the critically-validated Modernistart of the period,was heavily content-based.Although feminist art was extremelv diverse,certainbroadthemesare apparent,the most universalbeing the use of autobiography. Among the themesr,vhichare illustratedin this exhibitionare: women's sexuality,violence againstwomen,spirituality,thebody,the environment, multiculruralism. beau[v,and doinesticity. The exhibition also illustratesfeminist arfists' experimentationwith new media, such as perfcrmanceart and craft techniques. Feministartistsshareda concernwith documentation, probablybecauseof their historic invisibility. in the early 1970s,art critic and activist Lucy Lippard started the New York Women's Art Registry,the purposcof which was to collect slides,resurnesand addresses of women artists,in order to make their lvork availablewhile bypassrngthe gallery system. As women artistsgainedmore opportunitiesto show their work, the collectionwas augmentedby flyers and cards advertisingshows,exhibit catalogs,articles,and publicationsabout women artists. Since 1992,tne Women'sArt Registryhasbeenmaintainedat SpecialCollectionsand UniversityArchives. This exhibitionfeaturesmany iiems from this collection,as well as from the recordsof the Women's Caucusfor Art, the New York Feminist Art Institute and the HeresiesCollective.inc. While this exhibirionfocuseson feministart of the 1970s,many of theseartistscontinued producing work utilizing feminist themesin the 1980sand 1990s. Documentedworks from this laier period have been inciudedwhere appropriate,as well as a few examplesof recent work by young feminist artistswho generouslyloanedpiecesfor the exhibition. When I fust came to SpecialCollectionsand University Archives in I 992,my fust task was to inventory the records of the New York Feminist Art Institute and the Women's Art Registry. Since discoveringthe richnessand variety of thesecollections,I had hoped that some day I would be given a chanceto exhibit them. This exhibition could not have come about, however, without the supportof Ronald L. Becker, Head of SpecialCollectionsand University Archives; RutgersUniversity Libraries;the Mabel Smith DouglassLibrary; and Ferris Olin and MarianneFicarra,the curatorsof the Mary H. Dana Women Artists Series. I have also received invaluablehelp from my colleaguesat SpecialCollectionsand University Archives, particularly intern Amy Eawson for help selectingitems, Exhibitions Curator Ruth Simmons,'who was largely responsiblefor the arrangementof the exhibition,JaniceLevin, JanetRiemer and Maria Pisano for mounting the items and captions,and CatherineKeim for her hard work on the catalogue. I hope this exhibition will be as enlighteningfor othersas it has been for me. FernandaPerrone Curator Considering the Feminist Art Movement in the United States,circa 1970-79 Laura Cottingharn . Writing in 1980, American ferninist art's primary ally, Lucy R. Lippard, reflected that "perhapsthe movement'sgreatestconiributionhasbeenits lack of contribution to Modernism."r in the sameyear, America's foremostconservativeart critic, Hilton Kramer, rhetorically asked whether the "influence of the women's movement[hadn't] contributedto an erosionof critical standardsin art?".2'By 1980,the Women's LiberationMovementand its sisterart movementhad ceasedto exist as massmovements.But feministart's chief defenderand oue of its staunchest antagonistsbasicaily agreedupon the natureof its influence:The Feminist Art Movement had been antitheticalto the aims of Euro-AmericanModernism. An assauiton Modernism surfaceddefiantly within the Feminist Art Movement of the its explorationswere led rvithoutseriousregardfor the most fundamentaiprerequisites of what comprisesart and artistic value within the Euro-Arnericantradition. At the sanietime. the Movement was in no senseanti-art;rather,its participantswanteda "nelv" art, one inspired by ihe transformativepossibilitiesthey investedin radicalfeminism.A looselyamalgamated group of women artists and critics linked through sharednewsletters,slide registies, independent publications,cooperativegalleriesand ideologicalcommitment,the Movementwas far from a unifieci front. At the same time, its diverse activities were complimentary, if not always harmonious.The Feminist Art Movement refused a formalist imperative,insisted on the importanceof content,contestedthe absoluteness of history, favored collective production, reclaimedcraft,prioritizedprocessand performance, asserteda piace for the autobiographical, and, perhapsmosi radically,refutedthe ideathat art is evereitherneutraior universal.That art, like "ttrepersonal,"is political. '70s: The Movement'sparticipantswere,for the most part,academicallytrainedartistson the margins cf the visual art cornmunity--thatis, like other graduatesof American art schools,they rverervhiteanCiormiddle class,and unlikenearlyall successful living artistsin 1970,they rvere wornen.As artistsengagedin activismagainsttl-resystemicexclusionof rvomenfrom muser-rm they irreversiblyalteredrhe position of rvornenwithin exhibitions and art schoolprofessorships, '70s, thousandsof American artiststhroughoutthe country American visual culture. During the picketed and sued arts institutions to end discriminatoryhiring practicesand other forms of systemic prejudice against women involved with art. Without the feminist agitation aud '70s, idecllogicaltransformationsof the the American women artists who have risen to '80s '90scould internationalacciaimduringthe and not havehadthe samesubjectmatter,critical support,or eventhe .zerymaterialpossibilityof high level commercialrecognition.r As artistsengagedin an ideologicaland artistictransformation of the lr4odernistlegacy rvh.ichthey inheritedas Americans,but from which they were excludedas women and as non- a- rvhite women, the Feminist Art Movement so completelychallengedthe underlyingpremisesof what constitutesart that neither art, nor the criticaliry'that sun'oundsand informs art, has been the same since. While it would be possibieto argue that any number of subsequentartistic developmentsin the United Statesowe their existenceto the strategiesand aims of the '70s Feminist A-rt Movement, the most enduringlegacy is really one thing: feminism. While Minimalism was the most critically and commerciallyrespectedart in the United Statesduring the late '60s and early '70s, the Feminist Art Movement generally had more in colrunon with the other activist-basedvisual art practicesthat took place in the United States during that same period. Although SecondWave Feminism inspiredthe only large-scaleart movement,the other politicalmobilizations,includingthe ChicanoRightsMovement,the antiWar movement, the Black Power Movement and the Gay Rights Movement, all had both immediateand lastingeffectson art's productionandreceptionin the United States.The insights and demandsof 160sactivism,especiallythoseof Black Power,Women's Liberationand Gay Rights, continueto heaviiy form and inform the directionof American social, political and culrurallife. It was within the generaiizedactivismof the tJnited Statescirca '68, and againstthe overdetermination of American art history by the commercialmarket, that the Feminist Art ivlovementhad its genesisand, in consequence, its generaiizederasurefrom most cunent understandings of American art of the recentpast and the present.The Movement occurred during an economicrecessionin the United Statesand at a low level of art coliecting;many of its mostsignificantgestures occurredin noncommercial venuesor wereotherwiseephemeral. The artistsknew at the time that as women and as feministstheir activitieswere autoraatically marginalizedby both the dominantcommercialapparatusand the prevailingcritical discourse: it rvas for this reasonthat they developedalternativeeducationalvenues,publicationsand galleries,Aithoughsome,suchas Lynda Benglis,Adrian Piper,HannahWilke and cooperative EleanorAntin, garneredearlyand sustained representation from strongdor,vntown galleries,most of the early feminisi artistswere forcedto operateoutsideof art's professionalsupportsystenl and no New York gallery ever choseto representFeministArt "as a Movement."The general lack of initial commercialsupport for feminist-inspiredart continuesto exert an overriding influenceon ho'',vart from the'70s is curatedand otherwisehistoricized;in the development.of American art since Abstract Expressionism,there has never been a widely-recognized"ar] Movement"that lvasn't packagedas suchby one or more commercialgalleries.To accessthe influenceof the Feminist Art Movement is to confrontthe problem not only of how causal connectionsbetweenart and artistsare seldomaccountableto any single source,but to also acknowiedgethat the marginalposition within which feminist art first emergedcontinuesto preciudeits genuineassessment from the Americanart establishment, which is still closelytied to the samedealers,collectorsand critical opinionsthat the Movementwent up againstduring the '70s, Still, evidenceof the Movement'siegacyis undeniable: feminismcontinucsto be one of the central guiding principlesbehind the productionof new American art, especiailyof art producedby women.The stylisticbreadthof the first generationof feministart was wide enough to haveincorporated againstrape,FaithRinggoid's:quilts, SuzanneLacy's demonstrations Miriarn Lynda Benglis'sArtfontm advertisement of herselfnakedwith a dildo; Schapiro'sfemcollages, "porffaits",Betye EleanorAntin's photographicand scuiptual Saa.r'spersonalized assemblages, Harmony Hammond's shamanisticfabric pieces, Sylvia Sleigh's realistic paintings, tvlartha I{annahWilke's provocativenude body, Ana Rosier'svideotapes,JoanJonas'sperformances, Nancy Graves' cascadingceiling Mendieta'searth-bodyworks, Audrey Flack's photorealistn, pieces,Nancy Grossman'slithographsof gun-rvieldingmen, Judy Chicago'sporcelainplates, Mary Beth Edelson's feminized recreationof The Last Supper',Joan Snyder's expressionist in organdy,ReeMorton's scattered canvases, domestically-coded ElaineReichek'scompositions installations,Joan Semrnel'sre-renderingsof the female nude and Joyce Kozloff s public art works enactedin tile. The Movement neither adheredto, nor did it attempt to adhereto, the Greenbergianidea of formal progression;but what it did attempt to follow, even as it was "fentinism." creatingand debatingit, was an idea of "post-"Modemist,It rvasneither ironic,relativistic, The Movementwas "anti-"ratherthan from Like their activist sisters whom they cynical, or anything lessthan utopian. borrowed both theory(SimoneDe Beauvoir'sIhe SecondSa;r,ShulamithFirestone'sTheDialecticof Sex,Kate fenrinistartistssoughtto forge a Millet's SexualPolitics,)and practice(consciousness-raising), nerv art from a ;rew consciousness. Although utilized in variousr,vaysby differentindividual and groupsof artists,the primary '70s was consciousness methociinvolved in the productionof feministart during the raisin.g. raisingwas developedby Inspkedby Mao Tse-Tung'sLittie Red Book, feministconsciousness Redstockings, Kathie Sarachildof the Neu, York City-based one of the first radical feminist activist groups that ernergedout of the anti-war and counterculturalmovementsin 1968. Redstocking'srulesfor consciousness raisingrvereftrst distributedin the group'sNote.s ft'om the First Year,a1969 x.eroxpacket one of the most-widelyread of radicalfeministrvritingsthai r,'ras documentsoi the Women's LiberationNlovement,Althoughnot enrployedby every artist who workedin the nameof feminism,consciousness raisingwas centralto most of the newly-formed "womanartistgroups" the U.S. anciin othercountriesduring the '70s.o up throughout that sprung For instance,a 1972 newsletterof the feminist art nefwork West-EastCoast Bag (W.E.B.) prcvided its readerswith eight "consciousness-raising rules" fbllorvedby over fifty suggested "topics;" by 1974,sevenof eight city chaptersof W.E.B. who respondedto a query concerning raising as a basis.This collusionbetweenartistsand their "philosophy"listed consciousness duringthe'70s was a kind of historicalanomaly: activistsof the Women'sLiberationlvfovement althougha sharedaim betrveenartistsand activistsis common,if not necessary, to a political liberationmovement,I canthink of no otherhistoricalexampleof artistsactuallyborrowingand utilizing, as an artisticmethod,the samepraciiceusedby activiststo further political change. Like consciousness raising,much early feministart rvaslocatedin the belief that the description catalystthatwould eventually aridelucidationof women'sexperience couldprov-ide the necessary ctrangelived experience. The reiianceon consciousness raisinginrroducedautobiography as a veritablesourcefor visual production;it also contadictedthe "unconscious"or "random"r'isualseiectionprocess cherishedby so many Modernist creative theories.Feminism and its self-revelatorymethod brought a different awarenessto art making: while admittediypersonaland autobiographicalin its focus, it is, at the sametime, both sociallyconsciousand consciouslycritical.Feminismhad originated, after all, from women's feelings and observableexperiencethat something was "wrons": with the way their lives as women were perpetuallysubordinatedto the lives of men and children, and with the wa1'fine art, a culturalarenasupposedlyfree and enlightened,assisted in the ideological devaluation and material exclusion of women. Through their new "consciousness,"feminists felt they could changenot just their own lives, but the world itself. In terms of art, Lippard has described the influence this way: "A developed feminist consciousne.ss brings with it an alteredconceptof reality and morality that is crucial to the art being made and to the lived with that art. We take for grantedthat making art is not simply 'expressing oneself but is a far broader and more important task--expressingoneself as a member of a largerunity, or comm/unity,so that in speakingfor oneselfone is also speakingfor thosewho cannotspeak."s The goai of consciousness raising,and of a "consciousart," is similar in some ways to the self-reflexive artistic practice encouragedby the neo-lr4arxistcriticality of the Frankfurt Schoolbut it fundamentallydiffers in its prioritizationof women'ssituationand of the specific verity it privilegesto personalexperience.If consciousness raising,iike so many '70s artistic methods and strategies,is no longer widely practiced,its inchoateinfluencepersistsin the existence of so much recent Ameican art that constructspersonal narrative within an understanding of political exigency. This essayis a modified and abbreviated versionof "The FeministContinuum:Art After 1970," inciudedin the Power of FeminislA'1, Norma Broudeand lvlaryD. Gamard,eds.(New York: Ha.ry N. Abrams,1994),pp. 276-287. L,auraCottinghamis the author of How man.v"barl"feministscloes it taketo cltartgea tightbulb?, 1994and iesbiansare so chic..., 1996.She currentlyteachesart criticismat CooperUnion and in the Deoartmentof Visual Arts at RuteersUniversitv. El Endnotes TheContribution of Feminismto theArt of the r70s," i. Lucy R. Lippard,"sweepingExchanges: 1980,339-365. Art Journal,Fall./Winter NevvYorkTimes,January 2. Hilton Klamer, "DoesFeminismConflictwith Artistic Standards?", 27, 1980,section2; l, 27. 3. The situationfor womenartistsin Europeanart centers,whereno similar massagitationhas whattheNewYork artcommunitywaslike for femaleparticipants takenplace,closelyresembles '70s; regularlyexcludewornenfrom their exhibitions that is, galleriesandmuseums beforethe model, andthe few womenthat do shorvinvariablyfollow the Krasner/Frankenthaler/deKooning i.e.,they must be marriedto or sleepingwith powerfulart world men. raisingwith the aim in consciousness artistswho did not participate 4. Ivlanyfeminist-influenced participants in otherconsciousness raising$oups. of utilizing it for their art werenonetheless 5 . L u c yR . L i p p a rdi,b i d .,3 6 3 . -fransfigurations: Documentsand Imagesfrom ContemporaryFeminist Art Exhibition Captions C a s e1 : FEMINISM AND ART HISTORY In the early 1970s,there were severalgroundbreakingexhibits which inkoduced women artists to the public. These included Wtere lVe At: Black WomenArtistsin 1911, WomenChoose Womenat the New York CulturalCenterin 1913,and Ll/omen,4rtists: 1550-1950,curatedby L.indaNochlin and Ann SutherlandHarris,in 1976. The latterexhibitinspiredMiriam Schapiro "Collaboration," with her foremotherMary Cassatt.Shelaterdid similarworks with to createher ElisabethVigee-Lebrun,BertheMorisotandFridaKahlo. Collaboration, whetherwith eachother past. rvasa key conceDtfor feminist anists. or rvith women arfists of the JOANN D'ESPOSITO-WACHTNIANN, PLATE AND TWO BOWLS, GLAZ,ED TERRA coTTA. 1988-1992 JOANNE ZANGARA. HA}iD PAINTED SILK SCARF' and JoanneZangaraare two young women artists currently Joann D'Esposito-Wachtmann working in the craft tradition. C a s e2 : ART, FENIINISIVIAND THE ENVIR.ONNIENT In the iate 1970s,the use and abuseof the environmentappearcdas an importantthernein feminist art. Cultural feministsbeiievedthat the environrnentrvas of particularconcernto \,vomenas child-bearers; women were naturallypeace-loving,nurnrring,and canng about the earth. In art and literature,there was a traditionalconnectionbetweenwoman and nattrre,or betweenwomen's bodiesand the earth.This themecan be seenin the .rork of Brazilian artist joseiy Carvalho. and of Bea Nettles, whose autobiographicalphotographsexplore the luxuriant landscapeof her Florida childhood. Radical fen'rinistsassertedthat since genderwas sociallyconstrucied., rvomenheld no speciai responsibilityfbr the environment.Lucy Lippardnotesthai women,regardless of their position in this debate,are over-represented among artistswhose work deals with ecology,poilution, vrastedisposaland other environmentalissr.res.She citesthe rvork of JanetCulbertson.whose billboard seriespowerfully contrastsan idyllic past with a deskoyedlandscapeof the present.r Women artists were also among the leadelsin the productionof anti-nuclearart, suchis Dona Ann McAdams' photographsof performancesheld at nuclearpower plant sites,shown here. C a s e3 : FEMINIST ART AND POLITICS In the late 1960s,feminist artistssuchas Nancy Speroand May Stevensusedtheir art as a means of political protest againstthe Viehram War and civil rights violations in the southernt-lnited States. May Stevensdevelopeda seriesof imagesof "Big Daddy", whom Lucy Lippard describes as "the monstrous symbol of distorted patriotism, patriarchy, prejudice and imperialism."2 In her Big Daddy Paper Doll (1970), she dressesher characteras a hooded hangman,military figure,a riot policeman.anda butcher,makinga connectionbetweenpolitical oppressionand the oppressionof women in society. Nancy Spero,famousfor her War Series (1966-1970)on Vietnam,laterusedAmnestyInternational textsin her work depictingthe torrure of women. FEMINIST ART AND PIULTICULTURALISM Women artistsof color experienced racismwithin the feministart movement.Chicanaartistand organizerJudy Baca,bestknown for designingthe GreatWall of Los Angeles,a mural depicting a multi-ethnic history of California,writes, "The problem was aiways the same problem--the rvhite feministsthoughtthey rvoulddeterminehou'to approachanciconfrontrace. They never camein the-iapacityto listen."i Faith Ringgold rvasone of the fust feministartiststo take on the ciualstruggleagainstsexism and racism. In 1970, she and her daughterMichele Waliace founded WSABAL (Women Studentsand Artistsfor Black Art Liberation).Shetracesher developmentas a feministto 1972, rvhenshebeganto work in cloth. Inspiredby her family's multi-generational historyin Harlem, Ringgold collaboratedon the quilt "Echoesof Harlem,"with her mother,Willi Posey,shortly beforethe latter's death. New York-basedartist and curatorHowardenaPindellalso activelytook on racismthroughher work. in 1988, she curatedAutobiographt,:In Her hvn Image, a traveliing exhibit which broughttogetherworks by women of coior from many differentettrnicbackgrounds.She also conductedsurveyswhich exposedthe under-representation of artists of color in New York galleriesand mrtseums, which shedirectlyexperienced in her twelveyearsas an associatecurator at the Museum of Mt-rdernArt. Case4: FEMINIST ART AND SPIRITTIAI,ITY In their searchfor irnagesof powerful women,feminist artistsof the early 1970swere influenced by historical and archeologicalscholarship,such as the work of Marija Gimbutas and Merlin Stone, who studied pre-patriarchalcultures based on goddess-worship,as well as by the rediscoveryof Jung's archetypeof the GreatGoddessas representative of the feminine principle. Theseartists createda feminist iconography,reclaimingsuch forms as the spiral, the labyrinth, the egg,the circle,crescents, horns,quatrefoils,disks,and others. The imageof the Paleolithic goddess,the Venus of Willendorf,ostill influencescontemporaryarfists like Sheila Mudgett, as well as the unknorvndesignerof the necklaceshown here. in the early 1970s,goddessartiststendedtobelievethat the imageof the goddesswas universal, regardlessof cuiture. In the 1980sand 1990s.however,arfistsworking in this traditiontended to lccatetheseimageswithin a specificculturalcontext,as shorvnin Ann McCoy's depictionof the Greek goddessAphrodite,and Anne Elliott's renderingof Kali, the many-handedHindu goddessof divine retr-ibution.Feministailists from this later period also tendedto equatethe goddess'with narure and ecology. Sculptor Nancy Azara,rvho ha.sbeen working with these conceptsfor tr,venty-five years,usesfoundwood, red paint,and gold leaf to createher free-like sc'.rlptures.5 C a s e5 : FEMINIST ART PUBLICATIONS Nlany feministart organizations and publicationsrverefoundedin the eariy 1970s. Someof the earliestrvereinerpensivelyproduced,underground news sheetswhich servedas an inforrnation networkfor rvomenartists. Many wereshort-lived,othersweremore endirring,Of the examples displayedhere.only the Women'sCaucusfor Art Nevvsletter and the Lf/omen's Art Registryof fufinnescta pubiisb.ed. Nexsletterare still being ALI'ERNATI\TE SPACES Becauseof the Cifficulty of breakinginio the gallerysystem,somewomen artistsstartedtheir orvn all-women galleriesor found alteinativespacesin rvhich to exhibit. AIR Gallery, a cooperativewomen's gailery established in Ncw York in 1972,was one of the firrstof these. Other women's ealleriesrvereSoho 20 in Nerv York, Arten'risiaand ARC in Chicago,Hera irr Wakefield,P.hodeIsiand,and Womanspace in Los Angeies. Women artistsalso exhibitedin unusualvenueslike P.S. I in QueensandF'ashioniV{odain the SouthBronx. ln 1971,the first exhibit of the Women Artists Seriesat DouglassCollegewas heid in the lobby of the Mabcl SnrithDougiassLibrary. As well as launchingthe careersof somewoirren artists,the alternative 10 exhibition movement allowed controversial feminist art that would not have been shown elsewhereto be seen. Case6: ''THE BEAUTY MYTH'' "Making-up" and "dressing-up"are recurringthemesin feminist art. Someofthis work ironically commentson the contrastbetweenself and self-image,betweenhow women seethemselvesand how they are perceived. Another way of expressingthis theme is through the idea of transfiguration--howthe self canbe transformed,at leastextemally,t'hroughcosmetics,hairstyles, clothing, or plastic surgery. Another dimensionis the contrastbetweenthe contemporaryreality of women's diverseidentities,and the way that the ideal woman is definedby societyas young, thin and caucasian. Case7: HANNAH WILKE Someof the most radicaland provocativeart of the 1970swas doneby feministswho usedtheir own bodiesor imagesof the body in their work.6 HannahWilke's photographsand perfionnances attractedparticularattentionandnotoriety. In her StarificationObjectSeries(1974-1982),Wilke, a celebratedbeauty, strikes high fashion/pornographic poses,rvhile displaying a body studded with chewin$gum sculptures.Starification,a play on staring/scarring, represents the suffering that women undergoin their struggleto be beautiful. Lucy Lippard commentsthat, 'lA woman using her own face and body hasa right to do what shewill with them,but, it is a subtleabyss that separates men's use of womenfor sexualtitillationfrom rvomen'suse of womento expose that insult."7 HannahWilke died of cancerin 1993. ''CUNT.POSITIVE'' ART In the 1970s,feminist artists wanted to reclaim the female body for women by representing women's bodiesand bodily experiences.They soughtto createpositive imagesthat showedthe beauty,and sexualand spiritual power of the body, as seenfrom the female perspective. Some of this work attemptedto reclaim female genitaliafrom degradation,in imagessuch the placesettingsin Judy Chicago'swell-knownDinner Party installation,and the coloring book and pb.otographs shown here, Women artistscoinedtle phrase"cunt-positive"art, in an attemptto reclaim the term "cunt" from its connotationsof defilementand opprobrium.s 1l Case9: RECLAII\{ING THE CRAFT TRADITION For centuries,decorativeand dornestichandicraftshave been regarded,literally, as women's work, a form of "Low Art" from which western,male-dominated"High Art" strove to separate itself. In the early I970s, feminist artists, often working collaborativeiy,sought to reclaim women's traditional crafts like quilting, embroidery,lace-making,and china-painting,by using them in their work, Somewomen artistscombinedthesetechniqueswith sexualimageryto create w"itfy,ironic images,as shown by "The Boob Tree" and "The Girl in the Velvet Box". In the late 1970s,feminist artistsJoyceKozloff, Miriam Schapiroand Valerie Jaudonbecameieadersin a new mainstreammovement,Patternand Decoration,which emergedto challengethe dominant Minimalist aesthetic. C a s e1 0 : WOMANHOUSE In 1971,studentsin the FeministArt Programat the CaliforniaInstituteof the Arts in Valencia and their teachers,Judy Chicago and Miriam Schapiro, created Womanhouse.Working collaboratively,they took over a condemaedHollywood mansion,and painted,sculptedand decoratedeachroom to representthe fantasies,constraintsand hiddendespairof middle-class women'slives.Womanhousewas opento the public in 1972. Althoughthe housewas latertorn down, its powerful imageshave beenpreservedon film. THE L.A. IVO}IAN'S BUILDING The Woman's Building, a "public centerfot u,omen'sculture",rvasopenedin Los Angelesin 1973.It originally housedthe FeministStudioWorkshop,an alternativeart school for women foundedby JudyChicago,art historianArleneRaven,andgraphicartistSheilade Bretteville:the Women's Graphic Center;WomanspaceGallery,which had been founded n 1972 in an old iaundromat:AssociatedWomen'sPress;the Los AngelesFeministl-heatre;and other wonren's organizations. FeministStudioWorkshop,as well as teachingart-rnakingskills,tried to develop wornen'sidentitiesin the contextof a rvomen'scorffnuniry.It also servedas a performance space,giving a startto performancegroupslike FeministArt Workersand the Waitresses.The L.A. Woman's Building no longer exists. 13 THE NEW YORK FEMINIST ART INSTITUTE The New York Feminist Art Institute rvasfoundedin New York City in 1979by Nancy AzNa, Miriam Schapiro, Carol Stronghilos,Irene Peslikis, SelenaWhitefeatherand Lucille Lessane. Like the foundersof the L.A. Woman's Building, they askedthe fundamentalquestion,"How doesthe social and psychologicalcontextof our identity as womeninform our art?" which would becomethe ethosof the school.In the inhospitableclimateof the 1980s,NYFAI's existencewas overshadowedby the struggle for funding. In the early i980s, when the word "feminist" was becoming almost taboo,I.IYFAI adoptedthe additicnaltitle Women's Cenrerfor Learning, and broadenedits focus to include other arts suchasprint- and paper-making,basketry,and puppetry, as well as courses in psychology and writing. In 1989, NYFAI sponsoredan exhibit and symposium, Be.vondSurvival,which tackledthe issuesof raceand gender.Becauseof a shortage of funding, however.bIfFAI was forcedto drasticallycurtail its activitiesin 199C,and eventualiy dissolved. VISUAL DIARIES The New York FeministArt Institutecurricuiumwas non-haditional.In the first year, within the on developinga better understandingof context of group sessions,srudentsconcenrrated themselvesand their positionas womenbeforeembarkingon the study of artistictechnique.in her consciousness-raising classes,sculptorNancy Azarapioneeredthe conceptof visual diaries. through drawing, painting, These were journals kept by studentsrecordingtheir experiences personal their experiences into ari. sculptureand sometimestext, which helpedthem translate C a s e11 : FEIVIINIST ART AND THE DOMESTIC ENVIRONNIENT "Probablynlore than most artists,women make art to escape,overwhebn,or transformdariy rea.lities. So it rnakessensethat thosewomen artistswho do focus on domesiiciniageryoften seemto be taking off from, ratherthan gettingoff tx, the implicationsof floors and broornsand dirri' laundry.iley work from such imagerybecausethey can't escapeit."ro --Lucy Lippard 14 C a s e1 2 : PROTEST Beginning in the early 1970s,women artists,teachers,students,and curatorscompiied statistics and stagedprotestsagainstthe under-representation of women and minorities in galleries and museruns. in 19.i0,the New York Ad Hoc Women Artists'Committeeprotestedthe limited number of women artists in the Whitney Annual, leadingto an increasein representationfrom tive percentin 1970to 22 percentthe followingyear. In 1981,however,outragedby the absence of rvork by women and minorities in the Los Angeles Coung Museum of Art's Bicentennial exhibition, artistsdressedin cowgirl and cowboy outfits, or wearingmasksof the show's curator, Maurice Tuchman,stageda guerrillaperformancewith pink and black balloons. Displayedhere are artifactsfrom a 1984 demonstrationby the Ne'v York City Chapterof the Women's Caucus for Art againstthe inclusion of only 14 women out of a total of 165 participantsin An International Surveyof RecentPainting and Sculpture,lheexhibit marking the reopeningof the Nluseumof Modern Art after a four-yearrenovation. THE GUERRILLA GIRLS The women artists protest group, the Guerrilla Girls, was organizedin Manhattanin 1985. Appearingin public wearinggoriila masksto hide their identities,they distributedleafletsand posterswhich exposedthe continuinginequitiesin the representation of men and women in gallery and museumshows in New York. Using humor and irony, the Guerrilla Girls kept women's art activism alive throughthe 1980s,and into the 1990s,when they broadenedtheir agendato intlude otherfypesof socialcriticism.rl C a s q1 3 : VIOLENCE AGNNS'I WOMEN Itre themeof violenceagainstwomenhasbeenfrequentlyusedby feministperforrnanceartists such.as SuzanneLacey and Lesiie Labowitz, or by the Cuban-bornartist Ana Mendieta, who herselfdied tragicallyin 1985. In this piecedonewhile shewas still a studentat the University oi Iowa, spectatorswould suddeniycomeuporl her blood-stained, half-nakedbody. Women's. ,,vork in this gen-refocused on rape, domesticabuse,or the more muted .riolenceof the expioitationof women by society;suggested in the peribrmancepiece "Minimum Wage Rage," by young artist SuranSong. 15 ''WE OPPOSE VIOLENT PORI{OGR4.PHY'' "On July 4, 1986, 5 members of the Women's Freedom Front demonstratedagainst objectificationand againstpornographyby simuitaneouslyripping up pornographyand riding on a flrrat without shirts. The action took placein CedarBluff, Iowa, at a 4th of July paradeviewed by 15,000peopie....Women rvho removetheir shirts as they rvishin a noncommercialcontext are actively stopping the male pornographic fantasy of man as dominator and lvoman as object....Thisaction is one of a seriesof feministdirect actionsagainstpornographyby Citizens for Media Responsibilitywilhout Law and the lowa Women'sFreedomFrontlt2 Endnotes l. Lucy R. Lippard, "'fhe GarbageGitls," inThe Pink GlassSwan: SelectedFeminist Essuyson lrl QrlewYork, 1995),pp.258-261. Reprintedfrom Z lulagazine(DecemberI99l). 2. Quoted in Norma Broude and Mary D, Garrard,eds.The Pover of Feministlrf (New York, 1994),p. 142. 3. Quotedin YolandaM. Lopez and Moira Roth, "SocialProtest: Racismand Sexism,"inThe Power of FeministArt, p. 752. 4. JoelynnSnyder-Ott.ll'omen and Creativif (llillbrae, CA, 1978),p.55. 5. Flavia Rando,"sacredDwellings: The Work of Nancy Azara,"in Nancy* A:ara (Ne* York, p . 1995), 6. -6. JoannaFrueh,"The Body ThroughWomen'sEyes,"in ThePower of FeministArt, p. 190. 7, Quoted in Hannah Wilke, So Help Me Hannalr. Text for video performancetape. Privately printed,n.d. 8. Frueh,p. 192. 9 . I b i d . p, . 2 0 1 . 10. "Householdimagesin Art," in ThePink GlassSwan,p. 62. Reprintedfrom Ms. l, No. 9 (March 1973). I l. "Guerrilla Girls." in The Pink GlassSwan.o. 257. 12. Postcard.V,/omen'sFreedomFront. go*u Cirr-,1986). t6 Documentsand Imagesfrom ContemporaryFeministArt Transfigurations: Checklist Case 1: Feminism and Art llistory "Collaboration."January,1977, Ir{iriam Schapiro,poster, Mitzi Landau Gallery, Los Angeles.2611000.Inscribedfor Lucy Lippard by artists. Women'sArt Registry JoannD'Esposito-Wachtmann.Plate and two borvls.Glazedterra cotta, 1988-1992. Collection of the arttst JoanneZangara.Hand painted silk scarf. Collectionof the artist Case2: Art, Feminism and the Environment JoselyCarvalho. My Body is My Country.Hartfbrd,CT: Real Arts Ways,lggl. V/omen'sArt Registry Bea Netties. "Rain Forest,"Flamingo in the Dark. Rochester,NY: Inky Press Productions,1979.Women'sArt Registry Exhibition AnnouncementCards: --JanetCulbertson."Untitled." EastHampton.NY: Guild Hall -_ Museum. --ianet Culbertson."Facesof the Peconic." Riverhead,NY: East End Arts Council. --JanetCulbertson."Untitled." New York: Anita ShapolskyGallery. --JanetCulbertson."Memorial,1965." Frorn Seato ShiningSea. Riverhead,NY: SutTolkCommunity College. l\omen's Art Registry "RanchoSeco,Sacrarnento, Dona Ann McAdams, California. SacramentoMunicipal IJtility District." frorn.They're Juggling Our Genes!I'he Nuclear Suntival Kil. Postcard. Privatelyprinted,NY, 1981.Women'sCaucusfor Art "Karen Silkwood was murCered."Photo in Heresies.Issue I3 Yoko Ono. Color, Fiy, SlE. Museetfor Samtidskunst:Palaeet,Raskilde;Denmark, 1992. LYomen'sArt Registry JoanneZangara.llandpaintedsiik scu'f. Collectionof the artist t7 7 Case 2: Art, Feminism and the Environment (con't.) Kathy Vargas, poster,"Hunger & the Environment:A Seriesof Events Dedicatedto the Memory of Mickey Leland." 5th Annual World Food and FlungerConference.University of Texas Schoolof Public Health.october l6-19, 1989.Il/omen'sArt Registr}, Case 3: Art, Feminism, lVlulticulturalismand Politics Faith Ringgold and Willi Posey."Echoesof Harlem" in The Artist and the Quilt. New York: Alfred A. Ifuopf, 1983.RutgersArt Library Monica Sjoo, Halina Korn, GertrudeElias, MaureenScott, Heinke Jenkins,. Hilda Bernstein,JacquelineMorreau.int'o. by CharlotteYeldham. The World as We See It: GraphicsPaintinsSculpture.1975-1985. InternationalWomen's Decade.London: Camden Council for InternationalCooperation,1977.Women'sArt Registry . ExhibitsUSA, 1992.LYomen's Caucusfor Art May Stevens. --exhibitioncatalogfrom HerbertF. JohnsonMuseumof Art. Cornell University. November28-December 21, 1973. --"Big DaddyPaperDoll, 1971"from Bie Daddv, Lerneir-Heller Gallery,New York, NY. Art Registrlt Yomen's Adios Columbus. VistasLatinas. Hilhvood Ar1 Nluseunr.Long IslandUniversity. Brooklyn, NY, 1972. Women'sArt Registrv Betty La Duke: Multi-CulturalImaees. Paintines-Prints-Drawines l9-53-1986. Exhibition catalog,SeattleArt Museum.lI/'omen's Art Registr-:., --"Chiricahua Apaches,I99I ." --"Sampler(If you reallylove . . .), 1993." ElaineReichek.Home Rule. OrchardGallery,Derry: Irish Museumof Modern Art, Dublin, 1993. Women'sArt Registry Nancy Spero,"l984 The Year of the SouthAfrican Wonran".lrlevr'York,Art Against Apartheid,1984. Women'sArt Registty 18 Case4: Feminist Art and Spirituality Sheila Mudgett. Figwes. Llomen'sCaucusfor Art goddessnecklace.Loaned by Amy Da',vson Annabel Nicolson. "MenstrualHut." Exhibition "ConcerningOurselves.."Norwich, 1981. LVomen'sArt Registry Amy Zerner, poster,Materiatizatlonq.Whitelight Gailery.New York, NY, September 17 October24, i987. "Tabernacle",1987,depicted.l[romen'sArt Registry Nancy Azara. "Spirit House of the Mother". Exhibition catalog. E.M. Donahue Gallery, 1995,Essayby Flavia Rando. Prosepoem by Arlene Raven. Exhibition curatedby Ronald Sosinski. Vf/omen's Art Registrv "Heroic Female:lmagesof Power." Announcement of exhibitionat CeresGallery 1986.Work by Women Artists Associatedwith NliFAIAVomen's Center for Learning. New York Feminist Art Institute Anne Elliott, "Kali", 1984.Sculptue blwalqeLln the Eiehties. Exhibition at the UP Gallery,Universityof Pittsburgh,1985.Women'sCaucusfor Art "Work of the Spirit." Announcement of exhibitionat CeresGallery, 1988.Work by Women Artists Associatedwith NYFAI. Women'sArt Registrv AnnMcCcv: New RomanWorks.Rome 1989-1990.Exhibitioncatalog.Arnoid Iierstand& Company,New York, NY, 1990.Women'sArt Registt1t "Artist as Shaman."Exhibitionat the Woman'sBuilding Gallery,Los Angeles. November4-28, 1985.Women'sArt Registry Case5: FeministArt Publications,Organizationsand Erhibition Spaces Soimine off: a monthly newsletterof women'sculturepublishedat the Los Angeles Women's tsuilding. I(omen'sArt Regi.rtry WWAC NEWS (WashinglonWomen'sArt Center)Vol. 4, no. 12, February1982. Ilomen's Art Registry Womanart"What Ever Happenedto the Women Artists Movement?"Winter/Spring 1977.Women'sArt Registry 19 Case5: FeministArt Publications, Organizations and ExhibitionSpaces(con't.) WARM Journal(Women'sArt Registryof Minnesota)Vol. 2, no. 1, 1987.Women's Art Registry Women'sCaucusof the ColleqeArt Association of AmericaNewsletterNo. 1, 1973. Women'sArt Registry Vol. 10,no. 3, Spring1985.Women'sCaucus for Art The FeministArt JournalFalI 1972.Women'sCaucus for Art "Heresies'flyer. For HeresiesCollective,inc.Heresies "Heresies" poster.Heresies: a feministpublication on art & politics.Posterfor issue #2. Il'omen'sArt Registry Warm Art Gallery.ScenicViews:paintines.JaneBassuk,1979.Minneapolis,MN. Exhibit Opening.Ia/omen's Art Registry ArtemisiaGallery. PhyllisBramsonandLindaKramer,1976.Chicago,IL. Opening Announcement. Women's Art Registry ARC Gallery. JaneStevensandMarilyn Sward,1979.Chicago,IL. Opening Announcement. Lltomen's Art Registty Catafbgs. WomenArtistsSeries,MabelSmithDouglass Library,1973,1974,1975. W'omen's Art Registry Case6: "The BeautyMyth" "Age BeforeBeauty".A film by SarahGibson& SusanLambert.Discussionleaflets. Women'sFilm Fund,1980.LV'omen's Art Registry The Fat Book.BeverlyNaidus,1992.Privatelyprinted.LYomen's Art Registry "The Alien of a ShortStoryaboutthe Little Girl with the JapEyes,HawaiianPig NoseandNiggerLips." KatherineHall. Heresies, Issue9 ' "Girl with Mirror." MarthaMayerErlebacher.1974. From Wor4enArtists.Here& Now and exhibitionat the Art Gallery,O'Shaughnessy Hall, the Universityof Notre Dame. ll/'omen'sCaucus Art for 20 Case 7: Feminist Art, Sexuality and the Body So Help Me Hannah.HannahWilke. Text from videoperformance. Cardadvertising performance Art Registry at AIR.,February20, 1982.lVbmen's So Helo Me Hannah."oneof 48 ray gunphotos". HannahWilke, 1978.Women's Art Registry with Ray Gunscollectedfrom 1969-78.Exhibition Sc Help lrtleHannah:Snatch-shots Art Registry Opening,P.S.1. L.I. City,New York, 1978.Women's box S.O.S.Starificationobjectseries. i of 36 playingcardsfrom rnastication Art Registry peiformance.HannahWilke. Paris,1975.Women's Nipple balls, 1996. Suran Song, Artist statement.Collectiottof the artist 4 imagessuggestinglesbiansexualiry.He:resies,IssueI2 "The Great American Lesbian Art Show." GALAS. Announcement. Woman's Building. Los Angeles,1979.Women'sArt Registry "Wrappedparts.'l Judith N{oriarryand "Big Date EveningBag." HelenaD. Negrette from Erotica:Women CreatineBeyondthe Sexual.1984.By Evelyn PatriciaTerry and Gayle GrubisicRiordan.Women'sCaucusfor Art 3 phoios:Norma Hairnes. --"Mae West,"1975. --"Little Pussy,"1975. --"FannyHill," 1976.Lt/'omen's Art Registry Cunt ColorineBook. Drawingsby Tee Corinne. San Francisco,CA: Pearchild Art Registry Prociuctions.LVomen's Case 8: "What is Feminist Art?" Cards with originai art by: ----- Mary Beth Edelson Anita Steckel Avis Lang Sonya Rapoport 27 Case8: "What is Feminist Art?" (con't.) - Avis Lang -- SusanneMueller - Helene Aylon --unidentified .- Arlene Raven - Robin Tewes - Anita Steckel Judy Malloy. Heresies Case 9: Reclaiming the Craft Tradition Phyllis Green, "Boob Tree" and Anna Gustafson,"Girl in the Velvet Box." Woman as Viewer. Catalog,Winnepeg Art Gallery, 1975.An IntemationalWomen's Year Project Independentlypresentedby the Committeefor Women Artists, Winnepeg,Manitoba. lYomen'sArt Registry Barbara E. Harris et al., T,hreadsof Intimacy. Privatelyprinted, 1980. Women'sArt Registry Case10: Feminist Art Education WomanhouseInvitation, 1972.ll/omen'sArt Registry Photos: -Beth Bachenheimeret al., Dining Room, 1972. @Lloyd Hamrol. -Kathy Huberland,Bridal Staircase,1972.@Lloyd }Iamrol. -Robbin Schiff, NightmareBathroom, 1972. @L\oyd Hamrol. "Woman to Woman." The Woman's Building, a public centerfor woman's culture, welcomesyou to the Grand Opening.December13, 1973. Women'sArt Registry Visual Diaries. 1981.Nelv York FeministArt Institute NffFAIAVomen's Centerfor Learning -Catalog, 1979 -3 Schedules of Classes,Workshopsand Events,1986-1987 York Feminist Art Institute 22 New Case10: Feminist Art Education(con't.) "Reflections: Women in their own image Advertisementfor Opening. Autobiographical works by women artists.l' affiliated with I.ffFAIMomen's Center for Leanring, 1985. CeresGallery, New York, NY. New York FeministArt Institute "The Political is Personal." Work by Advertisementfor Opening. Women Artists Affrliated with i.flTAVWomen's Centerfor Learning, 1987.CeresGallery, NY. New York Feminist Art Institute Photo, "Anais Nin and Judy Chicagoat OpeningNight at the Woman's Building, November 28, 1973." Women'sArt Registry Case11: FeministArt and the DomesticEnvironment "Wages for housework." New York Wagesfor HouseworkCommitlee.Heresies, Issue 9 "Always a bridesmaid,nevera bride." SusanE. King. --"Miss SusanElizabethKing announces the publicationof her book Always a Bridesmaid,Never a Bride on Saturday,the fifteenth of April Nineteenhundredand seventy-eight 815 OceanFront Walk: Number 1 Art Registrlt Venice, California 90291." l't/'ornen's Art Installation."The Family Wash." MarianneEdwards.OpeningInvitation.Fashion Moda. Bronx, NY, July i9, 1980.Women'sArt Registry "Potato.1979." Beckv Cohen.lI/omen'sCaucusfor Art "Tell Me More." Carol Law. Women'sCaucusfor Art Scuipture."Woman's Work." RhondaRoland Shearer.CatalogueForeword by John A. Cherol.Essaysby Arlene Raven,RhondaRoiandShearer,1995.Women'sArt Registry Nipple cup, SuranSong. Collectionof the artist )? Case 12: Women Artists' Protests "MOMA Doesn't Always Know Best.", 1984.Women'sCaucusfor Art Mock-ups: "Whitney . . . 60 to 7 ?" Women's Caucusfor Art/lrlew york City Chapter,c. 1986. "Guggenheim . . . 50 to 2?", c. 1986.Women'sCatlcttsfor Art "Now You See Us, Women's Caucusfor ArL 1986." The Museu.mof Modern Art Opens,but not to Women Artists, Pin. Women'sCaucusfor Art 3 color phctosof protestat the MOMA, c. i986. I4/omen's Caucusfor Art Photo, "Guerilla Girls, Conscienceof the Art World." II/omen'sArt Registry Sticker. "Women in America Earn Only 213of what men do. Women Artists earn oniy l/3 of what men artistsdo." GuerrillaGvls. lltomen'sCaucusfor Art "Artists Missing in Action." Poster.Double X and Arts Coalition for Equality. Los Angeles,1981. Il/omen'sCaucusfor Art 2 black and white photos of protestat the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, July 1981.Women'sCaucusfor Art Tee-shirt,"Women artiststake overNew York," c. 1986,Women'sCaucusfor Art Bannir. "MOMA, Do only white men make art?",1984.Women'sCaucusfor Art Case13: \/iolenceagainstWomen Rape-Murder,1973. Ana lv{endieta.From Rape.presentedby the Ohio State University Gallery of Fine Art. Dedicatedto the Memory of Ana Mendieta,r,vhose unexpecteddeathorLSeptember8, 1985,underscores the violencein our society. Hoyt L. SherrnanGaliery.Photodocumentation of outdoorperiormance,in iowa City, IA. Women's Caucusfor ,4rt SuranSong, "Minimum Wage Rage:Hit the GlassCeilitrB",1994.2 photosof performance.Collection of the artist "$Ie , opposeviolent pornogiaphy."Postcard.Women'sFreedomFront. Iowa City, IA, l 1986.Women'sArt Registry IgrkSA45! 250 Feminist Cartoons.An exhibition curatedby A.ris Lang Rosenberg. Vancouver,IlC. UBC Fine Arts Gailery,1981,RatgersArt Library 24