insight - Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association
Transcription
insight - Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association
Volume 3, Issue 3 January/February 2010 Buying bling can mean cha-ching for your newspaper! PAGE 3 Wedding gowns, flower bouquets and newspapers? You bet! PAGE 7 Targeting advertising to reach the engaged couple PAGE 8 INSIGHT Marketing and Research Newsletter To Bridal Tab...Or Not to Bridal Tab? by Louella Reynolds, PNA ’Tis the season to think spring and Brides! With the onslaught of bridal shows being promoted across the region, we felt this would be a good time to touch base with newspapers and find out how they handle this ‘bridezilla’ time of year. Vanessa Baptista, who is in charge of business development for The Times-Tribune in Scranton, said they have traded in the bridal tab concept and have expanded the weekly ‘People’ section. The Times-Tribune used to do a bridal tab twice a year, which took a lot of time and energy to put together and only provided advertisers a twice-a-year shot at getting the attention of brides-to-be. Published with the Sunday issue, the ‘People’ section highlights anniversaries, engagements, and recent marriages, making this section highly read by a broad age group. Once a month, The Times-Tribune ramps up this section to include bridal ads, giving it more of a focus on the bridal aspect of area events. Vanessa said local retailers know that the key to increased sales is consistent advertising, and the ‘People’ section gives them the opportunity to promote their goods and services to a targeted audience on a weekly basis rather than just twice a year. The Times-Tribune does not sponsor bridal shows, nor has it seen spikes in circulation or online ads because of this change. But, according to Vanessa, this special section has increased the paper’s advertising revenue tremendously. Trib Total Media of Greensburg opts to publish both a Bridal Tab and a full color, glossy ‘Wedding Essential Regional Magazine.’ The Bridal Tab is published in mid- to late-January and mid- to late-February. The magazine publishes in January and July of each year. According to regional advertising manager-inside sales, Patty Klingensmith, this undertaking takes between two and three continued on page 2 Page 2 continued from page 1 months to pull together. By utilizing Print Alert, Patty says that everyone involved is notified of the various deadlines that need to be met; making the process smoother. It takes the collaborative efforts of all the retail advertising reps: An artist to design the fliers and covers, an advertorial writer for the editorial portion of the project, and, most importantly, advertisers. The sales process starts at least eight weeks out with a deadline of two weeks before publication. Producing a specific tab for each of the Trib Total Media’s products gives each market’s loyal readers the connection to local advertisers, better meeting the needs and desires of each area. Patty said that their goal is to have 60 percent of the tabs/magazines to be paid advertisements, but it can vary anywhere from 40 to 60 percent. Most of the advertising dollars come from local retailers, but the national retailers are still welcomed. the tab and magazine come out is in direct correlation with these publications. To give the advertisers the best value and a good return for their ad dollars, a monthly eNewsletter (also called Wedding Essentials) is distributed monthly. Both the magazine and eNewsletter go to people who have requested them, including all those placing an engagement announcement – providing increased value to the advertisers. Circulation figures do not necessarily increase with these editions, Patty said, but the increase in revenue dollars proves that finding advertisers interested in these products has had a positive impact on their bottom line. According to Patty, most bridal advertisers do not ask for an online component, but it is offered to them by the sales staff and often packaged with ROP and the eNewsletter. From time to time, when the bridal advertisers are interested in format pages at other times of the year, Trib Total Media jumps in with format pages that usually include some advertorial. In the past, Trib Total Media has directly sponsored bridal shows, but is not doing that at the present time. So, whether your paper decides ‘To Bridal Tab … Or Not to Bridal Tab,’ brides, and all the ‘zillas’ that come with them, are a way to generate advertising revenues which make an impact on the bottom line. ◆ A nice portion of the revenues generated during the months Bridal Shops are Bustling Late winter and early spring are busiest for bridal shops as most weddings occur on Saturdays in the summer. In general, marriages by month are as follows: • January - 4.7 percent • July - 9.7 percent • February - 7 percent • August - 10.2 percent • March - 6.1 percent • September - 9.6 percent • April - 7.4 percent • October - 9.4 percent • May - 9.8 percent • November - 7.4 percent • June - 10.8 percent • December - 7.8 percent [Source: National Association of Wedding Ministers. Accessed 2009.] Reprinted with permission – “© 2010 AdMall and Sales Development Services, Inc.” Page 3 Cashing in on Silver and Gold … and Platinum, too! by Jane Hungarter, PNA On average, couples shop at four different jewelry stores before selecting an engagement ring worth about $5,800. Add to that another $2,000 for the wedding bands that they’re going to buy – and you have yourself two very valuable customers. Fortunately, newspapers can demonstrate to jewelry store clients that they have what it takes to effectively reach this audience. According to the most recent Scarborough Research reports, Pennsylvanians who have shopped in any jewelry store in the past year are loyal newspaper readers. Adults 18+ who shopped or used the services of any jewelry store in the past year that have used selected media in the past week: Harrisburg/Lancaster/Lebanon/York DMA – Adams, Cumberland, Dauphin, Franklin, Juniata, Lancaster, Lebanon, Mifflin, Perry and York Counties1 Philadelphia DMA – Berks, Bucks, Chester, Delaware, Lehigh, Montgomery, Northampton and Philadelphia Counties2 Pittsburgh DMA – Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Clarion, Fayette, Forest, Greene, Indiana, Lawrence, Venango, Washington and Westmoreland Counties3 Wilkes-Barre/Scranton DMA – Bradford, Carbon, Clinton, Columbia, Lackawanna, Luzerne, Lycoming, Monroe, Montour, Northumberland, Schuylkill, Snyder, Sullivan, Susquehanna, Union, Wayne and Wyoming Counties4 Newspapers (read a daily or Sunday newspaper) 190,540 Television (watched morning or evening local news) 165,972 Radio (listened to morning drive radio) 167,556 Online (visited any newspaper Web site) 100,986 Newspapers (read a daily or Sunday newspaper) 606,540 Television (watched morning or evening local news) 483,568 Radio (listened to morning drive radio) 411,654 Online (visited any newspaper Web site) 303,534 Newspapers (read a daily or Sunday newspaper) 262,282 Television (watched morning or evening local news) 289,464 Radio (listened to morning drive radio) 204,240 Online (visited any newspaper Web site) 95,196 Newspapers (read a daily or Sunday newspaper) 196,114 Television (watched morning or evening local news) 175,266 Radio (listened to morning drive radio) 143,602 Online (visited any newspaper Web site) 56,962 Copyright 2010 Scarborough Research. All rights reserved. 1Source: 2009 Release 2 – Apr 09 – Sep 09 – Scarborough Report.; 2Source: 2009 Release 2 – Feb 09 – Jul 09 – Scarborough Report. PA Counties Only; 3Source: 2009 Release 2 – Mar 09 – Aug 09 – Scarborough Report. PA Counties Only; 4Source: 2009 Release 2 – Apr 09 – Sep 09 – Scarborough Report. Page 4 Whoever Said Love Was Free Certainly Wasn’t Planning a Wedding! In 2009, consumers were expected to spend $20,400 on their wedding. In 2008, average spending on a wedding was $28,704, down 0.1 percent from 2007. On average, couples spend three months looking at 28 rings in four different jewelry stores during the engagement ring buying process. Rings average $5,800 and center stones average slightly more than one carat. Couples typically spend $2,000 on both wedding bands. Despite the recession, 36 percent of grooms plan to spend approximately the same on wedding rings, compared to 52 percent of brides who said the same. Grooms plan to purchase the rings at the following retailers: • National jewelry store - 43 percent • Local independent jewelry store - 36 percent • Internet-only store - 7 percent • Big-box store - 7 percent • Established retailer Web site - 7 percent For women, the most important feature of an engagement ring is the stone cut/shape (53 percent) and style/setting (52 percent). Eighty-one percent of brides prefer platinum jewelry, and more than half of couples say metal type is important or very important when selecting wedding rings. continued on page 6 From the Editor Do your sales skills sizzle? Does the idea of finding new revenue streams get your heart pounding? Do you pull your hair out every time you read another story about the demise of the newspaper industry? Have you been chomping at the bit to help newspapers tell a better story about themselves? If you’ve answered “yes” to any of these questions, please consider joining one of the two new committees that PNA has formed this year – the Advertising Sales/Revenue Generating Committee or the Marketing Committee. The goal of these two committees is pretty straight forward. We’re bringing together the best of the best to pool our collective intelligence and resources so that we can fight a stronger fight to earn more advertising dollars, develop a better connection with our local communities and increase our readership base. Lisa Knight, vice president of sales at MANSI Media, PNA’s newspaper and online placement service, is heading the Advertising Sales/Revenue Generating Committee. More specifically, this committee will explore new selling techniques, new pricing model strategies, commission structures, value-added opportunities, and nontraditional revenue generating streams like book publishing, event marketing and online opportunities. This committee might also explore how a non-print ad can transition effectively into a newspaper ad and will consider creating an “ad share” program in which Pennsylvania’s newspapers distribute internally generated ad materials for other PNA members to use at no cost. The Marketing Committee, chaired by Jane Hungarter, vice president of marketing at PNA, will investigate how to position a newspaper within its community, use research to strengthen the newspaper’s position with readers and advertisers, and develop design templates that can be customized by a newspaper to help tout its value and competitive advantages as well as overcome the negative publicity about declining circulation and ad revenue. This committee might also develop a marketing/communications plan to help PNA members reengage with their lost readers. Feeling inspired? Want to pitch in and share some ideas? Each committee will meet once a month or every other month by conference call – so there’s no need for travel! Please contact Lisa Knight at lisak@ mansimedia.com or Jane Hungarter at [email protected] for more information or to sign up! ◆ Jane Hungarter Vice President of Marketing & Revenue Development Pennsylvania Newspaper Association Page 5 Retailers Elaborate on Their Participation in Bridal Expos by Louella Reynolds, PNA For many, getting married has turned into what seems more like a movie production than a wedding. All the planning and making sure every detail is perfect takes a lot more time and effort than most realize. Using newspaper, television and online ad mediums, the David’s Bridal corporate office in Conshohocken controls the advertising, but each store actively participates in the bridal shows in its own geographic area. Bridal expos and showcases go a long way in helping the bride-tobe make choices without having to run from shop to shop. Many businesses participate in these shows in an effort to prove that their services are what the bride needs to pull off her perfect day. With brides continually looking for the perfect dress, David’s has seen no real trends or changes in the way brides select a dress, saying brides still try on anywhere from one to 15 dresses until they find that perfect look. With 300 locations, David’s Bridal plays a part in bridal expos and showcases across the country. According to Christy Davis, PR Manager, David’s Bridal starts the year off in January with ‘Bridal Christmas,’ which extends into the first quarter of each year. Much like the bridal expos, David’s Bridal prides itself in great value and selection, offering a one-stopshop to complete the entire bridal party, from head pieces to shoes and accessories. Pealer’s Flower Shop participates in two, sometimes three, bridal shows per year. According to Michelle Smith-Lentz, bridal and ecommerce manager for Pealer’s, the shows it chooses to participate in are selected geographically in relation to its four store locations. Pricing and budget dictates what type of advertising is used to promote the store’s participation in the shows. Pealer’s does not use radio or television ads for this specific target audience. They do utilize online ads that are offered as free spots by wedding sites as well as a blog on their own Web site. Michelle says that a close relationship with area hotels offers Pealer’s the opportunity to be included in the hotel’s bridal taste-test functions. Print ads are not a part of Pealer’s bridal advertising program, but are utilized throughout the year for other special occasions. Michelle says Pealer’s gears up its bridal advertising at the beginning of the year because that is when brides who expect to tie the knot realize that the time to pull the big day together is quickly slipping away. With the high expectations of today’s brides, Michelle says that meeting their needs is not enough, and businesses have to reach higher and do the extraordinary. With more than eight decades of proven service, and designers with more than 35 years of experience, Michelle said Pealer’s offers talent behind its flower service that allows it to give the bride a ‘wow’ factor that makes her special day an exceptional one. Bridal expos give brides-to-be the opportunity to compare goods and services in a convenient and time-saving manner. The businesses that participate feel this is an opportunity that offers them the chance to put their best food forward and be the one selected to help each bride’s fairy tale come to life. ◆ Page 6 Save the Date Providing high-quality training opportunities for our members is at the core of the PNA Foundation’s mission. Our extensive selection of training opportunities includes a variety of topics including advertising sales and marketing. Below is a list of some of our upcoming sessions. Be sure to mark your calendar and plan to attend! Advertising Sales Negotiations Thursday, April 15, 1 p.m. – 5 p.m. PNA Headquarters An absolute imperative for the successful ad sales executive is making the investment to improve your sales negotiation skills. We’ll provide the framework specifically designed to improve your negotiating performance. Learn the tools and techniques that give you the ability to increase your sales revenues. Speakers: Cathy Reed, Advertising Director, The Indiana Gazette; Jennifer Bertetto, Advertising Director; Trib Total Media Advertising Roundtable Wednesday, July 21, 7 p.m. – 9 p.m. Trib Total Media, Pittsburgh Our members have told us that they would like to have more time to interact with other newspaper managers and advertising reps to share and exchange ideas. Participate in this roundtable and walk away with new insights and ideas to put into practice. Speakers: Tim Williams, President, PNA; Lisa Knight, VP, Sales, MANSI Media; Kevin Wert, Director, New Business ; Development, MANSI Media PNA On The Road – Practical Tips to Help Improve Your Advertising Sales Success Thursday, July 22, 9 a.m. – 4 p.m. Trib Total Media, Pittsburgh Have you heard from skeptics who say print media is dead? Are you looking for the facts so you can prove them wrong? We’ll give you that and more at this workshop. Members of MANSI Media will share strategies, tips and best practices so you can successfully sell the strengths of newspaper and online advertising to potential buyers. Speakers: Jane Hungarter, VP Marketing, PNA; Matt Caylor, Account Executive, Interactive, MANSI Media; Lisa Knight, VP Sales, MANSI Media; Kevin Wert, Director, New Business Development, MANSI Media For more information or to register, contact the Foundation at (717) 703-3003 or [email protected]. ◆ continued from page 4 Brides-to-be were expected to spend $841 on a wedding dress in 2009, down 8 percent from $916 in 2008. In 2008, the following amounts were spent, on average, on wedding flowers: • Bridal bouquet - $146 (down 3.9 percent from 2007) • Bridesmaid bouquet - $232 (-4.5 percent) • Flower girl flowers - $48 (-2.0 percent) • Corsages/boutonnieres - $169 (-5.1 percent) • Ceremony - $428 (-1.6 percent) • Reception flowers - $1,010 (+2.9 percent) According to a 2007 study by Discover Card, bridesmaids spend an average of $963 as part of a wedding party. Groomsmen actually spend more, paying an average of $1,009 on wedding expenses. ◆ [Sources: Wedding Shopping Survey. Discover Financial Services. May 2007, The Wedding Report. 2008, “June Bridal Study.” Jewelry Consumer Opinion Council. Conducted June 10-15, 2009, TheKnot data via Marketing to Women. September 2009, Modern Bride Magazine Survey. January 2009; The Wedding Report. 2009] Reprinted with permission – “© 2010 AdMall and Sales Development Services, Inc.” Page 7 Brides-To-Be Say “I Do” to Newspapers by Jane Hungarter, PNA Part of the fun of planning a wedding is doing the shopping for it. It is estimated that brides will spend more than $800 on a wedding dress and more than $2,000 on wedding flowers. As advertisers in your market vie for a share of this business, be sure to show them how newspapers reach bridal customers better than any other competing medium. Based on the most recent Scarborough Research reports, Pennsylvanians who shopped or used the services of any bridal shop or florist in the past year read newspapers more than they use any other media type. Adults 18+ who shopped or used the services of any bridal shop or florist in the past year who have used selected media in the past week: Harrisburg/Lancaster/Lebanon/York DMA – Adams, Cumberland, Dauphin, Franklin, Juniata, Lancaster, Lebanon, Mifflin, Perry and York Counties1 Philadelphia DMA – Berks, Bucks, Chester, Delaware, Lehigh, Montgomery, Northampton and Philadelphia Counties2 Pittsburgh DMA – Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Clarion, Fayette, Forest, Greene, Indiana, Lawrence, Venango, Washington and Westmoreland Counties3 Wilkes-Barre/Scranton DMA – Bradford, Carbon, Clinton, Columbia, Lackawanna, Luzerne, Lycoming, Monroe, Montour, Northumberland, Schuylkill, Snyder, Sullivan, Susquehanna, Union, Wayne and Wyoming Counties4 Newspapers (read a daily or Sunday newspaper) 238,112 Television (watched morning or evening local news) 207,046 Radio (listened to morning drive radio) 169,066 Online (visited any newspaper Web site) 107,156 Newspapers (read a daily or Sunday newspaper) 592,778 Television (watched morning or evening local news) 460,648 Radio (listened to morning drive radio) 374,702 Online (visited any newspaper Web site) 268,776 Newspapers (read a daily or Sunday newspaper) 274,540 Television (watched morning or evening local news) 262,386 Radio (listened to morning drive radio) 184,314 Online (visited any newspaper Web site) 111,356 Newspapers (read a daily or Sunday newspaper) 175,412 Television (watched morning or evening local news) 138,374 Radio (listened to morning drive radio) 126,610 Online (visited any newspaper Web site) 60,082 Copyright 2010 Scarborough Research. All rights reserved. 1Source: 2009 Release 2 – Apr 09 – Sep 09 – Scarborough Report.; 2Source: 2009 Release 2 – Feb 09 – Jul 09 – Scarborough Report. PA Counties Only; 3Source: 2009 Release 2 – Mar 09 – Aug 09 – Scarborough Report. PA Counties Only; 4Source: 2009 Release 2 – Apr 09 – Sep 09 – Scarborough Report. Page 8 Love is in the Air – Effectively Reaching the Engaged Couple Bridal shop and jewelry store advertising is generally done in the spring and may include tie-ins to events such as fashion shows. Local or regional magazine and newspapers (special sections), limited radio and television, Internet (Web sites, directories, social networks) and Yellow Pages are the most frequently used media outlets for bridal shops. Rural jewelers are more likely to run ads in a newspaper than their urban and suburban counterparts, while bridal magazine ads are significantly more frequent among urban and suburban jewelers. Fifty-three percent of brides consult the Internet when planning their wedding. Retailers continue to increase their online advertising, particularly their use of social networks and blogs, due in part to piqued interest among younger consumers. A study by National Jeweler and Zoomerang revealed that jewelers use the following media types: Print – 31 percent Direct mail – 18 percent Radio – 14 percent TV – 12 percent Web/E-mail – 9 percent Other – 7 percent Live event – 5 percent Outdoor – 5 percent A 2009 survey revealed that 63 percent of recentlyengaged women give themselves less than six months before their wedding to purchase a gown, and 38 percent wait until three months before the wedding. Bridal and Wedding Journal reports that the average bride visits six shops before making her purchase decision. Sixty percent of brides would like to customize their gown to reflect their personality. When looking for bridesmaid dresses, 75 percent of brides would like the dresses to be coordinating in style and color, and 34 percent prefer their bridesmaid to wear the same dresses. ◆ [Sources: “What’s on Bride’s Minds?” Leflein Associates, Inc. January 2009, North American Fine Jewelry Retailing Research Series: Marketing Best Practices. December 2007, North American Fine Jewelry Retailing Research Series, The Main Event. December 2007, Diamond Promotion Service data via National Jeweler, May 16, 2008] Reprinted with permission – “© 2010 AdMall and Sales Development Services, Inc.” The average bride is 27 years old, and the average groom is 29 years old. Tim Williams, President, [email protected] 717.703.3060 Jane Hungarter, Vice President of Marketing and Revenue Development, [email protected] 717.703.3041 Lisa Knight, Vice President of Advertising Sales, [email protected] 717.703.3043 Kevin Wert, Director of New Business Development, [email protected] 717.703.3049 Matthew Caylor, Account Executive, Interactive, [email protected] 717.703.3040